gundih ccs pilot project – indonesia: … to public engagement for ccs in blora district dr. farah...

RoadtoPublicEngagementforCCSin

BloraDistrict

Dr.FarahMulyasariPertaminaUniversity

CCOPCO2StorageMappingProgram(CCS-M)CCS-MSeminar6(S6):

Seminar/WorkshoponCO2GeologicalStorageandCO2forEOR7-9June2016,Hanoi,Vietnam

GUNDIHCCSPILOTPROJECT–INDONESIA:

IntroducZonu Reasonsfor

DevelopmentofPublicEngagementPlan

u MethodologicalStructureforPreliminaryPublicEngagementPlan

DataCollecZonu Stakeholder

Analysisu Opinion

ShapingFactors

RecommendaZonsu ArgumentsforCCS

GundihPilotProjectinBloraDistrict

u MessagingFramework

u CommunicaZonAcZonPlan

u LessonsLearnt

Outline

WayForwardu NextSteps

IntroducZontoPreliminaryPublicEngagementPlan

ReasonsforDevelopmentof

PublicEngagementPlan

MethodologicalStructureforPreliminary

PublicEngagementPlan

•  EngagethestakeholdersinClimateChangemiZgaZonasanefforttotransiZontoagreenerandmoreresilientsociety

•  Publicengagementplanisinaccordancewith/andaspartofEnvironmentalImpactAssessment

•  Engagelocalstakeholdersofpilotprojectarea(BloraDistrict,CentralJava)inmanagingperceivedrisks

•  StakeholderAnalysiso  Mappingo  Views&InterestofStakeholdersinBlorao  SocialSiteCharacteriza;on

•  OpinionShapingFactors

IntroducZontoPreliminaryPublicEngagementPlan

4Seminar/WorkshoponCO2GeologicalStorageandCO2forEOR7-9June2016,Hanoi,Vietnam

DataCollecZon

AcZvityofPublicEngagementStudy

ObjecZve Status/Progress

Stakeholdermapping Iden;fica;onofprojectstakeholdersandcharacterizingtheposi;oningofthevariousstakeholderswithrespecttotheCCSinBlora

June-August2014

Socialsitecharacteriza;on

Gathering&evalua;nginforma;oninobtainingaccurateportraitofstakeholdergroups,theirpercep;ons&concernsaboutCO2storageinBlora

July2014

MediaLandscape Iden;fica;onofeffec;vecommunica;onchannelsatlocallevel(Blora)

August2014

FocusGroupDiscussion Developmentofopinionshapingfactors,argumentmap,andkeymessagingframeworkforproposingstructuredengagementac;vi;esinpreliminarypublicengagementplan

28August2014

Ques;onnaireSurvey(BaselineSurvey)

Iden;fica;onthethoughtsandunderstandingoflocalpublicinBloraaboutCCSanditsengagementac;vi;esintheirarea

NextStep

DataCollecZon

  Toolsforfordevelopmentofpreliminarypublicengagementplan

DataCollecZon

BloraDistrict,CentralJavaProvince,846.432people(BDA,2013)

Central Processing Plant

Corbon Storage Well (Jepon Well-1)

CCS Gundih Pilot Project

Public

Funding Organization

Government of Indonesia

Media Legislative

PERTAMINA

SKK MIGAS

DITJEN MIGAS

DITJEN DIKTI

National

National MG

Local Senators

National Senators

Local MG

JICA/JST

Norwegian Embassy

Climit Program (Norway)

Local Public of Gundih

People of Indonesia

International communities

Kyoto University

Nedo (Japan)

DNV-GL CMR University of Bergen

Kenso Technos

DataCollecZon

8 Seminar/WorkshoponCO2GeologicalStorageandCO2forEOR7-9June2016,Hanoi,Vietnam

Local Public Of Gundih

Community Representative

Local Government of Blora District

State Owned Enterprise

Sub-districts Villages Service Agencies

CBOs Elderly Head of communities NGOs

Diva Blora Newspaper Community Radio

PERTAMINA CEPU PERUM PERHUTANI REGIONAL CENTRAL JAVA PROVINCE

LevelofClimateChangeandCCS

knowledgeConcernsand

IssuesLevelofSupportorResistance

ExpressAbtude

StakeholderAnalysis

MappingViews&InterestofStakeholdersinBlora

DataCollecZon

  StakeholderMapping

LocaleconomiccondiZons Localempowerment Underlyingviews

•  Agriculture(rain-fedricefield,seasonalcrops)

•  Teakforest(teakwoodandrootsproduc;on)

•  Oldwells(crudeoilproduc;on

•  Formalorganiza;ons:Forest-VillageCommunityBody,VillageCoopera;veUnit,WomenWelfareAssocia;on,FarmersGroupandWomenFarmersGroup.

•  Non-formalorganiza;ons:ReligiousMosquegroup/MajlisTa’lim

•  Overarchingviewsonfossilfuel-basedenergy,oilandgasproduc;on

•  Interested&takingpartinthediscussionforums,listeningtolocalauthori;es

DataCollecZon

  SocialsitecharacterizaZon

Environment Energy Trust Media

•  Damages:Roads(overburdenedtransporta;on)Teakforest(oilgasexplora;on)

•  Solu;on:FillingupwithlimestoneReforesta;on

•  Local&Regionalsourcesofenergy-Oil-Gas

•  Localgovernmentofficers(headofsub-district,headofvillage)

•  Keypersonincommunity(elderly/wise-man)

•  Stronglocalmediapresence(DIVAnewspaperofBlora)

•  Sourceofinforma;on:Localgovernmentofficers,newspapers,television&communityradio

DataCollecZon

LocaleducaZon/Localknowledge

LocaltrafficcondiZons Localhazards

•  Primary–Highschools•  Nohigheracademic

ins;tu;ons(universi;es)•  Opportuni;estocollaboratefor

educa;onalprograms•  Localwisdom/events(Annual

EarthThanksgiving)

Impactsofprojectconstruc;on&implementa;ononlocaltrafficconges;on•  Busiestatbusterminalduring

day;me•  Poten;aloftrafficconges;on

eitherbytwo-wheeled/four-wheeledvehicles,coupledwithdensepopulatedarea

•  Narrowroads&Cepumarket

•  Poten;altoearthquakerisks:LocatednearthefaultlineDrillinginanarea/theCO2

injec;onmaycausedEQTheabilityofCO2injec;on&

storageinfrastructuretowithstandhurricanes

•  Poten;altofloodrisk:Noproperditches(streets&

riveroverflowingduringtherainyseason)

Television(NaZonal)Government:TVRI

JawaTengahCommercialTV

Radio(Local)CommunicaZonandInformaZonServiceAgency

Internet(LocalGovernmentSite)

InfoBloraBappedaBlora

Newspaper(Local)DIVABloraJawaTengahPos

DataCollecZon

  LocalMediaLandscape

ExplaintheneedtomiZgateglobal

warming

ExplainCCSasameasureformiZgaZng

globalwarming

ExplainbothstrengthsandweaknessesofCCS

ProvidebasisfordecisionsconcerningimplementaZonofCCS

Explainothermeasurestolimitglobalwarming

Explainbothstrengthsandweaknessesofothermeasures

DataCollecZonIllustraZngimpactsofglobalwarmingon

everydaylife

Premise'General'support'is'gained'

na2on3wide'regarding'the'importance'of'CCS'

Acceptance'of'nega2ve'impacts,'risks'associated'with'CCS'

Build'local'rela2onship'of'trust'

Get'permission'to'implement'CCS'in'

Blora'

Recogni2on'of''benefits'associated'with'CCS'(improved'environment,'health,'infrastructure,'and'

local'job''Opportuni2es)'

DataCollecZon

•  Levelofknowledge/understandingofCCS

•  ArgumentandmoZvaZonoflocalpublicaboutCCS

•  Localpublicengagement/involvementofCCS

•  intheirarea

o  UnderstandingofCCandCCSo  SourceofCCSinforma;ono  HopeaboutCCSplaninBlorao  Posi;veandnega;veimpacts

ofCCSforBloraandtheirfocus

o  RoleofinvolvementinCCSo  Communica;onmodeand

CCSmediao  Importantstakeholder(s)to

beinvolvedinCCScommunica;on

¡  Sub-districts(7)andVillageleaders(26)

¡  LocalGovernmentWorkingUnits(LGUs)

¡  MediaGroup

DataCollecZon  FocusGroupDiscussion

RecommendaZons

LessonsLearnt

ArgumentsforCCSGundihPilotProjectin

BloraDistrict

MessagingFramework

CommunicaZonAcZonPlan

RecommendaZons

ArgumentsforCCSGundihPilotProjectin

BloraDistrict

o  7sub-districtsand26villageslocatedwiZhintheareaofCCSGundihPilotProject

o  IniZatestheprocessofintroducingplaned

CCSacZviZestoBlora’scommuniZeso  Tooltocreatethemessagingframeworkin

providinglocalpublicconvincingCCSinformaZon

o  ToolforspokespeopleoftheCCSGundihPilotProjecttoprepareforadialogue

o  GenericargumentsforCCSacZviZesinBlora:Climate,Energy,Environment,Safety,Economics,andEthics

o  AroundtheposiZveandnegaZveimpactsofCCSacZviZes

o  FocusingonposiZveimpactsofCSS

RecommendaZons

UlZmateGoalCCSGundihPilotProjectinBloraDistrictisapilotprojectasalearningstudyincomba;ng

GreenhouseGasasimpactofClimateChange

UmbrellaMessageIntroducinganewcleanandsafeenergytechnologytoreducetheCO2emissionsin

IndonesiaandBloraDistrictPosi;veimpactsofCCStopublicinBloraDistrict

MessagingCriteria

Thetypesofins;tu;onsthatarebehindthe

communica;onofCCS

ThelanguagesinwhichCCSwillbe

communicated

HowCCSwillbecommunicated&media

willbeused

Towhatextent,CCSisportrayedfroma

suppor;ve,neutralorcri;calperspec;ve

TheextenttowhichCCScommunica;oneffortsare

evidence-based

ThewaysCCScommunica;onis

fragmentedorlinkedacrossins;tu;onsand

HowCCSistaughtineduca;onalseings

FurthereffortsmightneededonhowCCS

communica;oncouldbedeveloped

RecommendaZons

MessagingFramework

CommunicaZonAcZonPlan

RecommendaZons

OutgoingAcZons(AcZvaZng)

ProjectStage

EngagementobjecZve

Stakeholdergroup

Channel EngagementAcZvity

ResourceRequirement

When Whatdoessuccesslooklike

IncomingAcZons(Monitoring)

ProjectStage

Channel Whatarewelookingfor?

Howdelookforit? ResponseStrategy

ObjecZves&mainstagesofCCSacZviZesforGundihPilotProjectwithfocusonpublicengagement

ProjectStage ObjecZves AcZviZes

ProjectpreparaZon

SubmissionandreviewoftheinjecZonplan

InjecZonandmonitoringprocess

Closure&disseminaZonofresultsandCCSacZviZes

Tiered/StageCommunica;on

FacilitatedCommunica;on

DirectCommunica;on

RecommendaZons

  Sub-districtandVillageCommunicaZonPlan

Sub$district+leaders+

Village+leaders+

Local+Residents+Government+of+Blora+District+

(BAPPEDA)+

CCS+Pilot+Project+

Management+

Community+Health++Center+

Formal+&+Informal+Gathering+

Youth+Union+

Religious+Session+

Community+Facilitators+

DirectCommunica;on

FacilitatedCommunica;on

RecommendaZons

  LocalGovernmentUnitCommunicaZonPlan

Government)of)Blora)District)

(BAPPEDA))

CCS)Pilot)Project)

Management)Local)Residents)

Village)leaders)

Community)Health))Center)

Formal)&)Informal)Gathering)

Youth)Union)

Religious)Session)

Local)Government)Working)Units)

Environment)

EducaKon)

InformaKon)and))

CommunicaKon)

TransportaKon)

Economic)

Mass$Media$

Local$Residents$

Government$of$Blora$District$

(BAPPEDA)$

CCS$Pilot$Project$

Management$

Newspaper$

Radio$

Television$

Internet$/$Website$

Social$Media$

(FB$etc.)$

Two-wayCommunica;on

OnewayCommunica;on

  LocalMassMediaCommunicaZonPlan

RecommendaZons

Facilitated)Communica/on)•  Formal'and'Informal'Gatherings'

•  WWAs'and'YUs'mee7ngs'

•  Integrated'health'center'ac7vi7es'

•  Religious'ac7vi7es'

Community)Tradi/onal)Event)•  Local'Wisdom:'Earth'Thanksgiving'

•  Village'Cleaning'

Media)and)Tools)•  3D'mini'CCS'mobile'interac7ve'model'

•  Posters'pamphlet:'o  Village'community�informa7on'board'

o  Coffee'stalls,'local'markets,'electricity'paying'shops'

SUB:DISTRICT)&)

VILLAGE))

Television)•  Covering'all'project'ac7vi7es'and'support'the'socializa7on'

•  Local'TV'develops'and'broadcast'community'service'ads'

•  Pos7ng'informa7on'through'TV'social'media'account'(FB,'TwiQer)'

Newspaper)•  Covering'all'project'ac7vi7es'and'support'the'socializa7on'

•  Press'release,'feature,'and'opinion'

•  Pos7ng'informa7on'through'Newspaper'social'media'account'(FB,'TwiQer)'

Radio)•  Covering'all'project'ac7vi7es'and'support'the'socializa7on'

•  Community'service'adds'and'jingles'

•  Talk'show'•  Pos7ng'informa7on'through'Radio'social'media'account'(FB,'TwiQer)'

MASS)MEDIA)

Local)Event)•  Organize'Poster'and'Video'clip'contest'

•  Exhibi7on''

Direct)Communica/on)•  Socializa7on'to'all'LGUs''

•  Seminars'and'FGDs'•  Community'gatherings'•  School'Campaign'

Media)and)Tools)•  Billboards'and'ads'•  Distribu7on'of'posters'to:'o  Schools,'police'sta7ons,'hospitals,'mail'office,'markets'

•  Ac7ve'in'social'media'•  Develop'YouTube'persuasive'video'

LOCAL)GOVERNMENT)

  PreliminaryPublic

EngagementPlan

LocalGovernment

MassMedia

Sub-DistrictandVillage

EngagingthelocalmediagroupinBloraaspartnerwithagreedac;vi;es

•  DevelopingMediaandTools

•  OrganizeCommunityTradi;onalEvent

•  ImplementFacilitatedCommunica;on

•  BaselineSurvey

•  DevelopingMediaandTools

•  OrganizeLocalEvent•  ImplementDirect

Communica;on

Mid2015-2017

Mid2015-2017 Mid2015-2017 Post2017

•  Reachingmorewidelylocalpublic(scienceexhibi;on,localCCSforumofBlora,sitevisit)

•  Rou;neeventswithschools,lectures

RecommendaZons

  TimelineofthePublicEngagementPlan

StakeholderMapping•  Remotestakeholder(s)are

equalimportantaslocalpublicinthestakeholderengagementplanningprocess

•  Localpopula;onrelieson

government.Ensureearly&con;nuesengagement.U;lizeitascommunica;onchannelforpubliccommunica;on

SocialSiteCharacterizaZon•  Earlyobserva;on&factfinding

enhancedunderstandingofthesocialcontextinplannedCCSpilotproject

•  Ensuresufficientlocal

resourcestounderstandlocalcondi;onsbejer

OpinionShapingFactors(FGD)•  Term“Gundih”isnotverywell

knownbypublicinBlora.•  Testourassump;onswhen

consideringusingterminologyorjargoninwiderstakeholderconsulta;on

•  Opinionabouttheprojectinfluencedbyhowitwillbringvaluetolocalpublic.Discussandtesttheideaswiththem

Messaging(FGD)•  ‘Transla;ngtheterm‘CCS’•  Posi;veframingoftheCCSpilot

projectintermsoflocalmerits(addressinginaconsistent,open&honestway)

•  Involvementoflocalleadersaslocalambassadors(guidance&supportneededinedu-materials)

CommunicaZonAcZons(FGD)Localstakeholders:•  interestinunderstandingCCS.

Crea;ngeasilytransportableeduca;onalmaterials,includesaphysicalmodeloftheCCSpilotinstalla;on.

•  havingcon;nuescommunica;onwiththeproject&trustcommunica;ngwithsameprojectrepresenta;ves 27

RecommendaZons

  LessonsLearnt

WayForward

NextSteps

o BaselinepublicsurveyonCCSo  FurtherrefinementofCCSmessaging

framework

o TrainingoflocalprojectambassadorsanddevelopmentofeducaZonaltooltosupportlocalambassadors

o EngagingthemediagroupatearlystageasthepartnerincoveringCCSprojectacZviZesanditscommunicaZonacZons

o SetuppublicengagementtaskforcewithintheCCSprojectstructure

http://www.scifun.ed.ac.uk/fusion/fusion-case1-CCSI.html

CreaZngeasilytransportableeducaZonalmaterials,includesaphysicalmodeloftheCCSpilotinstallaZon.

WayForward

o BaselinepublicsurveyonCCSinBloraDistrict

WayForward

DevelopingCommunica;onofCCSand

PublicOutreachStrategyforcertainTargetAudience

Topopulateandmeasure:§  baselinepercep;onsofissuesand

impacts,§  posi;veandnega;vethataremostrelevanttolocalstakeholdersinBlorarelatedtotheapplica;onofnewtechnologyinoil,gas,andenergysector(CCS)

TofindoutthelevelofknowledgeoflocalstakeholdersrelatedtoCCS 2

Crea;ngvarioustypesofcontentandac;vi;es,related

toCCSeduca;on

Dissemina;nginforma;onandimplemen;ngac;vi;es

(engaginglocalpublic)throughselectedmediums

Toiden;fybestmethodsinconveyingCCStolocalstakeholders 3

Objec;ves

WayForward

SurveyStructure&Content

DemographicItems:Informa;onaboutpar;cipantsthemselves,includinginforma;onthatwilliden;fywhatstakeholdergroupstheyarelinkedwith.

IssuesandImpactsItems:MeasuresofhowtheCCSprojectisperceivedtointeractwithcontextinwhichitoperates,bothnega;velyandposi;vely.

RelaZonalItems:MeasuresofhowtheCCSprojectisperceivedtointeractwithitsstakeholders.

OutcomeItems:MeasuresofhowstakeholdersperceivetheCCSproject’sreputa;on,theiracceptanceandapprovalofCCSac;vityandtheirbehavioralinten;ontowardstheCCSproject.

WayForward

Schedule

DescripZon Time

§  Comple;onofsurveytemplate

² MidJune2016

§  BaselinepublicsurveyonCCSinBlora

²  September2016

§  Analysisandreportofthebaselinesurvey

²  September–November2016

§  Prepara;onforPublicEngagementAc;vi;esforCCS(referringandinlinewithCCSProjectac;vi;es)

²  December2016

§  PublicEngagementAc;vi;esforCCS(basedonthesurveyanalysis)

²  Star;ngJanuary2017

ThankyouforyourakenZon!

Thepresenta;onispartoftheReportofPreliminaryPublicEngagementPlan(February,2015)thatwasmadebyIns;tutTeknologiBandung,(FarahMulyasari,currentlyaffiliatedatPertaminaUniversity),supportedby

UniversitasPembangunanNasionalVeteran-Yogyakarta(PujiLestari,PrayudiAhmad,AndiSungkowo,RenyTriwardani,EkhaYogafanny,andAmyUtami)andreviewedbyDNVGLNorway(AnastasiaIsaenkoandEelcoKruizinga).

ThesupportofUPNteammembersinsocialsitecharacteriza;onandFGDaswellascommentsfromDNVGLNorwayareacknowledged.ThesupportofPlanningandDevelopmentAgencyofBlora(BappedaBlora)isappreciated.

PublicEngagementPilotStudyforCarbonSequestraZonandMonitoringinGundihArea,CentralJavaProvince,IndonesiaINSTITUTTEKNOLOGIBANDUNGBasicScienceBuilding-B,3rdFloor,FacultyofMiningandOilEngineeringJl.GaneshaNo.10,Bandung40132,IndonesiaTel/Fax:+62-22-253-4205Mobile:+62-813-2189-2276Email:farah.mulyasari@gmail.comWeb:hjp://ccs-gundih.ttm.itb.ac.id

PERTAMINAUNIVERSITYCommunicaZonScienceDepartmentFacultyofCommunicaZonandDiplomacyJl.TeukuNyakArief,Simprug,JakartaSelatan12220,IndonesiaTel:+62-21-2904-4308Fax:+62-21-2904-4316Email:farah.mulyasari@universitaspertamina.ac.idWeb:universitaspertamina.ac.id

gundih ccs pilot project – indonesia: … to public engagement for ccs in blora district dr. farah...

Documents

the status of ccs, global-ccs-institute

ccs example

certification ccs

certificate in communication skill (ccs)...

global ccs institute the global status of ccs: 2010 alice...

uk ccs policies, especially industrial ccs

concrete colour palette 2014 - ever-ready concrete · ccs...

global ccs institute - day 2 - keynote - ccs in australia

maria ward, med, rhit, ccs, ccs-p director of him...

penyimpangan hukum kasus prita mulyasari oleh : dr

the ccs experience in china - ccs webinar presentation

migrating ccs 1.2 projects to ccs 2.0

gundih ccs pilot project - summary of research activities in...

cloud object storage | store & retrieve data anywhere...

ccs/reebok track ccs/reebok...

ccs optima+ stil – ccs optima – operation and...

global ccs institute ccs legal and regulator y...

overview of ccs pilot study at gundih field ......overview...

ccs/ccus program and activities in … merbau pt pertamina...

daftar pustaka -...