global stock plan design and redesign: issues relating to broad-based plans 2001 global equity...
Post on 28-Dec-2015
213 Views
Preview:
TRANSCRIPT
Global Stock Plan Design and Redesign:Global Stock Plan Design and Redesign:Issues Relating to Broad-Based PlansIssues Relating to Broad-Based Plans
2001 Global Equity Compensation Forum2001 Global Equity Compensation Forum
San Francisco, CaliforniaSan Francisco, CaliforniaNovember 5, 2001November 5, 2001
Edward D. BurmeisterBaker & McKenzie
Two Embarcadero Center, Suite 2400San Francisco, California 94111
(415) 576-3029edward.d.burmeister@bakernet.com
TYPES OF BROAD-BASED PLANS/AWARDSTYPES OF BROAD-BASED PLANS/AWARDS
Long-Term Incentive Plan or Omnibus Stock Plan• Stock Options (Always)
– ISOs– Non-Qualified Options
• Restricted Stock– Typical for Executives
• Other Awards– SARs– Stock Bonuses– Restricted Stock Units
BROAD-BASED AWARDSBROAD-BASED AWARDS
Hire Grants (Silicon Valley Model)
• All-Employee, “One”-Time Grant
• Ongoing Broad-Based Grants
STOCK PURCHASE PLANSSTOCK PURCHASE PLANS
• 423 Design
• Non-423 Design– Open Market– No Discount Plans– Other
OBJECTIVES FOR BROAD-BASED PLANSOBJECTIVES FOR BROAD-BASED PLANS
One-Time Grant Programs
• Recognition Event
• Global “Branding” to Employees
• Communication Vehicle for Corporate Values, Identify With Creating Shareholder Value
• Not Typically Designed As Compensation
HIRE GRANTS AND ONGOING GRANT HIRE GRANTS AND ONGOING GRANT PROGRAMSPROGRAMS
• Recruitment and Retention
• Recruitment and Retention
• Competitive Practice
• Incentive for Performance
• Intended As Compensation
EMPLOYEE STOCK PURCHASE PLANSEMPLOYEE STOCK PURCHASE PLANS
• Competitive Practice
• Recruitment
• Encouragement for Share Ownership by Employees
• Build an Ownership Culture
STOCK OPTIONS VERSUS STOCK PURCHASESTOCK OPTIONS VERSUS STOCK PURCHASE
Stock Option Advantages Stock Purchase Advantages
Ease of Administration/ Employee Makes InvestmentFlexibility
Virtually Universal and No ISS ConcernsWell Recognized
Participation Can Be Up Less Dilution100%
Vesting for Retention More Share Ownership Likely Automatic “Repricing”
STOCK OPTIONS VERSUS STOCK PURCHASESTOCK OPTIONS VERSUS STOCK PURCHASE
Stock Option Drawbacks Stock Purchase Drawbacks
Dilution 423 Design Inflexible
ISS Resistance More Difficult Administration
Underwater Options a Lower ParticipationDisincentive
Little Employee Share Withholding Issues Outside Ownership U.S.
STOCK OPTION PLAN DESIGNSTOCK OPTION PLAN DESIGN
• Global One Size Fits All Design
• Global Design With Limited Local Variations
• Global Plan With Significant Local Customization
ONE SIZE FITS ALL DESIGNONE SIZE FITS ALL DESIGN
• Pros:– Simplicity– Transfers Easier to Accommodate– Equity of Design
• Cons:– Unfortunate Employee Tax Results
• France• Italy• Netherlands• Switzerland• Belgium
ONE SIZE FITS ALL DESIGNONE SIZE FITS ALL DESIGN (Con’t) (Con’t)
• Cons:– Unfortunate Company Social Taxes
• France• U. K.• Italy• Sweden• Norway
– Failure to Take Advantage of Local Tax Advantages• U. K.• Ireland• Israel• Austria• Singapore• Italy
TOTAL CUSTOMIZATIONTOTAL CUSTOMIZATION
• Pros:
– Maximizes Employee Tax Results– Locally Competitive– Can Reduce Employer Social Costs
• Cons:
– More Difficult to Administer– Potential Inequities Within Company– Loss of Central Control
RECOMMENDATIONSRECOMMENDATIONS
• Draft Plan to Permit Local Customization
– Sub-Plan Authorization in Option Plans– Non-423 Component in ESPP
• Decide Process and Parameters for Local Customization
– Retain Ultimate Central Control– Do Customize Agreements/Enrollment Forms
OTHER DESIGN RECOMMENDATIONSOTHER DESIGN RECOMMENDATIONS
• Avoid Beneficiary Forms (at Least in ESPPs)
• Avoid Transferability Outside U.S.
• Avoid Stock-for-Stock or Attestation Exercise Methods Outside U.S.
OTHER DESIGN RECOMMENDATIONSOTHER DESIGN RECOMMENDATIONS (Con’t) (Con’t)
• Avoid U.S. Centric Inflexible Provisions
– 10-year Term– One-Year Post-Death Exercise– Compensation Definition in ESPP– Definition of “Subsidiary” in Option Plan– Methods of Exercise Locked In
• Disavow Maintaining “Qualified” Status
• Tailor Labor Law Language
WHAT IS END RESULT?WHAT IS END RESULT?
• Option Plan
– Flexible And General Plan Language
• Authorization for Sub-plans and Country-Specific Modifications
– Much Discretion in Committee
WHAT IS END RESULT? WHAT IS END RESULT? (Con’t)(Con’t)
• Option Plan
– Country-Specific Design Modifications
• U. K.: Approved Plan and NICPass-Through
• France: - Qualified Plan – 4-Year Requirement Mandatory- Closed Period Avoidance
• Italy: Prior Month’s Average Price as Minimum Grant Price
WHAT IS END RESULT?WHAT IS END RESULT? (Con’t) (Con’t)
• Option Plan
– Country-Specific Design Modifications
• Netherlands: Election to Defer Tax: “Pre-Acceptance”
orMandatory Cashless Exercise
• Belgium: Special Offer Letter andUndertaking
Consideration of Bank ProductsTo Minimize Employee Tax Problem
WHAT IS END RESULT? WHAT IS END RESULT? (Con’t)(Con’t)
• Option Plan
– Country-Specific Design Modifications
• Switzerland: Cantonal Tax Rulings on10-year, 6-month Term orMandatory Cashless
• Singapore: Use of CSOP Scheme
• Ireland: Consider Approved Plan
• Austria Consider Tax-Advantaged Plan
WHAT IS END RESULT?WHAT IS END RESULT? (Con’t) (Con’t)
• Option Plan
– Country-Specific Design Modifications
• Israel: Consider 102 Plan
– Mandatory Cashless Exercise
•Azerbaijan•Brazil•Bulgaria•China•Croatia•India•Indonesia
•Morocco•Nigeria•Romania•South Africa•Thailand•Uzbekistan•Yugoslavia
STOCK PURCHASE PLANSSTOCK PURCHASE PLANS
• Plan Redesign
– 423 Plan Component– Non-423 Plan Component– Coverage of “Affiliates” Rather Than Subsidiaries– Sub-Plans Authorized
STOCK PURCHASE PLANSTOCK PURCHASE PLAN (Con’t) (Con’t)
• Country Modifications – No Payroll Deductions (Alternatives: Direct Deposit, Checks)
• Hong Kong, Argentina, Mexico (Documentation May be Structured to Permit)
– Separate Accounts• Australia• Japan (if held by local sub)• Korea
STOCK PURCHASE PLANSTOCK PURCHASE PLAN (Con’t) (Con’t)
• Country Modifications
– Immediate Transfer of Payroll Deductions
– Coverage of Part-Time Employees
– EU Countries
COUNTRY-SPECIFIC OPTION AGREEMENTSCOUNTRY-SPECIFIC OPTION AGREEMENTS
• Tax Clauses
• Labor Law Language/Acknowledgement
– Not Part of Severance– Discretionary
• Data Privacy Consent
• Special Clauses – France, U.K., Italy, Other
STOCK PURCHASE PLANSTOCK PURCHASE PLAN
• Tailor Enrollment Form:
– Taxes, Labor Laws, Data Privacy
– Specific Clauses for United Kingdom (Deemed Loan)
• Qualified Arrangements
– U. K.:• SAYE• AESOP
top related