february 27, 2018 upstream oil and gas like-kind … · 2018. 4. 14. · upstream oil and gas...
Post on 05-Sep-2020
0 Views
Preview:
TRANSCRIPT
FEBRUARY 27, 2018
UPSTREAM OIL AND GAS LIKE-KIND
EXCHANGE TRANSACTIONS AFTER
TAX REFORM
Tax Executives Institute – Houston Chapter
Presented by
Julia Pashin and Megan James
Confidential and Proprietary ©2018 Vinson & Elkins LLP velaw.com 2
Summary of Practice
Julia is a tax attorney at Vinson & Elkins LLP, where she advises clients on the
U.S. federal income tax aspects of complex domestic and cross-border
transactions, including private equity, mergers and acquisitions, and joint
venture transactions.
Education and Professional Background
• Southern Methodist University Dedman School of Law, J.D.
magna cum laude, 2012 (Order of the Coif; SMU Law Review)
• The University of Texas, B.B.A. Business Honors Program & Finance,
with high honors, 2009
Contact Info: 214-220-7883
jpashin@velaw.com
BIOGRAPHY – JULIA PASHIN
Confidential and Proprietary ©2018 Vinson & Elkins LLP velaw.com 3
Summary of Practice
Megan is a tax attorney at Vinson & Elkins LLP, where she focuses her practice
on the federal income tax aspects of complex domestic and cross-border
transactions. She advises partnerships, corporations and individuals in a
variety of tax matters, including mergers and acquisitions, joint ventures,
reorganizations, and private equity.
Education and Professional Background
• Texas Tech University School of Law, J.D. summa cum laude, 2014 (Order of
the Coif; Managing Editor, Texas Tech Law Review; Burton Award, 2014
Distinguished Legal Writing Award)
• Texas A&M University, B.S., Sociology, 2010
Contact Info: 214-220-7781
meganjames@velaw.com
BIOGRAPHY – MEGAN JAMES
Confidential and Proprietary ©2018 Vinson & Elkins LLP velaw.com 4
• This presentation does not offer a comprehensive discussion of the
requirements for tax-deferral under Section 1031 of the Code
• Rather it is intended to provide an overview of the key U.S. federal
income tax traps encountered in structuring like-kind exchange
transactions involving upstream oil and gas interests, including in the
context of the Tax Cuts and Jobs Act.
SCOPE OF PRESENTATIONINTRODUCTION
Confidential and Proprietary ©2018 Vinson & Elkins LLP velaw.com 5
TOPICSINTRODUCTION
• Introduction
• Tax Reform
• Key Tax Traps in Oil and Gas Like-Kind Exchanges
– Does a Like-Kind Exchange Make Sense?
– Recapture
– What is Real Property?
– Same Taxpayer Requirement
– Tax Partnerships
– Retaining an ORRI
– Identifying Oil and Gas Properties
– Developing “Parked” Acreage in a Reverse Exchange
Confidential and Proprietary ©2018 Vinson & Elkins LLP velaw.com 6
• Terms Used in this Presentation
– “Relinquished Property” means the real property that the taxpayer
intends to dispose of in a Section 1031 transaction
– “Replacement Property” means the real property that the taxpayer
intends to acquire in exchange for the Relinquished Property in a Section
1031 transaction
INTRODUCTION
Confidential and Proprietary ©2018 Vinson & Elkins LLP velaw.com 7
• General Rule Under Section 1031(a)(1)
– Exception to Section 1001, which requires the recognition of gain upon a
sale or exchange of property
– No gain or loss is recognized on the exchange of real property held for
productive use in a trade or business or for investment if such property is
exchanged solely for real property of like kind which is to be held either
for productive use in a trade or business or for investment.
• Three main elements
– There must be an “exchange”
– The properties must meet the “held for” requirement
– Exchanged properties must be of “like kind”
INTRODUCTION
Confidential and Proprietary ©2018 Vinson & Elkins LLP velaw.com 8
INTRODUCTIONBASIC DEFERRED EXCHANGE STRUCTURES: FORWARD
Taxpayer
Relinquished
Property
Third Party
Buyer
Exchange
Proceeds
QI (Qualified
Trust or Escrow)
Step 1 –
Sale of Relinquished Property
Third Party
Seller
Replacement
Property
Step 2 –
Purchase of
Replacement Property
Relinquished
Property Purchase Price
Replacement
Property
Purchase Price
Confidential and Proprietary ©2018 Vinson & Elkins LLP velaw.com 9
INTRODUCTIONBASIC DEFERRED EXCHANGE STRUCTURES: REVERSE
Taxpayer
Replacement
Property
EAT
Third Party
Seller
Step 1 – Purchase of Replacement Property by EAT
Replacement
Property
Purchase Price
Taxpayer Loans EAT
Replacement
Property Purchase Price
Promissory Note from
EAT to Taxpayer
Confidential and Proprietary ©2018 Vinson & Elkins LLP velaw.com 10
BASIC DEFERRED EXCHANGE STRUCTURES: REVERSEINTRODUCTION
Taxpayer
Relinquished
Property
Third Party
Buyer
Replacement
Property
EAT
Step 2 – Sale of Relinquished Property and Closing of RLKE
QI (Qualified
Trust or Escrow)
Relinquished
Property
Purchase Price
Replacement
Property
Purchase Price
Repayment of
Promissory Note
Step 2(a)
Ste
p 2
(b)
Exchange
Proceeds
Confidential and Proprietary ©2018 Vinson & Elkins LLP velaw.com 11
• Tax Cuts and Jobs Act, Public Law 115-97 (Dec. 22, 2017)
– Amended Section 1031
• Limited Section 1031 to exchanges of real property
• Like-kind exchanges of personal property no longer qualify for gain deferral
• Applies to exchanges completed after December 31, 2017
TAX CUTS AND JOBS ACT OF 2017
Confidential and Proprietary ©2018 Vinson & Elkins LLP velaw.com 12
• Transitional Rules for Personal Property Exchanges
– Rule 1:
• Applies to deferred forward exchanges where Relinquished Property is
disposed of on or before December 31, 2017, even if the Replacement
Property is acquired in 2018. Tax Cuts and Jobs Act,§ 13303(c)(2)(A).
– Rule 2:
• Applies when Replacement Property is “received” on or before December 31,
2017. Tax Cuts and Jobs Act,§ 13303(c)(2)(B).
• What about reverse exchanges where Replacement Property was “parked”
with exchange accommodation titleholder (“EAT”) in 2017 but exchange was
(or will be) completed in 2018?
TRANSITIONAL RULESTAX CUTS AND JOBS ACT OF 2017
Confidential and Proprietary ©2018 Vinson & Elkins LLP velaw.com 13
• Section 1031 is still relevant for upstream oil and gas exchanges
• Most oil and gas interests qualify as real property for federal income
tax purposes
– E.g., operating and non-operating working interests and royalty interests
UPSTREAM OIL AND GAS EXCHANGESTAX CUTS AND JOBS ACT OF 2017
Confidential and Proprietary ©2018 Vinson & Elkins LLP velaw.com 14
• Before engaging a QI, Qualified Trustee or EAT, consider the
following:
– How much gain can be deferred?
• Determine the amount of gain that would be realized in a taxable transaction
(FMV of the Relinquished Property minus taxpayer’s adjusted basis in the
property)
• This represents the maximum amount of gain that could be deferred
– How much boot is expected to be received in the exchange?
• “Boot” is other property or cash received as part of the exchange
• Under Section 1031(b), built-in gain in the Relinquished Property is recognized
to the extent of the boot received
DOES A LIKE-KIND EXCHANGE MAKE SENSE?
Confidential and Proprietary ©2018 Vinson & Elkins LLP velaw.com 15
• Relinquished Property with FMV of $1,000,000 and adjusted tax
basis of $750,000
– Maximum gain deferred is $250,000
– If taxpayer acquires $1,000,000 or more of like-kind real property, all of
the gain can be deferred (subject to recapture, discussed later)
– If the taxpayer only received $500,000 of like-kind replacement property
and $500,000 in cash, then all $250,000 of gain would be recognized
EXAMPLEDOES A LIKE-KIND EXCHANGE MAKE SENSE?
Confidential and Proprietary ©2018 Vinson & Elkins LLP velaw.com 16
• The recapture rules of Section 1254 may cause an otherwise tax-free
like-kind exchange to be taxable
– Applies to dispositions of “natural resource recapture property” as defined
in Treasury Regulations Section 1.1254-1(b)(2) (“Section 1254 Property”)
– Disposition of Section 1254 Property in a taxable transaction results in
the recapture of previously deducted IDCs and depletion as ordinary
income to the extent of gain realized (the “Section 1254 Recapture
Amount”)
OVERVIEW SECTION 1254 RECAPTURE
Confidential and Proprietary ©2018 Vinson & Elkins LLP velaw.com 17
• In a like-kind exchange, Section 1254 Property (e.g., a working
interest in a developed oil and gas lease) cannot be exchanged for
real property that is not also Section 1254 Property (e.g., a ranch)
without triggering recapture of prior deductions
• Section 1254 Recapture Amount is recognized to the extent of the
sum of:
– (i) the amount of gain recognized under Section 1031 and
– (ii) the FMV of property acquired that is not Section 1254 Property and
that is not taken into account under clause (i) (i.e., the FMV of real
property that is not Section 1254 Property)
TAX TRAP: RECOGNITION OF ORDINARY INCOME SECTION 1254 RECAPTURE
Confidential and Proprietary ©2018 Vinson & Elkins LLP velaw.com 18
• It is uncertain whether the exchange of developed oil and gas
acreage (with respect to which the taxpayer has properly deducted
IDCs and depletion) for undeveloped oil and gas acreage can occur
without triggering Section 1254 recapture
• Definition of Section 1254 Property (Treas. Reg. § 1.1254-1(b)(2))
– Treasury Regulations define such property by reference to whether
expenditures described in Sections 263, 616 or 617 are properly
chargeable to such property
– An expenditure is properly chargeable to property if the property is an
operating mineral interest with respect to which the expenditure has been
deducted
• The past tense “has been deducted” creates a risk that Replacement
Property must be developed in order to avoid recapture on the
Relinquished Property in a like-kind exchange
TAX TRAP: EXCHANGING INTO UNDEVELOPED ACREAGE SECTION 1254 RECAPTURE
Confidential and Proprietary ©2018 Vinson & Elkins LLP velaw.com 19
• Base Case
– Taxpayer exchanges a working interest in one oil and gas lease with an
adjusted tax basis of $0 and a FMV of $100 for a working interest in
another oil and gas lease of the same FMV. Both leases are developed.
Taxpayer had taken $80 of IDCs and $20 of depletion on the relinquished
lease.
• No gain is recognized in the exchange, and no amount of IDC or depletion
recapture is triggered.
• The entire 1254 Recapture Amount is carried over to the Replacement
Property.
EXAMPLESECTION 1254 RECAPTURE
Confidential and Proprietary ©2018 Vinson & Elkins LLP velaw.com 20
• Base Case with Boot and Non-Section 1254 Property
– Taxpayer exchanges a working interest in one oil and gas lease with an
adjusted tax basis of $0 and a FMV of $100 for a working interest in
another oil and gas lease with a FMV of $50, an interest in ranch land
held for investment with a FMV of $40 and $10 cash. Both of the oil and
gas leases are developed. Taxpayer had taken $80 of IDCs and $20 of
depletion on the relinquished lease.
• Taxpayer recognizes $10 of gain under Section 1031 (to the extent of the boot),
and recaptures $50 as ordinary income under Section 1254 notwithstanding
that the $40 interest in ranch land is real property that is like-kind to the
taxpayer’s Relinquished Property
• What result if, instead of acquiring ranch land, the taxpayer acquired an
undeveloped oil and gas lease?
EXAMPLESECTION 1254 RECAPTURE
Confidential and Proprietary ©2018 Vinson & Elkins LLP velaw.com 21
• Real property is generally considered to be like-kind to other real
property despite significant differences in the nature of the properties
• Exception: Real property located in the United States and real
property located outside of the United States are not of “like kind.”
I.R.C. Section 1031(h)
• State law treatment is not controlling for purposes of determining
whether oil and gas interests are “real property” for purposes of
Section 1031
IN GENERALWHAT IS REAL PROPERTY?
Confidential and Proprietary ©2018 Vinson & Elkins LLP velaw.com 22
• Examples of exchanges of like-kind real property involving upstream
oil and gas interests:
– Undivided interest in unimproved real estate for overriding oil and gas
royalty interests (G.C.M. 34651 (Oct. 20, 1971))
– Mineral properties for an undivided interest in a hotel (Comm’r v. Crichton,
122 F.2d 181 (5th Cir. 1941))
– Working interests in two leases (Rev. Rul. 68-186, 1968-1 C.B. 354)
– An interest in a producing lease of an oil deposit in place for a fee interest
in an improved ranch (Rev. Rul. 68-331, 1968-1 C.B. 352)
• All of these examples involve oil and gas interests that are an
unlimited economic interest in oil and gas in place
– Palmer v. Bender, 287 U.S. 551 (1933)
UPSTREAM OIL AND GAS INTERESTSWHAT IS REAL PROPERTY?
Confidential and Proprietary ©2018 Vinson & Elkins LLP velaw.com 23
• Production payments and other limited oil and gas interests are not
considered real property for federal income tax purposes; instead, production
payments are generally treated as debt obligations. I.R.C. Section 636(a)
• Treas. Reg. Section 1.636-3 defines production payments as:
– a right to a specified share of the production from the mineral in place (if, as, and
when produced), or the proceeds from such production
– such right must be an economic interest in such mineral in place
– such right must have an expected economic life (at the time of its creation) of
shorter duration than the economic life of the mineral properties burdened thereby
• Test: Such right is not reasonably expected to extend in substantial amounts over the
entire productive life of such mineral property
– a production payment may be limited by:
• a dollar amount (e.g., dollar-denominated production payment)
• a quantum of mineral (e.g., volumetric production payment)
• a period of time
TAX TRAP: PRODUCTION PAYMENTSWHAT IS REAL PROPERTY?
Confidential and Proprietary ©2018 Vinson & Elkins LLP velaw.com 24
• Examples of exchanges of interests that do not qualify as like-kind
real property for purposes of Section 1031:
– Limited oil payment right for an overriding royalty reserved from the same
lease (Midfield Oil Co., 39 B.T.A. 1154 (1954))
– Carved-out oil payment rights of limited duration for a fee interest in a
ranch (Fleming v. Comm’r, 24 T.C. 818 (1955))
– Lease for a stated amount of oil to be recovered from other lands or
leases of the other parties to the transaction (Bandini Petroleum Co., 10
CCH TCM 999 (1951))
• Taxpayers should be cautious in effecting a Section 1031 exchange
where the Relinquished Properties or Replacement Properties may
include limited interests
TAX TRAP: PRODUCTION PAYMENTSWHAT IS REAL PROPERTY?
Confidential and Proprietary ©2018 Vinson & Elkins LLP velaw.com 25
• The taxpayer that transfers the Relinquished Property must receive
(or be deemed to receive) the Replacement Property
• Disregarded entities are disregarded from their owner for this
purpose; the owner is treated as the taxpayer transferring and
receiving the properties
– This allows a taxpayer to use different disregarded entities to transfer the
Relinquished Property and to acquire the Replacement Property
– To the extent multiple Replacement Properties are received, each
Replacement Property can be held in a separate disregarded entity
– Also applies to qualified Subchapter S subsidiaries
DISREGARDED ENTITIES SAME TAXPAYER REQUIREMENT
Confidential and Proprietary ©2018 Vinson & Elkins LLP velaw.com 26
• Section 1031 does not apply to exchanges of partnership interests.
I.R.C. Section 1031(a)(2)
• By default, jointly owned operating oil and gas interests are treated
as held by a tax partnership for federal income tax purposes under
Section 761(a)
• Diligence should be undertaken to confirm that the Relinquished
Property is not (and the Replacement Property will not be) treated as
held in a tax partnership, prior to effecting a 1031 exchange
TAX TRAPTAX PARTNERSHIPS
Confidential and Proprietary ©2018 Vinson & Elkins LLP velaw.com 27
• A valid election can be made to exclude a joint ownership
arrangement from the application of Subchapter K of the Code under
Section 761
• If a valid election is in place, a co-owner can exchange its jointly held
assets in an exchange that qualifies under Section 1031
• In order to be eligible to elect out:
– Parties must own the property as co-owners
– Each party must have the right to separately take in kind or dispose of its
share of any property produced, extracted or used
– Any delegations of authority to sell a co-owner’s share of property
produced or extracted must be only for such reasonable periods of time
as are consistent with the minimum needs of the industry, but in no event
for a period in excess of one year
– If property will produce natural gas, any imbalances must be resolved
using the cumulative gas balancing method
ELECTING OUTTAX PARTNERSHIPS
Confidential and Proprietary ©2018 Vinson & Elkins LLP velaw.com 28
• The IRS may challenge an election out made immediately prior to a
like-kind exchange
– IRS challenged exchange transactions in which the Relinquished
Property was received by the taxpayer as a distribution from an entity
prior the exchange on the basis that the Relinquished Property was not
“held for productive use in a trade or business or for investment” at the
time of the exchange (Rev. Rul. 77-337, 1977-2 C.B. 305)
• For a comprehensive discussion of the swap-and-drop and drop-and-
swap authorities, see Richard M. Lipton, Samuel P. Grilli & Samuel
Pollack, The ‘State of the Art’ in Like-Kind Exchanges-2015, 124 J.
Tax’n 5 (2016) and Richard M. Lipton & Leah J. Gruen, The ‘State of
the Art’ in Like-Kind Exchanges, 2012, 116 J. Tax’n 246 (2012)
RISKSTAX PARTNERSHIPS
Confidential and Proprietary ©2018 Vinson & Elkins LLP velaw.com 29
• Retention of a royalty or ORRI in connection with the sale of a working
interest is a common problem
– Buyer and Taxpayer have negotiated a package of assets with a targeted NRI, but Taxpayer
determines it has a greater NRI in certain assets within the package
– Taxpayer may believe that buyers will not properly value an NRI in excess of the target NRI
– Taxpayer desires to retain potential upside in the play
• Retention of an ORRI in connection with the sale of a working interest
causes the transaction to be treated as a lease or sublease for federal
income tax purposes (rather than a sale or exchange). Rev. Rul. 69-352,
1969-1 C.B. 34.
– Upfront proceeds are treated as advanced royalties/lease bonus
• Ordinary income
• No basis offset
– Cannot qualify as an exchange of property for purposes of Section 1031. Crooks v. Comm’r, 92
T.C. 816 (1989).
• Sale v. lease is determined on a property by property basis. Cullen v.
Comm’r, 118 F.2d 651 (5th Cir. 1941).
TAX TRAPRETAINING AN OVERRIDING ROYALTY INTEREST
Confidential and Proprietary ©2018 Vinson & Elkins LLP velaw.com 30
• Retain a production payment instead?
– Production payment is treated as a debt obligation or a loan rather than
an economic interest
– Risk: Must establish that the production payment is “not reasonably . . .
expected to extend in substantial amounts over the entire production life
of such mineral property.” (Rev. Rul. 86-119, 1986-2 C.B. 81)
• Carve off an overriding royalty interests and convey it to a separate
regarded affiliate of the taxpayer?
– There is very little authority on this structure
– IRS may apply a substance over form or step transaction theory to argue
that the transaction should still be treated as a leasing transaction
• Not clear how much time must elapse between ORRI conveyance and
disposition of WI
• Should have a meaningful non-tax business purpose for holding royalty
interests or ORRIs in a separate legal entity, but not clear what types of non-tax
business purposes are sufficient
POTENTIAL SOLUTIONS?RETAINING AN OVERRIDING ROYALTY INTEREST
Confidential and Proprietary ©2018 Vinson & Elkins LLP velaw.com 31
• Treasury Regulations Section 1.1031(k)-1 in the forward exchange context
(the “Forward Exchange Regs”) require the identification of potential
Replacement Properties in a forward exchange to be:
– Made in a written document
– Signed by the taxpayer
– Sent to the QI prior to the end of the 45-day identification period
– Description must unambiguously describe the property
• Real property is unambiguously described if a legal description is provided,
an address is provided, or it is described by a distinguishable name
• No specific guidelines for identifying oil and gas assets
– Oil and gas assets must be described so that they may not be mistaken for other
properties or assets
– Oil and gas assets should be identified using the same level of specificity that the
leases and wells exhibits to a standard purchase and sale agreement would
provide
TAX TRAP: UNAMBIGUOUSLY IDENTIFYING OIL AND GAS PROPERTIESIDENTIFYING OIL AND GAS PROPERTIES
Confidential and Proprietary ©2018 Vinson & Elkins LLP velaw.com 32
• The Forward Exchange Regs provide two key rules for identifying
multiple or alternative Replacement Properties in a deferred forward
exchange:
– Three Property Rule: Taxpayer may identify up to three properties of
any value as part of the same deferred exchange (regardless of the
number of properties relinquished).
– 200% Rule: Taxpayer may identify any number of properties as long as
their aggregate FMV as of the end of the 45-day identification period
does not exceed 200% of the aggregate FMV of all the relinquished
properties as of the date the relinquished properties were transferred by
the taxpayer.
TAX TRAP: IDENTIFYING MULTIPLE REPLACEMENT PROPERTIESIDENTIFYING OIL AND GAS PROPERTIES
Confidential and Proprietary ©2018 Vinson & Elkins LLP velaw.com 33
• Three Property Rule
– Oil and gas properties sometimes involve tens or hundreds of leases
spanning multiple counties and even multiple states
– It is not clear what a single “property” means for purposes of Section
1031
– In an acquisition involving multiple leases, is each lease a separate
property?
– In the depletion context, Section 614 defines “property” as “each
separate interest owned by the taxpayer in each mineral deposit in each
separate tract or parcel of land.”
• Can a taxpayer rely on the Section 614 definition (and the separation and
aggregation elections thereunder) for purposes of Section 1031?
TAX TRAP: IDENTIFYING MULTIPLE REPLACEMENT PROPERTIESIDENTIFYING OIL AND GAS PROPERTIES
Confidential and Proprietary ©2018 Vinson & Elkins LLP velaw.com 34
• Because of these uncertainties and lack of authority, taxpayers
should not rely on the Three Property Rule
• More prudent approach is to identify Replacement Properties that
satisfy the 200% Rule
• This trap is also present in the reverse exchange context, where the
taxpayer may identify multiple potential Relinquished Properties,
which may consist of multiple leases
TAX TRAP: IDENTIFYING MULTIPLE REPLACEMENT PROPERTIESIDENTIFYING OIL AND GAS PROPERTIES
Confidential and Proprietary ©2018 Vinson & Elkins LLP velaw.com 35
• A reverse exchange is straight forward if the parked Replacement
Property consists of solely non-operating interests
• Replacement property may be parked with an EAT for up to 180 days
• What if the Replacement Property consists of operating interests or
the taxpayer intends to develop the property during the parking
period?
– Taxpayer is not entitled to deduct IDCs or depletion or take depreciation
deductions with respect to the property until after the Replacement
Property is acquired by the taxpayer
• This is a consideration to take into account in determining the
potential cost of structuring into a reverse like-kind exchange
TAX TRAP: DEVELOPING “PARKED” ACREAGEREVERSE EXCHANGES UNDER REV. PROC. 2000-37
Confidential and Proprietary ©2018 Vinson & Elkins LLP velaw.com 36
Confidential and Proprietary ©2018 Vinson & Elkins LLP velaw.com
Austin
T +1.512.542.8400
Beijing
T +86.10.6414.5500
Dallas
T +1.214.220.7700
Dubai
T +971.4.330.1800
Hong Kong
T +852.3658.6400
Houston
T +1.713.758.2222
London
T +44.20.7065.6000
Moscow
T +7.495.544.5800
New York
T +1.212.237.0000
Palo Alto
T +1.650.687.8200
Richmond
T +1.804.327.6300
Riyadh
T +966.11.250.0800
San Francisco
T +1.415.979.6900
Taipei
T +886.2.2176.5388
Tokyo
T +81.3.3282.0450
Washington
T +1.202.639.6500
QUESTIONSJulia Pashin
jpashin@velaw.com
214-220-7883
Megan James
meganjames@velaw.com
214-220-7781
top related