capitalization policies and strategies - cooperative.com · 2019-08-13 · capitalization policies...

Capitalization Policies and Strategies

Jason Peacock, CPA|CITPPartner, Utilities Group

Tucker LemleyVP of Finance and Administration

Outline

• What is Capitalization?• What is Everyone Doing?• What Do I Need in My Capitalization Policy?• What Does the Guidance Say?

Why Do We Capitalize Assets?

• To Spread the Cost of an Assets Over a Period for Which it Will Produce an Economic Benefit

Why Is a Capitalization Policy Important?

• To Ensure Proper Treatment of Purchases and Ensure Compliance• To Simplify the Capitalization Process• To Meet Operational and Long-Term Strategic Goals

Capitalization: The Concept

• Matching Principal• Match the Cost (Depreciation

Expense) with Benefit• The Assets Provide Economic

Benefits Beyond the Current Year• There is a Link Between the Assets

and Future Revenues• Expense Asset Over the Estimated

Useful Life

Benefits Costs

Electric Cooperative Capitalization Survey

• 45 Responses• 16 States• Average Meter Count - 77,376

• Smallest Coop – 4,108• Largest Coop – 236,992

• Average Total Utility Plant - $408,704,605• Smallest TUP - $31,526,144• Largest TUP - $1,245,921,733

• Average Depreciation Reserve - 32%• Lowest Reserve – 17%• Highest Reserve – 54%

RUS Borrowers vs. RUS Guidance

26, 58%

19, 42%

RUS BORROWER

YES

NO

38, 84%

7, 16%

RUS DEPRECIATION RATES

YES

NO

Depreciation Studies

16, 36%

29, 64%

COMPLETED DEPRECIATION STUDY IN THE PAST 10 YEAR

YES

NO

36%

64%

IF NO, DO YOU PLAN ON COMPLETING ONE IN THE NEXT 3

YEARS

YES

NO

Depreciation

12, 27%

33, 73%

RUS CURVE FROM BULLETIN 183-1

YES

NO

• Bulletin 183-1• General Depreciation Guidelines

for RUS Borrowers• Has not been significantly updated

in 40 years

Depreciation – Bulletin 183-1

2000

2010

20152018

Capitalization Strategies

0

2

4

6

8

10

12

14

16

18

1-LessAggressive

2 3 4 5-MostAggressive

Capitalization Strategy

Capitalization Strategy

1 2 3 4 5 6

<20%

20%-25%

25%-30%

30%-35%

>35%

Capitalization Strategy

Labo

r Cap

italiz

atio

n Gr

oup

Capitalization Strategy vs. Labor Capitalization Rate

Capitalizing Interest

6, 13%

39, 87%

DOES YOUR COOPERATIVE CAPITALIZE INTEREST?

YES

NO3, 50%3, 50%

WHAT PROCESS IS USED TO CAPITALIZE INTEREST?

AFUDC

ICC

Special Equipment Treatment

39, 87%

6, 13%

METERS

YES

NO

32, 71%

13, 29%

TRANSFORMERS

YES

NO

General Plant Capitalization Threshold

5

18

14

7

1

0

2

4

6

8

10

12

14

16

18

20

$ Threshold to Capitalize

$ Threshold to Capitalize

17, 38%

28, 62%

CATEGORICAL EXCLUSION ?

YES

NO

Industry Benchmarking

• #123 – TUP Investment per Consumer ($)• #95 – Depreciation Expense as a % of TUP• #112 – Capitalized Payroll/Total Payroll %• #114 – Annual Growth in kWh Sold• #122 – TUP per kWh Sold• #123 – TUP per Consumer• #124 – TUP per Mile of Line

KRTAs – CFC Key Ratio Trend Analysis

Capitalization per Consumer ($)

Capitalization per Employee ($)

TUP Benchmarking

Labor Capitalization

A Capitalization Policy Should:

• Clearly Denote the Purpose• Aim to Achieve Uniformity• Clearly Define the Definition of a Fixed Asset• Clearly Provide Guidelines

• Threshold• Cost or Costs to be Capitalized• Asset Life (Depreciable Life)• Residual Value (If Any)• Classification of Asset

• Describe the Depreciation Method to be Employed• Outline Costs to be Expensed (Repairs and Maintenance)• Establish Procedures for Retirement of Assets

CAPI

TALI

ZATI

ON

U.S. GAAPASC 360, Property, Plant and Equipment

ASC 835-20, Capitalization of InterestASC 410, Asset Retirement and Environmental Obligations

Industry Specific GuidanceFERC Uniform System of Accounts (18 CFR 101)RUS Uniform System of Accounts (7 CFR 1767)

Internal Revenue Code (IRC)IRC Section 162IRC Section 263

Capitalization Under U.S. GAAP

• U.S. GAAP Requires the Capitalization of Cost When a Future Benefit for an Expenditure Exists

• An Asset Provides a Benefit Beyond the Current Year• An Asset has an Expected Useful Life of More than One Year

• U.S. GAAP Allows the Capitalization of Expenditures to Bring an Asset into Service (shipping, installation, etc.)

• The Cost of Maintaining Assets Cannot be Capitalized

Costs of Capital Assets

• Assets Purchased• Purchase Price

• Internally Constructed Assets• Cost to the Utility/Cooperative

• Direct Labor & Benefits• Indirect Labor & Benefits• Materials and Supplies• Transportation and Equipment Costs• Contract Labor

FERC and RUS Capitalization Procedures

• Electric Plant Should be Recorded at Cost• Stated on the Basis of Cost to the Utility – Purchased or Constructed

• Reduced by Contribution-in-Aid of Construction• Specifically, electric plant accounts shall not include the cost or other

value of electric plant contributed to the company. Plant constructed from contributions of cash or its equivalent shall be shown as a reduction to gross plant constructed.

• When the consideration given for property is other than cash, the value of such consideration shall be determined on a cash basis

Electric Utility Plant (Distribution Cooperative)

Distribution Plant• Land and Land Rights• Structure and Improvements• Station Equipment• Poles, Towers and Fixtures• Overhead Conductors• Underground Conductors• Line Transformers• Meters

General Plant• Land and Land Rights• Structures and Improvements• Office Furniture and Equipment• Transportation Equipment• Stores Equipment• Tool, Shop, & Garage Equipment• Power Operated Equipment• Communication Equipment

Distribution Plant - Components of Construction Cost Shall Include When Applicable: • Contract Work• Labor• Materials and Supplies• Transportation• Special Machine Service• Shop Service• Protection• Injuries and Damages• Privileges and Permits• Rents• Engineering and Supervision

• General Admin Capitalized• Engineering Services• Insurance• Law Expenditures• Taxes• Allowance for Funds Used During

Construction (Interest)• Earnings and Expenses During

Construction• Training Costs• Studies• Asset Retirement

Allowance for Funds Used During Construction: Capitalized Interest

• Ai = Gross allowance for borrowed funds used during construction rate.

• Ac = Allowance for other funds used during construction rate.

• S = Average short-term debt.

• s = Short-term debt interest rate.

• D = Long-term debt.

• d = Long-term debt interest rate.

• P = Preferred stock.

• p = Preferred stock cost rate.

• C = Patronage capital assigned.

• c = Entity's incremental borrowing rate.

• W = Average balance in construction work in progress plus nuclear fuel in process of refinement, conversion, enrichment, and fabrication, less asset retirement costs related to plant under construction.

Capitalization of Interest During Construction

• Allowance for Funds Used During Construction Includes the Net Cost for the Period of Construction of Borrowed Funds Used for Construction Purposes and Reasonable Rate on Other Funds When So Used.

• The Rates Shall be Determined Annually.• Interest Cannot be Capitalized on Projects which Have Been

Abandoned.• Capitalization of Interest is Not Allowed Once Plant is Placed Into

Service.

Special Equipment Accounting

• Why is it Special? • Items are classified as such because they are continually being moved from

one location to another due to changes in load and maintenance practices.• Meters• Transformers• Oil Circuit Reclosures• Line Regulators

• Special Equipment is Capitalized When Purchased• Capitalized with the Estimated Cost of Installation (All Costs Necessary to

Install the Equipment [1st Installation] and Prepare the Equipment for Use)• All Subsequent Costs are Expensed

Maintenance vs. Capitalization

• Does the expenditure create a future benefit?• Does the expenditure constitute a retirement unit?

• Per FERC and RUS, the cost of replacing items that do not constitute a retirement unit should be charged to maintenance.

• Must be able to remove the old asset from the books in order to add the replacement to the books.

Maintenance vs. Capitalization

RUS Accounting Procedure 127 –Continuing Property Records for Buildings

When establishing continuing property records for a building where there is no detailed breakdown of contract costs, it is necessary to estimate the cost of each component part.

It should be noted that the establishment of continuing property records is not required for buildings; however, if CPRs are not maintained, all repairs including the replacement of major component parts shall be expensed in the period incurred.

Depreciation

• Method – Must Allocate in a Systematic and Rational Manner the Service Value of Depreciable Property Over the Service Life of the Property.

• Service Lives – Estimated Useful Service Lives Must Be Supported by Engineering, Economic, and Other Depreciation Studies.

• Rate – Must use percentage rates of depreciation that are based on a method of depreciation that allocates in a systematic and rational manner the service value of depreciable property to the service life of the property.

RUS Bulletin 183-1

• Revised: October 28, 1977• Based on a review of “current”

industry depreciation rates and practices

• Provides depreciation rates for generation, transmission, distribution, and general plant.

Questions