big baby webinar

Big Baby Webinar

Rebecca Dekker, PhD, RN, APRNFounder, Evidence Based Birth®

Big Baby

Is “big baby” a big problem in your

community?

1) Cochrane Review

2) New RCT

3) Most pressing questions

Big Baby

Disclaimer

▪ Watching this webinar does not mean that we have entered into a patient-care provider relationship

▪ Nothing in this course shall be construed as medical advice

▪ Talk with a care provider before putting this information into practice

▪ Content is not guaranteed to be 100% accurate or up to date

One of my big babies…

Big Baby

We will cover:

▪ The new Cochrane review

▪ The new RCT

▪ EBB resources for learning more

▪ Your questions

▪ Your handout

Sound good? Type “Yes” in the chat!

Free Printer Friendly PDF!

Big Baby

Cochrane Review

Big Baby

Why do you think the results changed?

Big Baby

▪ In 2012, 1 in 3 U.S. women had their labor induced

▪ Most common reasons?

Declercq et al. Listening to Mothers SM III. New York: Childbirth Connection, May 2013.

1. Baby was full term or it was close to the due date 44%

2. Mother wanted to get pregnancy over with 19%

3. Care giver concerned that mom was overdue 18%

4. Mother had a health problem that required quick delivery 18%

5. Care provider concern about the size of the baby 16%

6. Water had broken and there was concern about infection 12%

Problems with estimating size..

▪ 98% of ultrasounds will be within 15% +/- of the baby’s actual birth weight

▪ If an ultrasound says your baby is going to weigh 8 lbs 15 oz or larger, 50% of the time it is right and 50% of the time it is wrong

▪ Haave to induce a lot of women early… and some of those women will NOT have had big babies!

Big Baby

Cochrane Review: Induction▪ Cochrane review of 4 RCTs

▪ 1,190 women with suspected big babies

▪ Randomly assigned to induction at 37-40 wks or not

▪ Results?▪ No difference in Cesarean rates, vacuum, or forceps

▪ Decrease in shoulder dystocia (absolute risk went from 6.8% to 4.1%)

▪ Decrease in collarbone fractures (2% down to 0.4%)

▪ Increase in severe perineal tears (0.7% vs 2.6%)Boulvain et al. (2016).

Cochrane Database Syst Rev(5): CD000938.

Big Baby

What about brachial plexus palsy?▪ No differences between groups in actual brachial plexus

injury rates▪ Such a rare event, would need a huge study to show a difference

▪ Also no corresponding decrease in NICU admissions or low Apgar scores

▪ Increased use of phototherapy for jaundice (11% vs 7%)

Boulvain et al. (2016). Cochrane Database Syst Rev(5): CD000938.

Big Baby

In Summary▪ Cochrane review was based heavily on two trials;

one of them just recently published

▪ Found a trade-off– lower rates of shoulder dystocia, higher rates of perineal tears

▪ Shoulder dystocia in itself is not a bad outcome, it’s considered a “surrogate” outcome

Big Baby

Questions about Cochrane Review?

New Randomized

Trial

Big Baby

What problems do you think researchers might run into when doing a study about induction for

suspected big babies?

Big Baby

▪ Women must weigh pros and cons of early induction with suspected big babies

▪ The risk/benefit profile may look different for different women!

Big Baby

▪ Careful when applying research from one population to another population (ex. VBAC moms)

▪ Coercion and bullying have no place in maternity care!

Big Baby

New Randomized Trial (2015)

▪ 818 women with singleton babies who were estimated to weigh in the 95th% at 36-38 weeks

▪ Randomly assigned to a) inducing labor at 37-38 weeks or b) waiting until 41 weeks

▪ Cross-over between groups▪ 11% of induction group had spontaneous labor

▪ 28% of waiting group were induced

Big Baby

Results from New Trial▪ Fewer cases of shoulder dystocia in induction group

(1% vs. 4%)

▪ No brachial plexus injuries in either group

▪ More jaundice in induction group (9% vs. 3%)

▪ No differences in NICU admission rates or any other newborn outcomes

Big Baby

Why did this RCT have different results from previous RCT?▪ New study: ▪ Larger study

▪ Researchers claimed better at predicting big babies

▪ Induced earlier (37-38 weeks)

▪ Some have said the diagnosis of shoulder dystocia is too subjective (and not blinded)

Big Baby

Questions about Randomized Trial?

Big Baby

Any other pressing questions?

Big Baby

In Summary…

Big Baby

Resources for You

Big Baby

Big Baby

Signature Article on Big Babies

Big Baby

Ebbirth.com/BigBaby

Big Baby

Where can Parents learn more?

Big Baby

Big Baby

Where can Professionals learn more?

Big Baby

Big Baby

EBB Professional Membership

Big Baby

▪ Professionals who want to change the world!

▪ Earn relevant CEUs in an inter-professional environment

▪ Support the work of EBB

Big Baby

What is included in your membership?

Big Baby

▪ All our continuing education courses

▪ Live monthly trainings (+ recordings!)

▪ Private community▪ Library ▪ Access to Rebecca

Big Baby

Continuing Education for…

Big Baby

▪ Nurses

▪ Doulas

▪ Childbirth educators

▪ CPMs, CNMs, CMs

▪ Midwifery Bridge Certificate (17 hours)

▪ Physicians

Big Baby

Available Courses

Big Baby

▪ Help Families get Evidence Based Care (8 hours, 0.7 ACNM CEUs, 8 AAFP credits)

▪ Big Babies & Gestational Diabetes (3 hours, 0.3 ACNM CEUs, 3 AAFP credits)

▪ Due Dates & Advanced Maternal Age (3 hours, 0.3 ACNM CEUs, 3 AAFP credits)

Big Baby

Available Courses

Big Baby

▪ Failure to Progress (2 hours, 0.2 ACNM CEUs, 2 AAFP credits)

▪ Vitamin K & Eye Ointment (2 hours, 0.2 ACNM Pharm CEUs, 2 AAFP credits)

▪ Overturning Hospital Bans (3 hours)

Big Baby

How to Join?

Big Baby

Big Baby

Membership Options

Big Baby

Big Baby

How to Join?

Big Baby

Big Baby

Scholarships

Big Baby

▪ Scholarships for midwifery, nursing, and medical students

▪ University subscriptions ($30/student per semester)

▪ Scholarships for persons of color

Big Baby

Question & Answer

Big Baby

Big Baby

Handout

Big Baby

Big Baby

Thank You!

Big Baby