beyond legal mechanisms — employment, housing, and other related critical support
Post on 08-Apr-2018
220 Views
Preview:
TRANSCRIPT
8/7/2019 Beyond Legal Mechanisms — Employment, Housing, and Other Related Critical Support
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/beyond-legal-mechanisms-employment-housing-and-other-related-critical 1/22
©COPYRIGHT 2010 BY IICLE. 6S — 1
Beyond Legal Mechanisms —Employment, Housing, andOther Related CriticalSupport
JODINA HICKSMICHAEL SWEIGSafer FoundationChicago
6
8/7/2019 Beyond Legal Mechanisms — Employment, Housing, and Other Related Critical Support
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/beyond-legal-mechanisms-employment-housing-and-other-related-critical 2/22
ILLINOIS CRIMINAL RECORDS: EXPUNGEMENT AND OTHER RELIEF — SUPPLEMENT
6S — 2 WWW.IICLE.COM
I. [6.1] Introduction
II. Employment
A. [6.2] General Barriers
B. Employment Issues To Review with Client
1. [6.3] Review Criminal Background Check
2. [6.4] Impact of Criminal Record on Specific Industries
3. [6.5] Discussing Criminal History with Employers
4. [6.6] Hiring Incentives Available to Employers
a. [6.7] Immunity for Employers Hiring Employees with a Certificate of
Rehabilitation
b. [6.8] Tax Incentives
c. [6.9] Bonding
d. [6.10] Other Financial Assistance
e. [6.11] Support Organizations
5. [6.12] Disincentive to Employers — Employer Liability
6. [6.13] Employment Rights of People with Criminal Records
7. Preparation for Job Market
a. [6.14] Getting Assistance
b. [6.15] Civic Engagement
c. [6.16] State Identification
d. [6.17] Employment Information Sources
III. Housing
A. [6.18] Exclusionary Policies
B. [6.19] Housing Issues To Review with Client
C. [6.20] Locating Housing Providers
IV. [6.21] Education
V. [6.22] Public Benefits Restrictions
A. [6.23] Temporary Assistance for Needy Families (TANF)
B. [6.24] MedicaidC. [6.25] Food Stamps
D. [6.26] Unemployment Insurance
VI. [6.27] Military Service
VII. [6.28] Voting and Political Engagement
8/7/2019 Beyond Legal Mechanisms — Employment, Housing, and Other Related Critical Support
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/beyond-legal-mechanisms-employment-housing-and-other-related-critical 3/22
BEYOND LEGAL MECHANISMS — EMPLOYMENT, HOUSING, AND OTHER RELATED CRITICAL SUPPORT §6.1
ILLINOIS INSTITUTE FOR CONTINUING LEGAL EDUCATION 6S — 3
I. [6.1] INTRODUCTION
About 700,000 people are released from state and federal prisons annually, and
approximately nine million are released from local jails. Allen J. Beck, The Importance of
Successful Reentry to Jail Population Growth, Jail Reentry Roundtable of the Urban Institute,
Washington, DC (June 27, 2006), www.urban.org/projects/reentry-roundtable/roundtable9.cfm.The number of people released from state prisons each year has been steadily increasing, from
slightly more than 600,000 in 2000 to more than 670,000 in 2004. See Paige M. Harrison and
Allen J. Beck, Prison and Jail Inmates at Midyear 2005, U.S. Department of Justice, Bureau of
Justice Statistics (May 2006), http://bjs.ojp.usdoj.gov/content/pub/pdf/pjim05.pdf.
In 1974, 1.8 million people, or 1.3 percent or the adult population, had served time. In 2001,
5.6 million people, or 2.7 percent of the adult population, had served time. The Department of
Justice estimates that if the 2001 imprisonment rate remains unchanged, 6.6 percent of Americans
born in 2001 will serve prison time during their lives. In addition to those who have served prison
time, an even larger proportion of the population has been convicted of a criminal offense without
going to prison. As of December, 2001, it was estimated that over 64 million people in the United
States, 30 percent of the nation’s adult population, had a rap sheet. United States Department of Justice, Office of Justice Programs, Bureau of Justice Statistics, Survey of State Criminal History
Information Systems, 2001 (Aug. 2003), http://bjs.ojp.usdoj.gov/index.cfm?ty=
pbdetail&iid=1089. According to a 2003 report of the Department of Justice, more than 71
million people, nearly 25 percent of the entire population, had some kind of a criminal record.
Office of Justice Programs, Attorney General Ashcroft Announces Nationwide Effort To
Reintegrate Offenders Back Into Communities, www.reentry.gov/ashcroftpr.html.
It may be generally accepted that people who are released from prison and return to the larger
society deserve a second chance. However, this second chance is laden with obstacles and
barriers that can develop into a seemingly insurmountable wall for those trying to navigate
prisoner reentry without support. Some of these obstacles are legally imposed collateral
consequences. According to an American Bar Association report on the collateral consequencesof conviction:
[W]hile some restrictions [on employment of convicted persons] are narrowly tailored
to protect against an identified public safety risk, more often they are categorical
and arbitrary, bearing little or no apparent relationship to particular offense
conduct, and without consideration of a particular individual’s post-conviction
rehabilitation. ABA, Commission on Effective Criminal Sanctions, Report to House of
Delegates (On Employment and Licensure of Persons with a Criminal Record), p. 4 (Feb.
2007), http://meetings.abanet.org/webupload/ommupload/CR209800/newsletterpubs/
Report.III.PDF.121306.pdf.
Other restrictions to critically needed employment and housing resources are imposed by
gatekeepers, such as employers and landlords, who are often hesitant to give people with records
a second chance. Consequently, those affected by the collateral consequences of conviction often
consider their criminal “confinement” to be life-long, no matter how short or long their actual
prison sentence.
8/7/2019 Beyond Legal Mechanisms — Employment, Housing, and Other Related Critical Support
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/beyond-legal-mechanisms-employment-housing-and-other-related-critical 4/22
§6.1 ILLINOIS CRIMINAL RECORDS: EXPUNGEMENT AND OTHER RELIEF — SUPPLEMENT
6S — 4 WWW.IICLE.COM
Prisoner reentry has progressed from a relatively new concept not sufficiently understood by
society at large. With the precipitous decline in the global, national, and local economies of the
late 2000s, the issue of prison reentry has taken center stage for policymakers, the media, and
direct service providers. Mass warehousing of prisoners is financially unaffordable and politically
problematic. With early release programs, rethinking sentencing and how to handle nonviolent
offenders (particularly nonviolent first-time offenders), diversion programs, alternativesentencing, and prison reentry have become primary social issues.
The challenging path from court to prison and back to society is not made any easier by
organized supportive services or resources for those seeking reentry, nor is it engineered by a
single or integrated set of agencies. It is up to the individual to navigate this path and reestablish
himself or herself after a criminal conviction, prison/jail time, or termination of home
confinement or probation. Too often the family of the person with a criminal record is left to
provide the support for that reentry effort. Also, it is well established that those affected by the
criminal justice system tend to be poor and from poor communities and families. For example,
more than half of the approximately 40,000 people leaving Illinois prisons who return to Chicago
annually end up in just 7 of the poorest of the city’s 77 neighborhoods. Rex W. Huppke, Ex-Cons
Flock to 7 Areas in Chicago: Jobs Scarce, Crime Prevalent, Study Finds, Chicago Tribune, NNWEd., Sept. 15, 2005, Metro Section, p. 4, available at http://articles.chicagotribune.com/2005-09-
15/news/0509150222_1_prisoner-re-entry-ex-offenders-illinois-department. The poorest
communities with the fewest resources are required to carry the weight of reentry with often
inadequate assistance or provision of resources.
While many efforts are underway to establish reentry services and systems, we are only
beginning to understand that every part of and every actor in the criminal justice system
(including public defenders, prosecutors, judges, and criminal defense lawyers) and public service
agencies must collaborate to establish and provide support to people during the reentry process.
Traditionally, these criminal justice actors were more concerned with the “front end,” i.e.,
determining guilt or innocence, establishing a plea, facilitating a speedy trial, and, in rare cases,
considering diversionary options.
It is becoming apparent to policy makers and criminal justice practitioners that the “back
end” of the process must be more fully understood to better represent clients and ensure that the
best interests of justice are served. In other words, clients and criminal justice actors must
understand the impact that each sentencing option has on the long-term career, housing, and other
challenges to future opportunities for their clients. For example, a public defender might
recommend a client take a plea that moves an attempt to distribute charge down to a drug
possession charge, but once legislative and administrative occupational impacts are reviewed, the
client may choose otherwise.
Indeed, awareness of the complexity and lifelong impact of collateral sanctions may and
perhaps even should create a new ethical consideration for criminal defense lawyers and
prosecutors. Also, legislation to address the issue is emerging, such as the Uniform Collateral
Consequences of Conviction Act, approved July 15, 2009, by the Uniform Law Commission
(ULC). See www.law.upenn.edu/bll/archives/ulc/ucsada/2009_final.htm.
8/7/2019 Beyond Legal Mechanisms — Employment, Housing, and Other Related Critical Support
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/beyond-legal-mechanisms-employment-housing-and-other-related-critical 5/22
BEYOND LEGAL MECHANISMS — EMPLOYMENT, HOUSING, AND OTHER RELATED CRITICAL SUPPORT §6.2
ILLINOIS INSTITUTE FOR CONTINUING LEGAL EDUCATION 6S — 5
While largely procedural, the provisions of the Act nonetheless are designed to rationalize
and clarify polices and provisions that are already accepted in the states in various degrees. The
Act includes provisions to ensure that defendants are aware of the existence of collateral
sanctions before conviction, are reminded of them at release, govern the effect of out-of-state
convictions, and provide the various means by which some offenders may obtain relief from
many such consequences. A perhaps unduly optimistic requirement of the Act, given the strainedstate coffers nationally, requires states that adopt the Act to collect in a single document all of the
collateral sanctions and disqualifications contained in state statutes or administrative regulations.
While at the time of this publication the Act has been introduced only in Wisconsin and
Oklahoma, the substance of the Act and the procedural safeguards it suggests can be an excellent
guide for judges, prosecutors, and criminal defense lawyers, even in states that have not formally
adopted the Act.
Criminal justice actors such as the Cook County State’s Attorney, the Cook County Public
Defender’s Offices, the Illinois Prisoner Review Board, and countless Illinois presiding judges
have become actively engaged and outspoken in both Illinois and national prisoner reentry
matters. Such matters include recommending diversionary options, establishing specialty courts
(e.g., drug court, domestic violence court, mental health court), supporting legislative relief (e.g.,expungement, sealing, certificates of rehabilitation, providing employer immunity for employing
holders of a certificate of rehabilitation). It is in the interest of public safety that this support for
the successful reentry and the removal of barriers has grown. It also reflects awareness that those
who have served their sentences want nothing more than to reestablish their lives and support
themselves and their families.
This chapter is written specifically for public defenders and criminal defense lawyers. While
focusing on the legal matters facing clients, the practitioner should understand the impact of the
criminal record on employment, housing, and other areas of importance to the client. Indeed, the
practitioner may be able to provide assistance to the client before, after, or outside of sentencing,
expungement, sealing, and certificate of rehabilitation processes that will strengthen the client’s
chances for long-term success, particularly in the employment arena.
II. EMPLOYMENT
A. [6.2] General Barriers
People with criminal records face multiple barriers to employment. Some of these barriers
come in the form of legislatively mandated prohibitions ranging from obtaining various
occupational licenses to maintaining certain distances from patients, the elderly, or children. In
Illinois alone, there are 57 statutes that limit licensing of 65 occupations and professions. Council
of Advisors to Reduce Recidivism through Employment (CARRE), Certificates of Relief from
Disabilities: Implementation and Tracking: Full Report (Nov. 2006), www.saferfoundation.org/
docs/15-crd_implementation_full_report_final.pdf. Other barriers come in the form of
governmental administrative rules or policies set by insurance companies to exclude people with
specific criminal offenses on their record.
8/7/2019 Beyond Legal Mechanisms — Employment, Housing, and Other Related Critical Support
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/beyond-legal-mechanisms-employment-housing-and-other-related-critical 6/22
§6.2 ILLINOIS CRIMINAL RECORDS: EXPUNGEMENT AND OTHER RELIEF — SUPPLEMENT
6S — 6 WWW.IICLE.COM
The State of Illinois has continued to recognize the collateral consequences of having a
criminal record with the passage of progressive legislation that provides important relief. One
example is P.A. 96-852 (eff. Jan. 1, 2010). The new law involves an amendment to the Illinois
Administrative Code and the Illinois Criminal Code, the key points of which are as follows:
1. The circuit court that entered a sentence of conviction, and no longer the Prisoner ReviewBoard, now has exclusive jurisdiction to grant certificates of rehabilitation.
2. The law expands eligibility as to who may prove their rehabilitation and receive a
certificate of relief from disabilities (no waiting period for occupational licensing) and certificate
of good conduct (three-year waiting period for relief from general, non-licensing employment
bars for felons, one-year waiting period for misdemeanants).
3. Even violent and non-probationable offenses may be eligible for relief.
4. The only eligibility limitations are
a. more than two felonies;
b. a Class X felony;
c. any felony that resulted in “great bodily harm or permanent disability” (730 ILCS
5/5-5.5-5);
d. conviction for aggravated DUI or aggravated domestic battery; and
e. offenses that require post-release registration (sex offenses, offenses against children,
rape, arson, etc).
5. Employers have immunity from third-party claims if they have hired the holder of acertificate of relief or certificate of good conduct.
6. Before a person with a criminal record begins the licensing process, the Department of
Financial and Professional Regulation must now offer a free, non-binding advisory opinion as to
whether one’s criminal record will be a dispositive obstacle to licensing. The non-binding nature
of this advisory opinion allows the Department to deny a license if the person subsequently has
additional contact with the criminal justice system while he or she is also involved in obtaining
licensing education and taking the required examinations.
Other examples of helpful legislation that provides more limited relief are expungement and
sealing. However, the significant expansion of eligibility for certificates of rehabilitation and
healthcare waivers provide more relief because they involve transparency, unlike expungement
and sealing. For example, §40 of the Health Care Worker Background Check Act, 225 ILCS
46/40, allows an employer who might otherwise have been prohibited from doing so to hire a
client with a criminal record.
8/7/2019 Beyond Legal Mechanisms — Employment, Housing, and Other Related Critical Support
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/beyond-legal-mechanisms-employment-housing-and-other-related-critical 7/22
BEYOND LEGAL MECHANISMS — EMPLOYMENT, HOUSING, AND OTHER RELATED CRITICAL SUPPORT §6.3
ILLINOIS INSTITUTE FOR CONTINUING LEGAL EDUCATION 6S — 7
For more on the Illinois law of certificates of rehabilitation and the significant expansion of
eligibility, see Chapter 8.
NOTE: Public defenders and criminal lawyers should be aware of the career goals and
occupational background of a client when they consider plea agreements. It could be that a plea
agreement that carries less time (e.g., pleading down from a violent offense to a drug offense)could carry a lifelong impact on the client’s employment options. Also, practitioners who
represent clients in sealing proceedings should strongly consider the transparent opposite relief,
which is the certificate of rehabilitation. Essentially the same proof of rehabilitation required for a
certificate of rehabilitation is required to obtain a sealing, and for those non-sealable or non-
expungeable misdemeanors, a certificate of rehabilitation is the viable and practical relief. The
client must accept that he or she will have to “front” or advertise their criminal record, rather than
suppress it, but employers respond more positively to such honesty.
Employer prejudice can have an even greater impact on a client’s job opportunities than
legislative and administrative barriers or policies. Thus, it is always in the client’s interest to
disclose a criminal record and to be candid and frank about the circumstances. Both public and
private employers operate from their own experience, understanding, and bias toward people withcriminal histories. Too often, the result is that the employer decides to establish blanket hiring
policies that exclude people with a criminal background. The easy access that potential employers
have to information by way of Internet background checks, which are unregulated and often
faulty, forces those with criminal backgrounds (or those with names that match those with
criminal records) to disclose and discuss their background with potential employers.
B. Employment Issues To Review with Client
1. [6.3] Review Criminal Background Check
Just as all people should review their credit history annually to verify its accuracy, an
individual with a criminal record should review his or her criminal background check and rapsheet. In Illinois, a rap sheet, also known as a criminal record, is the record of arrests and
convictions in the state for persons 17 years old or older. Rap sheets are maintained by the Illinois
Department of State Police (ISP), Bureau of Identification. The Federal Bureau of Investigation
(FBI) is notified of all arrests by the ISP. While the ISP or FBI are recommended as the most
accurate source for employers to utilize, there are also websites that collect information and
generate criminal histories for employers, but they cannot be relied on for definitive accuracy.
Therefore, clients should pull their criminal history, as well as two or three other background
checks, so that they will have a clearer assessment of what is available to employers via
background check services.
Conviction information can be obtained from the ISP under the Illinois Uniform Conviction
Information Act (UCIA), 20 ILCS 2635/1, et seq.:
Illinois State Police, Division of Administration, Bureau of Identification
260 North Chicago Street
Joliet, IL 60431-1060
815-740-5160 ext. 2743
8/7/2019 Beyond Legal Mechanisms — Employment, Housing, and Other Related Critical Support
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/beyond-legal-mechanisms-employment-housing-and-other-related-critical 8/22
§6.3 ILLINOIS CRIMINAL RECORDS: EXPUNGEMENT AND OTHER RELIEF — SUPPLEMENT
6S — 8 WWW.IICLE.COM
In Cook County, to obtain a Chicago Police Department rap sheet, the client can go to the
Chicago Police headquarters, 3510 South Michigan Avenue, between the hours of 8 a.m. and
noon, Monday through Friday. The fee for non-fingerprint conviction information is $16, and the
fee for fingerprint conviction information is $20. The client should return several days later to
pick up the documents. Information request forms can be ordered from the ISP website,
www.isp.state.il.us/services/uciaformreq.cfm. For information on how to clear mistakes in the rapsheet, see www.ides.state.il.us/exoffenders/rap.asp. See also the Legal Action Center’s manual,
HOW TO GET AND CLEAN UP YOUR ILLINOIS RAP SHEET, www.lac.org/doc_library/lac/
publications/050542_il_rap1.pdf.
Clients and their lawyers should be prepared to help correct or clear any inaccuracies in the
record. Not all background agencies update their records promptly. The client may want to
address any inaccuracies in the criminal records through a letter of explanation that can be
provided when seeking employment. Reviewing the rap sheet is also helpful to prepare for job
interviews, as many times people forget past convictions.
While accuracy, honesty, and the chance to discuss the record are critical aspects of the
employment process, the record ultimately can be tested and determined definitively only byaccessing and reviewing one’s court dispositions to assess whether these are consistent with the
rap sheet.
Court dispositions are found in the clerk’s office in the county where the case was tried. For
all Cook County cases, any clerk’s office will suffice (Room 1006 at the Daley Center, 5th Floor
at 26th Street, or any of the suburban district clerk’s offices — Skokie, Rolling Meadows,
Maywood, Bridgeview, and Markham). The cost is $9 per disposition, and the clerks may charge
a fee to look up the information, but there are free public access terminals that an individual can
use. All clerk’s offices are open 8:30 a.m. – 4:30 p.m.
For cases outside of Cook County, the client must go to the clerk of the court (at the
courthouse) in the county where they were convicted. Costs vary but approximate the Cook County fees. A person may call a clerk’s office to have information sent to them without making
the actual trip, but there are customarily additional fees for that service. Whether in person or by
phone, the client or lawyer should be sure to request a “certified disposition.”
It is not uncommon that a client is unclear as to where his or her conviction occurred, in
which case they should obtain an Illinois State Police (ISP) conviction report. The client should
call the ISP at 815-740-5160 to obtain information on where to get fingerprinted locally, so that
they may then access their information. The ISP contracts with private vendors to conduct the
fingerprinting, the charge for which is generally $20 – 30.
If a person’s conviction is from Chicago and before 1985, then a Chicago Police Department
rap sheet is necessary. The Cook County Clerk’s electronic system goes back only to 1984 or
1985, so the only way to know about earlier convictions and arrests is to get the rap sheet from
the Chicago Police headquarters, as referenced above.
8/7/2019 Beyond Legal Mechanisms — Employment, Housing, and Other Related Critical Support
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/beyond-legal-mechanisms-employment-housing-and-other-related-critical 9/22
BEYOND LEGAL MECHANISMS — EMPLOYMENT, HOUSING, AND OTHER RELATED CRITICAL SUPPORT §6.5
ILLINOIS INSTITUTE FOR CONTINUING LEGAL EDUCATION 6S — 9
2. [6.4] Impact of Criminal Record on Specific Industries
During the pretrial stage, a client should give serious and careful thought to the impact
various sentencing options may have on his or her future employment, particularly if he or she is
considering a plea bargain. Because it is a complex matter to obtain information about these
options, it is recommended that the public defender or criminal lawyer assist with gathering theinformation. If an occupational license is required for the client’s profession, then licensing and
legislative guidelines must be assessed, as well as licensing waiver guidelines. For example, a
person with a criminal record is excluded from having a barber’s license, but the Illinois
Department of Financial and Professional Regulations has a licensing waiver process, available to
anyone with a criminal history, no matter the number or type of offenses. Additionally, the State
of Illinois has a certificate of relief from disability that assists with a waiver process for those
with no more than two felony convictions. See Chapter 8.
If a business is regulated by the insurance industry, then insurance regulations should be
checked. For example, major insurance providers of the trucking industry typically impose
standards against hiring people with drug possession or DUI charges. Also, federal legislation
such as the Homeland Security Act of 2002, Pub.L. No. 107-296, 116 Stat. 2135, regulates hiringcriteria of specific occupation types and subtypes. The transportation of chemicals has an impact
on certain trucking jobs. State laws and city ordinances should also be reviewed. The highly
regulated healthcare industry excludes people with various offenses from being within a certain
distance of patients in nursing homes. Furthermore, while an employment position may be free of
legislative, administrative, and insurance regulations, it is possible that the industry itself has a
common practice to exclude people who have committed specific offenses. This is most likely to
occur when a few major employers dominate an industry. In such cases, it is relatively easy to
contact the human resource division of those employers and request copies of their hiring policies
or discuss the policies with the human relations officer.
3. [6.5] Discussing Criminal History with Employers
It is common for clients with criminal records to consider concealing or lying about their
criminal history. Employers emphatically recommend that applicants be honest. Employers are
more likely to hire someone who has discussed a criminal record than someone who has withheld
or lied about this information — information that is readily available through a criminal
background check. A client who has failed to disclose or lied is in a worse position (demotion or
termination) than one who has had a discussion during the hiring process. Discovery can come
about during a routine check run due to a policy change, an employer change, or a buyout or
when promotional paperwork is submitted for the personnel file.
The client should practice talking about his or her criminal history. The client should not
“over-discuss” his or her criminal history or prison experiences. For example, a client who
discusses a ten-year period in which there was a battle with addiction and involvement with the
criminal justice system is probably more acceptable to a potential employer than an applicant who
enumerates each sentence and elaborates on every prison term. A client who can explain what
was learned from the experience and imparts a sincere determination to be successful is more
likely to make a favorable impression. The client also should be prepared to talk about any work
8/7/2019 Beyond Legal Mechanisms — Employment, Housing, and Other Related Critical Support
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/beyond-legal-mechanisms-employment-housing-and-other-related-critical 10/22
§6.5 ILLINOIS CRIMINAL RECORDS: EXPUNGEMENT AND OTHER RELIEF — SUPPLEMENT
6S — 10 WWW.IICLE.COM
history or skills training gained in prison. Public defenders and criminal lawyers may be of great
assistance to their clients by helping prepare letters of explanation regarding criminal histories.
When well done, such a letter may also aid or even eliminate the need for lengthy discussion
during the interview.
The Chicago Jobs Council recommends that a client be prepared to answer the followingquestions:
a. What type of crime was committed?
b. How long ago was the conviction?
c. Are you getting assistance from an organization? If so, are there supports available?
d. Have you been drug tested recently?
e. Have you received supportive services, such as treatment or conflict resolution?
f. What are your employment-related assets, including employment history, educational
history, degrees and awards earned, and military service?
For additional information, go to the website for the Illinois Department of Employment
Security, www.ides.state.il.us, and click on “Re-Entry Services” in the menu bar or go to
www.ides.state.il.us/exoffenders/default.asp.
Clients should also understand that the topics to be discussed with Illinois employers include
only convictions that are not expunged or sealed.
Except with respect to law enforcement agencies, the Department of
Corrections, State’s Attorneys, or other prosecutors, and as provided in Section 13
of this Act, an expunged or sealed record may not be considered by any private or
public entity in employment matters, certification, licensing, revocation of
certification or licensure, or registration. 20 ILCS 2630/12(a).
Under the Illinois Human Rights Act, 775 ILCS 5/1-101, et seq., it is illegal for employers,
employment agencies, or labor organizations to ask about arrests or criminal history record
information that has been expunged or sealed, nor should clients offer this information. See
www.state.il.us/dhr/index.htm for more specific information on the Illinois Human Rights Act.
However, given that outdated or erroneous information is often available on the Internet via
background check companies, clients should determine whether expunged or sealed convictions
are shown and then decide whether to discuss that information with potential employers.
The job application process is further complicated because Illinois law does not state that it is
illegal for employers to ask, “Have you ever been arrested?” Potential employers may legally ask
about arrests even though they are permitted to receive information only on convictions in a
background check. The practitioner should advise clients on this matter before they fill out job
8/7/2019 Beyond Legal Mechanisms — Employment, Housing, and Other Related Critical Support
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/beyond-legal-mechanisms-employment-housing-and-other-related-critical 11/22
BEYOND LEGAL MECHANISMS — EMPLOYMENT, HOUSING, AND OTHER RELATED CRITICAL SUPPORT §6.8
ILLINOIS INSTITUTE FOR CONTINUING LEGAL EDUCATION 6S — 11
applications. If a client has been asked questions that are not legal or has been denied
employment on the basis of an arrest that did not lead to conviction, a complaint can be filed with
the Illinois Department of Human Rights. Additional information can be obtained at
www.state.il.us/dhr/index.htm.
Certain events during the 96th General Assembly in the Illinois legislature illustrate thechallenges in this area of criminal justice reform. The legislature failed to pass proposed
amendments to the Illinois Criminal Identification Act, 20 ILCS 2630/5.2, that would have sealed
records of (a) arrests or felony charges that resulted in acquittal or dismissal or did not result in
convictions and (b) convictions that were reversed or vacated.
4. [6.6] Hiring Incentives Available to Employers
There are a few benefits available to employers to counteract the stigma of a criminal record
and to encourage hiring. Clients should be aware of these incentives, discussed in §§6.7 – 6.11
below, because many employers are not. The ability to discuss these incentives or provide hard
copy information may provide a client with the competitive edge needed to prompt the offer of a
job.
a. [6.7] Immunity for Employers Hiring Employees with a Certificate of Rehabilitation
P.A. 96-852 (eff. Jan. 1, 2010) amended 730 ILCS 5/5-5.5-5 to provide that any employer
that hires a person with a criminal record who has obtained a certificate of rehabilitation after
January 1, 2010, is immune from any criminal or civil liability that can possibly arise from the
subsequent act or omission of the employee once employed. Certificates of rehabilitation include
both a certificate of relief from disabilities and a certificate of good conduct. This immunity for
employers regarding the holder of either type of certificate of rehabilitation includes potential
liability for negligent hiring or supervision and all forms of vicarious and respondeat superior
liability. This is a major advancement in the law. To date, Illinois is the only state that provides
such protection to employers as a hiring incentive.
For more on the new Illinois law of certificates of rehabilitation and the significant expansion
of eligibility, see Chapter 8.
b. [6.8] Tax Incentives
The work opportunity tax credit is a federal income tax credit. It is available to employers
who hire a person who has been convicted of a felony, was hired within one year of the release
date, is participating in a “work release” program, and is a member of a low-income family. This
credit can reduce an employer’s federal income tax liability by as much as $2,400 per qualified
new worker. Information can be found at www.ides.state.il.us/employer/ui-credits.asp. The client
should take IRS Form 5884 to the interview so that it is readily available should the employer
show interest. This form can be downloaded from the website above.
8/7/2019 Beyond Legal Mechanisms — Employment, Housing, and Other Related Critical Support
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/beyond-legal-mechanisms-employment-housing-and-other-related-critical 12/22
§6.9 ILLINOIS CRIMINAL RECORDS: EXPUNGEMENT AND OTHER RELIEF — SUPPLEMENT
6S — 12 WWW.IICLE.COM
Beginning January 1, 2007, the State of Illinois provides a tax credit to employers who hire
individuals released from an Illinois Department of Corrections adult facility within the previous
12 months. 30 ILCS 500/45-70. See also www.saferfoundation.org/iewpage.asp?id=35&storyid=
1039041973&pagetype=story. This state tax credit will reduce an employer’s state tax liability by
as much as $600 per qualified new worker.
c. [6.9] Bonding
The free Federal Bonding Program, which operates under the auspices of the United States
Department of Labor, provides individual fidelity bonds of at least $5,000 to employers for an
initial period of six months with the opportunity to request a renewal for an additional six months.
These bonds insure employers for dishonesty or theft by employees who have a criminal record.
The bond is effective immediately following certification, and the employer is not required to fill
out forms or meet a deductible. These fidelity bonds are a highly useful resource. “Since the
program’s inception in 1966, approximately 43,000 bonds have been issued with a 99 percent
success rate.” Illinois Department of Employment Security, Fidelity Bonding: Insurance for Your
Employees (Apr. 2009), www.ides.state.il.us/pdf/employers/fidelitybond.pdf.
d. [6.10] Other Financial Assistance
Other training and tax incentives are available to employers who hire low-income people with
criminal records. For example, the enterprise zone job tax credit, 35 ILCS 5/201(g), is available
for businesses in the 95 Illinois enterprise zones. TIFWorks Chicago provides grants to employers
to cover job training costs for Chicago residents. See www.cityofchicago.org/mowd. The
Workforce Investment Act of 1998, Pub.L. No. 105-220, 112 Stat. 936, provides reimbursement
to employers for on-the-job training, as well as eligible employee relocation assistance. For more
information on these incentives and how to access them, see Illinois Department of Employment
Security, Winning Strategies (Apr. 2007), www.ides.state.il.us/exoffenders/win_strat_eng.pdf.
e. [6.11] Support Organizations
Information gathered from various local and national focus groups indicates that employers
consider the provision of or access to an agency or organization that sponsors or supports the
individual the strongest incentive to hiring people with criminal records. Employers report that
organizations like the Safer Foundation (www.saferfoundation.org) provide help by screening,
matching, and supporting employees, thereby increasing the retention success rate. Additionally,
employers like having a “go-to” group to contact if issues beyond job training arise. Often, such
organizations help by providing or subsidizing transportation, work equipment, and work clothing
as well as dealing with issues outside the workplace, such as parole, child-care issues, etc., that
could negatively influence employment.
5. [6.12] Disincentive to Employers — Employer Liability
Employers are often concerned about being sued for negligent hiring ( i.e., the failure to use
reasonable care in the hiring process). As stated in §6.7 above, the law has changed as of January
1, 2010. Employers that hire employees who have obtained a certificate of rehabilitation (either a
8/7/2019 Beyond Legal Mechanisms — Employment, Housing, and Other Related Critical Support
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/beyond-legal-mechanisms-employment-housing-and-other-related-critical 13/22
BEYOND LEGAL MECHANISMS — EMPLOYMENT, HOUSING, AND OTHER RELATED CRITICAL SUPPORT §6.13
ILLINOIS INSTITUTE FOR CONTINUING LEGAL EDUCATION 6S — 13
certificate of relief from disabilities or a certificate of good conduct or both) are now immune
from all forms of hiring liability, including negligence. This immunity for employers regarding
the holder of either type of certificate of rehabilitation includes potential liability for negligent
hiring or supervision and all forms of vicarious and respondeat superior liability. This is a major
advancement in the law. To date, Illinois is the only state that provides such protection to
employers as hiring incentive.
Now, with the change in Illinois law, only employers who hire employees who do not have a
certificate of rehabilitation issued after January 1, 2010, have any risk whatsoever for negligent
hiring or supervision, and the risk is statistically minimal.
Negligent hiring is determined by two key elements: (a) whether the criminal activity was
foreseeable and (b) whether the employee was incompetent or unfit ( i.e., the employee possessed
personal or physical characteristics that created an unreasonable risk to third parties) for the work
assigned.
According to the Illinois Department of Employment Security website, www.ides.state.il.us/
exoffenders/work_employers.asp, employers are legally required to give full consideration to thefollowing three factors when determining whether to hire a person with a criminal record:
a. the nature and gravity of the crimes;
b. the time that has passed since the conviction or completion of sentence; and
c. the nature of the job being sought.
The key to determining liability is usually whether the employer could have foreseen the
crime — specifically, whether the employee had a history or propensity for harmful behavior and,
most importantly, whether the employer knew or should have known of the employee’s
propensities. Ordinarily, an employer’s reasonable efforts to check and consider background willsatisfy the legal requirements and eliminate the risk of liability for negligent hiring by the
employer. Similar reasonable precautions exercised during the course of employment would
protect against liability for negligent supervision.
As of the first printing of this chapter, according to the research of the Safer Foundation and
its Certificates Implementation Advisory Group, in Illinois, only four cases of negligent hiring of
persons with criminal records had been filed since January 1, 2000. Two of these cases were
decided in favor of the plaintiff, and two in favor of the defendant. Despite the low number of
cases brought in Illinois, the initial research shows that employers have a fear of liability, or say
they do, when an applicant has a history of violence, and headline cases that involve large
amounts of money deter employers from hiring people with records.
6. [6.13] Employment Rights of People with Criminal Records
Employers must follow the law with respect to employment of people with criminal records.
Unfortunately, a number of people with records have reported that some employers offer them
8/7/2019 Beyond Legal Mechanisms — Employment, Housing, and Other Related Critical Support
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/beyond-legal-mechanisms-employment-housing-and-other-related-critical 14/22
§6.14 ILLINOIS CRIMINAL RECORDS: EXPUNGEMENT AND OTHER RELIEF — SUPPLEMENT
6S — 14 WWW.IICLE.COM
employment under illegal conditions, e.g., paying less than minimum wage, requiring unregulated
overtime, or subjecting them to harassment. These practices are unethical and illegal, and any
such incident should be reported as follows:
a. violation of minimum wage or overtime regulations to the United States Department of
Labor, information at www.dol.gov/compliance/guide/minwage.htm#emplrights;
b. unsafe working conditions to the Occupational Safety and Health Administration
(OSHA), information at www.osha.gov/as/opa/worker/complain.html; or
c. racist/harassing conditions to the Illinois Department of Human Rights, information at
www.state.il.us/dhr.
7. Preparation for Job Market
a. [6.14] Getting Assistance
Many organizations specialize in providing job preparedness and placement assistance for people who have been out of the workforce, including displaced and underemployed workers.
Some of these organizations specialize in working with people with criminal records. The
practitioner can help a client prepare for the workforce by directing him or her to organizations
such as these. A good starting point for finding help with job preparedness and placement is the
website of the Illinois Department of Employment Security, www.ides.state.il.us/worknet/
default.asp, or by calling 888-337-7234. A search on the above website by ZIP code or city will
provide information on the closest “one-stop service centers” to be contacted for direct or referral
assistance for a client seeking employment. It is best to select a service provider that can assist
with
1. developing an updated resume and letters of recommendation;
2. preparing the criminal history letter and practicing how to discuss the criminal history;
3. preparing soft skills (skills that influence how people interact with each other such as
effective communication, problem solving, listening, etc.);
4. connecting with employers who hire people with records;
5. training in job search skills; and
6. training assistance with hard skills (skills that have to do with technical ability to do a
job).
b. [6.15] Civic Engagement
Civic engagement can also be helpful to people as they prepare for reentering (or in some
cases, entering for the first time) the workforce. A client who has been involved in community
8/7/2019 Beyond Legal Mechanisms — Employment, Housing, and Other Related Critical Support
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/beyond-legal-mechanisms-employment-housing-and-other-related-critical 15/22
BEYOND LEGAL MECHANISMS — EMPLOYMENT, HOUSING, AND OTHER RELATED CRITICAL SUPPORT §6.16
ILLINOIS INSTITUTE FOR CONTINUING LEGAL EDUCATION 6S — 15
service can offer evidence of job skills, a work ethic, and a sense of responsibility. This shows a
willingness to serve and also provides practical experience and may garner a recommendation to
an employer.
c. [6.16] State Identification
Employers do require state identification at the start of employment, as do some “helping”
organizations. Many times, clients lose their identification during their prison stay, and law
enforcement agencies often destroy identification. Public defenders and criminal lawyers can
assist their clients by informing them of the importance of state identification and helping them
locate a safe place to store their identification prior to the trial or incarceration.
The Intelligence Reform and Terrorism Prevention Act of 2004 (IRTPA), Pub.L. No. 108-
458, 118 Stat. 3638, §7213(a)(1)(B), codified at 42 U.S.C. §405(a)(1)(B) note, requires that the
Social Security Administration establish minimum standards for verification of documents or
records submitted by applicants to establish eligibility for original or replacement social security
cards and should be reviewed for compliance. In accordance with this requirement, effective
December 17, 2005, the Social Security Administration issued new requirements for identitydocuments presented with original and replacement social security number applications. 20
C.F.R. §422.107.
Generally, acceptable identity documents must show the applicant’s name, identifying
information, and a recent photograph. If the applicant is a United States citizen, the applicant
must present (1) a United States driver’s license, (2) a state-issued non-driver identity card, or (3)
a United States passport. If the applicant does not have these documents or cannot get a
replacement for them within ten days, the Social Security Administration will ask to see other
documents, including an employee identification card, a school identification card, a health
insurance card (not a Medicare card), a United States military identification card, or an adoption
decree. Office of the Inspector General, Social Security Administration, The Social Security
Administration’s Program for Issuing Replacement Social Security Cards to Prisoners (July2006), www.ssa.gov/oig/ADOBEPDF/audittxt/A-08-06-16025.htm (case sensitive).
To obtain a new or replacement social security card, one must fill out Social Security
Administration Form SS-5. The form is available at local Social Security offices and at
www.ssa.gov/online/ss-5.html. To obtain a new card, two documents with proof of age,
citizenship or lawful alien status, and name (e.g., birth certificate and school record) are required.
To obtain a replacement card, one identifying document is required. To change one’s name,
documentation showing the old name and the new name is required. Originals or copies certified
by the custodian of the record must be shown. Photocopies and notarized copies are not accepted.
Those born outside of the United States must show proof of U.S. citizenship or lawful alien
status.
Illinois offers three different types of official identification cards beyond the driver’s license.
They are an under-65 identification card, a senior identification card, and a disabled person
identification card. All types of identification cards require that the individual apply in person at a
driver services facility with acceptable proofs of identity.
8/7/2019 Beyond Legal Mechanisms — Employment, Housing, and Other Related Critical Support
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/beyond-legal-mechanisms-employment-housing-and-other-related-critical 16/22
§6.17 ILLINOIS CRIMINAL RECORDS: EXPUNGEMENT AND OTHER RELIEF — SUPPLEMENT
6S — 16 WWW.IICLE.COM
The senior card is available for free and has no expiration date. It provides proof of identity in
all the same situations in which one would show an Illinois driver’s license. The under-65
identification card is available to anyone who wants a proof of identity but who does not have, is
not old enough for, or does not want an Illinois driver’s license. It is also a good alternative form
of identification if one’s license has been suspended or revoked. This type of card is good for five
years. Current fees for the under-65 identification card are $20 for a new identification card, $10for a corrected identification card, and $20 for a duplicate identification card. The disabled
person’s identification card is a photo identification that also lists the classification code of the
person’s disability, which some may feel violates their privacy. To obtain this card, a doctor must
fill out the application. The identification card is free but has to be renewed every five years.
Illinois requires at least four pieces of documentation for a first-time applicant for an
identification card. All listed pieces of identification must be originals, not copies. In some cases,
notarized or certified copies may be accepted, but this is at the discretion of the examining
employee. Any document that looks suspicious will not be accepted. A detailed menu of what the
State of Illinois considers to be acceptable proofs of identity is located on its website. Information
on obtaining an Illinois identification card can be found at www.cyberdriveillinois.com/
departments/drivers/idcards.html.
d. [6.17] Employment Information Sources
Additional information about employment issues and assistance can be located at the
following sources:
• Chicago Jobs Council — www.cjc.net
• Illinois Department of Employment Security — www.ides.state.il.us
• National HIRE Network — www.hirenetwork.org
• Illinois Department of Financial and Professional Regulation — www.idfpr.com
• Illinois Human Rights Commission — www.state.il.us/ihrc
• Illinois Legal Advocate — www.illinoislegaladvocate.org
• Safer Foundation — www.saferfoundation.org
• U.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission — www.eeoc.gov
III. HOUSING
A. [6.18] Exclusionary Policies
Exclusionary housing policies are one of the most significant barriers that people with
criminal records face in their efforts to reenter general society. Typically, people leaving prison
8/7/2019 Beyond Legal Mechanisms — Employment, Housing, and Other Related Critical Support
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/beyond-legal-mechanisms-employment-housing-and-other-related-critical 17/22
BEYOND LEGAL MECHANISMS — EMPLOYMENT, HOUSING, AND OTHER RELATED CRITICAL SUPPORT §6.18
ILLINOIS INSTITUTE FOR CONTINUING LEGAL EDUCATION 6S — 17
and jail are categorized as among those with the most desperate housing needs. Studies show that
15 to 27 percent of incarcerated individuals expect to be homeless upon release, and up to 66
percent without appropriate housing recidivate within one year of release. See Anthony Lowery,
Housing People with Criminal Records, Housing Action Illinois 2005 Convention (Nov. 14 – 15,
2005), available at www.docstoc.com/docs/45652521/housing-people-with-criminal-records.
Federally subsidized housing is available to millions of low-income people who could not
otherwise afford housing. However, federal policy or legislation excludes countless people with
criminal records from housing support. Exclusionary federal housing policies imposed by the US
Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD) and local discretionary exclusions
practiced by the Chicago Housing Authority (CHA) constitute a major roadblock for people with
criminal records who wish to obtain Housing Choice Vouchers (Section 8). See Anti-Drug Abuse
Act of 1988, Pub.L. No. 100-690, 102 Stat. 4181; Housing Opportunity Program Extension Act
of 1996, Pub.L. No. 104-120, 110 Stat. 834; Quality Housing and Work Responsibility Act of
1998, Pub.L. No. 105-276, 112 Stat. 2461. The exclusion of people with criminal records from
public housing, often referred to as the “one-strike policy,” was developed in the 1990s in an
attempt to address drug trafficking, violent crime, and disorder in public housing, particularly in
high-risk urban housing projects.
The Housing Opportunity Program Extension Act bans three categories of people from
admission to public housing: (1) those who have been convicted of methamphetamine production
on the premises of federally funded housing; (2) those subject to lifetime registration
requirements under state sex offender registration programs; and (3) those who are currently
using illegal drugs, regardless of whether they have been convicted of any drug-related offense.
Additionally, Public Housing Authorities (PHAs) have the discretion to deny admission to
three additional categories of applicants: (1) those who have been evicted from public housing
because of drug-related criminal activity (for a period of three years following eviction); (2) those
who engaged in a pattern of disruptive alcohol consumption or illegal drug use, regardless of how
long ago such conduct occurred; and (3) those who have engaged in any drug-related criminalactivity, any violent criminal activity, or any other criminal activity, if a PHA deems the applicant
a safety risk. Current research indicates that these discretionary categories are used, in practice, to
exclude a broad segment of people with criminal records without establishing any reasonable
basis that they pose a risk. See Safer Foundation, Housing Admissions Standards for People with
Criminal Records, available at www.docstoc.com/docs/45644142/housing-admission-standards-
for-people-with-criminal-records.
There is no doubt that some people with criminal records do actually pose a risk and may be
unsuitable for public housing facilities. However, housing policies are so arbitrary, broad, and
harsh that they can exclude people who currently are law-abiding citizens or who may never have
presented a risk in the first place. Many PHAs do not allow for case-by-case determinations that
would take into account an applicant’s record and rehabilitation. In the five years preceding
publication of this handbook, 3.5 million people were classified as ineligible for public housing
because of their criminal records. Anthony Lowery, Housing People with Criminal Records,
Housing Action Illinois 2005 Convention (Nov. 14 – 15, 2005), available at
www.docstoc.com/docs/45652521/housing-people-with-criminal-records.
8/7/2019 Beyond Legal Mechanisms — Employment, Housing, and Other Related Critical Support
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/beyond-legal-mechanisms-employment-housing-and-other-related-critical 18/22
§6.19 ILLINOIS CRIMINAL RECORDS: EXPUNGEMENT AND OTHER RELIEF — SUPPLEMENT
6S — 18 WWW.IICLE.COM
The lack of access to public or subsidized housing for people with criminal records in Illinois
mirrors that of the nation. In an Illinois Housing Development Authority survey conducted for the
Governor’s Statewide Community Safety and Reentry Work Group, only a handful of the state’s
110 PHAs reported considering mitigating circumstances (such as rehabilitation and length of
time since conviction) prior to denying people with criminal records admission to housing. See
Safer Foundation, Housing Admissions Standards for People with Criminal Records, availableat www.docstoc.com/docs/45644142/housing-admission-standards-for-people-with-criminal-
records. For example, the Chicago Housing Authority (CHA) only considers arrests that led to
conviction in its admission criteria. The CHA does not make individual determinations about an
applicant’s eligibility based on the relevance of his or her criminal record; instead, there is a five-
year bar for all felony convictions. Families in public housing who allow a family member with a
criminal record to move in are in jeopardy for violating this provision and may be removed from
public housing. The CHA does have an appeal process for such circumstances.
B. [6.19] Housing Issues To Review with Client
Unfortunately, housing support for people with criminal records is extremely limited. Most
housing support comes from friends or family members. The practitioner can help clientsnavigate the housing system by first establishing a clear picture of a client’s probation or parole
conditions. Often, cohabitation with other parolees or with those having gang affiliations goes
against parole orders and could put a client in jeopardy of violating parole.
The attorney should determine the following when advising a client:
1. the local housing authority’s rules for admissions or criminal records policies (A
complete listing of Public Housing Authorities in Illinois may be found at www.hud.gov/
offices/pih/pha/contacts/states/il.cfm. Chicago’s Housing Authority may be found at
www.thecha.org.);
2. whether a client is disqualified due to his or her criminal record and, if so, whether thereis an appeal policy;
3. whether a client is qualified for public housing and, if so, the process to access such
housing and whether there is a waiting list;
4. the accessibility of other housing providers in the area (The Salvation Army, Catholic
Charities, Public Action to Deliver Shelter, Inc. (PADS), and other community and faith-
based groups have made great efforts to provide transitional housing for people with
criminal records and permanent housing for people with criminal records and physical or
mental health disabilities.); and
5. whether to contact the parole officer if the client is homeless and cannot identify safe
housing as the State of Illinois provides temporary housing for homeless parolees.
8/7/2019 Beyond Legal Mechanisms — Employment, Housing, and Other Related Critical Support
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/beyond-legal-mechanisms-employment-housing-and-other-related-critical 19/22
BEYOND LEGAL MECHANISMS — EMPLOYMENT, HOUSING, AND OTHER RELATED CRITICAL SUPPORT §6.21
ILLINOIS INSTITUTE FOR CONTINUING LEGAL EDUCATION 6S — 19
C. [6.20] Locating Housing Providers
For assistance in identifying local housing providers or information on effecting change in
this arena, please contact one of the following statewide associations:
•
Corporation for Supportive Housing (for Illinois)205 West Randolph, 23rd Floor
Chicago, IL 60606
Phone: 312-332-6690
Fax: 312-332-7040
E-mail: il@csh.org
• Supportive Housing Providers Association
212 East Ohio Street, 5th Floor
Chicago, IL 60611
Phone: 773-359-0123
Fax: 773-935-4662
E-mail: supportivehsg@AOL.com
• Illinois Community Action Association
3435 Liberty Drive
Springfield, IL 62704
Phone: 217-789-0125
Fax: 217-789-0139
www.icaanet.org/contact
• Housing Action Illinois
11 East Adams Street, Suite 1501
Chicago, IL 60603
Phone: 312-939-6074Fax: 312-939-6822
E-mail: info@housingactionil.org
IV. [6.21] EDUCATION
People in recovery from drug and alcohol addiction and others with past drug convictions
may obtain student aid under 20 U.S.C. §1091(r)(1). As of July 1, 2006, students who were
convicted of drug crimes prior to their enrollment and application for federal financial aid are
eligible for aid and will no longer be subject to a ban that delays or denies federal financial
assistance. Id. The federal financial aid ban will apply only to students who are convicted of a
drug offense while they are in school and receiving federal financial assistance. See Legal Action
Center, Legal Action Center Lauds Change in the Law That Will Increase Student Financial Aid
Eligibility for Individuals with Prior Drug Convictions, Including Thousands of People in
Recovery from Drug Addiction (Feb. 28, 2005), www.lac.org/doc_library/lac/news-alerts/
HEA_PRESS%20RELEASE%20FEBRUARY%202006.pdf (case sensitive).
8/7/2019 Beyond Legal Mechanisms — Employment, Housing, and Other Related Critical Support
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/beyond-legal-mechanisms-employment-housing-and-other-related-critical 20/22
§6.22 ILLINOIS CRIMINAL RECORDS: EXPUNGEMENT AND OTHER RELIEF — SUPPLEMENT
6S — 20 WWW.IICLE.COM
It is critical for clients to be advised of this change in the law even before they visit financial
aid offices, as some school officers may not be aware of it. Federal financial aid can be obtained
to cover higher education costs for community colleges, four-year colleges, and graduate schools.
V. [6.22] PUBLIC BENEFITS RESTRICTIONS
It is important that clients know what their eligibility status and rights to public benefits are
before applying for them. Local benefit office staff may not be fully informed about eligibility for
applicants with a criminal record, and consequently, a client who is not well informed may be
incorrectly turned down.
The Personal Responsibility and Work Opportunity Reconciliation Act of 1996, Pub.L. No.
104-193, 110 Stat. 2105, permanently bars anyone with a drug-related felony conviction from
receiving federal cash assistance and food stamps during the individual’s lifetime. Drug-related
felonies are those involving the use, possession, or distribution of illegal substances. The drug
felon ban does not apply to Medicaid or to non-federal assistance that a state may provide through
its own general program.
Under federal law, states are given an opportunity to opt out or modify the drug felon bar. 21
U.S.C. §862a(d)(1)(A). Illinois has chosen to opt out fully from the lifetime bar on the receipt of
public assistance for individuals with drug felony convictions. 305 ILCS 5/1-10. Therefore, in
Illinois, some individuals with a criminal record are eligible to receive Temporary Assistance for
Needy Families (TANF), Medicaid, and food stamp benefits. However, eligibility restrictions do
apply. See Chicago Jobs Council, Get the Facts! Public Benefits that Can Help You with Basic
Living Costs (3d ed. 2006), www.cjc.net/docs/GetTheFacts-EN-06-2.pdf (case sensitive), for
more detailed information.
Abbreviated information regarding eligibility can be found in §§6.23 – 6.26 below.
A. [6.23] Temporary Assistance for Needy Families (TANF)
A client who has been convicted of a Class 1 or Class X drug-related felony after August 22,
1996, will not be able to get TANF cash assistance. However, a person with a criminal record can
still obtain TANF assistance for his or her dependent children. See www.dhs.state.il.us/
page.aspx?item=30358.
If a client is convicted of any other drug-related felony, he or she cannot get TANF cash
assistance for two years from conviction. This does not apply if the person has completed or is
involved in a treatment or aftercare program. The attorney needs to contact the local office to
determine what constitutes proof of treatment. Id.
A client convicted of public benefits fraud (aid for the aged, blind, or disabled; TANF; or
transitional assistance) is banned from receiving TANF benefits for ten years from conviction. Id.
Persons who are fleeing felons or who are in violation of parole or probation are ineligible for
TANF benefits. Id.
8/7/2019 Beyond Legal Mechanisms — Employment, Housing, and Other Related Critical Support
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/beyond-legal-mechanisms-employment-housing-and-other-related-critical 21/22
BEYOND LEGAL MECHANISMS — EMPLOYMENT, HOUSING, AND OTHER RELATED CRITICAL SUPPORT §6.28
ILLINOIS INSTITUTE FOR CONTINUING LEGAL EDUCATION 6S — 21
B. [6.24] Medicaid
Persons convicted of public benefits fraud are banned from receiving Medicaid benefits for
ten years. See www.reentryillinois.net/GettingBenefits.html (case sensitive).
Persons who are fleeing felons or who are in violation of parole or probation are ineligible for Medicaid benefits. Id.
C. [6.25] Food Stamps
Persons convicted of public benefits fraud are banned from receiving food stamp benefits for
ten years. See www.reentryillinois.net/GettingBenefits.html (case sensitive).
Persons who are fleeing felons or who are in violation of parole or probation are ineligible for
food stamp benefits. Id.
D. [6.26] Unemployment Insurance
Eligible workers, including people with criminal records, who become unemployed and meet
all requirements set forth in the Unemployment Insurance Act, 820 ILCS 405/100, et seq., may
receive benefits for the maximum number of weeks payable under the law, unless the worker
finds employment or becomes ineligible through failure to meet a requirement. While there are no
restrictions to unemployment benefits based on ex-offender status, eligibility requires recipients
to be actively seeking work, to be able and available to work, to be unemployed through no fault
of their own, and to have received at least $1,600 of covered employment during the first four of
the last five completed quarters (with $440 earned outside the quarter with the highest earnings
during that period). See www.ides.state.il.us/resources/default.asp. Application for benefits can
be made (1) at www.ides.state.il.us or (2) in person at a local IDES office or Illinois Employment
and Training Center.
VI. [6.27] MILITARY SERVICE
In most cases, those with felony convictions will be excluded from military service in all
branches of the armed forces. However, exceptions may be allowed. Individual service branches
may also have recruiting policies that forbid enlistment of persons with specific offenses,
including misdemeanors. See Veronica Rose, Military Service and Misdemeanor Convictions
(July 7, 2005), www.cga.ct.gov/2005/rpt/2005-r-0556.htm.
VII. [6.28] VOTING AND POLITICAL ENGAGEMENT
Many of the barriers to employment and housing will not be removed until legislative efforts
are successfully implemented. It is critical that people with records and their families and friends
voice their opinions through the political process. In Illinois, unlike some other states, people
with records can vote during and after the completion of probation or parole. See 730 ILCS 5/5-5-
5; ILL.CONST. art. III, §2.
8/7/2019 Beyond Legal Mechanisms — Employment, Housing, and Other Related Critical Support
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/beyond-legal-mechanisms-employment-housing-and-other-related-critical 22/22
§6.28 ILLINOIS CRIMINAL RECORDS: EXPUNGEMENT AND OTHER RELIEF — SUPPLEMENT
6S — 22 WWW.IICLE.COM
Attorneys need to advise clients to
a. complete and return a voter’s registration card;
b. be informed about the political issues that most affect them and their community;
c. vote in every election;
d. visit, telephone, e-mail, or write to their elected officials, voicing their concerns about the
barriers and exclusions specific to people with a criminal record; and
e. volunteer in action-oriented groups that address issues of importance to people with
criminal records.
CARRE (Coalition of Advisors to Reduce Recidivism through Employment), convened by
the Safer Foundation, is an example of the type of activist group mentioned above. This group of
more than 90 members is comprised of advocates, people with criminal records, employers, and
representatives from government bodies, community organizations, and faith-based organizationswho are working together to reduce barriers to and increase incentives for the employment of
people with criminal records. Since its inception in June 2001, CARRE has
a. hosted yearly policy conferences and quarterly strategy meetings to evaluate the best
practices and to devise strategies for policy initiatives;
b. produced and disseminated seven policy papers to a variety of county, state, federal, and
community stakeholders;
c. conducted or participated in public education and advocacy campaigns leading to the
enactment of new policies and policy reform, legislative action, the creation of
employment programs, the establishment of public hiring standards, and the offering of hiring incentives and immunities for employers (P.A. 96-852 (eff. Jan. 1, 2010); P.A. 93-
210 (eff. July 18, 2003); P.A. 93-211 (eff. Jan. 1, 2004); P.A. 93-207 (eff. Jan. 1, 2004);
P.A. 93-208 (eff. July 18, 2003); P.A. 93-1084 (eff. June 1, 2005); Cook County reentry
employment program, policy reform of the City of Chicago’s hiring practices); and
d. in collaboration with the Illinois Department of Employment Security, produced and
disseminated brochures statewide, providing information about available government
funds, programs, and services available to support the hiring, training, and retention of
people with criminal records.
More information about the Safer Foundation and CARRE is available through the Safer
Foundation’s policy group at www.saferfoundation.org or direct inquiries to Anthony Lowery,
Director of Public Policy and Advocacy, Anthony.Lowery@saferfoundation.org, or the author,
Michael Sweig, JD, Public Policy Liaison, Michael.Sweig@saferfoundation.org.
top related