assessment practices that enhance instruction and learning alisa h. braddy senior consultant...

Assessment Practices that

Enhance Instruction and Learning

Alisa H. BraddySenior Consultant

International Center for Leadership in Education

Alisa H. Braddy

• Florence, SC• 26 years as an educator• Fulltime international education consultant• Taught grades K – 6 and 9 – 12• One son, 11 years old TODAY!

3

What’s wrong with our current

assessment practices?

4

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dY2mRM4i6tY

5

What’s wrong with our current

assessment practices?

Playing Card Discussion1. View the playing card given you when you arrived at the

breakout session.

2. Form a discussion group with the people who are holding the same numbered card as you.

3. Take turns answering the questions that match your suit.

4. Be sure to ask whether anyone in your group has anything to add about your topic.

5. Discussion continues until all group members have discussed their topics.

Playing Card Discussion Questions

SPADES: What are the purposes of assessment in teaching and learning and why are they important?

DIAMONDS: Describe the types of assessments you currently use and discuss the one assessment you use the most and explain why.

CLUBS: How does assessment fit into the process of teaching for high rigor and high relevance?

HEARTS: Summarize what you understand about designing assessments that mirror Next Generation Assessments and implementation of CCSS.

“Traditional” Assessment

Practices

8

Generally encourage rote/ superficial learning Can predict students results on external tests, but

provides little information about students’ learning needs

Focus on quantity, rather than quality, of work Over-emphasize grading, under-emphasize

learning

Did You Know…

The word ‘assess’ comes from the Latin verb ‘assidere’ meaning ‘to sit with’. In assessment one is supposed to sit with the learner. This implies it is something we do ‘with’ and ‘for’ students and not ‘to’ students (Green, 2009).

3 R’s For Creating Assessments That Improve Student Learning

• RIGOR• RELEVANCE• REFLECTION

The Common Core State Standards Next Generation Assessments will approach formative and summative assessment in a way that

addresses all four quadrants in the Rigor/Relevance

Framework.

Rigor/Relevance Framework®

12

Rigor/Relevance Framework

Assessment Purposes

★ Provide feedback to parents and students ★ Evaluate effectiveness of different programs★ Sort and reward students★ Evaluate schools

OF Learning

FOR Learning

AS Learning

★Diagnose, identify, monitor student’s progress ★Provides feedback to teachers to improve

instruction

★Engage students in active learning process ★Increase rigor and relevance w/ unpredictable

situations

Formative Assessment is FOR Learning

Assessment for learning is the 21st-century way, a way of garnering information about where students are in order to adjust and establish instruction that will move them toward specific learning goals. Assessment for learning is used to:

• Hold students accountable for learning• Diagnose, identify, and monitor students’ progress• Provide feedback to teachers to improve instruction• Provide feedback to students to inform learning

"Formative Assessment is a process not a specific type of

“test”."

Robert Marzano

Give One, Get One

1.Using the “Give One, Get One” model, create a chart and record three different formative assessments that you currently use with students..2.When the music begins, move quietly around the room with your chart and a pencil/pen.3.When the music stops, share one idea with the person closest to you.4.Ask your partner to do the same and fill in the “Get One” column.5.If you both have the same idea, brainstorm a new idea to write in one of the blanks on the chart.

Give One Get One

1. 1.

2. 2.

3. 3.

TOPIC: Formative Assessment Ideas

ObservationsQuestioningDiscussion

Exit/Admit SlipsLearning/Response Logs

Graphic OrganizersPeer/Self AssessmentsPractice PresentationsVisual Representations

Kinesthetic AssessmentsIndividual Whiteboards

Four CornersThink Pair Share

Appointment Clock

Types of Formative Assessments

• It is embedded as an essential part of teaching and learning

• It involves sharing learning goals with students• It helps students know and recognize the standards

they are aiming for• It involves students in self assessment• It provides feedback that helps students to recognize

their next steps and how to take them• Teachers and students both believe that every student

can improve• It involves both teachers and students reviewing and

reflecting on assessment data

Characteristics of Formative Assessment that Promote Learning

HOW CAN LEARNING IMPROVE THROUGH FORMATIVE ASSESSMENT?

• Providing effective feedback to students• Actively involving students in their own learning• Adjusting teaching as a result of analysis of assessment

data• Recognizing the profound influence assessment has on

the motivation and self esteem of students.• Helping students to self assess themselves and

understand how to improve

Video Clip Reflection Questions

• How does using the three colored chips act as both an assessment and a reflection strategy?

• Why is it important to elicit feedback about student thinking and experiences?

• How could this strategy be used with other lessons to assess understanding?

24

Three Colored Chips

25

http://teachertube.com/viewVideo.php?video_id=266847

Video Clip Reflection Questions

• How does using the three colored chips act as both an assessment and a reflection strategy?

• Why is it important to elicit feedback about student thinking and experiences?

• How could this strategy be used with other lessons to assess understanding?

26

29

Reflection QuestionHandout – Formative Assessment Organizer

How can you enhance your current use of formative assessments to ensure increased understanding and self-reflection by your students?

Assessment Purposes

★Provide feedback to parents and students ★Evaluate effectiveness of different programs★Sort and reward students★Evaluate schools

OF Learning

FOR Learning

AS Learning

★Diagnose, identify, monitor student’s progress ★Provides feedback to teachers to improve

instruction

★Engage students in active learning process ★Increase rigor and relevance w/ unpredictable

situations

Summative Assessment is

used AS Learning

Important to Know

Worth Being Familiar with

Enduring Understanding

Establishing Curriculum Priorities

Assessment Focus

Summative Assessment

33

SUMMATIVE assessments provide students with

a culminating appraisal of their performance.

Assessment AS Learning

Rubrics are most often used

CCSS Definition of Performance Tasks

What is a Performance Task?

Tasks that are authentic and meaningful that ask students to synthesize knowledge and skills learned and apply them to construct a response, create a product and/or performance that demonstrates understanding.

Rigor/Relevance Framework

1

2

3

4

5

6

1 2 3 4 5

Verb list for Assessment Design

Calculate matchchoose memorizecount namedescribe recitefind recordidentify selectlabel spelllist locate

analyzedifferentiatecategorizediscriminateclassifyevaluatecompare explainconclude infercontrast judge defend justifydiagram prove

adapt justifyargue modifycompose predictconclude prioritizeconstruct proposedesign rateevaluaterecommendformulate reviseinvent teachadjust interpretapply interviewbuild makeCalculate modelconstruct playdramatize relatedraw solveillustrate

Products for Assessment Design A

definitionworksheetlistquiztestworkbooktrue-falsereproductio

nrecitation

Bscrapbooksummaryinterpretationcollectionannotationexplanationsolutiondemonstrationoutline

Cessayabstractblueprintinventoryreportplanchartinvestigationquestionnaireclassification

Devaluationnewspaperestimationtrialeditorialplaycollagemachineadaptationpoemdebatenew gameinvention

Expressions and Equations – Solve real-life and mathematical problems using numerical and algebraic expressions and equations.

Common Core State Standard

How would you assess this CCSS?

A graphic designer is creating a poster for an art exhibition. The width of the poster will be 9 inches less than the length, and the perimeter of the poster will be greater than 74 inches and less than 110 inches. a) Write an inequality to show the possible lengths, in inches, of the graphic designer's poster. Don't forget to define the variables. b) Solve the inequality and graph the solution set on a number line. c) Write a one-paragraph interpretation of what the solution means for the graphic designer. Explain how you came up with the inequality, how you solved it, and what the graph represents.

Performance Task

Reading Standards for Literacy in History/ Social Studies

Integrate quantitative or technical analysis (e.g., charts, research data) with qualitative analysis in print or digital text.

Common Core State Standard

How would you assess this CCSS?

Visit the Electoral College’s website at http://www.archives.gov/federal-register/electoral-college/

Analyze the information on how the Electoral College works, and look at the statistics on the three most recent president elections, determining how the Electoral College vote and the popular vote differ. Then compose an editorial for your school or local newspaper identifying the pros and cons of the Electoral College. Decide whether you support the use of the Electoral College in presidential elections, and give reasons why or why not, based on the statistics you have examined.

Performance Task

Common Core State Standards• Social Studies Academic Standard K-3.1:

– Recognize the significance of symbols of the United States that represent its democratic values, including the American flag, the bald eagle, the Statue of Liberty, the Pledge of Allegiance, and The Star Spangled Banner.

• CCSS Reading Informational Text RI.K.1:– With prompting and support ask and answer questions about

key details in a text.• CCSS Writing W.K.7:

– Participate in shared research and writing projects (e.g. explore a number of books written by an author and express opinions about them).

Kindergarten Performance Task

Choose one of the American symbols we have been studying. Write at least two questions about that symbol. Use the books we have read in class to research the answers to your questions. Create a page for our American Symbols Photo Journal with visual images and your questions and answers. Read and respond to our photo journal during center time. 

Common Core State Standards• Science Academic Standard 1.2:

– The student will demonstrate an understanding of the special characteristics and needs of plants that allow them to survive in their own distinct environments.

• CCSS Reading Informational Text RI.1.2:– Identify the main topic and retell key details of a text.

• CCSS Writing W.1.2 and W.1.8:– Write informative/expository texts in which they name a topic,

supply some facts about the topic, and provide some sense of closure.

– With guidance and support from adults, recall information from experiences or gather information from provided sources to answer a question.

First Grade Performance Task• Based on evidence found in texts, other research conducted and

the information our guest speakers provided, create a communication tool (PSA, glog, bumper stickers, magnets, posted guidelines poster, etc.) to convey to the patrons of Sesquicentennial State Park the impact made to the plants and the life cycles of plants by hiking in areas that are not marked as official paths.

Common Core State Standards• Social Studies Academic Standard 2.3.1:

– Summarize roles of community workers who provide goods and services.

• CCSS Reading Informational Text RI.2.8:– Describe how reasons support specific points the author makes in

a text.• CCSS Writing W.2.1:

– Write opinion pieces in which they introduce the topic or book they are writing about, state an opinion, supply reasons to support that opinion….

2nd Grade Performance TaskBased on our readings and study of community workers, choose a worker who you think provides the most important good or service. Create a five panel comic strip to describe what the worker provides and specific reasons how and why it is the most important good or service.

Common Core State Standards• Science Academic Standard 3.2.4:

– Explain how changes in the habitats of plants and animals affect their survival.

• CCSS Reading Informational Text RI.3.3:– Explain events, procedures, ideas, or concepts in a historical,

scientific, or technical text, including what happened and why, based on specific information in the text.

• CCSS Writing W.3.2: – Write informative/explanatory texts to examine a topic and

convey ideas and information clearly

3rd Grade Performance Task•Design an informational brochure that educates

our local community of the impact human actions have on animal habitats. Include facts and other information from the articles and text book that will clearly convey your point. Suggest possible solutions and present a plan of action. Use your brochure to educate your relatives about human impact on animal habitats.

49

50

Identify and Clarify Goals

Design Formative and Summative

Assessments

Plan Instruction and Activities

3 Stage Backward Design

What is the Evidence of Understanding?

What is worthy and requiring of understanding? Enduring Ideas

Balloon Performance Task Blow up a balloon. Tie the balloon closed. Attach a piece of string. Hand the balloon to assessor for

assessment. Following acceptance or

rejection, start the process over.

Balloon Assessment CriteriaBalloons are rejected if they do not meet the following criteria:1.The balloon is blown up and has string tied to the knot.2. The person who hands it to you is holding onto the string.3. It is handed to you with the left hand.4. The balloon is a different color from the previous one accepted.

Creating Effective Assessments Planning assessments comes before the

learning begins in the classroom. Know what to assess - establish criteria to

assess each product and performance Students should know exactly what will

be required of them, and what criteria will be used to evaluate their performance BEFORE they begin.

Create rubrics for the project

Factors that Inhibit Teachers from Creating Effective Assessment

• A tendency for teachers to assess quantity of work and presentation rather than quality, and to assess at low levels of understanding

• Greater attention to marking and grading (much of it tending to lower self esteem of students) than providing feedback for improvement

• Teachers’ feedback to students often serving social or managerial purposes rather than helping them learn more effectively

• Teachers not knowing enough about their students’ learning needs

Next Generation Assessments http://parcconline.org

Actively Involve Students in Their Own Learning

Share the learning outcomes or learning goals with students at the beginning of a lesson/unit

Research shows that:

– not only are students more motivated and task-oriented if they know the learning outcome of the task,

– but they are also able to make better decisions about how to go about the task.

Learning goals should be clear and unambiguous, and explained to students in a way that they can understand.

REFLECTION

Students need to be involved in self assessment; teachers and students must review and reflect on assessment data

together

• How does effective reflection and self assessment lead to improved learning?

Self Assessment - Reflection• How is this assessment different than other

assessments I have created?• What will my students understand and be able

to do by completing this assessment?• Does it assess the intended learning?• Does it assess the learning at a high level?• How do I know?

What it does for students• Increases Engagement• Promotes Understanding of Learning Goals• Helps Learners Know How to Improve• Develops the Capacity for Self-Assessment• Makes Learning a Process• Focuses on How Students Learn

6060

62

May Your Moments be Many!

“Educators are addicted to the moment when a student’s eyes light up, when the teaching becomes learning. May your days be filled with such moments.”

Philip Patrick Horenstein

21st Annual

Model Schools Conference• Effective and efficient approaches to improving student achievement in times of

declining resources and increasing expectations • Focusing on instructional excellence as the key to the Common Core State

Standards, Next Generation Assessments, and Teacher Evaluations• Instructional approaches for special populations • Identifying and overcoming common barriers to dramatic school improvement

June 30 – July 3 | Washington, D.C.www.modelschoolsconference.com

How to Reach UsAlisa H. Braddy

inspireandengage@gmail.com

www.inspireandengage.com

FACEBOOK: inspireandengage

843.602.2919

64

Phone (518) 399-2776www.LeaderEd.com info@LeaderEd.com

International Center forLeadership in Education

RIGOR

RELEVANCE

A B

DC

Rigor/Relevance Framework

Recall, facts, observations, demonstrate

Next GenerationSummarize,

analyze, organize, evaluate

Predict, design, create, innovate

Apply, relate, demonstrate

High

HighLow

Low