addressing fatherhood with men who batter melissa scaia, john downing, and laura connelly –...

Addressing Fatherhood with Men Who Batter

Melissa Scaia, John Downing, and Laura Connelly – Advocates for Family Peace

Scott Miller – Domestic Abuse Intervention Programs

History of working with men who batter

and addressing fatherhood

Fatherhood Goals

• Goal for the curriculum: Add curricula and sessions to BIP programming that focuses on men as fathers and parenting partners

• Community / Systemic Goal: Every man who uses supervised visitation and exchange for battering will also participate in the IPMF

Goal for the development of this curriculum:

• To help end violence against women and children by motivating men to become better fathers (or father figures) and more supportive parenting partners.

Introduction to the beliefs about men who batter and fatherhood

• Most men who batter are fathers

• Most of the men have developed belief systems similar to their own fathers

• Last 30 years, BIPs have developed around the country to address men’s violence against women

• Very little time has been spent on men as fathers and as co-parents/parallel-parents

• Greater empathy by men toward their children’s experiences of the violence than toward their partners’ experiences

Why Should We Focus on Fathers?

Most men who batter have some level of contact with their children.

Many battered mothers report that their abusers purposefully involve children in violent events (Edelson, 2006).

Men who batter systematically undermine and interfere with battered mothers’ parenting in

multiple ways (Bancroft, 2002).

The violence perpetrated in the home is used to control the behavior of the other members in the

family.

Battered women want their children to have “safe” contact with the father.

On average, children exposed to adult domestic violence exhibit more

difficulties than those not exposed. The difficulties can vary in range and extremity in behavioral and emotional functioning and cognitive functioning

and attitudes (Edleson, 2006).

Most men in a batterers intervention program (BIP) are fathers.

Many men who batter are visiting parents in a supervised visitation

center.

History of the Fathering After Violence (FAV) Project

• AFFP was chosen as a pilot site by the Family Violence Prevention Fund as part of the Safe Havens: Supervised Visitation and Safe Exchange grant program of OVW

• Facilitators’ experiences in groups with men who have been abusive

• Blandin Foundation, Northland Foundation, Minneapolis Foundation and Bush Foundation Funding

• Research, Focus Groups, and Interviews

A Shared Understanding of Domestic Violence

Theory and Fatherhood

A Shared Understanding: The Blueprint for Safety

1. Adhere to an interagency approach and collective intervention goals

2. Build attention to the context and severity of abuse into each intervention

3. Recognize that most domestic violence is a patterned crime requiring continuing engagement with victims and offenders

4. Ensure sure and swift consequences for continued abuse

5. Use the power of the criminal justice system to send messages of help and accountability

6. Act in ways that reduce unintended consequences and the disparity of impact on victims and offenders

A Shared Understanding (cont’d)

• Men's use of violence towards their current/ex-partner should be considered when determining access to their children.

• All intervention practices must reflect an understanding of the interdependence of mother's and children's safety.

Theoretical Framework for understanding fathering by

men who batter

• Men who batter parent differently than other fathers and systematically undermine and interfere with battered mothers’ parenting in multiple ways (Bancroft, 2002).

• Most battered women want the children to have contact with the father – as long as it is safe for the children.

• Our culture closely ties fatherhood to dominance and strength

• Men who batter often believe that the children’s mother and children should provide unquestioning compliance.

• Most men who batter to do not believe that if they have harmed the mother that they have harmed the children

Why Does Domestic Violence Happen?

1. Diagnosable pathologies

2. It’s the relationship isn’t it?

3. Lenora Walker’s Cycle of Violence

4. Maintaining a system of dominance

Diagnosable Pathology

• The offender’s violence is explained through the diagnosis

• The focus is the individual rather than social construction

Therapy, chemical dependency treatment or parenting evaluations and treatment

It’s the Relationship Isn’t It?

The violence is a product of each person’s choices

Interventions could be couple’s therapy, family therapy, and/or parent/child therapy.

The Cycle of Violence

Psychological explanation for domestic violence

• tension-building• explosion• honeymoon

Since anger is the driving force, managing it becomes the intervention. Child management techniques to address anger with children.

System of Dominance

• System of power and control tactics

• Includes:• Physical violence• Sexual violence• Other tactics on Power and Control Wheel

• Men battering their family is socially constructed

• Need to balance power differential by using power of the state

Domestic Abuse Intervention Programs

Men’s vs. Women’s Use of Violence

• Types of violence used

• Intent of violence

• Impact of the violence

• Addressing parenting

Entitlement

Oppression and Resistance

Domestic Abuse Intervention Programs

Oppression

Resistance

Oppression and Resistance

Domestic Abuse Intervention Programs

ViolenceHealthy Relationship

Critical Dialogue

Learning Critical Dialogue: The Impact of My

Parents on Me

• Triad groups – learn from each other; ask questions to have a deeper understanding; practice dialogue

Not a “parenting” curriculum and

addressing fatherhood work with men who

batter

Not a parenting curriculum

• Traditional parenting curriculum seeks to provide parents with skills to parent children as circumstances arise (child management techniques) and to increase men’s knowledge of stages of “normal” child development

• Knowing child development stages + entitlement WILL STILL EQUAL = battering

• This curriculum focuses on the entitlement that men have in relationships to their children and the children’s mother as a parenting partner

• Intended to be incorporated into and/or with a BIP

Example of Missy and Scott

• Example of Missy and Scott

• If Randy’s beliefs aren’t non-violent, then any skill taught will be used with entitlement and violent beliefs behind it

Coordinating a Response to Fathers Who Batter

When are parenting skills classes appropriate?

What are the risks?

What beliefs does a father need to implement skills?

Who should skills programs be connected to?

The Four Themes of the Fatherhood Work with Men Who Batter

from curriculum “Addressing Fatherhood with Men Who Batter”

Theme One: Examining Men’s Own Childhood Experiences with their Father

Theme Two: The Impact and Effects of Men’s Abusive Behaviors on their Children

Theme Three: Becoming a Child-Centered Father

Theme Four: Examining How Men Can Be Respectful and Non-abusive of Their Children’s Mother and of the Mother-Child Relationship

Fatherhood Log

• Addresses each theme

1) Childhood experiences with your own father

2) Impact of your children and your children’s mother

3) Becoming a more nurturing, child-centered father

4) Respecting and supporting the woman as a parenting partner

Implementing practice,

philosophy, and principles with men who batter

as fathers

Written Curriculum, DVD, and future Trainings

• Written curriculum, “Addressing Fatherhood with Men Who Batter” = $100• Written by Melissa Scaia, MPA, Laura Connelly, and John

Downing• Forward by: Ellen Pence, PhD• Edited by: John Connelly, Scott Miller, and Jane Sadusky

oDVD = $125• Four vignettes• 911 call

o Purchase Curriculum and DVD at:www.stopdomesticabuse.org or

www.theduluthmodel.org

Contact information

Advocates for Family Peace1611 NW 4th StreetGrand Rapids, MN 55744218-326-0388

mscaia@stopdomesticabuse.org

www.stopdomesticabuse.org

Domestic Abuse Intervention Programs202 East Superior StreetDuluth, MN 55802

smiller@theduluthmodel.org

www.theduluthmodel.org

Resources

Mending the Sacred Hoop

www.msh-ta.org

Battered Women’s Justice Project

www.bwjp.org

Domestic Abuse Intervention Project

www.duluth-model.org

Praxis International

www.praxisinternational.org

Advocates for Family Peace

www.stopdomesticabuse.org