20160206__高雄美濃地震彙整簡報v5.0 (english)

February 6, 2016 (local time)

ML-6.4 Meinong Earthquake ML-6.4 Meinong Earthquake

Kaohsiung City, Taiwan

2016/02/06 – Ver5.0

1

2016.02.06 Meinong Earthquake

� ML 6.4, occurrence at 3: 57: 27.2 am, Feb. 6, 2016, local time (or, 7: 57: 27.2 pm, Feb. 5, 2016, UTC), CWB-defined Intensity Level 6 observed at TSMIP Caoling Station, Yunlin County

� Epicenter located at 22.93°N Lat., 120.54°E Long., focal depth 16.7 km, (Meinong District, Kaohsiung City ), 27.4 km Northeast of Pingtung County Hall

Source: Central Weather Bureau, Taiwan

PGA Distribution

� Maximum CWB-defined Intensity Level 6 observed at TSMIP CaolingStation, Yunlin County

� Intensity Level 5 in Pingtung County, Kaohsiung City, Tainan City, and ChiayiCounty.

� Intensity Level 4 in Taitung County, � Intensity Level 4 in Taitung County, Nantou County, Changhua County, and Taichung City.

� Intensity Level 1 or greater observed in Taiwan area, except for New Taipei City and Taipei City

� Tremor felt in New Taipei City and Taipei City

� Earthquake likely caused by rupture of Chishan fault (旗山斷層) according to CWB

Source: Central Weather Bureau, Taiwan

Shaking Intensity Contour

4

(P-alert info provided by Y.M. Wu) NCREE+P-alert

Waveforms recorded at Near-Fault Station

Caoling Intensity Level 6

(Central Weather Bureau, Taiwan)

PGA=344.12gal

Focal Mechanism Solution

� The focal mechanism solutions reported by CWB-Taiwan and USGS are similar

� Mixture of reverse and strike slip rupture

(USGS) (CWB_CMT)

Activities of Aftershocks

� 7 aftershocks observed as of 6:00am, Feb 6 (local time) according to CWB

� Max. magnitude of aftershocks measures ML4.9; all 7 aftershocks were located

west of the main shock and had deeper focal depths

(Source: CWB)

USGS Earthquake Hazards Program

� USGS reported the earthquake magnitude to be MW-6.4

� Epicenter located at 22.871°N, 120.668°E; focal depth 23 km

(USGS)

Major Historical Earthquake in Proximity

Epicenter, focal depth, and focal mechanism of

the quake is similar to Mw-6.4 Jiasian, Kaohsiung

Earthquake (高雄甲仙地震) on March 4, 2010

9Source: CWB

2016 Meinong Main Shock, Aftershocks and

2010 Jiasian Earthquake Epicenters

10

Stations w/ Velocity Pulses

CHN5草嶺

PGA Distribution calculated using NCREE + P-alert + CWB stations

Black triangle: station observing velocity pulsesBlack cross: building damage sites reportedWhite square: NCREE & P-alert stationsWhite triangle: CWB stationsCorrelation seemingly exists between

SCK七股

TAI台南市

SSH善化Correlation seemingly exists between velocity pulses observations and building damage sites.

Station

Code

PGV

(cm/s)

Tp (pulse

period)

CHN5 46 0.84

TAI 35 2.38

SSH 62 2.07

SCK 41 1.15

Velocity Pulses

CHN5 SCK

12

SSH TAI

Tp extracted using Shahi and Baker model (2014)

Shaking Intensity Contour

PGA Sa(T=0.3s) Sa(T=1.0s)

24.5

25.0

24.5

25.0

24.5

25.0

ObersvedPGA

ObersvedSa(0.3s)

ObersvedSa(1.0s)

2016/02/06 03:57:27Location=120.54E / 22.93N

ML=6.4 / Depth=16.7km, Data: 98sites

2016/02/06 03:57:27Location=120.54E / 22.93N

ML=6.4 / Depth=16.7km, Data: 98sites

2016/02/06 03:57:27Location=120.54E / 22.93N

ML=6.4 / Depth=16.7km, Data: 98sites

Database: CWB Real-Time Seismic Monitoring Network

120.0 120.5 121.0 121.5 122.0 122.5

Longitude,(E)

22.0

22.5

23.0

23.5

24.0

24.5

Latit

ude

,(N)

120.0 120.5 121.0 121.5 122.0 122.5

Longitude,(E)

22.0

22.5

23.0

23.5

24.0

24.5La

titu

de,(

N)

120.0 120.5 121.0 121.5 122.0 122.5

Longitude,(E)

22.0

22.5

23.0

23.5

24.0

24.5

Lati

tude

,(N)

Geometric mean

(I)

I

II

III

IV

V

VI

VII

0.82.5

8.0

25

80

250

400

(gal)

Geometric mean

(I)

I

II

III

IV

V

VI

VII

0.82.5

8.0

25

80

250

400

(gal)

Geometric mean

(I)

I

II

III

IV

V

VI

VII

0.82.5

8.0

25

80

250

400

(gal)

Recorded Accelerograms and Response Spectra

Stations observing PGA>80gal

StationCode 名稱 Long. Lat. Re

(km)PGA(V)

(gal)PGA(NS)

(gal)PGA(EW)

(gal)Max PGA

(gal)CHN5 草嶺 120.68 23.6 75.7 93.31 240.4 344.12 344.12

TAI 臺南市 120.21 22.99 35 82.49 152.17 233.82 233.82SCL 佳里 120.2 23.17 44.08 54.37 232.93 224.73 232.93SSH 善化 120.29 23.14 34.65 65.44 229.04 225.09 229.04

CHN7 六腳 120.24 23.48 68.9 20.1 190.81 175.32 190.81

震度六級

CHN7 六腳 120.24 23.48 68.9 20.1 190.81 175.32 190.81CHY 嘉義市 120.43 23.5 64.06 39.9 118.5 171.37 171.37WSF 四湖 120.23 23.64 84.78 27.46 164.67 129.8 164.67SCK 七股 120.09 23.15 52.41 31.76 103.48 163.18 163.18TAI1 永康 120.24 23.04 33.34 44.98 105.16 148.34 148.34

CHN1 楠西 120.53 23.19 28.72 77.46 147.45 123.94 147.45WGK 古坑 120.57 23.68 84.08 19.62 105.16 109.46 109.46SSD 三地門 120.64 22.74 22.65 71.3 105.46 62.15 105.46SGS 甲仙 120.59 23.08 17.92 72.38 104.86 63.82 104.86

CHN4 草山 120.59 23.35 47.46 55.93 104.68 88.95 104.68TWM1 旗山 120.43 22.82 15.99 31.4 87.93 57.72 87.93

ALS 阿里山 120.81 23.51 70.37 34.16 84.04 71.42 84.04

震度五級

Station CHN5 (Caoling)

Station TAI (Tainan City)

Station SCL (佳里)

Station SSH (善化)

NCREE Real-Time Seismic Monitoring

Network

Station Name E N PGA_U,gal PGA_N,gal PGA_E,galA730 南化埔仔 120.50 23.05 133.732 407.994 327.928 A800 茂林萬山 120.68 22.91 65.438 158.471 101.689 A660 六腳溪厝 120.28 23.50 36.330 138.891 184.579 A620 梅山圳北 120.57 23.58 31.837 79.585 96.053

• Stations observing PGA>20galRe = 21.5km

A620 梅山圳北 120.57 23.58 31.837 79.585 96.053 A590 二林香田 120.37 23.87 24.072 60.057 72.547 A771 路竹北嶺 120.27 22.82 28.233 50.669 59.984 A601 豐山 120.75 23.59 17.975 39.016 42.083 A600 達邦特富野 120.76 23.47 24.155 33.905 35.178 A770 大寮林園 120.40 22.54 13.807 28.637 28.800 A530 魚池東光 120.96 23.89 9.855 28.097 23.062 A810 瑪家佳義 120.63 22.64 19.682 27.570 33.943 A560 南投永興 120.64 23.89 12.969 27.446 26.643 A860 枋寮瓦磘 120.61 22.38 13.049 25.783 29.582

Station A730 (南化埔仔)

Shaking Intensity Contour

PGA Sa(T=0.3s) Sa(T=1.0s)

25.0 25.0 25.0

ObersvedPGA

ObersvedSa(0.3s)

ObersvedSa(1.0s)

2016/02/06 03:57:27Location=120.54E / 22.93N

ML=6.4 / Depth=16.7km, Data: 104sites

2016/02/06 03:57:27Location=120.54E / 22.93N

ML=6.4 / Depth=16.7km, Data: 104sites

2016/02/06 03:57:27Location=120.54E / 22.93N

ML=6.4 / Depth=16.7km, Data: 104sites

Database: CWB and NCREE Real-Time Seismic Monitoring Networks

CWB stations NCREE stations

120.0 120.5 121.0 121.5 122.0 122.5

Longitude,(E)

22.0

22.5

23.0

23.5

24.0

24.5

Latit

ude

,(N)

120.0 120.5 121.0 121.5 122.0 122.5

Longitude,(E)

22.0

22.5

23.0

23.5

24.0

24.5La

titu

de,(

N)

120.0 120.5 121.0 121.5 122.0 122.5

Longitude,(E)

22.0

22.5

23.0

23.5

24.0

24.5

Lati

tude

,(N)

Geometric mean

(I)

I

II

III

IV

V

VI

VII

0.82.5

8.0

25

80

250

400

(gal)

Geometric mean

(I)

I

II

III

IV

V

VI

VII

0.82.5

8.0

25

80

250

400

(gal)

Geometric mean

(I)

I

II

III

IV

V

VI

VII

0.82.5

8.0

25

80

250

400

(gal)

PGA Distribution Estimated by TELES

Spectral Accelerations Estimated by TELES

Sa (0.3sec) Sa (1sec)

Casualties Estimated by TELES

CityCasualties

Severely

InjuredDeaths Sum

Tainan 5 3 8

Kaohsiung 3 1 4

Total 8 4 12

Building Collapses and Nearly Collapses

Estimated by TELES

縣市Number of Building Collapses/Near CollapsesLow-Rise Mid-Rise High-Rise Sum

Tainan 228 35 5 268

Kaohsiung 68 11 4 83

Pingtung 4 0 0 4

Chiayi 2 0 0 2

Total 302 46 9 357

Print and Electronic Media Reports (1/2)

台南多棟大樓倒塌國官警消全力救援(News Radio, Broadcasting Corporation of China, 中廣新聞網 , 5:57am, Feb 6, 2016)

� 台南市永康永大路維冠大樓，整棟十六樓高的建築，不堪強烈地震搖晃倒塌，橫倒在「永大」路上。國軍官兵以及警消人員都已經趕到現場，包括消防署南部特搜中心，以及屏東和高雄特搜人員正在進行救援。目前已經救出三十四人。

26

前已經救出三十四人。� 台南歸仁也有大樓倒塌，七樓變四樓。地點在台南市歸仁區大仁路與大

通路路口 ，目前正在救援中。� 山上區南洲里房屋傾斜，有多名民眾受困，在五點左右，先救出三人，

之後再救出七人，目前屋內初步勘查，已經沒有人受困。� 東區長東街市場附近有大樓傾斜無人受困。新化京城銀行大樓傾斜，無

人受困。另有多起電梯受困狀況，目前都已經解除。

Print and Electronic Media Reports (2/2)

27

Building collapses in Yongkang District , Tainan

Sites of Severe Losses and Damages

1. Weikuan Jinlong (維冠金龍/燦坤) Complex, YongkangDistrict, Tainan City

2. King's Town Bank (京城銀行), Sinhua District, Tainan City

3. Dachih Market Place (大智市場), East District, Tainan City

4. Wind God’s Temple (風神廟), West Central District, Tainan CityCity

5. On Xinyi N. Rd. & Daren St., Gueiren District, Tainan City

6. Temple of Goddess Mazu, Cishan District, Kaohsiung City (旗山天后宮)

7. Lane 101, Taizi Rd. (太子路), Rende District, Tainan City

8. 205 Minzu Rd. (民族路), Yujing District, Tainan City

9. Tainan Municipal Yujing Junior High School (玉井國中)

10. Tainan Municipal Beimen Elementary School at Yuhu Branch (北門國小玉湖分校)

28

Sites of Losses and Damages

• 12 Lane 27, Sec. 5 Fuan Rd., Annan Dist., Tainan City (building tilt and displaced)

• 93 Lane 141, Dade St., South Dist., Tainan City (broken water pipeline, possibly elevator shaft damage or drop, wounded civilians, building damages)

• 104 Nanzhou, Shanshang Dist., Tainan City (Building collapse)• 104 Nanzhou, Shanshang Dist., Tainan City (Building collapse)

• 18 Alley 9, Lane 100, Heping Rd., Guanmiao Dist., Tainan City (unoccupied 1-story building collapse)

• 13 Nanxing St., Gueiren Dist., Tainan City (collapse of a 3-story RC building)

• 17 Shenkeng 3rd St., Guanmiao Dist., Tainan City（top story collapse of a 3-story RC building）

29

Coordinates of Reconnaissance

Spots and TELES-Estimated PGAs

No.0206 Meinong Eqk. Location of

Major DamagesLong._WG

S84Lat._WGS

84Long._TW

D67Lat._TWD

67

EstimatedPGA (gal)GeoMean

1 Weikuan Jinlong (維冠金龍/燦坤)

Complex, Yongkang District, Tainan120.261 23.00523 120.253 23.00697 144

2 King's Town Bank (京城銀行), Tainan 120.301 23.03636 120.2929 23.0381 171

3 Dachih Market Place (大智市場), 120.231 22.96216 120.2225 22.9639 163

30

3 Dachih Market Place ( ),

Tainan120.231 22.96216 120.2225 22.9639 163

4 Wind God’s Temple (風神廟), Tainan 120.196 22.99711 120.1876 22.99885 219

5 On Xinyi N. Rd. & Daren St., Tainan 120.298 22.96727 120.2895 22.96901 220

6 Temple of Goddess Mazu, Cishan (旗山天后宮)

120.482 22.88667 120.4742 22.88842 303

7 Lane 101, Taizi Rd. (太子路), Tainan 120.267 22.98984 120.2593 22.99158 151

8 205 Minzu Rd. (民族路), Tainan 120.468 23.1238 120.4598 23.12555 217

9 Yujing Junior High School, Tainan 120.47 23.12379 120.4615 23.12554 220

10 Beimen Elementary School at Yuhu

Branch , Tainan120.139 23.2616 120.1311 23.26333 141

11 Beimen Elementary School (北門國小) , Tainan

120.125 23.26509 120.1171 23.26682 126

Locations of Major Damages

31

20160206主要災情座標.kmz

32

33

Tainan Municipal Beimen Elementary

School and its Yuhu Branch

34

Tainan Municipal Yujing Junior High School

35

(1) Weikuan Jinlong (維冠金龍/燦坤) Complex

• On Section 2, Yongda Rd. and Guoguang 5th

St., Yongkang District, Tainan City

• 16-story RC building collapse

36

Before Earthquake (Google Street View)

37

Before Earthquake (Google Street View)

38

After Earthquake

39Source: https://sketchfab.com/models/5dca0c84762e4b58b63614bbe1aa70e1

After Earthquake

40

After Earthquake

41

After Earthquake

42

43

44

(2) King's Town Bank (京城銀行), Sinhua District

• 586 Zhongshan Rd., Sinhua District, Tainan

City

• 10-story

45

Before Earthquake (Google Street View)

46

Before Earthquake (Google Street View)

47

Photographical View of King's Town

Bank (京城銀行) after Earthquake

48

Photographical View

of King‘s Town Bank

(京城銀行) after

Earthquake

49

(3) Dachih Market Place, East District

• Lane 103, Changdong St., East Dist., Tainan

City

• Commercial-residential complex building (4-

story above ground, 1-story underground)story above ground, 1-story underground)

• Soft 1st story collapse, some of 4-story

buildings became 3-story

50

51

After Earthquake

52

After Earthquake

53

After Earthquake

54

(4) Wind God’s Temple (風神廟),

West Central District

• 8, Lane 143, Section 3 Minquan Rd., West

Central District, Tainan City

55

After Earthquake

(5) On Xinyi N. Rd. & Daren St.,

Guiren Dist.

• 46 Xinyi N. Rd., Guiren Dist., Tainan City

• 6-story RC building

58

(6) Temple of Goddess Mazu,

Cishan District (旗山天后宮)

• 16 Lane 23, Yongfu St., Chishan District,

Kaohsiung City

• Collapse of decorated archway

62

(7) Lane 101, Taizi Rd. (太子路),

Rende District, Tainan City

63

64

65

66

67

68

(8) 205 Minzu Rd. (民族路),

Yujing District, Tainan City

69

205 Minzu Rd. (民族路), Yujing

District, Tainan City

70

205 Minzu Rd. (民族路),

Yujing District, Tainan City

71

School Buildings

County School BuildingAssessment

Result

Estimated PGA

(gal)

Tainan

City

Yujing Junior High

School

Junior

College

Building

CDR=1.08 220.3745

Beimen Elementary

School

(Yuhu Branch)

West

BuildingIs=222(?) 125.5235

7272

Beimen Elementary

School

West

Building125.5235

Pingtung

County

Gaoshu Township (高樹鄉) Tianzi

Elementary School (田子國小)

Classroom

Building

Sandimen Township

(三地門鄉) Cingye Elementary

School (青葉國小)

Dancing

Classroom

Plan of Yujing Junior High School (玉井國中)

震損校舍

Junior College Building, Yujing Junior High School (玉井國中) before Earthquake

Built in 1998

Age of bldg: 28 yrs.

3-story

Damage of Junior College Building, Yujing

Junior High School (玉井國中)

7676

Damage of Junior College Building, Yujing

Junior High School (玉井國中)

7777

Damage of Junior College Building, Yujing Junior

High School (玉井國中) (A7 Column)

Damage of Junior College Building, Yujing Junior

High School (玉井國中)

Built in 1997

Age of bldg: 29 yrs.

Activity Center, Yujing Junior High School

(before Earthquake)

Damage of Activity Center, Yujing Junior High School

Damage of Activity Center, Yujing Junior High School

Damage of Activity Center, Yujing Junior High School

Damage of Activity Center, Yujing Junior High School

Damage of Yujing Junior High School

Plan of Beimen Elementary School at YuhuBranch

震損校舍

8686

West Building, Beimen Elementary School

at Yuhu Branch (before Earthquake)

Damage of West Building, Beimen Elementary

School at Yuhu Branch (北門國小玉湖分校)

8989

Damage of West Building, Beimen

Elementary School at Yuhu Branch

9090

Plan of Beimen Elementary School (北門國小)

震損校舍

West Building, Beimen Elementary School

(北門國小) before Earthquake

Damage of West Building, Beimen

Elementary School (北門國小)

West Building, Beimen Elementary School

(北門國小) after Earthquake

Highway Bridges

• 10 cm settlement and ruptures on pavement surface were observed of the Tungshipu Bridge deck (東勢埔橋) on Provincial Highway #3, Neimen District, Kaohsiung, and was emergency closed

• Water pipeline broke at 12k+150 on Provincial • Water pipeline broke at 12k+150 on Provincial Highway #20 (urban area of Sinhua Dist, Tainan), and 10 m of pavement surface sustained ruptures on the West Bound Fast Lane, road closed for traffic, and water supply was cut off.

• Pavement buckles (20 cm uplift) on Provincial Highway #3 in Cishan District (旗山)

96

Lifelines

• There were 69 major electric power line outages in Tainan City, affecting 12,1672 households

• Power outage in 467 households, Kaohsiung City

• Shutdown of Unit 2, Hsinta Coal-fired Power Plant (興達發電廠), Cieding District (茄萣區), Kaohsiung City發電廠), Cieding District (茄萣區), Kaohsiung City

• Maanshan NPP’s two nuclear units remained operational (unaffected)

• Shutdown of one distribution substation (D/S) in mountain area of Tainan, and shutdown of LongtienSecondary Substation (隆田二次變電所, S/S)

97

Nanpao (南寶) Golf Course

98

99