2 (14) universal upper air sounding system

2 (14) Universal Upper Air Sounding System

World Meteorological Organization WMO Technical Conference on Meteorological and Evironmental Instruments and Methods of Observation – TECO 2005

2

What is a Universal Upper Air System?

1. Flies sondes from any qualified manufacturer

2. Operates in multiple modes (RDF/GPS)

3. Complies with WMO and national reporting requirements

Photo courtesy of NOAA Archive

3

Universal System

1930s

Photo courtesy of NOAA Archive

Optical Theodolite

4

Universal System1940s

Photo courtesy of NOAA Archive

SCR-658 Manual Radiotheodolite

5

ART-1 and ART-2 Automatic RadiotheodolitesPhotos courtesy of NOAA Archive

Universal System: 1950s

6

1990: GPS Revolution• Rapidly dominates

synoptic market by offering high accuracy and ease of use

• High cost of disposables becomes unsustainable for many operators - leading to darkened sites

Image courtesy of USAF Research Lab

7

• In 2000 the Radiotheodolite returns as part of the NWS Radiosonde Replacement System

Photo: InterMet Systems

8

TRS: Telemetry Receiving System

• Multi-Sonde Compatible • Dual-Mode (GPS / RDF)• Digital Architecture• All Environment• High Gain / Long Range• Easy to Operate

Photo: InterMet Systems

9

2002: iMet-1500

• TRS technology in a flexible format

• Digital receiver with tunable bandwidth

• Multi-sonde compatible

• Multi-mode GPS/RDF• Military or Synoptic

Photo: InterMet Systems

10

2004: iMet-1700 • TRS technology at a

lower cost• Fixed site installations • Fewer moving parts,

reduced maintenance • Multi-sonde

compatible• Multi-mode GPS/RDF

Photo: InterMet Systems

11

Operational factors favor 403 MHz GPS: GPS

• Maintenance free• Accurate winds in all

conditions• Release and forget

operations

RDF• Complex hardware• Inaccurate winds at

low elevation angles• Training and

experience required

When properly integrated, PTU is a function of the radiosonde, and should be independent of the wind finding methodology

12

Tanzania Evaluation

• In October 2004, a team lead by Dr. John Nash from the Met Office evaluated an iMet-1500 installation on behalf of the WMO.– More training was required for a staff that had

not conducted synoptic flights for 10 years– Identified important integration issues– RDF Wind accuracy was deemed acceptable for

operational use in the Tropics

13

RDF Winds as Function of Height

14

GPS Winds as Function of Height

15

GPS vs. RDF Winds

16

Cost factors favor Universal RDF:• Low cost disposable• Multiple vendors for sonde reorders

Activity Level Total $ Per Flight % Diff 10 yr Life

365 flights peryear

$ 19,300 $ 53 30% $ 193,000

730 flights peryear

$ 44,850 $ 62 37% $ 448,000

Estimated Savings from Universal RDF System:

17

Universal Compatibility:• The Signal Processor

(decoder) is the key to multi-sonde use

Signal Processor

• Other Issues:– Bandwidth– Frequency selection– Transfer of calibration

coefficients– Solar correction

18

Meteorological Issues:

• Are RDF winds accurate enough for tropical locations with a low incidence of low angle tracking?

• Is a competitive market for annual sonde reorders compatible with providing consistent PTU time series data?

19

Conclusions:

• There is a place for Universal RDF Systems in the GUAN

• Additional work needs to be done on data quality and the potential impact of annual sonde changes

Photo courtesy of NOAA Archive