1 assessing the impact: tvbygirls media literacy program beth mcguire ree may 16 th 2007

1

Assessing the Impact: TVbyGirls Media Literacy Program

Beth McGuire ReeMay 16th 2007

2

Media’s Presence

Most kids watch 3-5 hours of TV a day Nearly 70% have internet access at

home

3

Issue: Media’s Influence

How can we lessen the impact of media’s negative influence on youth?

4

Media Literacy

Ability to interpret media messages

Ability to think critically

Ability to analyze media content

Proactive vs. passive approach

5

Growth in Media Literacy Education

Relatively new to schools No national standards Effectiveness is questioned

Also offered by a number of non-profit extracurricular programs Girl Scouts NEDA Go Girls! Local programs like YWCA

6

Local Response: TVbyGirls

Started in 2001 by local filmmakers with a particular interest in the power of media

2-4 hour workshops and camp sessions focused on media literacy

Select girls are further engaged through mentorship and learning applied media skills

7

Problem: Need Evidence of Impact

Affirm workshop format Guide future content Ensure it is making a difference Improve grant seeking

8

Research Question

Do the TVbyGirls workshops have a lasting impact on the media literacy skills of the program participants?

9

Methodology

Mailed survey sent to 146 previous program participants

Questionnaire consisted of 15 questions, most on effectiveness of program

Respondents incented with chance to win $100 Target gift card

10

Results

44 of 146 responded

30% response rate

Response limited due to availability and accuracy of contact information

Over half of the respondents are in high school

11

Results: Critical Thinking

“I became more aware of how women and girls are shown in the media.”

81% agree/strongly agree

12

Results: Critical Thinking

“I think more about the media because of what I learned from TVbyGirls.”

68% agree/strongly agree

13

Results: Critical Thinking

“I am able to tell the difference between realistic and stereotypical images of women in the media.”

95% agree/strongly agree

14

Results: Cultural differences

54% agree “I learned more about different cultures.”

28% disagreed/strongly disagree 18% unsure

15

Results: Personal Change

“I felt more confident about myself.” 68% agree/strongly agree

16

Results: Personal Change

“I would recommend TVbyGirls to my friends.” 81% agree/strongly agree

17

Results: Media Education

77% already receiving media literacy education in school and elsewhere

82% want to receive more media literacy education from TVbyGirls

18

Results: Media Education How would you like to receive more

information about the media from TVbyGirls?

9%

18%

27%

32%

32%

50%Additional Workshops

Email Updates

Website

Mailed Newsletter

Not Interested

Other

19

Results: Lasting Impact

“I still think about the things I learned from TVbyGirls.”

82% agree/strongly agree

“I feel the information has been valuable.”

86% agree/strongly agree

20

Results

Do the TVbyGirls workshops have a lasting impact on the media literacy skills of its participants?

YES

21

Key Observations

Program has been successful

Girls still think about what they learned

They continue to identify stereotypes and unrealistic images

Want to learn more from TVbyGirls

22

Recommendations

Continue to look for ways to optimize cultural relevancy

Work with schools to minimize duplication and differentiate TVbyGirls

Provide more workshops and online information

23

Questions?

24

“TVbyGirls had an extremely positive effect on me, it will be a part of me for the rest of my life.” -- Respondent