alliin
TRANSCRIPT
ANTIMICROBIAL ACTIVITIES OF SULFUR COMPOUNDS DERIVED FROM S-ALK(EN)YL-L-CYSTEINE
SULFOXIDES IN ALLIUM AND BRASSICA
K. H. Kyung1 and Y. C. Lee2
1Dept. of Food Sci., Sejong Univ., Seoul 143-747, Korea
2Dept. of Food Sci. & Technol., Chung-Ang Univ., Ansung 456-756, Korea
ABSTRACT
Allium and Brassica vegetables have long been known for their antimicrobial activity against various
microorganisms, including Gram-positive and Gram-negative bacteria and fungi. Most of microorganisms
tested were sensitive to extracts of the Allium and Brassica vegetables and the degree of sensitivity
varied depending on the strain under study and test conditions. Among the vegetables, garlic showed
the most potent activity, followed by onion. Brassica including cabbage showed the least potent activity.
The principal antimicrobial compounds of Allium and Brassica have been elucidated as allicin (S-allyl-L-
propenethiosulfinate) and methyl methanethiosulfinate, respectively. Both compounds belong to the
same chemical group, thiosulfinate, generated from S-allyl and S-methyl derivatives of L-cysteine
sulfoxide, respectively, existing in Allium and Brassica as major non-protein sulfur containing amino
acids. There have been only few applications of garlic as a natural food preservative, in spite of
numerous studies on antimcirobial activity of the vegetables. Relative instability of the antimicrobial
compounds and strong odor of their mother plants seem to limit the use of them as a practical food
preservative.
KEY WORDS: Antimicrobial activity, S-alk(en)yl-L-cysteine sulfoxide, garlic, cabbage, Allium and Brassica
INTRODUCTION
The antimicrobial activities of plant extracts, especially from Allium and Brassica have been recognized
for many years, since Walton et al. (1) and Sherman and Hodge (2) scientifically demonstrated the
presence of antimicrobial activity of garlic (Allium sativum) and cabbage (Brassica oleracae),
respectively. The major antimicrobial activity of Allium (3,4) and Brassica (5) vegetables is proven to be
due to volatile sulfur compounds derived from S-alk(en)yl-L-cysteine sulfoxide, as well as glucosinolates
in case of Brassica (6-8). The presence of S-alkenyl-L-cysteine sulfoxides is confined essentially to two
families; the Cruciferae and the Lilliaceae where they are particularly associated with Allium and Brassica
(9).
The antimicrobial activity of garlic has been the most studied area for natural antimicrobials. Cavallito
and Bailey (3) succeeded in isolating allicin (allyl 2-propenethiosulfinate) which is absent in intact garlic,
but generated from its precursor, alliin (S-allyl-L-cysteine sulfoxide), through enzymatic hydrolysis when
the tissue of garlic is disrupted (3, 4, 10). Although relatively fewer research has been conducted on the
antimicrobial activity of cabbage compared with garlic, the presence of antimicrobial activity of Brassica
including cabbage, has been confirmed (5, 11-14) following the initial demonstration of the activity in
1936 by Sherman and Hodge (2). S-Methyl-L-cysteine sulfoxide (SMCSO), a non-protein sulfur-containing
amino acid in Brassica (15-17), is structurally similar to alliin, another example of non-protein amino acid
commonly found in Allium including garlic. SMCSO and alliin are methyl and allyl derivatives of L-cysteine
sulfoxide, respectively. The two compounds generate methyl methanethiosulfinate (MMTSO) and allicin,
which are principal antimicrobial compounds of Brassica and Allium, respectively, as a result of enzyme
reaction when the tissue of vegetables is disrupted. MMTSO and allicin have similar chemical structure,
and are methyl and allyl derivatives of thiosulfinate. Some other genera among Cruciferae, Synapis (S.
alba L.; mustard), Raphanus (R. sativus; radish), Cherianthus (C. cheiri; wallflower), and Capsell (C.
bursa-pastoris L.; shepherd's purse) also contain SMCSO (15). Although Allium and Brassica vegetables
have been reported to have other biological activities, such as cancer-preventive (17, 18, 20, 21), anti-
ulcerative (22), serum lipid-lowering (23), antiviral (24), antithrombotic (25), hemolytic anaemia-causing
(26, 27) and enzyme inhibitory (28-32) activities, this article reviews the chemistry of S-alk(en)yl-L-
cysteine-sulfoxides of Allium and Brassica and the antimicrobial activity of sulfur compounds derived
from them.
ANTIMICROBIAL ACTIVITY OF EXTRACTS OF ALLIUM AND BRASSICA VEGETABLES
Antimicrobial activity of garlic extract has been recognized for many years. It was reported that 1-2%
garlic extract inhibited microbial growth, and higher concentrations were germicidal. Dababneh and Al-
Delaimy (33) reported that 1% garlic extract inhibited Staphylococcus aureus. Karaioannoglou et al. (34)
indicated that garlic extract >1% in culture media was inhibitory to Lactobacillus plantarum, and >2%
was bactericidal. Mantis et al. (35) showed that 2% garlic extract in culture media had growth inhibitory
effects against S. aureus. Extracts of <1% were non-inhibitory and those of >5% were germicidal. Garlic
extract at 1% was strongly inhibitory against yeasts (36). Salmonella typhimurium (37), Bacillus cereus
(38), Clostridium botulinum (39), C. perfringens (40), Candida utilis (24, 41) and many other bacteria (24,
42, 43) and fungi (24, 44, 45) have been inhibited by garlic extract. S. aureus, Escherichia coli, Proteus
mirabilis and Pseudomonas aeruginosa which are multiple resistant to antibiotics including penicillin,
streptomycin, doxycilline and cephalexin were inhibited by garlic extract (46). A multiple resistant
Klebsiella sp. was not inhibited by garlic extract. hin et al. (47) evaluated the antimicrobial activity of
garlic juice powder dehydrated by different methods. Freeze-dried garlic juice powder showed high
inhibitory effect on Gram positive bacteria (Bacillus subtilis, S. aureus and Streptococcus mutans) having
0.3 2.0% minimum inhibitory concentrations (MIC). But spray-dried garlic juice powder did not have
inhibitory effect on Gram positive bacteria, except B. subtilis. Garlic juice powder processed with both
hydration methods did not show any difference in inhibitory effects on E. coli and E. coli O 157:H7 with
1.0 2.0%. The antimicrobial activity of onion is relatively weaker than that of garlic and an area of fewer
research. While 1-4% garlic extract completely inhibited E. coli, S. typhosa, Shigella dysenterie and S.
aureus, 4% onion extract completely inhibited the growth of only S. dysenterie and S. aureus. (42).
However, in a test with non-growing S. typhimurium, freshly reconstituted dehydrated onion showed a
stronger bactericidal activity compared with freshly reconstituted dehydrated garlic (37). The presence
of the antimicrobial activity in cabbage is definite (5, 11-13, 48, 49), but much less potent compared with
those of garlic and onion. The antimicrobial activity of cabbage was reported to be destroyed by heating
(2, 11) as is the case with garlic. Yildiz and Westhoff (49), however, reported that heating caused
cabbage extract to become inhibitory. Kyung and Fleming (5) demonstrated inhibitory activity in fresh,
unheated juice of several cultivars of cabbage. Heating the cabbage before juice extraction prevented
formation of the inhibitor(s) in some cultivars, but not others. The growth inhibitory substance of fresh
cabbage was suggested to be carbohydrate in nature and of low molecular weight (13, 14). The identity
of the inhibitory compound has recently been elucidated as MMTSO generated from SMCSO in cabbage
(48).
S-ALK(EN)YL-L-CYSTEINE SULFOXIDES; THE PRECURSORS
Brassica is taxonomically far apart from the genus Allium which includes garlic and onion. However, they
have in common, that S-alk(en)yl-L-cysteine sulfoxides as major non-protein amino acids (50). S-
Alk(en)yl-L-cysteine sulfoxides were suggested to be important in sulfur metabolism, acting as a soluble
pool for organic sulfur (51). The amounts vary widely depending on plant species and on different parts
of the plants (16, 48). The general structure of the S-alk(en)yl-L-cysteine sulfoxides is shown in Fig. 1.
Five S-alk(en)yl-L-cysteine sulfoxides differing in R-side group have been described; four in Allium and
one in Brassica. Variety of R-side group of S-alk(en)yl-L-cysteine sulfoxides together with some source
plants and their amounts are given in Table 1.
Figure 1. Enzymatic cleavage of S-alk(en)yl-L-cysteine sulfoxides
Rundqvist (52) made the first effort to isolate the basic principle from which volatile sulfur compounds
are generated in garlic. Owing to the fact that the precipitation he obtained contained considerable
quantities of carbohydrate, he thought that the compound he was seeking was a glucoside which he
named "alliin". The term alliin has since been used (4). Later, pure alliin has been isolated by Stoll and
Seebeck (53) and identified as an amino acid. Alliin was chemically synthesized in 1951 by the same
group(54). SMCSO was initially isolated from cruciferous vegetables in two separate laboratories at the
approximately same time (15, 16). They analyzed SMCSO in cruciferous vegetables among which
Brassica contained it invariably, while other genera in Cruciferae showed mixed results.
Table 1. Kinds and amounts of S-alk(en)yl-L-cysteine sulfoxides in Allium and Brassica*.
Genus Alk(en)yl group Plant sources and amounts of S-alk(en)yl-L-cysteine sulfoxides(mg/kg) in parentheses
Allium methyl garlic, elephant garlic, wild garlic, onion [200 (9)], leek, scallion, shallot, Chinese chive
propyl onion [50 (9)], leek, scallion, shallot, chive
propenyl garlic, elephant garlic, wild garlic, onion [40* (9), leek, scallion, shallot, Chinese chive, chive
allyl garlic [900-11500 (54)], elephant garlic, wild garlic, Chinese chive
Brassica methyl
cabbage [185-2218 (15-17, 47, 60)], kale [1310-1380 (26)], turnip[43-202 (16)], swede, Chinese
cabbage [396-786 (16, 50)], cauli-flower [2380 (16)], kohlrabi [558-1069 (16)], broccoli [343-
2406(16, 61)]
From Block et al. (10).
When S-alk(en)yl-L-cysteine sulfoxides of garlic were analyzed by reverse-phase HPLC, S-methyl-
and S-allyl-L-cysteine sulfoxides were the only compounds which were identified with certainty (55).
Other sulfur amino acids were not found. Ziegler & Sticher (55) opined that the minor derivatives of
L-cysteine sulfoxide were absent or were below detection limits under the chromatographic
conditions. From the GC analytical results of thiosulfinates of crushed garlic, Freeman and
Whenham (56) showed that the L-cysteine sulfoxide fraction of garlic consists of 85% alliin along
with 2% S-propyl cysteine sulfoxide and 13% SMCSO. Therefore it can be safely assumed that the
concentration of minor L-cysteine sulfoxides could be too low to be detected by HPLC by Ziegler and
Sticher (55). Block et al. (10) reported HPLC analytical results of thiosulfinates of garlic and showed
that their ratios of allyl/methyl were similar to that of Freeman and Whenham (56). The allyl/methyl
ratio of garlic (10) ranged from 94:2 (New York grown) to 80:16 (store bought garlic) to 74:24
(Indian garlic grown at 32℃). Occurrence of ethyl (57, 58), and propyl (56) and butyl (58)
derivatives in garlic and allyl derivatives in onion (59) was suggested, but has never been positively
confirmed since (55). Allyl groups are absent in onion, scallion, shallot, leek, and chive and propyl
groups are absent in garlic, elephant garlic, wild garlic and Chinese chive (10; Table 1), judging from
various thiosulfinates isolated from Allium plants (Table 2).
Table 2. Thiosulfinates from the extracts of Allium and Brassica
Thiosulfinates Allium and Brassica vegetables
AllSS(O)propenyl-(E): garlic, elephant garlic
AllS(O)Spropenyl-(Z,E): garlic, elephant garlic, wild garlic
AllS(O)Sall: garlic, elephant garlic, wild garlic
n-pro-SS(O)propenyl-(E): onion, shallot, scallion, leek, chive
n-pro-S(O)S-propenyl-(Z,E): onion, shallot, scallion, leek, chive
n-pro-S(O)S-pro-n: onion, shallot, scallion, leek, chive
Me-S(O)S-Me: onion, shallot, scallion, leek, garlic, all Brassica
All-S(O)S-Me: garlic, elephant garlic, wild garlic, Chinese chive
Me-S(O)S-propenyl-(Z,E): onion, shallot, scallion, leek, garlic, elephant garlic, wild garlic, Chinese chive, chive
Me-SS(O)-pr: onion, shallot, scallion, leek, chive
Me-S(O)S-pr: onion, shallot, scallion, leek, chive
All-SS(O)-Me: garlic, elephant garlic, wild garlic, Chinese chive
Me-S(O)S-Me: onion, shallot, scallion, leek, garlic, elephant garlic, wild garlic, Chinese chive, chive
From Block et al. (1992). For Brassica, Marks et al. 1992
The concentration of the minor unsymmetrical thiosulfinates, which possess 1-propenyl group, varied
with the age and storage condition of garlic following harvesting. 1-Propenyl levels increased upon
refrigeration (10). All the Brassica vegetables including kale, swede, turnip, cabbage, Chinese cabbage,
cauliflower, kohlrabi and broccoli contains only S-methyl- derivative of L-cysteine sulfoxide (16; Table 1).
Onion contained γ-L-glutamyl-(+)-S-propenyl-L-cysteine sulfoxide and cycloalliin in addition to propyl,
methyl, propenyl derivatives of L-cysteine sulfoxide. Cycloalliin could be an artefact during elution from
cationic exchange resin, since S-propenyl-L-cysteine sulfoxide spontaneously cyclizes at pH> 7 (9).
Growth condition is known to modify the profile of S-alkenyl-L-cysteine sulfoxides of Allium and Brassica.
Some garlic varieties grown in cooler climates show a higher allyl to methyl ratio than garlic grown in
warmer climates (10). For example, NY grown garlic revealed low levels of (+)S-methyl-L-cysteine
sulfoxide (0.08-0.25mg/g of garlic compared to 1-1.6mg/g in California garlic) with normal levels of other
derivatives (10). Block et al.(10) suggested that garlic grown in colder climates are subject to stress and
that this stress causes reduced synthesis of SMCSO. Cruciferous vegetable species like kale, however,
has been known to accumulate more SMCSO when grown during periods of frost (60, 61).
ENZYMES AND THEIR REACTION PRODUCTS
Enzymes
In Allium plants, Alliin and alliinase are located in different compartments (63); the substrates in the
cytoplasm and enzyme in the vacuole. The reaction of alliinase (Fig. 1) takes place extremely rapidly, a
fact which is in agreement with the instantaneous appearance of the typical odor on crushing garlic.
More than 80% of the alliin is split by the enzyme within 2 minutes (4). The molecular weight of the
enzymes in onion and broccoli are quite similar (50, 64) and the enzyme appears to consist of a trimer
with a subunit molecular weight of approximately 50,000. All of these enzymes are glycoproteins
consisting of 5.8-6.0% carbohydrate by weight (50, 65). Cabbage leaves (66) and broccoli (50) have two
cystine lyases with somewhat different specificities. Alliinase of Allium and cystine lyase of Brassica act
on common substrate, S-alk(en)yl-L-cysteine sulfoxide (50) and Hamamoto & Mazelis (50) proposed a
new name L-cysteine sulfoxide lyase. Optimum pH range of onion and broccoli enzymes is 8.0-8.6 (50,
69), and of garlic enzyme is 5-8 (4, 50). Action of alliinase on the mixture of sulfoxides forms
allyl/methane, methyl/methane and other mixed thiosulfinates in addition to allicin (56). When studied
with synthetic alliin, (-)-S-allyl-L-cysteine sulfoxide was disintegrated more slowly compared to its (+)
isomer (54). In addition to methyl and propenyl derivatives of L-cysteine sulfoxide, as flavor precursors of
onion, γ-L-glutamyl-L-cysteine sulfoxide is present and is thus insusceptable to the action of the C-S lyase
(68). Since γ-L-glutamyl transpeptidase catalyzes the hydrolysis (Fig. 2) as well as glutamyl transfer, the
addition of this enzyme to onion liberate the flavor precursor, which in turn destroyed by C-S lyase (67,
68). γ-L-Glutamyl transpeptidase is found in sprouted onion. In addition to already-described alliinase
reaction common to Allium, alliinase of onion and leek, but not of garlic, has been reported to have an
activity of generating lachrymatory compound, thiopropanal S-oxide (70). Marks,et al. (17) reported the
formation of MMTSO, methyl methanethiosulfonate (MMTSO2) and dimethyl trisulfide (DMTS) in a model
system composed of SMCSO and partially purified cabbage C-S lyase. Bacteria are also known to have
enzyme(s) that catalyzes the hydrolysis of S-alk(en)yl-L-cysteine sulfoxides. Stoll and Seebeck (4)
reported the development of an odor of garlic, when E. coli was cultured in synthetic nutrient medium
with 0.2% alliin. Bacterial enzymes of Pseudomonas cruciviae (71) and Bacillus subtilis (72) catalyzed the
stoichiometric conversion of SMCSO to MMTSO, pyruvate and ammonia and required pyridoxal phosphate
as a coenzyme (71), as other alliinases and C-S lyases did. SMCSO is converted to dimethyl disulfide
(DMDS) by unspecified rumen microorganisms and cause hemolytic anaemia in cattle and sheep, known
as kale poisoning (27).
Figure 2. Liberation of L-cysteine sulfoxide from γ-glutamylpeptide in onion
Products and Their Chemistry
Cavallito and Bailey (3) succeeded in isolating a water-soluble antimicrobial substance from an aqueous
ethanolic extract of garlic by steam distillation under reduced pressure and named it "allicin", and the
Cavallito group (73) correctly assigned the structure as allyl-S(O)-S-allyl. Block et al. (10) made an HPLC
analysis of thiosulfinates in garlic and reported that the major thiosulfinates from garlic and elephant
garlic was allicin. Other kinds of thiosulfinates identified from the extracts of Allium species are as in
Table 2. Sinha et al. (59) reported a finding of allicin from the supercritical CO2 extract of onion. The
discrepancy was explained by Block et al. (10) as an artifact due to very high injection port temperature
employed by Sinha et al. (59). GC analysis employing high temperature may induce chemical
modification of less stable compounds during the procedure of chromatography. Block (74) urges to use
nonthermal methods of analysis like HPLC when volatile compounds of garlic are of interest. Allicin is not
stable, even at 3℃, and it loses its activity within 14 days (4). Brodnitz et al. (75) observed that allicin
underwent complete decomposition at 20℃ after 20hr resulting in DADS, diallyl trisulfide (DATS), diallyl
sulfide and sulfur dioxide. But allicin in garlic juice underwent complete decomposition at 40℃ after
144hr (76). The authors postulated that allicin was more stable in garlic juice than in pure state. The
particular instability of the allyl compound appears to be associated with the double bond (77).
Thiosulfinates are unstable toward alkalies, but are stable in dilute acids. The generation of MMTSO was
confirmed in a water extract of macerated Brussels sprouts which was the first evidence of MMTSO
generated enzymatically under natural conditions (17). Unless stored at dry ice temperature, MMTSO,
the primary breakdown product of SMCSO, has been shown to be degraded into volatile sulfur
compounds, including methyl methanethiosulfonate (MMTSO2) and dimethyl disulfide (DMDS) (78, 79;
Fig. 3).
Figure 3. Spontaneous disproportionation of methyl methanethiosulfinate
ANTIMICROBIAL COMPOUNDS DERIVED FROM S-ALK(EN)YL-L-CYSTEINE SULFOXIDES
Before the nature of the antimicrobial substance of garlic is known as allicin by Cavallito and Bailey (3),
some workers ascribed the garlic antimicrobial activity to other compounds including acrolein and
related aldehydes (80). However, antimicrobial activity is not confined to allicin alone, but is a general
property of alk(en)yl esters of alka(e)nethiosulfinate (4). The action of allicin, the first known natural
thiosulfinate is considerably more bacteriostatic than bactericidal (3). It is about equally effective against
Gram-positive and Gram-negative bacteria. A few observations were made by Small et al. (77) relative to
the chemical structure and antimicrobial activity of the thiosulfinates. In general, it requires about the
same quantities of the lower molecular weight thiosulfinates to inhibit Gram-positive as compared with
Gram-negative bacteria, but as the carbon chain length increases, activity against Gram-negative
organisms decreases, while that against Gram positive bacteria increases. Branching results in lowered
activity. Small et al. (81) compared the antimicrobial activity of thiosulfinate and thiosulfonate (synthetic
ethyl ethanethiosulfinate and ethyl ethanethiosulfonate, not found naturally). The two thiol esters were
of comparable antimicrobial activity, with thiosulfonate being slightly more effective against S. aureus
and Klebsiella pneumoniae.
Figure 4. Formation of ajoene from allicin (Block et al., 1984)
Ajoene, a derivative of allicin (Fig. 4), originally reported for its potent antithrombotic activity (25)
exhibited a strong antifungal activity toward Aspergillus niger and C. albicans at <20μg/ml (82). Yoshida
et al.(82) concluded that ajoene had stronger antifungal activity than allicin and that it damages the cell
wall of fungi and thus maintained that growth inhibitory activity of ajoene toward bacteria was not
expected except for a specific strain. Later Naganawa et al. (83) showed a different result concerning
antimicrobial activity of ajoene. They reported that ajoene was strongly inhibitory against Gram-positive
bacteria and yeasts and had various degrees of inhibition against Gram-negative bacteria like E. coli and
P. aeruginosa. DADS, one of degradation products of allicin, was shown to possess antituberculosis
activity (84). MMTSO, the primary breakdown product of SMCSO in Brassica (17, 48), has been shown to
be antibacterial (48). MMTSO is not as potent as allicin. MMTSO decomposes on standing to give
principally MMTSO2, DMDS and dimethyl trisulfide (DMTS) (17, 85), thus decreasing antimicrobial activity
by approximately half, because MMTSO2 has comparable antimicrobial activity with MMTSO, but DMDS
has only slight growth inhibitory activity. Kyung and Fleming (86) tested antimicrobial activity of SMCSO
and its derivatives against 15 bacteria and 4 yeasts. SMCSO itself was uninhibitory while DMDS was only
slightly inhibitory, and DMTS was weakly inhibitory. MMTSO2 was as inhibitory as MMTSO but with
different inhibitory patterns. MMTSOO is also generated in autoclaved cabbage and SMCSO solution and
was shown to be antibacterial (87).
Cysteine inhibits antimicrobial activity of allicin, which may be reactivated by hydrogen peroxide (88).
Antimicrobial activity of garlic was known to be stabilized by hydrogen peroxide (89). However, it is not
in agreement with the report (24) that catalase positive bacteria were sensitive to garlic while less
sensitive bacteria, e.g., lactic acid bacteria, were catalase negative.
MODE OF ACTION
The principal antimicrobial compounds of Allium and Brassica are those belonging to a group known as
thiosulfinate. The antimicrobial activity of thiosulfinates has been explained as a general reaction
between thiosulfinates and -SH groups of essential cellular proteins (41, 73, 77, 81). Small et al. (77)
mentioned that -S(O)S- was responsible for the antimicrobial activity and that reacted readily with
cysteine to yield mixed disulfides. Fujiwara et al. (57) showed essentially the same reaction between
allicin and thiamine. The general reaction (Fig. 5), as proposed by Small et al. (77) can apply to where
thiosulfinates are involved and the reaction is believed to be the common mechanism of antimicrobial
activity of thiosulfinates. Since the proposal of the general inhibitory mechanism of thiosulfinates, some
workers (28-32) have reported specific target processes or enzymes of thiosulfinates. Ghannoum (30)
and Neuwirth et al., (31) reported that allicin inhibited lipid biosynthesis and RNA synthesis, respectively,
without pointing out target enzymes. Wills (28) reported that allicin inhibited the acticity of many -SH
enzymes. Among them most strongly inhibited were xanthine oxidase, succinic dehydrogenase and
triose phosphate dehydrogenase. He confirmed the results of Small et al. (77) that -S(O)-S- group was
essential for the inhibition of -SH enzymes, while -S-S-, -S- and -SO- groups were not effective. Focke et
al. (32) found that allicin inhibited the incorporation of acetate, but not of acetyl CoA or malonate, into
fatty acids and concluded that only acetyl CoA synthetase for the fatty acid synthesis was inhibited by
allicin. They explained that the inhibition of acetyl CoA synthetase by allicin was specific and non-
sulfhydryl effect.
Figure 5. Proposed reaction between thiosulfinates and SH group of cellular proteins
Ajoene is reported to be another potent antimcirobial compound. Yoshida et al. (82), maintaining that
ajoene was even more potent antifungal agent than allicin, assumed that ajoene may damage the cell
walls of fungi, thus not expecting significant antibacterial activity, except for Staphylococcus aureus.
Later, however, Naganawa et al. (83) showed a different result concerning antimicrobial activity of
ajoene. They reported that ajoene was strongly inhibitory against Gram-positive bacteria and yeasts and
had various degrees of inhibition of Gram-negative bacteria like E. coli and P. aeruginosa. Naganawa et
al. (83) postulated that the disulfide group in ajoene appears to be necessary for the antibacterial
activity, since reduction by cysteine abolished its antimicrobial activity. Ajoene does not possess
thiosulfinyl group (Fig. 4).
USES IN FOODS AS A PRESERVATIVE
Although antimicrobial activity of Allium and Brassica vegetables represents a promising area of
research, use of the vegetables as natural food preservatives has not been common. There is only one
known example of using garlic as a food preservative. When Al-Delaimy and Barakat (90) treated ground
camel meat with 5% or more of ground garlic, they could extend storage shelf-life of camel meat at any
given storage temperature. Fifteen percent or more of garlic were found to act as strong bactericides
since the initial microbial population of ground camel meat was completely destroyed and no further
growth of any type of microorganisms was observed. Such a high level of garlic added to foods would be
fine with some segments of population of the world, but not with the rest. A way to reduce the level of
garlic added to foods for extending the shelf-life could be low temperature storage of them. For example,
meat products with added garlic could be stored at the refrigerated temperature with extended shelf-life.
However, there are difficult problems to be solved before garlic products are used as natural food
additives, such as the strong garlic flavor and instability of functional compounds in garlic.
CONCLUSION
The antimicrobial activity of Allium and Brassica used as flavoring agents or food materials have been
recognized for many years. Among the vegetables, garlic has been studied most extensively. The
antimicrobial activity of Allium and Brassica is believed to be due to thiosulfinates enzymatically
generated from S-alk(en)yl-L-cysteine sulfoxides. The antimicrobial action of thiosulfinates and their
derivatives are effective due to -S(O)-S- group in the molecules, which readily react with -SH group of
essential proteins of microorganisms. Ajoene and MMTSO2 which are generated from allicin and MMTSO,
respectively, are also known to possess antimicrobial activity. Levels of garlic normally used as food-
flavoring materials may not be sufficient to obtain the desired preservative effects. Garlic showed an
acceptable preservative effect only when substantial levels were added to food, which may not be
acceptable by many people because of the strong flavor. The relative instability of the activity further
discourage the use of them as food preservatives. We have to acquire ways to enhance stability of
antimicrobial compounds and to decrease objectionable sulfurous odor before finding more use of those
vegetables possessing potent natural antimicrobial activities as a food preservative.
REFERENCES
1 .Walton, L., Herbold, M. and Lindegren, C. C. (1936). Bactericidal effects of vapors from crushed garlic,
Food Res. 1, 163-169.
2. Sherman, J. M. and Hodge, H. M. (1936). The bactericidal properties of certain plant juices, J. Bacteriol.,
31, 96.
3. Cavallito, C. J. and Bailey, J. H. (1944). Allicin, the antibacterial principle of Allium sativum. I. Isolation,
physical properties and antimicrobial action, J. Amer. Chem. Soc., 66, 1950-1951.
4. Stoll, A. and Seebeck, E. (1951). Chemical investigation of alliin, the specific principle of garlic, Adv.
Enzymol., 11, 377-400.
5. Kyung, K. H. and Fleming, H. P. (1994). S-Methyl-L-cysteine sulfoxide as the precursor of methyl
methanethiosulfinate, the principal antibacterial compound in cabbage, J. Food Sci., 59(2), 350-355.
6. Virtanen, A.I. (1962). Some organic sulfur compounds in vegetables and fodder plants and their
significance in human nutrition, Angew. Chem. (Int. ed.), 6, 299-306.
7. Zsolnai, V. T. (1966). Die antimicrobielle Wirkung von Thiocyanaten und Isothiocyanaten. I. Mitteilung,
Arzneim. Forsch., 16, 870-876.
8. Delaquis, P. J. and Mazza, G. (1995). Antimicrobial properties of isothiocyanates in food preservation,
Food Technol., 49(11), 73-84.
9. Virtanen, A. J. (1965). Studies on organosulfur compounds and other labile substances in plants,
Phytochemistry, 4, 207-228.
10. Block, E., Naganathan, S., Putman, D. and Zhao, S.-H. (1992). Allium chemistry: HPLC analysis of
thiosulfinates from onion, garlic, wild garlic (Ramsons), leek, scallion, shallot, elephant (great-headed)
garlic, chive, and Chinese chive. Uniquely high allyl to methyl ratios in some garlic samples, J. Agric. Food
Chem., 40, 2418-2430.
11. Pederson, C. S. and Fisher, P. (1944). The bactericidal action of cabbage and other vegetable juices,
N.Y State Agric. Exp. Sta. Bull., 273.
12. Little, J. E. and Graubaugh, K. K. (1946). Antibiotic activity of some crude plant juices, J. Bacteriol., 52,
587-591.
13. Liu, J. Y., Teraoka, T., Hosokawa, D. and Watanabe, M. (1986). Bacterial multiplication and
antibacterial activities in cabbage leaf tissue inoculated with pathogenic and nonpathogenic bacterium,
Ann. Phytopath. Soc.(Japan) 52, 669-674.
14. Dickerman, J. M. and Lieberman, S. (1952). Studies on the chemical nature of an antibiotic present in
water extract of cabbage, Food Res., 17, 438-441.
15. Synge, R. L. M. and Wood, J. C. (1956). (+)-(S-methyl-L-cysteine S-oxide) in cabbage, Biochem. J., 64,
252-259.
16. Morris, C. J. and Thompson, J. F. (1956). The identification of (+)S-methyl-L-cysteine sulfoxide in
plants, J. Am. Chem. Soc., 78, 1605-1608.
17. Marks, H. S., Hilson, J. A., Leichtweis, H. C. and Stoewsand, G. S. (1992). S-Methylcysteine sulfoxide in
Brassica vegetables and formation of methyl methanethiosulfinate from Brussels sprout, J. Agric. Food
Chem., 40, 2098-2101.
18. Marks, H. S. (1992). Isolation, identification, and genotoxic inhibitory efficacy of naturally occurring
organosulfur compounds present in Brassica vegetables, Cornell Univ., Doctoral Diss.
19. Marks, H. S., Leichtweis, H. C. and Stoesand, G. S. (1991). Analysis of a reported organosulfur,
carcinogen inhibitor; 1,2-dithiole-3-thione in cabagge, J. Agric. Food Chem., 39, 893-895.
20. Caragay, A. B. (1992). Cancer-preventive foods and ingredients, Food Technol., 46, 65-68.
21. Alberto-Puleo, M. (1983). Physiological effects of cabbage with reference to its potential as a dietary
cancer-inhibitor and its use in ancient medicine, J. Ethnopharmacol., 9, 261-272.
22. Cheney, G. (1950). Anti-peptic ulcer dietary factor (vitamin U) in the treatment of peptic ulcer, J. Am.
Dietet. Ass., 26, 668-672.
23. Augusti, K. T. and Mathew, P. T. (1974). Lipid lowering effect of allicin (diallyl disulphide-oxide) on
long term feeding to normal rats, Experientia, 30(5), 468-470.
24. Rees, L. P., Minney, S. F., Plummer, N. T., Slator, J. H. and Skyrme, D. A. (1993). A quantitative
assessment of the antimicrobial activity of garlic (Allium sativum), World J. Microbiol. Biotechnol., 9, 303-
307.
25. Block, E., Ahmed, S., Jain, M.K., Creely, R. W., Apitz-Castro, R. and Cruz, M. R. (1984). (E,Z)-Ajoene: A
potent antithrombotic agent from garlic, J. Am. Chem. Soc., 106, 8295-8296.
26. Whittle, P. J., Smith, R. H. and McIntosh, A. (1976). Estimation of S-methylcysteine sulphoxide (kale
anaemia factor) and its distribution among Brassica forage and root crops, J. Sci. Food Agric., 27, 633-
642.
27. Smith, R. H. (1980). Kale poisoning: The brassica anaemia factor, Veter. Record, 107, 12-15.
28. Wills, E. D. (1956). Enzyme inhibition by allicin, the active principle of garlic, Biochem. J., 63, 514-520.
29. Adetumbi, M., Javor, G. T. and Lau, B.H.S. (1986). Allium sativum (garlic) inhibits lipid synthesis in
Candida albicans, Antimicrob. Agents Chemother., 30, 499-501.
30. Ghannoum, M. A. (1988). Studies of the antimicrobial mode of action of Allium sativum (garlic)J. Gen.
Microbiol., 134, 2917-2924.
31. Feldberg, R. S., Chang, S. C., Kotik, A.N., Nadler, M., Neuwirth, Z., Sundstrom, D. C. and Thompson, N.
H. (1988). In vitro mechanism of inhibition of bacterial cell growth by allicin, Antimicrob. Agents
Chemother. 32, 1763-1768.
32. Focke, M., Feld, A. and Lichtenthaler, H. K. (1990). Allicin, a naturally occurring antibiotic from garlic,
specifically inhibits acetyl-CoA synthetase, FEBS, 261(1), 106-108.
33. Dababneh, . F. A. and Al-Delaimy, K. S. (1984). Inhibition of Staphylococcus aureus by garlic extract,
Lebensm. Wissenschaft. Technol., 17(1), 29-31.
34. Karaioannoglou, P. G., Mantis, A. J. and Panetos, A. G. (1977). The effects of garlic extract on lactic
acid bacteria (Lactobacillus plantarum) in culture media, Lebensm. Wissenschaft. Technol., 10, 148-150.
35. Mantis, A. J., Karaioannoglou, P. G., Spanos, G. P. and Panetos, A. G. (1978). The effect of garlic
extract on food poisoning bacteria in culture media. I. Staphylococcus aureus, Lebensm. Wissenschaft.
Technol., 11, 26-28.
36. Conner, D. E. and Beuchat, L. R. (1984). Effects of essential oils from plants on growth of food
spoilage yeasts, J. Food Sci., 49, 429-434.
37. Johnson, M. G. and Vaughn, R. H. (1969). Death of Salmonella typhimurium and Escherichia coli in the
presence of freshly reconstituted dehydrated garlic and onion, Appl. Microbiol., 17(6), 903-905.
38. Saleem, Z. M. and Al-Delaimy, K. S. (1982). Inhibition of Bacillus cereus by garlic extracts, J. Food
Prot., 45(11), 1007-1009.
39. DeWit, J. C., Notermans, S., Gorin, N. and Kampelmacher, E. H. (1979). Effects of garlic oil or onion oil
on toxin production by Clostridium botulinum in meat slurry, J. Food Prot., 42, 222-224.
40. Mantis, A. J., Koidis, P. A., Karaioannoglou, P. G. and Panetos, A. G. (1979). Effect of garlic extract on
food poisoning bacteria, Lebensm. Wissenschaft. Technol., 12, 230-232.
41. Barone, F. E. and Tansey, M. R. (1977). Isolation, purification, identification, synthesis, and kinetics of
activity of the anticandidal component of Allium sativum, and a hypothesis for its mode of action,
Mycologia, 69, 793-825.
42. Al-Delaimy, K. S. and Ali, S. H. (1970). Antibacterial action of vegetable extracts on the growth of
pathogenic bacteria, J. Sci. Food Agric., 21, 110-112
43. Srivastava, K. C., Perera, A. D. and Saridakis, H. O. (1982). Bacteriostatic effects of garlic sap on
Gram negative pathogenic bacteria - an in vitro study, Lebensm. Wissenschaft. Technol., 15(2), 74-76.
44. Moore, G. S. and Atkins, R. D. (1977). The fungicidal and fungistatic effects of an aqueous garlic
extract on medically important yeast-like fungi, Mycologia, 69, 341-348.
45. Tansey, M. R. and Appleton, J. A. (1975). Inhibition of fungal growth by garlic extract, Mycologia, 67,
409-413.
46. Singh, K. V. and Shukula, N. P. (1984). Activity of multiple resistant bacteria of garlic (Allium sativum)
extract, Fitoterapia, 15(5), 313-315.
47. Shin, D.B., Kim, Y.S. and Lee, Y.C. (1999). Effect of dehydration methods on the antimicrobial activity
of garlic juice powder, 1999 IFT Annual Meeting, 98.
48. Kyung, K. H. and Fleming, H. P. (1994). Antibacterial activity of cabbage juice against lactic acid
bacteria, J. Food Sci., 59(1), 125-129.
49. Yildiz, F. and Westhoff, D. (1981). Associative growth of lactic acid bacteria in cabbage juice, J. Food
Sci., 46, 962-963.
50. Hamamoto, A. and Mazelis, M. (1986). The C-S lyases of higher plants. Isolation and properties of
homogeneous cystine lyase from broccoli, Plant Physiol., 80, 702-706.
51. Mae, T., Ohira, K. and Fujiwara, A. (1971). Fate of (+)S-methyl-L-cysteine sulfoxide in Chinese
cabbage, Brassica pekinensis RUPR, Plant Cell Physiol., 12, 1-11.
52. Rundqvist, C. (1909). Pharmacological incestigation of Allium bulbs, Pharmaceutiskt Notisblad, 18,
323-333.
53. Stoll, A. and Seebeck, E. (1948). Uber Alliin, die genuine Muttersubstanz des Knoblauchols. 1.
Mitteilung uber Allium Substanzen, Helv. Chim Acta, 31, 189-210.
54. Stoll, A. and Seebeck, E. (1951). Die Synthese des naturlichen Alliins und seiner drei optisch aktiven
Isomeren. 5. Mitteilung uber Allium-Substanzen, Helv. Chim. Acta, 34, 481-487.
55. Ziegler, S. J. and Sticher, O. (1989). HPLC of S-alk(en)yl-L-cysteine derivatives in garlic including
quantitative determination of (+)S-allyl-L-cysteine sulfoxide (alliin), Planta Medica, 55, 372-377.
56. Freeman, G. G. and Whenham, R. J. (1975). The use of synthetic (+_)-S-1-propyl-L-cysteine
sulphoxide and of alliinase preparations in studies of flavour changes resulting from processing of onion
(Allium cepa L.), J. Sci. Food Agric., 26, 1333-1346.
57. Fujiwara, M., Yoshimura, M., Tsuno, S. and Murakami, F. (1958). Allithiamine, a newly found
derivative of vitamin B1. IV. On the allicin homologues in the vegetables, J. Biochem. (Japan), 45, 141-
149.
58. Horhammer, L., Wagner, H., Seitz, M. and Vejdelek, Z. J. (1968). Onion flavors and their analysis by
gas chromatography-mass spectrometry, Pharmazie, 23, 462-466.
59. Sinha, N. K., Guyer, D. E., Gage, D. A. and Lira, C. T. (1992). Supercritical carbon dioxide extraction of
onion flavors and their analysis by gas chromatography-mass spectrometry, J. Agric. Food Chem., 40,
842-845.
60. Kunelius, H. T., Sanderson, J. B. and Narashimhalu, P. R. (1987). Effect of seeding date on yields and
quality of green forage crops, Can. J. Plant Sci., 67, 1045-1050.
61. Bradshaw, J. E. and Borzucki, R. (1982). Digestability, S-methyl-L-cysteine sulfoxide content and
thiocyante ion content of cabbage of stockfeeding, J. Sci. Food Agric., 33, 1-5.
62. Arnold, W. N. and Thompson, J. F. (1962). The formation of (+)S-methyl-L-cysteine sulfoxide from S-
methyl-L-cysteine in crucifers, Biochim. Biophys. Acta, 57, 604-606.
63. Lancaster, J. E. and Collin, H. A. (1981). Presence of alliinase in isolated vacuoles and of alkyl cysteine
sulfoxides in cytoplasm of bulbs of onion (Allium cepa), Plant Sci. Lett., 22, 169-176.
64. Anderson, N. W. and Thompson, J. F. (1979). Cystine lyase: beta-cystathionase from turnip roots,
Phytochemistry, 18, 1953-1958.
65. Nock, L. P. and Mazelis, M. (1985). Some new observations on the properties of garlic alliinase, Plant
Physiol., 77, S-115
66. Hall, D. I. and Smith, I. K. (1983). Partial purification and characterization of cystine lyase from
cabbage (Brassica oleraceae var capitata), Plant Physiol., 72, 654-658.
67. Schwimmer, S. (1971). Enzymatic conversion of gamma-L-glutamyl cysteine peptides to pyruvic acid,
a coupled reaction for enhancement of onion flavor, J. Agric. Food Chem., 19, 980-983.
68. Schwimmer, S. and Austin, S. J. (1971). Enhancement of pyruvic acid release and flavor in dehydrated
Allium powders by gamma glutamyl transpeptidases, J. Food Sci., 36, 1081-1085.
69. Mazelis, M. (1963). Demonstration and characterization of cysteine sulfoxide lyase in cruciferae,
Phytochemistry, 2, 15-22.
70. Freeman, G. G. (1975). Distribution of flavor components in onion (Allium cepa L.), leek (Allium
porrum) and garlic (Allium sativum), J. Sci. Food Agric., 26, 471-481.
71. Nomura, J., Nishizuka, Y. and Hayaishi, O. (1963). S-Alkylcysteinase : Enzymatic cleavage of S-methyl-
L-cysteine and its sulfoxide, J. Biol. Chem., 238(4), 1441- 1446.
72. Murakami, F. (1960). Studies on the nutritional value of Allium plants (XXXVI) Decomposition of alliin
homologues by microorganism and formation of substance with thiamine masking activity, Vitamins
(Tokyo), 20, 126.
73. Cavallito, C. J., Buck, J. S. and Suter, C. M. (1944). Allicin, the antibacterial principles of Allium sativim.
II. Determination of the chemical structure, J. Am. Chem. Soc., 66, 1952-1954.
74. Block, E. (1993). Flavor artifacts, J. Agric. Food Chem., 41, 692
75. Brodnitz, M. H., Pascale, J. V. and von Derslice, L. (1971). Flavor components of garlic extract, J. Agric.
Food Chem., 19, 273-275.
76. Yu, T.-H. and Wu, C.-M. (1989). Stability of allicin in garlic juice, J. Food Sci., 54(4), 977-981.
77. Small, L. D., Bailey, J. H. and Cavallito, C. J. (1947). Alkyl thiosulfinates, J. Am. Chem. Soc., 69, 1710-
1713.
78. Moore, T. L. and O'connor, D. E. (1966). The reaction of methanesulfenyl chloride with alkoxides and
alcohols. Preparation of aliphatic sulfenate and sulfinate esters, J. Org. Chem., 31, 3587-3592.
79. Ostermayer, F. and Tarbell, D. S. (1960). Products of acidic hydrolysis of S-methyl-L-cysteine
sulfoxide; isolation of methyl methanethiosulfinate and mechanism of the hydrolysis, J. Am. Chem. Soc.,
82, 3752-3755.
80. Ingersoll, R. L., Volirath, R. E., Scott, B. and Lindegren, C. C. (1938). Bactericidal activity of
crotonaldehyde, Food Res., 3, 389-392.
81. Small, L. D., Bailey, J. H. and Cavallito, C. J. (1949) Comparison of some properties of thiosulfonates
and thiosulfinates, J. Am. Chem. Soc., 71, 3565-3566.
82. Yoshida, S., Kasuga, S., Hayashi, N., Ushiroguchi, T., Matsuura, H. and Nakagawa, S. (1987).
Antifungal activity of ajoene derived from garlic, Appl. Environ. Microbiol., 53(3), 615-617.
83. Naganawa, R., Iwata, N., Ishikawa, K., Fukyda, H., Fujino, T. and Suzuki, A. (1996). Inhibition of
microbial growth by ajoene, a sulfur-containing compound derived from garlic, Appl. Environ. Microbiol.,
62(11), 4238-4242.
84. Brown, H. D., Matzuk, A. R., Becker, H. J., Conbere, J. P., Constantin, J. M., Solotorovsky, M., Winsten,
S., Ironson, E. and Quastel, J. H. (1954). The antituberculosis activity of some ethylmercapto compounds,
J. Am. Chem. Soc., 76, 3860
85. Chin, H.-W. and Linsay, R. C. (1994). Mechanisms of formation of volatile sulfur compounds following
the action of cysteine sulfoxide lyases, J. Agric. Food Chem., 42, 1529-1536.
86. Kyung, K. H. and Fleming, H. P. (1997). Antimicrobial activity of sulfur compounds derived from
cabbage, J. Food Prot., 60(1), 67-71.
87. Kyung, K. H., Han, D. C. and Fleming, H. P. (1997). Antimicrobial activity of heated cabbage juice, S-
methyl-L-cysteine sulfoxide and methyl methanethiosulfonate, J. Food Sci., 62(2), 406-409.
88. Kubelik, J. (1970). Antimicrobielle Eigenschaften des Knoblauchs, Pharmazie, 25, 266-269.
89. Lubeck, V. L. (1956). Verfahren zum Stabilisieren von antibiotisch wirksamen Inhaltsstoffen von
Allium sativum, Deutch. Pat. 943250.
90. Al-Delaimy, K. S. and Barakat, M. M. F. (1971). Antimicrobial and preservative activity of garlic on
fresh ground camel meat. I. Effect of fresh ground garlic segments, J. Sci. Food Agric., 22, 96-98.
Legends for Tables
Table 1. Kinds and amounts of S-alk(en)yl-L-cysteine sulfoxides in Allium and Brassica
Table 2. Thiosulfinates from the extracts of Allium and Brassica
Legends for Figures
Figure 1. Enzymatic cleavage of S-alk(en)yl-L-cysteine sulfoxides
Figure 2. Liberation of L-cysteine sulfoxide from gamma-glutamylpeptide in onion
Figure 3. Spontaneous disproportionation of methyl methanethiosulfinate