allahabad high court afr-landmark judgments-orders

8/13/2019 Allahabad High Court AFR-Landmark Judgments-Orders

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/allahabad-high-court-afr-landmark-judgments-orders 1/131

Allahabad High Court AFR/Landmark Judgments/Orders

Sl. No. Head Line Details

1. Headline Summary - Rape murder girl of 10 Circumstantial evidence Child itness relia!ility Counsel as"ed to clarify #1#Cr$C circumstances Death commuted to hole life

%udgment&'rder - C($)*(L C(S+S No. 1,0 of 01# %udgment&'rder Dated - &11&01# at (llaha!ad.

*itle - (sho" /s. State 'f .$.

Coram - Hon!le (mar Saran2%. and Hon!le 3achchoo Lal2%.

. Headline Summary - Comprehensive directions for legal aid issued 3ail in #04 3 )$C appeal )nformation sought from )5

$risons&D%s a!out old and long confined prisoners.

%udgment&'rder - CR)6)N(L ($$+(L No. ,,# of 007 %udgment&'rder Dated - 7&8&01# at (llaha!ad.

*itle - 5o!ardhan Singh (nd (nother /s. State 'f .$.

Coram - Hon!le (mar Saran2%. and Hon!le Sunita (garal2%.

#. Headline Summary - Conviction cannot !e maintained ignoring inherent intrinsic impro!a!ilities and unnaturalaties - appeal

alloed.

%udgment&'rder - CR)6)N(L ($$+(L No. 774 of 004 %udgment&'rder Dated - 1#&8&01# at (llaha!ad.

*itle - Narendra Singh 9 Nanga /s. State 'f .$.

Coram - Hon!le /inod $rasad2%. and Hon!le (n:ani ;umar 6ishra2%.

4. Headline Summary - 3ail re:ected from trial court conviction relying on dependa!le parts of itnesses testimony. Directionsissued for tac"ling hostile itnesses.

%udgment&'rder - CR)6)N(L ($$+(L No. #074 of 01# %udgment&'rder Dated - #&8&01# at (llaha!ad.

*itle - mesh <adav /s. State 'f .$.




7. Headline Summary - *rivialities cannot !e counted to discard prosecution case against main accused-appeal partly alloed.

%udgment&'rder - 5'/+RN6+N* ($$+(L No. #10 of 18 %udgment&'rder Dated - #&8&01# at (llaha!ad.

*itle - State 'f .$ /s. Radhey Shyam (nd 'thersCoram - Hon!le /inod $rasad2%. and Hon!le ;aruna Nand 3a:payee2%.

=. Headline Summary - Determination of :uvenility ithout in>uiry is de hors legal mandate.

%udgment&'rder - CR)6)N(L ($$+(L No. #=7 of 00 %udgment&'rder Dated - &8&01# at (llaha!ad.

*itle - Surendra /s. State 'f .$.

Coram - Hon!le /inod $rasad2%. and Hon!le ;aruna Nand 3a:payee2%.

,. Headline Summary - $erversity of approach in ac>uitting main assailants re>uire interference !y this Court-(ppeal partly

alloed.

%udgment&'rder - 5'/+RN6+N* ($$+(L No. 1#,7 of 1881 %udgment&'rder Dated - &8&01# at (llaha!ad.

*itle - State 'f .$. /s. )rfan (nd 'thers

Coram - Hon!le /inod $rasad2%. and Hon!le ;aruna Nand 3a:payee2%.

. Headline Summary - ...difficult for the Court...petitioners prayer if granted shall promote pu!lic interest..not !e proper for this

Court to interfere in policy matters

%udgment&'rder - 6)SC. 3+NCH No. ,444 of 01# %udgment&'rder Dated - #&&01# at Luc"no.

*itle - (so" $ande ?$.).L.@ /s. nion 'f )ndia *hrough Ca!inet Secretary2 Ne Delhi A 'thers

Coram - Hon!le Shiva ;irti Singh2Chief %ustice and Hon!le Devendra ;umar padhyaya2%.

8. Headline Summary - *otal denial of accused-appellants in:ury ma"es genesis of the incident suspect entitling the accused to

get ac>uitted.

%udgment&'rder - CR)6)N(L ($$+(L No. 4,0 of 00, %udgment&'rder Dated - &&01# at (llaha!ad.



*itle - /i:ay Narayan 6ishra /s. State 'f .$.

Coram - Hon!le /inod $rasad2%. and Hon!le Surendra Singh2%.

10. Headline Summary - Bitnesses not immediately disclosing seeing deceased ith appellant2 unrelia!le. Directions issued forstreamlining rape ith murder investigations..

%udgment&'rder - C($)*(L C(S+S No. 88 of 011 %udgment&'rder Dated - 8&,&01# at (llaha!ad.

*itle - Nem Singh 9 6ula /s. State 'f .$.


11. Headline Summary - Corpse found in house of accused. )n:uries unsatisfactorily eplained. Superstitious murder2 life

imprisonment to replace death sentence.

%udgment&'rder - C($)*(L C(S+S No. 4707 of 01 %udgment&'rder Dated - &,&01# at (llaha!ad.

*itle - Ram (shish 5aur A 'thers /s. State 'f .$.


1. Headline Summary - +traordinary :urisdiction cant !e e>uated ith appellate :urisdiction and this Court is not re>uired to

su!stitute its on vie in place of vies...

%udgment&'rder - BR)* - C No. ==87 of 01 %udgment&'rder Dated - 0&7&01# at (llaha!ad.

*itle - Ha:i (!dul Ha"im /s. State 'f .$. *hru Secy. (nd 'thers

Coram - Hon!le Shiva ;irti Singh2Chief %ustice and Hon!le Dilip 5upta2%.

1#. Headline Summary - (!sence of any reason to implicate the appellant is sufficient to uphold the conviction.

%udgment&'rder - CR)6)N(L ($$+(L No. 4=41 of 00 %udgment&'rder Dated - 1,&7&01# at (llaha!ad.*itle - (vaneesh /s. State 'f .$.

Coram - Hon!le /inod $rasad2%. and Hon!le Surendra ;umar2%.



14. Headline Summary - nrelia!ility of fact itnesses and unnaturality of their conduct is sufficient to discard prosecution case-

appeal alloed.

%udgment&'rder - CR)6)N(L ($$+(L No. #7, of 00= %udgment&'rder Dated - #&7&01# at (llaha!ad.

*itle - Sunil $asi /s. State 'f .$.


17. Headline Summary - D+(*H $+N(L*< $H+LD , (6)L< 6+63+RS 6RD+R 3< (E+2 )N(N* *HR'**L+D

D)(F+$(6 'ND )N /)SC+R( N'N R+'R6(3)L)*< +/)D+NC+ R+G)R+6+N* R+(D D'BN.

%udgment&'rder - C($)*(L C(S+S No. 700# of 010 %udgment&'rder Dated - =&4&01# at (llaha!ad.

*itle - Saleem /s. State 'f .$.

Coram - Hon!le (mar Saran2%. and Hon!le S.C. (garal2%.

1=. Headline Summary - $erverse analysis !y trial court ma"es incum!ent to set aside ac>uittal and convict accused therefore2

appeal alloed&accused convicted.%udgment&'rder - 5'/+RN6+N* ($$+(L No. =1, of 18,8 %udgment&'rder Dated - 1=&4&01# at (llaha!ad.

*itle - State 'f .$. /s. Sohan Lal


1,. Headline Summary - Neither under Chapter /))) Rule 7 of High Court Rules nor u&s 18 of C.C. (cts-appeal is maintaina!le

against re:ection of contempt application.

%udgment&'rder - C'N*+6$* ($$+(L No. # of 01# %udgment&'rder Dated - 17&4&01# at (llaha!ad.

*itle - Suresh ;umar 6ishra /s. (run ;umar Rai


1. Headline Summary - C'R* )SS+S D)R+C*)'NS 'R 6'N)*'R)N5 B'6+NS $R'*+C*)'N H'6+S (ND

*H+)R )N6(*+S



%udgment&'rder - CR)6)N(L BR)*-$3L)C )N*+R+S* L)*)5(*)'N No. 0,#= of 011 %udgment&'rder Dated - 7&4&01# at

(llaha!ad.

*itle - )n *he 6atter 'f )nmates 'f Bomen $rotection Home /ns. Coram - Hon!le (mar Saran2%. and Hon!le 3achchoo Lal2%.

18. Headline Summary - ( party should ta"e all grounds and raise all pleas availa!le to him and if he fails to do so2 the principle

of constructive res :udicata applies...

%udgment&'rder - BR)* - C No. 1#,0 of 01# %udgment&'rder Dated - 14&#&01# at (llaha!ad.

*itle - ;hur"hur (nd (nother /s. nion 'f )ndia (nd 'thers

Coram - Hon!le Shiva ;irti Singh2Chief %ustice and Hon!le Dilip 5upta2%.

0. Headline Summary - Suppression of factum of murder of mother of accused appellant !y prosecution-prosecution versionunrelia!le-appeal alloed.

%udgment&'rder - CR)6)N(L ($$+(L No. 4= of 18 %udgment&'rder Dated - 1&1&01 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - 6unendra (nd 'thers /s. StateCoram - Hon!le /inod $rasad2%. and Hon!le Surendra ;umar2%.

1. Headline Summary - Complaints against unauthoried occupation over the pu!lic ponds or other similar pu!lic lands2 D.6.

should ta"e all re>uired actions.

%udgment&'rder - $3L)C )N*+R+S* L)*)5(*)'N I$)LJ No. =##0 of 01 %udgment&'rder Dated - =&1&01 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - $rem Singh /s. *he State 'f .$. (nd 'thers

Coram - Hon!le Shiva ;irti Singh2(cting Chief %ustice and Hon!le $radeep ;umar Singh 3aghel2%.

. Headline Summary - Condition of pre-deposit under S. 1 of 00 (ct is mandatory in all appeals filed against the order

passed under S.1,.

%udgment&'rder - BR)* - C No. 70=4 of 011 %udgment&'rder Dated - 7&1&01 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - 6ohan Lal Saraf /s. Chairperson De!ts Recovery (ppellate *ri!unal A 'thers

Coram - Hon!le Dilip 5upta2%.



#. Headline Summary - *here is no poer to condone the delay in filing the election petition under Rule ## of the Fila $anchayat

Rules2 1884

%udgment&'rder - BR)* - C No. 7==, of 01 %udgment&'rder Dated - 7&1&01 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - Smt. Sharda Devi /s. State 'f .$. *hru Secy. (nd 'thers


4. Headline Summary - Committee and the complainant have no locus to defend the order of D6 for ceasing poers of $radhan

and the reply of $radhan has to !e considered

%udgment&'rder - BR)* - C No. #,4, of 01 %udgment&'rder Dated - 7&1&01 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - Narendra ;umar /s. State 'f .$. (nd 'thers


7. Headline Summary - )ndustrial *ri!unal is not a court su!ordinate to the High Court for the purposes of Section 4 C.$.C.

%udgment&'rder - *R(NS+R ($$L)C(*)'N IC)/)LJ No. #8, of 01 %udgment&'rder Dated - #&1&01 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - Shri"ant $andey /s. Ramsha!ad 6ishra

Coram - Hon!le $an"a: 6ithal2%.

=. Headline Summary - +ven a deemed niversity after grant of permission !y NC*+ has to ta"e affiliation from +amination

Regulatory (uthority for conducting to years 3*C.

%udgment&'rder - BR)* - C No. 7,7, of 010 %udgment&'rder Dated - 11&10&01 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - Shashi ;umar Divedi (nd 'thers /s. State 'f .$. (nd 'thers

Coram - Hon!le Dilip 5upta2%.,. Headline Summary - ' R C$C not a !ar to su!se>uent Suit if cause of action in to Suits is different.

%udgment&'rder - BR)* - C No. 4,7= of 01 %udgment&'rder Dated - &8&01 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - 6&S *rademan )nternational $vt. Ltd. /s. De!ts Recovery (ppellate *ri!unal (nd 'thers




. Headline Summary - Credi!le prosecution case supported even !y hostile itnesses and a!sence of false implication is enough

to uphold conviction.

%udgment&'rder - CR)6)N(L ($$+(L No. #1= of 18 %udgment&'rder Dated - =&8&01 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - Dhanpal /s. State 'f .$.


8. Headline Summary - )n a!sence of intention fatal in:ury at the spur of moment in anguish does not disclose the charge of

murder-appeal partly alloed.

%udgment&'rder - CR)6)N(L ($$+(L No. 1==1 of 18 %udgment&'rder Dated - 14&8&01 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - Sami /s. State

Coram - Hon!le /inod $rasad2%. and Hon!le $an"a: Na>vi2%.

#0. Headline Summary - $resence of informant dou!tful significant omission in ocular version and change in prosecution story aresufficient to discard prosecution case.

%udgment&'rder - CR)6)N(L ($$+(L No. 17# of 18# %udgment&'rder Dated - 14&8&01 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - Deo Ra: A 'thers /s. State 'f .$.


#1. Headline Summary - Separate appeal has to !e filed against dismissal of counter-claim in 188# De!ts (ct.

%udgment&'rder - BR)* - C No. 4#7 of 01 %udgment&'rder Dated - 1#&8&01 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - Deepa" 6itra /s. nited 3an" 'f )ndia (nd 'thersCoram - Hon!le Dilip 5upta2%.

#. Headline Summary - ( District Consumer orum&Commission is a Court and su!ordinate to the High Court in the contet of

Section 10 of Contempt of Courts (ct 18,1.



%udgment&'rder - C'N*+6$* ($$L)C(*)'N ICR)6)N(LJ No. # of 01 %udgment&'rder Dated - 10&8&01 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - )n ReK /s. (nil ;umar %indal (nd 'thers

Coram - Hon!le Dharnidhar %ha2%. and Hon!le (sho" $al Singh2%.

##. Headline Summary - 'rder of District %udge passed u&s 4 C$C is not appeala!le. )t also cant !e set aside !y the High Courtin eercise of poer u&s 4 C$C.

%udgment&'rder - *R(NS+R ($$L)C(*)'N IC)/)LJ No. 80 of 01 %udgment&'rder Dated - 10&8&01 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - Sha"eela /s. 6eh!oo! (li Siddi>ui


#4. Headline Summary - S.D.6. dealing ith election petition is not a court su!ordinate to the High Court for transfer of

proceedings under Section 4 of the C.$.C.

%udgment&'rder - *R(NS+R ($$L)C(*)'N IC)/)LJ No. 8 of 01 %udgment&'rder Dated - 7&8&01 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - 6ursaleem /s. <ogendra Sharma (nd 'thers


#7. Headline Summary - Bitnesses of day light murder cannot !e dis!elieved on insignificant mista"es !y the ).'.&(ppeal

dismissed.

%udgment&'rder - CR)6)N(L ($$+(L No. =00 of 00= %udgment&'rder Dated - #&8&01 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - (slam A 'thers /s. State 'f .$.

Coram - Hon!le /inod $rasad2%. and Hon!le <ogesh Chandra 5upta2%.

#=. Headline Summary - (ssignee 3an" can !e su!stituted in the recovery certificate for eecution of the decree even ifassignment deed as eecuted during pendency of suit.

%udgment&'rder - BR)* - C No. #14# of 01 %udgment&'rder Dated - #&8&01 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - Shalini (sha Chopra (nd 'thers /s. Chairperson2 De!ts Recovery (ppellate *ri!unal (nd 'thers




#,. Headline Summary - High court cannot transfer the case from one district consumer forum to another in eercise of poer

under Section 4 C.$.C.

%udgment&'rder - *R(NS+R ($$L)C(*)'N IC)/)LJ No. ,, of 01 %udgment&'rder Dated - #1&&01 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - Hanuman <adav /s. State Consumer orum (nd 'thers


#. Headline Summary - (r!itration (greementM contemplates agreement !y the parties to the dispute and not a unilateral

instrument.

%udgment&'rder - C)/)L R+/)S)'N No. # of 01 %udgment&'rder Dated - #1&&01 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - Smt.;rishna $remmai Devidasi /s. )nternational Society or ;rishna Conscieusness (nd 'thers


#8. Headline Summary - Realisation of *rade *a (rrears ill not ta"e precedence over the right of the 3an" to recover the duesas a secured creditor.

%udgment&'rder - BR)* - C No. 40=# of 01 %udgment&'rder Dated - 8&&01 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - Smt. rmila Devi (nd 'thers /s. De!ts Recovery (ppellate *ri!unal (nd 'thers


40. Headline Summary - Cooperative la to !e amended !y 14..01#

%udgment&'rder - BR)* - C No. 440# of 01 %udgment&'rder Dated - &&01 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - $rem Narayan Singh /s. State 'f .$. (nd 'thersCoram - Hon!le <atindra Singh2%. and Hon!le 6ahendra Dayal2%.

41. Headline Summary - Circumstantial evidence hay2 unclear and dou!tful-conviction cannot !e sustained-appeal alloed.

%udgment&'rder - CR)6)N(L ($$+(L No. =74 of 18# %udgment&'rder Dated - ,&&01 at (llaha!ad.



*itle - Narendra A 'thers /s. State 'f .$.


4. Headline Summary - Bhat period is to !e ecluded under eplanation to section 17I#J of $ ;shettra $anchayat and Fila$anchayat (dhiniyam2 18=1.

%udgment&'rder - BR)* - C No. #,=8 of 01 %udgment&'rder Dated - #&&01 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - Smt. Ru!i Singh /s. State 'f .$. (nd 'thers

Coram - Hon!le <atindra Singh2%. and Hon!le 6ahendra Dayal2%.

4#. Headline Summary - Court can refuse to entertain rit petition !y invo"ing doctrine of forum conveniens

%udgment&'rder - BR)* - C No. #,17 of 01 %udgment&'rder Dated - =&&01 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - 6&S Dynamic +ducation Systems I)nternationalJ Ltd. A (nother /s. 3an" 'f 3aroda (nd 'thers


44. Headline Summary - $rinciples to determine the genuineness of ill.

%udgment&'rder - S$+C)(L ($$+(L No. 8=1 of 004 %udgment&'rder Dated - #&,&01 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - Dinesh Chandra $andey /s. 3ri:esh Chandra $andey A 'thers

Coram - Hon!le <atindra Singh2%. and Hon!le 6ahendra Dayal2%.

47. Headline Summary - alse eplanation of accused in:ury is enough to set aside conviction of a murder charge&appeal alloed.

%udgment&'rder - CR)6)N(L ($$+(L No. 1840 of 180 %udgment&'rder Dated - 18&,&01 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - ;alloo /s. State


4=. Headline Summary - 6(**+R ND+R S+C*)'N 14 ' *H+ 5(RD)(NS A B(RDS (C* 180 )S N'* )N *H+

N(*R+ ' ( *R(NS+R ($$L)C(*)'N 3* ( R++R+NC+ 'R '$)N)'N ' *H+ H)5H C'R*

%udgment&'rder - *R(NS+R ($$L)C(*)'N IC)/)LJ No. 18 of 01 %udgment&'rder Dated - 1&,&01 at (llaha!ad.



*itle - Smt. Savitri Devi /s. Smt. Raman Lata


4,. Headline Summary - $rosecution story credi!le&defence una!le to dislodge it&conviction upheld.

%udgment&'rder - CR)6)N(L ($$+(L No. 48, of 00 %udgment&'rder Dated - =&,&01 at (llaha!ad.*itle - 5ovind Das 9 3uddha /s. State 'f .$.


4. Headline Summary - *ransfer of lease hold rights is transfer of lease !y ay of assignment under (rticle =# of Schedule 13 of

the Stamp (ct.

%udgment&'rder - BR)* - C No. 7,#= of 011 %udgment&'rder Dated - #&,&01 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - 'm Shree 5anesh Sah"ari (vas Samiti Limited /s. State 'f .$. (nd 'thers


48. Headline Summary - High Court of (llaha!ad is not a principle civil court of original :ursidiction under Section I1JIeJ of the

(r!itration A Conciliation (ct2 188=.

%udgment&'rder - (R3)*R(*)'N and C'NC)L). ($$L.&s11I4J No. # of 01 %udgment&'rder Dated - #1&7&01 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - 6&S 3.6.5. Construction /s. National Small )ndustries Corporation Ltd. (nd 'thers


70. Headline Summary - +vidence of itnesses cannot !e !rushed aside on petty issues-appeal dismissed.

%udgment&'rder - CR)6)N(L ($$+(L No. 18,, of 181 %udgment&'rder Dated - #1&7&01 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - 5anesh (nd (nother /s. State 'fu.$.

Coram - Hon!le /inod $rasad2%.

71. Headline Summary - Reasona!le prognosis of right of private defence is sufficient to ac>uit the accused-appeal alloed.

%udgment&'rder - CR)6)N(L ($$+(L No. ,0 of 181 %udgment&'rder Dated - #0&7&01 at (llaha!ad.



*itle - (ad ;han (nd 'ther /s. State 'f .$.


7. Headline Summary - %uvenility delay and no !enefit to the complainant cumulatively are sufficient to >uash prosecution.

%udgment&'rder - ($$L)C(*)'N &s 4 No. 1,#7, of 007 %udgment&'rder Dated - #0&7&01 at (llaha!ad.*itle - Smt. /imla Devi /s. State 'f .$. A (nother


7#. Headline Summary - 6edical practice is a profession. Doctors clinic in residential area is not a commercial activity.

%udgment&'rder - BR)* - C No. 1=4# of 011 %udgment&'rder Dated - 8&7&01 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - Satya $ra"ash Singh A (nother /s. State 'f .$. A 'thers


74. Headline Summary - Some suggestions for reducing committee of management disputes.

%udgment&'rder - S$+C)(L ($$+(L No. 84 of 01 %udgment&'rder Dated - 4&7&01 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - /i:ay $ratap Singh Nd (nother /s. Dios (nd 'thers

Coram - Hon!le <atindra Singh2%. and Hon!le 6ohd. *ahir2%.

77. Headline Summary - (ppellate order not to !e passed !y the same officer ho has passed the !asic order impugned in appeal.

%udgment&'rder - BR)* - C No. 4=8 of 01 %udgment&'rder Dated - &7&01 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - 6ohd. Chand (nd (nother /s. State 'f .$. (nd 'thers


7=. Headline Summary - Release of property u&s 1, of the 5angsters (ct and punishment of crime u&s # of the 5angsters (ct are

different proceedings.

%udgment&'rder - CR)6)N(L ($$+(L No. #000 of 00# %udgment&'rder Dated - &7&01 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - ;ailash Sah"ari (as Samiti /s. State 'f .$. A 'thers




7,. Headline Summary - (ppointment of the ar!itrator named&designated in the agreement is the Rule hich can only !e deviated

!y the Chief %ustice for valid reasons.

%udgment&'rder - (R3)*R(*)'N and C'NC)L). ($$L.&s11I4J No. =4 of 011 %udgment&'rder Dated - 1,&7&01 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - 3harat Bire Ropes Ltd. /s. nio 'f )ndia *hru 6inistry 'f Railay (nd 'thers


7. Headline Summary - 6atter decided !y civil court - cannot !e reopened !efore )ndustrial *ri!unal

%udgment&'rder - S$+C)(L ($$+(L No. 0, of 011 %udgment&'rder Dated - 1=&7&01 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - Central 3an" 'f )ndia /s. nion 'f )ndia (nd 'thers


78. Headline Summary - irst proviso to section 11I1J of Land (c>uisition (ct - or !enefit of government2 ac>uiring !ody.

%udgment&'rder - BR)* - C No. ,00 of 00 %udgment&'rder Dated - 8&7&01 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - Dau Dayal (nd 'thers /s. State 'f .$. A 'thers


=0. Headline Summary - ees deposited seat reserved in %++-)neligi!le to appear in net :++.

%udgment&'rder - S$+C)(L ($$+(L No. =0, of 011 %udgment&'rder Dated - ,&7&01 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - Su:eet Chaudhary /s. nion 'f )ndia (nd 'thers


=1. Headline Summary - Scheme of administration of College does not prohi!it indirect elections.

%udgment&'rder - S$+C)(L ($$+(L No. 0, of 01 %udgment&'rder Dated - 1&7&01 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - C&6 D.(./. )ntermediate College (nd (nother /s. State 'f .$. (nd 'thers




=. Headline Summary - Che>ue dishonoured2 information sent though not served2 insurance company not lia!le.

%udgment&'rder - )RS* ($$+(L R'6 'RD+R No. =41 of 188 %udgment&'rder Dated - ,&4&01 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - National )nsurance Co. Ltd. /s. Smt. Ra: ;umari Singh A 'thers


=#. Headline Summary - (3R)C(*+D D<)N5 D+CL(R(*)'N 3< $'L)C+ ')C+R SS$+C*+D C'R* D)R+C*S

+NG)R< $N)SH6+N* $'L)C+ ')C+R (ND D'C*'R C+R*)<)N5 D+(D $+RS'NS )*N+SS

%udgment&'rder - CR)6)N(L ($$+(L No. 1,# of 010 %udgment&'rder Dated - 0&4&01 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - pendra Singh 9 (lalan /s. State 'f .$.

Coram - Hon!le (mar Saran2%. and Hon!le (nurag ;umar2%.

=4. Headline Summary - )nvocation of ar!itration clause is sine >ua non for maintaining an application &S 11 of the (r!itration

and Conciliation (ct2 188=.

%udgment&'rder - (R3)*R(*)'N and C'NC)L). ($$L.&s11I4J No. 7= of 001 %udgment&'rder Dated - 18&4&01 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - (!dul Rashid /s. National 3uilding Construction Corp. Ltd.2 Ne Delhi


=7. Headline Summary - Directions issued in Ra:"iya Shishu 5rih Shiv"uti 2 (llaha!ad minor girls rape case.

%udgment&'rder - CR)6)N(L BR)*-$3L)C )N*+R+S* L)*)5(*)'N No. 40, of 01 %udgment&'rder Dated - 1=&4&01 at

(llaha!ad.

*itle - )n *he 6atter 'f 5ovt. ChildrenS Home (t Shiv"uti (llaha!ad Coram - Hon!le (mar Saran2%. and Hon!le (sho"

Srivastava2%.

==. Headline Summary - Land ac>uisition - aard of a plot - not in piecemeal.

%udgment&'rder - BR)* - C No. #4,0# of 00 %udgment&'rder Dated - 1&4&01 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - Smt. ;amla Devi A 'thers /s. State 'f .$. *hru Chief Secy. .$. 5ovt. A 'rs.



Coram - Hon!le <atindra Singh2%. and Hon!le 3. (mit Sthale"ar2%.

=,. Headline Summary - 6alice an intent to defame is a must for charge of defamation&it are a!sent&prosecution >uashed.

%udgment&'rder - CR)6)N(L R+/)S)'N No. 88 of 00= %udgment&'rder Dated - 11&4&01 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - Dr. /ishnu Dutt (garal /s. State 'f .$. A (nother


=. Headline Summary - *he lease deed eecuted !eteen the tenant and landlord that the Rent Control (ct ill not apply is void.

%udgment&'rder - BR)* - ( No. 7= of 010 %udgment&'rder Dated - 7&4&01 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - Dr. ;. 5opal /s. Smt. Sudarshan Devi 3hatia


=8. Headline Summary - or sustaining conviction u&s #882 40 ).$.C. evidence has to !e of an unimpeacha!le character-appeal

alloed-conviction set aside.

%udgment&'rder - CR)6)N(L ($$+(L No. 1##, of 181 %udgment&'rder Dated - 1&#&01 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - Hoti (nd 'thers /s. State


,0. Headline Summary - Some leases& permits less than 7 hectares may re>uire environmental clearance

%udgment&'rder - BR)* - C No. 80#= of 011 %udgment&'rder Dated - 0&#&01 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - Ra:esh ;umar Nishad /s. State 'f .$. (nd 'thers

Coram - Hon!le <atindra Singh2%. and Hon!le 3. (mit Sthale"ar2%.

,1. Headline Summary - Revisional Court should hesitate to compare the signatures hen handriting epert opinion is availa!le

particularly hen *rial Court has accepted it.

%udgment&'rder - BR)* - ( No. =7#1 of 00= %udgment&'rder Dated - #&&01 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - Ra:a Ram Sharma /s. District %udge (nd 'thers




,. Headline Summary - Circumstance under hich a decree is a nullity or merely illegal2 o!:ection to the decree cannot !e raised

!efore +ecuting Court if decree is illegal

%udgment&'rder - BR)* - ( No. 47410 of 00 %udgment&'rder Dated - #&&01 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - 5hani /s. Smt. Haseen 3ano


,#. Headline Summary - Denial for ant of "noledge in ritten statement is admission of plaint averments and suit for e:ectment

can !e filed !y 6utaalli on !ehalf of a"f.

%udgment&'rder - BR)* - ( No. #4== of 00# %udgment&'rder Dated - #&&01 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - Syed 6usta:a! Husain /s. (dditional District %udge ICourt No. 1#J (gra (nd 'thers


,4. Headline Summary - Bithout esta!lishing genuineness2 photo cannot !e admitted as secondary evidence.

%udgment&'rder - CR)6)N(L ($$+(L No. 17=7 of 18 %udgment&'rder Dated - #&&01 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - Hauslla $rasad /s. State


,7. Headline Summary - Section 4#,-( Cr$C - Some Suggestions and Recommendations

%udgment&'rder - CR)6)N(L ($$+(L No. 701 of 00, %udgment&'rder Dated - 1#&&01 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - Nannu (nd 'thers /s. State 'f .$.

Coram - Hon!le <atindra Singh2%. and Hon!le Ram Surat Ram I6auryaJ2%.

,=. Headline Summary - Complaint cannot !e dismissed hen prima facie offence is disclosed !y meticulously eamining

prosecution allegations.

%udgment&'rder - ($$L)C(*)'N &s 4 No. ,,08 of 010 %udgment&'rder Dated - &&01 at (llaha!ad.



*itle - mrao Singh /s. State 'f .$. (nd 'thers


,,. Headline Summary - 3enefit of Section 8-( of 18, Rent (ct is not availa!le to a tenant if only temporary structures areraised ith the consent of the landlord.

%udgment&'rder - BR)* - C No. #8=8 of 004 %udgment&'rder Dated - #1&1&01 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - Rameshar Dayal (garal /s. $aan ;umar A 'thers


,. Headline Summary - (n unchallenged lease document cannot !e the !asis of a criminal trial for cheating.

%udgment&'rder - ($$L)C(*)'N &s 4 No. 10# of 010 %udgment&'rder Dated - 4&1&01 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - Ramesh Chandra 3hatia /s. State 'f .$. (nd (nother


,8. Headline Summary - $etition challenging +lection Commission order directing covering elephant and 6s 6ayaati statues2

dismissed.

%udgment&'rder - $3L)C )N*+R+S* L)*)5(*)'N I$)LJ No. =#0 of 01 %udgment&'rder Dated - 4&1&01 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - Dheera: $ratap Singh /s. Chief +lection Commission2 nion 'f )ndia (nd (nother

Coram - Hon!le (mar Saran2%. and Hon!le Ramesh Sinha2%.

0. Headline Summary - )nconsistent plea and documents !y the accused is sufficient to re:ect claim of :uvenility.

%udgment&'rder - CR)6)N(L R+/)S)'N No. 441 of 011 %udgment&'rder Dated - 18&1&01 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - (tin %aisal /s. State 'f .$. A (nother


1. Headline Summary - $rayer for discharge can !e alloed u&s , Cr.$.C.only hen no prima facie case is disclosed.

%udgment&'rder - CR)6)N(L R+/)S)'N No. #1= of 00= %udgment&'rder Dated - 1&1&01 at (llaha!ad.



*itle - Su!hash Chand 5upta A 'thers /s. State 'f .$. A (nother


. Headline Summary - La relating to !onded la!our eplained. Direction issued to constitute Legal aid clinics and providesocio-economics reliefs.

%udgment&'rder - H(3+(S C'R$S BR)* $+*)*)'N No. ,040# of 011 %udgment&'rder Dated - 7&1&01 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - Sageer A 'thers /s. State 'f .$. A 'thers

Coram - Hon!le (mar Saran2%. and Hon!le Ramesh Sinha2%.

#. Headline Summary - Dying declaration can !e accepted only hen it is free from all infirmities2 em!ellishment and

tutoring&appeal alloed as the same is missing.

%udgment&'rder - CR)6)N(L ($$+(L No. 1=8 of 181 %udgment&'rder Dated - 4&1&01 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - (sha Ram A (nother /s. State 'f .$.


4. Headline Summary - or a che>ue issued !y a third party-3an" 6anager cannot !e prosecuted u&s 1# N.). (ct.

%udgment&'rder - ($$L)C(*)'N &s 4 No. 1=# of 00, %udgment&'rder Dated - 4&1&01 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - R.;.Diit /s. State 'f .$. A (nother


7. Headline Summary - Change in the circumstances is essential for re-eercising poer u&s #11 Cr.$.C.

%udgment&'rder - ($$L)C(*)'N &s 4 No. 1#788 of 010 %udgment&'rder Dated - 1=&1&011 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - /inod ;umar Singh /s. State 'f .$.Coram - Hon!le /inod $rasad2%.

=. Headline Summary - 3enefit of difference in age should !e given to the accused for offences u&ss #=#2 #==2 #,= )$C&(ppeal

alloed.



%udgment&'rder - CR)6)N(L ($$+(L No. 708 of 007 %udgment&'rder Dated - 1=&1&011 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - Ra: ;umar Shu"la /s. State 'f .$.


,. Headline Summary - Bires laid under section 1=4 of the +lectricity (ct - $ermission of D6 is not re>uired.

%udgment&'rder - )RS* ($$+(L R'6 'RD+R No. #7# of 011 %udgment&'rder Dated - ,&1&011 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - $oer 5rid Corp. 'f )ndia Limited /s. (:ay ;umar 5upta (nd 'thers

Coram - Hon!le <atindra Singh2%. and Hon!le Ram Surat Ram I6auryaJ2%.

. Headline Summary - raud and :ustice cannot live together. )f something o!tained !y fraud and factum of fraud is proved2

things !ecomes non-est

%udgment&'rder - S$+C)(L ($$+(L No. 44# of 00 %udgment&'rder Dated - 8&11&011 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - Smt. /i!ha Shu"la (nd (nother /s. D.+. I3asicJ .$.2 (lld. (ndothers

Coram - Hon!le Syed Rafat (lam2Chief %ustice and Hon!le Ran /i:ai Singh2%.

8. Headline Summary - High Court directs C3) to conduct preliminary en>uiry in the implementation of NRH6 and utilisationof NRH6 funds at various levels in State of .$.

%udgment&'rder - 6)SC. 3+NCH No. #=11 of 011 %udgment&'rder Dated - 17&11&011 at Luc"no.

*itle - Sachchidanand ISachcheyJ ? $.).L. @ Civil /s. State 'f .$. *hru $rincipal Secretary Health A amily Belfa

Coram - Hon!le $radeep ;ant2%. and Hon!le Ritu Ra: (asthi2%.

80. Headline Summary - Not necessary to issue rit2 even if order is rong

%udgment&'rder - S$+C)(L ($$+(L No. 107 of 00# %udgment&'rder Dated - 17&11&011 at (llaha!ad.*itle - Ramesh Chand /s. +ecutive +ngineer (nd 'thers

Coram - Hon!le <atindra Singh2%. and Hon!le Dinesh 5upta2%.



81. Headline Summary - No conviction for dacoity can !e recorded if identification is not confidence inspiring&(ppeal is partly

alloed.

%udgment&'rder - CR)6)N(L ($$+(L No. 00 of 008 %udgment&'rder Dated - &11&011 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - Ram $al A 'thers /s. State 'f .$.


8. Headline Summary - ull 3ench %udgement on Land (c>uisition 6atter of 5reater N')D( A N')D(

%udgment&'rder - BR)* - C No. #,44# of 011 %udgment&'rder Dated - 1&10&011 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - 5a:ra: (nd 'thers /s. State 'f .$. (nd 'thers

Coram - Hon!le (sho" 3hushan2%. 2 Hon!le Si!ghat llah ;han2%. and Hon!le /.;. Shu"la2%.

8#. Headline Summary - or charge of dacoity participation of five or more accused essential&itnesses unrelia!le&prosecution

version false&appeal alloed.

%udgment&'rder - CR)6)N(L ($$+(L No. 11, of 18 %udgment&'rder Dated - 14&10&011 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - 5yan Singh /s. State 'f .$


84. Headline Summary - Conviction under ND$S (ct cannot !e sustained for violation of Section 42 7, of the (ct& recovery

dou!tful&appellant ac>uitted.

%udgment&'rder - CR)6)N(L ($$+(L No. #81= of 010 %udgment&'rder Dated - 14&10&011 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - Shyam 3a!u /isha"arma A (nother /s. State 'f .$.


87. Headline Summary - Direction given to police A 6agistrates on manner of remanding accused in offences punisha!le upto ,

years in accordance ith nely introduced section

%udgment&'rder - CR)6)N(L 6)SC. BR)* $+*)*)'N No. 1,410 of 011 %udgment&'rder Dated - 11&10&011 at (llaha!ad.



*itle - Shau"in /s. State 'f .$. (nd 'thers

Coram - Hon!le (mar Saran2%. and Hon!le ;alimullah ;han2%.

8=. Headline Summary - 48-( offence--La procedure for mediation and directions for ma"ing 48-( )$C offencecompounda!le

%udgment&'rder - CR)6)N(L 6)SC. BR)* $+*)*)'N No. ## of 010 %udgment&'rder Dated - #0&8&011 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - ReK )n *he 6atter 'f 6atrimonial Disputes /s. State 'f .$. A 'thers

Coram - Hon!le (mar Saran2%. and Hon!le Shyam Shan"ar *iari2%.

8,. Headline Summary - Defence suggestion can !e considered to :udge veracity of prosecution version-victim minor-conviction

maintained-sentence reduced.


*itle - 6ohammad <ashin (lias %agdish A 'thers /s. State 'f .$.


8. Headline Summary - *' C'NS)D+R ($$L)C(*)'N 'R D)SCH(R5+ ND+R S+C*)'N 47 IJ Cr$C2 $R+S+NC+

' (CCS+D )S N+C+SS(R< ) *H+ C(S+ H(S R+(CH+D *H+ S*(5+ ' S+C*)'N 44

%udgment&'rder - ($$L)C(*)'N &s 4 No. =7=, of 011 %udgment&'rder Dated - ,&8&011 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - 6ano: Dalmia /s. State 'f .$. (nd (nother

Coram - Hon!le Shri ;ant *ripathi2%.

88. Headline Summary - *' +S*(3L)SH *H+ CH(R5+ &S 41 )$C2 *H+ $R'S+C*)'N H(S *' $R'/+ *H(* *H+

(CCS+D H(D ;N'BL+D5+ *H(* *H+ R+C'/+R+D $R'$+R*< B(S S*'L+N )N ( D(C')*<.

%udgment&'rder - CR)6)N(L ($$+(L No. 48= of 00= %udgment&'rder Dated - 1&8&011 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - (nil 9 3a!lu Srivastava /s. State 'f .$.




100. Headline Summary - $reponderance of pro!a!ility is enough to confer right of private defence&(ppeal alloed.

%udgment&'rder - CR)6)N(L ($$+(L No. 1,1 of 181 %udgment&'rder Dated - 0&8&011 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - $o"hpal /s. State


101. Headline Summary - (dmission is conclusive unless eplained

%udgment&'rder - )RS* ($$+(L No. 8= of 004 %udgment&'rder Dated - 0&8&011 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - State 'f .$. *hru Collector2 6athura /s. *ha"ur Sri Radha Raman:i 6ahara:

Coram - Hon!le <atindra Singh2%. and Hon!le Dinesh 5upta2%.

10. Headline Summary - %D56+N*S ' C'R*S ' %S*)C+ (R+ R+L+/(N* 'NL< ND+R S+C*)'NS 40 *' 44

' *H+ +/)D+NC+ (C* (ND N'* '*H+RB)S+.

%udgment&'rder - ($$L)C(*)'N &s 4 No. 1848, of 011 %udgment&'rder Dated - 18&8&011 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - ("ash ;umar Sharma (nd (nother /s. State 'f .$.


10#. Headline Summary - (N (CCS+D H(S )ND++(S)3L+ R)5H* *' CL()6 C'$)+S ' D'C6+N*S R+L)+D

$'N 3< *H+ $R'S+C*)'N.

%udgment&'rder - ($$L)C(*)'N &s 4 No. == of 011 %udgment&'rder Dated - 18&8&011 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - /inay Sharma /s. State 'f .$. (nd (nother


104. Headline Summary - ) ( C(S+ D)SCL'S+S 3'*H CR)6)N(L (ND C)/)L L)(3)L)*< ' *H+ (CCS+D2 *H+CR)6)N(L $R'C++D)N5S C(NN'* 3+ G(SH+D.

%udgment&'rder - ($$L)C(*)'N &s 4 No. 1,01 of 011 %udgment&'rder Dated - 17&8&011 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - De!o!roto Dutta (nd 'thers /s. ;m. Sunanda 5hosh (nd (nother




107. Headline Summary - Conviction for Dacoity can not !e sustained on impro!a!le and unnatural evidences

%udgment&'rder - CR)6)N(L ($$+(L No. 11, of 18 %udgment&'rder Dated - 14&8&011 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - Satyadeo 3ahela A (nother /s. State 'f .$.


10=. Headline Summary - (n election petition2 hich does not conform to the statutory re>uirements2 must !e dismissed outrightly.

%udgment&'rder - +L+C*)'N $+*)*)'N No. 8 of 008 %udgment&'rder Dated - 14&8&011 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - /.6.Singh S&' 6ander Singh /s. eroe /arun 5andhi


10,. Headline Summary - Section #8 Cr.$.C.-pending consideration final !ail prayer in appeal-appellant can !e released on

interim !ail.

%udgment&'rder - CR)6)N(L ($$+(L No. 108 of 011 %udgment&'rder Dated - 14&8&011 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - Smt. *ara Devi (nd (nr. /s. State 'f .$.


10. Headline Summary - Custody of son cannot !e handed over to an unchaste mother ith murder charge&Ha!eas Corpus

dismissed.

%udgment&'rder - H(3+(S C'R$S BR)* $+*)*)'N No. 8,1 of 011 %udgment&'rder Dated - 8&8&011 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - 6aster Sho!hit /s. State 'f .$. (nd 'thers

Coram - Hon!le /inod $rasad2%.108. Headline Summary - Denial of accused right to get sample retested deserves >uashing of proceeding.

%udgment&'rder - ($$L)C(*)'N &s 4 No. #1071 of 008 %udgment&'rder Dated - &8&011 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - 6ano: ;umar (ssistant 6anager 3harat )nsectsides Ltd. /s. State 'f .$.




110. Headline Summary - Denial of accused right to get sample retested deserves >uashing of proceeding.

%udgment&'rder - ($$L)C(*)'N &s 4 No. #107# of 008 %udgment&'rder Dated - &8&011 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - 3harat )nsecticides Ltd. (nd (nother /s. State 'f .$. *hrough )nsecticides )nspector 3i:nore


111. Headline Summary - 'nly the to senior most teachers or"ing in the institution at the time the re>uisition is sent to the

3oard can !e called for intervie.

%udgment&'rder - BR)* - ( No. #1,#= of 011 %udgment&'rder Dated - 8&&011 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - Shyam Lal (nd (nother /s. State 'f .$. (nd 'thers


11. Headline Summary - 5's curtailing freeship to students of ea"er section >uashed. HC says State must not say from

constitutional o!ligation to do elfare of its su!:ect%udgment&'rder - 6)SC. 3+NCH No. 11740 of 00 %udgment&'rder Dated - 8&&011 at Luc"no.

*itle - 6eydha 6eritorious +ducation or <ouths /s. State 'f .$. *hru Chief Secretary A 'rs. I$.).L.JOCivilP


11#. Headline Summary - Guashing of prosecution-dispute !eteen Deemed niversity and students-compromise arrived at-

proceedings >uashed.

%udgment&'rder - ($$L)C(*)'N &s 4 No. 7=7 of 008 %udgment&'rder Dated - =&&011 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - /inod 3. Lal /s. State 'f .$. A (nother


114. Headline Summary - +vidence inherently impro!a!le and unmerited-charge under Section 10-3 ).$.C. cannot !e framed-

revision alloed.



%udgment&'rder - CR)6)N(L R+/)S)'N No. 71 of 010 %udgment&'rder Dated - =&&011 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - Dev Sharma A 'thers /s. State 'f .$. A (nother


117. Headline Summary - or the purposes of proviso to 'rder /) Rule 1, of C$C the relevant date for commencement of the trial

is the date on hich issues are framed

%udgment&'rder - +L+C*)'N $+*)*)'N No. 1 of 008 %udgment&'rder Dated - 1=&&011 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - Chandra Narain *ripathi /s. ;apil 6uni ;arariya


11=. Headline Summary - Conviction under N.D.$.S. (ct-Sections 42 70 and 7, not complied ith-(ppeal alloed-Conviction set

aside-(ppellant ac>uitted.

%udgment&'rder - CR)6)N(L ($$+(L No. 080 of 00, %udgment&'rder Dated - 1=&&011 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - $andav Sar"ar /s. State 'f .$.Coram - Hon!le /inod $rasad2%.

11,. Headline Summary - High Court directs C3) to investigate into the murders of Dr./.;.(rya and Dr. 3.$.Singh2 C6's

alongith the cases relating to NRH6 scam.

%udgment&'rder - 6)SC. 3+NCH No. #=78 of 011 %udgment&'rder Dated - ,&,&011 at Luc"no.

*itle - Be *he $eople ? $.).L. @ Criminal /s. nion 'f )ndia2 *hru. $rin. Secy.26inistry 'f Home A 'rs.


11. Headline Summary - 147 proceeding&parties failed to esta!lish possession&attachment and order for relief from civil court :ustand proper&rit dismissed.

%udgment&'rder - CR)6)N(L 6)SC. BR)* $+*)*)'N No. 8#=1 of 011 %udgment&'rder Dated - &,&011 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - Smt. 3ala Dhama A 'thers /s. S.D.6. 3araut A 'thers




118. Headline Summary - Section1&3ail to :uvenile&defence to :uvenile ith favoura!le report should !e given due

consideration&!ail alloed.

%udgment&'rder - CR)6)N(L R+/)S)'N No. = of 011 %udgment&'rder Dated - 1&,&011 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - $ushpendra 9 3ri: 3ihari 9 $appi /s. State 'f .$. A (nother


10. Headline Summary - 3ail to :uvenile&etraneous material ithout evidence should not !e considered&!ail alloed.

%udgment&'rder - CR)6)N(L R+/)S)'N No. 14 of 011 %udgment&'rder Dated - 1&,&011 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - ;ushagra 6o"hariale /s. State 'f .$. A (nother


11. Headline Summary - Section 1 %.%. (ct&no criminal history&circumstantial evidence case&surmises cropped in

re:ection&revision alloed&!ail granted.%udgment&'rder - CR)6)N(L R+/)S)'N No. 4=# of 011 %udgment&'rder Dated - 1&,&011 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - Shiva 9 Surya"ant /s. State 'f .$.


1. Headline Summary - No contravention of mentioned control order&confiscation illegal&order set aside.

%udgment&'rder - CR)6)N(L R+/)S)'N No. 1,4 of 011 %udgment&'rder Dated - 1&,&011 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - 6adan Lal Sahu /s. State 'f .$.

Coram - Hon!le /inod $rasad2%.1#. Headline Summary - High Court directs C3) investigation in Dr. <.S.Sachans unnatural death in :udicial custody2investigation

to !e completed ithin maimum three months

%udgment&'rder - 6)SC. 3+NCH No. ==01 of 011 %udgment&'rder Dated - 14&,&011 at Luc"no.



*itle - Sachchidanand ISachcheyJ ? $.).L.@ Civil /s. State 'f .$.*hrough )ts $rin. Secy. IHomeJ .$.Civil Sectt.


14. Headline Summary - Defaulter cannot ta"e advantage of his default in divorce proceeding.

%udgment&'rder - )RS* ($$+(L No. #, of 188 %udgment&'rder Dated - 7&,&011 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - Dr. *ara Charan (garal /s. Smt. /eena (garal

Coram - Hon!le <atindra Singh2%. and Hon!le <ogesh Chandra 5upta2%.

17. Headline Summary - Charge&,& Cr.$.C.&accused contention must !e decided !y a spea"ing reasoned order&Revision

alloed.

%udgment&'rder - CR)6)N(L R+/)S)'N No. 114 of 011 %udgment&'rder Dated - 4&,&011 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - Shiv $ra"ash *iari A 'thers /s. State 'f .$. A (nother


1=. Headline Summary - HC dismisses $)L against constitution of %DC for Lo" $al 3ill2 says it is ithin eecutive discretion of5overnment to constitute such a committee.

%udgment&'rder - 6)SC. 3+NCH No. #=0 of 011 %udgment&'rder Dated - &=&011 at Luc"no.

*itle - (so" $ande A (nr. ? $.).L. @ Civil /s. nion 'f )ndia2*hru. Secy.2 $rime 6inisterS 'ffice2 A 'rs.

Coram - Hon!le $radeep ;ant2%. and Hon!le /edpal2%.

1,. Headline Summary - N'*))C(*)'N N'. S.). 84 I+J D(*+D 1.11.008 )SS+D 3< *H+ 5'/+RN6+N* ' )ND)(

SH(LL ($$L< $R'S$+C*)/+L<

%udgment&'rder - CR)6)N(L ($$+(L No. 1#74 of 00, %udgment&'rder Dated - #0&7&011 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - Suresh Singh ;ushaha /s. State 'f .$.




1. Headline Summary - conviction u&s 48(2 #043 ).$.C.- D&D not truthful and hear-se-relative itnesses not relia!le-appeal

alloed-conviction set aside.

%udgment&'rder - CR)6)N(L ($$+(L No. 7744 of 00= %udgment&'rder Dated - 7&7&011 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - 5ovind Hari Samy (nd (nother /s. State 'f .$.


18. Headline Summary - *here are eceptions to grant !ail to a :uvenile&revision dismissed.

%udgment&'rder - CR)6)N(L R+/)S)'N No. 1=81 of 011 %udgment&'rder Dated - 4&7&011 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - 6onu 9 6oni 9 Rahul 9 Rohit /s. State 'f .$.


1#0. Headline Summary - $etition of (mar Singh dismissed. )n petition of S.;.*ripathi2 investigation entrusted to +nforcement

Directorate )st Status report in )st ee" of %ul

%udgment&'rder - CR)6)N(L 6)SC. BR)* $+*)*)'N No. 47 of 008 %udgment&'rder Dated - 0&7&011 at (llaha!ad.*itle - (mar Singh /s. State 'f .$. A 'thers

Coram - Hon!le )mtiya 6urtaa2%. and Hon!le Shyam Shan"ar *iari2%.

1#1. Headline Summary - Charge of rape-no consent of ill present-summoning order :ustified-revision dismissed.


*itle - Shiali" 5hosh (nd (nr. /s. State 'f .$. (nd (nr.


1#. Headline Summary - *o declare a person :uvenile2 his date of !irth recorded in high school certificate ill !e given preferenceover date of !irth given in other record.

%udgment&'rder - CR)6)N(L R+/)S)'N No. of 00 %udgment&'rder Dated - 1&7&011 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - Dharam Singh /s. State 'f .$. A (nother




1##. Headline Summary - D.6 3i:nor2S.$ 3i:nor and S' ordered to !e transferred. )R against %udicial officer >uashed. urther

investigation !y C3). report ithin # months

%udgment&'rder - CR)6)N(L 6)SC. BR)* $+*)*)'N No. 14, of 010 %udgment&'rder Dated - 1,&7&011 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - *a!re (hmad Civil %udgeI%.D.J2 Nai!a!ad23i:nor /s. State 'f .$.

Coram - Hon!le )mtiya 6urtaa2%. and Hon!le Shri ;ant *ripathi2%.

1#4. Headline Summary - )R discloses commission of cognia!le offence. Guashing of )R refused. 5ovt. of La Commission

recommended to ma"e Section #74 )$C non-!aila!le.

%udgment&'rder - CR)6)N(L 6)SC. BR)* $+*)*)'N No. 0, of 011 %udgment&'rder Dated - 8&7&011 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - (mit ;umar 9 6ittal /s. State 'f .$. A 'thers


1#7. Headline Summary - SCH+DL+ (NN+E+D B)*H *H+ $+*)*)'N )N S$$'R* ' *H+ (LL+5(*)'NS )S+/)D+NC+ (ND C(N N'* 3+ *R+(*+D (S $L+(D)N5.


*itle - Chandra Narain *ripathi /s. ;apil 6uni ;arariya


1#=. Headline Summary - )t is mandatory to o!tain environmental clearance under the Notification dated 14.8.00=......

%udgment&'rder - $3L)C )N*+R+S* L)*)5(*)'N I$)LJ No. =,8 of 011 %udgment&'rder Dated - #&7&011 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - %agriti Sansthan (nd 'thers /s. State 'f .$. (nd 'thers

Coram - Hon!le erdino )nacio Re!ello2Chief %ustice and Hon!le $ra"ash ;rishna2%.

1#,. Headline Summary - +nvironmental clearance is mandatory prior to carry on the mining operations.

%udgment&'rder - 6)SC. 3+NCH No. 841= of 010 %udgment&'rder Dated - 8&4&011 at Luc"no.



*itle - 6ohd. ;ausar %ah ? $.).L.@ Civil /s. nion 'f )ndia *hrough Secy. 6inistry 'f +nvironment (nd

Coram - Hon!le erdino )nacio Re!ello2Chief %ustice and Hon!le Devi $rasad Singh2%.

1#. Headline Summary - Conviction ell merited2 hoever compensation granted-sentence reduced as first offence.


*itle - Naal ;ishor *eari /s. State 'f .$.


1#8. Headline Summary - Section 0 %uvenile %ustice (ct has got precedence over Section 1-Revision dismissed.

%udgment&'rder - CR)6)N(L R+/)S)'N No. 80= of 011 %udgment&'rder Dated - #0&#&011 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - Sur:eet Singh /s. State 'f .$. (nd 'thers


140. Headline Summary - $oers of (ssistant Registrar cancelling the registration of Society2 (llaha!ad High School2 (llaha!ad

%udgment&'rder - S$+C)(L ($$+(L No. 1 of 011 %udgment&'rder Dated - 7&#&011 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - (llaha!ad High School Society (lld. *hru Secry2 A (nother /s. State 'f .$. A 'thers

Coram - Hon!le D.S.R. /arma2%. and Hon!le /i"ram Nath2%.

141. Headline Summary - N' C(S+ C(N 3+ *R(NS+RR+D 'N R()S)N5 ' (N ($$R+H+NS)'N H(/)N5 N'

R+(S'N(3L+ 3(S)S

%udgment&'rder - *R(NS+R ($$L)C(*)'N ICR)6)N(LJ No. 7 of 011 %udgment&'rder Dated - 7&#&011 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - Lami Narain $andey /s. State 'f .$. (nd 'thers


14. Headline Summary - $remium for driver not paid - )nsurance Company not lia!le to pay compensation.

%udgment&'rder - )RS* ($$+(L R'6 'RD+R No. 40= of 188 %udgment&'rder Dated - 4&#&011 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - Ne )ndia (ssurance Co. Ltd /s. Smt. ma Devi (nd 'thers



Coram - Hon!le <atindra Singh2%. and Hon!le Shyam Shan"ar *iari2%.

14#. Headline Summary - )nterim mandamus issued to D5$ to clear railay trac"s and report compliance 8.#.011 fied net date

%udgment&'rder - $3L)C )N*+R+S* L)*)5(*)'N I$)LJ No. 1=80, of 011 %udgment&'rder Dated - 1&#&011 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - ;m. 3harti ;ashyap /s. State 'f .$. (nd 'thers


144. Headline Summary - (ppeal against conviction under #0, )$C-medical report coo"ed up-investigation unfair-#1# Cr.$C not

complied ith-appeal alloed-conviction set aside.

%udgment&'rder - CR)6)N(L ($$+(L No. 11= of 00 %udgment&'rder Dated - 1=&#&011 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - Shashi ;ant Singh (nd (nother /s. State 'f .$.


147. Headline Summary - (pplicant successful in lottery for li>uor shopsQ application counter signed - lia!le to pay licence fee on

65G.%udgment&'rder - BR)* *(E No. 148 of 00= %udgment&'rder Dated - 8&#&011 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - 3ri: ;ishore %aisal (nd (nother /s. State 'f .$. *hru $rinc. Secry.2 I+ciseJ (nd 'thers

Coram - Hon!le <atindra Singh2%. and Hon!le $ra"ash ;rishna2%.

14=. Headline Summary - No person can !e added as accused under Section #18 Cr.$.C. after closer of the case.

%udgment&'rder - CR)6)N(L R+/)S)'N No. 1440 of 011 %udgment&'rder Dated - &#&011 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - (:ay /s. State 'f .$.

Coram - Hon!le /inod $rasad2%.14,. Headline Summary - Circumstantial evidence last seen recovery of eapon statement of deceased of invitation of accused

admissi!le u&s #I1J of +vidence (ct(ppeal dismiss

%udgment&'rder - %()L ($$+(L No. 718 of 007 %udgment&'rder Dated - #&#&011 at (llaha!ad.



*itle - Saeeduddin /s. State

Coram - Hon!le (mar Saran2%. and Hon!le Naheed (ra 6oonis2%.

14. Headline Summary - Deceaseds amputated organ reason for preferring unvirtuous DB evidence to $Bs Section ,2 14=2 14+vidence (ct discussed.

%udgment&'rder - CR)6)N(L ($$+(L No. ,#0 of 00= %udgment&'rder Dated - #&#&011 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - Rishi $al /s. State 'f .$.

Coram - Hon!le (mar Saran2%. and Hon!le Naheed (ra 6oonis2%.

148. Headline Summary - Repeated 4 Cr.$.C. (pplications for the same relief ithout change of circumstances and facts not

maintaina!le-4Cr.$.C. (pplications dismissed.

%udgment&'rder - ($$L)C(*)'N &s 4 No. #00#0 of 008 %udgment&'rder Dated - #&#&011 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - C.$. Singh /s. State 'f .$. (nd (nother

Coram - Hon!le /inod $rasad2%.170. Headline Summary - S66'N)N5 'RD+R B)*H'* '3*()N)N5 R+L+/(N* 6(*+R)(LS )N S$$'R* ' *H+

)N'R6(*)'N R+C+)/+D &S180 I1JICJ ' *H+ CR)6)N(L $R'C+DR+ C'D+ )S N'* $R'$+R

%udgment&'rder - CR)6)N(L R+/)S)'N No. 1408 of 001 %udgment&'rder Dated - 7&&011 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - Ram /ilash Chauhan A 'thers /s. State 'f .$.A 'thers


171. Headline Summary - ( H+(/< D*< L)+S 'N *H+ S*(*+ *' $R'*+C* B)*N+SS+S R'6 3+)N5 *(6$+R+D

B)*H. (CCS+D )N/'L/+D )N *(6$+R)N5 B)*H *H+ +/)D+NC+ )S N'* +N*)*L+D *' 3()L.

%udgment&'rder - CR)6)N(L 6)SC. 3()L ($$L)C(*)'N No. #4 of 008 %udgment&'rder Dated - 4&&011 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - 5ufran (hmad /s. State 'f .$.




17. Headline Summary - )nterest for the period accounts !oo"s ere seied should !e aived.

%udgment&'rder - BR)* *(E No. 7 of 007 %udgment&'rder Dated - 10&&011 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - 6&S %.S.D. Coloniers I$J Ltd /s. niion 'f )ndia A (nother


17#. Headline Summary - )f search under )ncome *a (ct is challenged2 the Department has to disclose information ecept source.

%udgment&'rder - BR)* *(E No. ,7 of 010 %udgment&'rder Dated - 4&&011 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - 6&S 6.D. 'verseas Ltd. /s. Director 5eneral 'f )ncome-*a I)nv.J North (nd 'thers


174. Headline Summary - $)L for reforming police or"ing2 train it it ith scientific s"ill. 5overnment called upon to file counter

affidavit sorn !y officer.

%udgment&'rder - CR)6)N(L 6)SC. BR)* $+*)*)'N No. 1,8, of 011 %udgment&'rder Dated - &1&011 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - 6ohammad Gasim /s. State 'f .$. (nd 'thers


177. Headline Summary - Notice issued to 5ovt in the matter of harassment or torture of villagers in 6adau"a village Naini $S on

Hindustan reports


*itle - )n *he 6atter 'f Harassment 'r *orture 'f /illagers /s. State 'f .$.


17=. Headline Summary - Section 1,4I1JIaJ 6unicipal Corporation (ct is valid%udgment&'rder - BR)* *(E No. 1704 of 00= %udgment&'rder Dated - 4&1&011 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - Clar" Hotel Limited *hru 6anaging Director pendra 5upta /s. Stae 'f .$. *hru *he $rincipal Secretary .D.L.3. A

'thers




17,. Headline Summary - Conviction u&s #,= )$C&victim ma:or&eloped on her on volition&consenting party& conviction set

aside&appeal alloed.

%udgment&'rder - %()L ($$+(L No. #7= of 008 %udgment&'rder Dated - 4&1&011 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - San:iv 9 San:u /s. State


17. Headline Summary - (ppeal against ac>uittal-incident #4 years ago-remand of case not desira!le-!lea" chances of evidence

!eing availa!le-appeal dismissed

%udgment&'rder - 5'/+RN6+N* ($$+(L No. 8,1 of 180 %udgment&'rder Dated - 1&1&011 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - State 'f .$. /s. Shamim 3eg


178. Headline Summary - )n Sheelu Nishad case2 the victim ordered to !e released forthith from :ail attended ith direction to provide security to the victim and her family.


*itle - )n *he 6atter 'f Sheelu Nishad2 ( Rape /ictim Lodged )n %ail /s. State 'f .$.

Coram - Hon!le )mtiya 6urtaa2%. and Hon!le S.C. (garal2%.

1=0. Headline Summary - $rior to 1.4.1882 assessment u&s 141I1J of the )* (ct as regular assessment.

%udgment&'rder - )NC'6+ *(E ($$+(L No. =1 of 000 %udgment&'rder Dated - ,&1&011 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - *he Commissioner 'f )ncome *a /s. D.S. 3atra I)ndlJ


1=1. Headline Summary - 'ne out of to eemptions can alays !e opted unless specifically or impliedly !arred !y other.

%udgment&'rder - C+N*R(L +EC)S+ R++R+NC+ No. #1 of 000 %udgment&'rder Dated - #&1&010 at (llaha!ad.



*itle - Cce 6eerut /s. 6odi Eero Ltd. Rampur


1=. Headline Summary - ull 3ench vieed that order &S 17=I#J Cr.$.C. interlocutory2 no revision or application 4 Cr.$.C.lie !y prospective accused

%udgment&'rder - CR)6)N(L R+/)S)'N No. 1=40 of 001 %udgment&'rder Dated - &1&010 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - ather *homas /s. State 'f .$. A (nother

Coram - Hon!le (mar Saran2%. 2 Hon!le (sho" ;umar Roopanal2%. and Hon!le Surendra Singh2%.

1=#. Headline Summary - Co-accused granted !ail-only conviction for conspiracy-appellant granted !ail.

%udgment&'rder - CR)6)N(L ($$+(L No. ,= of 010 %udgment&'rder Dated - 1#&1&010 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - (sho" Chaturvedi /s. Central 3ureau 'f )nvestigation (nd (nr.


1=4. Headline Summary - Collective decision of Statutory 3oard-cannot !e conspiracy !y one-consensus evidence missing-Smt. Neera <adav granted !ail.

%udgment&'rder - CR)6)N(L ($$+(L No. ,#4 of 010 %udgment&'rder Dated - 1#&1&010 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - Smt. Neera <adav /s. State 'f .$. *hru. C.3.).


1=7. Headline Summary - +ntertainment *a (ct - no provision to impose damages for loss of entertainment ta

%udgment&'rder - BR)* *(E No. #8 of 00= %udgment&'rder Dated - 10&1&010 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - Sita Ram *e"arial /s. State 'f .$. A 'thersCoram - Hon!le <atindra Singh2%. and Hon!le $ra"ash ;rishna2%.

1==. Headline Summary - )n the matter of Ra"hi Saant2 stay order of arrest granted




*itle - Ra"hi Saant /s. State 'f .$. A 'thers

Coram - Hon!le )mtiya 6urtaa2%. and Hon!le Ram (utar Singh2%.

1=,. Headline Summary - sho cause noticed issued to (3 Ra:mauli Distt 6agistrate 3i:nor for initiating contempt proceeding./igilance en>uiry set up.


*itle - *a!re (hmad Civil %udgeI%.D.J2 Nai!a!ad23i:nor /s. State 'f .$.


1=. Headline Summary - 5.'. dated 7..010 is modified to the etent that appointment of Ro:gar Sea"s shall !e reneed for

one year at a time su!:ect to satisfactory or".

%udgment&'rder - BR)* - ( No. 7==44 of 010 %udgment&'rder Dated - ,&1&010 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - Shiv 6anorath Shu"la (nd 'thers /s. State 'f .$. (nd 'thers

Coram - Hon!le Dilip 5upta2%.1=8. Headline Summary - (mount sent !y 6andi Samiti to the $arishad is application of records under )ncome *a (ct.

%udgment&'rder - )NC'6+ *(E ($$+(L D++C*)/+ No. 7 of 010 %udgment&'rder Dated - &1&010 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - *he Commissioner 'f )ncome *a (nd (nother /s. ;rishi tpadan 6andi Samiti


1,0. Headline Summary - ee for advertisement on */ Channel !y Nagar $ali"a $arishad - not permissi!le

%udgment&'rder - BR)* *(E No. 0== of 00 %udgment&'rder Dated - #0&11&010 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - San:ai 5upta /s. State 'f .$. *hru D.6.2 +tah (nd 'thersCoram - Hon!le <atindra Singh2%. and Hon!le $ra"ash ;rishna2%.

1,1. Headline Summary - Rule 11 of 18, Rules for 6adarsa ill also apply to earlier recognised 6adarsas.

%udgment&'rder - BR)* - C No. #,=87 of 010 %udgment&'rder Dated - 8&11&010 at (llaha!ad.



*itle - C&62 6adarsa Guraniya (dampur ("!ar *hru 6anaer A 'thers /s. State 'f .$. *hru Chief Secretary 5ovt. 'f .$. A

'thers


1,. Headline Summary - (rrest of the petitioners stayed as a conse>uence of )R resulting from episode Ra"hi ;a )nsaf

%udgment&'rder - CR)6)N(L 6)SC. BR)* $+*)*)'N No. 1##1 of 010 %udgment&'rder Dated - 8&11&010 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - (n:u Rai"ar (nd 'thers /s. State 'f .$. (nd 'thers


1,#. Headline Summary - *he :urisdiction to verify the caste certificate and hether it should !e validated or invalidated is of the

Caste Scrutiny Committee.

%udgment&'rder - BR)* - C No. =8018 of 010 %udgment&'rder Dated - =&11&010 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - Hiana 3ano /s. State 'f .$. *hru Collector (nd 'thers

Coram - Hon!le erdino )nacio Re!ello2Chief %ustice and Hon!le /ineet Saran2%.1,4. Headline Summary - Case falling under to heads u&s 17# )ncome *a (ct - time should !e ecluded for !oth.

%udgment&'rder - )NC'6+ *(E R++R+NC+ No. 18 of 18, %udgment&'rder Dated - #&11&010 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - C.).*. /s. 6&S Luco +lectronics


1,7. Headline Summary - Draft order under section 1443 of )ncome *a (ct should !e referred to )(C conferred concurrent

:urisdiction.

%udgment&'rder - )NC'6+ *(E R++R+NC+ No. 7, of 18= %udgment&'rder Dated - #&11&010 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - C.).*. (llaha!ad /s. 6&S. S. Sugar 6ills $vt. Ltd.2 5ora"hpur




1,=. Headline Summary - (t the stage of charge2 neither pros and cons of the case nor the defence evidence can !e considered.

Charge can !e framed even on grave suspicion.

%udgment&'rder - &S 4&#,&40, No. 81 of 010 %udgment&'rder Dated - 18&11&010 at Luc"no.

*itle - /i:ay ;umar *rivedi /s. State 'f .$. (nd (nother


1,,. Headline Summary - *he >uestion hether model shop during ecise year can !e relocated - referred to the third :udge.

%udgment&'rder - BR)* *(E No. 104# of 010 %udgment&'rder Dated - 1&11&010 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - Ra"esh Singh /s. State 'f .$. (nd 'thers

Coram - Hon!le <atindra Singh2%. and Hon!le Ra:es ;umar2%.

1,. Headline Summary - contempt notice issued to +ditor and others2 Hindustan *imes to appear in court on 1#.1.010

%udgment&'rder - C'N*+6$* ($$L)C(*)'N ICR)6)N(LJ No. 0 of 010 %udgment&'rder Dated - 11&11&010 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - /i"as *iari /s. State 'f .$. A 'thers

Coram - Hon!le )mtiya 6urtaa2%. and Hon!le (sho" Srivastava2%.

1,8. Headline Summary - Not necessary for the empoered officer to personally record reasons.

%udgment&'rder - BR)* *(E No. 18 of 00# %udgment&'rder Dated - ,&10&010 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - 6&S N.;. Laminates $vt Ltd. /s. Supdt IC.$.J Central +cise2 ;anpur A 'thers


10. Headline Summary - summoning order-not to !e a spea"ing order-presumption u&s 114IeJ of +vidence (ct can !e applied.

%udgment&'rder - ($$L)C(*)'N &s 4 No. ##7= of 010 %udgment&'rder Dated - ,&10&010 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - (nand ;umar $oral /s. State 'f .$.(nd (nother


11. Headline Summary - ( ord used at different place in the (ct or Rule may have different meaning according to its contet.



%udgment&'rder - BR)* - C No. #=1 of 00 %udgment&'rder Dated - =&10&010 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - /ive"a Nand <adav /s. State 'f .$. (nd 'thers


1. Headline Summary - 'pportunity to head of local !ody necessary !efore ceasing financial poer.

%udgment&'rder - BR)* - C No. =4, of 00 %udgment&'rder Dated - =&10&010 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - Hafi (taullah (nsari /s. State 'f .$. (nd (nother

Coram - Hon!le <atindra Singh2%. 2 Hon!le Ra:es ;umar2%. and Hon!le ;rishna 6urari2%.

1#. Headline Summary - prayer for criminal contempt against Chief 6inister-statement not scandalie to :udicial proceeding-

prayer refused

%udgment&'rder - C'N*+6$* ($$L)C(*)'N ICR)6)N(LJ No. , of 008 %udgment&'rder Dated - &10&010 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - Smt. (l"a Rai +. 6.L.(. /s. 6iss 6ayaati *he Hon3le Chief 6inister 'f .$.


14. Headline Summary - No fresh declaration under 7,5 +cise Rules unless change in input or final product.

%udgment&'rder - C+N*R(L +EC)S+ R++R+NC+ No. 11 of 000 %udgment&'rder Dated - 18&10&010 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - Commissioner Central +cise2 ;anpur /s. 6&S Standard Sul. Ltd. (nd 'thers


17. Headline Summary - cogniance ta"en !y ay of suo motu proceeding against out Loo" magaine fiing 1.11.010 for

pu!lishing article denigrating C.% of (lld High Court

%udgment&'rder - C'N*+6$* ($$L)C(*)'N ICR)6)N(LJ No. 1, of 010 %udgment&'rder Dated - 11&10&010 at (llaha!ad.*itle - Ravi ;iran %ain Senior (dvocate /s. /inod 6ehta +ditor-)n-Chief 'utloo" A 'thers

Coram - Hon!le )mtiya 6urtaa2%. and Hon!le Naheed (ra 6oonis2%.



1=. Headline Summary - Su!se>uent involvement of accused on !ail in similar cases amounting regular harassment of

complainant a itness2 arrants cancellation of his !ail.

%udgment&'rder - CR)6)N(L 6)SC. 3()L ($$L)C(*)'N No. 1701 of 008 %udgment&'rder Dated - &10&010 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - Smt. /eena /erma /s. State 'f .$. A (nother

Coram - Hon!le /irendra Singh2%.

1,. Headline Summary - ...it appears that the ord (D<(*(N means up-to-date and not merely as on date....

%udgment&'rder - S$+C)(L ($$+(L No. 17=7 of 010 %udgment&'rder Dated - &8&010 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - ;m. Seema /s. State 'f .$. *hru. Sec. L"o. (nd 'thers

Coram - Hon!le erdino )nacio Re!ello2Chief %ustice and Hon!le (mreshar $ratap Sahi2%.

1. Headline Summary - %ustice must !e seen to !e done.

%udgment&'rder - BR)* *(E No. 11#8 of 010 %udgment&'rder Dated - ,&8&010 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - 5anesh $olyte Ltd *hru Director Sharad Sharma /s. nion 'f )ndia A 'thers


18. Headline Summary - Corporater2 Society of nion are not union - (rticle 7 not applica!le.

%udgment&'rder - BR)* *(E No. #4, of 004 %udgment&'rder Dated - #&8&010 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - 3anaras Hindu niversity2 /arnaasi *hru )ts Registrar /s. State 'f .$. *hru $rincipal Secy. Nagar /i"as A 'rs.


180. Headline Summary - 6oney charged for advertisement hoarding on 3oards land - not a ta.

%udgment&'rder - BR)* *(E No. =1 of 010 %udgment&'rder Dated - 0&8&010 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - .$. (dvertiser (ssociation A (nother /s. nion 'f )ndia A 'thers




181. Headline Summary - Section 1 of the %uvenile %usticeICare A $rotection of ChildrenJ (ct2 000 overrides section #, of the

Narcotic Drugs and $sychotropic Su!stances (ct

%udgment&'rder - CR)6)N(L R+/)S)'N No. 88 of 010 %udgment&'rder Dated - 1=&8&010 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - $raveen ;umar 6aurya 9 $raveen 6aurya /s. State 'f .$.


18. Headline Summary - a"e encounter&sanction for prosecution nor re>uired&prayer for >uashing refused.

%udgment&'rder - ($$L)C(*)'N &s 4 No. 178 of 010 %udgment&'rder Dated - 14&8&010 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - %ai $ra"ash *iari /s. State 'f .$. A (nother


18#. Headline Summary - stridhan dispute-complaint at 5haia!ad ithout :urisdiction against all accused ecept hus!and-

prosecution of all relatives !ut for (-1 >uashed.

%udgment&'rder - ($$L)C(*)'N &s 4 No. 11#17 of 008 %udgment&'rder Dated - 14&8&010 at (llaha!ad.*itle - Su:eet ;umar A 'thers /s. State 'f .$. A (nother


184. Headline Summary - Guashing of murder case&evidence disclosed&Brit $etition dismissed.

%udgment&'rder - CR)6)N(L 6)SC. BR)* $+*)*)'N No. ,1#8 of 010 %udgment&'rder Dated - 1#&8&010 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - 6ahadeo $rashad /s. State 'f .$. A (nother


187. Headline Summary - (uthorised Controller&$ra!andh Sanchala"&(dministrator ill eercise all poers conferred !y thescheme of administration in addition poers ......

%udgment&'rder - BR)* - ( No. 4=#0 of 004 %udgment&'rder Dated - &8&010 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - <ashoda Ra: ;umari ;un:il /s. State 'f .$. (nd 'thers



Coram - Hon!le erdino )nacio Re!ello2Chief %ustice and Hon!le /.;. Shu"la2%.

18=. Headline Summary - ..ithdraal of e>uivalence ould2 therefore2 not apply retrospectively and prior to that the certificates

ould not stand annulled automatically..

%udgment&'rder - S$+C)(L ($$+(L No. 14= of 010 %udgment&'rder Dated - ,&8&010 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - 3hagat Narain Chaturvedi A (nother /s. State 'f .$. A 'thers


18,. Headline Summary - prayer for >uashing of case u&s 48-( etc-part of cause of action arose in district /aranasi-application

dismissed.

%udgment&'rder - ($$L)C(*)'N &s 4 No. 80# of 008 %udgment&'rder Dated - ,&&010 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - Ravi Shan"er $al A 'rs /s. State 'f .$.A (nr


18. Headline Summary - ... it is trite la that su!se>uent events relating to controversy can !e ta"en :udicial notice of and reliefcan !e moulded to do complete :ustice...

%udgment&'rder - S$+C)(L ($$+(L D++C*)/+ No. ,,, of 010 %udgment&'rder Dated - =&&010 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - *he 3asic Shi"sha (dhi"ari2 +tah A 'thers /s. Ram Dularey Sharma A 'thers


188. Headline Summary - 3enefit of Scheme dated #.11.1888 from date of installation& upgradation.

%udgment&'rder - BR)* *(E No. 70# of 007 %udgment&'rder Dated - =&&010 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - 6&S Nandan *al"ies /s. State 'f .$. *hru Secy. *a A )nstitutional inance A (nr


00. Headline Summary - No opportunity is re>uired to !e given if selection is made on the !asis of a forged mar"sheet

%udgment&'rder - BR)* - ( No. 7144 of 010 %udgment&'rder Dated - 7&&010 at (llaha!ad.



*itle - Harendra Singh /s. State 'f .$. (nd 'thers


01. Headline Summary - 'rder of ac>uittal reasona!le - no interference !y appellate court.

%udgment&'rder - C($)*(L C(S+S No. 0,, of 00 %udgment&'rder Dated - 1,&&010 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - 'm Nath /s. State 'f .$.


0. Headline Summary - *herefore2 if at all la of agency applies it ould !e !eteen sender and post office ...post office is

!ound .. to deliver it to the addressee...

%udgment&'rder - BR)* - ( No. 041 of 008 %udgment&'rder Dated - 1#&&010 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - Neena Chaturvedi /s. $u!lic Service Commission

Coram - Hon!le erdino )nacio Re!ello2Chief %ustice 2 Hon!le Dilip 5upta2%. and Hon!le San:ay 6isra2%.

0#. Headline Summary - Directors are not lia!le for the offence committed !y the company merely on the ground that they aredirectors.

%udgment&'rder - ($$L)C(*)'N &s 4 No. 1,4 of 1887 %udgment&'rder Dated - 1&&010 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - <ogendra Singh /s. Ran!ir Sharma A (nother


04. Headline Summary - Bitness protection programme is integral part of criminal :ustice reforms.

%udgment&'rder - C($)*(L C(S+S No. 1,4 of 00 %udgment&'rder Dated - 10&&010 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - Rishipal /s. State 'f .$.Coram - Hon!le <atindra Singh2%. and Hon!le Surendra Singh2%.

07. Headline Summary - Crl.(ppeal u&s #0 )$C&)R ante-timed&itnesses unrelia!le&recovery not proved&appeal alloed&accused

ac>uitted.



%udgment&'rder - CR)6)N(L ($$+(L No. 141, of 00= %udgment&'rder Dated - =&&010 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - Dharmendra /s. State 'f .$.

Coram - Hon!le /inod $rasad2%. and Hon!le Ra:esh Chandra2%.

0=. Headline Summary - Crl.(ppl u&s #0, )$C&right of private defence claimed&Section #4 not applica!le&charged

defective&itnesses relia!le&appeal partly alloed&

%udgment&'rder - CR)6)N(L ($$+(L No. 1871 of 00= %udgment&'rder Dated - =&&010 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - 6ulla I;aluJ I*ahirJ A (nother /s. State 'f .$.


0,. Headline Summary - $rosecution agency must !e toned up.

%udgment&'rder - C($)*(L C(S+S No. 1#4 of 00 %udgment&'rder Dated - 7&&010 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - /inay ;umar /s. State 'f .$.

Coram - Hon!le <atindra Singh2%. and Hon!le Surendra Singh2%.

0. Headline Summary - Diverting 5$ funds for paying salaries of illegally appointed 3allia teaching2 nonteaching staffunarranted. Court orders no ecuse. )R not >uashed

%udgment&'rder - CR)6)N(L 6)SC. BR)* $+*)*)'N No. 8,# of 010 %udgment&'rder Dated - 4&&010 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - /inayendra Nath padhyay (nd 'thers /s. State 'f .$. A 'rs.


08. Headline Summary - ...once the tenure has come to an end2 there is no legal right vested to claim continuance ...

%udgment&'rder - S$+C)(L ($$+(L D++C*)/+ No. =1 of 010 %udgment&'rder Dated - &,&010 at (llaha!ad.*itle - Smt. 5eeta Devi /s. ma Shan"er <adav (nd 'thers


10. Headline Summary - 6odern scientific methods should !e used !y investigators.



%udgment&'rder - C($)*(L C(S+S No. ==# of 00 %udgment&'rder Dated - &,&010 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - ;anhaiya /s. State 'f .$.


11. Headline Summary - 4 Cr.$.C. application-#0,&#8&704&70= ).$.C.-parties closely related-compromised the case-application

alloed-proceeding >uashed.

%udgment&'rder - ($$L)C(*)'N &s 4 No. 1#, of 008 %udgment&'rder Dated - #&,&010 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - %itendra $al 9 $appu (nd 'thers /s. State 'f .$.(nd (nother


1. Headline Summary - )ntermediate +amination Certificate cannot !e issued on the !asis of a forged document

%udgment&'rder - BR)* - C No. 1088# of 00, %udgment&'rder Dated - 1&,&010 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - Navneet ;umar /s. State 'f .$. *hru Secry. 6adhami" Shi"sha $arishad A 'rs.


1#. Headline Summary - Criminal (ppeal u&s #0&sudden occurrence&a!sence of intention&deceased started >uarrel&convictionaltered under #04I))J&appeal partly alloed.

%udgment&'rder - %()L ($$+(L No. 7= of 00, %udgment&'rder Dated - 1=&,&010 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - Ram $yare raon A 'thers /s. State


14. Headline Summary - Criminal (ppeal&#0 )$C&charge defective&#1# no circumstance put&(ppeal alloed&conviction set aside.

%udgment&'rder - CR)6)N(L ($$+(L No. 414 of 004 %udgment&'rder Dated - 1=&,&010 at (llaha!ad.*itle - Raees /s. State 'f .$.

Coram - Hon!le /inod $rasad2%. and Hon!le /irendra Singh2%.



17. Headline Summary - 4-Recall (pplication-(pplicants committed fraud and material concealment-Recall (pplication

dismissed.

%udgment&'rder - ($$L)C(*)'N &s 4 No. #141 of 008 %udgment&'rder Dated - 8&,&010 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - Suresh Chandra 6ishra A (nother /s. State 'f .$. A (nother


1=. Headline Summary - 6em!ers of Committee of 6anagement cannot !e removed !y vote of no confidence in the a!sence of

such provision in the 3ye-Las

%udgment&'rder - BR)* - C No. 7=4## of 008 %udgment&'rder Dated - 7&,&010 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - C&62 Dharma S.S. )nter College A Sans"rit $athsala A 'rs. /s. State 'f .$. A 'thers


1,. Headline Summary - Criminal (ppeal&Conviction under #8# )$C&fact itnesses unrelia!le&accused arrest dou!tful&appeal

alloed&conviction set aside.

%udgment&'rder - CR)6)N(L ($$+(L No. #7 of 010 %udgment&'rder Dated - &=&010 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - Ravindra /s. State 'f .$.


1. Headline Summary - 'rder u&s #18 Cr$C should !e passed only hen evidence is of such >uality as to lead conviction.6ere

non-eamination of itness doesnt vitiate order.

%udgment&'rder - &S 4&#,&40, No. 7# of 010 %udgment&'rder Dated - &7&010 at Luc"no.

*itle - Ra:ol (nd 'thers /s. State 'f .$. (nd (nother


18. Headline Summary - Notithstanding2 (ganadi or"ers are not holders of civil posts they are entitle to invo"e rit

:urisdiction against termination of their services.

%udgment&'rder - S$+C)(L ($$+(L No. 111 of 007 %udgment&'rder Dated - &7&010 at (llaha!ad.



*itle - Smt. Sheela Devi A (nother /s. State 'f .$. *hru $rincipal Secy. A 'thers

Coram - Hon!le Sheo ;umar Singh2%. 2 Hon!le $an"a: 6ithal2%. and Hon!le (sho" ;umar Roopanal2%.

0. Headline Summary - Conviction on etra :udicial confession corro!orated !y circumstances - permissi!le.

%udgment&'rder - C($)*(L C(S+S No. 1,4, of 00, %udgment&'rder Dated - &7&010 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - Shafi> /s. State 'f .$.


1. Headline Summary - )ncident in night - )f accused are ell "non then identification can not !e >uestioned.

%udgment&'rder - C($)*(L C(S+S No. ==10 of 008 %udgment&'rder Dated - &7&010 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - Randhey A (nother /s. State 'f .$.


. Headline Summary - $eriod of lease cannot !e etended !y the Court direction to the State 5overnment to realise !enefit

under the interim order.

%udgment&'rder - BR)* - C No. ,0 of 00 %udgment&'rder Dated - 7&7&010 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - Smt. Ram Lali 6ishra /s. State 'f .$. *hru Secy. 6inistry 'f 5eology A 6ining A 'rs


#. Headline Summary - 'rder passed !y the /ice-Chancellor for cancellation of the $ost 5raduate 6edical +ntrance

+amination for )nstitutional seats set aside.

%udgment&'rder - BR)* - C No. #88, of 010 %udgment&'rder Dated - 1&7&010 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - Dr. (nurag ;umar *iari A 'rs. /s. nion 'f )ndia *hru. Secr. 6inistryof H.R.D. A 'rs.Coram - Hon!le Dilip 5upta2%.

4. Headline Summary - Circular of State 5overnment for ecluding negative mar"ing for SC&S* candidates only for admission to

$.5. 6edical Courses set aside



%udgment&'rder - BR)* - C No. 014, of 010 %udgment&'rder Dated - 0&7&010 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - Hemant ;rishna 6aurya (nd 'thers /s. State 'f .$. (nd 'thers


7. Headline Summary - Criminal (ppeal&charge of gang rape !y 4 accused&medical consistent ith victims testimony&conviction

confirmed&(ppeal dismissed.

%udgment&'rder - CR)6)N(L ($$+(L No. #08 of 00= %udgment&'rder Dated - 14&7&010 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - /ipin A (nother /s. State 'f .$.


=. Headline Summary - ine &s #0 )$C is not mandatory.

%udgment&'rder - C($)*(L C(S+S No. =,1# of 008 %udgment&'rder Dated - 11&7&010 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - Santosh ;umar 3aranal /s. State 'f .$.

Coram - Hon!le <atindra Singh2%. and Hon!le 3.N. Shu"la2%.

,. Headline Summary - Brit for >uashing of )R&marriage not sanctified !y muslim la&)R cannot !e >uashed&rit dismissed.

%udgment&'rder - CR)6)N(L 6)SC. BR)* $+*)*)'N No. =1=8 of 010 %udgment&'rder Dated - 10&7&010 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - Dil!ar Ha!i! Siddi>ui /s. State 'f .$. A 'thers


. Headline Summary - Direction to the Dental College to refund of ecess fees and for issuance of Certificates given

%udgment&'rder - BR)* - C No. #4# of 00= %udgment&'rder Dated - =&7&010 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - Rama +deucational Society (nd (nother /s. State 'f .$. (nd (nother


8. Headline Summary - Criminal (ppeal& 10 years sentence&appellant already undergone 8 and a half year& conviction altered to

sentence undergone& appeal partly alloed.



%udgment&'rder - CR)6)N(L ($$+(L No. =8, of 00, %udgment&'rder Dated - 7&7&010 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - 6uneshar 9 (rvind /s. State 'f .$.


#0. Headline Summary - No eplanation adds a lin" in cases of circumstantial evidence.

%udgment&'rder - C($)*(L C(S+S No. ,7 of 010 %udgment&'rder Dated - 8&4&010 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - Ram Samu:h <adav /s. State 'f .$.


#1. Headline Summary - Brong admission cancelled as no sympathy is to !e shon and direction for admission of petitioner

given.

%udgment&'rder - BR)* - C No. 7008 of 008 %udgment&'rder Dated - =&4&010 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - ;m. (n:uman padhyay /s. $rincipal2 District )nsti. 'f +duc. A *raining A 'rs.


#. Headline Summary - *erm of Committee of 6anagement ill start hen charge is given in vie of such a Clause in theScheme of (dministration

%udgment&'rder - BR)* - C No. 77=40 of 008 %udgment&'rder Dated - 0&4&010 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - Dr. 6ahendra $ratap Singh (nd 'thers /s. State 'f .$. (nd 'thers


##. Headline Summary - Dying declaration !efore police is admissi!le u&s 1= IJ Cr$C.

%udgment&'rder - CR)6)N(L ($$+(L No. 1 of 18 %udgment&'rder Dated - 1=&4&010 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - Lami (nd 'thers /s. State 'f .$.




#4. Headline Summary - conviction u&s #0 ).$.C.-circumstantial evidence recovery of !ody and cycle of deceased from the

appellant-itnesses relia!le-appeal dismissed

%udgment&'rder - CR)6)N(L ($$+(L No. = of 184 %udgment&'rder Dated - 7&#&010 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - 3a!u /s. State 'f .$.

Coram - Hon!le /inod $rasad2%. and Hon!le /edpal2%.

#7. Headline Summary - Statements under section 1=1 Cr$C not supplied - *rial not vitiated unless there is failure of :ustice.

%udgment&'rder - C($)*(L C(S+S No. =00 of 008 %udgment&'rder Dated - 18&#&010 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - /ishal $armanand A 'thers /s. State 'f .$.


#=. Headline Summary - (fter re:ecting final report2 cogniance can not !e ta"en on the !asis of affidavits etc. filed in support of

protest petition.

%udgment&'rder - ($$L)C(*)'N &s 4 No. 70# of 010 %udgment&'rder Dated - 1=&#&010 at (llaha!ad.*itle - /imlesh /s. State 'f .$. (nd (nother

Coram - Hon!le /i:ay ;umar /erma2%.

#,. Headline Summary - Currency notes of same num!er and in one series foundfrom different accused in 6ela suggest

traffic"ing punisha!le for life us 48-3 )$C. 3ail refused

%udgment&'rder - CR)6)N(L ($$+(L No. 404 of 010 %udgment&'rder Dated - 17&#&010 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - Ra:u 9 Riyauddin /s. State 'f .$.


#. Headline Summary - 6urder of ife-$resence of hus!and esta!lished-D&D truthful-conviction confirmed.

%udgment&'rder - %()L ($$+(L No. =#=7 of 00 %udgment&'rder Dated - 17&#&010 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - Su"hram /s. State




#8. Headline Summary - HC recommends mediation in cases &S 48-( )$C and #&4 D$ (ct and allied offences and otherthan

eceptional cases restrains immediate arrests on )R

%udgment&'rder - CR)6)N(L 6)SC. BR)* $+*)*)'N No. ## of 010 %udgment&'rder Dated - =&&010 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - San:eev ;umar A 'thers /s. State 'f .$. A 'thers


40. Headline Summary - Case of circumstantial evidence - all circumstances must !e proved.

%udgment&'rder - C($)*(L C(S+S No. 4=7 of 008 %udgment&'rder Dated - #&&010 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - San:ay /s. State 'f .$.


41. Headline Summary - 6edical evidence not inconsistent2 if can !e eplained.

%udgment&'rder - CR)6)N(L ($$+(L No. 10 of 18 %udgment&'rder Dated - &&010 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - %ala $rasad /s. State


4. Headline Summary - *rial %udge issuing 11 )$C prosecution notice2 then discharging threatened hostile itness2 cancelling

!ail of accused appreciated.3ail re:ected !yHC

%udgment&'rder - CR)6)N(L 6)SC. 3()L ($$L)C(*)'N No. 084 of 008 %udgment&'rder Dated - 18&&010 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - $intoo A 'thers /s. State 'f .$.

Coram - Hon!le (mar Saran2%.

4#. Headline Summary - 6ano: Nigam (dvocate ;anpur Nagar convicted and sentenced to one month S) a fine of Rs. 02000&-

!ut sentence shall remain suspended for to years.

%udgment&'rder - C'N*+6$* ($$L)C(*)'N ICR)6)N(LJ No. 14 of 008 %udgment&'rder Dated - 1=&&010 at (llaha!ad.



*itle - )n ReK Sri. Ravindra ;umar-)i Civil %udgeIS.D.J ;snpur Nagar /s. 6ano: NigamI(dvocateJ


44. Headline Summary - ma Shan"er Sharma (dvocate 3udaun convicted under contempt of court court and sentenced to onemonth S) and fine of Rs. 02000&-


*itle - )n Re K Sri 6.;. Singh2 (.D.%. 3udaun /s. Sri ma Shan"ar Sharma2 (dvocate


47. Headline Summary - Nahar Singh <adav and Shailendra Sharma convicted and each of them sentenced to undergo R.). for si

months and pay fine of Rs. 02000&


*itle - )n ReK /s. Shailendra Sharma2 Nahar Singh <adav (dvocates Civil-Court

Coram - Hon!le )mtiya 6urtaa2%. and Hon!le Shyam Shan"ar *iari2%.4=. Headline Summary - Sec.#,= )$C-Rape-victims evidence truthful- serologist report supported case-(ppeal dismissed.

%udgment&'rder - CR)6)N(L ($$+(L No. 1,4 of 00, %udgment&'rder Dated - 8&&010 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - Shami llah /s. State 'f .$.


4,. Headline Summary - 3ri: ;ishore 6isra (Dvocate aru"ha!ad convicted and sentenced to # months Si fine Rs. 02000&- for

contempt

%udgment&'rder - C'N*+6$* ($$L)C(*)'N ICR)6)N(LJ No. = of 00 %udgment&'rder Dated - 7&&010 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - )n ReK /s. 3ri: ;ishore (dvocate

Coram - Hon!le )mtiya 6urtaa2%. and Hon!le Naheed (ra 6oonis2%.

4. Headline Summary - Contempt - )nformation sent !y su!ordinate court is reference.



%udgment&'rder - C'N*+6$* ($$L)C(*)'N ICR)6)N(LJ No. #0 of 00= %udgment&'rder Dated - 7&&010 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - )n ReK C.%.6. atehpur *hru. D.%. atehpur /s. Sri $ra"ash Singh (dvocate

Coram - Hon!le <atindra Singh2%. and Hon!le Shri ;ant *ripathi2%.

48. Headline Summary - 3hagati Sharma (dvocate civil court ;ushinagar convicted for contempt. His conduct ould !e

atched.

%udgment&'rder - C'N*+6$* ($$L)C(*)'N ICR)6)N(LJ No. 0 of 00 %udgment&'rder Dated - 7&&010 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - )n ReK ISri. S.$.Sharma C.%.6. ;ushinagarJ /s. 3hagati Sharma (dvocate ;ushinagar


70. Headline Summary - Ra:vir Singh *yagi (dvocate Civil courts 6eerut convicted and sentendced to three months S.) and fine

of Rs. 02000&- for contempt

%udgment&'rder - C'N*+6$* ($$L)C(*)'N ICR)6)N(LJ No. 1# of 00 %udgment&'rder Dated - 7&&010 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - )n ReK /s. Ra:veer Singh (dvocateCoram - Hon!le )mtiya 6urtaa2%. and Hon!le Shyam Shan"ar *iari2%.

71. Headline Summary - Harish 3a!u 5upta (dvocate Chandausi 6orada!ad convicted and sentenced to one month

imprisonment and fine of Rs. 02000&- for contempt

%udgment&'rder - C'N*+6$* ($$L)C(*)'N ICR)6)N(LJ No. of 00= %udgment&'rder Dated - 7&&010 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - )n ReK ISri. R.$.Saro: ?S.D.@ (.C.%.6. 6orada!adJ /s. Sri Harish 3a!u 5upta (dvocate


7. Headline Summary - %asvir Singh $aar (dvocate 6uaffarnagar convicted and sentenced to undergo S) for # molnths and

fine of Rs. 02000&- for contempt

%udgment&'rder - C'N*+6$* ($$L)C(*)'N ICR)6)N(LJ No. #1 of 007 %udgment&'rder Dated - 7&&010 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - 6rs. 6an:u Lata Consolidation 'fficer /s. %as!ir Singh $aar (dvocate




7#. Headline Summary - Digvi:ai Singh $al (dvocate Hamipur convicted under contempt of court (ct D.% to monitor conduct

%udgment&'rder - C'N*+6$* ($$L)C(*)'N ICR)6)N(LJ No. 1 of 00 %udgment&'rder Dated - 7&&010 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - )n Re K /s. Digvi:ai Singh $al


74. Headline Summary - State cannot declare a *ri!e as S.*. $arliament may include&eclude a *ri!e as S* in $residential 'rder.

State can forard its recommendation to $arl

%udgment&'rder - S$+C)(L ($$+(L D++C*)/+ No. , of 004 %udgment&'rder Dated - 4&&010 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - State 'f .$. A 'thers /s. Shiv ;umar 3harda:

Coram - Hon!le Chandramauli ;umar $rasad2Chief %ustice and Hon!le (run *andon2%.

77. Headline Summary - Signature of the (ccused on the recovery memo - not re>uired.

%udgment&'rder - C($)*(L C(S+S No. ,07 of 00, %udgment&'rder Dated - #&&010 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - ;rishan ;umar 9 $appu /s. State 'f .$.


7=. Headline Summary - 5angsters (ct-(ttachment&Release of property under Section 1,-(ppeal under Section 1 maintaina!le

%udgment&'rder - CR)6)N(L ($$+(L No. #000 of 00# %udgment&'rder Dated - &&010 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - ;ailash Sah"ari (as Samiti /s. State 'f .$. A 'thers


7,. Headline Summary - (s the property is a pu!lic property2 every citien has the right to !id for its settlement.%udgment&'rder - S$+C)(L ($$+(L D++C*)/+ No. of 010 %udgment&'rder Dated - 1&&010 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - Chatthu /s. State 'f .$. *hrough Chief Secretary (nd 'thers




7. Headline Summary - High Court too" serious note of fa"e drugs.

%udgment&'rder - CR)6)N(L 6)SC. BR)* $+*)*)'N No. 1=1 of 00 %udgment&'rder Dated - 8&1&010 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - 3rahma:i /s. State 'f .$.A 'thers


78. Headline Summary - State 5ovt. also comes ithin the definition eecuting agencyQ nothing prevents the State 5ovt. to issue

auction notice for collection of fee.

%udgment&'rder - BR)* - C No. ,1=14 of 008 %udgment&'rder Dated - &1&010 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - /inay ;umar $andey /s. nion 'f )ndia A 'thers


=0. Headline Summary - #,= )$C&testimony of prosecurti !elieva!le against one appellant&appeal partly alloed.

%udgment&'rder - CR)6)N(L ($$+(L No. 047 of 00# %udgment&'rder Dated - 7&1&010 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - (sho" ;umar A (nother /s. State 'f .$. A (nother


=1. Headline Summary - ( mem!er of reserved cat. can claim appointment on merit against unreserved post2 !ut not

converse................

%udgment&'rder - S$+C)(L ($$+(L No. 1, of 010 %udgment&'rder Dated - 1&1&010 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - Shom Ra: Shu"la /s. $u!lic Service Commission *hrough Chairman (nd 'thers

Coram - Hon!le Chandramauli ;umar $rasad2Chief %ustice and Hon!le $an"a: 6ithal2%.

=. Headline Summary - *rue principle of no or" no pay is not of universal application !ut e>ually true payment of arrears of

salary not to !e granted as a matter of course

%udgment&'rder - S$+C)(L ($$+(L No. =# of 008 %udgment&'rder Dated - ,&1&010 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - Syed /a"il (hmad /s. State 'f .$. A 'thers



Coram - Hon!le Chandramauli ;umar $rasad2Chief %ustice and Hon!le $an"a: 6ithal2%.

=#. Headline Summary - 5eneral transfer policy not applica!le to police department. (pe Court 5uidelines in $ra"ash Singhs

case folloed in $ ith creation of $+3s.

%udgment&'rder - BR)* - ( No. 717 of 008 %udgment&'rder Dated - 8&11&008 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - Rishi $al Singh /s. State 'f .$. A 'thers


=4. Headline Summary - $arity can not !e the sole ground for !ail. 6erit also has to !e seen.

%udgment&'rder - CR)6)N(L 6)SC. 3()L ($$L)C(*)'N No. of 00 %udgment&'rder Dated - 1#&10&008 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - (marnath <adav /s. State 'f .$.


=7. Headline Summary - )nvestigation of the offence under SC&S* (ct !y unauthoried police officer is illegal and invalid. Charge

under SC&S* (ct >uashed.

%udgment&'rder - ($$L)C(*)'N &s 4 No. 14#,0 of 008 %udgment&'rder Dated - 1&10&008 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - %ahir Sharma A (nother /s. State 'f .$. A (nother


==. Headline Summary - 'n granting !ail !y one !ench2 another !ench is not under o!ligation to grant !ail to similarly placed co-

accused on the ground of parity.

%udgment&'rder - CR)6)N(L 6)SC. 3()L ($$L)C(*)'N No. 4,, of 008 %udgment&'rder Dated - 1=&8&008 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - Nahar Singh /s. State 'f .$.


=,. Headline Summary - 3ail #0 )$C-not named in the )R-eyeitness "ne applicant-named after three days-not assaulted

deceased-!ail granted.



%udgment&'rder - CR)6)N(L 6)SC. 3()L ($$L)C(*)'N No. 407 of 00 %udgment&'rder Dated - 14&8&008 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - (rvind 9 Da!aloo /s. State 'f .$.


=. Headline Summary - 3ail cancellation-!ail granted more than 1-1& years ago-!ail order not perverse or illegal-cancellation

application dismissed-condition imposed

%udgment&'rder - CR)6)N(L 6)SC. 3()L ($$L)C(*)'N No. 7,81 of 00 %udgment&'rder Dated - 14&8&008 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - $ra!hat Ran:an Shu"la /s. State 'f .$. A 'thers


=8. Headline Summary - 6oninder Singh $andher appellant ac>uitted. Death sentence of Surendra ;oli appellant confirmed.

%udgment&'rder - C($)*(L C(S+S No. 14,7 of 008 %udgment&'rder Dated - 11&8&008 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - Surendra ;oli A (nother /s. State 'f .$.

Coram - Hon!le )mtiya 6urtaa2%. and Hon!le ;ashi Nath $andey2%.,0. Headline Summary - 17= I#J Cr.$.C.-Rape allegation against father-in-la-no reason not to direct registration of )R-order>uashed-matter remanded

%udgment&'rder - ($$L)C(*)'N &s 4 No. 1=0= of 008 %udgment&'rder Dated - 10&8&008 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - Smt. Sha!nam /s. State 'f .$.


,1. Headline Summary - 3ail pending trial-accused a 6inister and an influential person-chances of tampering and fair trial a

remote possi!ility-!ail prayer re:ected

%udgment&'rder - CR)6)N(L 6)SC. 3()L ($$L)C(*)'N No. 1= of 00 %udgment&'rder Dated - 8&8&008 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - %amuna Nishad /s. State 'f .$.




,. Headline Summary - $ermission under section 177 IJ Cr.$.C. can !e granted !y the magistrate on the application of

complainant or other aggrieved person also.


*itle - Ram Narayan A 'thers /s. State 'f .$. A (nother


,#. Headline Summary - *he magistrate is not !ound to grant remand under section 1=, Cr.$.C. in those sections only for hich

prayer has !een made in remand application.

%udgment&'rder - ($$L)C(*)'N &s 4 No. 1#= of 008 %udgment&'rder Dated - #&8&008 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - /a"eel (hmad /s. State 'f .$. A (nother


,4. Headline Summary - Crl. (ppeal-conviction &S #0&#4 ).$.C.-prosecution itnesses relia!le and their evidence is

un!lemished-motive also proved-appeal dismissed

%udgment&'rder - CR)6)N(L ($$+(L No. 1=, of 00= %udgment&'rder Dated - #&8&008 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - Ram /eer A (nother /s. State 'f .$.


,7. Headline Summary - conviction under Sections #0&#4 and ##&#4 ).$.C.-common intention not esta!lished-each accused

lia!le for individual act-appeal partly alloed.

%udgment&'rder - CR)6)N(L ($$+(L No. 704 of 004 %udgment&'rder Dated - #1&&008 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - Surya ;ant (nd 'thers /s. State 'f .$.


,=. Headline Summary - +arlier !ail alloed2 unless canceled2 moving fresh !ail A its re:ection is unarranted as a!sconding

accused in custody may move u&s 44= ( Cr$C

%udgment&'rder - CR)6)N(L 6)SC. 3()L ($$L)C(*)'N No. 1=44= of 008 %udgment&'rder Dated - &&008 at (llaha!ad.



*itle - 6ahendra /s. State 'f .$.

Coram - Hon!le /irendra Singh2%.

,,. Headline Summary - 6urder-single !lo-intention to murder a!sent-partly alloed-convicted u&s #04 part 1-sentence of ,years R.). implanted

%udgment&'rder - CR)6)N(L ($$+(L No. 4#,1 of 00= %udgment&'rder Dated - 7&&008 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - Ram Ratan /s. State 'f .$.


,. Headline Summary - Criminal (ppeal-conviction u&s #0&#4 )$C-presence of appellant dou!tful-false implication pro!a!le

-appeal alloed-conviction set aside.

%udgment&'rder - CR)6)N(L ($$+(L No. #8 of 00= %udgment&'rder Dated - 7&&008 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - /eer Singh /s. State 'f .$.


,8. Headline Summary - Criminal (ppeal &S #0 ).$.C. day light murder - parents A !rother of the deceased gave convincing

evidence appeal dismissed - sentence confirmed.

%udgment&'rder - CR)6)N(L ($$+(L No. #=1, of 00= %udgment&'rder Dated - 4&&008 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - Daya Shan"ar /s. State 'f .$.


0. Headline Summary - Section 4 of the Code of Criminal $rocedure ICr.$.C.J is not controlled !y section #0 Cr.$.C.

%udgment&'rder - ($$L)C(*)'N &s 4 No. 1=00# of 008 %udgment&'rder Dated - 1&&008 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - $rem Shan"ar $andey A 'thers /s. State 'f .$. A (nother




1. Headline Summary - Role of ehortation2 !ail granted2 data on prisioners in :ail compared ith present capacity2 appeals and

rits pending given

%udgment&'rder - CR)6)N(L ($$+(L No. =71 of 008 %udgment&'rder Dated - ,&&008 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - 5ora"h $andey A 'thers /s. State 'f .$.

Coram - Hon!le (mar Saran2%. and Hon!le Dasu Ram (ad2%.

. Headline Summary - ( State action hich is unreasona!le and ar!itrary2 stri"es at the very root of (rticle 14 of the

Constitution of )ndia.

%udgment&'rder - S$+C)(L ($$+(L D++C*)/+ No. ,0 of 008 %udgment&'rder Dated - =&&008 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - State 'f .$. *hru $rincipal Secy Home Deptt (nd 'thers /s. (nand ;umar 6ishra A 'thers

Coram - Hon!le Chandramauli ;umar $rasad2Chief %ustice and Hon!le (mreshar $ratap Sahi2%.

#. Headline Summary - #0 )$C-ife murdered !y hus!and-itnesses are relia!le-no reasons for false implication-conviction

upheld

%udgment&'rder - CR)6)N(L ($$+(L No. 0 of 1888 %udgment&'rder Dated - 4&&008 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - Salim /s. State 'f .$.


4. Headline Summary - petitioners representation against transfer shall !e decided !y the authority strictly in accordance ith

la ithin stipulated period.

%udgment&'rder - BR)* - ( No. #8,,8 of 008 %udgment&'rder Dated - 4&&008 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - Naval ;ishore Sharma /s. State 'f .$. A 'thers

Coram - Hon!le 3ala ;rishna Narayana2%.

7. Headline Summary - order passed ithout affording any opportunity of hearing and assigning any reason got stayed !y the

High Court till further orders.

%udgment&'rder - BR)* - ( No. #8778 of 008 %udgment&'rder Dated - 4&&008 at (llaha!ad.



*itle - Durga $rasad Srivastava /s. State 'f .$. A 'thers

Coram - Hon!le 3ala ;rishna Narayana2%.

=. Headline Summary - #04-3-Sentence of life imprisionment-Cause of death not "non-Sentence reduced to 10 years R.). andfine of Rs. 2002000&-

%udgment&'rder - CR)6)N(L ($$+(L No. #41 of 00= %udgment&'rder Dated - 8&,&008 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - $an"a: Rai /s. State 'f .$.


,. Headline Summary - Conviction under Section #0 )$C-)R anti-timed-informant presence dou!tful-investigation tainted-

conviction set aside

%udgment&'rder - CR)6)N(L ($$+(L No. 11=8 of 00= %udgment&'rder Dated - 8&,&008 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - Sahim /s. State 'f .$.


. Headline Summary - (dult oman entitle to live independely and not to !e detained in Nari Ni"etan !ecause matter

communally sensitive or parents unilling to ta"e her

%udgment&'rder - H(3+(S C'R$S BR)* $+*)*)'N No. 4# of 008 %udgment&'rder Dated - #&,&008 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - ;umari (:ra ;han /s. State 'f .$. A 'thers

Coram - Hon!le (mar Saran2%. and Hon!le Dasu Ram (ad2%.

8. Headline Summary - )nsurance Company not lia!le to pay if proposer does not intimate a!out change in condition of health

!efore issuance of $R

%udgment&'rder - BR)* - C No. =01 of 007 %udgment&'rder Dated - 10&,&008 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - (!himanyu Chau!ey /s. )nsurance 'm!udsman .$. A 'thers

Coram - Hon!le Dilip 5upta2%. and Hon!le Shashi ;ant 5upta2%.



80. Headline Summary - $erson entitled to remuneration according to status or statutory or presdri!ed minimum.

%udgment&'rder - S$+C)(L ($$+(L No. 1= of 00 %udgment&'rder Dated - &,&008 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - State 3an" 'f )ndia A 'thers /s. Chandra Deo


81. Headline Summary - Small or commercial >uantity of Narcotic Drug is to !e determined on the !asis of actual contents of such

drug in the recovered article.

%udgment&'rder - CR)6)N(L 6)SC. 3()L ($$L)C(*)'N No. #7 of 008 %udgment&'rder Dated - #&,&008 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - $rem Shan"er (lias Nanhey $ahelan /s. State 'f .$.


8. Headline Summary - condition to deposit the amount of earlier eecuted personal !ond can not !e imposed at the time of

granting fresh !ail to the accused.

%udgment&'rder - CR)6)N(L 6)SC. 3()L ($$L)C(*)'N No. 17884 of 008 %udgment&'rder Dated - 1&,&008 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - $appu /s. State 'f .$.


8#. Headline Summary - $ossession of counterfeit currency notes ithout furnishing any eplanation !y the accused is non-

!aila!le offence punisha!le under section 48-3 )$C.

%udgment&'rder - CR)6)N(L 6)SC. 3()L ($$L)C(*)'N No. 81# of 00 %udgment&'rder Dated - 8&=&008 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - Shyam Lal /s. State 'f .$.


84. Headline Summary - Committing suicide !y a omen as a conse>uence of rape constitutes the offence of a!atement to suicide.

%udgment&'rder - CR)6)N(L 6)SC. 3()L ($$L)C(*)'N No. #1741 of 00 %udgment&'rder Dated - 8&=&008 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - (nil /s. State 'f .$.




87. Headline Summary - $ossession of counterfeit currency notes ithout furnishing any eplanation !y the accused is non-

!aila!le offence punisha!le under section 48-3 )$C.

%udgment&'rder - CR)6)N(L 6)SC. 3()L ($$L)C(*)'N No. #4817 of 00 %udgment&'rder Dated - 8&=&008 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - Ram Nias /s. State 'f .$.Coram - Hon!le /i:ay ;umar /erma2%.

8=. Headline Summary - Second !ail application on the same grounds is not maintaina!le.

%udgment&'rder - CR)6)N(L 6)SC. 3()L ($$L)C(*)'N No. 1188 of 008 %udgment&'rder Dated - 8&=&008 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - ;hursheed (nd (nother /s. State 'f .$.


8,. Headline Summary - Condition to deposit the amount of previously eecuted personal !ond can not !e imposed at the time of

granting fresh !ail.

%udgment&'rder - CR)6)N(L 6)SC. 3()L ($$L)C(*)'N No. 1#1= of 008 %udgment&'rder Dated - 7&7&008 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - Radhey /s. State 'f .$.


8. Headline Summary - $ossession of counterfeit currency notes - 3ail Re:ected - $arity can not !e the sole ground for granting

!ail.

%udgment&'rder - CR)6)N(L 6)SC. 3()L ($$L)C(*)'N No. =4 of 008 %udgment&'rder Dated - 7&7&008 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - Shahnaa 9 Shanu /s. State 'f .$.


88. Headline Summary - criminal appeal no.1=1, of 18=

%udgment&'rder - CR)6)N(L ($$+(L No. 1=1, of 18= %udgment&'rder Dated - 11&7&008 at (llaha!ad.



*itle - %ai Ram (nd 'thers /s. State 'f .$.

Coram - Hon!le $oonam Srivastava2%.

#00. Headline Summary - Revision against summoning order is legally maintaina!le and is not !arred under su! section IJ ofsection #8, Cr.$.C.

%udgment&'rder - CR)6)N(L R+/)S)'N No. 7=10 of 007 %udgment&'rder Dated - =&7&008 at (llaha!ad.*itle - %ag Narain A 'thers /s. State 'f .$. A (nother


#01. Headline Summary - Long incarceration in :ail during trial is not per-se illegal and ould not !e violative of article 1 of the

Constitution .

%udgment&'rder - CR)6)N(L 6)SC. 3()L ($$L)C(*)'N No. 787, of 00 %udgment&'rder Dated - 1&7&008 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - ma Charan (asthi /s. State 'f .$.


#0. Headline Summary - Notice to the prospective accused is not re>uired to !e issued prior to passing the order under section #18

Cr.$.C.

%udgment&'rder - ($$L)C(*)'N &s 4 No. 11,10 of 188# %udgment&'rder Dated - 4&4&008 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - 3. Shu"la /s. State


#0#. Headline Summary - se of the ord ordinary - condition not mandatory.

%udgment&'rder - BR)* - C No. 1=#0 of 008 %udgment&'rder Dated - 4&4&008 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - (r:un Singh /s. State 'f .$. (nd 'thers

Coram - Hon!le <atindra Singh2%. and Hon!le (nil ;umar2%.

#04. Headline Summary - %SCC re:ected the o!:ection of third party in eecution - first appeal not maintaina!le.



%udgment&'rder - )RS* ($$+(L No. 18 of 00 %udgment&'rder Dated - 8&4&008 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - Bahid /s. 6ohd. (nar

Coram - Hon!le <atindra Singh2%.

#07. Headline Summary - Section #IJIvJ SC&S* (ct ill not !e attracted in those cases here the offence committed under )$C is

punisha!le less than ten years imprisonment.%udgment&'rder - CR)6)N(L ($$+(L No. 1,1= of 008 %udgment&'rder Dated - #1&#&008 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - 6unni Devi /s. State 'f .$.

Coram - Hon!le Shiv Charan ISharmaJ2%. and Hon!le /i:ay ;umar /erma2%.

#0=. Headline Summary - 6entioning the names of accused and itensses is not the re>uirement of la. )n case of direct evidence2

a!sence of motive looses significance.

%udgment&'rder - CR)6)N(L ($$+(L No. 44 of 000 %udgment&'rder Dated - #1&#&008 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - 5anesh <adav A 'thers /s. State 'f .$.


#0,. Headline Summary - 6agistrates to grant interim !ailQ circumstances hen they should not.

%udgment&'rder - CR)6)N(L 6)SC. BR)* $+*)*)'N No. 48# of 008 %udgment&'rder Dated - #0&#&008 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - $radeep *yagi /s. State 'f .$. A 'thers

Coram - Hon!le (mar Saran2%. and Hon!le Ravindra Nath 6isra2%.

#0. Headline Summary - (n aggressor has no right of private defence. (ctive participation !y causing in:uries is not essential to

attract section 148 )$C.

%udgment&'rder - CR)6)N(L ($$+(L No. 07 of 18 %udgment&'rder Dated - #0&#&008 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - 6unaf (nd 'rs. /s. State 'f .$.




#08. Headline Summary - )n appropriate cases2 interim !ail may !e granted !y su!ordinate courts pending disposal of !ail

applications.

%udgment&'rder - ($$L)C(*)'N &s 4 No. 1888# of 00 %udgment&'rder Dated - ,&#&008 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - Ra:esh 6ishra 9 $appu /s. State 'f .$.

Coram - Hon!le /i:ay ;umar /erma2%.#10. Headline Summary - /arun 5andhis plea for >uashing .).R dismissed

%udgment&'rder - CR)6)N(L 6)SC. BR)* $+*)*)'N No. 4870 of 008 %udgment&'rder Dated - 7&#&008 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - /arun 5andhi /s. State 'f .$. A 'thers

Coram - Hon!le )mtiya 6urtaa2%. and Hon!le Su!hash Chandra Nigam2%.

#11. Headline Summary - Criminal Revision-Revisional Court cannot reappreciate evidence

%udgment&'rder - CR)6)N(L R+/)S)'N No. 14= of 1888 %udgment&'rder Dated - 0&#&008 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - Chotey Lal A (nother /s. State 'f .$. A 'thersCoram - Hon!le Raghunath ;ishore Rastogi2%.

#1. Headline Summary - 'n the !asis of vicarious lia!ility2 !ail can not !e re:ected. Role of individual accused has to !e

considered at the stage of !ail.

%udgment&'rder - CR)6)N(L ($$+(L No. 70,# of 00 %udgment&'rder Dated - 4&#&008 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - Surendra Singh /s. State 'f .$.


#1#. Headline Summary - )nterest is paya!le even if possession is ta"en prior to notification u&s 4 of the Land (c>uisition (ct.

%udgment&'rder - )RS* ($$+(L No. 114 of 1880 %udgment&'rder Dated - #&#&008 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - State 'f .$. /s. 3echoo Ram




#14. Headline Summary - (ppointment not made in accordance ith Removal of Difficulties 'rder void. )rrespective of

continuance for a long period.

%udgment&'rder - BR)* - ( No. 40, of 00# %udgment&'rder Dated - &#&008 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - Ram:ee Divedi /s. State 'f .$. (nd 'thers

Coram - Hon!le Dilip 5upta2%.#17. Headline Summary - +lection of Sham!hu Chaudhary from .$. Legislative (ssem!ly reserved seat declared void as he does

not !elong to Scheduled Caste.

%udgment&'rder - +L+C*)'N $+*)*)'N No. of 00, %udgment&'rder Dated - &#&008 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - $ooran 6asi Dehati /s. Sham!hu Chaudhary A 'thers


#1=. Headline Summary - 6otive and suspicion hosoever strong can not !e made the !asis of conviction ithout any legal

evidence.

%udgment&'rder - CR)6)N(L ($$+(L No. 1#= of 001 %udgment&'rder Dated - 1,&&008 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - 3hura /s. State 'f .$.


#1,. Headline Summary - +istence of an ar!itration agreement is a sine >uo non for invo"ing the :urisdiction of the court u&s 8 of

the (r!itration A Conciliation (ct 188=

%udgment&'rder - )RS* ($$+(L R'6 'RD+R No. ,7# of 00 %udgment&'rder Dated - 1=&&008 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - Ra: ;umar /s. nion 'f )ndia A 'thers

Coram - Hon!le Sheo ;umar Singh2%. and Hon!le $an"a: 6ithal2%.#1. Headline Summary - ine for the offence punisha!le under section #04-3 ).$.C. can not !e imposed.

%udgment&'rder - CR)6)N(L ($$+(L No. 4,=# of 00 %udgment&'rder Dated - 1#&&008 at (llaha!ad.



*itle - Dinesh /s. State 'f .$.


#18. Headline Summary - Sentence of fine less than Rupees fifteen thousand can not !e imposed for the offence under section # ofDory $rohi!ition (ct.

%udgment&'rder - CR)6)N(L ($$+(L No. =0 of 00 %udgment&'rder Dated - 4&&008 at (llaha!ad.*itle - 'mati A 'thers /s. State 'f .$.


#0. Headline Summary - 'rder of investigation passed under section 17=I#J Cr$C can not !e challenged in Revision or proceeding

under section 4 Cr$c !y propsective accused.

%udgment&'rder - CR)6)N(L R+/)S)'N No. =# of 00 %udgment&'rder Dated - #0&1&008 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - Ram Dhani /s. State 'f .$. A 'thers


#1. Headline Summary - )n case of direct evidence2 a!sence or ea"ness of motive looses significance

%udgment&'rder - CR)6)N(L ($$+(L No. 7= of 18 %udgment&'rder Dated - #0&1&008 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - ;allu /s. State 'f .$.

Coram - Hon!le Shiv Shan"er2%. and Hon!le /i:ay ;umar /erma2%.

#. Headline Summary - separate conviction and sentence under section #IJI7J SC&S* (ct simplicitor is illegal.

%udgment&'rder - CR)6)N(L ($$+(L No. =#07 of 00 %udgment&'rder Dated - 17&1&008 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - Sri Narain *rivedi A 'thers /s. State 'f .$.


##. Headline Summary - Sentence for the conspiracy of offence ould !e same as provided for the offence

%udgment&'rder - CR)6)N(L ($$+(L No. = of 00 %udgment&'rder Dated - 1&1&008 at (llaha!ad.



*itle - Neera: /s. State 'f .$.


#4. Headline Summary - $rospective accused can not challenge the order directing investigation of the case after registration of the)R.

%udgment&'rder - ($$L)C(*)'N &s 4 No. ##1## of 00 %udgment&'rder Dated - &11&00 at (llaha!ad.*itle - (!dul (i (nd 'thers /s. State 'f .$.(nd (nother


#7. Headline Summary - (!sence or ea"ness of motive is not fatal2 if the prosecution evidence is orthy of reliance

%udgment&'rder - CR)6)N(L ($$+(L No. 171, of 1888 %udgment&'rder Dated - &11&00 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - Ram Chandra 5upta /s. State 'f .$.

Coram - Hon!le 3ar"at (li Faidi2%. and Hon!le /i:ay ;umar /erma2%.

#=. Headline Summary - 6agistrate having no :urisdiction to ta"e cogniance of the offence can not pass the order forinvestigation under section 17=I#J Cr.$.C.

%udgment&'rder - CR)6)N(L R+/)S)'N No. 70, of 007 %udgment&'rder Dated - 1&11&00 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - Ra::an $rasad /s. State 'f .$. (nd 'thers


#,. Headline Summary - *he 6agistrate can pass order for further investigation on the final report.


*itle - 5opi Singh /s. State 'f .$. A (nother


#. Headline Summary - Carrying the co2 !ull or !ulloc" ithin the State for slaughtering is no offence under Co Slaughter

(ct.



%udgment&'rder - CR)6)N(L R+/)S)'N No. 1#1 of 007 %udgment&'rder Dated - 1,&11&00 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - ;ailash <adav (nd 'thers /s. State 'f .$. (nd (nother


#8. Headline Summary - C.3.) en>uiry ordered in +taah firing incident at ccs $5 college Haivara Safai.SS$ (S$ ordered to !e

transferred forthith%udgment&'rder - CR)6)N(L 6)SC. BR)* $+*)*)'N No. =78 of 00 %udgment&'rder Dated - 11&11&00 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - Ram 5opal /s. State 'f .$. (nd 'thers

Coram - Hon!le )mtiya 6urtaa2%. and Hon!le Ra: 6ani Chauhan2%.

##0. Headline Summary - $rinciples for determining enhancement of monthly rent under Section 1IJ of Rent (ct discussed.

%udgment&'rder - BR)* - ( No. =,,8 of 1887 %udgment&'rder Dated - ,&11&00 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - Smt. $adma *andon /s. /iith (.D.%.2 (lld. A 'thers

Coram - Hon!le Dilip 5upta2%.##1. Headline Summary - *ransporting and carrying the co or !ulloc"s for slaughtering ithin the State is no offence.

%udgment&'rder - CR)6)N(L R+/)S)'N No. 141 of 007 %udgment&'rder Dated - ,&11&00 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - (sfa> (hmad (nd (nother /s. State 'f .$. (nd (nother


##. Headline Summary - Second or su!se>uent !ail application can !e considered on ne ground or change of la.

%udgment&'rder - CR)6)N(L ($$+(L No. 118 of 00, %udgment&'rder Dated - 1&10&00 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - Dharmpal A 'thers /s. State 'f .$.Coram - Hon!le 3ar"at (li Faidi2%. and Hon!le /i:ay ;umar /erma2%.

###. Headline Summary - $eriod of detention in :ail can not !e the sole ground for !ail.

%udgment&'rder - CR)6)N(L ($$+(L No. =777 of 00= %udgment&'rder Dated - 1&10&00 at (llaha!ad.



*itle - (nees /s. State 'f .$.


##4. Headline Summary - Special %udge under $revention of Corruption (ct can pass order for registration of )R on theapplication under section 17=I#J Cr.$.C.

%udgment&'rder - CR)6)N(L R+/)S)'N No. 1, of 00 %udgment&'rder Dated - 1,&10&00 at (llaha!ad.*itle - 6ahipal /s. State 'f .$. A 'thers


##7. Headline Summary - ( divorced 6uslim oman can not claim maintenance from her former hus!and under Section 17

Cr.$.C.

%udgment&'rder - CR)6)N(L R+/)S)'N No. 1=, of 00 %udgment&'rder Dated - 1,&10&00 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - Shahid %amal (nsari /s. State 'f .$.A (nother


##=. Headline Summary - 6ore that one )R can !e registered against the same incident.

%udgment&'rder - CR)6)N(L R+/)S)'N No. #4= of 00 %udgment&'rder Dated - =&8&00 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - $arve $ara /s. State 'f .$.


##,. Headline Summary - Cricle rate cannot form !asis for mar"et rate under L. (. (ct. Statutory !enefits to !e given even if

claimant has not filed (ppeal&Cross-'!:ection.

%udgment&'rder - )RS* ($$+(L No. 117= of 1880 %udgment&'rder Dated - =&8&00 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - Ram (dhar /s. State 'f .$.


##. Headline Summary - )f found relia!le2 conviction can !e !ased on dying declaration alone ithout consideration.




*itle - (r:un /s. State 'f .$.


##8. Headline Summary - Second !ail can !e considered on fresh ground only.

%udgment&'rder - CR)6)N(L ($$+(L No. =,84 of 00, %udgment&'rder Dated - 1,&8&00 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - %aivir A 'thers /s. State 'f .$.


#40. Headline Summary - ac>uittal of coaccused in separate trial cannot !e made !asis for >uashing trial of other accused persons

in case for offences under same transaction.

%udgment&'rder - CR)6)N(L 6)SC. BR)* $+*)*)'N No. 1=470 of 00 %udgment&'rder Dated - 1=&8&00 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - ;m. Rin"i /s. State 'f .$. A 'thers

Coram - Hon!le )mtiya 6urtaa2%. and Hon!le Ra: 6ani Chauhan2%.#41. Headline Summary - 'rder dismissing Crl. Revision for default or non-prosecution as ell the order deciding the revision onmerit in a!sence of any party can !e recalled

%udgment&'rder - CR)6)N(L R+/)S)'N No. 4=8# of 00= %udgment&'rder Dated - 1&8&00 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - 6ithaee Lal /s. State 'f .$. A 'thers


#4. Headline Summary - Report 1,# IJ !y )' mere opinion and 6agistrate no !ound !y opinion. He has to apply mind to facts

Hearing must to informant if R to !e accepted.

%udgment&'rder - CR)6)N(L 6)SC. BR)* $+*)*)'N No. 1=0, of 00 %udgment&'rder Dated - 10&8&00 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - $ra"ash /s. State 'f .$. A 'thers

Coram - Hon!le )mtiya 6urtaa2%. and Hon!le Ra: 6ani Chauhan2%.



#4#. Headline Summary - +. $. against re:ection of nomination of a candidate dismissed !ecause defect of rong electoral roll

num!er is not of su!stantial character


*itle - Saleem 6asood /s. Rasheed 6asood

Coram - Hon!le Dilip 5upta2%.#44. Headline Summary - 6agistrate is not !ound to treat the protest petition as complaint in each and every case.


*itle - Naa! Saiyyed Fafar Hussain /s. State 'f .$.


#47. Headline Summary - $articipation of all the accused in criminal act !y doing some overt act is not necessary to attract Section

#4 of )ndian $enal Code.

%udgment&'rder - CR)6)N(L ($$+(L No. 77 of 18 %udgment&'rder Dated - 8&&00 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - Ram Naresh /s. State 'f .$

Coram - Hon!le Sushil Har"auli2%. and Hon!le /i:ay ;umar /erma2%.

#4=. Headline Summary - police is competent to investigate su!sidiary non cognia!le offences ith cognia!le offences

%udgment&'rder - CR)6)N(L 6)SC. BR)* $+*)*)'N No. 1774 of 00 %udgment&'rder Dated - =&&00 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - (ad 9 (ad ;han /s. State 'f .$. A 'thers

Coram - Hon!le )mtiya 6urtaa2%. and Hon!le S.N.H. Faidi2%.

#4,. Headline Summary - Notice under section 111 Cr.$.C. ithout full su!stance of police report is invalid.

%udgment&'rder - ($$L)C(*)'N &s 4 No. =, of 007 %udgment&'rder Dated - &&00 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - 3aleshar (nd 'thers /s. State 'f .$.




#4. Headline Summary - Shoponers cross )R refused. Civil Courts 3ar resolved to !oycott accused. H.C. directs registration of

)R

%udgment&'rder - CR)6)N(L 6)SC. BR)* $+*)*)'N No. 1#4 of 00 %udgment&'rder Dated - 1&&00 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - (mit Chaurasiya /s. State 'f .$. A 'thers

Coram - Hon!le (mar Saran2%. and Hon!le Ravindra Nath 6isra2%.#48. Headline Summary - +lector has sufficient interest to oppose B$ challenging dis>ualification of 6$.

%udgment&'rder - BR)* - C No. 8,70 of 00 %udgment&'rder Dated - #1&,&00 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - 6ohammad Shahid ("hla> /s. nion 'f )ndia A 'thers

Coram - Hon!le <atindra Singh2%. and Hon!le Shashi ;ant 5upta2%.

#70. Headline Summary - *estimony of itnesses can not !e !rushed asied on the ground of relation ith the deceased& victim.

%udgment&'rder - CR)6)N(L ($$+(L No. 48= of 184 %udgment&'rder Dated - &,&00 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - 3hagan Das A (nother /s. State 'f .$.Coram - Hon!le Sushil Har"auli2%. and Hon!le /i:ay ;umar /erma2%.

#71. Headline Summary - 'rder of registration of )R and its investigation !y the police is not essential on each and every

application uunder section 17=I#J Cr.$.C.

%udgment&'rder - CR)6)N(L R+/)S)'N No. 1=8 of 00, %udgment&'rder Dated - 1&,&00 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - /ishanath 9 3ande /s. State 'f .$. (nd 'thers


#7. Headline Summary - 5oonda (ct-no interference at the stage of issue of sho cause notice-see ;a!ir Chala v. State of .$.

1884 SCC ICrl.J 7,,

%udgment&'rder - CR)6)N(L 6)SC. BR)* $+*)*)'N No. 1, of 00 %udgment&'rder Dated - 1=&,&00 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - (:meruddin A 'thers /s. State 'f .$. A 'thers



Coram - Hon!le )mtiya 6urtaa2%. and Hon!le /i"ram Nath2%.

#7#. Headline Summary - *here is no parity in re:ection of !ail.

%udgment&'rder - CR)6)N(L 6)SC. 3()L ($$L)C(*)'N No. 1#40 of 00 %udgment&'rder Dated - 4&,&00 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - Naal /s. State 'f .$.


#74. Headline Summary - +ven after ac>uittal of co-accused2 trial of other similarly placed accused ill not !e !arred.

%udgment&'rder - CR)6)N(L 6)SC. 3()L ($$L)C(*)'N No. 171=0 of 00 %udgment&'rder Dated - 4&,&00 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - 6ano: /s. State 'f .$.


#77. Headline Summary - )f matrimonial dispute has !een settled !y the parties2 High Court can >uash the proceedings of criminal

cases.

%udgment&'rder - ($$L)C(*)'N &s 4 No. 10888 of 00, %udgment&'rder Dated - 4&,&00 at (llaha!ad.*itle - Smt. Soniya A 'thers /s. State 'f .$. A (nother


#7=. Headline Summary - 3ail to the :uvenile cannot !e refused on the ground of gravity of the offence

%udgment&'rder - CR)6)N(L R+/)S)'N No. #8= of 00, %udgment&'rder Dated - 4&,&00 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - $rem Chandra 9 6onu /s. State 'f .$. A (nother


#7,. Headline Summary - Crl. *rial $rosecution produced document favouring accused prayer for further cross of $Bs re:ected.%udgment&'rder - ($$L)C(*)'N &s 4 No. 14#0# of 00 %udgment&'rder Dated - =&=&00 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - Ram"esh Sharma /s. State 'f .$. A (nother

Coram - Hon!le Raghunath ;ishore Rastogi2%.



#7. Headline Summary - Criminal *rial2 # Charge Sheets on # )Rs of # informants in respect of one incident in continuation-all

cases consolidated.

%udgment&'rder - ($$L)C(*)'N &s 4 No. 148 of 00 %udgment&'rder Dated - 7&=&00 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - $ra!hat ;umar A 'thers /s. State 'f .$. A (nother

Coram - Hon!le Raghunath ;ishore Rastogi2%.#78. Headline Summary - Criminal *rialK $.B. cross- eamined2 further cross eamination not permissi!le2 specified >uestions may

!e as"ed ith post permission.

%udgment&'rder - ($$L)C(*)'N &s 4 No. 141 of 00 %udgment&'rder Dated - 4&=&00 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - %afar /s. State 'f .$. A (nother


#=0. Headline Summary - interlocutory non (R

%udgment&'rder - 6)SC. S)N5L+ No. ,01 of 00 %udgment&'rder Dated - &=&00 at Luc"no.

*itle - Nagar Nigam Sle: arm 5omtinagar L"o.*hrough )ts 6unicipal /s. D.6.L"o.(nd # 'rs.

Coram - Hon!le (!hinava padhya2%.

#=1. Headline Summary - Section 40= )$C2 +ntrustment of $roperty necessary2 in its a!sence hus!ands sister A mother discharged.


*itle - Smt. $ra"ash ;aur (nd 'thers /s. State 'f .$. (nd (nother


#=. Headline Summary - Seniority depends upon the statutory rules.

%udgment&'rder - BR)* - ( No. #,0, of 001 %udgment&'rder Dated - 1&7&00 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - /irendra ;umar Singh /s. State 'f .$. A 'thers

Coram - Hon!le <atindra Singh2%. and Hon!le Shashi ;ant 5upta2%.



#=#. Headline Summary - $etitioners have !een transferred from C.$. to (.$ in !reach of Reg. 77. Said order >uashed as per

:udgment of Hon!le (pe Court in %asveer Singh

%udgment&'rder - S+R/)C+ S)N5L+ No. 448 of 00, %udgment&'rder Dated - &7&00 at Luc"no.

*itle - C.$. No. 107 Santosh Singh A 1# 'rs. /s. State 'f .$. *hru $rin. Secy. Home A 4 'rs.

Coram - Hon!le /.;. Shu"la2%.#=4. Headline Summary - ine cannot !e imposed for the offence punisha!le under Section #04-3 ).$.C.

%udgment&'rder - CR)6)N(L ($$+(L No. 1877 of 00 %udgment&'rder Dated - 7&7&00 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - 6ohd. Shafi /s. State 'f .$.

Coram - Hon!le S.S. ;ulshrestha2%. and Hon!le /i:ay ;umar /erma2%.

#=7. Headline Summary - Criminal revision against the order of registration of .).R. and investigation is not maintaina!le.

%udgment&'rder - CR)6)N(L R+/)S)'N No. 01 of 00, %udgment&'rder Dated - 7&4&00 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - 5ulam 6ustafa 9 %a!!ar /s. State 'f .$. A 'thersCoram - Hon!le /i:ay ;umar /erma2%.

#==. Headline Summary - Section 1=4 Cr. $.C. 6agistrates eamination not necessary to prove statements of itness recorded !y

him

%udgment&'rder - ($$L)C(*)'N &s 4 No. =710 of 00, %udgment&'rder Dated - 18&4&00 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - %eera: 9 /i:ai A (nother /s. State 'f .$. A (nother


#=,. Headline Summary - Circumstantial evidence not orthy of credence-(ppeals alloed-Death sentence set aside-(ccused

appellants ac>uitted.

%udgment&'rder - CR)6)N(L ($$+(L No. ,# of 00, %udgment&'rder Dated - 18&4&00 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - (dil (nd (nother /s. State 'f .$.



Coram - Hon!le (mar Saran2%. and Hon!le /i:ay ;umar /erma2%.

#=. Headline Summary - )R for the offence punisha!le under section 1 )$C cannot !e directed to !e lodged against the

informant at the time of passing the :udgement.

%udgment&'rder - ($$L)C(*)'N &s 4 No. ==8 of 00 %udgment&'rder Dated - 8&4&00 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - Le"hra: /s. State 'f .$.Coram - Hon!le /i:ay ;umar /erma2%.

#=8. Headline Summary - $erson in custody2 no !ail application pending - hen preventive detention possi!le.

%udgment&'rder - H(3+(S C'R$S BR)* $+*)*)'N No. 7,=8 of 00, %udgment&'rder Dated - &4&00 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - Sandeep /s. State 'f .$. A 'thers

Coram - Hon!le <atindra Singh2%. and Hon!le Ran /i:ai Singh2%.

#,0. Headline Summary - Clu!s do not re>uire license from the Cantonment 3oard to serve li>uor.

%udgment&'rder - BR)* *(E No. =7 of 00, %udgment&'rder Dated - ,&#&00 at (llaha!ad.*itle - $ra!hu Narayan nion Clu!2 /aranasi A (nother /s. State 'f .$. A 'thers


#,1. Headline Summary - No fetter on 6agistrate ta"ing cogniance against non-chargesheeted accused prior S. #18 Cr$C-Dharam

$als Case ISCJ preferred to Ran:its Case ISCJ

%udgment&'rder - ($$L)C(*)'N &s 4 No. #,7 of 00 %udgment&'rder Dated - =&#&00 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - (rshad A 'thers /s. State 'f .$. A (nother


#,. Headline Summary - Sec. 40= )$C- No offence made out ithout entrustment of property

%udgment&'rder - ($$L)C(*)'N &s 4 No. 7#7 of 00, %udgment&'rder Dated - 18&#&00 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - Nagendra ;umar (nd 'thers /s. State 'f .$. (nd (nother




#,#. Headline Summary - 'rder passed under Section 17=I#J Cr.$.C. for registration of .).R. and investigation can not !e

challenged in Revision !y prospective accused.

%udgment&'rder - CR)6)N(L R+/)S)'N No. 741 of 00= %udgment&'rder Dated - ,&#&00 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - Surya"ant Du!ey A 'thers /s. State 'f .$. A (nother Coram - Hon!le /i:ay ;umar /erma2%.

#,4. Headline Summary - .K$. Control of 5oondas (ct- Notice u&s # can !e challenged in rit only hen it is illegal.

%udgment&'rder - CR)6)N(L 6)SC. BR)* $+*)*)'N No. 418 of 00, %udgment&'rder Dated - 7&&00 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - 3achchara: /s. State 'f .$. A 'thers

Coram - Hon!le Syed Rafat (lam2%. and Hon!le Raghunath ;ishore Rastogi2%.

#,7. Headline Summary - Crl.trial-itness cross eamined-further cross to !e limited to specified >uestions only.

%udgment&'rder - CR)6)N(L R+/)S)'N D++C*)/+ No. #8# of 00, %udgment&'rder Dated - 1&&00 at (llaha!ad.*itle - aisal A 'thers /s. State 'f .$. A (nother


#,=. Headline Summary - Crl.trial-itness cross eamined2further cross can !e permitted on specified >uestions only.

%udgment&'rder - ($$L)C(*)'N &s 4 No. 414 of 00, %udgment&'rder Dated - 1&&00 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - ;halid (hmad ;han /s. State 'f .$. A (nother


#,,. Headline Summary - S.4 Cr.$.C.-application after su!mission of C.S. not maintaina!le for >uashing of .).R.%udgment&'rder - ($$L)C(*)'N &s 4 No. 04 of 00, %udgment&'rder Dated - 1&&00 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - Harpal Singh /s. State 'f .$. A (nother




#,. Headline Summary - Section 17I1JIcJ Cr.$.C. - refusing maintenance to unmarried ma:or daughter - Notices issued to 5ovts.

hy this clause should remain on the statute.

%udgment&'rder - ($$L)C(*)'N &s 4 No. 1,=0 of 00 %udgment&'rder Dated - #1&1&00 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - Smt. Ra: ;umari (asthi A (nother /s. State 'f .$. A (nother

Coram - Hon!le (mar Saran2%.#,8. Headline Summary - nder %uvenile %ustice (ct order refusing !ail to :uvenile !y 3oard and S.%. is not proper.

%udgment&'rder - CR)6)N(L R+/)S)'N D++C*)/+ No. of 00, %udgment&'rder Dated - #1&1&00 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - Lavi <adav 9 Love <adav /s. State 'f .$. A (nother


#0. Headline Summary - Candidate appearing in selection is estopped from challenging it.

%udgment&'rder - BR)* - ( No. #4041 of 001 %udgment&'rder Dated - 7&1&00 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - Dr. Dinesh ;umar ;esarani /s. nion 'f )ndia A 'thersCoram - Hon!le <atindra Singh2%. and Hon!le Ran /i:ai Singh2%.

#1. Headline Summary - Same accused involved in to different incidents of same date-:oint ttrial refused.

%udgment&'rder - ($$L)C(*)'N &s 4 No. 07 of 00 %udgment&'rder Dated - #&1&00 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - ;hali> (hmad A 'thers /s. State 'f .$. A 'thers


#. Headline Summary - Cognia!le offence-recovery also invalid-6ag.s order re:ecting application set aside.

%udgment&'rder - ($$L)C(*)'N &s 4 No. ,,4 of 00 %udgment&'rder Dated - &1&00 at (llaha!ad.*itle - $ra!hash Chatuvedi /s. State 'f .$.


##. Headline Summary - No disciplinary proceeding after superannuation unless there is provision.



%udgment&'rder - BR)* - ( No. 1#8= of 188= %udgment&'rder Dated - 1&1&00 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - Ra:ya ;rishi tpadan 6andi $arishad .$. (nd (nother /s. $u!lic Service *ri!unal2.$. Luc"no (nd 'thers


#4. Headline Summary - Suspension of Conviction only in very eceptional circumstances2 hich need to !e indicated. Nav:ot

Singh Sidhu2s case distinguished%udgment&'rder - CR)6)N(L ($$+(L No. 1#=7 of 00= %udgment&'rder Dated - 8&11&00, at (llaha!ad.

*itle - Daya Shan"ar Rai A (nother /s. State 'f .$.


#7. Headline Summary - )n the a!sence of any evidence2 conviction cannot !e !ased merely on the admissions&confession of

accused made in the eamination u&s #1# Cr.$.C.

%udgment&'rder - CR)6)N(L ($$+(L No. 140 of 187 %udgment&'rder Dated - #&11&00, at (llaha!ad.

*itle - 3almant /s. State 'f .$.

Coram - Hon!le (mar Saran2%. and Hon!le /i:ay ;umar /erma2%.

#=. Headline Summary - S.#0 )$C prosecution case that dead!ody as carried to another place !y accused-due to a!sence of

!lood on spot accused ac>uitted.

%udgment&'rder - CR)6)N(L ($$+(L No. 80 of 18 %udgment&'rder Dated - 1&11&00, at (llaha!ad.

*itle - 3ri:veer (nd 'rs. /s. State 'f .$.

Coram - Hon!le ;aal:eet Singh Ra"hra2%. and Hon!le Raghunath ;ishore Rastogi2%.

#,. Headline Summary - S.#0 )$C-cased !ased on circumstantial evidence failed to prove guilt !eyond dou!t-accused ac>uitted.

%udgment&'rder - CR)6)N(L ($$+(L No. #7 of 18 %udgment&'rder Dated - 18&11&00, at (llaha!ad.

*itle - Dayashan"ar /s. State 'f .$




#. Headline Summary - nregistered (greement to sell can not !e specifically enforced

%udgment&'rder - )RS* ($$+(L No. 40 of 188 %udgment&'rder Dated - 1=&11&00, at (llaha!ad.

*itle - /i:ay ;umar Sharma /s. Devesh 3ehari Saena

Coram - Hon!le <atindra Singh2%. and Hon!le /i:ay ;umar /erma2%.

#8. Headline Summary - S.#= Cr.$.C.-6ag. could not revie earlier order passed !y his predecessor.

%udgment&'rder - ($$L)C(*)'N &s 4 No. ,48 of 007 %udgment&'rder Dated - 1=&11&00, at (llaha!ad.

*itle - Ramesh /s. State 'f .$.


#80. Headline Summary - Crl trial - $unishment in departmental proceedings no !ar to Crl. prosecution

%udgment&'rder - ($$L)C(*)'N &s 4 No. 01 of 00, %udgment&'rder Dated - 1=&11&00, at (llaha!ad.

*itle - Ra:esh ;umar Srivastava /s. State 'f .$. A (nother


#81. Headline Summary - S. 4 Cr.$.C.- No allegation in complaint that accused had "noledge or reason to !elieve property asstolen- proceedings >uashed

%udgment&'rder - ($$L)C(*)'N &s 4 No. 8,81 of 004 %udgment&'rder Dated - 1=&11&00, at (llaha!ad.

*itle - 3a!loo (nd 'thers /s. State 'f .$. (nd (nother


#8. Headline Summary - S.#0 )$C circumstantial evidence of last seen-etra :udl.confession-accused ac>uitted.


*itle - Naal Singh /s. State 'f .$.


#8#. Headline Summary - S.#8= )$C-accused not named in )R2 identification evidence not good-conviction set aside.



%udgment&'rder - CR)6)N(L ($$+(L No. 1100 of 18# %udgment&'rder Dated - 1#&11&00, at (llaha!ad.

*itle - Ra:!ir /s. State 'f .$.


#84. Headline Summary - S.#,= )$C-accused ravished girl a&a years-R) 10 years :ustified.

%udgment&'rder - CR)6)N(L ($$+(L No. 1470 of 00= %udgment&'rder Dated - 1#&11&00, at (llaha!ad.

*itle - (rvind /s. State 'f .$.


#87. Headline Summary - t

%udgment&'rder - S$+C)(L ($$+(L No. #4= of 004 %udgment&'rder Dated - =&10&00, at Luc"no.

*itle - Shashi Sharma /s. State 'f .$.*hrough Secy 3asic +ducaiton

Coram - Hon!le $radeep ;ant2%. and Hon!le Shri Narayan Shu"la2%.

#8=. Headline Summary - Section #=# )$C- 5irl ma:or as per High School Certificate -no need to medical eamtion to ascertain herage

%udgment&'rder - ($$L)C(*)'N &s 4 No. 7#=, of 004 %udgment&'rder Dated - 4&10&00, at (llaha!ad.

*itle - ;haderu Ram <adav /s. State 'f .$.


#8,. Headline Summary - $arties compromise in case u&s 4182 4024=,2 4= and 70= ).$.C.-application u&s 4 Cr.$.C. alloed.

%udgment&'rder - ($$L)C(*)'N &s 4 No. 1#07# of 00= %udgment&'rder Dated - 4&10&00, at (llaha!ad.

*itle - %iut 3andhan /s. State 'f .$. (nd 'thers

Coram - Hon!le <atindra Singh2%. and Hon!le Raghunath ;ishore Rastogi2%.

#8. Headline Summary - No difference !eteen 3.+d. Iface to faceJ and 3.+d. IDistant 6odeJ

%udgment&'rder - S$+C)(L ($$+(L No. 1,1 of 00, %udgment&'rder Dated - #&10&00, at (llaha!ad.



*itle - 5yanendra ;umar Sharma A 'thers /s. State 'f .$. A 'thers

Coram - Hon!le Hemant Laman 5o"hale2%. and Hon!le (n:ani ;umar2%.

#88. Headline Summary - )n theft case oner is entitled to custody of ornaments during the pendency of the case

%udgment&'rder - ($$L)C(*)'N &s 4 No. 14##1 of 00= %udgment&'rder Dated - &8&00, at (llaha!ad.

*itle - /i:ay ;umar /s. State 'f .$.


400. Headline Summary - S.1# N.).(.- Notice given and complaint filed after epiry of limitation period- complaint >uashed.

%udgment&'rder - ($$L)C(*)'N &s 4 No. ##4# of 00= %udgment&'rder Dated - &8&00, at (llaha!ad.

*itle - Smt. Sunita (graal /s. State 'f .$. A (nother


401. Headline Summary - $roperty of Churches of )ndia vest for purposes of Church of +ngland and is su!:ect to the Rules

%udgment&'rder - )RS* ($$+(L No. 77= of 187 %udgment&'rder Dated - =&8&00, at (llaha!ad.

*itle - State 'f .$. A 'thers /s. )ndian Christian *rusties


40. Headline Summary - Cr.$.C.- 'rder for deposit of passport and /isa to ensure attendance of accused is not coercive process

%udgment&'rder - ($$L)C(*)'N &s 4 No. 411 of 004 %udgment&'rder Dated - 7&8&00, at (llaha!ad.

*itle - %arrar Hussain (nd 'thers /s. State 'f .$. (nd (nother


40#. Headline Summary - $lea of :uvenileship not to !e re:ected due to delay%udgment&'rder - ($$L)C(*)'N &s 4 No. 11807 of 00= %udgment&'rder Dated - 7&8&00, at (llaha!ad.

*itle - ;uldeep ;umar (nd 'thers /s. State 'f .$.




404. Headline Summary - 'rder summoning a person as accused u&s #18 Cr.$.C. to !e passed after cross eaminaiton

%udgment&'rder - ($$L)C(*)'N &s 4 No. 118# of 00, %udgment&'rder Dated - 4&8&00, at (llaha!ad.

*itle - Havendra Singh 9 Harvendra ;umar /s. State 'f .$. A (nother


407. Headline Summary - S.0, Cr.$.C.-prosecution not !ound to give copies of evidence not relied upon !y it.

%udgment&'rder - ($$L)C(*)'N &s 4 No. #=88 of 00, %udgment&'rder Dated - 4&8&00, at (llaha!ad.

*itle - Ramadhin A 'thers /s. State 'f .$. A (nother


40=. Headline Summary - $rotection of 18,Cr.$.C. not availa!le to government servant in case of !eating in personal capacity.

%udgment&'rder - ($$L)C(*)'N &s 4 No. 14 of 00, %udgment&'rder Dated - 1&8&00, at (llaha!ad.

*itle - 6unesh $rasad /s. State 'f .$. A (nother


40,. Headline Summary - Summoning of acused u&s #18 Cr.$.C. - guideline eplained

%udgment&'rder - ($$L)C(*)'N &s 4 No. # of 00, %udgment&'rder Dated - 18&8&00, at (llaha!ad.

*itle - (mar Singh A 'thers /s. State 'f .$. A (nother


40. Headline Summary - Su!se>uent unverfied compromise chaing terms unenforcea!le.

%udgment&'rder - ($$L)C(*)'N &s 4 No. 8#,0 of 004 %udgment&'rder Dated - 18&8&00, at (llaha!ad.*itle - Sarvesh ;umar Shu"la /s. State 'f .$. (nd 'thers




408. Headline Summary - N)(-'fficers of Comp>ny or firm lia!le to ma"e payment to!e impleaded as accused and not others.

%udgment&'rder - ($$L)C(*)'N &s 4 No. 7=44 of 007 %udgment&'rder Dated - 18&8&00, at (llaha!ad.

*itle - 6ohd. Daud (nd (nother /s. State 'f .$. (nd (nother


410. Headline Summary - $roceedings u&s 10,&11= Cr.$.C. must !e concluded ithin si months from the date of institution

%udgment&'rder - ($$L)C(*)'N &s 4 No. 077 of 00, %udgment&'rder Dated - 1,&8&00, at (llaha!ad.

*itle - (tul Nigam /s. State 'f .$. A 'thers


411. Headline Summary - 5ratuity in ttar $radesh cannot !e forfeited under Regulation #71-( of the Civil Service Regulations.

%udgment&'rder - BR)* - ( No. 74 of 00# %udgment&'rder Dated - 10&8&00, at (llaha!ad.

*itle - 3hagati $rasad /erma /s. State 'f .$. *hru *he Secy. 3asic +du. .$. Shasan A 'rs.

Coram - Hon!le /i:ay 6anohar Sahai2%. and Hon!le Shishir ;umar2%.

41. Headline Summary - Rule 4I1J irst $roviso of Rules2 1888 mandatory. +mployee can !e suspended only on seriousallegations.

%udgment&'rder - BR)* - ( No. #78# of 00, %udgment&'rder Dated - =&8&00, at (llaha!ad.

*itle - Dr. (rvind ;umar Ram /s. State 'f .$. *hru )ts Secretary (nd 'thers

Coram - Hon!le /i:ay 6anohar Sahai2%. and Hon!le 3harati Sapru2%.

41#. Headline Summary - +nhancing rent is fundamental right of the landlord

%udgment&'rder - BR)* - ( No. =8#71 of 00= %udgment&'rder Dated - &&00, at (llaha!ad.

*itle - (!dul %alil /s. Special %udge +.C.(ct&(ddl. Distt. I+.$.%.S.C.C.J A 'thers

Coram - Hon!le Ra"esh *iari2%.



414. Headline Summary - Rs.2=824##&- !eing diminution price of machinery2 assessee failed to declare it truly to (.'.

Reassessment roceedings u&s 14,IaJ rightly initiated.

%udgment&'rder - )NC'6+ *(E R++R+NC+ No. #=1 of 18 %udgment&'rder Dated - &&00, at (llaha!ad.

*itle - *he )ncome *a Commisioner /s. 6&S %.;. %ute 6ills Co. Ltd.

Coram - Hon!le Hemant Laman 5o"hale2%. and Hon!le R.;. (graal2%.417. Headline Summary - if one claims that he is not lia!le to pay ta on transfer of goods from one State to another or return

thereof2 he has to furnish declaration orm

%udgment&'rder - BR)* *(E No. #0 of 00, %udgment&'rder Dated - 1,&&00, at (llaha!ad.

*itle - 6&( (m!ica Steels Limited /s. State 'f .$. A 'thers

Coram - Hon!le R.;. (graal2%. and Hon!le /i"ram Nath2%.

41=. Headline Summary - miing of spices manufactures a ne and different commodity2 (sho" 5rah dyog ;endra I$J Ltd.2

004 N*N I7J ,0 I(llaha!adJ is not a good la

%udgment&'rder - BR)* *(E No. 11== of 00# %udgment&'rder Dated - 1,&&00, at (llaha!ad.

*itle - 6&S (sho"a ood A De-Hydred Sansthan /s. State 'f .$. A 'thers


41,. Headline Summary - NS(-+valuation of anser !oo"s !y unauthorised eaminers not a point concerning pu!lic order-

detention illegal.

%udgment&'rder - H(3+(S C'R$S BR)* $+*)*)'N No. 818 of 00, %udgment&'rder Dated - #&&00, at (llaha!ad.

*itle - Ram $ratap Singh /s. nion 'f )ndia A 'thers

Coram - Hon!le <atindra Singh2%. and Hon!le Raghunath ;ishore Rastogi2%.41. Headline Summary - High Court hile giving its opinion in a reference does not sit in appeal over the findings recorded !y the

*ri!unal2 hich are not perverse.

%udgment&'rder - )NC'6+ *(E R++R+NC+ No. 17, of 188 %udgment&'rder Dated - 0&,&00, at (llaha!ad.



*itle - C.).*. /s. 6&S 3.D. (uthority


418. Headline Summary - 6ag. can grant !ail in offences under SC&S* (ct not punisha!le ith death or Life imprisonment.

%udgment&'rder - BR)* - ( No. 41##8 of 007 %udgment&'rder Dated - 18&,&00, at (llaha!ad.

*itle - Saro: ;umar padhyaya /s. Highcourt 'f %udicature (t (lld. *hru Registrar 5eneral A(nr


40. Headline Summary - Sec.#IJIvJSC&S* (ct-no charge if noallegation that offence committed on the !asis that victim !elongs

to SC&S*.

%udgment&'rder - CR)6)N(L R+/)S)'N No. 1,0 of 00# %udgment&'rder Dated - 1#&,&00, at (llaha!ad.

*itle - Ra:nish Divedi /s. State 'f .$. *hroughh Secretary Home2 (t L"o.


41. Headline Summary - Section 14,2 +pl.))I!J of )* (ct added .e.f. 1.4.188 provides !y deeming fiction that income can !e

treated to have escaped assessment.

%udgment&'rder - BR)* *(E No. 78# of 1888 %udgment&'rder Dated - =&,&00, at (llaha!ad.

*itle - 6&S S.;.5upta A Company /s. )ncome *a 'fficer2 Bard-)2 5haia!ad

Coram - Hon!le R.;. (graal2%. and Hon!le 3harati Sapru2%.

4. Headline Summary - circular directs +cise Deptt to release non-relied seied goods&documents to assessee2 here notice is

not issued ithin si months from seiure.

%udgment&'rder - BR)* *(E No. #, of 00, %udgment&'rder Dated - =&,&00, at (llaha!ad.

*itle - 6&S Novament )ndistreis A (nother /s. nion 'f )ndia *hru Secretary 6in. 'f in. A'thers

Coram - Hon!le Hemant Laman 5o"hale2%. and Hon!le R.;. (graal2%.



4#. Headline Summary - $etitioners can file application u&s 1#(I=J of $ *rade *a (ct for release of goods ithout furnishing

security2 here matter can !e gone into

%udgment&'rder - BR)* *(E No. 11, of 00= %udgment&'rder Dated - =&,&00, at (llaha!ad.

*itle - 6&S Ra:eev ;umar %ain /s. State 'f .$. A 'thers

Coram - Hon!le R.;. (graal2%. and Hon!le 3harati Sapru2%.44. Headline Summary - reasons have to !e assigned !y (ddl. Commissioner hile granting sanction u&s 1IJ of $ *rade *a

(ct2 authorisation set aside

%udgment&'rder - BR)* *(E No. 1077 of 001 %udgment&'rder Dated - =&,&00, at (llaha!ad.

*itle - 6&S Ramayan *raders2 3areilly (nd (nother /s. (sstt. Commissioner I(ssessmentK)iiJ2 *rade *a23areilly A(n


47. Headline Summary - (.C. has no poer to sit in appeal or revie a good entry aarded !y (.%.2 thus2 eceeded its poer and

its decision set aside

%udgment&'rder - BR)* - ( No. 741# of 007 %udgment&'rder Dated - =&,&00, at (llaha!ad.

*itle - Desh 3hushan %ain /s. State 'f .$. (nd (nother


4=. Headline Summary - Crl *rial-'n re:ecting final report case to proceed as State Case if sufficient evidence in C.D. is not

otherise

%udgment&'rder - ($$L)C(*)'N &s 4 No. 171= of 00, %udgment&'rder Dated - 7&=&00, at (llaha!ad.

*itle - 6ohd. <usuf A 'thers /s. State 'f .$. A (nother

Coram - Hon!le Raghunath ;ishore Rastogi2%.4,. Headline Summary - )n a complaint tria!le !y a Sessions Court2 6agistrte must record statements of all itnessess u&s 0

Cr.p.C.

%udgment&'rder - ($$L)C(*)'N &s 4 No. 17#7 of 00, %udgment&'rder Dated - 7&=&00, at (llaha!ad.



*itle - ;ailash Nath $andey A (nother /s. State 'f .$. A (nother


4. Headline Summary - 6aintenance alloance fied in the compromise can !e altered u&s 1, Cr.$.C.

%udgment&'rder - ($$L)C(*)'N &s 4 No. 118# of 00, %udgment&'rder Dated - 1&=&00, at (llaha!ad.

*itle - Ram Narayan 5upta /s. Smt. Lami Devi A (nother


48. Headline Summary - 'rders dt.1,.8.07 and .,.0= of ()C*+ >uashed A ()C*+ directed to decide matter afresh in

accordance ith la and o!servations made.

%udgment&'rder - S$+C)(L ($$+(L No. 4# of 00= %udgment&'rder Dated - 1&=&00, at (llaha!ad.

*itle - (mity 3usiness School *hru (uthoried Signatory A (nother /s. (ll )ndia Council or *echnical +ducation A 'thers


4#0. Headline Summary - approved draft scheme cannot !e >uashed for inordinate delayQ eisting permit holders are entitled to

compensationQ temp. permit cannot !e reneed

%udgment&'rder - BR)* - ( No. 8## of 00 %udgment&'rder Dated - 1&=&00, at (llaha!ad.

*itle - .$.S.R.*.C. *hru 6anaging Director /s. State 'f .$. *hru $rincipal Secy. *ransport A (nr.


4#1. Headline Summary - (ccused sentenced to four years R.). u&s #= ).$.C.-(ppeal heard after 7 years2 fine of Rs. 472000&-

su!stituted.

%udgment&'rder - CR)6)N(L ($$+(L No. 40 of 18 %udgment&'rder Dated - #1&7&00, at (llaha!ad.

*itle - (sghar (li A 'thers /s. State 'f .$.A 'thers


4#. Headline Summary - Sec.#8 Cr.$.C.-(ccused may !e discharged if no case made out on the !ais of prosecution documents



%udgment&'rder - ($$L)C(*)'N &s 4 No. 110= of 00, %udgment&'rder Dated - #1&7&00, at (llaha!ad.

*itle - Rais 6iyan A 'thers /s. State 'f .$. A (nother


4##. Headline Summary - Criminal trial -hile claiming charge only prosecution evidence ill !e considered and not defence plea.

%udgment&'rder - ($$L)C(*)'N &s 4 No. 11,,1 of 00, %udgment&'rder Dated - #0&7&00, at (llaha!ad.

*itle - Raghvendra ;umar Srivastava A 'thers /s. State 'f .$. A (nother


4#4. Headline Summary - Sec 1=4 Cr.$.C.-'nly )' can apply regarding statement of itness and none else

%udgment&'rder - ($$L)C(*)'N &s 4 No. 11,#8 of 00, %udgment&'rder Dated - #0&7&00, at (llaha!ad.

*itle - Smt. %ag Devi 9 %agati A (nother /s. State 'f .$.


4#7. Headline Summary - Crl.*trial- (fter completion of statement2specific >uestion to !e specified for further cross.%udgment&'rder - ($$L)C(*)'N &s 4 No. 11, of 00, %udgment&'rder Dated - #0&7&00, at (llaha!ad.

*itle - (inesh /s. State 'f .$. A (nother


4#=. Headline Summary - Sec.7 (rms (cft sentence !elo minimum prescri!ed u&s 7-3I1J can !e imposed in suita!le cases.


*itle - Laturi /s. State 'f .$

Coram - Hon!le Raghunath ;ishore Rastogi2%.4#,. Headline Summary - Chargesheet !y police in non-cognia!le case to !e treated as a complaint.

%udgment&'rder - ($$L)C(*)'N &s 4 No. 11=#7 of 00, %udgment&'rder Dated - 8&7&00, at (llaha!ad.



*itle - Santosh ;umar *rivedi /s. State 'f .$. A (nother


4#. Headline Summary - S.#74 )$C-considering long gap of 7 yrs imprisonment commuted to enhanced fine.

%udgment&'rder - CR)6)N(L ($$+(L No. 188 of 18 %udgment&'rder Dated - &7&00, at (llaha!ad.

*itle - Ram Chandra /s. State 'f .$.


4#8. Headline Summary - hen recruitment is held ithin year of recruitment2 !enefit of second proviso to Rule 10 is not availa!leQ

Rule 4ImJ valid.

%udgment&'rder - BR)* - ( No. =814 of 00= %udgment&'rder Dated - 7&7&00, at (llaha!ad.

*itle - Shi"ha Srivastava (nd 'thers /s. State 'f .$. (nd (nother

Coram - Hon!le R.;. (graal2%. 2 Hon!le Sunil (m!ani2%. and Hon!le S.S. ;ulshrestha2%.

440. Headline Summary - Sec.#= Cr.$.C. !ars revie&recall of order !y same court. Remedy to approach superior court.

%udgment&'rder - CR)6)N(L R+/)S)'N No. 8== of 00# %udgment&'rder Dated - 7&7&00, at (llaha!ad.

*itle - Smt. 5ayatri 6ishra /s. State 'f .$. (nd 'thers


441. Headline Summary - Sec.17=I#J Cr.$.C.2 $oers of 6agistrate2 correctness of dictum in Cr..6..(ppl. =17&0= dou!ted-

referred to larger 3ench.

%udgment&'rder - ($$L)C(*)'N &s 4 No. 88, of 00, %udgment&'rder Dated - 1&7&00, at (llaha!ad.

*itle - Su"hasi /s. State 'f .$.


44. Headline Summary - $etition dismissed. Court !eing dissatisfied directed for action under Regulation #71-( CSR if Comm.2

*rade *a2 forms such an opinion



%udgment&'rder - BR)* *(E No. 7=# of 00, %udgment&'rder Dated - 11&7&00, at (llaha!ad.

*itle - 6&S ;ing (gency /s. State 'f .$. A 'thers


44#. Headline Summary - Complaint u&s 1# Negotia!le )nstrucments (ct not maintaina!le ithout service of notice

%udgment&'rder - ($$L)C(*)'N &s 4 No. ,,, of 00, %udgment&'rder Dated - &7&00, at (llaha!ad.

*itle - Ravindra Singh 5ugyani (lias San:u /s. State 'f .$. A (nother


444. Headline Summary - Section #18 Cr.$.C.2 accused not to !e summoned on hearsay evidence

%udgment&'rder - CR)6)N(L R+/)S)'N No. 100 of 00, %udgment&'rder Dated - &7&00, at (llaha!ad.

*itle - %amuna Devi A 'thers /s. State 'f .$.


447. Headline Summary - *a authorities to eamine&state in memo hether appeal involving ta effect less than 4 lacs falls ithinone of eceptions.

%udgment&'rder - )NC'6+ *(E ($$+(L D++C*)/+ No. 01 of 001 %udgment&'rder Dated - 1&7&00, at (llaha!ad.

*itle - *he Commissioner 'f )ncome *a ;anpur /s. 6&S Roshan Lal *alar I6a:. Grs.J %hansi


44=. Headline Summary - $ Higher +ducation Services Commission (ct is valid.

%udgment&'rder - BR)* - ( No. #1014 of 007 %udgment&'rder Dated - 1=&4&00, at (llaha!ad.

*itle - C&6 D.N. I$.5.J College 6eerut *hru Hony Secy.2 A (nr /s. State 'f p *hru Secy Higher +ducation (nd 'thers


44,. Headline Summary - *he >uestion hether the scheme of arrangement should !e stamped or not - referred to third %udge.

%udgment&'rder - BR)* - C No. 4111 of 00= %udgment&'rder Dated - =&4&00, at (llaha!ad.



*itle - 6&S Hero 6otors Limited2 Ne Delhi *hru )ts $resident /s. State 'f .$. *hru (dm Iinance A RevenueJ (nd 'thers


44. Headline Summary - $rocedure for issuing gate pass !y 6andi Samitee eplained

%udgment&'rder - BR)* - C No. #87, of 000 %udgment&'rder Dated - 1=&#&00, at (llaha!ad.

*itle - )tc Ltd. /s. 6andi $arishad A (nother

Coram - Hon!le <atindra Singh2%. and Hon!le San:ay 6isra2%.

448. Headline Summary - Non !aila!le arrant A process u&s A # Cr.$.C. cannot !e issued simultaneously.

%udgment&'rder - ($$L)C(*)'N &s 4 No. #0,= of 00, %udgment&'rder Dated - &&00, at (llaha!ad.

*itle - Shamsher (nd 'thers /s. State 'f .$. (nd (nother


470. Headline Summary - 'ffences non-compounda!le !ut invie of spl. facts compounding permitted u&s 4=72 4=,2 4= A

4,1)$C.

%udgment&'rder - CR)6)N(L 6)SC. BR)* $+*)*)'N No. 84, of 00, %udgment&'rder Dated - 7&1&00, at (llaha!ad.

*itle - ;umar 6anglam 3irla /s. (ddl. Chief %udicial 6agistrate A 'thers


471. Headline Summary - Sec.1,# Cr.$.C. permits further investigation A not reinvestigation.

%udgment&'rder - CR)6)N(L 6)SC. BR)* $+*)*)'N No. ,8= of 00, %udgment&'rder Dated - &1&00, at (llaha!ad.

*itle - Smt. Sugandha Devi (nd 'thers /s. State 'f .$. *hru )ts Secy. IHomeJ 5ovt. 'f .$. A 'rs.


47. Headline Summary - (ccused having fire arms caused in:uries from !uts and !arrels of those arms prima facie has no

intentionto "ill

%udgment&'rder - ($$L)C(*)'N &s 4 No. 11,1 of 00, %udgment&'rder Dated - 1&1&00, at (llaha!ad.



*itle - $appu A 'thers /s. State 'f .$. A (nother


47#. Headline Summary - Name of the medicine in the licence under the Drugs (ct- can not infringe *rade mar".

%udgment&'rder - BR)* - C No. ,4= of 001 %udgment&'rder Dated - 1&1&00, at (llaha!ad.

*itle - 6&S Cattle Remedies *hrough )ts $artner A (nother /s. *he Licensing (uthority A 'thersCoram - Hon!le <atindra Singh2%. and Hon!le Ran /i:ai Singh2%.

474. Headline Summary - $olice report A complaint for same incident against different persons-S 10 CR.$.C.not applica!le to

!oth cases to !e decided together.

%udgment&'rder - ($$L)C(*)'N &s 4 No. 878 of 00= %udgment&'rder Dated - 1&1&00= at (llaha!ad.

*itle - Smt. Harpyari A 'thers /s. State 'f .$. A (nother


477. Headline Summary - 6ag. cannot summon accused on protest petition in .R. here there is no evidence in C.D.

%udgment&'rder - ($$L)C(*)'N &s 4 No. 1=,#0 of 00= %udgment&'rder Dated - 17&1&00= at (llaha!ad.

*itle - 3ai:nath (nd (nother /s. State 'f .$. (nd (nother


47=. Headline Summary - 5.'. dated#.1.00# and #.8.00= providing for self eamination centre in the high school and

intermediate eaminations>uashed

%udgment&'rder - BR)* - C No. ,##8 of 00= %udgment&'rder Dated - 17&1&00= at (llaha!ad.

*itle - C&6. Shri 6ohan Singh )nter College2 6athura (nd (nother /s. State 'f .$. (nd 'thers

Coram - Hon!le Sham!hu Nath Srivastava2%.

47,. Headline Summary - *he %udges of superior Courts are particularly trained to give reasona!le decisions even on complicated

matters re>uiring any special epertise



%udgment&'rder - (R3)*R(*)'N and C'NC)L). ($$L.&s11I4J No. #8 of 001 %udgment&'rder Dated - 1&1&00= at (llaha!ad.

*itle - Big A Sons /s. Chief +ngineer I(ir orceJ2 3amrauli2 (lld.

Coram - Hon!le (:oy Nath Ray2%.

47. Headline Summary - *he ell "non principle of la is that actus curiae neminem grava!it

%udgment&'rder - S$+C)(L ($$+(L No. =8 of 00= %udgment&'rder Dated - 1&1&00= at (llaha!ad.*itle - /ice Chancellor2 3anaras Hindu niveristy2 /aranasi A 'thers /s. (nand ;umar Rai A 'thers

Coram - Hon!le (:oy Nath Ray2%. and Hon!le (sho" 3hushan2%.

478. Headline Summary - *he interim order refused in $.C.S.I%J eamination2 rit petition dismissed.

%udgment&'rder - BR)* - ( No. 78=7# of 00= %udgment&'rder Dated - &11&00= at (llaha!ad.

*itle - %ai $ra"ash *iari (nd 'thers /s. State 'f .$. (nd 'thers

Coram - Hon!le Sushil Har"auli2%. and Hon!le $an"a: 6ithal2%.

4=0. Headline Summary - 6agistrate can treat an application u&s 17=I#J Cr.$.C. as a complaint and vice versa.%udgment&'rder - ($$L)C(*)'N &s 4 No. 118# of 004 %udgment&'rder Dated - 1#&10&00= at (llaha!ad.

*itle - Shiv Narain %aisal (nd 'thers /s. State 'f .$. (nd (nother


4=1. Headline Summary - .R. su!mitted-6agistrate dou!ting geneuineness of statement to summon accused ithout further

investigation-order illegal.

%udgment&'rder - ($$L)C(*)'N &s 4 No. ,78 of 007 %udgment&'rder Dated - 1#&10&00= at (llaha!ad.

*itle - (un 6ohammad Na>vi 9 Siddan A (nother /s. State 'f .$. A (nother


4=. Headline Summary - Sec.4 Cr.$.C.here no evidence of unnatrural death charge u&s #04-3 )$C to !e pro!ed.

%udgment&'rder - ($$L)C(*)'N &s 4 No. =10 of 00= %udgment&'rder Dated - 1#&10&00= at (llaha!ad.



*itle - Smt. /imla Devi A (nother /s. State 'f .$. A (nother


4=#. Headline Summary - )n a case of .R. 6agistrate to consider .R. itself A supporting evidence hile passing order on protest petition.

%udgment&'rder - ($$L)C(*)'N &s 4 No. 1,4 of 007 %udgment&'rder Dated - 1#&10&00= at (llaha!ad.

*itle - Diari Lal (nd 'thers. /s. State 'f .$ (nd (nother


4=4. Headline Summary - Second (ppeal-parties reached compromise-ithdraal application-second appeal dismissed as not

pressed-no li!erty for fresh second appeal

%udgment&'rder - S+C'ND ($$+(L No. 7, of 181 %udgment&'rder Dated - =&10&00= at (llaha!ad.

*itle - $ratappur Sugar A )ndustry Ltd. /s. (shani ;umar Shu"la

Coram - Hon!le Satya $oot 6ehrotra2%.

4=7. Headline Summary - Second (ppeal 2 sole defendant-appellant epired-no Su!stitution (pplication filed-Second (ppeal

dismissed as a!ated.

%udgment&'rder - S+C'ND ($$+(L No. #1 of 18 %udgment&'rder Dated - ,&8&00= at (llaha!ad.

*itle - 5auri Shan"er Srivastava /s. Shri Radha ;ishna %i 6ahara: Sri 6ulloo Sami23.6.


4==. Headline Summary - *he action must !e initiated in a contempt proceeding ithin a period of one year from the date the

contempt is alleged to have !een committed.

%udgment&'rder - S$+C)(L ($$+(L No. 100 of 00= %udgment&'rder Dated - 1&8&00= at (llaha!ad.

*itle - 3ali Ram /s. Chief +ngineer2 )rrigation2 Deptt. 5ora"hpur A 'thers




4=,. Headline Summary - S.10 Cr.$.C.-complaint case and State case in respect of same incident !e tried together.

%udgment&'rder - ($$L)C(*)'N &s 4 No. 147,8 of 007 %udgment&'rder Dated - &8&00= at (llaha!ad.

*itle - Smt. ;amlesh 3harda: (nd (nother /s. State 'f .$. (nd (nother


4=. Headline Summary - %uvenile %ustice (ct - (ge to !e determined as per Rule of .$.%uvenile %ustice Rules 004%udgment&'rder - ($$L)C(*)'N &s 4 No. 81#0 of 007 %udgment&'rder Dated - =&8&00= at (llaha!ad.

*itle - Devendra 9 Chintu /s. State 'f .$. (nd 'thers


4=8. Headline Summary - $lea of %uvenile cannot !e refused on the ground of delay

%udgment&'rder - ($$L)C(*)'N &s 4 No. 77 of 00= %udgment&'rder Dated - =&8&00= at (llaha!ad.

*itle - Ram 3a!u /s. State 'f .$. A (nother

Coram - Hon!le <atindra Singh2%. and Hon!le Raghunath ;ishore Rastogi2%.4,0. Headline Summary - Second (ppeal contesting plaintiffs-respondents epired-Su!stitution (pplication not filed-Second(ppeal dismissed as a!ated.

%udgment&'rder - S+C'ND ($$+(L No. =,, of 181 %udgment&'rder Dated - 7&8&00= at (llaha!ad.

*itle - Smt.Sham Sundri (nd (nother /s. Ram Nandan (nd 'thers


4,1. Headline Summary - 5ross misconduct - act pre:udicial to the interest of 3an" - B$ dismissed

%udgment&'rder - BR)* - ( No. 4010 of 000 %udgment&'rder Dated - 7&8&00= at (llaha!ad.

*itle - ;omal Singh /s. 5eneral 6anager I$J Syndicate 3an" A 'thers


4,. Headline Summary - ( minor not entitled to compassionate appointment after 17 years of death of father. $etition dismissed.



%udgment&'rder - BR)* - ( No. 477,1 of 00= %udgment&'rder Dated - 7&8&00= at (llaha!ad.

*itle - 6ahendra ;umar <adav /s. State 'f .$. (nd 'thers


4,#. Headline Summary - Second (ppeal-dismissed as a!ated-restoration and su!stitution application filed-in:unction&stay may !e

granted-sections 141 and 171 cpc

%udgment&'rder - S+C'ND ($$+(L No. 7,= of 18# %udgment&'rder Dated - 1&8&00= at (llaha!ad.

*itle - 3asan Lal /s. La"shmi Chand


4,4. Headline Summary - S-70 ND$S (C* applica!le to personal search of !ody of accused and not for search of his !elonging2

li"e !ag etc.

%udgment&'rder - CR)6)N(L 6)SC. 3()L ($$L)C(*)'N No. 1=#=0 of 00= %udgment&'rder Dated - 8&&00= at (llaha!ad.

*itle - $radeep ;umar $atha" /s. State 'f .$.


4,7. Headline Summary - Brit petition in eceptional circustances is maintaina!le even against a notification issued under Section

4 of the Land (c>uisition (ct.

%udgment&'rder - BR)* - C No. ,0=# of 007 %udgment&'rder Dated - 7&&00= at (llaha!ad.

*itle - ;shama Sah"ari (vas Samiti Ltd. /s. State 'f .$. (nd 'thers

Coram - Hon!le Ram $ra"ash 6isra2%. and Hon!le $an"a: 6ithal2%.

4,=. Headline Summary - Revisional court cannot record finding of fact A can simply issue direction to loer court.

%udgment&'rder - CR)6)N(L R+/)S)'N No. ==, of 18 %udgment&'rder Dated - 7&&00= at (llaha!ad.*itle - R.;.Singh /s. State




4,,. Headline Summary - $.3oard directed to recognise 6oral +ducation as compulsory su!:ect-See article 71 ( of Const.

%udgment&'rder - BR)* - C No. 441 of 00= %udgment&'rder Dated - #&&00= at (llaha!ad.

*itle - )>!al Hussain /s. State 'f .$. 'thers


4,. Headline Summary - Crl.court hen una!le to decide title to case property should direct parties to see" declaration of title.%udgment&'rder - ($$L)C(*)'N &s 4 No. 184, of 004 %udgment&'rder Dated - &&00= at (llaha!ad.

*itle - District Co-'perative 3an" Ltd. atehpur /s. State 'f .$.


4,8. Headline Summary - prescri!ing to alternate >ualification A omitting preference clause to degree holder do not create hostile

discrimination. $reference is for e>uals

%udgment&'rder - BR)* - ( No. #### of 1888 %udgment&'rder Dated - 18&&00= at (llaha!ad.

*itle - Dr. ("hilesh 6ishra /s. State 'f .$. A 'thers

Coram - Hon!le R.;. (graal2%. and Hon!le San:ay 6isra2%.

40. Headline Summary - (ppointment de hors statutory provisions on non-availa!le post cannot !e ta"en note of for regularisation

and such regularisation is void

%udgment&'rder - BR)* - ( No. #7148 of 1888 %udgment&'rder Dated - 18&&00= at (llaha!ad.

*itle - Hari 3ansh Divedi /s. /ice Chancellor 6ahatma 5andhi ;lashi /idyapith A 'thers


41. Headline Summary - (ccused is entitled to !ail here in:uries on the accused side are not eplained !y the prosecution.

%udgment&'rder - CR)6)N(L 6)SC. 3()L ($$L)C(*)'N No. 178 of 00= %udgment&'rder Dated - 1,&&00= at (llaha!ad.

*itle - Ra"esh ;umar Singh 9 $uppu /s. State 'f .$.




4. Headline Summary - delay deprecated2 direction to refur!ish educational system

%udgment&'rder - BR)* - C No. 1#1# of 00= %udgment&'rder Dated - 1,&&00= at (llaha!ad.

*itle - Narendra ;umar /s. State 'f .$. *hru *he Secretary 6inistry 'f +ducation


4#. Headline Summary - 'rder for regularisation hen the initial engagement is dehorse the prescri!ed procedure is !ad.%udgment&'rder - BR)* - ( No. 1, of 188, %udgment&'rder Dated - 11&&00= at (llaha!ad.

*itle - (nup 3ehari Lal Srivastava /s. %.$. Rai


44. Headline Summary - seniority to !e counted from date of su!stantive appointment u&r 1I1J unless the order mentions

otherise

%udgment&'rder - BR)* - ( No. 4=4 of 001 %udgment&'rder Dated - &&00= at (llaha!ad.

*itle - %ai $ra"ash /s. State 'f .$.*hrough $rincipal Secy. (dmin. Reforms Dept1 L.

Coram - Hon!le R.;. (graal2%. and Hon!le Ran /i:ai Singh2%.

47. Headline Summary - Second (ppeal-counsel for the appellant not present-repeated ad:ournments-Second (ppeal dismissed

for ant of prosecution.

%udgment&'rder - S+C'ND ($$+(L No. 41 of 184 %udgment&'rder Dated - ,&&00= at (llaha!ad.

*itle - 5ulam Filani /s. (!dul Rahman (nd (nother


4=. Headline Summary - *he ord should !y itself is of a considera!ly less mandatory character and meaning than the orld shall.

%udgment&'rder - S$+C)(L ($$+(L No. 7 of 00= %udgment&'rder Dated - 4&&00= at (llaha!ad.

*itle - Ram 5opal A (nother /s. *he nion 'f )ndia A 'hters




4,. Headline Summary - Second (ppeal -sole plaintiff-appellant died-Su!stitution (pplication not filed -Second (ppeal dismissed

as a!ated

%udgment&'rder - S+C'ND ($$+(L No. 841 of 181 %udgment&'rder Dated - &&00= at (llaha!ad.

*itle - %amuna Das /s. 5anga Ram A 'thers


4. Headline Summary - Second (ppeal -Sole plaintiff-appellant dead-Su!stitution (pplication dismissed for ant of prosecution.

Second (ppeal dismissed as a!ated.

%udgment&'rder - S+C'ND ($$+(L No. 1=00 of 187 %udgment&'rder Dated - #1&,&00= at (llaha!ad.

*itle - <adgar Husain /s. %ais 6ohd.


48. Headline Summary - unfairmeans. !elated disposal depreciated certain directions issued

%udgment&'rder - BR)* - C No. =88,0 of 007 %udgment&'rder Dated - 8&,&00= at (llaha!ad.

*itle - (!hay ;umar *ripathi /s. State 'f .$. (nd 'thers


480. Headline Summary - Second (ppeal-Counsel for the defendants-appellants not appeared-dismissed for ant of prosecution.

%udgment&'rder - S+C'ND ($$+(L No. #070 of 181 %udgment&'rder Dated - &,&00= at (llaha!ad.

*itle - Suleman /s. (miruddin


481. Headline Summary - Second (ppeal -Sole plaintiff-appellant dead-no su!stitution application-Second (ppeal dismissed as

a!ated.%udgment&'rder - S+C'ND ($$+(L No. 48 of 18 %udgment&'rder Dated - &,&00= at (llaha!ad.

*itle - Sarv:eet Singh /s. Ra: ;umari (nd 'thers

!l h




48. Headline Summary - Second (ppeal- Sole plaintiff-appellant-Su!sitution (pplication dismissed for non-prosecution-Second

(ppeal dismissed as a!ated.

%udgment&'rder - S+C'ND ($$+(L No. 18#1 of 184 %udgment&'rder Dated - =&,&00= at (llaha!ad.

*itle - Sia Ram /s. Sura: $rasad


48#. Headline Summary - Second (ppeal-Counsel reporting no instructions-Second (ppeal dismissed for ant of prosecution.

%udgment&'rder - S+C'ND ($$+(L No. 7,4 of 18# %udgment&'rder Dated - 1&,&00= at (llaha!ad.

*itle - Su!edar /s. Ram Saroop A 'thers


484. Headline Summary - No 3ail here there is no evidence to su!stantiate cross allegation

%udgment&'rder - CR)6)N(L 6)SC. 3()L ($$L)C(*)'N No. #78 of 00= %udgment&'rder Dated - 18&,&00= at (llaha!ad.

*itle - Nan"u Lal <adav /s. State 'f .$.


487. Headline Summary - *enders not invalid due to omission of amount in figures or ords and in case of discrepancy higher

amount shall !e accepted

%udgment&'rder - BR)* - C No. 48107 of 004 %udgment&'rder Dated - 1&,&00= at (llaha!ad.

*itle - Consolidators )nformation Systems $vt. Ltd. A (nr. /s. Chairman2 Noida A 'thers


48=. Headline Summary - Second (popeal- Repeated ad:ournment- Learned counsel not appearing -Dismissed for ant of prosecution.

%udgment&'rder - S+C'ND ($$+(L No. # of 184 %udgment&'rder Dated - 1&,&00= at (llaha!ad.

*i l H id ll h ( d ' h / 3 ddh ( d ( h



*itle - Hamidullah (nd 'thers /s. 3uddhu (nd (nother


48,. Headline Summary - Contempt $etition is dismissed as not pressed.

%udgment&'rder - C'N*+6$* ($$L)C(*)'N IC)/)LJ No. #4=7 of 004 %udgment&'rder Dated - 1,&,&00= at (llaha!ad.

*itle - Smt. Sadhana Sinha /s. 3rig R.;. ;ashyap2 Director A 'thersCoram - Hon!le Satya $oot 6ehrotra2%.

48. Headline Summary - rom 1.1.8= the pensioners entitled at least 70T of minimum of revised pay scale as pension2 interest on

delayed payment of arrears is aarded

%udgment&'rder - BR)* - ( No. 17108 of 00 %udgment&'rder Dated - 7&,&00= at (llaha!ad.

*itle - Chaudhary Shan"ar Singh /s. State 'f .$. *hru Secy. inance Deptt. A 'rs.


488. Headline Summary - 3ail to father&mother-in-la in dory death case can !e refused in case of direct allegation A evidence of

cruelty.

%udgment&'rder - CR)6)N(L 6)SC. 3()L ($$L)C(*)'N No. 147, of 00= %udgment&'rder Dated - 4&,&00= at (llaha!ad.

*itle - /i:ay $al Singh (nd (nother /s. State 'f .$.


700. Headline Summary - Horiontal Reservations to !e or"ed out for physically handicapped persons of general category.

%udgment&'rder - BR)* - ( No. 1=0# of 00# %udgment&'rder Dated - #&,&00= at (llaha!ad.

*itle - Dr. Ravindra ;umar $andey /s. State 'f .$. (nd 'thers

Coram - Hon!le /i:ay 6anohar Sahai2%. and Hon!le Sa!ha:eet <adav2%.

701. Headline Summary - 5overnors order retaining Legal (dvisor stayed.

%udgment&'rder - $3L)C )N*+R+S* L)*)5(*)'N I$)LJ No. ##14= of 00= %udgment&'rder Dated - #&=&00= at (llaha!ad.

*itl ) R S t Hi h C t 3 ( i ti (ll h ! d / U



*itle - )n Re K Secretary2 High Court 3ar (ssociation2 (llaha!ad /s. U

Coram - Hon!le Ra"esh *iari2%. 2 Hon!le S.S. ;ulshrestha2%. 2 Hon!le $ra"ash ;rishna2%. 2 Hon!le Devendra $ratap Singh2%. and

Hon!le (mreshar $ratap Sahi2%.

70. Headline Summary - (mendment irrelevant for determination of controversy !eteen the parties2 not lia!le to !e alloed.

%udgment&'rder - BR)* - ( No. #0## of 00= %udgment&'rder Dated - =&7&00= at (llaha!ad.

*itle - Ram:i Das (nd (nother /s. Ra:endra 6ohan 6athur (nd (nother

Coram - Hon!le ;rishna 6urari2%.

70#. Headline Summary - Recovery of ecess amount paid on fiation2 not occasioned !y misrepresentation or fraud !y petitioner2

is ine>uita!le.

%udgment&'rder - BR)* - ( No. 144 of 00 %udgment&'rder Dated - =&7&00= at (llaha!ad.

*itle - Ra: Nath Ram /s. State 'f .$. *hru Secy. )nstitutional inance A 'rs.


704. Headline Summary - punishment of removal for not :oining at transferred place and remaining a!sent ithout sanctined leaveis appropriate

%udgment&'rder - BR)* - ( No. #8=7 of 000 %udgment&'rder Dated - =&7&00= at (llaha!ad.

*itle - Dinesh Chandra %ain /s. Syndicate 3an" A 'thers


707. Headline Summary - Ration shop-5.'. regarding cancellation on election of licensee or his family mem!ers-legal position

eplained.

%udgment&'rder - BR)* - C No. 170 of 00# %udgment&'rder Dated - 7&7&00= at (llaha!ad.

*itle - Ram 6urat /s. Commissioner (amgarh Divn. A 'thers


70= H dli S C l d !l t ! d d h h ! d d if ttl d di t i !l



70=. Headline Summary - Crl. noncompounda!le case to!e dropped hen hus!and and ife settled dispute amica!ly.

%udgment&'rder - ($$L)C(*)'N &s 4 No. 10= of 00# %udgment&'rder Dated - 1,&7&00= at (llaha!ad.

*itle - $an"a: 6ishra A (nother /s. State 'f .$. A 'thers


70,. Headline Summary - 3uilding assessed to *a2 date of first assessment shall !e deemed to !e completion of !uilding fordetermining the applica!lity of Rent (ct.

%udgment&'rder - BR)* - ( No. #484 of 00# %udgment&'rder Dated - 17&7&00= at (llaha!ad.

*itle - 6ohammad (slam /s. 'm $ra"ash Divedi


70. Headline Summary - Second (ppeal-Su!stitution (pplications conse>uent to the death of sole defendant-appellant dismissed-

Second (ppeal stands a!ated

%udgment&'rder - S+C'ND ($$+(L No. # of 181 %udgment&'rder Dated - &7&00= at (llaha!ad.

*itle - 5ulam Hussain /s. 6ohd.aroo>


708. Headline Summary - once regular en>uiry instituted2 findings recorded in preliminary en>uiry loose its significance

%udgment&'rder - BR)* - ( No. 1,= of 004 %udgment&'rder Dated - &7&00= at (llaha!ad.

*itle - Su!hash Chandra padhyay /s. State 'f .$. (nd 'thers


710. Headline Summary - (pplication for condonation of delay not to !e alloed if there are latches on the part of applicant.

%udgment&'rder - CR)6)N(L R+/)S)'N D++C*)/+ No. 4, of 00# %udgment&'rder Dated - &7&00= at (llaha!ad.

*itle - Lami Devi /s. State 'f .$. A 'thers


711 Headline S mmar 3ail can !e ref sed to : enile on the gro nd mentioned in S 1 of % enile % stice (ct



711. Headline Summary - 3ail can !e refused to :uvenile on the ground mentioned in S.1 of %uvenile %ustice (ct.

%udgment&'rder - CR)6)N(L R+/)S)'N D++C*)/+ No. 70 of 007 %udgment&'rder Dated - &7&00= at (llaha!ad.

*itle - $appi 9 $rem Singh /s. State 'f .$.


71. Headline Summary - Second (ppeal-sole plaintiff-appellant dead2 steps for notice on Su!stitution (pplication not ta"e.Second (ppeal dismissed as having a!ated.

%udgment&'rder - S+C'ND ($$+(L No. 81 of 181 %udgment&'rder Dated - 7&7&00= at (llaha!ad.

*itle - 6ohd. (nar ;han /s. Harish Chandra


71#. Headline Summary - officating principal can !e divested of his duty to restore normalcy in College

%udgment&'rder - BR)* - ( No. 18#41 of 00= %udgment&'rder Dated - #&7&00= at (llaha!ad.

*itle - Dr. ;iran Shan"er /s. nion 'f )ndia (nd 'thers


714. Headline Summary - 5arages may not !e used for purposes other than "eeping vehicles or as a store.

%udgment&'rder - BR)* - C No. 0 of 00= %udgment&'rder Dated - 1&7&00= at (llaha!ad.

*itle - )n *he 6atter 'f K 5roup Captain Su"h Deo Singh Sidhu A (nr. /s. State 'f .$. (nd 'thers

Coram - Hon!le <atindra Singh2%. and Hon!le Shishir ;umar2%.

717. Headline Summary - $rinciple of ' 41 R , C$C to !e folloed !y (ppellate (uthority under Rent Control (ct hile

receiving additional evidence.

%udgment&'rder - BR)* - ( No. 48 of 00= %udgment&'rder Dated - 1&7&00= at (llaha!ad.

*itle - Shri Durga 3hagati )ndustries2 Hathras (nd 'thers /s. Shri 'm $ra"ash Lohia (nd 'thers


71= Headline Summary 3ail to %uvenile can !e refused only on grounds given in S 1 %% (ct



71=. Headline Summary - 3ail to %uvenile can !e refused only on grounds given in S 12 %% (ct

%udgment&'rder - CR)6)N(L R+/)S)'N No. #7 of 007 %udgment&'rder Dated - &4&00= at (llaha!ad.

*itle - /ishal Du!ey /s. State 'f .$.


71,. Headline Summary - No revision lies agains t preliminary orders u&s 147A14= Cr.$.C..(ggrieved party to file o!:ection !eforeSD6.

%udgment&'rder - CR)6)N(L R+/)S)'N No. ,0# of 001 %udgment&'rder Dated - &4&00= at (llaha!ad.

*itle - 6aan 3a!u Du!ey /s. State 'f .$. A (nother


71. Headline Summary - Reservation in constituencies of C6 in Cooperative Societies rotate according to Hindi alpha!et.

%udgment&'rder - BR)* - C No. 1=448 of 00= %udgment&'rder Dated - ,&4&00= at (llaha!ad.

*itle - Sudhir *yagi /s. State 'f .$. (nd 'thers


718. Headline Summary - iation of separate >uota for promotion of different post in feeder cadre does not tantamount to

reservation.

%udgment&'rder - BR)* - ( No. ,4=# of 00= %udgment&'rder Dated - =&4&00= at (llaha!ad.

*itle - Dinesh ;ant Srivastava /s. State 'f .$. (nd 'thers

Coram - Hon!le /i:ay 6anohar Sahai2%. and Hon!le Sa!ha:eet <adav2%.

70. Headline Summary - %udicial revie of administrative order-cancellation of auction !ad-petition alloed

%udgment&'rder - BR)* - C No. 107 of 00= %udgment&'rder Dated - 7&4&00= at (llaha!ad.

*itle - 6&S *rilochan Rice (nd (lloy 6ills Ltd. %aunpur /s. State 'f .$. (nd 'thers

Coram - Hon!le 3.S. Chauhan2%. and Hon!le Dilip 5upta2%.

71 Headline Summary $etition under (rticle , dismissed on ground of alternative remedy in:unction application filed in



71. Headline Summary - $etition under (rticle , dismissed on ground of alternative remedy-in:unction application filed in

regular irst (ppeal-

%udgment&'rder - 6(**+RS ND+R (R*)CL+ , No. 7 of 00= %udgment&'rder Dated - 7&4&00= at (llaha!ad.

*itle - 6ohd. *ahir ;han /s. 6ohd. <unus ;han (nd 'thers


7. Headline Summary - Copy of notice terminating the tenancy served after filing of suit no valid service

%udgment&'rder - BR)* - ( No. 1=40 of 00= %udgment&'rder Dated - 4&4&00= at (llaha!ad.

*itle - 6ohamad )smail /s. )i (ddl. Distt. %udge (nd 'thers


7#. Headline Summary - (ppeal decided !y S'C 6au after transfer from 3allia Revision lies !efore DDC 6au

%udgment&'rder - BR)* - 3 No. 1##8 of 00= %udgment&'rder Dated - 4&4&00= at (llaha!ad.

*itle - $arshuram /s. Dy. Director 'f Consolidation2 3allia A 'thers


74. Headline Summary - Second (ppeal-Sole plaintiff-appellant-dead. No Su!stitution (pplication filed. Second (ppeal stands


%udgment&'rder - S+C'ND ($$+(L No. 17, of 181 %udgment&'rder Dated - 18&4&00= at (llaha!ad.

*itle - )nder Singh /s. Chaumal


77. Headline Summary - (r!itration (ard #0 days o!:ection time from notice of filing date A not from any later date.

%udgment&'rder - )RS* ($$+(L R'6 'RD+R No. 1#= of 001 %udgment&'rder Dated - 18&4&00= at (llaha!ad.

*itle - *he National $ro:ects Construction Corp.Ltd.2 Sone!hadra /s. 6&S 3.3./erma (nd (nother


7= Headline Summary *he area of )ndustrial *onship under proviso to (rticle 4#G is to ecluded from delimitation of ards



7=. Headline Summary - *he area of )ndustrial *onship under proviso to (rticle 4#G is to ecluded from delimitation of ards.

%udgment&'rder - BR)* - C No. 1#### of 00= %udgment&'rder Dated - 7&4&00= at (llaha!ad.

*itle - Hindalco )ndustries Limited /s. State 'f .$. (nd 'thers


7,. Headline Summary - Chapter E))2 Rule 4 of the Rules of the Court- Second (ppeal dismissed against respondents 1 A only-%udgment&'rder - S+C'ND ($$+(L No. 0 of 181 %udgment&'rder Dated - 4&4&00= at (llaha!ad.

*itle - 3hagan Das A 'rs. /s. Sri Sumer Chand


7. Headline Summary - Second (ppeal sole defendant-respondent-Su!stutiton (pplication dismissed u&Ch E)) R4-Second

(ppeal dismissed as a!ated.

%udgment&'rder - S+C'ND ($$+(L No. ,, of 18# %udgment&'rder Dated - #0&#&00= at (llaha!ad.

*itle - 6ata Seva" /s. Sar:u $rasad


78. Headline Summary - spl. adverse entry should relate to particular instance&or" on application of mind thereto

%udgment&'rder - BR)* - ( No. 170, of 00 %udgment&'rder Dated - #0&#&00= at (llaha!ad.

*itle - 3a:rang 3ahadur Singh /s. State 'f .$. *hru $rincipal Secy. $.B.D. A (nr.

Coram - Hon!le R.;. (graal2%. and Hon!le Ravindra Nath 6isra2%.

7#0. Headline Summary - Brit in non-contractual matters- Direction to decide representation-No

%udgment&'rder - BR)* - C No. 1,180 of 00= %udgment&'rder Dated - 8&#&00= at (llaha!ad.

*itle - Sant 5adge Seva Ni"etan (nd (nother /s. State 'f .$. (nd 'thers


7#1 Headline Summary - 5ovt directed to ta"e steps toards ameliorating or"ing conditions of officers on revenue as ell as



7#1. Headline Summary - 5ovt. directed to ta"e steps toards ameliorating or"ing conditions of officers on revenue as ell as

consolidation side

%udgment&'rder - BR)* - 3 No. 10=1 of 00= %udgment&'rder Dated - &#&00= at (llaha!ad.

*itle - Smt. Shanti Devi A (nother /s. State 'f .$. A 'thers


7#. Headline Summary - 5' prohi!iting reneal of hole sale fertilier registration ithin 7 ;m of )ndo-Nepal !order-illegal

%udgment&'rder - BR)* - C No. ##44 of 007 %udgment&'rder Dated - &#&00= at (llaha!ad.

*itle - 6&S Ra:pal *rading Co. *hru $rop. A (nother /s. State 'f .$. *hru Secy. Deptt. 'f (griculture A 'rs.


7##. Headline Summary - Brit-conditional stay of eviction-damages aarded at enhanced rate-direction for deposit-no

modification re>uired

%udgment&'rder - BR)* - ( No. 71= of 00 %udgment&'rder Dated - #&#&00= at (llaha!ad.

*itle - 5ulshan ;umar Shondhi /s. S.6. College Chandausi


7#4. Headline Summary - $C loan-ho to auction2 Decree set aside-even then !ona fide purchaser to !e protected.

%udgment&'rder - BR)* - C No. ,8=8 of 188 %udgment&'rder Dated - #&#&00= at (llaha!ad.

*itle - %alesh 3hatia (nd 'rs. /s. .$.S.C. (nd 'rs.


7#7. Headline Summary - transit fee is paya!le on stone !allast2 ;handa and !oulder if they cross the forest during transportation

%udgment&'rder - BR)* - C No. ,877 of 007 %udgment&'rder Dated - #&#&00= at (llaha!ad.

*itle - (sho" ;umar (nandani (nd 'thers /s. State 'f .$. (nd 'thers

Coram - Hon!le R.;. (graal2%. and Hon!le Saro: 3ala2%.

7#= Headline Summary - Consolidation authorities have :urisdiction to provide cha" road nali etc to an individual tenure holder



7#=. Headline Summary Consolidation authorities have :urisdiction to provide cha" road2nali etc to an individual tenure holder

%udgment&'rder - BR)* - 3 No. 1#487 of 18# %udgment&'rder Dated - &#&00= at (llaha!ad.

*itle - (sha Ram 6isra and others /s. *he %t. Director of Consoliation and another


7#,. Headline Summary - Brit $etition against )C' is not maintaina!le. Reference ansered.%udgment&'rder - BR)* - ( No. 11810 of 000 %udgment&'rder Dated - 1&#&00= at (llaha!ad.

*itle - %yoti ;umar 6alviya /s. )...C.'. Ltd.2 A others2 $hoolpur pro:ect2 $hoolpur2 (llaha!ad


7#. Headline Summary - $ (ct No.1# of 18,- 'ccupation after %uly 18,= ithout allotment order-No regularisation u&s 14-

/acancy rightly deemed.

%udgment&'rder - BR)* - ( No. 78= of 1881 %udgment&'rder Dated - 10&#&00= at (llaha!ad.

*itle - Sira: (hmad /s. R.C.


7#8. Headline Summary - Guantum of punishment-no interference-B.$. dismissed.

%udgment&'rder - BR)* - ( No. #4=08 of 000 %udgment&'rder Dated - 10&#&00= at (llaha!ad.

*itle - Charan Singh /s. State 'f .$. A 'thers


740. Headline Summary - Rule 8-(2 $ 6inor 6inerals IConcessionJ Rules2 18=#2 having !een declared ultra vires2 no !enefit can

!e claimed under the lease sanctioned

%udgment&'rder - BR)* - C No. 77 of 00= %udgment&'rder Dated - ,&#&00= at (llaha!ad.

*itle - Ra:an Nishad (nd 'thers /s. State 'f .$. (nd 'thers


741 Headline Summary - Crl Revision dismissed on merits ithout hearing revisionist cannot !e restored



741. Headline Summary Crl.Revision dismissed on merits ithout hearing revisionist cannot !e restored.

%udgment&'rder - CR)6)N(L R+/)S)'N No. 1871 of 188 %udgment&'rder Dated - =&#&00= at (llaha!ad.

*itle - (nand Saroop A 'thers /s. State 'f .$. A (nother


74. Headline Summary - Refusal of Regularisation of Daily Bages +mployees of Cooperative 3an"s.%udgment&'rder - S$+C)(L ($$+(L No. 10= of 007 %udgment&'rder Dated - #&#&00= at (llaha!ad.

*itle - /inita Singh A 'thers /s. State 'f .$. A 'thers


74#. Headline Summary - %udgment in the matter of dis>ualification of 3S$ 6L(s

%udgment&'rder - 6)SC. 3+NCH No. 707 of 00# %udgment&'rder Dated - &&00= at Luc"no.

*itle - Sami $rasad 6aurya2 6.L.(. /s. Spea"er Legislative (ssem!ly .$. A 40 'rs.

Coram - Hon!le (:oy Nath Ray2Chief %ustice 2 Hon!le %agdish 3halla2%. and Hon!le $radeep ;ant2%.744. Headline Summary - Levy of royalty on ordinary earth upheld and contractors are lia!le to pay royalty on ordinary earth

%udgment&'rder - BR)* - C No. 4,,74 of 007 %udgment&'rder Dated - &&00= at (llaha!ad.

*itle - 6&S %.;. Construction +ngineers A Contractor A 'thers /s. nion 'f )ndia *hru Secy 6ines (nd 6ineral (nd 'thers


747. Headline Summary - *he Court must allo the electoral process to go first and then2 if proper2 upset the elections2 if goodgrounds can !e given

%udgment&'rder - BR)* - C No. 11#8# of 00= %udgment&'rder Dated - ,&&00= at (llaha!ad.

*itle - Chandra Narayan *ripathi (lias Chandoo /s. *he Registrar2 Socieities2 irms and Chits and 'thers

Coram - Hon!le (:oy Nath Ray2%. 2 Hon!le (:ay ;umar <og2%. 2 Hon!le <atindra Singh2%. 2 Hon!le Sushil Har"auli2%. and Hon!le

*arun (garala2%.

74=. Headline Summary - Second (ppeal-(dmitted-Steps for notices not ta"en-Second (ppeal Dismissed



74=. Headline Summary Second (ppeal (dmitted Steps for notices not ta"en Second (ppeal Dismissed

%udgment&'rder - S+C'ND ($$+(L No. , of 18# %udgment&'rder Dated - 4&&00= at (llaha!ad.

*itle - Satya Narain 6isra /s. 6&S2Sardar inance Corp.


74,. Headline Summary - n!ro"en identity of holding and not of individual plot to !e considered to treat it as ancestral%udgment&'rder - BR)* - 3 No. 7, of 18,# %udgment&'rder Dated - &&00= at (llaha!ad.

*itle - Ram Dhari /s. D.D.C.


74. Headline Summary - Second (ppeal-Sole plaintiff-appellant dead-Su!stitition (ppln.dismissedu&Ch E)) R4-Second (ppeal


%udgment&'rder - S+C'ND ($$+(L No. == of 184 %udgment&'rder Dated - 0&&00= at (llaha!ad.

*itle - *he Nagar $ali"a /s. /inodi Lal


748. Headline Summary - Hy!rid mode of promotion or (c>uiescence -B$ dismissed

%udgment&'rder - BR)* - ( No. #8#7 of 00# %udgment&'rder Dated - 1=&&00= at (llaha!ad.

*itle - R.;. $andey /s. *he Ne )ndia (ssurance Company Ltd. (nd 'thers


770. Headline Summary - Serious challenge to :urisdiction2 court fee suits maintaina!ility should !e decided first.

%udgment&'rder - )RS* ($$+(L R'6 'RD+R No. #41 of 004 %udgment&'rder Dated - 17&&00= at (llaha!ad.

*itle - (run ;umar *iari /s. Smt. Deepa Sharma A 'thers


771. Headline Summary - resh rit for same relief or for eecution of order passed in earlier rit not maintaina!le.

%udgment&'rder - BR)* - C No. 140, of 00= %udgment&'rder Dated - 17&&00= at (llaha!ad.



%udg e &' de B C No. 0, o 00= %udg e &' de a ed 7& & 00= a a a!ad.

*itle - ;rishna ;umar /s. State 'f .$. (nd 'thers


77. Headline Summary - 6ining leases granted under R.8( cannot !e reneed after 3 :udgment in 001I1J S(5 4,7.

%udgment&'rder - BR)* - C No. #701 of 004 %udgment&'rder Dated - 17&&00= at (llaha!ad.*itle - 5opal $rasad 5upt /s. State 'f .$.(nd 'thers


77#. Headline Summary - +ntry o!tained !y fraud epunged eparte proper course is to give post decisional hearing

%udgment&'rder - BR)* - 3 No. =7 of 00# %udgment&'rder Dated - 10&&00= at (llaha!ad.

*itle - Ra"esh A 'thers /s. Collector A 'thers


774. Headline Summary - Crl. *rial- *a"ing of addl. evidence can !e alloed in suita!lae cases even in appeal%udgment&'rder - CR)6)N(L R+/)S)'N No. 1,88 of 18= %udgment&'rder Dated - 10&&00= at (llaha!ad.

*itle - 6ool Chand /s. State


777. Headline Summary - Crl *rial-Sentence lenient vie to !e ta"en considering long gap !eteen date of incident and :t

%udgment&'rder - CR)6)N(L R+/)S)'N No. 11 of 18= %udgment&'rder Dated - 10&&00= at (llaha!ad.

*itle - $rem $al /s. State 'f .$.


77=. Headline Summary - (ccused has a right to summon relevant evidence at the stage of defence.

%udgment&'rder - ($$L)C(*)'N &s 4 No. 1781 of 00= %udgment&'rder Dated - 10&&00= at (llaha!ad.

*itle - 6ano: ;umar Sami /s. State 'f .$.



:


77,. Headline Summary - Case &s 487 ).$.C. cannot proceed on charge sheet- proper procedure to file complaint

%udgment&'rder - ($$L)C(*)'N &s 4 No. 1= of 00= %udgment&'rder Dated - 10&&00= at (llaha!ad.

*itle - Ram Saroop A (nother /s. State 'f .$. A (nother Coram - Hon!le Raghunath ;ishore Rastogi2%.

77. Headline Summary - Dismissal order of 3an" employee on serious charges is not disproportionate. B.$. Dismissed.

%udgment&'rder - BR)* - ( No. 41#1 of 188, %udgment&'rder Dated - &&00= at (llaha!ad.

*itle - /irendra ;umar 3harda: /s. Syndicate 3an" *hr. Chairman (nd 6.D. A 'thers


778. Headline Summary - Crl.*rial-(ccused to !e summoned relying upon unre!utted prosecution evidence.

%udgment&'rder - ($$L)C(*)'N &s 4 No. ,10 of 007 %udgment&'rder Dated - &&00= at (llaha!ad.*itle - Suresh Shahi A (nother /s. State 'f .$. A (nother


7=0. Headline Summary - Cr.*rial-$endency of civil suit no !ar to crl. proceedings.

%udgment&'rder - ($$L)C(*)'N &s 4 No. 4#80 of 001 %udgment&'rder Dated - &&00= at (llaha!ad.

*itle - Chhedi Lal ;edia A 'thers /s. State 'f .$. A (nother


7=1. Headline Summary - Crl. *rial-Cross case to !e heard A decided !y the same court.

%udgment&'rder - ($$L)C(*)'N &s 4 No. 1=,8 of 004 %udgment&'rder Dated - &&00= at (llaha!ad.

*itle - Ravi Shan"ar /s. State 'f .$. (nd (nother




g g 2

7=. Headline Summary - crl.*rial-Defence evidence not to !e summoned at the time of charge.

%udgment&'rder - ($$L)C(*)'N &s 4 No. 84=1 of 007 %udgment&'rder Dated - &&00= at (llaha!ad.

*itle - 6ahesh /s. State 'f .$. (nd (nother

Coram - Hon!le Raghunath ;ishore Rastogi2%.7=#. Headline Summary - Second (ppeal filed on 0.1.187-*ri!unal esta!lished on 1.11.7 under (dministrative *ri!unals

(ct2187-Second (ppeal dismissed as not maintains!le.

%udgment&'rder - S+C'ND ($$+(L No. #07 of 187 %udgment&'rder Dated - ,&&00= at (llaha!ad.

*itle - nion 'f )ndia /s. Dr./isha /eer


7=4. Headline Summary - (rt.4#-* intra viresQ S.8-(I7J26unicipalities (ct ultra viresQ Rules = A =-( illegal A invalid

%udgment&'rder - BR)* - C No. 4, of 001 %udgment&'rder Dated - =&&00= at (llaha!ad.

*itle - Heera Lal mar (nd (nr. /s. State 'f .$.


7=7. Headline Summary - $ost decisional hearing.$etitioner failed to sho any defect in impugned orders.No interference

%udgment&'rder - BR)* - 3 No. 1#00 of 004 %udgment&'rder Dated - #1&1&00= at (llaha!ad.

*itle - Ram Narain /s. D.6. A 'thers


7==. Headline Summary - )llegality at stage of Sec. A ( $rovisional Consolidation Scheme rightly directed to !e reframed

%udgment&'rder - BR)* - 3 No. 1787 of 000 %udgment&'rder Dated - ,&1&00= at (llaha!ad.

*itle - Sundar Lal (nd (nother /s. D.D.C. (nd 'thers


7=,. Headline Summary - $ *rade *a (ct S.8 Refund. No specific order for refund is re>uired.



y p >

%udgment&'rder - BR)* *(E No. 1=17 of 00 %udgment&'rder Dated - 18&1&00= at (llaha!ad.

*itle - 6&S Reva +nviro Systems $. Ltd.2 3areilly /s. State 'f .$. A 'thers

Coram - Hon!le (:ay ;umar <og2%. and Hon!le $ra"ash ;rishna2%.

7=. Headline Summary - Second (ppeal- compromise verified !y the Court- decided in terms of compromise.%udgment&'rder - S+C'ND ($$+(L No. ###0 of 18 %udgment&'rder Dated - 1&1&00= at (llaha!ad.

*itle - Noor (hmad /s. )fti"aruddin


7=8. Headline Summary - Dealer having opted for composition cannot resile from lia!ility for no turnover.

%udgment&'rder - BR)* *(E No. 7 of 1884 %udgment&'rder Dated - 1#&1&00= at (llaha!ad.

*itle - 6&S 3hadauria 5ram Sea Sansthan /s. (sstt. Commissioner Sales *a (llaha!ad A 'thers

Coram - Hon!le R.;. (graal2%. 2 Hon!le $ra"ash ;rishna2%. and Hon!le ;ailash Nath ':ha2%.7,0. Headline Summary - (ppointment on the !asis of false caste certificate is void. $etition dismissed.

%udgment&'rder - BR)* - ( No. 8# of 1884 %udgment&'rder Dated - 1&1&00= at (llaha!ad.

*itle - 3.S. Negi /s. 5eneral 6anager Syndicate 3an" (nd 'thers


7,1. Headline Summary - $arties to dispute agree to a!ide !y statement of itness.Decision on such statement.No illegality

%udgment&'rder - BR)* - 3 No. ##0 of 18,4 %udgment&'rder Dated - 10&1&00= at (llaha!ad.

*itle - 6st. 6ahara:i /s. (.D.C. A 'rs


7,. Headline Summary - Second (ppeal -sole plaintiff-appellant died. No Su!stitution (pplication filed. Second (ppeal stands

dismised as a!ated.

%udgment&'rder - S+C'ND ($$+(L No. 1 of 181 %udgment&'rder Dated - 8&1&00= at (llaha!ad.



*itle - 3undeo Devi /s. Ra: 3ahadur


7,#. Headline Summary - $CH (ct - S. 4 - Direct revision against order of (C' A C' is maintaina!le !efore the DDC

%udgment&'rder - BR)* - 3 No. 107= of 00 %udgment&'rder Dated - =&1&00= at (llaha!ad.*itle - au:dar /s. *he D.D.C.2 (amgarh (nd 'thers

Coram - Hon!le (:ay ;umar <og2%. and Hon!le $ra"ash ;rishna2%.

7,4. Headline Summary - *he last dran pay of the persons ac>uiring disa!ility during service has to !e protected.

%udgment&'rder - BR)* - ( No. 8 of 004 %udgment&'rder Dated - 4&1&00= at (llaha!ad.

*itle - nion 'f )ndia (nd 'thers /s. 6ohd. 6o!in ;han (nd (nother


7,7. Headline Summary - 70T 6ohammadan >uota for the $.5. 6edical Courses in (6 is unconstitutional and impermissi!le.

%udgment&'rder - S$+C)(L ($$+(L No. 1#1 of 007 %udgment&'rder Dated - &1&007 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - (ligarh 6uslim niversity2 (ligarh *hrough )ts /.C. /s. 6alay Shu"la A 'thers


7,=. Headline Summary - .$. r!an Local Self 5overnment Las I(mendmentJ (ct2 007 is a valid piece of legislation

%udgment&'rder - BR)* - C No. ,#087 of 007 %udgment&'rder Dated - &1&007 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - (nugrah Narain Singh /s. State 'f .$. (nd 'thers


7,,. Headline Summary - Change in constitution of the firm under )ncome *a (ct eplained Ref. ansered in favour of Revenue

%udgment&'rder - )NC'6+ *(E R++R+NC+ No. 14# of 1881 %udgment&'rder Dated - 1=&1&007 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - C.).*. /s. 6&S S.6.S. Nath



Coram - Hon!le (:ay ;umar <og2%. and Hon!le Dilip 5upta2%.

7,. Headline Summary - Long standing entry in the revenue record ithout possession does not confir any right !y estopple

%udgment&'rder - BR)* - 3 No. 78 of 18,, %udgment&'rder Dated - 17&1&007 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - (cchai!ar (nd 'rs. /s. D.D.C. (nd 'rs.Coram - Hon!le ;rishna 6urari2%.

7,8. Headline Summary - (ppointment not in accordance ith Sec. 1 of the Secondary +ducation 3oard (ct- !ad- B$- dismissed

%udgment&'rder - BR)* - ( No. 17881 of 1888 %udgment&'rder Dated - &1&007 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - 6anvendra $ratap Singh /s. State 'f .$. A 'thers


70. Headline Summary - Higher authorities to accept recommendation of 3.6.-unless any material to the contrary

%udgment&'rder - BR)* - ( No. 47=#0 of 00# %udgment&'rder Dated - 1&1&007 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - 6ahendra ;umar 5upta /s. *he 5eneral 6anager I$ension DepttJ. Central 3an" 'f )ndia

Coram - Hon!le /i"ram Nath2%.

71. Headline Summary - Rent can !e enhanced for the period stay order has !een en:oyed !y the tenant

%udgment&'rder - BR)* - ( No. 14=# of 18# %udgment&'rder Dated - 1&1&007 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - %han:hi Ram /s. )v (d: (nd 'thers


7. Headline Summary - irearms licence holder to deposit arms upon suspension of licence. Reference ansered.

%udgment&'rder - BR)* - C No. #4#4 of 00# %udgment&'rder Dated - 1&1&007 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - Shafat ;han /s. State 'f .$. A 'thers




7#. Headline Summary - 6onthly deposit of rent under 'rder E/ Rule 7 C$C in same Court here suit is filed.Ref. ansered

%udgment&'rder - BR)* - ( No. 4#,#4 of 001 %udgment&'rder Dated - #0&11&007 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - Haider (!!as /s. (ddl. District %udge2 (llaha!ad A 'thers

Coram - Hon!le 3.S. Chauhan2%. and Hon!le Dilip 5upta2%.74. Headline Summary - 6os>uito 6ats are insecticides for the purposes of imposing ta. Brit $etition alloed.

%udgment&'rder - BR)* *(E No. 114 of 007 %udgment&'rder Dated - 7&11&007 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - 6&S ;night Gueen )ndustries I$J Ltd /s. State 'f .$. *hru )nstitutional inance Secy. A 'thers

Coram - Hon!le (:ay ;umar <og2%. and Hon!le Dilip 5upta2%.

77. Headline Summary - *eacher not possessing >ualification on date of occurence of vacancy-not eligi!le for promotion.

%udgment&'rder - S$+C)(L ($$+(L No. 1044 of 188, %udgment&'rder Dated - &11&007 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - )>ramul Ha> /s. 6ohd. Sa!ir A 'thers

Coram - Hon!le Syed Rafat (lam2%. and Hon!le /i"ram Nath2%.

7=. Headline Summary - *emporary employee-no right to post order not stigmatic

%udgment&'rder - BR)* - ( No. 81 of 188, %udgment&'rder Dated - 1&11&007 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - Rohit ;umar /s. 6u"hya Nagar (dhi"ari A 'thers


7,. Headline Summary - Reservation :udgement dated 7.10.007 partly stayed in Special (ppeal

%udgment&'rder - S$+C)(L ($$+(L No. 1#0 of 007 %udgment&'rder Dated - 10&11&007 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - State 'f .$. A 'thers /s. Hari Ram <adav

Coram - Hon!le Syed Rafat (lam2%. and Hon!le Sudhir (garal2%.

7. Headline Summary - $ $CSI%J +am 00# - $artly >uashed




*itle - Dinesh $ratap Singh (nd 'thers /s. State 'f .$. (nd 'thers

Coram - Hon!le Sushil Har"auli2%. and Hon!le 5anga $rasad Srivastava2%.

78. Headline Summary - Land (c>uisition (ct- 7T deduction from compensation for development of ac>uired land%udgment&'rder - )RS* ($$+(L No. = of 188 %udgment&'rder Dated - 1&10&007 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - ;..6.S. /s. 3ishan Dass A 'thers


780. Headline Summary - )ndependent feeder consumer - lia!le 17T surcharge in case of use during restrictive hours

%udgment&'rder - )RS* ($$+(L R'6 'RD+R No. 4= of 007 %udgment&'rder Dated - 1&10&007 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - 6&S Northern Coalfields Ltd /s. Chairman A 6.D.2 .$.C.L. A (nother


781. Headline Summary - Candidate claiming reserved category can not !e considered in the general category


*itle - Hari Ram <adav /s. State of .$. A 'thers

Coram - Hon!le Sunil (m!ani2%.

78. Headline Summary - %udicial revie of order fresh allotment of plots !y Committee en>uiry !y C3)

%udgment&'rder - BR)* - C No. 4, of 007 %udgment&'rder Dated - 4&10&007 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - Deepa" Sharma /s. State 'f .$. (nd 'thers


78#. Headline Summary - Reservation on the !asis of religion for 6uslims in (6 - >uashed

%udgment&'rder - BR)* - C No. 17704 of 007 %udgment&'rder Dated - 4&10&007 at (llaha!ad.



*itle - Dr. Naresh (garal /s. nion 'f )ndia *hru Secy. 6inistry 'f Human A 'thers

Coram - Hon!le (run *andon2%.

784. Headline Summary - Contempt of Courts (ct2 18,1-no contempt- $etition !arred under Sec 0

%udgment&'rder - C'N*+6$* ($$L)C(*)'N IC)/)LJ No. ,81 of 007 %udgment&'rder Dated - ,&8&007 at (llaha!ad.*itle - 3alant /idyapeeth Rural )nstitute *hru )ts $rincipal /s. Shri Dev Ra: Singh


787. Headline Summary - Negligence -6(C$ claim passenger shifted from one 3us to another 3us

%udgment&'rder - )RS* ($$+(L R'6 'RD+R No. 4 of 18,, %udgment&'rder Dated - #1&&007 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - .$.State Road *ransport Corporation /s. Smt. Rani Srivastava and others


78=. Headline Summary - Brit against C3S+ maintaina!le !ut not against the schools affiliated to C3S+

%udgment&'rder - BR)* - ( No. 10# of 000 %udgment&'rder Dated - #0&&007 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - 6.;. 5andhi A 'thers /s. Director 'f +ducation L"o.A 'thers

Coram - Hon!le <atindra Singh2%. 2 Hon!le Sunil (m!ani2%. and Hon!le Devendra $ratap Singh2%.

78,. Headline Summary - H6 (ct S 8-$laintiff failed to produce !est evidence to prove marriage - adverse inference dran

%udgment&'rder - )RS* ($$+(L R'6 'RD+R No. 7 of 188 %udgment&'rder Dated - 1&&007 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - Smt.Sure"ha and another /s. %itendra alias Deshpal


78. Headline Summary - Distance learning Centres can !e esta!lished in accordance ith (ct&Statutes

%udgment&'rder - BR)* - C No. 4,7 of 007 %udgment&'rder Dated - 7&,&007 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - (llaha!ad College 'f +ngineering A 6anagement A 'thers /s. His +cellency *he Chancellor 6.%.$. Rohil"hand niv.




788. Headline Summary - )ndian Succession (ct2 187-*estamentary Case-Non-contentious matter-alloed

%udgment&'rder - *+S*(6+N*(R< C(S+S No. 8 of 004 %udgment&'rder Dated - 0&,&007 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - )n *he 6atter 'f Late Su"h Ram K Rama Shan"ar /s. UUCoram - Hon!le Satya $oot 6ehrotra2%.

=00. Headline Summary - Reservation- applies to the cadre and not to the vacancies

%udgment&'rder - BR)* - ( No. 4,# of 001 %udgment&'rder Dated - =&7&007 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - Shridhar Divedi /s. State 'f .$. A 'thers


=01. Headline Summary - $arole of dai 3han Singh 6L( stayed - +C to inform dis>ualification development

%udgment&'rder - BR)* - C No. 1178 of 007 %udgment&'rder Dated - 4&4&007 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - Sarvesh Narain Shu"la /s. State 'f .$. *hru $rincipal Secy. A 'thers


=0. Headline Summary - Legitimate epectation-:udicial revie of policy

%udgment&'rder - BR)* - C No. 4,7 of 007 %udgment&'rder Dated - #&#&007 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - (.H. Bheeler A Co. $vt. Ltd. /s. nion 'f )ndia A 'thers


=0#. Headline Summary - 5uidelines for appointment of (dministrator in Cooperative Socities - laid don

%udgment&'rder - BR)* - C No. #0 of 004 %udgment&'rder Dated - 1,&#&007 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - C&6 Distt. Coop. 3an" Ltd. *hru Chairman A (nr. /s. State 'f .$. *hru Secy. ICoop.J A 'rs.




=04. Headline Summary - Contempt $etn.-filedin Sept.1887-No order for issuance of notice to o.ps.-Contempt $etn.dismissed as

infructuous.

%udgment&'rder - C'N*+6$* ($$L)C(*)'N IC)/)LJ No. 1#10 of 1887 %udgment&'rder Dated - ,&&007 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - 6ahadeo Ram (nd 'thers /s. Sri Nagendra Rai2 Secretary Distt. Sah"ari ed. (nd 'thers


=07. Headline Summary - Contempt $etition- on the ground of violation of interim order-rit petition dismissed as infructuous-

contempt petition too dismissed as infructuous

%udgment&'rder - C'N*+6$* ($$L)C(*)'N IC)/)LJ No. 8#1 of 1887 %udgment&'rder Dated - &&007 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - 3anshi Lal Chaddha (nd (nother /s. (nil $ra"ash


=0=. Headline Summary - Notice for no confidence motion - not on prescri!ed proforma - not illegal

%udgment&'rder - BR)* - C No. 7847 of 004 %udgment&'rder Dated - &&007 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - Smt. ;rishna %aisal /s. State 'f .$. *hru Secy. $anchayat Ra: A 'thers

Coram - Hon!le <atindra Singh2%. and Hon!le /i:ai Shan"ar 3a:pai2%.

=0,. Headline Summary - Contempt $etn.-Notice issued in 1884 to o.p.No.1-Not received !ac".Contempt $etn. dismissed as

infructuous.

%udgment&'rder - C'N*+6$* ($$L)C(*)'N IC)/)LJ No. ,= of 1884 %udgment&'rder Dated - #&1&007 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - /i"ramaditya Chauhan /s. Smt. Ram Lal Singh (nd (nother

Coram - Hon!le Satya $oot 6ehrotra2%.=0. Headline Summary - Contempt $etn. -violationg of interim order in rit -stay vacation pending of rit sent to ttran.H.C.-

Contempt $etn. dismissed as infructuous.

%udgment&'rder - C'N*+6$* ($$L)C(*)'N IC)/)LJ No. 1 of 1887 %udgment&'rder Dated - #&1&007 at (llaha!ad.



*itle - 3ahadur Singh (nd (nother /s. $.;. Do!hal A 'thers


=08. Headline Summary - Contempt $etition dismissed as infructuous !y lapse of time.

%udgment&'rder - C'N*+6$* ($$L)C(*)'N IC)/)LJ No. 1= of 1887 %udgment&'rder Dated - 14&1&004 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - %ai Ram Singh 5aur /s. ;m. Champa 6ishra


=10. Headline Summary - Contempt $etn.-Reard of rit transferred to ttranachal H.C.-Contempt $etition dismissed as

infurctuous.

%udgment&'rder - C'N*+6$* ($$L)C(*)'N IC)/)LJ No. #4 of 1884 %udgment&'rder Dated - 14&1&004 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - .$. Sinchai ;armcheri $ragetisheel (am /i"as Sangh /s. 3ri:endra 3ihari 6athur


=11. Headline Summary - Contempt $etn.-nature of controversy-continued a!sence of counsel for petitioner-applicant-Contempt$etn.dismissed as infructuous !y lapse of time.

%udgment&'rder - C'N*+6$* ($$L)C(*)'N IC)/)LJ No. 1,, of 1884 %udgment&'rder Dated - 14&1&004 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - Dinesh 3ehari 6athur /s. Sri 3ri:endra Sahai A (nother


=1. Headline Summary - Contempt $etn.-continued a!sence of learned counsel for parties-Contempt $etn.dismissed as infructuous

!y lapse of time.

%udgment&'rder - C'N*+6$* ($$L)C(*)'N IC)/)LJ No. 1=17 of 1887 %udgment&'rder Dated - 14&1&004 at (llaha!ad.*itle - Ra: Dev /s. R" *yagi


=1#. Headline Summary - Senior most teacher not entitle to continue as officiating principle in case of in>uiry against him



%udgment&'rder - BR)* - ( No. 4717 of 004 %udgment&'rder Dated - #0&11&004 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - Dr. 3irendra Singh /s. Director 'f +ducation Higher (nd 'thers


=14. Headline Summary - Contempt $etn.-iled in 6ay21887-Contempt $etn dismissed as infractuous.

%udgment&'rder - C'N*+6$* ($$L)C(*)'N IC)/)LJ No. # of 1887 %udgment&'rder Dated - 1&11&004 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - (!ul 'aiss /s. S.N. Du!ey A 'thers


=17. Headline Summary - Contempt $etn.-Notice to engage another counsel-Returned ith Report-Contempt $etn.dismissed for

ant of prosecution.

%udgment&'rder - C'N*+6$* ($$L)C(*)'N IC)/)LJ No. ,, of 1887 %udgment&'rder Dated - 1&11&004 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - (mar Nath $al /s. Sri dai $al Singh (nd (nother


=1=. Headline Summary - State advised price of sugar cane for crushing season 00#-04 is valid

%udgment&'rder - BR)* - C No. =81 of 004 %udgment&'rder Dated - ,&10&004 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - Best .$. Sugar 6ills (ssociation *hru Secy. A 'rs. /s. State 'f .$. *hru Secy. Sugar )ndustry A 'rs.


=1,. Headline Summary - )mportant >uestion regarding right to information raised

%udgment&'rder - BR)* - C No. #17 of 004 %udgment&'rder Dated - =&&004 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - $eoples nion for Ciil Li!erties2 $ 3ranch /s. +lection Commission of )ndia and others


=1. Headline Summary - Contempt $etn.-Nature of controversy -compliance report-Contempt $etn.dismissed as infructuous.

%udgment&'rder - C'N*+6$* ($$L)C(*)'N IC)/)LJ No. 1#0= of 004 %udgment&'rder Dated - 1&&004 at (llaha!ad.



*itle - (mol Singh /s. Sri N.S. $andey2 )ncharge Commissioner 'f Nagar Nigam A (no


=18. Headline Summary - Bife gang raped - hus!and not entitled to divorce

%udgment&'rder - )RS* ($$+(L No. 104 of 00# %udgment&'rder Dated - 7&&004 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - Ra:esh ;umar Singh /s. Smt. Re"ha Singh A 'thers


=0. Headline Summary - Contempt $etn.-filed in e!.1884-No order passed for issuance of notices--Section 0 Contempt of

Courts (ct218,1 also !arred-Contempt $etn. dismissed.

%udgment&'rder - C'N*+6$* ($$L)C(*)'N IC)/)LJ No. # of 1884 %udgment&'rder Dated - 1&4&004 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - $rem Navain 5upta /s. R.;. ;hanna A 'thers


=1. Headline Summary - Contempt $etition-'rder complied ith-Delay neither ilful nor deli!erate-sho cause noticedischarged-$etition disposed of.

%udgment&'rder - C'N*+6$* ($$L)C(*)'N IC)/)LJ No. 11,1 of 188# %udgment&'rder Dated - 1&#&004 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - 6.(hmad /s. H.;.*iari


=. Headline Summary - Contempt $etition-'rder complied ith-Delay neither ilfuil nor deli!erate-sho cause notice

discharged-Contempt $etition stands disposed of.

%udgment&'rder - C'N*+6$* ($$L)C(*)'N IC)/)LJ No. 81 of 188# %udgment&'rder Dated - 4&&004 at (llaha!ad.*itle - C&6.%.).Collage /s. ;arnail Singh


=#. Headline Summary - Contempt $etition-'rder complied ith-No contempt-sho cause notices discharged.



%udgment&'rder - C'N*+6$* ($$L)C(*)'N IC)/)LJ No. ,71 of 188# %udgment&'rder Dated - 7&&004 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - $.N.Singh /s. 3.;.Nair A 'thers


=4. Headline Summary - ;hud"ast land su!merged in river on the date of vesting - No right under Famindari (!olition (ct

%udgment&'rder - BR)* - 3 No. 18# of 18,# %udgment&'rder Dated - ,&1&004 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - 6ohiuddin /s. 3.R.


=7. Headline Summary - (ppointment on long leave of more than 10 months - only Commission can appoint

%udgment&'rder - BR)* - ( No. 4414 of 00 %udgment&'rder Dated - 17&8&00# at (llaha!ad.

*itle - Dr. $ra"ash Chandra ;am!o: /s. C&62 3areilly College2 3areilly A 'thers

Coram - Hon!le <atindra Singh2%. and Hon!le 6u"teshar $rasad2%.

==. Headline Summary - Circumstances - hen compromise decree inecuta!le

%udgment&'rder - BR)* - C No. 880 of 000 %udgment&'rder Dated - #&7&00# at (llaha!ad.

*itle - 3ri: 6ohan ;apoor /s. Evi (d: 6eerut A 'thers


=,. Headline Summary - +clusive property - hen can !e divided u&s , of the Hindu 6arriage (ct

%udgment&'rder - )RS* ($$+(L No. 7 of 188 %udgment&'rder Dated - 14&7&00# at (llaha!ad.

*itle - Sri Hemant ;umar (grahari A (nother /s. Smt. La"shmi Devi A (nother


=. Headline Summary - *he decision of ar!itrator regarding ecepted matter - not final

%udgment&'rder - )RS* ($$+(L R'6 'RD+R No. 40 of 188# %udgment&'rder Dated - 8&4&00# at (llaha!ad.



*itle - nion 'f )ndia A (nother /s. 6&S 6adnani Construction Corp. $. Ltd. A (nother


=8. Headline Summary - $ (ct No.1# of 18,-Section IJI1JI!!!J-Ba>f $roperty not recorded in the 6unicipal record

%udgment&'rder - BR)* - ( No. 1748 of 00# %udgment&'rder Dated - ,&1&00# at (llaha!ad.

*itle - 6ohd. Sa!ir ISince DeceasedJ A 'thers /s. 6ohd. )rshad A 'thers


=#0. Headline Summary - Brit petition can !e decided on the !asis of compromise

%udgment&'rder - S+C'ND ($$+(L No. 1,1 of 000 %udgment&'rder Dated - 14&7&00 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - Surendra Nath Rai (nd (nother /s. $rahlad Singh (nd 'thers


=#1. Headline Summary - $rinciples of 5ood management and good (dministration - discussed

%udgment&'rder - BR)* - ( No. 1=,8 of 1888 %udgment&'rder Dated - 7&&001 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - Net Singh /s. La!our Secy.2 .$. Shasan L"o. A 'thers


=#. Headline Summary - Delay caused pre:udice - )ndustrial dispute can not !e raised

%udgment&'rder - BR)* - C No. 144=4 of 188 %udgment&'rder Dated - 7&&1888 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - 6ea Lal /s. State 'f .$. A 'thers


=##. Headline Summary - Stamp duty - on value on the date of eecution of the deed and not on the date of the decree

%udgment&'rder - BR)* - C No. #4#7 of 1880 %udgment&'rder Dated - ,&7&1888 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - Smt. Har $yari /s. D.R.

C !l i d d !l i d Si h



Coram - Hon!le 3inod ;umar Roy2%. and Hon!le <atindra Singh2%.

=#4. Headline Summary - Death in police custody - State to prove that it is not negligent

%udgment&'rder - BR)* - C No. 101= of 1887 %udgment&'rder Dated - ,&7&1888 at (llaha!ad.

*itle - Smt.Shahin ;han A (nother /s. #rd (.D.%.2;anpur Nagar A 'thers

Coram - Hon!le 3inod ;umar Roy2%. and Hon!le <atindra Singh2%.

allahabad high court afr-landmark judgments-orders

Documents