8/7/2019 All is not yet lost

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/all-is-not-yet-lost 1/2

Sunday, October 11, 2009

All is not yet lost

Dr. Nasim Ashraf

Gen. Stanley A. McChrystalʹs report told us what we were afraid to hear. We are going to lose

the war in Afghanistan! President Obamaʹs Afghanistan-Pakistan policy, launched just in March

whose main goal was to disrupt, dismantle and defeat al Qaeda, doesnʹt seem to be going well.

Growing insurgency and a totally ineffective and discredited government in Afghanistan pose

lethal threats that can result in Americaʹs total defeat unless something is done immediately.

I agree with Gen. McChrystal that more troops may be needed presently. However, before

additional troops are sent to Afghanistan, there must be a clear operational strategy as well as a

political surge. Military victory is not possible, and the path of extended military engagement is

a recipe for disaster.

But simply abandoning the region is also not an option. This would be the same mistake the

United States made in 1989 afer helping to expel the Soviet army from Afghanistan.

The sooner Afghanistan is stabilized politically, the earlier the United States can disengage

militarily. How does America do that?

Initiate a political dialogue with the various Pashtun leaders in Afghanistan and the Taliban but

also enlist the help of their tribal cousins in Pakistan. Pakistan would welcome such a move and

defi

nitely would assist, as it is entirely in Pakistanʹ

s interest to have peace in Afghanistan.

The political instability and ethnic imbalance brought about in Afghanistan afer Sept. 11, 2001,

when the U.S. essentially outsourced the country to the Northern Alliance - comprised of the

minority groups of Tajiks, Uzbeks and Hazaras - marginalized the Pashtuns and pushed them

into the Taliban fold even though the Pashtuns were not ideological supporters of Taliban.

Hamid Karzai, although a Pashtun, was never accepted by the Pashtuns as their legitimate

representative, as he was an outsider and did nothing to stop the disenfranchisement of the

ington Times - All is not yet lost http://www.washingtontimes.com/news/2009/oct/11/all-is-not-yet-l

10/19/2009 1

8/7/2019 All is not yet lost

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/all-is-not-yet-lost 2/2

Pashtuns. When his defense minister and later his running mate in the recent elections,

Mohammad Qasim Fahim, a Tajik warlord, raised 80,000 troops for the Afghan National Army,

it had hardly any Pashtun representation. This created resentment and forced the Pashtuns to

seek jobs with the Taliban and other local warlords.

All Taliban may be Pashtuns, but all Pashtuns are not Taliban. While the majority of Pashtuns are

fighting alongside the Taliban against the U.S. and coalition forces, they are not ideologically

aligned with, nor do they support the Taliban. For them, it is a mater of custom and tradition to

fight against any outsider.

For starters, as part of the new political strategy, a U.N. peacekeeping mission comprising

troops from Muslim countries such as Turkey, Bangladesh and Indonesia could be deployed in

Afghanistan. This would create a sense of confidence among the Afghans and also preclude the

need for more and more U.S. troops in the future. Simultaneously, the Afghan army must be

strengthened and ethnically balanced by recruiting at least 50,000 Pashtuns from various tribes.Not only would this create jobs for these people, but it would go a long way in winning the

hearts and minds of the Pashtuns as well.

A political solution is the only option. Talks with the Taliban can be facilitated indirectly through

allies and friendly countries of the region and the Middle East. As Mr. Obama once said, ʺIt is

not about saving face.ʺ

Afghanistan is at a critical juncture. Whatever decision is made by Mr. Obama, it will have

far-reaching effects and long-term consequences, not only for Afghanistan and neighboring

countries of the region, but for the entire world. While vital U.S. national security objectives

must be achieved by eliminating all threats to America from Afghanistan and the region, the

Afghan people must be allowed to establish their own political government with representation

from all ethnic groups in a fair and representative manner. That would be the first step to

removing the political vacuum of governance and leadership in Afghanistan that creates more

space for the insurgents and al Qaeda.

Nation-building is best done by the people of that country. Friends can only assist and provide

support.

Dr. Nasim Ashraf is the executive director of the Center for Pakistan Studies, Middle East Institute,

and former minister in the Musharraf administration in Pakistan.

Ads by Google Iraq Afghanistan War Afghan New Afghan Taliban Karzai Taliban Hazara

ington Times - All is not yet lost http://www.washingtontimes.com/news/2009/oct/11/all-is-not-yet-l

10/19/2009 1