alexander j. smith, barry p. baldigo, mike r. mchale
DESCRIPTION
Assessing the effects of Hurricane Irene on benthic macroinvertebrate communities in the Upper Esopus Creek. Alexander J. Smith, Barry P. Baldigo, Mike R. McHale. New York State Department of Environmental Conservation. Outline. Project Background - PowerPoint PPT PresentationTRANSCRIPT
Assessing the effects of Hurricane Irene on benthic macroinvertebrate communities in
the Upper Esopus CreekAlexander J. Smith, Barry P. Baldigo, Mike R.
McHale
New York State Department of Environmental Conservation
OutlineProject Background
“Quantitative Assessment of Water Quality in the Upper Esopus Creek: fish, macroinvertebrates, periphyton, turbidity and nutrients”
Response to Hurricane IreneCurrent ResultsNext steps
New York State Department of Environmental Conservation
Upper Esopus Creek ProjectObjectives
Assess water quality and identify sources of: Turbidity Nutrients
Quantify the impacts of: Shandaken Portal Village of Phoenicia (septic systems) Turbidity and Nutrients
Methods 20 sites in August 2009, 2010, and 2011 Biological communities Water chemistries and discharge
New York State Department of Environmental Conservation
Precipitation
August 29
August 28
New York State Department of Environmental Conservation
Hurricane Irene FloodingFlood recurrence
interval was 100-500 years
Irene ~ 80,000 cfsAve. ~ 300 cfs
One of the worst in recorded history for the Esopus Creek drainage
IreneLee
Pre-Irene Post-Irene
New York State Department of Environmental Conservation
Sampling Month
Aug-2009 Aug-2010 Aug-2011 Sept-2011 Nov-2011
Bio
logi
cal A
sses
smen
t Pro
file
Sco
re (B
AP
)
0.0
2.5
5.0
7.5
10.0Non-impacted
Slightly Impacted
Moderately Impacted
Severely Impacted
Condition Assessment - BAP
Multimetric Spp. RichnessEPT RichnessBiotic IndexModel Affinity
Sampling Month
Aug-2009 Aug-2010 Aug-2011 Sept-2011 Nov-2011
Spe
cies
Ric
hnes
s
0
10
20
30
40
50
Sampling Month
Aug-2009 Aug-2010 Aug-2011 Sept-2011 Nov-2011
Hils
enho
ff's
Bio
tic In
dex
(HB
I)
0
2
4
6
8
10Sampling Month
Aug-2009 Aug-2010 Aug-2011 Sept-2011 Nov-2011
May
fly/S
tone
fly/C
addi
sfly
Ric
hnes
s (E
PT)
0
5
10
15
20
25
Sampling Month
Aug-2009 Aug-2010 Aug-2011 Sept-2011 Nov-2011
Per
cent
Mod
el A
ffini
ty (P
MA
)
0
20
40
60
80
100
Sample Processing Effort
Sampling Month
Aug-2009 Aug-2010 Aug-2011 Sept-2011 Nov-2011
Per
cent
of S
ampl
e S
orte
d
0
20
40
60
80
100
Transform: Log(X+1)Resemblance: S17 Bray Curtis similarity
MonthAugNovSept
Similarity20
2D Stress: 0.21
Community Structure
Transform: Log(X+1)Resemblance: S17 Bray Curtis similarity
Acentrella turbida
0.4
1.6
2.8
4
AugAug
Nov
SeptAug
Aug
Nov Sept
Aug
Aug
Nov Sept
Aug
Aug
NovSept
Aug
Aug
Aug
Nov
Sept
Aug
Aug
AugNov
Sept
Aug
Aug
AugNov
Sept
AugAug
Aug
Nov
Sept
AugAugAug
Nov
Sept
AugAug Aug
Nov
Sept
AugAugAug
Nov
Sept
AugAug
Aug
Nov Sept
AugAug Aug
Nov
Sept
AugAug
Aug
Nov
Sept
AugAug Aug
Nov
SeptAugAug
Aug
Nov
Sept
AugAug
Aug
NovSept
AugAugAug
NovSept
Aug
AugAug
Nov Sept
AugAugAug
NovSept
2D Stress: 0.21
Transform: Log(X+1)Resemblance: S17 Bray Curtis similarity
Baetis flavistriga
0.3
1.2
2.1
3
AugAug
Nov
SeptAug
Aug
Nov Sept
Aug
Aug
Nov Sept
Aug
Aug
NovSept
Aug
Aug
Aug
Nov
Sept
Aug
Aug
AugNov
Sept
Aug
Aug
AugNov
Sept
AugAug
Aug
Nov
Sept
AugAugAug
Nov
Sept
AugAug Aug
Nov
Sept
AugAugAug
Nov
Sept
AugAug
Aug
Nov Sept
AugAug Aug
Nov
Sept
AugAug
Aug
Nov
Sept
AugAug Aug
Nov
SeptAugAug
Aug
Nov
Sept
AugAug
Aug
NovSept
AugAugAug
NovSept
Aug
AugAug
Nov Sept
AugAugAug
NovSept
2D Stress: 0.21
ConclusionsAlthough significant impacts to diversity, the
Upper Esopus is a resilient system
Water quality assessment not necessarily the best indicator of recoveryMultivariate ordination of community data
shows a more complete picture
Monitoring is complete, full analysis and work up by spring/summer 2013