Air Breathing Propulsion JPC Report

45th Joint Propulsion ConferenceDenver, Colorado3 August 2009

Marty Bradley (for Jeff Hamstra)

2

ABPABPABPABP

Agenda for ABP Dinner Meeting

1. Special topic (Lance Chenault)2. Introduction (Marty Bradley for Jeff Hamstra)3. HSABP Summary (Marty Bradley)4. GTE Summary (Rob Bruckner)5. ABPSI (Jeff Flamm for Ray Best)6. Education (Rick Gaeta)7. Awards (Jeff Flamm)8. Communications (Tom Kaemming)9. JPC (Ryan Starkey)10. ASM (D.R.Reddy)

We also have two get well cards being

passed around

3

ABPABPABPABP

Special TopicA Strategy for Aerospace Vehicle Design Research & Development

Lance Chenault

4 Aug 2009 3

4

ABPABPABPABP

Facts and Problem

• Tomorrow’s Air Defense platforms will be multifunctional and highly integrated systems

• Failure to account for interdisciplinary effects have cost, and continue to cost, billions of dollars to correct or else place unintentional operating limits on the systems.

• Interdisciplinary scientific analysis (ISA) required early in product development Long Range Strike, Sensor Craft, flapping micro-UAVs, and

hypersonic vehicles will never be realized without ISA

4 Aug 2009 4

5

ABPABPABPABP

Solution

• National aerospace community develop a strategic plan to identify critical research areas and educational requirements to be addressed.

• Proposed two step solution to involve industry, academia, DoD and other Government agencies.

4 Aug 2009 5

6

ABPABPABPABP

Step One: National Design Build and Test Competition

• AFOSR sponsor an undergraduate / graduate program resulting in a National Design Build and Test Competition.

• Projects would partner academic institutions with industry participants as design consultants.

• Competition would focus and develop the students’ ability to understand and apply the appropriate level fidelity and discipline coupling to predict actual system response of the vehicle they will build and test.

4 Aug 2009 6

7

ABPABPABPABP

Step Two: Interdisciplinary Design Research Centers

• AFOSR lead a team consisting of industry, academia, and Government agencies to develop nation-wide Interdisciplinary Design Research Centers (IDRCs).

• Located at universities in proximity to major industry and government development centers.

• Focus on the research challenges for interdisciplinary science and technology.

• Develop and support a graduate education program to produce scientist and engineers capable of developing multifunctional, highly integrated systems.

4 Aug 2009 7

8

ABPABPABPABP

Summary of Propulsion and Energy Group Meeting (Marty for Jeff Hamstra)

• Tuesday PM Panel Session on Hypersonics• Positions open:

JPC 2011 in San Diego –Technical Program Chair JPC 2012 Technical and General Chair P&E Steering Committee Chair

• AIAA rolling out new conference software for JPC 2010 Training sessions on Monday and Tuesday (see Committee Meeting list)

• Funding at TAC level available for “growth” activities $300-$400 per TC

• Chris Pestak made a nice presentation – Cleveland wants JPC/IECEC in 2014

• Propellants and Combustion wants to liaison with the ABP TC’s

9

ABPABPABPABP

ABP Group Jeff Hamstra

Gas Turbine EnginesRob Bruckner

Air Breathing Propulsion Systems Integration

Ray Best

High Speed Air Breathing Propulsion

Marty Bradley

Common ElementsCommon Elements

CommunicationsTom Kaemming*

Honors & Awards Jeff Flamm*

Aerospace Sciences MeetingD.R. Reddy

Joint Propulsion ConferenceRyan Starkey

MembershipKeith Blodgett*

EducationRick Gaeta

Conferences JPC/ASM

Membership

Liaison

Technical Disciplines

Air Breathing Propulsion Subgroup Organizational Structure

Communications

Education

Honors & Awards

Separate TCsSeparate TCs

Conferences JPC/ASM

Membership

Liaison

Communications

Education

Honors & Awards

Technical Disciplines

Conferences JPC/ASM

Membership

Liaison

Communications

Education

Honors & Awards

*Acting or rotational positionUPDATES?

10

ABPABPABPABP

Introduction

Marty Bradley for Jeff Hamstra

4 Aug 2009 10

11

ABPABPABPABP

ABP Group Jeff Hamstra

Gas Turbine EnginesRob Bruckner

Air Breathing Propulsion Systems Integration

Ray Best

High Speed Air Breathing Propulsion

Marty Bradley

Common ElementsCommon Elements

Communications*Tom Kaemming

John Sordyl

Honors & Awards* Jeff Flamm

Aerospace Sciences MeetingD.R. Reddy

Joint Propulsion ConferenceRyan Starkey

Membership* EducationRick Gaeta

Conferences JPC/ASM

Membership

Liaison

Technical Disciplines

Air Breathing Propulsion Subgroup Organizational Structure

Communications

Education

Honors & Awards

Separate TCsSeparate TCs

Conferences JPC/ASM

Membership

Liaison

Communications

Education

Honors & Awards

Technical Disciplines

Conferences JPC/ASM

Membership

Liaison

Communications

Education

Honors & Awards

*Acting or rotational position

12

ABPABPABPABP

Meetings … lots of meetings …Date Meeting Lead Expected

AttendanceActual

Attendance

Sunday,2 Aug 09

Start Stop

12:00 PM 1:30 PM ABP Steering (Mineral DE) Bradley for Hamstra

20

10

1:30 PM 3:00 PM GTE Steering (Agate) HSABP Steering (Mineral BC)

ABPSI Steering (Mineral FG)

Rob BrucknerMarty BradleyRaymond Best

3 Rooms @ 10 People each

2 / 6 / X

2:30 PM 3:00 PM New Member Orientation (Mineral DE) Keith Blodgett 15

9

3:00 PM 5:00 PM Gas Turbine Engines (Centennial G) High Speed Air Breathing Propulsion (Centennial H)

Air Breathing Propulsion System Integration (Centennial F)

Rob BrucknerMarty BradleyRaymond Best

3 Rooms @ 35 People each

14 / XX / XX

5:00 PM 7:00 PM P&E Group Meeting (Centennial D) TC Chairs N.A.7:00 PM 9:00 PM JPC Reception N.A.

Monday,3 Aug 2009

9:00 AM 10:30 AM ABP Education (Mineral FG) Rick Gaeta 30 12

10:30 AM 12:00 PM ABP Honors & Awards (Mineral BC) Jeff Flamm 30 7

12:00 PM 1:30 PM Lunch Break1:30 PM 3:00 PM ABP Communications (Mineral BC) Tom Kaemming 30

13

3:00 PM 4:00 PM ABP Joint ASM/JPC (Centennial GH) Reddy/Starkey 30

4:00 PM 5:30 PM GTE Splinter (Mineral DE) HSABP Liaison (Mineral FG)

ABPSI Splinter (Mineral BC)

Rob BrucknerMarty BradleyRaymond Best

3 Rooms @ 15 People each

X / 9 / X

7:00 PM 10:00 PM ABP Dinner Meeting (Centennial DE) Bradley for Hamstra

100

All members should attend these meetingsMore time needed Attend depending on subcommittee assignment(s) Less time needed New members should attend

Steering Committee members should attend*

Time

High Speed Air Breathing Propulsion (HSABP)

TC Summary

Marty Bradley

14

ABPABPABPABP

HSABP Summary (Marty Bradley)

• Activities since ASM Annual report Monthly steering committee telecons Website updates – transition to Sharepoint Two new members HSABP banners for conference sessions

• Actions for JPC meetings (what you want to accomplish before we leave Denver) 1st telecon/webex HSABP meeting at JPC

– Executed, did not receive expected attendance, Sunday meeting is difficult Ensure all subcommittees have the staffing they need Ensure all subcommittees have leadership (& succession plan) Enable liaison assignments and opportunities

– HyTASP, JANNAF, Univ. Chapters, Local Chapters, Ground Test TC, Aerothermal TC, NASA Aeronautics, Europe, Asia

Plan for membership “drive” – recruit additional International members Ordering of HSABP logo polo shirts

15

ABPABPABPABP

High Speed Air Breathing Propulsion – Steering Committee

CommunicationsTom Kaemming*

Honors & AwardsJinho Lee

EducationDaniel Kirk

MembershipDoug Garrard

Service Subcommittee RepresentativesService Subcommittee Representatives

Conference Subcommittee RepresentativesConference Subcommittee Representatives

TC ChairmanMarty Bradley

Vice ChairJoaquin Castro

Past ChairLance Chenault

Joint Propulsion Conference 2009

Ryan Starkey

Aerospace Sciences Meeting 2009

D.R. Reddy

*Need to find replacement

16

ABPABPABPABP

HSABPTC T-Shirts (Joaquin Castro)

• Selected Royal Blue for the polos and the tri-color logos

• Shirt sample here at JPC • Ordering instructions

Sizes – men’s and women’s

Cost to Members = $25 Money to Joaquin – cash

or check made out to Joaquin Castro

17

ABPABPABPABP

17

Membership (Doug Garrard)

Government 11Industry 20Academia 6 Total

37

Member 31Associate Member 4International Member 2 Total 37

Student 1

Member 7

Senior Member 14

Associate Fellow 12

Fellow 1

Unknown 2

Total 37

18

ABPABPABPABP

18

High Speed Propulsion – Member Positions (1)

• TC Chair – Marty Bradley Vice Chair – Joaquin Castro

• Membership - Doug Garrard Applications & Data– Doug Garrard/Datta Gaitonde Recruiting (International) – Joaquin Castro, TBD Member Upgrades – Doug Garrard

• Communications - Tom Kaemming – TBD Replacement Year in Review Article – Takeshi Kanda, Dean Andreadis, see Liaison Newsletter – Chris Smith?, see Liaison Website – Dave Lucia, Ravi Srinivasan Dora Musielak, TBD, TBD?

• Education - Daniel Kirk Student Design Competition – Joel Malo-Molina Outreach – Paul Czysz Short Courses – Dan Paxson, Dora Musielak Rick Dyer -Steve Beckel – Dean Andreadis – Roy Hartfield – Dianne DeTurris - Hassan Hassan

• Honors and Awards - Jinho Lee Propulsion Award Packages – Venkat Tangirala Coordination with HyTASP Fred Billig Award – Balu Sekar Student Award – David Allen (missing) , Dora Musielak Best Paper Awards – James Donohue John Bradford

New Members:Dora MusielakHassan Hassan

19

ABPABPABPABP

19

High Speed Propulsion – Member Positions (2)

• ASM - D.R.Reddy ASM 09 - D.R. Reddy

– Dan Paxson / Ron Springer / Jinho Lee ASM 10 –Bill Engblom

– Houshang Ebrahimi ASM 11 – Venkat Tangirala

– TBD• JPC – Ryan Starkey

JPC 09 – Ryan Starkey– Tim O’Brien, John Klinge

JPC 10 – Ryan Starkey– Manfred Peinemann

JPC 11 - Roy Hartfield– TBD- Liaison with Ground Test TC

• Liaison HyTASP – Joaquin Castro JANNAF – Phil Drummond / Dean Andreadis /Steve Beckel European Orgs. – John Steelant (David Perigo filling in for John) Other TC’s/PC’s– Aerothermal TC Moehlenkamp Ground Test – Balu Sekar / Doug Garrard Congressional Visits Day – Joaquin Castro AIAA Sections – Dora Musielak AIAA University Chapters - Joel Malo-Molina NASA Aeronautics – Dianne DeTurris – D.R. Reddy / Jinho Lee

20

ABPABPABPABP

HSABP Liaison (Joaquin Castro) (1)

• Activities since ASM Congressional Visit Day – 1 member participated (Joaquin) Some JANNAF discussions

• Actions for JPC meetings (what you want to accomplish before we leave Denver) Investigate possibility of having joint dinner meetings with

HyTASP PC at some future meetings.– Planning meeting every other year

HSABP Liaison meeting Monday 4-5:30 Plan for increased liaison (next slide)

21

ABPABPABPABP

HSABP Liaison (Joaquin Castro) (2)• Plans for next 6-months:

JANNAF coordination – HSABP Liaison members to contact individual authors and encourage authors to submit to AIAA

NASA Hypersonics research conferences –Encouraging NASA researchers to present at AIAA conferences

AIAA Sections – Joaquin (West Palm Beach) – Dora Musielak (Baltimore) AIAA University Chapters (Marty-USC,CSLA, Faure Malo-Molina – UD, Univ. Cin., Wright State, U

Florida, U Miami, Embry Riddle, GTech, Fred – UCLA, Cal Tech, USC, Northridge, Cal Poly ) Congressional Visit Day – Joaquin to work with HyTASP – goal to make Hypersonics an AIAA

Policy Issue HIT – Hypersonic Industry Team – Joaquin is involved and will keep us informed Steve Dunn visiting from Ground Test TC – meet in Orlando to set up joint sessions at JPC 2011 –

set up 2-hour joint planning session Balu Sekar / Doug Garrard to attend Ground Test TC meeting at JPC• European Orgs. – John Steelant (David Perigo filling in for John) LAPCAT, Atllas to be presented at

Hypersonics Conference – Propulsion Conference in Spain (Faure is attending) – Can we present a summary presentation at a future AIAA event? Faure to encourage presenters to submit to AIAA.

Aerothermal TC Bob Moehlenkamp to engage at ASM Bob Moehlenkamp to look at other TC’s for possible liaison

22

ABPABPABPABP

HSABP Summary (Marty Bradley) (continued)

• Plans for next 6 months Sponsor at least one new short course Increase liaison activities Plan for Congressional Visit Day International recruitment Other ideas TBD at JPC meetings

• Succession planning Joaquin Castro to take over at JPC 2010

23

ABPABPABPABP

Gas Turbine Engine Tech CommitteeJPC 2009 Meeting

45th Aerospace Sciences MeetingDenver, CO2 – 5 August 2009

Robert Bruckner

24

ABPABPABPABP

2009 JPC - Agenda

24

25

ABPABPABPABP

2525

Gas Turbine Engines TC Scope & CharterScope• The application of mechanical design, fluid mechanics and

thermodynamics to the science and technology of air vehicle gas turbine engines and engine components, including: Complete engine systems Compressor and Turbine systems Combustors and augmentors Auxiliary systems and structures

Charter• Advance air vehicle gas turbine engine technology by:

Developing and sponsoring technical sessions at ASM, JPC and other conferences of interest

Working effectively with AIAA TCs and PCs and other technical societies to organize and promote joint sessions and activities

Providing for technical communications and reviews, educational activities, and honors and awards

Providing the Institute with authoritative technical opinions and public policy recommendations

26

ABPABPABPABP

2626

Gas Turbine Engines TC

• Evolve into an independent / autonomous TC• Active membership – Do not rely on ABP service committees• Independent conference administration – JPC 09• Independent best paper competition – 2• Develop a joint graduate student design competition with IGTI• Strengthen technical sessions at conferences

• Work to reduce no-shows / withdrawals by active session chairs / TAO’s

• Work to improving quality by offering special section in Journal of Propulsion and Power

• Maintain strong ties to High Speed and System Integration• Jointly administer awards and design competition• Jointly sponsor technical / invited session at each conference

27

ABPABPABPABP

27

Gas Turbine Engine TC - Organization

Honors & AwardsSivaram Gogineni

EducationRick Gaeta

MembershipJeff Cohen

Service Subcommittee RepresentativesService Subcommittee Representatives

TC ChairmanRob Bruckner

Vice ChairIan Halliwell

Past ChairLance Chenault

ConferencesRick Gaeta, et al.

28

ABPABPABPABP

28

Membership - Gas Turbine Engines TC Roster

29

ABPABPABPABP

29

Membership - Gas Turbine Engines TC Profile – 2009

Government 7

Industry 13

Academia 10

Total 30

Fellow 1

Associate Fellows 13

Members 16

Total 30

Regular Member 25

International Member 2

Associate Member 3

Total 30

Employment Sector AIAA Member Grade

TC Member Status •Available member positions: 10•Still missing several GT OEM’s•No members from Asia•Active recruitment underway

•KSPE, Honda Wako, individual recruitment

30

ABPABPABPABP

30

Gas Turbine Engines TC Subcommittee Assignments

John Sordyl Chair

James Kenyon Arathi Gopinath

Andrew Nix David Lior

S. Todd Bailie

Sivaram Gogineni Chair

Nicole Key Bryce Roth

Dan Jensen Mathias Ihme

Robert Webster Garth Hobson

Rick Gaeta Chair

Jay Kapat Janet Convery

Anthony Watts Aaron Byerly

Razi Nalim

Communications Honors and Awards

Education

Rick Gaeta Chair

S. Mani Subramanian JPC09

Anthony Watts ASM10

Janet Convery JPC10

Jay Kapat ASM11

Guillermo Paniagua JPC11

Jerry Welch John Anderson

Conferences

Jeff Cohen Chair

Steve Gorrell Ken Suder

Membership

31

ABPABPABPABP

Communications

• John Sordyl is the new Communications Sub-Committee Chair• Websites for all 3 TC’s have been updated and maintained

Need to transition to new AIAA software / server• YIR article is due in September (600 word) • ABP tri-fold was published this year in lieu of the newsletter

31

John Sordyl Chair

James Kenyon Arathi Gopinath

Andrew Nix David Lior

32

ABPABPABPABP

Conferences

• Updates from TAO’s…. Add a position of “special session organizer”• Continue to update and evolve call for papers• Develop guidelines • To maintain connectivity between TC’s, sponsor joint sessions (eg.

TBCC with High Speed, Engine Compatibility with Integration, Open Rotor)

32

Rick Gaeta Chair

S. Mani Subramanian JPC09

Anthony Watts ASM10

Janet Convery JPC10

Jay Kapat ASM11

Guillermo Paniagua JPC11

Jerry Welch John Anderson

• JPC 09 – Denver• 14 sponsored technical sessions

• 56 presentations scheduled• 1 invited session – Welch (Tu am)

• 2 panel session • Tuesday 12:30 – 15:30• Tuesday 13:00 – 15:00

33

ABPABPABPABP

Education

33

• Status of the engine design competition – RFP written, high speed• The engine design short course has been cancelled due to lack of

pre-registered students (also cancelled JPC 08)• Explore the possibility of offering the NPSS training through an

AIAA short course• Continue working the issue of a joint student design competition

with IGTI• Other ideas for outreach / education?

Rick Gaeta Chair

Jay Kapat Janet Convery

Anthony Watts Aaron Byerly

Razi Nalim S. Todd Bailie

34

ABPABPABPABP

Honors and Awards

34

• Advertise GCO Graduate Student Award and serve as judges• Ensure at least 3 candidates are nominated for the ABP award

The ABP Award will not be presented in 2009

• Best Paper Award Proposal to establish 2 new TC awards for best paper: one for YP one for non-YP Papers to be published through AIAA and presented in a GTE sponsored session Nominated by the session chair – must have read paper No restrictions

Sivaram Gogineni Chair

Nicole Key Bryce Roth

Dan Jensen Mathias Ihme

Robert Webster Garth Hobson

35

ABPABPABPABP

GTETC Logo

Ian Halliwell

September 31, 2009

36

ABPABPABPABP

36

New GTETC Logo - Requirements

• Gas Turbine Engine technology means a lot of things to a lot of people.

• A Gas Turbine Engine Technical Committee logo should capture and convey the skills and excitement involved in the technology of gas turbine engines in a clear & exciting manner, not only to people who are experts, but also to those whom we hope to attract.

• It should link the Technical Committee with AIAA.

• In conveying the technical message, the design should be artistic, modern, dynamic, abstract and sustaining.

37

ABPABPABPABP

37

New GTETC Logo – The Designer

• The new logo was designed by Mike Madero, Graphics Designer & Program Manager at Avetec Inc., a non-profit Aerospace Research Organization in Springfield Ohio.

38

ABPABPABPABP

38

New GTETC Logo – Implementation

• The design incorporates an image of rotating turbomachinery – but it does so while avoiding specific blades shapes, flowpaths, components or engines.

• It includes cold & hot colors, signifying compression, combustion & expansion processes. The choice of non-primary colors is deliberate.

• The effect of an unsteady, swirling inlet flow has been caught in the light-blue “brush-stroke”. The swirling effect is accentuated & reinforced by the direction of slope of the “blades”.

• The name of the Technical Committee – in maroon - surrounds the upper portion of the logo.

• This is combined with the Official AIAA logo in standard blue, which is used as a base.

• “The World’s Forum for Aerospace Leadership” is included whenever it is legible. For small applications, such as letterheads or polo shirts, this may be eliminated.

39

ABPABPABPABP

GTETC Logo

39

40

ABPABPABPABP

40

New Initiatives

• Public Policy, CVD, Position Papers CS should obtain prior clearance from legal counsel

• Liaisons with other TC’s, PC’s, and other Societies Collaboration (Coexistence) with SAE, IGTI, and ASME Propulsion

Committee should be explored• Evolve into an independent / autonomous TC

• Active membership – Do not rely on ABP service committees• Independent conference administration – JPC 09• Independent best paper competition – 2• Develop a joint graduate student design competition with IGTI• Strengthen technical sessions at conferences

• Work to reduce no-shows / withdrawals by active session chairs / TAO’s

• Work to improving quality by offering special section in Journal of Propulsion and Power

41

ABPABPABPABP

Air Breathing Propulsion Systems Integration Tech CommitteeJPC Report

45th AIAA/ASME/SAE/ASEE Joint Propulsion Conference & ExhibitDenver, Colorado2 - 5 August 2009

Jeff Flamm for Ray Best

42

ABPABPABPABP

42

Air Breathing Propulsion System Integration TC – Office holders

CommunicationsWeldon Wainright

Honors & AwardsJeff Flamm

EducationIan Halliwell

MembershipK. Blodgett/C. Wilson

Service SubcommitteesService Subcommittees

Conference SubcommitteesConference Subcommittees

TC ChairmanRaymond Best

Vice ChairJeff Flamm

Past ChairLance Chenault

Joint Propulsion ConferenceDon Malloy

Aerospace Sciences Meeting

Vance Dippold

43

ABPABPABPABP

43

Air Breathing Propulsion Systems Integration TC Scope & Charter

Scope• The application of mechanical design, fluid mechanics and thermodynamics to

the science and technology of air vehicle propulsion and power systems integration, including: Installed performance and controls (SPO, PPT) Propulsion aerodynamics; inlet and nozzle systems (IE) Power and thermal management (SPO, PPT) All aspects of propulsion system / air vehicle interface and certification (RVCT)

Charter: Advance air breathing propulsion integration technology by: • Developing and sponsoring technical sessions at ASM, JPC and other conferences of

interest • Working effectively with AIAA TCs and PCs and other technical societies to organize and

promote joint sessions and activities • Providing for technical communications and reviews, educational activities, and honors and

awards• Providing the Institute with authoritative technical opinions and public policy

recommendationsNear Term Goal: Update the Short Course to include certification –airframer lead?Long term is a book on the same subject.

44

ABPABPABPABP

4444

Systems Integration – Member Positions and population

• TC Chair – Raymond Best Deputy – Jeff Flamm

• Membership – Keith Blodgett 4 Applications & Data Recruiting Member Upgrades

• Communications – Weldon Wainright 5 Sub comm. Vice Chair Hayden Reeve Year in Review Article- Hayden Reeve Newsletter - Weldon Wainright Website – Charles Beard

• Education - Ian Halliwell 7 Sub comm Vice Chair Rod

Daebelliehn (Eric Loth) Student Design Competition Outreach Short Courses

• Honors and Awards - Jeff Flamm 5 Sub Comm Vice Chair (Chen Chuck) Propulsion Award Packages -

EveryBody! Student Award - Jeff Flamm Best Paper Awards - Doug

Kisling/Keith Blodgett

45

ABPABPABPABP

4545

Systems Integration – Member Positions and population

• ASM - 5 ASM 09 Jeff Flamm (Orlando) ASM 10 Vance Dippold (Orlando) ASM 11 –Don Malloy (Orlando) ASM 12 – Vance Dippold (Dallas)

• JPC – 5 JPC 09 Doug Kisling (Denver) JPC 10 Don Malloy (Nashville) JPC 11 Rod Daebelliehn (San Diego) JPC 12 – TBD

In addition, all member are expected to be session chairs and conduct abstract reviews for our conferences

46

ABPABPABPABP

46

Systems Integration Technical Areas and population

Integrated Aero Performance (10 members) New Name– Jeff Flamm Chair, Thomas Berens Vice Chair

Subsystem, Performance, Optimization (8 members)– Steve Johnson Chair, Hayden Reeve Vice Chair

Propellers/Pistons/Turboprops (3 members)– Weldon Wainright Chair, Charles Beard Vice Chair

Requirements Verification, Certification and Testing (4 members)

– Don Malloy Chair, Dave Wang, Vice Chair ABPSI Steering (8 members)

47

ABPABPABPABP

47

TC Profiles – August 2009

Government 4

Industry 26

Academia 1

Total 31

ABPSI has room to grow (max is 35)

Members 24

Associate 4

International 2

* Dual 3

2.07 GPA 2.17 ASM 09 V.S. JPC 09

Fellow 0

A. Fellow 12

Senior 12

Member 8

Fellow 0

A. Fellow 11

Senior 8

Member 9

Everyone should be at least a Senior Member!

20

0

Goal for ASM 10

48

ABPABPABPABP

48

ABPSITC Current Membership

Dropped

New

# First Last Description AIAA Member Grade Organization1 Ken Alabi Member Member TTC Technologies Inc2 Charles Beard Member Senior Member Boeing3 Raymond Best Chair Associate Fellow Hawker Beechcraft Corporation4 Norbert Bissinger International Associate Fellow5 Keith Blodgett Member Associate Fellow GE Aviation6 Jay Carskaden Member Member The Boeing Company

7Clarence

ChenaultMember

Associate FellowAerospace Business Development Associates (ABDA)

8 Chen Chuck Member Senior Member The Boeing Company9 Roderick Daebelliehn Member Senior Member Aerojet

10 Vance F. Dippold, III Associate Member NASA Glenn Research Center11 Jeffrey Flamm Member Associate Fellow NASA Langley Research Center12 Egbert Frowein Member Member US Navy - NAVAIR AIR-4.413 Ian Halliwell Member Associate Fellow AVETEC Inc14 Jeffrey Hamstra Member Associate Fellow Lockheed Martin15 Lanny Jines Member Senior Member Ohio Aerospace Institute16 Stephen Johnson Member Senior Member Northrop Grumman17 Douglas Kisling Member Associate Fellow Belcan18 Donald J. Malloy Member Associate Fellow Aerospace Testing Alliance, Inc.19 Dave Mayer Member Associate Fellow Boeing20 Bruce McKay Member Member Lockheed Martin Aeronautics21 Roger Mussard Member Senior Member

22 Hayden M. Reeve Associate MemberUnited Technologies Research Center

23 Weldon Wainright Member Senior Member Piper24 William Westphal Member Associate Fellow Rolls-Royce Corporation25 Bryan Westra Member Member Northrop Grumman26 Christopher Wilson Associate Senior Member The Boeing Company27 David Young Associate Senior Member Raytheon Missile Systems28 Thomas M. Berens International Senior Member EADS Military Air Systems 29 Jonathan Litt Member Senior Member NASA Glenn Research Center30 Eric Loth Member Associate Fellow University of Illinois31 Michelle McMillian Member Member SynGenics Corporation32 David Wang Associate Member Edwards AFB Flight Test Center

49

ABPABPABPABP

Liasions

• Other AIAA TC’s/PC’s Energy Optimized Aircraft and Equipment Systems- Hayden Reeve Fluids Dynamics TC - Flamm contributed to Flow Control Book

• Other Societies ASME propulsion committee Don Malloy

– Sponsoring technical sessions at the IGTI Turbo Expo in collaboration with ASME IGTI Aircraft Engine TC

• Local Sections Hampton Roads Section – Jeff Flamm Tennessee Section – Don Maloy

• Other Engine Icing Consortium – Ray Best PPSA – Jeff Flamm

• Pursue connections with SAE, Ground Test Committee

49

50

ABPABPABPABP

50

New ABPSI Logo

51

ABPABPABPABP

51

Logo Shirts

Lands’ End Business Outfitter Sample• $175 1 time setup fee

• Approx $32/shirt• Approx $1200 for 35 shirts

Logo#: 0941796wLogo Size: 4.05" x 2.74"

52

ABPABPABPABP

52

Accomplishments at JPC 09

• Eliminated TBD’s for job assignments• Succession Plan for all sub-committees in place• Directed Recruitment drive – list of contacts generated• Indentified existing liaison activity and possible new activities• New Logo picked /Decision to purchase shirt• Suggestion from Don Malloy for Author Acceptance Form to help

with no show form

53

ABPABPABPABP

53

Plans for next 6 months

• Plans for next 6 months Member Recruitment Drive Year in Review Article 9/25 Develop CVD/Public Policy plan Coordinate Call for papers between ASM/JPC conferences Special Sessions Still short session chairs for ASM 10 Increase Liaison activities

– Engine Icing Consortium– EOASys PC (Energy Optimized Aircraft and Equipment Systems) – No response– SAE– Ground Test

• Chairman’s Award for John Rockensies He will be at the RLC Thurs/Fri

54

ABPABPABPABP

ABP Education Committee JPC Report

45th Joint Propulsion ConferenceDenver, Colorado2 - 3 August 2009

55

ABPABPABPABP

55

ABP Group

Gas Turbine Engines Air Breathing Propulsion Systems Integration

High Speed Air Breathing Propulsion

Common ElementsCommon Elements

Communications Honors & Awards

Aerospace Sciences Meeting Joint Propulsion Conference

Membership Education

Conferences JPC/ASM

Membership

Liaison

Technical Disciplines

Air Breathing Propulsion Subgroup Organizational Structure

Communications

Education

Honors & Awards

Separate TCsSeparate TCs

Conferences JPC/ASM

Membership

Liaison

Communications

Education

Honors & Awards

Technical Disciplines

Conferences JPC/ASM

Membership

Liaison

Communications

Education

Honors & Awards

56

ABPABPABPABP

Attendees – JPC 2009

Jeff Flamm Rick Dyer Dan Paxon Bryan WestruRod Daebelliehn Anthony Watts Rick Gaeta

Dora Musielak Marty Bradley Dianne DeTurris Bill Westphal Keith Blodgett Steve Beckel

13 Attendees: 6 ABPSI, 5 HSABP, 2 GTE

57

ABPABPABPABP

ABP Education Committee Working Groups

Identified Working Group Leads

K-12 Outreach

Rod Daebelliehn

Short CoursesEngine Design

Competition

Dora Musielak Ian HalliwellDianne DeTurris

Keys to getting things done:• Stay focused on working group tasks• Have working group interaction (telecons/webinars/email) at least once a month• Use conference meetings more as a place to solve larger issues, float new

ideas, update technical committees on progress

58

ABPABPABPABP

AIAA Short Courses - Update

Develop, produce, and administer Short Courses that are offered to industry and academia that relate to ABP Science and Technology

Development

Continuation of ABP Design Short Course developed by John Rockensies (ret.) • Received previous course notes from John• Lined up instructors• Course offered for JPC ‘09• JPC ’09 Course was canceled due to lack of enrollment (1 enrolled – need 10)

We are committed to continue to this short course on AB Engine Design Fundamentals

Working Group to explore new course topics and marketing with AIAA

59

ABPABPABPABP

AIAA Engine Design Competition - Update

Develop and produce RFP for AIAA Air Breathing Engine Design Competition for Undergraduates; Provide judges for evaluation of proposals and determine winners

2008-2009 Topic: A Variable Cycle Engine for Subsonic Transport Applications

5 Entries (2 Schools: BYU & KU) Results of Judges due to AIAA by August 17th

60

ABPABPABPABP

AIAA Engine Design Competition - Update

2009-2010 Proposed Topic: A Propulsion System for a Hypersonic TBCC Technology Demonstrator Vehicle

RFP just about completed; Due to AIAA ASAP Working Group Lead to coordinate with other group members as needed

61

ABPABPABPABP

K-12 Education - Update

Promote and Facilitate the education of Air Breathing Propulsion Science

and Technology

Good discussion on how ABP can focus on this problem

Ideas• ABP as a teacher resource to be drawn upon – direct access (thru website) to

professionals • Provide forum for teachers to see success stories on local level• Work with “Passport to Future” meeting as the primary interface for ABP and K-12

outreach• Focus on a specific “table top” experiment that teachers can use to demonstrate a

propulsion concept

Working group lead to take action on making this happen

62

ABPABPABPABP

Honors & Awards Subcommittee

August 2, 2009Jeff Flamm

ABPABP

63

ABPABPABPABP

Transition Period (2007/08)

Sivaram Gogineni, Turbine (chair 2007/08)

Jinho Lee, High Speed, (2008/09)

Jeff Flamm, PAI (2009/10)

The Honors & Awards Subcommittee Leads of HS, Turbine and PAI agreed to serve as one (Reno 2008)

64

ABPABPABPABP

2009/10 ABP Awards Timeline

Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec Mar Apr May Jun JulJan Feb

Aerospace SciencesMeeting - 1/10

AwardsCeremony At

JPC - 7/10

2010

Air Breathing Propulsion

Nominations Due 10/1/09

Nominations to ABP TC

SelectionTo AIAA HQ

Gordon Oates

Nominations Due 1/31/10

SelectionTo AIAA HQ

Nominations to ABP TC

Best Paper

SelectionTo AIAA HQ

CandidatesAvailable

From JPC ’09

CandidatesAvailable

From ASM ’10

2009

Award SelectionTeams

Established

Typical

65

ABPABPABPABP

Air Breathing Propulsion Award

• Award can be given only if a minimum of 3 nominations are active.

• Chronic problems obtaining the requisite 3 nominations and maintaining an appropriate nomination pool.

• Nominations are only active for a total of three cycles.

• Four nominations this year

• To maintain active nominations in the pipeline, we need at least TWO additional nominations prior to October 1st.

• Each TC Chair (Turbine Engine, High-Speed Propulsion and Propulsion Integration) is asked to ensure at least one nomination package is submitted in a given cycle. ALL TC members are also asked to encourage nominations.

• Please have nominator advise Nicole Key of “intent to nominate” as soon as possible.

Awarded for meritorious, career-spanning accomplishment in the science or art of Air Breathing Propulsion

POC for 2010 is Nicole Key

66

ABPABPABPABP

Air Breathing Propulsion Award

• AIAA membership not obligatory to receive award (although may be tiebreaker)

• Selection Team now consists of 6 or 7 people as follows:

- Each TC Chair

- Each Honors & Awards Subcommittee Chair

- Representative of the Propellants and Combustion TC.

Selection Process

67

ABPABPABPABP

Air Breathing Propulsion Award

• The selection team’s decision must be endorsed by an e-mail vote of at least 50% of the ABPTC and P&C TC.

• ABPTC and P&C TC Chairs and Group Director must approve final selection by ensuring process was followed.

• Documented, quantitative grading scale (audit trail) with minimum threshold below which award is not given out.

- New scoring sheet developed

- For ABP award, minimum threshold will be 100 points (150 points is perfect score)

Selection Process Continued

68

ABPABPABPABP

2009 Air Breathing Propulsion Award

• 4 nomination packages received• 1 candidate had possible conflict of interest• Selection committee pursued conflict issue with AIAA and TAC H&A

committee• Candidate initially ruled acceptable from conflict of interest standpoint• After judging and candidate selected TAC ruled there was a conflict of interest• TAC changing guidelines to clarify• No award given this year because there are not enough eligible candidates

(min 3)

• Selection committee Jinho Lee (head judge) Raymond Best Marty Bradley Robert Bruckner Jeffrey Flamm Sivaram Gogineni

69

ABPABPABPABPABP Award Past Recipients

Year Name Primary Organization

2001 Dr. John J. Adamczyk NASA Glenn Research Center

1999 Dr. Allen S. Novick Allison

1998 Dr. Joseph A. Schetz Virginia Polytechnic Institute

1997 Dr. H. Lee Beach, Jr. NASA Langley Research Center

1996 Dr. Louis A. Povinelli NASA Glenn Research Center

1995 Thomas A. Auxier Pratt & Whitney

1994 Dr. "Bud" Lakshminarayana Pennsylvania State University

1993 Thomas L. DuBell Pratt & Whitney

1992 Donald M. Dix Department of Defense

1991 F. Blake Wallace, Jr. Allison

2000 Charles R. McClinton NASA Langley Research Center

2002 Dr. Richard Rivir Air Force Research Laboratory

2003 Dr. Ben Zinn Georgia Tech

2004 Dr. E. Tom Curran Air Force Research Laboratory2005 Dr. Vigor Yang Pennsylvania State University2006 Dr. Anthony Strazisar NASA Glenn Research Center

2008 Dr. Hukam Mongia GE Aviation2007 Dr. Dilip Ballal University of Dayton Research Inst.

70

ABPABPABPABP

Air Breathing Propulsion Award

Scoring Sheet

2

3

Recommended Change

71

ABPABPABPABP

Gordon C. Oates Graduate Award

• 2009 Recipient: Mr. Vijay Ramasubramanian, A Ph.D candidate from the University of Maryland

• Research focus: "is to develop the theoretical basis for robust, high-performance ramjet/scramjet/combined-cycle air breathing inlets derived from the inward-turning Busemann flowfield

• Nine applicants this year (3 to 4 not directly applicable to ABP)• Selection committee

Jeff Flamm (head judge) Norbert Bissinger Stephen Gorrell Nicole Key Jinho Lee

POC for 2010 – Jeff Flamm

$5,000 cash award presented for outstanding Graduate Student Research in the area of Air Breathing Propulsion

72

ABPABPABPABP

ABP Best Paper Award

AIAA Paper 2009-1423 "Scalability of Ethylene Gaseous Jets for Fueling High-Speed Air-Breathing Combustors" by Kuo-Cheng Lin, Michael Ryan, Cambell Carter, Mark Gruber and Charbel Raffoul.

Awarded for the best technical paper presented in an Air Breathing Propulsion Session at the 2008 Joint Propulsion Conference or

2009 Aerospace Sciences Conference

73

ABPABPABPABP

ABP Best Paper Award

• AIAA provides copies of ABP session forms from both conferences (usually significant time lag)

• Process improvement: ABP Technical Organizer forwards copies of Session Chair Forms to Honors & Awards at end of conference.

• Session chairs at JPC are requested to nominate one paper in their session and submit completed session chair form to Ryan Starkey or AIAA before departing the JPC Meeting.

Awarded for the best technical paper presented in an Air Breathing Propulsion Session at the 2009 Joint Propulsion Conference or

2010 Aerospace Sciences Conference

74

ABPABPABPABP

H&A Recommendations

• Split Best paper award into 3 - 1 for each TC

- Add a block to session chair rating form:

- “ I do not recommend any papers for best paper”

- No show = no award

- ABPSI Doug Kisling/KeithBlodgett

- High Speed – James Donohue

- Gas Turbine - Sivaram Gogineni

• YP Paper award? Wait till next year

• Recommend change to ABP Award criteria

- Change Weight of Publications etc from 3 to 2

- Change Weight of References/Reputation from 2 to 3

75

ABPABPABPABP

H&A Recommendations

Need 1 nominee from each TC to maintain ABP Award

Deadline Oct 1!

It is everyone’s responsibility to seek out nominees!

76

ABPABPABPABP

Communications Subcommittee

Joint Air Breathing Propulsion Technical CommitteesTC General MeetingJPC 2009 – Denver, CO

ABPABP

77

ABPABPABPABP

Agenda

• Roll Call• Communication Subcommittee Roles• Status Reports

Websites Newsletter Banners Tri-Fold Year in Review Highlights Minutes

• 2009 Task Assignments• Succession

82

ABPABPABPABP

Agenda

• Roll Call• Communication Subcommittee Roles• Status Reports

Websites Newsletter Banners Tri-Fold Year in Review Highlights Minutes

• 2009 Task Assignments• Succession

83

ABPABPABPABP

Websites Status

• Websites for all 3 TC’s are up and running• Webmasters established for each TC

Gas Turbine – Arathi Gopinath & TBD High Speed – Ravi Srinivasan, David Lucia

(assisted by Dora Musielak) Integration – Charles Beard

• AIAA Transitioning to SharePoint Each TC Webmaster Needs to Coordinate Transition

with AIAA (Betty Guillie)

84

ABPABPABPABP

Newsletter 2009

• Electronic Release ABP Members Website AIAA Members with Air Breathing Propulsion Interest

• Sole Public Publication of ABP• Recognition of Honors & Awards• Roles And Responsibilities of TCs

• *** 2009 JPC Deadline Missed ***

85

ABPABPABPABP

Tri-Fold

• ABP Level• Provide TC Information to Interested People• Update Yearly• Handout at JPC and ASM Sessions

• Completed for JPC 2009 Special Thanks to Chris Smith and John Sordyl`

86

ABPABPABPABP

Tri-Fold

87

ABPABPABPABP

Tri-Fold (cont)

89

ABPABPABPABP

Banner

92

ABPABPABPABP

Assignments for 2009

• Newsletter ’09 – Subgroup Level Coordinating Lead – Tom Kaemming ABPSITC – Weldon Wainright, Piper Aircraft & Hayden Reeve, UTRC GTETC – Ian Halliwell, Avetec & Rob Bruckner, NASA HSABPTC – Tom Kaemming

• Highlights Articles for December, Submission req’d in September ABPSITC – Hayden Reeve, UTRC GTETC – Jim Kenyon, DOD & Robert Webster, UT-Chattanooga;

Todd Bailie, AFRL (John Sordyl POC) HSABPTC – Dean Andreadis, P&W (???) (Tom Kaemming POC)

• Dinner Meeting Minutes JPC – John Sordyl

• TC Webmasters ABPSITC – Charles Beard, Boeing Co. GTETC – Arathi Gopinath, GE & TBD HSABPTC – Ravi Srinivasan (???), Texas A&M & David Lucia, USAF

93

ABPABPABPABP

Highlights 2009 for AEROSPACE AMERICA

• Articles to be 3 – 600 word (1 page) articles for each TC

• Deadline – 25 September Should include events that have already occurred or will

by proof manuscripts review (late Oct.) Oct. thru Dec. events covered following year TC POC should have been submitted to AIAA

94

ABPABPABPABP

2008 Approach Worked Well

• Teams of two or more from each TC led the effort Could, or should be, more of a ‘working group’ activity engaging

small teams– Lessens the burden & encourages more participation

European and Asian content will be more of a challenge for this coming year

• Solicit Topics and Points-of-Contact from all TC Members• Focus on Major Events• Solicit Gov’t/Industry Inputs Via Public Affairs/Business

Development ‘Free Publicity’ for your organization

96

ABPABPABPABP

Succession

• Tom Kaemming Replacement Needed *• ABP Communications Chair

Coordinate ABP Level Communication Tasks Coordinate GTE, ABPSI and HSABP

Communications Can Be TC Communications Lead

• Candidates John Sordyl

* HSABPTC Chair req’d also

97

ABPABPABPABP

Joint Propulsion Conference SubcommitteeAir Breathing PropulsionDinner Meeting

Aug. 3, 2009

Denver, CO

ABPABP

98

ABPABPABPABP

98

JPC 2009

• JPC Subcommittee Chair Ryan P. Starkey (member HSABPTC)

• Technical Area Chairs

Gas Turbine Engines TC – S. Mani Subramanian - Gas-Turbine Engine (14)

HyTASP PC / High Speed Air Breathing Propulsion TC– Ryan P. Starkey – Hypersonic and Combined Cycle Propulsion (16)

Air Breathing Propulsion Systems Integration TC– Doug Kisling – Air Breathing Propulsion (7) – Don Malloy – System Concepts and Supporting Propulsion Technologies (9)

99

ABPABPABPABP

99

JPC 2009 Statistics (HyTASP PC/High Speed ABP TC)

• 64 Abstracts received• 61 Abstracts accepted (due to openings in sessions)

29 US / 21 China / 6 Japan 1 Australia / Britain / Canada / Egypt / S. Korea

• 2 Invited Sessions Recent Advances in Constant Volume Combustion

– Tom Kaemming / Dan Paxson X-51, Prelude to the 2009 First Flight

– Joaquin Castro

• 14 Paper Sessions 9 papers withdrawn (5 China / 3 US / 1 Egypt)

100

ABPABPABPABP

100

JPC 2009 Statistics – Gas Turbine Engines TC

• 62 Abstracts received• 50 Abstracts accepted• 13 paper sessions – currently 50 papers

27 US / 10 China / 4 Britain 2 Brazil / Germany / India 1 Belgium / Japan / S. Korea

• 1 Invited Session Inlet-Engine Compatibility (3 oral presentations)

101

ABPABPABPABP

101

JPC 2009 Statistics - ABP System Integration TC

• 44 Abstracts received • 34 Abstracts accepted – 6 Rejected / 4 Transferred

15 China / 12 US / 2 Italy 1 Iran / Netherlands / Portugal / Russia / S. Korea

• 7 paper sessions 5 papers withdrawn (4 US / 1 China) 3 no-planned attendance (China)

• No invited sessions

102

ABPABPABPABP

102

JPC 2009 Statistics – ABPSI: System Concepts and Supporting Propulsion Technologies

• 43 Abstracts received • 35 Abstracts accepted

26 US / 2 Germany 1 Britain / China / France / Israel / Iran / Japan / Russia

• 8 Abstracts Rejected 4 China; 1 Azerbaijan / Germany / US / Other

• 8 paper sessions• 1 invited session

Transition in Gas Turbine Engine Control System Architecture: Modular, Distributed, Embedded

103

ABPABPABPABP

103

JPC 2009 Summary Statistics

• 213 Abstracts received• 180+ Abstracts accepted

94+ US / 47+ China / 7+ Japan / 30+ Other• 4 Invited Sessions • 42 Paper Sessions

104

ABPABPABPABP

104

JPC 2010 – Nashville, TN

• Subcommittee Chair Ryan P. Starkey

• Technical Area Chairs

Gas Turbine Engines TC – Janet Convery

HyTASP PC / High Speed Air Breathing Propulsion TC– Ryan Starkey

Air Breathing Propulsion Systems Integration TC– Don Malloy

105

ABPABPABPABP

105

Issues for Discussion (for JPC 2010+)

• No-podium/no-paper Yes! – Don’t let it get left out of call for papers

• Special session suggestions X-51 update TBD

• Possible use of “author acceptance forms” – authors would need to get management signature at abstract submittal step ???

• Involvement for paper reviews/chairing sessions• Need to get more people to review papers & chair sessions –

spread the effort to more members, rather than doubling up

106

ABPABPABPABP

Aerospace Sciences Meeting Subcommittee (D.R. Reddy)Air Breathing PropulsionSubgroup General Meeting

Aug. 3, 2009

Denver, CO

ABPABP

107

ABPABPABPABP

107

ASM 2010 Statistics (High Speed ABP)

• 47 Abstracts received (114 in 2009 for all 3 TCs)• ~42 Abstracts to be accepted (Reviews 80% complete)• 7 sessions (15 in 2009 for all ABP); no Invited Sessions • Reduced submittal from India (0!) and China (3)

May be attributed to No podium, No paper policy enforcement• Reduced submittal in PDE area

9 abstracts received (4 sessions, 20 papers in 2009) Propellants & Combustion TC has ?? PDE abstracts

(waiting for response)

108

ABPABPABPABP

108

ASM 2010 Statistics – Gas Turbine Engines TC

• 37 Abstracts received• Abstracts accepted - U/Review• 6 sessions (subject to # of accepted abstracts)

Materials (2-4) Turbines I (6) Turbines II (6) Engine Simulations (3) Combustors (4-7) Fans & Compressors (4-6)

• 2 Invited Sessions (co-sponsored w/ABPSI TC) Alternate Fuels – Technology Development (Balu Sekar) Alternate Fuels – Government Funded Programs (Balu Sekar)

• 1 Invited Session – Pressure-gain combustors• 1 more possible – large engine simulation

109

ABPABPABPABP

109

ASM 2010 Statistics (ABP System Integration TC)

• 24 Abstracts received • 20 Abstracts accepted – 4 Transferred to other areas• 4 sessions • Co-sponsored (w/GTE TC) 2 Invited Sessions –

Alternative Fuels• Abstracts submitted - low compared to the number of

ABPSI-focused papers at ASM09

110

ABPABPABPABP

110

ASM 2010 (High Speed ABP)

• Session Name Reviewers (Chairs/Co-Chairs)* Pulse Detonation Engines - Paxson / Tangirala Supersonic Inlets - Malo-Molina / Moehlenkamp Supersonic Inlets and Isolators - D.R. Reddy / Engblom Scramjet Fuel Injection - Donohue / Steelant Scramjet Flow Simulation - Sekar / Drummond or Lucia Hypersonic Vehicle Design - Starkey / Springer or Lucia Scramjet Performance - O’Brien / Peinemann

*preliminary assignments

111

ABPABPABPABP

111

ASM 2011

• Subcommittee Chair D. R. Reddy

• Technical Area Chairs from 3TCs Jay Kapat - Gas Turbine Engines Don Malloy - ABP System Integration Venkat Tangirala- High Speed ABP

• Specialty Sub-chairs To be determined by the TACs as needed

112

ABPABPABPABP

112

Issues for Discussion (for ASM 2011)

• ASM 2011 Special sessions: Future of Pulse Detonation Engines (?) Other ideas?

– Open Rotors– Engine Icing?

113

ABPABPABPABP

Other topics from the floor?

• PDE comments: There is a call for detonation related papers out of propellants and

combustion, may have overlap Suggest sponsoring a joint session to avoid overlap

• Winner for slides/minute rate: Kaemming, 12 in 6 min• Honors and Awards: GCO – will not split into 3 right now due to

lack of candidates and funding issues. Resolution: better advertising

• Methods to address issues with no shows/withdrawals – ABP has a higher rate than other groups Path forward on author acceptance form Non-standard AIAA procedure, needs more discussion Effort to recruit China/Indian members to TC, encourage podium shows Recommending supervisory concurrence with abstract submittal