agriculture and climateagriculture and climate …agriculture and climateagriculture and climate...
TRANSCRIPT
Agriculture and ClimateAgriculture and Climate ChangeChange
Impacts, Adaptation, Mitigation and Tradep , p , g
Gerald NelsonS i R h F llSenior Research Fellow
INTERNATIONAL FOOD POLICY RESEARCH INSTITUTEICTSD/IPC Side Event on “Climate Change, Agriculture and Trade: Promoting
Policy Coherence” 6 April 2009
Presentation Overview
Climate change will affect agriculture• Higher global temperatures, more precipitation, more
variability and extreme events• Likely negative effects: Where and how much?• Likely negative effects: Where and how much?Adaptation/resilience: Agriculture will need• New varieties, more infrastructure, changes in management , , g g
practices and policies• International institutions that support resilience globally Miti ti A i ltMitigation: Agriculture can• Reduce emissions of greenhouse gasses • Act as a sink for other sectors• Act as a sink for other sectorsClimate Change, Agriculture and Trade
INTERNATIONAL FOOD POLICY RESEARCH INSTITUTE Page 2
Consequences: Higher temperatures and more but shifting precipitation…Higher temperatures and more but shifting precipitation…
Dec-F bFeb
Jun-Aug
Page 6Hadley Model, SRES A1B ScenarioGCM3.1 (T63), SRES A1B Scenario
http://ipcc-wg1.ucar.edu/wg1/Report/suppl/Ch10/Ch10_indiv-maps.html
… but uncertainty about where and how much
Dec-F bFeb
Jun-Aug
Page 7Hadley Model, SRES A1B ScenarioHadley Model, SRES A1B Scenario
http://ipcc-wg1.ucar.edu/wg1/Report/suppl/Ch10/Ch10_indiv-maps.html
Climate Change Effects on Agriculture
What did we think in the mid-1990s?What did we think in the mid 1990s?No problems• Agricultural effects of climate change would be• Agricultural effects of climate change would be
manageable• Negative yield effects in temperate regions buffered byNegative yield effects in temperate regions buffered by
trade• CO2 fertilization importantCO2 fertilization important• Increased trade flows needed
INTERNATIONAL FOOD POLICY RESEARCH INSTITUTE Page 8
Climate Change Effects on Agriculture
What did we think in the early 2000s?What did we think in the early 2000s?Potential problems but manageable• Production in DCs benefit; declines in LDCs• Production in DCs benefit; declines in LDCs • Regional differences grow stronger over time• Substantial increases in risk of hunger in poorer nations• Substantial increases in risk of hunger in poorer nations• CO2 fertilization important
Increased trade flo s needed• Increased trade flows needed
INTERNATIONAL FOOD POLICY RESEARCH INSTITUTE Page 9
Climate Change Effects on Agriculture
What did we think in the mid-2000s?What did we think in the mid 2000s?Potential for problems is larger• Yields would likely increase somewhat in all regions• Yields would likely increase somewhat in all regions• Smaller gains in the temperate regions than previous
modelsmodels• Small yield gains in the tropics • CO fertilization important• CO2 fertilization important• Increased trade flows needed
INTERNATIONAL FOOD POLICY RESEARCH INSTITUTE Page 10
What about the CO2 fertilization effect?2
Needed in all models to offset some of productivity losses from climate change, but…Recent reports on field experiments on CO2p p 2fertilization are negative• Higher levels of atmospheric CO2 increase susceptibilityg p 2 p y
Soybeans to the Japanese beetle Maize to the western corn rootworm
INTERNATIONAL FOOD POLICY RESEARCH INSTITUTE Page 11
Climate Change Effects on AgricultureWhat do we think in 2009?What do we think in 2009?
Rainfed maize yields decline 17% by 2050
Page 12Preliminary results
Climate Change Effects on AgricultureWhat do we think in 2009?
Irrigated rice yields decline 20%
Page 13Preliminary results
Suggested Negotiating Outcome for AgricultureAgriculture
Make funds available for research to improve our punderstanding of the interactions between climate change and agriculture• Higher spatial resolution and
more relevant outputs from climate modelsbetter integration of agriculture into integrated assessment models
• Better biophysical and socioeconomic modeling of• Better biophysical and socioeconomic modeling of climate change-agriculture interactions
INTERNATIONAL FOOD POLICY RESEARCH INSTITUTE Page 19
Adaptation in agriculture is essentialGood development policy is important first stepp p y p p• Higher incomes from productive agricultural resources,
used sustainably, provide resilience in the face of climate change
Location, location, location• Climate change effects vary across the landscape• What’s needed?
Location-specific analysisLocation-specific programs and policy measures
International institutions that support resilience globally are critical
INTERNATIONAL FOOD POLICY RESEARCH INSTITUTE Page 21
Adaptation needs
Increased expenditures in agricultural science and p gtechnology
Increased investments in water storage and managementg
More development of rural Infrastructure physical andMore development of rural Infrastructure, physical and institutional
Policy improvements to internalize externalities associated with environmental services
INTERNATIONAL FOOD POLICY RESEARCH INSTITUTE
associated with environmental servicesPage 22
Agriculture adaption: Suggested negotiating outcomesSuggested negotiating outcomes
Include funding modalities for agriculture• Recognize the connection between pro-poor
development policies for sustainable growth and climate change adaptionclimate-change adaption
• Recognize and support synergies between adaptation and mitigationg
Provide funds for • Technology, infrastructure and institutional innovationsgy,• Global data collection
improves understanding of the spatial context of agricultureSupport international institutions that foster resilience
INTERNATIONAL FOOD POLICY RESEARCH INSTITUTE Page 23
Agriculture’s GHG emissions are large, but shares differ by regionbut shares differ by region
Total GHG
Regionemissions (Mt
CO2e)Share from agriculture
Share from land‐use change and forestry
Europe 7,600 9.1 0.4
North America 7,208 7.1 ‐4.7
South America 3,979 23.6 51.6
Sub‐Saharan Africa 543 12.7 60.4Sub Saharan Africa 543 12.7 60.4
Asia 14,754 14.4 26.8
D l i i * 22 186 15 7 35 6Developing countries* 22,186 15.7 35.6
World 40,809 14 18.7
Page 25Source: WRI CAIT, 2009* - Non Annex 1 countries
Agricultural mitigation: Cost-effective optionsCost-effective options
Change crop mixesg p• plants that are perennial and/or with deep root systemsUse cultivation systems that leave residuesUse cultivation systems that leave residues• reduce tillage, especially deep tillageShift land use from annual crops toShift land use from annual crops to • Perennial crops• Pasture• Pasture• AgroforestryKEY Issue MRV Measurable Reportable andKEY Issue – MRV - Measurable, Reportable, and Verifiable
INTERNATIONAL FOOD POLICY RESEARCH INSTITUTE Page 26
Agricultural mitigation: Suggested negotiating outcomesSuggested negotiating outcomes
Establish a chapter for agriculture-related mitigation p g g(and adaptation) investments as part of any global mitigation funding mechanismInclude agriculture and land-use change from the outset of any Post-Kyoto agreement but allow for long-term means-tested adjustment opportunitiesFund development and implementation of low-cost monitoring systemsAllow innovative payment mechanisms and support for novel institutions for agricultural mitigation
INTERNATIONAL FOOD POLICY RESEARCH INSTITUTE Page 27
Climate Change, Agriculture and Tradeg g
Climate change will alter comparative advantageg p g• Current trade flows will change• Direction and magnitude of changes are uncertaing g• LDC agricultural export growth has been in high value
ecological niche products with uncertain futuresExploiting seasonal differences (vegetables from south to north in north’s winter)Unique climate/soil niches coffee tropical fruitsUnique climate/soil niches – coffee, tropical fruits
Trade measures that restrict flows make adjustmentsTrade measures that restrict flows make adjustments more difficult
INTERNATIONAL FOOD POLICY RESEARCH INSTITUTE Page 28
Concluding remarksg
Our children will pay the price of climate changep y p g
We must start adaptation now if we are to feed theWe must start adaptation now if we are to feed the world sustainably and reduce poverty
Agriculture can play an important role in mitigating GHG emissionsGHG emissions
Including agriculture in a Copenhagen agreement isIncluding agriculture in a Copenhagen agreement is essential
INTERNATIONAL FOOD POLICY RESEARCH INSTITUTE Page 29