aema-arra-issa-ppra fall meeting 2015 -...

39
AEMA-ARRA-ISSA-PPRA Fall Meeting 2015 Recycling, Ayrton Senna Highway Brasil, & USA

Upload: dangtruc

Post on 10-Mar-2019

218 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: AEMA-ARRA-ISSA-PPRA Fall Meeting 2015 - ppralliance.orgppralliance.org/Docs/PPRA2015/Papers/PPRA2015_F1_MikeMarshall_arra... · AEMA-ARRA-ISSA-PPRA Fall Meeting 2015 . ... Before

AEMA-ARRA-ISSA-PPRA Fall Meeting 2015

Recycling, Ayrton Senna Highway Brasil, & USA

Page 2: AEMA-ARRA-ISSA-PPRA Fall Meeting 2015 - ppralliance.orgppralliance.org/Docs/PPRA2015/Papers/PPRA2015_F1_MikeMarshall_arra... · AEMA-ARRA-ISSA-PPRA Fall Meeting 2015 . ... Before

2

2012:

The Ayrton Senna Highway in Brazil was rehabilitated under challenging conditions by using the Wirtgen Cold Recycling technology in plant.

Sao Paulo:

a city with more than

20 million citizen.

CCPR (Cold Central Plant Recycling)

Page 3: AEMA-ARRA-ISSA-PPRA Fall Meeting 2015 - ppralliance.orgppralliance.org/Docs/PPRA2015/Papers/PPRA2015_F1_MikeMarshall_arra... · AEMA-ARRA-ISSA-PPRA Fall Meeting 2015 . ... Before

3• KMA 220 – Ayrton Senna Highway in Sao Paulo / Brazil

AYRTON SENNA HIGHWAY

CCPR (Cold Central Plant Recycling)

Page 4: AEMA-ARRA-ISSA-PPRA Fall Meeting 2015 - ppralliance.orgppralliance.org/Docs/PPRA2015/Papers/PPRA2015_F1_MikeMarshall_arra... · AEMA-ARRA-ISSA-PPRA Fall Meeting 2015 . ... Before

LOCAL BAR

Page 5: AEMA-ARRA-ISSA-PPRA Fall Meeting 2015 - ppralliance.orgppralliance.org/Docs/PPRA2015/Papers/PPRA2015_F1_MikeMarshall_arra... · AEMA-ARRA-ISSA-PPRA Fall Meeting 2015 . ... Before

Ayrton Senna Highway / Brazil:8-lane divided facility – Brazil’s most heavily trafficked highway

5

CCPR (Cold Central Plant Recycling)

Page 6: AEMA-ARRA-ISSA-PPRA Fall Meeting 2015 - ppralliance.orgppralliance.org/Docs/PPRA2015/Papers/PPRA2015_F1_MikeMarshall_arra... · AEMA-ARRA-ISSA-PPRA Fall Meeting 2015 . ... Before

6

Ayrton Senna Highway / Brazil: Pavementcondition after standard rehabilitation procedure “Mill and Fill”

CCPR (Cold Central Plant Recycling)

Page 7: AEMA-ARRA-ISSA-PPRA Fall Meeting 2015 - ppralliance.orgppralliance.org/Docs/PPRA2015/Papers/PPRA2015_F1_MikeMarshall_arra... · AEMA-ARRA-ISSA-PPRA Fall Meeting 2015 . ... Before

ADT > 250,000vpd (15% Trucks)(OUTER RECYCLED LANE > 15,000 trucks / day in each direction)

Milling & Replacing 4 ins HMA lasts < 3 months

Lane closure only between 21:00 – 05:00

Ayrton Senna Highway / Brazil: Traditional Rehabilitation / Traffic Loading

CCPR (Cold Central Plant Recycling)

Page 8: AEMA-ARRA-ISSA-PPRA Fall Meeting 2015 - ppralliance.orgppralliance.org/Docs/PPRA2015/Papers/PPRA2015_F1_MikeMarshall_arra... · AEMA-ARRA-ISSA-PPRA Fall Meeting 2015 . ... Before

8• Results of pavement investigations

HMA ± 4 ins

CEMENTED CRUSHED STONE (G2) ± 10 ins

CRUSHED STONE (G2) ± 8 ins

SELECTED COARSE GRAVEL (G6) ± 8 ins

EMBANKMENT (RIVER LEEVEE) (G7) Semi-infinite

CCPR (Cold Central Plant Recycling)

Page 9: AEMA-ARRA-ISSA-PPRA Fall Meeting 2015 - ppralliance.orgppralliance.org/Docs/PPRA2015/Papers/PPRA2015_F1_MikeMarshall_arra... · AEMA-ARRA-ISSA-PPRA Fall Meeting 2015 . ... Before

HMA ?13.75 ins

BSM-a 8 ins Nominal

BSM-b HMA2 ins

4 ins

Rehabilitation options

Page 10: AEMA-ARRA-ISSA-PPRA Fall Meeting 2015 - ppralliance.orgppralliance.org/Docs/PPRA2015/Papers/PPRA2015_F1_MikeMarshall_arra... · AEMA-ARRA-ISSA-PPRA Fall Meeting 2015 . ... Before

4 ins

Step 1 - mill off asphalt layers

Page 11: AEMA-ARRA-ISSA-PPRA Fall Meeting 2015 - ppralliance.orgppralliance.org/Docs/PPRA2015/Papers/PPRA2015_F1_MikeMarshall_arra... · AEMA-ARRA-ISSA-PPRA Fall Meeting 2015 . ... Before

11

Construction sequence

Ayrton Senna Highway / Brazil:Milling of the asphalt layer (4 ins) at night

Page 12: AEMA-ARRA-ISSA-PPRA Fall Meeting 2015 - ppralliance.orgppralliance.org/Docs/PPRA2015/Papers/PPRA2015_F1_MikeMarshall_arra... · AEMA-ARRA-ISSA-PPRA Fall Meeting 2015 . ... Before

12

Ayrton Senna Highway / Brazil:Crushing screened RAP – 1 ins minus

Construction sequence

Page 13: AEMA-ARRA-ISSA-PPRA Fall Meeting 2015 - ppralliance.orgppralliance.org/Docs/PPRA2015/Papers/PPRA2015_F1_MikeMarshall_arra... · AEMA-ARRA-ISSA-PPRA Fall Meeting 2015 . ... Before

13

KMA 220 – Sized RAP loaded to CCPR (Cold Central Plant Recycler) BSM (Bitumen Stabilised Material) Mix Design: 2.5% Foamed Asphalt + 1.5% Cement

Construction sequence

Page 14: AEMA-ARRA-ISSA-PPRA Fall Meeting 2015 - ppralliance.orgppralliance.org/Docs/PPRA2015/Papers/PPRA2015_F1_MikeMarshall_arra... · AEMA-ARRA-ISSA-PPRA Fall Meeting 2015 . ... Before

10 ins

Step 2 - mill and remove CTB layer

Page 15: AEMA-ARRA-ISSA-PPRA Fall Meeting 2015 - ppralliance.orgppralliance.org/Docs/PPRA2015/Papers/PPRA2015_F1_MikeMarshall_arra... · AEMA-ARRA-ISSA-PPRA Fall Meeting 2015 . ... Before

15

Ayrton Senna Highway / Brazil:Mill & Remove 10 ins CTB layer in one pass

Construction sequence

Page 16: AEMA-ARRA-ISSA-PPRA Fall Meeting 2015 - ppralliance.orgppralliance.org/Docs/PPRA2015/Papers/PPRA2015_F1_MikeMarshall_arra... · AEMA-ARRA-ISSA-PPRA Fall Meeting 2015 . ... Before

16

Ayrton Senna Highway / Brazil:Paving of the first BSM layer with a thickness of 8 ins

Construction sequence

Page 17: AEMA-ARRA-ISSA-PPRA Fall Meeting 2015 - ppralliance.orgppralliance.org/Docs/PPRA2015/Papers/PPRA2015_F1_MikeMarshall_arra... · AEMA-ARRA-ISSA-PPRA Fall Meeting 2015 . ... Before

17

Ayrton Senna Highway / Brazil: The BSM layeris levelled and pre-compacted with an asphalt paver

Construction sequence

Page 18: AEMA-ARRA-ISSA-PPRA Fall Meeting 2015 - ppralliance.orgppralliance.org/Docs/PPRA2015/Papers/PPRA2015_F1_MikeMarshall_arra... · AEMA-ARRA-ISSA-PPRA Fall Meeting 2015 . ... Before

18

Ayrton Senna Highway / Brazil:Full depth (8ins) compaction of the BSM material with apadfoot roller

Construction sequence

Page 19: AEMA-ARRA-ISSA-PPRA Fall Meeting 2015 - ppralliance.orgppralliance.org/Docs/PPRA2015/Papers/PPRA2015_F1_MikeMarshall_arra... · AEMA-ARRA-ISSA-PPRA Fall Meeting 2015 . ... Before

19

Ayrton Senna Highway / Brazil:Final compaction with a tandem steel drum roller

Construction sequence

Page 20: AEMA-ARRA-ISSA-PPRA Fall Meeting 2015 - ppralliance.orgppralliance.org/Docs/PPRA2015/Papers/PPRA2015_F1_MikeMarshall_arra... · AEMA-ARRA-ISSA-PPRA Fall Meeting 2015 . ... Before

20

Ayrton Senna Highway / Brazil:Paving the second BSM layer 4 ins

Construction sequence

Page 21: AEMA-ARRA-ISSA-PPRA Fall Meeting 2015 - ppralliance.orgppralliance.org/Docs/PPRA2015/Papers/PPRA2015_F1_MikeMarshall_arra... · AEMA-ARRA-ISSA-PPRA Fall Meeting 2015 . ... Before

21

Ayrton Senna Highway / Brazil: 4 ins BSM layer after final compaction. Ready for the asphalt overlay.

Construction sequence

Page 22: AEMA-ARRA-ISSA-PPRA Fall Meeting 2015 - ppralliance.orgppralliance.org/Docs/PPRA2015/Papers/PPRA2015_F1_MikeMarshall_arra... · AEMA-ARRA-ISSA-PPRA Fall Meeting 2015 . ... Before

2 ins HMA (gap-graded / fine mix)

Finish – Pave – 2 ins HMA

Rockfill where heavingwas detected.

Page 23: AEMA-ARRA-ISSA-PPRA Fall Meeting 2015 - ppralliance.orgppralliance.org/Docs/PPRA2015/Papers/PPRA2015_F1_MikeMarshall_arra... · AEMA-ARRA-ISSA-PPRA Fall Meeting 2015 . ... Before

23

Ayrton Senna Highway / Brazil:A tack coat is applied between the BSM and the asphalt layer

Construction sequence

Page 24: AEMA-ARRA-ISSA-PPRA Fall Meeting 2015 - ppralliance.orgppralliance.org/Docs/PPRA2015/Papers/PPRA2015_F1_MikeMarshall_arra... · AEMA-ARRA-ISSA-PPRA Fall Meeting 2015 . ... Before

24

Ayrton Senna Highway / Brazil:Pave 2 ins HMA

Construction sequence

Page 25: AEMA-ARRA-ISSA-PPRA Fall Meeting 2015 - ppralliance.orgppralliance.org/Docs/PPRA2015/Papers/PPRA2015_F1_MikeMarshall_arra... · AEMA-ARRA-ISSA-PPRA Fall Meeting 2015 . ... Before

25

Ayrton Senna Highway / Brazil:

Construction sequence

Page 26: AEMA-ARRA-ISSA-PPRA Fall Meeting 2015 - ppralliance.orgppralliance.org/Docs/PPRA2015/Papers/PPRA2015_F1_MikeMarshall_arra... · AEMA-ARRA-ISSA-PPRA Fall Meeting 2015 . ... Before

26

Monitoring

Ayrton Senna Highway / Brazil:two months under heavy traffic

Page 27: AEMA-ARRA-ISSA-PPRA Fall Meeting 2015 - ppralliance.orgppralliance.org/Docs/PPRA2015/Papers/PPRA2015_F1_MikeMarshall_arra... · AEMA-ARRA-ISSA-PPRA Fall Meeting 2015 . ... Before

Average: 0.45 mm 0.34 mm

Before rehab After rehab

• Deflection decrease from average 0.45 mm to 0.34 mm

Monitoring

Page 28: AEMA-ARRA-ISSA-PPRA Fall Meeting 2015 - ppralliance.orgppralliance.org/Docs/PPRA2015/Papers/PPRA2015_F1_MikeMarshall_arra... · AEMA-ARRA-ISSA-PPRA Fall Meeting 2015 . ... Before

Monitoring

June 2015 – 30 months after construction

Est traffic > 9.0 million trucks

Page 29: AEMA-ARRA-ISSA-PPRA Fall Meeting 2015 - ppralliance.orgppralliance.org/Docs/PPRA2015/Papers/PPRA2015_F1_MikeMarshall_arra... · AEMA-ARRA-ISSA-PPRA Fall Meeting 2015 . ... Before

Decision to Proceed

Confidence in Concept

Page 30: AEMA-ARRA-ISSA-PPRA Fall Meeting 2015 - ppralliance.orgppralliance.org/Docs/PPRA2015/Papers/PPRA2015_F1_MikeMarshall_arra... · AEMA-ARRA-ISSA-PPRA Fall Meeting 2015 . ... Before

I-81 Virginia DoT Recycling Alternative

FIRST MULTI RECYCLING/STABILISATION PROCESS IN N.AMERICA

Interstate I-81

30,000 VPD

8,000 trucks

Continual maintenance problem due to poor base materials

Page 31: AEMA-ARRA-ISSA-PPRA Fall Meeting 2015 - ppralliance.orgppralliance.org/Docs/PPRA2015/Papers/PPRA2015_F1_MikeMarshall_arra... · AEMA-ARRA-ISSA-PPRA Fall Meeting 2015 . ... Before

10 ins Asphalt layers

Poor Clay Support

Native

Mill & Fill Maintenance, limited successCracks reflecting back after 6 months

Page 32: AEMA-ARRA-ISSA-PPRA Fall Meeting 2015 - ppralliance.orgppralliance.org/Docs/PPRA2015/Papers/PPRA2015_F1_MikeMarshall_arra... · AEMA-ARRA-ISSA-PPRA Fall Meeting 2015 . ... Before

ALTERNATE FOAMED ASPHALT STABILISED BASE PROPOSAL

Material StructuralCoefficient

Thickness S.N

SMA 0.44 2 0.88

IM-19.0D 0.44 2 0.88

BM-25.0 0.40 10 4.00

DGAB 21B 0.12 6 0.72

OGB 0.05 12 0.60

Total 32 7.08

Material StructuralCoefficient

Thickness S.N

SMA 0.44 2 0.88

IM-19.0D 0.44 2 0.88

FBSB 0.30 12 3.60

LSSB 0.15 12 1.80

Total 28 7.16

Re-Construction Design Proposed Recycling Alternative

FBSB – Foamed Bitumen Stabilised Base

LSSB – Lime Stabilised Base

Page 33: AEMA-ARRA-ISSA-PPRA Fall Meeting 2015 - ppralliance.orgppralliance.org/Docs/PPRA2015/Papers/PPRA2015_F1_MikeMarshall_arra... · AEMA-ARRA-ISSA-PPRA Fall Meeting 2015 . ... Before

I81 Truck Lane

Page 34: AEMA-ARRA-ISSA-PPRA Fall Meeting 2015 - ppralliance.orgppralliance.org/Docs/PPRA2015/Papers/PPRA2015_F1_MikeMarshall_arra... · AEMA-ARRA-ISSA-PPRA Fall Meeting 2015 . ... Before

Milling 10ins depth Lime Stabilisation 12ins depth

100% Recycle Millings Pave Recycled Millings as Base

Page 35: AEMA-ARRA-ISSA-PPRA Fall Meeting 2015 - ppralliance.orgppralliance.org/Docs/PPRA2015/Papers/PPRA2015_F1_MikeMarshall_arra... · AEMA-ARRA-ISSA-PPRA Fall Meeting 2015 . ... Before

I81 Fast Lane

Page 36: AEMA-ARRA-ISSA-PPRA Fall Meeting 2015 - ppralliance.orgppralliance.org/Docs/PPRA2015/Papers/PPRA2015_F1_MikeMarshall_arra... · AEMA-ARRA-ISSA-PPRA Fall Meeting 2015 . ... Before

Phase 2: LH Fast Lane

Cold In Place Recycle

Depth 5”

Width 12’ 6”

2.2% Foamed Bitumen

Pave with attached AB375T screed

Page 37: AEMA-ARRA-ISSA-PPRA Fall Meeting 2015 - ppralliance.orgppralliance.org/Docs/PPRA2015/Papers/PPRA2015_F1_MikeMarshall_arra... · AEMA-ARRA-ISSA-PPRA Fall Meeting 2015 . ... Before

Concept Summary

Right Lane Traffic

7.8 million trucks

20.2 million cars

Left Lane Traffic(overtaking lane)

1.6 million trucks

3.8 million cars

August 2015 (4 years)

Page 38: AEMA-ARRA-ISSA-PPRA Fall Meeting 2015 - ppralliance.orgppralliance.org/Docs/PPRA2015/Papers/PPRA2015_F1_MikeMarshall_arra... · AEMA-ARRA-ISSA-PPRA Fall Meeting 2015 . ... Before

Economics of Recycling

Questions

Can we recycle and save $

Do we lose performance

YES SAVE $$

NO LOSS OF PERFORMANCEWELL ENGINEERED PRODUCT

Page 39: AEMA-ARRA-ISSA-PPRA Fall Meeting 2015 - ppralliance.orgppralliance.org/Docs/PPRA2015/Papers/PPRA2015_F1_MikeMarshall_arra... · AEMA-ARRA-ISSA-PPRA Fall Meeting 2015 . ... Before