activity report of the nuclear data group at centro ...centro atomico bariloche argentina wpec sg-42...

22
ACTIVITY REPORT OF THE NUCLEAR DATA GROUP AT CENTRO ATOMICO BARILOCHE,ARGENTINA Jos´ e Ignacio M ´ arquez Dami´ an Florencia Cantargi Christian Helman Jos´ e Rolando Granada Neutron Physics Department Centro Atomico Bariloche Argentina WPEC SG-42 third meeting May 16th-18th, 2017 OECD, Paris, France J.I. M ´ ARQUEZ DAMI ´ AN, F. CANTARGI, C. HELMAN, J.R. GRANADA CAB ACTIVITY REPORT WPEC SG-42 1 / 22

Upload: others

Post on 12-Oct-2020

2 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Activity Report of the Nuclear Data Group at Centro ...Centro Atomico Bariloche Argentina WPEC SG-42 third meeting May 16th-18th, 2017 OECD, Paris, France J.I. M ´ARQUEZ DAMI ´AN

ACTIVITY REPORT OF THENUCLEAR DATA GROUP

AT CENTRO ATOMICO BARILOCHE, ARGENTINA

Jose Ignacio Marquez DamianFlorencia CantargiChristian Helman

Jose Rolando Granada

Neutron Physics DepartmentCentro Atomico Bariloche

Argentina

WPEC SG-42 third meetingMay 16th-18th, 2017OECD, Paris, France

J.I. MARQUEZ DAMIAN, F. CANTARGI, C. HELMAN, J.R. GRANADA CAB ACTIVITY REPORT WPEC SG-42 1 / 22

Page 2: Activity Report of the Nuclear Data Group at Centro ...Centro Atomico Bariloche Argentina WPEC SG-42 third meeting May 16th-18th, 2017 OECD, Paris, France J.I. M ´ARQUEZ DAMI ´AN

WHO WE ARE: THERMAL SCATTERING NUCLEAR DATA GROUP ATCENTRO ATOMICO BARILOCHE

Rolando Granada Florencia Cantargi Christian Helman Ignacio MarquezScattering theory

and advancedneutron sources

Cold moderatormaterials andneutron filters

Solid state physicsand ab initio

methods

Nuclear reactorapplications andbenchmarking

Past members: Monica Sbaffoni (currently at IAEA), Victor Gillette (currently atUniversity of Sharjah, U.A.E).

J.I. MARQUEZ DAMIAN, F. CANTARGI, C. HELMAN, J.R. GRANADA CAB ACTIVITY REPORT WPEC SG-42 2 / 22

Page 3: Activity Report of the Nuclear Data Group at Centro ...Centro Atomico Bariloche Argentina WPEC SG-42 third meeting May 16th-18th, 2017 OECD, Paris, France J.I. M ´ARQUEZ DAMI ´AN

WHAT WE DO

LD2

H2O

H2O

D2O

CH2

PMMA

TBP

Dodecane

Mesitylene (l)

LH2

Mesitylene (s)

Mesitylene (s)

Clathrate

Ice

Ice

Ice

Mesitylene (s)

Mesitylene (s)

D2O

SD2

Mesitylene (s)

CH4 (s)

CH4 (l)

Mesi / Toluene

Silicon(monocrystalline)

Silicon(polycrystalline)

Silicon(monocrystalline)

Silicon(polycrystalline)

Sapphire

Bismuth

SiO2

H2O

J.I. MARQUEZ DAMIAN, F. CANTARGI, C. HELMAN, J.R. GRANADA CAB ACTIVITY REPORT WPEC SG-42 3 / 22

Page 4: Activity Report of the Nuclear Data Group at Centro ...Centro Atomico Bariloche Argentina WPEC SG-42 third meeting May 16th-18th, 2017 OECD, Paris, France J.I. M ´ARQUEZ DAMI ´AN

ACTIVITY REPORT

1. Development of new scattering kernels.

2. Collaboration with NEA - JEFF.

3. Collaboration with CSEWG - ENDF/B.

4. Activities in support of LAHN Project.

5. Other R&D activities and collaborations.

J.I. MARQUEZ DAMIAN, F. CANTARGI, C. HELMAN, J.R. GRANADA CAB ACTIVITY REPORT WPEC SG-42 4 / 22

Page 5: Activity Report of the Nuclear Data Group at Centro ...Centro Atomico Bariloche Argentina WPEC SG-42 third meeting May 16th-18th, 2017 OECD, Paris, France J.I. M ´ARQUEZ DAMI ´AN

1A) DEVELOPMENT OF NEW SCATTERING KERNELS: LIQUID ETHANE

Liquid ethane has been proposed by Dr. Granada as an interesting replacementfor liquid methane as an intermediate energy “cool” neutron moderator:

Wide temperature range as a liquid (90 - 184 K).Important protonic density (higher than liquid methane).Presence of low energy CH3 rotational modes.

Development continues this year with transmission measurements at Vesubio(ISIS - UK).

J.I. MARQUEZ DAMIAN, F. CANTARGI, C. HELMAN, J.R. GRANADA CAB ACTIVITY REPORT WPEC SG-42 5 / 22

Page 6: Activity Report of the Nuclear Data Group at Centro ...Centro Atomico Bariloche Argentina WPEC SG-42 third meeting May 16th-18th, 2017 OECD, Paris, France J.I. M ´ARQUEZ DAMI ´AN

1A) DEVELOPMENT OF NEW SCATTERING KERNELS: LIQUID ETHANE

1E-3 0.01 0.1 1

1E-6

1E-5

1E-4

(E

)

E (eV)

Water 293KMethane 22KMethane 100K

Thermal

Cold

Cool

J.I. MARQUEZ DAMIAN, F. CANTARGI, C. HELMAN, J.R. GRANADA CAB ACTIVITY REPORT WPEC SG-42 6 / 22

Page 7: Activity Report of the Nuclear Data Group at Centro ...Centro Atomico Bariloche Argentina WPEC SG-42 third meeting May 16th-18th, 2017 OECD, Paris, France J.I. M ´ARQUEZ DAMI ´AN

1A) DEVELOPMENT OF NEW SCATTERING KERNELS: LIQUID ETHANE

80 100 120 140 160 180

6

7

8

9

ls

s

s-MESITYLENE

WATER-RT

METHANE

Pro

ton

Den

sity

(10

22at

/cm

3 )

T (K)http://www.engineeringtoolbox.com/ethane-thermal-properties-d_1761.html

ETHANE

o

os

l

J.I. MARQUEZ DAMIAN, F. CANTARGI, C. HELMAN, J.R. GRANADA CAB ACTIVITY REPORT WPEC SG-42 7 / 22

Page 8: Activity Report of the Nuclear Data Group at Centro ...Centro Atomico Bariloche Argentina WPEC SG-42 third meeting May 16th-18th, 2017 OECD, Paris, France J.I. M ´ARQUEZ DAMI ´AN

1A) DEVELOPMENT OF NEW SCATTERING KERNELS: LIQUID ETHANE

J.I. MARQUEZ DAMIAN, F. CANTARGI, C. HELMAN, J.R. GRANADA CAB ACTIVITY REPORT WPEC SG-42 8 / 22

Page 9: Activity Report of the Nuclear Data Group at Centro ...Centro Atomico Bariloche Argentina WPEC SG-42 third meeting May 16th-18th, 2017 OECD, Paris, France J.I. M ´ARQUEZ DAMI ´AN

1A) DEVELOPMENT OF NEW SCATTERING KERNELS: LIQUID ETHANE

J.I. MARQUEZ DAMIAN, F. CANTARGI, C. HELMAN, J.R. GRANADA CAB ACTIVITY REPORT WPEC SG-42 9 / 22

Page 10: Activity Report of the Nuclear Data Group at Centro ...Centro Atomico Bariloche Argentina WPEC SG-42 third meeting May 16th-18th, 2017 OECD, Paris, France J.I. M ´ARQUEZ DAMI ´AN

1B) DEVELOPMENT OF NEW SCATTERING KERNELS: LIQUID HYDROGENAND DEUTERIUM

The COLDH subroutine in LEAPR applies the Young-Koppel model for quantumrotators to hydrogen and deuterium.

The subroutine applies a Vineyard correction to the translational motion of themolecule. This is incorrect, and was corrected by Granada and Gillette in 2004.

The current model is an update of the model by Granada and Gillette, using theSkold approximation for the coherent correction and updating the frequencyspectra and structure factors.

New evaluations available for 14 -20 K (ortho/para H2) and 19-23 K (ortho/paraD2).

J.I. MARQUEZ DAMIAN, F. CANTARGI, C. HELMAN, J.R. GRANADA CAB ACTIVITY REPORT WPEC SG-42 10 / 22

Page 11: Activity Report of the Nuclear Data Group at Centro ...Centro Atomico Bariloche Argentina WPEC SG-42 third meeting May 16th-18th, 2017 OECD, Paris, France J.I. M ´ARQUEZ DAMI ´AN

1B) DEVELOPMENT OF NEW SCATTERING KERNELS: LIQUID HYDROGENAND DEUTERIUM

1×10-4

1×10-2

1×100

1×102

Energy [eV]

1

10

100S

ca

tte

rin

g C

ross S

ectio

n [

b]

CelliGrammerENDF/B-VII (20 K)

New CAB Evaluation (19 K)

Seiffer (- 0.5% ortho H)

J.I. MARQUEZ DAMIAN, F. CANTARGI, C. HELMAN, J.R. GRANADA CAB ACTIVITY REPORT WPEC SG-42 11 / 22

Page 12: Activity Report of the Nuclear Data Group at Centro ...Centro Atomico Bariloche Argentina WPEC SG-42 third meeting May 16th-18th, 2017 OECD, Paris, France J.I. M ´ARQUEZ DAMI ´AN

1B) DEVELOPMENT OF NEW SCATTERING KERNELS: LIQUID HYDROGENAND DEUTERIUM

1×10-4

1×10-2

1×100

Energy [eV]

10

100

1000S

ca

tte

rin

g C

ross S

ectio

n [

b]

Seiffert (normal H)

New CAB evaluation (19 K)

ENDF/B-VII (20 K)

J.I. MARQUEZ DAMIAN, F. CANTARGI, C. HELMAN, J.R. GRANADA CAB ACTIVITY REPORT WPEC SG-42 12 / 22

Page 13: Activity Report of the Nuclear Data Group at Centro ...Centro Atomico Bariloche Argentina WPEC SG-42 third meeting May 16th-18th, 2017 OECD, Paris, France J.I. M ´ARQUEZ DAMI ´AN

1B) DEVELOPMENT OF NEW SCATTERING KERNELS: LIQUID HYDROGENAND DEUTERIUM

1×10-5

1×10-4

1×10-3

1×10-2

1×10-1

1×100

1×101

Energy [eV]

10

20S

ca

tte

rin

g C

ross S

ectio

n p

er

D2 m

ole

cu

le [

b]

PSI (low energy)

PSISeiffertNew CAB EvaluationENDF/B-VII evaluation

J.I. MARQUEZ DAMIAN, F. CANTARGI, C. HELMAN, J.R. GRANADA CAB ACTIVITY REPORT WPEC SG-42 13 / 22

Page 14: Activity Report of the Nuclear Data Group at Centro ...Centro Atomico Bariloche Argentina WPEC SG-42 third meeting May 16th-18th, 2017 OECD, Paris, France J.I. M ´ARQUEZ DAMI ´AN

1B) DEVELOPMENT OF NEW SCATTERING KERNELS: LIQUID HYDROGENAND DEUTERIUM

Code is available as a development branch of NJOYin our repository at Github:

https://github.com/marquezj/NJOY2016/tree/H2D2

Combining the options ncold and nsk, different models can be used:

ncold nsk model

1/2/3/4 0 ENDF/B-VI models1/2/3/4 1 Granada model (2004)1/2/3/4 2 Granada model (2017)

The code also allows to change smin as an input parameter.

J.I. MARQUEZ DAMIAN, F. CANTARGI, C. HELMAN, J.R. GRANADA CAB ACTIVITY REPORT WPEC SG-42 14 / 22

Page 15: Activity Report of the Nuclear Data Group at Centro ...Centro Atomico Bariloche Argentina WPEC SG-42 third meeting May 16th-18th, 2017 OECD, Paris, France J.I. M ´ARQUEZ DAMI ´AN

2) COLLABORATION WITH NEA - JEFF

Collaboration NEA to provide scattering kernels to JEFF:Thermal moderators: light water, heavy water.Cold moderators: light water ice, mesitylene, tolune, methane, liquid hydrogen, liquiddeuterium.Neutron filters: silicon, sapphire.

Nuclear data users from the advanced neutron sources community (many inEurope) will be benefited.

JEFF will become the most complete evaluated data library for neutron scatteringapplications

(see talk by Florencia Cantargi at 15:30)

J.I. MARQUEZ DAMIAN, F. CANTARGI, C. HELMAN, J.R. GRANADA CAB ACTIVITY REPORT WPEC SG-42 15 / 22

Page 16: Activity Report of the Nuclear Data Group at Centro ...Centro Atomico Bariloche Argentina WPEC SG-42 third meeting May 16th-18th, 2017 OECD, Paris, France J.I. M ´ARQUEZ DAMI ´AN

3) COLLABORATION WITH CSEWG - ENDF/B

Participation in CSEWG in support of ENDF/B, in collaboration with Danila Roubtsovfrom Canadian Nuclear Laboratories:

Continued support for light and heavy water libraries: extrapolation to 650 and800 K (light water) and 650 K (heavy water).

Coordination of TSL section in the ”big paper”.

Collaboration with BNL on QA of TSL libraries: standarization of basic TSLchecks.

J.I. MARQUEZ DAMIAN, F. CANTARGI, C. HELMAN, J.R. GRANADA CAB ACTIVITY REPORT WPEC SG-42 16 / 22

Page 17: Activity Report of the Nuclear Data Group at Centro ...Centro Atomico Bariloche Argentina WPEC SG-42 third meeting May 16th-18th, 2017 OECD, Paris, France J.I. M ´ARQUEZ DAMI ´AN

4) ACTIVITIES IN SUPPORT OF LAHN PROJECT.

LAHN (Laboratorio Argentino de Haces de Neutrones) is a project for thescientific utilization of neutron beams at the future RA-10 reactor.

RA-10 is a 30 MW experimental reactor being built at Centro Atomico Ezeiza,Argentina.

First concrete poured on May 6th, expected to become critical in 2019.

The Nuclear Data Group is supporting this project by providing shielding andbeam shielding calculations, and helping with education and training.

J.I. MARQUEZ DAMIAN, F. CANTARGI, C. HELMAN, J.R. GRANADA CAB ACTIVITY REPORT WPEC SG-42 17 / 22

Page 18: Activity Report of the Nuclear Data Group at Centro ...Centro Atomico Bariloche Argentina WPEC SG-42 third meeting May 16th-18th, 2017 OECD, Paris, France J.I. M ´ARQUEZ DAMI ´AN

4) ACTIVITIES IN SUPPORT OF LAHN PROJECT.

J.I. MARQUEZ DAMIAN, F. CANTARGI, C. HELMAN, J.R. GRANADA CAB ACTIVITY REPORT WPEC SG-42 18 / 22

Page 19: Activity Report of the Nuclear Data Group at Centro ...Centro Atomico Bariloche Argentina WPEC SG-42 third meeting May 16th-18th, 2017 OECD, Paris, France J.I. M ´ARQUEZ DAMI ´AN

4) ACTIVITIES IN SUPPORT OF LAHN PROJECT.

J.I. MARQUEZ DAMIAN, F. CANTARGI, C. HELMAN, J.R. GRANADA CAB ACTIVITY REPORT WPEC SG-42 19 / 22

Page 20: Activity Report of the Nuclear Data Group at Centro ...Centro Atomico Bariloche Argentina WPEC SG-42 third meeting May 16th-18th, 2017 OECD, Paris, France J.I. M ´ARQUEZ DAMI ´AN

5) OTHER R&D ACTIVITIES AND COLLABORATIONS

Ab initio calculations: beryllium and uranium dioxide.

Development of LEAPR/NJOY: contributions will be made available online.

Collaboration with CCHEN (Chile): calculation of delayed neutron fraction andeffective delayed neutron fraction.

Collaboration with PSI (Switzerland): transmission experiments in cold water /ice.

Participation in UCANS / ICANS.

IAEA CRP on Advanced Moderators for Intense Cold Neutron Beams in MaterialsResearch.

J.I. MARQUEZ DAMIAN, F. CANTARGI, C. HELMAN, J.R. GRANADA CAB ACTIVITY REPORT WPEC SG-42 20 / 22

Page 21: Activity Report of the Nuclear Data Group at Centro ...Centro Atomico Bariloche Argentina WPEC SG-42 third meeting May 16th-18th, 2017 OECD, Paris, France J.I. M ´ARQUEZ DAMI ´AN

5) COLLABORATION WITH PSI.

0 2 4 6 8 10Wavelength [A]

0

50

100

150

200

250To

tal c

ross

sec

tion

per H

2O m

olec

ule

[b]

Ice (-2 °C)Liquid Water (6 °C)Supercooled water (-2 °C)Room temp (20 °C)

PRELIMINARYDATA

Comparison of preliminary ice and water transmission data with TSL models. Datawas measured by Pierre Boilat and Muriel Siegwart from PSI at the test beamline of

BER II reactor.

J.I. MARQUEZ DAMIAN, F. CANTARGI, C. HELMAN, J.R. GRANADA CAB ACTIVITY REPORT WPEC SG-42 21 / 22

Page 22: Activity Report of the Nuclear Data Group at Centro ...Centro Atomico Bariloche Argentina WPEC SG-42 third meeting May 16th-18th, 2017 OECD, Paris, France J.I. M ´ARQUEZ DAMI ´AN

THANKS FOR YOUR TIME.QUESTIONS?

PATAGONIA, ARGENTINA