accounts chamber of the russian federation approaches to comprehensive project and program audit in...
TRANSCRIPT
Accounts Chamber of the Russian Federation
Approaches to comprehensive
project and program auditin the Accounts Chamberof the Russian Federation
Main problems for project implementations
• Incompleteness and inconsistencyof information.
• Irrelevance and lack of coordinationin management decisions.
• Poor resource management.
2
Information technology improvements in management and audit
3
Structure of this talk
• Methodology:
– comprehensive audit;
– architecture and capabilities evaluation;
– scenario evaluation.
• Tools:
– resource and schedule audit;
– interval-based evaluations.
4
METHODOLOGY
5
The architecture of comprehensive audit
6
Indicators for comprehensive evaluation
7
The practice of comprehensive audit
8
Some approaches to activity management
• Classic project management.
• Business performance management (BPM).
• Architecture management.
• Capability management.
• Net-centricity.
9
The scheme of the methodical and IT infrastructure
10
Evaluating architecture
• Coherence of the architecture withthe goals and budgets.
• Interaction of stakeholders.
• Cost of ownership.
• Dynamics of architectural change.
112
According to ANSI/IEEE 1471-2000:
Architecture is the fundamental organization of a system embodied in its components*, their relationships to each other and to the
environment, and the principles guiding its design and evolution
* - information, financing, materials, products …..
Using the capabilities approach fora comprehensive evaluation of an information system
12
Capability: property of a system, probability that the system will succeed in achieving the goal of its functioning.
The correspondence between required and predicted state sets in the functioning of a system can be represented as the probability of the following binary predicate being true:
1,
дk k
k K
Poss Y Y
, 1, ;kY k K прогнозные значения
, 1, .дkY k K требуемые значения
predicted state set
required state set
Methodical basis for comprehensive scenario evaluation
13
TOOLS
14
Information technology for assessment of large projects
15
Audit of programs and projects (software package)
Interval-based assessment of investment projects
16
Estimating capabilities with an interval analysis system
17
Capability indicator at a high level
18
19
The capability level requires detailed analysis
Capability indicator at a critically low level
20
Conclusion
The application of these methods and tools will allow to formulate recommendations on:
• improving the feasibility of projects and programs,
• minimizing negative consequences of projects,
• reducing risks in project implementations,
• and generally improving efficiency of projects.
21
Questions?