accl steering committee july 16, 2012 with data
TRANSCRIPT
Steering CommitteeAthens-Clarke County Library
Strategic Plan
July 15, 2012
Gail Griffith
Athens-Clarke County Library
Planning Process Overview
Library Board AdoptsPlan
Steering Committee Meeting #2:
Learning more about the library and best practices;
gap analysis
Steering Committee
Meeting #3: Review and react
to draft documents
Athens-Clarke County:The Comprehensive
Plan
Library BoardInput Session
Data Review:Census, Economic Analysis, Recent Library planning data
Core Planners begin to
meet
Our wiki is a place to share and learn:http://athenslibraryplan.pbworks.com
Confidential project hotline:[email protected]
Steering Committee Meeting #1:Trends identification, community vision, library roles
Outcome: A vibrant Athens-Clarke County Library in 2016, supported and enjoyed by the entire community
Online Survey for
Community and Staff
Key Stakeholder Interviews
Best Practices Research
Staff Team Input
Session
Gail L. Griffith for Athens-Clarke County Library
Staff Visioning Sessions: All Staff
Contribute
February May July September October 2012
2012
Focus Groups
Three Meetings
May July September
•Provide information about community needs
•Participate in a trends analysis
•Help build a vision of the community and the library’s role in meeting that vision
•Learn more about the Library and what it is well-positioned to do
•Learn about trends in libraries
•Help to identify priorities
•Review project findings and recommendations
What We Heard in May
Board, Steering, Staff SWOT
Visions
Organizational Strengths and Weaknesses (From Board, Staff)
Strengths Weaknesses
•Staff!
•Youth programming
•Access and inclusiveness
•Technology
•Collection, including newer formats
•Leadership and advocacy, including at the State level
•Shrinking resources/need financial independence
•How to engage non-users?
•Technology upgrades needed/mobile presence
•Patron behavior issues and how they affect perceptions
•Stronger programming for adults
•Internal communication improvements
Trends that Bring Opportunities and Threats
Common to the Lists of Board, Steering, and Staff Groups
1. High poverty level
2. Becoming international, multicultural, and multiracial community—still segregated
3. E-books and changes in the publishing industry
4. Growing population of seniors
5. Education system facing large cuts, flight of affluent families
6. High dropout rate
7. Technology changing rapidly—what and when to acquire?
Vision Themes
Diversity
Opportunity
Connectedness
Caring
Empowerment
Progressive
Prosperous
Educated
Libraries can’t operate in a bubble. Much more partnering is needed. Some of our uniqueness has been lost—so we need to work on that.
The library is an unlimited and inclusive resource for the community, dedicated to public service with person-to-person interaction, and focusing on learning.
Serving the community by developing internal and external relationships, bringing people into the library, and improving the community’s quality of life
Staff: Library of the Year, 2016
Steering: Ideal Athens
8
Stakeholder Interviews
Summary (8 of 13—Interviews still in progress)
July 2012
9
Purpose of Interviews
To collect data from key stakeholders for input into the strategic plan
To enhance relationships and opportunities for collaboration
10
Who we interviewed
Valdon Daniel, Principal of Oglethorpe Middle School (retired)
Phil Pollock, former head of UGA Institute of Government, Talking Book volunteer
Mary Quinn, former City Council, Friends of the Library
Commissioner Harry Sims
Julie Walker, Deputy State Librarian, Athens resident
Barbara Dooley, businesswoman and motivational speaker
Doc Eldridge, President and CEO, A-CC Chamber of Commerce
Kay Giese, attorney and retired Municipal Court Judge
Commissioner Kelly Girtz
Don Nelson, Communications Coordinator, Athens Technical College
Dr. William Gray Potter, UGA Associate Provost and University Librarian
Diego del Pozo, UGA Lecturer, Romance Languages
Amanda Tedrow, Agriculture and Natural Resources Extension Agent, Cooperative Extension Service
11
Relationship with the Library
All positive!
Some worked closely with the library
Even non-users felt positive about the library and its importance to the community
12
Strengths
Library Outreach (3) Is a presence in the community, makes itself
accessible (2) Levels the playing field, providing opportunities to
all Involves the community Provides good community meeting space Provides broad range of services—programs,
collection, public meetings, literacy
13
Strengths
Technology
Computer access for public, well-used (2)
Keeps up to date
Online access to PINES and account
Computers important for job seekers
Staff
Helpful and knowledgeable overall
Provide good service
Children’s department staff especially strong
Leadership and Advocacy—Kathie is one of the strongest Directors in the state
“Kathryn and her staff have done an incredible job with limited resources of providing what the community needs. “
14
Strengths
Programs
Youth programs excellent and important, help introduce children to reading (3)
Community programs (2)
Library is a good partner for programs—handles logistics well and attends to partner’s needs
Collection
Good collection overall (2)
Book collection well-used
Galileo
15
Weaknesses or Limitations
More current e-Books—hard to find anything both interesting AND available (2)
More books on CD (2) Would love to see a
significant branch with great children’s services on the east side of town
Website could be more user-friendly
Wish we still had bookmobiles—both a symbol and a way to provide access
More social networking More activities to draw in the
whole community? Example—film festival around cultural issues
More computer access for disadvantaged?
Expand Heritage Room, provide access to statewide digitized materials (or promote if already doing)
16
Trends
Shift to digital and online (6) Must be online to participate in the world; can’t even find a job
without it Technology influences how people read, learn, are entertained Free access to downloadable books, music, and movies could
attract a group of non-users Easy to get so much from home and office, need to work
harder to draw people in It’s everywhere—plants at Botanical Garden will have QR codes
Economic turnaround—when? (2)
Caterpillar plant coming, with jobs (2)
17
Trends
High poverty rate (2)
Athens is a music town—could the library tie into it? (2)
High teen pregnancy rate
Latino population growing
18
Unmet Community Needs
Bifurcated community in terms of education, jobs, wealth—need to serve both parts of the community (5)
Need to engage children in their own education
Tremendous resources exist (UGA, Athens Tech); need to do more to determine what synchronicities are possible
20% of public school population is Hispanic, many come from homes where only Spanish is spoken
Community always needs space to come together and engage in activities
19
Ideas for Partnering
Local history/genealogy programs with UGA Special Collections Library
More digitization projects with UGA
Orientations for AT students
Full-day conference with multiple speakers from CES—maybe a fundraiser for the library?
Hold more community events that appeal to broad range of people—not just literature-based programs
Osher Lifelong Learning Institute at UGA (OLLI)
Whatever It Takes: Athens Community Plan for Children
20
Opportunities to Improve Relationship
“You are doing it now by reaching out to me! I feel like I need to get involved now.”
Be more visible participants in events like those of the Chamber of Commerce, where many potential partners come together.
Many expressed interest in creating more links to the community themselves—seemed to be waiting to be asked!
21
Ways to Tell Story
Outreach (3) Go to schools and talk to students Visit large employers and tell them what’s in it for their
employees Distribute online newsletter to partners, have them link or
distribute within their network
Create relationships with opinion leaders and use their word-of-mouth; face-to-face works here (2)
Social media—does library have a Facebook page? (2)
Get a consultant, skilled volunteer, or marketing intern to help analyze your promotion. Community has large group of retirees with expert knowledge. (2)
22
Ways to Tell Story
Need a new marketing campaign with new attitude to go along with the new building. “We’re here—we rock and roll.” (2)
Seek out opportunities to have events like candidate forums that could be broadcast from the library
Library Board is key—they should be connected and use their connections
23
Advice for Us
Continue to think about how to leverage resources and keep them going
Make sure you have marketing and technology expertise on your Board
Serve everyone, including the disadvantaged
Look for ways to draw non-users in
Work with leaders of the Hispanic community
Ask for suggestions from the public and show how you’re acting on them
24
Advice for us
It’s all going digital, you have to be there!
“Don’t give up! Think of yourselves as a crucial community resource. Don’t lose sight of this—you are education and learning at the core. And don’t be afraid to say it!”
25
Keep at all Costs…
Basic collection (2)
Facilities in lower-income neighborhoods
Keep technology alive
“Children’s services are the most critical. Nobody else is doing what you are doing for children.”
26
$1,000,000
Improve the lives of the disadvantaged (5) Partner with social workers
and educators to raise their sights
Ensure access to technology
Put together a dynamite marketing campaign that makes people think of the library as exciting (2)
Put some in an endowment for future needs (2)
Outreach—go into the community with books and programs
Keep up with trends
Keep collection as strong as possible
Improve technology, including resources accessed remotely
27
Library Staff Survey
Summary of FeedbackJuly 2012
28
Survey
Online Zoomerang survey
Sent to all staff
Received 54 responses Response rate =?
Questions covered Programs and services Suggestions for change
29
Demographics: Length of Service
Less than one year 11%
1-5 years 44%
6-10 years 19%
11+ years 26%
Total 100%
30
What would entice the public to use the library more often?
Number Percent
Easier to use PINES database to find and request books and other materials 45 70%
Have the books and media I want available when I want them 41 64%
Easier to download books from the library's website 40 62%
Better selection of books, music, and other media 36 56%
Knowing more about what services and resources are available 36 56%
More computers in the library 34 53%
Offer drop-off boxes at other locations in the community so I can return my books more easily 23 36%
Have staff available to help me when I need it 21 33%
Make it possible for me to check out and check in my own materials 20 31%
Staff assistance more proactive--staff roving or maintaining constant awareness and availability to help me 11 17%
I am completely satisfied with the services and resources available at the Library 9 14%
Staff assistance more courteous 4 6%
31
What else?
Small group meeting spaces (3)
Better, faster computers and wi-fi throughout building (2)
Easier to search PINES
Way to pay fines online or by phone
More tutorial options for job seekers
More staff
More computer training
Better organized web page, easier to find what services are available
Way to keep sleeping patrons from discouraging use by others—solution unknown
32
Select up to Four Critical Service Responses
33
If You Could Choose Only One…
34
Top 3 Improvements with Largest Impact on Public Service
Be creative and systematic in the recruitment, training, and use of volunteers
Provide programs and services (like computer classes) off-site
Offer more opportunities for people to enrich their lives. Examples: book discussions, digital content creation labs, programs including music, arts, crafts
35
Community Survey
Summary of FeedbackJuly 2012
36
Survey
Online Zoomerang survey available on website June 5—July 8
Also distributed in hard copy
English and Spanish
Received 1097 responses (9 in Spanish)
Questions covered Programs and services Suggestions for change
37
Where are you completing this survey? Number Percent
Athens-Clarke County Library (Athens-Clarke County) 918 84%
Online, from somewhere other than a library 139 13%
On paper, from somewhere other than a library 8 1%
East Athens Resource Center (Athens-Clarke County) 1 0%
Lay Park Resource Center (Athens-Clarke County) 2 0%Pinewoods Library & Learning Center (Athens-Clarke County) 8 0%
Winterville Branch Library (Athens-Clarke County) 4 0%
Lavonia-Carnegie Library (Franklin County) 1 0%
Royston Public Library (Franklin County) 3 0%
Madison County Library (Madison County) 5 0%
Bogart Branch Library (Oconee County) 2 0%
Oconee County Library (Oconee County) 4 0%
Oglethorpe County Library (Oglethorpe County) 2 0%
1088 100%
38
Demographics: Gender
39
Demographics: Age
40
Demographics: Computer with internet access at home
41
How often do you visit the library or the website?
42
Do you have a PINES card?
43
Borrow, use, or reserve library material such as books, CDs, DVDs 529 49%
Use library computers or wi-fi 211 19%
Specifically to complete this survey 84 8%
Other, please specify* 69 7%
Attend a program or event for children (ages birth-10) 40 4%
Get information from the library's resources, including online research tools 35 3%
Use library web site to find information 32 3%
Prepare a resume or look for a job online 24 2%
Get homework help 9 1%
Conduct genealogical research 6 1%
Use the photocopier or fax machine 7 1%
Borrow an e-book or learn more about e-books 15 1%
Attend a program or event for adults 5 0%
Attend a program or event for families 5 0%
Attend a program or event for teens 2 0%Attend a Friends of the Library meeting or work with the Friends of the Library 4 0%
Attend a computer training session 2 0%
Apply for or get information about a U.S. passport 2 0%
Obtain information from a library staff member 4 0%
Primary Reason for Visiting the Library or Website Today
44
Other Reasons For Visit
Read, study, work using my own laptop
Use printer
Return items
Summer program info
45
How satisfied are you with your visit today?
46
I would have been more satisfied…
If I could have found the material I wanted in the library 95 45%
Other, please specify* 50 24%
If there were more computers available to use in the library 35 17%
If the PINES database had been easier to use 28 13%
If there were more electronic resources available 25 12%
If the library’s website had been easier to use 17 8%
If the website had the information I needed 11 5%
If staff were more helpful and courteous 8 4%
If there were more staff available to help me 8 4%
If the program were more stimulating 6 3%
47
“Other”—I would have been more satisfied if…
Specific subjects, titles were available
There were quiet rooms
There were more parking
I could renew my library card online
I could check out books using my smartphone
I could request media from other libraries
E-book downloads were more user-friendly
Your hours were longer
I could get a job here
48 comments
48
Which of the library’s services have you used in the past year?
1. Borrow, use, or reserve library material such as books, CDs, DVDs 824 80%
2. Use library computers or wi-fi 474 46%3. Use library web site to find information 290 28%4. Get information from the library's resources, including
online research tools 243 24%5. Obtain information from a library staff member 200 19%6. Attend a program or event for children (ages birth—10) 183 18%7. Use the photocopier or fax machine 174 17%8. Attend a program or event for adults 143 14%9. Attend a program or event for families 131 13%10. Borrow an ebook or learn more about ebooks 125 12%
49
Which of the library’s services have you used in the past year? (continued)
11.Prepare a resume or look for a job online 99 10%
12.Apply for or get information about a US passport 47 5%
13.Conduct genealogical research 54 5%
14.Get homework help 44 4%
15.Attend a program or event for teens 40 4%
16.Other, please specify* 42 4%
17. Attend a Friends of the Library meeting or work with the Friends of the Library 36 3%
18.Attend a computer training session 23 2%
50
Other Services Used
Host an event
Tutor
Use digital scanner
Apply for jobs
Get tax forms
Came on a field trip
Meet friends
Donate books
Attend book sale
37 comments
51
In my experience with the library, I am satisfied with the following:
1 Helpfulness/courtesy of staff 94
2 Overall satisfaction with my most recent experience at the library 91
3 Hours of operation 84
4 Availability of the books, movies, and music I want to borrow 83
5 Ease of using the website to find hours, services, and access online research tools
78
6 Ease of using the PINES database to find materials, place holds, or renew materials online
72
7 Quality of reference services 70
8 Access to online research tools 64
9 Speed of library internet connection 58
10 Waiting time to use computers 50
11 Quality of programs and events for children 49
12 Quality of programs and events for families 45
13 Quality of programs and events for adults 45
14 Ease of locating and downloading e-books and e-audio 35
15 Quality of educational programs, such as computer training 35
16 Quality of programs and events for teens 33
52
“Other” Changes
Longer hours ($)
More e-books
Finish construction
More fun and free events, including for adults
Less noise
Require better behavior of patrons
Branch library on east side
Tutorial on the library
Longer checkout for DVDs, renew online
And many compliments
142 comments
53
1 Friends or family 429 44%2 Newspaper stories 388 40%3 Radio 338 35%4 Newspaper advertisements 308 32%5 Posters and flyers 273 28%6 Email from the sponsoring organization 208 21%7 School 167 17%8 Local television news 158 16%9 Social networks like Facebook or Twitter 160 16%10 Websites of local news organizations 124 13%11 Other, please specify* 87 9%12 Television advertisements 81 8%13 Sponsoring organization's website 72 7%14 RSS feeds or blogs 25 3%15 Text message alerts via cell phone 34 3%
How do you hear about local community events?
54
“Other” ways to hear about community events
UGA staff listserv
Community volunteers who visit my neighborhood
Flagpole
athensparent.com calendar
Yahoo! Parenting groups
We need an Athens web page for cultural events!
78 comments
55
What else would you like us to know?
322 comments! Still being analyzed, but we see: Lots and lots of kudos, including compliments for
individual staff Requests for specific materials or specific changes to
programs Comments desiring a more ‘quiet, safe, and pleasant’
experience
What stood out for you?
What ideas for changing or emphasizing services do you get from the survey results?
What delights or surprises you?
What other ideas would you like to see in the mix?
What are the top 3 ideas you think the Athens-Clarke County Library should pursue?
Next Steps