Accelerating Change December 3, 2015 By Stuart Cohen S CENARIO P ERFORMANCE A SSESSMENT Comparing Forecasted Outcomes to Regional Targets 14 S CENARIO P ERFORMANCE A SSESSMENT Comparing Forecasted Outcomes to Regional Targets 15 C ALTRAIN D OWNTOWN E XTENSION S AMPLE H IGH - P ERFORMING P ROJECTS P RIORITIZED FOR R EGIONAL F UNDING BART M ETRO U RBAN BRT S YSTEMS F REEWAY P ERFORMANCE I NITIATIVE SMART E XPANSION D UMBARTON R AIL F REEWAY W IDENING (US-101 & SR-239) S AMPLE L OW - P ERFORMING P ROJECTS R EQUIRED C OMPELLING C ASE FOR I NCLUSION IN P LAN S AMPLE M ODERATE - P ERFORMING P ROJECTS N OTHING TO S EE H ERE, M OVE A LONG U RBAN B US F REQUENCY I MPROVEMENTS E XPRESS L ANE N ETWORK 21 Projects re-scoped: (7) Environmental phase only (5) Sponsor agreed to fully fund project locally (1) Down-scoped to achieve B/C ratio greater than 1 Projects withdrawn by sponsors Compelling cases approved: (6) Communities of Concern (1) Air quality (1) Recreational trips Case slated for rejection; settled out of court I MPLICATIONS OF C OMPELLING C ASE R EQUIREMENT FOR L OW -P ERFORMING P ROJECTS Image Source:22 TODAY PLANNED HOV STANDARD HOT OPTIMIZED HOT TODAY PLANNED HOV STANDARD HOT OPTIMIZED HOT