abstract justification - · person”, one each for p, f ... , time-span the lrm is expected ......

RSC/RelationshipWG/1 8 August 2016

of 31 To: RDASteeringCommittee

From: GordonDunsire,Chair,RSCRelationshipDesignatorsWorkingGroup

Subject: RDAmodelsforrelationshipdata

AbstractThispaperdiscusseshowRDAaccommodatesrelationshipsbetweeninstancesofdifferent

entities.ThepapermakessomegeneralrecommendationsfordevelopingRDAtoimproveitsaccommodationofrelationshipdata.ItalsoproposesspecificrevisionstoRDAToolkit.

ThispaperwasdevelopedincollaborationwiththeRSCTechnicalWorkingGroup.

JustificationAtask(#1)fortheRSCRelationshipDesignatorsWorkingGroupin2016istoinvestigatethe

requirementsandreviewthetreatmentandstructureofrelationshipdesignatorsinRDA

Toolkit,clarifytherelationshipofdesignatorstoelements,andclarifytherequirementsof

same-entityandcross-entitydesignators,buildingon6JSC/AggregatesWG/1.

Anadditionaltask(#2)istoprepareaproposal/discussionpaperfortheorganizationof

designatorsbetweenPersons,Families,andCorporateBodiesinAppendixK,takingintoaccount6JSC/ALA/43andJSCresponses.

Anadditionaltask(#3)istoreviewtheuseofparentheticalentityqualifiersandinvestigatealternativeapproachestodesignatorlabels.

Anadditionaltask(#4)istoproposeguidelinesonsubmittingnewrelationshipdesignators,includinglabels,definitions,scope,andhierarchies.

Atask(#7)fortheRSCTechnicalWorkingGroupin2016istoinvestigatehowRDA

accommodatesrelationshipsbetweeninstancesofdifferententities,incollaborationwiththeRSCRelationshipDesignatorsWorkingGroup,andprepareaproposals/discussionpaper.

Thispaperistheoutcomeoftask#1,andpartiallyfulfilstasks#2,#3,and#4,fortheRSC

RelationshipDesignatorsWorkingGroup,andfulfilstask#7oftheRSCTechnicalWorkingGroup.

Scope


of 31 Thepapertakesintoaccounttherelationshipissuesdiscussedin6JSC/TechnicalWG/51,andis

compatiblewiththe4-foldpathforidentifyingarelatedentitywithanunstructureddescription,structureddescription,identifieroraccesspoint,andURI.

ThepaperassumesthatRDAwillgenerallycomplywiththeIFLAbibliographicmodels,consolidatedasFRBR-LRM(LibraryReferenceModel).

TerminologyTheprimaryterminologyusedinthisdocumentisfromtheRDAToolkit.TheequivalentterminologyfromtheRDARegistryisgiveninparentheses.

RelationshipsinRDARDAprovidesguidanceandinstructionsforcreatingdescriptionsandrelationshipsforthingsof

interesttousersoflibraryandculturalheritageservices.Theunderlyingconceptualmodels

(FRBR,FRAD,FRSAD)specifytheentities(RDFclasses)thatfocusoncommonattributesand

relationshipssharedbytheindividualthingsbeingdescribed;thingscanbetangible(for

example,personsormanufactureditems)orintangible(forexample,intellectualorcreative

works).Aunifiedconceptualmodel,FRBRLibraryReferenceModel(LRM),isinthefinalstagesforreviewandapprovalduring2016-2017.

EntitiesTheentitiesusedinRDAare:

Work(W),Expression(E),Manifestation(M),Item(I),Person(P),Family(F),CorporateBody(C).

Place(Pl)wasaddedtotheRDARegistrytoenabletheadditionofRDAToolkitelementsfor

placetosupporttheAugust2016releaseofRDAToolkit.ItisotherwiseundevelopedintheToolkit.

ElementsRDAprovideselements(RDFproperties)forspecificattributesandrelationships.Eachelement

hasaspecifiedentitytowhichitapplies(RDFdomain).Eachrelationshipelementalsospecifiestherelatedentitytowhichitapplies(RDFrange).

Primaryrelationshipelements

1http://www.rda-jsc.org/sites/all/files/6JSC-TechnicalWG-5.pdf


of 31 PrimaryrelationshipelementsareusedtorelatetheWEMIentitiesassociatedwithasingle

resource:

Table1:RDAprimaryrelationshipelements

Entity(domain) Relationshipelement Relatedentity(range)

W expressionofwork E

E workexpressed W

W manifestationofwork M

M workmanifested W

M expressionmanifested E

E manifestationofexpression M

M exemplarofmanifestation I

I manifestationexemplified M

Primaryrelationshipsformreciprocalpairs.

Manifestationofworkisashort-cutforexpressionofwork+manifestationofexpression;workmanifestedisashort-cutforexpressionmanifested+workexpressed.Theshort-cutsandprimaryrelationshipsareexpressedasanRDFgraphinFigure1.


of 31

Figure1:RDFgraphofRDAprimaryrelationships.

High-levelrelationshipelementsHigh-levelrelationshipelementsareusedtorelateWEMIPFCentitieswithotherWEMIPFCentities.

Table2:RDAhigh-levelrelationshipelements


W relatedwork W

E relatedexpression E

M relatedmanifestation M

I relateditem I

PFC relatedperson P

PFC relatedfamily F

PFC relatedcorporatebody C

W

E

M

I


of 31 WEMITheWEMIrelationshipsaretheirownreciprocals(theyaresymmetricproperties).

TherearenorelationshipsbetweendifferentWEMIentitiesassociatedwithdifferent

resources,thatis,nocross-entityrelationships

TheWEMIhigh-levelrelationshipsareexpressedasanRDFgraphinFigure2.

Therearenohigh-levelrelationshipsbetweenWEMIentitiesandPFCentities(e.g.,WhasrelatedP).Theserelationshipsareprovidedusingmorespecificrelationshipdesignators.

ThisisaresultofdifferentialtreatmentoftheRDAentities.PFCentitiesaretreatedas

secondaryentitiesonlyrequiredforaccesspointstoWEMIdata,reflectinglegacypractices

basedonAACR2andaninterpretationoftheoriginalFRBRmodel.TheLRMtreatsallentities

equally,asdoestheRDARegistry,becauseitisoptimizedforlinkeddataenvironments.The

currentdifferentialtreatmentinRDAislikelytoimpedeaccommodationoftherequirementsofculturalheritagecommunities.

PFCThePFChigh-levelrelationshipsformacross-entitymatrix:anyPFCentitycanberelatedtoany

otherPFCentity(e.g.CrelatedpersonP).ThePFChigh-levelrelationshipareexpressedasan

RDFgraphinFigure2.

Figure2:RDFgraph(s)ofRDAhigh-levelrelationships.

Figure2showstheabsenceofhigh-levelcross-entityrelationshipsbetweenmanyentities,forexamplebetweenWorkandrelatedExpression.

W1 W2 E1 E2

M1 M2 I1 I2

P1 F1

C1

P2 F2

C2


of 31 AgentRDAdoesnotspecifyasuper-entityforPFC,buttheRDARegistrydeclaresAgent(A)asasuper-classofPFCinordertoreducethenumberofsingle-domainpropertiesrequiredtorepresent

theassociateddesignators.Forexample,thethreesingle-domainpropertiesfor“relatedperson”,oneeachforP,F,andC,arereplacedbyonepropertywiththedomainAgent:

• A–(has)relatedperson–P

TheAgententityisincludedintheLRM.IfthisentityisintroducedtoRDA,thehigh-levelPFC

relationshipelementswillbecomerefinementsof:

Table3:PotentialRDAhigh-levelrelationshipsforAgententity


A relatedagent A

Thisrelationshipisitsownreciprocal,asisthecaseforhigh-levelrelationshipsforWEMI.

Figure3:RDFgraphofhigh-levelrelationshipsforAgent.

ImpactofLRMAgententitiesTheLRMisexpectedtointroduceanAgententitysimilartotheRDARegistryAgentclass.Itwillbe,indirectly,asuper-typeofPerson,Family,andCorporatebody.

TheLRMisexpectedtointroduceaCollectiveAgententity(GforGroup)thatisasuper-typeofFamilyandCorporatebody;itisdefinedastwoormorePersonsactingasaunit.

PrimaryrelationshipsTheequivalent“primary”relationshipsforthesetofagententitiesarelikelytobe:

A1 A2


of 31 Table4:PrimaryrelationshipelementsforLRMandRDAagententities


C entitysub-type G

F entitysub-type G

G entitysub-type A

P entitysub-type A

Theserelationshipsarerequiredforthesemanticintegrityoftheagententities.Theexisting

PFCentitiesbecomesub-typesofthenewGandAentities.ThisisexpressedintheRDFgraphinFigure4.

Figure4:RDFgraphofLRMandRDAprimaryrelationshipsforagententities.

Place,Time-spanTheLRMisexpectedtointroducenewentitiesforPlace(Pl)andTime-span(T).Time-spanincludesdates.IftheyaretreatedinRDAashavingthesamefunctionalityastheagententities,thenrelationshipdesignatorsbetweenWEMIandPlaceandTime-spanwillberequired.

Forexample:

• M–(has)dateofpublication–T

• M–(has)placeofpublication–Pl

P

F C

G

A


of 31 Itislogicaltoassumethatrelationshipdesignatorsbetweentheagententities(PFC)andPlaceandTime-spanwillalsoberequired.

Forexample:

• P–(has)dateofbirth–T

• P–(has)placeofbirth–Pl

High-levelrelationshipsforrelatingPlaceandTime-spantoWEMIPFC(A)andeachotherwillalsoberequired;forexample:

• W–(has)relatedplace–Pl

• Pl–(has)relatedtime-span-T

RelationshipdesignatorsRelationshipdesignatorsspecifymoredetailedrelationshipswithintheWEMIandPFCsetsof

high-levelrelationshipelements.Theyalsospecifyrelationshipsbetweenthosesets,butno

high-levelrelationshipelementsaredefined,asnotedabove.

Designatorsarearrangedinsemantichierarchies.ThebroadercategoriesreflecttheFRBR

examplesofgroupsofrelationships:forexample,RDAJ.2.2Derivativeworkrelationships.

Thearrangementismono-hierarchical;adesignatorhasonlyone“parent”.Thereisnolimiton

theleveloffinergranularityofadesignator.

DesignatorlabelsThedesignatorshavethegeneralpattern:

• Entity1(has)relatedentityEntity2

The"entity"inthegeneraldesignator"(has)relatedentity"isthereforeEntity2,therangeofthedesignator.

TheRegistrylabelsareverbalizedusing“has…”and“is…of”templates,butthisapproachis

notappropriateforRDAToolkit.TheToolkitelementanddesignatorlabelsneedtobegeneral

andsuitableforarangeofdifferentimplementationscenarios.Thelabelsareintendedforuse

inname/valuepairformatsaswellasRDFpredicate-propertiesthathaveintrinsicverbalization

inthesemanticsofthepredicate.Theproblemisubiquitousandunresolved,andiswhythe

TechnicalWorkingGrouphasbeenassignedongoingtask#2tomonitortheneedforvalue


of 31 vocabularyrepresentationsoftheRDAToolkitrelationshipelementsanddesignators,following

recommendation#7in6JSC/CILIPrep/3.

TheToolkitdesignatorlabelsareessentiallyconfinedtothenon-verbalizedpattern:

• Entity1relatedentityEntity2

Again,the“entity”ofrelatedentityisEntity2,notEntity1.

TheOMRthereforeaccommodatesdifferentlabelsfortheToolkitandtheRegistry.

Labelsfordesignatorsforsimilarrelationshipsbetweendifferentpairsofentityare

distinguishedbyaddingthenameoftheentity(e.g.,“(Expression)”)towhichthedesignator

applies;thatis,theentitybeingdescribedgivenasthedomainoftheproperty.Theresultisartificial,likeanaccesspointforthedesignator.

Furtherdistinctionbetweenlabelswillberequiredifmorecross-entitydesignatorsareadded

toRDA.Thecurrentmethodproducestwosetsofparentheses,asshownintheresultsofChange3.

Somelabellingissueshavebeennotedanddiscussedbefore,forexamplein6JSC/CILIPrep/2and6JSC/CILIPrep/3.

Issuesinclude:

ConfusinglabelsRDAToolkitusersfindthequalifiedlabelsusingparenthesesconfusing,althoughtheyarenot

intendedforend-userconsumption,forexampleasdisplaylabels.Thisconfusionislikelyto

increasewithcross-entitydesignatorsrequiringtwoqualifiers,asshownintheresultsofChange3.

AmbiguityoftherelatedentityTheToolkitlabelsdonotalwaysindicatethedirectionoftherelationship.Forexample,reproducedas(manifestation)canbeusedunambiguouslyas:

• Manifestation1-reproducedas(manifestation)-Manifestation2

ItisclearthatManifestation2isthereproduction.

Ontheotherhand,thisisambiguous:

• Manifestation1-electronicreproduction(manifestation)-Manifestation2

RSC/RelationshipWG/1 8 August 2016 of 31

ItisnotclearifthereproductionisManifestation1orManifestation2.

Notethattheparenthesescanberemovedwithoutaggravatingorresolvingthisissue.

ListingofverbalizedlabelsItisdifficulttolistdesignatorlabelsinalphabeticalorderoftheir“root”relationshipifthey

startwithaverbsuchas“has”or“is”.

InconsistencyThe“product”and“productionmethod”arebothusedinlabels.Forexample,theterms

“reproduced”and“reproduction”areusedinreproducedas…andreproduction…whichareindirecthierarchicalorder.

Note:hasreproductionisaregisteredFRBRooproperty.2

Cross-entityrelationshipsanddesignatorsHigh-levelrelationshipelementsTheLRMprovidesahighest-levelrelationshipelementbetweentwodifferentinstancesofaRes(asuper-entityofallLRMentities):

• Res1-isassociatedwith–Res2

ThecurrentRDAhigh-levelrelated…entityelementsareelementsub-typesofthisLRMrelationshipelement;thecurrentRDAentitiesthemselvesaresub-typesofRes.

Thereisarequirementforhigh-levelrelated…entityelementsbetweentheWEMIentities,forexamplerelatingaWorktoanExpressionofanotherWork:

• W-(has)relatedexpression–E

Thecurrentdefinitionsoftherelated…entityelementsaretoorestrictive,althoughthe

definitionshavebeensimplifiedintheAugust2016releaseofRDAToolkit.Forexample,related

workhasthedefinition“Aworkthatisassociatedwiththeworkbeingdescribed”.Although

thisdefinitionisdirectlycompatiblewiththeLRMhighest-levelrelationshipelement,thereis

anintermediaryelementrequired,withthedefinition“Anentitythatisassociatedwiththeworkbeingdescribed”.IntermediateelementsarealsorequiredfortheimplicitAgententity:

Res1–isassociatedwith-Res2

2http://metadataregistry.org/schemaprop/show/id/16000.html


Haselementsub-type:W–(has)relatedentity–Res[=anyRDAentity]

Haselementsub-type:W–(has)relatedwork–W[currentRDAelement]Haselementsub-type:W–(has)relatedexpression–EHaselementsub-type:W–(has)relatedmanifestation–M…Haselementsub-type:W–(has)relatedagent–A Haselementsub-type:W-(has)relatedperson–P Haselementsub-type:W–(has)relatedfamily–F ……

Currenthigh-levelRDArelationshipelementsoccupythefinerlevels,asshowninthecompletematrixofhigh-levelentityrelationshipsgiveninAppendix1.ThefullsetofrelationshipelementsinAppendix1isusefulforsupportinglinkeddatacommunitiesandapplications.Itisnotnecessary,noworinthenearfuture,toaccommodatealloftheelementsinAppendix1

inRDAToolkit.SomeoftheAgentrelationshipelementsarealreadyimplicitinthedefinitions

ofrelatedperson,relatedfamily,andrelatedcorporatebody;forexample,relatedpersonhasthedefinition“Apersonwhoisassociatedwiththeperson,family,orcorporatebodybeing

identified”.ItistobeexpectedthatnearlyalloftheelementsinAppendix1willbeaccommodatedinfuturedevelopmentofRDAforculturalheritagecommunities.

Recommendation1:Generalizetherelated…entityelementstocoverallRDAcurrentandfutureentitiesasspecifiedinAppendix1:

a. Addageneralrelatedentityrelationshipelementwiththedefinition“Anentitythatis

associatedwiththeentitybeingdescribed”.Thiselementisitsownreciprocal.

b. Generalizethedefinitionsofthecurrentrelated…entityelementsaselementsub-types

ofrelatedentity.c. Retainthecurrentsame-entityrelated…entitydefinitionsbutqualifythelabels,as

elementsub-typesofthegeneralizedrelated…entityelements.

d. Addspecificcross-entityrelated…entityelementsforallnon-samepairsofRDA

entities.

e. Differentiatethelabelsbyaddingqualifiersforthesourceentity.

f. UpdatetheRDAToolkitinstructionsfortheelementsmarked**.g. AddpropertiesforthefullsetofdesignatorstotheRDARegistry.


Cross-entityrelationshipdesignatorsThereisarequirementfordesignatorsacrosstheWEMIentities,forexamplerelatingaWorktoanExpressionofanotherWork.

SubjectrelationshipelementsThehigh-levelsubjectrelationshipelementhasthedefinition“Aterm,phrase,classificationnumber,etc.,thatindicateswhattheworkisabout”.IthasthedomainWork,butnorange.

Itisthereforeanelementsub-typeoftherelatedentity(work)elementproposedinAppendix1.

OnlyWEMIsubjectrelationshipdesignatorsareaccommodatedinRDAAppendixM.TheEMI

designatorsarecross-entity.NoprovisionismadeforPFCorotherentitiesthatmightbethe

subjectofaWork,althoughtheyarenotexcludedbytheinstructionsatRDA23.4.TheRDARegistryincludespropertiesforPFCsubjectrelationshipdesignatorstosupportlinkeddata

communitiesandapplications.

Recommendation2:Adddesignatorsforsubject-relatedPerson,Family,andCorporateBodyentitiestoAppendixM.

ReproductiverelationshipdesignatorsAnindividualItemcanbethebasisofareproductionManifestation.

NewdesignatorsarerequiredtoaccommodateItemtoManifestationrelationshipsforthereproducedasandreproductionofgroupsinRDAAppendixJ.5.2.

Recommendation3:Addcross-entitydesignatorsforitemsthatarereproducedasmanifestationstoAppendixJ.

ReciprocaldesignatorsInversepropertiesforreciprocaldesignatorsareincludedintheRDARegistryforallRDArelationshipdesignators.

ReciprocaldesignatorsareaccommodatedinRDAToolkitforsame-entitydesignatorsforWEMI

inAppendixJandPFCinAppendixK,butnotforthecross-entityWEMItoPFCdesignatorsin

AppendixI.ThisisaresultofdifferentialtreatmentofPFCentitiesinRDA,reflectinglegacypracticesbasedonAACR2.

Recommendation4:Addreciprocaldesignatorsforcross-entityPFCtoWEMIdesignatorstoRDAToolkit.


OrganizationofdesignatorsinRDAToolkitTheToolkitpresentsdesignatorsinasetofappendicesbasedontheWEMIandPFCgroupsofentities.Thecurrentstructureandlayoutisinconsistentandhasweaknesses:

• AnewappendixisrequiredforeachnewentityorgroupofentitiesaddedtoRDA,say

fromtheLRM.

• Thereisnoprovisionforcross-WEMIsub-categoriesinthearrangementofAppendixJ

correspondingtothecross-PFCcategoriesofAppendixK.

• Cross-WEMIdesignatorsareincludedinAppendixM.

• Thearrangementofsame-andcross-PFCdesignatorsinAppendixKisprovisionaland

requiresdevelopment.

• ThereisnoprovisionforreciprocalrelationshipsinAppendixK.

• Therearenoactivelinksbetweendesignatorinversesandothercross-references.

• ThereisnospecificindexofdesignatorsintheToolkit.Theyarepresentedin

hierarchicalorderintheAppendices.

TheWorkingGroupswelcometheinclusionofdesignatorsandreciprocalsinacomprehensive

alphabeticallistingastheGlossaryintheAugust2016releaseofRDAToolkitbecauseitpartiallyresolvesthelastitem.

ThenewToolkitandRegistrysynchronizationinfrastructureisbasedonthelinkeddata

representationofRDAReferenceasRDAVocabulariesintheOpenMetadataRegistry.This

shouldallowgreaterflexibilityinthepresentationofrelationshipelementsanddesignatorsinRDAToolkit.

Toolkituserswillbenefitfromgreaterinteractivitywiththehierarchiesandcross-referencestonavigatetheincreasingnumbersofentitiesandrelationshipsbetweenthem.

ThebasicgroupingsofelementsanddesignatorsbasedontheoriginalFRBRgroupsarenotcompatiblewiththeLRMorthepreviousmodificationbyFRSAD.

Groupingsarerequiredbecausethenumberofdesignatorswillincreaseifthe

recommendationsofthispaperareaccepted.Itisbettertoorganizethedesignatorsprimarily

bysourceentity(domain);thatis,theentitybeingdescribed.Witheachprimarygroup,the

designatorscanbesub-groupedbytargetentity(range);thatis,therelatedentity.Aseparate

primarygroupisrequiredforthe“anyentity”high-levelrelationshipelements,andaseparate

sub-groupisrequiredwithineachprimarygroupfor“anyentity”designators,oftenreciprocals.Separateprimaryandsub-groupsforAgentwillallowde-duplicationofPFC-to-PFCdesignators.


Table5:Primarygroupingsandsub-groupsforrelationshipdesignatorsinRDAToolkit

Primarygroup Sub-group

Anyentity W Anyentity

WEMIPFCPletc.

E sameM sameI sameA sameP sameF sameC samePletc. same

Table5reflectstheserequirements.Itisconsistentandisscale-abletoaccommodatenewentities.Appendix1isorganizedinthesameway.

Recommendation5:Considerotherarrangementsofrelationshipelementsanddesignators

andtheirassociatedinstructionsinRDAToolkit,includingtablesandthesaurusarchitectures

withnavigablebroader/narrowerandsee/seealsocross-references,andconsiderre-organizingthebasiclayoutofdesignatorstoreflectTable5.

IssuesrequiringresolutionIdentificationofnewdesignatorsNewdesignatorsareproposedfortwomainreasons:

A. ToreflectthewayaManifestationdescribesitself,usuallyintheStatementofresponsibilityrelatingtotitleproper.

B. ToreflectamodelofrelationshipssuggestedbyFRBRandsupportedbyliterarytheoryandcriticism.

A.isessentiallyabottom-updesignmethod.B.isatop-downmethod.


AnA-typedesignatormustalsobeaB-typedesignator,butnotvice-versa.

CreatingandmaintainingA-typedesignatorsforeveryvariationfoundinmanifestationsisnot

sustainable,andimpairsutilityforthecataloguerandend-user.

ThereisnoformaldecisionframeworkforacceptingproposalsforA-typedesignators,although

proposalsmustindicatewheretheproposeddesignatorfitsintheexistinghierarchy.

TheLRMwillspecifyonlyprimaryandhigh-levelrelationshipsbetweenentities.Thechoiceof

broadcategoriesforRDArelationshipdesignatorswillnotaffectcompatibilitywiththeLRM.

AspecifieddecisionframeworkforproposedRDAdesignatorsisdesirable.

Allnewdesignatorsshouldspecify:

• ThedomainorRDAentitythatisbeingdescribed.

• TherangeorRDAentitythatisrelatedtotheentitybeingdescribed.

• Whatrelationshipelementordesignatoritrefines.Thedomainandrangeofthe

“parent”designatormustbethesameas,orsuper-classesof,therefiningdesignator.

• AdistinctiveToolkitlabel,usingdomainandrangequalifiersasnecessaryto

disambiguatethelabel.

• Adefinitionoftherelatedentitythatqualifiesthescopeoraspectoftheentity.

• AToolkitlabelanddefinitionfortheinversedesignator,ifthenewdesignatorisnot

symmetric.Thelabelanddefinitionmustbequalifiedforinverteddomainandrange.

TheRelationshipDesignatorsWorkingGroupiscontinuingitsanalysisofthisissueand

welcomescommentsandsuggestionsfromRDAcommunities.

ResolvinglabelissuesApossibleresolutionofthelabelissuesistobasealllabelsonthehigh-levelRelated…elementsofRecommendation1,withoneadjustment:

ReplacethequalifyingparenthesesinAppendix1with“of“.

Forexample:

• relatedworkofmanifestation(notrelatedwork(manifestation))• relatedmanifestationofwork(notrelatedmanifestation(work))

Thelabeltemplateis:

“Related“+rangeentity+designator{+“of“+domainentity}


{}isonlyaddedfordisambiguation.Alternatively,itcouldbeincludedinthebasictemplatefor

alllabels.

Example(fromAppendixI):

• relatedagentactorReciprocalrelationship:relatedexpressionofactor

Here,“actorof”intheinversehasbeeninvertedto“ofactor”.

ThelabelsforreciprocalsinAppendixIfocusonAgent,whichisthedomainentityratherthan

therangeentity.IfthereciprocalsforAppendixIfocusedontheWEMIratherthantheAgent,

thenthereciprocalrelationshipmightberelatedexpressionact,ortoemphasizeontheprocess,relatedexpressionacting.

Thisissueisconnectedtothecreator/contributordistinctionforaWorkanditsExpressionidentifiedin6JSC/AggregatesWG/1.3

Example(fromAppendixJ):

• relatedmanifestationfacsimileReciprocalrelationship:relatedmanifestationof

facsimile

Here,“facsimileof”hasbeeninvertedto“offacsimile”.

Note:AppendixKavoidsmanylabellingissuesbyusingnaturallydifferenttermsforreciprocalroles,forexampleteacherandstudent.

Thenewsynchronizationinfrastructuremayprovideinnovativesolutionstotheseissues.

Recommendation6:TheRSCRelationshipDesignatorsWorkingGroupshouldundertakea

completereviewofdesignatorlabelsinthecontextoftheproposedmatrixofhigh-level

relationshipelementsinRecommendation1andthepotentialfordifferentdisplaysandlayoutsofthedesignationsinRecommendation5,incollaborationwiththeRDADevelopmentTeam.

RecommendationsRecommendation1:GeneralizetheRelated…entityelementstocoverallRDAcurrentandfutureentitiesasspecifiedinAppendix1:

3http://www.rda-jsc.org/sites/all/files/6JSC-AggregatesWG-1.pdf


a. Addageneralrelatedentityrelationshipelementwiththedefinition“Anentitythatis

associatedwiththeentitybeingdescribed”.Thiselementisitsownreciprocal.

b. GeneralizethedefinitionsofthecurrentRelated…entityelementsaselementsub-

typesofrelatedentity.c. Retainthecurrentsame-entityrelated…entitydefinitionsbutqualifythelabels,as

elementsub-typesofthegeneralizedrelated…entityelements.

d. Addspecificcross-entityrelated…entityelementsforallnon-samepairsofRDA

entities.

e. Differentiatethelabelsbyaddingqualifiersforthesourceentity.

f. UpdatetheRDAToolkitinstructionsfortheelementsmarked**.g. AddpropertiesforthefullsetofdesignatorstotheRDARegistry.

Recommendation2:Adddesignatorsforsubject-relatedPerson,Family,andCorporateBodyentitiestoAppendixM.

Recommendation3:Addcross-entitydesignatorsforitemsthatarereproducedasmanifestationstoAppendixJ.

Recommendation4:Addreciprocaldesignatorsforcross-entityPFCtoWEMIdesignatorsto

RDAToolkit.

Recommendation5:Considerotherarrangementsofrelationshipelementsanddesignators

andtheirassociatedinstructionsinRDAToolkit,includingtablesandthesaurusarchitectures

withnavigablebroader/narrowerandsee/seealsocross-references,andconsiderre-organizingthebasiclayoutofdesignatorstoreflectTable5.

Recommendation6:TheRSCRelationshipDesignatorsWorkingGroupshouldundertakea

completereviewofdesignatorlabelsinthecontextoftheproposedmatrixofhigh-level

relationshipelementsinRecommendation1andthepotentialfordifferentdisplaysandlayoutsofthedesignationsinRecommendation5,incollaborationwiththeRDADevelopmentTeam.

ImpactoftherevisionsTherecommendedrevisionswillserveuserneedstofullyrelateRDAentitiesusingrelationshipelementsanddesignators.

Aneworganizationofrelationshipelementsanddesignatorsandassociatedinstructionswillsupportgreaterflexibilityinfindingandidentifyingthemostappropriaterelationshiptouse.


Change1:Revisionof24.1.3and29.1.3ThisrevisionisassociatedwithRecommendation1.

OnlycleancopyisprovidedbecausetheseareasofRDAToolkitareknowntobeunderrevision

aspartofthedevelopmentoftheRDAReferenceandToolkitGlossaryinfrastructure.ThefinallayoutofelementlabelanddefinitionshouldbeconsistentwithotherchangestotheToolkit.

Cleancopy

24.1.3RelatedWork,Expression,Manifestation,andItem

Thetermsrelatedentity,relatedwork,relatedexpression,relatedmanifestation,andrelateditemareusedasfollows:

relatedentity▼:Anentitythatisassociatedwiththeentitybeingdescribed.

relatedwork▼:Aworkthatisassociatedwiththeentitybeingdescribed.

relatedexpression▼:Anexpressionthatisassociatedwiththeentitybeingdescribed.

relatedmanifestation▼:Amanifestationthatisassociatedwiththeentitybeingdescribed.

relateditem▼:Anitemthatisassociatedwiththeentitybeingdescribed.

====

29.1.3RelatedPerson,Family,andCorporateBody

Thetermsrelatedagent,relatedperson,relatedfamily,andrelatedcorporatebodyareusedasfollows:

relatedagent▼:Aperson,family,orcorporatebodythatisassociatedwiththeentitybeingdescribed.

relatedperson▼:Apersonthatisassociatedwiththeentitybeingdescribed.

relatedfamily▼:Afamilythatisassociatedwiththeentitybeingdescribed.

relatedcorporatebody▼:Acorporatebodythatisassociatedwiththeentitybeingdescribed.

====


Change2:RevisionofAppendixMThisrevisionisassociatedwithRecommendation2.

ThelabelsusethecurrentRDAdisambiguationtemplate.

Thesearealladditions,soonlyacleancopyversionisgiven.

Cleancopy

M.2.6PersonasSubjectofaWork

describedin(person)Aworkthatdescribesadescribedperson.Reciprocalrelationship:descriptionof(person)descriptionof(person)Apersondescribedbyadescribingwork.Reciprocalrelationship:describedin(person)

M.2.7FamilyasSubjectofaWork

describedin(family)Aworkthatdescribesadescribedfamily.Reciprocalrelationship:descriptionof(person)descriptionof(family)Afamilydescribedbyadescribingwork.Reciprocalrelationship:describedin(person)

M.2.8CorporateBodyasSubjectofaWork

describedin(corporatebody)Aworkthatdescribesadescribedcorporatebody.Reciprocalrelationship:descriptionof(person)descriptionof(corporatebody)Acorporatebodydescribedbyadescribingwork.Reciprocalrelationship:describedin(person)

====


Change3:RevisionstoAppendixJThisrevisionisassociatedwithRecommendation3.

Nonumberingissupplied.Therearetwoshort-termoptionsforshort-termplacementwithin

theAppendixJ:

1. AsanadditiontoJ.5.2

2. AsanewsectionJ.5.6

Option2maybelessconfusing.

ThelabelsuseanextensionofthecurrentRDAdisambiguationtemplate.AversionusingalternativelabelsisavailableinAppendix3.

Allchangesareadditions,soonlyacleancopyversionisgiven.

Cleancopy

EquivalentItemRelationships

reproducedas(manifestation)(item)Amanifestationthatreproducesanitemofanothermanifestation.Reciprocalrelationship:reproductionof(item)(manifestation)

digitaltransfer(manifestation)(item)Amanifestationinadigitalformatthatresultsfromthetransferofaniteminanotherdigitalformat.Reciprocalrelationship:digitaltransferof(item)(manifestation)electronicreproduction(manifestation)(item)Amanifestationinadigitalformatthatistheresultofthetransferofaniteminanalogformat.Reciprocalrelationship:electronicreproductionof(item)(manifestation)facsimile(manifestation)(item)Amanifestationthatexactlyreproducesanitemofanothermanifestation.Reciprocalrelationship:facsimileof(item)(manifestation)

preservationfacsimile(manifestation)(item)Amanifestationthatconsistsofanexactreproductionofanitemofanothermanifestationonpreservation-qualitymedia,suchasacid-freepermanentorarchivalpaper.Reciprocalrelationship:preservationfacsimileof(item)(manifestation)

reprintedas(manifestation)(item)Amanifestationthatisareissueofanitemthatexemplifiesanotherprintedmanifestation.Reciprocalrelationship:reprintof(item)(manifestation)


reproductionof(item)(manifestation)Anitemthatisusedasthebasisformanifestationthatisareproduction.Reciprocalrelationship:reproducedas(manifestation)(item)

digitaltransferof(item)(manifestation)Aniteminadigitalformatthatistransferredtoanotherdigitalformatasamanifestation.Reciprocalrelationship:digitaltransfer(manifestation)(item)electronicreproductionof(item)(manifestation)Aniteminananalogformatthatistransferredtoadigitalformatasamanifestation.Reciprocalrelationship:electronicreproduction(manifestation)(item)facsimileof(item)(manifestation)Anitemthatisusedasthebasisforamanifestationthatisanexactreproduction.Reciprocalrelationship:facsimile(manifestation)(item)

preservationfacsimileof(item)(manifestation)Anitemthatisusedasthebasisforamanifestationthatisanexactreproductiononpreservation-qualitymedia,suchasacid-freepermanentorarchivalpaper.Reciprocalrelationship:preservationfacsimile(manifestation)(item)

reprintof(item)(manifestation)Anitemthatexemplifiesaprintedmanifestationthatisusedasthebasisforareissueofamanifestation.Reciprocalrelationship:reprintedas(manifestation)(item)

====


Appendix 1: Full matrix of high-level RDA entity relationship elements

Appendix1:Fullmatrixofhigh-levelRDAentityrelationshipelements*ExistingRDArelationshipelements,requiringdifferentiatedlabels.**RecommendedrelationshipelementsforRDAToolkitinstructions.Entity(domain)

Relationshipelement Relatedentity(range)

Definition

relatedentity** Anentitythatisassociatedwiththeentitybeingdescribed. relatedwork** W Aworkthatisassociatedwiththeentitybeingdescribed. relatedexpression** E Anexpressionthatisassociatedwiththeentitybeingdescribed. relatedmanifestation** M Amanifestationthatisassociatedwiththeentitybeingdescribed. relateditem** I Anitemthatisassociatedwiththeentitybeingdescribed. relatedagent** A Aperson,family,orcorporatebodythatisassociatedwiththeentitybeing

described. relatedperson** P Apersonthatisassociatedwiththeentitybeingdescribed. relatedfamily** F Afamilythatisassociatedwiththeentitybeingdescribed. relatedcorporatebody** C Acorporatebodythatisassociatedwiththeentitybeingdescribed.W relatedentity(work) Anentitythatisassociatedwiththeworkbeingdescribed.W relatedwork(work)* W Aworkthatisassociatedwiththeworkbeingdescribed.W relatedexpression(work) E Anexpressionthatisassociatedwiththeworkbeingdescribed.W relatedmanifestation(work) M Amanifestationthatisassociatedwiththeworkbeingdescribed.W relateditem(work) I Anitemthatisassociatedwiththeworkbeingdescribed.W relatedagent(work) A Anagentthatisassociatedwiththeworkbeingdescribed.W relatedperson(work) P Apersonthatisassociatedwiththeworkbeingdescribed.W relatedfamily(work) F Afamilythatisassociatedwiththeworkbeingdescribed.


Appendix 1: Full matrix of high-level RDA entity relationship elements Entity(domain)


Definition

W relatedcorporatebody(work) C Acorporatebodythatisassociatedwiththeworkbeingdescribed.E relatedentity(expression) Anentitythatisassociatedwiththeexpressionbeingdescribed.E relatedwork(expression) W Aworkthatisassociatedwiththeexpressionbeingdescribed.E relatedexpression(expression)* E Anexpressionthatisassociatedwiththeexpressionbeingdescribed.E relatedmanifestation(expression) M Amanifestationthatisassociatedwiththeexpressionbeingdescribed.E relateditem(expression) I Anitemthatisassociatedwiththeexpressionbeingdescribed.E relatedagent(expression) A Anagentthatisassociatedwiththeexpressionbeingdescribed.E relatedperson(expression) P Apersonthatisassociatedwiththeexpressionbeingdescribed.E relatedfamily(expression) F Afamilythatisassociatedwiththeexpressionbeingdescribed.E relatedcorporatebody(expression) C Acorporatebodythatisassociatedexpressiontheworkbeingdescribed.M relatedentity(manifestation) Anentitythatisassociatedwiththemanifestationbeingdescribed.M relatedwork(manifestation) W Aworkthatisassociatedwiththemanifestationbeingdescribed.M relatedexpression(manifestation) E Anexpressionthatisassociatedwiththemanifestationbeingdescribed.M relatedmanifestation(manifestation)* M Amanifestationthatisassociatedwiththemanifestationbeingdescribed.M relateditem(manifestation) I Anitemthatisassociatedwiththemanifestationbeingdescribed.M relatedagent(manifestation) A Anagentthatisassociatedwiththemanifestationbeingdescribed.M relatedperson(manifestation) P Apersonthatisassociatedwiththemanifestationbeingdescribed.M relatedfamily(manifestation) F Afamilythatisassociatedwiththemanifestationbeingdescribed.M relatedcorporatebody(manifestation) C Acorporatebodythatisassociatedmanifestationtheworkbeing

described.I relatedentity(item) Anentitythatisassociatedwiththeitembeingdescribed.I relatedwork(item) W Aworkthatisassociatedwiththeitembeingdescribed.I relatedexpression(item) E Anexpressionthatisassociatedwiththeitembeingdescribed.I relatedmanifestation(item) M Amanifestationthatisassociatedwiththeitembeingdescribed.




Definition

I relateditem(item)* I Anitemthatisassociatedwiththeitembeingdescribed.I relatedagent(item) A Anagentthatisassociatedwiththeitembeingdescribed.I relatedperson(item) P Apersonthatisassociatedwiththeitembeingdescribed.I relatedfamily(item) F Afamilythatisassociatedwiththeitembeingdescribed.I relatedcorporatebody(item) C Acorporatebodythatisassociateditemtheworkbeingdescribed.A relatedentity(agent) Anentitythatisassociatedwiththeagentbeingdescribed.A relatedwork(agent) W Aworkthatisassociatedwiththeagentbeingdescribed.A relatedexpression(agent) E Anexpressionthatisassociatedwiththeagentbeingdescribed.A relatedmanifestation(agent) M Amanifestationthatisassociatedwiththeagentbeingdescribed.A relateditem(agent) I Anitemthatisassociatedwiththeagentbeingdescribed.A relatedagent(agent) A Anagentthatisassociatedwiththeagentbeingdescribed.A relatedperson(agent)* P Apersonthatisassociatedwiththeagentbeingdescribed.A relatedfamily(agent)* F Afamilythatisassociatedwiththeagentbeingdescribed.A relatedcorporatebody(agent)* C Acorporatebodythatisassociatedagenttheworkbeingdescribed.P relatedentity(person) Anentitythatisassociatedwiththepersonbeingdescribed.P relatedwork(person) W Aworkthatisassociatedwiththepersonbeingdescribed.P relatedexpression(person) E Anexpressionthatisassociatedwiththepersonbeingdescribed.P relatedmanifestation(person) M Amanifestationthatisassociatedwiththepersonbeingdescribed.P relateditem(person) I Anitemthatisassociatedwiththepersonbeingdescribed.P relatedagent(person) A Anagentthatisassociatedwiththepersonbeingdescribed.P relatedperson(person) P Apersonthatisassociatedwiththepersonbeingdescribed.P relatedfamily(person) F Afamilythatisassociatedwiththepersonbeingdescribed.P relatedcorporatebody(person) C Acorporatebodythatisassociatedpersontheworkbeingdescribed.F relatedentity(family) Anentitythatisassociatedwiththefamilybeingdescribed.




Definition

F relatedwork(family) W Aworkthatisassociatedwiththefamilybeingdescribed.F relatedexpression(family) E Anexpressionthatisassociatedwiththefamilybeingdescribed.F relatedmanifestation(family) M Amanifestationthatisassociatedwiththefamilybeingdescribed.F relateditem(family) I Anitemthatisassociatedwiththefamilybeingdescribed.F relatedagent(family) A Anagentthatisassociatedwiththefamilybeingdescribed.F relatedperson(family) P Apersonthatisassociatedwiththefamilybeingdescribed.F relatedfamily(family) F Afamilythatisassociatedwiththefamilybeingdescribed.F relatedcorporatebody(family) C Acorporatebodythatisassociatedfamilytheworkbeingdescribed.C relatedentity(corporatebody) Anentitythatisassociatedwiththecorporatebodybeingdescribed.C relatedwork(corporatebody) W Aworkthatisassociatedwiththecorporatebodybeingdescribed.C relatedexpression(corporatebody) E Anexpressionthatisassociatedwiththecorporatebodybeingdescribed.C relatedmanifestation(corporatebody) M Amanifestationthatisassociatedwiththecorporatebodybeing

described.C relateditem(corporatebody) I Anitemthatisassociatedwiththecorporatebodydescribed.C relatedagent(corporatebody) A Anagentthatisassociatedwiththecorporatebodybeingdescribed.C relatedperson(corporatebody) P Apersonthatisassociatedwiththecorporatebodybeingdescribed.C relatedfamily(corporatebody) F Afamilythatisassociatedwiththecorporatebodybeingdescribed.C relatedcorporatebody(corporatebody) C Acorporatebodythatisassociatedcorporatebodytheworkbeing

described.


Appendix 2: Full matrix of high-level RDA entity relationship elements (alternate labels)

Appendix2:Fullmatrixofhigh-levelRDAentityrelationshipelements(alternatelabels)ThisisAppendix1withnon-parentheticallabels,usingthepotentialresolutiontolabelissuesinRecommendation6.

Entity(domain)


Definition

relatedentity** Anentitythatisassociatedwiththeentitybeingdescribed. relatedwork** W Aworkthatisassociatedwiththeentitybeingdescribed. relatedexpression** E Anexpressionthatisassociatedwiththeentitybeingdescribed. relatedmanifestation** M Amanifestationthatisassociatedwiththeentitybeingdescribed. relateditem** I Anitemthatisassociatedwiththeentitybeingdescribed. relatedagent** A Aperson,family,orcorporatebodythatisassociatedwiththeentitybeing

described. relatedperson** P Apersonthatisassociatedwiththeentitybeingdescribed. relatedfamily** F Afamilythatisassociatedwiththeentitybeingdescribed. relatedcorporatebody** C Acorporatebodythatisassociatedwiththeentitybeingdescribed.W relatedentityofwork Anentitythatisassociatedwiththeworkbeingdescribed.W relatedworkofwork* W Aworkthatisassociatedwiththeworkbeingdescribed.W relatedexpressionofwork E Anexpressionthatisassociatedwiththeworkbeingdescribed.W relatedmanifestationofwork M Amanifestationthatisassociatedwiththeworkbeingdescribed.W relateditemofwork I Anitemthatisassociatedwiththeworkbeingdescribed.W relatedagentofwork A Anagentthatisassociatedwiththeworkbeingdescribed.W relatedpersonofwork P Apersonthatisassociatedwiththeworkbeingdescribed.W relatedfamilyofwork F Afamilythatisassociatedwiththeworkbeingdescribed.W relatedcorporatebodyofwork C Acorporatebodythatisassociatedwiththeworkbeingdescribed.E relatedentityofexpression Anentitythatisassociatedwiththeexpressionbeingdescribed.


Appendix 2: Full matrix of high-level RDA entity relationship elements (alternate labels) Entity(domain)


Definition

E relatedworkofexpression W Aworkthatisassociatedwiththeexpressionbeingdescribed.E relatedexpressionofexpression* E Anexpressionthatisassociatedwiththeexpressionbeingdescribed.E relatedmanifestationofexpression M Amanifestationthatisassociatedwiththeexpressionbeingdescribed.E relateditemofexpression I Anitemthatisassociatedwiththeexpressionbeingdescribed.E relatedagentofexpression A Anagentthatisassociatedwiththeexpressionbeingdescribed.E relatedpersonofexpression P Apersonthatisassociatedwiththeexpressionbeingdescribed.E relatedfamilyofexpression F Afamilythatisassociatedwiththeexpressionbeingdescribed.E relatedcorporatebodyofexpression C Acorporatebodythatisassociatedexpressiontheworkbeingdescribed.M relatedentityofmanifestation Anentitythatisassociatedwiththemanifestationbeingdescribed.M relatedworkofmanifestation W Aworkthatisassociatedwiththemanifestationbeingdescribed.M relatedexpressionofmanifestation E Anexpressionthatisassociatedwiththemanifestationbeingdescribed.M relatedmanifestationofmanifestation* M Amanifestationthatisassociatedwiththemanifestationbeingdescribed.M relateditemofmanifestation I Anitemthatisassociatedwiththemanifestationbeingdescribed.M relatedagentofmanifestation A Anagentthatisassociatedwiththemanifestationbeingdescribed.M relatedpersonofmanifestation P Apersonthatisassociatedwiththemanifestationbeingdescribed.M relatedfamilyofmanifestation F Afamilythatisassociatedwiththemanifestationbeingdescribed.M relatedcorporatebodyofmanifestation C Acorporatebodythatisassociatedmanifestationtheworkbeing

described.I relatedentityofitem Anentitythatisassociatedwiththeitembeingdescribed.I relatedworkofitem W Aworkthatisassociatedwiththeitembeingdescribed.I relatedexpressionofitem E Anexpressionthatisassociatedwiththeitembeingdescribed.I relatedmanifestationofitem M Amanifestationthatisassociatedwiththeitembeingdescribed.I relateditemofitem* I Anitemthatisassociatedwiththeitembeingdescribed.I relatedagentofitem A Anagentthatisassociatedwiththeitembeingdescribed.




Definition

I relatedpersonofitem P Apersonthatisassociatedwiththeitembeingdescribed.I relatedfamilyofitem F Afamilythatisassociatedwiththeitembeingdescribed.I relatedcorporatebodyofitem C Acorporatebodythatisassociateditemtheworkbeingdescribed.A relatedentityofagent Anentitythatisassociatedwiththeagentbeingdescribed.A relatedworkofagent W Aworkthatisassociatedwiththeagentbeingdescribed.A relatedexpressionofagent E Anexpressionthatisassociatedwiththeagentbeingdescribed.A relatedmanifestationofagent M Amanifestationthatisassociatedwiththeagentbeingdescribed.A relateditemofagent I Anitemthatisassociatedwiththeagentbeingdescribed.A relatedagentofagent A Anagentthatisassociatedwiththeagentbeingdescribed.A relatedpersonofagent* P Apersonthatisassociatedwiththeagentbeingdescribed.A relatedfamilyofagent* F Afamilythatisassociatedwiththeagentbeingdescribed.A relatedcorporatebodyofagent* C Acorporatebodythatisassociatedagenttheworkbeingdescribed.P relatedentityofperson Anentitythatisassociatedwiththepersonbeingdescribed.P relatedworkofperson W Aworkthatisassociatedwiththepersonbeingdescribed.P relatedexpressionofperson E Anexpressionthatisassociatedwiththepersonbeingdescribed.P relatedmanifestationofperson M Amanifestationthatisassociatedwiththepersonbeingdescribed.P relateditemofperson I Anitemthatisassociatedwiththepersonbeingdescribed.P relatedagentofperson A Anagentthatisassociatedwiththepersonbeingdescribed.P relatedpersonofperson P Apersonthatisassociatedwiththepersonbeingdescribed.P relatedfamilyofperson F Afamilythatisassociatedwiththepersonbeingdescribed.P relatedcorporatebodyofperson C Acorporatebodythatisassociatedpersontheworkbeingdescribed.F relatedentityoffamily Anentitythatisassociatedwiththefamilybeingdescribed.F relatedworkoffamily W Aworkthatisassociatedwiththefamilybeingdescribed.F relatedexpressionoffamily E Anexpressionthatisassociatedwiththefamilybeingdescribed.




Definition

F relatedmanifestationoffamily M Amanifestationthatisassociatedwiththefamilybeingdescribed.F relateditemoffamily I Anitemthatisassociatedwiththefamilybeingdescribed.F relatedagentoffamily A Anagentthatisassociatedwiththefamilybeingdescribed.F relatedpersonoffamily P Apersonthatisassociatedwiththefamilybeingdescribed.F relatedfamilyoffamily F Afamilythatisassociatedwiththefamilybeingdescribed.F relatedcorporatebodyoffamily C Acorporatebodythatisassociatedfamilytheworkbeingdescribed.C relatedentityofcorporatebody Anentitythatisassociatedwiththecorporatebodybeingdescribed.C relatedworkofcorporatebody W Aworkthatisassociatedwiththecorporatebodybeingdescribed.C relatedexpressionofcorporatebody E Anexpressionthatisassociatedwiththecorporatebodybeingdescribed.C relatedmanifestationofcorporatebody M Amanifestationthatisassociatedwiththecorporatebodybeing

described.C relateditemofcorporatebody I Anitemthatisassociatedwiththecorporatebodydescribed.C relatedagentofcorporatebody A Anagentthatisassociatedwiththecorporatebodybeingdescribed.C relatedpersonofcorporatebody P Apersonthatisassociatedwiththecorporatebodybeingdescribed.C relatedfamilyofcorporatebody F Afamilythatisassociatedwiththecorporatebodybeingdescribed.C relatedcorporatebodyofcorporatebody C Acorporatebodythatisassociatedcorporatebodytheworkbeing

described.


Appendix 3: Change 3 with alternative labels

Appendix3:Change3withalternativelabelsThisvariantrevisionforChange3useslabelsconstructedaccordingtothepossibleresolutionoflabelissuesinRecommendation6.

relatedmanifestationreproductionofitemAmanifestationthatreproducesanitemofanothermanifestation.Reciprocalrelationship:relateditemreproductionofmanifestation

relatedmanifestationdigitaltransferofitemAmanifestationinadigitalformatthatresultsfromthetransferofaniteminanotherdigitalformat.Reciprocalrelationship:relateditemdigitaltransferofmanifestationrelatedmanifestationelectronicreproductionofitemAmanifestationinadigitalformatthatistheresultofthetransferofaniteminanalogformat.Reciprocalrelationship:relateditemelectronicreproductionofmanifestationrelatedmanifestationfacsimileofitemAmanifestationthatexactlyreproducesanitemofanothermanifestation.Reciprocalrelationship:relateditemfacsimileofmanifestation

relatedmanifestationpreservationfacsimileofitemAmanifestationthatconsistsofanexactreproductionofanitemofanothermanifestationonpreservation-qualitymedia,suchasacid-freepermanentorarchivalpaper.Reciprocalrelationship:relateditempreservationfacsimileofmanifestation

relatedmanifestationreprintofitemAmanifestationthatisareissueofanitemthatexemplifiesanotherprintedmanifestation.Reciprocalrelationship:relatedreprintofmanifestation

relateditemreproductionofmanifestationAnitemthatisusedasthebasisformanifestationthatisareproduction.Reciprocalrelationship:relatedmanifestationreproductionofitem

relateditemdigitaltransferofmanifestationAniteminadigitalformatthatistransferredtoanotherdigitalformatasamanifestation.Reciprocalrelationship:relatedmanifestationdigitaltransferofitemrelateditemelectronicreproductionofmanifestationAniteminananalogformatthatistransferredtoadigitalformatasamanifestation.Reciprocalrelationship:relatedmanifestationelectronicreproductionofitemrelateditemfacsimileofmanifestationAnitemthatisusedasthebasisforamanifestationthatisanexactreproduction.Reciprocalrelationship:relatedmanifestationfacsimileofitem


Appendix 3: Change 3 with alternative labels

relateditempreservationfacsimileofmanifestationAnitemthatisusedasthebasisforamanifestationthatisanexactreproductiononpreservation-qualitymedia,suchasacid-freepermanentorarchivalpaper.Reciprocalrelationship:relatedmanifestationpreservationfacsimileofitem

relateditemreprintofmanifestationAnitemthatexemplifiesaprintedmanifestationthatisusedasthebasisforareissueofamanifestation.Reciprocalrelationship:relatedmanifestationreprintofitem

abstract justification - · person”, one each for p, f ... , time-span the lrm is expected ......

Documents