a survey measuring hifzun nafs in maqasid e...

20
1 A Survey measuring Hifzun Nafs in Maqasid e Shariah Zohra Jabeen Assistant Professor, Institute of Management Sciences Romana Bangash Assistant Professor, Institute of Management Sciences Syed Waqar Hussain Assistant Professor, Institute of Management Sciences Abstract This paper is highlighting the development of measure of Hifzun Nafs through survey technique. It measures the extent of poverty of poor people under the dimension of Hifzun Nafs, (Safeguard of Life) as basic need of living, a fundamental objective of Maqasid e Shariah. It uses a questionnaire for this purpose to survey local poor communities in Peshawar. It measures the deprivations in minimum living conditions as deprivation of Hifzun Nafs by assigning relative numbers or scores to their living standards at the poverty line threshold of $1.25 (2015 figures of UNDP) and below them starting from zero and going as far as minus five, constructing a Sharia based reporting measure of Hifzun Nafs of poor people through survey. This paper is unique in focusing on the survey based measurement of poor’s living conditions as reflection of Hifzun Nafs in contributing to development of Maqasid e Shariah living standards Index in future as it is not yet developed and work on it is in process in various studies. The results of the study are useful for a first hand data collection and analysis of local population according to Hifzun Nafs of Maqasid e Shariah for contributing to construction of Maqasid e Sharia Index and for effective policy implications for governments as well as all stakeholders. Keywords: Hifzun Nafs, Living standards, scoring, Maqasid e Shariah, Poverty, Survey

Upload: others

Post on 27-Dec-2019

9 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: A Survey measuring Hifzun Nafs in Maqasid e Shariahajss.abasyn.edu.pk/admineditor/specialissue/papers/CP 04.pdfNafs in contributing to development of Maqasid e Shariah living standards

1

A Survey measuring Hifzun Nafs in Maqasid e Shariah

Zohra Jabeen

Assistant Professor, Institute of Management Sciences

Romana Bangash

Assistant Professor, Institute of Management Sciences

Syed Waqar Hussain

Assistant Professor, Institute of Management Sciences

Abstract

This paper is highlighting the development of measure of Hifzun Nafs through survey technique.

It measures the extent of poverty of poor people under the dimension of Hifzun Nafs, (Safeguard

of Life) as basic need of living, a fundamental objective of Maqasid e Shariah. It uses a

questionnaire for this purpose to survey local poor communities in Peshawar. It measures the

deprivations in minimum living conditions as deprivation of Hifzun Nafs by assigning relative

numbers or scores to their living standards at the poverty line threshold of $1.25 (2015 figures of

UNDP) and below them starting from zero and going as far as minus five, constructing a Sharia

based reporting measure of Hifzun Nafs of poor people through survey. This paper is unique in

focusing on the survey based measurement of poor’s living conditions as reflection of Hifzun

Nafs in contributing to development of Maqasid e Shariah living standards Index in future as it

is not yet developed and work on it is in process in various studies. The results of the study are

useful for a first hand data collection and analysis of local population according to Hifzun Nafs of

Maqasid e Shariah for contributing to construction of Maqasid e Sharia Index and for effective

policy implications for governments as well as all stakeholders.

Keywords: Hifzun Nafs, Living standards, scoring, Maqasid e Shariah, Poverty, Survey

Page 2: A Survey measuring Hifzun Nafs in Maqasid e Shariahajss.abasyn.edu.pk/admineditor/specialissue/papers/CP 04.pdfNafs in contributing to development of Maqasid e Shariah living standards

2

1. Introduction

The vision of development in Islam is the well-being or falah of humankind in material and

moral sense including spiritual wellbeing. This concept of well- being has its impact in both this

world and the hereafter (Ayub, 2007; Chapra, 2008). Hence there is a difference in the approach

of measuring well-being of people from Islamic point of view and that of conventional

economics, as the former (Islamic vision) is based on the Shariah and the objectives (termed

Maqasid) of the Sharia. The conventional economics approach towards human well-being is

primarily in material sense.

Renowned scholars1 of sharia defined the objectives or Maqasid of the Shariah as the main

elements of life for which Allah has revealed the Sharia. It is composed of five main objectives

which are the safeguard and promotion of life, religion2, progeny (family), intellect and wealth.

(Al-Shatibi, 2012) (Moosa, 2016) . These are called Hifzun Nafs, Hifz ul Deen , Hifz ul Nasl, Hifz

ul Aql and Hifz ul Maal respectively. Broadly speaking, as interpreted by scholars, these

objectives are meant to serve the interest of human beings and to save them from harm. Besides,

they are inter related (Chapra, 2008). Muslim scholars of current times are working to develop an

index of society’s wellbeing based on the objectives or Maqasid of the Shariah. Deliberations on

these are taking place in seminars, conferences and through various researches. The parameters

for measurement and assessment taken or proposed also vary across studies. Hifzun Nafs or

safeguard of Life has also been studied. For example, Mehdi (2014), using secondary data

statistics, considers Hifzun Nafs to be the product of poverty gap (measures poverty intensity),

human rights Index, health care index, and the Crime Index. Similarly the components of each

1 The highly esteemed scholars of the shariah who have described the maqaasid e sharia include Abu Ishaq Al-

Shatibi (of Maliki school of thought/fiqh) , Abū Hāmid al-Ghazālī (d.505AH/1111AC), Ibn Qayyim aljawiziyyah

(Hanbali school of fiqh),and Al Izz ibn Abd al Salam (Shafiite ) 2 It basically means belief in the oneness of God (Allah) and the belief in Mohammad (Peace be upon Him) as the

Messenger of Allah and the belief in his message from Allah and living life accordingly

Page 3: A Survey measuring Hifzun Nafs in Maqasid e Shariahajss.abasyn.edu.pk/admineditor/specialissue/papers/CP 04.pdfNafs in contributing to development of Maqasid e Shariah living standards

3

category of the five Maqasid also vary across studies. For example children’s basic (primary)

education is placed under Hifzun Nasl (safeguard, promotion and protection of family/

Posterity). The study of Khan, Sulaiman and Bahari (2015) focused on Hifzun Nasl (safeguard of

progeny) and included children’s education in it. Yet Mehdi (2014) has placed basic education of

children in Hifzul Aql (safeguard, promotion and protection of intellect). Hence there will be

overlaps across the five maqaasid and this is a reflection of different perspectives.

This present study is conducted to measure the extent of poverty of poor people under the

dimension of Hifzun Nafs, as basic needs of life which is one of the fundamental objectives of

Maqasid e Shariah, through survey analysis. While the objective set for the study is to construct a

Sharia based reporting measure of Hifzun Nafs of poor people through survey. The study is

highlighting the development of measure of Hifzun Nafs through survey technique. By

constructing the measures of Hifzun Nafs, the study aims at its use for developing a living

standards index based on Maqasid e Shariah. Work on this index (generally abbreviated as MSI)

in many forms and for many purposes it is in process, but holistically, it is not yet developed,

especially for living standards. This paper is unique in focusing on the survey based

measurement of poor’s living conditions as reflection of Hifzun Nafs in contributing to

development of Maqasid e Shariah living standards Index (MSI). Islamic MSI Index for living

standards or living conditions is different from other indices of development and human

development because it is based on the standards of the Shariah deduced from the Quran and

Sunnah, touching upon the five basic focal points of the human life which are called the

objectives of Shariah or Maqaasid e Shariah.

Page 4: A Survey measuring Hifzun Nafs in Maqasid e Shariahajss.abasyn.edu.pk/admineditor/specialissue/papers/CP 04.pdfNafs in contributing to development of Maqasid e Shariah living standards

4

2. Literature Review:

2.1 Maqasid e Shariah:

The main concept of Maqasid al Shariah was developed by eminent scholars of Islamic

jurisprudence from 5th century to 8th century such as Al-Juwaini, Abu Hamid al-Ghazali

(Ghazanfer and Islahi, 1997) and most significantly by the works of Abu Ishaq al-Shatibi (Al-

Shatibi, 2012 [Nyazee Trans.]) (Moosa, 2016) (Mehdi, 2014). Later, in the twentieth century,

Muhammad al-Tahir ibn Ashur’s (1879 -1973) work on Maqasid is noteworthy and is well cited

in the Islamic jurisprudence called Usul al Fiqh (El Mesawi, 2006). The Maqasid theory

emerged as an important theory in Law by the Muslim scholars for Shariah- based reform in the

existing theories and practice. Recently the Maqasid concept is applied by scholars in other

fields as well for providing the shariah lens of analysis. (Kasri, 2016) For instance, in the

Islamic banking and finance numerous studies assess Islamic banks’ performance and

governance in the light of Maqasid e Shariah , proposing measures of performance as well as

assessing results with respect to the Maqasid either holistically or of any aspect of them

singularly or developing a Maqasid e Shariah based Index of performance. Anto (2009)

discussed development of Islamic Development Index (I-HDI) as a measure of development in

Organization of Islamic Countries (OIC). Rehman and Askari (2010) developed an Economic

Islamicity Index. Asutay and Harningtyas, (2016) discussed developing Maqasid e Shariah Index

for measuring social performance of Islamic banks. Nizam and Larbani (2016) proposed

Maqasid e Sharaih based composition Index to socio-economic performance measurement.

Faliza’s work (2016) was relating CSR and Islamic Bank’s performance by adding the

dimension of Maqasid al Shariah and Mohamad et al (2016) discussed determinants of Maqasid

al Shariah based practices of Islamic banks in Malaysia. Other studies include Alabeed., Askari.,

Page 5: A Survey measuring Hifzun Nafs in Maqasid e Shariahajss.abasyn.edu.pk/admineditor/specialissue/papers/CP 04.pdfNafs in contributing to development of Maqasid e Shariah living standards

5

Iqbal and Ng,(2014) on performance measurement and Budiman., Mohammad Amin., Yusof and

Adewale (2015) on proposes safeguard and preservation of wealth based on Maqasid al Shariah

while Khan Z,. Sulaiman and Bahari ( 2015) presented developing of a socio economic well-

being and posterity index based on the Maqasid. A very recent study of Ali and Hasan (2018)

was on Maqasid al Shariah based Index relating poverty level of countries while Jabeen (2017)

presented a paper on Maqasid e Shariah- based Identifier for Extreme Poor in Pakistan.

2.2 Hifzun Nafs:

The safeguard and promotion of life is Hifzun Nafs. It is one of the five components delineated in

the Maqasid e Shariah. Hifzun Nafs means taking care of the bodily needs of human beings,

such as food and water, health, shelter, etc. These are the basic needs that must be fulfilled at

least at the minimum level of human requirements to live a safe and healthy life individually and

socially. The level of safe and healthy life means the bare basics of living. On an international

level basic living includes the basic right which includes the right to receive basic education also.

In the conventional economics sense, poverty means deprivation of basic necessities of life. In

other words, poverty means that the poor are deprived of basic material necessities of life. This

includes very low income per capita leading to very low consumption. There is also the

capability approach to human development , which considers capability as functioning , i.e. the

ability to do things which a person values such as spiritual things as social human beings such

social participation, spreading and discussing ideas and getting respect (Wong, (2012); Alkire

and Foster (2009)). From Shariah perspective, poverty can create a lot of problems and

difficulties for people in their obedience to Allah (SWT) and can create the possibility of loss of

faith in Allah and His message (Zaman, Naveed and Rehman, 2014).

Page 6: A Survey measuring Hifzun Nafs in Maqasid e Shariahajss.abasyn.edu.pk/admineditor/specialissue/papers/CP 04.pdfNafs in contributing to development of Maqasid e Shariah living standards

6

This study has picked Hifzun Nafs as the basic parameter of life with the notion that existence of

extreme poverty conditions mean a system lacking the objective of Shariah (non-functioning or

poor functioning basis) in a Muslim society. Therefore the study undertakes the study of the

poor, in the poor localities in order to seek their deprivations. It has taken the basic income

approach and measures the income, nature of shelter, education, water availability, health and

hygiene & sanitation of the respondents.

2.3 Parameters in Hifzun Nafs (chosen for the study)

2.3.1 Daily Income per capita

2.3.2 Nature of shelter and occupancy

2.3.3 Children’s education

2.3.4 Health expenses

2.3.5 Source of water

2.3.6 Hygiene

Given below are the examples of poverty conditions that defy the parallels in Maqasid e Sharia

indicators. The list is not final or conclusive, and is a beginner’s course of action. The examples

also have overlaps among different Maqasid.

Page 7: A Survey measuring Hifzun Nafs in Maqasid e Shariahajss.abasyn.edu.pk/admineditor/specialissue/papers/CP 04.pdfNafs in contributing to development of Maqasid e Shariah living standards

7

Table 1: Maqasid e Shariah Chart and examples of Extreme Poverty related to Hifzun Nafs

No Objective of

Shariah

Extreme poverty conditions

1. Hifzun Nafs

(The human

body & self

(zaahir o Baatin)

a) Hunger, malnourished

b) lack of proper or sufficient shelter

c) lack of water, lack of hygiene facilities, (toilet, sanitation) lack of

electricity

d) poor health due to lack of means for medical health.

e) disability, physical or mental handicap

f) “izzat e nafs” – honour ( not begging, not enslaved due to poverty

and helplessness)

Source: Author’s own

3. Methodology of the Research

Poverty scoring is an alternative approach among measures of poverty (Schreiner, 2006), where

measures of poverty as deprivations are identified and each measure is assigned a score

depending on the level of deprivation. The method of scorecard uses a few simple indicators to

estimate the likelihood that a household has consumption below a poverty line. The scorecard

method is particularly being used for finding the effectiveness of a poverty alleviation funds. For

example, it is being used for collecting data from recipients in Pakistan’s Benazir Income

Support Program (BISP) for the poor. It is also being used in many other countries (Schreiner,

2015, 2016, 2017). In addition the method is considered effective in disseminating easily

understandable information for managers, decision makers and other stakeholders who are not

Page 8: A Survey measuring Hifzun Nafs in Maqasid e Shariahajss.abasyn.edu.pk/admineditor/specialissue/papers/CP 04.pdfNafs in contributing to development of Maqasid e Shariah living standards

8

necessarily economists. This scoring is quite similar to multidimensional poverty index

measurement (MPI) studies which aim at identifying poor, where scores or counts are assigned

as 0 to non-deprived dimension and 1 to a deprived dimension, and then the number of

deprivations are counted and surveyees categorized as poor or non-poor (Alkire, Roche, Ballon,

Foster, Santos, & Seth. 2015). However, this scorecard method is deeper with the scores ranging

from 0 to -5, in addition to measuring each chosen dimension separately. The current’s study’s

scoring method is given in detail below.

In this scorecard method, the scoring range was 0 to -5 for all categories of income, education,

shelter, water, health, hygiene. Hence all categories were divided into six bands. A sample of 300

was chosen through oversampling of the poor people. Six responses were discarded due to

insufficient information the sample size to net 294. The apparent profile of these poor included

the people who were laborers or selling some things in baskets, push carts on road side and

markets, or doing shoe- polish, or collecting scrap etc. The choice of questions was on a similar

pattern to the Alkire and Foster (2009, 2015), studies of poverty in multidimensional poverty

studies which coincided with the selected Hifzun Nafs parameters of Maqasid e Shariah.

Six parameters of Hifzun Nafs were chosen for the study3. Income is the main component of the

survey for identifying poverty and finding the extent of deprivation of Hifzun Nafs among the

poor people. This was complimented by other components as shelter, access to potable drinking

and household use water, children’s education, health expense (and having health insurance

card), and hygiene ( as existence and type of toilets at home). The daily per capita income was

considered as the income data of respondents. This is a foremost factor in poverty estimation

according to the income approach. The United Nations Development Program (UNDP) poverty

estimates have raised the minimum per capita income for the world wide poverty line as $ 1. 90i,

3 These parameters are not a complete list and other parameters can be added to it.

Page 9: A Survey measuring Hifzun Nafs in Maqasid e Shariahajss.abasyn.edu.pk/admineditor/specialissue/papers/CP 04.pdfNafs in contributing to development of Maqasid e Shariah living standards

9

up from $1.25 per capita4 (Nino, F. S. United Nations Sustainable Development.[cited 2016 Nov

22].). 0 is the highest score representing, income wise more than Rs. 131 (US$ 1.24 @ Rs 105.

= US$1). Overall, for all categories, levels -3 to -5 indicated existence of conditions of extreme

poverty, categorizing hunger and “maskenah”.

Table 2- Scores

Score Daily

Income per

capita

Nature of

shelter and occupancy

Children

going to school

Health

Expenses

Source of

water

Description

-5 Below

Rs. 50 per

person

per day

House with

more than 4 people per

room

Not going to

school, left un educated

No money for

health expenses and

no borrowing

for health.

No source or

very far off source

No toilet at

home

-4 Rs 51-70

House with 4 people per

room

Left school after some

time

Rs. 4000 and above spent on

health and

borrowed

Mosque 1 Rudimentary “kacha” toilet at

home

-3 Rs 71-

90

House with 3

people per

room

If out of 2

children, 1 is

going to

school

Rs. 2500 to Rs

3,999 spent on

health and

borrowed

Tap in Street 2 Rudimentary

“kacha” toilets

at home

-2 Rs 91-

110

House with 2

people per

room

2 going to

school (in 3

children)

Rs. 500 to Rs.

2499 spent on

health( borrowed or

own money)

Neighbor’s

tap

1 flushable toilet

at home

-1 Rs 111-

130

House with 1

person per room

3 or more

children going to

school (More

than half going to

school )

Rs.0 to Rs.499

spent on health ( borrowed or

own money)

Municipal

committee’s tap at home

2 flushable

toilets at home

0 Above

Rs 131

Living in own

house.

All going to

school

Health

Insurance Cover (Insaf

Health card)

Well or hand

pump at home

More than 2

flushable toilets at home

Source: Authors’ own

4. Analysis and Findings

4The previous UN poverty line was US$ 1.254 per capita (per person per day) (1.25 x 105 (@Rs 105=1 US$) = Rs.

131.25) . Nino ,F.S. Sustainable Development Goals, (UNDP), 2015.

Page 10: A Survey measuring Hifzun Nafs in Maqasid e Shariahajss.abasyn.edu.pk/admineditor/specialissue/papers/CP 04.pdfNafs in contributing to development of Maqasid e Shariah living standards

10

Respondents with income per capita below Rs. 50 are the highest, i.e. 83 out of 294. This is 28%

of the sample. The next highest cluster is of those with income ranging from Rs 51 to 70. These

are 78 and make 26% of the total. After that results for score 2, which are between 71 and 90 are

50, which is 17%. It means that out of a sample of 294 the income of (83+78+50= 211) 211

respondents is less than Rs. 90 per capita. This is more than half of the sample. Then 55

respondents have between Rs. 90 and Rs131, which is also below the previous poverty line of

Rs. 131 equivalent to US $ 1.25 per capita.

From these results, the extremely poor respondents are categorized in bands minus five, minus

four and minus three (-5, -4 and -3). 211 respondents are in this band. This means more than

half of the respondents are having income less than US$0.85 per day per person (@ Rs 105:

1US$). In the complete data only 30 households are in zero category for income, which means

only 10% (100* (30/294) = 10%) of the sample are at (or above) the (old) poverty threshold line,

and the remaining sample lies under the poverty line.

Overall except level Zero, comprising Rs 131 and above the income levels of the whole sample

was below the United Nations’ defined poverty line of US $1.25 (Rs. 1315) per capita per day as

well as the new poverty line of US$ 1.90 per capita. According to our results 89.7% of the

sample had per capita income below the poverty line of US$1.25 per capita and US$ 1.90 per

capita in the selected poor localities in the city of Peshawar.

4.1 Signs of Malnourishment:

5 At exchange rate of US$ 1 = Rs. 105, Source: The State Bank of Pakistan Date: October 02,2017

Page 11: A Survey measuring Hifzun Nafs in Maqasid e Shariahajss.abasyn.edu.pk/admineditor/specialissue/papers/CP 04.pdfNafs in contributing to development of Maqasid e Shariah living standards

11

Score minus five and minus four are those respondents with nil to Rs fifty per capita and those

earning Rupees Seventy One to Rupees Ninety respectively. These are the lowest levels of this

category. Below Rs. 100/- is extreme miserable conditions of living. At score minus five, with

maximum Rs 50 per capita, for instance, consider the fact that a bread per person costs Rs .10

and two breads per day would be for Rs. 20/-. The rest Rs. 30/- will be too little available for

cooking fuel, sugar, tea, vegetables, lentils or sugar. This leads to malnourishment in such

families and stunted growth of many children. At score minus five, 83 out 294 respondents of the

sample showed signs of malnourishment and extreme poverty. Those 78, at score minus four too,

were not much better off. It were the children of people at this level of subsistence that were sent

for picking stuff from garbage dumps and bins in order to meet ends.

Based on the results of survey it can be seen that overall the sample of respondents were very

poor, did not have the means to afford better education for their children except the free

government schools or madrassas, were living in poor quality shelters, could not afford their

health expenses if they fall ill, had tough hygiene conditions of availability of toilets. Their

access to water as reported by them was relatively better as compared to other factors of

measurement in the survey.

In the survey of poor in any locality and country, the factors that will increase or reduce their

deprivation can be, free health care, free and standard ( good) quality education, subsidized

housing with facilities for a good system of sanitation and sewage connected to all houses.

However, in countries, where such a support system is non- existent or poor, the poor will

become more helpless and disadvantaged.

Page 12: A Survey measuring Hifzun Nafs in Maqasid e Shariahajss.abasyn.edu.pk/admineditor/specialissue/papers/CP 04.pdfNafs in contributing to development of Maqasid e Shariah living standards

12

4.2 Meaning of Hifzun Nafs survey drawn for Maqasid e Shariah Index and policy measures:

The results of the local community level Hifzun Nafs survey of poor people given above shows

existence of abject poverty in the city. Existence of these conditions of the people within the

society proves that the Islamic system of distributive justice, based on the Maqasid e Shariah and

Maslaha is disrupted in this city and its slums suburbs, in particular. There is either leakage from

the system or blockage causing poor transmission of resources to the poor over the long run.

Hence we argue that in the MSI, the value or number that may be given to the localities will be a

negative number for income as well as education, shelter, health and hygiene. This would be

within the measurement of Hifzun Nafs, and overlap with other parameters of the Maqaasid also.

Impact and placement of this Hifzun Nafs survey: Within an MSI calculation, the basic

respectable living according to the Maqaasid e Shariah shall be at least above the zero level if

plotted on an integer line, meeting at least the bare basics of living. Conditions below the neutral

level shall have scores in minus. In addition, a negative score on the parameters of Hifzun Nafs

give scores of multiple minuses in Hiful Aql for poor education or no education, Hifzul Nasl, for

poor living conditions poor health facilities, poor sanitation and lack of access to potable water,

Hifzul Maal for inability to provide for themselves as well as Hifzud Deen for lack of access to

education as well as religious education and development of the mind for seeking further

knowledge. These implications and cross implications are ideas for further studies to consider.

4.3 Data for Region and district-wise MSI:

The information at national level implies reduction in overall poverty figures in Pakistan.

However, in this survey of poor people, 89% of the respondents were very poor experiencing

extreme poverty. Hence, the poor and extremely poor people need to be identified in similar

studies across all regions by similar surveys in order to give region or district-wise positions and

Page 13: A Survey measuring Hifzun Nafs in Maqasid e Shariahajss.abasyn.edu.pk/admineditor/specialissue/papers/CP 04.pdfNafs in contributing to development of Maqasid e Shariah living standards

13

Hifzun Nafs status in MSI and provide a correct reflection of poverty in making national level

MSI. This will make the MSI more realistic in highlighting poverty and hunger (ghurbat and

Maskena) for the development of quality of life. It will also provide district-wise MSI figures

which would be further useful in assessing Maqasid e Shariah based progress or lack of it. By

searching for these slums of poor people within a district or city or town and conducting their

poverty based surveys, index-forming studies as well as distributing waqf and zakat benefits will

be more effective.

5. Conclusion and Recommendations

Renowned Muslim scholars have synthesized the overall purpose and meaning of Islam as the

objectives of the Shariah or Maqasid e Shariah. Our study has helped in some way in finding

improvements or deterioration in society’s wellbeing in terms of falah in accordance to the

Maqasid e Shariah, by measuring the real level of poverty and the nature of poor as a measure of

Hifzun Nafs.

This paper’s measurement of Hifzun Nafs and the results of 89% of the sample living below the

2015 poverty line, shows presence of poverty as well as extreme poverty in indicators scoring

below zero. This shows gross deviation from the Maqasid e Shariah. This kind of measurements

need to be incorporated in the MSI by conducting such surveys particularly in localities where

the poor people live. This needs to be the starting point of the MSI, as poverty can lead to Kufr,

meaning loss of faith (in Arabic: AlShub ul Eeman Lil Bahhaqi) (Zaman et al, 2014). Taking

immediate action and providing help to eradicate hunger and extreme poverty /maskana is the

foremost duty and objective or Maqsad of the Shariah for individuals (civil society) as well as

government. All else remains secondary, in Maqasid e Shariah when the poor people sleep

hungry or are malnourished, when the sick cannot get medical help, the handicapped are left

Page 14: A Survey measuring Hifzun Nafs in Maqasid e Shariahajss.abasyn.edu.pk/admineditor/specialissue/papers/CP 04.pdfNafs in contributing to development of Maqasid e Shariah living standards

14

unattended, the children cannot get basic education and protection (kafalah), when people do not

have access to clean drinking water, when they are living below the basic hygiene and sanitation

levels, when people are living under debt

Poverty and deprivation, if plotted on an integer line would place the prevalent Hifzun Nafs in

Maqasid e Sharia level in the negative in areas where there is poverty and extreme poverty.

Therefore, the Maqasid e Sharia level in society should first be brought from the negative to the

neutral level and then to the positive level. From the negative to the neutral level is also progress

and so is the progress from zero level to positive and further up. Any Maqasid e Sharia

measurement or indicator must include the basic needs of all the population. The study also

asserts that for finding out about the extent of poverty, the statistics of the poverty line is not

enough. It is essential to find out about the extent or “face” of poverty by doing sampling in poor

localities because conditions vary from one place to another. This can also be effective in

bringing about the local living conditions of the poor people, with this local level study. It shows

this point through the survey of poor people who are working and living in slums.

Recommendations:

The paper recommends identification and survey of pockets of poverty and extreme poverty (like

the current study’s example and inclusion of results in adjustment of poverty figures for a

country and in its Hifzun Nafs assessment in MSI. Future recommendations for research are of

conducting more surveys in such areas in different cities and towns. Another recommendation is

for further research focusing further on quantification of poverty in Maqasid e Shariah index and

broadening of the questions asked without making the questionnaire cumbersome. There is a

need for problem identifiers like the current study, after its identification, the information must

be disseminated to the policy makers to implement necessary changes in order to bring the

Page 15: A Survey measuring Hifzun Nafs in Maqasid e Shariahajss.abasyn.edu.pk/admineditor/specialissue/papers/CP 04.pdfNafs in contributing to development of Maqasid e Shariah living standards

15

society on the right track of fulfilling the Maqasid e Sharia and promoting them further. In

addition to the government level action, an ideal Muslim society is a caring society where the

well to do general public steps in to reduce the hardships of the poor. Studies like these highlight

actual living conditions of poor neighborhoods. Sensitizing the society about their abject poverty

is recommended further to bridge the gap between the rich and the poor through practical steps

by the society. A local community level connection between the affluent and the poor will make

waqf, zakat and charity more effective and the hadith for Muslims to ensure that their neighbors

do not sleep hungry, can be materialized.

Page 16: A Survey measuring Hifzun Nafs in Maqasid e Shariahajss.abasyn.edu.pk/admineditor/specialissue/papers/CP 04.pdfNafs in contributing to development of Maqasid e Shariah living standards

16

References:

Alaabed, A., Askari, H., Iqbal, Z., & Ng, A. (2014). Developing benchmark index for

monitoring compliance with Maqasid al Shari'ah. Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia: paper presented

at the Fourth International ISRA Colloquium, 3–4 September 2014,Kuala Lumpur,

Malaysia.

Ali, S. S. and Hasan, H. (2018). Measuring Deprivation from Maqāṣid Al-SharīʿAh

Dimensions in OIC Countries: Ranking and Policy Focus Journal of King Abdulaziz

University: Islamic Economics, Vol. 31, No. 1. DOI: 10.4197 / Islec. 31-1.1

Alkire, S., & Foster, J. (2009). Counting and Multidimensional Poverty Measurement,

Journal of Public Economics 95 (7-8) 2011, 476-487, Retrieved from

https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S0047272710001660

Anto, M. H. (2009). Introducing an Islamic human development index (I-HDI) to measure

development in OIC countries”. Islamic Economic Studies, 19(2), pp. 69-95. Retrieved from

http://www.irti.org/English/Research/Documents/IES/049.pdf

Askari, H., & Rehman, S. S. (2010). An Economic IslamicityIndex (EI2). Global Economy

Journal, 10(3). Retrieved from https://hossein-askari.com/wordpress/wp-

content/uploads/islamicity-index.pdf

Asutay, M. and Harningtyas, A.F. (2015) 'Developing Maqasid al-Shari'ah index to evaluate

social performance of Islamic banks: a conceptual and empirical attempt.', International

journal of Islamic economics and finance studies., 1 (1), 5-64 Retrieved from

http://dergipark.gov.tr/download/article-file/303975

Budiman, M. A., Mohd Amin, R., Yusof, S., & Adewale, A. A. (2015, March). Measuring

Maqasid Al-Shari’ah at a Micro Level with Special Reference to the Preservation of Wealth.

Page 17: A Survey measuring Hifzun Nafs in Maqasid e Shariahajss.abasyn.edu.pk/admineditor/specialissue/papers/CP 04.pdfNafs in contributing to development of Maqasid e Shariah living standards

17

The First International Conference on Shariah Oriented Public Policy in Islamic Economic

System (ICOSOPP 2015), held in Banda Aceh, Indonesia (pp. 30-31).

Chapra, U.M. (2008). The Islamic Vision of Development in the Light of Maqāsid Al-

Sharī‘ah. Islamic Research and Training Institute. Version: Occasional Papers # 235

doi:10.13140/RG.2.1.4188.5047

Faliza, N. (2016). CSR and Islamic Banking Performance in Aceh: The Role of Innovation

as Mediation. Journal of Management and Marketing Review, 1(1), 45-56. Retrieved from

https://www.academia.edu/34136902/CSR_and_Islamic_Banking_Performance_in_Aceh_T

he_Role_of_Innovation_as_Mediation

Jabeen, Z. (2017, October 31). Maqasid e Shariah- based Identifier for Extreme Poor in

Pakistan. International Thematic workshop on Developing Developing a Framework for

Surveys and Impact Analysis through Maqasid al-Shariah based Index of Socio-Economic

Development. Islamic Research and Training Institute, IDB. Islamabad.

Kasri, R. A. (2016). Maqasid al-Shariah and Performance of Zakah Institutions.

Kyoto Bulletin of Islamic Area Studies, 19–41. Retrieved from

https://www.asafas.kyoto-u.ac.jp/kias/pdf/kb9/03esf_03_kasri.pdf

Khan, Z., Sulaiman, J., & Bahari, Z. (2015). Socioeconomic human well-being and

posterity: a newly proposed faith-based measurement index. Journal of Religion &

Spirituality in Social Work: Social Thought, 34(1), 72-90. Retrieved from

https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/pdf/10.1080/15426432.2014.955244?needAccess=true

Mehdi, M. (2014). A Structural Model for Human Development. Islamic Economic Studies,

22(02). doi:10.12816/0008095

Page 18: A Survey measuring Hifzun Nafs in Maqasid e Shariahajss.abasyn.edu.pk/admineditor/specialissue/papers/CP 04.pdfNafs in contributing to development of Maqasid e Shariah living standards

18

Mohamad, M. H. S., Ali, M. A., & Sharif, R. A. M. (2016). Determinants Of Maqāsid Al-

Sharī ‘ah-Based Performance Measurement Practices: The Case Of Malaysian Islamic

Banks. International Journal of Economics, Management and Accounting, 24(1), 49-81.

Retrieved from

http://journals.iium.edu.my/enmjournal/index.php/enmj/article/view/393/205

Nizam, I. and Larbani, M. (2014) AMaqāsid Al-Shari’ah based Composite Index to Measure

Socio-economic Prosperity in OIC Countries , International Thematic Conference on

Developing Maqaasid Al-Shari'ah based Measurement of Socio-economic Development,

Islamic Research and Training Institute, IDB, Yog Jarkata, Indonesia (June 26 - 29, 2014)

Wong, S. Y. (2012). Understanding Poverty: Comparing Basic Needs Approach and

Capability Approach. Available at SSRN 2066179.

Zaman, A., Naveed, A. and Rehman A. (2014). Wealth as an Indicator of Socio-Economic

Development: Islamic Views. DOI:10.2139/ssrn.3216638

Books and reports:

Al-Shatibi (2012), The reconciliation of the fundamentals of Islamic law by Ibrahim ibn

Musa Shatibi. [Nyazee,I. A.K. Trans.] , Southern Court, UK: Garnet Publishing ( original

work published in 1884) https://www.amazon.com/Reconciliation-Fundamentals-Islamic-

Law-Al-Muwafaqat/dp/1859642683

Alkire, S., Roche, J. M., Ballon, P., Foster, J., Santos, M. E., & Seth, S.

(2015). Multidimensional poverty measurement and analysis. Oxford University Press, USA

Ayub, M. (2007). Understanding Islamic Finance, West Sussex England: Wiley, ISBN 978-

0-470-03069-1 (HB)

Page 19: A Survey measuring Hifzun Nafs in Maqasid e Shariahajss.abasyn.edu.pk/admineditor/specialissue/papers/CP 04.pdfNafs in contributing to development of Maqasid e Shariah living standards

19

Chen, S., & Schreiner, M. (2016). Simple Poverty Scorecard Poverty-Assessment Tool:

Vietnam. Retrieved from http://www.simplepovertyscorecard.com/VNM_2006_ENG.pdf

El-Mesawi, M. E.-T. (2006). Ibn Ashur: Treatise on Maqasid Al-Shari'ah. London .

Washington: The International Institute of Islamic Thought.

Ghazanfar, S. M., & Islahi, A. A. (1997). Economic thought of al-Ghazali. Jeddah:

Scientific Publishing Centre King Abdulaziz University.

Moosa, E. (2016). The Reconciliation of the Fundamentals of Islamic Law (al-Muwāfaqāt fī

Uṣūl al-Sharīʿa), written by Ibrāhīm ibn Mūsā Abū Isḥāq al-Shāṭibī, 2012. Islamic Law and

Society, 23(3), 318-322

Nino, F. S. (2016). Sustainable Development Goals—United Nations [Internet]. United

Nations Sustainable Development.[cited 2016 Nov 22]

Schreiner M., (2017). Simple Poverty Scorecard Poverty-Assessment Tool Mexico.

Retrieved from http://www.simplepovertyscore card.com/MEX_2014_ENG.pdf

Schreiner M., (2017). Simple Poverty Scorecard Poverty-Assessment Tool South Africa.

Retrieved from http://www.simplepoverty scorecard.com /ZAF_2014_ENG.pdf

Schreiner, M. (2015). An Expert-Based Poverty Scorecard for Rural China. Retrieved

from http://www.localcommunityfinance.com/

English/Papers/Scoring_Poverty_China_EN.pdf

Schreiner, M., Woller, G., & Woller, G. (2016). Simple Poverty Scorecard Poverty-

Assessment Tool: Guatemala. Retrieved from http://www.simplepovertyscorecard.

com/MEX_2016_ENG.pdf

i http://blogs.worldbank.org/developmenttalk/international-poverty-line-has-just-been-raised-190-day-global-poverty-basically-unchanged-how-even

Page 20: A Survey measuring Hifzun Nafs in Maqasid e Shariahajss.abasyn.edu.pk/admineditor/specialissue/papers/CP 04.pdfNafs in contributing to development of Maqasid e Shariah living standards

20