a piece of humble pie this map shows the state of the southern california desert about 10,000 years...

19
A piece of humble pie This map shows the state of the southern California desert about 10,000 years ago. The presence of these lakes is confirmed by oral histories, packrat nests, water- line marks on mountain-sides, fish traps, lakeside campsites and other evidence. Is this much climate change really due to variations in the Earth’s orbit? Do we really think we understand climate change?

Upload: garret-stanwood

Post on 28-Mar-2015

213 views

Category:

Documents


1 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: A piece of humble pie This map shows the state of the southern California desert about 10,000 years ago. The presence of these lakes is confirmed by oral

A piece of humble pie

This map shows the state of the southern California desert about 10,000 years ago.

The presence of these lakes is confirmed by oral histories, packrat nests, water-line marks on mountain-sides, fish traps, lakeside campsites and other evidence.

Is this much climate change really due to variations in the Earth’s orbit?

Do we really think we understand climate change?

Page 2: A piece of humble pie This map shows the state of the southern California desert about 10,000 years ago. The presence of these lakes is confirmed by oral

MODELING TSIVARIATIONS USING AUTOCLASS SOFTWARE ON MWO DATA

R.K. Ulrich1 · D. Parker1 · L. Bertello1 · J. Boyden1

1 Department of Physics and Astronomy, University ofCalifornia, Los Angeles 90095 email: [email protected]: [email protected] email: [email protected]: [email protected]

Page 3: A piece of humble pie This map shows the state of the southern California desert about 10,000 years ago. The presence of these lakes is confirmed by oral

How AutoClass Works

AutoClass works on a set of observations.

Each observation has attributes which are values of observed parameters.

Each observation is referred to as an instance.

In our case the instance is a single pixel.

The attributes are the absolute value of the magnetic field and a line intensity ratio Ir.

The line intensity ratio is:

Page 4: A piece of humble pie This map shows the state of the southern California desert about 10,000 years ago. The presence of these lakes is confirmed by oral

Sample Images

Intensity ratioAbsolute magnetic field

Page 5: A piece of humble pie This map shows the state of the southern California desert about 10,000 years ago. The presence of these lakes is confirmed by oral

How AutoClass Works (cont.) AutoClass takes all observed

instances and uses posterior Bayesian statistics to determine a set of classes to which all observations can be assigned.

The output of an AutoClass search is a number of classes.

Each class is described by probability distribution functions for the values of the attributes.

For our application we get central values and gaussian widths for Ir and |B|.

Page 6: A piece of humble pie This map shows the state of the southern California desert about 10,000 years ago. The presence of these lakes is confirmed by oral

The PDF’s for an 18-class classification.AutoClass finds that 18 classes describe a set of observations consisting of 12 image pairs.

Each image pair consists of an absolute field magnetogram and in intensity ratiogram.

The image pairs were selected as one per year for the period 1996 to 2008.

Page 7: A piece of humble pie This map shows the state of the southern California desert about 10,000 years ago. The presence of these lakes is confirmed by oral

Application of AutoClass to MWO Data There are J classes denoted by index

j. Each pixel i is assigned a probability

that it belongs to class j. We remember which image the

pixels come from and denote that image by index n.

The sum over all pixels on image n of the probabilities each belongs to class j gives us an index Ajn which is effectively the fractional area of solar image n covered by class j.

Page 8: A piece of humble pie This map shows the state of the southern California desert about 10,000 years ago. The presence of these lakes is confirmed by oral

Properties of the Indicies The indicies obey:

The TSI is reproduced by:

The sj represent the TSI the sun would have if entirely covered by class j.

A deviation in sj is usefully defined as:

with

Page 9: A piece of humble pie This map shows the state of the southern California desert about 10,000 years ago. The presence of these lakes is confirmed by oral

Properties of the classes

Page 10: A piece of humble pie This map shows the state of the southern California desert about 10,000 years ago. The presence of these lakes is confirmed by oral

Modeling the TSI, part 1

Page 11: A piece of humble pie This map shows the state of the southern California desert about 10,000 years ago. The presence of these lakes is confirmed by oral

Modeling the TSI part 2

Page 12: A piece of humble pie This map shows the state of the southern California desert about 10,000 years ago. The presence of these lakes is confirmed by oral

Modeling the TSI part 3

Page 13: A piece of humble pie This map shows the state of the southern California desert about 10,000 years ago. The presence of these lakes is confirmed by oral

Simulation of a TSI image

Page 14: A piece of humble pie This map shows the state of the southern California desert about 10,000 years ago. The presence of these lakes is confirmed by oral

Comparison between an SBI image and a TSI simulation

Page 15: A piece of humble pie This map shows the state of the southern California desert about 10,000 years ago. The presence of these lakes is confirmed by oral

Quiet Groups Q0 and Q1

Page 16: A piece of humble pie This map shows the state of the southern California desert about 10,000 years ago. The presence of these lakes is confirmed by oral

Groups Network, Plage 0, Plage 1

Page 17: A piece of humble pie This map shows the state of the southern California desert about 10,000 years ago. The presence of these lakes is confirmed by oral

Time trends of the groups

Page 18: A piece of humble pie This map shows the state of the southern California desert about 10,000 years ago. The presence of these lakes is confirmed by oral

Log of the fractional areas

Page 19: A piece of humble pie This map shows the state of the southern California desert about 10,000 years ago. The presence of these lakes is confirmed by oral

Final Scatter DiagramThe final cross correlation reaches 0.97. The Virgo data has been detrended for the drift from the previous time of solar minimum to the present condition.

The comparison has also been smoothed with a three-point wide Gaussian.

Points at the beginning of the series are brown while those at the end are green.