ˇ− , , ,..."# ˜ ! ˚ ˛ ˙˝ , ˇ− , , , editorial board א (division editor) ˇˆ ˙˝˛˚ ˜...
TRANSCRIPT
-
�� ,����� ����� �� ����, � ��,� � ��−��, � �������������� !�"#
�
-
$%&��'( )�#�*��+�� )��, : .../��01� 2 �%3�0%� �4�� :56%789��
-
�� ,����� ����� �� ����, � ��,� � ��−��, � �������������� !�"#
�
� �
��א������������ Editorial Board
���� ����� ��� � �� �������� ���� ������ �������� � �� ���� ��!"�� #$����� ������ ���� %&'� ()���� ��
����)!�� ��� � ��*+ �� ��,�� -� � .�/ �� �-� #)�0���� ��)�� � � ��12��3�
Prof. Mohammed Aljarrah (Division Editor)
Prof. Ahmed A. Almohaimeed
Prof. Abdelmohsen A. Nassani
Prof. Mohamed Abdel Mawla Osman
Dr. Fuad Abdullah Alawwad
Dr. Yahya Ali Al Jabr
Elwaleed Abdulqayoum Ali (Secretary)
�� Advisory Board א���א��������א��
%&�4 5��6 ���� �%:���;� )0��� ,�?�:%@ ����* University of Chicago, USA
Prof. James J. Heckman
1�3 7�8 ���� �%��A4( , B��C� ����* University of Melbourne, Australia Prof. Nasser Spear
-� 9��� ���� �%:���;� )0���, �%3�DE8' �3��03� ����* Indiana University of Pennsylvania, USA Prof. Abbas Ali
5��2 �:�� ���� �%3��D%��F ����*− �%:���;� )0��� , GFHC' University of California, Berkeley, USA Prof. David J. Teece
��;�� 1�3 ���� I%' ����* − ,J����%3 �%:���;� )0��� Pace University, New York, USA Prof. Samir El-Gazzar
� �� ���� /�E3�F ����*− �%:���;� )0��� , I3���� University of Kansas at Lawrence, USA Prof. Mohamed El-Hodiri
?�6– @ )3 �%:���;� )0��� , K0%��L ����* University of Toledo, USA Prof. Jeen-Su Lim
-
$%&��'( )�#�*��+�� )��, : .../��01� 2 �%3�0%� �4�� :56%789��
S
-
�� ,����� ����� �� ����, � ��,� � ��−��, � �������������� !�"#
T
-
$%&��'( )�#�*��+�� )��, : .../��01� 2 �%3�0%� �4�� :56%789��
�
-
�� ,����� ����� �� ����, � ��,� � ��−��, � �������������� !�"#
!
-
$%&��'( )�#�*��+�� )��, : .../��01� 2 �%3�0%� �4�� :56%789��
�
��4 U1� ����* �� ,��! ,����� ����� �� � � ,��−��� � � ,�%'����'� −�� � ������ ,��V%W3�'����������# �
��א����� �
-./0
F�!�� ��0��
�%3�0%� �4�� :X4KY�6� 5D%Z��� �[��� \] )�%N� 5^_`;� 0�C�� �a(
%&�G��� � �� H�IJ�� K LM���� 9K�M �� ������������������������������������������������������� N
b*K c� ��4 U1� ����* 2 �%6%789�� �
-
�� ,����� ����� �� ����, � ��,� � ��−��, � �������������� !�"#
��
-
� �� ,���� ���� ��� ����� � ,�,� � ������������������
������� ��� :������� ������� ����� �� ������ ���� � �!"�� �#$١
%&��'�� (� �"� )�*+,� ������ -��� �.$
�� ! "#$%�& �%� '( ��)�* ,+,-�� .*�/� ,01(2 �3 �,�4 ,����� �� 5$6 ,�����
����� ,
�7 8�& ����%
,����� �� 5$6 ,����� �� 9�#7: ,;(�$& .*�/� ,01(2 �3 �,�4
����% ����� ,
�7 8�&
! ����� !
-
� �� ,���� ���� ��� ����� � ,�,� � ������������������
����� K�,� O1X=� ! e��� e�@ ���� O�,G� u��a
Q�@ A#� O�,G� O�,4�$U �6H�� O9 �ZY& uJj �,G� O�,6HI: A� _q*�/� �@�=a leadership ethics
O�,6 s@� �L�� �%�*
%@ pGa A#� O�,4�$U ]#Z#a ,���W}U �1#�k@ ,�YW;�: g,Gy n3 O1X=&
Ga �,6HI: 5 "$�@ ,5Y-1#J@ ,5Y-k@ _1D �#��U@ ,5��=�� ]W�@
K�=� LJ A&��� S#$& '�W, EZ#Y& Q� ;�;�� S�J
e�,6� �q4: ?Z( "���& O1X=& ��\a �@U E7�;�@, �Wa�P�B4@ ,01(2 O�,6HI: EU _s#� ,5��4� ���� O�,4�$� ��r �,6
%@ 5# 8�9@ ,�:,�
/a�� �ZX=& f;�: g,Gy@ �\a _2 ;��s[�a@ ,�,6HI2 �,G� �72�U@ ,�ZX=& ;-�G� � ��;� A#� �G��\��U
HI2 O�,4�$��U ,�y u�\#� 8�9@ ,7�1� N� �,6 �� �/� ]� O�,4�$� 8�a ��$J ]� ,"/4 ?`tU ]Z#&@ ,EBC& Q� ?4 '( �Y-�#J gGL##� ;�Z,�$� 5,G� ?�L#U e�/��\� ;-�G� /w� �G��\� MN@ KhL& A%��I �7 n3 M"`Ba@ ,J;%@ ! �,�I;� �,6HI2
I@ ,Q�;U�(� �,6HI2 �/&�U �[#�� ,_@�����K�� ?I �G�� �,6HI2 O�,4�$��U �1#�k ;�[a ]�@
"I2 �J@ ! O1X=&, Eq*�/� EU OkF�$#� O;�a MN� �@ 0* ?Z�� O�,6HI: 0�� ! Ew#i&@
�T:@ O�,4�$��� ?Z�� O�,4�7 ?,�Ba@ �,Z=a !,?Z��
% E$y �} Q� A#� ,�,6HI2 ,�,%�#J�@
�L): �GT [�[�a ]� ,�\,L& � ,/� ! �ZX=Z�� ��@p�@ ,��
-
:A��,� @;� ;®: @ _1,�$� ¯;/( 0�Y#U AB,C� �D�� '( �,G�� A6HI2 ;�/� �T:E7@F�Z��KKK
O���k@ O�G#JH� ���#a �Y��% N� ��2 ,S�I: �7�1ZU �B�#i& �H(� ?-�7@@ E=V& ?|/°6 Q� P�\I2 ±�U
%� e�XJ ;�,6HI2 " O�,4�$�
" O�7�1&@2 O�$7§& ! EBC& ±�/� �,6HI ],^ _}U e�(�/\J pa A#� ,O��#$& ¢�#² '( ����� '( �,/�7 �-�#J n3 §� N� ��2 ,8�9 ! P7 EBC& ; °GB ª� �R ,O��;d Q� E�B#=& E=V&@ ,����� ��
/U 5Y#GT EBC& ;GB ª�@ , ���U �Gq� QV& 5Y¨�� ë �U ,�ZX=Z�� P1#Jk@ Pk� '( e�,/�7 �T§�@K �YXa 8�9 Q�@
�,wit� �,�@§$& �HI Q� Z=a ?Z( O� ,U �¥3 �,m: O�,4�$U E��� P�7F�� hy g��V Q( EBC& S;� 5��D�@ ,5Y-: ! EBC& '( ���@;U +`�=a �,6HI:
�,G� ��Y� QZW ,?Z�� Q( BJ ! ³HI2 � @;G� ��;I@ ,�p*k '( �Z-�G� ,�J@��#& @�� �¥U EBC&
,A��� ����� ��w&����K�� �,6HI2 �,G� "T}a n3 O�7�;� ±�U O��: ;G�
01(2 O1X=� ! �B�#² uJ% '( ¤�¥�,
4,EBC& �[#� S#$�@ ,?Z�� O�6H( Q� ;©@ ,�Gq�@
,�\,L& � ,/� ! �ZX=& ��Z7 E$y@ ,� ,$� O�,4�$� �Y#,U9�%@ �Y*�J@(Mayer et al, 2010 ; Frisch and
Huppenbauer, 2014) ´;a ;�U "I2 OP�% .,* O�4
-
�� ,���� ���� ��� ����� � ,�,� �−�, � ������������������
�A6HI2 uJ�j �@ k: �,G� uJ%, ! #7��R �,m:@
hZ�� ]6� :h� �� 0HI Q� � − ��U2 ��$62 P�7F�@ Q���;& �7��R S;� '( f��#�
�,6HI2 �,G� c�d�U [�[�� ;/( QU ��\7 "�2 ����% !K �− ����% ! E��� E7@F�& S;� �D�� �%� �,6
Kc�d�U [�[�� ;/( QU ��\7 "�2 − O�6H�� ��,/V �7� �D��@ �,6HI2 �,G� ��U: EU
Kc�d�U [�[�� ;/( QU ��\7 "�2 ����% ! AB,C� �− �7��R �T: �,6 �,G� ��U2 ��$62 P�7F�@ Q���;&
����% ! E7@F�Z�� AB,C� �D�� '( �,6HI2Kc�d�U [�[�� ;/( QU ��\7 "�2
>− O�*pG&@ O�,)#� ±�U 5�;Ga �-�#J '( eP�=UK�,J;,& �7�;�
������ ��?$ :@�!,� : Q`Z� A#� O���Y7� 0HI Q� �7�;� �,m: sa _
:�#� L=� '( �,G,/\#�@ �,Z��42 �,*�=� Q� �Y�;Ga - ! �)�I@ ,�,U��� �/#`&�U �,qL/� B� ;7 ! �m�$&
O�Y%#� ! ;�[#� .,* ,�,6HI2 �,G� �D� g,/\a@ �,W�Bt�@ �#BJk�U �=a A#� �¹� �q�;©
3� ;�[a �@º@ ,E`Z#� O�,,ap7 f�V: EU �Gq �,G� O�,4�7 A� �Gq� 8�a ��w� ;*:@ ,�ZX=&
K�,6HI2 - Q� P2 E$L#� �Z-H� ?Z( � ,U "Wa '( ;(�$&
Q� ;�[a A#� �,6HI2 �,G� O�,4�7 �7� 0HI EU �6H�� ��,/V �W���@ ,E����� S;� AB,C� �D��
O�,4�$� MN�, �D�� ��s@ KAB,C� - O�,4�7 ��t#J �;( Q( �#=a A#� �,/�$� ��T ?,�Ga
,* 0�� ! �)�I �,6HI2 �,G�5Y�@ 0�� �@KO����j
������ A�BC�� �DE� :9�'��� : − :����� � ������
�,G�� ¢���a �¥3 EB�§&@ Eq*�/� ±�U 0@�* ;G�
� �YW��W �,6HI2Shaw �}U � ,%a@ �W2 5,X=a �,�Z( "���&@ ;(G� ]� gW#� �7}U �,�,/\� �& �W»� � V�d@ �L,Lw� O�,4�$� E/�@ ,�,�Z#&
,
Z������ 0@�* E* ! K��Burns ¢���a ]D@ �� ?��, U �YW z��W �} �,6HI: O��� '( �,=/� �6H( �¥3
�@ ;-�G� EU ; ,5 �)�d O�%�© �(�� ]� ,E���� ,´@��a A(�^ ?Z( s�J3 f; ,5YZ,6@ 5�*ZV@ ,O�,6HI2 Q� ��;G#� O��#$� n3 O�7�1&�U A6��@
,�,$/©� �,�W;�@���� ;GW �,6HI2 �,G� [4�� ��: K�� :�}U �YW�(" ! #(�@ ,�,7�72 Z,G� ;-�G� �W���
@ ¼,������� �L�wZ�� ��;I a�,* uJ% ?4 ! � e�GW" ,¤�©� ���>:�>½>� �YW z�( "I:@ K�Brown et al,
2005 hZ�� g,/\#�@ ,u7�=& ��,�& �$� ��YC3 �}U � S;� �$� N� ��@�a@ ,�,wit� O�6H�� 0HI Q� 9�¾ �,�Z(@ �$� [�[�a@ 0�wak 0HI Q� ��/a2
KO��G� QZ¨#a �,6HI2 �,G� _: �GU�$� O�B���#� Q� E/#�
�$,-� �=( �THT, 5T ,u7�=& A6HI2 �$� �Wa �@: :³�V HqU � ��@p� 8�9 ;�U@ ,�ZX=& ! e�,�Z( #7��R
,Q$*@ ¿������:� �− ,�,6HI: �G��\U �ZX=& �W: ]� �)a@ ;-�G� 0�wa
� ]�K5YZ,6 5�Ga ! 5;(�$ �− ?`tU (�/a: ]� ;-�G� ?���#U A6HI2 �$� [�[�a
W�`�@ ,A6HI:} ,�=$© �,6HI2 O�,4�$� @N� a O�@;� "Wa ]� ,� ,$� O�,4�$� @N� #/6���@ ��\a@ ,�,6HI2 O�,4�$� ?,�B#U 5# A#� �,/��;#�
K�Z,6 �,6HI: O�J@;� − 9�¾ ��w& Q( ;,�/� ����� �,6HI2 O��G�
K�,wit� ,8�N�@ u$* e�,-�%3 �,6HI2 �,G� ¢���a Q`Z�
;& �7��R �}U �7�;�Q��� O�,�4 ! ��$62 P�7F�@ M� �/7�=& �,6HI2 O�,4�$�� c�d�U ��\7 "�2 ����%
0HI Q� O�,4�$� MN� ��@�a@ ,5Y(�/a: ,0��B� ?)#�KO��G� 9�¾ �,�Z(@ ,[�[�#�@
-
:A��,� @;� ;®: @ _1,�$� ¯;/( 0�Y#U AB,C� �D�� '( �,G�� A6HI2 ;�/� �T:E7@F�Z��KKK
>:����� � ������ F�"�
8�N4 +,� @: A6HI: J}U ?�W '( 5`© �J�: 93, W �,6HI2 �/& @: �,6HI2 O���X=� n3
�� Q� ;UH
,�w��@ O�W�Gq� ( �/& MN� ¢�#¾@ ,]Z#Z��,�J��� 8�9 ;4§�@������ ³HI:
%@ �;( S�� .,*
�W@��& O��Z#& ],^ _: S�� ?U�G& ! =`� ,�,G,G* �,&�( ,N`�� ��N/J ]� ,0;��@ ,��[=�@ ,³;w� Q( 'i#a k �� gB#�@ ,�B� 5�X�@ ,HI� �;(@ ,�J��2 �;(@
� Q� ?4Resick et al,2011�/� ��@ ?`� _: ! �- �Y A#� �,6HI2 o7 ! 5Y#7�@ 5YqLU ;�U@ ,�Y,�( "$a
,�,/�t� Ew� ���Y^ :! ?qZ#a �,&�( 0@@ ,bJ4 bJ�@ ,_��a@ , ;L#& O��k�@�,J�&:@ ,;=���3, ;�;L#�
�,G� 0* O�W�Gq� EU fH#Ik@ ��G#� Ok�� �,wit� �YXa .,* ,
%� ��G#� _: #/T: �,6HI2
& A� Q� E/,#$& ¢wJ Q( ?G� k �� :� u$* �=Z,Y ,³;w� :�,wit� QZ¨#a@ ,0@;� 8�a ! Q���;&
À+Á ¬}a ��;�U@ ,¬N� x�/¨Jk@ ,��[=�@ ,�J��2@ Q� ,��P�$& :! ?qZ#a S�I2 O�,4�$�@ O�Bw� ,%#� ]� ,��[,,Z#� �����& �;(@ ,f�wJ�@ ,�p*k@
]D@@ f~#�@ ,�,wit� ��w& '( �ZX=& �L�w�O��G� Q� ��;#7k �T: ! �X=�@ ,�,�@§$ZU, �W�D��U
�#BJk n3 ,�J@�&@, KP� ¢�#i& �1#7k@ � Q� ?4 S�� 8�N4Resick et al, 2006 �-�#J ! �
;-�G� ,�( _`� _: Av/=� �� ;�;y �Y,W @�: A#� 5Y#7�
2 O�W�Gq� ( �,6HI2 �,G�� ����W uJ% ��U�: A6HI
,�,wit� ! ?qZ#a �B�#i&@ ,��[=�@ [,BL#�@ ,��q��KA(1j
,,�(@ "/4 ;* n3 �LZ#a �,6HI2 �,G� �/� _W ,�p*k !@ ,+B=� '( 5���q�U Q��I ��;I@ ,��;��
@W K]Z#& P�=U@ ,³;w�� �7� �-�#J O��: ;GFrisch, Huppenbauer, 2014 [,r A#� O1$� s�U: Q� _: '( �
,��[=� :A6HI2 ;-�G�@ ,HI�@ , �;j@ ,³;w�@ ,��;��@�p*k@ ,�(�t�K o/a� �I uJ�% Q�@
�7�(Taylor, Strickland, 2002)
-
�� ,���� ���� ��� ����� � ,�,� �−�, � ������������������
½ O�,4�$� �G� �7��R S;� '( �7�;� MN� ~#Ga E*
o$U [,Z#a :h� 1,W ?qZ#a �,6HI: O17 �− :�����H0� ,?���#� ! �,J�$J� ���X� Q� �YX� #�a
O�(1j@ �W2 EU �Gq� ��s@ ,³G© ÂB* _1D@,¢,�I����� g-�G© ;-�G� ¢t4 A=�a@ ,��
���@� O����&@�ZY&@ ,EBCZ�� ?Z���U �G��#& ,�* P�z=/� Ä�G=� ?,�Ba ]� «5T Q�@ 5Y�,ta ],\#$�
,,W �Gq� ]� ,?Z�� ! �,�@§$&@ �V�i& ?Zy '(,5��4� �D���� _@@ 1LU a�Y,%a ��/a@
����K�:,� �G� � [,Z#� _: Av/=� A#� O1$� 5�: �,6;w& ;�a@
_,6HI2� A#7� �-�#=� e�G/VTaylor, Strickland, 2002);Frisch andHuppenbauer, 2014 ;*:@ ,�
! Q���;& Q� ;( �Y,�( ]^: A#� �,6HI2 O�Bw��,7, �,�1t� �`���:@, � �,U�v� �U@�@:@Resick et al,
2011K� �− :���� � u%� P: '( �© A=�a ;-�G�� �/$=��U
! eH��4 "$� ! M;Y% ;B=#$� _:@ ,U x�=� N� ?Z�� O�/�\#& e�w�² _`� _:@ ,Q`Z& 01`� n3 �Z�U
Am� d '( #XW� ]� ,M�@ O��6a@ N��pBª� ?v#$� k:@ ,Q��I ]� #6H( ! M;�#� k:
M"v� @: � �,wi ��B=� '( 0w© ! �6�,¢,�I������� ,#�a@ O�Bw� ;*: �J��2
! Q���;& Q� �(Z� �Y,�( ]^: A#� �#$� �,6HI2 �7� ! �,U�v� �U@�@:@ ,�,�1t� �`���:@ ,�,7
�Resick et al, 2011 K� − :����!�� #����� ! M[,,r @: ;-�G� [,y �;( A=�a
,5��4� EBCZ������ O�,4�$� Q� ;�a 8�NU@ ,�:,2 �ZY&;-�6 ?`� �,7�7, �LZ4 �Y�D@ u�\#a .,*
Q� �s��� ��;( ;6@ KO��G�@ OH���#� ! Å�7: ,¢,�I� ?-�¨B������ ��#( 14 K�Frisch and
Huppenbauer, 2014 ;-�G� [,r A#� O1$� s�U: Q� � �,6HI2 -�wd 5�: �}U �h,U� �YB)@@ ,A6HI2
E������ �,7�72 Å�72 :;/& �:@ ,����� ��;d ! ,�U4� S�I2 �/& ³B� N�����K� ]^: ;6@
�7� ! _TL/& �Resick et al, 2011 �Y#,m: '( �K��W�GT fH#I '( O��Z#& Q� "q4 !
@ ,������ ��;�� Q� �J: �THT EU _q*�/� [«,� ;G�,A/��v����µ: �
:− :��J��KE� ����!�� ��,) D@ �%� A=�a@;(6@ ?Z�� O�7�,7M ,�YG,/\a ���,*@ ��G#7@ ,
zg/\ ª� }\d U�`a� ;=( ?���� '( zg/\� N� P[j�WK�G��\� +B=U ��;& '(
L− :��!NO�+�� ����!�� �& ]�sa S;� A=�a@w,w¾@�Y�� u/$U [,,r _@ ,O�%�i&@ , @: ,�Z
KO��Y&@ P�B`� O@�$a 0�* ! �,�G� @: ,+=j P− :������+�� ����!�� ,���`U ],Zj ������ S;� A=�a@
,�p*�U EBC& ������ ! ?qZ#a@ ,�p*@ ,��[J@@ ,EW�\� EU ���/#& �Gq�@ ,0�wak@ �© ! ��;��
C�@ �G� EU �G=�@ P� NI:@ ,5Y,B8�N�@ ;�� O�,4�$� s[�a A#� ��;�� �J: 5�: Q� .��q� �=�
,5��4� ?Z�� ! �,6HI2����K�:,� �− :�>NE� ! Q��I�U P�=#(k '( 5-�G� �$� �
�ZX=&, : ]6a _@ 5YB-�C@ P: '( 5;(�$�@,5��4� 8�9 '( }W�`� @: @������ ,�:, Æ;��@ Q�
: �H7� �;) ! �� �Y#W�( A#� ���,G� O1$� 5� Q( ,I2 _�$J� ;(�$�@ ,´�B#& ?Z�� n3 (;� YW
J} Q� N� ��2 ,��=#6@ �D� _: �G� Upa ,_@�I@ ,�Z=�� ¢�Ç#a@���½ �1#�k ;�� 8�N4K�
]D@ QZ¨#� .,* �,6HI2 �,G� �7: Q��I�U�,��W� � ,U ! 8�N4@ ,\d ! �;w� ]D� ��/a2
,?Z�� :� '( 5Y,BC& Q���;& u��;a ! ?Z�� ,�=V& O�,4�7@ ,g��B� P�=U@ E`Z#� O�,4�7@ f~#�@ ,5Y©�wZU a k A#� O��G� 9�¾ ]�
,�,$/©� ],Z�� ]B=� gGy �G��\U����,� o#/T: ;6@¯;/(� �7� ,+J�@ ,���� ��q�� _: � Æ;�� 5�: Q�
-
:A��,� @;� ;®: @ _1,�$� ¯;/( 0�Y#U AB,C� �D�� '( �,G�� A6HI2 ;�/� �T:E7@F�Z��KKK
µ �L& ?`t� �@ ,EBC& ¿�a A#� �,G� O�B)
K �,G�� +,-�� A6HI2 >− :�.����®��@ gW���U ¢w#� ;-�G� _�4 93, 8�9 _W
]� 5�6H( ! gW���U _Bw#� .,* ,,�U�a '( +`�=� 5Y¨�U� ë �U ?4�t& �j��� ! 8�N4@ ,5YY%a A#� ,¢,�I����� �7� �,G� ! �®�� uJ% Q�@ K�
! }\I @: ,�ZY� P: ! ?tB� ;=( 5[*: ! Q��I ¿�v#� 8�N4@ ,uw=� Q� 0[( @: ,E�� ��6 9�¾ ! E7@F�& ?/6 Q�
wG& " P�\I2 ±�U Q(
,5��4� ?Z������K�:, ½− :Q�R/:� ;-�G�� �p*k :;/� �,m: Eq*�/� ±�U ;4:
:;-�G� Q� �p*k A=��@ ,EBC& ]� ����a ;=( ,EBC& n3 �1#��U O�wJ�@ ,5Y�� ¢V��#�
@ ,M�XJ �Y%@ ]� �D���#& 5��XJ O�Y%@ ]� ��$#� ,5���@ ,5;G#�� s[�a ³�\U 5Y�� ?���#�@
K5YZ,6@@Q� ;© QZ¨#� ?G)@ ,[,L#�@ �U�L& ]� A(D� ?`tU ?���#�@ ,�,wit� O��Y& '( �Ga ?Z( O�6H( 5(@ P�=U ]� ,���B� ³@�B�
�p*k, f;�: g,GL#� ?-�74 5Y�� ?���#� �;(@ ,�,$/©� ;-�G� O���@���� �7� o#/T: ;6@ K��
�Frisch andHuppenbauer, 2014 �p*k _: � Æ;�� Q� n3 �W�D��U A6HI2 ;-�G� [,r A#� O�,4�$� s�U:
KS�I2 O�,4�$� Q� �(Z�
����� � ������ ��&0 ��,�SE� �#T� À��T �,6HI2 �,G�� P: S#$ZU AGa�a ;6 �,U�¥3
�,G� �Ga N� A(1#%k 0�/#� 0HI Q� ��/a2 ,�,�B#U �,6HI2 �=$© OH���& 0HI Q� 8�9 _`�@
�Gq� 0�/a@ ,����/#(k@ ,��/a2 ]�K ��`W2 MN� ],^@ _@;Y�#� ��/a2 ?�¥ �R ¢V�� 0�/#� 0�& ,#a
¤�¥� �$� �7�1ZU, ±��=& �$� �7��R Q� ;©@�ZX=& S#$� '( ��: ,�ZX=& f;�2, �,G� �7��R _W
,ÈB=� Q�2�U ��t� Q� '(: S#$ZU �\/a�� �,6HI2 0F�B#�@ ,�Gq�@ ,�ZX=& ³�q,ZU AG,G© �[#�k Q( eH¨W
,�¨����� AZX=&����K�� �,G�� ¤�¥� "T}#� O�7�;� ±�U O;4: ;6@
£J '( �,6HI2 ;�#�, ,
Z� �,Z,X=#� �Gq��4 ����
%@ ,�� �[#�k S#$�@ ,P�W�@ ,?Z�� O�6H(
,�=$© ��Z$� �ZX=& �$43 ]� ,�ZX=& ! E������� ?�\� S;& '( �& �=�@ ,�,U9�j@ ,�Gq�@Frisch
andHuppenbauer, 2014 e�@ �,6HI2 �,G� u��a 14 ,�
�7 P7 S#$� Q� ;©@ ,A6HI: ¦�=� g�I ! e17�*
� EBC&Mayer et al, 2010 K� $ − ������� �����
;& �1#� O��T: A#� ],D& Q� AB,C� �D�� ;� ª�Q��� V�/a�k �,J�$J� O�7�;�@ ���� ¢�#² ! Eq*�/�@
N�
-
�� ,���� ���� ��� ����� � ,�,� �−�, � ������������������
���t� N� +`�=� ?U�G& !@ ,��/�\#�@ �,© Q(, N�@
,�,%�#J� ��Ba� :.,* Q� ]B=��U �ZX=& '( P2@ ±,B¾ z?4@ ,�ZX=Z�� Pk� S#$� ��Ba� ]� ,c�#J� ¢,��`a ��Ba� �) ! �¥��U ,L& ]Z#& '(
�� 8�9 ���w#6k �,���B�� g,Gy@ ,Z=�@ c�#J� Ok;�&
,¼�@�����K�� �;� Q� ;�;�� O;4: ;6@ �D�� �7� �,m: O�7
S;� �,%�#J�@ �,�W;� S#$ZU V�/a�@ AB,C�,��$�� �7� O��: .,* ,EBC&���� z_: n3 �M
9 AB,C� �D�� �7�@ �¹� �/$=��U "/4 �,m:, Q�W ;�#& 5���@ �W2 �(�t� '( �� f��#a G��V
,�Z�� uJ% ¢�#² LJ ,���� � «5T Q�@ '( f��#a�wG� uJ%, 5�( '( /wa@ ,�Y,WHa 0@�y@
?B`a A#� �/7�=& 0�© ]¨#� E����� 5 A#� OH`t&�U�7� �-�#J ;4§a 14 ,�,%�#J� ��s@ �;G#� �ZX=Z��
,�Yt������ �D�� S#$� EU ���V �6H(
%@ �� S#$�@ AB,C� Os AB,C� �D�� s 1�`W �,%�#J�
KAB,C� �D�� s �,%�#J� Os 1�4@ ,�,%�#J�
:������� ����� U ��#V0� W���!�� �D�� �%� ! �T§a ;6 A#� ?��� Q� ;( �=� Q( �#=� _: Q`Z& Q� S�I: ?�(@ ,E7@F�Z�� AB,C�
;� �D�� �;�J ���* ��
%@ �;( _q*�/� �YB=) ;6@ K5É �Y=ZW :�$,-� O� W HT n3�� $BJ �B��U g��#�, �� �Y=�@
�B,C��U g��#�, �7�;� MN� !@ K�ZX=&�U g��#� �� �Y=�@7 �,G� O�,4�7 '( [,4p� 5#,, 1,7k@ A6HI2 ;�/�
'( ;,j fÊ� _: _q*�/� �pB� .,* K�Y=�$*@ ,E7@F�& ! �T§& �ZY& ?��� Q� ,5Y#����� Q
Q�`a 0HI Q� 8�9 gGL#�@ ,E7@F�Z�� AB,C� �D�� EU _@��#�@ ,�p*k@ ,�Gq� Q� % g�I@ ,�/,V O�6H(
,�����& ! ��;�� n3 �W�D��U ,,7@F��@ +,-��@ .U ,E����� EU g��B� @�@ ,%#�@ ���(���U 5�;Y�a
�$� ,5,@ ,5Y=,U ���B� ³@�B� fH#I �(��@ 5Y(HV
,M��Z#7@ �;G#� N� 5( ?-�7@@ ,5Y�;Ga S;� '( ,u,\�� =,* ! ��;G#� Q� 5YG* 5Y-�\(3@����K��
��,�'�� 1������ :9����
Q� AB,C� �D��@ �,6HI2 �,G� �D� z;� ª��� �� ?G* ! �ZY& ],D& ±�U O�YC ;6@ ,���
.L/a _: o�@�* A#� O�7�;� ! �,*�J Q� E/J�j Q�N�1Y¨�/U 1Y#6H(@ ,�,m2@ ,�YB&, ���� ],D&�U@
N� ,S�I25#Y,7 P[j N�U O�7�;� ±�U ���#7�K�7�;� �DZU �6H�� O9 �GU�$�
$ − :����� � ������ X� ��,�� 1��� oJ��6 � �7�Hoch, Bommer, Dulebohn and Wu,
2018 �,G�� �,U�¥k �,G� Q� ;�;% 0�`: �THT EU � ,��,)2@�,6HI2, �$� '( ;ta A#� ��,�;d@
�,��L#� �,G� ]� A6HI2, ;( ]� 5Y#6H( ! 8�9@ eP�=/W K�ZX=&�U �6H�� O9 +,��G& Q� "/4 Q� ��$�7 '(
,�6H�� O9 O�,U2 ! O�7�;� �,�,Z#� OH,�L#� �,G� Q� ?4 EU �,��( O�6H( OH,�L#� 8�a oLD@:
�,6HI2 �,G�@ ��,)2, ,�(@ ,�,��L#� �,G� EU@ �;i#7 5#� Ë �� M;* '( 5Y=� ?4 �;i#7 ��B=� ��BiJ
=a �-�#J � $� 5Y=� ?4 �,�;d �,G� ��: K ; �,Z,X Eq*�/� ;(�$� '( e��6 e;(@ e���,6 e�Y=� oLD@: ;GW
K�,Z,X=#� �-�#=� Q� ]7@ ;�� ?¨W: Ê '( E7�1&@ � A-�\� �� z;(: �7� !@���µ �,6HI2 �,G� 0* ��
�$B� O��Nv� Q� ;L�� �,Z,X=#� ��[=� ! ���@@
� fÊ2 ¢=� �XW� �-@ Q� �=,( '( g,/\#��U �
� Q� �J`�µ� �;i#7�U@ ,�ZY� �-@ HT ! e�BC� � O"v#& EU �,U�¥3 �T: �6H(
%@ �-�#=� O�YC: �J�/#7k �$B�@ ,�,Z,X=#� ��[=�@ ,�,6HI2 �,G� :�THq�
8�9 '( eP�=U@ ,�a@�B#� u$=U �� ;�;�� .*�/� � z;6 ��[=� g,Gy ! �,6HI2 �,G� �,m: [�[�#� O�,)#� Q� '( P�¨G�@ �� �$B� P
-
:A��,� @;� ;®: @ _1,�$� ¯;/( 0�Y#U AB,C� �D�� '( �,G�� A6HI2 ;�/� �T:E7@F�Z��KKK
�� _q*�/� ��6Wang, Chiang, Chou and Cheng,
20176HI2 �,G�� �,4�$� %@2 Q( P�wG#7k�U � ! �, ABW K�,6HI2 �,G�� A=,w� �,G& @�V@ �,=,w� � ,/� ,�,6HI2 �,G� ��,/V Q( ÌG#��U ��6 �,B,`� �7�;� :O��G� �#7 Q� _ z`& �,G& ��\a 5a �Y-�#J '( eP�=U@
,�,6HI2 �(�t�@ ,;G=� LJ �#BJk@ ,�$B� �;(@ ,�,6T&@��;�� @;G�@ ,role modeling �7�;� !@ K
�,6HI2 �,G� �,G� ]D@ ;�U �-�#=� oLD@: �,G,/\#� �,=,w� �,6HI2 �,G�� �#$� ��U2 _: /¨� oy �,U�v�
E7@F�&�U �G��#� �-�#J ;�U }/=#a, ����G#U ]W�� �Y=ZD Q�@ ÍV�d ?Z�� Q(wrongdoing ,@��#� uV�i#� ´@
cooperative voice ,@ ,�ZX=& �� ���®@ A© "Z¨�conscientiousness ,@�i2 EU 5�=#�interpersonal
harmonyK��Y& P:@ , � _q*�/� �;i#7Bedi, Alpaslan and Green,
2016A(1#%k 5��#� A#��XJ �, A(1#%k 0�/#�@ �,G� EU �6H�� ��/#Ik�,6HI2, ?Z�� O�%�² EU@
�6H(
%@ n3 �-�#=� O��: ;6@ K5Y#7� ! E�U�#���,6HI2 �,G� EU �,U�¥3, O�%�² Q� "/4 ;( EU@
E�U�#�� ?Z��, ;-�G�� �,�(�B#� ��;�� �3 ?q�, �$�@ U�t#� Q( _q*�/� ÎG#7 14 ,E�U�#�� A6HI2
fH#Ik@ �,6HI2 �,G� EU, �,G� ¤�7: EU@ �,6HI2 �,G� _: 8�9 Q( �#J@ ,�,-�%�@ �,��L#�
�,��L#� �,G��U e�,U�¥3 �\/a�� ,AB6& [,BL#� ;�ªU ]�@ contingent reward dimension K�,-�%� �,G��
¤�© O z;(: ����> '( f��#� n3 oW;� �7� �%� �,G�� S�G� �: ����U +��;#� � ,� ¨( �7��R �
,����j �/�V �XJ �Y%@ Q� �$Zd ����U}U �,6HI2 oJ�4 93 �� ;)�� oW;� 14 ,5Y,W �7�1& MN� "T}a �%�@ Q� _�4@ K�6H�� MN� �,(J@ ,1Y=,U �,V�/a� �6H( �=�
;#� � ,� ¨( �7��R OP�% _: �-�#=� s�U: �,G�� +�� P�%@ ,����U: �W�4 !@ �Y�Z( ! �\7#� �%�;U �,6HI2 ¤�¥3 x�/a�
%@ o/T@ ,e�\7#� �/�\� '( �7�1& "T}a PD ! �/�\� '( ��"T}a@ �,6HI2 �,G� �7��R EU
�@º ��,)a ! P�%@ K�,,ap7� ����j O�Y%a�1& �@;� 5�G#� �T§� �4 �,6HI2 �,G� O�7
� ����j O�Y%a ! ]V�6 ?`tU@K�,,ap7 � Q� ?4 ��6Frisch, Huppenbauer, 2014 �7�;U �
0HI Q� O�4½ �-�#=� oBt4 �J�/#7k �;i#7�U@ ,�Z���@ e1��� �
5,G�@ �,6HI2 �,G�� �,�`� �%�;� ! ��Ba� Q( �,-�w*3 ��k O9 ³@�W
%@@ ,�7�;� ]Z#& �,Z,X=#�
%� ! O�U�Q( z"v#& S[�ªa �,6HI2 �,G� �7��R �%�
�,-�w*3 ��k O9 �6H(
%@ n3 �W�D��U ,GW d
-
�� ,���� ���� ��� ����� � ,�,� �−�, � ������������������
�� 5YZ,6@ �,6HI2 �,G�� Q���;& �7��R �%� EU �/%�
K�,Z,X=#� � 5��4 S�%:���� �6H�� �W��� n3 oW;� �7� �:,�
;�@ �,6HI2 �,G� O�,4�7 EU �Z4* �/� g,/\a S ]Z#� e; , ;*� f~ZU ��qR �,/,�� �m�$& O�$7§& ]6� f~Z�� ����� �� ! E����� Q���;&�U �7�;�
� 5�;( b��/�@ s�v=U �=�;ZU�> �Y=( �#J ;6@ Ke��;� � S;� �,6HI2 O�,4�$��U �[#�k ! ¢�D f�t#4
��� O�,G� ! �Z4© �/� g,/\a �%� _: 14 K�,��� � f~& Æ;�� n3 �W�D��U ,7#& S#$& QZD �� ;* n3
�,G� O�,4�7 EU �,-�w*3 ��k O9 �6H(
%@ �;( ³G* '( �XW�L&@ ����� �����& :;/� Q� ?4@ �,6HI2
�L): ³G* '( �XW�L& :;/�@ ,5Y72 ��® ,��w& �,G� O�,4�7 EU �,-�w*3 ��k O9 �6H(
%@ ]� O�,� $�@ O�,*H) ,Da :;/� Q� ?4@ �,6HI2 �[#�k :;/�@ ,��N,B=#� ��@ �� +�� P�¨(: �,� $&�U �[#�k :;/�@ ,�,W�Bt�@ �wW� O�/�\#ZU
�;� o)@: �-�#=� '( eP�=U@ K�,(1#%k .* �@U �7 A=Y& �$� �/� �(��@ �p* '( �� $& O�Yj
K?Z�� ! A6HI2@ � _@�I@ ,Q�;U�( ���%: �7� !@���� n3 oW;� �
�,G�� 5É��;� �7��R �%�;� EZ��& O��;Ga �W��� ! �,�`© �;& AZ��� Q� �,-t( �=,( EU �,6HI2
�XW� �,G�� Q���;& �7��R _: n3 �-�#=� O��: K;G� _: 14 ,��Ba�� �%�;U OP�% _Z��& ���;G� 14 �,6HI2 O�U�#7 O�\7#� ! �,-�w*3 ��k O9 e�6@�W �=� ¶@: �R@ K�4N� ��w�@ ,5��& +=% u$LU EZ��&
,��#�@ �,Up� �s@ �1#� �@º :_q*�/� U [�[�#U 5 5YW �%� �7� ]� ,E,��© Q���;Z�� �,6HI2 �,G�
K��/�\#�@ �,6HI2 �,G� +72 Q���;& � AB�
-
:A��,� @;� ;®: @ _1,�$� ¯;/( 0�Y#U AB,C� �D�� '( �,G�� A6HI2 ;�/� �T:E7@F�Z��KKK
�� ,�,/�t� Ew� ���Y^ :�B�#² 0@ Q� O�,�^ o7 !
@ ,bJ4 bJ�@��a ,_@ , ;L#& O��k�3@ �,J�&:@ ,;=��� 0* O�W�Gq� EU fH#Ik@ ��G#� Ok�� ;�;y f; KO��Z#& MN� ( �,6HI2 "@ �,6HI2 �,G� O�B) ;�;L#� A(=� .L/� u,��7: �7�;� o�;i#7@ N� _�,/#7k �;i#7�U ,]Z#� ?4 ! Q���;& O�,4�7@
a or Q���;& Q� u°� ªV@ ,�7�;� ;,6 0@;� O�v�� #^� �,6HI2 �,G� ]� �Y\U�@ ,O�,4�$�@ O�Bw� ¢)@ ;6@ K�)�d 5Y#v�U@ ,5 �)�d O1�`��U �,6HI2 "@
� �#7��> o7 n3 �-�#=� o�)a@ ,Q���;& Q� �O��Z#& ! �=Z,Y� �,6HI2 �,G�� O�,4�7@ O�B)
,��P�$& :! o�qr@ ,�p*k@ ,f�wJ�@ 0;��@ O�/T3³;w�, �J��2@, ��[=�@, ¬N� x�/¨Jk@@ , 5a A#�
�ZX=& �L�w� ]D@@ ,%#� ,�,wit���U �Y=( "/�#� 14 K�#BJk@ �J@�& e"I:@ ,�,wit� �L�w& ³W
! o�qr �,6HI: " S�I: O�B) o7 n3 o�)a ��,G� ,�,aN� ��w&�U@ ,?,�¨#�@ �;d@ �,W�Bt� �;�J
,��P�$&@@ ,�,6HI2 �(�t� n3 ��G#Wk@ ,�D�¨B�@ "t� �� N�@ ,QZT }U �Z#$& U�� '( [,4p� n3 _:
"@ �,6HI2 ���,G� O�7�1& +7: !
%� ��G#� �7�;� o)@: ;6@ K�,6HI2 Q� O�,)#� Q� ;�U
�,6HI2 �,G� "T}a �7�;� L/� Q� ;�[& P�%3 :�Ym: " �,G� "T}a@ ,AZ,X=#� �$� uJ% ¢�#² !
KO�W�Gq� ( 5Y4�7@ EBC& [,By '( �,6HI2 � ��:Mayer et al, 2010 �7�;U ��6 ;GW � oW;�
� EU U��� �XJ ��V3 ]D� �7 P7@ �,6HI2 �,G ,1Y=,U �6H��� ,74 A6HI2 ¦�=& ?�% ]� ,EBC& ;�;L#U ��6@ ,O�,D�B� Q� �(Z� _q*�/� ]D@ ;6@
� ! �7�;� �=,(@ ]Z#��� ! �B�#² O1X=� Q� ;*@ � ;L#& O��k� ³Ê =% �U � z;G ªa �=,( NI: 5a@ ,
��Ò>�> eBC� ��
-
�� ,���� ���� ��� ����� � ,�,� �−�, � ������������������
��@ ,2@ ,�#BJk@ ,�,7�$©@ ! ]D#�@ ,�;U�
�Y,�a A#� ua�&Ku,ap� '( L− :������� ����� X� ��,�� 1���
� A�,/$� ��6���>� �s@ ABC� '( �,J;,� �7�;U oW;� .,* ,������U �H(�@ �W�Gq�#7� f��#� n3
�XJ �Y%@ Q� �s� ! AB,C� �D�� S#$� '( ,=� ;© ?-�7@@ ?Z�� _�@;� ��§& �/72@ ,ETL/&
@AB,C� �D�� S#$� EU x�/a�k �6H(, �/72@ Q� ;©@ ,?Z�� � ,U E$y ?-�7@@ ,?Z�� _�@;� ��§&
�7�;� Q( �#J@ K �s� ! ?Z�� _�@, �=,�� �W: _: ��§& �/72@ AB,C� �D�� '( 5Y#GW� ! _@;��
8�9 ?U�G� !@ ,?Z�� _�@;�, �;� o#/T: 5Y#GW� �7 �;( ]� ,?Z�� _�@ Q� ;© ?-�7@ '( e;% "/4 �%�;U AB,C� �D�� S#$� EU �,-�w*3 ��k O9 �6H(
%@ _�@ Q� ;© ?-�7@@ ,?Z�� _�@;� ��§& �/72@ P�7F�� ,%a :O�,)#� 5�: Q� _�4@ K �s� ! ?Z��
��/& @� P;U� �s� ! �=$© @;G� ?,qr@ ,?Z�� ! :� '( 5� Q& u��;a �W g�I ! ]7#�@ ,5Y,7@F�& ]� =�&@ �& [,BL#� �7�,7 ��/a ]� ,?Z�� U�;a �� g,/\a ! EU�;#Z�� ;(�$& 5�;Ga@ ,5Y,7@F��
,�(. � @�#�;j �7� ��:���� ,Da n3 oW;� ;GW ��
#� �,G� �T: AB,C� �D�� '( O����j P�7F�� �,��L �,J�2 O����j ! �,Z��42 ��$62 P�7F�@ P;Z��� �7��R S#$� '( f��#� 0HI Q� ,�)�d@ �,Z7�� AB,C� �D�� S#$�@ ,�,��L#� �,G�� O����j P�7F� ;6@ K5��XJ �Y%@ Q� �,Z��42 ��$62 P�7F�@ P;Z���
5a ]Z#� _ z`a@ ,O�J�,/� ]Zj }4 �J�/#7k '( 1#(k� Q� �7�;���>� e;,Z( � b�U@ ,AZ��4: 5$6 +,-�@� �=,�� 5*��� e;,Z( � AZ��4: 5$6 +,-�@ @"#Iª ,
7#� S#$� �Wa �7�;� Q( �#J@ K�,-t( �G��\U ,O����j P�7F� ?/6 Q� �,��L#� �,G� �7�1& S#$�@
,�,Z��42 ��$62 P�7F�@ P;Z��� AB,C� �D�� �Wa
AB,C� �D�� S#$ZU §/=#� '( �;6 ��U2 �q4: _: 14 Q�@ K� e�� �B� ��/#(k@ �q& "T}#� 5T ,�q& "T}#� � �G� ;(� ;���� P�tJ3 :�7�;� U o)@: �� 5�:
�7��R '( 5Y/��;a@ P�7F� .*@ ,�,��L#� �,G� �D� ?`ta A#� ?����U �1#�k ��s '( O����j
P;Z��, K�,Z��42 ��$62 P�7F�@ � _k[G� o��6 ;G����� EBC& '( �,G,/\a �7�;U �
�,U��� �`�Z&�U gV�=& _@§t� �,�I;� �s@ ���4@ ! oW;� ,��
�$� n3J2 '( f��#� ;-�$� ���,G� x1
,���� �`/t� ���X=� e�GW@ ���4� ! Q���;& S;� ,EBC& S;� AB,C� �D�� S#$� '( f��#�@ �D�� S#$�@ Q���;Z�� �,G� Z=� EU �6H��@ N� �,G� Z=� �Wa 8�9 Q( �#J@ KEBCZ�� AB,C�
� 7#ZU �,(1j ���U 5#ÉÒ��( �GW� ! O@�Ba ]� ,� 7#ZU AB,C� �D�� S#$� '( �=,�� �W:Ò> K�
���4� ! E������ AB,C� �D�� EU x�/a� �6H(
%@@ �6H�� oJ�4@ ,�,(1j ���U 5#É N� �,G� Z=�@
?��`#� g��B4 �,(1j ���U �1#�k s 1�`W K���V, s� O�@ ;G( �,m: :O�,)#� ! P�% ;6@ KAB,C� �D�
;&@ E������ �,/��;aQ��� �,G� 0�� ! �,=�2 [Y%2 ! ]� ,EBC& O�%�,#*�U �1#�k@ ,AB,C� �D��@ ��/a
?qZ#� N� AB,C� �D�� O��#$� ;�[� N� �,G� ZJ���U 5#É N� �,G� Z=� !�,(1j .
P− �����, ����� � ������ ���� X� ��,�� 1���
:�������
� �7� OP�% ;G�Jang and Oh, 2018 ,Da f; � Q� �Y4�3 5#� 14 �,6HI2 �,G�@ A6HI2 ¦�=& "T}a ;6@ ,�,U=j ���4 ! AB,C� �D�� '( O�D�Z& ?/6
� Q� �7�;� �=,( oJ`a�½ O�,Bt#$� ��U�: Q� �D�R � EU �,U�¥3 �6H( _�q*�/� ;%@ ;6@ ,�,U=j ���4 ! ���( KAB,C� �D�� EU@ �,6HI2 �,G�@ A6HI2 ¦�=&
�7�;� �-�#J '( eP�=U@, ¦�=& E$L#U _�q*�/� ¶@: ,?Z�� _�`� ! ��/G� �,6HI: "����
%@ ]� A6HI2
-
:A��,� @;� ;®: @ _1,�$� ¯;/( 0�Y#U AB,C� �D�� '( �,G�� A6HI2 ;�/� �T:E7@F�Z��KKK
�'( _:@ AG,G© �1#�k@ 5(;�@ �p*k O�D�Z& �6
1UJX*H� K�,6HI: " ��: Q� O�D�Z& � _�q*�/� p6Moon and Jung, 2018 1Y#7� ! �
! ���� u)�=& ! �,6��� O�,�62@ P�$=� �/$J ��s _:#� _: ¢,4 �7�;� 4: M�/#J n3 S: ����� O1X=& ?,qZ
�,G� �7: ?�@ EBC& O��� '( �T§� �� �D��@ �� ?,qZ#� O"v#� EU �6H�� 7#�
AB,C�? Q�"v#� "T}a �7�;U ���6 p6k N� '( eP�=U@ ,�� ?,qZ#� O"v#� Q�−A6��� ?,qZ#�@ +=j−
#$� AB,C� �D�� '( �,6HI2 �,G�@ Q� O�J�,U E�;i
%@ n3 �-�#=� O��: ;6@ K�,��;,B� ��`© ABC� �,G�@ �� ! A6��� ?,qZ#� Q� ?`� ¤�¥3 "T}a �,G� _: _�q*�/� ;%@ 14 KAB,C� �D�� '( �,6HI2 �� ?,qZ#� "v#� EU �6H�� 7#a �,6HI2
.,* ,AB,C� �D��@3 _ ]� e�,U�¥3 /a�� �� ?,qZ#�K�,���� �,6HI2 �,G� oy 4: ?`tU AB,C� �D��
� �7� Q� f; _�4Ren and Chadee, 2017 � � A6HI2 �$�� EBC& �3 "T}a �,B,4 Q� gGL#� ;6@ ,Ew� ! ?Z�� Q4��: ! AB,C� 5��D� '( 5�G�
�;� �=,( oJ�4� Q( ��/( �7�� eBC� �� eWp� ]$a !�,���B� _: �7�;� �-�#J oLD@: ;6@ KE`U ! O1X=�−
�,aN�self-efficacy 9@ ¤�¥3 ?`tU 7#a ��k
;6@ KAB,C� �D��@ �,6HI2 �,G� EU �6H�� �,-�w*3 57�U f@��& �,=,w� �,G� �7: _: n3 _�q*�/� �I
guanxi �,6HI2 �,G� ? ? e�@ u���, 8�NU@ '(@ AB,C� �D�� '( �,6HI2 �,G� O"T}a ±BÓ ]���t& ]� �J��G� E,=,w�� �4�Z& ]���t& ! I2
KuJ�%: H& � �7� o��6Tu, Lu and Yu, 2017 0HI Q� �
�U ,A(1#%k �� ���XJ O�J`� �;i#7 �6H�� ��/#IAB,C� �D��@ EW
-
�� ,���� ���� ��� ����� � ,�,� �−�, � ������������������
��� K�,Lw� ��;d�9 O�D�Z& �3 _�4 �O@ & S#$
� P�B`,��� 9@O@ � �D�� AB,C�¤�¥, 9@O@ � ��=& �q4: A6HI2 ¦�=Z�� �B,C� p� �¨Bi=3 �,U�¥
K�,-�w*3 ��k;U@ � h,G�� O�%:���� '( g,/\#��U �,J;,� �7� �
������U
�7 8�& ����% ! O���� O�BC&, oW;� �Y=� n3 �D���U ?Z�� O�,6HI: �6H( '( f��#� KAB,C�
����% ! O���� O�BC& Q� �7�;� ]Z#� _ z`a ;6@ ��;( �\,$U �,-t( �=,( ��,#I 5a@ ,������U
�7 8�&
�� �W: �GW� �%� ! O@�Ba
%@ �Y=( �#J ,�BC� � O�,6HI2�U O���� O�BC& �[#�� ;�ªU '( �7�;�
O@�B#�
%@ ]� ,��,B,C� Q( �D�� S#$� 0* e�¨�: ��k O9 ���V ��6 �6H(
%@ n3 �W�D��U ,�%2
�,B,C� ?Z�� O�,6HI: EU �,-�w*3, �D�� S#$�@ S;� �,B,C� ?Z�� O�,6HI: o=$y 1�`W KAB,C�
O�BC&, S;� �D�� S#$� E$y n3 8�9 S:p� :O�,)#� ! P�% �R@ KO�BC& '( O�� ! [,4
! �6�B#� �;(@ ,OÇW�`& =� ! @�$&@ ��;�� �(�� �wwi#& �,/��;#� O�@;� ¢,q`#U �1#�k ]� ,�����& ,?Z�� O�,�@§$�@ ��Y� ,Da@ ,�B,C� P�/(: ?ZL#� ?/6 Q� � �[#�k u%� ?Z�� O�,6HI2 ?,� ]D@@
KEBC& Q� Â*H� "v#� �,m: O�7�;�� gU�$� ����
O1X=& �3 ! .L/�, O�7�;� 8�a o�;i#7 .,* �=,( Q� �(=#� O�(�\6 '( oGz/ ªV@ ,�B�#² �,qLU ?I;� ! S�I:@ ,01(2 O1X=� ! o��%: �Y¨�/W ,�7�;� ;6@ ,�,L)@ ,�,=�: O1X=� ! ��"@ ,�,Z,��a O1X=�
;� 8�a '( u� �I;ZU AB)� �Y=& �;i#7 O�7� ,O����& ]Zj �,$,-� }4 _�,/#7k �;i#7@ , ;�#& ,%a ! O;(�7@ Eq*�/� ��F� O�7�;� Os[( ;6@
À�T: � _�4@ ,5,�$� ,%#� �7�;� ��$� À0��W : ;(3 !K.L/�
�,6HI2 �,G� O�7�;� ±�U o�@�=a, ; z4:@ �,m: O
O1X=& �J: ¢�#² ! �,6HI2 �,G� O�7��R o�@�=a 14 ,�Y=( �#=a A#� �,U�¥� ��T@ ,O�(�\G�@ �Y#6H�4 S�I2 �,Z,X=#� O"v#& ±�U EU@ �Y=,U �6H��
,
Z� �,Z,X=#� �Gq��U����,5��4� �Z4© ,�� ���� ,�:,�@ AB,C� �D��Celik, Dedeoglu and
Inanir, 2015 ; Tu, Lu and Yu, 2017) , �@ �7 P7� EBC&Mayer et al, 2010 �,Z,X=#� ��[=�@ ,�
,A-�\�����µ��K
%@ O�7�;� u�: O�YC: ;6@ �%� 0@�=a ;GW �I ±�/� ��: ,�Y=,U �,U�¥3 �,V�/a� �6H(
¤�©� O�7�;4 �B�#² O1X=� ! �Y#7��R,���> ; �,_@�I@ ,Q�;U�(���� ,�¨���� ; ����� E* ! ,��
�,G� O�,4�7 ! O�7�;� Q� ��" o� zwW@ o6�\a O�7�;4 ;�#� �XJ O�Y%@ Q� �,6HI2(Frisch,
Huppenbauer, 2014 ; Taylor, Strickland, 2002) !@ ,� �B�#² 0@Resick et al, 2011�Bak �;( ;4: �R ,� '( ³
EU ��G#�
%@ ]� ,�,6HI2 �,G�� ; O�,4�7 ;�;�� O; z4: ?U�G& !@ ,O�,4�$� ±�U ! O��Z#& �,/��;a ?Z( Ä�@@ O�@ ?Z( �,m: O�7�;� Q� ;g,/\#�@ ���X=� EU �� ]Z �,6HI2 �,G� 0* �Z#$�
G� 9�¾ '( u��;#� J} Q� N� ��2 �,6HI2 O��K?Z�� ! �Z,�$�
AB,C� �D�� o�@�=a A#� O�7�;�� �/$=��U ��:, ;GW O1X=� ! AB,C� �D�� S#$� �,GU �Y�,^ oZ#� S�I: O"v#ZU �Y#6H( �Y¨�U oW�D: 1,W ,�B�#²
,h,G��� ?Z�� O�,6HI}4���� ,��@ ��§& �/72 ,A�,/$�� ?Z�� _�@;����> ,��@� �,6HI2 �,G�Tu,
Lu and Yu, 2017 ,�5Y¨�U@ Q� ;( �T: 0@�=a �I,@�#�;j� �7� ?q� AB,C� �D�� '( O"v#&
���� �D�� '( �,��L#� �,G� �T: o�@�=a .,* ���@ ,AB,C�Jang and Oh, 2018� �T: ! A6HI2 ¦�=&
om�7 ;6@ ,AB,C� �D�� '( �,6HI2 �,G�@ '( �T§& ?��� ! O�WH#Ik '( f��#� ! O�7�;�
K7�,6 u,��7:@ ,a���XJ@ ,M��T@ ,AB,C� �D��
-
:A��,� @;� ;®: @ _1,�$� ¯;/( 0�Y#U AB,C� �D�� '( �,G�� A6HI2 ;�/� �T:E7@F�Z��KKK
�> P�7F�@ Q���;& �7��R S;� +,G#� �,��© �7�;� ¬}a
9 �T:@ ,�,6HI2 �,G�� ��$62 Q� AB,C� �D�� '( 8� ;/( QU ��\7 "�2 ����% ! E��� EBC& �XJ �Y%@ �,G� EU �6H�� ��,/V '( f��#� ]� ,c�d�U [�[�� ;�ª/� �,m: '( P¨� P�G�� ;AB,C� �D��@ �,6HI2 �,G� O�7��R Q� ;( 0@�=a 0HI Q� �,G�� A6HI2
@ �,6HI2 ,��;��@ ,�J��2@ ,�,6;w& :! ��qZ#& ;*: 0@�=#a 8�NU A�@ ,�p*k@ ,��q��@ ,�®��@ g/$� Ë A#� "I2 �J@ ! Os�U A#� �ZY& O�(D&
K�7�;� ]Z#� ! �Y,W .L/� ;*: �@�=#U �GU�$� O�7�;� ]� �,��© �7�;� U�t#a
P7 �7�;� �� ,AB,C� �D�� @: �,6HI2 �,G� _�4 �YW;�: ±�U ! �GU�$� O�7�;� ±�U ]� AG#�a 14, !@
! �Y=( ¢�#¾@ ,AB)� h,�L#� �Y=& �Y�;i#7 ;6 �,6HI2 �,G� _: ;J .,* ,�7�;� ]Z#�@ O"v#� ?=� Ë AB,C� �D���U �Y\U� Q`� .L/� Q� u,w=U o,X* ;$a _: ?�}J �=JW N� ;�,U��� O�7�;� ! �)�I �;G� +BJ
R U� uJ�% ! B� ±�U �7�;� MN� �,G� �7��KE7@F�Z�� AB,C� �D���U �,6HI2
������ ��Y*C� :9�!,�� $ − ������ �C�� Z�+[:
E��� EBC& ],^ Q� �7�;� ]Z#� ¢�}#� ;/( QU ��\7 "�2 ����% O�,�4 ! E����� O����@ �3 �,�4� :O�,�4 � Q� O��/( ��− �µK� � '( ?Z#t�@ :��q��>� Q� O��/( ���− ��K� � '( ?Z#t�@ :�®��>� Q� O��/( ��− �µK�
� '( ?Z#t�@ :�p*k>� Q� O��/( ���− �K� ^�>�� ]'��� �J��#7k 5a .,* ,AB,C� �D���U #Ó :
,h,G��� �;(: A#� AB,C� �D���U �G��#& �J�/#7k�U����� '( o�Z# A#� ���>� n3 �Z$G� ��/( �½ �
��U:, :A� � '( ?Z#t�@ :�%2� � Q� O��/( �− ½K�
� '( ?Z#t�@ ,?Z�� � ,U f@�C>� Q� O��/( �µ− ��K�
� '( ?Z#t�@ ,�,6p� �W� Q� O��/( ���− ��K� � '( ?Z#t�@ ,fÊ��� Q� O��/( ��>− ��K�
� '( ?Z#t�@ ,PH�[� ]� �6H��>� Q� O��/(���− >K�
� '( ?Z#t�@ ,���& ?����� Q� O��/( �>�− >µ K��K�gL�& �XJ
P− : �_�"# 1����"�� Z\ ��$ `�a U gGL#�� �,��#� O\d ��/a 5a �7�;� : 5,Zwa ;�
:´;,& g,/\#�� �Y#,*H) Q�
-
�� ,���� ���� ��� ����� � ,�,� �−�, � ������������������
�½:������ ��$ `�a
,�,6HI2 �,G� �Y,GtU ���X� �J�/#7k ³;) Q� ;4}#�� '( �YD�( 5a ,7�,G� o�D@ �� �,6 ! AB,C� �D��@
! +��;#� � ,� P�̈ (: Q� EZ`L& Q� �(Z� 8�& ����% ,
�7@ ,��\7 "�2 ����%@ ,�,U��� ¢��J ����%@ ,/a ����%
����� �� ;Y��@; �Y#�PH� S;�@ �* 5�X*H� NI2 : ;(3 5a@ KOH�;�#� ±�U o��%: 5Y-� PD !@ ,�,G�� .*�/� ?/6 Q� �gL�&� ! �LD&@ �,-�Y=� ��wU �7�;�
+,-�� .L/� � '( �,J@p �̀3 �i$J ?Z�U ��,G� 5T Q�@�google [�[�� ;/( QU ��\7 "�2 ����% O�,�4 P;Z�� ��7�3@ �
8�& ����U ����� �� 5$6 Q� %� �\I u%ZU c�d�U����j O�,�4 O���3@ A��3 ],Zj e��;��U �YZ,Z�a 5#,�
�7
@ �Y��sa 5a 14 ,c�d�UK+,-�� .*�/� g��V Q( e�,6� : ������ ��$ 1�"#
�B�:� ����� �;i#7 5a �7�;� : O�/T S;� �,G�� �¦�/J@�4Cronbach's Alpha)�; : O�/T Q� ;4}#��
� 0@;j@ ,�7�;��K�7�;� : O�/T OH���� D� �
b )�Kc���� ��$ 1�"# -���� d�"��G ���$ W��!� : e��
Q fg+0� ��
1��"!�� 1�"#fg+0�
c �,6;w& ½ hijkll m �J��2 ½ hikmcn o ��;�� > hikmol p ��q�� > hikomj n �®�� > hikmoo l �p*k > hikcpn
����� � ������ Q�!�� 1�">�� om hikjm q �%2 � hiqjhj j ?Z�� � ,U f@�C > hijlnj k �W�,6p� hikhhc
ch f� � hikhmn cc PH�[� ]� �6H�� > hijjlj cm ���& ?��� � hijmlk
������� ����� Q�!�� 1�">�� mn hikol
� 0@;% Q� ¨#��� ]#Z#a �7�;� O"v#� +,��G� _: ´;,& g,/\#� ! �Y,�( 1#(k Q`Z� ��Ba�� O�/T �%�;U
K�7�;��
������ rJ�+� :9�C��# �,�y@ O�J�,/� ��( �7�;� Q� P[j N� QZ¨#��Y
�U�%¹�Q( �U�%¹�@ K�7�;� OkF�$aQ( 0@2 0§$� ��$62 P�7F�@ Q���;& �7��R S;ZU g��#� N� �7�;�� [�[�� ;/( QU ��\7 "�2 ����% ! �,6HI2 �,G��
7#& �$* 5a ,c�d�U ��,�& f�LJk@ ¤�$©� 0@;% ! D� � 14 �,6HI2 �,G� O"v#&��
b )�Km����� � ������ Q�'� � s��� XN�N�0� ���t u��:e
fg+0� v�'w� x��+0� A��!0� NE� oick cimhc
����� � ������ oipm cihnp
� 0@;% Q� ¨#���7�;� �=,( _: �, Q���;& _: S�a [�[�� ;/( QU ��\7 "�2 ����% O�,�4 ! ��$62 P�7F�@ 7#ZU �,��( �%�;U �,6HI2 �,G� _7�1� c�d�U
��� Q�> P�7F�@ Q���;& �7��R �H� s�U: _:@ K� �J��2 "v#& 5Y#7��R ! o�qr �,6HI2 �,G�� ��$62
� 7#ZUÒ>� Q�>4 K� ?6: _: n3 0@;j "t� 1� 7#ZU ��q�� � �,6HI2 �,G� O�,4�7Ò�� Q�
>K� �U�%¹�@Q( �%�;U g��#� N� �7�;�� ´�q� 0§$�
;/( QU ��\7 "�2 ����% ! E7@F�Z�� AB,C� �D�� f�LJk@ ¤�$© 7#& �$* 5a ,c�d�U [�[��
��U2 ��,�&� 0@;% ! D� � 14 AB,C� �D���
-
:A��,� @;� ;®: @ _1,�$� ¯;/( 0�Y#U AB,C� �D�� '( �,G�� A6HI2 ;�/� �T:E7@F�Z��KKK
�µb )�Koe: �N�E� ������� ������� ����� �K
�!, � v�'w� x��+0� A��!0� ! o�qr �D�� �H� s�U: _:@ ,� �D�� ;� ªU � 7#ZU �,��( �D� �%�;U PH�[� ]� �6H�� Q(Õµ½
Q�> ,�_: E* ! ! o�qr AB,C� �D�� �H� ?6: ;� ªUK�%2 Q( �D��
�U�%¹�@Q( ��,/V 0* �7�;�� .��q� 0§$� 5a AB,C� �D��@ �,6HI2 �,G� ��U: EU O�6H��
U x�/a� ?���� �;i#7 KO�6H�� 8�a ;�;L#� _7"� 0@;%@�K?,�L#� N� �-�#J D� �
b )�Kpe3 ������� ����� ����� � ������ �!,$ �, ��J�C>�� 1���!��
1�f
g+0�
������� �����
�K � �{�, <��
W�!�� ���R�� |�} ** �Õ���** �Õ�µ** � K½µ½ **
��J�H/E� ��:��� ���� ���� ���� ���� ���� ���� ����
����!�� ~�";:� W��!� �Õ�µ** �Õ½��** �Õ�µµ** �Õµ��** �Õ�½µ** �Õ��** �Õ½µ�**
��J�H/E� ��:��� ���� ���� ���� ���� ���� ���� ����
�>NE� ~�";:� W��!� �Õ�>�** �Õ½�µ** �Õ���** �Õµ��** �Õ�>�** �Õ���** �Õ½µ�**
��J�H/E� ��:��� ���� ���� ���� ���� ���� ���� ����
�.��� ~�";:� W��!� �Õ�µ�** �Õ½�½** �Õ���** �Õµµ�** �Õ�½�** �Õ>½** �Õµ��**
��J�H/E� ��:��� ���� ���� ���� ���� ���� ���� ����
Q�R/:� W��!�~�";:� �Õ�½µ** �Õ½��** �Õ��µ** �Õ���** �Õ�µ�** �Õ�½** �Õµ��**
��J�H/E� ��:��� ���� ���� ���� ���� ���� ���� ���� ������
����� �
~�";:� W��!� �Õ���** �Õ½µ** �Õ>�** �Õ���** �Õ>��** �Õ��** �Õµ�** ��J�H/E� ��:��� �Ò��� �Ò��� �Ò��� �Ò��� �Ò��� �Ò��� �Ò���
S#$� ;=( �� **��� ?6}W
� 0@;% ! �-�#=� "ta�� ;=( ���V �6H(
%@ n3� �,-�w*3 ��k S#$���� ,�,6HI2 �,G� EU �
�,G� �7��R Os 1�`W KE7@F�Z�� AB,C� �D��@
Q z$y ,�,6HI2 14 KE7@F�Z�� AB,C� �D�� S#$�� 0@;% Q� Â*HJ ×A4�7 _: � �m �®��@ �p*k
KE7@F�Z�� AB,C� �D���U �V�/a� '(2
-
�� ,���� ���� ��� ����� � ,�,� �−�, � ������������������
�� �U�%¹�@Q( ]U�� �7�;� 0§7, Q( .L/� N� 0§$�
�,6HI2 �,G� ��U2 ��$62 P�7F�@ Q���;& �7��R �T:AB,C� �D�� '(, ;�#& �;LJk ?,�y �;i#7 5a ;GW
� 0@;j ! D� � 14> ,½ @µK�
b )�Kn�!+0� ��5�:� W�� 1��� : e
P��C�� U 1�fg+0� �;�; P��C�� U ������� 1�fg+0�
c ����� � ������
m Q�R/:�
� 0@;% ����>;�#& �;LJk ?,�y �-�#J �− ?,�y
\I \dStep-wise analysis _: Â*HJ .,* ,"v#&��G#$& QEN�� � �;LJk ����� ! 1Y%�3 5a Q
�m ]U�#� "v#& '( �m"T}a 6@ 1Y��Y73 u$* ;�#& "v#� 5T u4�� "v#Z4 �,6HI2 �,G� "v#� ! �p*k
E* ! ,�,6HI2 �,G� "v#� O�J`� ;*}4 �,J�q� �/a�& ,�,6;w&� O"v#& �,GU _:@ ,�J��2@ ,��;��@ ,��q��
@ � +,�W ,�(@ ,;�#& �;LJk ����� ! c�;a Ë ��®��KE7@F�Z�� AB,C� �D�� ! "T}a
b )�Kl�!,$ �; �� �"'� : e ������� ����� U XN�"+�� X� ����� � ������
�H0� ����R2
W��!��N�5+��
��[1�!,�0�
1�K
�N�w�
x��+�1�!,�0�
���� e
� S#$� '( �,-�w*3 ��k O9 **�Ò�� ≤α �
� 0@;% Q� ¨#�½ ;�#& �;LJk ?���� ]U�� _: ��(R square @�$� ;�;L#� ?���� @:)�Ò>�� Q�"v#Z�� �
N��� Q�N� _: A=�� N�@ K�;LJk ����� ! 1�I3 5a Q
� #/$J �� _ÐB� Q�"v#&>�Ò� ! h`� Q��/#� Q� �%KAB,C� �D��
b )�Kq XN�"+�� X� Q�R/:� ����� � ������ X� WG �N �� �"'� : e
������� ������� ����� U
���+'0� 1�fg+0� B �
A��!0� Beta ����e1b
��:�����J�H/E�
,�>�� �Õ�> �Õ��µ ��Õ>µµ hhhh** ����� � ������ �Õ�� �Õ��� �Õ>�� �Õ��> hhhh**
Q�R/:� �Õ�� �Õ��½ �Õ��> �Õ��½ hhop * ** � ��k S#$� ;=( �,-�w*3 ��k O9�Õ�� ≤α �
� 0@;% Q� Â*HJµ� OH���� ��U�#� Q�@ ,�Beta ,�
Ø0 oU�q� _: �O� ��/#I@ �,G� _: Â*HJ 14 Ke�,-�w*3� #/$J �� ÐB� u4�� "v#Z4 �,6HI2�� "v#� _:@ �,
� #/$J �� ÐB� �p*k�� �D�� ! h`� Q��/#� Q� �,E7@F�Z�� AB,C�, ! x�/a�k ?,�y ]� gW#� N�@
� 0@;%� Q� '(2 � �p*k "v#� _: Â*HJ .,* � x�/a�k .,*KE7@F�Z�� AB,C� �D�� ]�
1��a�+�� rJ�+C�� �8��C� :9�!��;
�7��R '( �7�;� �W: �GW� �-�#=� oLD@: �,��( �%�;U �,6HI2 �,G�� ��$62 P�7F�@ Q���;&
� 7#ZU�� Q�>8�9 "$Ba Q`Z�@ K� , �G� S;� _: e�;6 ��(�e, �,6HI2 �,G� ��U: �7��R Q�, I2 '(@
�7� ]� �,#=� MN� oGBa ;6@ KE7@F�Z�� �p*k ;�ªU,_@�I@ ,Q�;U�(� ���� �%� _: n3 O��: A#� ��
,_Z��& ���;G� 14 �,��( �,6HI2 �,G�� Q���;& �7��R,A-�\�� �7�@���µ� ��U: �Y,W oGG* A#� �� �,G
MN� ¢�#¾@ K�7�;� �=,( P� u$* �,��( �%� �,6HI2 Q( �#J .,* ,�GU�$� O�7�;� ±�U �-�#J ]� �-�#=�
,5��4� �7�����,� �[#�k ! ¢�D
%@ �: ,�,��� ���� O�,G� S;� �,6HI2 O�,4�$��U
,�¨����� �7� n3 �W�D��U����#$� o=,U A#� �� S _1( ! �,�`© ��J�q� �;& ��;� �7��R Q� 7#�
-
:A��,� @;� ;®: @ _1,�$� ¯;/( 0�Y#U AB,C� �D�� '( �,G�� A6HI2 ;�/� �T:E7@F�Z��KKK
�� 8�N4@ ,�Y,W EZ��& �XJ �Y%@ Q� ,�,6HI2 �,G��
,¤�©� �7����> Q� �\7#� �%� e�¨�: o=,U A#� �� !@ ,�Y�Z( ! �,6HI2 �,G�� +��;#� � ,� ¨( �7��R
k N� S[� ª� _: Q`Z�@ K����U: �W�4 fH#I n3 fH#I O��Z#� ! �GU�$� O�7�;� g,/\a 5a .,* ,]Z#& ,�7�;� �W: ;( ! fH#Ik n3 �W�D��U ,�B�#² ! fH#Ik@ ,5Y�Z( ��,/V@ ,5Y#%[�:@ ,5�Y%a@ O�7�1& �%� '( �T§a ;6 A#� 0@;� �ZXJ:@ EJ6
K�,6HI2 �I £uJ�% Q�, � ±�U OP�% �GU�$� O�7�;� ]� gB##
! �Y#,m: ;4§a@ ,�7�;� ;,6 O�7�1& ±�U �,m:� �7� Q( �#J ;GW ,O��Z#&Resick et al, 2011 _: �
�J��2@ ,�,6;w&@ ,��;��@ ,�p*k :O�,4�7, A� o�)a 14 ,��W�GT fH#I '( O��Z#& ! �=Z,Y&
� �7�Frisch andHuppenbauer, 2014 s�U: Q� _: n3 � ,��[=� :A6HI2 ;-�G� [,r A#� O�,4�$�@ ,HI�
@ , �;j@ ,³;w�@ ,��;��@ !@ K�p*k@ ,�(�t�,A-�\�� �7����µ _: '( �=,�� �W: u�: gBa 8�N4 �
K�,6HI: �,G� _4 '( ?,� ��;�� :;/� gW@ ?���#� P�7F�@ Q���;& �7��R fH#I �7�;� o#/T: 14 c�d�U [�[�� ;/( QU ��\7 "�2 ����% O�,�4 ! ��$62 �/a�& ! �J��2 �7��R OP�W ,�,6HI2 �,G� ��U2 �Ù: '( +,-�� �XW� ! ��7��R s�U: o�qr@ ,n@2
;�U �,#=� MN� "$Ba Q`Z�@ ,EBC& +,-�� 0Hv#7 � '( #XW� ;4§� �R �Y=� �,wi ��B=� '( 0wL�� #J�`� s�U: o�@ ,�p*k P�% 8�9 ;�U K,7@F�� �Ù: MN� S[�a@ K7�7: '( ?Z�� O�6H( P�=U ! a�7��R =( �#=� �R ,E����� @ u$4 '( +,-�� �* n3 �,#=�
'( �z,=/� ?Z( O�6H( P�=U +,-�� EU 0�/#& �p*kK@F�&@
s�U: O�YC@ ,�q��q� �/a�& ! P�% ;GW �®�� ;�ªU ��: ��t/U ;j EBCZ�� ��sH� ;(�$& 5�;Ga ! ��7��R
+,-�� �U �,#=� MN� "$Ba Q`Z�@ ,g�I Q$*@ n35�;Ga '( )�* ; �� �R ,5(;�� ;j EBC& �%�*
��;�� OP�% 5T Kg�I Q$*@ ,��t/U 5 ��sH� ;(�$& Q`Z�@ ,A(D� ?`tU EBC& f@�C ��;Ga ! e ���C ],Zj ������ '( � +,-�� _: n3 �,#=� MN� S[�a _:
KA(D� ?`tU f@�X� ��;Ga n3 §� �R ���( �G��\U & s�J3 ! ��qZ#� �,6;w& OP�% 8�9 ;�U ��4& ��Y
+,-�� _}U �,#=� MN� "$Ba Q`Z�@ ,HIU +,-�� n3 a�,�@§$� Q� M��/#(�U �ZX=& ���7� g,Gy '( �
�,$,-��, ,�3 ��4& ��Y& s�J3 '( �© n3 §� �R Os�J3 ],ta ! e�,�#� ��q�� ;�ªU P�% e"I:@ KHIU
[�a _: Q`Z�@ ,EBC& +,-�� �* n3 �,#=� MN� S ],t#� �W;� �R ,s�J¹� E7@F�& �,�W [�[�a '(
,5s�J3,8�N�@ �7� ,�3 O��: �� �7�;� o#/T: ,+J�@ ,¯ ;/(����� ¿�a O�B) �,G�� _: ! ��
K��q�� :�Ym: Q�@ ,EBC& AB,C� �D���U g��#� 1,W ��:, � o#/T: ;GW_: �7�;
?`tU AB,C� �D�� Q� �\7#� �%� .L/� �=,( S;�AB,C� �D�� ��U: �W�4 ! �\7#� �%� 8�N4@ ,��(,
,h,G��� �7� �,#J ]� gB#a 8�NU A�@���� ¢�#¾@,��,A�,/$�� �7� ]����> �-�#=� ! O�WH#Ik S[�a@ K��
�7� ! AB,C� �D�� ��U: ! fH#IH� ,A�,/$� ,?Z�� ��,/V@ ,�=,��@ ,]Z#& ! fH#Ik 8�N4@
K�\,L& ?���@ ,�,=�N� 5���@ �W2 ��,/V@ �D�� �H� s�U: _: n3 �,��© �7�;� O��: ;G� o�qr �7�;� ;,6 ]Z#& ! E��� EBCZ�� AB,C�
,PH�[� ]� �6H�� Q( �D�� ;�ªU ! ]� gB#a 8�NU A�@ ,h,G��� �7����� �D�� �H� s�U: _: O;%@ 14 K��
?Z�� ;=( �*���U ��t� ! ?qZ#a PH�[� ]� �6H�� Q( _�#Z#� E��� EBC& _: '( 0;� N�@ ,PH�[� ]�
5Y¨�U ]� ;,% O�6H�U� ë �U �*���U ��t� s[�� �R ,a�& !@ ,?Z�� P�=T: ���& ?��� Q( �D�� P�% �,J�q� �/
,h,G��� �7� +`�U ��Ba�� �D� �%�;U���� ;6@ K�� ?��� Q( �D�� �H� s�U: _: �,��© �7�;� oLD@: S[��@ ,?Z�� _�`� ! P�D� Q( �D�� ! ?qZ#� ���& ;,j ?Z�� � ,U � , '( �y ����j _: n3 8�9
-
�� ,���� ���� ��� ����� � ,�,� �−�, � ������������������
��U$=&KAB,C� 5��D� Q� s[�� �R ,�Y,
EGU�$� Q�;�/� Q( �D�� �%� ��Ba� ?U�G� !@, ;GW�%2 ;�ªU Q( 5��D� ¢�D Q( �7�;� oLD@:,
��4& ��Y& _: _@�� EBC& _}U �,#=� MN� "$Ba Q`Z�@ ;6 @: ,�ZX=& Q� ,�( _�w N� �%2 sa k 5Y,�3
Æ"va u/$U _`� S�� HW ��@;� ! ���w#6k ��D@2 �-�#=� O��: 14 ,�,t,�& a�%�,#*k �%2 ���B4 ¢C& ?qZ#a E��� EBCZ�� AB,C� �D�� �H� ?6: _: n3
K�,6p� �W ;�ªU ! fÊ� Q( �D�� ��:, ;% ª@@ ,�q��q� �/a�& ! P�% ;GW
=( �D�� �H� s�U: _: O�*pGZU P�7F�� u,*�a ! ?qZ#a S;� ��/& @� [�[�a '( 5Y)�* '( 0;� �R ,E7@F�& ,��U�� �/a�& ! ?Z�� � ,U f@�C Q( �D�� 5T ,5Y,7@F�� E��� EBC& =� ! ;�/� N� �H� s�U: o�qr .,* Q`Z�@ ,5YV�tJ ��#7 '( 5�;(�$� �R ,�*��� O�6@:
a ea�6@: EBC& =r ����j _}U �,#=� MN� "$B� ;�*��� ,5YV�tJ ��#7 '( 5;(�$&5T Q�@ ��t� Q� ?,�G#�
K5É;� AB,C� �D�� s[�� �R ,´;/� �Y%��U ;=( �,U�¥ x�/a� �6H(
%@ �,��© �7�;� O;%@
� ��=�� S#$����@ �,6HI2 �,G� EU � �D�� �,G� O�7��R o=$y 1�`W ,E7@F�Z�� AB,C� EBC& S;� AB,C� �D�� S#$� Q z$y ;�,6HI2 �,G� O�7��R E$y _: '( 0;� N�@ ,�Y,W E��� ]W� s[�� �R ,EBC& ]� ?���#� Q� Q $ �,6HI2
KAB,C� 5��D� S#$� 7��R "T}a ! �X=� ;=(@�,6HI2 �,G� � u4�Z4
�,��© �7�;� _: ;J ,AB,C� �D�� '( ����U:@ �D�� '( �,6HI2 �,G� �7�1& "T}a
%@ n3 o�)a '( e"T}a �,6HI2 �,G� O"v#� �q4: _:@ ,AB,C� oB�#I ;6@ ,�p*k ! ?qZ#� E7@F�Z�� AB,C� �D��
�,#=� MN� ,+J�@ ,¯ ;/(� �7� ,�3 o�)a 1(���� ! Å�72 A6HI2 �L& ��q�� O#( .,* ��
K¢C& '( "T}#�
,h,G��� �7� ]� �GU�$� �,#=� gB#a���� A#� �� EU �,-�w*3 ��k O9 ���V ��6 �6H(
%@ o#/T:
,C� �D�� S#$�@ ,�,B,C� ?Z�� O�,6HI: AB �7� O��: ;GW 8�9 n3 �W�D��U KO���� O�BCZ��
�Frisch and Huppenbauer, 2014 ¤�¥� �,G� "T}a n3 � S#$�@ , d�U ��t�@ ,?Z�� O�6H(
% Q� ?4 '( ��Z$� �ZX=& �$43@ ,EBCZ�� AZ,X=#� �[#�k
Z��� EL�Z�� �,U9�j@ ,�Gq�@ ,�=$© �W�D��U ,�Y,W ?K?�\� S;& '( �& �=� n3
�=� _: n3 �,��© �7�;� ?)a �;( Â*H� "I:@ e"T}a 9 ?q� �,6HI2 �,G� ��U: ±�/� �,-�w*3 ��k
�,6;w&, N� KE7@F�Z�� AB,C� �D�� '( 0;��@#,m: 5� ,Q�;�/� Q�N� _: �#=#$J �=��¥ O�,U: ! 1Y
1Y#7��R 5#� k ,�,�Z�� �7�1& !@ �,6HI2 �,G� �%�;U 8�9 n3 _@"t� E7@F�& ?�¥ N� !�`� ?`t��U
K�,��( �%� ! ��Ba� Q� �-�#=� ,�3 o�)a �� '( eP�=U@ ,c�d�U ����j O�,�4 ! �,6HI2 �,G�� P�7F�� �7��R
�6H(
%@ ]� �D��@ �,6HI2 �,G� �7��R EU ���V �Y�Z�U �,6HI2 �,G�� "T}a
%@ n3 �W�D��U ,AB,C�
:¬�U �7�;� a ,AB,C� �D�� '( �− �ZXJ2 N,B=#U �,6HI2 �,G� �7��R ! ��Z#7k
�YL,Da@ ,��"$Ba@ ,��;�U EBC& '( EJG�@Y(�=63@ ,5 '( ¡�B©@ ,5Y©�w� g,Gy ! ��@;U 5
.L/�@ ,�Y#7��R S;& �@ 5�Ga P�%3 ]� ,5Y6G* ��U2 ±�U �7��R Q� ;y A#� ?��� !,�ZY& ?q�
�,6;w&, 0;��@, MN� E$y ?%: Q� ;�Y#j���@K��[�[�a@ O�7�1&
�− ����j �G� u��;a ���U N,B=a@ ;(3; 5Y#,(#� O��G� ! �,6HI2 uJj ¢�#iZU 5YB���a@ ]� ,��" Q( �,6HI2 ¢6& [,,r �,B,4@ ,���� ?%: Q� 5Y�� �YG,/\a ����j 0@�y A#� 5,G� �t6�=�
K����`#� �,6HI: ��X=� P�=U
-
:A��,� @;� ;®: @ _1,�$� ¯;/( 0�Y#U AB,C� �D�� '( �,G�� A6HI2 ;�/� �T:E7@F�Z��KKK
��− ],ta ��@�@ ,����j ! �,6HI2 �J@;& ?,�Ba
�$� ! ��;,$ ;,4}#�@ ,EBC&@ , �G�� A�,� K�,6HI2 O�,4�$� �7��R �,m: '(
�− �,G� ��U: �7��R 0* O�7�;� Q� ;�[& P�%3 ! E7@F�Z�� AB,C� �D�� '( ��"T}a@ �,6HI2
O����j Q� ;(, �-�#=U c@�d@ �J��G& f; 8�9@ "T}#� O9 ��U2 0* ?¨W: �D�� '( S62
KE7@F�Z�� AB,C� �D�� �%� _: Q� �-�#=� ,�3 o�)a �� '( eP�=U@ _:@ ,�Y�Z( ! �\7#� c�d�U ����j O�,�4 ! AB,C� �YG/$�@ ,�,6p� �W ;�U ! o�qr �D�� O�%� ?6: ,�\7#� �%�;U ?Z�� � ,U f@�C@ ,f� Q( �D��
� �W: �D� �;(@ �7�;� a �%2 ;�ªU Q( �7�;:h� 1U E�@§$&
�− P: ��;Ga ]� ,EBCZ�� ����� [W©@ ,OÇW�`& =� 5��D� S#$� ]W� ! ;(�$Z�� ;?Z�� ! Q�;Y#&
KAB,C� �− E��� EBCZ�� �,/��;a ���U N,B=a@ ;(3,
�,6p� �BU �¨��@ ¢���#��; � Q� ?,�G#�� 5�� s[�� �R ,5�X��U Q�KAB,C� 5��D�
− ]W�� ;EBCZ�� ?Z�� � ,U f@�C E$y '( ?Z�� K5��D� ��s@ ,��=�& 5Y*@�
�− S;�@ ,5Y-: Q( �,$`( ��Nv#U EBC& ;�@[#U �1#�k ?%: Q� ,?/G#$& ! M��\a@ =,$y �7:@ ,*�J
K5É;� AB,C� �D�� S#$� ]W�
ZK��0� :��,�!��
� K
Z ÃB\w� ,�`U U:���� K�� W�!�� ]�� 1�����$ :���!�� 1&BC0� ���2w� O�*� U
% _1¨� ?I;�
s�Yj ! �$B� O�//$� ]=�@ �� H)�K�,���j �;� :���;=`7� KA�`©
5��4� K;Z� _1,�7 ;Z� ,���� �,G� O�,4�7 K�:,� ! �Z4© �/� g,/\a S;ZU �Y#6H(@ �,6HI2
K�,/,�� O�$7§&��Y+�� �H+��� ����!�� ��Y0� ,��� ,����µ−��½� K
� K;�Z _1,�7 ;�Z ,5��4���� pG� c9ZJ K�,�'( �,6HI2 �,G� O�,4�7 "T}#� �3 �YB� g,/\a
KO�,Bt#$& ! ����t�
j �H+��� ����!�� ��Y0���Y+���� ,� ,�>��−>½� K
� K"\� ��) ,H/���� K�M A�N�0 ������� ����� 3]=�B� �*K X� ���20� �2� �CN��, ���+0� -��0�
KS�G� �: ����% :���`& �`� , �t=� "#$%�� ���7� � ,� P�¨(: _@§ 1( ,[�[�� ;/( QU ��\7 "�2 ����%
� KEBC&@ +��;#���> K�M������ � `�>�0� �� KK�_K� :c�d K�n@2 ��/\��
� K�( �[� ¯ �% ,@�#�;j���� K�� ������ �#$ s���!�� ������� ����� �� 1�!��� s����� ���N�5+��
Q�'� � s���3��� � 1�!��� U ���N�G � ���7� �,�H7� ���� ����% :_1( , �t=� " M�#4
K�,&��� � KO�U@� ,_@��U@ ,;�"% ,c=��%���� K�� ��
31&BC0� U ��'�� A(�W� �^�a� K���U�$� ��/\�� Ú��& � :����� K�´,$U h( ?,(173@ ,A(�W� ;Z
� >�� ,� ,� >>>−½��K
� K;®: ���7: ,EJ�$*���� �,G� EU �6H�� ?,�y K�� �7� :�,%�#J¹� �¨& ?Z�� O�,4�7@ �,6HI2
-
�� ,���� ���� ��� ����� � ,�,� �−�, � ������������������
�� K�,J;,���!0� �N�Y+�� �5"�� ��[ ��#� �,�4 ,
c��7 ����U– ,~� ����>�, ����, �−>�K
� K;Z� Q$* ;�Z ,O�®���� K�� ���BC+�� ��'���� 3�N�,R�� 1�'�V0� U ���"�+'0� 1�N�5+ ��/\��
K]�s#�@ �� �� ����"; ��� :�N�!'�� ��,�!�� �2��0�, ���50�3���20� �2� ��C� �N��� ��C� �� U ����!��
�,U��� ¢��J ����% :����� , �t=� "#$%�� ���7���K�,=�2 ���
� K;,�7 ;�Z ,_�\�7���� K�� U ^�'�E� ��'��31&BC0� K ;�;j ����j � :���;=`7�
� K��7 ,��$����� K�M ����BC+�� W�!�� ~�g� W���� 31�N�E� 1�}��� ������� �����, �*+��� ���7�
K
�7 8�& ����% :����� , �t=� " "#$%�� ,Z$�� K;�Z Q$L& ;/( ,���� K���[#�k AZ,X=#�
�,Z��� ;���& ��;� S;� AB,C� �D���U #6H(@ K�,�H7�
�7 QU ;�Z ���� ����U �� ��[
,�N�,R�� 1������ ��� ,�½�−���K � KÃ% ��� ,k@ @ , @�;J: ,A6k[,7���� K���
3s� � ���BC+�� ��'�� � K�;®: 57�G� U: �B�% �^�a �^p� ?/6 �#`� °
-
:A��,� @;� ;®: @ _1,�$� ¯;/( 0�Y#U AB,C� �D�� '( �,G�� A6HI2 ;�/� �T:E7@F�Z��KKK
� K?)& �=�;� O�,Bt#$� ! P�/V2 Q� ���C; ��[
,XN�}���� ������ ,��µ ,���>−���K � K;®: ,�,/V @ ,;�Z ,],Z$� ;/(���� K�� 1�����$
3���!�� ��E� _��[� +,�% � :_1( K�n@2 ��/\��K]�s#�@ K
,7 ;Z� ,0��#& ;/( Kg��d ;/( 1( ,_�L\� @ , ;®: ;����� K�� ��} � ��'� ��� :���BC+�� ��'��
)&� � 1&BC� U 1��&�K ���G� K � K��/� A4�U ;®: ,A/,#����� K�� A�N�� ���t �K
]*���, �*+��� ����� � ������ �N���>�� -��0�U ���!0� �B� �*K X� ����BC+��3N�2�� �� ���7�
K7� ³
-
�� ,���� ���� ��� ����� � ,�,� �−�, � ������������������
��� K¼�@� ;Z ,;Z @ ,;YW ;��I ,"\&���> K��
K�%9ZJ �)�d �,Up� ;�� :AB,C� �D�� O� /=�,��,R�� ���G ��[ ������ ,�� ,��½>−���K
;Z ,
Z ;¢7� ´�� ,AG�I ;;Z
�7 ,�Z=�� K;,7 ;Z ,@[® ;AL#W���½ K��!�� ��E� :���
3J����� � � �/#`� :����� K��7�$� ��/\��K�Gt�
� K´��[� ,�J����� M��T@ AB,C� �D�� O; K�� K�,4�$�@ �,W��& O���X=� ?C ! O�$7§& '( ��[
,���&+K:� ����'�E� Q��!�� ��� ,����−��½K
� K�#B� ;/( ;�Z ,A������ K����� �3��E� U 1�� K]�s#�@
-
:A��,� @;� ;®: @ _1,�$� ¯;/( 0�Y#U AB,C� �D�� '( �,G�� A6HI2 ;�/� �T:E7@F�Z��KKK
�>the Impact of Public School Principals’
Perceptions and Attitudes as They Relate to Job Satisfaction. AASA Journal of
Scholarship and Practice, VOL (5), NO
(4) , PP 10-60.
Sigurjonsson, Throstur Olaf; Vaiman, Vlad;
Arnardottir, AudurArna. (2014). The Role
of Business Schools in Ethics Education in
Iceland: The Managers’ Perspective. J Bus
Ethics, (122), PP 25-38.
Taylor, Rosemarye, Strickland, Jessie S.
(2002). Ethical Leadership While Making
The Grade. The International Journal of
Education Management, vol. 16, (6), PP
297-299.
Tu, Y., Lu X. and Yu Y. (2017) "Supervisors' Ethical Leadership and Employee Job
Satisfaction: A Social Cognitive Perspective"
Journal of Happiness Studies, 18: 229-
245.
Wang, A., Chiang J., Chou W. and Cheng B.
(2017) "One Definition, Different
Manifestations: Investigating Ethical
Leadership in the Chinese Context" Asia
Pacific Journal of Management, 34: 505-
535.
-
�½ �� ,���� ���� ��� ����� � ,�,� � ������������������
/�0�
5,*�� Q®�� ¯ 5$U
��
�$� �,U��� �`�Z&
�7 8�& ����% 01(2 �3 �,�4 ����� �� 5$6
: ���0� �+�$��$ �QR50�
: ;�U@ a�4�U@ ¯ �®�@ 5`,�( �H$� O�,�4 ! �,6HI2 �,G�� ��$62 P�7F�@ Q���;& �7��R S;� '( f��#� ��@�L& f; 5`�;�: EU A#� �J�/#7k
;/( QU ��\7 "�2 ����% 5`=� %�}W ,�Y,W E��� EBC& �XJ �Y%@ Q� AB,C� �D�� '( 8�9 �T:@ ,c�d�U [�[��5`#6@ Q� eP[% �J�/#7k MN� P�\(U ��`#�, K�7�;� �-�#J ! �,m: Q� 5`#U�%� �& 8�9@
M� �/7�=& O�,4�$�� hZ�� ,D#� :� ;wG� �,6HI2 �,G� _}U e1�( O�W~#� 0HI Q� �L�w& �L): ],^K��G� ]=)@ ,?)#� 0HI Q� E����� S;� �$� N� [�[�a@ ,�,�(�B#� O�6H��@ ,�,wit�
,?Z�� g��V Q( gGL#a A#� ��$� Q( "/�a :Q( ��/( YW AB,C� �D�� ��:5T Q�@ �(Z� n3 "t� �YB� YW @: �,B,C� �(�t&K�Z( LJ �B� � ��t� A#� �,$B=� ���©
KGW AZ��� .L/� ��2 k3 �;i#$a Q� O����&@ ,AZ��4: � �J�/#7k MN 0@2 f; _}U 54;,W:@
K 5`J@��a Q$* 5`� �4�
�>/�"�� %&��'�� (� �"� )�*+,�
-
:A��,� @;� ;®: @ _1,�$� ¯;/( 0�Y#U AB,C� �D�� '( �,G�� A6HI2 ;�/� �T:E7@F�Z��KKK
�µ ������: ����� �
8�:�� e�GW@ ��/( ?4 ���: ��3 �]D eH¨W ,�,6HI2 �,G�� ?Z�� ! 8$,-� �7��R S;� +,Ga O��/( h� 1,W:Ìit�
Q
��"!��
��8,
}��
�
}���
�G+�
f
}���
f
��8,
}��
� f
� ���7� g,Gy '( ?Z��K�,�`� � KEBC& ]� �,�`� 5,6 ¼6�=� KEBCZ�� ?Z���U �G��#& ��Y& D� � K���W: ]� �6: 5$=a > KHIU ,�3 ��4& ��Y& [=� ½ KQ��I ���: \iU fp�� µ K�Z( ��Y� �W�4 P: ! �J��2�U �[#�� � KEBC& �Ù: '( ÂW� � K$B=U ?Z�� "7 '( f KQ�~G& �/7� ! ��;�� g,/\#U �[#�� �½ K�,(DZU EBC& P: � zG� �µ KA(D� ?`tU EBC& f@�C � z;G� �� K?Z�� :� '( ,BC� u��;#U �G� �� KEBC& Os�J3 ] zt� �� �,��W� ]¨�K\\I ! �;w� ]D� ,BC� �� K�(@
-
�� ,���� ���� ��� ����� � ,�,� �−�, � ������������������
��
Q
��"!��
��8,
}��
�
}���
�G+�
f
}���
f
��8,
}��
� f
�� K],Z�� ]B=� gGy O��6 Ni#� � K5Y,�( _�= ZVH� EBC& ;GB#� �� K�,wit� EBC& O�%�* A(�� �> K_�`�� �;6 EBC& ]� ��$#� �½ � z;G���t/U ;j EBCZ�� ��sH� ;(�$& Kg�I Q$*@ �µ K5Y-� Q( "/�#�� EBCZ�� �)�B� ,#� �� K�p*k �7: '( ?Z�� O�6H( A=/� �� KEBCZ�� ���B� ³@�B� ]� �,(DZU ?���#� � K�,wit� EBC& 5,6 �p � ;Yj 0N/�KEBC& �XJ O�Y%@ 5YBa ��@�L& � K�,(1#%k 5�/7�=� ! EBC& ��t�
������� �����
8�:�� e�GW@ ��/( ?4 ���: ��3 �]D eH¨W ,�� ¢C& �D� +,Ga A#� O��/�� Q� �(Z� h� 1,W:Ìit�
Q
��"!�� ��
8,
}���
}���
�G+�
f
}���
f
��8,
}��
� f
K?Z�� P�/(: M�D�Ga: N� �%: 5-H� � KOÇW�`& =� ! @�$� ;%a > K�Yt� A/a� Q� 0/G� P[% ��I ],\#7: ½ ]D� ]� A/a� u7�=#�K]Z#& ! ���� �w#6k µ K?Z�� ��Y& D@ �=� � KA#B,C@ P�/(: �,/��;#� O�@;� 5-Ha � KhZ( ��,/V ]� u7�=#a 01(}U ¢z�4:
-
:A��,� @;� ;®: @ _1,�$� ¯;/( 0�Y#U AB,C� �D�� '( �,G�� A6HI2 ;�/� �T:E7@F�Z��KKK
��
�� KAV�tJ ��#7 '( ´;(�$� �R �*��� O�6@: =�ª: �� ��,G�� �,W�`� O�,*Hw��U ]#r:KAGa�( '( �G�& O�,�@§$&�U �� K����j ! A6p� ��XJ D@ � K P�B`��U ����j ! �,6p� /a�a �� K���( +7: '( �Ga �,��© A#B,C@ ! �,6p� �W �> K¬�*pGZU ?Z�� ! È,-� u*�� �½ ��/#(k E�U ?Z�� ! È,-� NI}�KA#ZY� M� ��N¾ A#� O��G�� �µ K¢w=� hZ( P: ��U�#& ?Z�� ! È,-� �/#� N� �U�6�� �7: �� K¬��6 ",v#� �W� ��;=( �*���U ��:KhZ( PH�s ]� ?Z(: >� K?Z��
$� g��B� @�U ��: >� K�=,J}Z\��U 5$#a ?Z�� P%: > KhZ( PH�s EU@ A=,U ���/#& �Gq� Q� e� , �=� _: ��: >� K ;,% hZ( _�`ZU ��Y#� >> K ;,% hZ( _�`ZU P�D� >½ P@;
$�K��Y& ��}a P�=T: �*���U ��: A=��¥ �R hZ( _�`� >µ Ku7�=� hZ( _�`ZU ¢,,`#�
-
�� ,���� ���� ��� ����� � ,�,� �−�, � ������������������
�
The Effect of the Ethical Leadership Dimension on Subordinates' Job
Satisfaction: A Field Study
Ahmed M. Alyami Ibthal A. Alslaiman
Professor, College of Business Administration
King Saud University, Riyadh Graduate Student Public Administration Department
College of Business Administration
King Saud University, Riyadh
(Received 14/5/2018, Accepted for Publication 10/1/2019)
Key words: Leadership, Ethical Leadership Dimension, Subordinates, Job Satisfaction, Field Study
Abstract: This study has been conducted to identify the extent to which managers and department heads, at Prince
Sattam Bin Abdul Aziz University in AlKharj city, are practicing ethical leadership. Also to identify the effect of
ethical leadership on subordinates’ job satisfaction. A Descriptive analytical approach has been used to achieve the
objectives of the study through distributing a questionnaire among all the administrative staff of the university.
The study shows that managers and department heads practice ethical leadership to some extent and the most
prominent element mostly practiced is respecting their subordinates. In addition, the study found statistically
significant relationships between the components of ethical leadership and subordinates’ job satisfaction. Step-
wise regression analysis shows that the construct of ethical leadership and one of its components, respect, have a
significant effect on subordinates’ job satisfaction.
In the light of these results the researchers recommend the necessity of reviewing the practices of ethical
leadership in the university and study the factors that limit the practice of some elements of ethical leadership,
such as credibility and justice. And the university should emphasize the importance of ethical leadership through
training its staff about it and its importance for employees’ attitudes, especially subordinates’ job satisfaction.
-
�� ,����� ����� �� ����� � ,�,� � ��−��, � ������������� ��!"
#�
���� ��� � �������� ��������� �� �� ���� ������� � �! "#$% �&'(��� ��) &�����
*+���� ��� ,�-. ��$ %&� ����' ,()*+� ,��- �./ ,0*�1&� ������ ,��� 2�3$4
5 67� �08�#��9����� 5 67� :;8< ,�=� ������
:��0�'�� 12�3��>�.?.@73�� �AB�� C�.8 ,�.?.@73�� �AB