a national web conference on reducing provider burden ......presentation, type your ... design...

91
AHRQ National Web Conference on Reducing Provider Burden Through Better Health IT Design Presented by: Pascale Carayon, PhD Zia Agha, MD Lukasz Mazur, PhD Moderated by: Bryan Kim, PhD Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality January 25, 2018

Upload: others

Post on 20-Sep-2020

0 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: A National Web Conference on Reducing Provider Burden ......presentation, type your ... design requirements that support collaborative VTE prophylaxis teamwork. ... During clinical

AHRQ National Web Conference onReducing Provider Burden Through Better

Health IT Design

Presented by:Pascale Carayon, PhD

Zia Agha, MD Lukasz Mazur, PhD

Moderated by:Bryan Kim, PhD

Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality

January 25, 2018

Page 2: A National Web Conference on Reducing Provider Burden ......presentation, type your ... design requirements that support collaborative VTE prophylaxis teamwork. ... During clinical

Agenda

• Welcome and Introductions • Presentations • Q&A Session With Presenters • Instructions for Obtaining CME Credits

Note: After today’s Webinar, a copy of the slides willbe emailed to all participants.

2

Page 3: A National Web Conference on Reducing Provider Burden ......presentation, type your ... design requirements that support collaborative VTE prophylaxis teamwork. ... During clinical

Presenter and Moderator Disclosures

The following presenters and moderator have no financial interests to disclose:

Pascale Carayon, PhD Presenter

Zia Agha, MD Presenter

Lukasz Mazur, PhD Presenter

Bryan K im, PhD Moderator

This continuing education activity is managed and accredited by the Professional Education Services Group (PESG), in cooperation with AHRQ, TISTA, and RTI.

PESG, AHRQ, TISTA, and RTI staff have no financial interests to disclose.

Commercial support was not received for this activity. 3

Page 4: A National Web Conference on Reducing Provider Burden ......presentation, type your ... design requirements that support collaborative VTE prophylaxis teamwork. ... During clinical

How to Submit a Question

• At any time during thepresentation, type yourquestion into the “Q&A”section of your WebEx Q&Apanel.

• Please address your questionsto “All Panelists” in the drop-down menu.

• Select “Send” to submit your question to the moderator.

• Questions will be read aloud bythe moderator.

4

Page 5: A National Web Conference on Reducing Provider Burden ......presentation, type your ... design requirements that support collaborative VTE prophylaxis teamwork. ... During clinical

Learning Objectives

At the conclusion of this activity, participants should be able to:

1. Identify the cognitive and team work involved in venousthromboembolism (VTE) prophylaxis and the sociotechnical systemdesign requirements that support collaborative VTE prophylaxisteamwork.

2. Describe methods for capturing and analyzing EHR use for providing acomprehensive assessment of usability, clinical workflow, physician-patient communication, cognitive load, and user satisfaction in twodistinct outpatient settings.

3. Explain an evaluation to assess provider mental workload andperformance on abnormal test result follow-up in both a standard and an enhanced EHR environment that includes results trackingfunctionality.

5

Page 6: A National Web Conference on Reducing Provider Burden ......presentation, type your ... design requirements that support collaborative VTE prophylaxis teamwork. ... During clinical

Sociotechnical Design of Health IT for Teams Application to VTE Prophylaxis

Pascale Carayon, PhDWisconsin Institute for Healthcare Systems Engineering

University of Wisconsin-Madison

Page 7: A National Web Conference on Reducing Provider Burden ......presentation, type your ... design requirements that support collaborative VTE prophylaxis teamwork. ... During clinical

• Ann Schoofs Hundt• Peter Hoonakker• Megan Salwei• Roger Brown

UW-Madison

• Peter Kleinschmidt• Brian Patterson• Shashank Ravi [Yale]

UW He alth

Geisinger • Vaibhav Agrawal• Jason Stamm• Ken W ood [Univ ersity of Mar yland]

• Becky Price

7

Acknowledgments

Funding by AHRQ: 5R01HS022086“Health IT-supported process for preventing and managing VTE”

https://cqpi.wisc.edu/vte-and-health-it/

Yushi Yang [Drexel] •

Doug Wiegmann• Yudi Wang•• Emily Wirkus

Page 8: A National Web Conference on Reducing Provider Burden ......presentation, type your ... design requirements that support collaborative VTE prophylaxis teamwork. ... During clinical

Venous Thromboembolism (VTE)

• VTE:

– Patient safety problem (Goldhaber & Bounameaux, 2012;Maynard et al., 2013, 2014)

• Solutions for preventing VTE:

– Guidelines for VTE prophylaxis

– Risk assessment algorithms

– EHR (CDS) to support VTE prophylaxis

• But…

ØUsability, usefulness and workflow integration of health ITØNot just admission:

• Missed doses of enoxaparin à DVT formation [Louis et al., 2014]

ØCollaborative work of physician, pharmacist, nurse, etc…8

Page 9: A National Web Conference on Reducing Provider Burden ......presentation, type your ... design requirements that support collaborative VTE prophylaxis teamwork. ... During clinical

Admission Interruption Re-initiation Initiation Transfer

VTE Prophylaxis

VTE Prophylaxis in the HospitalSEIPS Model of Work System and Patient Safety

[SEIPS = Systems Engineering Initiative for Patient Safety] (Carayon et al., 2006, 2014)

9

Page 10: A National Web Conference on Reducing Provider Burden ......presentation, type your ... design requirements that support collaborative VTE prophylaxis teamwork. ... During clinical

Study Design

• Multiple case study design (Eisenhardt, 1989)

11 cases

GMC

CCM

Cardiology

Hospitalist

GWV

CCM

CCS

Hospitalist

GSACH

Hospitalist

IM

UWHC

CCM

CCS

Hospitalist

4 hospitals

CCM=Critical Ca re MedicineCCS=Critical Ca re Surgery IM=Internal Medicine 10

Page 11: A National Web Conference on Reducing Provider Burden ......presentation, type your ... design requirements that support collaborative VTE prophylaxis teamwork. ... During clinical

11

Data Collection Methods • Survey: – To assess clinician attitudes toward and perceptions of VTE

prophylaxis and potential solutions – N=1,009 (attendings, residents, PA/NP, pharmacists, nurses);

85% response rate • Observation: – Focused on morning rounds: VTE-related activities – N=40; 69 hours

• Interviews and focus groups: – Based on SEIPS model: W hat is the work system? System barriers and facilitators? – N=40; 61 hours

Multiple feedback loops

Page 12: A National Web Conference on Reducing Provider Burden ......presentation, type your ... design requirements that support collaborative VTE prophylaxis teamwork. ... During clinical

Results à Sociotechnical Design Considerations

1. Survey 2. Role network analysis 3. Cross-case analysis

Participatory Human-Centered Design

12

Page 13: A National Web Conference on Reducing Provider Burden ......presentation, type your ... design requirements that support collaborative VTE prophylaxis teamwork. ... During clinical

Participatory Human-Centered Design

• Objective:– To define design considerations for health IT that

supports cognitive and team work in VTEprophylaxis [interruption/re-initiation]

• Divergence/convergence (Brown, 2009-Design Thinking]

• Local and national experts• Participation of clinical team

membersØSociotechnical system

13

Page 14: A National Web Conference on Reducing Provider Burden ......presentation, type your ... design requirements that support collaborative VTE prophylaxis teamwork. ... During clinical

Sociotechnical Design Considerations for VTE Prophylaxis

focus on interruption & re-initiation Ø 13 categories with 22 specific design considerations:

1. Patient journey 2. Clinical appropriateness 3. Physician teamwork 4. Role clarity 5. Built-in redundancy/error recovery 6. Structure-rounds-shift change 7. Organizational culture 8. Workload 9. Technology access 10. Environment 11. Education of nurses and physicians 12. Education of patients 13. Unit-level monitoring

14

Page 15: A National Web Conference on Reducing Provider Burden ......presentation, type your ... design requirements that support collaborative VTE prophylaxis teamwork. ... During clinical

2. Role network analysis3. Cross-case analysis

Results à Sociotechnical Design Considerations

1. Survey

15

Page 16: A National Web Conference on Reducing Provider Burden ......presentation, type your ... design requirements that support collaborative VTE prophylaxis teamwork. ... During clinical

Who is best able to provide daily assessment of patient need for VTE prophylaxis?

16

Page 17: A National Web Conference on Reducing Provider Burden ......presentation, type your ... design requirements that support collaborative VTE prophylaxis teamwork. ... During clinical

Error recovery Role clarity (resilience)

Sociotechnical Design Considerations

• Need to reduce role ambiguity… but also need for a “second pair of eyes”

• Team configurations and responsibilities

• Automation to monitor and/or suggestinterruption or re-initiation

17

Page 18: A National Web Conference on Reducing Provider Burden ......presentation, type your ... design requirements that support collaborative VTE prophylaxis teamwork. ... During clinical

3. Cross-case analysis

Results à Sociotechnical Design Considerations

1. Survey 2. Role network analysis (Hundt et al., 2017)

18

Page 19: A National Web Conference on Reducing Provider Burden ......presentation, type your ... design requirements that support collaborative VTE prophylaxis teamwork. ... During clinical

Role Network Analysis [Interruption]

GWV-Hospitalist

(Hundt et al., 2017)

GWV-CCM

Activities in blue = performed during multidisciplinary bedside rounds

19

Page 20: A National Web Conference on Reducing Provider Burden ......presentation, type your ... design requirements that support collaborative VTE prophylaxis teamwork. ... During clinical

Sociotechnical Design Considerations

• Need to support teamwork… in particular communication between attendingphysician and proceduralists [technology for teamcommunication]

• Transparent, open organizational culture… anyone can suggest interrupting or re-initiating VTEprophylaxis

• Structure for team discussion and team awareness… checklists and reminders in EHR

20

Page 21: A National Web Conference on Reducing Provider Burden ......presentation, type your ... design requirements that support collaborative VTE prophylaxis teamwork. ... During clinical

1. Survey 2. Role network analysis

Results à Sociotechnical Design Considerations

3. Cross-case analysis

21

Page 22: A National Web Conference on Reducing Provider Burden ......presentation, type your ... design requirements that support collaborative VTE prophylaxis teamwork. ... During clinical

Cross-Case Analysis Cross-case analysis table

[focus on interruption & re-initiation] 11 case reports: 11-25 pages each 1. Contextual information 2. Data on VTE process and

outcomes [survey, observation]

3. Perceptions of and attitudes toward VTE prophylaxis [survey]

4. VTE prophylaxis across the hospital journey [role network analysis]

5. Roles in VTE prophylaxis [survey]

6. VTE-related team interaction during morning rounds [observation]

7. Perceived barriers to VTE prophylaxis [survey]

8. Possible solutions for VTE prophylaxis [survey]

Perspectives: ü Contextual d ata ü Survey data ü Observation data ü Role networks ü Comparing CCM ü Comparing CCS ü Comparing hospitalist

(Miles, Huberman & Saldana, 2014)

22

Page 23: A National Web Conference on Reducing Provider Burden ......presentation, type your ... design requirements that support collaborative VTE prophylaxis teamwork. ... During clinical

Sociotechnical Design Considerations for VTE Prophylaxis

focus on interruption & re-initiation Ø 13 categories with 22 specific design considerations:

1. Patient journey 2. Clinical appropriateness 3. Physician teamwork 4. Role clarity 5. Built-in redundancy/error recovery 6. Structure-rounds-shift change 7. Organizational culture 8. Workload 9. Technology access 10. Environment 11. Education of nurses and physicians 12. Education of patients 13. Unit-level monitoring

23

Page 24: A National Web Conference on Reducing Provider Burden ......presentation, type your ... design requirements that support collaborative VTE prophylaxis teamwork. ... During clinical

e

Sociotechnical Design Considerations for VTE Prophylaxis

focus on interruption & re-initiation Ø 13 categories with 22 specific design considerations:

1. Patient journey 2. Clinical appropriateness 3. Physician teamwork 4. Role clarity 5. Built-in redundancy/error r covery 6. Structure-rounds-shift change 7. Organizational culture 8. Workload 9. Technology access 10. Environment 11. Education of nurses and physicians 12. Education of patients 13. Unit-level monitoring

24

Page 25: A National Web Conference on Reducing Provider Burden ......presentation, type your ... design requirements that support collaborative VTE prophylaxis teamwork. ... During clinical

Sociotechnical Design Considerations for VTE Prophylaxis

focus on interruption & re-initiation Ø 13 categories with 22 specific design considerations:

1. Patient journey 2. Clinical appropriateness 3. Physician teamwork 4. Role clarity 5. Built-in redundancy/error recovery 6. Structure-rounds-shift change 7. Organizational culture 8. Workload 9. Technology access 10. Environment 11. Education of nurses and physicians 12. Education of patients 13. Unit-level monitoring

25

Page 26: A National Web Conference on Reducing Provider Burden ......presentation, type your ... design requirements that support collaborative VTE prophylaxis teamwork. ... During clinical

Sociotechnical Design Considerations for VTE Prophylaxis

focus on interruption & re-initiation Ø 13 categories with 22 specific design considerations:

1. Patient journey 2. Clinical appropriateness 3. Physician teamwork 4. Role clarity 5. Built-in redundancy/error recovery 6. Structure-rounds-shift change 7. Organizational culture 8. Workload 9. Technology access 10. Environment 11. Education of nurses and physicians 12. Education of patients 13. Unit-level monitoring

26

Page 27: A National Web Conference on Reducing Provider Burden ......presentation, type your ... design requirements that support collaborative VTE prophylaxis teamwork. ... During clinical

Sociotechnical Design Considerations for VTE Prophylaxis

focus on interruption & re-initiation Ø 13 categories with 22 specific design considerations:

1. Patient journey 2. Clinical appropriateness 3. Physician teamwork 4. Role clarity 5. Built-in redundancy/error recovery 6. Structure-rounds-shift change 7. Organizational culture 8. Workload 9. Technology access 10. Environment 11. Education of nurses and physicians 12. Education of patients 13. Unit-level monitoring

27

Page 28: A National Web Conference on Reducing Provider Burden ......presentation, type your ... design requirements that support collaborative VTE prophylaxis teamwork. ... During clinical

Sociotechnical Design Considerations for VTE Prophylaxis

focus on interruption & re-initiation Ø 13 categories with 22 specific design considerations:

1. Patient journey 2. Clinical appropriateness 3. Physician teamwork 4. Role clarity 5. Built-in redundancy/error recovery 6. Structure-rounds-shift change 7. Organizational culture 8. Workload 9. Technology access 10. Environment 11. Education of nurses and physicians 12. Education of patients 13. Unit-level monitoring

28

Page 29: A National Web Conference on Reducing Provider Burden ......presentation, type your ... design requirements that support collaborative VTE prophylaxis teamwork. ... During clinical

Sociotechnical Design Considerations for VTE Prophylaxis

focus on interruption & re-initiation Ø 13 categories with 22 specific design considerations:

1. Patient journey 2. Clinical appropriateness 3. Physician teamwork 4. Role clarity 5. Built-in redundancy/error recovery 6. Structure-rounds-shift change 7. Organizational culture 8. Workload 9. Technology access 10. Environment 11. Education of nurses and physicians 12. Education of patients 13. Unit-level monitoring

29

Page 30: A National Web Conference on Reducing Provider Burden ......presentation, type your ... design requirements that support collaborative VTE prophylaxis teamwork. ... During clinical

Sociotechnical Design Considerations for VTE Prophylaxis

focus on interruption & re-initiation Ø 13 categories with 22 specific design considerations:

1. Patient journey 2. Clinical appropriateness 3. Physician teamwork 4. Role clarity 5. Built-in redundancy/error r ecovery 6. Structure-rounds-shift change 7. Organizational culture 8. Workload 9. Technology access 10. Environment 11. Education of nur ses and physicians 12. Education of pa tients 13. Unit-level monitoring

Context matters!

30

Page 31: A National Web Conference on Reducing Provider Burden ......presentation, type your ... design requirements that support collaborative VTE prophylaxis teamwork. ... During clinical

Sociotechnical Design Considerations for Care Process

Ø 13 categories with 22 specific design considerations: 1. Patient journey 2. Clinical appropriateness 3. Physician teamwork 4. Role clarity 5. Built-in redundancy/error r ecovery 6. Structure-rounds-shift change 7. Organizational culture 8. Workload 9. Technology access 10. Environment 11. Education of nur ses and physicians 12. Education of pa tients 13. Unit-level monitoring

ü Sociotechnical system (SEIPS model)

ü Participatory human-centered design

ü Multidisciplinary ü Multiple contexts

31

Page 32: A National Web Conference on Reducing Provider Burden ......presentation, type your ... design requirements that support collaborative VTE prophylaxis teamwork. ... During clinical

Contact Information

Pascale Carayon, PhDWisconsin Institute for Healthcare Systems Engineering

University of Wisconsin-Madison

[email protected]

32

Page 33: A National Web Conference on Reducing Provider Burden ......presentation, type your ... design requirements that support collaborative VTE prophylaxis teamwork. ... During clinical

Quantifying EHR Usability To Improve Clinical WorKflow -

QUICK

Funding support AHRQ R01 2012-2016

Zia Agha, MD Prof . Departmen t o f Medicin e UCSD

CMO and EVP Wes t Health [email protected]

Page 34: A National Web Conference on Reducing Provider Burden ......presentation, type your ... design requirements that support collaborative VTE prophylaxis teamwork. ... During clinical

Aim 1: Measure and compare EMR use patterns.

• EMR usability must be expressed inoperational terms to guide objectivecomparisons.

• We propose to measure and compareclinicians’ use of EMRs during outpatientvisits, based on video recordings, EMR screencapture, and EMR mouse-click and key-clickdata.

34

Page 35: A National Web Conference on Reducing Provider Burden ......presentation, type your ... design requirements that support collaborative VTE prophylaxis teamwork. ... During clinical

Aim 2: Measure and compare clinical workflow and clinician-patient communication.

• During the limited timeframe of an outpatientvisit, clinicians multitask between EMR work andinteraction with patients.

• The complexity of the clinical workflow is notdirectly observable from EMR alone, yet must betaken into account to make meaningfulcomparisons across visits.

• We propose to measure clinician workflow andclinician-patient verbal communication, based onvideo recording of visits and coded to a discreteset of behaviors.

35

Page 36: A National Web Conference on Reducing Provider Burden ......presentation, type your ... design requirements that support collaborative VTE prophylaxis teamwork. ... During clinical

Aim 3: Measure satisfaction and cognitive load.

During clinical encounters, clinicians managemultiple needs that impose an administrativeand cognitive burden. Therefore, we willmeasure cognitive burden via the NASA TaskLoad Index (NASA-TLX), a validated and widelyused tool that enables subjective assessments ofthe workloads associated with those interactingwith human-machine systems.

36

Page 37: A National Web Conference on Reducing Provider Burden ......presentation, type your ... design requirements that support collaborative VTE prophylaxis teamwork. ... During clinical

Aim 4: Explore associations between aims 1, 2, and 3.

• To understand real-world EMR usability, wewill explore associations between EMR usage,workflow, communication, user satisfaction,and cognitive load.

• Additionally, separate analyses will also beconducted to study the effect of sites (UCSDand VA), clinician types (Primary andSpecialty), and EHRs (CPRS and EPIC) onusability and workflow.

37

Page 38: A National Web Conference on Reducing Provider Burden ......presentation, type your ... design requirements that support collaborative VTE prophylaxis teamwork. ... During clinical

Site comparison in terms of care delivery model, staff support, and EHR features.

38

Page 39: A National Web Conference on Reducing Provider Burden ......presentation, type your ... design requirements that support collaborative VTE prophylaxis teamwork. ... During clinical

• Specialties included gastroenterology, pulmonology,cardiology, rheumatology, nephrology.

Recruitment by site and specialty groupings

39*

Page 40: A National Web Conference on Reducing Provider Burden ......presentation, type your ... design requirements that support collaborative VTE prophylaxis teamwork. ... During clinical

Visit process data

Body tracking

Eyetracking

Primary Instruments Secondary Instruments

Mouse + keyboard activity

EHR screen recording

Vocalization + verbal activity

Nonverbal + clinical workflow

Usability SoftwareRoom Video Sensor data

restricted to window of the visit

40

Page 41: A National Web Conference on Reducing Provider Burden ......presentation, type your ... design requirements that support collaborative VTE prophylaxis teamwork. ... During clinical

Figure 1: Visit activity

41

Page 42: A National Web Conference on Reducing Provider Burden ......presentation, type your ... design requirements that support collaborative VTE prophylaxis teamwork. ... During clinical

Summary of data coding quality in terms of intercoder agreement across dual-coded visits.

42

Page 43: A National Web Conference on Reducing Provider Burden ......presentation, type your ... design requirements that support collaborative VTE prophylaxis teamwork. ... During clinical

Comparison of EHR function activity between the two sites based on mouse clicks and timing based on physicians’ gaze-to-EHR.

43

Page 44: A National Web Conference on Reducing Provider Burden ......presentation, type your ... design requirements that support collaborative VTE prophylaxis teamwork. ... During clinical

unid actually group of 9 CPRS tabs

not all behaviors are considered here, will add up to less than 100% of visit duration

EHR Activity + NonVerbal Gaze / Visit

44

Page 45: A National Web Conference on Reducing Provider Burden ......presentation, type your ... design requirements that support collaborative VTE prophylaxis teamwork. ... During clinical

Comparison of CPOE frequency, time-at-task per order and EHR UI burden as measured by numbers of clicks/order

45

Page 46: A National Web Conference on Reducing Provider Burden ......presentation, type your ... design requirements that support collaborative VTE prophylaxis teamwork. ... During clinical

Figure 4

46

Page 47: A National Web Conference on Reducing Provider Burden ......presentation, type your ... design requirements that support collaborative VTE prophylaxis teamwork. ... During clinical

47

Page 48: A National Web Conference on Reducing Provider Burden ......presentation, type your ... design requirements that support collaborative VTE prophylaxis teamwork. ... During clinical

Distribution of navigation across EHR functions. Tab-level transitions based on mouse clicks tagged to the top-level screen or ‘‘Tab” coding.

48

Page 49: A National Web Conference on Reducing Provider Burden ......presentation, type your ... design requirements that support collaborative VTE prophylaxis teamwork. ... During clinical

EHR Navigation patterns for one randomly selected visit foreach study physician, based on mouse click activity human-coded to top-level Tab or EHR screen.

Each colored square represents atransition between major EHR functions or ‘‘Tabs” (e.g., Notes ? Orders).

The number of Tab transitions is shown to the right of each navigation sequence.

49

Page 50: A National Web Conference on Reducing Provider Burden ......presentation, type your ... design requirements that support collaborative VTE prophylaxis teamwork. ... During clinical

Cognitive load ratings and rank orders - NASA TLX

50

Page 51: A National Web Conference on Reducing Provider Burden ......presentation, type your ... design requirements that support collaborative VTE prophylaxis teamwork. ... During clinical

Gender in NASA TLX

52

Page 52: A National Web Conference on Reducing Provider Burden ......presentation, type your ... design requirements that support collaborative VTE prophylaxis teamwork. ... During clinical

Correlation of CPOE activity and effort rating on TLX

53

Page 53: A National Web Conference on Reducing Provider Burden ......presentation, type your ... design requirements that support collaborative VTE prophylaxis teamwork. ... During clinical

Figure 5

54

Page 54: A National Web Conference on Reducing Provider Burden ......presentation, type your ... design requirements that support collaborative VTE prophylaxis teamwork. ... During clinical

Summary

We demonstrated a novel approach to collecting and analyzing multiplesources of data during clinical activities and integrated these streams intomeaningful measures, enabling comparison across two clinical settingswith different EHRs and a spectrum of primary and specialty (outpatient) care.

This effort revealed a high degree of variation in observed activity andclinical practice despite accounting for similar types of visits and patientcomplexity.

We identified similar patterns of EHR use and navigation at the 2 sitesdespite differences in functions, user interface, and consequent codedrepresentation.

Both sites displayed remarkably high burden (frequency and time at task)to attended to EHRs along with high subjective workload as measured byNASA Task Load survey.

55

Page 55: A National Web Conference on Reducing Provider Burden ......presentation, type your ... design requirements that support collaborative VTE prophylaxis teamwork. ... During clinical

Summary

Commonly noted high-level clinical tasks, such as medicationreconciliation or preventive care were highly distributedacross the visits and very difficult to measure, suggesting theneed for further levels of integration.

Preliminary workload analyses suggested a complexrelationship between levels of measurable physicians’ activityduring visits and perceptions of effort and task performance.

As no single visit activity factor was highly correlated with subjective task load, a fuller understanding of the workflowand cognitive flow will require integration of qualitative data,e.g., physician interviews.

56

Page 56: A National Web Conference on Reducing Provider Burden ......presentation, type your ... design requirements that support collaborative VTE prophylaxis teamwork. ... During clinical

QUICK Team

Zia Agha, MD - West Health / UCSD

Shazia Ashfaq, MD - VMRF / VASDHS

Lin Liu, PhD - VMRF / UCSD

Charlene Weir, PhD - University of Utah

Kai Zheng, PhD - University of Michigan

Mark T. Gabuzda, MD - VASDHS / UCSD

Braj B. Pandey, MD - VASDHS / UCSD

Robert El-Kareh, MD - UCSD

Jing Zhang, MS - UCSD

Kellie Avery, BS - VMRF

Alan Calvitti, PhD - VASDHS

Steven Rick, BS - VMRF / UCSD

Neil Farber, MD - UCSD

Harry S. Hochheiser, PhD - University of Pittsburgh

Nadir Weibel, PhD - UCSD

Kristin Bell, MD - VASDHS / UCSD

Richard Street, PhD - Texas A&M

Yunan Chen , PhD - UCI

Sara Mortensen, BS - VMRF

Elizabeth Kang - VMRF / UCSD

57

Page 57: A National Web Conference on Reducing Provider Burden ......presentation, type your ... design requirements that support collaborative VTE prophylaxis teamwork. ... During clinical

Contact Information

Zia Agha, MD

Prof . Departmen t o f Medicin e UCSD CMO and EVP Wes t Health

[email protected]

58

Page 58: A National Web Conference on Reducing Provider Burden ......presentation, type your ... design requirements that support collaborative VTE prophylaxis teamwork. ... During clinical

Reducing Provider Burden through BetterHealth IT Design – Part 3

Providers’ Interaction with EHRs

Lukasz Mazur, PhD

Division of Healthcare Engineering, University ofNorth Carolina, Chapel Hill, NC

Page 59: A National Web Conference on Reducing Provider Burden ......presentation, type your ... design requirements that support collaborative VTE prophylaxis teamwork. ... During clinical

Acknowledgment

• Federal Project Officer: Steve Bernstein, AHRQ, CEPI, Division of Health IT

• Grant Number: R21HS024062 • Co-PI: Carlton Moore MD, Lawrence Marks, MD • Investigator: Prithima Mosaly, PhD • UNC Epic consultant: Amy Coghill, MSN, RN, OCN

• This study was supported by the grant from the Agency forHealthcare Research and Quality. The content is solely theresponsibility of the authors and does not necessarily represent theofficial views of the Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality.

Acknowledgment: Dr. Donald Spencer, Professor; Vice President andChief Medical Informatics Officer, UNC Health Care.

60

Page 60: A National Web Conference on Reducing Provider Burden ......presentation, type your ... design requirements that support collaborative VTE prophylaxis teamwork. ... During clinical

Health IT and Patient SBuilding Safer Systems fo

afetyr Better Care

• Health IT can improve patient safety and quality of care and should be widely embraced (Bates 2003; Ash 2009).

• For example, Hill (2013) found that providers seeing (on average per hour) 2.4 patients require about 4,000 mouse-clicks in EHRs during a 10-hour shift.

• Reports focused on EHR-related medical malpractice identified over 80% of the reported events involve patient harm (Garber 2015).

61

Page 61: A National Web Conference on Reducing Provider Burden ......presentation, type your ... design requirements that support collaborative VTE prophylaxis teamwork. ... During clinical

Workflow and communications 24% (high/variable workload)

Usability 33%

Actions 6%

Policies & procedures 6%

Harm

The Joint Commission Report on EHR-related errors (n=120)

A complimentary publication of The Joint Commission Issue 54, March 31, 2015 62

Page 62: A National Web Conference on Reducing Provider Burden ......presentation, type your ... design requirements that support collaborative VTE prophylaxis teamwork. ... During clinical

Specific Aims

To quantify the effect of: • EMR environment (baseline/enhanced)• Volume (low/high) of abnormal test resultson providers’ experienced task demands, workload, and performance.

Our focus was on follow-up of abnormal test results, and the baseline and enhanced EMR environment used for the study was Epic®.

63

Page 63: A National Web Conference on Reducing Provider Burden ......presentation, type your ... design requirements that support collaborative VTE prophylaxis teamwork. ... During clinical

Background and Significance

• Clinicians fail to acknowledge over one-third of the

EHR alerts for critically abnormal imaging studies

(Singh 2007).

• Even when providers acknowledge abnormal results,

7-10% of patients still do not receive timely follow-up (Singh 2009; Hysong 2010, 2011).

• The likelihood for lack of timely follow-up doubleswith dual-alert communication in which providers

receive abnormal results for other providers’ patients

(Zapka 2010).

64

Page 64: A National Web Conference on Reducing Provider Burden ......presentation, type your ... design requirements that support collaborative VTE prophylaxis teamwork. ... During clinical

Human Factors Laboratory • VisionTrack ISCAN• Tobii X-60• SMI glasses• BrainVision • ABM EEG • NeXus

• Epic Playground• Mosaiq• PLUNC• Elekta Emulator

• Computers• Printers• Phones

65

Page 65: A National Web Conference on Reducing Provider Burden ......presentation, type your ... design requirements that support collaborative VTE prophylaxis teamwork. ... During clinical

Study Participants

Total of 38 residentsfrom the school ofmedicine at one largeacademic institutionparticipated in thisstudy, all withsufficient experiencewith EHR (Epic) asrelated to oursimulated scenarios

Specialty # of Participants

Post Graduate Year (PGY) PGY: count

Gender F: female;M: Male

1:4 2:2 3:5 4:3

Internal Medicine 14 F:9 M:5

1:1 2:1 3:1 4:1

Family Medicine 4F:2 M:2

1:3 2:2 3:4 4:0

Pediatrics 9F:7 M:2

1:1 2:2 3:0 4:1 5:1

Surgery (general, neuro, ortho, head

& neck)5

F:3 M:2

1:1 2:1 3:1 4:2 5:1

Other (cardiology, psychiatry, critical care, ob/gyn)

6F:3 M:3

1:10 2:08 3:11 4:06 5:03

Total 38 F:24 M:14

66

Page 66: A National Web Conference on Reducing Provider Burden ......presentation, type your ... design requirements that support collaborative VTE prophylaxis teamwork. ... During clinical

Study Design

Randomize

Providers(n=38)

Recognition of Abnormal

Results

Recognition of Abnormal

Results

Track & Follow-up on Planned

Diagnostic Evaluation

Session 1:Current Epic Environment

Session 2:Current (n=20) vs. Enhanced (n=18)

Epic Environment

Low vs. High volume of abnormal test results

67

Page 67: A National Web Conference on Reducing Provider Burden ......presentation, type your ... design requirements that support collaborative VTE prophylaxis teamwork. ... During clinical

68

Page 68: A National Web Conference on Reducing Provider Burden ......presentation, type your ... design requirements that support collaborative VTE prophylaxis teamwork. ... During clinical

69

Page 69: A National Web Conference on Reducing Provider Burden ......presentation, type your ... design requirements that support collaborative VTE prophylaxis teamwork. ... During clinical

Planning Sheets

75 master patients; 12 reserved provider logins; 175 hours to plan, build, test (about 5 weeks)

70

Page 70: A National Web Conference on Reducing Provider Burden ......presentation, type your ... design requirements that support collaborative VTE prophylaxis teamwork. ... During clinical

Current Epic Design

71

Page 71: A National Web Conference on Reducing Provider Burden ......presentation, type your ... design requirements that support collaborative VTE prophylaxis teamwork. ... During clinical

Enhanced Epic Design

Singh H, Spitzmueller C, Petersen NJ, et al. Primary care practitioners' views on test result management in EHR-enabled health systems: a national survey. J Am Med Inform Assoc 2013;20:727-735. 72

Page 72: A National Web Conference on Reducing Provider Burden ......presentation, type your ... design requirements that support collaborative VTE prophylaxis teamwork. ... During clinical

Data Collection

Experienced task demands:– navigation clicks (e.g., moving from one window

to another window on the screen, etc.),– decision clicks (e.g., accepting/cancelling a test or

medication, etc.),– search clicks (e.g., initiating the search option for

medications/orders/etc.),– total clicks (sum of navigation, decision, and

search clicks).

73

Page 73: A National Web Conference on Reducing Provider Burden ......presentation, type your ... design requirements that support collaborative VTE prophylaxis teamwork. ... During clinical

Data Collection

Quantification of perceived workload • NASA-Task Load

Index (NASA-TLX), a widely applied and valid tool, was used to measure perceived workload.

74

Page 74: A National Web Conference on Reducing Provider Burden ......presentation, type your ... design requirements that support collaborative VTE prophylaxis teamwork. ... During clinical

Data Collection

Quantification of physiological workload – eye tracking– electroencephalography [EEG]

75

Page 75: A National Web Conference on Reducing Provider Burden ......presentation, type your ... design requirements that support collaborative VTE prophylaxis teamwork. ... During clinical

Data Collection

Quantification of physiological workload– eye tracking• Tobii X2-60, 60Hz remote eye tracker and Eyeworks

data recording software.

• baseline measures, task-evoked pupillary response(TEPR) and blink rate (Mosaly 2017).

– electroencephalography [EEG]• X-10 wireless EEG headset system from Advanced Brain

Monitoring (ABM)

• bi-polar sensor sites: Fz, F3, F4, Cz, C3, C4, POz, P3, P4.

76

Page 76: A National Web Conference on Reducing Provider Burden ......presentation, type your ... design requirements that support collaborative VTE prophylaxis teamwork. ... During clinical

Data Collection

• Quantification of performance– unacknowledged abnormal test results (identified

by failure to order a referral, medication oradditional testing)

– unacknowledged patients with ‘no-show’ statusfor their scheduled appointments (identified byfailure to follow up with ‘no-show’ patients)

– total amount of time that participants took tocomplete each session.

77

Page 77: A National Web Conference on Reducing Provider Burden ......presentation, type your ... design requirements that support collaborative VTE prophylaxis teamwork. ... During clinical

Data Analysis

• Multivariable analysis of variance– Pooled data (all results combined)

– Abnormal vs. ‘no-show’

• Participants as a random factor.

• All our data analyses were conducted using JMP 13software with significance level set at 0.05(normality: all p>0.05; equal variance: all p>0.05;suitable for parametric analysis).

78

Page 78: A National Web Conference on Reducing Provider Burden ......presentation, type your ... design requirements that support collaborative VTE prophylaxis teamwork. ... During clinical

Results – Task Demands - Pooled data

• High-volume of abnormal test results generatedsignificantly more total clicks when compared to thelow-volume of abnormal test results condition(p<.01).

Current-EMR(Low-volume)

Current-EMR(High-volume)

Task Demands (average per scenario)

Enhanced -EMR(Low-volume)

Enhanced-EMR(High-volume)

390(91) 496(110) Total Clicks (count) † 396(83) 479(118)

223(73) 276(76) Navigation Clicks (count) 239(75) 286(78)

120(22) 155(29) Decision Clicks (count) 106(25) 124(47)

46(17) 63(14) Search Clicks (count) 51(18) 69(24)

79

Page 79: A National Web Conference on Reducing Provider Burden ......presentation, type your ... design requirements that support collaborative VTE prophylaxis teamwork. ... During clinical

Results – Task Demands - Abnormal vs. No-show

Current-EMR(Abnormal)

Current-EMR(No-Show)

Task Demands(average per result)

Enhanced -EMR(Abnormal)

Enhanced-EMR(No-Show)

33(11) 28 (12) Total Clicks (count) † 31(12) 21(9)

17(7) 15(7) Navigation Clicks (count) † 16(6) 11(5)

5(2) 4(2) Decision Clicks (count) 5(3) 3(2)

11(4) 9(5) Search Clicks (count) † 9(2) 6(4)

• Enhanced-EMR, specifically for patients with

‘no-show’ status, indicated lower task demands

as quantified by total, navigation, and search

clicks (p<.01).

80

Page 80: A National Web Conference on Reducing Provider Burden ......presentation, type your ... design requirements that support collaborative VTE prophylaxis teamwork. ... During clinical

Results – Subjective Workload- Pooled data

• Analysis of NASA-TLX scores indicated no significant differences (p>.05).

• NASA-TLX > 55 are associated with degradation in performance (Hart, 2006; Mazur, 2013, 2016).

Current-EMR(Low-volume)

Current-EMR(High-volume) NASA-TLX Enhanced -EMR

(Low-volume)Enhanced-EMR(High-volume)

48(15) 58(13) NASA-TLX (0=low to 100=high) 49(18) 49(13)

81

Page 81: A National Web Conference on Reducing Provider Burden ......presentation, type your ... design requirements that support collaborative VTE prophylaxis teamwork. ... During clinical

• On average, human eye blinks 20-25/minute.• Blink rate was significantly lower in the current-EMR

(p=.01), suggesting higher mental workload (Mosaly2017).

Current-EMR(Low-volume)

Current-EMR(High-volume) Physiological Workload Enhanced -EMR

(Low-volume)Enhanced-EMR(High-volume)

15(9) 17(7) Blink Rate (blinks/minute) 24(10) 22(6)

Results – Physiological Workload- Pooled data

82

Page 82: A National Web Conference on Reducing Provider Burden ......presentation, type your ... design requirements that support collaborative VTE prophylaxis teamwork. ... During clinical

Results – Physiological Workload- Abnormal vs. No-show

• Blink rate was significantly lower in the current-EMR, specifically for ‘no-show’ (p<.01) patients, suggesting higher mental workload.

• Power of Fz (6-7Hz) – Pz (8-10 Hz) was significantly less in enhanced-EMR, specifically for ‘no-show’ patients (p=.02), suggesting ‘less optimal’ information processing efficiency (Klimesh, 1999).

Current-EMR(Abnormal)

Current-EMR(No-show) Physiological Workload Enhanced-EMR

(Abnormal)Enhanced-EMR

(No-show)

18(9) 18(9) Blink Rate (blinks/minute) † 19(9) 24(11)

0.8(0.4) 0.7(0.4) Power of Fz (6-7 Hz) - Pz (8-10 Hz) (!"#)† 0.9(0.6) 0.9(0.7)

83

Page 83: A National Web Conference on Reducing Provider Burden ......presentation, type your ... design requirements that support collaborative VTE prophylaxis teamwork. ... During clinical

Results – Performance

• Significant improvement in performance in the enhanced-EMR (p<.01).• Significant longer time to complete scenarios in the high-volume of abnormal

test results condition (p<.01).• Significant less time to process patients with abnormal test results in the

enhanced-EMR (p<.01), specifically with no-show status (p<.01).

Current-EMR(Low-volume)

Current-EMR(High-volume)

Enhanced -EMR(Low-volume)

Enhanced-EMR(High-volume)Performance

Clinical Performance†-missed abnormal results

-missed to follow-up on ‘no-shows’2

156

170 2

1 4

26:12(7:48) 37:18(10:24) Time-to-complete (min) † 28:54(6:12) 34:12(12:06)

Abnormal results only:Time to Scenario Completion (min:sec) †2:20(0:58) 2:42(1:00) 2:25(0:49) 2:30(1:12)

‘No-show’ results only:Time to Scenario Completion (min:sec) †1:48(0:36) 2:06(1:13) 1:36(0:48) 1:25(0:46)

84

Page 84: A National Web Conference on Reducing Provider Burden ......presentation, type your ... design requirements that support collaborative VTE prophylaxis teamwork. ... During clinical

Reducing Provider’s Burden- Abnormal & No-Show

(n = results)Performance

(total # of errors)Task

Demand(total clicks)

Average Time to Complete a Result

(min:sec)

Enhanced EMR(n=189) 0 23 1:51

Current EMR(n=210) 0 32 2:27

+9 clicks+36 sec

Given 50 results per interaction: 450 clicks and 30 min!

85

Page 85: A National Web Conference on Reducing Provider Burden ......presentation, type your ... design requirements that support collaborative VTE prophylaxis teamwork. ... During clinical

Conclusions

• Need to ‘optimally’ design features of the EMR to focus providers attention on:– i) abnormal test results– ii) patients’ status, both with enough detail to facilitate (or

not facilitate) appropriate follow-up communications.

• Develop and publicize policies and guidelines regarding work practices and demands to ensure appropriate levels of workload and performance.

• Innovative education/training requirements (e.g., simulation based training vs. traditional training) and performance feedback systems could be organized and implemented (Mazur 2017).

http://www.ihi.org/resources/Pages/Publications/Closing-the-Loop-A-Guide-to-Safer-Ambulatory-Referrals.aspx 86

Page 86: A National Web Conference on Reducing Provider Burden ......presentation, type your ... design requirements that support collaborative VTE prophylaxis teamwork. ... During clinical

87

Page 87: A National Web Conference on Reducing Provider Burden ......presentation, type your ... design requirements that support collaborative VTE prophylaxis teamwork. ... During clinical

Limitations

• One experiment with relatively small number of participants from one teaching hospital, performed on set of scenarios.

• Time between simulated sessions varied from 1 to 3 weeks, which could have unexpectedly bias the study due to some carryover effects between sessions.

• Day and time of the day to conduct assessments varied, which could have also affected the results.

• Simulated environment, where the subjects knew that their work was going to be assessed, may have affected participants’ performance.

• Reporting workload via NASA-TLX is subjective and can be challenging for some participants.

• Quantification methods of physiological workload, while validated and broadly used, may not fully considered potential confounding factors streaming from cognitive information processing or general cognitive states.

88

Page 88: A National Web Conference on Reducing Provider Burden ......presentation, type your ... design requirements that support collaborative VTE prophylaxis teamwork. ... During clinical

Contact Information

Lukasz Mazur, PhDDivision of Healthcare Engineering

University of North Carolina, Chapel [email protected]

89

Page 89: A National Web Conference on Reducing Provider Burden ......presentation, type your ... design requirements that support collaborative VTE prophylaxis teamwork. ... During clinical

Questions

Page 90: A National Web Conference on Reducing Provider Burden ......presentation, type your ... design requirements that support collaborative VTE prophylaxis teamwork. ... During clinical

How to Submit a Question

• At any time during the presentation, type your question into the “Q&A” section of your WebEx Q&A panel.

• Please address your questions to “All Panelists” in the drop-down menu.

• Select “Send” to submit your question to the moderator.

• Questions will be read aloud by the moderator.

91

Page 91: A National Web Conference on Reducing Provider Burden ......presentation, type your ... design requirements that support collaborative VTE prophylaxis teamwork. ... During clinical

92

Obtaining CME/CE Credits

If you would like to receive continuing education credit for this activity, please visit:

https://ahrq.cds.pesgce.com