a metal hydride as a means of energy storage in a canal boat
TRANSCRIPT
A Metal Hydride As A Means Of Energy
Storage In A Canal Boat Alex Bevan, David Book, Andreas Züttel and Rex Harris,
Department of Metallurgy and Materials
University of Birmingham, UK and EMPA, Switzerland
Alex Bevan & Rex Harris
7th February 2012
Structure of Talk
Background to the project
The boat design
Converting the boat
Details of the system
Preliminary operational data
Future developments
Conclusions
Why a canal boat ?
Water based transport is inherently efficient
High speeds are not required
The weight and volume of the hydrogen store
are small fractions of the total weight and
volume of the vessel
The weight and volume of the store can be
compensated by the removal of existing ballast
and diesel engine
The canal boat also offered an ideal
opportunity to incorporate not only
hydrogen/ fuel cell technology but also
NdFeB permanent magnet systems.
Thus the project covered the two main
areas of research of the Birmingham
group.
Also the canal runs through the heart
of the University campus
From the 1760s onwards, a large network of
canals were built across Birmingham and the
Black Country, to transport raw materials and
finished goods.
By the 1820s an extensive canal system had
been constructed; Birmingham is often
described as having more miles of canals than
Venice. Nationwide today there still exists
2,000 miles of canal network which is primary
used for the leisure industry.
Canals in Birmingham (UK)
Boat Schematic
Solid-state
Hydrogen Store
1kW PEM
Fuel Cell
‘Brushed’
Motor
Lead-Acid
Batteries
Sealed
bulkhead
wall
Seating and Passenger Area
16 m length
H2 sensor =
Ventilation = Drive-by-wire
propeller
Weight ~12 tonnes
PEM
1kW
FUEL CELL
NdFeB
Steering motor
(Brushless)
Rudder
Converting the boat
• 8 large cylinders, each containing 30 kg of metal hydride power.
• Gives about 4 kg of hydrogen.
• Operating pressure is < 10 bar
PEM Fuel Cell Batteries & Motor
www.hydrogen.bham.ac.uk
Propulsion unit
Why use a PM-Electric motor?
BrushedDC
Induction PM SR
SpecificTorque
13.5 7.4 23.7 6.4
RelativeWeight
2100 50 25 40
Efficiency 78% 84% 90% 85%
RelativeCost
2100 100 150 150
Cost and Performance Comparison
Comments: •Highly influenced by size ( particularly torque and
efficiency figures)
•Costs based on potential costs rather than current
1- Torque per unit stator
volume (kNm/m3) 2- Brushed DC machine = 100 3- Overall efficiency of motor
and power electronics
Source: J.G. West - IEE Power Division
Colloquium Digest 1993/080
Original engine
Two cylinder diesel internal combustion engine
Drive belt
Motor
Propeller
shaft
Permanent Magnet Drive Motor
Motor housing
Permanent magnets
Motor windings
& commutator
The motor is designed by the Lynch motor company based on a
brushed 4 quadrant axial flux motor, giving a power output of 10 kW
or 13 hp with a max efficiency of 89%
Hydrogen is also used in the
manufacture of the magnets
There is also the possibility of
using hydrogen to recycle the
magnets after use.
Possible Recycling Routes for
NdFeB-type Magnets
Scrap
Magnets
HD / Degas HDDR
LPPS
Zn Coating
Polymer Bonded
Magnets
Hot Pressed
Magnets
Blend with
Fresh Powder
Sintered
Magnets
The steering system also employs
NdFeB magnets
Steer By Wire Actuator Joystick
Actuator
Tiller
Hydrogen Storage
Andreas Züttel, Switzerland, 6/22/2014 2
6
HYDROGEN ABSORPTION IN METALS
Hydrogen & metal Physisorption Chemisorption
Subsurface hydrogen Solid solution (a-phase) Hydride (b-phase)
Pressure composition isotherms
• where α- & β-phases co-exist, a plateau occurs
• plateau pressure is temperature dependent
Andreas Züttel, Switzerland, 6/22/2014 2
8
HYDROGEN DENSITY
Ref: A. Züttel, “Materials for hydrogen storage”, materialstoday, Septemper (2003), pp. 18-27
Hcov H-
H2
Characterisation of storage
alloy
TiMn2-Based alloy used
Prepared and crushed to 0-10mm
Ti0.93Zr0.05(Mn0.73V0.22Fe0.04)2
Composition
TiMn-Based alloy after cycling
(30 cycles)
Particle size reduced to ~30um
A very important characteristic
for the material is its ability to be
cycled with out loss of capacity
or kinetics
0
5000
10000
15000
20000
25000
30000
0 0.5 1 1.5 2
wt%
Pre
ss
ure
(m
ba
r)
Cycling storage materials
Cycling system, based on a
volumetric system which is
equipped with automated valves
allowing pressure cycling of the
alloy and PCT measurement.
Room temperature PCT
measurement on boat
alloy
Cycling behavior in normal
industrial grade hydrogen
Cycling of Ti0.93Zr0.05(Mn0.73V0.22Fe0.04)2
Pressure cycling
between 20 and 1 bar
No noticeable change
in cyclic behaviour
was noticed up to
600 cycles
Cycling performance
Store Design
Valve
Filter and manifold
Fuel
cell Gas
distribution
Hydride store design
Modular design
incorporating 6
horizontal stainless steel
tubes per module with a
water cooling/ heating
jacket
Moto
r
Ti0.93Zr0.05(Mn0.73V0.22Fe0.04)2
Heat exchanger
Water pump (1)
Water pump (2)
Water filter
Heat exchange with canal water
Heat exchanger
Canal
water in
Water pump (1) Filter
Water pump (2)
Expansion
tank
Canal
water out
Hydride
modules
Antifreeze
Canal temperature
16°C September
13°C October
8°C December
3°C January
Hydrogen Recharging Hydrogen charging vs. time
Procedure 1) Connect exterior hydrogen
supply at 20Bar
2) Manually open a number of
valves
3) Follow computer controlled
filling procedure
0
1000
2000
3000
4000
5000
6000
0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7
Time (Hours)
Hyd
rog
en
Flo
we
d (
Ltr
s)
Static water With water cooling flow
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7
Time (Hours)
Wate
r te
mp
era
ture
(C
els
ius)
Static water With water cooling flow
Hydrogen Charging: Large scale
The stored hydrogen is used to
power a PEM fuel cell
Air
Air + Water
Hydrogen
Hydrogen
+ -
Anode Cathode
Membrane
Electrical Load
H2 2 H+ + 2 e- O2+ 4H+ + 4e- 2H2O
Electron Flow
Proton Flow
Anode Reaction Cathode Reaction
PEM Fuel Cell
The Air cooled 1kW Reli-On PEM fuel cell
with 8 removable modules
Do we need a hybrid system?
Why batteries?
Provide a power source for the fuel cell to start up
Require peak currents higher that current fuel cell capacity
Can cope with variable electrical loads
Need somewhere to dump electrical loads (back emf)
Security, providing no loss of motive power for potential
fuel cell/ hydrogen store problems
Require battery power for long tunnels, as it might be
necessary for the fuel cell to be shut down to prevent venting
of hydrogen into tunnel
Initial running trials
Some well known faces on the
Ross Barlow
Dame Ellen MacArthur Bill Giles O.B.E
Speed, distance Vs. Motor Performance
0.00
2.00
4.00
6.00
8.00
10.00
12.00
14.00
0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7
Speed (kph)
Mo
tor
po
wer
(kW
)
0
50
100
150
200
250
300
350
1.5 2.5 3.5 4.5 5.5 6.5 7.5
Speed (kph)
Bo
at
ran
ge (
km
)
Battery power
Battery power + Hydrogen store
Based on 2.5kgs of hydrogen
Some important questions to be answered:
• What is the lifetime of the hydride store?
• How do the hydrogen charging and discharging kinetics
vary with cycle numbers?
• What is the lifetime of the PEM fuel cell?
• How does the performance of the fuel cell vary with time?
• What are the real costs of converting the boat to a
hybrid/electric system?
• What is the cost of “green” hydrogen?
It is possible to “up-scale” this
technology
A very large scale marine
application for metal hydride/ PEM/
PM motor.
A large scale marine application also using a PM motor, a
PEM fuel cell and metal hydride store
HDW, Shipyard/ Germany
In this case storing around
one tonne of hydrogen in 50
tonnes of metal hydide
Why call the boat the
Ross Barlow ?
In memory of Ross Barlow. PhD student in the Hydrogen Materials Group,
Metallurgy and Materials. 1st November 1979 - 13th March 2005
Ross Barlow was a postgraduate student
who worked on the Protium project in the
early stages of its development. He was
an enthusiastic supporter of all things
sustainable. Tragically, he died in a hang
gliding accident in March 2005 at the age
of 25. With the strong support of his
family we named the boat after him, as a
lasting tribute to a remarkable young man.
Other Hydride
Applications
Uninterruptible/ remote power
supplies
Fuel cell
Control system
Hybrid Fuel cell battery power
supply for remote equipment.
Control system designed using
microcontrollers to monitor
battery voltage, current usage
and control fuel cell to optimise
battery recharging and extend
running duration of equipment.
Store designed with an AB5
material, packed with a thermal
ballast material.
Hydrogen reggae
26th February 2009
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=n1pnNErpu-I
Hydrogen BBQ
Hydrogen recovery
Bio-Reactor
Hydride Store
Drying column
Chiller
0
200
400
600
800
1000
1200
1400
1600
-15 -10 -5 0 5 10 15 20 25
Temperature (C)
Pre
ss
ure
(m
ba
r)
Absorption
Desorption
LaNi5-Based
material
Cooling jacket
Cooling In
Cooling Out
Filter
Isolation valve Isolation valve
Gas
In/Out Purge line
Store design, loaded with LaNi5 based material
Cooled to -3ºC for absorption, warmed to 12ºC for desorption
High pressure storage
Applications – High pressure hydride Hybrid hydrogen storage vessel
Carbon fibre or Aluminium
(depending on pressure)
0
10000
20000
30000
40000
50000
60000
70000
0 0.5 1 1.5 2 2.5
wt%
Pre
ss
ure
(m
ba
r) -5C
0C
10C
20C
30C
Developing new Ti-V-Mn based alloys
• Hydrogen capacity (wt%) similar to state-of-the-art
• Can operate at high pressures
• Reduced hysteresis
• Indication that they are easier to activate
Metal Hydride Compressor
Two stage design with independent water cooling/ heating for each stage
Development of a hydride compressor
Applications
Hydrogen filling stations
Boosting hydrogen pressure from electrolysers
Hydrogen recovery (possibly deuterium)
Delivering hydrogen at a pressure beyond that
commercially available for lab scale applications
Possible advantages compared to a
mechanical compressor
Higher efficiency
Low noise
Higher reliability due to fewer moving parts
Extremely high purity hydrogen can be
delivered
High delivery pressures are possible
The long term sustainable solution
Electrolysis
The splitting of H2O using an electrolyser
- The purified water is split into oxygen and hydrogen by electrolysis using electricity generated from a biomass reactor.
Vents
Stacks
H2/O2
Electrolyser
Production of hydrogen through electrolysis with clean electricity
Hydrogen from Renewables
Load Matching
• Energy storage is needed (to balance varying supply with varying demand)
S u r p lu s D e f i c i t
Power
Time
Demand
RE Supply
Storage
Hydrogen
Flywheels
Super capacitors
Batteries
0
5000
10000
15000
20000
25000
30000
0 0.5 1 1.5 2
wt%
Pre
ss
ure
(m
ba
r)
Hydrogen
Fuel station of the future
Thank you for your attention
Acknowledgments
Advantage West Midlands
Beacon Energy Ltd
Black Country Housing Association
BOC Ltd
British Waterways
Bryte Energy
EMPA Switzerland
European Commission
Less Common Metals
Martineau Johnson
Proto Systems
SHEC/EPSRC
Solar Boat Company
Tempus
TRW Birmingham
University of Birmingham
University of Sheffield
and the following individuals:
Mr Michael Rawlinson
Mr John McConnell
Mrs Jane Tyler
Professor Rex Harris
Professor Ian Dillamore
David Book, Lydia Pickering, Allan Walton, Dan
Reed, John Turner, Malik Degri and Rex Harris
Some final thoughts…
60 million people in the UK
produce more CO2 than the 472
million living in Egypt, Nigeria,
Pakistan and Vietnam combined
The people who came before us didn’t
know about climate change and the
ones who come after us will be
powerless to stop it. Frannay Armstrong
Film: The Age of Stupid
A final sobering statistic…
From the start and finish of this
talk the world has consumed
around 2.4 million barrels of oil