a highly sensitive and quantitative ... - cellmax life...1. r&d, cellmax life, sunnyvale, ca, united...

1
A HIGHLY SENSITIVE AND QUANTITATIVE MULTIMODAL BLOOD TEST FOR THE DETECTION OF COLORECTAL ADENOMAS AND CANCER Friedland, Shai 2 ; Watson, Drew 1 ; Pan, Jennifer Y. 2 ; Chen, Yu 2 ; Nimgaonkar, Ashish 3 ; Gulzar, Zulfiqar 1 ; Gupta, Pratyush 1 ; Lucas, Julian 1 ; Atkins, Alex 1 ; Lai, Jr-Ming 1 ; Hsieh, Huangpin B. 1 ; Su, Stephen 1 ; Lim, Austin 1 ; Chu, Iris 1 ; Setthasap, Ploy 1 ; Sninsky, John 1 ; Mei, Rui 1 1. R&D, CellMax Life, Sunnyvale, CA, United States. 2. Veteran Administration Health Center, Palo Alto, CA, United States. 3. The Johns Hopkins Hospital, Baltimore, MD, United States BACKGROUND Colorectal cancer is among the most preventable cancers when detected early, yet, it is the second leading cancer killer in the U.S. There are 50,000 colorectal cancer (CRC) deaths per year in the U.S., many of which can be aributed to one- third of eligible Americans not following recommended screening guidelines. New guidelines from the American Cancer Society recommend screening for CRC starng at age 45, down from age 50. This means that 20 million Americans from the age of 45 to 50 are newly eligible for tesng. Even so, an overwhelming 39 million Americans of the eligible 112 million in the 50-plus age group have never been tested. The two objecves of screening are early detecon and prevenon of CRC through removal of adenomas using colonoscopy. FDA-approved stool tests have poor compliance and low sensivity for detecon of advanced adenomas (24-42%) and non-advanced adenomas (8-17%). As colorectal adenomas account for 98% of aconable colonoscopies [Fig.1], there is an unmet need for a highly sensive non-invasive test for colorectal adenoma detecon. The new understanding of the natural history of adenomas and CRC informs integraon of clinically relevant biomarkers for detecon of CRC and adenomas with a blood test [Fig.2]. We have conducted a prospecve U.S. clinical study, Zenith, to assess a highly sensive mulmodal blood test based on proprietary technologies detecng pre-cancer and cancer markers in a sample of blood. RESULTS The test achieved 90% specificity, with sensivity of 100% (95% CI: 71.5%-100%) and 76% (95% CI: 61.7%-86.2%) for detecon of CRC and AA, respecvely [Fig. 4]. Univariate and mulvariate logisc regressions demonstrated that each biomarker contributes significant independent informaon to the Score. Ordinal logisc regression demonstrated significant associaon between the quantave Score and disease severity (Likelihood rao p-value < 0.0001). Furthermore, the Score correlated with the size of the index adenomas. In paents with elevated Scores but with non-AA or negave colonoscopy clinical results, a chart review of paent histories revealed prior history of AA removal in several cases [Fig. 5], suggesng that a higher specificity can potenally be achieved by excluding paents with a prior history of AA, and that some cellular and molecular changes detected by the assay persist even aſter removal of those advanced adenomas. METHODS AND STUDY DESIGN A single-center, IRB-approved, prospecve, blinded study was conducted at the Veterans Affairs Palo Alto Health Care System [Fig.3]. Interim results for 354 paents with no prior diagnosis of CRC who were scheduled for colonoscopy are presented. Indicaons for colonoscopy were 86% asymptomac and 14% with symptoms or posive-FIT. Paents had blood drawn immediately prior to colonoscopy. The test analyzes three biomarkers: circulang gastrointesnal epithelial cells, somac mutaons and methylaon of cell-free DNA. A quantave age- and gender-adjusted composite CMx Score (Score) scaled from 0 to 100 was developed using ordinal and nominal logisc regression and bootstrapping methods. CONCLUSIONS A novel noninvasive blood-based assay that analyzes cell-free DNA and circulang gastrointesnal epithelial cells, and integrates expected incidence rates can detect colorectal adenomas and cancer. Compared with FDA-approved tests, the FirstSight blood test significantly improves the sensivity for advanced and non-advanced adenomas with high specificity [Fig.6]. A mulcenter prospecve clinical study is in design to further validate FirstSight as a sensive and specific, non- invasive liquid biopsy for adenoma and CRC detecon. The authors sincerely appreciate the help and contribuons from staff at the Veterans Affairs Palo Alto Health Care System and all paents who contributed samples to this study. Disease Category Number of Paents Colorectal Cancer & Advanced Adenomas 64 (18.1%) Colorectal Cancer (TNM Stage I-IV) 11 (3.1%) Advanced Adenomas (Adenomas ≥1cm, high-grade dysplasia, or ≥25% villous features) 53 (15.0%) Non-Advanced Adenomas (Adenomas <1cm with <25% villous features and low-grade dysplasia) 178 (50.3%) Non-Neoplasc Findings (Includes hyperplasc polyps <1cm) 33 (9.3%) Negave Colonoscopy 79 (22.3%) [Fig.3] Prospecve study design to evaluate the performance of the CMx test for early and pre-cancer detecon. Test Sensivity for AA Sensivity for CRC Specificity CellMax FirstSight Blood 76% 100% 89.9% FIT Stool 24% 74% 94.9% Stool DNA + FIT Stool 42% 92% 86.8% Methylated Sepn9 Blood 22% 68% 78.8% [Fig.1] Adenoma removal prevents cancer and is shown to reduce mortality from colorectal cancer. Aconable findings from a colonoscopy screening are mostly adenomas. Adenoma Removal Prevents Cancer 98% 53% Adenomas (pre-cancer) account for 98% of actionable colonoscopy findings Adenoma removal reduces mortality by 53% [Fig.2] Due to its slow progression, early detecon can be effecve in decreasing both the incidence and mortality rate of CRC. However, compliance with screening colonoscopy is low, around 38%. NORMAL EPITHELIUM ABNORMAL EPITHELIUM SMALL ADENOMA LARGE ADENOMA CANCER BENIGN MALIGNANT 5 to 15 Years Prevention Colonoscopy Removes Pre-cancer Too Late Adenoma Carcinoma Sequence [Fig.4] Results from this study show that CellMax Life’s mulmodal blood test can detect pre-cancers (advanced adenomas) with 75.5% (95% CI: 61.7%-86.2%) sensivity, at a 90% specificity, while successfully detecng colorectal cancer with 100% (95% CI: 71.5%-100%) sensivity. VA U.S. Department of Veterans Affairs Paent undergoes colonoscopy Blood sample collected Colonoscopy Pathology Tesng N=354 Whole blood with preservave in one EDTA tube CTC capture Staining and imaging Proprietary cell counng soſtware Whole blood in two BCT tubes cfDNA extracon SEPT9 methylaon Sequencing CMx Score Library prep. Bisulfite conversion Mutaons idenfied Methylaon detected CTC Counts Proprietary software algorithm Final Clinical Status Final Clinical Status Compared With CMx Score Age, Gender Disease Category Number of Paents Sensivity (95% C.I.) Mean Polyp Index Size (mm) Mean CMx Score Colorectal Cancer & Advanced Adenomas 64 (18.1%) 79.7% (67.8, 88.7) Colorectal Cancer (TNM Stage I-IV) 11 (3.1%) 100% (71.5, 100) 38.8 71.3 Advanced Adenomas (Adenomas ≥1cm, high-grade dysplasia, or ≥25% villous features) 53 (15.0%) 75.5% (61.7, 86.2) 17.6 49.9 Non-Advanced Adenomas (Adenomas <1cm with <25% villous features and low-grade dysplasia) 178 (50.3%) 48.3% (40.8, 55.9) 5.1 35.6 Non-Neoplasc Findings (Includes hyperplasc polyps <1cm) 33 (9.3%) 9.1% (1.9, 24.3) 4.4 20.0 Negave Colonoscopy Number of Paents Specificity (95% C.I.) 79 (22.3%) 89.9% (81.0, 95.5) 18.1 1.00 0.50 0.75 0.00 0.25 0.00 1.00 0.50 0.25 0.75 Specificity Sensivity Advanced Adenomas + CRC Sensivity: 79.7% Specificity: 89.9% Receiver Operang Characterisc (ROC) for detecon of Advanced Adenoma + CRC. Area Under the Curve (AUC) = 0.797 ZENITH Run-In Study Interim Results 10 Negave results Non-neoplasc findings Non-advanced adenomas Advanced adenomas Colorectal cancer 0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100 Prior History of Advanced Adenomas 18.1 20.0 35.6 49.9 71.3 Mean CMx Score ± Standard Error CMx Score ZENITH Run-In Study Design [Fig.5] Correlaon between CMx Score and disease status for all 354 paents. The black dot represents paents who had a prior history of advanced adenoma(s) removal. By excluding paents with any prior history of advanced adenomas, a higher specificity could potenally be achieved. Distribuon of CMx Score vs Disease Category [Fig.6] Preliminary data for FirstSight test compared to current FDA-approved tests for colorectal cancer screening FirstSight Performance vs. FDA-Approved Colorectal Screening Tests

Upload: others

Post on 12-Feb-2021

1 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

  • A HIGHLY SENSITIVE AND QUANTITATIVE MULTIMODAL BLOOD TEST FOR THE DETECTION OF COLORECTAL ADENOMAS AND CANCER

    Friedland, Shai2; Watson, Drew1; Pan, Jennifer Y.2; Chen, Yu2; Nimgaonkar, Ashish3; Gulzar, Zulfiqar1; Gupta, Pratyush1; Lucas, Julian1; Atkins, Alex1; Lai, Jr-Ming1; Hsieh, Huangpin B.1; Su, Stephen1; Lim, Austin1; Chu, Iris1; Setthasap, Ploy1; Sninsky, John1; Mei, Rui1

    1. R&D, CellMax Life, Sunnyvale, CA, United States.2. Veteran Administration Health Center, Palo Alto, CA, United States.3. The Johns Hopkins Hospital, Baltimore, MD, United States

    BACKGROUNDColorectal cancer is among the most preventable cancers when detected early, yet, it is the second leading cancer killer in the U.S. There are 50,000 colorectal cancer (CRC) deaths per year in the U.S., many of which can be attributed to one-third of eligible Americans not following recommended screening guidelines.

    New guidelines from the American Cancer Society recommend screening for CRC starting at age 45, down from age 50. This means that 20 million Americans from the age of 45 to 50 are newly eligible for testing. Even so, an overwhelming 39 million Americans of the eligible 112 million in the 50-plus age group have never been tested.

    The two objectives of screening are early detection and prevention of CRC through removal of adenomas using colonoscopy. FDA-approved stool tests have poor compliance and low sensitivity for detection of advanced adenomas (24-42%) and non-advanced adenomas (8-17%). As colorectal adenomas account for 98% of actionable colonoscopies [Fig.1], there is an unmet need for a highly sensitive non-invasive test for colorectal adenoma detection.

    The new understanding of the natural history of adenomas and CRC informs integration of clinically relevant biomarkers for detection of CRC and adenomas with a blood test [Fig.2]. We have conducted a prospective U.S. clinical study, Zenith, to assess a highly sensitive multimodal blood test based on proprietary technologies detecting pre-cancer and cancer markers in a sample of blood.

    RESULTSThe test achieved 90% specificity, with sensitivity of 100% (95% CI: 71.5%-100%) and 76% (95% CI: 61.7%-86.2%) for detection of CRC and AA, respectively [Fig. 4]. Univariate and multivariate logistic regressions demonstrated that each biomarker contributes significant independent information to the Score. Ordinal logistic regression demonstrated significant association between the quantitative Score and disease severity (Likelihood ratio p-value < 0.0001). Furthermore, the Score correlated with the size of the index adenomas. In patients with elevated Scores but with non-AA or negative colonoscopy clinical results, a chart review of patient histories revealed prior history of AA removal in several cases [Fig. 5], suggesting that a higher specificity can potentially be achieved by excluding patients with a prior history of AA, and that some cellular and molecular changes detected by the assay persist even after removal of those advanced adenomas.

    METHODS AND STUDY DESIGNA single-center, IRB-approved, prospective, blinded study was conducted at the Veterans Affairs Palo Alto Health Care System [Fig.3]. Interim results for 354 patients with no prior diagnosis of CRC who were scheduled for colonoscopy are presented. Indications for colonoscopy were 86% asymptomatic and 14% with symptoms or positive-FIT. Patients had blood drawn immediately prior to colonoscopy. The test analyzes three biomarkers: circulating gastrointestinal epithelial cells, somatic mutations and methylation of cell-free DNA. A quantitative age- and gender-adjusted composite CMx Score (Score) scaled from 0 to 100 was developed using ordinal and nominal logistic regression and bootstrapping methods.

    CONCLUSIONSA novel noninvasive blood-based assay that analyzes cell-free DNA and circulating gastrointestinal epithelial cells, and integrates expected incidence rates can detect colorectal adenomas and cancer. Compared with FDA-approved tests, the FirstSight blood test significantly improves the sensitivity for advanced and non-advanced adenomas with high specificity [Fig.6]. A multicenter prospective clinical study is in design to further validate FirstSight as a sensitive and specific, non-invasive liquid biopsy for adenoma and CRC detection.

    The authors sincerely appreciate the help and contributions from staff at the Veterans Affairs Palo Alto Health Care System and all patients who contributed samples to this study.

    Disease Category Number of Patients

    Colorectal Cancer & Advanced Adenomas 64 (18.1%)

    Colorectal Cancer (TNM Stage I-IV) 11 (3.1%)

    Advanced Adenomas(Adenomas ≥1cm, high-grade dysplasia, or ≥25% villous features)

    53 (15.0%)

    Non-Advanced Adenomas(Adenomas