a good proposal-3 provide strong justification

Workshop Penyusunan Dokumen Rancangan Proyek-JLWA, 28 Nov 2008-Tajudin Komar

A GOOD PROPOSAL-3

PROVIDE STRONG JUSTIFICATION

Problem Is Clearly Addressed Cause Is Clearly Stated And Described The Effect Is Strongly Stated Hypotheses are Clearly Defined Priority Matches


How To Clearly Define Problem?

PROBLEM

EFFECT IF THE PROBLEM PERSISTS

CAUSES OF THE PROBLEM


Banjir, kekeringan, daya

serap carbon hilang

Penebangan liar-

perambahan hutan

Hutan gundulProblem (masalah

inti)

Causes (penyebab

)

Effects (akibat)


Hutan gundul, keanekaragaman

hayati hilang

Penegakan hukum lemah-

kemiskinan

Penebangan liar

Problem (masalah

inti)

Causes (penyebab

)

Effects (akibat)


Penebangan liar-perambahan

hutan

Mental lemah, koruptif,

kesejahteraan kurang

Penegakan hukum tidak berjalanProblem

(masalah inti)

Causes (penyebab

)

Effects (akibat)


Problem (masalah inti)

Causes (penyebab)

Effects (akibat)

Convert Problem Into A Problem Tree

Penebangan liar-perambahan hutan

koruptif

Penegakan hukum tidak berjalan

Mental Lemah

Kesejahteraan

kurang


Objective Tree?

PROJECT OBJECTIVE

LONG TERM GOAL/OBJECTIVE

OUTPUTS/ ACTIVITIES


Project level objective

Immediate objective

Long term goal

Convert Problem Tree to An Objective Tree

Membasmi penebangan liar-

perambahan hutan

Menghilang-kan sifat koruptif

Memacu keberhasilan penegakan hukum terhadap

penebangan liar dan perambahan

Memperbaiki mental

Memperbaiki Kesejahteraan


Convert Objective Tree To Project Elements

Membasmi penebangan liar-

perambahan hutan

Sifat koruptif hilang

Memacu keberhasilan penegakan hukum terhadap

penebangan liar dan perambahan

Mental membaik

Kesejahteraan membaik

Long term goal: development

objective

Project level objective:

Specific Objective

Project Outputs


Up-load Project Elements into Log Frame

Indicator Verifier Assumption

Project ElementsLong term goal:

development objective


Specific Objective

Project Outputs

Activities Horizontal logic

Vert

ical lo

gic

Vertical logic: action or condition necessary to achieve the higher order of project elements

Horizontal logic: condition required or to show the achievement of each level of project elements


Indicator, verifier and Assumption Indicator Verifier Assumptio

nProject

ElementsLong term goal: development

objective


Specific Objective

Project Outputs

Activities Horizontal logic

Vert

ical lo

gic

Indicator: something to show

Verifier (Mean of Verification): accessible documents or any material to be used as proof Assumption: condition required to execute or achieve



Project Elements

development objective

Specific Objective

Outputs

Activities

Membasmi penebangan liar-perambahan hutan

Memacu keberhasilan penegakan hukum terhadap penebangan liar dan perambahan

1. Kesejahteraan membaik2. Sifat koruptif hilang

1.1. Menaikkan tunjangan harian, 1.2. …..2.1. Memberlakukan hukuman mati bagi polisi yang korupsi, 2.2. …..



Project Elements

DO: Membasmi penebangan liar-perambahan hutan

SO: Memacu keberhasilan penegakan hukum terhadap penebangan liar dan perambahan

OP 1. Kesejahteraan membaikOP 2. Sifat koruptif hilang

Act.1.1. Menaikkan tunjangan harian, 1.2. ..Act. 2.1. Memberlakukan hukuman mati bagi polisi yang korupsi, 2.2. …..

Penebangan liar dan perambahan hutan menurun

Penebang liar dan perambah hutan menurun akibat penangkapan dan hukuman, Punya rumah, belanja dapur cukup.. ……….



Project Elements





Laporan statistik nasional etc

Laporan statistik local, laporan DG PHKA..

Laporan statistik, kepolisian dll

……….



Project Elements





Kebijakan pemerintah mendukung

Instansi terkait mendukung…

Instansi terkait mendukung dan keuangan negara

memungkinkan……….


Contoh - Propinsi Riau Propinsi Riau in 1990 and 2007


KEANEKARAGAMAN HAYATI

Keanekaragaman tertinggi ke dua setelah Brazil

- 28 000 jenis tumbuhan berbunga- 122 jenis bambu- 400 jenis Dipterocarpaceae


To Support REDD-I1. Promoting underground capture of carbon by selecting vegetation cover

2. Promoting carbon sequestration through selection of agro-forestry plantation model

3. Reducing potential carbon emission through the application of Reduced Impact Logging (RIL)

4. Up-dating biological database to monitor GHG emission to atmosphere: forest cover type, lake and stream

5. Measuring capacity of small stream to capture CO2 emission

6. Wise use of land cover to reduce carbon emission

a good proposal-3 provide strong justification

Documents