a · ct iq n 0 d ql 0 a cll i ib x iua (g0 iij 0 iy (0 ql io cbl0 z ct ill m io icd th at 0 id0 0 o...
TRANSCRIPT
~ID(I ~f~gt ++,,;5b ~tb((tbf
'!~8I.":"=.'
0ICI
0CI
CJJ
Q(
Z0IZ5LUZLLI
0C((j
+iI
fbID
IQCD0
U. KO
Ql
o ELLt Qtv- (L0 0C QlQf
E clmm 0
Cm .Cl
Ct IQN
0 D
Ql
0 acll
IIb XIU (ga 0IIJ 0IY (0
Ql
IO
Cbl
0Z
CTIll
m
IO
ICD
th
at
0ID00O
Z0IO0(0K
O0OZ
O0 Z0
ZQ! 0 O
UJ
UJ
Q(
0
IU
VO00
Ql
IJI m
Om CI!
Rm0UJ '0
0Ib C~ I-
QtR Ch
Ift C(
IDIb
Ol~mm I/I Z
Ib
O "a-m mOOQ
W~ OC0'm cUl ! Qt
ODam—m EQl ZID Qt CtI- m
E I-0(U m0 M
OZ Z
m
Eg0
Ib ID
(g Ib ID
DC ID fbZ 0O ut-
CO
Z~(00.L
Dl
0ot
00m
0 fo- Ct
0 NC N0OC0C
E2ttl
0 to5 ~~ Ct
0 I0V p
IQCDmm
IZ LL
Z0I-O00Z
UII-CI0IY
Z
O
E0O
0b(ZO0
JQ00
DI
(0UJO
m.'d
C9ZCIUJIJIO0
0CIL
0Z0Qt
E2
Ct0CJ
Qt0caChCh
ID
IOCb
00QQQlO00Ql
I(:CbOtCh
ICICt
Qt
0tll
IJI
th
00\000
CL
IbC0!0
0Z
mE
C
0
0IDC!CbCbIb
0'0m
0
CbCt!Cb
IO
'000QlX
ILI
QtD
0m b
IOCm Qt
Ot
—0Q!
CL CD
CII w
QI
E
fb
2Ct0
CU
0mm0
IOcaC!
COCcl
Cb
0mO00QI
IOCtCtNOt
CbCt'0Qt
IJID
LLI
ID'a
CID
E ID
m CcCO
>0 Ctfb
OZ
QfNNCtCtCtCbCI
0Z
tb
I/I
D00tbm0
CD
Ct
CICbC!
0Qt
00ID
NeQt'20ID
E0
0
150000532
niE
ntL
00Sl'O(D
CI
(5(0Cl
00
GlIY
CI
CI
OlaO
0U
X(D
IU(n
e'00
OC (GeEOe O(n OO
.e 0QZ
lpOI-0Z
0 0
c e0 r0 nna. e
eC OGi .—ld
0 pIn 0
nl (n0'oIo
fnni
(Tl QlC C0
0 O0 (N
'2e cQt +
r '0n!ID
e CCC8
pm
c(DGl
0 3
QIC
0 (DCe (n
Otr(00OPIea.r00
Gt rr eI- U
00tn
UJQl
C p
0 ep a.
Ct0 Gt
0 CU0O GlC 0
0 C'
13Qt QtE—tD(fl
OrZO
Ql IRcd-
p 0C
n! 00 Qnn0(L C0
nlnl 'IJ0 p0 I-Ol 00prp. GI
Qtr cGl
eE ~0
0
IP
0000a.
0
00(D
cC
(n 0(ne
ID0.Gl»'0
dm c0
Ca.Ql0 L~
ln 0(D
0'L ~
C1,
0
0E (nID Yl
P0e cID ec cnl 0m (Dnl )O
G!cv Tt
tD
E0e
Onl
(Dnnc
000G!
00Ql
Ql
Qt
0C0O
Gl
PI
Gl
Ul(0 tD'n'
eI0nt
O c0
(D
0tD
0nlQl
(0Qz I0IP
4
O—(n0Z tp (nnl Glo—0!O mOnn (n ml-
0 CGl 0> eGf. '0c ec co(neO'0 eooe Z 'ooZ gm e
=Ct rGl nle 5< goe tp 0 0. 0ID e ) 0( 0:m»< e
E Ip0 0
mSyeplnn —0 XOc(p e
ln 0 Lld e c Gl-ere epOI- mEIU
N
cUJ cI> 0Gl XozeOC
em (U0 —IU a.cfd
Ue+ 0 ) o
W4 0%(DCec(II 0 0m0 a.eZ eoodm pm(npcrfnn(p c.e .ROontr (n 0 nnOO e e'6U(GEE 0—manne oe+ h»
ln m IDmEec"-e tn
> e0 —e 0oO Gl
(De >ma'0m
Cg L»(fmpea~Kmm e 0mac pcni -5 c 0
Gl
e Ql U
m((l 0 m PC(m-ira v
0IUI-z
0Nt
00Ct 0C0. IJJ
I
CtaI
Ct oCtCt
I «CDlO OO O
aCt
CDI«l
O «Co a150000532
laaCl
O OO8a o
oCft«tOCa
L0
0E
CtCtlata
Ct
Ct
CtOCt
OaCIla
O OO OCI O
CtaCtta
o aa oO Ota ta
OCIO
aNt
O IDC
z 0CL
ID
m0IDC
UL
CmEmL
0CD
C
0Dl
I-C
I-C
00
O
0
R.
I-
0
I-C I,
S20
Q
'|D
la
I-
CIO
al
Ctl
0
K
NCI0
2C«
O
e
Ie
CtO
C«
0C00K
eNl
Cll
PID
hZIN
O
IatNl
ID
OCa
t«0CI00ID
e
O
IVCtt
O
Nl
'0ID0K0ma.0tD0.C«
0
IIJ
E0'0
WtN ta
CIIa oO O
C«Ctt
«L'
IX
0
CtlCDO
0ID
CI
CYJ
eDl
UJmtN
UJ
laC«
«() Cm
mD 0
20 m0CIJ
Zagl
CD
ta
IDm
m OIN
0Ca
C«I
O O
CtI
N
CN )0) 0Nt
CI Ca
ID «0m OO xCCI 0Ctt
x 0-0Ia IN
2Q.0
Cl
0 ($VX
ZO Z
CIOla0Ca
Cdl
CD
K
IZC9
NlC
0
0
O
CNmNl
m CaGl
eE—0 I
Nl
0 0O Nl
E N9I I-C«
IDD0«0
D
NI
NI
2«a0.
«0IN
mll
0C «-
e0 mal
e e'I 80 D
C0Di
4 a,
~ '00 0m 0IU De 'c
e
6C0Nl ~
ml
00 CICDv0 0e
CageCCa 4c 'R
8v e50 00 IUCl y4 TD)Z
0r ~
ID
00 e00 000am
JC00 ce g'I IU0 vm JD
c%g D
4 0mIZIU l7
NlCCI
ni 0
X0Ca
OX0O
0Ch
CIJ
I-
C
CD
CN
'00CD
Nt
0CI
8m
C052CL0CID
IC!0ID
0
I0-0
P IU0 IZ
IUg0g
IL'
olif-o m0 o,e-E
E
e —clD ill 0
8'rna
h. El.m o0 eV
Z emeol Q(g9
mÃ+$Dc 0m ml
«n'm emom.m 8 oOl o t:)e8
v v ooe e
m
Oo ee o,o'tlN mmmeoemamC Ola
mo m
w o o 0)o o cnmO. e ill
e az er ag.rtll o
mou oc
>'o e~P, o~eCI lo
m cme leoe
oemQ g pc„ooo2:m m Pll
U me lm.mo Dm
ae ho~ eomcC o o.e
150000532DONE AND EXECUTED this 20 day of March, 2015 by a majority of the Virginia Gas and OitBoard.
Chairman, Bradley C. Lambert
COMMONWEALTH OF VIRGINIACOUNTY OF RUSSEI L
Acknowledged on this ~today of ~xurM, ZG personally before me a notary publicIS'n
and for the Commonweakh of Virginia, appeared Bradley C. Lambert, being duly sworn diddepose and say that he is the Chairman of the Virginia Gas and Oil Board, that he executedthe same and was authorized to do so. nol lour
Sarah Jessee Gilnjg), Notary Public262946 = *
i MYEBMMISSIQII I *=9; EXPIRES
My Commission expires: July 31, 2017
DONE AND PERFORMED this 23 day of March, 201 5 by Order of the Virginia Gas and OilBoard.
Rick CooperPrincipal Executive to thestaff, Virginia Gas and Oil Board
COMMONWEALTH OF VIRGINIACOUNTY OF RUSSELL
Acknowledged on this 25- day of i i r~r I~,ROIS personally before me a notary publicIn and for the Commonwealth of Virginia, appeared Rick Cooper, being duly sworn diddepose and say that he is the Principal Executive to the staff of the Virginia Gas and Oil
Board, that he executed the same and was authorized to do so.
My Commission expires: July 31, 2017 pUBLIC
REB, e262946 ', *=*:MX COMMISSIONc'; EXPIRES.
NEREID D
un I lie
Page Number 5.
BEFORE THE VIRGINIA OIL AND GAS BOARD
APPLICANT: CNX Gas Company LLC
RELIEF SOUGHT: (1) Disbursement from escrowRegarding tracts 1B8 4C (royalties currently beingPaid under BUG I SGU2, VGOB 08-1118-2387i and(2) Dismissal of coal claimants
UNIT: U36
BUCHANAN COUNTY, VIRGINIA
DIVISION OF GAS AND OILDOCKET NOJ VGOB 98-0421-0648-04
HEARING DATE:PLACE:
February17, 2015Russell County Government Conference Center139 Highland DriveLebanon, Virginiie9:00a.m.
NOTICE OF HEARING
COMNIONWEALTH OF VIRGINIA: To the following persons who wil! race've a disbursement of sscrowed funds if
the relief sought by Applicant's Petition is granted by the Virginia Gas and Oil Board:
Bessie Lowe, Wards Hagy, Curls Lee Stilwell, Theodore Stllwe(l Elate Ettzebetb Stllwoll, Sylvia L. Byrd. I oisCasey, Hurt tdcGuire Land Trust, Trustees ol tt!e Wilderness Tabernacle Church
COMMONWEALTH OF VIRGINIA: To the following persons identified as COAL OWNERS in the pooling
application{a) and Virginia Gas snd Oil Board Orders pertaining to the referenced Docket No. who were previously pooled by-Virginia Gas and Oil Board Order as conflicting daimants to the coaibed methane tc be produced from the Unrt, YOURCLAIMS TO COALBED METHANE ROYALTIES ANDlOR WORKING OR CARRIED INTERESTS for coalbed methane gasproduoed from this Unit ARE SUBJECT TO DISMISSAL BY BOARD ORDER AT THE HEARING NOTICED ABOVE:
Hurt tifcGuko Land Ti'ust cro Chartes Gmen
NOTICE IS HEREBY GIVEN that Applicant is requesting that the Virginia Gas en Oil Board (hereinafter Board)issue an order as follows:
(1) Direding the Board's Escrow Agent to make the disbursements to the persons identified in Table 1 heretousing the peroentages stated therein;
(2) Dismissing the Respondentslcoal ovmers listed above as Respondents and as conflicting claimants
NOTICE IS FURTHER GIVEN that this cause has been set for tiearing and the taking of evidence before the Boardat 9:00 a.rn., on February 17, 2015 at the RusseR County Government Conference Center, 139 Highland Drive, Lebanon,Virginra. and that notice will bs published as required by law and the Rules of the Board.
NOTICE IS FURTHER GiVEN that you may attend this hearing, with or without an attorney, and cger evidence orstale any comments you have. Fcr further informsbon or a copy of the Application and Exhibits, either contact the VirginiaGas and Oil Board, the Department if Mines, Minerals and Energy, the Division of Gas and Oil. 135 HigMand Dmre,Lebanon, Virginia, 276, or the Appiicanl at the address strown Below.
NOTICE IS FURTHER GIVEN that any Cca! Owner idenlified above who does not appear at the said headng andpiuvide the Board with evidence and/or a credible theorylargurnent that he/she/it has a good faith basis under existing law toclaim an interest in the coalbed methane produced from the Unit, is subject to dismissal as a pooled Respondent and as aconRicting dsimant to coalbedrnethane royalties, wooing interest and/or carried interest
CNX Gas Company LLCBY ITS PROFESSIONAL k((AAAGERGNX
CPS+MPAhF)i( LC1 PETITIONER
U IMJttinlta D. DutyP)udihg Supetvtsor /;2461 John Nash Blvd.Biuefiold, West Virginia 24701
Page Number 6.
150000532BEFORE THE VIRGINIA OIL AND GAS BOARD
APPLICANT: CNX Gas Company LLC DIVISION OF GAS AhlD OILDOCKET NOx VGOB 98-0421-0648-84
RELIEF SOUGHT; (1) Disbursement from escrowRegarding tracts 18 & 4C (royalties currently beingPaid under BUC1SGU2, VGOB 08-1118-2367;and(2) Dismissal af coal claimants
UNIT: tl36
BUCHANAN COUNTY, VIRGINIA
HEARING DATE: February 17, 2815
PETITION TO DISBURSE AND MODIFY
Aoalicant and its counsel: Applicant is CNX Gas Company LLC, 2461 John Nash Blvd., Bluefield, WV.24701, 304.323.6500. Applicant's counsel is Mark A. Swartz, Hilfiard & Swarlz, LLP, 122 Capitol St., Ff 2,Charleston, WV 25301.
2. Relief souaht: (1) the disbursement of escrawed funds heretofore deposited with Ihe Board's EscrowAgent{s) attributable ta Tnrcts 18 & 4C to the persons identified in Table 1 using the percentages set for!h in
Table 1; and (2) dismissal af coal owner(s)/claimant{s) named in the Notfce af Hearing and identified m Exhibit
82 who were pooled by the Board as canfficting claimants.
3. Factual basis for disbursements: (a) Trustees cf wilderness Tabernacle church are entBed ta 100% of theCBM royalties awarded under Case No. CL 12-174, Opinion dated November 13, 2014. (b) Hurt McGuireLani Trust and Thomas Stilwefl Heirs including Bessie Lowe, Wanda Hagy, Curlis Lee Stilwell, TheadoreSliiweli, Elsie Elizabeth Stilweil, Sylvia A. Byrd, and Lois Casey have entered into rayelty split agreement(s).Said royalty split agreement allows the Applicant and Designated Operator to pay royaltres directly to thepersons identified in Exhibit EE annexed hereto and the annexed Table 1 specifies how said royalties are to bedivided and paid.
4. ReasorLfar>ismiasaL Given legislative action and supreme court decision(s) following adaption of the 1990Act, the Board's paficy of idenfifying a conflict befween coal owners and oil and gas owners to pra'feet
correlative rights should be changed to a policy of not requfring coal ovmers to be identBed as confiictlng
claimants, subject to coal owner(s) offering evidence of a viable claim, after receiving notice.
5. Leaal Authority: Va. Cade Ann. Q 45A46IA3, 45.1-361 14.8, 45.1-361.15A3,8.2, 8.10, 8.12,361.19.A.,45.1-361.21:1,45.1-361.22.1, .5, 4VAC25-160-10, 50, Swords Creek Lend Partnership v. Be!char, ef af.,4131590, September 12, 2014.
6. Exhibits: The relevant exhibits are annexed to the Notice of Hearing and this Appfication.
7. Applicant*s standlna: Designated Opsmtor.
8. Attestatfon; The foregoing application, to the best of my knowledge, information and belief, is true and correct.
CNX Ges Company LLCBY ITS PROFESSIONAL MANAGERCNX G~OMPANY L~ETITIQNERApplfrfbnt
8,: 4 0<4-'~mr(alta D. DutyI)4tolipg Supervisor24)TFJohn Nash Blvd. UBluefield, West Virginia 24701
Page Number 7.
150000532
TRACT LAND HDDK
TRACT LAND -'ID'5
EXHIBIT A
OAKWOOO PIELO UhlIT Ut-36
FORCF POO! ING
VGOS-98-0421 -0648
r seta i!Ca-CDPer. 9r9I
L
Call@all Y paaaharriae DOS parftterehia liel! Haste sita Nuttl>er
gttutterart tg;s+r,,ae aoragh, goats: '4 'rt 22991'- rtCC' E/12299
era tt ! tar
9:certaed Prafessicrtai E~ti:~ ts Li„etsea Lord Surrey% ar~~,-.~P
Page Number S.
POCAHONTAS 6AS PARTNERSHlPUNIT U~
Tract tdentglcatton
Alpha Sgckhry, et al - Coal, ON 5 GesCoal LesseesIsland Creek Coal CompanyJewsg Smokeless Coal CorporagonPennsc, Inc,Pocahorrlas Gas Partnership- CBM LeasesJoel L Abcher -Surface0.50scree 0.5250%
McGuka 5 Hurt Heka -CoalConan gdsgon Coal Co. —Below drainage coal LeasedUn4od Coal Ccm pany -Above draklge coat LeasedPccahontss Gss Parhrenddp - CBM LesseeThomas 88hvefl Heirs - Surface. DN 5 Gas1.51acres 22tyuI%
McGulre 4 Hurt Hoke-CostConscadakcn Coal Co. - Below dndnsge coal LeasedUnkvd Coal~- Abave drakurge coal LeasedPocahontas Gas Psrtnenrhlp- CBht LesseeJos idpper -Surface, Dil 4 Gss2.17 acres 2.7125%
McGuka 4 Hurt Heirs —CoalC~n Coal Co. - Below dminsge coal LeasedUnited Coal Company - Above drrdnage coat LeasedPccshcntss Gas Partnership-CBM LesseeDonald Hipper - Surface, ON 5 Gss2.01 acres 2.5125%
Coal~kgnktg ~Tr 28 - Feeconsolidskcn Coal Co. - Below drainage coal LeasedUntied Coal Company- Above drainage coal LeasedPccshcntss Gss Psrtnershhr - ON 5 Gas LesseePccshcntas Gss Partnership- CBM Lessee2.08acres 2.8000%
Hear Garden Coal Company- Coal, CW 5 GssConsokdsgcn Coal Co. - Below dndnsge coal LeasedUnksd Coal Company-Above drainage coal LeasedPocahontss Gas Partnership-08 8 Gss LassosPeon henna Gea Psrtnenrhlp- CBM Leaeee52.85 acres 85.8500%
Benny Danag Davh - SurfaceJewel t Smohohrae Coal Cori@- SurfaceSamuel Glsnn Sproles- Surface
Page 1
I
Page Number 9.
POCAHONTAS GAS PARTNERSHIPUNIT U48
Tract fdetffaaghm
McGufre 8 Hurt Heirs ~ CoalCcneoNdagon Coal Co. - Below drainage cost Leasedunaed Coal Company- Above dmiuefe coat LeasedPocahornse Gas Pennarship - CSM LeereeJewsa Smokeless Coal Corp. - Surface, Oil 8 Gss8.82 acres 11.0250%
McGuirs 8 Hurt Heis —CoalConsogd agon Ccsl Co. - Setcw drainage coal Leasedunhed Cca'i Company -Above dud mpr hami LmmrdPccahonivs Gss Partnership - CBhl LesseeSamuel Glenn Spmles - Surface, Oy 8 Gas1.7$acres 2.1875%
hfcGuire 8 Hurt Heirs- CoalConaogdshon Cost Cc. - Below drainage coal Leasedunfed Coal Company- Above drshurge coal LeasedPocahcntss Gas Parlnerahip- CSM LesseeVNdemess Tsbemsde- Surface, O8 8 Ges8.85~ 7~
4D. McGuis 8 Hurt Heirs - CoalConsogdafen Coal Co. - Mow drainage coal Leasedunhed Coal Company- Above drainage Ccsl LeasedP~Gss Parlnerahip - CBM LesseePaul SShveh —Surhce, Oll *Gas2.13scree 2.8825%
Page 2
I
Page Number 10.
Exhibit 8-2Unit U-36
Docket ¹V GOB 08.04214I648-04List of Respondents ta be Added ar Dismissed
Acres In UnitPercenl al
Un ft
Division of interest in
6-Right 7-Right Reason far6.10175% 16.3488'tyx Dismfssal
i rect ¹18. 1.81acres 1.81 acres
COAL owneFRNHIP
(I) Hurt mcG¹ire Lena Trustcfa Charles GreenP. O. Box 1067Bluefield, VA 24605
0.013 acres Coal Owner
See Exidbff EE for Ffoyafry Spffr Agreemcnta
Tract ¹44. 8.82 earns
COAL OWNERSHIP
(1) Hurt McGuire Land Truslc/o Charles GreenP O Sox 1067Bluelield, VA 24805
&82 acres Coat Owner
Trecf ¹48. 1.75acres
COAL OWNERSHIP
(1) Hurl McGutm Land Trust
cfa Charles GreenP. O. Bax 1067Bluefwfd, VA 24605
1.75 acres Coal Owner
Page 1 af 1 1I14I2015
Page Number ( I
Exhibit EUnit U~
Docket 6 VGOB SS0421-0648-04Ust of Owners in escrow, not including persons dismissed on Exhlhg 8-2
Tract «tS. t.af acresAcres in Unit
1.S1 acres
Percent ofUnit
2 2625%
Division of Interest in
6-Right 7-Right6.10175% 16.34981%0.13805% 0.36991%
Thomas Sti/well Heirs, Devisees,Successors or Assigns
0.013 acresof 'I.81 antes
0.0157% 0.00096% 0.00257%
(5) Sylveale Stilwes Heirs, Devisees,Successors or Assigns
(5.1) cora Arnold Hers, Devisees,Successors or Assigns
(5.1.5) Jey C. Stiiwell Sr. Heirs, Devisees,Successors or Assigns
(5.1.5.1)Kathy Stilwell
PO Sox 'l196Raven, VA 24630
0.004 acres1/432 of 1.81 acres
0.0052% 0.00032% 0.00086'Yo
(5.18.2) Jay Clarence Slilwell, Jr.Pocahontas Pr/son
0.004 acresI/432 of 1.81 acres
0 0052% 0.00032% 0.00086%
(5.1.5.3)Verordca Gail Helton
200 Bryant StreetCedar Stuff, VA 24609
0.004 acres1/432 of 1.81 acres
0,0052ni 0.00032% 0.00086%
Total tract scaleTotal tract percent
0,013
6.015'7'%/act
644. 8.82 ecms
OII a Gan rnwNFRSHIp
(1) Jewell Smokeless Coal CorpP.O. Sox70Varlsant, VA 24656
Tarot 84th 1.75acres
6 82 acres 11.D25D% 0.572718% 1.802557%
OIL 3 Gaa OWNERSHIP
(1) Samuel Glenn Sprolesc/o Ludfe Collins5222 Stewansvil/e RoadMcneta, VA 24121
1.75 acres 2.'I 375% 0.133476% 0.357652%
Total Acreage in Unil
Total Percentage In Unit
10.58313.2282%
Pages of1 12/I 5/2014
Page Number 12.
Exhibit EEV nit V.36
Docket 5 VGOB 8&0421-0648-04Liat or Respondents with Royally Sput Agreements aridior Courl Orders
45000053~
Acme In Vnh
Divirsion of interest inPercent of O.Right 7-Right Pc/cont
Vnft 5.10175% 16.34981% o'scrow
Tmct SHB. 1 81 acres 'L81 eci'ss 2 2625%. 0.138052% 0 369814%
BOJULO~I
(1) Hurt MCGulle LSISI T/Ust
c/o Charles GreenP. O. Box 1067Bluefietd. VA 24805
1.797 acresCI 1.81acres
04122%
OIL 8 OA6 OWNERSHIP
Thomas Staueg Heirs, Oevisees,Successors or Assigns
1.81 acres 2.2625'Y 0.13805% 0 36991%
(1) Beulah V. Osborne Heirs, OeviseesSUccsssors or Assigns
(1.1) Sterling Osborne3639 CNton Fork roadRaven. VA 24839
0.019 acres1/96 M1.81 scree
GJ)236% D.CG144vv D.00355% n/a
(1.2) Mas hktler8'IDI Brown MCUrseln RoadJewall Ridge, VA 24622-8706
0.019 acresI/96 of 1.81 acres
0.0236% O.D0144'4, 0.00385% n/a
(1 3) Sylvma sager3999 Osborne RoadRaven, VA 24639
0.019 acres1/96 of 181 acme
0 0236% 0.00144% 0.00385% rr/a
('1,4) Oons &tchet1045 Jewel! Ridge RoadRlchlands, VA 246tt
0.0'lg acres1/96 oft.81 acres
0 0236'A 0.00144% 0.00385% nle
(1%) Brenda ShuntPO Box 652Keen Mountain. VA 24624
0.019 sweeI/96 o'.81 ames
0.0236% U.00144% 0 00335'/ n/e
(1,6) Bcbby Osborne349 Bridgestone Drive, Box 12Raven, VA 24639
0.018 acres1/96 of 1.81acres
0,0236% 0.00144% 0.00385% n/a
(1.7) Danny OsbornePO Box 454Keen Mountan, VA 24624
(I 8) Hamld Eugene Osborne214 Oarson Avenue, Apt 46Rlchlends, VA 2484'I
0.019 acres'I/96 ot 1 81 acres
0.019 acresI/96 of 1.81 acres
0 0236% 0.001444 0 00385% n/a
0.0236'l 0.00144% 0.00385% nls
(1.9) Jeny I ene Osborne2414 Harrys Branch RoadWhBewood, VA 24657-9452
0 019 acres1/06 of 1.81acres
0.0236% 0 00144% 0.00385% me
(1.10)Melvin Junnr OstcmePQ Box 1239Raven, VA 24639
0.019 acres1/96 of 1.81acres
0.0236% 0 00144'4
(1.11)Roger
Osborne
Hairs. Oevisees,Successors or Aswgns
(1.111) Michete Tuggie420 Veer Harven OnveCastlewood, VA 24224
0.009 acres1/192 of 1.81 acme
0.0118% 0.00072% 0.00193% n/a
Page 1 of 7 2/I 0/2015
Page Number 13.
Exhlhlt EEUnit U-SB
Docket 8 YGOB tmxt4214I6484»Ust of Resaondenls with Royalty Bpat Agreemsnta ancyor Court Ordent
15000053"
(1.11.2)Susie Oshorne116Tmonsway RoadWlnstom Salem, NC 27127
(1.12)Betty L Smah Hei>8. Deviance.Suer»escm or AssignsOcean»nfeBCn cn Htxra persecg
Acres In Unit
0.009 acres1/192 of 1 81 acres
0.019 acres18ra of 1.81acres
Division of Interest InPwcent of BRlght ydtlght Percent
Unit 6.10176% 1834681% ot Esmcnr
0.0118% O.D¹2% 0 00193% Als
0.0236% 0.00144% 0.0fEB6% nfs
(1.12.1)Gary WaP» SmithAddress PsndlrM
(1.122) Randy BmllhAddrsr» Pendhg
(1.12.3) David SmithAddress Pending
(1.12.4) Jsmla Lee Smith161 Meadows SheetPounding lell, VA 24837
(1.12.6) Colonel SmOh. Jr.PO Bm 642Raven, VA 24639
(1.12.6)TImmy James Smarm
Addrm» Pending
(2) Ene Qaaome Helm, Devlsass,Successors or Assigr»
(2.1)John OshomeBIBGcv. G.C. Peery HighwayRaven, VA 24639
(22) Msxie Jean Osborne Boyd Hair% Dsvimes,Successors or Aawgns
(2,2,1) Waker BOydPC Box 148Raven, VA 24838
(22.2) Anthony Boyd14632 shxs cnuek RoadGrundy, VA 24614
(2.3) Ruth SmhhPO Bcx 676Oorsn, VA 246\2
0.038 acresUm! af 1S1 acres
0.019 acmeIFBB of IS1aces
0.019 acres1IBB ol 1.81 acres
0.038 screeV46 of 1.81aces
0.0471% 0.00268% 0.00771% ner
0.0238% 0.06144% 0.00336% nre
0.02381k 0»0144% D.D0386% nts
0.0471% 0.00263% 060771% nts
(2.4) Judy BlsnkenshipBcx 221Oarsn, VA 24612
(2.6) kla Pmflltt128 MajOr ReadRaven. VA 24639
(2.8) Myrae smah Heirs, oevisess,Succssam or Assigns
(2.6.1) Nar»y JacksonPC Box 448Dora n VA 24812
D 038 screeV48 Of I.af mn»
0.038 acres1i48 cf IJH scree
0.019 acmeIi98 cf 1.81ames
0.0471% 0.00263% 0.00771%»h
0.0471% D.D0288% 0.00771% nrh
D.D236% 0.00141% D.D0363%
Page 2 of 7 2IIDI201 6
Page Number )4.
Exhibit EEUrlit U.36
Docket 8 VBOB 98-042?-0848-04List Of ReepOndents with Royalty Sput Agreements and/or Court Drdam
i5000053"
Acres in Unit
Division of Internet irt
Percent rrr 8-Right 7-RightUnit 6.'!0175% '1634981%
Percentof Escrow
(2.6.2) Danerre Ward117 Franklin Avenuef8chfande. VA 24641
0.019 aves'l/96 of 't.81 acres
0,0236'/ 0 00144% 0,00385% r/a
(3) Arthur M Stiiwell
P.O. Bax 314Raven, VA 24639
0.226 aciest/6 of 1.81acres
0.2828% 0 01726% 0.04624% n/
(d) Flassie Stilweg Osborne Heim. Dewsees.Successors or Assigns
(4.1) Adm w. Qsbom* Heirs. Deviance.Successors or Assrgns
(4.1.1)Mary Jane osbame Heink Devlsees,Successam or AssgnsDac rra!'r term Pand!'o ..nr/r frt
0.025 acres1/72 of 1,81 acres
00314% 0.00192% 000514% rua
(4.2) Daniel J. Osborne1068 Harvest Moon Rd.Raven. VA 24639
0.025 acres1/72 cf 1.81aoes
OD314% 0.00192% 0.00514% n/a
(4.3) Marvin J.OsborneP. Q. Box 16D7Cade! Slug, VA 24509
0.025 ac!!ret/72 of 1.61acres
0.031d% 0 00192'%.00514'8 n/a
(4.4) Hubbsnf Osborne3'I 85 Osborne Mountern Rd.Raven, VA 24639
0.025 acres1/72 of t%%dt acres
0.03t4'%.00192% 0.00514% n/8
(4.5) Jackie D. Osborne1995 Altrzer ReadRaven, VA 24639.1995
(4.6) Jerline Davis118Coron8da RoslfNorth Tazewelf, VA 24630
(4.7) Sylvia /t. Byrd
719 Holly St.Richlands. VA 24641-3037
0 025 acres1/72 of 1.81acres
0.025 aoas1/72 o. 1.81aCreS
0 026 acres'I/72 of 1,61 8crss
0.0314% 0.00192% 0 00514% n/e
O.f1314% D.OG192% G.D0514% rr/a
0.0314% 0.00192% 0 00514% 0 0749™
(4.6) Lafs Casey759 Big Creek RoadRichlands, VA 24641
(4.9) linda S ShatlonP. O. Box 521Pooh!ling Mlt. VA 24637
(5) Sylvester Stawdl Heirs, Devisees,Successors or Assigns
(5.1) Cora Arnold Heim, Devisees.Successors or Asagns
(5.1.1)Bessie Laws1D82 Rive.'side DriesRaven, VA 24639
0025 acrest/72 of 1.81acres
0,025 acres1/72 af 1.81acres
0013 acres1/141 of 1 81 aC/eS
0.0314% 0 OD'192% D 00514!/, 0 0?49/
0.0314% D.00192% 0.00514% n/a
0 0157% 0.00096B%%d 0,00257% O.o375%
(5.1.1) Bessie taws1082 Riverside DnvsRaven, VA 24639
0,004 earns1/504 Of 1 81 aCres
0 0046% 0.0002'r% 0.00073'/ n/s
Page Eaf7 2/10/20t 5
Page Number (5.
Exhibit EEUnit U.36
Docket ¹VBOB 98-0421-0648-04List of Respondents with Royalty split A9reemsnts and/or court Drders
SS0O0O5S:
Acres in Umt
Percent ofUnif
Olvfstan af interest lii
B.Right 7.Right6 t {H75% 18.34981%
Percellrot Escrow
(51 2) Wsnds Hagy127 Largen Street ¹5Rlchlands, VA 24641
0.013 ac/esI/f44 af 1 81 acres
0 0157% O.OK96% 0OD257'Y. 0.03754,
(5.1.2) Wanda Hagy127 {argon S iran/ ¹5Ftichlsnds, VA 24841
O Oos acresI/504 of 1 81 acres
0 0045% 0 00027% 0 K073% n/a
(5.1.3) cunw Lee stilwetPO Box 22t6Cedar Bluff, VA 24609
(5.1.3) Curtis Les Stiiwsll
PO Box 2216Cedar Bluff, VA 24609
0.013 acres1/144 of 1.81acres
0.004 sores1/504 sf 1.8",acme
00157% 0,00096% 000257% f'3769
0¹045% D 00027% 0.00073% n/a
(5 1 4) Theodont S¹lweil2212 Pea Patch RoadJswet Ridge, VA 24622-8706
0.013 acres1/144 Of 1 81 acres
O.D157% G.00096% O.OD257% O.0375%
(5,1.4) Theodore StllweO
2212 I-se Patch RoadJtiwell Ricfge, VA 24622-8706
(5.1.5) Jay C. Stikvell Sr. Heirs. Devrsees.Successor or Assigns
D.D04 acres1/504 of 1.81acres
Q.0045% O.OD027% 0,00073% n/s
(51.5.1).Ha&yStllw*U
PD Box 1196Rave'.. VA 2@i39
O.QD1 acres1/1512 of1.81acras
0.0015% D QK0'3% 0.00024% n/a
(6.1 5.2) Jsy Clarence Stilweli, Jr.Pocahantas Pnson
0.001 acres1/1512 of 1.81 acres
0.0015% D QQ009% G 00024% n/a
(5.1.53) Veronica Gall Helton
Ko Bryant StreetCeder Blu¹, VA 24609
0.001 acres1/1512 of 1.81acres
O.K15% O.OK09% 0 G0024% rr/a
(5.1.6) Leonard stilarell Heirs, Devisees,Successors oi Assigns
(5HI.6%i ) Elsie Elizabeth StilweU
c/o BeeJe Laws1082 R/versids Drlye
Raven, VA 24639
D,013 a rest/144 af 'l.81 acres
0.0157% 0.00096% O.D0257% il D375%
(5.2) Jsy C. SIUweo Sr Heirs, Devlsees,Successors or Amigos
{52 1) Connie Jean S!ilweU Heirs, Devisee sSuccessors ar Assigns
(5.2.1.1)Kathy StilweU
PO Bax 1196Raverl, VA 24639
0 G05 acres1/336 of 1.81 sass
0OD67% 000041% 000110% n/e
(5.2.1.2) Jey Clarence Stilwell, Jr.Pocshontas Prison
O.K5 acres1/336 of 1.81 acres
0.0067% 0.00041'4 0.00110% n/a
(5.2 1.3) Veranica Gall Hei'.on
200 Srysnt SireetCedar Bluff, VA24609
0.006 acres1/336 of 1.8'I saws
Q.0067% O.K041% 0.00110% n/s
Page 4 of 7 2/10/2015
Page Number )6.
Exhibit EEunit 0-3e
Qochut 6 VGDB 98-0421-Obfe-04List of Respondents with Royalty Split Agreements and/or Court Orders
15G000532
Acres in Unit
Percent ofUnit
Division of Interest In
6-Right 7-Right8.1ofTS% 16.34981%
Psr .enlof Escmw
(5.2.1,4) Beverly Chaniel Slilwel! Cook Heirs. Devisees,Successcre or Assigns
(5.2.1.4.1)Cssondra Keen232 Bryant StreetCedar Blufl. VA 24609
0005 acresI/336 af 1.81acres
0.0067% 0 00041%0.00'!10'%6.3)
Cudis Lce Sliiwell
P.D. Box 2216Ceder Bkdf, VA 24509-22I6
O.O25 acmef/72 af 1.81acres
0.0314% 0.00192% 0.005'l4% 0.0749%
(5.4) Leonard Suwell Heirs, Davisees,Successors m Assigns
(5. L1) Ela* Elrzabsth Stilwell
c/o Bessie Laws1082 Riverside Ddve
Raven, VA 24639
0,022 acme1/84 of 1.81arses
0,0259% O.M184% 0.00440%»/o
(5.5) Thecdcre Stilwali
2122 Pea Patch RoadJeweg Ridge, VA 34622-8705
(6.8) Bessie Lowe1082 Rtverside Dr veRaven, VA 24639
0.022 acres1/84 of I 81 aCreS
0.022 acresI/54 of 1.81acre
0.0269% 0.00164'4 0.00440%
0.0269% 0.00164% 0.00440%
»/s
(5.7) Wanda Hagy127 Largen Street FERichlands, YA 24641
0.022 acres1/64 of 1,81 acme
0 0269% 0.00164% 0.00440%
(5.8) Camas James Carlos Siiiwell Heirs. Dsvisesu,Successors or Assigrw
(5.8.I) Cora Arnold Heirs, Dsvtsees,Successors or Asslgrs
Deeded ra Cora»»mid 'dur /r xr u 13 Qvu
Sss 5.1
(6) Chsnss Stllwell Hmrs, Devieees.Successors or Assigns
(6 1) Bamadms R Lisburg Heirs, Devlxees.Successom ar Assigns
(ti 2) David Wayne Stilwsll
507 E. kdnnesota 9107Rapid Cily, su 57701
Life Estele
0.038 acresI/48 of 1.5'I acres
0.0471% 0 00288y. 0.00771%
(6.3) Thomas H Slilwell
27 Homeshoe Trailer CL
Horace. ND 5604T 57'IB
0.036 acresI/48 cf 1.81 acme
0.0471% 0.00268%%u 0.00771% »/e
(6N) Qusmin A. sliiweil
P. D. Box 154Rhame, ND 58651
0 036 screeI/48 of 1.81acreS
0.0471% 0.00266% 0.00771% n/e
(5.2) Gladys E. POllert
1121 79 Street NW
Forge, ND 58102
0.038 acresI/48 of 1.81acres
0,0471% ~ .00288% 0.00771% n/e
(6.3) Daniel J. Slliwell
D77 El Rancho Trailer Ct.Ssandan, ND 56554
O.Q38 sc/es1/48 of 1.81acres
Q.0471% 0.00288% 0.00771% n/e
(6 7) Bernice R Lamb2124 County Road 116lntsmstrona! Fairs, kfN 66549
0.036 acres1/48 of 1.81 acres
0.0471tk 0.00288% 0.0077f% n/u
Page 5 cry 2/10/2015
Page Number 17.
Exhihit EEUnit II-36
Docket ¹VGQB 9S-0421-5648-94List of Respondents with Royalty Split Agreements and/or Court Orders
15000053"
Acres in Unit
Percent ofUnit
Division of Interest In
5-Right 7-Right6.10175% 16.349S1%
Percentot Esc mar
(7) Paul Elmer Stiiweg Heirs, Devlsees.Successors or Assigns
(7.1)Virginia N. Stilweii, wdcw1106Oral RoadRaven, VA 24539
0.226 acres1/8 of 1.81acme
0.2828% 0.01726% 0.04624% n/a
(8) Roley (a.k.e Raleigh) EdwarrfSIfwell Hers, Devfsces,Successors or Assrgns
(S) Marina J (e k.a. Juanita) Slilwel!
2375 Page Street, 6cx 2Richiands, VA 24541
D.226 acres 0.2828% 0.01726% D 04624% n/4
1/3 of 1.81 acres
Tract ttIC 2.1?scree
Total tmct acresTotal tract percent
1.7972.2468%
~WNERSHIP
(1) Hun McGu re land Trustoro Charles Green
P. O. Box 1067Blue/raid, VA 24S05
2.17 acres 2.7125% 0 165510% 0.443489% n/a
OIL 8 GAS OWNERSHIP
(\) Joe Nipper
1111Nipper RoadRaven, VA 24639
2 17 acme 2 7125% 0,165510% 0.443489% h/a
Tract ¹1D.2.0f acres
CJIAI OWNERSHIP
(1) Hurt NLGufre fend faustc,'o Chwies GreenP. Q. Box 1067Biuefiekf, VA 24605
2.01 acme 2.5125% 0.15330S'/ DA10789% n/a
OIL 6 GAS OWNERSHIP
(1) Dona ki NipperP. O. Box 909Raven, VA 24539
2.01 acme 2.5125% 0,153306% 0 410789% n/s
7ract ¹4C. d.95 acres
COAL OWNERSHIP
(I) Hurl McGwre Lend Trustcfo Chance GreenP. O Box 1007Sfushsld. Via?46D5
6 05 er/ea 7.5625% 0.461445% I 236454% nra
OIL 6 GAS OWNERSHIP
(1) Trueteesoflhewsdemess Tabernacle church
4656 Osborne Mounlaira Rd
Raven, VA 24S39
6.05 acme 7.5625% 0.481445% 1.236454% 3e 0745%
f'rovailfr'g claotiyf undec csee No ct 12-r/4rrwnrdrd 100% artie CSNroyafty.
Page 6 rd 7 2/10/201 5
Page Number ) ff.
Exhfhlt EEtink V-36
Docket ¹YDD 9 96-0421-0640-04List of Responoems wfth Royalty split Agreements and/or court onfers
15000053
Acies irl unitPercent Of
Unk
Division ot interest in
6.Right 7.Rigltt6.70175% 76.349917
Pementol Escrow
Tract ¹4D. 2.'/3 acies
COAL OfsnuEREHfo
(7) Hurt fuPGuim Laud Trust
c/o Gfmnes GreenP. Q. Eox 1067Bluekeid, VA 24605
GIL 6 Qae Ot¹HERSHfg
2.13 acres 2.6625% 0.1624 99 0435314% n/a
)'1) Vliglnh Stilwes
1106 Dial ReedRaven. VA 24639
2.1 3 ~ c fee 266257, 0 162459i/ 0.43531439 n/a
Total Acreage ResolvedTotal Percentage Resolved
14 1574'I7 6968'/
Page 7 of 7 2/10/2015
Page Number 19.
15000053"
POW ER OF ATTORNEYof
RAY51OXD DAVIS
l. Raymond Davis, a resident uf Raven, Virginia (Grantor and Grantee for the purpose of
indexing in the event this powwr of anorney is recorded) make thi» Power ofAttorney appointing T.
SHEA COOK my true and lawful anomev-in-fact. THIS POWER OF ATTORNEY IS UMITED TO
THE FOLLOWCIG
l. 'I'o receive the escmw royalty check from the VGOB,
2. Tu compare what I» obtained versus production record:
3. Deposit tbe same into the trust account of T. Shee Cook P.C and distrtbute the proceeds
according to foa agreement,
This Fewer ef attepney shaII be Limited tn natllre.
WITNESS the following signature and sml: ! '=~~AREAL)
RA'YtM6ND DA VIS
D~(S: %-I I-9 I
S fATE OF VIRGINIACOUN1 Y OF Wssatuell To 'Cat:
The fomgoing instmmect was acknowledged before me tbe 8 day of~ev..2014 by Raymond Davis.
bty commission expires %'5DI IS
ML~. h UA Q
rico ps»esseo . + aaass»Krr:
IUS Q>IIu ~ uru
Page Number 20.
150000582
POtrVKR OF Arf OIIPIEYof
JEFFERY DAVIS
I, leffeD Davis, a resident of Rain. Virginia (Grantor and Grantee for the purpose of
index~ in the event this pov or ofattorney is recorded) make this Power ofAttorney appoiniing T.
SHEA COOK my true and lawful anorney-in-fact THIS POWER OF ATTORNEY IS LLvtf I EDTO
THE FOLLOWING
l. Io receive the escrow royalty check from the VGOB;
2. To compare what is obtained versus production record;
3. Deposit the same into the trust account of T Shee Cook P.C. and Attribute thc proceeds
according to iee agreement.
This Power of attornev shag be Limited in nature
~S the followhtg signature and seal:
JQ~ DAVIS
D!0/Br
(SEAL)
STATE OF %'IRGMACOUNTY OF '~clue ~'iil To win
day of
o I I!
Notary PuMic,REG, +sama.
:, <er .:ease''..~s
o,II ui
My commission expims ~!%/
r'he
foregoing insnument was acknowledged before me the
fl WfttAIvr v, 2014 by ieffety Datds.
Page Number 2 t.
iS000053".
POWER OF ATTORNEYof
JKSSKE DAVIS
I, tessec Davis, a resident of Raven. Virginia (Cnnntor snd Cirantee for the purptne
oi'ndexing
iu the cvctrt dns power of attorney is recorded) make this Power ofAttorney appointing T.
SHEA COOK my true aud lawful attorney-In-fscL THIS POWER OF ATTORNEY IS UMITED TO
THF. FOLLOW&:G
1. To receive the escrow royalty check fiom the VGOER
2. To compare what is obtained versus production record;
3. Deposit the same inm the trust account of T. Shee Cook P.C. and distribute the proceeds
according to fee agrecmcnt,
This Pmver of attorney shall be Lhalted m nature.
WITNESS the following signature aud sctdt f~(SEAL)
JFBSEE DA VIS
DiOre: '- "W- /'2 V%.
STATE OF VIROFNIACO(1NTY OF ~6'~r r ~n& To wit:
foregoing. instrumem was acknowledged before me the 9 X day ofr, 2014 by Iessee Davis.
C,~'.Notary Pubhc
My commission expires' ~/8-
Page Number 22.
POWKR OF AlTORXKYof
IyIKUMIA DAVIS
I, Itdelinda Davis, s resideia of Raven, Virginia (Grarnor aud ~grr tbs purpose of
indexing in the event this power of'anotney is~)make this Power ofAtbsrttey appohaing T.
SHBA COOK roy tttz: aod lawful ~-~fact, THIS POWER OF ATTORNEY IS~TO
THE FOLLOWINO
I, Tu receive the esctovv royalty check Bum the VCi08„
2. To cofopaie vvbst Esobuuaod versus pludtlctxlu Iccoidr
3. Deposit tbe stuns into tbe truu scooura ofT. Shee Cook P.C. Nxl dbaribute tbe proceeds
to fee agreemenL
This Power uf~shag be Lhuhed iu aatursv
WITNESS the following htnatuue aud seat:
(aa '~w. 'I .ca. r (SEAL)
'BLIRDA DAVIS
Dr'0/8r
STATE OF VIRGINIACOUNTY OF TQ~. ~ To wit,
Tbe foregoing i~was acboowbrdged belore me tbe W4 day of.2014 by h4slinds Davis.
ri'iI.4,Rotary Public
bfy cotunuuuou expirtu 6 I ~» '
Page Number 23.
VIRGINIA:IN THE CIRCUIT COURT FOR THE COIJNTY OF BUCHANAN
RAYMOND DAVIS, et al,
Plaintiffs,
Case No. CL 12 - 174
HURT-MCGUIRE HEIRS LAND TRUST,BY ITS TRUSTEE CHARLES GREEN,
Defend ants.
FINAL ORDKR GRANTING JUDGMENT FOR PLAINTIFF
Upon the joint motion of Plaintiffs, Raymond Davis, Jessee Davis, Jeffrey Davis, and
Melinda Davis, m their capacity as Tmstees of the Wilderness Tabernacle Church, and
Defendant Hurt-McGuire Heirs Land Trust, for entry of judgment in favor of Plaintiff upon the
issue that it is the owner of the coal-bed methane gas at issue in this action and it is thereby
entitled to all royalties relating to the production thereof, it is, therefore,
ADJUDGED, ORDERED and DECREED that Plaintiffs, Raymond Davis, et al, are the
owners of the cord-bed methane gas at issue in this action and are entitled to all royalties relating
to the extraction of coal-bed methane gas by CNX Gas, LLC.
All other claims asserted by either of the remaining parties against the other are denied,
any motions pending before the Court are denied as moot, and this action is dismissed wdth
prejudice to the Plaintiff and Defendant. Hurt-McGuire, as to any such other claims.
The Clerk ts directed to forward an attested copy of this Final Order to all counsel of
record, to remove this matter from the active docket of this Court and to phce the same among
the ended actions before this Court.
ENTER: This the P day November, 2014.
Page Number 24.
i5000053"
I'AT|lItZ R 3DHNSQN
REQUES
Terence rifle Coo~sqCounsel for Plainttffs, Raymond Davis, Jessee Davis,Jeffrey Davis, and Melinda Davis, in their capacity asTrustees of the Wilderness Tabernacle Church,
REQUESTED:
Eric D. Whitesell, Esq.Of Counsel fox Defendant,Hurt-McOuire Heirs Land Trust
Page Number 25.
INBTP!P!ENT 415QDDD532RECORDED IN THE CLERK'B OFFICE GF
BUCHANAN COUNTY DN
APRIL h~ 2015 AT D2:ibPN
BEVEL.Y S. TIi LER~ CLERKFKCORDED BY: GGB