a content analysis of french online news media · 7/19/2010 · • argumentation schemes •...
TRANSCRIPT
![Page 1: A Content Analysis of French Online News Media · 7/19/2010 · • Argumentation schemes • Degrees of acceptability : • Certain vs. uncertain (Freudenburg, 2008) ; likely vs](https://reader035.vdocuments.us/reader035/viewer/2022081222/5f797b4f397fe23def31c24c/html5/thumbnails/1.jpg)
Communicating on Climate Negotiations A Content Analysis of
French Online News Media
Mathieu SIMONSON Technology Assessment
Research Unit University of Namur
Omar V. ROSAS Department of Political,
Social and Communication Sciences
University of Namur
19th July 2010
![Page 2: A Content Analysis of French Online News Media · 7/19/2010 · • Argumentation schemes • Degrees of acceptability : • Certain vs. uncertain (Freudenburg, 2008) ; likely vs](https://reader035.vdocuments.us/reader035/viewer/2022081222/5f797b4f397fe23def31c24c/html5/thumbnails/2.jpg)
Outline
1. Context
2. Platforms
3. Case study : methodology
4. Case study : results of discourse analysis
5. Conclusion
![Page 3: A Content Analysis of French Online News Media · 7/19/2010 · • Argumentation schemes • Degrees of acceptability : • Certain vs. uncertain (Freudenburg, 2008) ; likely vs](https://reader035.vdocuments.us/reader035/viewer/2022081222/5f797b4f397fe23def31c24c/html5/thumbnails/3.jpg)
Context • Increasing participation, increasing centrality of the
user (OxIS, 2010 ; Pew, 2009)
• France: 23% use the Internet as an important news source ; trust crisis (TNS Sofres, 2008)
![Page 4: A Content Analysis of French Online News Media · 7/19/2010 · • Argumentation schemes • Degrees of acceptability : • Certain vs. uncertain (Freudenburg, 2008) ; likely vs](https://reader035.vdocuments.us/reader035/viewer/2022081222/5f797b4f397fe23def31c24c/html5/thumbnails/4.jpg)
Platforms
• Three types of platforms
- Traditional journalism : Lemonde.fr, Lefigaro.fr …
- Citizen journalism : Agoravox, LePost.fr …
- Network journalism : Rue89, MediaPart …
![Page 5: A Content Analysis of French Online News Media · 7/19/2010 · • Argumentation schemes • Degrees of acceptability : • Certain vs. uncertain (Freudenburg, 2008) ; likely vs](https://reader035.vdocuments.us/reader035/viewer/2022081222/5f797b4f397fe23def31c24c/html5/thumbnails/5.jpg)
…
k
![Page 6: A Content Analysis of French Online News Media · 7/19/2010 · • Argumentation schemes • Degrees of acceptability : • Certain vs. uncertain (Freudenburg, 2008) ; likely vs](https://reader035.vdocuments.us/reader035/viewer/2022081222/5f797b4f397fe23def31c24c/html5/thumbnails/6.jpg)
Case Study
• French media coverage of climate negotiations (7th dec. 09 – 18th dec. 09)
• Previous research ? : Brossard & al. (2004); Dirickx & Gelders (2010)
![Page 7: A Content Analysis of French Online News Media · 7/19/2010 · • Argumentation schemes • Degrees of acceptability : • Certain vs. uncertain (Freudenburg, 2008) ; likely vs](https://reader035.vdocuments.us/reader035/viewer/2022081222/5f797b4f397fe23def31c24c/html5/thumbnails/7.jpg)
Method
- Data : 230 articles about “Copenhagen” : 2 traditional, 1 citizen, 1 network J. platform.
- Nvivo - Text-based codification :
identification of central/marginal actors and issues
- Discourse analysis (Searle, 1979 ; Van Eemeren & al., 2004)
![Page 8: A Content Analysis of French Online News Media · 7/19/2010 · • Argumentation schemes • Degrees of acceptability : • Certain vs. uncertain (Freudenburg, 2008) ; likely vs](https://reader035.vdocuments.us/reader035/viewer/2022081222/5f797b4f397fe23def31c24c/html5/thumbnails/8.jpg)
8
Platforms selected for this study
![Page 9: A Content Analysis of French Online News Media · 7/19/2010 · • Argumentation schemes • Degrees of acceptability : • Certain vs. uncertain (Freudenburg, 2008) ; likely vs](https://reader035.vdocuments.us/reader035/viewer/2022081222/5f797b4f397fe23def31c24c/html5/thumbnails/9.jpg)
I. Editorial choices
• Central/marginal themes • Traditional platforms focused on (1)
negotiations, (2) education/eco-sensitivity, (3) demonstrations, (4) communication
• Participatory platforms focused on (1) negotiations, (2) science, (3) education and (4) religion and ideology.
• Note : “demography” is stressed by Agoravox, “fact checking” by Rue89
9
![Page 10: A Content Analysis of French Online News Media · 7/19/2010 · • Argumentation schemes • Degrees of acceptability : • Certain vs. uncertain (Freudenburg, 2008) ; likely vs](https://reader035.vdocuments.us/reader035/viewer/2022081222/5f797b4f397fe23def31c24c/html5/thumbnails/10.jpg)
Central/marginal themes
10
![Page 11: A Content Analysis of French Online News Media · 7/19/2010 · • Argumentation schemes • Degrees of acceptability : • Certain vs. uncertain (Freudenburg, 2008) ; likely vs](https://reader035.vdocuments.us/reader035/viewer/2022081222/5f797b4f397fe23def31c24c/html5/thumbnails/11.jpg)
Central/marginal actors • Identification
• Political actors : developed (US, EU) vs. emerging and developing countries (BRIC, G77)
• Media, pressure groups … • Scientists and scholars : tendency relay the voices that are
convenient with the view one is willing to defend (Ereaut and Segnit, 2006 ; Carvalho, 2007)
• Evaluation : • Trustworthy (estiment, préconisent, pensent…) vs. discreputed
(brandissent, proclament, vocifèrent…) + ad personam, circumstanciae
• Dominant vs. dependant 11
![Page 12: A Content Analysis of French Online News Media · 7/19/2010 · • Argumentation schemes • Degrees of acceptability : • Certain vs. uncertain (Freudenburg, 2008) ; likely vs](https://reader035.vdocuments.us/reader035/viewer/2022081222/5f797b4f397fe23def31c24c/html5/thumbnails/12.jpg)
II. Speech Acts
1. Assertives 2. Directives 3. Commissives 4. Expressives 5. Declaratives
12
![Page 13: A Content Analysis of French Online News Media · 7/19/2010 · • Argumentation schemes • Degrees of acceptability : • Certain vs. uncertain (Freudenburg, 2008) ; likely vs](https://reader035.vdocuments.us/reader035/viewer/2022081222/5f797b4f397fe23def31c24c/html5/thumbnails/13.jpg)
1. Assertives • Definition: … commits oneself to the acceptability of • Argumentation schemes • Degrees of acceptability : • Certain vs. uncertain (Freudenburg, 2008) ; likely vs. unlikely • Ethics of inaction (Boykoff & Rajan, 2007)
• Platforms : • Participatory: (i) controversy, (ii) critique of the logics of
the negotiations • Traditional: (i) responsibility of actors, (ii) agreement
13
![Page 14: A Content Analysis of French Online News Media · 7/19/2010 · • Argumentation schemes • Degrees of acceptability : • Certain vs. uncertain (Freudenburg, 2008) ; likely vs](https://reader035.vdocuments.us/reader035/viewer/2022081222/5f797b4f397fe23def31c24c/html5/thumbnails/14.jpg)
2. Directives • Definition: … gets someone to do (of to refrain to
do) something
• Degrees of obligation : • Forbidden, mandatory : should (not), ought (not) to ; • Permitted, optional : can, could, don’t have to etc.
• Platforms : • Traditional platforms (LM, LF) : edito, carte blanche • Citizen platform (AG) : in every article.
14
![Page 15: A Content Analysis of French Online News Media · 7/19/2010 · • Argumentation schemes • Degrees of acceptability : • Certain vs. uncertain (Freudenburg, 2008) ; likely vs](https://reader035.vdocuments.us/reader035/viewer/2022081222/5f797b4f397fe23def31c24c/html5/thumbnails/15.jpg)
3. Commissives • Definition: One claims that one undertakes (…) to
do something
• Promise, commitment : I/we will, continue, maintain, accept, reject …
• Reflexive act : subjectivity (personal responsibility)
• Platforms : • Traditional platfoms : - • Participatory platform (RU) : +
15
![Page 16: A Content Analysis of French Online News Media · 7/19/2010 · • Argumentation schemes • Degrees of acceptability : • Certain vs. uncertain (Freudenburg, 2008) ; likely vs](https://reader035.vdocuments.us/reader035/viewer/2022081222/5f797b4f397fe23def31c24c/html5/thumbnails/16.jpg)
4. Expressives • Definition: Expression on personal feelings
• Reflexive act : subjectivity, regret, congratulation
• Platforms : • Traditional Media (LM, LF) : rare, quotes only • Citizen media (AG) : more frequent • “I won’t regret”, “a pity” (RU), “would be sad” (AG) • It is indecent, I’m outraged (AG) • Apologies : “naïvely, I have taken it for granted”, “I should have
been” (AG) 16
![Page 17: A Content Analysis of French Online News Media · 7/19/2010 · • Argumentation schemes • Degrees of acceptability : • Certain vs. uncertain (Freudenburg, 2008) ; likely vs](https://reader035.vdocuments.us/reader035/viewer/2022081222/5f797b4f397fe23def31c24c/html5/thumbnails/17.jpg)
5. Declaratives • Definition: To obtain the acceptance of a reality
among a given audience
• Platforms : • (1) about climate science : “the bases of science are
stable” (Trad.) vs. “severely damaged”, “discredited”… • (2) about the negotiations : “historical
moment” (Trad.) vs. “media circus” • Gap … • between science/politics as it is, and as we want it
to be 17
![Page 18: A Content Analysis of French Online News Media · 7/19/2010 · • Argumentation schemes • Degrees of acceptability : • Certain vs. uncertain (Freudenburg, 2008) ; likely vs](https://reader035.vdocuments.us/reader035/viewer/2022081222/5f797b4f397fe23def31c24c/html5/thumbnails/18.jpg)
Conclusions
The mere identification of central issues/actors establishes specific frameworks which favour the expression of particular viewpoints.
True for both traditional and participatory media
Participatory press assumes a higher degree of subjectivity than traditional media.
Citizen platform (AgoraVox) is concerned with the free expression of marginal viewpoints, and th critique of institutional viewpoints
Network journalism platform (Rue89) is concerned with media reflexivity and – presumably - interaction with the reader.
18
![Page 19: A Content Analysis of French Online News Media · 7/19/2010 · • Argumentation schemes • Degrees of acceptability : • Certain vs. uncertain (Freudenburg, 2008) ; likely vs](https://reader035.vdocuments.us/reader035/viewer/2022081222/5f797b4f397fe23def31c24c/html5/thumbnails/19.jpg)
Thank you !
19
![Page 20: A Content Analysis of French Online News Media · 7/19/2010 · • Argumentation schemes • Degrees of acceptability : • Certain vs. uncertain (Freudenburg, 2008) ; likely vs](https://reader035.vdocuments.us/reader035/viewer/2022081222/5f797b4f397fe23def31c24c/html5/thumbnails/20.jpg)
Speech Act Analysis (1)
20
Assertives (Committing oneself to the acceptability of a particular proposition)
*Existence (or inexistence) of GW
Not frequent. Only one instance on AgoraVox
*Causes of GW More frequent. Mostly emphasized by participatory media. Traditional media only mentioned causes in response to climate skeptics
*Actual and possible consequences of GW
*Actors’ Responsibility in GW
Directives (trying to get someone to do something or to refrain from doing something)
*Actor/Negotiations Participatory Media: collective commitment to fight against GW/Political leaders’ responsibility in negotiations Traditional Media: focus on (European)political leaders/financial help for developing countries
*Media/Communication Participatory Media: criticisms at the shared international editorial (The Guardian)/criticisms directed at media appearances of climate skeptics Traditional Media: relayed deontic assessments coming from other newspapers (Daily Telegraph, Guardian, Financial Times)
*Science Participatory Media: Climate skepticism and Anthropogenic Global Warming Traditional Media: Climategate and its impact on negotiations
*Social/Political Issues Participatory Media: Educations for Sustainable Development (RU89)/Urgent worldwide social problems besides GW (AG) Traditional Media: Global expectations during and after negotiations(LF)/climate-friendly collective action (LM)
![Page 21: A Content Analysis of French Online News Media · 7/19/2010 · • Argumentation schemes • Degrees of acceptability : • Certain vs. uncertain (Freudenburg, 2008) ; likely vs](https://reader035.vdocuments.us/reader035/viewer/2022081222/5f797b4f397fe23def31c24c/html5/thumbnails/21.jpg)
Speech Acts Analysis (2)
21
Commissive (claiming that one undertakes to do—or refrains from doing—
something)
*Eco-sensitivity (LF) *CO2 emission cuts (LF)
“We will honor our words by real acts..”
*First-person pronoun (Rue89) “I will continue”, “I will maintain”
Expressives (expressing one’s personal feelings)
Traditional Media: Expressives appear only in quotes
“Mr. Sarkozy ‘hopes that’..”
Participatory Media: First-person pronouns
“I’m sorry but I can’t stand to it..”
Declaratives (looking to have a reality accepted by the audience)
Traditional Media legitimates public actors and sets a frame for political interaction
IPCC’s report is “unequivocal” “Science id settled” (Al Gore)