a comparison of iso 9613-2 and advanced calculation ... · •member of ioa, asa, aes, helina,...
TRANSCRIPT
![Page 1: A Comparison of ISO 9613-2 and Advanced Calculation ... · •Member of IOA, ASA, AES, HELINA, IEEE, and the Cyprus Technical Chamber (ETEK). Slide 3 of 33 Introduction PART 1 . Slide](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022051921/600e802f7b559f44572b6fbf/html5/thumbnails/1.jpg)
Slide 1 of 33
Panos Economou Mediterranean Acoustics Research & Development
Cyprus
21st March 2012
A Comparison of ISO 9613-2 and Advanced Calculation Methods Using Olive Tree Lab-
Terrain, An Outdoor Sound Propagation Software Application: Predictions Versus
Experimental Results
![Page 2: A Comparison of ISO 9613-2 and Advanced Calculation ... · •Member of IOA, ASA, AES, HELINA, IEEE, and the Cyprus Technical Chamber (ETEK). Slide 3 of 33 Introduction PART 1 . Slide](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022051921/600e802f7b559f44572b6fbf/html5/thumbnails/2.jpg)
Slide 2 of 33
Panos Economou’s background
• Founder of Panacoustics Ltd an acoustics consultancy in Cyprus in 1982
• Between 1990 and 1992, Principal Engineer at Noise and Vibration Department Atkins-Epsom, UK, in charge of Architectural Acoustics
• Founder of P.E. Meditarranean Acoustics Research & Development (PEMARD) – developers of Olive Tree Lab - Terrain™, in Cyprus in 2009
Panos holds • BSc in Mechanical Engineering • MSc in Applied Acoustics • Member of IOA, ASA, AES, HELINA, IEEE, and the
Cyprus Technical Chamber (ETEK).
![Page 3: A Comparison of ISO 9613-2 and Advanced Calculation ... · •Member of IOA, ASA, AES, HELINA, IEEE, and the Cyprus Technical Chamber (ETEK). Slide 3 of 33 Introduction PART 1 . Slide](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022051921/600e802f7b559f44572b6fbf/html5/thumbnails/3.jpg)
Slide 3 of 33
Introduction
PART 1
![Page 4: A Comparison of ISO 9613-2 and Advanced Calculation ... · •Member of IOA, ASA, AES, HELINA, IEEE, and the Cyprus Technical Chamber (ETEK). Slide 3 of 33 Introduction PART 1 . Slide](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022051921/600e802f7b559f44572b6fbf/html5/thumbnails/4.jpg)
Slide 4 of 33
Introduction
• Mediterranean Acoustics Poll on LinkedIn showed that well above 50% of acousticians favour ISO 9613-2 for outdoor sound propagation.
• Nord 2000, Harmonoise, Concawe and other methods share the remaining 50% of those asked.
• Nord 2000, Harmonoise are advanced calculation models implemented in user friendly software.
• How many ISO 9613-2 users are there in this room?
Overview
![Page 5: A Comparison of ISO 9613-2 and Advanced Calculation ... · •Member of IOA, ASA, AES, HELINA, IEEE, and the Cyprus Technical Chamber (ETEK). Slide 3 of 33 Introduction PART 1 . Slide](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022051921/600e802f7b559f44572b6fbf/html5/thumbnails/5.jpg)
Slide 5 of 33
Introduction
This is a question you might help answer after the presentation during a brief discussion.
Why is ISO 9613-2 still the favourite method?
![Page 6: A Comparison of ISO 9613-2 and Advanced Calculation ... · •Member of IOA, ASA, AES, HELINA, IEEE, and the Cyprus Technical Chamber (ETEK). Slide 3 of 33 Introduction PART 1 . Slide](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022051921/600e802f7b559f44572b6fbf/html5/thumbnails/6.jpg)
Slide 6 of 33
Standards vs Independent Research Standards
• Positive: standards provide same answers by
independent users
• Negative: perceived as dogma, and often
provide inaccurate results
• By-products: provide widely accepted
algorithms
Introduction
![Page 7: A Comparison of ISO 9613-2 and Advanced Calculation ... · •Member of IOA, ASA, AES, HELINA, IEEE, and the Cyprus Technical Chamber (ETEK). Slide 3 of 33 Introduction PART 1 . Slide](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022051921/600e802f7b559f44572b6fbf/html5/thumbnails/7.jpg)
Slide 7 of 33
Independent Research
• Detective work with lots of twists and turns in
the plot
• Great fun and mentally rewarding
• It needs intuition and a stomach for the ups &
downs
• By-products: unique algorithms – possibly less
widely accepted
Introduction
![Page 8: A Comparison of ISO 9613-2 and Advanced Calculation ... · •Member of IOA, ASA, AES, HELINA, IEEE, and the Cyprus Technical Chamber (ETEK). Slide 3 of 33 Introduction PART 1 . Slide](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022051921/600e802f7b559f44572b6fbf/html5/thumbnails/8.jpg)
Slide 8 of 33
Software (SW) based on Standards vs Independent research
• SW based on standards provide: simpler code,
fast and approximate results
• SW based on Research provides: complicated
code, slower yet more accurate results than
sw on standards
Introduction
![Page 9: A Comparison of ISO 9613-2 and Advanced Calculation ... · •Member of IOA, ASA, AES, HELINA, IEEE, and the Cyprus Technical Chamber (ETEK). Slide 3 of 33 Introduction PART 1 . Slide](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022051921/600e802f7b559f44572b6fbf/html5/thumbnails/9.jpg)
Slide 9 of 33
What follows in this presentation
• OTL- Terrain theoretical background
• ISO 9613-2 background
• Presentation of comparison of results
• Discussions on results
• Conclusions
Introduction
![Page 10: A Comparison of ISO 9613-2 and Advanced Calculation ... · •Member of IOA, ASA, AES, HELINA, IEEE, and the Cyprus Technical Chamber (ETEK). Slide 3 of 33 Introduction PART 1 . Slide](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022051921/600e802f7b559f44572b6fbf/html5/thumbnails/10.jpg)
Slide 10 of 33
Background – OTL - Terrain
OTL – Terrain is based on the work of : • Salomon’s ray model using analytical solutions
• Hadden & Pierce for spherical wave diffraction coefficients
• Chessel for spherical wave reflection coefficients
• Delany & Basley for finite surface impedance
• Clay on finite size reflectors with Fresnel zones
• Keller on his geometrical theory of diffraction
• Sound path explorer – an in-house model to detect and draw diffraction and reflection sound paths in a 3D environment
• Harmonoise for atmospheric turbulence
![Page 11: A Comparison of ISO 9613-2 and Advanced Calculation ... · •Member of IOA, ASA, AES, HELINA, IEEE, and the Cyprus Technical Chamber (ETEK). Slide 3 of 33 Introduction PART 1 . Slide](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022051921/600e802f7b559f44572b6fbf/html5/thumbnails/11.jpg)
Slide 11 of 33
ISO 9613 – 2, background
• Empirical method adopted as a standard in 1996
• Lends itself for spreadsheet calculations
• There were good reasons at that time for adopting ISO 9613-2 as a standard
But
• There is ambiguity in its implementation
• Two different users can come up with different results
Background – ISO 9613 - 2
![Page 12: A Comparison of ISO 9613-2 and Advanced Calculation ... · •Member of IOA, ASA, AES, HELINA, IEEE, and the Cyprus Technical Chamber (ETEK). Slide 3 of 33 Introduction PART 1 . Slide](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022051921/600e802f7b559f44572b6fbf/html5/thumbnails/12.jpg)
Slide 12 of 33
Presentation of comparison of results among, OTL – Terrain, ISO 9613-2 and
published measured data.
PART 3
![Page 13: A Comparison of ISO 9613-2 and Advanced Calculation ... · •Member of IOA, ASA, AES, HELINA, IEEE, and the Cyprus Technical Chamber (ETEK). Slide 3 of 33 Introduction PART 1 . Slide](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022051921/600e802f7b559f44572b6fbf/html5/thumbnails/13.jpg)
Slide 13 of 33
Published measured data used, was also used for the validation of Nord2000 model.
• Cases selected from measured data are based on distance,
with and without barrier. Also, chosen to be simple to be
handled by ISO 9613-2.
Presentation of comparison of results
Cases used for the validation of NORD 2000 (www.delta.dk) and implemented in ISO 9613-2 and OTL – Terrain.
Distance
S - R
4.5 m Case 13 Case 17 Case 33 Case 36
50 m Case 91 Case 92
100 m Case 77
120 m Case 40
![Page 14: A Comparison of ISO 9613-2 and Advanced Calculation ... · •Member of IOA, ASA, AES, HELINA, IEEE, and the Cyprus Technical Chamber (ETEK). Slide 3 of 33 Introduction PART 1 . Slide](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022051921/600e802f7b559f44572b6fbf/html5/thumbnails/14.jpg)
Slide 14 of 33
Presentation of results template
• All results in Excess Attenuation (EA i.e. Transfer Function) which is the effect of the environment on direct sound.
• Results: Black dots represent measurements results, the blue curve OTL - Terrain results and the red curve ISO 9613-2 results
• Geometry
• Sound paths between Source and Receiver up to 3rd order diffraction
• Mapping, using OTL – Terrain, either on vertical or horizontal planes
• Depending on the case, mapping shows EA of ground, EA of barrier, level with or without barrier
-30-25-20-15-10
-505
10
10 100 1000 10000frequency Hz
SP
L r
e F
F d
B
OTL - Terrain Measurements ISO 9613-2
case 40
120.0,
0.0
2.3,
0.0
11.0,
2.7
9.0,
2.7
S R
0.0,
0.7
120.0,
1.5
case 40
Results Geometry sound paths mapping of EA or Lp
![Page 15: A Comparison of ISO 9613-2 and Advanced Calculation ... · •Member of IOA, ASA, AES, HELINA, IEEE, and the Cyprus Technical Chamber (ETEK). Slide 3 of 33 Introduction PART 1 . Slide](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022051921/600e802f7b559f44572b6fbf/html5/thumbnails/15.jpg)
Slide 15 of 33
Distance
S - R
4.5 m Case 13 Case 17 Case 33 Case 36
50 m Case 91 Case 92
100 m Case 77
120 m Case 40
Sound paths between
Source and Receiver
Mapping, on horizontal plane
depicting EA of ground,
broadband results
Mapping, on horizontal plane
depicting EA of ground, 10 kHz
![Page 16: A Comparison of ISO 9613-2 and Advanced Calculation ... · •Member of IOA, ASA, AES, HELINA, IEEE, and the Cyprus Technical Chamber (ETEK). Slide 3 of 33 Introduction PART 1 . Slide](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022051921/600e802f7b559f44572b6fbf/html5/thumbnails/16.jpg)
Slide 16 of 33
Distance
S - R
4.5 m Case 13 Case 17 Case 33 Case 36
50 m Case 91 Case 92
100 m Case 77
120 m Case 40
Sound paths between
Source and Receiver
EA mapping, on vertical plane
behind barrier
EA mapping on horizontal plane
across barrier
![Page 17: A Comparison of ISO 9613-2 and Advanced Calculation ... · •Member of IOA, ASA, AES, HELINA, IEEE, and the Cyprus Technical Chamber (ETEK). Slide 3 of 33 Introduction PART 1 . Slide](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022051921/600e802f7b559f44572b6fbf/html5/thumbnails/17.jpg)
Slide 17 of 33
Distance
S - R
4.5 m Case 13 Case 17 Case 33 Case 36
50 m Case 91 Case 92
100 m Case 77
120 m Case 40
Sound paths between
Source and Receiver
SPL mapping, on vertical plane
across barrier BEFORE
SPL mapping, on vertical plane
across barrier AFTER
![Page 18: A Comparison of ISO 9613-2 and Advanced Calculation ... · •Member of IOA, ASA, AES, HELINA, IEEE, and the Cyprus Technical Chamber (ETEK). Slide 3 of 33 Introduction PART 1 . Slide](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022051921/600e802f7b559f44572b6fbf/html5/thumbnails/18.jpg)
Slide 18 of 33
Distance
S - R
4.5 m Case 13 Case 17 Case 33 Case 36
50 m Case 91 Case 92
100 m Case 77
120 m Case 40
Sound paths between
Source and Receiver
EA mapping, on horizontal plane
across barriers, side view
EA mapping, on horizontal plane
across barriers, top view
![Page 19: A Comparison of ISO 9613-2 and Advanced Calculation ... · •Member of IOA, ASA, AES, HELINA, IEEE, and the Cyprus Technical Chamber (ETEK). Slide 3 of 33 Introduction PART 1 . Slide](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022051921/600e802f7b559f44572b6fbf/html5/thumbnails/19.jpg)
Slide 19 of 33
Distance
S - R
4.5 m Case 13 Case 17 Case 33 Case 36
50 m Case 91 Case 92
100 m Case 77
120 m Case 40
Sound paths between
Source and Receiver
SPL mapping, on vertical plane
across barrier BEFORE
SPL mapping, on vertical plane
across barrier AFTER
![Page 20: A Comparison of ISO 9613-2 and Advanced Calculation ... · •Member of IOA, ASA, AES, HELINA, IEEE, and the Cyprus Technical Chamber (ETEK). Slide 3 of 33 Introduction PART 1 . Slide](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022051921/600e802f7b559f44572b6fbf/html5/thumbnails/20.jpg)
Slide 20 of 33
Distance
S - R
4.5 m Case 13 Case 17 Case 33 Case 36
50 m Case 91 Case 92
100 m Case 77
120 m Case 40
EA mapping, on vertical planes,
10kHz
EA mapping, on vertical planes,
broadband
Sound paths between
Source and Receiver
![Page 21: A Comparison of ISO 9613-2 and Advanced Calculation ... · •Member of IOA, ASA, AES, HELINA, IEEE, and the Cyprus Technical Chamber (ETEK). Slide 3 of 33 Introduction PART 1 . Slide](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022051921/600e802f7b559f44572b6fbf/html5/thumbnails/21.jpg)
Slide 21 of 33
Distance
S - R
4.5 m Case 13 Case 17 Case 33 Case 36
50 m Case 91 Case 92
100 m Case 77
120 m Case 40
Sound paths between
Source and Receiver
EA mapping, on horizontal plane
across barrier, side view 10 kHz EA mapping, on horizontal plane
across barrier, top view 10 kHz
![Page 22: A Comparison of ISO 9613-2 and Advanced Calculation ... · •Member of IOA, ASA, AES, HELINA, IEEE, and the Cyprus Technical Chamber (ETEK). Slide 3 of 33 Introduction PART 1 . Slide](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022051921/600e802f7b559f44572b6fbf/html5/thumbnails/22.jpg)
Slide 22 of 33
Distance
S - R
4.5 m Case 13 Case 17 Case 33 Case 36
50 m Case 91 Case 92
100 m Case 77
120 m Case 40
Sound paths between
Source and Receiver
SPL mapping, on horizontal
plane across barrier BEFORE
SPL mapping, on horizontal plane
across barrier AFTER
![Page 23: A Comparison of ISO 9613-2 and Advanced Calculation ... · •Member of IOA, ASA, AES, HELINA, IEEE, and the Cyprus Technical Chamber (ETEK). Slide 3 of 33 Introduction PART 1 . Slide](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022051921/600e802f7b559f44572b6fbf/html5/thumbnails/23.jpg)
Slide 23 of 33
Discussion On Comparison Of Results • Measurement data
• OTL-Terrain results
• ISO 9613-2 results
PART 4
![Page 24: A Comparison of ISO 9613-2 and Advanced Calculation ... · •Member of IOA, ASA, AES, HELINA, IEEE, and the Cyprus Technical Chamber (ETEK). Slide 3 of 33 Introduction PART 1 . Slide](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022051921/600e802f7b559f44572b6fbf/html5/thumbnails/24.jpg)
Slide 24 of 33
Measurement Data • There is little information on methodology used to obtain
results for the cases examined
• We were able to track down some of the cases where the
methodology is given but which are not included in this
presentation
• K.B. Rasmussen, the person who conducted some of the
sound measurements, mentions that for some cases there
was uncertainty about the choice of flow resistivity.
Discussion On Comparison Of Results
![Page 25: A Comparison of ISO 9613-2 and Advanced Calculation ... · •Member of IOA, ASA, AES, HELINA, IEEE, and the Cyprus Technical Chamber (ETEK). Slide 3 of 33 Introduction PART 1 . Slide](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022051921/600e802f7b559f44572b6fbf/html5/thumbnails/25.jpg)
Slide 25 of 33
OTL – Terrain Results
• Fair match between OTL-Terrain & measurements
• Anticipated better agreement
• More information on measurements allows better modelling
• We have conducted measurements to simulate diffraction
(scattering) from stone steps in ancient theatres.
• Lateral shifts of source or receiver with respect to the barrier
produce significant change in results.
Discussion On Comparison Of Results
![Page 26: A Comparison of ISO 9613-2 and Advanced Calculation ... · •Member of IOA, ASA, AES, HELINA, IEEE, and the Cyprus Technical Chamber (ETEK). Slide 3 of 33 Introduction PART 1 . Slide](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022051921/600e802f7b559f44572b6fbf/html5/thumbnails/26.jpg)
Slide 26 of 33
-30
-25
-20
-15
-10
-5
0
5
10
10 100 1000 10000frequency Hz
SP
L r
e F
F d
B
MeasurementsOTL - Terrain S-R axis at 90 deg to barrierOTL - Terrain Receiver shifted by 5cm off axis to the left
case 36
OTL – Terrain Results contd. • Results are very sensitive to 3d modelling
• 5cm shift of receiver to the left, improves match between measurements & simulation
Discussion On Comparison Of Results
-30
-25
-20
-15
-10
-5
0
5
10
10 100 1000 10000frequency Hz
SP
L r
e F
F d
B
MeasurementsOTL - Terrain S-R axis at 90 deg to barrierOTL - Terrain Receiver shifted by 5cm off axis to the left
case 36
Case 36
![Page 27: A Comparison of ISO 9613-2 and Advanced Calculation ... · •Member of IOA, ASA, AES, HELINA, IEEE, and the Cyprus Technical Chamber (ETEK). Slide 3 of 33 Introduction PART 1 . Slide](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022051921/600e802f7b559f44572b6fbf/html5/thumbnails/27.jpg)
Slide 27 of 33
ISO 9613-2 Results • Apparent deviations from measured data
• Lack of detail to interpret sound propagation mechanisms
• Ambiguity of the standard could allow different results
-30
-25
-20
-15
-10
-5
0
5
10
100 1000 10000frequency Hz
SP
L r
e F
F d
B
1st order diff Measurements 2nd order diff
case 33
Discussion On Comparison Of Results
![Page 28: A Comparison of ISO 9613-2 and Advanced Calculation ... · •Member of IOA, ASA, AES, HELINA, IEEE, and the Cyprus Technical Chamber (ETEK). Slide 3 of 33 Introduction PART 1 . Slide](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022051921/600e802f7b559f44572b6fbf/html5/thumbnails/28.jpg)
Slide 28 of 33
Conclusions PART 5
![Page 29: A Comparison of ISO 9613-2 and Advanced Calculation ... · •Member of IOA, ASA, AES, HELINA, IEEE, and the Cyprus Technical Chamber (ETEK). Slide 3 of 33 Introduction PART 1 . Slide](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022051921/600e802f7b559f44572b6fbf/html5/thumbnails/29.jpg)
Slide 29 of 33
ISO 9613-2
• Empirical method
• Simple in concept to be understood
• Simple to implement
• Widely used since its publication in 1996
• It has served the acoustical community well
But
• Inaccurate and imprecise
Conclusions
![Page 30: A Comparison of ISO 9613-2 and Advanced Calculation ... · •Member of IOA, ASA, AES, HELINA, IEEE, and the Cyprus Technical Chamber (ETEK). Slide 3 of 33 Introduction PART 1 . Slide](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022051921/600e802f7b559f44572b6fbf/html5/thumbnails/30.jpg)
Slide 30 of 33
Advanced calculation methods offer
Conclusions
Sound rays in a 3D environment carrying
information on how to:
• Lose intensity vs distance
• Interact with atmosphere, turbulence and refraction
• Reflect from objects
• Diffract around and scatter from objects
• In the near future, lose intensity through structures
![Page 31: A Comparison of ISO 9613-2 and Advanced Calculation ... · •Member of IOA, ASA, AES, HELINA, IEEE, and the Cyprus Technical Chamber (ETEK). Slide 3 of 33 Introduction PART 1 . Slide](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022051921/600e802f7b559f44572b6fbf/html5/thumbnails/31.jpg)
Slide 31 of 33
In the future advanced calculation methods could offer….
One calculations engine for:
• Outdoor Sound Propagation
• Building acoustics
• Room acoustics
• Duct-borne sound transmission and others
But
• They are computationally expensive
Conclusions
![Page 32: A Comparison of ISO 9613-2 and Advanced Calculation ... · •Member of IOA, ASA, AES, HELINA, IEEE, and the Cyprus Technical Chamber (ETEK). Slide 3 of 33 Introduction PART 1 . Slide](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022051921/600e802f7b559f44572b6fbf/html5/thumbnails/32.jpg)
Slide 32 of 33
Conclusions
• Nowadays technology allows the replacement of old empirical methods with new scientific methods
• Advanced calculation methods offer better results
But
• Their implementation in software applications should offer more answers than questions
• Users need a better understanding of the science behind them in order to properly interpret results
• They need to serve the user and not the other way round
We say,
“The less time one needs to use a software application the better the application is”
![Page 33: A Comparison of ISO 9613-2 and Advanced Calculation ... · •Member of IOA, ASA, AES, HELINA, IEEE, and the Cyprus Technical Chamber (ETEK). Slide 3 of 33 Introduction PART 1 . Slide](https://reader033.vdocuments.us/reader033/viewer/2022051921/600e802f7b559f44572b6fbf/html5/thumbnails/33.jpg)
Slide 33 of 33
Discussion
I would welcome some answers, questions or comments.
The question still remains: Why is ISO 9613-2 still the favourite
method?
Thank you for your attention.