A comparative study of M.A.Jinnah and S.C.Bose

Sidra Jabeen Khan

IntroductionHeroes success and lost

legacy Jinnah: Charismatic

leader Bose: true

nationalist criticism Great Quaid Warrior Bose Conflict in thoughts

Beginning Years (early life-1910)S.C.Bose: Intellectualstudies in philosophyCalcutta and Cambridge educational

institutesSwami Viveknanda as spiritual guideviolent meansICS officer

Beginning Years (early life-1910)M.A.Jinnah: studied lawMadrasa tul IslamEnglandcharisma emergingStart of PoliticsJoining of CongressA lawyer

Formative Years (1911-1920)S.C.Bose: completion of studiesTopped ranksICS officer4th position in ICS exam

Formative Years (1911-1920)M.A.Jinnah: Formation of intrinsic magnetismhypocrisy of Congresspolitical journeyMarriagedaughter

1913: joining Muslim League

1917: president of Home rule league

1920: resigned home rule league

and congress

Years of disillusionment and tangled politics (1920-1935)S.C.Bose: political careerhard strugglecampaigns, strikes prison timingsfighting’s against Raj

1934: Returned to India

11 time jails

1932: Issued

manifesto in Vienna

Nov, 1934: Issued

book: “The Indian

Struggle”

1930: mayor of Calcutta

Years of disillusionment and tangled politics (1920-1935)M.A.Jinnah: political rivalriesambassador of Hindu-Muslim unityHindu Vendettasuffered in personal lifeExilereturn to Indiatactics

1922: APC

1927: Simon Commission

1925: national convention

1929: Nehru Report

1930: Round Table Conferences

Reawakening (1935-1940)S.C.Bose: joining of CongressJinnah-Bose correspondenceviolent meansdifferences with GandhiResignationhouse arrest

Reawakening (1935-1940)M.A.Jinnah: ElectionsCongress Rajheight of Charismaresolution as phoenix in the ashes

1936: elections

1937: provincial elections

Congress raj

1939: day of Deliverance

1940: Lahore Resolution passed

A good fighter & a warrior (1941-1948)S.C.Bose: escaped house arrestseek Hitler’s help formation of Azad

Hind Radio, army and Govt

war against Britishcounterattack of

commonwealthescaped to Russiakilled in Japanese

Bomber (1945)

Calcutta

Gomo

PeshawarKabul

Germany

Escaped house arrest

Seeked help from

Adolf Hitler

Formed:

Azad Hind Radio Station

(1943)Azad Hind

Fauj (Singapore,

India)Azad Hind

Government (own rules)

Freed admand & Mcobar

Islands

Named them as Swaraj &

Shaheed

Rangoon became new basecamp

Barma: Hoist Indian flag in

Manipul

Counterattack of common

wealth

Retreat and fall of

Rangoon

Bose’s dreams destroyed

Escaped to Russia for

seeking help

Got killed in Japanese

Bomber in Taipei

A good fighter & a warrior (1941-1948)M.A.Jinnah: Jinnah’s successAIML sessionsGandhi Jinnah talkscabinet Mission planIndependenceQuaid-e-Azam1st governor Generaldeath (1948)

A Fight

er

1943: rejected Raja

Gopal Acchariya formula

1944: Gandhi Jinnah talks

1945: Simla conference

1946: sweeps polls in

elections, accept cabinet

mission plan then rejected

1947: Indian Independence act passed,

Pakistan came into

being

ConclusionBrave and courageousCharismamagnetic personalitiesmastermind tactician JinnahEmotional fool Boselost legacy of BoseA great hero Jinnah

THE LIGHT SHINES IN THE DARKNESS

AND THE DARKNESS HASN’T OVERCOME IT..!!

THANK YOU SO MUCH FOR LISTENING