a comparative study of 8-hydroxyquinoline-5-sulphonic … loaded on f-400 granular activated carbon...
TRANSCRIPT
INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENCES Volume 3, No 6, 2013
© Copyright by the authors - Licensee IPA- Under Creative Commons license 3.0
Research article ISSN 0976 – 4402
Received on May 2013 Published on July 2013 2048
A comparative study of 8-hydroxyquinoline-5-sulphonic acid and its 7-nitro
derivative loaded on F-400 granular activated carbon for removal of
copper ions from aqueous solutions Doss V.R, Kodolikar S.P
Department of Chemical Engineering, Sinhgad College of Engineering, Vadgaon (Bk),
Pune -411041, Maharashtra, India
doi: 10.6088/ijes.2013030600024
ABSTRACT
The purpose of this study was to compare 8-hydroxyquinoline -5-sulphonic acid (QSA) and
its 7- nitro derivative (NQSA) loaded on F-400 GAC as a suitable adsorbent material for
adsorption of Cu ions in aqueous solutions. Batch experiments were performed to evaluate
effect of various parameters like pH, contact time, temperature, agitation speed, etc. Kinetic
studies were done which showed 90.14% removal of copper for QSA and 94.19% removal
for NQSA. The adsorption isotherm data were validated to Langmuir, Freundlich and DR
isotherms. Kinetic data showed that it follows pseudo second order kinetics for both QSA and
NQSA. The thermodynamic parameters of the adsorption process like Gibb’s free energy,
entropy and enthalpy were also determined for both the ligands. The Langmuir constants
have been calculated at different temperatures and the adsorption is found to be exothermic
(∆ H = -36.08 kJ/mole for QSA and ∆ H = -48.11 kJ/mole for NQSA). Maximum removal is
observed at pH 5.5 for both the ligands. It has been observed in the qe values that even though
NQSA is adsorbed to a marginally lower extent than QSA, it is able to remove more copper
than QSA because of proper orientation to form a 1:2 complex with copper ions on the
surface of ligand loaded GAC. The results demonstrates that NQSA loaded GAC has an edge
over QSA as an effective adsorbent for removal of copper ions. The 7-nitro derivative owing
to its bulky nature shows better adsorption capacity.
Keywords: Adsorption, Isotherms, Kinetics, Thermodynamics, Heavy metals, Ligands, 8-
hydroxyquinoline -5-sulphonic acid and Granular Activated Carbon.
1. Introduction
Many industrial processes involve the use of materials that are potentially toxic if released
into the environment. The industrial effluents containing heavy metals pose severe threat to
ecology when allowed to mix with surface waters by altering the chemistry of the receiving
water. The treatment and disposal of heavy metal bearing waste presents a unique challenge.
Many physico-chemical processes are employed for the removal of heavy metals but the
conventional methods like precipitation, ion-exchange, electrolysis, are becoming non-
effective and economically non-feasible to achieve the required stringent standards1.
(Kurniawan, 2006)
Activated carbon adsorption appears to be a particularly competitive and effective process for
removal of heavy metals at trace levels. Some researchers have emphasized on the use of
natural adsorbents for metal removal like peat, wood, peanut shell, saw dust, rice husk, etc 2
(P.SenthilKumar, 2011) and also on modified surface of the adsorbent. Huang using 8-
A comparative study of 8-hydroxyquinoline-5-sulphonic acid and its 7-nitro derivative loaded on F-400
granular activated carbon for removal of copper ions from aqueous solutions
Doss V.R, Kodolikar S.P
International Journal of Environmental Sciences Volume 3 No.2, 2013 2049
hyrdroxyquinoline as an effective chelating agent improved Cu ion adsorption3. (Huang,
1978). Natarajan et al. separated Cu ions from aqueous medium either alone or in admixtures
with other divalent ions using GAC containing adsorbed 8-hydroxyquinoline-5-sulphonic
acid 4(Deshmukh, 1989). Similarly, Ruey-shin juang et al studied the adsorption ability of
Cu(II) using chitosan from simulated rinse solutions containing chelating agents including
ethylenediaminetetraacetic acid (EDTA), citric acid, tartaric acid and sodium gluconate 5.
(Ruey-shin juang, 1999) Activated carbon can, therefore be used to enhance the adsorption
capacity for metal ions in aqueous solutions by ligands adsorbed on the surface.
In view of the high toxicity, persistent and increasing use of chemicals, the most important
non-ferrous metal copper having varied uses in industries like metal cleaning and plating
baths, paper and pulp and fertilizer industry6 (Shell, 1981) and also household appliances was
chosen for the present work. Copper is highly toxic to humans and animals in high dosages.
Prolonged oral administration of copper in excess may cause damage to vital organs.
Consequently its removal from wastewater assumes importance. Aquatic animals also get
influenced by its toxicity depending on alkalinity, pH, hardness and organic compounds
present in water7.(Hodgen, 1997).The tolerance limit for inland surface water discharge is 3
ppm for copper while drinking water tolerance limit is 0.05 ppm.8 (ISI, Drinking water
specification, 1991).
In the present work the sorption of Cu ions from aqueous solutions by using ligand QSA and
NQSA loaded granular activated carbon was investigated. A comparative adsorption capacity
of adsorbent QSA and its derivative NQSA was conducted in batch experiments.
2. Material and methods
2.1 Adsorbent F-400 GAC: Preparation and its Characterization
F-400 GAC is a well documented adsorbent in literature9 (Tiwari 1989). The samples were
gifted by m/s Calgon Corporation Inc, Pittsburg, USA. The sample of GAC was first sieved
as per the ASTM method DDY74910
(American Society for Testing and Materials, 1994),
particles having mesh size 12 x18 was chosen. The samples were washed thoroughly and
dried in a dessicator. In a period of 10 days time the GAC is fairly of constant composition in
regard to residual moisture content.
The sample was characterized by SEM and FTIR in order to understand the basic
morphology and presence of surface active groups responsible for the process of adsorption.
The SEM was done on a Cambridge stereoscan S 250 MKIII model instrument and FTIR
recorded on a Nicolet Magna IR 550 Spectrometer. The SEM photograph and FTIR are
shown in figures (1) and (2).
A comparative study of 8-hydroxyquinoline-5-sulphonic acid and its 7-nitro derivative loaded on F-400
granular activated carbon for removal of copper ions from aqueous solutions
Doss V.R, Kodolikar S.P
International Journal of Environmental Sciences Volume 3 No.2, 2013 2050
Figure 1: SEM photograph of F-400 GAC
Figure 2: FTIR spectra of F-400 GAC
Table 1 enlists the properties of F-400 GAC used. For modification of its surface it was
loaded with ligands QSA and NQSA.
Table 1: Characteristic properties of GAC
Carbon
Type*
Surface Area[N-
BET]
Particle
Density
Apparent
Density True Density
Pore
Volume Porosity
sq.m./g g/cc g/cc g/cc cc/g
F-100 841 --- --- 2.679 0.549 0.26
F-200 825 0.858 0.53 2.267 0.724 0.53
F-300 970 0.7303 0.48 2.1 0.85 0.64
F-400 998 0.795 0.48 2.308 0.825 0.65
*Origin for all carbon types is Bituminous Coal
2.2 Copper solution
A comparative study of 8-hydroxyquinoline-5-sulphonic acid and its 7-nitro derivative loaded on F-400
granular activated carbon for removal of copper ions from aqueous solutions
Doss V.R, Kodolikar S.P
International Journal of Environmental Sciences Volume 3 No.2, 2013 2051
All chemicals used were of analytical reagent grade. A stock solution of 1000 ppm Cu (II)
was prepared and used for all adsorption and kinetic studies. Experimental solutions of the
desired copper concentration were obtained by successive dilutions. Using Na-DDC method
the concentration of copper was determined spectrophotometrically at 520 ηm11
( Vogel,
1979)
2.3 Ligand 8-hydroxyquinoline sulphonic acid and its 7-nitro derivative.
The properties of 8-Hydroxyquinoline and its derivatives as chelating agents are well
documented in literature12
(Moeller, 1954). These ligands behave as a bidentate (N, O)
univalent ligand and thus could chelate effectively with metal ions like copper. Variation in
the structure of ligand could help in understanding the role of substituent groups in the
adsorption process on the GAC. The sulphonic acid derivatives have a hydrophilic character
due to which the metal complexes have an unusually high water solubility13
(Bailer,
1956).Further the ligand has a crystalline nature and is easily soluble in hot water thus
suitable for chemical analysis.
QSA was of Riedel de Haen, West Germany make. Estimation was done by pH titration
using standard alkali solution. The sulphonic acid group undergoes neutralization at pH 4-5.
The molecular weight determination experimentally was found to be 243.8 while reported
literature value is 243.2. 7-nitro QSA was prepared in the laboratory using the method of
Fresco and Freiser14
(Fresco, 1963). The molecular weight determination was done by
sulphonic acid group pH titration which was found to be 270.82 while reported literature
value is 271.2.
2.4 Sorption experiments
Batch experiments were carried out in order to determine the adsorption isotherm of a
particular ligand on F-400 GAC. 0.1g-1.5 g of GAC was transferred into 6 clean dry shaking
bottles. 200 ml of 0.002M ligand solution, QSA added to each of the bottles. The bottles were
fixed on to a mechanical shaker and subjected to shaking for 8 hrs. There was practically no
visible attrition of the GAC sample. The contents were filtered and dried in oven at 1100C for
an hour and then placed in a dessicator for further use. Same procedure was followed for
ligand NQSA.
The value of Ce, the equilibrium concentration was obtained by determining the residual
ligand concentration by UV-visible spectrophotometer of make systronics digital
spectrophotometer type 166 at 350 nm for both the ligands. Using this value of Ce, the
equilibrium ligand concentration on GAC in moles/g was calculated using the expression15
(Eloussaief, 2010)
dVCCq ee /)( 0
where qe = equilibrium ligand concentration on GAC in moles/g
C0 and Ce = concentration of ligand in solution at initial and equilibrium conditions in moles/l,
V= volume of solution in liters, d= weight of GAC in g
Due to formation of a monolayer of adsorbate on the surface of the adsorbent the value of qe
reaches a saturation value which represents the maximum amount of ligand that can be
A comparative study of 8-hydroxyquinoline-5-sulphonic acid and its 7-nitro derivative loaded on F-400
granular activated carbon for removal of copper ions from aqueous solutions
Doss V.R, Kodolikar S.P
International Journal of Environmental Sciences Volume 3 No.2, 2013 2052
adsorbed for the given amount of adsorbent under given set of experimental conditions. To
verify adherence to various adsorption models like Dubinin-Radushkevich, Langmuir and
Freundlich isotherms, some representative plots of ln qe vs e2, 1/qe vs 1/ Ce and ln qe vs ln Ce
are shown in figures 3,4 , and 5 for QSA and figures 6, 7 and 8 for NQSA respectively. These
figures clearly indicate that these isotherms are all validated as referred to in literature16
(Chereminisoff, 1978)
Adsorption isotherm studies were carried out with different initial concentrations of Cu (II)
and a fixed concentration of carbon. In order to study adsorption of Cu ions on these ligand
loaded GAC, the GAC was first saturated with the ligand to hinder direct adsorption of the
copper by the GAC. 0.5 g of GAC was shaken with 100 ml of 0.002M sulphonated oxine for
8 hrs. The solution was filtered and washed thoroughly with distilled water to remove all
adhering ligand solution. The residual ligand solution after filtering was checked for its
absorbance and only those GAC systems were used for later work which fixed the same
amount of ligand on them. To this ligand loaded GAC was then added 100 ml of copper
solution 25-120 mg/l and contents of the flask were shaken for 8 hrs in a mechanical shaker.
The initial concentration of copper i.e. C0 was determined spectrophotometrically at 520 nm
using Na-DDC method. Similar procedure was adopted for NQSA. Once equilibrium is
reached then Ce, the equilibrium metal ion concentration in mg/l was determined. Using both
these quantities the value of qe, the amount of copper on the ligand loaded GAC was
determined using a similar relation
dVCCq ee /)( 0
where qe = concentration of copper ion on ligand loaded GAC in mg/mmole of ligand C0
and Ce = initial and equilibrium concentration of copper ion in solution in mg/l, V= volume
of solution in litres, d= millimoles of ligand on GAC
Plot of qe vs Ce representing adsorption isotherm of copper on the ligand loaded GAC is
shown in figure 3 and 7 for both QSA and NQSA.
To check the adherence of the adsorption process to Freundlich, Langmuir and DR adsorption
isotherm plot of log qe vs log Ce, Ce/qe vs Ce and ln qe vs e2 are given in figures 4, 5 and 6 for
the ligand QSA and figures 8, 9 and 10 for ligand NQSA.
The % removal of copper is calculated by the following equation
100/)(Re% 00 xCCCmoval e
It was found to be 90.14 % using QSA and 94.19% using NQSA.
A comparative study of 8-hydroxyquinoline-5-sulphonic acid and its 7-nitro derivative loaded on F-400
granular activated carbon for removal of copper ions from aqueous solutions
Doss V.R, Kodolikar S.P
International Journal of Environmental Sciences Volume 3 No.2, 2013 2053
Figure 3: Adsorption data [F-400: QSA] Figure 4: Freundlich Isotherm [F-400:QSA]
Figure 5: Langmuir Isotherm [F-400:QSA] Figure 6: D R Isotherm [F-400: QSA]
Figure 7: Adsorption data [F-400:NQSA] Figure 8: Freundlich Isotherm [F-400:NQSA]
A comparative study of 8-hydroxyquinoline-5-sulphonic acid and its 7-nitro derivative loaded on F-400
granular activated carbon for removal of copper ions from aqueous solutions
Doss V.R, Kodolikar S.P
International Journal of Environmental Sciences Volume 3 No.2, 2013 2054
Figure 9: Langmuir Isotherm [F-400:NQSA] Figure 10: D R Isotherm [F-400: NQSA]
2.5 Kinetic studies
Experiments were carried out to study the rate of adsorption. A study of the rates of diffusion
could verify on the type of diffusion operative in the adsorption process of ligands used in
this work by the GAC. 500 ml of ligand solution was taken in a flask placed in a thermostat at
25±1°C. The concentration of the ligand approximated to a value of Ce in the adsorption
isotherm. This was necessary to allow rapid rise of qe during the adsorption process. 0.5 g of
GAC sample was added and 5 ml sample of ligand was withdrawn after every 15 minutes in
the first hour and then after every half an hour for the remaining 3 hrs by which time the fall
in concentration of ligand solution almost stabilized. The agitation speed was maintained by a
remi stirrer (model RQ 122) at 800 RPM. This was necessary in order to eliminate film
diffusion from operating in the process. The absorbance values were measured at 350 ηm
using digital spectrophotometer model 166. A plot of Ct vs time gives an idea of fall in ligand
concentration with time17
(Chatwal, 2007). At definite time intervals the value of qt the
amount of ligand absorbed at these time intervals are calculated as
txVCCq et /)( 0
qt and Ct represent the values at the intervals of time and not equilibrium values18
(Yenkie,
1985). However it was possible to find out the equilibrium concentration of ligand on GAC
using this value of Ct, and in conjunction with the adsorption isotherm curve, value of qe was
read at the value of Ce=Ct. this represented the value of q*. A plot of q*and q vs time then
indicated the process approach to equilibrium. The difference between values of q* and q at
any time is the driving force operative in the process leading to adsorption on GAC. At
definite time intervals values of dq/dt and (q*2-q
2)/2q were also computed from q* and q
values. These represented the QDF plots as shown in figures 11[a] and 11[b].19
(Vermeulen,
1953). The expression proposed for QDF plot is
q
qqx
a
D
dt
dq
2
*. 22
2
2
The QDF equation was used to obtain the values of D; the diffusion coefficient for the system.
A comparative study of 8-hydroxyquinoline-5-sulphonic acid and its 7-nitro derivative loaded on F-400
granular activated carbon for removal of copper ions from aqueous solutions
Doss V.R, Kodolikar S.P
International Journal of Environmental Sciences Volume 3 No.2, 2013 2055
Figure 11[a]: QDF plot [F-400: QSA] Figure 11[b]: QDF plot [F-400: NQSA]
To study the kinetics of copper adsorption on ligands loaded GAC, 0.5 g of GAC F-400 was
shaken for 4 hrs with 0.002M 100 ml of sulphonated oxine solution. The solution was filtered
and filtrate discarded. To the ligand loaded GAC 500 ml of copper solution at a concentration
obtained from the adsorption isotherm was added. 2 ml samples were withdrawn
intermittently over a period of 4 hours. The value of q, the concentration of copper ions on
GAC containing adsorbed ligand was estimated using the relation
dxVCCq t /)( 0
Where q is concentration of copper on ligand loaded GAC in mg/mmole of ligand, C0 and Ct
are concentration of copper in mg/l at t=0 and t=t, V is volume of copper solution in liters, d
is mmoles of ligand on 0.5g of GAC. The results are depicted in figures 12 and 13 for QSA
and NQSA ligands respectively.
Kinetic Data [F-400:QSA-Cu]
0
1
2
3
4
5
6
0 1 2 3 4 5
time hrs
Ct
mg
/l
Kinetic Data [F-400:NQSA-Cu]
0
1
2
3
4
5
6
0 1 2 3 4 5
time hrs
Ct
mg
/l
Figure 12: Kinetic Data [F-400: QSA] Figure 13: Kinetic Data [F-400: NQSA]
3. Result and conclusion
3.1 Characterization of F-400 GAC
The SEM image at 1000x magnification reveals the nature of the surface of GAC in figure 1.
It shows a layered loosely packed porous irregular structure with cavities, cracks and pores
thus makes possible the adsorption of copper ions on different parts of the adsorbent.The
FTIR shown in figure 2 shows presence of surface active functional groups. At 3500cm -1
the
A comparative study of 8-hydroxyquinoline-5-sulphonic acid and its 7-nitro derivative loaded on F-400
granular activated carbon for removal of copper ions from aqueous solutions
Doss V.R, Kodolikar S.P
International Journal of Environmental Sciences Volume 3 No.2, 2013 2056
peak observed is due to presence of free OH stretch vibration of phenolic OH group and a
peak around 1760-1690 cm-1
was due to asymmetric O=C=O stretch vibration of the free
COOH group. These surface active groups contribute significantly to adsorption of ligands on
GAC and also on adsorption of copper on ligand loaded GAC. Presence of free COOH group
favors adsorption of ligand on the GAC20
. (Mattson, 1969)
3.2 Adsorption isotherm studies
The sorption data for copper ions on ligand loaded GAC were tested against the standard
isotherm models, the Langmuir, Freundlich and D-R isotherms. The representation plots
justify the adherence to these models as shown in figures 14, 15, 16 and 17 for QSA and 18,
19, 20 and 21 for NQSA.
Figure 14: Adsorption data[F-400:QSA:Cu] Figure 15: Langmuir Isotherm[F 400:QSA:Cu]
Figure 16: Freundlich Isotherm[F-400:QSA:Cu] Figure 17: D R Isotherm [F-400:QSA:Cu]
A comparative study of 8-hydroxyquinoline-5-sulphonic acid and its 7-nitro derivative loaded on F-400
granular activated carbon for removal of copper ions from aqueous solutions
Doss V.R, Kodolikar S.P
International Journal of Environmental Sciences Volume 3 No.2, 2013 2057
Figure18: Adsorption data Figure 19: Langmuir Isotherm
[F-400: NQSA: Cu] [F-400: NQSA: Cu]
Figure 20: Freundlich Isotherm Figure 21: D R Isotherm
[F-400: NQSA: Cu] [F-400: NQSA: Cu]
3.3 Effect of Parameters
3.3.1 Effect of pH
The pH of solution is an important parameter which relates to the surface chemistry and
binding sites of the adsorbent. On the basis of the electrostatic interaction model21
(Bhattacharya, 1984) the influence of pH on Cu (II) removal on ligand loaded GAC can be
explained. The pH was maintained at 5.5 for all the experiments. At lower pH the surface of
the carbon exhibits an increasing positive charge due to increasing H3 O+ since the species to
be adsorbed i.e., Cu (II) is also positive it experiences a repulsive force and thus adsorption is
not favored and to add to this the H3 O+
would also compete with Cu (II) for the adsorption
sites available thus reducing the uptake of Cu (II) by the ligand loaded GAC. On the contrary,
as pH increases till pH 5.5, the adsorbent surface becomes negatively charged and favors the
adsorption of positively charged Cu (II) 22
(Periasamy, 1996). However, on further
increasing the pH it resulted in precipitation of copper as its hydroxide derivative.23
(Reddy,
1997).Irrespective of the ligand used the maximum removal of Cu ions was observed at pH
5.5.
A comparative study of 8-hydroxyquinoline-5-sulphonic acid and its 7-nitro derivative loaded on F-400
granular activated carbon for removal of copper ions from aqueous solutions
Doss V.R, Kodolikar S.P
International Journal of Environmental Sciences Volume 3 No.2, 2013 2058
3.3.2 Effect of adsorbent dosage
The dependence of adsorption of copper ions on the dosage of carbon is shown in figure
22.The adsorption experiments were carried out in the copper concentration range of 25-
120mg/lit for an adsorbent dose of 0.5g of GAC loaded with 100ml 0.002M for both QSA
and NQSA at pH 5.5. However, the amount of Cu adsorbed in mg/g of GAC was found to
decrease with increasing adsorbent dosage due to high number of unsaturated adsorption
sites24
. (Shukla, 2002)The higher concentrations of heavy metal resulted in depletion of
surface active sites. As the surface coverage of active sites increase, adsorption to these sites
becomes limited thereby leading to a decrease in the adsorption intensity. The effect of
weight of adsorbent for QSA and NQSA showed a similar trend.
Figure 22: Effect of mass of adsorbent [F-400: QSA, NQSA:Cu]
3.3.3 Effect of contact time
Figure 23 shows the effect of contact time on removal of Cu (II) by GAC. The adsorption of
Cu (II) was found to increase with increase in contact time for a fixed adsorbate dosage and
fixed concentration of copper ions and the removal in mg of Cu/g of carbon increases with
time and attains equilibrium in 4 hrs for GAC for an initial Cu (II) concentration of 5.68 mg/l.
Initially adsorption is rapid due to external surface adsorption of copper which occurs
instantaneously and later on becomes slower once equilibrium uptake was achieved. A
comparative account does not show any significant difference in the effect of contact time.
Figure 23: Effect of Contact Time [F-400: QSA, NQSA:Cu]
3.3.4 Effect of shaking speed
A comparative study of 8-hydroxyquinoline-5-sulphonic acid and its 7-nitro derivative loaded on F-400
granular activated carbon for removal of copper ions from aqueous solutions
Doss V.R, Kodolikar S.P
International Journal of Environmental Sciences Volume 3 No.2, 2013 2059
For the experimental runs an optimum speed of 800 rpm was maintained for both the ligands.
At higher speed of 1200 rpm, the diffusion coefficient of metal ions was significantly
affected as the energy due to high speed probably assisted in breaking bonds formed between
metal ion and their adsorbent. At lower speed of 500 rpm the degree of mixing reduces. The
maximum removal efficiency was 90.14% for QSA and 94.19% for NQSA loaded GAC-Cu
system at 800 rpm as shown in figure 24.
Figure 24: Effect of shaking speed.
3.4 Adsorption Isotherm Models
In the present study the distribution of metal ions between liquid and solid phases has been
described by using various adsorption isotherm models. The Langmuir isotherm model 25
(Langmuir, 1916) is valid for monolayer adsorption onto surface containing finite number
of identical sorption sites The Langmuir equation, was applied for adsorption equilibrium for
both QSA and NQSA
00 //1/ QCbQqC eee
Where Ce is the equilibrium copper concentration (mg /l), qe the amount of copper adsorbed
at equilibrium (mg/g), Q0 and b are Langmuir constants related to maximum adsorption
capacity (mg/g) and energy of adsorption (L /mg) respectively.
The linear plots of Ce/qe vs qe show that the adsorption obeys Langmuir isotherm model for
both QSA and NQSA. (figures 15 and 19).The correlation coefficients are found to be 0.999
and 0.996 respectively and the values of Q0 and b were determined from the slopes and
intercepts of the Langmuir plot and are found to be 27.03 mg of Cu/g for ligand and 0.027
lit/mg of Cu for QSA and 32.258 mg of Cu/g for ligand and 0.5484 lit/mg of Cu for NQSA.
The maximum adsorption capacity of copper by ligand loaded GAC was 27.03 mg/ g for
QSA and 32.258 mg/g for NQSA (Table 2).On comparing the value of maximum adsorption
capacity obtained from this study with values from other reported adsorbents, ligand loaded
GAC is suggested as a potential scavenger for removal of copper in wastewater. It was
observed that the adsorption capacity for copper using ligand loaded GAC is comparable with
other reported adsorbents as shown in Table 2. 26
(Ahmaruzzaman, 2011)
Table 2: Langmuir, Freundlich and Dubinin–Radushkevich isotherm constants and
correlation coefficients
A comparative study of 8-hydroxyquinoline-5-sulphonic acid and its 7-nitro derivative loaded on F-400
granular activated carbon for removal of copper ions from aqueous solutions
Doss V.R, Kodolikar S.P
International Journal of Environmental Sciences Volume 3 No.2, 2013 2060
Isother
m
Model
Langmuir Freundlich
Dubinin–Radushkevich
Type of
ligand
qmax
(mg/
g)
b
(L/mg
)
R2 KF
(mg/
g)
RL KF
(mg/g)
n R2 qm
(mg/
g)
E
(kJ/m
ol)
R2
QSA 27.03 0.027 0.99
9
0.46
1
4.22 5.55 0.93 23.01 50 0.792
NQSA 32.25
8
0.548
4
0.99
6
0.03
2
3.804 7.63 0.97 28.73 9.129 0.661
The Langmuir model can be expressed in terms of RL, a dimensionless constant separation
factor given by the following equation to predict the affinity between the sorbate and
sorbent27
(Hall, 1966):
01
1
bCRL
where b is the Langmuir constant (l/ mg) and C0 is the initial copper concentration (mg /l). It
has been established that for favorable adsorption, 0 < RL < 1. All the values of RL was found
to be between 0.1 and 0.5 for the initial copper concentration range from 25 to 120 mg/l
indicating favorable adsorption of copper onto ligand loaded GAC .
The Freundlich isotherm model is derived to model the multilayer adsorption and applicable
to highly heterogeneous surface, and is given as:
eFe CnKq log/1loglog
where KF is maximum adsorption capacity (mg/ g) and n is related to adsorption intensity.
If the value of n is greater than 1, it indicates favorable adsorption of metal ions on the
surface of adsorbent28
(Mohanty, 2006). The value of n determined from Freundlich
isotherm was 5.55 for QSA and 7.63 for NQSA as shown in Table 2, indicating that Cu (II)
ions are favorably adsorbed by ligand loaded GAC.
The Dubinin-Radushkevich (D-R) equation can be expressed as:
2lnln Keqq me
where e (Polanyi potential) is equal to RT ln (1 + 1/Ce), qm is the maximum adsorption
capacity (mg/ g),
K is related to mean adsorption energy E in kJ mol−1
as:
KE 2/1
The mean adsorption energy (E) gives information about chemical and physical adsorption29
(Erdem, 2004).
3.5 Thermodynamics of copper adsorption
A comparative study of 8-hydroxyquinoline-5-sulphonic acid and its 7-nitro derivative loaded on F-400
granular activated carbon for removal of copper ions from aqueous solutions
Doss V.R, Kodolikar S.P
International Journal of Environmental Sciences Volume 3 No.2, 2013 2061
To determine the spontaneity of a process thermodynamic parameters such as enthalpy
change (∆H°), entropy change (∆S°) and free energy change (∆G°) have to be taken into
consideration. For the present study the experiments at temperatures of 295,300, and 303 K
were conducted. ∆G°, ∆H° and ∆S° are calculated using the following equations:
e
Adc
C
CK
cKRTG ln0
RTHRSKc //ln 00
Where Kc is the equilibrium constant, CAd is the concentration of copper adsorbed on solid at
equilibrium (mg /L), Ce is the equilibrium concentration of copper in the solution (mg /L),R is
the gas constant (8.314 J/K. mol) and T is the temperature in Kelvin.
Figure 25: Van’t Hoff plot of adsorption of copper onto ligand loaded GAC.
The values of ∆H° and ∆S° can be obtained from the slope and intercept of Van’t Hoff plot as
shown in figure 25. The negative values of ∆H° (−36.08 kJ /mol for QSA and -48.1116 kJ
/mol
for NQSA) as shown in Table 3 indicates exothermic nature of adsorption. The low value of
heat of adsorption obtained in this study indicates that adsorption is likely due to
physisorption through weak intermolecular interactions30
(Alkan, 2004).
The results of these thermodynamic calculations are shown in Table 3 below. The negative
value of free energy change (∆G°) shows that it is a spontaneous process. However, the
values of ∆G° decreased with increasing temperature, indicating that adsorption of Cu (II)
ions on ligand loaded GAC became less favorable at higher temperature. The negative value
of entropy change (∆S°) shows a decreased disorderliness at the solid/liquid interface during
copper adsorption. As the temperature increases, the mobility of copper ions increases
A comparative study of 8-hydroxyquinoline-5-sulphonic acid and its 7-nitro derivative loaded on F-400
granular activated carbon for removal of copper ions from aqueous solutions
Doss V.R, Kodolikar S.P
International Journal of Environmental Sciences Volume 3 No.2, 2013 2062
causing the ions to escape from the solid phase to the liquid phase. Therefore, the amount of
copper that can be adsorbed will decrease.
Table 3: Thermodynamic parameters of copper adsorption by ligand loaded GAC
Type of ligand Temperature (K)
∆G° (kJ/ mol) ∆H° (kJ/mol) ∆S° (1/kJ mol)
QSA 295 -8731.362999
-36.0837 -73.3702
299 -8972.228552
303 -9262.883023
NQSA 294 -8701.765158
-48.1116 -85.3981
300 -9002.236005
305 -9324.024165
3.6 Adsorption Kinetics
Kinetic models, namely first-order and pseudo-second order models have been validated
with the experimental adsorption data for copper (II) onto ligand loaded GAC. The study of
adsorption kinetics describes the rate of solute uptake which further controls the residence
time of adsorbate uptake at the solid-solution interface including the diffusion process.
For the kinetic studies 0.5 g of F-400 GAC was adsorbed on 100ml of 0.002 M QSA and
NQSA separately by shaking for 8 hours on a mechanical shaker. 500 ml of Cu solution at a
concentration equivalent to a value from the descending portion of the adsorption isotherm of
Cu F-400 NQSA system was chosen. The run lasted for 4 hrs by which the fall in
concentration of the Cu ion in solution stabilized. The data for both QSA and NQSA were
then regressed against the Lagergren equation, which represents a first-order kinetic equation, 31
(Namasivayam, 1995)
where qt is the metal uptake per unit weight of GAC (mg/g) at time t, qe is the metal uptake
per unit weight of GAC (mg/g) at equilibrium, and k1 (min−1
) and k2 (g mg−1
min−1
) are the
rate constants of the first-order and pseudo-second-order kinetics equations, respectively. The
slopes and intercepts of these curves were used to determine the values of k1 and k2, as well
as the equilibrium capacity (qe). The first-order kinetics model was considered initially which
gave R2 value (0.965 for QSA and 0.908 for NQSA) (Figure 26[a] and 26[b]); however, the
linearized second-order kinetics model (Figure 27[a] and 27[b]), provided R2
values (0.998
for QSA and NQSA). As a result, the sorption system appears to follow pseudo-second-order
reaction kinetics for both the ligands.
A comparative study of 8-hydroxyquinoline-5-sulphonic acid and its 7-nitro derivative loaded on F-400
granular activated carbon for removal of copper ions from aqueous solutions
Doss V.R, Kodolikar S.P
International Journal of Environmental Sciences Volume 3 No.2, 2013 2063
Figure 26[a]: First-order kinetics model Figure 26[b]: First-order kinetics model
[F-400: QSA: Cu] [F-400: NQSA: Cu]
Figure 27[a]: Pseudo-2nd
order kinetics Figure 27[b]: Pseudo-2nd
order kinetics
model [F-400: QSA: Cu] model [F-400: NQSA: Cu]
3.7 Adsorption capacities
The comparative adsorption capacities (saturation values of qe) of the two ligands on F-400
GAC used in the present investigation could be estimated from the figures 3 and 7. The
saturation values of qe for the ligands QSA and NQSA were found to be 12.90 x 10-4
and 7.11
x 10-4
moles/g as shown in table 4.
Table 4: Values of qe for the ligands and for copper on the ligand loaded GAC
Sr. No System qe
1. F-400-QSA 12.90 X 10-4 moles/g
2. F-400-NQSA 7.11 x 10-4 moles/g
3. F-400-QSA-Cu 26 mg/millimole
4. F-400-NQSA-Cu 37 mg/millimole
A comparative study of 8-hydroxyquinoline-5-sulphonic acid and its 7-nitro derivative loaded on F-400
granular activated carbon for removal of copper ions from aqueous solutions
Doss V.R, Kodolikar S.P
International Journal of Environmental Sciences Volume 3 No.2, 2013 2064
The lower value of qe in case of F-400-NQSA could be correlated to the Q0 values obtained
from Langmuir equation which represents the area on the surface of the carbon consisting of
a monomolecular layer which is formed at the saturation point. From value of Q0, S is
calculated as:
AQNS 0
0
Where N0= Avogadro's number, S= surface area in m2/g, Q
0= moles/g
The values of Q0, A and S for GAC F-400 are shown in table 5. The surface area values of
the GAC is likely to differ based on the area of each ligand molecule.
Table 5: Values of Q0, A and S for GAC F-400
Ligands Q
0 [moles/g] x 10
3
A [cm2 ]x 10
16 S [m
2/ g]
QSA 1.2 55.9 401
NQSA 0.8 60.1 301
The amount of copper held per mmole of ligand QSA was found to be 26 mg/mmole while
for NQSA it was higher 37 mg/mmole. The striking change in the qe values in QSA and
NQSA is probably not something to do with stability of the complex formed but probably due
to the hindrance on the surface of GAC. QSA ligand being smaller in cross sectional area as
compared to NQSA is able to penetrate deep into the pore of GAC and with narrowing of the
pores sufficient QSA ligand molecules are unavailable for proper orientation to form 1:2
complex with copper ions on the surface of GAC, thus making the value of qe, the amount of
copper per mmole of ligand in the case of QSA appear smaller. On the other hand the nitro
derivatives of oxine is not able to penetrate deep into the pores owing to the bulky nature of
the groups and further the already diffused material, which are in the wider macro portion of
the pores form a chelate readily with the copper. Thus the amount of copper per mmole is
higher in case of NQSA compared to QSA. This is further supported by the amount of ligand
adsorbed at the saturated level found to be lower in case of NQSA. Thus, pore structure of
GAC and chemistry of the ligand molecule probably contributes to removal of certain metal
species through ligand adsorbed on the surface from aqueous solutions.
A critical analysis of the values of diffusion coefficient (D) in Table 6 clearly speaks of
surface diffusion phenomena operating in the process in the present investigation. These
values were obtained from QDF plots of GAC -ligand and GAC -ligand Copper system used
in the present work as shown in figure 28[a] and 28[b] respectively. The values of D in QSA
and NQSA parallels the trends observed earlier regarding the qe values at the saturation level.
The value of 19.92 x 10-8
for QSA is unusually high compared to NQSA. This could be
because QSA being highly soluble in aqueous medium and having a smaller cross -sectional
area helps in diffusing readily into the pores and once adsorbed would readily undergo
surface diffusion on the GAC. However NQSA once adsorbed would find steric factors
affecting surface diffusion owing to substituent and hence has value lower than that of QSA.
Table 6: Diffusion Coefficient data
Sr. No. System K D x 108
1. F-400-QSA 0.3143 19.9234
2. F-400-NQSA 0.0735 4.6592
A comparative study of 8-hydroxyquinoline-5-sulphonic acid and its 7-nitro derivative loaded on F-400
granular activated carbon for removal of copper ions from aqueous solutions
Doss V.R, Kodolikar S.P
International Journal of Environmental Sciences Volume 3 No.2, 2013 2065
3. F-400-QSA-Cu 0.0929 5.8889
4. F-400-NQSA-Cu 0.1704 10.8016
Where K= Slope from QDF Plot, D= Diffusion coefficient in cm2/sec
Figure 28[a]: Quadratic driving force plot Figure 28[b]: Quadratic driving force plot
for system : F-400-QSA: Cu for system : F-400-NQSA: Cu
4. Conclusion
The results obtained from equilibrium studies show adherence to adsorption models
Langmuir, Freundlich and D-R isotherms while the kinetics fitted well to pseudo-second
order Lagergren kinetic equation. Further it can be concluded that the pore structure of GAC
and chemistry of the ligand molecule probably contribute significantly towards uptake of
copper ions by ligand loaded F-400 GAC. Based on the results of this analysis, external mass
transfer appears to control the rate of adsorption. The adsorption process was also
thermodynamically spontaneous under natural conditions.
5. References
1. Kurniawan, T.A., Chan, G.Y.S., Lo, W.H., Babel, S., (2006), Physico-chemical
treatment techniques for wastewater laden with heavy metals, Chemical engineering
journal, 118, pp 83-98.
2. P.SenthilKumar, S. Ramalingam, V. Sathyaselvabala, S. Dinesh Kirupha, S.
Sivanesan., (2011), Removal of copper(II) ions from aqueous solution by adsorption
using cashewnut shell, Desalination 266, pp 63-712
3. Huang C.P., (1978), Carbon Adsorption Handbook, edited by P.N. Chermisinoff & F
Elllerbusch, (Ann Arbor Science Publishers, Michigan), p 281.
4. Deshmukh K, Pande H, Natarajan S and Nageshwar G., (1989), Indian journal of
environmental protection, 9, p 428, CA 113:102772x.
5. Ruey-shin juang, Feng-chin wu and Ru-ling tseng (1999), Adsorption removal of
copper(II) using chitosan from simulated rinse solutions containing chelating agents.
Wat. Res. 33(10), pp 2403-2409.
6. N.J. Shell., (1981), Industrial Pollution Control: Issue and Techniques,
A comparative study of 8-hydroxyquinoline-5-sulphonic acid and its 7-nitro derivative loaded on F-400
granular activated carbon for removal of copper ions from aqueous solutions
Doss V.R, Kodolikar S.P
International Journal of Environmental Sciences Volume 3 No.2, 2013 2066
Van Nastrand Reinhold Company, New York, p 177.
7. Hodgen L., (1997), Environmental Pollution, 2nd
edn, Holt, Rinehart and Windston,
USA, p 10
8. ISI, Drinking water specification, IS : 10500 (1991)
9. Tiwari, D., Pramod, K., Mishra, A., Singh, R. and Srivastav, R. Indian J. Environ
Health 31 (2), 120 (1989). AC 113 : 84213j
10. American Society for Testing and Materials, Method D4749, (1994), Standard Test
Method for performing the Sieve Analysis of Coal and Designating Coal Size, USA.
11. Vogel, A., (1979), Quantitative Inorganic Analysis, ELBS. Longman Group Limited,
England, p 901.
12. Moeller T & Jackson, (1954), Analytical Chemistry, 22, 1950, p 1393.
13. John C. Bailer Jr & Daryle H Busch, (1956),The chemistry of the coordination
compounds, Reinhold Publishing Corporation, New York, Chapman and Hall,
London.
14. Fresco H. and Freiser, J. Inorganic Chem 2, 82 (1963)
15. Mabrouk Eloussaief and Mourad Benzina, (2010) Efficiency of natural and acid-
activated clays in the removal of Pb(II) from aqueous solutions, Journal of hazardous
materials, 178, pp 753-757
16. Chereminisoff, P. and Ellerbusch, F., (1978), Chemical interactions between
Inorganics and Activated Carbon, pp 281-329, Carbon Adsorption Handbook. Ann
Arbor Science Publishers, Ann Arbor, MI.
17. Chatwal G., Anand S., (2007), Instrumental methods of chemical analysis, Himalaya
Publishing Company, New Delhi, pp 2.108-2.109.
18. Yenkie, M.K.N., (1985), Ph.D. Thesis, Nagpur University, Nagpur.
19. Vermeulen, T., (1953) Ind. Eng. Chem., 45, 1664.
20. James S.Mattson, Havy B.Mark, Walter J. Weber, (1969), Analytical Chemistry,
41(2), pp 355-358.
21. Bhattacharya K and Venkobachar C.,(1984), Removal of Cd(II) by Activated Carbon
adsorption", J. Environ Eng Div., ASCE, 110, pp 110-112.
22. K. Periasamy and C. Namasivayam (1996), Removal of copper(I1) by adsorption onto
peanut hull carbon from water and copper plating industry wastewater", Chemosphere.
32(4), pp 769-789.
23. B.R. Reddy, N. Mirghaffari, I. Gaballah., (1997), Removal and recycling of copper
from aqueous solutions using treated Indian barks, Resour. Conserv. Recycl. 21, pp
227-245.
A comparative study of 8-hydroxyquinoline-5-sulphonic acid and its 7-nitro derivative loaded on F-400
granular activated carbon for removal of copper ions from aqueous solutions
Doss V.R, Kodolikar S.P
International Journal of Environmental Sciences Volume 3 No.2, 2013 2067
24. A. Shukla, Y.H. Zhang, P. Dubey, J.L. Margrave, S.S. Shukla, (2002), The role of
sawdust in the removal of unwanted materials from water, J. Haz. Mat. B95, pp 137-
152.
25. I. Langmuir., (1916), The constitution and fundamental properties of solids and
liquids, J. Am. Chem. Soc., 38, pp 2221-2295.
26. M. Ahmaruzzaman, (2011), Industrial waste as low cost potential adsorbents for the
treatment of waste water laden with heavy metals, Advances in Colloid and Interface
Science, 166, pp 36-59.
27. K.R. Hall, L.C. Eagleton, A. Acrivos, T. Vermeulen., (1966), Pore and solid-diffusion
kinetics in fixed-bed adsorption under constant-pattern conditions, Ind. Eng. Chem.
Fundam. 5, pp 212-223.
28. K. Mohanty, M. Jha, B.C. Meikap, M.N. Biswas., (2006), Biosorption of Cr(VI) from
aqueous solutions by Eichhornia crassipes, Chem. Eng. J. 117, pp 71–77.
29. E. Erdem, N. Karapinar, R. Donat., (2004), The removal of heavy metal cations by
natural zeolites, J. Colloid Interface Sci. 280, pp 309–314.
30. M. Alkan, O¨. Demirbas¸, S. C¸ elikc¸apa, M. Dog˘an, (2004), Sorption of acid red 57
from aqueous solution onto sepiolite, J. Hazard. Mater. B116, pp 135-145.
31. C. Namasivayam, R.T.Yamuna, (1995), Adsorption of chromium (VI) by a low-cost
sorbent: biogas residual slurry, Chemosphere, 30 (3), pp 561–578.