CPT DEU N Heinz‐Georg Buss9 OCTOBER 2013

NON SENSITIVE INFORMATION RELEASABLE TO THE PUBLIC

Aim:Conduct a MSA Gap Analysis thatexamines current MSA deficiencies & shortfalls in order to develop needs and requirements for improved MSA.

1NON SENSITIVE INFORMATION RELEASABLE TO THE PUBLIC

1. Analysis of strategic/operational/tactical environment (What is?)

2. Identify capability needs (What should be?)

3. Develop capability requirements (What is needed?)

4. Conduct gap analysis and fulfillment

5. Identify and select solutions

[6. Conduct Implementation]

1. Analysis of strategic/operational/tactical environment (What is?)

2. Identify capability needs (What should be?)

3. Develop capability requirements (What is needed?)

4. Conduct gap analysis and fulfillment

5. Identify and select solutions

[6. Conduct Implementation]

MSA Review Study – How?Systematic of Work

2NON SENSITIVE INFORMATION RELEASABLE TO THE PUBLIC

MSA Review Study – Roadmap

3

1st Combined MSA Work Shop

in Istanbul

9-11 OCT 2013

Presentation to NATO &Maritime

Community of Interest

2nd Combined MSA Work Shop

in GRC

17-21 FEB 2014

CD&E ConferenceThe Hague/NLD 18-20 NOV 13

Gap Analysis, Shortfalls, Deficiencies

MSA Status

Report & Discussion

Milestone 1“Gap Analysis”

MSC 2014

NON SENSITIVE INFORMATION RELEASABLE TO THE PUBLIC

MSA Status Report & Discussion

Task: MSA Concept Review

Initial Study Detailed Study

Milestone 3“Detailed MSA Study Paper”

CJOS & CSW COE agree “Study Development Plan”

04 JUL 2013

Milestone 0“MSA Study

Development Plan”

CD&EWorking Group

MAR 2013

Milestone 2“Initial MSA Study Paper”

MSA Review Study – Workshop #1 in Istanbul, 9 – 11 OCT 2013

4

Venue: Harbiye Military Museum

Topic: MSA Gap Analysis (Milestone 1)

Objectives:Analyze current MSA environment, Identify Capability Needs, Develop Capability Requirements

What is? + What should be? + What is needed?

Organization: MSA Panel & Legal Panel

Participants: 39 MSA experts and LEGADs fromCOEs: COE CSW, CJOS COE, MARSEC COE, C2 COE, CMRE,

CIMIC COENCS: ACT, MARCOM, JWC Nations: AUS, CAN, DEU, FRA, GBR, NZL,, ITA, TUR, USAOrganizations: MSCHOA/EUNAVFORNON SENSITIVE INFORMATION RELEASABLE TO THE PUBLIC

Milestone 1: Conduct of “MSA Gap Analysis” - Method -

5

Gap analysis on different levels in the eight DOTMLPFI capability areas:

CJOS COE on strategic levelCOE CSW on operational levelMARSEC COE on tactical level

Current MSA Future MSA• Doctrine• Organization• Training• Material• Leadership• Personnel• Facility• Interoperability

Future/desired/required

DOTMLPFI

Current

DOTMLPFI

NON SENSITIVE INFORMATION RELEASABLE TO THE PUBLIC

A. MSA Concept (MCM 0073‐2008, MCM 0140‐2007; 14 JAN 2008)B.      MSA Phase 1 Final Report (1000 FCX 0010/Ser:NU 0652; 30 NOV 2010)C.      Implementation of  MSA (IMSM‐0371‐2011; 19 JUL 2011)D.      Implementation MSA in FMIS (MCM‐0073‐2008‐Add1; 16 DEC 2011)E.      NATO Surveillance Co‐ord. Concept & Surveillance Co‐ord. Centres (MC 367/1); 25 JUL11F.      MSA Space MMR (MCM‐0108‐2012)G.     Info Sharing (SH/PRM/13‐302406) NATO‐INTERPOL cooperation initiativeH.     MCM 0125‐2012 NATO Future Mission Network Concept; 21 Nov 2012I.       Maritime Command and Control incl. Maritime Situational Awareness Capability  

development (1930/SHSPO/EWS/11‐280724); 15 JUN 2011J.     CJOS COE Review of the NATO Concept for MSA; 30 MAR 2010K. SACEUR: Operational Requirements for NATO MSA; 25 MAR 2009L. OPC: NATO Maritime Ops – Food for Thought; 2 APR 2012M. CHENS: Developing a European Interagency Strategy for Maritime Security Ops N. EXTAC 790 MSA, MAR 2010O. EXTAC 619(E) & NATO RMP SOPP. Maritime Security Regime Manual & Enterprise Proposal, 29 NOV 2012Q. MSA Phase I ‐ Legal Study Report (SACT) R. MARCOM Maritime Vision 2010, version 4; 30 MAY 2012S. MSA CD Plan‐Phase – CD Development Assessment WS (MSA War Game Final Report); 31 AUG 2010T. Study investigating all options to cover the surveillance gap in OAE; 31 JAN 2012U. MSC 2012 Proceedings & MSC series Analysis; FEB 2013V. Closing the Gap: Enhanced Maritime Security Cooperation & Awareness, DAL University, 2012W. VAdm Krause: “Developing Maritime Operations”; August 2013 X. MC 588, Concept for NATO Maritime Security Operations

Main References

MSA – Gap Analysis (Tool)Objective/goal: Information superiority in the maritime domain

7

Capability

What is MSA?

Current MSA (What is?)Available?

Capability Needs (What should be?)Sufficient, as required?

Capability Requirements (What is needed?)

RemarksRefer to your LL/BP/reports

Attributes, performance level,competencies

Factors needed to achieve future objectives

List & discriminate between the different capability areasInformation

handling, fusion

of the critical elements of info

of information to decision makers, customers and stakeholders

NON SENSITIVE INFORMATION RELEASABLE TO THE PUBLIC

8

0900 Opening Workshop CAPT (CAN N) CrainCAPT (DEU N) Buss

0910 Host Nation Welcome Director MARSEC COE RADM Omer Bayram CETIN

0920 - 0940 Key Note Address CAPT (CAN N) Crain0940 - 0955 Key Note Address CAPT (DEU N) Buss0955 - 1010 Common Understanding on MSA CDR (DEU N) Levien1010 - 1035 Presentation on Future Maritime Information System. CDR (CAN N) Delhaise1035 - 1050 Coffee Break1050 - 1200 MSA Review

1050 - 1125 Gap analysis. Current MSA and shortfalls (strategic level)1125 - 1200 Gap analysis. Current MSA and shortfalls (ops level)

CJOS COECOE CSW

1200 - 1240 Presentation Maritime Security Centre Horn of Africa & EUNAVFOR CDR (DEU N) Kleemann1240 - 1400 Lunch1400 - 1440

1400 - 1500 MSA Review: Gap analysis. Current MSA and shortfalls (tactical level)

MARSEC COE

1400 - 1500syndicate room

Legal Syndicate1400 - 1420 Introduction to MSC 20141420 - 1500 The Legal Panel/ Maritime Law Project

CDR (NLD N) ZendmanDr. Schildknecht (CIV)

1500 - 1515 Coffee Break1515 - 1600 MSA; Best Practice: Demonstration Virtual Regional Maritime Traffic

Centre (VRMTC)LT (ITA N) Sabatini

1515 - 1600 Legal Syndicate; Presentations of participants/ study findings Legal Syndicate participants1730 - 2200 Boat trip to Hosted Dinner Meet at 1700, bus pick up

8

0800 Introduction to Day 2 CAPT (DEU N) Buss0805 - 0820 Wrap-up of Day 1

Opening Remarks for Day 2 CAPT (CAN N) Crain

0820 - 0900 Presentation on “MSA Interagency coordination” CAPT (R) (CAN N) Salchert0900 - 1030 MSA Review

- Gap analysis discussion: DoctrineCombined COEsCOE CSW

0900 - 1030syndicate room

Legal SyndicatePresentations of participants/ study findings continued

Legal Syndicate participants

1030 - 1040 Coffee Break1040 - 1230 MSA Review

- Gap analysis discussion: OrganizationCombined COEsCJOS COE

1040 - 1230syndicate room

Legal SyndicatePresentations of participants/ study findings continued

Legal Syndicate participants

1230 - 1345 Lunch 1345 - 1515syndicate room

Legal SyndicateStudy findings continued/ drafting of common legal position

COE CSW; Participants Legal Syndicate

1345 - 1430 MARCOM Presentation on “MSA current and future needs” CDR (TUR N) Aydin 1430 - 1515 MSA Review

- Gap analysis discussion: Training and MaterialCombined COEsMARSEC COE

1515 - 1525 Coffee Break1525 - 1645 MSA Review

- Gap analysis discussion: InteroperabilityCombined COEsCOE CSW

1525 - 1645syndicate room

Legal SyndicateStudy findings continued/ drafting of common legal position

COE CSW; Participants Legal Syndicate

8

0800 Introduction to Day 3 CJOS COE

0805 - 0820 Wrap-up of Day 2Opening Remarks for Day 3

COE CSW

0820 - 0900 Presentation of Best Practices & Lessons Learned: An Australian Perspective

CAPT (AUS N) Peter Bowers

0900- 0950 MSA Review- Gap analysis discussion: Leadership, Personnel and Facilities

Combined COEsMARSEC COE

0900 - 0950syndicate room

Legal SyndicateStudy findings: MSA legal analysis

LTCOL (NZL A) FerrisParticipants Legal Syndicate

0950 - 1000 Coffee Break1000 - 1115 Outcome Presentation Legal Syndicate

and DiscussionLTCOL (NZL A) FerrisALL

1115 - 1200 MSA Review; - Product/Deliverable Outline, Next actions, Delineation of Work, Way Ahead towards MSA Initial Study Paper

Combined COEsCOE CSW

1200 - 1315 Working Lunch1315 - 1400 MSA Review; continuation of morning

discussion; final wrap-upCombined COEsCOE CSW

1400 Way Ahead CAPT (DEU N) Schmidt-Thomée1415 Closing Address CDRE (GBR N) Steve Chick1430 End of Workshop

Istanbul, Harbiye Military Museum    9-11 OCTOBER 2013

NON SENSITIVE INFORMATION RELEASABLE TO THE PUBLIC