(#7-548) class a quality rulemaking: received department
TRANSCRIPT
Kathy Cooper
From: [email protected]: Wednesday, May 1, 2019 9:57 AMTo: [email protected]; IRRC; [email protected];
[email protected]; [email protected]; [email protected]: [email protected] Comment received - Proposed Rulemaking: Water Quality Standards - Class A Stream
Redesignations (#7-548)
fl pennsyLvaniard DEPARTMENT OF ENVIRONMENTALPROTECTiON MAY — 1 2019
The enclosed comment was received as part of the following testimony: Independent RegulatoryReview Commission
Testimony name: Public Hearing - Class A Stream RedesignationsTestimony date: 4/26/2019 12:00:00 AMTestimony location: Harrisburg, PA
Re: eComment System
The Department of Environmental Protection has received the following comments onProposed Rulemaking: Water Quality Standards - Class A Stream Redesignations (#7-548).
Commenter Information:
Robert Schott([email protected])1411 Skyview CircleHarrisburg, PA 17110 US
Comments entered:
No text comments were provided as part of this comment submittal. Please refer to attachmentsbelow.
These links provide access to the attachments provided as part of this comment.
Comments Attachment: 7-548 Testimony April 26 Robert Schott.pdf
Please contact me if you have any questions.
Sincerely,Jessica Shirley
Jessica ShirleyDirector, Office of Policy
I
LI\èYtL91
3 MAY —12019
Testimony to the Environmental Quality Board, April 26, 2019
___________________
Good afternoon. My name is Robert Schott. I am a retired aquatic biologist having worked for nearly33 years with the Deparunent of Environmental Resources (DER) and then the Department ofEnvironmental Protection (DEP) in the Southcentral Regional Office. Upon retirement in 20111 wassupervising a staff of3 other biologists. One of our responsibilities was surveying streams to gatherdata for the purpose of upgrading them for special protection. It was a task that I took very seriouslynot only with my staff but with other DEP biologists in the various regional offices and our centraloffice.
After retirement in 2011 I continued to attend an annual meeting of biologists from states within EPARegion 3. While at a meeting in March of 20141 was speaking to a biologist from the PA Fish andBoat Commission (PFBC). He told me that he had submitted a list of 50 Class A trout streams to DEPin 2012 for possible upgrade to High Quality but as of that point there had been no movement by DEE’.
Over the next week or two I had further conversations with DEP staff who indicated that an individualin upper management in the Division of Water Quality Standards was preventing streams from goingthrough the special protection process. After hearing this I started a review ofthe PennsylvaniaBulletin going back to 2003 looking for Notices of Steam Redesignations issued by DEP. Based onthose reviews and DEP’s list of “Completed Stream Redesignation Evaluations” dated August 6, 2013(Exhibit 1) it appeared that the last final rule-making by the EQB to redesignate streams was inSeptember, 2011, the year I retired. It was now April, 2014 representing almost 3 years with no newstream upgrades.
I contacted Katy Dunlap, who at that time was the Eastern Water Project Director of the PennsylvaniaCouncil of Trout Unlimited (‘EU) and explained the situation to her. I was able to get the support of TOand was tasked with writing a letter for TO to be sent to DEE’ (Exhibit 2). Correspondence between TOand DEE’ led to a meeting on September 17,2014. At that meeting DEP admitted that there was abacklog and that the process would start moving again beginning with the 50 Class A streams submittedby PFBC in 2012. DEP’s list of “Ongoing Stream Redesignation Evaluations” dated April 3, 2014(Exhibit 3) prior to this meeting did not show the Class A Streams listing. The updated list of March18,2015 (Exhibit 4) listed the Class A Streams suggesting that DEE’ was starting to move on ourrequests.
In order to keep up the pressure a meeting was scheduled with DEE’ Secretary John Quigley on April 6,2015. Deputy Secretary of Water Management, Kelly Heffiier was also at that meeting. Upon makingSecretary Quigley aware of the hold-up in the stream redesignation process we received his assurancethat the necessary steps would be taken to recti& the mater.
Two more meetings between TO and DEP were held on July 16, 2015 and on March 9,2017.
The latest DEE’ list of “Completed Stream Redesignation Evaluations” dated January 29, 2018(Exhibit 5) shows that four streams that were up for redesignation made it to an EQS meeting in 2017.Also, the 50 Class A trout streams that were submitted by PFBC in 2012 made it to an EQS meetingon June 20,2017 and have been officially upgraded. All of these streams were the first to beredesignated since 2011 and the first since the meetings between TO and DEP. It appears that theprocess is once again moving forward.
a
Ml of this brings us to today and the present list of Class A trout streams up for redesignation to HighQuality. These streams were surveyed by professional biologists working for PFBC. The datapresented in those reports is based on the actual status of the trout populations in those streams whichindicate that they are Class A wild trout streams as approved by the Commissioners of the PFBC. Asurface water that has been classified as Class A automatically qualifies for High Quality designationbased on Chap. 93 .4b(a)(2)(fl) of the Rules and Regulations of DEP.
Likewise, other surveys conducted by DEP biologists document the status of the macroinvertebratecommunities which are also indicators of water quality and have been used to upgrade streamclassification. Throughout my career as an aquatic biologist I have never documented a fish ormacroinverterate community that lies or has a hidden agenda. The fish and bugs don’t lie. The dataspeaks for itself. Objective decisions should be made on real science, not political science.
In light of the fact that the stream redesignafion process was hijacked for several years and a back-logof streams now exists I urge the EQB to vote yes on this recent package of stream upgrades.
The people have a right to clean air, pure water, and to the preservation of the natural, scenic,historic and aesthetic values of the environment.
Thank you for your time.
Ep
us’
TA
Com
ple
ted
Str
eam
Red
asig
nq
ilo
nE
val
uat
ions
pennsylvania
I——
Wrs
ris4
SS
eIfl
vrtsØ
ftfl
°‘
tt
Im
,fla
á.p
t.t.
U.m
tsi
‘tsw
awiai
3051
14*3
.1
I—
—H
-—-—
—-
tr—
—r
0e
J1Z
a.
eit
t
7r
I..fl
ILL
%W
’
W4
°“
—C
_W
?a
we
ci,a
——
S’r
MQ
weQ
fl
iii.
£.-
.._j.
__
e1
Lit
..‘1
fl4
DQ
?A._
Zfl
ILs,_,.
Iin
tt.
!inn
-j,c.t_m
annaa
L_
...J
flt_
v.e
.4ll
C5e
4e*
s4c
fli
tL_
____
_O
14,
4I
O$
SI4
1S
4C
IS
tile
’it
Cl’
3.i
t.j!
wso
*.s
In
—C
l4
sati
cZ
LC
1a-
..
ptt
t.,
4i5
DIP
——
ISI7
IOtf
lI
--
*m
a.S
IM2
_.J
LtL
.Jt
IIY
IL.
.S&
WC
S4s
I—IP
SOD
iV—
—nstj
pfl
*434
,431
431W
3015
113ftI
I
Gid
s0
1?
34,1
0343
ObS
n..S
L_
“II
CT
%00
3514
,304
O.f
r.i
.,ri
£.Jq
qd€0
1lx
12ff
laV
I*
CI*
*._
92bL
_0
13
1q
I1il
ctm
oab
ns
I-
Ic.i
tr—
.In
zlx
Ia
—w
eIV
I?
....
.S..
..0*
1150
4IU
IIO
S
H—
x,&
c.
ea.
cm
n.j
at._
____
,.,•
,jtn
C,
Yx
itlf
ltsC
rwn
-it
1$?t2
ZIII
WW
IjS
OiI
00
?ix
xe’
s_
Iin
1fl•_
ljfl
Ix.._
21
a....
e’
SC
10W
I.1
L.
1Q
n_
_flI
ra._
‘.j
flfln
t-W
11
.sia
..JIS
t.S
IMI_
.-aw
t
,R
IJf___
‘.03
OW
Ci
Sn.
‘—
—
I-
9fliiiI
oto
..>
wv
,.,
ore
C—
.QIr
flL
.J_
jjI
5lx
vii
311r
n1*5311
V.W
tn,.
5—
1271
‘sts
DC
n.
WnV
IItt
Il1
.*S
II
0n
,tJa
Ru
.-
.se
V04
1tin
t.si0
.x
3.
.._M
i*..
__.
4on,,a
-I
C.i7
63fl
23
-t’
S11
P
‘ix
iwic
its
I
‘z0
“—
‘—
yw
.e...t...
L_
_C
!,,
c”1
’-—
._‘a
32
_-
JmM
L—
1si
s‘4
*tp
g4
-cir
r..aj
I_______
tflt
MW
’S•C
LI
I-
.,
1w
n3
1ta
....
1,t
PC
MS
L__
t__
_T
C‘_sa_
._sx
n.c
a.L
__
14
Wt
wic
tin
ts
..S
IML
..-
111_
—1
1%
eIn
a3,,
,,?
{_
SZ
Mj
tW
sn_,_
qa.,,_
.ernar
c._
..cf_u&
_.
._nc
nla
o—
itti
2ax9_
_Ifli
.-
-34
01-
oI8
3,O
,ire
j--
•In
iI
.
IaIn___
1Q
OS
.1U
Sn
ow
-31
4)17
1111
0fl’
let.
fli
rt’
all
0’tp
.eaIn
fl
aI
ixIa
c4l
ine.’
iO
l01
4111
i.fl1
1050045
I
‘zn.
Ir..
a.
3411
fl’)
ln
.d-,
os_i
IW
iolc
43
‘-
,€
‘Ic
.w—
lssi,
&-
ci
Iflra
w’r
Leisa
I
II
t[19Fjfl11FIE[IJIElI IIIjUrrrrrrrrrntrnrErrrrrrnrJrr jUEl
I
rrrFiFrrEFrrrFFrFFrFrFrrrFrFi.I
rrFrrfflrrrrrFTrrfrjrrr[F[rirr •.11 ‘KKLI
ttrtLLL*:.1 rr———rrr——rr——r1—r——rrrrrrr—r—r
LLtLLtLLt!iil
1‘Fr—
I‘F!‘FHHFr1F
I.1
LLLLLLLLLLL_LLLLLLLLLIHJLLI
Iii1Ii31!
:III.U
EEJE1JJET iti!1!!I
%%*$RR*R[It
E%WP,JT 7’
cOU!W4
Pennsylvania CouncilTrout UnlimitedP.O. Box 5148
UNLIMITED e e on O
April 24, 2014
Mr. Tony ShawDivision of Water Quality StandardsBureau of Point and Non-Point Source ManagementDepartment of Environmental ProtectionP.O. Box 8774Harrisburg, PA 17105-8774
Dear Mr. Shaw:
Trout Unlimited has recently reviewed Pennsylvania Bulletins going back to 2003, looking for Notices ofStream Redesignations issued by the Department of Environmental Protection (DEP) pursuant to 25 Pa.Code §93.4d. We also looked for announcements from the Environmental Quality Board (EQB) thateither propose to amend or amend stream designations listed in 25 Pa. Code Chapter 93.
Based on those reviews and the list of “Completed Streams Redesignations Evaluations” from DEP’swebslte, it appears that the last final rulemaking by the EQB to redesignate streams was in September,2011. Since the beginning of 2011, the Pennsylvania Bulletin shows that DEP has announced that itplans to conduct redeslgnatlon evaluations on 24 stream basins/streams. Also, from 2003 through2010, DEP announced that it was going to evaluate at least 69 stream basins/streams forredeslgnation—only 11 of which have made it to final rulemaking by the EUB.
In addition to the announcements mentioned above, we have also determined that the PennsylvaniaFish and Boat Commission (PFBC) submitted a list of 50 Class A Wild Trout stream segments to beredesignated as High Quality-Cold Water Fishes (HQ-CWF). That list was posted by DEP in the PABulletin on May 26, 2012. According to §93.4b.(a) of Title 25 of the Pennsylvania Code, a surface waterthat meets eltherthe chemical requirements or the biological requirements, defined therein, isa HighQuality Water. Under §93.4b.(afl2)(ii), if the stream has been designated as a Class A Wild Trout stream,It automatically qualifies as a High Quality water.
We understand that assessing streams for redesignation takes a considerable amount of time inplanning, reconnaissance, sampling, lab work, data analysis, and report wrIting and that it could takeyears before a particular stream make5 It to the proposed rulemaking stage of the process. However,we do not understand why there has been no movement in the process since September, 2011. Whatespecially stands out is the lack of movement on the SO stream segments submitted by the PFBC forlisting as HQ-CWF. Those streams have already been assessed by the PFBC and have been designated asClass A Wild Trout streams by the PFBC, following public notice and comment—meeting therequirements fora High Quality designation under Chapter 93. Thus, redesignation as HQ-CWF by DEP
1•
should be merely procedural and administrative. Although it appears that those streams have receivedExisting Use protection as HQ-CWF, they have not gone through the rulemaking process by the EQBensuring their protection for the long-term.
TU Is not alone in our concern about the status of stream redesignations. We have heard the sameconcerns raised by numerous local sportsmen conservation clubs and watershed groups, and we allagree that we need some answers.
For these reasons, Trout Unlimited is respectfully requesting the followIng:
1) The present status of PFBC’s 2012 request to have 50 stream segments redesignated as HQ-CWF.
2) An explanation as to why there has not been any proposed rulemaking by the EQB with regard tostream redesignations since September, 2011.
3) A list of streams that have been surveyed by DEP central or regional offices and redesignation hasbeen found to be warranted, but the list has not yet been sent to EUB.
4) In those Instances where the DEP has sufficient data to warrant an upgrade, we would likeverification showing that those streams have be added to the Existing Use list.
At some point Trout Unlimited may request copies of reports for review, If deemed necessary, or we willschedule to come to the DEP office to review those reports.
it is Trout Unlimited’s mission to protect, conserve, restore and reconnect trout water, and as such, wework to protect our existing outstanding habitat from Irresponsible development that could have lastingImpacts, not only on fish and fishing, but also on people. Likewise, the DEP Is responsible for enforcingits Rules and Regulations and also the Clean Streams Law which is Intended “To preserve and improvethe purity of the waters of the Commonwealth..,” Upgrading the status of streams tD High Quality orExceptional Value, where the stream meets the approprIate chemical or biological requirements, willhelp to protect Pennsylvania’s streams and rivers, aquatic life, and drinking water supplies today and forgenerations to come.
Thank you for your cooperation. Please do not hesitate to contact katy Dunlap, [email protected] or 607-703-0256, if you require additional clarification on this request. We look forward to hearing from you.
Sincerely,
BAAI2_, C4Japr .ob sokottBrian Wagner Bob Schott Katy DunlapPresident Cumberland Valley Chapter Eastern Water ProjectPennsylvania Council of of Trout Unlimited DirectorTrout Unlimited Trout Unlimited
Cc: Kelly Heffner, DEP Deputy Secretary of Water Management
Ong
oing
Str
eam
Red
eslg
nado
nE
valu
atio
ns1s
11U
tL
SI
I
e)Q
fl
3
Pa
7fl
——
Pgfl
Fib
—X
PP
.41
lP
a—
—C
a.q
Ey
-V
1a
ib_tin
pa
at.
!al
Dia
Wi
Iin
tS
ICP
kg
a.*
In
-—
—
fla
an..
nrn
PF
—G
.mO
C
b_R
uI
jn
0-n
It‘i
ota
Wa’
i*d
X__
____
ç__
__
oaT
WIG
Qw
Oib
a.a
Wse.d
Maa.o
Pa.
Caib
i.7I
%.
KE
——
Cn
n—
Go
aD
ew
Ce*,
aiC
a,
glo
at—
—
Ceo.cm
*L
a.
in
lZ2
D—
X
Qa
—,4
0PP
Ontl
yant
laW
n‘o
wB
ee.w
afl
KK
0—
Lb
_fl
aN
w.a
,m.r
x.c
KK
tuck
FM£_..
....
_.
O4
G.m
‘i_
C_C
MO
WIo
Eat
Iflh
mH
oto
ta0t4
wn
EatW
rT
e,r,
—
mw
oC
uek
ma.
‘—a‘—
.c.._
.04
411
-to
Cna
T’t
taIe
sD
,23
411
TIn
.Ihi.d
KK
0410
1O
Wl
0W
.R
ta01..
.4O
7It
o,
HiP
In
ana
K.k
1110
3O
w’
‘*
fl’f
l—
I..,—
q_
__
__
cm
e—c
o
II,t
afl
a.e_
.r
——
Q—
—°-
‘-
40
-fliR
ia
i.S
O
‘I
On
go
ing
Str
eam
Hed
esig
naf
ian
Eval
uat
ions
LalL
ali
d:
41
m0
14
Q—
——
——
nPC
]D
C47
A’n
c—
—‘
Pfl
OWm
EP
a—
b—
_td
—_.
iiy_—
Nc*
*a
Pa.
P,
IN
i*
_,.
LaE
,,aae*
a’
—
Lfl
Stay
o,a
‘w
7L*
Xfl
’Ufl
2I3
imicuc.
—.
a—
“
a‘M
*O
(.Ifl
QIC
K_
O7I2
Sj
0011
110
haan
k—
XN
0O
1
—a
t—
5.1
—n_i—
NN
04c1
ol
aaR
,m
0____
F—
,_,fl
q!_
a’
—
P_
_____
L.IM
’ya_
b6
.p
at.
,..
‘(aet
N
fla
90’R
tiII
Qic
.2
7D
SP
a-—
ant
in
19
1tnai
NN
O7
OW
&—
—X
_C
.orate
bis
a-
C_
!._
Oth
am
nM
CI
11
II...k..
SD
SP—
X_
V1
fl7
if0tO
dof
aE
wao
M_
iL
l*
aW
Jd
IAb
tWif
iote
di_i
NN
.cnm
tooaw
e.r
.p—
u—
’—_
_
T-
—W
—D
SP—
—-_
__
Ia-
ta
‘112
__.rcam
n,,
_0
4O
Na
UaO
,dId
4.9a
__.
an
mm
aT
1N
*rn
an
w1.,4..
3ca
1Ww
a43
70o
aY
t.dA
nX
CS
tta
co
itb
0_
nB
c—
C—
no
—7
*11
87D
O’
x
——
——
sIn
‘a--
—4-_
1*
tR
wt
N
0=(0a=0
‘ft-I0
C3
ED.
0=m
C
0
C.,
¶j)Ii
0
aIDCD
RI
0z
C
a0
4:.a
0Ca-S
>LuC0-S
cii
(U
0tC,-SC,0.F0U
2 .
>-
—
0CC4-
C
Ct>InCC
Ct
0
C0
U)t00aEC0
‘4
‘4
2w>->90CCWln
Com
plet
edS
trea
mR
edes
igna
tion
Eva
luat
ions
penn
syL
vani
aL
nlu
pd
a.d
I12
t10
l8A
YU
TT
CT
I0N
-—
—-
-
Fm
fls.Ø
(d
sb
Fbç.f
ldly
VA
*S
18
4fl
frflt_
__
__
_ç
TS
7m
T..
$PW
*L&0i
mrB
w,*
.m
.Iw
a)
C’t
er
52S
ØC
on.’
.X
X12
*912
*902
1111
02dE
uii
mT
aR
eaeai.
Ptà
s.a
Ope
nM
fl1
1Y
144
Sp
ceC
t.
KX
12*9
12*9
W2
Op
WIT
On
tlerC
nfl
vn
595
flM
na.a
KX
12*9
12*9
Cre
ek03
1111
02O
5O
&03fl
S05
1311
0311
101*
9
UII
TC
.n.,
Ieo
.C
reak
I.-
7702
PF
14*9
0002
Ck.C
nek
0211
5110
0413
0)6
95*9
110
0511
5111
0110
3111
Ufl
Ls&
li.n
aR
,nrl
fletl
——
—
Ca!)
Wie
e21
800
lhs.
KK
04*9
04
Cm
iC
nn
0211
8110
0413
4110
9510
1110
031)
5111
0110
1211
UlJ
Jkatd
Cre
aC
abea
5978
DK
0413
204
:02
N8
lC
gk
0322
0*9
08.2
0*9
1010
4*9
IW
l70
I10
7U
NT
Sd
in*
tlR
,tr(
Saw
mM
.t—
——
J1
L-m
0fl
Odey
So
adK
K01*9
0313
3C
ak
eC
rab
0311
4110
oIa
Isio
95*9
110
0511
51Ii
0*01
117
UN
TT
uq
rc.n
On*
5d%
118
2120
0P
—K
0410
204*9
—E7
Rim
0422
1*9
9513fl
0510
4109
121l
1139
0410
1110
W.
L*e
Sades
5788
9P
——
05*9
03*9
0s
0211
7104
04,1
7104
9510
)104
0312
1135
1012
2105
0243
DEP
——
04*9
04*9
&.a
1.U
ndo..
1211
7102
0813
3103
16)0
1*9
9511
5134
1111
3*4
Cn
n1
ny
844
uçe
G’q
tdd
T.
KB
ig&
oa
0212
007
0912
107
0313
8*7
0015
138
3813
9120
-W
eil5,r
lP
efl,
Cra
bB
.v8s
1439
Bet
aC
mw
Ca,n
i.ey
KK
52*9
12*9
Cn
n03
1191
0205
104*
995
1211
0295
1072
0308
.071
0305
1212
0311
131)
03--
Peat.
YW
o,n
a,e
Cn
nL
,o21
809
DIP
—K
04*9
0420
30
42
8E
flR
unouz,m
*39
109
9510
4109
1211
5*9
0413
3110