637916

8/13/2019 637916

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/637916 1/20

Tryphon De Tropis

Author(s): M. L. WestSource: The Classical Quarterly, New Series, Vol. 15, No. 2 (Nov., 1965), pp. 230-248Published by: Cambridge University Press on behalf of The Classical Association

Stable URL: http://www.jstor.org/stable/637916 .

Accessed: 15/06/2013 03:59

Your use of the JSTOR archive indicates your acceptance of the Terms & Conditions of Use, available at .http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp

.JSTOR is a not-for-profit service that helps scholars, researchers, and students discover, use, and build upon a wide range of

content in a trusted digital archive. We use information technology and tools to increase productivity and facilitate new formsof scholarship. For more information about JSTOR, please contact [email protected].

.

Cambridge University Press and The Classical Association are collaborating with JSTOR to digitize, preserve

and extend access to The Classical Quarterly.

http://www.jstor.org

This content downloaded from 159.149.103.9 on Sat, 15 Jun 2013 03:59:43 AMAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

http://www.jstor.org/action/showPublisher?publisherCode=cup

http://www.jstor.org/action/showPublisher?publisherCode=classical

http://www.jstor.org/stable/637916?origin=JSTOR-pdf

http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp





http://www.jstor.org/stable/637916?origin=JSTOR-pdf

http://www.jstor.org/action/showPublisher?publisherCode=classical

http://www.jstor.org/action/showPublisher?publisherCode=cup

8/13/2019 637916


TRYPHON DE TROPISTHEwork with which I am concerned is not the one that appearsunder thename of Tryphon in RhetoresGraeci, iii. 726-60 Walz, iii. 191-206 Spengel,but the one that appearsunderthe name ofGregoryof Corinth,viii. 76 1-78 W.and iii. 215-26 Sp. What I now offer amounts to a makeshift edition. I callit makeshift,because I have not soughtout and assessedall existing manuscriptsof the work, or versed myself in Greekgrammaticalwriting to the extent thata seriouseditor would have to do; I offer it because,whatever its deficiencies,it representsa more complete and a recensionally better founded text than

those of the three existing editions, the most recent of which is now Io09yearsold.

Thenature ndoriginof thework

This is one of seven extant or partially extant Greek works r-Ept pdoroaor

rrEptroL770KWVVpdrrWov.The full list is:

Anon. i: P. Wiirzburg (U. Wilcken, Mitteilungenaus der

WiirzburgerapyrussammlungBerlin 1934], Pp. 22-3I

and P1. iii).Tryphon i: viii. 726-60 W., iii. I91-206 Sp.Anon. ii: 714-25 207-14

Tryphon ii = [Gregory]: 761-78 215-26Anon. iii: Fredrich-Wentzel, N.G.G., 1896, 337-40; partial

text in viii. 779-8I W., iii. 227-9 Sp.Cocondrius: 782-98 230-43[Choeroboscus]: 799-820 244-56Cf. also [Plutarch], vit. Hom. ii, 15-26 (vii. 344-50 Bern.).

In what follows I shall refer to these works(except

Anon. i andiii) by

the

page and line in Spengel; to Anon. iii by page and line in Fredrich-Wentzel.Besidesthese, there exist four similarworksin Latin:

Charisius Arsgrammatica,p. 358-65 Barwick (= i. 272-7 Keil)Diomedes ,, i. 456-64 KeilDonatus ,, iv. 399-402 K.Sacerdos ,, vi. 460-70 K.

Although published with the Rhetores, these works properly belong to

grammatical, not rhetorical, literature.' They are not didactic, they simplyrecord

linguisticfacts and

(not always happily) classifythem.

Theymake no

attempt at being works of literature; they are not treatises, but dictionaries.Each begins with a preface on the concept of a trope, and an index of tropes.The rest of the book then consistsof a briefaccount of each trope, in the sameorder as in the index: a verbal definition, followed by one or two examples

'J. Stroux ap. Wilcken, p. 23. The men

by whom they were written, or to whom

they were attributed, are indeed normally

classed as grammarians: Tryphon, Choero-

boscus, Gregory of Corinth. Nothing is knownabout Cocondrius.





8/13/2019 637916


TRYPHON DE TROPIS 231

from literature. There is normally no syntactical connexion between theentries.

This patternis ancient. The Wiirzburgpapyrus,dated to the second century

A.D.,gives a terminusntequem, nd there is no reasonwhy it should not go backto, say, the first century B.c. Cf. Stroux, loc. cit.: the Latin works 'fiihrengemeinsam auf eine frtih-kaiserzeitlicheQuelle zuriAck,die ungefihr gleich-zeitig mit dem echten Tryphon anzusetzen ist, und die ihrerseits schon Vor-

liufer in r6misch-republikanischer eit hatte. Das Systemund dieTerminologiezeigen, dassdie Abschnitte detropis ei den lateinischen Grammatikernauf die

gleiche griechisch-grammatischeTheorie zurtickgehen,wie die bei Spengelgesammelten griechischen Traktate. Die Abweichungen wieder beweisen,dass sich beide Zweige frfihzeitigtrennten und der lateinische seinen eigenen.berlieferungswegfand'.

The ascriptionsof the extant works are of doubtful authority. It is evidentthat few if any of them are original compositions,but rather revisionsand re-

arrangementsof traditional material; and a celebrated grammarian'sname

might easily find itself attached to a summary (or prolix) Byzantine text ofwhich his own workwas a distant ancestor.The historyof scholiagivesa warn-

ing example of how a grammatical text may suffer in transmission.The workwith which we are principallyconcerned is ascribed to Tryphon

in the manuscriptsknown to me; that is to say, to an Alexandriancontemporaryof Didymus to whom a work rmpt rpdrrwvs in fact ascribed in the Suda(iv.602. 2

Adler).Walz, followed

by Spengel, printedit under the name of

Gregory of Corinth, because (a) there is another work rEpt 'rpodrrovearingthe name of Tryphon, and (b)Leo Allatius,DiatribadeGeorgiis, . 416, claimedto have foundin a Vatican manuscripta work with the same openingsentence,under Gregory'sname.z That Gregorycannot have composedit was provedbyC. E. Finckh,3and finally by Maas'srecognitionof it in P. Vind.29332,4whichis probably of the fourth century, some six or seven centuries earlier than

Gregory.sThe editor of the papyruswas not unnaturally led to consider the

possibility that the work does after all ultimately derive from Tryphon.'Ultimately' is obviously a necessaryqualification,and even then no certainty

is possible. But one must presume that Tryphon did write a work on tropes,and there is no particular reason why this should not be it or a form of it,in other words, why we should wholly reject the ascription in the known

manuscripts. I refer to it as Tryphon ii to distinguish it from the other rrEptrpdopwv earing Tryphon's name.

The relationshipf Tryphoni to Tryphon and [Choeroboscus]Within the tropographic corpus, certain works are much more closely

interrelated than others. Anon. iii is related to Cocondrius; one can almost

I In general these characteristics, as wellas a certain amount of material, are sharedby the works rTEp't

aX-i&•wroyv.2 Allatius' report 'scheint auf einem Irr-tum zu beruhen' (C. Wendel, R.-E. vii A

730). I suppose this means that Wendelcould not find the work in the Vatican

catalogues; but that does not prove much.Allatius must at any rate have found it in

a manuscript somewhere, for it was notprinted until 162 years after his death.

3 Zeitschr. f. Altert. 1838, 1053 ; Philologusxxv (1867), 347.

* H. Oellacher, Mitteilungen us d. Papyrus-sammlungderNationalbibl.in Wieniii (1939),pp. 59-6 I.

s On Gregory's date see P. Maas, Byz.-Neugr. Jb. ii (1921), 53-55-





8/13/2019 637916


232 M. L. WEST

treat them as differentrecensionsof the samework. In the sameway, Tryphonii is related both to Tryphon i and to [Choeroboscus].

In Tryphon ii, the examples, except for a few relating to the usages of

single words, are all taken from classical poetry: the majority from Homer,others from [Hesiod] K4vKog yoalos,Simonides' epigrams,a lost tragedy, andCallimachus' Iambi. he choicegivesan indication of the work'sbasicantiquity.[Choeroboscus]representsa versionin which many of these classicalexampleshave been replacedor supplementedby Biblical ones.' The author has omittedthe initial distinction,drawnin both Tryphons,between KvpLoAoyiand rpdnros.The first seven of his tropes are the same as those of Tryphon ii, and in thesame order, but after that the order is more confused; he leaves out aapKaato'Ls,

aU-rEcalzo•',dapipfloAla, Tav,•gas,

while adding 7rE7roL'vE'Vov,EiravAArjts,7rrapa-PoA7j",v7rarr8oa's, rrpouaorro7roda,and rrapdSEypeta. gainst the authorship of

Choeroboscusare (I) the christianization,which is not characteristic of thegrammarian's other writings; (2) the style, indeed the whole unambitious

conception, which lack the 'geschwitzige Weitschweifigkeit'of Choeroboscus z

(3) the reference tod MEraqpaur~g

at p. 251. 19; if this is Symeon Metaphrastes,the author is not earlier than the tenth century,and Choeroboscus s probablyto be put in the sixth (though admittedly the only certain terminus ntequemfor him is in the tenth) ;3 (4) the inclusion ofa 7Xta as a trope, before 6a5-EpoAoyta

(255. Io), seems to be secondary to what we find in Tryphon ii. There, aXfaLacomes after 6arEpoAoyla, at the end of the whole work. In one branch of the

tradition, moreover,the section is

omitted,in another it is at the

beginningof

the work, and in both, aX-pa is absentfrom the initial list of tropes. Evidentlyit does not belong to the De Tropis: t is the beginning of a separatework rrept

aXr-pd-wovhich has become attached to Tryphon ii at a date later than the

archetypeof our manuscripts, ausingthe interpolationof the words Kat

uaXa intheinitial ndex npartof the tradition.Onthispartof thetradition f

Tryphon i, 'Choeroboscus's dependent;4ndthat thebranches f thetradi-tion wereseparate searlyas the sixthcenturydoesnot seem omethelikeliestexplanation f thisfact.s

Tryphon , like Tryphon i, does not admit Christian xamples,and has

in fact more classicalexamples: romvariousriddles,fromHesiod (Erga),Sappho, the Delphic Oracle, Pindar, Aeschylus(Agamemnon),ophocles(Peleus nd an unidentifiedplay), Euripides Medea nd Orestes), iphilus,Menander,Callimachus(Iambi).But in spiteof this apparent ndependence,comparison f the two worksrevealsa basicidentity n the definitions ndexamples,and they seem to represent wo branches,alreadyseparate n

antiquity,of a single radition.Whenwe considerhat bothbearthe name ofTryphon, hepossibilityrises hat he wasthe sourceof thattradition.Tryphoni and ii eachpreserve omeancientfeaturesmorefaithfullyhan the other.

A good parallelfor this relationshipsprovided by Anon. rTEpLaX~y71zdrwo,ii.174-88 Sp., in comparisonwith Zonaeus,ibid., pp. 161-70o.

2 The phraseis Cohn's,R.-E. iii. 2364.3 Cf. A. Hilgard,Grammaticiraeci,v. 2

(1894), praef. pp. lxiii-lxviii; K. Krum-bacher,Gesch. . byz.Litt.2,p. 583; Maas,Byz. Zeitschr.xxv (0925), 359. A. Lud-wich, De loannePhiloponorammaticoProgr.

Konigsberg,I888),

p. 9, argued that '

Mcra pauar-gmightbe DemosthenesThrax,the paraphrastof Homer and Hesiod; butcf. Hilgard,p. lxxxix.

4 Cf. the apparatusat Try. ii, 217. 3 =cap. 2. 6.

s The authenticityof the section axijyais further disproved by the non-classicalexampledKP 'IAtOVVwy

'V 0 OCEO••,•'aE7Odyae0dson.





8/13/2019 637916



We can see this in the distributionof the ancient examplesbetween them, andin the choice and arrangement of the tropes: rather than elaborate on this

here, I referto (Stroux-)Wilcken'scommentary on Anon. i.

Noteson themanuscripts

Tryphon ii was first published by Boissonade, AnecdotaGraecaii (1831),pp. 270-87, from the Parisini gr. 2551 and 2929, with some acute textual

suggestions. Two years later, Cramer published three excerpts from Bodl.

Barocc. 76 (The PhilologicalMuseumi [1833], 432-4). Two years after that,Walz edited the work in volume viii of his RhetoresGraeci,using Par. gr. 2008in addition to the two manuscriptsused by Boissonade and the excerptspub-lished by Cramer. Spengel's edition of 1856was based on Walz. The existingeditions are, therefore,based on fourmanuscripts-or rather three and a bit-

none of which is earlier than the sixteenth century.I have collated the Leidensis VossianusGr. Q 20 (f. 263v-265r), of the thir-

teenth century; the Matritensis 7211 (f. 86-9, r), written by Constantine

Lascaris; and the Baroccianusin full.e. Besides the manuscripts containing the whole work, we must make use

of the excerpts published by Hilgard in the midst of a somewhatindiscriminatevolume entitled Scholia n Dionysii ThracisArtemGrammaticam= Gramm.Gr.i 3, Leipzig, 1901). I call them e. They extend from p. 456. 17 to p. 462. 35-They are found in two manuscripts,Brit. Mus. Add. 5118 and Matr. 4613;in the latter, they are mixed up with excerpts from Anon. iii (which Hilgardmistook for a paraphraseof Cocondrius).Both must be used in reconstructingthe excerptor'stext, as Hilgard shows (praef. pp. xxxv-xxxvi).

The excerpts give the correct text, against the rest of the MSS. known to

me, in four places:217. 3 El 841wovTva KEdVOSVpEV p1

U•j-Tvq(vas. So Homer; E'M'pEal

t-•-v6qalv'vEhe manuscripts.

218. 27 dvaarpooq8E"E•u

AELS v7TP077YEr

aL gouqatVo•1EtgEv-

avot'aSSEvrTEpav'Xovra-ra•ev.

Here E'Xovaas proved right, against E'Xovaavf

manuscriptsand editions, by the sense as well as by Try. i, 197. 11 and

Coc. 239- 3-220. 16 wrEpL`0paaclEatLpdai . .. 8Aho-a0a.he manuscriptsomit bpcuts.But bpoasgor AE'gs or pu'pos

AO•yovis absolutely standard in these defini-

tions. ForqOpciasghere, cf. Try. i, 197- 4, Coc. 238. 4, [Choer.] 251. 9-

224. I5 &AAtih~E'onqpcCnpS ..7d i-T -Epc) 7irpaXOEv181 KOLVCWSirapaAapL-

fdvovaa. - 1a ;'IKO•tVWSMSS.

L. The Leidensis (L) is anotherimportantwitnessto the text, as its relative

age would lead us to expect. It is the only manuscriptto give a full and correcttext of 218. 8 ff. and 221. 10 (see ad locc.), and it has other good readings incommon with e or with Barocc. 76; most notable of these are two major

divergencesfrom the editions,p. 222, where the sectionon &dv-rqpacss followedby one on E'vavr-lwaY, and p. 224, where the whole section rapdeKauLs, withthe last three lines of the precedingsection Jpt•eoila,

is omitted. Both of these

divergences agree with the index of tropes, 215. 14-20, which includes dvav-'l-wcS and omits

"rapK/Iaa3Ls.m = MP. Matr. 72II (M) and Par. 2551 (P) arecopied from a single hyp-archetype which may be called m. For the most part the text given by mresemblesthat of L, but containsrather more errorsand omissions.It was not





8/13/2019 637916


234 M. L. WEST

derived from L itself, however, as certain individual errorsof L show: 216. 2

8vvavrat, 217. 18 EPovoXEt, 19. 8 a'o Aar', 223. 8 and Io auaauv'wv.L and mseem to have been copied from a book in which alternative versions of two

sections were added in a margin.Thus in m we have, as in the printededitions,two alternative accounts of dv-rl'paansside by side, linked by '4 (222. 20-22,

23-29). In L, the second version precedes the first, and the connecting " isabsent. (In Barocc. and in the London MS. of the excerpts,the secondversionis absent; while the Madrid MS. of the excerptshas both versions,in the sameorder as in m, but without the connecting -q.)Similarlyin the section dvrovo-ptaada(223. 2-13): two versions side by side in m and Matr. 4613, the firstomitted in L, the second in Barocc. and Lond.

Par. 2929, copied by Constantine Palaeocappa,' is an apograph of P, sofar as I can judge fromBoissonade'sapparatus. Its divergentreadings (which

have all become canonical) can be explained as conjectures:223. 27 'rr"E3OKEt7 "ItLOS T7EEX atYaM

(.'.m)":3OKEt om. P:CJ1

"IAtor•ETEXlturat

Par. 2929.

225. 2 aadrp ETEt SaroSgv rEEtca7)S Ee EpOv Evro Lm: ava2apE2TEt8' ao701

-LEVKvKdGY7r)5pOv EV70Par.2929.225. 3 otovoaLm: Katoa3 ar.2929.225. 6

EKKEKdOQat.M: EKKOdGOat: EA. tL ar. 2929.

225. 27oqav

8 SEt 7rp rov AytwE'Epdv -rS d7f LM:r-f•

om. P:d•'peo

t

Par. 2929.226. 8 I

wVV•awg7OvTraVES

EAEovaLV ayaOoe arM

(and presumablym):

4.Loefhv

P: uLuo-utv, and iAbthrro5or 'Iwdvvq)s, perhaps for some personal

reason, Par. 2929.The Vatican manuscript from which Allatius cites 215. 3-4 agrees with Par.

2929 in the corruption 78,7)or Et"S).

B, b. Barocc. 76 (B) and Par. 2008 are copied from another hyparchetypewhich may be called b. b has the right or more nearly right reading againsteLm in the following places:

215. 14EKOUa•LE,

15. 18 '4yovvXAEv7)m., 216. 5 LapyoivraSLr7rovS, 16. 7

The same applies to B in some places where Walz does not give the readingof the Parisinus:

215. 6 rte (that is, -rS corrected to -r), 220. 27 AEAdflaqEEAcdxovaL,21. 26

KapTrrv,24. 17 ELAnOLEVEJVW"EoV'rVa,

224. 20 a'&.In 223. 23, whereLm have omittedseveralwordsand e is absent,B givessomethingikethe correct ext; while at 225. 2, whereagaine is absent,B's

0&ct)ss closer o the (presumably)orrectEitc•

thanis rEOE1da`7f Lm.But in otherplaces,b (or B) shareserrorswith Lm againste (as in the

examplesadducedfor the indispensabilityf e); with m against(e)L, as221. 26 OEOV, 224. 30 zrapd; and with e against Lm, as 219. 6 "OrXE, ELX?'7

B, 222. 22 KaAov'OEV,24. 20 (?) \AAa,25. 8 7rpdOElv. b must therefore betreated as contaminated, but indispensable because one of its sources is in-dependent of eLm.

Our conclusions about the transmission may be summed up in theaccompanying stemma.2

I The compiler of the Violarium of'Eudocia'.

2 The work is also contained on ff. 182-6

of Atheniensis 1083 (s. xvi), which I havenot investigated.





8/13/2019 637916



In constituting a text, I have used principally LmB, and e and the Vienna

papyrus (fH)where available. B becomes b where Walz reports the readingsof Par. 2008. I have relied on Boissonade and Walz for the readingsof P, and

on Hilgard for those of e; those ofILMB are from my own collations (fromphotographsin the case offl, from microfilmsin the case of LM).

TryphonQ)

'Tryphon'

'Tryphon' P. Vind.

Cocondrius Anon. ii

[Choeroboscus]

iL

e m b

Matr. B.M.Add M P B Par.20084613 5118 (Lascaris)

Par.2929(Palaeocappa)

The text profitsconsiderablyfrom the use of better manuscripts; but thereremains not a little scope for emendation. Walz and Spengel were extra-

ordinarilynegligentin the use of the parallel texts to correctthis one (and vice

versa), and unduly content to print nonsense; of the twelve pages of Spengel'stext, only two make continuous sense from top to bottom. We shall find thatthe remedy that is most often effective is the assumption of a lacuna. The

frequencyof omissions s evident fromcomparisonof the manuscriptswith one

another, with II, and with the parallel texts.I number the sections for easier reference. I print section headings, as do

Walz and Spengel, they are not in the late manuscripts,but they were in II,and they are convenient. In the critical commentary I use compendia for twoarticles by C. E. Finckh:

Finckh' = Philologusxxiv (1866), 545-9.Finckhz = Philologus xv (1867), 347-8.





8/13/2019 637916


236 M. L. WEST

215 Tpowvvog Ept rpOrOwv

Praefatio. To Ao'yovEkI`' pELpoEvov&o), r5 'vy U7rUvptLoy<, 70

aX/t'a Kat 7pdTro9. Kvptohoyta tzv o v aTtVq7(TV K7ar atV hAE'e v 7r-7EVXvLapC~cTLSarE yap OKLtkLS 7TpOEpOLTO v 7TL, 7TV /tk-7T7aparpa7 TOOKvpLwSEyo-

IdEyOUV, LOY

7rb%t•vd[LVKua (KAv0rol•Eacaldvoarosov"V K O V M

AyKatov U -irTcAvAEvpovLov,'I

ot VE'Tr-r')>"IOLKAOV•

Tr•EUULTrapCGpatlOVaOdAVEdvTra

(K0vpt 8' vTEtLpElaAovOPvA-qaE KatHoAvopov.>

7podwS'oTTLAE'•

S 7"paCLS EK7S KaaO Eav7vvdoTWUOiV&o0d7TSO•E7a7pOIrTVElA9IqVca, B Ka% pTO KaL7ra. rTapEr77rat 6S 70roLXPLa 'VEKa 77K l?OUV

ITEpL 771) 9pCiTw. 7pdoTOL EL"EULKS

'LAAqyOpl, /LE7qOp , KaGaXP7atLS, EraA 7LS, 2

TEpladv, dVaTrpo , VVEKo0X7,ovo/arrooIota, t

Erwrovvta, replpaats, rTAEovau-0ds, lTapalTA -pw/ta, JAAELV1LS,ITEpfloA , ElpwvEla, apKaoctdos, {4yovv XAEV'h,}

darEt'LUdS, dvrlpaLS, rvavalwr ,dlrovoaa,

av-oOLcUa, atkpofloAla,lrdAA7s, a' vLypta,dE7rave-LS, EiOX77, vcrTEpoAoylc {Kal orXcta}.

AAA-qyopia 1

AAA-qyoplaUTl qpaLs rTEpovttEV

rL (KvpLWS-) r7Aov-Ua,7EpOU SE%VOvtav

216Trap•LuCa.

rdrE UKa7raXPovraLOdvrWS-rAAryoptl, oaiy I"&'S3VdELad'1

S&'alUXVvrvV 0 8moWVraLCavEp<W^o dra7TLyyELAa, rpodrov rTap&KaAAqtcdaXpElv

efpriraL"o0 yp repL> ITvpoS ovE l

rrropolLaSE~ dyos, &AA'

W<TrEpa'o"-

(LEVOSE0K8qWSKETEoV,6

7a S EA-Y pt'a)> lEtE 7-)Vt-Ep7 O V 7S OpavT?7T70S.

Titulus: rpv'dOwvospatLa7t-Ko rr'EpLpdrrwvm, (T)oi 7rpdowvosrfEplrporrwv, Tro avoiO

rEpt 7pdorwov(praecedit 'Trypho' ffrrept'raOGv)Praefatio I. roDydp Adyov e in suo contextu &3oaddidi aXua Kal om. b

ovv om. Lm: cf. Try. i, 191. 6, Anon. iii, 340o.2

7E•rvXVa

eL: rErvXvia L corr., mb

rrpoau potroB rt scripsi: rtc B: rS cett. 7rlb-HoAh'6wpovHom. 9T 34-7: versusexplevi, cl. Try. i. 191. 8-I 1. deest e den om. e A•~r Finckh2 347, cl. Anon.

iii, 337. I, Coc. 230. 4-5: A'6EWsLmbPraefatio 2. rpdo'rot

' Lmb: rrTot-qrKOt irpo'noL(cod. Lond.: dwrravrrs oLrolqTLKOl rp?7Tro

abv70roL raptO/IqOatELLwod. Matr. post excerptum ex Anon. iii) EuKodalEb: EIKOO

irr-d L: K em 9yovv XAEV77eest in bdv•rwvo~aat'a

LmB KalaX'ftjadeestin eb

I. jupvi-ot b KvpiwS addidi (desideravit Stroux p. 29 adn. 6); cf. Try. i, 193. 9,Coc. 234. 28, etiam Tiber. rr.

aXlt•P. 70. 3 3vvavratL ov rpordov7rapaKaAAqtuccx

Lmb:o•s

Ka~AAt'~aXo Call. fr. 195. 23-29, ex quo verba aliquot supplevi ut sensusconstet 67rEpLmB: J-IePar. 2008: e'7' [Choer.] 245. 6: SE ropap. Callimachi, undeSe rv- Pfeiffer (Se rdv-iam prius Meineke) dvCKavaasLm [Choer.] pap.: ivrEKavaao~

ows oz supplevi ex [Choer.]: aXP's oi Callim. rroAA-... KEXp-qKE(v) cAoyl [Choer.](om. rrpo'aw) t Callim.: woAA'V.. KEXP77KEAOdyaere codd. nostri (K'xPIlqj

II B, KEiXP'r7raPar. 00oo8 et Matr. 4613) 6pdLov Callim., [Choer.]:

Gpdo•vcodd.

tapyLvYas

i'rrTovSCallim., [Choer.]:

tapyoivras rTrrovSb:

tapyo0vr•Swrroov eLm LrGI-KUvfla-

rMayhabet [Choer.], itaque et noster olim habuit 8Evrip-qv Callim. rEpt add.

Walz, cl. cod. Par. 2087 (= [Choer.]) dErrv c b: &n-1 eLm EK A9WS: iK jAWveLm:

K•KEAoiVSpengel dE1TEV,&d

-7i dAArlyopiasex. gr. supplevi; cf. [Choer.] loc. cit.

dAA' orrEpaltodLEvo•

EL7TEVYEfloVAEro,if

dAArlyopl4 EIXpjOa7o qAEy•E eLm: qhAA•E B:

7jMyE Par. 00oo8





8/13/2019 637916



2ME•aopd

ME-raopd E'ar Aodyovp pospgEraE-pdolEvov (drTO 70to KVPLOVE') ETEpOV> o70t

LUEWS- 77o'eo)aws EVEKC. TiVIETSCOpV ELv877 E UTL•7TE'VTE Cat V ypav)LaWV aErodW E),v/XWV E'l v1a, a S ro3vvav-rt5o aro &#vxwv wIr4 vxa, at

Eaaodlt0vTxwv

Et1Ebvxa,

at SE . .wladvXwv JadE vxa, at SE"dw 7rrpa6Ews 'E2 1pTcLEw. cdd tvph kvxw Em bvXa, as -av d Eromrvpisdil r6v o0pci-rwv AEy

oAAa''S Kal (LEUUyV

•posXpdaa

, AEvo

v

EaTLavpEVE)Vyaqt iLravo,

Atadtot'Evae

poo dar.

To yap TpoOVuElEcOacEnTL[F•IVXOv

ETarLV,QrTEp

7c 8dpaTL rTEpdErlOKEVrv'Xco3 OVTL' 70TovTo70 ELpY7TaL Kiai E L/ V Ti E &bXiwv E vXwa,Asd

lEuo 0-o'

ap' v pro yEAWS.ro yap dacEfErrov a7To Cwvov To0 IvpOS ETrIVEXrmlITL

IIvXov

rTVyd'Awra, Kat'

4 0TO7Va'T E ULV.aL•o oEEv EXWvEIT ElvXiVLa,LOVOtLLEVaaV v, T7vflaaAE'a

-V ,xAwV'c Ytpcl-Epa ,LvXa. ,s yrpo7- ,,K-L

AO", , 7-

O

o,,,,i7w 7i- /3aoLAEFf' 'AoL, roqu-v 8 c pa3LraEds- ELpr7ai70E70 KcOS'OLTd77-0L.

5 ir7d10d wyva dlXvEa, C EMl 0ro

UITrp/CaLVpOs T'w?Y, w a'

7a TkoEV"

cEAAoEv a"o*

El 8-

TooTLvaKEWVOS?V (bpEUMt77W VfYJvCSg.

Toyap alvEMPw7d01AvA

0aocrlrwvT7cLU7ETCtKVpUs VV EET 77S KCTLUrKEVU7S

-q flovAjSqEdA,77TTrac.1-WV SE 11ETrWoopWV at 16EV ELULYE(ta'OCLEWS-g8Aw70KCL Oa cTp OVatUC 77V' O(LOLot77aT ,

at 3E(dioOd7Or77T5roaEV

eucLdcdE•O,

at 3 E &Ovtni7) vjv

o0LLoedrT7a>) 13o0KaC V

2. I dad ... TEpovsupplevi cl. Anon. i, 1.46/47, Try. i, 191. 24-192. I, Anon. ii, 208. 2-3,Anon. iii, 338. o10,Coc. 232. 15-16, [Choer.] 245. -5-6 ElaLwV&rTvXov Ermcd vxua,at -roavav-r'ov drT

'EtkwXoTV&'vXa b ES'7Tpeitw, cf. 2. 6 et Anon. iii, 338. 7,

[Choer.] 246. 18

2. 2 oTov S &i-rayLb: -ravm: locum decurtavit e rroAAa--aaLHom. A 573-74 =O 316-17; versum priorem om. e Eom. m LEUaa77yts

y5,7b (ex yE- B) TO

ydp

urpoOvLELaOaL-E•tv"y

ovre Lm: TO3E 7rpoOvLELaOaL'dl d4Xowv E'darlvB: 7~) yap 3dparL

v'XCpvr T7 TpoOVLELt-eaLrapE'lqKEv,OTEp auTLV•7JtovXwY e

2. 3 ir'd E dO~w--v-v

ydEAwCram: similiter e:'47T5

'x•Vde' gvxa, otov 5cVy d

'O3vaa3Es A~dyAlavI.L

76n ycdp advwirdAeiro,

d'TEl K0a d &paS puyas (v B, quod ita emendan-

dum est: "ro70oyCadp rtvirpyo&

&racAEo"= A 556), wdTE~aL

'ALas ikyags v. Cf. [Choer.]

246. i-5 cuEauror--y~oAwsHorn. A 599, 0 3262. 4 ioq~pva acv saepius apud Horn.: [Plu.] 20 et Coc. 233. 3 laudant integrum versum

8fl 3' p' &'5JTpdEt7V Aya.LkE'vova Totlbva Aadov,ui est conflatus ex B 18 et 243. Ad explica-

tionem cf. Apoll. Lex. Hom. p. 133. 8roqg"jvKvplw 7~v rv rpoI7-rowv,

iLEQ7aOpLKCo$

dc2rdT v TpoPd3wV

EUry7V

0 7j7EdV' Kac 7TOYaaLAEa A•Ey'. Hesych. TOLblEva

ajv"paaEa TWv

6XAOwvKal yap-s /3aaEI&S Om. B acFLpdTEpa~4tvXa eL:D&tdrEpa

ETL ELpvxa mrn2. 5 <os dr2 70-oom. B arnptBa--aoLT Hom. E 490a,--b' vxa om. B2. 6 ElS rpd?tvB et (cod. Lond.) e, cf. supra ad 2. I El 834-tq-4vaS Hom. 8 739

'r( Lm, [Choer.] 246. 19tTII

pE•aFCr

#WValveL Lmb ( davvnm);IIarvE [Choer.]

777&K•IrTUKEUv7

Lm:7-V

KaaTUKE1VYV: KaaTUKWV e: E "l 7•v7-•7j

ovA77& KaraUKEU7V /ETEV?7VEKTcL

[Choer.] 246. 21I2. 7

E• dL•Ew&3rlw7LKal oz

eB": E•4Lcd•oEv3?7AW07LKal ac oz Lm

(d/o-drp-0o9-d/•oLdr)a)

ex. gr. supplevi: (dKoLodr?7roS r7AW7-Kacat OUjwJU/L

Uv baULv, a38K/wo

auqovUaL

(vel3rl,~Aoaa)

7?7vdpobLOdr7ra)inckh' 546: at 3~8 40OKoa

(7rVvdold7o7-a

Kat) Hilgard





8/13/2019 637916


238 M. L. WEST

KardXPIa•is3

KaTaXprla7gs are dpoS Aoyov (KderT0To KVplWSgKal ETvtW'WSKaTOVOtLaoOEVTO>

AEydoLEVOVre lTvos erepov aKaTOvopaUTr KaTaTo OLKElOV,lov 1TvlS XaAK'7Kal

7p07papXos.Kat - ItEV1TVets-KVp1WsKat ET7VWSg OaTLV EK{WAov} TVOV KaT-

EUKEVaU/LEv7,KaTaXpl77UT&K$G> 7d- Oolva <KaL 7TK>XaAK<iT7e>Is-

irpoaayopEVo0Ev"Ka 7•ptpapXov 0 UdvpovV 7pt&povgS pXova, dAAaKa" 7TEEVT7pOv

Kat&4pov9-.

Kat,Tv 8vspadvraKa1yvvaltKos AEYOfEV.

Ka, "OoPrloog

VEKTap EPVOXoEL,

v Ka 7r OKELY, c' aKaTavtaa7-ov EUT.

ME-rdJA4tS 4

MerdA'ig EUt r AfEs arr $t 7, Tgovvwv ov 7r)vyopvvkov 8rlAov0a, olov

EVEV S' a'Tv`otrO E7TL7TPOE•1KE9•7•0tL.

Tag ydp ar7Td 0o qX7 ~Ltarog'OEtags KaAov(LEvaSiVrqov•>S

LE7aA-q7TrtK-9 V'GOUSc0asgpr7KE.

T71,

yap

0o,avvOUvvko'vEr& 7TaLv ToKT7 KlrV OCv

o•v,>{Kat}

rovrw,E OPLJvvLLdvarTL rVy 70 Kal7 aUX'ILaOd6. {o0ElAwv 7ap 'O El6sELTEr•, ELrTE

Oouatv,ETEl3Oo0vorLa'cVELa'7T7TaX a•T .} Ka' TCVL

TEpog S'TO'r •WvXpwpLEvog>)oE&oWAL

rV7TpcrdpoVrrrwLvrags UTr7CK>) pv'yas

218 J ydp Ka-7 7Tov ov ELOAOS aUVVWYALWS9L lKp7t S KaAE7Ta,0 U tVVILEL

T7,KaTa7 77V 7 XVnrVKptfE, rTOUVTEOrWvUTodXP.

3 a&teLm: 6S B

(d<wrr0)o... KarovotLaaOEV(r0)>inckh' 546, cf. Try. i, I92. 21,Anon. ii, 208. 21, Coc. 232. 5, [Choer.] 246. 23 KVPlwSKa

&oooklwScodd. utroque loco:

corr. Boissonade <o3) Ka-rdFinckh ibid. cl. 3 fin.; at vide Try. i, i92. 23, Coc. 232. 7otov om. B XaAKbqm, yp. L: XaAKLsB Kat ante TptqpapXos om. LB, post ins. in

M: deest in e <Kal dv3ptds)excidisse ci. Boiss. evAovdeest in B, cf. Try. i, 192. 26,Anon. ii, 208. 21, Coc. 232. 8, [Choer.] 246. 26: Kvpiws ydp ~n a7dw v6Awv e (<Kara-

XPpOTLKW0S1) (et plura) suppl. Finckh ibid. (KaLrd>)XaAK(<a~rv•)asupplevi; nescio

an scribendum sit i-d<(s)LoAlPStva<9Kat'ds) XaAK(KaT7rpv7p7ipovs--~i6jpovSLB, cf.

Try. i, 192. 31-193. 2, Coc. 232. 11-12, [Choer.] 246. 31-247. I: Tobs7p•(•-jeV PXOVraSaAA'Ka 7TE~crvrpEWVaL e7pCwv M VEK7ap

•(mpVOodf Hom. A 3; cf. schol. BT ad loc. et

schol. T ad A 598 JAAa Ka-rovitaardv m

4 "reydPdvvtUov

eB, cf. Coc. 239. 10o:T'd"dvvupov m, cf. Try. i, 195. 1o, Anon. ii, 209. 2,

[Choer.] 247. 20ao vev--Oo?rL Hornm. 299: utrum0o-a&u

an Oof-cLvoluerit poeta,nescio; at noster certe &Oo~antellexit, cf. Coc. 239- 14 rdS y dvpvdLa7L70LeoXiLt'aroS'O~da~r KaAovLEvas viaovs IuEraA-qTr&LKC

oEoSplYqKEV. Try. i, 195. 13 TaS' 7dp KaAovUlEvag

ovoLaa7-TLKc 'O~EIas vcTovs"SL

-6aX7itLa .LE7raAqr'TLK(Js

.d0sE)KdAAcUEv.Item Strabo p. 350/1 de

versu eodem: &oda 8 E'p77KE rTa9'Olda"

Cl v 'ExwdS3wv3S'dc'tlYai-ra, rhrA7TOduaovaaL?c apx?

70oKopwOtaKO•o

dA7TOVa'Tra EK'KOAatro .lXEAov 7rdTdp e: rovs ydpB: Kai yapLm

<'Oe(-as---viaovs>

addidi ex Coc. loc. cit. uLEraA77rr&KTK rad~vi'/ovs Lm

v4aovoSort. delendum, cf. Coc. et Try. i, 11.cc. r7 yap

0o.....

(.r<dTOKar•)

77r

KV7aCTLv)cripsit et Ka sustulit Finckh' 547, quod ego leviter mutavi, cf. Coc. 239. I6--17,[Choer.] 247. 27: 7r Poy~p e:

•dyap GodsLmb: 7o ydp o00v Ka' beBoissonade, cl. Try.

i, 195. 13 roirw Boissonade: 70oT70LmbdEidAwvydp--3 dosZ aria recensio

quam om. B dITEOO^laLr

eL: Oo•Lvlregv m Kat 7-7"aX

Kat&d Oev: fort. -d raxbKa do'v' TEDKpos-'-Ppyas Trag. fr. adesp. 569; Sophoclis Teucro ascripsit Blomfield;cf. Soph. Ai.

x279r7dv Anon. ii, 209. 3, [Choer.] 247. 29: -drovcodd., praeter quod

M rdoovexhibet ex Lascaris coniectura (deest e): rdoov Try. i, I95. 16 ELshALos--r7Cov b 7rv ftdv M: 7iv 3dOwL Anon. ii, [Choer.] d 84

UvvovvlLEcodd., corr.

Boissonade; cf. Anon. ii, [Choer.]





8/13/2019 637916



5 TrreparddvY7TEp/3p-o'v

'Y7TEpPa-roJdorr pi vvv E19 9 EXouva. ylvovrat SE TvTEpfarc

iv ELS~L vUlyV, <'EE VAY)

E A T E V'' JV E EEL,)

OLOV

)1vraI pp••Pt

TEoO pWpEL"OEU7TL&aLS

7TVp

Aa.Evov.

7r yVp Es oVosqXEL"TCavr1

7prT'P

7 "ELXOS Av CovopwpE OE LaS p.

S'icK8 tia

v vv0ot AE'~EUVV7TEpiarawVd6LEVa,LOV

vlmrot,OL Kara7 OOS Yr7tEPlovoS 'HEAloLO

77Otov,

2 ivrT70toKcrTr0Uov. r 8 6' Ac' tw ytvoLEvaXELoV"wS

7trap' Ot7pp?

s ' a'- '4 pydEOLE i'aXov,, /p t,EV71ESg

arkEpsaAEov Kov iaPUav avuav-rwv. 7TrAxat~av,

t080ovwralvdav-re

'OSvacy og 0Eloto.

TryapE o;rwSdrog81j0otra•"

O4 aro, tpyEdoECi/E'

'axvovvov 7rawtvvrTe.3 IvLOLKaE EVTL vAAa/atE7TEpa7 7TE7TOLKcLUW,d Kat

C %wv"

t5v 5t-

aypcpau. *j]*

* AoQ-O TOOV'7TEp[E ai r JOS7

i-v [E]AEv-Tacia [lTEpEglflauE-] To yap O'6- "T-o7T o&S07orattEpjtf7vrdv3]fc avE6OKEV

rzj[p?]Tpto,'p0ta6'OVK 'v

-•rpo0[]pots ..rv7pos , .. [.1.

o.t

•.a [

6 Avaoarpoq'

Avaurpof)l 8'E'e a-rtsd V XP)7TpoP07yELcOcLtT-s rfLatv/Ev7 lSt Gavolas EV-UpaV

'xovor T ErV E'vCoa&0Kat o&aELdVWV dyov LEpWV77)V IvauTponV A4YOUvL

ylvErOat. Ka'>E'7TAELtVwV0yOvEfLOEPWVVd C'V r7POOE'OELv~7WSI

COEM7ir5' Etoy7aa,

5. IE1rrpLalrdvLO--Iov •7Eaw7Icaavr•E

(posteriore loco) cit. Gregorius Corinthius comm. in

Hermog.weEplELoov d•wor'qroSii.1250. 20-1251. 8 Walz vdadpos-e: ctdauov

Greg.:&S~a

oov Finckh,Zeitschr..Altert.

1838, 1o53 (dELEV

Aodyp)ddidi,noluit

Boissonade; cf. Phoebammon. p. 48. 7 Sp., Try. i, 197. 21-22, Coc. 238. 12-13 K(vAE'EL)addidi 7Iryv--rAdvov Hom. M 177-8 Ad'vov. Tb &p--7Tep om. m: T ydp-rrOpom. e Ac'ivov on postT-ErXOSed post ifrp B v4-rLLoL-?raOwvom. a 8

5. 2 -rap' 'O/iL,4pom. e 3SE(Ipa'TO-EloL

Hom. B 333-5 Tas oavAAaf3aE:avAAa/P3e Simonides: fr. 159 Bergk4, 113 Diehl lacunam statui. nam in codd. sequitur statim

'Eptjv-- -rpo0v'pot (AqL~pdrposro AdJr-ppto L), deinde dvr' 7rov oQK apOta d' 3Eom. e); verumin H, quae hic incipit, ea habes quae supra dedi. locum non poteram ita explicare utomnibus persuaderem; sed non tacebo quid suspicer. pone poetam nescioquem, ne dicamus

Simonidem, epigramma ludicrum in hunc modum scripsisse:

'Epj4v 7rdv'adVEY'•KE

V'poSAI7L7PtLOS, VKE".

6pGta 3'S ArJL7Tp'

i•p

PTEv EV7TpOOVpoS.

id est, homo Syrus, Demetrius nomine, erexit hermam ante domum suam et deo (Mercurio

videlicet) dedicavit; male quidem, cum illa imago non deceat Cereris aedem. haec potuitgrammaticus perperam interpretari, ut esset, 'Syrus hermam dedicavit Cereri': TO ydp i~gs,'Epl.djv rdv3' avEO7IrKEVlj]pPL, OpOLa ' OK dV7rpOOgpOLS

dg,•ry7poS =pEIEV.6. I CpacLetcA

11:"cpdCaTS AdgSOellacher&avoa"s:

item H ut mihi videtur:EnLVOLCCeg. Oellacher SEV-rEpaV ~Xovaa crd~v e: &EvrEpav •XovUav rdciv Lmb: ra~tv

f EXJ]ovcav vel 3EvrVEpaVEX]ovcav et inter lineas ra$L]v H ut vid.: cf. Try. i, 197. I I, Coc. 239- 3

iVLOt eLmb:tc.•

H: EvLoTESpengel (iii, p. xi) verbum (quale rroLoawv) excidisse ci.

Finckh' 547: (Kt~L-Kal) inserui, cf. Anon. iii, 34o. 4 et 9 c~'-dLy'aa Hom. A 162





8/13/2019 637916


240 M. L. WEST

[avr]t T0%P[6]' L (d)>AA' EKcKO7TcL6'77[ca.]V'

E7TLpp 7L,

219 7TagEtqoAoSAavvEwr&OKEagspVLaSg,

avrt 70oy co opvL7ar. {dv S E'av8ETLkOLS} (Kat>

T70oP 7PTpXEtaKat ovX t7T7Tr-AaTOSUTLy' ,

o 'S A'7v Av7Tp-4, 7rp o33' EVpELa TETVKTaL.

(Qv3S) avv8rja[oLs, dOKaAA~lt'Faos

Maaaa]y•.Ta[L

Ka fLaKpovoLTEVOLEV7T 6pa,

CdwLV70 Ka' Maaaay'raL.] rara , vzrpvpuavvaa7p'ETtaL AESLV AAaXO E 2

aT7t poS 7TAElova tIdpq Aodyov v dvaaorpoqv XELYV,tov

"EK-ropoCO'E

ETaV7-t Ooj V7T - UV 7TECTOaL.

a'yp pdOETLs oVKE7Tt LtL V707TOTE7aL,

aAAa~vatE'e•tLv, Ka'LTK7 5l vO')

"EKropOS ddAEIT7E.

,EvVEKO'Xo 7

ZEVEKSOX7r'TLpdCaTLSo Ka7CTo 7T 7pESKKOEpoIfE'VI,TpOCTEOIEVr' 7rtVOSEgWOEv &avotlaS. EXEL SE'taoopS TEraaapasg Kal yap c TO{ro} [(dpovs 7TAov

O77XAo, KLa oroy oov 7d pE'poS,K9 a7T Oo} avp4aLvovrosTo 7 TpO77yOvfEVOV,

Katao avtPj3Aovo KVPLOV.7To

Evoiv

pzpovg oJAov,ov2

OElAEvKdAEVOoS

"Hp-q.

U77ka vEt yap aio {DoI} Lpovs 70Tov^ aXovor vT7VO'A7rv EVK-V. a07ToSTO Aov T3

/zposg, otov

ot tiV97T2 STELXOS EV/Jl7)T0V /3as avas,

dvTroo--EKaKoId9~laa 7, om. codd.; cf. Try. i, 197. 17, Coc.

239-5

i•a--csHom.

B 764 JvrTo700 LB: ivAtm Ka pro iv • oavv lootLSscripsi. quo iure? quaeris.vide sis Anon. iii, 340 ( = 460. i Hilg.), qui docet (perperam sane) id esse in his versibus

anastrophes, quod oz A&lqvvrrpi7dictum sit pro o'-Av7rpadtav.quae explicatio fort. et hicolim sequebatur.-post '

ro----.r&v'KTaL(Hom. v242-3) sequuntur in codd. statim Taora t4v pTs

iLUav.T.A., n H vero

cvV•.5.E

[: lacunam explevi ad exemplum Anonymi iii, loc. cit. Maaaa-

y,at-adv3pa

Call. fr. r. 15. in H supersunt vestigia verbo

ftacca]yf'.T[L

non dissimilia. hoc

est ultimum quod in papyri priorefacie dispicitur; sequebantur litterae ferecxxx de anastrophe,deinde titulus CVV4EKOX77.

6. 2 cAAaxo 8' ia':: AAaE e: JAAa e'anUB; cf. infra ad 22. 2 •XEL LaXEL :

ELaxriB: ElpELVFinckh' 547 'EKropos--7T6Ea &OaLHom. Q 254

67rordcaaaEraLHil-

gard:avvrd-aa'Era

eLmb. cf. Anon. iii, 340. 2

7. IbpdaaLsAEes

Anon. ii, 209. 25; AELfst" Opda

s Coc. 236. 28 Stavolas: item

[Choer.] 248. 16-17:dKoAovO•as

Try. i, 195. 29: om. Anon. ii, loc. cit. &Saqopas

rcEaaapas, [Choer.] loc. cit., cf. Try. i, 196. I, Anon. ii, loc. cit., Coc. 236-30 : Traaapas3taoopc-Lmb -70oante pipovg et ante avl43avovros seclusi; cf. quae sequuntur, et Try. i, 196. 2,

Anon. ii, 210. I, Coc. 236. 31, [Choer.] 248. 20. sed librorum in hac re haud magna estfides dcic avL43dAovB: d8d

70"oivtfldAov Lm: aiwocvpfloAo H, quae hic denuo incipit

7. 2 To

p.A[o].

8&rAotH OGE--"Hpr) Hom. A 55 et saepe

c7)L.L.VEL

yap a~To79v

[•E]povUC ['rovIpaxLovoc] r'r)v

oA'r

.?EVKYv

LI, cf. Anon. ii, 20o. 1-3, Coc. 237. 5, [Choer.]

248. 21id•r

ydpo70o

paXiovos rd5Aov (mriv e) a6Waa3'rAo"

m et in margine L: om. B

7. 3 dir 8 JAov rd•Ldpos~

LB oL-3[oac avac (Homrn.M 137) H: fldas~aias eLmb in H

sequuntur vyv yap

floa.A•YEL

-rac acrrytac E[K yap SEpLa]Tw v gict JLEpoc BE rpy oAov [raoSEpLa]

garo8•.

F~IPLawovroc K.r.A.





8/13/2019 637916



CavT"70o

vpaas,Tro0VTEr•T

dsg S.Cr yaa p jAov

70"o 3o5 'AwsTE tO pos,

4 'yovv7TOpLa. a7TOSE aVlOvoros Td rporyovLEvov, olov

EodtevoL AE5KaVOV VwpESC

7)S EcLt7L.

'T AEV1KaWOVdpE•7TEV

aTV7TTO aUVVTOWS(pEaOV'EK ydp TOo Ko7TrrlAaraELOa5avzpalvEtEvKlIVEUaOT owp.7T'EUav4PO'AOU

7,KVPOVY,OLOV)

aUK77rTrpovLEV0roL KE 7TE-r7TaOaLTptEPTcV7WV.

avTl yap r70oE7TEL•v

T?flaalAE•La

E To" afoAov, SELKVv E)KOKToU 7To KvptOV,

'jyovv 7T-v paoLElaV* naztfloAov yap EaT T7S.7 a7AElaS TOrUK7pTTPOV.

8 'OvoaTro'TodLta 220

Ovotzaoro7TOLta EUTt /IpoS Ad'yov 7TE7TOL771E'VOVKaT7 adcUrtV 7OV a7TOTEA OViE`VCV

alA<JmrnS. pvcAtELa Xatal /d3o377a E 7TEUov^oa.

wvYj77S.7TOr70oLrov, otov 77

OAoAvy/Kal d ,lUVK77O(Ld,al

o70S EAEEwVaKaTr'T LETE7rpy^c7a..

9 MEroWVVAvtL

MErwyovv'•l

'E'aT'LdposAo'yov ) pOVrp YV7WVOS VpLW9ELLEVOV,TEpOVE

atVO0V KL7T TO O KELOV, OLOV

V7TELPExov Hla"roLo.

aU7yalv~Et TO70TvpOd, O TEp EarT OLKEYOV0VTO Hatrov. Kat 7CTaLV

'vOa S' Er7TEL' CfEL LEYOS ovptoS A9P77S,

aYTL

7V0 c&7p0O. K

OTa AyWLET

ObV OYVO Y

'VcO,

KU TOY ULTOY 7paV,-Vt TO at -roro'T8PO"'

Kat o"rav AE'CO/EV dv otvov /Jtovvaov, Kat 7dvq [rOV d•Tf•77,rpav,

Kat 7T TapaTA7T Lta.

avrt roo ras Pfpaas B daidyap-iE'pipa om. B

7. 4 70oiavtLPalvovros

eEOdl'EvoC-EAdL7TaLom. ?t 172 ii4'ar-s (om. 'cwp)

e: EarTqTSELT•v

aVtLH: EtlTEv m. Lmb: deest e EKyadp-vwp Lm: EK

t70oKW7•7•AaTELeatGL

y Lp-• ccp e: (cvf)PaLvEL yap [EK TOUTro OVVvv ]O r

ro7.•.AVqe

rA[o~ TO

KWcTrlAaTrELc]PatLH: om. B

7. 5 (<oov) add. Palaeocappa: om. eLmb: deest H UK'7rTpov--7TVrVTwoorn. I 38

advT,yap-PaLtlaE•av

eLm: om. B: 70] cv 0floAoyap

E..YV

ri[c acLELacr70o

70K]T71rpO[v

a]yr ToPvcvp[tov et in proximo versu ovo]Liaro7r[otta H, quae hic deficit8 post 9 habet B: hoc loco HeLm: cf.I. 2 Ale3LSj dpo AOdyovAnon. ii, 210. 27,

[Choer.] 249. 20 ( wv•l"s Xw>V)Finckh' 547, pdvaddidi; cf. Coc. 231. 17 sqq.,[Choer.] 249. 21 A~yE fLto'dom. A 125: om. B

atA•Lcms--7Eaoaa

Hom. N 530

'o0S-••Ep7y'TasHomrn. B 314

9 p4pos~ Adyov em, yp. L: &vola LB: A•~Ls [Plu.] 23, Try. i, 195. 20o, Anon. ii, 209. 8,Coc. 232. 22, [Choer.] 250. 21 cb&' i7r'pov m otor eB: omrn.Lmrn integrum

versum aorAdyxva 8' cp' &LTrdtpavrES 7TEiPExov 'H aba-roeo(Hom. B 426) habent [Plu.] Try.[Choer.] ll.cc., et potuit noster habere Iv~a-A1prj~ Hom. N 444

R





8/13/2019 637916


242 M. L. WEST

Heptpaots 10o

Hlp~plpaca~rT tare qpa aS a(AAcaaaovea)>7Tr aVToEeAoV9 Kat Kvptas AEeWS,

ad7TAELtVWVir 7 CVp•pov rAooaa TirpaPi u

aeY 70Tv laawovoewvotov

P1,7'HpaKA27Cb Kal tEpoV dvos AlAKVdOLO,cV7ATo7

e"HpaKA?g Kal AAKIVOO9.

(Kal 7TaALv>

7ap a ' dcAirovLEpodKT7V.

HAEovQao~Ld II

HAEovaCtlds eare OpieS v ari hTAovrdov a, -4qacoa,

,g•'Xe7t

Kara avaAoylav.

rav8

AE•yOpLEvWVrrAEovaca,/v

O( v ipwv EVEKa

O.p.ov7ra,

o( & 'L9cdEWso.

Kal ppWVt[LeV 7d 70o7oara, oovOELOV ao, Hpta4toLo,hAEA/3fuL,EacXXWc,al ITavE

A•XyE'ratKa-7a

rrapaywyTqv.E(LactEWs

Ura•lav7•Ka7r

70rotara

pLotoQayotveOWESEVovpeaU 8ap8da7Trovca,Kat

22I 4pnnwv iwapa Otva*

7r (ydp) vwOpovE(4 aLVEL at auTraTov' at

TovTovT'arpvyE-rovpKE'KETO KpvaAdElwv.

HapaITA-rpwptta 1

HapairXA4pwcicd' bpdckSa'

A4wLS K TEptruaOVapaAajg4avoLdVlr, OLOV

apxov; av v77?cv Epcwv7'c

Ia EripoImaas.

, ydp rrpoTapeAKEL. Kat

dcrdEptIwpwvVmaAlyKtos,s 7TEa'ALTa,

awV700oB 'Adtra. Ka' ' 7OEo

Ka K 7L9' EPEELIpLjWVr7TEP7VOPEdV7W

.

"EAAEc o13

"EAAEtl uarte pcdass 3 KaTT 7r A7pES K'EpO)'v2/,AA

A'E' LEt tV

JAAE•vTovaa"otov

KOTTW7V9oo07TpI7cLv,

1o Opdatgom. Lmb ta(<AAaaaovaaa)x. gr. scripsi: &a<a'd~ratc Boissonade: ,pjfvelaFinckh' 547, cl. Phoebammon. p. 47. 4 et Tiberio p. 75. 26 PflqHpaKAerldr

Hom. A

690 etc. lEPOvptvos AAKL•w'otoHom. q 167 etc. <Ka TCiAtv>)nserui 7rapd-

dK•r7V(Hom. A 631) om. m: deest e

II eP avrT7: EavT-

B i s EIv3XETatLaraT7vaAoylavnon intelligo o0

p v...o

8e Spengel (iii, p. xi): i& V . . . 8 eLmb AAdpflySa, om. eLm. quis hac formausus sit, nescio; ap. Homerum reperitur AEAaPiE'aat, 388. fort. scribendum

A'd/l•a

A•dXXWaLLM: AEAdXovaL:

•Ao'xaac(Boiss. p. 480)

c<tofdyoL-8ap&z7rovaLHom.

A 479epw'dwov rapa OrvaHom. v 220

r-eLB: rcv m yap inserui vwop3v

eLm: vceOsB (debuitvw•O•s) rdovo-AE/l3wv Hom. E84

EPEacKET•Oodd. (deesi

e), propter aapdcrrovcn credo

I1Aatzfavoyt'vq

e dpxodr--rpocreas Hom. B 493 2 7yp 7rpOrapE'AKEt

m. B

da'rdp-p-/LdAcaraom. E 5 KE Kal om. m:

Ka?"KalB: deest e Kaia E-ltErrpqvo-

pEov'rwvHomrn. 176





8/13/2019 637916



E'AA•Errap ra~ XEpolv.d olws

EVKaOapa, oL 8) VEKV(AWLEaLVETOx(iOSI.

(AA:El•TEap rTddTrr. Kat>&AA'El E V 8UoovaL yEpas LLEydaOviotLxatol,

apo'avTEs Ka7Ta UOvlO, O7irws dv7tovLOV Orat.

E'AAE••rEaprTKaAsGvEXOtLrEKpCELaToap7q&?vota.

EvtOL 7TvrpdoTO ovrov 7Tpouv7TaKOUdv0EIVOVaAoVULV.

TYrrepfloA14 '

Y 7ep7~og

'Y•EpfloAErt Aoyos vTEpalpwov EldoEW ~

aEVEKGara a7E, C E TOvTOvU'v

at 8' rE EVt KLpr7EPETLE pOVpOUpav,aKpOV EIT avotEpLKWVKapIo OV OVOv'SK'KTEKACoWv

{Kal} AA'oTE 8 UKLp7-rwEV E'7r EvpEa v3-ra 6aAduorus,

aKpOVET LtVOS a rOLOO EKOV.

El Iv oPvVVOtLK-S

7LSKOVOLT770TLU0TOV, dKUpoAoyla 0av7aUratL, Ed ELTI, 7rraX-0%oerat 7rfViTEploA^. ( )

. ro

AEVKd7EpOL OVOS, QELELY aVE1LVOLuLVLOLOL.

ElpwvEla15 EpwvEla rt pdSat- To-S PrS AEyo<(LE'voLS' LTro>L) V rovav-rov LEO'

vrTOKpLUEwS.,OLOv

AvrTLvo', Viv KaA'

7%T77pS K7E t vLov^.

I6

2apKacrtLd(

ZapKao'"sds EUTLopdaST0L5r

pO~Ws. AEYO<ItLVOLS.ltVLTTo>tEV•Trov V7avtotE7ol

XAEvao=utov,tov

v6v4v&

CL5dAarrdyXvMEAdvOtEvKTabvAde4tELS

EvyT EV tLaAaK-IKaKTaAytlEVOS.

13 fort. (Kal)d0olcos, cv-XpOS0

Hom. K 199 lacunam secutam esse vidit Boissonade,

explevi ego; cf. schol. BT ad loc. rdvKaOap8vr0rov dAA'-~a-raLHom. A 135-6 8oovaU

M apaaVTES9 a7aUOvd'vm. B av E lXOLLm (Ev deletum in M): deest e; cf.schol. B ad vers. 137 drrEKpEiaTro: drrEKpEaaT70LM: d7rroKEKpaaUTO: malim dirOKpE-

Ia-raLvel a7roKEKpE~7araL

14 ET Todrov:e: TOTrirW B: EMdT0oo: rd m at 8'&OT--OEEaKov

Hom. Y 226-9 at 8'

GCE•y":AA'

A•TES Lmb (deest e) Kap7rrv eLm KaTcKAovB KaLseclusi aKOVtE

Palaeocappa dKvpoAoyt : KvpLoAoyl'aFinckh2 347 lacunam statui. si supra suppleas

iLcdacwS • LaoTLEwsEr)KarVK E'lk.

E/cdaUo•s

v,>) C K.T.A.,hic requiras

(dkoLwaEwso"'). cf. [Choer.] 252. 28-30, 253. 3-4 C9 Kal To B (Kal post insertum) AEVKdTEpOL-l0otoLHom. K 437

15 qpcasi: KOAaKELta (KwA-B)plrCrg

Finckh' 548: jr~pogS Lmb AEyo/Lyv7eLmB:A-eo/LdvoLS Par. 2008:

A•yor/voLS(Kd aivovaa) Finckh loc. cit.:

avr-ro)>zV7(cf.

Anon.rr.

aXrylp.141. 19 Sp.) vel flovAo)>ivr ego /LE0'-I6 roVvavrtov om. b Avrivo'

-vlo) Horn. p 397 tdaAa ro /Ev Palaeocappa propter ydAa ldyXv quod paullo infrafertur

i6 qpaoaLs om. e P'ITroLSAEyo1lv'q eLm: eadem ac supra Finckh et ego vov-

KaTraAEytvosHom. X 195-6 6A om. eLmb





8/13/2019 637916


244 M. L. WEST

Evav•d vTpd~ d

orKpELT70V?7LK

'SLqaivoUGa,

O.OVEt, rSt jTovtos'

OV d7TEV7S'vae AE'yE, KaLo

TEXVL•x arEXvos, Kal dayao'g aa'osv.vEot&47ov daTE*odv oplaavro r7Tpoorom)lvELvaItr &X7dlEas-.

Avrt'p•acn'x8

Artppaals- Ea-r par 70TS KpEToT0U- rTaptaaT V 7oVKVaKlaV ov ' (a)Eav- r a•rEAoAaova,oor av•rdv AovILO Ka•^ aVKal 7jv XoAv YVAKEaV,

KaL 7rV /p/opov doXEo7dV, lTal7 apaTrA?7U'La.

{Av rlOpaols 'ar Ats 8t 70~ vavtovT Evavriovuav'alvovua xwpis ro-

(b)KpLUEWS. 1TOErat 3 rT70OKar E' Uo'V K' Evav?TwUa. Ka'T Ev

rlt~)tLov

tzdy, -rav T'v aKavOav /3c7-ov AE'y(OJLLV, T OUK UErv tv rL/3Vp L, Kal 7T-V XoA VyAvKEt-a. Ka7 ~VaV7EtaCW8

o'8' 'pa 7rdWE 18 yEv rlA

v -XLAAEv'S,

avOT)rO77vta7.}'EvavrT wajr z19

'EvavtCwusEi dar A4Lts8& rio Evavn'twv To EVavTloV Ka7-rd cro/oA-OV 87Aovoura,

W9s TO

r v'OUKKOVE7TE~rEOr,

avT& 70 o 8& KOV7ES.. T.77lUaV.

K7L

ov8'apa

ararp dVrKOaUT7rEVv7rdAAwV,

avTl 70T7KOUV•E

TOy 7raT7pdoKalT Trrap7TA•r

tla.

223 Avrovo/atau20

Avrovol7aLala 'artv ovo1za EEtOErLKOV Kal zodVoVV7r KvptOU irapaAatUflavEraL,(a)

Sop' Etc FaVKtA LS, 7raV c 7aTaXPt ?7

dVT70to7 A28Orlvi.Kal

olw ydap S7 Ttro7tuLjoXE KUvavoXatT,

avTl70TUO)o170 ov. Kal7r apa7TA4a.

17 7rs ELvat A'yELeB:

"•vat 7Evr•sA'yot Lm o ante dyaOdsm. eP

x8 recensionem (a) ante (b) habent m (cum coniunctione ) et e (cod. Matr.): (b) ante

(a) L: (b) om. e (cod. Lond.) et B 70o om. M a.c. irap-aravol•'vov B 0rav om. e

KaAOVLLEvB Kalante rv orn. Lm Katlrv-raparAGata

om. m: Katpriusom. La 700TovavTlov Trevavrlov e (cod. Matr.) et L: io dvavrltovSa 70to vavrTov m atzlatlvet

M a.c. o0V'--XAXLEAAEom. A 330I1 hoc caput om. m ,As~rMatr. 46I3 (ex coni. ?) om. Lond., LB7( -'-rTrTEaOlIv

Horn. E 366 etc. o0 1 KOVTES L: IKOV7ES e: oi3 aKOVTES B r7r7daOav B:

Errd7aOrivL: om. e oB'--A~rdAAwv Hom. O 236, H 676 avr

oT70qKOU(E TOO

rarpds L: omr. B: deest e

2o recensionem (a) om. L: (b) om. B Lond. in m coniunguntur verbo i, in Matr. 4613verbis Kat6

9osf d&vrvooLaaiamB qp'-pdx7paL Hom. O 406 ELdf Lm et

codd. Homeri fere omnes: i' eB, Try. i, 204. 27r om. B

o••7w-KvavoXai7aHom. O 201

olAo" codd. (mB) d

7roodw&ovB Kal

r

T rapaTrrjata om. m





8/13/2019 637916



(b) {Mvrovoaiala arTA•E, S' ,•,

87t

l-Erw.v

-s&q UavaaTo' OY

vo?ia Lt&'OVTrpoPUarY1ptKOV

arvtalvovaa.

8t' mrnOEr'7v v oIE v, otov

A-rpEtlr KV8tarTE,

avrLovc w AyiEiLvov. 8t& 8 UVLO ,

,otov

dply8ovrrosrdoat"Hpr-s,

Ka, Avroi^sKal> zhl vtds.}

21 A'tqpqoAla

Aj t oAla art' pacas~&8o TAEL'Oasvolla7s alvovaa, otov

XEtIpar' avpodvovsO'ILEVOSr77OErE E-ralpov.

i8rqApoyap, 7doEpo rd7 o3 HarpdKAov XEp AE'yE r To XAAEw. Katl

dl T 70T CEptov Elp tEva-

aEva7' rTELTEr7 KvtLaop(p

wpvt &OLK'S',

o' 7E Ka7a 8tEVOVS OT7TOUS t~ 7rpU LO

XG1vssypoaawv 7vKtVa 77-rEpa 8E6 aL (ACi-.

rot yadpTo vKtLVd7rpoS7T aypCiUUwVA77OTrTEOV, q 7TVKLV ypWaatoV, 7 TTVKLV

2 rTEpa8EVEaEa" .(ac... .oAov

8 Kal 070'

K17)UKE9S ava ouv GEWVbEpOVpKta 7rLUra,

W70EVEV &vva IvovKEL•EOaL

Er 7E 7TWVt)pVKWV 7WVEpVV Kat 7srOEws,1TrEEI"80KEF 7' IAtOSETELX Oa6L TmOEV'EWv &' Kal 7TOAAaRKLS'EpaY>aV3r7'vAE'yEt,

"IAtovs LeEP7Yv.

Kal7TCEATpXodv7'

al•XrTv AIrdtAtovOl'aov TE.

Kal o(L1tw

,ELV•,8'O

'gAXtA'aVK(OLEVOV,fa-o770vLa?. 224

{ylvE-raL8 'E dqsL/oAlaE'aE, C A'las, i'3v8Aovdp7ir r6v 8'o, Kal

Ayc",s80 8E rdz' v8pa JAELEvat E op/l7)VEYXEOSE'AEV.

HapKflau~l art Ayoso x tV

a•Trop0ps• EVEqaAOylaS -TapaAatzflavodCEvoS-,Co

r7

r70o o0VLKOS~EptKovp'4rwv"

dvrwvolaala Lm rmOL&ov p Ev v Matr. 4613: Pv Lm ArpEtIq v'U-r7EHomrn. I22 yLE'7LUtE sscr. KLCrt7E)

m 5 om. Matr. 4613, L Eply0ovros

Ortg's wHprgHorn. N 154 al. Ayro6g KaLALSto S Horn. A 921. I

X•Epas-EralpovHorn. 317 q•a: rcs om. P ra dE roo: d rlom. P advar'

--&ah Hom. E 51-53 KdOTovt a7'pvyC'70ooOaAaaars codd. rvKLva--7pd TO

&ypcoaawv om. Lm (homoeoteleuton) E1ETa qAPt~seclusi

2I. 2 (< lfPoAv-rov-rooro)x. gr. addidi: lacunam hic esse susp. Finckh' 548 KpVKES~

--7a'rd Horn. F 245; cf. schol. BT ad loc. 'Sva-ro -T' Eiv Kal TOL7 Sp UVT•oUUEUat, El

trtTLV70r

0oo

i 9j Lv "OpKLa7TL7 OE~Va(Vayov" T7V LEpiVKGaiTs AerroXEWscripsi:7-i 7dAEWS Kal 7t

VLEpWV ibri (Kal 7LV LEpWvpost additum in B): (KGa)77 7TdEs

Ka,r -cTv

LEp•V(-=-rv dpK•wv?) BoissonadeOKEL om. P, unde EE XLtraLscripsit Palaeocappa

r50•

BEvL: wrd av OEWv : om. B LEpdvddidi "IALovE••

LEPrVorn. H 20o,ElS "IALovpg4v 196, O 169, al. ELSEpiV m: E~epo v B: EdEpiv L: (pry Boiss. TpiTXov--Ovdopadv JrEHom. E 706 rprlXv Lmr: 7rpL2Xv

ewELvv--KraHom. 'P 24o

YwVEra---rd•EI (cf. Try. i. 203. 2I1-204. 2) om. eLMB (sed in M margine additum) ds--

JAOEtVHom. E Ii8





8/13/2019 637916


246 M. L. WEST

tdEClY7)LatLOE pyov rEyl a l o, Ort vEoQ yE,

c .7V,V3V, Vt pEt oIP arTECE L oT.

KovpijrE' r' iadxovro7Kal

Al•wAo' wEvExdPaLat,

KaltI Eel7S.}

AAhhrLs 22

ZEAA-h~lt

Es

'

tpdatsS

vELV V

"TOKEL

VWV TpOUWTWV T7 T

lETEp

TpaXOEV a

KOLVWS-rrapaAatflpvovaaU otov '08voaev s rrEpt 7rOs avatpE~Ewos AAdEovs yEL

NE'aropt,

TOv 7pLUKaLE3KaTovUKO7TOVEL•oliEVVEyyvOtwV.

ELAAoLEVL7TE, atroL ToO-ALO0rL7JsVS"

ovov avo VEA 7T V ETLyLa TOy 2

v' EiXELTpoS'va

7jrov

oAAgowvAAaoosE

E'av' a'avAAc3vEt Eva7Tpd

ohovs., d(0 sExt r vo op trov 'E-L vyap ova"ro v' 't,(L'

EXrEL a7WE ('EpULTOV AEyo',IEva lTpo AyajtCivOvai

AEat`oTtXaAKOKtLULat,Toha8E vvatLKES

Eltal Evl KtOLUTs atPEro70t,a"s0rot atot

rrpwrtar•SLoI0LEV,,7' av 71rroALE•pov

gAwotLEv.

avyKa7aptO4LELap avTrov TOts apLUTEVUVatvaUGEV-sKat ov'auvos TrvyXa VV.

A)'vtyCa 23

ALvetyjc arTqpaats-

St'votav

a7TOKEKPV,4EIV)qVKat

$avEorov

TrELppotEv7)rrotLEV,

CaSrd ap' 'Hatdo rptrpT~ KS LKOS EydLEV'

225tz&7

or'olvoxdoTvrLElEV Kp~ TrPOSVITEpOEV.

avrdp TEL aroa sj&vta~ E?7S E E ovYEvro,

ftolvo0ot ropavrp, < >vdyoro<a(aAEvjv 7E Kat' 07-aAEV)V U9%7EpOLUL 7EKErUUL

TEOva'vat.

,IELvY7lLatL•-~EvExappatHom. I 527 sqq. pwLExdppat om. libri: pEvEXaPpotM:

•EvE'-

Xaptpot

P

22. I pdsat om. m vELAvL: 8votv emB 7rpoarcrowvFinckh' 548, cl. Anon.

rr.aXr*. i58. 9 Sp.: rrpayptrwv odd. r@drpq LM, B p.c.: rc ealpw B a.c.: drdpw :om. P. cf. [Herodian.] rr.

axryqt.. Ioo. 6 Sp. in Anon. ii, 211. 2 lege JAAcpro JAAws, icut

[Choer.] 249. I 151aKOLV4Oe":

15 7' KOLVW mB7v-v-v--yv

Hom. K 561 dyyv'Otv7)qVrestitui:

dtLVOEw"rV B: om. eLm JEAopLEvTr om. eLm

KaloLtem: Kal7rTp,

yp. TroL: Kat 7reptB 40dvovLMB: 4d0vov22. 2 d'AAaxoom: JAAa B: eadem variatio supra 6. 2 St' & : &eLm rrEat-

AwFlyevom. B 226-8 apwtarevovarw da0ov-gsbvy (omissis reliquis) et L

23 adcvElrovFinckh2 348: avvOerov

codd. 'Hatd6Scrd Lm rTEptL: rapambKVALKo0Sihil in sequentibus de calice dicitur, sed potuit auctor de interpretatione versusfalli. &KV"Aoverkelbach, versu proximo non recepto; 7rap 70ov

K,4VKOSgo olim eodem

pacto 4t7qdC7ro7'-7rcEpOEvHes. Op. 744: versum habent eLm (ErepOE(v) KpatrpOS

omnes), om. b. Hesiodum av4floAtrLKaicere docent scholia ad loc. (p. 226. 11-227. 11 Pert.cum explicationibus variis), et vv. 745-6 ut aenigmatis exemplum laudat Try. i, 194. J .

itaque non audeo, ut olim ausus sum, versum expellere. post eum excidisse existimo inter-

pretationem nescioquam, deindeKaG"

el sim. a1rdp-rEOvdvaL Hes. fr. 158 Rz.3; cf. C.Q.,I96 1, 142-5; Merkelbach-West, Rh. Mus. 1965. EiUy7ollatio codicis B a Cramero facta:

OIalS B ipse: rTEOdE(Ur~Sm: 3aLros tLEVOELKEOSNauck, Melanges grico-romains, iii. 273: 8' atrol

pEvKvinaas Palaeocappa 4EpEovro L a.c. et fortasse pap. [Hesiodi] (Oxy. 2495 fr.

37. 8) a.c. otov o1 LmB: Kal o0 Palaeocappa postt,-rpu

lacunam statui propter

pap. [Hes.]

]..ayovro (rratc]wLLobel) post dyovro lacunam statui et ex. gr. explevi





8/13/2019 637916



5vravOatu7rTpa trpoS

AYEL ijv PCdAavov-alo'rcav-rl"

yap ylvovrac at 8pvES,

adTod%62v 3pvy5V LVO0LKWSotsO cvOpCdTovs AyOUvorYEYEV7•cTaG.>

?aVAE'7v al

7TraAdyv,WTEL0KE Trpcy7orav qpat•vEuOat,L7-aTI7-acOL."t. ETEpOLULEKE(U,

TotLS EavTOV TEKVOLS, AEEL QE TOLSEVOLS. TO7Q TEUVCVC, KLU Q0KEL EK 7SvatS

EKKEKOdc7L.

24'Errad:O•7s

'Errave •••sEcr- qpa~ULS KaLa 7TpdOOEutLVvlavovua To-7qLaLVOvtLEVOV, .9 EXEL

7a TotClUwa'

rWVVEES' KELat~ S E' 7TTEpoVE Vdo77/La.

WOKVTEpOpVp 7) vV7V T?capEUT-quE dXos, dEtavvdasc r7irTTEp,

CO v•o77,ta. (KA)>

ad-t XS'XaAls EELLa 70T E KEAOS- aVy?7

"/ ov"

E•,

ov

'vtow'o•

TvposatOoLEvov - Ao vo'vros.

lKLavovap ~- ElKEAoO'S ?y , wpOUTLEdSoE77S EU77,'/v7ETo

tLVO/1EVOV.

25 'EDoxrj

'E,OX•

uatv ovo/daros Stac-roA) Kam7d a opav 7Tpos7dolota, otov

ZE %C, E'I)TEovTpC'is 7TEKa'L"EKropa vqvaL TEraaacUEv,

wTTEp o703 "'EKo0pos7o-q Xt

EdVO7 TP~OV, TELTOVTOVEYKEK

KT• 'EoX7Vap avrTv E'•jAwE0. Kal dc~Owsov ydp E"7 Ov-qos I?uEyaA--7ropoS

v EES~7•aav,

o"' Ep'E'T avr s E-•v OOdVEE 6avOes MEAE'aypos.

26 YorEpoAoyla

'YuTEpoAoyta~E•tv &orav

uEposAo'yov 8SEiwrrpc_,rov

AE'yEw a-Epov 'LS- Ta, oLov

&ta TpdcEV 7q EdYEvovTO,

dvrt7"00

6O?o dE'yVOV70KaUETrp g7o.aav. Kat

SOV'7T7E<(v>E'TErwV,

avr70tTO)TEoWV EV7ToUaE. Kac

cdaAqv LB: dyaASqv M (et m ?, inde) : at'aAEqvP rE>)Ka' Bergk,Poet.Lyr.Gr. ii4. 668

aEr7poLc4 Finckh'549": ~E7rpoLa:B: E'

KrdpoLam BrKEUUL: rTKELB: 7EK'ETTLm

davrT, Klou'ek ap. Rzach3 4dvoLrbscurumr: I 'votg :v,'AoL~

Cramer:E': IvdsAnon.,Lit. Centralbl.1878, 1643 rEOvcvaL: rEOvivaLM: r7eOvYIEva Bergk loc. cit. dKKdOeP, unde ElAigqOaLalaeocappa

24 POaLsom. e rrpdOelv eB rwC-v-vdtjaHom. ~ 36 wK7TEpovBoissonade:

KdrrV7TEpOV odd. (deest e) rciv vylqv7rapdEa•aaE

LB: 7rapdEuT7rlE 7v Ylqv m vELv

Walz (ex codice ?) nrEp6 Boissonade: wrpordpqcodd. (Kal) addidi d4 •-

dvdovroSHom. X 134-5 WKEAosm (et infra) atoodvoCo ~ EAloLoodd.25 Proca eLB, yp. m: aUl?/aLvo•IEva m in textu ZEb;S-wdtE'aUOEv Horn. N I; cf. schol.

ABT et Eust. ad loc. pg om. P 70o0Ivos B ETEL scripsi: d'l codd.

ol-MEAdEayposHorn. B 641-2; cf. schol. A (ad v. 641) et B26 Aeav ispos Adyovscripsi:Mdpos Adyov57avem: odyogsav L (yp. tdipos Adyov),B. ad

formulam. .. rlyv, Jrav cf. Coc. 240. 29, 241. 2, 7, [Choer.] 250. 14, 252. 8, 254.4, etauctores rEpL aXE?Ltrwmvassim rcfy eLMB: om. P: inCdpEL Palaeocappa cs

oav dErwLEv oLov evCa-•y~vovro Hom. A 251 3ovrelav 8 T

r•aoVyHom. A

504 et saep.





8/13/2019 637916


248 M. L. WEST

226 &AA'ye pot 7VoVE•pOV

TToKptcKaKCLKOaOVY,

avl 70oyaKO0VOV Ka lfVToKptvat. KaC

EL.LaTra8' aLJtlEaUava OV Ea Kal Aovcaaa.

Kal

Aao~7' p77Lavro, EOLut~XEtpasaVEIXov.

{z('Xl•dEo(TtoAOLKLtCLrjzuSOAoytOaVE•XwV, dOyav EiTW4LLEV, KVpLOS'IOCaVV7S-,

ov o 'EgSEJAE EL,dayaOd&art. SLtao/pELE aX-7' coAotKLtuILOV,7TEL&7TX - a

ILEV EUTL o7TLg70rov-

uvyyp?EcEws -cqLap-r-lia EKOVULOV Xv qV EVOvlcV -q

KacAAWTLCLoVdV,uOAOtKLtcrjIsSE'qltpT774pta cKOVXLOV, O &La 7-XVr7V cLAAl8t') aptaoclav

ywdprvov.}

c~AA'ye-cKovaov Hornm.535 v7roKptVEodd. hic et infra ctLtaTa-Aovaaaa Hom.E 264 Aao-advoEaXov Horn. 1 318

aXiCt•a--yLvo'tCvovom. B; cf. quae de hoc

capite in praefatione dixi adroAoylav e'xwvaoAOLKLatso'Choer.] 255. IO 0 KVpLOS

'IcoCyvvjS3L [Choer.]: d 'IwadvvrjCm: C (IAr7Tos Palaeocappa d Oeos eL [Choer.]:

radvTES EAe?4E e [Choer.]: ~AE'lat : 'AEoatvM: toov-aw : ftwooawvPalaeocappa

JdyaO's eLm: KaA3savOpowrrdsChoer.]

EPIMETRUM

Anon. iii: collation of cod. Leidensis Vossianus Gr. Q20 against the textof Fredrich-Wentzel.

337. 3 APatKV-V dCya p apa 5 alMv 7 ol oAAA recte, cf.Coc. 230. 20) 10 q dcvarr7j 338. I ' re 4

acvrwvopau•a6 8E

12E•'ELovro

15 Epov aCos7i7r" 27mapep•?ros

29 avdeest 339-2 &Ad9m. 3 7rovA7v 5cAP Cret 7 v7rv aurpoyyvAq,ed -

ex os 8 -70o-ds 13dKaTWVO•OfaaTV

14 XaAK 16 5' 19 Ad'ivov.rodydp

iTELrXOsAd'ivov ot3'rTp 20

:o'aro 23 '?ar'- 24rvU-

aOos 340. I dE' 8 2LErafLoA3 rovovv7TrorauaotjEvr"

'IEL 51S-

9 Adyov om. 12o0 A•lqv

13 AvTrqlp 13/14tpaKpdV

15Prpoo•q-OVU77S 16

Ed'E8aSvov

c om. 171ramprqurtsL dv cart deest Ecr&70ovui

•deov XwoplS-rra20

OV'VEKc

UniversityCollege,Oxford M. L. WEST

637916

Documents