6 18 12 0204 62337 60838 107 pages 12-18963 filed motion for leave to file opposition to scr 117...

7/29/2019 6 18 12 0204 62337 60838 107 Pages 12-18963 Filed Motion for Leave to File Opposition to SCR 117 Petition. No

1/107

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF THE STATE OF NEVADA

In Re Matter of:

ZACHARY BARKER COUGHLIN ES!"

Ne#a$a Bar No: %&'(

"

))

)

)

))

S*+re,e Co*rt No: -./(/

MOTION FOR LEAVE TO FILE THIS OPPOSITION TO SCR 00' PETITION

COMES NO1 ZACHARY BARKER COUGHLIN ES!" an$ f23e4 t5e a6o#e na,e$

$o7*,ent an$ ,o#e4 t524 Co*rt for t5e re32ef re8*e4te$ 5ere2n" T524 f232n9 24 f*rt5er 6a4e$ *+on t5e

+a+er4 an$ +3ea$2n94 on f23e 5ere2n an$ 2n t5e 7a4e 2n t5e tra23 7o*rt an$ t5e a++ea3 2n t5e D24tr27t

Co*rt an$ t5e Me,oran$*, of Po2nt4 an$ A*t5or2t2e4 4*6,2tte$ 5ere2t5 an$ an; ora3 ar9*,ent t524

Co*rt ,a; $e42re" A3ternat2#e3; Co*9532n re8*e4t4 t5at t5e Co*rt 4et a42$e 524 te,+orar; 4*4+en42on

+*r4*ant to SCR 000%& -


Electronically Filed

Jun 18 2012 09:25 a.mTracie K. LindemanClerk of Supreme Cour

Docket 60838 Document 2012-18963


2/107

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

to +*t +o2nt4 on t5e 6oar$ for t5e, t5ro*95 2nn*en$o nann;?4tat2n9 a6*4e of +ro7e44 et7" et7" T524

7a4e 24 a 3ot ,ore 2,+ortant t5an ,e" I =no I a, an 2n429n2f27ant 7o9 2n t524 4+5ere 6*t 5at 24 at

4ta=e 5ere 24 t5e +er7e+t2on an$ t5e rea32t; a4 to 5et5er a 7328*245 t;rann; o#err2$e4 t5e +r2n72+3e4

*+on 5275 t5e 63a7= 2n= 2n t524 Co*rt@4 o+2n2on4 f3o"

STATEMENT OF FACTS

0" T5e *n$er429ne$


3/107

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

6e7a*4e 2t 24 not +re4ente$ 2n +ro+er for, a4 re8*2re$ 6; t5e4e r*3e4 or an; 3o7a3 r*3e4 or +ra7t27e4"G

NRCP eF3e 4taff ref*42n9 to f23e +a+er4 4*6,2tte$ for f232n9

+3ea4e 7on42$er:

S*332#an #" E295t5 *$272a3 D24t" Co*rt In an$ For Co*nt; of C3ar= %.& P"$ 0.(% 000 Ne#"

0(-'


4/107


5/107

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

a$$re44 24 not e+3a2ne$ 2n t5e $o7*,ent4 6efore t524 7o*rt" Ne#ert5e3e44 t5e 4tate@4 a44ert2on t5at

+et2t2oner@4 a++327at2on a4 $en2e$ 24 2n7orre7t" T5e 5an$r2tten notat2on on +et2t2oner@4 *nf23e$

a++327at2on 73ear3; $oe4 not 7on4t2t*te a +ro+er *$272a3 $24+o42t2on of t5at a++327at2on" F*rt5er t5e

a7t2on of t5e 73er= of t5e $24tr27t 7o*rt 2n ret*rn2n9 +et2t2oner@4 a++327at2on an$ 72#23 7o,+3a2nt to 52,

*nf23e$ 24 2n $2re7t #2o3at2on of t524 7o*rt@4 2n4tr*7t2on4 to t5e 73er= of t5e $24tr27t 7o*rt 2n 152t,an #"

152t,an 0./ Ne#" %&% /&. P"$ 0(


6/107


7/107

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

t524 ,2n24ter2a3 $*t;" H*e6ner #" State 0.' Ne#" (/ ((. /0. P"$ 0.% 000


8/107


9/107


10/107


11/107

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

C2t; Attorne; Pa, Ro6ert4: 15at 4+e72f27 2nfor,at2on $2$ ;o* a4= of Mr" Co*9532n

T5o,a4 Front2no: I$ent2f27at2on 524 na,e 62rt5 $ate 4o72a3 4e7*r2t; n*,6er"

C2t; Attorne; Pa, Ro6ert4: An$ $2$ 5e +ro#2$e an; of t5at 2nfor,at2on to ;o*T5o,a4 Front2no: No 5e $2$ not"

C2t; Attorne; Pa, Ro6ert4: Ba4e$ *+on 524 *n2332n9ne44 to +ro#2$e t5at 2nfor,at2on $2$ ;o* ta=e

an; f*rt5er a7t2onT5o,a4 Front2no: Ye4 e 7a33e$ t5e +o327e t5e Reno S+ar=4 In$2an Co3on; Tr26a3 Po327e

De+art,ent" T5e; *4*a33; arr2#e 2t52n ten ,2n*te4 I 6e32e#e ,; 4tate,ent ref3e7t4 2t a4 3e44 t5an

t5at"

Hoe#er 2t a4 not 3on9 6efore Front2no 7ontra$27te$ t5at te4t2,on; 6e7o,2n9

*n7o,forta63e 2t5 Co*9532n@4 32ne of 8*e4t2on2n9"

'" Here 24 an atte,+t at ,a=2n9 a tran47r2+t 42n7e t5e RMC 75o4e not to +re+are one an$ forar$ 2t

on to t5e D24tr27t Co*rt 2n t5e A++ea3


12/107


13/107

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

te4t2,on; offere$ t5at t5e 7ontent4 of Co*9532n@4 45o++2n9 6a9 fro, t5e /("/ ort5 of 2te,4 +a2$

for $2$ or $2$ not 2n73*$e an o+ene$ an$ or 5a3f f*33 +a7=a9e of t5o4e #er; D*ra7t Co*95 Me3t4)"

To t5e etent t5at RMC *$9e Hoar$ ref*4e$ to 3et Co*9532n te4t2f; on 524 on 6e5a3f at tr2a3

4*75 an *tter +a*72t; of e#2$en7e to 4*++ort t5e a33e9at2on4 7o,62ne$ 2t5 t5e ,;r2a$ 2n4tan7e4

5ere t5e te4t2,on; of 1a3?Mart@4 Front2no an$ t5at of RSIC Po327e Off27er4 Crafor$ an$

Bra*nort5 24 +art27*3ar3; tro*632n9 e4+e72a33; to t5e etent t5at t5e C2t; of Reno an$ t5e Reno

M*n272+a3 Co*rt ar9*a63; 5a#e a #e4te$ 2ntere4t 2n 32,2t2n9 t5e 7o4t4 a44o72ate$ 2t5 +ro#2$2n9

$efen4e 7o*n4e3 to 2n$29ent +art2e4


14/107

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

item rung up by the cashier and off the top of his head know that none of those items bore a UPC

with the same number as the Duract Cough Melts Frontino alleged Coughlin consumed while

shopping?...F*rt5er Front2no@4 te4t2,on; a6o*t 5o 5e +er4ona33; 2tne44e$ Co*9532n 7on4*,e

t5e 7o*95 $ro+4 523e 45o++2n9G 24 2n7on424tent 2t5 524 te4t2,on; t5at 1a3?Mart +o327; $2$ not

+er,2t Front2no to fo33o Co*9532n 2nto t5e re4troo, at 1a3?Mart an$ t5at t5erefore Front2no 3a7=

a 6a424 for ,a=2n9 f*rt5er atte,+t4 to 2n#e4t29ate an; 4*4+272on 5e 5a$ 2t5 re4+e7t to t5e D*ra7t

Co*95 Me3t4 t5erefore 3ea#2n9 1a3?Mart an$ Front2no to 52n9e t5e2r 5o+e4 of 3e#era92n9 t5e RSIC

Po327e to 7on$*7t an *n3af*3 4ear75 of Co*9532n" To t5e etent t5at Front2no a$,2tte$ ne2t5er 5e

or an;one 1a3?Mart ,a; 5a#e 4o*95t to te4t2f; at tr2a3 7o*3$ 5ear 5at a4 4a2$ 6eteen Co*9532n

an$ t5e 7a452er Front2no@4 #anta9e +o2nt $oe4 not ,eet t5e 2n t5e +er4on@4 +re4en7eG 4tan$ar$

re8*2re$ 6; NRS 0'0"0-


15/107

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

Ha3ett?Ste#en4 an$ 2n8*2re$ a4 to t5e a#a23a6232t; of 4*75 2tne44 4tate,ent4 +o327e re+ort4 or an;

ot5er ,ater2a34 fro, 1a3?Mart t5e RSIC or an;one e34e an$ a4 to3$ 6; Ha3ett?Ste#en4 t5at t5e

C2t; Attorne;@4 Off27e 5a$ not an$ o*3$ not re7e2#e 4*75 ,ater2a34 *nt23 after t5e arra29n,ent 2n

t524 ,atter 5275 a4 4et for 4o,e (. $a;4 after t5e arre4t


16/107


17/107


18/107

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

na,e on t5e :2tne44 4tan$ at tr2a3 :a4 3eft to t5e $*62o*4 at 6e4t a33e9at2on t5at 5e 5a$ to ,a=e an

arre4t 6e7a*4e Co*9532n fa23e$ to +ro#2$e 524 $r2#er@4 327en4e< t524 a44ert2on :a4 $*62o*4 at 6e4t an$

fra*$*3ent +o327e ,247on$*7t $one *n$er 7o3or of 4tate 3a: 6e4t 7on42$er2n9 t524 o77*rre$ at a reta23

+ro+ert; o:ne$ 6; t5e 4a,e ent2t; t5e Reno S+ar=4 In$2an Co3on; t5at o:n4 an$ r*n4 t5e RSIC

+o327e for7e an$ :5275 +artner4 :2t5 an$ rent4 to 3an$ on :5275 t524 1a3?Mart 42t4 to 2t4 6*42ne44

+artner 1a3?Mart 7on42$er2n9 t5at t5e 2nterro9at2on roo, #2$eo4 +ro+o*n$e 6; t5e C2t; of Reno

2t4e3f an$ f23,e$ 6; 1a3?Mart 73ear3; 45o: Off27er Cra:for 6e2n9 5an$e$ Co*9532n@4 $r2#er@4

327en4e 6; Co*9532n an$ Cra:for$@4 :r2tten re+ort 5a4 2n Cra:for$@4 o:n 5an$:r2t2n9 t5e ea7t

$r2#er@4 327en4e n*,6er 6e3on92n9 to Co*9532n on t5e 4*4+e7t4 2nfor,at2onG +ort2on of t5e re+ort

2n a$$2t2on to ot5er 2nfor,at2on ta=en $2re7t$3; off of t5e $r2#er@4 327en4e Co*9532n +ro#2$e$ to

Cra:for$)" F*rt5er Co*9532n@4 atte,+t4 to o6ta2n t5e $24+at75 7a334 an$ re7or$4 an$ an; %00 7a334

,a$e 6; 1a3?Mart :5ere ,et :2t5 7ontra$27tor; re4+on4e4 an$ o6f*47at2on" Nonet5e3e44 *+on

2nfor,at2on an$ 6e32ef 4*75 re7or$4 :o*3$ 45o: :5at t5e 2nterro9at2on roo, #2$eo 45o:4 2e

Off27er Cra:for$ *42n9 524 ra$2o to 7a33 2nto $24+at75 an$ r*n a 75e7= for +r2or4 on Co*9532n

*t2322n9 Co*9532n@4 $r2#er4 327en4e n*,6er" In$ee$ t5e NCIS re+ort4 an$ re7or$4 32=e3; are

re8*2re$ to 45o: :5en 4*75 a re+ort :a4 r*n an$ 6; :5o, an$ Off27er Cra:for$@4 4*64e8*ent

,2n72n9 a44ert2on on t5e :2tne44 4tan$ t5at t5e 1a45oe Co*nt; Ba23 +ro#2$e$ 52, Co*9532n@4

$r2#er@4 327en4e n*,6er 24 not on3; 7o*nter to +r2#a7; 3a:4 an$ 1a45oe Co*nt; Ba23 +o327; an$

+ro7e$*re 2t 24 a34o 63atant3; fa34e an$ a +at5et27 atte,+t to 9a,e t5e 4;4te, *n$er 7o3or of 4tate

3a:" To t5e etent t5at C2t; of Reno De+*t; Pro4e7*tor Pa,e3a Ro6ert4 E48" :a4 2n +o44e442on of

t5e4e 2nterro9at2on roo, #2$eo4 an$ 7ont2n*e to fa7232tate Off27er Cra:for$@4 a++arent +er*r; or at

3ea4t 93ar2n9 ,24?re,e,6eran7eG 2t 45o*3$ ,2t29ate an; an9er or reta32at2on ,a$e a9a2n4t

Co*9532n for atta7529n a4 an e5262t to a +retr2a3 ,ot2on t5e #ar2o*4 3a: re#2e:4 re3ate$ to

- 0/>%& -



19/107

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

+ro4e7*tor2a3 ,247on$*7t t5at for,er +ro4e7*tor RMC *$9e Hoar$ 4ee,e$ to f2n$ 4o offen42#e

an$ off+*tt2n9"

A ,2n*te 6; ,2n*te 75rono3o9; re#ea34 t5at t5e /("/ re7e2+t a4 244*e$ at 0:0& on

Se+te,6er %t5 .00" T5e 0&"'& re7e2+t t5at 1a3?Mart 7reate$ to 4*++ort 2t4 #a3*at2on of t5e 2te,4

a33e9e$3; 7on4*,e$ 523e 45o++2n9 6*t not +a2$ for a4 7reate$ 4o,e ten ,2n*te4 3ater at 0:&


20/107


21/107


22/107


23/107


24/107


25/107

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

tr2a34 to treat +at2ent4 2t5 7on$2t2on4 ran92n9 fro, f26ro,;a392a to PTSD an$ 24 2n73*$e$ 2n t5e 73a44

of ,e$27at2on4 =non a4 $244o72at2#e4 t5at Ca,+ra3 24 2n a4 e33" Ca,+ra3


26/107


27/107

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

arre4t at 1a3?Mart on Se+te,6er %t5 .00" Co*9532n@4 $o,e4t27 +artner of fo*r an$ 5a3f ;ear4 an$ 5e

+arte$ :a;4 4o,et2,e 2n *ne .00 an$ Co*9532n 6e7a,e a:are of 4e#era3 ,ont54 rent a33e9e$3;

6e2n9 o:n t5e2r ne*ro4*r9eon 3an$3or$ Dr" Matt5e: " Mer3244 MD 4o,et2,e 2n ,2$?A*9*4t"

1523e 2n a23 2n72$ent to t5e A*9*4t . t5 .00 arre4t


28/107


29/107

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

fro, 1a3?Mart Co*9532n ,a2nta2n4 t5at 5e 24 not 9*23t; of t5e a33e9e$ +et2t 3ar7en; fro, 1a3?Mart

an$ 24 7*rrent3; +*r4*2n9 an a++ea3 of t5e ,atter 2t5 t5e Ne#a$a S*+re,e Co*rt 2n 7a4e n*,6er

-.-(."

12t5 re4+e7t to ,atter4 5275 ,a; 6r2n9 2nto $o*6t t5e #a32$2t; of t5e 7on#27t2on 2n t5e tr2a3

7o*rt *$9,ent 2n RMC 00 CR -/..: In t5e a++ea3 to t5e D24tr27t Co*rt 2n CR00?.-& *$9e E332ot

*t232e$ a 72#23 4tat*te 2n e7*42n9 t5e RMC fro, 2t4 fa23*re to forar$ to t5e D24tr27t Co*rt a 7o+; of

t5e tran47r2+t of t5e a*$2o re7or$2n9 of t5e tr2a3 an$ to forar$ 4*75 to t5e D24tr27t Co*rt 2t52n ten

$a;4 of t5e f232n9 of t5e Not27e of A++ea3" F*rt5er Co*9532n ,a$e n*,ero*4 atte,+t4 to or$er 4*75 a

tran47r2+t an$ a4 t5arte$ 2n 524 atte,+t4 to $o 4o 6; t5e RMC@4 e+re44 $27tate t5at on3; t5e RMC@4

tran47r2+t2on24t of 75o27e Pa, Don9on2 o*3$ 6e +er,2tte$ to +erfro, t5e tran47r262n9 $*t2e4 an$

M4" Don9on2 5*n9 *+ t5e +5one on Co*9532n an$ ref*4e$ to +ro#2$e 2nfor,at2on re3ate$ to 5ere an$

2n 5at ,et5o$ of +a;,ent Co*9532n 7o*3$ +a; for t5e tran47r2+t an$ a44*re 2t4 +ro$*7t2on" F*rt5er

t5e RMC ref*4e$ to t2,e3; +ro#2$e Co*9532n a 7o+; of t5e a*$2o re7or$2n9 of t5e tr2a3 *nt23 e33 after

t5e $ea$32ne for f232n9 to332n9 ,ot2on4 or a Not27e of A++ea3 5a$ +a44e$ an$ f*rt5er t5e RMC fa23e$

to notate 2n t5e 7ert2f2e$ $o7=et


30/107

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

#2o3at2on4 :ere 244*e$ to Co*9532n *+on Co*9532n 6e2n9 to3$ 6; t5e Reno PD to 3ea#e t5e off27e of

o++o42n9 7o*n4e3 2n t5e e#27t2on fro, 524 for,er 3a: off27e


31/107


32/107


33/107


34/107


35/107


36/107


37/107


38/107


39/107


40/107

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

:-:%

Za75 Co*9532n: O6e7t2on 5ear4a;

Hon" B*$9e Hoar$: O#err*3e$W D2$ ;o* 5ear ,e S2r D2$ ;o* 5ear t5at

:':0'

Reno C2t; Attorne; Pa, Ro6ert4: D2$ ;o* a7t*a33; 7on$*7t t5e 47ann2n9 of t5o4e 2te,4 to 7reat t5etra2n2n9 re7e2+t

T5o,a4 Front2no: I $on@t 5a#e a 7a452er n*,6er 4o I 9o 2t5 t5e, an$ 4tan$ 2t5 t5e, an$ at75

523e t5e; 47an t5e 2te,4 to 7reate t5e re7e2+t %& -



41/107


42/107


43/107

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

Za75 Co*9532n: I 6e32e#e t5at a4 a $2fferent 8*e4t2on S2r" I $2$n@t a4= 2f 2t 5a$ ,; na,e I a4=e$ 2f 2t

5a$ aG na,e on 2t"

T5o,a4 Front2no: T5ere 24 ot5er +eo+3e@4 na,e4 on t5e $e4= 4o 75an7e4 ere ;e4 t5ere a4 anot5er+2e7e of +a+er 2t5 4o,e6o$;@4 na,e on 2t 4o,e5ere on t5e $e4="

Za75 Co*9532n: An$ ;o* 5a#e #2$eo of t524

T5o,a4 Front2no: T5ere 24 #2$eo of t5e off27e at t5at t2,e"Za75 Co*9532n: 1o*3$ 5a#e 5a#e t5o4e +2e7e4 of +a+er

T5o,a4 Front2no: T5ere@4 a 3ot of +a+er"""I $2$n@t =no 5275 one ;o* ante$ ,e to 6r2n9"

Za75 Co*9532n: So ;o* are 4a;2n9 *n$er oat5 t5at t5ere a4n@t a +2e7e of +a+er 2t5 ,; na,e or ana,e t5at 24 4*64tant2a33; 42,23ar to 2t 2n t5e off27e a3rea$; at t5e t2,e ;o* 6ro*95t ,e 2n t5ere"

T5o,a4 Front2no: 15en I 6ro*95t ;o* 2n o*r off27e t5ere a4 no +2e7e of +a+er 2t5 ;o*r na,e on 2t

or a na,e t5at a4 4*64tant2a33; 42,23ar"

Za75 Co*9532n: I 233 re,2n$ ;o* t5at ;o* are *n$er oat5 S2r"


44/107


45/107

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

;o* ante$ 2t5 t5e 7o*95 $ro+4 5oe#er I 4to++e$ ;o* for t5e 7an$; 6ar an$ t5at 24 5; I 4to++e$

;o*""" e re7o#ere$ ,ore a3,art ,er75an$24e 3ater" It $2$ not affe7t t5e 75ar9e 2n an; a;"

Za75 Co*9532n: an; ;o* 4a; t524 a4 a 7an$; 6ar"T5o,a4 Front2no: 2t a4 a 75o7o3ate"""4*64tan7e I 7an 92#e ;o* t5e ea7t 2te, t5e re7e2+t 45o*3$ 6e

on 7a,era #2e fro, 5en ;o* entere$ t5e AP off27e"

Za75 Co*9532n: an$ ;o* 4a; ;o* 4a ,e 4e3e7t 2tT5o,a4 Front2no: I $2$ 4ee ;o* 4e3e7t 2t"

Za75 Co*9532n: fro, 5ere

T5o,a4 Front2no: Fro, t5e 7an$; 243e"""fro,"""t5e 27e 7rea, en$7a+ an$ """t5e 7an$; 243e"Za75 Co*9532n: 24 2t a 7an$; 243e or an 27e 7rea, 243e

T5o,a4 Front2no: 2t4 t5e 4a,e"""+3a7e"""7* t5ere@4 t5e"""27e 7rea,""en$7a+"""t5at 5a4"""t5e 7an$; 243e"

Za75 Co*9532n: 7an ;o* 6e ,ore 4+e72f27 2n re9ar$ to 5ere 2n t5e 4tore ;o* 4a;"""

T5o,a4 Front2no: 5en ;o* enter t5e fa7232t; 2t4 a6o*t fo*r 243e4 4o a6o*t &. feet 5en ;o* +a44 t5ere924ter4 ;o* 5an9 a 3eft an$ t5at@4 5ere a33 of o*r 7an$;?t;+e 4*64tan7e4 are"

Za75 Co*9532n: T5e 7an$; 243e En$7a+ 1a4 2t on an en$7a+

T5o,a4 Front2no: Yo* 4e3e7te$ 2t fro, t5e 7an$; 243e t5ere4 t5e 27e 7rea, en$7a+ an$t5en t5e 7an$;

243e ;o* 4e3e7te$ 2t fro, t5e2r"Za75 Co*9532n: 15at@4 an en$7a+G

T5o,a4 Front2no: It 7a+4 off t5e en$ of an 243eZa75 Co*9532n: 4o ;o* are 4a;2n9 2t a4n@t 4e3e7te$ fro, t5e 7an$; 243e

T5o,a4 Front2no: %3' say"g t *as sele!ted fro' t(e !a"dy sle. T5ere@4 an 27e 7rea, en$7a+ 9o

3eft t5ere an$ t5en t5ere@4 t5e 7an$; 243e"

Hon" B*$9e Hoar$: A3r295t I 5a#e 5ear$ eno*95 7ont2n*e 2t5 anot5er 32ne of 8*e4t2on2n9 e 5a#e5ear$ re+eate$3; t5at 5e o64er#e$ ;o* 4e3e7t 2t fro, t5e 7an$; 243e 5275 24 a34o a44o72ate$ 2t5 t5e

27e 7rea, 243e" He 5a4 e+3a2ne$ to ;o* 5at an en$7a+ 24 3et@4 9o forar$"

Za75 Co*9532n: I 6e32e#e t524 24 #er; +ro6at2#e Yo*r Honor"Hon" B*$9e Hoar$: 15; 15at@4 t5e re3e#an7e"

Za75 Co*9532n: I 7an te33 ;o* S2r 6*t 2n or$er to

Hon" B*$9e Hoar$: I ant ;o* to e+3a2n 2t r295t no 5at@4 t5e re3e#an7eZa75 Co*9532n: 2n Or$er to 5a#e ,; a6232t; to 2,+ea75 524 te4t2,on; Yo*r Honor t5ere 24 4o,e

3eea; t5at o*3$ 6e 5e3+f*3 2n or$er to 5a#e 52, +*t 4o,e an4er4 on t5e re7or$

Hon" B*$9e Hoar$: 15at 24 t5e re3e#an7e of t524 32ne of 2n8*2r;"Za75 Co*9532n: I 7an te33 ;o* t5at"""

Hon" B*$9e Hoar$: If ;o* 7an@t 4tate 2t I a, 9o2n9 to ,a=e ;o* ,o#e on"

Za75 Co*9532n: I 7an 4tate 2t S2r 6*t to 4tate 2t 6efore I a, a63e to 9et 52, +*t 4o,e t52n94 on t5e

re7or$ 2,+a2r4 ,; a6232t; to 2,+ea75 52,"Hon" B*$9e Hoar$: F2n$2n9 no re3e#an7e to t524 32ne of 2n8*2r; I a, not 9o2n9 to a33o 2t"

Za75 Co*9532n: I 233 te33 ;o* t5e re3e#an7e""

Hon" B*$9e Hoar$: I a, not 9o2n9 to a33o 2t ,o#e onWZa75 Co*9532n: Yo*r Honor I $2$n@t 4a; I o*3$n@t re#ea3 t5e re3e#an7e""

Hon" B*$9e Hoar$: Mo#e OnW I 5a#e 92#en ;o* e#er; o++ort*n2t; to re#ea3 t5e re3e#an7e of t524 32ne

of 2n8*2r;"""Za75 Co*9532n: I $on@t 6e32e#e ;o* 5a#e Yo*r Honor"""

Hon" B*$9e Hoar$: Yo* fa23e$ to $o 2t"""I a, not 9o2n9 to a33o 2t

Za75 Co*9532n: I 233 4tate t5e re3e#an7e r295t no"

Hon" B*$9e Hoar$: No 2t4 too 3ate no ,o#e onW

- &>%& -



46/107


47/107


48/107


49/107


50/107

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

Hon" B*$9e Hoar$: Do ;o* =no an;t52n9 a6o*t t5at

T5o,a4 Front2no: I 7an 4+ea= to 4o,e of 2t fro, ,; 42$e te75n27a33; t5ere are to $2fferent

o+erat2on4 2n t5e 4tore t5ere are o+erat2on4 t5at $ea3 2t5 7*4to,er4 an$ t5ere 24 a44et +rote7t2on5275 e are te75n27a33; f2e3$ a4o72ate4 4o e 5a$ o*r on rea4on4 for ant2n9 to 5a#e ;o*

tre4+a44e$ fro, t5e fa7232t; 6a4e$ *+on o*r on $ea32n94 2t5 ;o* e ,ean2n9 ,; ,ana9er Ant5on;

R27=er4on Sean 5o 24 anot5er a442tant ,ana9er 5o 24 aare of ;o* A3o$2a 5o 24 anot5era4424tant ,ana9er 5o 429ne$ ;o*r tre4+a44 for,"

Za75 Co*9532n: 15en ;o* 4a; e are ;o* *4t referr2n9 to 2n$2#2$*a34 5o or= 2t5 ;o* 2n ;o*r

+art27*3ar AP 9ro*+ or 2n ;o*r +art27*3ar 1a3?Mart 4toreT5o,a4 Front2no: 1e $o 7o,,*n27ate 6eteen 4tore4 #2a e,a23 e a33 5a#e a77e44 to t5e 4a,e

$ata6a4e 7a33e$ a+24 A P I S"

Za75 Co*9532n: D2$ ;o* 7o,,*n27ate a6o*t ,e 2t5 ot5er 4tore4 or $2$ an;6o$; e34e at ;o*r 4tore

T5o,a4 Front2no: not to ,; =no =no3e$9e"C: 4o 2f t5e 1e4t 't5St" 1a3,art ,a$e a reta32ator; t5reat to t5e a77*4e$ 2n 7on*n7t2on 2t5 t5e

a77*4e$ +o2nt2n9 o*t t5at t5e ,ana9er4 5o 5a$ 6een t5ere for o#er ten ;ear4 4ee, to 7on#en2ent3;

for9etG t5e Ret*rn Po327; 5ene#er t5e n*,6er4 $on@t or= o*t 2n a a; t5at ,a=e4 t5e, 5a++; 24

t5at 4o,et52n9 ;o* o*3$ 5a#e ne#er 6een 2nfor,e$ ofReno C2t; Attorne; Pa, Ro6ert4: o6e7t2on re3e#an7e

Hon" B*$9e Hoar$: 5at 24 t5e re3e#an7e of t524Za75 Co*9532n: reta32ator; ,ot2#e 4+e72f27a33; for front2no or ot5er4 to 32e

T5o,a4 Front2no: I 9et +a2$"""

Hon" B*$9e Hoar$: Ho3$ on 5o3$ on" O6e7t2on 4*4ta2ne$" I 5a#e 92#en ;o* a 9reat $ea3 of 3at2t*$e"1e 5a#e 5a$ t524 2tne44 te4t2f; for o#er an 5o*r" 1e are 9o2n9 ot 9et t5ro*95 t524 tr2a3 ton92t5" T5e

7o*rt 5a4 a +ero9at2#e to e+e$2te t524 +ro7ee$2n9" In t5e f*t*re 2f ;o* 2n8*2re 2nto ,atter4 t5at are

not re3e#ant 5et5er or not t5e 72t; o6e7t4 I a, 9o2n9 to 7*t ;o* off"

Za75 Co*9532n: are ;o* aare t5at an a+ a44o72ate fro, 1a3,art ,a$e t5reat4 to t5e a77*4e$ t5at 5eo*3$ reta32ate a9a2n4t t5e; a77*4e$ for tr;2n9 to a44ert 524 r295t4 *n$er t5e Ret*rn Po327; t5at

1a3,art +*t4 fort5 to 7*4to,er4 6; 5a#2n9 52, 6anne$ fro, a33 a3,art4 an$ or ,a3272o*43;

+ro4e7*te$"T5o,a4 Front2no: no ot5er t5an +re#2o*4 to 7o*rt t5at 4e#era3 t52n94 ere ,ent2one$ 6efore t5at no"


51/107

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

Za75 Co*9532n: 4o r295t 5en t5e a77*4e 7a,e 2nto t5e 4tore ;o* 6e9an ta232n9 52, a4 an;oneat752n9 t5e f23,523e ;o* ere ta232n9T5o,a4 Front2no: noZa75 Co*9532n: 4o no6o$;@4 at752n9 t5e #2$eo>f23, 2t4 D*4t 6e2n9 re7or$e$T5o,a4 Front2no: 2t4 6e2n9 re7or$e$ 4o 2f 2t4 nee$ e 7an 9o 6a7= to 2t an$ a78*2re 2t 2n 3ar9er 4tore4

2t5 5295 t5eft t5at 5a#e +an t23t oo, 7a,era4"Hon" B*$9e Hoar$: 1e are D*4t 7on7erne$ 2t5 5at 24 9o2n9 on 5ereWT5o,a4 Front2no: o=a;"Za75 Co*9532n: ;o*r 4tore $oe4 not 5a#e +an t23t oo, 7a,era4T5o,a4 Front2no: no 42r"Za75 Co*9532n: $2$ ;o* at75 an; or atte,+t to at75 an; #2$eo of at75 ;o* a33e9e a4 $one 2t5t5e 7o*95 $ro+4T5o,a4 Front2no: no I $2$ not"Za75 Co*9532n: 5; notT5o,a4 Front2no: 6e7a*4e I 9enera33; $on@t 6a4e$ *+on 0&".. $o33ar +ett; 3ar7en;"Za75 Co*9532n: 6*t 2f ;o*r e,+3o;er 7o*3$ 9et 4*e$ for ron9f*3 arre4t or $a,9e to one4@

+rofe442ona3 re+*t2on 7o*3$nt 2t 6e7o,e 6299er 244*e t5n fo*rteen $o33ar +et2t 3ar7en;Hon" B*$9e Hoar$: 5e 5a4 an4ere$ t5e 8*e4t2on a4 to 5; 5e $2$ not re#2e t5e #2$eo ta+e:Za75 Co*9532n: an$ I a, a4=2n9 a fo33o *+ 8*e4t2on"Hon" B*$9e Hoar$: a4= anot5er 8*e4t2onWW I a, not 9o2n9 to a33o t5at 8*e4t2onW It 5a4no re3e#an7eWWW[X\Za75 Co*9532n: $o ;o* 5a#e an; $*t; to a47erta2n 5et5er or not t5e a33e9at2on ;o* ,a=e an$5et5er an; arre4t4 ;o* ,a=e are 6a4e$ 2n fa7t or 4*++orte$ 6; a$,244263e e#2$en7eT5o,a4 Front2no: a64o3*te3;",a!( Co$g(l"2 does t(at d$ty "ot "!l$de bot(er"g to loo- at t(e )deo9

T5o,a4 Front2no: 2t $2$ not 5a#e an;t52n9 to $o 2t5 6ot5er2n9 to 3oo= at t5e #2$eo 2t 5a$ to $o ,ore2t5 3oo=2n9 at t5e +3a7e4 5ere I =ne ;o* 5a$ 4e3e7te$ to 7on7ea3 2te,4 t5ere not 6e2n9 4+e72f27#2$eo e#2$en7e $on t5o4e 243e4 be!a$se *e do"3t (a)e a lot of sl& "!de"ts " t(e !a"dy sle+*al'art ele!ts "ot to &$t a )deo !a'era " t(at sles.

Za75 Co*9532n: 5ere $o ;o* a33e9e$ ea75 2te, a4 4+e72f27a33; 4e3e7te$ o+ene$ an$ t5en7on7ea3e$"T5o,a4 Front2no: T5e 7an$; 2te, ;o* 4e3e7te$ o+ene$ an$ 7on4*,e$ 523e a3=2n9 aro*n$ t5e4tore"Za75 Co*9532n: 2t a4 4e3e7te$ fro, an en$7a+ ;o* 4a2$ fro, t5e 7an$; 243eReno C2t; Attorne; Pa, Ro6ert4: o6De7t2on t5at a4 not 524 te4t2,on;"Hon" B*$9e Hoar$: t5at a4 not 524 te4t2,on;"Za75 Co*9532n: I@, 4orr; 7o*3$ I"Hon" B*$9e Hoar$: no 2t4 a4=e$ an$ an4ere$ 2f ;o* $on@t re,e,6er 2t ;o* 7an re#2e t5etran47r2+t 3ater" Go forar$ 2t5 anot5er 8*e4t2on"Za75 Co*9532n: o5 I@33 6e re#2e2n9 t5e tran47r2+t 3ater" 15ere a4 t5e 7an$; 6ar 4e3e7te$Reno C2t; Attorne; Pa, Ro6ert4: Yo*r Honor a4=e$ an$ an4ere$"T5o,a4 Front2no: 2n t5e 7an$; 243e"Za75 Co*9532n: 4o not on an en$7a+ 6*t 4o,e5ere 2t52n t5e 243e 2t4e3f"T5o,a4 Front2no: Ye4"Za75 Co*9532n: t5e 7an$; 6ar a4" 1a4 2t"""an$ 5at 2te, a4 t5at Yo* 4a; 2t a4 a 7an$; 6ar

- 0>%& -



52/107

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

T5o,a4 Front2no: It a4 a""";e4 2t a4 a 75o7o3ate 2te, I 6e32e#e"""I 6e32e#e 2t 5a$ 7ara,e3 2n42$e 2t I

$2$n@t 2n4+e7t 2t 2t 5a$ a3rea$; 6een 7on4*,e$" I 5a#e a +27t*re of t5e ra++er"

Za75 Co*9532n: an$ e 5a#e a n*,6er for 2t a n*,6er for t5e 6ar 7o$eT5o,a4 Front2no: t5e UPC ;e4 t5e 6ar 7o$e t5e n*,6er on t5e re7e2+t ;e4 t5at@4 7orre7t"

Za75 Co*9532n: o*3$ 2t 6e 7orre7t to 4a; on t5e re7e2+t 2t4 t5e t52r$ 2te, $on ,a9n$637r,3 n*,6er

..''-'0(/F: Ye4 t5at 24 7orre7t

C: o=a; 6*t ;o* $on@t =no 5at ea7t 2te, t5at 24"

F: U, 2t4 t5e 2te, t5at I 5a#e a +27t*re of r295t 5ere 6a4e$ *+on t5e UPC 7o$e *4*a33; I 7an $247ernt5e,

C: He@4 not enter2n9 t5at 2nto e#2$en7e at t524 +o2nt I $on@t 6e32e#e 4o I $on@t =no 2f t5e Co*rt@4

a77e+t2n9 2t

HK 2t 5a4n@t 6een offere$ ;et]7: t5e 6a232ff too= 2t fro, t5e 2tne44 an$ 9a#e 2t to t5e D*$9e I@33 note for t5e re7or$

f: no 5e 5a4 t5e re7e2+t

r: no 5e $2$n@t t5at@4 not t5e 7orre7t re7or$ t5e $o7*,ent t5e *$9e 5a4 24 E5262t 0"

C: H5 I@, 4orr; t5at a4 not t5e +27t*re ,; ,24ta=e I@, 4orr; ;o* ere ta3=2n9 a6o*t t5e +27t*re 4o2t 4ee,e$ ;o* ere

F: no 2t a4 not t5e +27t*re(:%:

&:..:.. +","

Za75 Co*9532n: o=a; 4o t524 a4 ta=en fro, 4o,e5ere 2n t5e ,2$$3e of t5e 7an$; 243e ;o*+er4ona33; 2tne44e$ t5at r295t ;o* D*4t te4t2f2e$ to t5at 7orre7t

T5o,a4 Front2no: t5at ;o* too= 2t fro, t5e 7an$; 243e ;e4 I 7o*3$n@t te33 ;o* 5o far $on ea7t3; I

$2$n@t +a7e 2t o*t"

Za75 Co*9532n: O5"""6*t o5"""o=a;""";o* 4a2$ ;o* +er4ona33; e;e 2tne44e$G t524T5o,a4 Front2no: ;e4 6*t I $on@t ta=e ,ea4*r2n9 ta+e4 afteror$4""""or"""

C:o=a; 6*t 9enera33; ;o* 7o*3$ 4a; r295t on t5e e$9e of t5e 243eG or 4o,e5ere 73o4er to 5a3f a;G"

So,et52n9 32=e t5at r295t Be7a*4e ;o*""";o* are te332n9 *4"""Hon" *$9e Hoar$: $o ;o* =no ea7t3; 5ere 2t a4 %& -



53/107


54/107


55/107


56/107


57/107

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

! o-ay a" dyo$ dd"3t 'a-e a"y state'e"t to t(e effe!dt t(at yo$ s(o$ld o"ly say 4%5 be!a$se

Mr. C$"""g(a' (ad "ot a!t$ally ret$r"ed fro' l$"!( yet9

F "o % dd "ot 'a-e t(at state'e"t.

C a"d f *e re)e*ed t(e ta&e t(at *o"3t be s(o*"9 T(e ta&e of t(s (ear"g9

r ob7e!to"+ % do"3t $"dersta"d t(e $esto"able

( % do"3t $"dersta"d et(er. S$sta"ed. As- a"ot(er $esto".C so *(ere dd yo$ see t(e !o$g( dro&s9 6o$ say yo$ sa* t(e' sele!ted " t(e &(ar'a!y sle9

F !orre!t

! t(e" at *(at &o"t dd yo$ see t(e'...*(ere yo$ &erso"ally *t"essed t(e' be"g o&e"ed9

F yo$ o&e"ed o"e te' " t(e !a"dy sle a"d ds!arded t(e &a!-age a"d yo$ o&e"ed t(e se!o"d

&a!-age " t(e soda sle a"d ds!arded t(e &a!-age.

C so *as t a !ase of o&e""g t(e &a!-age a"d ds!ard"g t rg(t a*ay9

F o" bot( !ases yo$ dd "ot o&e" t(e' bot( at t(e sa'e t'e. 6o$ o&e"ed o"e " t(e bas-et

ds!arded t(e &a!-age+ yo$ &rete"ded to blo* yo$r "ose *t( t(e &a&er to*el t(at *as abo)e

t(e garbage !a"+ &$lled do*" t(e &a&er to*el+ yo$ t(e" &$t t(e &a!-age "sde t(e &a&er to*el

a"d t(e" &la!ed bot( te's toget(er t(e &a&er to*el !o"!eal"g t(e !o$g( dro& &a!-age "to t(e

garbage !a".C a"d yo$ &erso"ally *t"essed t(s9

F % &erso"ally *t"essed t(s

! "ot o" )deo...b$t *t( yo$r o*" eyes9

F *t( 'y o*" eyes.

C (o* !lose *ere yo$9

F at t(at &o"t % *as sta"d"g o" t(e e"d!a& a"d yo$ *ere sta"d"g 7$st "sde t(e sle

! "d t(s *o$ld be t(e !a"dy sle9

F2 so (o* 'a"y feet a*ay *o$ld yo$ say yo$ *ere

f A fe* feet 'aybe...

! % do"3t -"o* *(at a fe* feet 'ea"s+ does t(at 'ea" less t(a" te" *o$ld yo$ say9

F def"tely less t(a" te" t *as &robably so'e*(ere aro$"d E.

! yo$ *ere t(ree feet a*ay+ yo$ *ere at t(e e"d!a& a"d t(e a!!$sed *as *(ere9

f % *as at t(e e"d!a& a"d *ere 7$st "sde t(e sle at t(e garbage !a". ?o$ld yo$ l-e...$(.

C a"d yo$ *ere"3t obs!$red " a"y *ay9

F "o % *as "ot

! yo$ *ere " &la" sg(t

f $(+ % *as (d"g+ % *as "ot sta"d"g "e8t to t(e garbage !a".

C o-ay+ so yo$ sad yo$ *ere "ot obs!$red a"d t(e" yo$ sad yo$ *ere (d"g

f 'y l"e of sg(t *as "ot obs!$red+ 'y body *as obs!$red fro' yo$r )so"

! o-ay+ a"d (o* s t(at &ossble *as t(ere so'e (ole " t(e sle yo$ &eered t(ro$g(

f t(eres+ t(eres t(e e"d!a&s t(at (a)e s(el)es so *(at *e *ll do s *e *ll et(er !ro$!( do*"

or *e *ll sta"d stall a"d loo- *(ere)er *e "eed to loo- t(ro$g( t(e ga& a"d *e get !lose

e"o$g( to t a"d t(e &ro&s " t(e s(el)es do"3t obs!$re o$r )so" at all a"d alls t(e &eo&le t(at

*ere really loo-"g for $s t(ey *o$ld see s o$r eyes+ b$t t(at3s f t(ey *ere really loo-"g for

$s.

C so t(ere3s "o &rod$!ts o" t(e s(el)es t(at *o$ld '&ede yo$r )e* of t(at9

F t(ere are &rod$!ts o" t(e s(el)es a"d t(ere are t'es *(e" t(ere are &rod$!ts t(at !o$ld

obs!$re o$r )so"+ (o*e)er+ *e do"3t !(oose t(ose sles...*e do"3t !(oose t(ose e"d!a&s to loo-

t(ro$g( as t obs!$res o$r )so"

- '>%& -



58/107


59/107


60/107


61/107

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

C So D*4t to 6e 73ear Yo*r Honor I 7an a4= Mr" Front2no a6o*t 5at 5e 5ear$ t5e Off27er 4a; 2n

re9ar$ to 5et5er or not t5e; ere 7on$2t2on2n9 arre4t *+on fa23*re to 7on4ent to""

r O6De7t2on 7a334 for 5ear4a;H If ;o* 7an 2f ;o* 7an"""+ro#2$e ,e 2t5 a 5ear4a; e7e+t2on n*,6er one an$ n*,6er to +ro#2$e

,e 2t5 a re3e#an7e a4 to 5; t5at@4 re3e#ant ;e4 a64o3*te3; 4o 9o forar$"

C I fee3 2t 24 re3e#ant Yo*r Honor 6e7a*4e t5e re4*3t4 of t5e 4ear75 t5e fr*2t of t5e +o24ono*4 treefa7tor 2n 5ea#23; 2n t5e Reno C2t; Attorne;@4 7a4e 2t5o*t t5at"""t5e2r 7a4e re4t4 on"""I $on@t =no

5at"" an$ 5et5er or not t5e4e 7o*95 $ro+4""

H So 6efore ;o* 9o on ;o*r ar9*,ent 24 t5e fr*2t"""I ta=e 2t"""5at are t5e fr*2t4 5ereC 1e33 2n t5e2r arre4t re+ort t5e; ,ent2on t5at t5e 4ear75 2n72$ent to arre4t ;2e3$e$ 4o,e 7o*95 $ro+4

not 7o*95 $ro+4 2n a 7onta2ner or 4o,e +a7=a92n9 6*t D*4t 4o,e 7o*95 $ro+4""an$"""

H So 2f ;o* ere 4*77e4f*3 an$ ;o* Got t5at t5ron o*t on 5at 6a424 o*3$ t5e 7a4e fa33

C 1e33 2t4""""H A4 fr*2t of t5e +o24ono*4 tree

C 1e33 I 6e32e#e t5e a7t*4 re*4 o*3$ 6e 3a7=2n9"""t5e +ro+ert; 2t4e3f"""t5e +5;427a3 e#2$en7e o*3$

not 6e t5ere to t5e etent 2t4 a33e9e$ to 6e +5;427a3 e#2$en7e t5at o*3$ not 6e a#a23a63e

H A3r295t I *n$er4tan$"""no 92#e ,e t5e re4+on4e to t5e 5ear4a; o6De7t2on47: I 6e32e#e one 24 t5at 2t4 a 4tate,ent a9a2n4t 2ntere4t to t5e etent t5at t524 1a3,art 24 rente$ o*t 6;

t5o4e Off27er@4 e,+3o;er4 to 1a3,art t5e +ro+ert; Mr" Front2no te4t2f2e$ ear32er t5at t5ere 24 a 73o4eor=2n9 re3at2on452+ 2t5 t5e4e In$2an Co3on; Po327e 4o ,*75 4o t5at t5e; are a63e to 42t an$ 5a#e

Do#2a3 7on#er4at2on an$ 3a*95ter for a++ro2,ate3; & ,2n*te4 +r2or to tr2a3" T5e; a33 ,a; +otent2a33;

fa7e a 92ant 32a6232t; for a 0%/( 7a*4e of a7t2on for a ron9f*3 arre4t a4 4*75 t5ere 24 a +o4426232t; t5att5e; are a7t2n9 2n 7on7ert an$ t5at an; 4tate,ent4 ,a$e 6; In$2an Co3on; Po327e are ne7e44ar232;

2,+*te$ to 1a3,art an$ t5erefore are a 4tate,ent a9a2n4t 2ntere4t"

HK O=a; a3r295t an; re4+on4e fro, t5e C2t;

R F2r4t of a33 Yo*r Honor Mr" Front2no te4t2f2e$ t5at 5e 2tne44e$ t5e $efen$ant I 6e32e#e 7on4*,e4o,e of t5e 7o*95 $ro+4 an$ re9ar$3e44 of 5et5er t5ere ere an; 7o*95 $ro+4 fo*n$ 2n 524 +o7=et

t(at t(at obser)ato"24 not ne9ate$"""e ,a; not 6e a63e to a47erta2n t5e #a3*e of t5e 7o*95 $ro+4

6e7a*4e e o*3$n@t 5a#e t5e +a7=a9e""" 2n a$$2t2on e#en 2f t5e 7o*95 $ro+4 an$ t5e e#2$en7e re3ate$to t5e 7o*95 $ro+4 a4 e73*$e$ t5at o*3$ not a++3; to t5e 7an$; 6ar or t5e 75o7o3ate 2te, t5at Mr"

Front2no referre$ to" Re9ar$2n9 t5e 5ear4a; e7e+t2on I $on@t 6e32e#e t5e fa7t t5at 5e ,a; 6e e#en

6e4t fr2en$4 2t5 one of t5e Off27er4 ,a=e4 or ,eet4 t5e 5ear4a; o6De7t2on 2t $oe4n@t ,eet an; ofe7e+t2on4 *n$er t5e 5ear4a; r*3e t5ere 24 no 4*75 t52n9 a4 fear of 32a6232t; an$ t5e Off27er 24 not a

32t29ant 2n t524 ,atter ,a;6e a f*t*re 32t29ant at 4o,e +o2tn 2t5 Mr" Co*9532n 2t 7erta2n3; 24 not t5e

7a4e to$a;"

C: Yo*r HonorH No not52n9 f*rt5er" I 5a#en@t fo*n$ an; 5ear4a; o6De7t2on nor $o I f2n$ t524 +art27*3ar3; re3e#ant

2t4 4*4ta2ne$ a4= anot5er 8*e4t2on"

C2 Alrg(t+ 6o$r 0o"or+ a"d % *ll 7$st &reser)e t(e ob7e!to" for t(e re!ord t(at ts "ot be"g

offered to &ro)e t(e tr$t( of t(e 'atter asserted+ t(at t does (ae "d!a of relablty g)e" t(e

!o"te'&ora"eo$s "at$re of t(e state'e"t+ &art!$larly *t( regard to t be"g a &erfor'at)e

$ttera"!e.

BO(+ 'a"+ dd t(at (alf !o$rt s(ot at t(e b$DDer &ss 1$dge 0o*ard off+ to t(e &o"t *(ere (e

(as to bas( so'eo"e 7$st for (a)"g t(e "d$stry to le)erage te!("ology%& -



62/107

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

H: A4= anot5er 8*e4t2onW I 9a#e ;o* e#er; o++ort*n2t; to 92#e ,e ;o*r ar9*,ent" 15at ;o* 5a#e

$one no 2t 4a; e33 ;o* =no 5at I 5a#e 9one to ,; 32tt3e 3a+to+ an$ I@#e 9ot 4o,e a$$2t2ona3

2nfor,at2on t5at I ant to +re4ent""" an$ I 5a#e re+eate$3; 2n$27ate$ to ;o*: one 45ot I ,a=e t5er*32n9 e ,o#e on""""an$ ONCE AGAIN ;o*@#e 9one 6e52n$ ,; r*32n9 an$ a$$e$ a$$2t2ona3

2nfor,at2on" A4= t5e 8*e4t2on S2rW

C:O-ay+ a"d also 7$st to t(e e8te"t t(at !o''a"ds are "ot (earsay. Mr" Front2no $2$ ;o* ,a=ean; 4tate,ent4 to t5e a77*4e$ t5at ;o* o*3$ 6ar9a2n 2t5 t5e a77*4e$ an$ t5at 2f 5e 9a#e ;o* 6a7=

t524 or t5at 2te, ;o* o*3$ 3et 52, 9o"""

f No I $2$ not"C Do ;o* e#er ,a=e 4*75 4tate,ent4

F I 6e32e#e ;o* are referr2n9 to t5e fa7t t5at after I 5a$ a3rea$; 5a$ t5e +o327e t5ere I 5a$ 4a2$ t5at 5a$

;o* 7oo+erate$ t5en t5e; o*3$ not 5a#e 6een 2n#o3#e$" Per +o327; e 7o*3$ 5a#e a33oe$ ;o*

3ea#e t5e fa7232t; *+on +*tt2n9 ;o*r 2nfor,at2on 2nto o*r 4;4te,"

B:EG2G &.'. Note Fro"t"o $ses t(e *ord !(o!e 4allo*ed yo$ to lea)e+ *(!( !learly

"d!ates t(e a!!$sed "ot be"g t(ere e"trely )ol$"tarly ANOT0ER KUEST%ONLMJLMJLM:

C O=a; ear32er $2$ ;o* te4t2f; t5at ;o* =ne: a 6o of t5at 4a,e UPC for t5o4e 7o*95 $ro+4 :a4

NOT on t5e /.re!e&t9F % *at!(ed yo$r tra"sa!to" a"d % dd "ot see t(e de"t!al !o$g( dro&s r$"g $& o" yo$rre!e&t..

! 6o$ watchedt(e tra"sa!to"...yo$ *ere able to see t !losely e"o$g(...yet yo$ *ere"3t able to

heara"y of t(e tra"sa!to"9

F T(at s !orre!t9

C =o yo$ (a)e so'e (ear"g &roble's9

F No+ % do "ot.

C Do ;o* 5a#esuper powerful #242onF I 7an 42,+3; 4ee fart5er t5an I 7an 5ear +eo+3e 4+ea=2n9 at nor,a3 #o27e"C A6o*t 5o: far :5ere ;o* fro, t5e +o2nt of r2n92n9 *+ t5e 2te,4 on t5e /. re7e2+tF U5"""+ro6a63; a6o*t t52rt feet 6e52n$ ;o*""""6e52n$ t5e re924ter4"""7 O=a; 4o :5ere ;o*"""":5en ;o* 4a; 6e52n$ t5e re924ter4 24 t5at""":o*3$ t5at +*t ;o* 73o4er to t5e6a7= of t5e 4tore or t5e front of t5e 4toreF U,"""t5e front of t5e 4tore""7 Near t5e entran7e"""f U5"""no 6; 6a7= of t5e 4tore>front of t5e 4tore ;o*r ta3=2n9 a6o*t front to 6a7= 2t4 not re3e#ant to t5ee2t4"C I 9*e44 2t4"""24 2t fa2r to 4a; t5e front of t5e 4tore 24 :5ere t5e e2t4 areF Ye4"C Entran7e an$ t5e e2t4 at t5e front of t5e 4tore>f Ye4"C O=a; 4o 7an ;o* 92#e ,e 4o,e 2n$27at2on :5ere ;o* :ere 3o7ate$ at t5e t2,e t5e 2te,4 :ere6e2n9 r*n9 *+F at t5e t2,e ;o* :ere 4+e72f27a33; 6e2n9 r*n9 *+ I :a4 4tan$2n9 2n :o,en@4 a++are3 :5275 24$2re7t3; 6e52n$ t5e re924ter4 2t4 a6o*t t:ent; feet a:a; fro, t5e re924ter4"""7 Yo* 4a2$ ;o* :ere a6o*t t52rt; feet a:a;f Corre7t I :a4 2n :o,en@4 a++are3"C So"""6*t t5en ;o* 4a2$ t:ent; feet

- ->%& -



66/107


67/107


68/107


69/107


70/107


71/107

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

F I o*3$ 5a#e to 3oo="" I $on@t re7a33 5o ,an; ere 2n ea75 +a7=a9e"""T5e; ere atta75e$"""t5e;

ere 2n 6324ter +a7=4

7" Not eno*95 to ,a=e to +a7=a9e4F No not eno*95 to ,a=e to +a7=a9e4

C 1e33 t5en 5o are ;o* a63e to a44ert t5at t*oere 4to3en

f Be7a*4e ;o* o+ene$ to an$ ;o* 7on7ea3e$ t5e 7ontent4 of to"C An$ ;o*r 4tore@4 +o327; 24"""5at Yo* 4a2$ 4o,et52n9 a6o*t a 6at5rooo, an$ not 6e2n9 a63e to"""

5 A4=e$ an$ an4ere$"""9o on

7 O=a; 4o 24 2t ;o*r 4tore@4 +o327; t5at 2f ;o* aren@t a63e to re7o#er t5e 2te,4 ;o* 4t233 a44ert an$affe7t an arre4t 75ar92n9 t5at t5e 2te,4 ere 4to3en

F 1233 ;o* a4= t5e 8*e4t2on a9a2n

C Yea5" Ho $o ;o* =no to +a7=a9e4 ere 4to3en 2f ;o* on3; re7o#ere$ +art of one

F I ,a$e an a44*,+t2on t5at 6ot5 ere 4to3en"C An$ $2$ ;o* 5a#e an; e#2$en7e of t5at a44*,+t2on

F 6o$ sele!ted a"d !o"!ealed t(e !o"te"ts of t*o &a!-ages.."t(at *as 'y ass$'&to".T5e

+a7=a9e4 ere t5ron 2n t5e 9ar6a9e 5275 o*3$ ren$er *4 *na63e to a77o*nt for t5e,"""

%& -



72/107


73/107


74/107

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

Crafor$ 24 ear2n9 a $ar= 7o3ore$ 4o*+ 2t5 t5e $ar=?7o3ore$ 452rt an$ a 4ett2n9 5ere t5e $efen$ant

o*3$ 6e 42tt2n9

Hoar$ t5e re7or$ 233 ref3e7t t5at Crafor$ 2$ent2f2e$ Mr" Co*9532nRo6ert4 5en ;o* f2r4t ,a=e 7onta7t 2t5 Mr" Co*9532n 5a$ ;o* on a4 5e 4tan$2n9 42tt2n9 or 5at

Crafor$ 5e a4 42tt2n9 $on on a 6en75

Ro6ert4 o=a; an$ 2t a4 an; =2n$ 5an$7*ff4 re4tra2nt4Ro6ert4

ro6ert4 an$ 5en ;o* a++roa75 t5e 4*4+e7t ;o* 5a#e to a4= 52, an; 8*e4t2on4 or 5a#e a $247*442on

2t5 52,7rafor$ I $2$ a4= 52, 8*e4t2on4

Ro6ert4 an$ 5at 8*e4t2on4 45o*3$ ;o* a4= 52,

Crafor$ I a$#24e$ 52, 5; I a4 t5ere t5at 1a3,art 5a$ 7a33e$ 6e7a*4e t5e; 4*4+e7te$ 5e 5a$ ta=en

+ro+ert; I t5en to3$ 52, t5at 2t a4 ,; $e7242on to e2t5er r2te *+ t5e 72tat2on or ta=e 52, to a23 an$t5at I o*3$ +refer to r2te 52, a 72tat2on 4o I $2$n@t a, *+ o*r Bo*3e#ar$ 2t5 *nne7e44ar; +eo+3e

9o2n9 *+ t5ere


75/107

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

Crafor$ ;e4 2t 24

Ro6ert4 an$ 24 2t ro*t2ne for ;o* to 7onf2r, a44*,2n9 t5e; 7on4ent to Pat Donna ,a=e 4*re t5at t5e;

$on@t 5a#e an; ea+on4Crafor$ ;e4 2t 24

Ro6ert4 an$ t5at@4 5at ;o* $o 2t5 t524 +art27*3ar 4*4+e7t

Crafor$ 7orre7t3; to3$ ,e not to 9o 2nto 524 +o7=et4 6*t t5at I 7o*3$ 4ear75 for ea+on4 4o I 4ear75t5e o*ter 73ot52n9 of 524 +o7=et4 to ,a=e 4*re 5e $2$n@t 5a#e an; ea+on4 5e $2$ not 5a#e ea+on4

Ro6ert4 4o 5e 32,2te$ 524 7on4ent

Crafor$ ;e4 5e $2$Ro6ert4 an; re4+e7t to t5at 32,2tat2on

Crafor$ ;e4 ,a@a,

Ro6ert4 $2$ t5at 5a++en 6efore or after ;o* ere a4=2n9 52, 8*e4t2on4 7on7ern2n9 t5e 2nfor,at2on

;o* nee$e$ to f233 o*t t5e 72tat2on


76/107

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

DERISIVE TONE BY KING TO COUGHLIN THAT COUGHLIN IS NO

LONGER AN ATTORNEY"""KING ALSO HAS MADE A GREAT DEAL OF FALSE ANDMISLEADING STATEMENT TO AND ABOUT COUGHLIN AND REFUSED TO PROVIDE

COUGHLIN COPIES OF MOST OF 1HAT 1AS PROVIDED TO KING INCIDENT TO THE

VARIOUS GRIEVANCES FILED BY RICHARG G" HILL ES!" AND UDGE DOROTHYNASH HOLMES %& -



77/107

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

Hoar$ 3et ,e 4a; an$ t524 24 for ;o*r 6enef2t on7e a9a2n e 233 5a#e a 5ear2n9 2n re9ar$ to 7ontent

on7e t524 +ro7ee$2n9 24 7on73*$e$ 4o e#er; t2,e ;o* en9a9e 2n one of t5e4e *n+rofe442ona3 a7t4 I@,

=ee+2n9 7o*nt an$ e 233 a$$re44 t5e, at t5e en$ of t524 tr2a3 o"e t("g (as "ot("g to do *t( t(e

ot(erI 233 ,a=e a 4e+arate an$ 2n$e+en$ent $e7242on 2n re9ar$ to 9*23t or 2nno7en7e 6*t I 5a#e

a3rea$; ,a$e a f2n$2n9 2n re9ar$ to 7onte,+t 2t5 t5at 9o a5ea$ an$ +ro7ee$

Co*9532n an$ I@33 enter an o6e7t2on 2t5 re9ar$ to t5e fa7t t5at"""Hoar$% do"3t *a"t to (ear a"yt("g fro' yo$ at t(s &o"t t'eLQROJJRQOJMNCo*9532n at t5e +o4426232t; of a23 t2,e e24t I 5a#e a r295t to 7o*n4e3


78/107

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

15ene#er an; +er4on 24 arre4te$ 6; a +r2#ate +er4on a4 +ro#2$e$ 2n NRS 0'0"0- for

an; #2o3at2on of a 7o*nt; 72t; or ton or$2nan7e or 4tate 3a 5275 24 +*n245a63e a4 a

,24$e,eanor s$!( &erso" arrested 'ay be ss$ed a 'sde'ea"or !tato" by a

&ea!e off!er " le$ of be"g ''edately ta-e" before a 'agstrate by t(e &ea!e

off!er f:

0" T(e &erso" arrested f$r"s(es satsfa!tory e)de"!e of de"ttyK an$

" T5e +ea7e off27er 5a4 reaso"able gro$"dsto 6e32e#e t5at t5e +er4on arre4te$ 233

=ee+ a r2tten +ro,24e to a++ear 2n 7o*rt"

NRS 171.177: For' a"d !o"te"ts of !tato"2 ?(e" ss$ed after arrest by &r)ate

&erso".

0" In t5o4e 2n4tan7e4 $e47r26e$ 2n NRS 0'0"0'' t5e +ea7e off27er 4*,,one$ after t5earre4t 45a33 +re+are a ,24$e,eanor 72tat2on ,an*a33; or e3e7tron27a33; 2n t5e for, of a

7o,+3a2nt 244*2n9 2n t5e na,e of T5e State of Ne#a$a or 2n t5e na,e of t5e

re4+e7t2#e 7o*nt; 72t; or ton an$ 7onta2n2n9:


79/107


80/107

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

Ro6ert4 an$ 5at 24 t5e rat2ona3e for $o2n9 t5at

Crafor$ to +rote7t t5e off27er 2t@4 a 4afet; 244*e fro, 52, 9ett2n9 2nto t5e +atro3 7ar or +rote7t2n9

52,4e3f 2n 7a4e 5e 5a4 an; ea+on4 4o 5e $oe4n@t 5*rt an off27er or 52,4e3f


81/107

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

Co*9532n I $on@t a7=no3e$9e t5at 75ara7ter2at2on a4 7orre7t"

Ro6ert4 Of7" Crafor$ after 5e t5re 52,4e3f aro*n$ 2n t5e 6a7= of ;o*r +atro3 7ar a4 t5ere an;

t52n9 e34e t5at 5a++en4 6efore ;o* 9ot t5e Da23 2n#o3#2n9 t5e 4*4+e7tCrafor$ to 4tate,ent4 5e ,a$e a6o*t *4 tr;2n9 to ta=e a$#anta9e of t5e or=2n9 ,an@4 $o33ar 2n

re7on4tr*7t2on an$ 7o3on; t52n=4 t5at nat*re D*4t 4tate,ent4

Ro6ert4 I 5a#e no f*rt5er 8*e4t2on4 for t524 2tne44Hoar$ Mr" Co*9532n 7ro44 ea,2nat2on of Of7" Crafor$

Co*9532n Of7" Crafor$ ;o* rea32e ;o*@re *n$er oat5 7enter

Crafor$ ;e4Co*9532n 4o ere ;o* 3;2n9 5en ;o* 4a2$ ;o* offere$ to +*t a 4eat 6e3t on t5e a77*4e$

Crafor$ No 42r"

Co*9532n Yo* eren@t 3;2n9

Crafor$ No 42rCo*9532n $2$ t5e a77*4e$ +o2nt o*t to ;o* $*r2n9 t5e freeare 7ar r2$e to o*r on (% at 4+ee$4 2n

e7e44 of . ,23e4 an 5o*r t5at 2t a4 ne9329ent for ;o* an$ ;o*r +artner to fa23 to 6ot5 +*t a 4eat6e3t

on t5e a77*4e$ or offer to an$ f*rt5er ne9329en7e a4 e5262te$ 2n ;o*r fa23*re to $o 4o on7e t5e

a77*4e$ re8*e4te$ ;o* $o 2f 4o +*t a 4eat6e3t on t5e a77*4e$Crafor$ 4orr; I@, 7onf*4e$ on t5e 8*e4t2on

Ro6ert4 t5at@4 a 7o,+3e 8*e4t2onHoar$ 24 a 7o,+3e 8*e4t2on 24 $one 2t re+eate$3;

Co*9532n $o ;o* re7a33 t5e a77*4e$ ,a=2n9 4tate,ent4 to ;o* $*r2n9 t5e 7ar r2$e to +ar

Crafor$ ;e4terCo*9532n to t5e 7ar r295t aren@t 73*e$ a tr2+ on H295a; (% 2n e7e44 of . ,23e4 an 5o*r

Crafor$ ;e4ter

Co*9532n $2$ 5e D*4t ,a=e 4tate,ent4 2t5 re9ar$ to ;o*r fa23*re to +ro#2$e a 4eat6e3t

Crafor$ ;e4terCo*9532n $2$ t5e a77*4e$ a4= 2f 5e 7o*3$ 5a#e a 4eat6e3t

Crafor$ No4a2r

5 on t5e freea; 2t5o*t a 4eat 6e3t

Crafor$ I 6e32e#e t5e a77*4e$ $2$ 4a; t5at

Co*9532n $2$ ;o* +er7e2#e t5e 3oan

Crafor$ No4a2r

- /0>%& -



82/107

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

Co*9532n 5; not

Crafor$ 6e7a*4e 2t@4 not +o327; to +*33 o#er on t5e 42$e of t5e freea; to +*t a 4eat6e3t on 2t5

Co*9532n o=a; $2$ ;o* ,a=e an; atte,+t4 to $o 4o after +*332n9 off freea;Hoar$ Mr" Co*9532n e 5a#e 6een $on t524 roa$ 6efore 6*t 5at 24 t5e re3e#an7e 2t5 re9ar$4

;o*r 9*23t or 2nno7en7e on t5e +ett; 3ar7en; of 5et5er or not ;o* are +ro#2$e$ 4eat6e3t

Co*9532n I o*3$ 32=e toHoar$ 42r $on@t 2nterr*+t 5o $oe4 t5at 9o ;o*r 9*23t or 2n4tan7e of t5e 452rt of +ett; t5eft

Co*9532n ,a;6e e 7o*3$ a4= M4" Ro6ert4 t5at 42n7e 45e@4 t5e one 5o a4=e$ t5e4e 8*e4t2on4 2n t5e

f2r4t +3a7e 45e@4 t5e one 5o 6ro*95t *+ t5e 4eat6e3t on t5e r2$e o#er an$ a33 t5e 4t*ff """an$ I $2$n@t 4ee;o* 4*a 4+onte o6e7t to 5er"""

Hoar$ M4" Ro6ert4

Ro6ert4 9r2n$2n9 o6e7t to t5e re3e#an7e t5e te4t2,on; I 324tene$ fro, 3o44 of 4tar Crafor$ $ea3t 2t5

t5e non7o,+32ant nat*re an$ att2t*$e of t5e $efen$ant Mr" Co*9532n a34o =non a4 t5e a77*4e$ an$ It52n= t5at 9oe4 to t5e 7re$26232t; an$ t5e 7on424ten7; 2n t5e te4t2,on; of Mr" Fran72ne 5o a34o

te4t2f2e$ a6o*t 524 3a7= of 7oo+erat2on an$ 7o,+32an7e

Hoar$ o=a; Co*9532n 92#e ;o* t5e 3a4t or$ 9o a5ea$

Co*9532n 5o ere ta3=2n9 a6o*t t5e o6e7t2on 5ere An$ t524 24 ;o*r o6e7t2on Yo*r HonorHoar$ o=a; t5e te4t2,on; 24 not re3e#ant 9o a5ea$ an$ 9o to anot5er 32ne of 8*e4t2on2n9

Co*9532n e33 2t a4 re3e#ant 5en M4" Ro6ert4 a4 a4=2n9 a6o*t 4eat6e3t4 an$ 4t*ff o=a; 42r ;o*4a2$ *n$er oat5 t5at t5e a77*4e$ =27=e$ t5e 2n$o

Crafor$ I 6e32e#e ;e4

Co*9532n ;o* believe4oCrafor$ 5e e2t5er""" T5e a77*4e$ e2t5er =27=e$ t5e 2n$o or 52t 2t 2t5 524 5ea$ I@, a44*,2n9

5e"""5e =27=e$ 2t

Co*9532n 52t 2t 2t5 524 5ea$ ;o* 4a;

Crafor$ one of t5e to ;e4Co*9532n 6*t ear32er ;o* 4a2$ ;o* ere 4*re t5at 5e =27=e$ t5e 2n$o ;o* 4at 5ere a4 a ,an 2t5 a

6a$9e *n$er oat5 an$ to3$ t524 7o*rt t5at ;o* =ne t5e a77*4e$ kicked a 2n$o an$ no no 2t@4 ;o*

believe... M295t@#e 6een 524 5ea$""",295ta 6een 524 foot""""I *4t $on@t =no""" 24 t5at tr*e

Cra*ford -"o* t *as (s foot

B5E525 &.'.4> Za75 Co*9532n

Za75 Co*9532n

Pro Per Attorne;

- %(>%& -



94/107

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25

26

27

28

%N=EP TO EP0%#%TS

0" E5262t 0: T5e to 1a3?Mart re7e2+t4 fro, Se+te,6er % t5 .00 one for /("/ re+re4ent2n9 2te,44e3e7te$ an$ +a2$ for an$ one for 0&"' re+re4ent2n9 2te,4 a33e9e$3; 7on4*,e$ 523e 45o++2n9 an$

not +a2$ for an$ +roof of t5e ea7t 2te, re+re4ente$ 6; t5e #ar2o*4 Un2#er4a3 Par7e3 Co$e4


95/107

EXHIBIT 1



96/107

UPC

No.:

732216300932

APPEARS

nOTE:

ON

THIS

RECE

IPT

FOR

$83.8

2

AS

WELL

AS

ON

THE

NEXT

RECEIPT

FOR

$14.72,

DESP

ITE

WAL-MART'

S

FRONTINO

AND

OFFICER

CRAWFORD

TEST

IFYING

UNDER

OATH

T

HAT

THAT

UPC

ONLY

APPEARED

ON

THE

RECEI

PT

FOR

$14.72

.


97/107

NOTE: this is a "receipt" for the allegedly stolen or consumed items

propounded in discovery by the Reno City Attorney


98/107

num Ice Cream Bar Nutrition Information | ShopWell

//D|/...20ie%20and%20firefox/7756713282%20magnum%20double%20caramel%20single%20ice%20cream%20bar.htm[6/11/2012 3:0

Scan foods to get your nutrition info at home or in the store!Get Free iPhone App

o thanks

Sign InSign Up

ShopWell

Browse FoodsDownload iPhone App

Magnum Ice Cream Bar

S, Double Caramel 3.38 ozShare on emailTweet

ngredients:

ce Cream: Milk, Cream, Sugar, Whey, Mono and Diglycerides, Locust Bean Gum, Vanilla Bean Specks,arrageenan, Natural Flavor, Annatto Extract (Color), Caramel Color, Belgian Milk Chocolate Coating: Suhocolate Liquor, Cocoa Butter, Milk, Milk Fat, PGPR (Emulsifier), Soy Lecithin (Emulsifier), Natural Flavoaramel Sauce: Water, Sugar, Corn Syrup, High Fructose Corn Syrup, Nonfat Milk Solids, Coconut Oil

Modified Corn Starch, Caramel Color, Salt, Mono & Diglycerides (Emulsifier), Carrageenan, Soybean Oilodium Citrate, Potassium Sorbate (Used to Protect Quality), Natural Flavor, Chocolatey Coating: Coconu

Oil, Sugar, Cocoa, Soy Lecithin (Emulsifier), Vanilla Extract.

ersonalize this Nutrition Label

Nutrition Facts

erving Size 1.0 bar (95 g)

ervings Per Container 1

http://www.shopwell.com/magnum-ice-cream-bar-s-double-

caramel/ice-cream-popsicles/p/7756713282

NOTE: the URL l sted above for th s page endsthe UPC of this "Magnum Double Caramel Ice Cr

Bar", 7756713282 (the "zero" at the start of

number on the $14.72 Wal-Mart receipt is

traditionally left off of UPC notations, as h

This frozen or refrigerated item would not be

found in "the candy isle" as Thomas Frontino

that he "personally eye witnessed"

Coughlin select it from "the candy is

and also swore that none of Wal-Mart'

legion of cameras captured any of tha

activity on video...


99/107

SiteMap

www.AmericanOTC.com

Valley

MedicalPharmacySince1986

Home

ShippingPolicy.

Professional

Associations

Refun

dPolicy.

View

ShoppingCart

NewS

earch:

AllItems

Allergy,

Cough,

Cold,

SoreThroat&

More

AdvilCold(2)

Afrin(12)

Airborne(8)

Alavert(5)

Alka-SeltzerCold(1)

AllegraOTC(8)

Allerest(1)

Altamist(1)

Ayr(12)

Banophen(2)

Benadryl(19)

Benzedrex(1)

Benzodent(2)

BlairexSaline

Solution(3)

BreatheClearNasal

Strips(4)

BreatheRight(17)

BrezNasalStrips(3)

Broncosan(3)

Capital

Pharmaceuticals(1)

Cepacol(22)

Cepastat(2)

Cetirizine(5)

Cheracol(1)

CherrySyrup(2)

C h e s t R u b ( 1 )

www.AmericanOTC.com>

Aller

gy,Cough,Cold,SoreThroat&

More>

Duract>

DuractMax

StrengthCoughCherry

8Hour30mg12EaBuy3and

GetFreeShipping

$8.3

9

DuractMaxStre

ngthCoughCherry8Hour3

0mg12EaBuy3andGetFr

eeShipping

UPCNo.:7322163

00932Mfg.ItemNo.:221010DuractMaxStrengthCough8H

our30mg12Ea

CherryItemNo:

C4394672Ndc73221630093G

enericNameDextromethorpha

nHbr.Asper

California'sLawS

B514(Simitian),youmustbe

over18tobuythisproduct.T

hisRegulationof

Dextromethorpha

n-ContainingProductsprohibitsthesaleofproductscontainin

gdextromethorphanto

apersonundertheageof18inanover-the-countersale.TradeNameDuract

MaxStrengthCough

AdditionalDescription

Haveaquestion?

AddtoShoppingCart

url:

http://www.pr

estostore.com/store.p

hp?

seller=AmericanOTC&

pd=4593480

as

of

6/11

/2012

NOTE:

THE

UPC

IS

LISTED

IMMEDIATELY

BE

LOW

AND

MATCHES

THAT

FOUND

ON

BOTH

THE

RECEIPT

FOR

$14.72

AND

THE

RE

CEIPT

FOR

$83.82,

DESPITE

FRONTINO

AND

THE

RSIC

OFFICER

CRAWFORD

TESTIFYING

UNDER

OATH

THAT

THIS

UPC

ONLY

APPEARED

ON

T

HE

RECEIPT

FOR

$14.72

UPC

UPC

UPC

Shop!


100/107

EXHIBIT 2

EXHIBIT 2



101/107


102/107


103/107


104/107


105/107


106/107


107/107

6 18 12 0204 62337 60838 107 pages 12-18963 filed motion for leave to file opposition to scr 117...

Documents