53418359 a comparitive study of plastic money with reference to credit card debit card

54
INTRODUCTION Bankin g has evolve d a long way from the days of the medie val money lenders countin g coins on the bench to the present scenario, where it is hard to trace the trail of money from the beginning to the end. The trail starts right from the small saver leaving a few rupees in his local bank to the  billions of rupee loans raised by a syndicate banks and financial institutions, capable of financing projects in any country in the world. Still, these banking majors are heavily dependent upon their retail home base of savers and borrowers. Most of the bankers  began focusing on this retail market segment as global competition intensified in late seventies and early eighties. The debit card has emerged from the shadow of its older sibling, the credit card. Over the  past decade, debit card has grown from accounting for 274 million transactions in 1990 to 8.15 billion transactions in 2002, to challenge the credit card as the preferred payment card. As it stands, the debit card industry is a multi-billion dollar engine that helps drive  bank profits and point-of purchase consumer sales - but is also beginning to redefine traditional payment options in the business and government sectors, such as food stamps,  benefits, and payroll. The debit card has arrived and is here to stay. And ye t, though it re mains pois ed for gr owth, the debi t card has also reached a crossroads. A recent settlement has cost VISA and MasterCard approximately $3 billion, and has dr amat ical ly reduced the fe es they can cha rge for si gna ture-based deb it  purchases. The effects of the settlement reach into every layer of the industry - from rewards incentives, to mar ket ing progra ms, to fut ure fee arr ange ments, and future growth. Consumer preferences for PIN- or signature-based debit will certainly influence how things unfold, and whether either debit card option will suffer or bloom in the short, mid, or long term.

Upload: gurluv-singh-

Post on 08-Apr-2018

229 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: 53418359 a Comparitive Study of Plastic Money With Reference to Credit Card Debit Card

8/6/2019 53418359 a Comparitive Study of Plastic Money With Reference to Credit Card Debit Card

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/53418359-a-comparitive-study-of-plastic-money-with-reference-to-credit-card 1/54

INTRODUCTION

Banking has evolved a long way from the days of the medieval money lenders counting

coins on the bench to the present scenario, where it is hard to trace the trail of money

from the beginning to the end.

The trail starts right from the small saver leaving a few rupees in his local bank to the

billions of rupee loans raised by a syndicate banks and financial institutions, capable of

financing projects in any country in the world. Still, these banking majors are heavily

dependent upon their retail home base of savers and borrowers. Most of the bankers

began focusing on this retail market segment as global competition intensified in late

seventies and early eighties.

The debit card has emerged from the shadow of its older sibling, the credit card. Over the

past decade, debit card has grown from accounting for 274 million transactions in 1990 to

8.15 billion transactions in 2002, to challenge the credit card as the preferred payment

card. As it stands, the debit card industry is a multi-billion dollar engine that helps drive

bank profits and point-of purchase consumer sales - but is also beginning to redefine

traditional payment options in the business and government sectors, such as food stamps, benefits, and payroll. The debit card has arrived and is here to stay.

And yet, though it remains poised for growth, the debit card has also reached a

crossroads. A recent settlement has cost VISA and MasterCard approximately $3 billion,

and has dramatically reduced the fees they can charge for signature-based debit

purchases. The effects of the settlement reach into every layer of the industry - from

rewards incentives, to marketing programs, to future fee arrangements, and future

growth. Consumer preferences for PIN- or signature-based debit will certainly influencehow things unfold, and whether either debit card option will suffer or bloom in the short,

mid, or long term.

Page 2: 53418359 a Comparitive Study of Plastic Money With Reference to Credit Card Debit Card

8/6/2019 53418359 a Comparitive Study of Plastic Money With Reference to Credit Card Debit Card

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/53418359-a-comparitive-study-of-plastic-money-with-reference-to-credit-card 2/54

Credit cards, one of the banking products that cater products to the needs of retail

segment has seen its number grow in geometric progression in recent years. This growth

has been strongly supported by the development in the field of technology, without which

this could not have been possible.

The history of phenomenal growth in the credit cards segment traces way back to in

1950, the time when “Dinar Club” was established .The card provided select members

with credit at 22 restaurants in New York and collected a commission for paying the bills

promptly. The credit card industry got a further boost with the arrival of American

express began selling their card as a prestige to hotels,restaurants,shops or airlines in

America and slowly expanded the network across the world.

The success of these two players attracted many other banks to join the credit card

business. The entire breed of new players saw a fresh opportunity of granting unsecured

loans at high interest rates to those credit cardholders who did not pay their bills on time.

These banks were not so concerned with collecting commissions from shops but were

thriving on high interest income from those who did not pay their bills on time.

It’s not that only the card numbers have increased, but even the types of cards on offer

have seen a surge. Today the domestic card industry is flooded with different types of cards ranging from gold, silver, global, co-branded credit cards, smart to secure ….the list

is endless. Foreign banks have shouldered the major responsibility of increasing the card

base and adding value-added services to the card products in the past. This is also evident

from the fact that the market share of these foreign banks is estimated to be well over

70%. But the scenario has changed dramatically in the last of couple of years with the

entry of State Bank of India (SBI), a domestic major in the banking sector. More and

more nationalised banks and private sector banks like ICICI and HDFC Bank are

aggressively launching credit card with value added features.

Although at present the card market is mainly limited to India’s relatively bigger cities

and tourist locations only, there is also a potential in smaller cities. Domestic banks,

owing to their vast network and reach to smaller cities, can easily tap this potential. They

3

Page 3: 53418359 a Comparitive Study of Plastic Money With Reference to Credit Card Debit Card

8/6/2019 53418359 a Comparitive Study of Plastic Money With Reference to Credit Card Debit Card

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/53418359-a-comparitive-study-of-plastic-money-with-reference-to-credit-card 3/54

would be better off, penetrating into smaller cities and bringing credit card to the masses

rather than cannibalising other foreign banks’ existing cardholder base.

The efforts of these banks to increase the card base is going to be wholeheartedly

supported by the residents of these smaller cities with their higher disposable income,

changing lifestyle, increasing travel and the growth in the entertainment sector.

O ver the years, Indians have been averse to credit cards. This is primarily because they

believed that spending through credit is a sure shot way of getting into the debt trap. Of

course, movies highlighting the sad state of a borrower did not exactly help matters. And

even the local kirana shops have the famous lines Aaj Nagad, Kal Udhari (cash today,

credit tomorrow).

But the situation is not actually that scary. And it is all about right timing. Credit cards

can be a useful tool at the hands of savvy consumers who can effectively use the benefits

offered by cards.

It is important to know that credit card is a financial tool that needs to be used

responsibly. While it ensures cash flow, it is not advisable for customers to borrow for a

longer period of time. Use it effectively and take good advantage of the time line and

clear your debts, without any additional costs.

Plastic Money: the Currency of Modern India

Indian consumers have never had it so good. The soiled notes are definitely out. Carrying

cash is no more `a pain in the neck' as consumers are relying more on the `plastic card'

which gives them money on credit.

Plastic money basically means debit cards and credit cards which is having a magneticstripe, logo, signature of the cardholder made of plastic.

Credit Cards have finally arrived in India. The card industry which is growing at the rate

of 20% per annum is flooded with cards ranging from gold, silver, global, smart to

4

Page 4: 53418359 a Comparitive Study of Plastic Money With Reference to Credit Card Debit Card

8/6/2019 53418359 a Comparitive Study of Plastic Money With Reference to Credit Card Debit Card

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/53418359-a-comparitive-study-of-plastic-money-with-reference-to-credit-card 4/54

secure….the list is endless. From just two players in early 80s, the industry now houses

over 10 major players vying for a major chunk of the card pie.

Currently four major bishops are ruling the card empire---Citibank, Standard Chartered

Bank, HSBC and State Bank of India (SBI). The industry, which is catering to over 3.8

million card users, is expected to double by the fiscal 2003. According to a study

conducted by State Bank of India, Citibank is the dominant player, having issued 1.5

million cards so far. Stanchart follows way behind with 0.67 million, while Hongkong

Bank has 0.3 million credit card customers. Among the nationalized banks, SBI tops the

list with 0.28 million cards, followed by Bank of Baroda at 0.22 million.

The credit card market in India, which started out in 1981, is on the verge of an

unprecedented boom. Between 1987 and 2000, the market has virtually grown to over 3.8

million cards with almost 25-30 % growth in new cardholders.

SBI, one of the late entrants in the card market, has managed to grab over 8 per cent of

the market share from the bigwigs like Citibank and Standard Chartered Bank. The

bank's credit card business has grown by 8 per cent over the last two years. According to

bank officials, SBI's card issue so far is to the tune of 0.28 million which is expected to In

a bid to tap the lower middle class segment, SBI is currently sharpening its marketingThe bank is putting its best foot forward to compete with global card majors like Citibank

and Standard Chartered Bank. The global bigwigs have already established themselves as

the `bankable brands' in the metros. However, in a bid to move to greener pastures, they

are trying to tap the co-branded card market which has vast potential for growth.

Citibank, which is leading the card empire recently launched a co-branded credit card in

partnership with Indian Oil Corporation. The card will offer its members reward points

on every international spend which can be redeemed for free fuel in India.

ATM- debit cards are the flavour of the season

The credit card business may have fallen short of expectations, but the debit card seems

to lend issuers and payment systems a cause for hope.

5

Page 5: 53418359 a Comparitive Study of Plastic Money With Reference to Credit Card Debit Card

8/6/2019 53418359 a Comparitive Study of Plastic Money With Reference to Credit Card Debit Card

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/53418359-a-comparitive-study-of-plastic-money-with-reference-to-credit-card 5/54

Plastic money is getting popular, according to a survey conducted by MasterCard

international in the Asia pacific region comprising of Korea, Malaysia, Indonesia,

Philippines and Thailand. Eighty percent of those who participated in the survey were

either the owners of a card or desired to own an ATM card. 50% owned one and 30%

wish to own a card.

According to Jeff Portelli, Maestro (MasterCard’s debit card offering) has grown from

zero to 70 m cards in the Asia pacific region since its launch six years ago. Today,

Maestro is issued in 16 Asia Pacific markets and is accepted at over 35,000 ATMs and

more than 220,000 points of sale. In India, the card is available through Citibank, Times

Bank and HDFC Bank.

The concept of debit cards has been a slow starter in India. Debit cards are currently

offered by only a handful of banks, which has made availability low. Besides, the annual

fee attached to these cards adds to the perception that consumers are asked to pay for

their own money. However as the market get cracking, these fears are expected to be

alleviated in future.

6

Page 6: 53418359 a Comparitive Study of Plastic Money With Reference to Credit Card Debit Card

8/6/2019 53418359 a Comparitive Study of Plastic Money With Reference to Credit Card Debit Card

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/53418359-a-comparitive-study-of-plastic-money-with-reference-to-credit-card 6/54

DEBIT CARDS

A debit card is a plastic card which provides an alternative payment method to cash when

making purchases. Physically the card is an ISO 7810 card like a credit card; however, its

functionality is more similar to writing a cheque as the funds are withdrawn directly from

either the cardholder's bank account (often referred to as a check card ), or from the

remaining balance on a gift card.

Depending on the store or merchant, the customer may swipe or insert their card into the

terminal, or they may hand it to the merchant who will do so. The transaction is

authorized and processed and the customer verifies the transaction either by entering a

PIN or, occasionally, by signing a sales receipt

As it is popularly known, it is an ATM card on the move. The Debit Card gives the

freedom to access the Savings or Current Account at merchant locations and ATMs.

Whenever to make payments, the amount will be instantly debited to the account. There

are around more than 5.3 lakh Visa/PLUS ATMs and equally strong Mastercard/ Cirrus

ATMs in over 140 countries worldwide. All the purchases and cash withdrawals will bein the currency of the country are in, while account will be debited in rupees. So you

needn't carry traveller's cheques or foreign exchange the next time you travel

Debit Card can be used at any merchant location displaying the Visa or Mastercard logo

or at any ATMs displaying the Visa/PLUS or Mastercard/Cirrus logo. Besides that, one

can always use it at any of the bank ATMs as a normal ATM card.

Working of Debit Card

The user has to present the card to merchant who will swipe it through the electronic

terminal and enter the amount of purchase. The customer need to sign the transaction slip.

Account will be automatically debited for the amount of the purchase and the transaction

can be verified by entering the PIN. Debit Card can be used to access the Account from

7

Page 7: 53418359 a Comparitive Study of Plastic Money With Reference to Credit Card Debit Card

8/6/2019 53418359 a Comparitive Study of Plastic Money With Reference to Credit Card Debit Card

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/53418359-a-comparitive-study-of-plastic-money-with-reference-to-credit-card 7/54

over 5,000 Shops, Department Stores, Petrol Pumps and Restaurants and over 235 ATMs

in India .It can also be used at over 4 million Visa Electron merchant locations and

equally strong Mastercard outlets. If Debit Card ever gets lost or stolen, card companies

protect from fraudulent usage at the loss.

It is necessary to have a savings or current account with the debit card issuer; by filling

an application form. The card company then couriers the card across around a week’s

time. The Debit card does have a daily limit which could be somewhere around Rs.

15,000 at ATMs, and Rs. 10,000 at merchant locations. This again is subject to the

balance available in the account.

Advantages of Debit Card

• Debit Card is often easier to get than a credit card.• Check approval or to show identification at store is not required.• No need to carry cash, a checkbook or traveler's checks.• Debit cards are more readily accepted than checks, especially at the time of

traveling.• No interest charges are to be paid by debit cardholders.•

Debit card processing fee for the merchant are generally lower than credit cardfees.

Disadvantages of a debit card

• Enough money is required in bank account to have debit card.• Once the amount is paid for purchase, if something goes wrong with the

purchase.. Bank won't put money back into your account for items that are never

delivered, don't work or were misrepresented.• Bank fees—such as monthly service charges, per-transaction costs or penalties—

for dropping below the required minimum balance are charged by debit card

holders.• More chances of lose or misuse of debit card than a credit card.

8

Page 8: 53418359 a Comparitive Study of Plastic Money With Reference to Credit Card Debit Card

8/6/2019 53418359 a Comparitive Study of Plastic Money With Reference to Credit Card Debit Card

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/53418359-a-comparitive-study-of-plastic-money-with-reference-to-credit-card 8/54

Two types of debit cards: There are currently two ways that debit card transactions are

processed: online debit (also known as PIN debit) and offline debit (also known as

signature debit). In some countries including the United States and Australia, they are

often referred to at point of sale as "debit" and "credit" respectively, even though in either

case the user's bank account is debited and no credit is involved.

In India there are basically three types of cards namely Visa, Master Card and Amex.

Participating banks like ANZ Grindlays, BoB then issue these cards to the subscribers.

Both Visa and Master Card have been popular in India and Amex a relatively new player

in India as it issues its cards only through American Express

ATM Cards

These cards are typically used at automatic teller machines (ATMs) to withdraw cash,

make deposits, or transfer funds between accounts. ATM card is used by inserting the

card into an automatic teller machine and enter a personal identification number, or PIN,

for security. The system checks the account for adequate funds before permitting any

transaction.

Check Cards

These cards can be used to purchase products at any merchant that accepts VISA or

MasterCard credit cards. On the surface, they look exactly like ATM cards. However,

check cards cannot be used at automatic teller machines. When using a check card no

PIN is used. Instead, you will be asked to sign a transaction slip as would be done with a

credit card.

Debit Card Problems can be worse than Credit Card Problems

When an improper charge appears on the credit card it can not automatically out the

money and simply need to work with the credit card issuer to have the charge removed

from the bill. When an improper charge occurs with a debit card, however, the funds are

automatically taken from the account and customer is burdened with attempting to get the

9

Page 9: 53418359 a Comparitive Study of Plastic Money With Reference to Credit Card Debit Card

8/6/2019 53418359 a Comparitive Study of Plastic Money With Reference to Credit Card Debit Card

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/53418359-a-comparitive-study-of-plastic-money-with-reference-to-credit-card 9/54

Page 10: 53418359 a Comparitive Study of Plastic Money With Reference to Credit Card Debit Card

8/6/2019 53418359 a Comparitive Study of Plastic Money With Reference to Credit Card Debit Card

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/53418359-a-comparitive-study-of-plastic-money-with-reference-to-credit-card 10/54

CREDIT CARDS

A credit card is a system of payment named after the small plastic card issued to users of

the system. A credit card is different from a debit card in that it does not remove money

from the user's account after every transaction. In the case of credit cards, the issuer lends

money to the consumer (or the user) to be paid to the merchant. It is also different from a

charge card (though this name is sometimes used by the public to describe credit cards),

which requires the balance to be paid in full each month. In contrast, a credit card allows

the consumer to 'revolve' their balance, at the cost of having interest charged. Most credit

cards are the same shape and size, as specified by the ISO 7810 standard.

Credit cards in India is gaining ground. A number of banks in India are encouraging

people to use credit card. The concept of credit card was used in 1950 with the launch of

charge cards in USA by Diners Club and American Express. Credit card however became

more popular with use of magnetic strip in 1970.

Credit card in India became popular with the introduction of foreign banks in the country.

Credit cards are financial instruments, which can be used more than once to borrow

money or buy products and services on credit. Basically banks, retail stores and other

businesses issue these.

Major Banks issuing Credit Card in India

• State Bank of India credit card (SBI credit card)• Bank of Baroda credit card or (BoB credit card)• ICICI credit card• HDFC credit card• IDBI credit card

11

Page 11: 53418359 a Comparitive Study of Plastic Money With Reference to Credit Card Debit Card

8/6/2019 53418359 a Comparitive Study of Plastic Money With Reference to Credit Card Debit Card

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/53418359-a-comparitive-study-of-plastic-money-with-reference-to-credit-card 11/54

• ABN AMRO credit card• Standard Chartered credit card• HSBC credit card• Citibank Credit Card

How credit cards works

A user is issued credit after an account has been approved by the credit provider, and is

given a credit card, with which the user will be able to make purchases from merchants

accepting that credit card up to a pre-established credit limit. Often a general bank issues

the credit, but sometimes a captive bank created to issue a particular brand of credit card,

such as Chase, Wells Fargo or Bank of America, issues the credit.

When a purchase is made, the credit card user agrees to pay the card issuer. The

cardholder indicates their consent to pay, by signing a receipt with a record of the card

details and indicating the amount to be paid or by entering a Personal identification

number (PIN). Also, many merchants now accept verbal authorizations via telephone and

electronic authorization using the Internet, known as a Card not present (CNP)

transaction.

The credit card may simply serve as a form of revolving credit, or it may become a

complicated financial instrument with multiple balance segments each at a different

interest rate, possibly with a single umbrella credit limit, or with separate credit limits

applicable to the various balance segments. Usually this compartmentalization is the

result of special incentive offers from the issuing bank, either to encourage balance

transfers from cards of other issuers, or to encourage more spending on the part of the

customer. In the event that several interest rates apply to various balance segments,

payment allocation is generally at the discretion of the issuing bank, and payments will

therefore usually be allocated towards the lowest rate balances until paid in full before

any money is paid towards higher rate balances. Interest rates can vary considerably from

card to card, and the interest rate on a particular card may jump dramatically if the card

user is late with a payment on that card or any other credit instrument , or even if the

12

Page 12: 53418359 a Comparitive Study of Plastic Money With Reference to Credit Card Debit Card

8/6/2019 53418359 a Comparitive Study of Plastic Money With Reference to Credit Card Debit Card

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/53418359-a-comparitive-study-of-plastic-money-with-reference-to-credit-card 12/54

issuing bank decides to raise its revenue. As the rates and terms vary, services have been

set up allowing users to calculate savings available by switching cards, which can be

considerable if there is a large outstanding balance

Because of intense competition in the credit card industry, credit providers often offer

incentives such as frequent flyer points, gift certificates, or cash back (typically up to 1

percent based on total purchases) to try to attract customers to their program.

Parties involved :

• Cardholder: The owner of the card used to make a purchase; the consumer.

• Card-issuing bank: The financial institution or other organization that issued the

credit card to the cardholder. This bank bills the consumer for repayment and

bears the risk that the card is used fraudulently. American Express and Discover

were previously the only card-issuing banks for their respective brands, but as of

2007, this is no longer the case.

• Merchant: The individual or business accepting credit card payments for products

or services sold to the cardholder

• Acquiring bank: The financial institution accepting payment for the products or

services on behalf of the merchant.

• Independent sales organization: Resellers (to merchants) of the services of the

acquiring bank.

• Merchant account: This could refer to the acquiring bank or the independent sales

organization, but in general is the organization that the merchant deals with.

• Credit Card association: An association of card-issuing banks such as Visa,

MasterCard, Discover, American Express, etc. that set transaction terms for

merchants, card-issuing banks, and acquiring banks.

• Transaction network: The system that implements the mechanics of the electronic

transactions. May be operated by an independent company, and one company

may operate multiple networks. Transaction processing networks include:

Cardnet, Nabanco, Omaha, Paymentech, NDC Atlanta, Nova, Vital, Concord

EFSnet, and VisaNet.

13

Page 13: 53418359 a Comparitive Study of Plastic Money With Reference to Credit Card Debit Card

8/6/2019 53418359 a Comparitive Study of Plastic Money With Reference to Credit Card Debit Card

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/53418359-a-comparitive-study-of-plastic-money-with-reference-to-credit-card 13/54

Benefits of Accepting Plastic

• More Sales: Studies show that credit card customers spend 2 1/2 times more than

customers who only carry cash.• Impulse Buying: Credit cards give customers freedom to spend for previously

unplanned purchases.• More Expensive Merchandise: Credit cards entice customers to purchase more

expensive merchandise than they had originally planned to buy.• Competitive Weapon: Credit card customers are often less conscious of slight

price differences and will seek out businesses that offer credit card payment

options.• Enhanced Advertising: Since customers are more likely to shop at businesses

where they have credit card acceptance, they tend to look for and read those ads

first.• Steadier Sales: Credit smoothes out business peaks. Cash shoppers buy heavier

on paydays and just before holidays; credit card customers buy whenever the need

arises• Customer Loyalty: Research shows customers who spend more on credit tend to

return to the same business again.

Disadvantages

On the other hand, credit cards can

1. Cost much more than other forms of credit, such as a line of credit or a personal loan, if

not paid on time.

2. It damages the credit rating if payments are late.

3. Allow to build up more debt than actually handled by customer.

4. It has complicated terms and conditions.

14

Page 14: 53418359 a Comparitive Study of Plastic Money With Reference to Credit Card Debit Card

8/6/2019 53418359 a Comparitive Study of Plastic Money With Reference to Credit Card Debit Card

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/53418359-a-comparitive-study-of-plastic-money-with-reference-to-credit-card 14/54

DIFFERENT TYPES OF CREDIT CARDS

• Charge card

A charge card carries all the features of credit cards. However, after using a charge card

you will have to pay off the entire amount billed, by the due date. If you fail to do so, you

are likely to be considered a defaulter and will usually have to pay up a steep late

payment charge.

At the time of using the card he is not declared not as a defaulter even if misses due date.

A 2.95 per cent late payment fees (this differs from one bank to another) is levied in the

next billing statement.

• Amex card

Amex stands for American Express and is one of the well-known charge cards. This card

has its own merchant establishment tie-ups and does not depend on the network of

MasterCard or Visa.

• Smart card

A smart card contains an electronic chip which is used to store cash. This is most useful

when you have to pay for small purchases, for example bus fares and coffee. No

identification, signature or payment authorisation is required for using this card.

15

Page 15: 53418359 a Comparitive Study of Plastic Money With Reference to Credit Card Debit Card

8/6/2019 53418359 a Comparitive Study of Plastic Money With Reference to Credit Card Debit Card

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/53418359-a-comparitive-study-of-plastic-money-with-reference-to-credit-card 15/54

The exact amount of purchase is deducted from the smart card during payment and is

collected by smart card reading machines. No change is given. Currently this product is

available only in very developed countries like the United States and is being used only

sporadically in India.

• Diners Club card

Diners Club is a branded charge card. There are a wide variety of special privileges

offered to the Diners Club cardholder. For instance, as a cardholder you can set your ownspending limit. Besides, the card has its own merchant establishment tie-ups and does not

depend on the network of MasterCard or Visa.

However, since this card is typically meant for high-income group categories, it may not

be acceptable at many outlets. It would be a good idea to check whether a member

establishment does accept the card or not in advance.

Photo card

In this photograph is imprinted on a card, and then you have what is known as a photo

card. Doing this helps identify the user of the credit card and is therefore considered

safer. Besides, in many cases, your photo card can function as your identity card as well.

• Global card

Global cards allow you the flexibility and convenience of using a credit card rather than

cash or travellers checks while travelling abroad for either business or personal reasons.

• Co-branded card

16

Page 16: 53418359 a Comparitive Study of Plastic Money With Reference to Credit Card Debit Card

8/6/2019 53418359 a Comparitive Study of Plastic Money With Reference to Credit Card Debit Card

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/53418359-a-comparitive-study-of-plastic-money-with-reference-to-credit-card 16/54

Co-branded cards are credit cards issued by card companies that have tied up with a

popular brand for the purpose of offering certain exclusive benefits to the consumer. .

• Affinity card

The card issuer ties up with popular organisations/ institutions which are often non-profit

organisations (Citi-WWF card or the Stanchart-Cricket cards) to offer an affinity card.

When the card is used, a certain percentage is contributed to the organisation /institution

by the card issue

• MasterCard and Visa

MasterCard and Visa are global non-profit organisations dedicated to promote the growthof the card business across the world. They have built a vast network of merchant

establishments so that customers world-wide may use their respective credit cards to

make various purchases.

Visa card: Visa, Inc. , commonly called VISA , is an economic joint venture of

21,000 financial institutions that issue and market Visa products including credit

and debit cards. The company was originally named Visa International Service

Association . The name change occurred in the fall of 2007 as a part of Visa’s

restructuring and IPO plan. The company is based in San Francisco, California,

USA.

Operations

Visa offers through its issuing members the following types of cards:

• Debit cards (pay from a checking / savings account)• Credit cards (pay monthly payments with interest)• Prepaid cards (pay from a cash account that has no check writing privileges)

Visa operates the PLUS ATM network and the Interlink EFTPOS network, which

facilitate the "debit" protocol used with debit cards and prepaid cards.

17

Page 17: 53418359 a Comparitive Study of Plastic Money With Reference to Credit Card Debit Card

8/6/2019 53418359 a Comparitive Study of Plastic Money With Reference to Credit Card Debit Card

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/53418359-a-comparitive-study-of-plastic-money-with-reference-to-credit-card 17/54

Visa card

Credit vs. debit

Even though the service is offered by thousands of banks, the end result is standardized

for consumers by the Visa International Association. Two protocols are used, depending

upon the type of card marketed, often called "credit" and "debit." The names of the two

protocols use the arbitrary "debit" and "credit" from accounting meaning left and right,

and they originally had the meanings (and still do to many people) that with credit the

cardholder pays later for the purchase, and with debit the cardholder pays immediately.

The debit protocol involves using the card at a point of sale terminal (POS) or automated

teller machine where the PLUS or Interlink logo is shown, with a Visa card that has the

PLUS or Interlink logo on the back of the card. A PIN (personal identification number,

known by its acronym) is used to identify the cardholder. The money is deducted from

the attached checking account or prepaid account (which is similar with no paper check-

writing capability). The credit protocol involves using the card at a POS or a banking

center where the Visa logo is shown. The cardholder's signature is generally used for

identification, often together with the cardholder's civic registration number or ID

card/passport. Holders of any Visa card may use the credit protocol even if the card is

marketed as a debit card or prepaid card (basically since it has the Visa logo on the front

of the card)

MasterCard: MasterCard Worldwide is a multinational corporation based in Purchase,

New York, USA. Throughout the world, its principal business is to process payments

between the banks of merchants and the banks of purchasers that use its "MasterCard"

brand debit and credit cards to make purchases. MasterCard Worldwide has been a

publicly traded company since 2006. Prior to its initial public offering, MasterCard

18

Page 18: 53418359 a Comparitive Study of Plastic Money With Reference to Credit Card Debit Card

8/6/2019 53418359 a Comparitive Study of Plastic Money With Reference to Credit Card Debit Card

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/53418359-a-comparitive-study-of-plastic-money-with-reference-to-credit-card 18/54

Worldwide was a membership organization owned by the 25,000+ financial institutions

that issue its card.

It was originally created by United California Bank (later First Interstate Bank,

subsequently merged into Wells Fargo Bank), Wells Fargo, Crocker National Bank (also

subsequent .As at 31 March 2007, over 187 million MasterCard cards (excluding

Maestro ® and Cirrus) had been issued by MasterCard customer financial institutions

across APMEA. Cardholders in the region made more than 667 million purchase

transactions in the first quarter of 2007 and could use their MasterCard cards at 25.1

million acceptance locations worldwide. Serving nearly 25,000 member financial

institutions worldwide, MasterCard is the #2 payment system in the US. The company

does not issue credit or its namesake cards; rather, it markets the MasterCard (credit anddebit cards) and Maestro (debit cards) brands, provides the transaction authorization

network, establishes guidelines for use, and collects fees from members. The company

provides services in more than 210 countries and territories; its cards are accepted at

more than 23 million locations around the globe. MasterCard also operates the Cirrus

ATM network .

As a significant link between monetary institutions plus millions of businesses,

cardholders and traders globally, mastercard card provide services in further than 210

countries along with territories. Debit mastercard plus credit mastercard moves forward

trade worldwide by increasing extra secure, suitable and satisfying payment results,

dealing out billions of expenses flawlessly transversely the globe, and structuring fiscal

connections that speed up business.

The mastercard com modernized and smart approach to dealing out enables competent

trade on a global level. It is found on a supple network, lone of the biggest VPNs in the

globe, which presents unmatched speed, combination, and consistency. MasterCardassists banks along with merchants raise by enabling fast acceptance of new ways to

disburse and offering modified solutions that bring importance in the course of

technology

19

Page 19: 53418359 a Comparitive Study of Plastic Money With Reference to Credit Card Debit Card

8/6/2019 53418359 a Comparitive Study of Plastic Money With Reference to Credit Card Debit Card

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/53418359-a-comparitive-study-of-plastic-money-with-reference-to-credit-card 19/54

As it seems to the prospect, MasterCard are dedicated not just to ongoing to distribute

value to its clients and further stakeholders, but as well to helping the benefits of

electronic payments, speeding up the dislocation of cash as well as checks, and going

forward trade transversely the world.

To help educate consumers on financial management, MasterCard launched free tools

that are designed to be easily understandable for consumers in order to help them manage

personal finances

DIFFERENCE BETWEEN A DEBIT CARD AND A CREDIT CARD

A debit card looks like a credit card; it works more like cash or a personal check.” pay

now." With a credit card, you "pay later."

Debit means "subtract." In case of debit card the amount is automatically subtracted from

checking or saving account, credit cards are used in stores for purchases. At check-out,

the card reader electronically contacts the bank and subtracts the amount from theaccount. The money in bank account limits how much the customer can spend. However,

if the customer is not careful in watching the daily account balance, he can over withdraw

the account. Some systems will allow to use the debit card even when don't have enough

money in the account to cover the purchase. This can result in hefty overdraft fees.

Using a credit card is somewhat like taking out a loan from a bank or other financial

institution. Customer have to pay back the credit used each month. If he pays back less

than the full amount owe each month, he is to pay interest on the amount not paid back.

The credit card company sets the total amount that can charge based on your credit

history, income, debts and ability to pay.

Some cards are dual-purpose credit/debit cards. Before swiping the card through the

reader, select a "credit" or "debit" button on the reader. If you select "debit," then enter

20

Page 20: 53418359 a Comparitive Study of Plastic Money With Reference to Credit Card Debit Card

8/6/2019 53418359 a Comparitive Study of Plastic Money With Reference to Credit Card Debit Card

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/53418359-a-comparitive-study-of-plastic-money-with-reference-to-credit-card 20/54

your Personal Identification Number (PIN). If select "credit," the credit receipt is given to

sign and credit charges will appear on the next charge account bill.

ICICI

DEBIT CARDS

Combining the wide acceptability of a credit card and the thoughtful prudence of an

ATM card, the ICICI Bank Debit Card is the most convenient accessory. No more fear of

overspending. No more searching for the nearest ATM. Only more comfort and

convenience in the debit cards provided by ICICI.

Various Products

• The ICICI Bank Private Banking Debit Card• The ICICI Bank Gold Debit Card• The ICICI Bank HPCL Debit Card• The ICICI Bank Ncash Silver Card•

The ICICI Bank Ncash Debit Card

CREDIT CARDS

ICICI Bank Credit Cards give you the facility of cash, convenience and a range of

benefits, anywhere in the world. These benefits range from life time free cards, Insurance

21

Page 21: 53418359 a Comparitive Study of Plastic Money With Reference to Credit Card Debit Card

8/6/2019 53418359 a Comparitive Study of Plastic Money With Reference to Credit Card Debit Card

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/53418359-a-comparitive-study-of-plastic-money-with-reference-to-credit-card 21/54

benefits, global emergency assistance service, discounts, utility payments, travel

discounts and much more.

TYPES OF CARDS

• Premium Cards• Classic Cards• Value for Money Cards• Co Branded Cards• Affinity Cards• EMI Card

HDFC

DEBIT CARD

HDFC BANK Debit Cards give you complete and instant access to the money in

accounts without the risk or hassle of carrying cash.

TYPES OF DEBIT CARDS

Easy Shop International Debit Card

Easy Shop International Gold Debit Card

Easy Shop International Business Debit Card

Easy Shop Woman's Advantage Debit Card

Kisan card

CREDIT CARD: HDFC bank credit card provide a facility of easy availability of cash

and convenience to the cardholder.

TYPES OF CREDIT CARDS OF HDFC BANK

• CLASSIC CARDS

22

Page 22: 53418359 a Comparitive Study of Plastic Money With Reference to Credit Card Debit Card

8/6/2019 53418359 a Comparitive Study of Plastic Money With Reference to Credit Card Debit Card

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/53418359-a-comparitive-study-of-plastic-money-with-reference-to-credit-card 22/54

Silver Credit Card

Value plus Credit Card

Health Plus Credit Card

Gold Credit Card

Titanium Credit Card

Platinum Plus Credit Card

Visa Signature Credit Card

REVIEW OF LITERATURE

Cunningham Julie (Nov 98), Kansas state university in the study “College

Student Using The Credit Card ” stated that there is a need to determine whether

college students are responsible with their credit cards. This study was concerned

with the problem faced by the credit cardholders. Consumer perception regarding

credit cards and debit cards is very much different as it is precisely in a defined

sector. Role of online commerce or payment over the internet .it future prospects

of credit card and debit card in India. It also includes consumer preference among

debit card and credit card, consumer satisfaction level in case of both cards.

Loebecke S .Elliot (Jan 98) in his article “Smart Card Based Electronic

Commerce: Characteristics And Roles” stated that the origin of smart cards began when consumer requirements for convenience and security out spaced the

capabilities of magnetic stripe cards. Providing increased data storage and added

security, smart cards were introduced in Europe in the early 1970’s as stored

value cards for payphones. These early smart cards were disposable and were an

23

Page 23: 53418359 a Comparitive Study of Plastic Money With Reference to Credit Card Debit Card

8/6/2019 53418359 a Comparitive Study of Plastic Money With Reference to Credit Card Debit Card

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/53418359-a-comparitive-study-of-plastic-money-with-reference-to-credit-card 23/54

effective means to reduce losses. Today's advanced contact less and dual-interface

smart card technologies - together with emerging digital signature laws and the

development of biometric techniques - can bring a range of services to life on a

single piece of silicon.

Swift, Kevin (May 1998) in his article “Credit Card And Debit Cards: What

New? Where To?” stated that trends have changed and forces have impact on the

card issuer, and forecasting its future and the resulting impact on the card economy

through the year 2002.The report takes a different viewpoint from many studies of the

industry which examined trends from the issuers viewpoint. This study takes those

trends as the end –point, and looks at the forces that will impact the card issuers. It

offers insight into the combination of industry, economic, demographic, and

technological changes that will have an effect on credit and debit card products, and

how together they will reshape the industry landscape and result in a credit/debit card

industry that will look far different in the year 2002 that it does today. The

convergence of the internet and various consumer and other electronic technologies in

combination with a desire on the part of companies in a number of industries to forge

new alliances and offer enhanced services has established a role for electronic cash.

Hayashi, Fumiko and Weiner Stuart E. (sept 2005) in their article “Competition

and Credit and Debit Card Interchange Fees” stated that there is a bridge between

the theoretical and empirical literatures on interchange fees. Credit and debit card

industries are examples of two-sided markets. The distinguishing Feature of two-

sided markets is they contain two sets of end users, each of whom needs the other in

order for the market to operate. In the case of credit and debit cards, the two end-user

groups are cardholders and merchants.

Payment card systems take one of two principal forms. They may be three-party systems:

Cardholders, merchants, and a single financial institution that offers proprietary network

services, for example, American Express. Alternatively, they may be four-party systems:

cardholders, merchants, card-issuing banks, and merchant acquiring banks, using the

services of a multi-party network such as MasterCard, Visa, or a domestic debit card

24

Page 24: 53418359 a Comparitive Study of Plastic Money With Reference to Credit Card Debit Card

8/6/2019 53418359 a Comparitive Study of Plastic Money With Reference to Credit Card Debit Card

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/53418359-a-comparitive-study-of-plastic-money-with-reference-to-credit-card 24/54

network. In four-party systems, the interchange fee is an instrument that networks can use

to achieve a desired

Balance of cardholder.

Chakravorti ,Sujit (June 2003) in his article “ Theory of Credit Card Networks:

A Survey of the Literature” stated that Credit cards provide benefits to consumers

and merchants not provided by other payment instruments as evidenced by their

explosive growth in the number and value of transactions over the last 20 years.

Recently, credit card networks have come under scrutiny from regulators and antitrust

authorities around the world. Focusing on interrelated bilateral transactions, several

theoretical models have been constructed to study the implications of several business

practices of credit card networks

Hunt, Robert in this article “An Introduction to the Economics of Payment Card

Networks” stated that how payment cards work and explains how the market for

consumer payment methods differs from most other markets economists study. These

differences have implications for when, why, and how the rules of antitrust law –

which regulate how firms may exercise market power – should be applied to this

industry. He focused on general-purpose credit cards, such as Visa or MasterCard,and debit cards. We do not discuss department store cards, oil company cards, or

bankcards when they are used at ATMs Debit cards allow customers to pay for goods

and services at the point of sale by authorizing a withdrawal from their checking or

savings account. Most ATM cards can be used at the point of sale as debit cards. Such

transactions are called PIN debit transactions because the cardholder must enter a

four-digit personal identification number (PIN) to authorize the transaction. Funds are

then immediately withdrawn from the associated bank account. The transaction itself

is routed through an electronic funds transfer (EFT) network, for example Star,

NYCE, and Pulse.7 transaction, a signature debit transaction does not immediately

remove funds from the cardholder’s account; it typically takes a day or two for the

transaction to clear. MasterCard must also accept the comparable brand of debit card.

25

Page 25: 53418359 a Comparitive Study of Plastic Money With Reference to Credit Card Debit Card

8/6/2019 53418359 a Comparitive Study of Plastic Money With Reference to Credit Card Debit Card

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/53418359-a-comparitive-study-of-plastic-money-with-reference-to-credit-card 25/54

Chartered financial analyst in the article “Credit Card Crisis In South Korea”

stated that in the aftermath of the economic crisis of 97-98 South Korea has

undertaken several measures to deal with prudential problem relating to credit cards.

This study attempts to find out why the credit cards have been a disaster in South

Korea in 1999, the Korean policy makers came up with some revolutionary changes

in the policy and law that stepped up the usage of credit cards. Banks and credit card

companies started issuing credit cards without properly assessing the credit capacity

of the customer. The South Korean credit industry and the economy suffered a painful

blow in 2003.it was a major credit card fiasco throughout the country with thousands

of citizens committing suicide to avoid the burden of debt & fear of bankruptcy.

Chartered financial analyst (Nov 2007) in the article “Ethical Issues And

Challenges” stated that the credit card company has to take into consideration the

challenges which are their in the markets. Credit cardholders have the fear of loosing

the card and the card is being misused by other person. The credit card is stolen or

lost and being misused .credit card companies have to focus on the security and

ethical issues related to credit cards.

26

Page 26: 53418359 a Comparitive Study of Plastic Money With Reference to Credit Card Debit Card

8/6/2019 53418359 a Comparitive Study of Plastic Money With Reference to Credit Card Debit Card

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/53418359-a-comparitive-study-of-plastic-money-with-reference-to-credit-card 26/54

OBJECTIVES OF STUDY

• To know the perception of people towards plastic money .

• To know the importance of plastic money in the daily life of consumers’ w.r.t

credit and debit cards.

• To study the benefits of debit card and credit cards.

• To find out the market leader among the various banks/ companies issuing credit

and debit cards

• To know the problems faced by respondents using plastic money.

• To study the satisfaction level of consumers towards plastic money.

27

Page 27: 53418359 a Comparitive Study of Plastic Money With Reference to Credit Card Debit Card

8/6/2019 53418359 a Comparitive Study of Plastic Money With Reference to Credit Card Debit Card

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/53418359-a-comparitive-study-of-plastic-money-with-reference-to-credit-card 27/54

NEED AND SCOPE OF THE STUDY

Need of the study

It is rightly said the plastic money is need of hour. People are using these cards on a vast

scale. But after considering the review of literature it is seen the whole payment process

of processing these cards is not safe and customer are facing many problems relating to

plastic money. That’s why study is focused on consumer perception regarding the plastic

money. Need of the study is to get to know about the comparative analysis of plastic

money. There are many ethical issues and challenges in the market of plastic money

which is required to be studied. This study is concerned with the Seven perks of plastic

money Convenience, Budgeting technology, Reputation boosting , Corporate might, Cops

and robbers, The float, Openness to negotiations.

Scope of study: the following are the areas covered by plastic money :

ATM cards are slowly being transformed into value-added debit cards. Bankers and

analysts see tremendous scope for growth in debit cards. "There is tremendous potential

for debit cards. It will soon be substituting cheques. Utility payments will soon be made

28

Page 28: 53418359 a Comparitive Study of Plastic Money With Reference to Credit Card Debit Card

8/6/2019 53418359 a Comparitive Study of Plastic Money With Reference to Credit Card Debit Card

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/53418359-a-comparitive-study-of-plastic-money-with-reference-to-credit-card 28/54

through debit cards, either at the ATMs or at the counters. The debit card can be used to

withdraw cash from ATMs of other banks depending on whether the debit card-maker

has a Visa or a Maestro tie-up. Visa and MasterCard both confirmed yesterday that they

had been notified of the breach and had in turn notified several banks and credit card

companies of the potential data compromise. They declined to say how many companies

have been notified. Credit cards As well as convenient, accessible credit; credit cards

offer consumers an easy way to track expenses, which is necessary for both monitoring

personal expenditures and the tracking of work-related expenses for taxation and

reimbursement purposes.

RESEARCH METHODOLOGY

Research methodology deals with the method of study i.e. how the study can be carried

out and what techniques can be used. It is the careful investigation and enquiry in a

systematic manner in order to find solution to find problems in research. it consists of

defining and redefining the problems, formulating the hypothesis or suggestions solutions

,collecting data and evaluating the data and at last carefully testing the conclusions to

determine whether they fit he formulated hypothesis or not.

RESEARCH DESIGN : Research design states the conceptual structure within

which research is to be conducted. A research design is the arrangement of conditions for

collections and analysis of data in a manner that aims of data in manner that aims to

combine relevant the research purpose with economy in procedure. The different researchdesigns available are:

• Exploratory research : it generally emphasis on discovery of ideas and insights.

It’s more qualitative rather than quantitive.

29

Page 29: 53418359 a Comparitive Study of Plastic Money With Reference to Credit Card Debit Card

8/6/2019 53418359 a Comparitive Study of Plastic Money With Reference to Credit Card Debit Card

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/53418359-a-comparitive-study-of-plastic-money-with-reference-to-credit-card 29/54

• Descriptive research : it is concerned with determining the frequency with which

something occurs or extent relationship between two variables. This study will be

having an exploratory research which is based on discovery of ideas and insights.

SAMPLING PLAN:-

Universe : the universe consists of all people who are using plastic money for different

purposes.

Sample size : this refers to the number of respondents to be selected from the universe to

constitute a sample. Large samples gives more reliable results than the small samples. So

the sample size of 100 respondents was taken into consideration in case of research work,

which includes both debit and credit card holders.

Sampling unit : sampling unit implies that who are the respondents. In this sample all

those who are using debit cards and credit cards.

Sampling technique : the technique used for my study is convenient sampling that

consists of questionnaire, which are given to respondents who are the regular users of

plastic money.

METHODS OF DATA COLLECTION :

PRIMARY DATA:

Primary data is that data which is collected for the first time and thus happens to be

original in character. In the study, primary data will be collected from direct source of

information like customers with the help of questionnaire survey and personal interview.

Questionnaire: The second tool used for study is questionnaire. Various

questions regarding the purposes of plastic money and the various procedures for

obtaining credit cards, the necessity of credit cards, increasing relevance of plastic

money among consumers, market leader among various companies issuing credit

and debit cards.

SECONDARY DATA:

30

Page 30: 53418359 a Comparitive Study of Plastic Money With Reference to Credit Card Debit Card

8/6/2019 53418359 a Comparitive Study of Plastic Money With Reference to Credit Card Debit Card

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/53418359-a-comparitive-study-of-plastic-money-with-reference-to-credit-card 30/54

Secondary data are those which have already been collected by some one. For this study

there will be following secondary data.

Websites

Magazines

Articles And Newspapers

Books

TOOLS OF ANALYSIS:

Diagrams and Tables: Various graphs and tables are used to describe the

performance of different credit cards and debit cards.

Weighted Average : Weighted average method is also used to analyze the

comparison between plastic money. Weighted average means finding out the

average by assigning the weights to different factors. Formula for calculating

weighted average is ∑WiXi/Wi.

Pie chart and percentage: Pie charts and percentage are also used as a tool for

analysis.

DATA ANALYSIS AND INTERPRETATION

1: To know about respondents who are using the plastic money.

Respondents were asked whether they use plastic money or not .The results are as

follows:

Table no. 5.1 Use of plastic money by the respondents .

Options No. of respondents %age of respondentsYes 100 100%No 0 -

Figure 5.1 Use of plastic money by the respondents.

31

Page 31: 53418359 a Comparitive Study of Plastic Money With Reference to Credit Card Debit Card

8/6/2019 53418359 a Comparitive Study of Plastic Money With Reference to Credit Card Debit Card

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/53418359-a-comparitive-study-of-plastic-money-with-reference-to-credit-card 31/54

Interpretation : From the above figure it can be interpreted that 100 respondents who are

taken for the study are using plastic money and hence it can be said that majority

respondents now a days are using plastic money.

2: Card possessed by respondents.

Respondents were asked to explain that which card they possess and the results are as

follows:

Table 5.2 Card possessed by respondents

Options No. of respondents % age of respondentsDebit card 58 58%

Credit card 28 28%Both 14 14%

Figure 5.2 Card possessed by respondents

100%

Yes

32

Debit card48%

Credit card38%

Both14%

Debit cardCredit cardBoth

Page 32: 53418359 a Comparitive Study of Plastic Money With Reference to Credit Card Debit Card

8/6/2019 53418359 a Comparitive Study of Plastic Money With Reference to Credit Card Debit Card

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/53418359-a-comparitive-study-of-plastic-money-with-reference-to-credit-card 32/54

Interpretation: From the above data collected we can interpret that that people mostly

have debit card, as credit card is little expensive than debit card so people mostly prefer debit card, but still people have applied for their credit card also. Some people have both

debit card and credit card

3: Debit cards of different companies/banks owned by respondents.

Respondents were asked to explain that how many no. of debit card owned by them and

the results are as follows:

Table 5.3- No. of debit cards of different companies owned by respondent

Options No. of respondents %age of

respondents1 56 56%

2 26 26%3 12 12%None 6 6%

Figure 5.3 No. of debit cards of different companies owned by respondent

33

Page 33: 53418359 a Comparitive Study of Plastic Money With Reference to Credit Card Debit Card

8/6/2019 53418359 a Comparitive Study of Plastic Money With Reference to Credit Card Debit Card

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/53418359-a-comparitive-study-of-plastic-money-with-reference-to-credit-card 33/54

Interpretation: The above chart reveal that mostly people have one debit card; about

26% of the respondent are using two debit cards from different companies.its clear that

people are satisfied with their debit card.

4: No. of credit cards of different companies/banks owned by respondents.

Respondents were asked to explain that how many no. of credit card owned by them and

the results are as follows:

Table 5.4 No. of credit cards of different companies owned

Options No. of respondents %age of respondents1 46 46%2 22 22%3 10 10%

None 22 22%

Figure5.4 No. of credit cards of different companies owned

56%26%

12%6%

123

None

34

Page 34: 53418359 a Comparitive Study of Plastic Money With Reference to Credit Card Debit Card

8/6/2019 53418359 a Comparitive Study of Plastic Money With Reference to Credit Card Debit Card

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/53418359-a-comparitive-study-of-plastic-money-with-reference-to-credit-card 34/54

Interpretation: From the above information it can be interpreted that 46% of the

respondent have one credit card from different companies. and 22% have don’t own

credit card. But still people have knowledge about these cards.

5: Companies /bank card owned by the respondents.

Respondents were asked to explain which company/bank card owned by them. The result

are as follows:

Table 5.5: Companies /bank card most preferred

Options No. of respondents %age of respondents

HDFC Bank 22 22%ICICI Bank 28 28%IDBI Bank 12 12 %CBOP 6 6%

Any other (PNB)(SBI)

2210

22%10%

1

46%

2

22%

3

10%

None22%

123

None

35

Page 35: 53418359 a Comparitive Study of Plastic Money With Reference to Credit Card Debit Card

8/6/2019 53418359 a Comparitive Study of Plastic Money With Reference to Credit Card Debit Card

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/53418359-a-comparitive-study-of-plastic-money-with-reference-to-credit-card 35/54

Figure 5.5 Companies /bank card most preferred

Interpretation: From the above data it’s clear that people mostly prefer ICICI bank to

get the plastic money, after that respondent prefer PNB and HDFC bank.people usually

like to have credit card with whom they have account.

6: Time period of using the debit card/credit card/both.

Respondents were asked to explain the time period for which they are using them. The

result are as follows:

Table 5.6: Time period of using the card

Options No. of respondents % age of respondentsLess than 1 yr 22 22%Between 1yr-3yr 26 26%

Between 3yr-5yr 34 34%More than 5 yr 18 18%

Figure 5.6 Time period of using the card

22%

28%12%6%

22%

10%HDFC Bank ICICI Bank IDBI Bank CBOPPNB

SBI

36

Page 36: 53418359 a Comparitive Study of Plastic Money With Reference to Credit Card Debit Card

8/6/2019 53418359 a Comparitive Study of Plastic Money With Reference to Credit Card Debit Card

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/53418359-a-comparitive-study-of-plastic-money-with-reference-to-credit-card 36/54

Interpretation: The above data reveals that mostly people are using plastic money from

last 3 to 5 yrs and rest are using it for less than one yr. plastic money become a trend

from the last few years.

7: Purpose for using the card.

Respondents were asked to explain the purpose of using the card. The results are as

follows:

Table 5.7: Purpose for using the card.

Options No. of

respondents

%age of respondents

Shopping 36 36%Withdrawal of money 24 24%Hotel & restaurant 20 20%Petrol filling 14 14%

Any other(like going for

movies etc)

4 4%

Less than 1yr 22%

Between 1yr-3yr 26%

Between 3yr-5yr 34%

More than 5yr 18%

Less than 1yr Between 1yr-3yr Between 3yr-5yr More than 5yr

37

Page 37: 53418359 a Comparitive Study of Plastic Money With Reference to Credit Card Debit Card

8/6/2019 53418359 a Comparitive Study of Plastic Money With Reference to Credit Card Debit Card

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/53418359-a-comparitive-study-of-plastic-money-with-reference-to-credit-card 37/54

Figure 5.7 Purpose for using the card.

Interpretation: It is clear that mostly people use the card for the shopping purpose. and

then for withdrawal of cash, 20%use it for going for hotel and restaurants. So the plastic

money is used by the respondent everywhere.

8: Card which is more beneficial.

Respondents were asked to explain which card is more beneficial according to them.

The result are as follows:

Table 5.8: Card which is more beneficial .

Options No. of respondents % age of respondentsDebit card 36 36%

Credit card 34 34%Both 30 30%

Figure5.8 Card which is more beneficial

36%

24%

20%

14%4%

ShoppingWithdrawl of moneyHotel &restaurantPetrol fillingAny other purpose

38

Page 38: 53418359 a Comparitive Study of Plastic Money With Reference to Credit Card Debit Card

8/6/2019 53418359 a Comparitive Study of Plastic Money With Reference to Credit Card Debit Card

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/53418359-a-comparitive-study-of-plastic-money-with-reference-to-credit-card 38/54

Interpretation: From the above table it is clear people mostly prefer debit card but credit

cards are not far behind, about 34% of the respondents feel that credit card is more

beneficial than debit card and some feel that both are beneficial.

9: Benefits provided by debit card

Respondents were asked to rank the benefits provided by debit card on a scale. The result

are as follows:

Table 5.9: Benefits provided by debit card

Wi 1 2 3 4 5Options

(Xi)

Strongly

Disagree

(No. of

respond

Disagree

(No.0f respondents)

Neither agree

Nor disagree

(No. of

respondents)

Agree

No. of

respondents

Strongly

agree

No. of respondents

Weighted

average

36%

34%

30%

Debit cardCredit cardBoth

39

Page 39: 53418359 a Comparitive Study of Plastic Money With Reference to Credit Card Debit Card

8/6/2019 53418359 a Comparitive Study of Plastic Money With Reference to Credit Card Debit Card

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/53418359-a-comparitive-study-of-plastic-money-with-reference-to-credit-card 39/54

ents )

Security 40 36 2 12 10 14.4

Free from

fraud

42 32 4 12 10 14.4

No

interest

charges

30 22 28 20 19.16

Anytime

access

12 10 2 44 32 25

Easy

to

carry

8 12 - 36 44 26.4

Figure 5.9 Benefits provided by debit card

40

Page 40: 53418359 a Comparitive Study of Plastic Money With Reference to Credit Card Debit Card

8/6/2019 53418359 a Comparitive Study of Plastic Money With Reference to Credit Card Debit Card

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/53418359-a-comparitive-study-of-plastic-money-with-reference-to-credit-card 40/54

14.4 14.4

19.1

2526.4

0

5

10

15

20

25

30

w e i g h t e d a v g

no of respondents(weightedaverage)

14.4 14.4 19.16 25 26.4

securityfree from

fraudno interest

chargesanytimeaccess

easy tocarry

Interpretation: From the above collected data it is clear that respondents are highly

dissatisfied with the security matters relating to debit card. After calculating the weighted

average it is clear that mostly respondents believed that it is easy to carry but they are

highly dissatisfied with security and frauds

10: Benefits provided by credit cards.

41

Page 41: 53418359 a Comparitive Study of Plastic Money With Reference to Credit Card Debit Card

8/6/2019 53418359 a Comparitive Study of Plastic Money With Reference to Credit Card Debit Card

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/53418359-a-comparitive-study-of-plastic-money-with-reference-to-credit-card 41/54

Respondents were asked to rank the benefits provided by credit card on a scale. The

result is as follows:

Table 5.10: Benefits provided by credit cards

Wi 1 2 3 4 5Options (Xi) Strongly

disagree

(no.

of

responden

ts)

disagree

(no. of respondents)

Neither agree

Nor disagree

(no. of respondents)

agree

(no. of respondents)

Strongly

agree(no. of respondents)

Weighte

average

Easy to

carry

8 12 - 36 44 26.4

Convenient to

pay

2 4 - 42 52 27

Overdraft

facility

14 24 4 36 22 22

Prestige to

holder

10 8 2 44 36 25

Figure 5.10 Benefits provided by credit cards

42

Page 42: 53418359 a Comparitive Study of Plastic Money With Reference to Credit Card Debit Card

8/6/2019 53418359 a Comparitive Study of Plastic Money With Reference to Credit Card Debit Card

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/53418359-a-comparitive-study-of-plastic-money-with-reference-to-credit-card 42/54

26.4 27

22

25

0

5

10

15

20

25

30

w e

i g h t e d

a v g

no of respondents(weightedaverage)

26.4 27 22 25

easy tocarry

convienentto pay

overdraftfacility

prestige toholder

Interpretation: from the above study it can be seen that respondents agreed that credit

card is easy to carry and it give prestige to the holder. After calculating weighted average

it is clear that convenient to pay is the most preferred benefit among respondents.

11. Problems faced in processing the card

43

Page 43: 53418359 a Comparitive Study of Plastic Money With Reference to Credit Card Debit Card

8/6/2019 53418359 a Comparitive Study of Plastic Money With Reference to Credit Card Debit Card

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/53418359-a-comparitive-study-of-plastic-money-with-reference-to-credit-card 43/54

Respondents were asked to rank the problems provided by card. The result are as follows:

Table 5.11: Problems faced in processing the card

Wi 1 2 3 4 5Options (Xi) Strongly

disagree

(no.

of

respondents

)

disagree

(no. of

respondents)

Neither agree

Nor disagree

(no. of respondents)

agree

(no. of respondents)

Stronglyagree

(no. of respondents)

Weigd

Aver

Feeling

of

insecurity

10 12 2 38 38 25

Fear of loosing

card

8 10 - 36 46 25

Unnecessary

formalities

8 12 4 36 40 22

High fee charged

by bank

8 6 32 54 2

Figure 5.11 Problems faced in processing the card

44

Page 44: 53418359 a Comparitive Study of Plastic Money With Reference to Credit Card Debit Card

8/6/2019 53418359 a Comparitive Study of Plastic Money With Reference to Credit Card Debit Card

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/53418359-a-comparitive-study-of-plastic-money-with-reference-to-credit-card 44/54

Interpretation: From the graph it is clear that that the cardholders have the problem in

processing the card .According the weighted average the problem which is faced by most

of the respondents is the high annual fee charged by the banks. They also face the problem

of loosing the card and being misused by some other person.

12. Future prospects of plastic money.

25 25

22

28

0

5

10

15

20

25

30

Weig

hted

avg

No of respondents (weightedaverage)

25 25 22 28

Feeling of Insecurity

Fear of loosingthe card

UnneceesaryFormalities

High feeCharged bybank

45

Page 45: 53418359 a Comparitive Study of Plastic Money With Reference to Credit Card Debit Card

8/6/2019 53418359 a Comparitive Study of Plastic Money With Reference to Credit Card Debit Card

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/53418359-a-comparitive-study-of-plastic-money-with-reference-to-credit-card 45/54

Respondents were asked to explain to future prospects of plastic money. The results are

as follows:

Table 5.12: Future prospects of plastic money.

Options No. of respondents %age of

respondentsRapid Growth 56 56%Steady Growth 32 32%Stagnant 4 4%Can’t Predict 6 6%Declining 2 2%

Figure 5.12 future prospects of plastic money

Interpretation: It is clear from the graph mostly people believe that the future of plastic

money is at boom. 56% believe that their will be steady growth and 32% are of the viewof steady growth.6% can’t predict anything.

FINDINGS

Following are the findings that are drawn from the study:

No of respondents

56%

32%

4% 6%2%

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

Rapid growth Steady growth Stagnant Can’t predict Declining

46

Page 46: 53418359 a Comparitive Study of Plastic Money With Reference to Credit Card Debit Card

8/6/2019 53418359 a Comparitive Study of Plastic Money With Reference to Credit Card Debit Card

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/53418359-a-comparitive-study-of-plastic-money-with-reference-to-credit-card 46/54

Respondent taken for this study are those who are using the plastic money in their

daily life.

62% of the respondents believe that plastic money is the currency of modern India.

56% of respondents own one debit card and 26%owns two debit cards.

People have less craze for credit card. Only 46% of the respondents have credit card.

Respondents mostly prefer the plastic money of ICICI bank and PNB.

34% using the cards for the last 3 years and the trend of plastic money have emerged

from the last few years.

Mostly people use the cards for shopping and withdrawl of money .plastic money is

mostly preferred at the time of shopping.

Debit card is more beneficial according to 36% respondents.

Debit card don’t provide security to the cardholders.

42% respondents are dissatisfied that debit card is free from fraud.

Mostly people agreed that debit card provide the facility of anytime access. Anytime

you can withdraw your money.

Credit card is convenient way to pay agreed by most of the respondents.

Credit card provide prestige to holders having the tie up with the famous card

companies it provides the sense of pride.

38% cardholder agreed that the plastic money holders have to tackle with the problem

of insecurity.

Cardholders have to fulfill the unnecessary formalities while obtaining the card.

Plastic money has a rapid growth in the coming years.

The growth credit card in India is still very slow. Companies are going really hard to

increase the sale of credit cars.

According to weighted average method the respondents highly satisfied that the debit

card is easy to carry and credit card provide convenience to pay.

LIMITATIONS

47

Page 47: 53418359 a Comparitive Study of Plastic Money With Reference to Credit Card Debit Card

8/6/2019 53418359 a Comparitive Study of Plastic Money With Reference to Credit Card Debit Card

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/53418359-a-comparitive-study-of-plastic-money-with-reference-to-credit-card 47/54

The limitations of a study are:

The result are based on primary data.

The accuracy of the result is also limited to the reliability of methods of

investigation, measurement and analysis of data.

There was lack of time.

The data collected may or may not be accurate because of the biasness from

respondent side.

Findings are not justified because each market player have their unique

characteristics of debit cards and credit cards. so its very difficult to decide which

bank has upper edge in plastic money.

RECOMMENDATIONS

48

Page 48: 53418359 a Comparitive Study of Plastic Money With Reference to Credit Card Debit Card

8/6/2019 53418359 a Comparitive Study of Plastic Money With Reference to Credit Card Debit Card

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/53418359-a-comparitive-study-of-plastic-money-with-reference-to-credit-card 48/54

Various offers and discounts should be provided on the plastic money so that all

the users feel satisfied with their card choice.

The interest charges on credit cards should be reduced so that people are

encouraged to use it in regular routine

More facility should be provided to the cardholder in order to satisfy them

completely.

There should be more sales executives to reinforce new customers.

More outlets should be provided where the cards can be easily accepted.

The unnecessary formalities should be reduced in order to obtain the plastic

money.

Advertisements should be given through TVs, magazines and hoarding to have

maximum reach because the respondents perceive these as important promotional

tools.

The whole procedure of obtaining the plastic money needs to be authentic.

Companies should provide security to the cardholders.

Companies should reduce the amount of the annual fee charged on the cards.

49

Page 49: 53418359 a Comparitive Study of Plastic Money With Reference to Credit Card Debit Card

8/6/2019 53418359 a Comparitive Study of Plastic Money With Reference to Credit Card Debit Card

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/53418359-a-comparitive-study-of-plastic-money-with-reference-to-credit-card 49/54

CONCLUSION

In the last two years, spending pattern through plastic money has changed drastically.

Travelling, dining and jewellery are the top three purchases that Indians make through

credit cards. Two years ago, it was jewellery and apparel purchases that formed the

largest chunk of purchases through plastic money. Fuel accounts for a very small portion

of credit card purchases as these are largely paid through debit cards.

Consumers were not only more open to the possibility of owning a financial card, but

were also more than willing to use their cards to settle dues. The status symbol aspect of owning and using cards, too, played its part in bringing about such robust growth over the

space of a single year. Debit cards, in particular, proved immensely popular.

According to projections for the 2003-2008 period, the number of financial cards in

circulation will register a compounded annual growth rate of nearly 51 per cent so the

satisfaction of consumers has also increased. There are many ethical issues and

challenges for plastic money issuing banks/companies. Security relating to card should be

first priority for each bank/company.Consumers are preferring these cards mostly for shopping online E-commerce has given

a better way to use the plastic money.

At last it is concluded that plastic money has a very bright future in the coming years

because of the increasing trend of e-commerce.

50

Page 50: 53418359 a Comparitive Study of Plastic Money With Reference to Credit Card Debit Card

8/6/2019 53418359 a Comparitive Study of Plastic Money With Reference to Credit Card Debit Card

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/53418359-a-comparitive-study-of-plastic-money-with-reference-to-credit-card 50/54

BIBLIOGRAPHY

Kothari C.R, “Research Methodology: Research and Techniques”; Vishwa Prakshan,

New Delhi, 4 th edition.

E.gordan and Natrajan, Financial Services, Himalaya Publishing House, Mumbai . , 5th

edition.

• ARTICLES

Cunningham Julie, Kansas State University ,article “College Student Using The

Credit Card” Nov’ 98

Loebecke.S Elliot, article “Smart Card Based Electronic Commerce Characteristics

And Roles” Jan’ 98

Swift, Kevin, article “Credit Card and Debit Cards: What New? Where To?” ,May’

1998

Hayashi fumiko and weiner Stuart E. ,article “Competition And Credit And Debit

Card Interchange Fees” ,Sept’2005

Chakravorti ,Sujit ,article “Theory Of Credit Card Networks: A Survey Of Literature“June 03 2003

Hunt Robert ,article “An Introduction To The Economics Of Payment Card

Networks”

Chartered financial analyst ,article “Credit Card Crisis In South Korea” 2003

Chartered financial analyst ,article “Ethical Issues And Challenges” ,Nov 2007

WEBSITEShttp://www.rba.gov.au/PaymentsSystem/Publications/BISCommitteeOnPayment

AndSettlementSystems/retail.pdf

http://www.federalreserve.gov/boarddocs/speeches/2001/20011205/default.htm

http://www.icicibank.com/pfsuser/cards/creditcard/cc_home.htm

51

Page 51: 53418359 a Comparitive Study of Plastic Money With Reference to Credit Card Debit Card

8/6/2019 53418359 a Comparitive Study of Plastic Money With Reference to Credit Card Debit Card

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/53418359-a-comparitive-study-of-plastic-money-with-reference-to-credit-card 51/54

http://www.direct.gov.uk/en/MoneyTaxAndBenefits/ManagingMoney/BankAcco

untsAndBankingProducts/DG_10035158

http://www.paypal.com/cgi-bin/webscr?

cmd=xpt/cps/account/VDCFrequentlyAskedQuestions-outside

http://finance.indiamart.com/investment_in_india/plastic_money.htm

QUESTIONNAIRE

Dear sir/madam

I am the student of RIMT in Mandi Gobindgrah and topic of my project report is

“Comparative Study of Plastic Money with special Reference to Debit Cards and Credit

Cards”. I want your cooperation to fill this questionnaire related to my project.

Q1.Do you use plastic money?

(i) yes

(ii) No

Q2.Which card do you have?

(i) Debit card

(ii) Credit card

(iii) Both

Q3.How many no. of debit cards of different companies owned by you?

(i) 1

(ii) 2

(iii) 3

(iv) None

Q4 How many no. of credit cards of different companies owned by you?

(i) 1

(ii) 2

52

Page 52: 53418359 a Comparitive Study of Plastic Money With Reference to Credit Card Debit Card

8/6/2019 53418359 a Comparitive Study of Plastic Money With Reference to Credit Card Debit Card

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/53418359-a-comparitive-study-of-plastic-money-with-reference-to-credit-card 52/54

(i) 3

(ii) None

Q5: Which companies /bank card do you have?

(i) HDFC Bank

(ii) ICICI Bank

(iii) IDBI Bank

(iii) Centurion Bank

(v) Any Other If yes, specify……………….

Q6: Since how long you have been using debit card/credit card/both?(i) Less than 1 yr

(ii) Between 1yr-3yr

(iii) Between 3yr-5yr

(iv) More than 5 yr

Q7: Normally for what purpose do you use cards? Rank according to your preference

(i) shopping

(ii) withdrawal of money

(iii) Petrol filling

(iv) Hotel & Restaurants

(v) Any other (going to theater etc)

Q8: Which card according to you is more beneficial?

(i) Debit Card

(ii) Credit Card

(iv) Both

Q9: What are the benefits provided by debit cards?

Strongly disagree neither agree agree stronglyDisagree nor disagree agree

(i) Security

53

Page 53: 53418359 a Comparitive Study of Plastic Money With Reference to Credit Card Debit Card

8/6/2019 53418359 a Comparitive Study of Plastic Money With Reference to Credit Card Debit Card

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/53418359-a-comparitive-study-of-plastic-money-with-reference-to-credit-card 53/54

(ii) Free From Fraud

(iii) No Interest Charges

(iv) Anytime Access

(v) easy to carry

Q10: What are the benefits provided by credit cards?

Strongly disagree neither agree agree stronglyDisagree nor disagree agree

(i) Easy To Carry

(ii) Convenient to Pay

(iii) Overdraft Facility

(iv) Prestige to Holder

Q11: What are the problems you are facing in processing the card?

Strongly disagree neither agree agree stronglydisagree nor disagreeagree

(i) feeling of insecurity

(ii) fear of loosing the card

(iii) Unnecessary formalities

(iv) High fee collected

by banksQ12::What are the future prospects of plastic money?

(i) Rapid Growth

(ii) Steady Growth

(iii) Stagnant

(iv) Can’t Predict

(v) Declining

Personal information:

Name:

Address:

Occupation:

54

Page 54: 53418359 a Comparitive Study of Plastic Money With Reference to Credit Card Debit Card

8/6/2019 53418359 a Comparitive Study of Plastic Money With Reference to Credit Card Debit Card

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/53418359-a-comparitive-study-of-plastic-money-with-reference-to-credit-card 54/54