4th quarter 2018 early intervention system report · de-escalation techniques use of force...

4th Quarter 2018

Early Intervention System Report

San Francisco Police Department

Legal Division

Public Safety Building

1245 3rd Street, Room #1025

EARLY INTERVENTION SYSTEM PERFORMANCE INDICATORSINDICATORS ASSOCIATED FACTORS

Citizen Compliment

Department Awards

Arrests by Officer

Citations by Officer

Reports by Officer Vehicle Stops

Pedestrian Stops

Training History

Voluntary Overtime worked

Discretionary Time Off

Sick Pay not protected by

Fed/State

Participant in Critical

Incident

Criminal Cases

Dismissed

Charges of Assault on an

Officer

Charges of Resisting an

Officer

Use of Force DPA

OIS OID

EEO IAD

Civil Suit

Tort Claim

On Duty Collision

Vehicle Pursuit

REVIEW BY EIS SERGEANT

Supervisory Performance Review?

Indicator-Related Documents

Factors-Related Documents

EIS THRESHOLD ACTIVATION

NO

YES

CLOSE

REVIEW BY SUPERVISOR(S)?

Pattern of at-risk behavior?

YES/NO

VERIFICATION BY EIS SERGEANT

Pattern of at-risk behavior?

YES

NO CLOSE

INTERVENTION1

4th Q 2018 Alerts 3+ UOF within 3 mo 95 3+ OCC within 6 mo 4 5+ indicators within 6 mo 34 4+ OCC within 12 mo 2 6+ indicators within 12 mo 58

TOTAL 193

Members Receiving Alerts 91 members had 1 alert 36 members had 2 alerts 10 members had 3 alerts

137 members had at least 1 alert

As of December 31, 2018, there were 2,330 members. This means 5.9% (137) of total members had at least 1

2

Active Interventions Members Intervention received in each instance

Failure to Appear in Court 2 Mentoring Mentoring

Tactical Communication 3 UOF training at

academy, Mentoring

Post-certified tactical communication training,

Mentoring

Post-certified tactical communication training,

Mentoring

Failure to Appear:

• Mentoringo Create a physical and electronic calendaro Monitoring of calendar by supervisor and subordinate

Track subpoenas Track PT and Range times

o Supervisor reviews DGOs and department bulletins with subordinateo Clear explanation of expectations and consequenceso Schedule follow-ups (30/60/90/180 days) to sit down and review progress

Tactical Communication:

• Mentoringo Supervisor reviews DGOs and department bulletins with subordinateo Clear explanation of expectations and consequenceso Schedule follow-ups (30/60/90/180 days) to review progresso One-on-one session with the instructor from the Academy course "Tactical Communication"o POST Learning Portal Class on Tactical Communicationo Supervisor arrives on scene to monitor subordinateo Supervisor requires subordinate to activate body camera on all calls for serviceo Supervisor monitors DPA Complaints

• Use of Force Trainingo One-on-one session with Defensive Tactics Instructors at the Academy

Proper handcuffing techniques De-escalation techniques Use of Force documentation Tactical positioning Review of Defensive Tactics Manual

o Supervisor schedules follow-up (30/60/90 days) to review progresso Supervisor reviews DGOs and department bulletins with subordinateo Supervisor reviews all Use of Force reportso Supervisor monitors DPA Complaints

Members Receiving Interventions 2015 Interventions 9 2016 Interventions 4 2017 Interventions 3

Active Interventions 5

Interventions Outside EIS 2017 (partial year) 2018 (1st Q)

Formal Counseling 19 9 Informal Counseling 146 90

PIPs 14 3

3

EIS Alerts by Quarter

OIS OID 3+

UOF 3+

DPA Any 5 4+ DPA Any 6 Monthly

Total Quarterly

Total

4th Q 2017

October 29 9 1 27 66 223 November 1 41 10 1 26 79

December 3 40 2 8 25 78

1st Q 2018

January 37 2 8 15 62 216 February 10 33 11 1 20 75

March 12 1 38 1 11 1 15 79

2nd Q 2018

April 2 33 1 9 18 63 200 May 2 1 27 1 6 23 60

June 1 31 2 16 1 26 77

3rd Q 2018

July 1 33 5 14 20 73 222 August 37 3 9 1 31 81

September 37 2 8 21 68

4th Q 2018

October 36 1 14 25 76 193 November 30 2 10 2 18 62

December 29 1 10 15 55 TOTAL 32 2 511 23 153 8 325 1054 1054

4

4th Q 2018 Alerts by Station 3+ UOF 3+ DPA Any 5 4+ DPA Any 6 TOTAL

Mission 23 9 8 40 Central 21 4 10 35 Tenderloin 9 1 7 1 9 27 Bayview 9 2 2 8 21 Northern 9 2 5 16 Southern 7 5 1 3 16 Ingleside 3 7 10 Richmond 4 3 7 Taraval 2 3 5 Park 1 1 1 3

TOTAL 88 4 32 2 54 180

5

4th Q 2018 Alerts by Unit 3+ UOF Any 5 Any 6 TOTAL MEDI 2 1 3 TACT 3 3 MTA 2 2 ACAD 1 1 AFOB 1 1 GTF 1 1 NIGH 1 1 SVU 1 1 TOTAL 7 2 4 13

6

Alerts by Station Trailing 12 Months

Jan 2018

Feb 2018

Mar 2018

Apr 2018

May 2018

Jun 2018

Jul 2018

Aug 2018

Sept 2018

Oct 2018

Nov 2018

Dec 2018 TOTAL

Mission 15 14 24 22 15 25 24 20 16 17 12 11 215 Bayview 18 15 14 7 8 10 6 9 9 7 6 8 117 Tenderloin 4 9 8 5 5 11 11 13 6 9 9 9 99 Central 4 3 5 3 2 7 12 11 12 9 16 10 94 Northern 7 11 5 5 13 5 7 5 8 9 3 4 82 Southern 4 9 6 7 5 9 4 9 7 7 5 4 76 Ingleside 4 3 6 5 4 3 1 6 4 3 4 3 46 Richmond 5 2 3 4 1 4 1 5 3 2 2 32 Taraval 4 4 3 1 2 4 3 2 23 Park 1 1 1 1 3 7

TOTAL 57 70 75 61 60 72 71 78 67 70 57 53 791

7

Alerts by Unit Trailing 12 Months

Jan

2018 Feb

2018 Mar 2018

Apr 2018

May 2018

Jun 2018

Jul 2018

Aug 2018

Sept 2018

Oct 2018

Nov 2018

Dec 2018 TOTAL

GTF 3 1 1 1 1 1 1 9 TACT 1 1 1 1 2 1 7 SVU 2 1 1 1 1 6 MEDI 1 2 1 4 CED 1 1 2 DOC 1 1 2 FOB 1 1 2 MTA 1 1 2 SID 1 1 2 ACAD 1 1 AFOB 1 1 MUNI 1 1 NIGH 1 1 TOTAL 5 5 4 2 0 5 2 3 1 6 5 2 40

8

Indicators per Member

Year Quarter 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 Total Members with 1+ Indicators

2016

1 1610 429 149 60 32 9 5 684 2 1739 374 144 69 33 13 3 3 639 3 1591 441 168 63 30 10 3 1 1 717 4 1598 429 150 77 36 16 2 4 1 715

2017

1 1581 441 162 52 26 8 4 1 694 2 1699 404 143 55 16 8 2 2 3 633 3 1727 379 134 53 16 7 2 2 593 4 1781 374 143 41 19 10 5 1 1 594

2018

1 1664 398 159 48 18 11 4 3 2 643 2 1715 374 129 51 18 3 2 1 578 3 1739 386 132 47 14 7 2 1 589 4 1814 370 100 25 14 3 2 2 516

Count of Indicators Year 1st Q 2nd Q 3rd Q 4th Q TOTAL 2016 1110 1105 1169 1232 4616 2017 1096 1009 933 955 3993 2018 1048 891 901 742 3582

Count of Members Year Quarter Sworn Members

2016

1 2294 2 2378 3 2308 4 2313

2017

1 2275 2 2332 3 2320 4 2375

2018

1 2307 2 2293 3 2328 4 2330

9

Indicators Over 3 Years

OIS OID UOF DPA IAD EEO Civil Suits

Tort Claims

Vehicle Pursuits

On-Duty Collision TOTAL

2016 5 7 2771 736 458 27 91 308 21 192 4616 2017 9 2 2514 594 425 34 42 207 166 3993 2018 21 2 2230 762 269 22 32 151 93 3582

10

4th Q 2018 Indicators by Month


Tort Claims


Oct 2018 179 56 13 10 24 6 288

Nov 2018 155 35 14 15 219

Dec 2018 171 37 15 1 11 235

Oct - Dec 2017 3 603 141 114 9 9 30 46 955

Oct - Dec 2018 505 128 42 11 50 6 742

11

Indicators by Month Trailing 12 Months OIS OID UOF DPA IAD EEO Civil Suits Tort Claims On-Duty Collision TOTAL

Jan 2018 218 59 37 2 4 13 18 351

Feb 2018 7 227 65 43 7 4 8 14 375

Mar 2018 12 1 188 72 22 2 1 18 6 322

Apr 2018 161 69 22 1 11 12 276

May 2018 1 1 139 115 17 3 6 9 11 302

June 2018 1 212 66 10 5 11 8 313

July 2018 197 81 22 10 4 314

Aug 2018 203 74 29 1 6 6 319

Sept 2018 180 33 25 1 6 15 8 268

Oct 2018 179 56 13 10 24 6 288

Nov 2018 155 35 14 15 219

Dec 2018 171 37 15 1 11 235

Jan - Dec 2017 9 2 2514 594 425 34 42 207 166 3993

Jan - Dec 2018 21 2 2230 762 269 22 32 151 93 3582

12

4th Q Indicators by Station


Tort Claims


Central 91 12 1 6 110 Mission 64 20 4 5 2 95 Tenderloin 52 15 5 2 1 1 76 Southern 39 13 6 4 62 Ingleside 44 9 2 5 2 62 Bayview 42 8 2 2 2 56 Northern 44 7 3 54 Taraval 19 14 33 Richmond 22 6 4 32 Park 23 3 2 2 30

TOTAL 0 0 440 107 29 0 4 25 5 610

13

4th Q Indicators by Unit


Tort Claims


TACT 19 1 3 11 34 CED 6 4 1 11 MEDI 4 1 1 4 10 MTA 4 2 1 1 1 9 SEPA 7 7 AFOB 6 6 SVU 5 1 6 BURG 3 2 5 NARC 2 2 1 5 CIS 1 1 1 1 4 SID 2 1 1 4 CGIC 1 1 1 3 DOC 3 3 GTF 2 1 3 ACAD 1 1 2 CHIE 1 1 2 LEGA 1 1 2 NIGH 2 2 PROF 1 1 2 RISK 2 2 ADMI 1 1 AIRP 1 1 CSI 1 1 FOB 1 1 HSU 1 1 IAD 1 1 Muni 1 1 ROBB 1 1 SOB 1 1 STAF 1 1 TOTAL 0 0 65 21 13 0 7 25 1 132

14

Indicators by Station Trailing 12 Months (Jan 2018- Dec 2018)


Tort Claims


Mission 9 332 86 26 1 12 9 475 Central 1 267 75 25 3 2 12 7 392 Tenderloin 1 246 92 21 6 7 9 382 Bayview 219 55 16 4 20 8 322 Northern 4 198 59 21 6 2 290 Southern 192 54 23 1 9 6 285 Ingleside 1 158 61 15 1 2 13 8 259 Taraval 115 46 10 3 4 4 182 Richmond 1 81 41 12 1 1 7 4 148 Park 67 32 12 1 3 7 122

TOTAL 16 1 1875 601 181 8 18 93 64 2857

15

INDICATORS BY UNIT TRAILING 12 MONTHS (JAN 2018 - DEC 2018)


Tort Claims


TACT 1 57 13 6 18 4 99 CED 2 49 26 8 1 6 92 MEDI 1 38 20 8 1 5 2 75 AFOB 30 15 9 4 1 2 61 SEPA 1 31 11 5 1 1 4 3 57 MTA 23 9 7 1 2 4 1 47 SVU 1 21 9 5 1 3 2 42 GTF 15 5 2 4 26 SID 13 3 1 2 19 BURG 8 6 0 1 3 18 CIS 8 2 3 2 1 1 17 DOC 3 1 12 16 NARC 5 2 0 2 3 12 HOMI 5 2 2 2 11 Muni 8 3 11 ACAD 2 6 1 1 10 CSI 1 1 3 2 3 10 LEGA 8 2 10 ROBB 5 2 1 2 10 FOB 5 2 1 1 9 IAD 6 1 0 1 1 9 NIGH 8 1 0 9 STAF 1 3 1 2 2 9 CGIC 2 2 1 1 1 7 PROF 2 3 1 1 7 TCI 4 3 0 7 HSU 1 3 1 1 6 RISK 1 3 0 2 6 CHIE 2 0 1 3 ADMI 1 0 1 2 ADMN 1 0 1 2 AIRP 1 1 0 2 COS 1 0 1 PROP 1 1 SOB 0 1 1 TECH 1 1

TOTAL 5 1 355 161 88 14 14 58 29 725

16

Use of Force (previous 4 quarters) Use of Force

Incidents Members

Using Force Count of Subjects

Applications of Force

1st Q 2018

334 633 403 814

2nd Q 2018

316 513 371 601

3rd Q 2018

355 580 406 660

4th Q 2018

301 505 354 635

1st - 4th Q 2016-2018, w/ and w/o pointing Use of Force

Incidents Members

Using Force Count of Subjects

Applications of Force

1st-4th Q 2016

1417 2781 1873 3747

w/o Pointing

644 1052 661 1142

1st-4th Q 2017

1361 2512 1699 3513

w/o Pointing

617 1051 640 1112

1st-4th Q 2018

1304 2231 1534 2710

w/o Pointing

718 1124 752 1221

Incidents can involve numerous members, subjects, and types of force applied. This is a count of report numbers.

Count of Members/Subjects is the number of members/ subjects involved in each incident.

Applications of Force is the total count of force types used by each member per subject.

18

Applications of Force 2018 Type of Force 1st Q 2nd Q 3rd Q 4th Q TOTAL

Pointing of Firearms 525 337 284 343 1489 Physical Control 171 118 223 166 678 Strike by Object/Fist 67 92 105 75 339 Impact Weapon 17 22 21 13 73 OC 6 18 8 11 43 Other 2 4 8 18 32 ERIW 6 4 6 6 22 Firearm 19 2 21 Spike Strips 1 4 5 3 13

TOTAL 814 601 660 635 2710

19

1st -4th Q 2018 Use of Force

Incidents Members

1st Q 2nd Q % ∆ 3rd Q % ∆ 4th Q % ∆ 1st Q 2nd Q % ∆ 3rd Q % ∆ 4th Q % ∆ Pointing of Firearms 183 163 -11% 144 -12% 150 4% 387 273 -29% 231 -15% 262 13% Physical Control 110 81 -26% 144 78% 116 -19% 171 118 -31% 223 89% 165 -26% Strike by Object/Fist 48 63 31% 76 21% 54 -29% 66 90 36% 105 17% 75 -29% Impact Weapon 16 17 6% 19 12% 13 -32% 17 19 12% 21 11% 13 -38% OC 6 18 200% 8 -56% 9 13% 6 18 200% 8 -56% 9 13% Other 2 2 0% 6 200% 13 117% 2 2 0% 8 300% 16 100% ERIW 5 4 -20% 4 0% 2 -50% 6 4 -33% 6 50% 6 0% Firearm 3 2 -33% -100% 0% 19 2 -89% -100% 0% Spike Strips 1 2 100% 2 0% 1 -50% 1 2 100% 2 0% 1 -50%

TOTAL 374 352 -6% 403 14% 358 -11% 675 528 -22% 604 14% 547 -9%

Subjects Applications

1st Q 2nd Q % ∆ 3rd Q % ∆ 4th Q % ∆ 1st Q 2nd Q % ∆ 3rd Q % ∆ 4th Q % ∆ Pointing of Firearms 248 204 -18% 182 -11% 195 7% 525 337 -36% 284 -16% 343 21% Physical Control 110 83 -25% 145 75% 117 -19% 171 118 -31% 223 89% 166 -26% Strike by Object/Fist 49 67 37% 78 16% 55 -29% 67 92 37% 105 14% 75 -29% Impact Weapon 16 21 31% 19 -10% 13 -32% 17 22 29% 21 -5% 13 -38% OC 6 18 200% 8 -56% 11 38% 6 18 200% 8 -56% 11 38% Other 2 4 100% 6 50% 15 150% 2 4 100% 8 100% 18 125% ERIW 5 4 -20% 4 0% 2 -50% 6 4 -33% 6 50% 6 0% Firearm 3 2 -33% -100% 0% 19 2 -89% -100% 0% Spike Strips 1 4 300% 5 25% 3 -40% 1 4 300% 5 25% 3 -40%

TOTAL 440 407 -8% 447 10% 411 -8% 814 601 -26% 660 10% 635 -4%

20