3.review of literature 3-12-2012
TRANSCRIPT
-
8/13/2019 3.Review of Literature 3-12-2012
1/24
Review of Related Literature
3.1 Literature Review on Conceptulisation of Value Added
3.2 Literature Review on conceptulisation of Value Added Statement (VAS)
3.3 Literature Review on Usefulness of Value Added Statement (VAS)
3. Literature Review on VAS as a tool of !erformance "valuation
3.# Literature Review on "conomic Value Added ("VA)
3.$ Literature Review on %ar&et Value Added (%VA)
3.' Literature Review on Relationsip etween "VA and %VA
3.* Summar+
-
8/13/2019 3.Review of Literature 3-12-2012
2/24
A literature review is desi,ned to identif+ related researc- to set te
current researc proect witin a conceptual and teoretical conte/t. 0t is
,enerall+ carried out to &now aout te e/istin, practices and to fasten teresearc process. Under tis ac&drop- te present capter covers an overview of
Value Added Accountin, and Reportin,. or te purpose an e/tensive surve+ was
made on literature availale on te suect and found more tan 1# articles-
oo&s and researc reports pulised on te suect since 1#. 4e researc
pulised concentrated mainl+ on te
Conceptulisation of Value Added
Conceptulisation of Value Added Statement (VAS)-
Usefulness of Value Added Statement (VAS)-
VAS as a tool of !erformance "valuation-
"conomic Value Added ("VA)-
%ar&et Value Added (%VA)- and
Relationsip etween "VA and %VA
3.1 Literature Review on Conceptulisation of Value Added
Morely, (19'*)1defined Value added is te value- wic te entit+ as
added in a period tat e5uals its sales less ou,t6in6,oods and services (). 0n
terms of e5uation it ma+ e e/pressed as follows7
Value added 8 Sales 9 :ou,t6in6,oods and services.
ICAI, (19!)2defines Value added is te increase in mar&et value rou,t
1%icael . %orle+- ;4e Value Added Statement in :ritain
-
8/13/2019 3.Review of Literature 3-12-2012
3/24
aout + an alteration in te form- location or availailit+ of a product or service
e/cludin, te cost of ou,t6in6materials and services. 4is can e e/pressed in
te followin, e5uation7
Value added 8 Value after alteration 9 Value efore alteration
"rown and#oward (199$)3- te value added can e measured as te sales
value less te cost of ou,t6in6,oods and services used in producin, tose sales.
Van %taden ($&&&',Value added as een defined as te value created +
te activities of a firm and its emplo+ees> i.e. sales less te cost of ou,t6in6
,oods and services.
L. %tain)an* ($&&9) stated tat- Value added is te surplus of sales revenueplus oter incomes from ,oods and services over te cost of ou,t6in6,oods and
services from outside.
Ru++les!is of te view tat- ;te value added + a firm- i.e. te value
created + te activities of te firm and its emplo+ees alone- can e measured +
te difference etween te mar&et value of te ,oods tat ave een turned out
+ te firm and te cost of tose ,oods and materials purcased from oter firms.
Annual %urvey of Industries (A%I'descried value added as tat part of te
value of te products wic is created in te factor+ and is computed +
deductin, from te ,ross e/6factor+ value of output- te ,ross value of input. 4e
terms ?te ,ross e/6factor+ value of output@ and ?te ,ross value of input@
correspond wit tose of ?te mar&et value of ,oods tat ave een turned out@
and ?te cost of tose ,oods and materials purcased from oter firm@
2lossar+ of te 0nstitute of Cartered Accountants of 0ndia- Sept. 1*3.
3:rown- =.L. and Boward L.R7 %ana,erial Accountin, inance- London7 4e "n,lis Lan,ua,e :oo&
Societ+- 1*2- p. *1.
4 Van Staden- C.=. (2)- Revisitin, te Value Added Statement7 4o !ulis or Dot to !ulis in
!roceedin,s of te 12tAsian pacific Conference on 0nternational Accountin, 0ssues- Ectoer.
5Ru,,les- R7 Dational 0ncome and 0ncome Anal+sis- Dew For&- %craw Bill :oo& Co.- 1- p.$
$Annual Surve+ of 0ndustries- C.S.E.- 1$$- Vol 0- p. /viii
-
8/13/2019 3.Review of Literature 3-12-2012
4/24
respectivel+. 4us in accountin,- value added is te e/cess of ?output@ over
?input@. %atematicall+ it can e e/pressed as follows7
Value Added (VA) 8 (ross e/6factor+ value of output) 9
(ross value of 0nput)
Gere-
Eutput 8 (a,,re,ate value of products H wor& done for customers H Sales
value of ,oods sold in te same condition as ou,t I stoc& of semi6
finised ,oods)
0nput 8 ross value of materials- fuel etc- wor& done + oter concerns for
te firm- non6industrial service ou,t- depreciation and purcase valueof ,oods sold in te same condition as ou,t.
Lewis and -endrill (19' mentioned tat- ;Value added ma+ e
calculated as te difference etween te value of ,oods or services produced +
te team- i.e. sales revenue- less te value of ,oods and services purcased from
outsiders- i.e. te cost of ou,t in materials and services.
/0e epart2ent of Co22erce, United States e/pressed tat- ;Value
Added + manufacturer is calculated + sutractin, te cost of materials-
suppliers and containers- fuel purcased- electric ener,+ and contract wor& from
te total value of sipments. 0n tat it appro/imates te value created in te
process of manufacturer- value added provides te most satisfactor+ measure of
te relative economic importance of ,iven industries in te census of
manufactures.
CIMA ter2inolo+ydefines te term value added as- ;4e increase in te
mar&et value resultin, from an alteration in te form- location or availailit+ of a
7Lewis- Ricard and !endrill Javid7 Advanced inancial Accountin,- London7 !itman !ulisin, Ltd.1*'- p. ##28
Cartered 0nstitute of %ana,ement Accountants- 4e Cartered 0nstitute of %ana,ement
Accountants- 2# edition- p23
-
8/13/2019 3.Review of Literature 3-12-2012
5/24
product or service- e/cludin, te cost of ou,t out materials or services
-
8/13/2019 3.Review of Literature 3-12-2012
6/24
Value Added Statement ma+ e defined as a statement wic sows te siKe
of te ?value added ca&e@ and ow te ?ca&e@ as een divided amon,st te
various sta&eolders (%i5er, 199)11.
Value Added Statement (VAS) reveals te value added + an enterprisewic it as een ale to ,enerate and its distriution amon, tose contriutin,
to its ,eneration &nown as sta&eolders (ICAI, 19!)12.
Value Added Statement ma+ e defined as te performance of an
or,aniKation to wat e/tent te enterprise as added value durin, a particular
period to te providers of capital- emplo+ees- ,overnment and reinvestment of
te ,rowt and e/pansion (A+arwal, $&&$'13.
Value Added Statement is a report wic sows te amount and te sources
of value added durin, some specified period of time. 0n oter words- it is also
descried as e/tra wealt created + sellin, ,oods and services to te customers.
So it is entitled as ?wealt ,enerated and distriuted@ (Rao, 1999'1.
4e value added statement reports on te calculation of value added and its
application amon, te sta&eolders in te compan+ (V. %taden, $&&&)1#
4us a Value Added Statement is a statement- wic sows te income of
te compan+ as an entit+ and ow tat is divided etween te people wo ave
contriuted to its creation. Gile te income statement reports on te income of
sareolders- te value added statement reports on te income earned + a lar,e
,roup of sta&eolders7 providers of capital plus emplo+ees and te ,overnment.
11 SiKer- =on7 An 0nsi,t into %ana,ement Accountin,- London7 !itman !ulisin, Ltd.- 1'- p.3#
12
0CA0- - lossar+ of terms- !rentice Ball of 0ndia- Dew Jeli- 1*#13A,rawal- R.S.- 22- Value Added Statement6 A etter performance indicator6 A case stud+ of %%4C-
4e %ana,ement Accountant- Jec. 2*- p6*6.
14 !.%. Rao- Value Added Reportin,7 0n 4eor+- !ractice and Researc- Jeep and Jeep !ulications2- !! *$
15Van Staden- C.=. (2)- Revisitin, te Value Added Statement7 4o !ulis or Dot to !ulis in
!roceedin,s of te 12tAsian pacific Conference on 0nternational Accountin, 0ssues, Ectoer.
-
8/13/2019 3.Review of Literature 3-12-2012
7/24
Since VAS represents ow te value or wealt created or ,enerated + an entit+ is
sared amon, different sta&eolders- it is si,nificant from te national point of
view. 4erefore- VAS represents a move in a new and different direction for
financial reportin,.
3.3 Literature Review on 6sefulness of Value Added %tate2ent (VA%'
L.7. %tain)an*, (1991)1$in is article ?te value added statement7 does it
add an+ valueM@ %editari Accountanc+ Researc- Vol. 1' 0ss7 2- pp.13' 9 1-
surve+ed te preparers of value added statements and finall+ concluded tat it is
desirale to prepare a value added statement.
C.7. Van %taden, (199)1'N4e usefulness of te value6added statement in
Sout AfricaN- %ana,erial inance- Vol. 2 0ss7 11- pp. 9 #- Reports a surve+ of
representatives of all financial statement user ,roups in Sout Africa to assess
teir use of VASs- teir prolems- possile future uses and te information
needsOdecisions ein, affected. Compares past and present use of VASs- discusses
teir sortcomin,s and concludes tat te+ sould not e pulised in Sout Africa
an+ more.
8ary Mee* %idney 8ray (19'1ar,ued tat value added statements
(VAS) would sow profits in a format tat would e easil+ understood and usale
+ all sta&eolders rater tan ust te sareolders. 4e VAS sows ow value
created + a compan+ is used to pa+ tose sta&eolders wic created te wealt
or value added. %oreover- te+ identified four areas tat would enefit from VAS
reportin,7 measurin, wealt created + te compan+- empasiKin, sta&eolder
interdependence- conditionin, emplo+ee e/pectations of pa+ and prospects- and
16Stainan&- L. 11 .4e value added statement 6 its nature and purpose- % Com 4esis- Universit+ of
Datal- Juran.
1' C.=. van Staden- (1*) N4e usefulness of te value6added statement in Sout AfricaN-%ana,erial inance- Vol. 2 0ss7 11- pp. 9 #
18ar+ %ee& Sidne+ ra+ (1**)- ?4e Value Added Statement7 An innovation for U S companies-Accountin, BoriKons- pp'36*1
-
8/13/2019 3.Review of Literature 3-12-2012
8/24
estalisin, productivit+ incentive pro,rams. %easurin, and reportin, wealt
trou, VAS would raise te ,eneral pulic@s awareness of a compan+@s activities-
enefitin, te compan+ and te pulic. 0t is noted tat tou, income received
te most attention- ut are not te most effective wa+ to sow a compan+@s
performance. 4e VAS empasiKes te interdependence of te sta&eolders +
sowin, ow sources of income are paid to emplo+ees- ,overnments- providers of
capital- and te usiness. Mee* and 8ray (199'wrote tat VAS would enefit
emplo+ees + conditionin, teir e/pectations for pa+ and + formin, a asis for
productivit+ incentive pro,rams.
C. R. %ar*ar . C. andi, ($&11)1 in teir stud+ on ?Corporate Social
!erformance trou, Value Added Reportin,7 A case stud+ of Bindustan !etroleumCorporation Ltd@ concluded tat mana,ement of te compan+ as not onl+
improved its profitailit+ ut as also fulfilled its responsiilit+ towards te
societ+ at lar,e + pulisin, VAS.
"rown andRao, ($&&&)2opines tat te Value Added Statement sows te
total wealt created and ow it was distriuted- ta&in, into account te amounts
retained and reinvested in te ,roup for te replacement of assets and
development of operations. 4e value added statement sows te total wealt
created- ow it was distriuted to meet certain oli,ations and reward tose
responsile for its creation- and te portion retained for te continued operation
and e/pansion.
0n addition- a numer of surve+s ave een conducted amon, companies
pulisin, te statement (Mayne, 1999)21. 4ese surve+s found little evidence of
actual use. 4e companies used te statement mostl+ for emplo+ee
19C. R. Sar&ar andDandi- . C. (211)7 Value Added 0ncome7 An Accountin, !oint of View- 0ndian
=ournal of !ulic "nterprise- 0nstitute of !ulic "nterprise Researc- B+deraad.
20 :rown and Rao (2)- Corporate Social !erformance trou, Value Added Reportin,- =ournal ofAccountin, and inance- Volume 1- Dumer 1- %arc- 2
21%a+ne- =. (1)- Addressin, Attriution trou, Contriution Anal+sis7 Usin, !erformance %easures
Sensil+. Ettawa
http://www.academia.edu/315016/Journal_of_Accounting_and_Finance_._Volume_1_Number_1_March_2009http://www.academia.edu/315016/Journal_of_Accounting_and_Finance_._Volume_1_Number_1_March_2009http://www.academia.edu/315016/Journal_of_Accounting_and_Finance_._Volume_1_Number_1_March_2009http://www.academia.edu/315016/Journal_of_Accounting_and_Finance_._Volume_1_Number_1_March_2009 -
8/13/2019 3.Review of Literature 3-12-2012
9/24
communication and wa,e ne,otiations. 4e Corporate Report (1'#)
recommended- amon, oter tin,s- a statement of value added sowin, ow te
enefits of te efforts of an enterprise are sared + emplo+ees- providers of
capital- te state- and reinvestment.
Value added (tat is- sales income less materials and services purcased) is
te wealt te reportin, entit+ as een ale to create + its own and its
emplo+eesP efforts (Ria0i:"el*aoui, 1999)22. 4is statement would sow ow value
added as een used to pa+ tose contriutin, to its creation. 0t usefull+
elaorates on te profit and loss account and in time ma+ come to e re,arded as
a preferale wa+ of descriin, performance.
%in0a (193'$3sumits tat te statement of value added provides a useful
measure to elp in ,au,in, performance and activit+. 4e fi,ure of value added
can e a pointer to te net output of te firm> and + relatin, oter &e+ fi,ures
(for e/ample- capital emplo+ed and emplo+ee costs) si,nificant indicators of
performance ma+ e otained.
Gile income statement reports on te income of sareolders- te value
added statement reports on te income earned + a lar,e ,roup of sta&eolders6
providers of capital plus emplo+ees and te ,overnment. VAS reveals te VA + an
enterprise wic it as een ale to ,enerate and its distriution amon, tose
contriutin, to its ,eneration &nown as sta&eolders(ICAI, 19!'$.
4e ,rowt of value added reportin, was elped + trade
union support of te concept. A document produced + one of te trade unions
stated- N4e ederation terefore aims to encoura,e te use of te added value as
a discipline- so tat all mana,ers- wit or witout e/perience of accountin,
22 Riai6:el&aoui- A. 1."arnin,s6Returns Relation versus Det6Value Added6Returns Relation7 4e
Case for a Donlinear Specification- Advances in Quantitative Anal+sis of inance and Accountin,-Vol.- pp1'#61*#.
23Sina- . (1*3)- Value Added 0ncome- :oo& Gorld- Calcutta
24 Ibid
-
8/13/2019 3.Review of Literature 3-12-2012
10/24
practices- will appreciate te financial environment witin wic decisions
affectin, manpower are ta&en (Ria0i "el*aoui, 19)2#.
4o te laour movement- te value added report was deemed a ,ood
veicle for information disclosure and a asis for determinin, wa,es and rewardswat is termed value added incentive pa+ment sceme (Rao, $&&&)2$0n addition
to tese uses- Cruns (19$)2'mention its occasional use in te conte/t of te
performance of :ritis industr+- in reformin, compan+6wide profit6sarin,
scemes- and in facilitatin, financial performance anal+sis.
Altou, evidence was found in tis review tat value added information
as ,reater predictive and e/planator+ power tan earnin,s- tese findin,s were
inconclusive.
3. Literature Review on VA% as a tool of -erfor2ance ;valuation
A. %u)ra2aniya2 ". i2alat0asan, ($&1&'$in a stud+ for appraisin,
te performance and ud,in, te productivit+ of A:ADS manufacturin, compan+
listed in Colomo Stoc& "/can,e concluded tat VA fi,ure can e re,arded as te
inde/ of mana,erial performance and te+ would e more sensitive to displa+ te
vivid picture aout te efficienc+ of mana,ement of a firm in a i,l+ comple/
and competitive usiness environment.
L.7. %tain)an*, ($&&9)2in is article N4e value added statement7 does it
add an+ valueMN %editari Accountanc+ Researc- Vol. 1' 0ss7 2- pp.13' 6 1
25 Riai6:el&aoui- A. (1$)- !erformance Results in Value Added Reportin,, Quorum :oo&s- Gestport
2$ Rao- !.%. (2)- ;Value Added Reportin,< in 4eor+ and !ractice of Researc- Jeep and Jeep!ulications- Dew Jeli
27 Cruns- R.!. (1*2)- Added6Value7 4e Roots run Jeep into Colonial and "arl+ America- Accountin,
Bistorian =ournal- fall.
28A. Suramani+am :. Dimalatasan- (21)- 0ndustrial Relation S+stem7 Lessons for :an,ladesand Sri Lan&a from =apanese !erspectives- "conomic Science Series- !etroleum6as Universit+ of!loiesti :ulletin- 3O21
29 iid
-
8/13/2019 3.Review of Literature 3-12-2012
11/24
4e value added statement as een voluntaril+ reported + Sout African
companies for man+ +ears despite reservations aout its usefulness. 4e results of
te empirical surve+ indicate tat te maorit+ of te respondents are of te
opinion tat it is desirale to prepare a value added statement- ut tat it is not
used in te maorit+ of companies. 4e article recommends tat te preparation
of te value added statement sould e standardised. Bowever- te disclosure of
an independentl+ prepared value added report ma+ e more useful to all users.
/. C0ristop0er, %. #assan, A. Isla2, (199$)3on a stud+ on NVoluntar+
Reportin, of Value Added Statements in Sin,aporeN- Asian Review of Accountin,-
Vol. 0ss7 1- pp.2# 9 3- oserved tat pulication of VAS is positivel+ related to
firmPs interest covera,e- siKe- and industr+ memersip- of wic te latter twovariales- firm siKe and industr+ memersip- are also found to e si,nificant in
te Australian studies.
"adani and %a*sena (1*)31 in teir stud+ concluded tat since te
corporate sector occupies an important place in te national econom+- tere is an
imperative need to disclose te value added statement.
A firm is an enterprise or decision6ma&in, centre and Accountanc+Ps role in
tis re,ard is to report te results to te various interested parties in wa+s te+
can understand est. %uo
-
8/13/2019 3.Review of Literature 3-12-2012
12/24
0n te words of Clar*e (1*)- a firm not ma&in, an+ profits is onl+
considered ?sic&@ ut firm not ma&in, an+ contriution- + creatin, wealt or
value- to te societ+ ma+ e termed as a ?social parasite@. 4e inclusion of value
added statement in te corporate annual report is must in accountin,.
arpi* and "el*aoui (1)33 in teir stud+ estalised tat value added
accountin, information could suppl+ considerale e/planator+ power of mar&et
ris& e+ond tat provided + earnin,s or cas flow measures- especiall+ at te
individual firm level.
Mat0ews -erera (1$)reported tat in Dew ealand ver+ few companies
pulised a VAS as part of teir financial statement. 0n Sout Africa te interest in
value added statements started wit te pulication of te Corporate Report in
1'#. Unli&e te situation in te United in,dom- wen te incidence of
pulication as fallen since 1*- te incidence of Sout Africa companies
pulisin, te value added statement as increased.
Ria0i:"el*aouiand R.. -icur3in teir stud+ in 1 concluded tat value
added information can suppl+ important e/planator+ power of securit+ valuation
e+ond tat provided + earnin,s.
Similarl+ -avli*r and Ria0i:"el*aoui (1)3! in teir stud+ e/amined te
effect of ownersip structure on a value added measure of performance. 4e+
concluded tat wen te concentration of ownersip is low- total return
ma/imiKation as measured + value added is also low and vice6versa.
Ria0i:"el*aoui (1$)3 found tat value added information pulised
concurrentl+ wit earnin,s does ave additive information content. 0n te same
33arpi&- !. :el&aouiP- A. 1- 4e Relative Relationsip etween S+stematic Ris& and Value AddedVariales- =ournal of 0nternational inancial %ana,ement and Accountin,- Vol.3 pp.2#62'$
34Riai6:el&aoui- A. !icur- R.J. 1."/plainin, %ar&et Returns7 "arnin,s versus Value Added Jata-
%ana,erial inance- Vol.2 Do.-pp.6##
35 Riai6:el&aoui- A. !avli&r- 1."/plainin, %ar&et Returns7 "arnin,s Versus Value Added Jata-
%ana,erial inance- Vol.2 Do.- pp.6##.
36 Riai6:el&aoui- A. 1$.!eiformance Results in Value Added Reportin,- Quorum :oo&s- Gestport-Connecticut
-
8/13/2019 3.Review of Literature 3-12-2012
13/24
+ear e also found tat value added6returns relationsips offered etter
e/planator+ power tan te earnin,s6return relationsips- wen te relationsips
were e/pressed + a non6linear conve/6concave function.
"ao and"ao(1$)3
e/amined te time series properties of value added aswell as prediction accurac+ of te value added series.
%0a*untala2oni (1'*) made a stud+ wic was underta&en wit te
oective of anal+sin, trends in value and distriution of value added in selected
te/tiles mills- composite mills and 11 spinnin, mills was selected for te stud+.
4e stud+ as concluded tat all te 1# te/tile mills- under tis stud+- ave
improved teir net value added. Bowever- te factors influencin, te level of net
value added ave not een covered in tis stud+.
"urritt and Clar*e (1*)3reported tat te Australian approac to value
added ad een ver+ cautious- sowin, notin, li&e te initial Keal in :ritain. A
few companies pulised value added statement as a re,ular supplement to te
traditional accounts.
e+eswara Rao (23)39 in is stud+ made an attempt to evaluate te
performance of pulic enterprises + appl+in, te value added approac. Bis stud+as covered all te production enterprises in te pulic sector in 0ndia. 4e main
findin, of te stud+ is tat te contriution in terms of value added + pulic
enterprises is massive and social surplus ,enerated is more in te case of
petroleum industries.
0n a researc stud+ %u)0as0 C0ander, (199)&made an attempt to &now
te practices adopted + te pulic and private sector enterprises in 0ndia
37 :ao- :. :ao- J. 1$- 4e 4ime Series :eavior and !redictive6Ailit+ Results of Annual ValueAdded Jata. =ournal of :usiness inance Accountin,- April 1$- pp.6$
38:urritt- R.L. and . Clar&e- (1*)- wat are te prospects for corporate value added statements in
AustraliaM 4e Cartered Accountant in Australia %a+ 1*- 3$63.
39Rao- Da,eswar 23- Jisclosure !ractices of Value Added Statements in !ulic "nterprises- 4e
%ana,ement Accountant- %arc 2$- p633.
40 Suas Cander- (1*)- ?Corporate Reportin, !ractices in 0ndia@ Jeep and Jeep !ulications- DewJeli pp3#'6#*
-
8/13/2019 3.Review of Literature 3-12-2012
14/24
re,ardin, te disclosure of value added statement in teir annual reports. 4is
stud+ covered 1 companies (# from pulic sector and # from private sector for
te +ears 1*# 9*'). 0t as revealed tat onl+ 1' companies- from pulic sector
and * from private sector- disclosed tis statement in teir annual reports. 4is
stud+ as estalised tat value added concept is definitel+ an improvement over
te traditional profit and loss concept in te sense tat it puts te efforts of
different interested ,roups in an or,aniKation into a proper perspective.
"0attac0aryya, (1991'1 in is stud+ made an attempt to evaluate te
leadin, issues and controversies in respect of value added concept. 4is stud+ as
concluded tat te contriutors of capital ave released a part of retained
earnin,s one of value for developin, industrial estates and for e/tendin, realenefits to teir laour forces as it confirms arl %ar/@s contention of Surplus
Value.
%0ar2a(11) in a stud+ made an attempt to evaluate te performance of
4ata 4ea Limited + appl+in, te value added concept. 4e value added
statements of 4ata 4ea Limited as sown an increase in value added from Rupees
#31.*2 la&s durin, 1*39* to Rs. '#$2. la&s durin, 1*'9 **. 4is stud+ as
pointed out tat enterprise- not ma&in, profit sall ecome sic& ut not
,eneratin, value added ma+ die over a period of time.
Moni,(1991) in is stud+ made an attempt to populariKe te four wa+s i.e.-
price increase- product development and diversification- increasin, sales and cost
reduction- + wic manufacturin, companies can increase added value. 4e
stud+ as revealed tat added value is a etter indicator of te performance of a
compan+ tan te sales turnover. 4is stud+ as concluded tat te creation of
added value (i.e. wealt creation) sould e te fundamental oective of an+
compan+ ecause added is te &e+ to te success.
41 :attacar++a- S (11)-Value Added Concept of 0ncome7 return needed for corporate ,rowt-
Cartered Secretar+- =an .11
-
8/13/2019 3.Review of Literature 3-12-2012
15/24
%0an*araia0, (1991) in is stud+ estalised te si,nificance of value
added concept as a tool for corporate performance appraisal since it elps te
mana,ement to assess te performance of te compan+- to compare and anal+Ke
te ,rowt of te compan+ and enale tem to identif+ te factors tat are to e
controlled to improve te performance.
8anesan (199)$made an attempt to measure value + 11 spinnin, mills in
4amil Dadu in order to assess teir performance. 4is stud+ as revealed tat
added value is a etter indicator of te performance of mill tan te net profit.
4is stud+ as concluded tat it as laid foundation for full6fled,ed development
of concept of value added and for effective corporate reportin,.
%0an*araia0, (1999' in is stud+ estalised te si,nificance of value
added concept as a tool for corporate performance appraisal since it elps te
mana,ement to assess te performance of te compan+- to compare and anal+Ke
te ,rowt of te compan+ and enale tem to identif+ te factors tat are to e
controlled to improve te performance.
%0ar2a A+arwal, (1991'in teir stud+ made an attempt to evaluate te
performance of nine State Road 4ransport Corporations of 0ndia in te perspective
of value added concept. 4is stud+ as concluded tat te State Road 4ransport
Corporation is contriutin, muc to te societ+ trou, te ,eneration of
emplo+ment and ta/es. 4e ustification for te e/istence of State Road 4ransport
Corporations was found on its capacit+ to ,enerate surplus alon, wit te value
added. 4e stud+ as estalised tat te value added concept is a i,l+ useful
metod to evaluate te operational efficienc+ of tese transport corporations.
4e researc of "urc0ell et.al (1*#)3 indicated tat te incidence of
pulication reaced a clima/ in 1*- ut started declinin, after tat. 0n U..-
42anesan- S.- (1)- Jeterminants of value added- =ournal of accountin,- Vol. #* April- pp. 161.
43:urcell S.- Clu C.- Bopwood A.. (1*#)7 Accountin, in its social conte/t7 towards a istor+ of
value added in te United in,dom. Accountin,- Er,aniKations and Societ+- 17 3*113.
-
8/13/2019 3.Review of Literature 3-12-2012
16/24
tere were- terefore- definite trend towards and awa+ from te pulication of
value added statement.
Van %taden ($&&3' is of t0e opinion t0at %out0 Africa is at present
e=periencin+ t0e 0i+0est incidence of pu)lication of t0e value added state2ent
reported anyw0ere in t0e world to date. In addition researc0 investi+atin+ t0e
predictive a)ility of value added infor2ation 0as )een conducted in t0e 6%A
since 199&, even t0ou+0 t0e value added state2ent 0as not )een pu)lis0ed
t0ere. /0e researc0 reported in 0is paper sets out to esta)lis0 w0et0er t0e
value added state2ent is a disclosure wort0 considerin+ )y co2panies around
t0e world, )y investi+atin+ t0e %out0 African e=perience wit0 t0e value added
state2ent.
0n 0ndia- a lar,e numer of companies are preparin, Value Added
Statements (VAS) wit a view to disclose te income under te social perspective.
4e companies- wic are preparin, tis statement- are not onl+ interested to
e/iit te income from te sareolder@s point of view ut also interested to
e/iit te income under social conte/t. 4is welcome can,e in te attitude of
te corporate sector as made tis sector an inte,ral part of te societ+.
Bowever- in 0ndia- ver+ few researc studies ave een underta&en on te value
added concept.
3.# Literature Review on "conomic Value Added ("VA)
0n tis section a review of earlier literature in te area of "conomic Value
Added is presented. En reviewin, te articles pulised in ot forei,n and 0ndian
ournals on te suect matter> it was oserved tat tere are ver+ few studies
amon, tese researc wor&s wic ave een done teoreticall+ and also
empiricall+ in 0ndia. Bowever- te summar+ of te articles pulised in te
ournals- varied views- opinions and commands pertainin, to teor+ and empirical
44 Van Staden C.=. (23)7 4e relevance of teories of political econom+ to te understandin, of
financial reportin, in Sout Africa7 te case of value added statements. Accountin, orum- 277 2292
http://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/cf_dev/AbsByAuth.cfm?per_id=102778http://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/cf_dev/AbsByAuth.cfm?per_id=102778http://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/cf_dev/AbsByAuth.cfm?per_id=102778 -
8/13/2019 3.Review of Literature 3-12-2012
17/24
wor& of te concepts of "conomic Value Added ("VA) ave een summariKed in a
cronolo,icall+ as under7
%tern (199&'!oserved tat "VA as a performance measure captures te
true economic profit of an or,aniKation. "VA6ased financial mana,ement andincentive compensation sceme ,ives mana,er etter 5ualit+ information and
superior motivation to ma&e decisions tat will create te ma/imum sareolders@
wealt in an or,aniKation. "VA is a performance measure wic is most closel+
lin&ed to te creation of sareolders@ wealt over a period of time.
%tewart (199'as e/pended tat "VA is a powerful new mana,ement
tool tat as ,ained worldwide reco,nition as te standard tool of corporate
performance. "VA presents an inte,rated framewor& of financial mana,ement and
incentive compensation.
8rant (199'found tat te "VA concept ma+ ave everlastin,l+ can,ed
te wa+ real profitailit+ is measured. A surve+ was conducted tat e/amines te
empirical relations etween "VA and corporate valuation. Results su,,est tat "VA
si,nificantl+ an,s te %ar&et Value Added of a firm and tat tis wealt effect
stems from te compan+@s residual return on capital.
Ra
-
8/13/2019 3.Review of Literature 3-12-2012
18/24
;t0ira< (199'9derived tat in 0ndian mar&et man+ companies are usin,
capital inefficientl+ and tus destro+in, value. 4e tool to measure capital
efficac+ and economic value is economic value added. 4a&in, "VA as a tool of
financial performance BLL and 04C stand at te top of te list. Also important is
te relation etween "VA and total operatin, capital emplo+ed. 4is would sow
ow muc value te compan+ as ,enerated in relation to te assets it as
deplo+ed. 0t is ar,ued tat stoc& price move up as a compan+ adopts "VA as an
internal performance criterion.
%a=ena (199'!& elucidated tat tere is no one metod of measurin,
financial performance tat is totall+ perfect. 4us a measure sould e suc tat
satisfies sareolders@ e/pectations and is also ein, committed + topmana,ement. "VA is a measure tat sould e used + top mana,ement to
evaluate investment center mana,ers- ecause it considers ,oal con,ruence
etween sareolders and mana,ers.
"aner
-
8/13/2019 3.Review of Literature 3-12-2012
19/24
8urudas ($&&&'!3 e/amines te different wa+s in wic it can e
ascertained weter te value of a sare is ein, enanced or not. Be starts +
loo&in, at te sift from "arnin, per Sare- !rice earnin,s Ratio- etc. to "conomic
Value Added and %ar&et Value Added. Be demonstrates ow "VA is te est
measure for deducin, sareolder value enancement.
"aner
-
8/13/2019 3.Review of Literature 3-12-2012
20/24
(%VA). As per Stewart@s (11) claim- "VA is te ultimate pro/+ of %VA. Several
studies e/amined te relationsip etween "VA and %VA and %ost of tem found
evidence to support Stewart@s claim.
Jespite te popularit+ of te concept- ver+ few studies ave eenunderta&en to empiricall+ test te ailit+ of "VA to reflect or pro/+ te %VA of
0ndian companies. 4us e ma&es in is stud+ an attempt to fill te ,ap and
empiricall+ e/amines te relationsip etween %VA and "VA of te 0ndian
companies. inall+ e indicates tat tere is no stron, evidence to support tat
"VA is superior to te traditional performance measures in its association wit
%VA
3. Literature Review on Mar*et Value Added (MVA'
ARM 7oi)ary2, ($&1$'!is of opinion t0at Mar*et Value Added (MVA' is
t0e difference )etween t0e 2ar*et value of an enterprise and t0e capital
contri)uted )y s0are0olders and investors. 8reater Mar*et Value Added (MVA'
0i+0li+0ts t0at t0e enterprise 0as added 2ore value t0an w0at was contri)uted
)y t0e s0are0olders and investors, w0ile a ne+ative Mar*et Value Added (MVA'
displays t0at t0e enterprise destroys value. In fact, a ne+ative Mar*et Value
Added (MVA' reveals t0at t0e value of 2ana+e2ent actions and invest2ent are
lower t0an t0e value of t0e contri)ution to t0e co2pany )y t0e capital 2ar*et.
Mar*et Value Added (MVA' is a tool to 2easure s0are0older4s value at a
particular 2o2ent t0at was introduced )y %tewart in 1991. Mar*et Value
Added (MVA' is t0e additional 2ar*et capitali5ation over and a)ove t0e )oo*
value of e>uity (8upta ? undu, $&&'!9. @ro2 an investor4s point of view, MVA
is t0e )est final 2easure of a co2pany4s perfor2ance.
58 AR% =oiar+m- (212) %ar&et !erformance %easurement Ef :an,alore Stoc& "/can,e- =ournal ofRadi/ 0nternational "ducational and Researc Consortium- Vol.1 Sept 212 pp '
59upta- A. and undu- J. (2*)- "nancin, profitailit+ and sareolder value trou, mer,er 9 A
case stud+ of 0C0C0 :an&- Vid+asa,ar Universit+ =ournal of Commerce- %ar- Vol. 13
-
8/13/2019 3.Review of Literature 3-12-2012
21/24
%tewart (1991'&states t0at MVA is a cu2ulative 2easure of corporate
perfor2ance and t0at it represents t0e stoc* 2ar*et4s assess2ent fro2 a
particular ti2e onwards of t0e net present value of all a co2pany4s past and
pro
-
8/13/2019 3.Review of Literature 3-12-2012
22/24
6ye2ura, antor and-etit (199'3used a sample of te 1 lar,est USA
an&s for te period etween 1*$ to 1#.4e+ calculated te %VA and tested
te correlation wit "VA as well as four oter accountin, measures- namel+ net
income (D0)- "arnin,s per Sare ("!S)- Return on "5uit+ (RE")- and Return on
Assets (REA). 4e results of teir researc indicated tat tere is a stron, relation
etween "VA and %VA. 4e correlations etween tese performance measures and
%VA are7 "VA T- REA 13T- RE" 1T- D0 *T and "!S $T.
Milunovic0 and /suei (199'displa+ed tat %VA is stron,l+ correlated
wit "VA tan wit C- C ,rowt- "!S- "!S ,rowt- and RE".
@ernande5 ($&&1' !studied te correlation etween "VA and %VA of #*2
American companies for te period 1*36'. 0t was sown tat for 2$ firms in te
sample te can,es in te DE!A4 ad i,er correlation wit can,es in %VA tan
te "VA- wile for 21 sample firms te correlation etween "VA and %VA was
ne,ative.
i2, A0n, and Bun ($&&' otained direct stron, positive correlation
etween "VA and %VA from ot tests of te parametric and nonparametric.
!erformance indicators cosen in te stud+ usin, mar&et value added (%VA) as a
pro/+ for sareolder value of companies listed on te =S" Securities "/can,e
Sout Africa did not support superiorit+ of "VA. 4e findin,s su,,ested stron,er
relationsips etween %VA and cas flow from operations. 4e stud+ also found
ver+ little correlation etween %VA and "VA.
6319 U+emura- J..- antor- C.C.- and !etit- =.%. (1$)- "VA for :an&s7 Value creation- Ris&
%ana,ement and !rofitailit+ %easurement. =ournal of Applied Corporate inance 6 :an& Am = ApplCorp inance - Vol. - Do. 2- pp. 61
642 %ilunovic- S.- A. 4suei- (1$)- "VA in te Computer 0ndustr+- =ournal of Applied Corporate
inance- vol. - Do. 2- pp. 1611#
6521ernandeK- !. (21)- Sareolder value creators and sareolder value destro+er in U.S.A7 +ear
2. SSRD "6 =ournal- wor&in, paper- Do.2'22#2- JE07 1.213Ossrn.2'22#2
66im- =on =.- An- =ae6B+eon- Fun- =. . (2). "conomic value added ("VA) as a pro/+ for
mar&et value added (%VA) and accountin, earnin,7 empirical evidence from te usiness c+cle.American academ+ of accountin, finance (!. 161$)
-
8/13/2019 3.Review of Literature 3-12-2012
23/24
#er2anu (2')$'in is tesis e/amined relationsip etween "VA- %VA and
SiKes of a compan+ and its sare price performance 1# 6 2$ in 0ndonesia. 4e
result of te anal+sis sowed tere is no relationsip etween "VA- %VA and SiKes
of a compan+.
3. %u22ary
0t is oserved tat tere are various concepts and tecni5ues of measurin,
te value added and tus it is necessar+ to develop a standard practice for its
measurement- so tat te performance of different enterprises ma+ e ud,ed in
a meanin,ful wa+ and inter6firm as well as intra6firm comparison ma+ e possile.
A Value Added Statement is a statement- wic sows te income of te
compan+ as an entit+ and ow tat is divided etween te people wo ave
contriuted to its creation. Gile te income statement reports on te income of
sareolders- te value added statement reports on te income earned + a lar,e
,roup of sta&eolders7 providers of capital plus emplo+ees and te ,overnment.
Since VAS represents ow te value or wealt created or ,enerated + an entit+ is
sared amon, different sta&eolders- it is si,nificant from te national point of
view. 4erefore- VAS represents a move in a new and different direction for
financial reportin,.
Altou, evidence was found in te review tat value added information
as ,reater predictive and e/planator+ power tan earnin,s- tese findin,s were
inconclusive.
0n 0ndia- a lar,e numer of companies are preparin, Value Added
Statements (VAS) wit a view to disclose te income under te social perspective.4e companies- wic are preparin, tis statement- are not onl+ interested to
e/iit te income from te sareolder@s point of view ut also interested to
67Bermanu- iotto. (2'). Anal+sis of "conomic Value Added ("VA)- %ar&et Value Added (%VA)- and
Compan+ SiKe and its relation to compan+ sare price performance of 3 listed companies in =S".Under,raduate tesis- :inus 0nternational Universit+- 2'
-
8/13/2019 3.Review of Literature 3-12-2012
24/24
e/iit te income under social conte/t. 4is welcome can,e in te attitude of
te corporate sector as made tis sector an inte,ral part of te societ+.
Bowever- in 0ndia- ver+ few researc studies ave een underta&en on te value
added concept.
Jespite te popularit+ of te concept- ver+ few studies ave een
underta&en to empiricall+ test te ailit+ of "VA to reflect or pro/+ te %VA of
0ndian companies. 4us e ma&es in is stud+ an attempt to fill te ,ap and
empiricall+ e/amines te relationsip etween %VA and "VA of te 0ndian
companies. inall+ e indicates tat tere is no stron, evidence to support tat
"VA is superior to te traditional performance measures in its association wit
%VA.