36711831 virgin-soft-drinks-working-capital-management
Post on 13-Sep-2014
1.281 views
DESCRIPTION
TRANSCRIPT
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
UNIVERSITY OF DHAKA DEPARTMENT OF ACCOUNTING AND INFORMATION SYSTEMS
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Submitted to
Mr Md Amirus Salat
Assistant Professor
Department of Accounting and Information Systems
University of Dhaka
Submitted by
Shah KamalDepartment of Accounting amp Information SystemsUniversity of Dhaka
Table of Contents
Executive Summary
1 Introduction 01
2 Objectives of the Study 02
3 Methodology 02
4 Limitations of the Study 03
5 Working Capital Management 04
51 Defining Working Capital 04
52 Working Capital Policies 05
53 Working Capital Cycle 07
531 Cash Management 08
532 Inventory Management 19
533 Managing Accounts Receivable (Debtors) 22
534 Managing Accounts Payable (Creditors) 26
6 Overview of Virgin Group 29
7 Overview of Virgin Soft Drinks 31
8 Finding of Working Capital Management Maintained by Virgin Soft Drinks in Bangladesh
32
81 Cash Management 32
82 Inventory Management 38
83 Managing Accounts Receivable (Debtors) 40
84 Managing Accounts Payable (Creditors) 43
9 Recommendation
43
10 Conclusion 44
Bibliography
Annexure
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
Working capital is basically an expression of how many in liquid assets the company
currently has to build its business fund its growth and produce value for the owner
The faster a business expands the more cash it will need for working capital and
investment The cheapest and best sources of cash exist as working capital right
within the business Good management of working capital will generate cash and
help improve profits and reduce risks My study is based on the comparison between
theoretical and practical aspects of working capital management For this purpose
Ive collected some information regarding working capital its cycle and its
management from Virgin Soft Drinks It has been found that their major transactions
are handled in cash But one of its major weaknesses is that it keeps its surplus funds
in banks rather than investing in marketable securities Therefore they can earn
optimum profit by implementing effective mechanism which will help to gain
optimum working capital
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
1 INTRODUCTION
Working capital is the life blood of any business big or small However smaller
businesses might find it more trying to maintain a comfortable level of capital
Managing working capital is an important factor for them Working capital
management is important because maintaining a balance of income to debt can be
difficult and owners must be diligent to assure that it is kept Sometimes it takes a
little assistance to maintain levels of fluidity or make major purchases If working
capital dips too low a business risks running out of cash Even very profitable
businesses can run into trouble if they lose the ability to meet their short-term
obligations Working capital financing can be used as a fast cash option to cushion
the periods when the flow is not ideal or readily available Even when owners are
meticulous in managing working capital finding the right levels to remain
comfortable and competitive can be difficult
The analogy has often been made that cash is the lifeblood of any business A
transfusion will miraculously bring the patient back from the brink of death but only
if
The blood is of the right kind
The problem causing the leakage is attended to
In other words the financial requirements of any business must be tailored to suit
that businesss own particular needs For example fixed assets should be financed by
long term loans and capital Working capital requirements should be attended to by
short term finance eg overdrafts
Page 1 of 46
It goes without saying that before capital is injected into the business it should first be
ascertained whether all unnecessary leakages have been plugged Otherwise in time
the transfusion will follow the same route To control and exploit the cash cycle
through any business so that it can continue to function on a day-to-day basis is
therefore the hub of working capital management The fundamental principle of
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
working capital management is having just the right amount of money available
when needed Every rand in the business should be earning its maximum return
wherever employed
2 OBJECTIVES OF THE STUDY
The study has been undertaken with the following objectives
To know the fundamentals of working capital management
To gather practical knowledge about the implementation of working capital
management by Virgin Soft Drinks
To understand the efficiency of Virgin Soft Drinks in managing working
capital
3 METHODOLOGY
In this paper the following methods are used
a) Sources and Data Collection
The major part of this paper is collected from the primary and secondary data
collection method
Conducted formal interview and focus observation and intensive practical
work to collect information
Page 2 of 46
Collected information from companys profiles
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Collected current information from website
b) Segregation of Data
Necessary data were segregated from the source material for the purpose of preparing
the report
c) Processing of Data
Collected data were compiled and processed for the purpose of preparing the report
d) Presentation of Data
Collected data were presented in charts and tables
4 LIMITATIONS OF THE STUDY
On the way of my study I have faced a number of problems which may be turned
as the limitation of report
Many personnel of the organization due to their pressure of the work were
reluctant to provide much useful information
Sufficient records publications facts and figures are not available These
constraints narrowed the scope of real analysis
Due to time constraint I could not spend sufficient time which was
necessary to make this report more representative of the fact
Page 3 of 46
Lack of experience has also acted as constraint for the exploration of the
topic
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
5 WORKING CAPITAL MANAGEMENT
51 DEFINING WORKING CAPITAL
The term working capital refers to the amount of capital which is readily available to
an organization That is working capital is the difference between resources in cash
or readily convertible into cash (Current Assets) and organizational commitments for
which cash will soon be required (Current Liabilities)
Current Assets are resources which are in cash or will soon be converted into cash in
the ordinary course of business
Current Liabilities are commitments which will soon require cash settlement in the
ordinary course of business
Thus ndash
WORKING CAPITAL = CURRENT ASSETS - CURRENT LIABILITIES
In a firms Statement of Financial position these components of working capital are
reported under the following headings
Current Assets
Liquid Assets (cash and bank deposits)
Inventory
Debtors and Receivables
Current Liabilities
Bank Overdraft
Creditors and Payables
Other Short Term Liabilities
Page 4 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Working capital management involves the relationship between a firms short-term
assets and its short-term liabilities The goal of working capital management is to
ensure that a firm is able to continue its operations and that it has sufficient ability to
satisfy both maturing short-term debt and upcoming operational expenses The
management of working capital involves managing inventories accounts receivable
and payable and cash
52 WORKING CAPITAL POLICIES
The aim of working capital policy is to balance having too little working capital
which can lead to an inability to pay debts as they fall due or the need for expensive
short term borrowings and too much which is wasteful in terms of lost opportunities
for the funds tied up The crucial role of working capital is that it finances the goods
inwards production and sales activities
A firmrsquos working capital policy has two components
1 Policies regarding the appropriate level of current assets (Current Asset Investment Policy)
2 Policies regarding the use of short-term financing (Current Asset Financing Policy)
Alternative Current Asset Investment Policies
These policies are general strategies that firms may follow with regard to their overall
level of current assets investment or holdings There are three types
1 Relaxed Current Asset Investment Policy ndash
Relatively large amounts of cash marketable securities and inventories are carried
and sales are stimulated by a liberal (generous) trade credit policy resulting in high
levels of receivables This is a low risk strategy because the firm always has plenty of
cash and inventory on hand The return is low because more money is invested in
low yielding assets
Page 5 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
2 Restricted Current Asset Investment Policy ndash
Holdings of cash securities inventories and receivables are minimized This is a
high risk strategy because the firm tries to keep the bare minimum of cash and
inventory The potential return is high because less money is invested in low
yielding assets
3 Moderate Current Asset Policy ndash
Balance between relaxed and restricted current asset investment policies (moderate
risk - moderate potential return)
Alternative Current Asset Financing Policies
These policies are general strategies that firms may follow with regard to how current
assets are to be financed Current assets can be classified as permanent or temporary
Permanent current assets are the current assets that the company needs to maintain
throughout the entire year Temporary current assets are those that are due to
seasonal fluctuations With respect to the current asset financing policy the question
is how the permanent current assets will and temporary current assets are financed
(long-term or short-term financing)
Page 6 of 46
Aggressive Moderate Conservative
Cash Minimum holding Prepared to hold
some precautionary
balances
Prepared to hold idle
cash balances
Debtors and
stock
Minimum
consistent with
business needs
Moderate levels High stock and
debtor levels to
maximize sales
Creditors Maximum
available without
compromising
business needs
Moderate level Low level seeking
discounts and
reputation for good
payment
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Future cash
flows
Predictable Reasonably
predictable
Unpredictable
Attitude to
Risk
Accepting Neutral Rejecting
Total assets = Fixed Assets + Permanent Current Assets + Fluctuating Current Assets
53 WORKING CAPITAL CYCLE
Cash flows in a cycle into around and out of a business It is the businesss life blood
and every managers primary task is to help keep it flowing and to use the cash flow
to generate profits If a business is operating profitably then it should in theory
generate cash surpluses If it doesnt generate surpluses the business will eventually
run out of cash and expire
The faster a business expands the more cash it will need for working capital and
investment The cheapest and best sources of cash exist as working capital right
within business Good management of working capital will generate cash will help
improve profits and reduce risks
Working capital can be broken down into the following major components cash (or
bank overdraft) stock debtors creditors Each of these items can have a major
influence on the working capital (or simply cash) that any business requires on an
ongoing basis For example when a business starts up the owner may inject a
certain amount of cash into the business which will enable him to purchase his initial
stock pay his workers their first months wages and cover other overheads such as
rent He then sells his product and this income may be utilized to purchase more
stock pay more wages and overheads and perhaps even have a surplus over for his
own use The quicker he can turn his stock over to receive payment the sooner the
working capital cycle will be completed
Page 7 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Figure Working Capital Cycle
These major components of working capital are discussed below
531 CASH MANAGEMENT
The term cash management refers to the management of cash from the time it starts
its transit to the firm until it leaves the firm in payments Cash management
encompasses the design of collection and disbursement systems for cash and the
temporary investment of cash while it resides with the firm Widely used money
market instruments are-
Treasury bill
Commercial paper
Certificate of deposits
Bankerrsquos acceptance
Page 8 of 46
Repurchase agreement
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
5311 Motives for Holding Cash
Despite the seemingly low returns there are several good reasons why firms hold
cash and marketable securities These reasons are ndash
Cash for transactions
Cash and near cash assets as hedges
Temporary investment and
Compensating balances
5312 Components of Cash Management
A Cash Flow Statement shows the sources and uses of cash and is typically divided
into three components
Operating Cash Flow
Operating cash flow often referred to as working capital is the cash flow generated
from internal operations It comes from sales of the product or service of your
business and because it is generated internally it is under your control
Investing Cash Flow
Investing cash flow is generated internally from non-operating activities This
includes investments in plant and equipment or other fixed assets nonrecurring gains
or losses or other sources and uses of cash outside of normal operations
Financing Cash Flow
Financing cash flow is the cash to and from external sources such as lenders
investors and shareholders
Page 9 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
5313 Tools for Cash Management
Flotation and Check Clearing
Management of cash when it is not in the firmrsquos hands that is in transit to and from
the firm is on important function in the area of finance Transit times for the check
takes in three stages These are mail float at firm float and clearing float Normally
mail float takes 1 to 5 days at firm float takes 025 to 1 day and clearing float takes 0
to 2 days The firm should care about this process because every delay in the receipt
of money by the firm lowers the firmrsquos returns and therefore its shareholdersrsquo wealth
There are several strategies that firm can use to reduce the delay in receiving funds
Each of these strategies addresses one or more of the three float times (mail float
time at time float time and clearing float time) that make up the total transit time of
fund from one firm to another
Other Cash Management Tools
When the economy is strong companies can lapse into sloppy cash-management
practices Firm should try exploring these options
1 Sweep accounts
These bank accounts are the easiest way to generate some income from companys
spare funds however they make sense only if the money youll earn will be greater
than the fees your bank will charge Business owners have two types of sweep
accounts to choose between
Page 10 of 46
Controlled-investment accounts These are the most profitable form of
sweep account but they wont work for company if the firm has any
electronic payments or wire transfers since those may be submitted for
payment later in the day and the account wont have enough cash in it to
cover them
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Page 11 of 46
End-of-day sweep accounts A safer bet for most small-business owners
these accounts wait until a late-hour cutoff to determine how much to
sweep into the firms overnight investments Typically their investment
yields are 10 to 20 basis points (1 to 2 of the investment) lower than
those offered with controlled investments
2 Lock-box accounts
A lock box is a cash-management system that helps the firm collect funds quickly
Generally set up with the assistance of a big money center or regional bank lock
boxes provide the firm with a special zip code and usually quicker deliveries from
regional post offices They are especially important if the firm has clusters of
customers in out-of-state locations and dont want to lose days waiting for their
checks to arrive by long-distance mail
5314 Cash Concentration and Cash Disbursement
Once the remittances from the firmrsquos customers have been received and cleared the
resulting cash balances is available in the firmrsquos lockbox (depository) banks It is
useful for the firm to gather these balances from the lockbox banks into the central
bank account The process of collecting funds is called cash concentration
Several concentration mechanism are available for the firm to use in transferring
funds from its collection banks to regional concentration banks and from there to the
central concentration bank These mechanisms differ in cost and in the availability of
funds that they provide These are ndash
a) Depository Transfer Check
It is the cheapest transfer mechanism This document instructs one bank to
send funds to another and is treated the same as any other check
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
b) Automated Clearing House (ACH) Electronic Transfer
This vehicle is essentially an electronic version of the depository transfer
check and can be used between banks that participate in the automated
clearing house system
c) Wire Transfer
These are electronic message between banks
Decisions regarding concentration mechanism usually hinge on the size and
spread of the firmrsquos deposits Firms with small deposits spread over a
substantial number of banks will tend to have more extensive concentration
systems and will transfer among accounts using low-cost transfer vehicles that
offer only delayed availability (such as depository transfer checks) Firms with
larger deposits will have fewer accounts (since a local deposit for transfer to
an upstream bank is not needed) and will use more expensive and more rapid
transfer mechanisms (such as wire transfers) The concentration systems of
major chemical companies for example tend to be structured in this way ndash
DepositoryLockbox Banks
Regional Concentration Banks
Central Concentrated Bank
Figure A typical Cash Concentration System
(Arrows indicate transfers of collected funds)
Page 12 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Disbursement management addresses the efficient payout out of this cash once it is
concentrated The firmrsquos objective in disbursement management is to retain the cash
for as long as possible In this way the firm will have the maximum amount of funds
available for investment and transactional purposes Certainly this management
means making disbursement only when they are due and not before The firm has
several available set of techniques for disbursement management Included among
these are ndash
a) Management of Disbursement Float
In this set of techniques the disbursing firm attempts to increase the length of
time between the mailing of its checks and the eventual withdrawal of funds
from the banks This involves strategies for increasing mail float at firm float
and clearing float on its outgoing checks For example the disbursing firm
may intentionally address checks to the firmrsquos office address rather than its
lockbox creating at firm float
b) Zero-Balance Accounts
Here the firm holds the cash until the check arrive (or expected to arrive) at
the disbursement bank In this strategy an account for disbursement is first
established at a bank For the zero-balance system to be effective the
participating bank must be one on which most disbursement are made via the
Bangladesh Bankrsquos clearance system (which presents disbursements to banks
early in the morning) and not a bank where disbursements occur throughout
the day (as with a major money-center bank) Consequently the banks used
in zero-balance strategies are usually branches of major banks and not their
main locations
Page 13 of 46
c) Controlled Disbursing
In this system the firm projects the amount of checks to arrive each day at the
disbursement bank (based on the checks written in previous days and historic
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
statistics on disbursement float) and transfers the amount of the expected
checks to the account on that day or just before
5315 Cash Forecasting
Defining Cash Forecasting
The cash forecast is an estimation of the flows in and out of the firmrsquos cash account
over a particular period of time usually a quarter month week or day The cash
forecast is primarily intended to produce a very useful piece of information an
estimation of the firmrsquos borrowing and lending needs and uncertainties regarding
these needs during various future periods Cash forecasting is very crucial to most
firms It enables them to anticipate periods of surplus cash and periods where
financing will be necessary This anticipation is the reason that cash forecasts are
generated Anticipation enables the firm to plan much more effectively for
investment and financing and via this planning produce superior return
Types of Cash Forecasts
The types of cash forecasts generated by firms can be differentiated along two
dimensions the length of the periods included within the cash forecast and the approach
to cash flows used in the cash forecast The length of the period refers to the units of
time into which the cash forecast is divided Firms may make cash flow forecasts
over periods of various lengths yearly flows quarterly flows monthly flows weekly
flows or even daily flows The most popular forecast involves monthly flows but
most firms do not confine themselves to a single forecast Instead they use several
forecasts with periods of various lengths When the firm makes forecasts involving
multiple and overlapping period lengths one forecast relates to another Starting
with data on relatively long periods and breaking it down into smaller periods is
called distribution starting with data on relatively short periods and aggregating into
longer periods is called scheduling
Page 14 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Firms use two common approaches to cash flows in generating the cash forecast the
receipts and disbursements approach and the adjusted net income approach The receipts
and disbursements approach use the amounts of cash expected to be received and
disbursed by the firm over the periods chosen for forecast The adjusted income
statement approach is sometimes called the sources and use approach Here the
forecaster starts with projected net income on an accrual basis and adjusts to a cash
basis This method provides a representation of changes in asset and liability
accounts since the level of these accounts are of interest to the firm this aspect of the
adjusted income statement is an advantage over the receipts and disbursements
method
Items to Be Forecast
In the receipt and disbursements cash forecasting method estimates need to be made
of the numerous major and minor items that the firm collects (receipts) and that it
pays (disbursements) The more individual categories of items the firm includes in its
forecast procedure the more accurate the forecast may be but the more costly in
terms of time and effort it will be to generate
Some Possible Types of Cash Receipts and Cash Disbursements
Cash Disbursements Cash Receipts
Cash Purchases of Materials Payroll
Taxes
Maturing Accounts Payable
Maturing Notes Payable
Miscellaneous Disbursements
Accounts Receivable
Notes Receivable
Rental Income
Interest Income
Miscellaneous Receipts
Methods of Financial Forecasting
Page 15 of 46
Financial forecasting is the estimation of the future level of a financial variable often
a cash flow asset level or liability level It is usually assumed that the relationship
between the financial variable and other variable is linear The general linear model
can then be used
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
nnt xaxaxaaY 22110 ++=
Here
= Financial variable (Y) to be forecast in period t tY
x = Explanatory variable it is assumed to cause the level of Y in period t
0a = Represents a constant unaffected by the x
The other terms are the estimated coefficients of the explanatory x variables
There are n terms with xrsquos in them
There are four common approaches to forecasting financial variables but they
are all special cases of the general linear model These are ndash spot method proportion
to another account compounded growth and multiple dependencies
Using Cash Forecast
The estimate of available funds for investment and needed financing enables the firm
to plan so as to obtain the most advantages borrowing terms for deficits and achieve
the greatest interest income on surplus A useful chart for this planning purpose is a
bar chart eg
Figure Bar Chart of Cash Surpluses and Deficits from hypothetical data
Page 16 of 46
75
50
-60
30
100
-20
-80-60-40-20
020406080
100120
Defic
it
S
urpl
us
January February March April May June
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Sources of Uncertainty in Cash Forecasting and Hedging Uncertainties
There are numerous sources of risk in cash forecasting Among the sources are sales
uncertainty collection rate uncertainty production cost uncertainty and capital
outflow uncertainty
5316 Models for the Management of Cash and Temporary Investments
There are different models for the management of cash and temporary investments
Among these the most popular methods are ndash Baumol model Beranek model
Miller-Orr model and Stone model
Baumol and Beranek use the same model The formula is cited below ndash
Interest Income = iYn
n⎥⎦⎤
⎢⎣⎡ minus
21
Profit = naiYn
nminus⎥⎦
⎤⎢⎣⎡ minus
21
Optimum number of transactions = ⎟⎠⎞
⎜⎝⎛
aiY2
Where n = Optimum number of transactions
i = Interest rate per period
a = Transaction cost
Y = Total inflow for the period
Page 17 of 46
Miller-Orr and Stone use the same model ie R-Statistic The model is ndash
31
43
iav
R ⎟⎠⎞
⎜⎝⎛=
Optimum Control Limit = R + L
Upper Control Limit = 3R + L
Where a = Transaction Cost
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
v = Variance of daily cash flows
i = Daily interest rate
5317 Administration
Cash receipts should be processed and banked as quickly as possible because
They cannot earn interest or reduce overdraft until they are banked
information about the existence and amounts of cash receipts is usually not
available until they are processed
Where possible cash floats (mainly petty cash and advances) should be avoided If
on review the only reason that can be put forward for their existence is that weve
always had them they should be discontinued There may be situations where they
are useful however For example it may be desirable for peripheral parts of
departments to meet urgent local needs from cash floats rather than local bank
accounts
5318 Internal Control
Cash and cash management is part of a firms overall internal control system The
main internal cash control is invariably the bank reconciliation This provides
assurance that the cash balances recorded in the accounting systems are consistent
with the actual bank balances It requires regular clearing of reconciling items
5319 Practicing Good Cash Flow Management
Good cash management is simple It involves
Knowing when where and how firms cash needs will occur
Page 18 of 46
Knowing the best sources for meeting additional cash needs
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Page 19 of 46
Being prepared to meet these needs when they occur by keeping good
relationships with bankers and other creditors
532 INVENTORY MANAGEMENT
Inventory management is necessary for owners who want to maintain a stocking
service for quick turnaround to help ensure total customer satisfaction The fill rate
of an item on a managed inventory list must be maintained to avoid shortages of
frequently used items Even when utilizing an inventory management system
occasional shortages will still occur Inventories are lists of stocks-raw materials
work in progress or finished goods-waiting to be consumed in production or to be
sold The total balance of inventory is the sum of the value of each individual stock
line
Basically firms hold stocks for the following reasons
To act as a buffer in times of unusually high demand
To ensure continuity of production
Avoid high costs of emergency orders
To take advantage of quantity discounts by ordering more at a time
To reduce ordering costs by ordering more items on fewer
As part of the production process eg maturing whisky or keeping oil in
pipelines
Seasonality of demand (eg firework) or supplies
Suppliers insist on minimum order quantities
The key issue for a business is to identify the fast and slow stock movers with the
objectives of establishing optimum stock levels for each category and thereby
minimize the cash tied up in stocks Factors to be considered when determining
optimum stock levels include
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Page 20 of 46
What are the projected sales of each product
How widely available are raw materials components etc
How long does it take for delivery by suppliers
Can the firm remove slow movers from its product range without
compromising best sellers
Inventory management is an important aspect of working capital management
because inventories themselves do not earn any revenue Holding either too little or
too much inventory incurs costs
Costs of carrying too much inventory are
Opportunity cost of foregone interest
Warehousing costs
Damage and pilferage
Obsolescence
Insurance
Costs of carrying too little inventory are
Stock out costs
Lost sales
Delayed service
Ordering costs
Freight
on Order administrati
nts
Loss of quantity discou
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Carrying costs can be minimized by making frequent small orders but this increase
ordering costs and the risk of stock outs Risk of stock-outs can be reduced by
carrying safety stocks (at a cost) and re-ordering ahead of time
The best ordering strategy requires balancing the various cost factors to ensure the
firm incurs minimum inventory costs The optimum inventory position is known as
the Economic Reorder Quantity (ERQ)
Nowadays many large manufacturers operate on a just-in-time (JIT) basis whereby
all the components to be assembled on a particular today arrive at the factory early
that morning no earlier - no later This helps to minimize manufacturing costs as JIT
stocks take up little space minimize stock-holding and virtually eliminate the risks of
obsolete or damaged stock Because JIT manufacturers hold stock for a very short
time they are able to conserve substantial cash JIT is a good model to strive for as it
embraces all the principles of prudent stock management For better stock control
firm may try the following
Review the effectiveness of existing purchasing and inventory systems
Know the stock turn for all major items of inventory
Apply tight controls to the significant few items and simplify controls for the
trivial many
Sell off outdated or slow moving merchandise - it gets more difficult to sell the
longer the firm keeps it
Consider having part of its product outsourced to another manufacturer rather
than make it itself
Review its security procedures to ensure that no stock is going out the back
door
Higher than necessary stock levels tie up cash and cost more in insurance
accommodation costs and interest charges
Page 21 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
However it is important to keep an overall perspective It is not cost-effective to
closely manage a large number of low value inventory lines nor is it necessary A
usual feature of inventories is that a small number of high value lines account for a
large proportion of inventory value The 8020 rule (PARETO) predicts that 80
of the total value of inventory is represented by only 20 of the number of inventory
items Those high value lines need reasonably close management The remaining
80 of inventory lines can be managed using broad-brush strategies
533 MANAGING ACCOUNTS RECEIVABLE (DEBTORS)
Cash flow can be significantly enhanced if the amounts owing to a business are
collected faster Every business needs to know who owes them money how much is
owed how long it is owing for what it is owed
Debtors (Accounts Receivable) are customers who have not yet made payment for
goods or services which the department has provided The objective of debtor
management is to minimize the time-lapse between completion of sales and receipt
of payment The costs of having debtors are
Opportunity costs (cash is not available for other purposes)
Bad debts
If firm doesnt manage debtors they will begin to manage business as the firm will gradually
lose control due to reduced cash flow and of course it could experience an increased
incidence of bad debt The following measures will help manage debtors
Having the right mental attitude to the control of credit and make sure that it
gets the priority it deserves
Establishing clear credit practices as a matter of company policy
Page 22 of 46
Making sure that these practices are clearly understood by staff suppliers and
customers
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Page 23 of 46
Being professional when accepting new accounts and especially larger ones
Checking out each customer thoroughly before the firm offers credit Use
credit agencies bank references industry sources etc
Establishing credit limits for each customer and sticking to them
Continuously reviewing these limits when it suspects tough times are coming
or if operating in a volatile sector
Keeping very close to the firms larger customers
Invoicing promptly and clearly
Considering charging penalties on overdue accounts
Considering accepting credit debit cards as a payment option
Monitoring its debtor balances and ageing schedules and dont let any debts
get too large or too old
Debtor management includes both pre-sale and debt collection strategies
Pre-sale strategies include
Offering cash discounts for early payment andor imposing penalties for late
payment
Agreeing payment terms in advance
Requiring cash before delivery
Setting credit limits
ning credit Setting criteria for obtai
Billing as early as possible
rogress payments
ost-sale strategies include
for collecting the debt upon the center that made the sale
Requiring deposits andor p
P
Placing the responsibility
Identifying long overdue balances and doubtful debts by regular analytical reviews
Having an established procedure for late collections such as
A reminder
A letter
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Page 24 of 46
ion of further credit Cancellat
Telephone calls
n agency Use of a collectio
he firm should recognize that the longer someone owes firm the greater the chance
Legal action
T
it will never get paid If the average age of debtors is getting longer or is already very
long it may need to look for the following possible defects
Weak credit judgment
res Poor collection procedu
ms Lax enforcement of credit ter
Slow issue of invoices or statements
Errors in invoices or statements
Customer dissatisfaction
Debtors due over 90 days (unless within agreed credit terms) should generally
demand immediate attention For example warning signs of a future bad debt ndash
Longer credit terms taken with approval particularly for smaller orders
Use of post-dated checks by debtors who normally settle within agreed terms
Evidence of customers switching to additional suppliers for the same goods
New customers who are reluctant to give credit references
Cre G
Receiving part payments from debtors
dit ranting to Marginal Accounts
Traditional Approach
In the traditional approach to the credit granting decision it is the credit analysts job
rmation that has been collected and reach a judgment
regarding the applicants creditworthiness One traditional way of organizing this
to synthesize all the info
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
information is by characterizing the applicant along five dimensions These
dimensions are called the Five Cs of credit ndash
Capital
Character
Collateral
and Capacity
Conditions
Net Present Value (NPV) Approach
Once a firm has assessed the creditworthiness of a customer it has to decide whether
r not credit should be granted The firm should use the NPV rule to make the
ld be granted
Figure
o
decision If NPV is positive credit shou
Credit Granting Decision
Credit Granting Decision
he act of collecting money is one which most people dislike for many reasons and
therefore put on the long f selves there is something
ore urgent or important that demands their attention now There is nothing more
T
inger because they convince them
m
important than getting paid for firms product or service A customer who does not
Page 25 of 46
Grand Credit
Payment received Payment not received
Benefit of present value of future net cash flow
Cost of present value ment of lost invest
Net Payoff PV of benefit-cost
No Credit
No Payoff
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
pay is not a customer Here are a few ideas that may help the firm in collecting
money from debtors
Firm should develop appropriate procedures for handling late payments
It should track and pursue late payers
It might get external help if its own efforts fail
or money its firms and it is entitled Company shouldnt feel guilty asking f
to it
ction
Firm must make that call now And it should keep asking until it gets some
satisfa
lessens the problem
In difficult circumstances take what the firm can now and agree terms for the
remainder It
paying
When asking for money be hard on the issue - but soft on the person It shouldnt
give the debtor any excuses for not
534 BLE (CREDITORS)
ices for goods or services have
een paid Organizations often regard the
not
to delay all payments until the latest possible date Regular weekly or
The firm make it its objective is to get the money - not to score points or get
even
MANAGING ACCOUNTS PAYA
Creditors (Accounts Payable) are suppliers whose invo
been processed but who have not yet b
amount owing to creditors as a source of free credit However creditor
administration systems are expensive and time-consuming to run The over-riding
concern in this area should be to minimize costs with simple procedures
While it is unnecessary to pay accounts before they fall due it is usually
worthwhile
Page 26 of 46
fortnightly payment of all due accounts is the simplest technique for creditor
management
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Electronic payments (direct credits) are cheaper than check payments considering
that transaction fees and overheads more than balance the advantage of delayed
presentation Some suppliers are reluctant to receive payments by this method but in
view of the substantial cost advantage (and the advantages to the suppliers
themselves) departments may wish to encourage suppliers to accept this option
However electronic payments are likely to be used in conjunction with rather than
as a replacement for check payments
Applying Best Practices in Managing Accounts Payable
f course simply deferring payments to suppliers could have adverse consequences
O
that more than offset the benefits of this additional cash flow Therefore it is
important to develop a holistic approach The firm should consider the following
best practices for payables management
Managing payment dates and terms to maximize cash flow ndash
y reporting on
receivable and
id penalty charges and taking advantage of
wer vendors and negotiate for more
to buying consortia with others even
voices for
payment based on receipt of goods or receipt of invoice whichever
comes later
Calculating and setting performance targets Regularl
AP performance measures such as days in payables
Coordinating the AP processes with accounts
inventory management to ensure that the company is collecting more
cash than it is paying out
Paying bills on time to avo
prompt-payment discounts where the discounts exceed the companyrsquos
cost of working capital
Consolidating purchases with fe
favorable payment terms
Considering entering in
Page 27 of 46
competitors to obtain favorable supplier pricing and terms
Unless contract terms specify otherwise setting up in
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Page 28 of 46
Em
process
-time payments with Electronic Funds Transfer (EFT)
uraging vendors to utilize electronic invoice presentment
a
ndancies and more
ploying technology to automate the accounts payable transaction
es ndash
Making just-in
Using an electronic invoice-matching application
Enco
For companies with multiple locations or business units employing
shared service approach for AP to eliminate redu
quickly implement process improvements
Mainta
vendor
Communicating accounts payable requirements to suppliers at the
m key suppliers
for suggestions on how to improve the
Efficient a
and making th rsquos cash is just good business
ining open communications and building strong relationships with
s to access valuable trade credit ndash
beginning of transactions
Requesting summary invoicing fro
Requiring suppliers to send invoices directly to accounts payable
Asking tier-one suppliers
payment process
nd effective management of accounts payable helps improve cash flow ndash
e most of company
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
6 OVERVIEW OF VIRGIN GROUP
Virgin - one of the most respected brands in Britain - is now becoming the first global
brand name of the 21st century Virgin is involved in planes trains finance soft
drinks music mobile phones holidays cars wines publishing bridal wear - the lot
What tie all these businesses together are the values of its brand and the attitude of its
people Virgin has created over 200 companies worldwide employing over 25000
people Its total revenues around the world in 2002 exceeded pound4 billion (US $72
billion)
In 1970 Richard Branson founded Virgin as a mail order record retailer and not
long after he opened a record shop in Oxford Street London During 1972 a
recording studio was built in Oxfordshire and the first Virgin artist Mike Oldfield
recorded Tubular Bells which was released in 1973
This album went on to sell over 5 million copies Since then many household names
including Belinda Carlisle Genesis Phil Collins Janet Jackson and The Rolling
Stones have helped to make Virgin Music one of the top six record companies in the
world The equity of Virgin Music Group - record labels music publishing and
recording studios was sold to THORN EMI in 1992 in a US$1billion deal
Page 29 of 46
The Virgin Group has now expanded into international music Mega stores air
travel mobile financial retail music internet drinks rail hotels and leisure with
around 200 companies in over 30 countries
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
In Virgins customers eyes Virgin stands for value for money quality innovation
fun and a sense of competitive challenge It delivers a quality service by empowering
its employees and facilitates and monitors customer feedback to continually improve
the customers experience through innovation
When they start a new venture Virgin bases it on hard research and analysis
Typically they review the industry and put themselves in the customers shoes to see
what could make it better Virgin asks fundamental questions
Is this an opportunity for restructuring a market and creating competitive
advantage What are the competitors doing
Is the customer confused or badly served
Is this an opportunity for building the Virgin brand
Can we add value
Will it interact with its other businesses
Is there an appropriate trade-off between risk and reward
Page 30 of 46
Virgin is also able to draw on talented people from throughout the group New
ventures are often steered by people seconded from other parts of Virgin who bring
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
with them the trademark management style skills and experience Virgin frequently
creates partnerships with others to combine skills knowledge and market presence
and so on Contrary to what some people may think their constantly expanding and
eclectic empire is neither random nor reckless Each successive venture demonstrates
its skill in picking the right market and the right opportunity
7 OVERVIEW OF VIRGIN SOFT DRINKS
The Virgin Drinks Group first launched as the Virgin Cola Company in 1994 with
Virgin Cola in the UK Since then the company has ventured across the carbonated
soft drinks arena and beyond into energy drinks tea and flavored Colas This
expansion has lead to the evolution of the Virgin Drinks Company a company
whose aim is to put the excitement back into the world of soft drinks It launched in
Bangladesh in 1999 Virgin Soft Drinks is monitored by Global Beverage Co Ltd in
Bangladesh
Brief history of Virgin Drinks is given below
Page 31 of 46
1994 November Virgin Cola launched in the UK
1996 March Virgin Cola launched in France
1998 June Virgin Cola launched in Belgium
April Virgin Cola launched in the French West Indies
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
August Virgin Cola launched in Switzerland
1999 March Virgin Colours launched in Italy
March Virgin Cola launched in Japan
July Virgin Colours launched in South Africa
December Virgin Colours launched in Bangladesh
2001 January Sweden launched Virgin Colours
November Singapore launched Virgin Colours
2002 February Croatia launched Virgin Colours
June Russia launched Virgin Colours
June Tunisia launched Virgin Colours
2003 May Israel launched Virgin Colours
8 FINDINGS OF WORKING CAPITAL MANAGEMENT MAINTAINED BY
VIRGIN SOFT DRINKS IN BANGLADESH
81 CASH MANAGEMENT
811 Holding Cash and Marketable Securities
Although there are many good reasons why firm hold cash and marketable
securities Virgin Drinks holds cash and marketable securities for two reasons ndash
i) Cash for transactions
ii) Cash as hedges
This indicates that the firm does not hold cash and marketable securities for some
important reasons such as ndash
i) Near cash assets as hedges
Page 32 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
ii) Temporary investment and compensating balances
Virgin Soft Drinks does not invest in money market securities such as Treasury bill
commercial paper certificate of deposits bankerrsquos acceptance and repurchase
agreement This firm deposits its money in bank as currant AC or fixed AC They
say that they do not have enough money to invest in money market instrument
They also say that if they have enough money they will invest it in money market
short term securities We know that near cash interest earning assets can be
substituted for cash when motivation for holding these assets is the hedging of cash
flow uncertainties or is the temporary investment of surplus funds In this point
Virgins position is not good as there is no significant hedging against uncertainty of
cash
812 Floatation and Check Clearing
Virgin is very smart in handling the problem of transit time for checks Here mail
float takes 2 to 3 days at firm takes 025 day and clearing float takes 1-3 days Virgin
uses most of the strategies available for reducing the delay in receiving funds It
(Virgin) has linked Islami Bank which posses an accelerated clearing facility It uses
electronic collection process which ensures faster collection and its at the firm check
processing is satisfactory But Virgin does not use lockbox The reason behind this is
that it is not cost-effective for Virgin to set lockboxes At this point we can say that
Virgins check clearing mechanism is much good
813 Cash Concentration and Disbursement Management
Page 33 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks takes the matter of cash concentration very seriously They use all
the available cash concentration mechanism Virgin is a firm with small deposits
spread over a substantial number of banks and this is why the firm tends to use
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
depository transfer checks extensively If is less costly Virgin also uses automated
clearing house and wire transfer To Virgin wire transfer seems too costly
Like other firm Virgin tries to retain the cash for as long as possible But Virgin
always performs it in an ethical manner Virgin does not try to defeat the receiving
firmrsquos attempts to reduce the float on incoming checks It does not take any strategy
for increasing mail float at firm float and clearing float on its outgoing checks To
Virgin it is deemed to be unethical It thinks that maximization of disbursement float
will not go unnoticed by sophisticated creditors for very long When it is noticed it
will negatively affect relations with these creditors reducing the firmrsquos bargaining
power with them This may ultimately cost Virgin dearly when future prices and
delivery schedules for goods and services purchased from trade creditors are
negotiated Virgin follows ldquoZero-Balance Accountsrdquo methods for managing
disbursement It thinks that in this method the coordination of funds inflows to
disbursement banks with the presentation of checks does not work to the detriment
of creditors since the firmrsquos checks to them are honored as presented and this strategy
does not affect float significantly Controlled disbursing method is less attractive to
Virgin because zero-balance system is already feasible
814 Cash Forecasting
Cash Forecasting and Its Types
Page 34 of 46
Virgin forecasts the future cash inflows and outflows To Virgin cash forecast is an
important part of the firmrsquos cash control system and is one of the forecasts that are
part of the Virginrsquos financial plan Virgin forecasts cash on monthly basis and on
yearly basis Virgin does not forecast on daily basis assuming that the temporary
shortage of funds within these periods can be covered without value cost eg
advance receipts from customers Virginrsquos cash forecasting system involves a
combination of distribution and scheduling The receipts and disbursements
approach of cash forecasting is used in virgin This method is used because it
minutely traces the movement of cash and very close control of cash is possible
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Virgin does not use adjusted net income approach on two grounds First it does not
permit the tracing of the individual types of cash inflows and outflows for any given
period which is often useful information for virgin Second it is not simple to use
Items to be Forecast
Virgin does not forecast all the items It forecasts only major items eg accounts
receivable notes receivable payroll cash purchases of raw materials In this regard
virgin trade off between cost and benefit
Methods of Financial Forecasting
Virgin forecasts the future level of financial variable such as cash level asset level or
liability level We know in short term forecasts many things will result from plans
and events that are already in place (contracts capital budgets long-range financing
plans and so forth) But in the long run most things can vary and are dependent on
outside influences such as the firmrsquos long-term growth rate Since Virginrsquos cash
forecasting deals mostly with near future many of the items on the cash forecasts are
estimated by some variation of the spot method and remaining estimates are mostly
on a ldquoproportion of another accountrdquo basis with this ldquoother accountrdquo often being a
particular periodrsquos sales Virgin uses the other two methods less frequently
Using Cash Forecast
Virgin forecasts cash for meeting general objectives (ie to know the available funds
for investment and need financing) and for meeting some special objectives (eg to
know whether the firm will fulfill its out of debt requirement) But it is matter to note
that Virgin does not make any short term investment of its surplus cash but only keep
this surplus in Bank Account
Page 35 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Sources of Uncertainty in Cash Forecasting and Hedging Uncertainties
Virgin faces uncertainty in cash forecasting mainly from two sources These are ndash
sales and production cost In peak season (hot season like autumn summer) sales
increases but in dull season (eg in winter) sales decreases drastically Production
cost may be increased because of increase of price of sugar chemicals aluminum
can Virgin follows two methods for hedging cash balance uncertainties These are ndash
i) Holding a stock of extra cash and
ii) Extra borrowing capacity
815 Modes for the Management of Cash and Temporary Investments
Virgin does not follow any of these methods wholly Virgin receives cash
continuously and pays salary at steady rate and pays continuously for other
expenses So it neither follows Baumol model nor Beranek model It has no upper
control limit lower control limit return point in case cash management So it neither
follows Miller-Orr model nor Stone model
In Summary
Page 36 of 46
Standard Compliance by Virgin Soft Drinks
Generally all firms hold cash and
marketable securities
Virgin holds only cash
Firms hold cash and marketable
securities for some reasons like
bull Cash for transactions
bull Cash and near-cash assets as
hedges
bull Temporary investments
bull Compensating balances
Virgin holds cash only for
two reasons ndash
bull Cash for transactions
bull Cash as hedges
Available money market instruments Virgin does not invest in any such
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
(short term securities) are ndash
Treasury Bills
Commercial Paper
Certificates of Deposit
Bankerrsquos Acceptance
Repurch menase Agree ts
instruments They only keep cash in
Bank Account
Mail Float
(1 to 5 days)
At Firm
Float
(025 to 1
day)
Clearing
Float
(0 to
2 days)
Mail Float
(2 to 3 days)
At firm
Float
(025
day)
Clearing
Float
(1 to 3
days)
Figure Transit time for a typical check Figure Transit time for a check for
Virgin
Strategies that firms can use to reduce
the delay in receiving funds are ndash
Selecting of Banks with
accelerated clearing capabilities
of check processing Acceleration
at the firm
ectronic collection Use of el
procedures
Use of lockboxes
Virgin follows the first three strategies
but does not use lockboxes
Available cash concentration
mechanisms are ndash
Depository transfer check
ouse Automated Clearing H
(ACH) electronic transfer)
Wire transfer
Virgin uses all these mechanisms of
cash concentration
Available sets of techniques for cash
disbursement management are ndash
ement of disbursement
Page 37 of 46
Manag
float
Virgin uses zero-balance accounts
technique
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Zero-Balance Accounts
Controlled disbursing
Firms may make cash flow forecasts
over periods of various lengths yearly
flows quarterly flows monthly flows
weekly flows or even daily flows
Virgin forecasts cash on yearly basis and
monthly basis
Cash forecasting system may involve ndash
Distribution
Scheduling
Virginrsquos cash forecasting system
involves a combination of distribution
and scheduling
Two common approaches to cash flow
in generating the cash forecast
and disbursement Receipts
approach
Adjusted net income approach
Virgin uses the receipts and
disbursement approach
There are many items to forecast Virgin forecasts only major items like
AR payroll etc
Four common approach to forecasting
fina i ndash nc al variables are
Spot method
Proportion to another account
Compounded growth
Multiple dependencies
Virgin uses spot method for forecasting
cash It uses proportion to another
account method for other variables and
remaining two methods are frequently
used
Sources of uncertainty in cash
forecasting are ndash
Sales uncertainty
Collection rate uncertainty
Production cost uncertainty
Capital outflow uncertainty
Virgin faces uncertainty mainly from
sales and production cost
Methods for hedging cash balance
unc a
Page 38 of 46
ert inties are ndash
i) Holding a stock of extra cash
Virgin two available methods for
hedging cash balance uncertainties
Th ese are ndash
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
ii) stock of near-cash Holding a
assets
iii) Extra borrowing capacity
iv) ary surpluses in Investing tempor
near-cash assets
i) Holding a stock of extra cash
ii) Extra borrowing capacity
(advance receipt from
customers)
Models for the management of cash and
temporary investments are ndash Baumol
model Beranek model Miller-Orr
model and Stone model
Virgin does not follow any method
wholly but a combination of Baumol
model and Beranek model is occurred
82 INVENTORY MANAGEMENT
21 Certainty Approach
isnt used in
irgin because it thinks it is not possible to implement in Bangladesh
d time is one to three days It
oes not use ABC system of inventory management
8
Main item of inventory of Virgin is Can pet chip sugar label chemical artificial
sweet etc Virgin maintains a minimum level of inventory but it does not have to face
problems because inventory is managed efficiently just-in-time (JIT)
V
Virgin maintains buffer stock because of the shortage of work-in-process (WIP)
inventory Its production process may also be hampered Thats why it maintains
safety stock to avoid stock out cost In case of imported goods normal lead time is
about one month and within the country normal lea
d
Page 39 of 46
Inventory Model
In reality Virgin does not use any of models of EOQ ordering and holding strategy
and safety stock strategy They maintain inventory based on their prior experience
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
822 Uncertainty Approach
Virgin does not use any model for handling inventory uncertainty It says that such
decision depends on business cycle and market situation Long before Eid festival
they bought large amount of sugar because of price increase on the occasion of Eid
In summary
Standard Compliance by Virgin Soft Drinks
Firms maintain inventory to guard
against several problems
Virgin maintains a minimum level of
inventory which is managed efficiently
Some firms use JIT to avoid inventory
cost
JIT is not used by Virgin as it thinks it is
impossible to implement in Bangladesh
Firms maintain buffer stock Virgin maintains buffer stock too
Firms maintain safety stock to avoid
shortage cost
Virgin also maintains safety stock
Firms use ABC system to monitor
inventory
Virgin doesnt use ABC system
EOQ model is an appropriate method
for measuring quantity that has to be
ordered per order
Virgin does not use EOQ model rather
makes order based on experience and
market demand
83 MANAGING ACCOUNTS RECEIVABLE (DEBTORS)
831 Terms of Sale Decision
Page 40 of 46
Virgin offers the term 210 net 30 enables the customers to deduct 2 percent from the
face value of the bill when paying within the first 10 days but if the discount is not
taken the customer must remit the full amount within 30 days But Virgin does not
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
offer the same terms of sale to all customers For prime customers it offers special
terms of sale In setting an appropriate term of sale it costs and benefits regarding
this are compared It uses the standard approach of terms of sale decision as it is
simple to use
832 Credit Granting Decisions
In case of Virgin the Capital and Character of Five Cs get more importance
Although there are many problems with the traditional approach Virgin uses it
because of its simplicity Virgin does not use Net Present Value (NPV) method in
credit granting decision It thinks that NPV is an appropriate method and should be
used next time It does not face any severe problem because of bad debts The reason
is that notes receivable is used when credit is granted
833 Monitoring Accounts Receivable
Virgin monitors its accounts receivable Virgin believes that in any case both positive
and negative durations in accounts signal differences from the results that
management believe to be the most advantageous for the firm
Tools for Monitoring Accounts Receivable
Page 41 of 46
For monitoring accounts receivable there are several tools such as aging schedule
the ratios of receivable outstanding to original sales customers payment proportion
and sales weighted DSO (Days Sales Outstanding) For monitoring accounts
receivable Virgin uses aging schedule fractions and traditional DSO statistics
because of their simplicity in use Although payment proportions ratios of
receivables outstanding and sales weighted DSO methods are free from inherent bias
None of these is used because all these are complex to maintain
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
In summary
Page 42 of 46
Standard Compliance by Virgin Soft Drinks
Generals terms of sale is 210 net 30 Normally Virgin also use general terms
of sale ie 210 net 30
Firms do not offer the same terms of
sale to all customers
Yes For prime customers Virgin offers
special terms of sale
Approaches of terms of sale decisions
are ndash
bull Standard approach
bull Multi period approach
Virgin uses standard approach of terms
of sale decision as it is simple to use and
understand
Source of credit information are ndash
Sellers prior experience with the
customer
Credit agency ratings and
reports
Personal contact with the
applicants bank and other
creditors
Analysis of applicants financial
statements
Customer visit
Main source of credit information to
Virgin is its prior experience with the
customer All other sources are not cost-
effective for Virgin
Approaches of credit granting to
marginal accounts are ndash
Traditional approach
Net Present Value (NPV)
approach
It uses traditional approach still now but
thinks that NPV should be used for the
next periods
Firms monitor accounts receivable
because deviations from the expected
levels of turnover and of bad debt can
Virgin also monitors its accounts
receivable
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
signal several different problems
Different tools for monitoring accounts
receivable are ndash
Aging schedule
Ratios of receivables
outstanding to original sales
Customers payment
proportions
Sales-weighted DSO
For monitoring accounts receivable
Virgin uses aging schedule and
traditional sales outstanding statistics
84 MANAGING ACCOUNTS PAYABLE (CREDITORS)
Virgin has almost accounts payable of Tk 8000000 But most of its liabilities are to
the banks rather than suppliers But we dont have any clear information about
Virgins accounts payable
9 RECOMMENDATION
Virgin should invest its surplus cash in short term marketable securities
because it is suitable hedging against cash uncertainties and will also give
some returns (interest income)
Virgin should publish its own annual report which will satisfy information
needs of stakeholders and also increase the credibility of information provided
by Virgin
Page 43 of 46
Virgin should use multi period approach in terms of sale decision because
standard approach which is already exists in Virgin has some inherent
problems
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
It should stop using traditional approach from now It should use NPV
method in credit granting to marginal accounts
In monitoring accounts receivable Virgin should use sales-weighted DSO
method because it has least limitation compared to the others
It should be more flexible in granting credit which will ultimately increase its
sales
To get the appropriate number of quantity to be ordered per order it should
use DSO model
It should be ABC system for proper monitoring of inventory
10 CONCLUSION
The use of other peoples money in business is usually an expensive resource Before
looking outside for finance a firm should examine its own working capital cycle to
make sure that every rand of its own internal funds is being fully utilized Good
management of working capital is part of good financial management Effective use
of working capital will contribute to the operational efficiency of the whole
organization optimum use will help to generate maximum returns Furthermore
working capital management is not an end in itself It is an integral part of the firms
overall management The needs of efficient working capital management must be
considered in relation to other aspects of the Virgins financial and non-financial
performance Thats why when planning the development of a business it is critical
that the impact of working capital be fully assessed
Page 44 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
BIBLIOGRAPHY
Scherr FC (1989) International Edition Prentice-Hall International Inc Modern
Working Capital Management Text and Cases
Hussain Riaz (2002) Working Capital Management
Robertson Lonnie (July 1998) Inventory Management
httpwwwasashoporg visited on March 13 2006
The Art of Cash Management
httpwwwinccom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management
httpwwwstudyfinancecom visited on March 13 2006
White Paper ndash Managing Working Capital
httpwwwplanwareorg visited on March 13 2006
Management of Working Capital
httpwwwbusinesscentralcoza visited on March 13 2006
Cash Management
httpwwwsbagov visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management Objectives
httpwpsprenhallcom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management
Page 45 of 46
httpwwwadvancemecom visited on March 13 2006
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Business Receivables Financing
httpwwwbbtcom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Finance
http wwwfnbcoza visited on March 13 2006
Tips to manage your working capital
httpsmallbusinessninemsncomau visited on March 13 2006
Inventory Financing
httpwwwfranklincapitalnetworkcom visited on March 13 2006
Accounts Receivable Management
httpwwwfranklincapitalnetworkcom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management
httpwwwtreasurygovtnz visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management
httpwwwtreasurystrategiescom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Works
httpwwwinvestopediacom visited on March 13 2006
Treasury Services
httpwwwjpmorganchasecom visited on March 13 2006
what were about
Page 46 of 46
httpwwwvirgincom visited on March 13 2006
Annexure
Annexure
Interview with YASEER RIZVI
Mr Yaseer Rizvi the DMD of Global Beverage Co Ltd obtained his MBA degree
from a reputed university He had been the Director of Ocean Container Ltd before
joining in Global Beverage Co Ltd He possesses a nice personality
I interviewed Yaseer Rizvi Excerpts from his interview are as follows ndash
Shah Kamal Sir would you please tell me do you invest in short term marketable securities
Yaseer Rizvi Basically we do not invest our surplus cash in short term marketable
securities like T-Bill commercial paper certificate of deposit etc But we keep our
surplus cash in Bank
Shah Kamal Would you tell me something about transit time for a typical check
Yaseer Rizvi Well in Virgin the transit time for a typical check is ndash
For mail float 2 to 3 days
At firm float 6 hours
Clearing float 1 to 3 days
Shah Kamal Do you maintain any cash concentration mechanism like depository transfer check automated clearing house and wire transfer
i
Annexure
Yaseer Rizvi Our position in this case is very strong as we use all the mechanisms
you mentioned As Virgin is a firm with small deposits spread over a substantial
number of banks so we tend to use depository transfer checks extensively It is less
costly We also use automated clearing house and wire transfer but later is used in a
less extent
Shah Kamal Sir what techniques of disbursement management is used by your firm
Yaseer Rizvi Like other firms Virgin tries to retain the cash for as long as possible
But we always perform it in an ethical manner We do not use management of
disbursement float as it seems unethical We follow Zero-Balance Accounts method
for managing disbursement We do not prefer Controlled Disbursing method since
Zero-Balance system is already practiced in Virgin
Shah Kamal How do you hedge cash balance uncertainties
Yaseer Rizvi Well you may say that we do not invest in short term securities but for
facing cash difficulties we keep our surplus cash in bank
Shah Kamal Sir would you please tell me the general terms of sale of Virgin
Yaseer Rizvi Though it is difficult to maintain a fixed terms of sale our general terms
of sale is 210 n30 But for prime customers we offer special terms of sale
Shah Kamal What are the sources of credit information in case of your firm
Yaseer Rizvi We grant credit on the basis of prior experience with the customers In
case of a new customer personal contact is weighted
Shah Kamal Does your firm consider 5 Cs in granting credit
ii
Annexure
Yaseer Rizvi In case of Virgin Capital and Character get more importance than the
others Mind one thing personal relationship is the main measure in granting credit
Shah Kamal Do you use NPV method in credit granting decisions
Yaseer Rizvi We do not use NPV method But we think that NPV is a suitable
method and we have to use it from the next period
Shah Kamal Sir how do you handle the problem of bad debt
Yaseer Rizvi Well in this case our position is very strong Yet we do not face any
problem because of bad debt Just note that we make more than 80 of sales in cash
and we monitor accounts receivable very carefully
Shah Kamal What level of inventory is maintained by Virgin
Yaseer Rizvi We maintain a minimum level of inventory but do not have to face
stock out problems because inventory is managed efficiently
Shah Kamal What is the normal lead time
Yaseer Rizvi In case of imported goods normal lead time is about 1 month and when
we purchase raw materials from inside the country lead time is 1 to 3 days
Shah Kamal What method do you use for managing inventory
Yaseer Rizvi We do not use any method particularly rather inventory decision
depends on business cycle and market situation Long before the Eid festival we
bought large amount of sugar because price of sugar was increased on the occasion
of Eid
iii
Annexure
Shah Kamal What are the main items of inventory of your firm
Yaseer Rizvi Well these are ndash aluminum can pet chip sugar label chemical and
artificial sweet
Shah Kamal What are the uncertainties in maintaining appropriate level of stock
Yaseer Rizvi These are ndash
bull Increase in price of raw materials
bull Sales uncertainty
bull Market trends etc
Shah Kamal Thank you for your kind cooperation
Yaseer Rizvi Most Welcome
iv
Global Beverage Company Limited
UNIVERSITY OF DHAKA DEPARTMENT OF ACCOUNTING AND INFORMATION SYSTEMS
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Submitted to
Mr Md Amirus Salat
Assistant Professor
Department of Accounting and Information Systems
University of Dhaka
Submitted by
Shah KamalDepartment of Accounting amp Information SystemsUniversity of Dhaka
Table of Contents
Executive Summary
1 Introduction 01
2 Objectives of the Study 02
3 Methodology 02
4 Limitations of the Study 03
5 Working Capital Management 04
51 Defining Working Capital 04
52 Working Capital Policies 05
53 Working Capital Cycle 07
531 Cash Management 08
532 Inventory Management 19
533 Managing Accounts Receivable (Debtors) 22
534 Managing Accounts Payable (Creditors) 26
6 Overview of Virgin Group 29
7 Overview of Virgin Soft Drinks 31
8 Finding of Working Capital Management Maintained by Virgin Soft Drinks in Bangladesh
32
81 Cash Management 32
82 Inventory Management 38
83 Managing Accounts Receivable (Debtors) 40
84 Managing Accounts Payable (Creditors) 43
9 Recommendation
43
10 Conclusion 44
Bibliography
Annexure
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
Working capital is basically an expression of how many in liquid assets the company
currently has to build its business fund its growth and produce value for the owner
The faster a business expands the more cash it will need for working capital and
investment The cheapest and best sources of cash exist as working capital right
within the business Good management of working capital will generate cash and
help improve profits and reduce risks My study is based on the comparison between
theoretical and practical aspects of working capital management For this purpose
Ive collected some information regarding working capital its cycle and its
management from Virgin Soft Drinks It has been found that their major transactions
are handled in cash But one of its major weaknesses is that it keeps its surplus funds
in banks rather than investing in marketable securities Therefore they can earn
optimum profit by implementing effective mechanism which will help to gain
optimum working capital
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
1 INTRODUCTION
Working capital is the life blood of any business big or small However smaller
businesses might find it more trying to maintain a comfortable level of capital
Managing working capital is an important factor for them Working capital
management is important because maintaining a balance of income to debt can be
difficult and owners must be diligent to assure that it is kept Sometimes it takes a
little assistance to maintain levels of fluidity or make major purchases If working
capital dips too low a business risks running out of cash Even very profitable
businesses can run into trouble if they lose the ability to meet their short-term
obligations Working capital financing can be used as a fast cash option to cushion
the periods when the flow is not ideal or readily available Even when owners are
meticulous in managing working capital finding the right levels to remain
comfortable and competitive can be difficult
The analogy has often been made that cash is the lifeblood of any business A
transfusion will miraculously bring the patient back from the brink of death but only
if
The blood is of the right kind
The problem causing the leakage is attended to
In other words the financial requirements of any business must be tailored to suit
that businesss own particular needs For example fixed assets should be financed by
long term loans and capital Working capital requirements should be attended to by
short term finance eg overdrafts
Page 1 of 46
It goes without saying that before capital is injected into the business it should first be
ascertained whether all unnecessary leakages have been plugged Otherwise in time
the transfusion will follow the same route To control and exploit the cash cycle
through any business so that it can continue to function on a day-to-day basis is
therefore the hub of working capital management The fundamental principle of
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
working capital management is having just the right amount of money available
when needed Every rand in the business should be earning its maximum return
wherever employed
2 OBJECTIVES OF THE STUDY
The study has been undertaken with the following objectives
To know the fundamentals of working capital management
To gather practical knowledge about the implementation of working capital
management by Virgin Soft Drinks
To understand the efficiency of Virgin Soft Drinks in managing working
capital
3 METHODOLOGY
In this paper the following methods are used
a) Sources and Data Collection
The major part of this paper is collected from the primary and secondary data
collection method
Conducted formal interview and focus observation and intensive practical
work to collect information
Page 2 of 46
Collected information from companys profiles
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Collected current information from website
b) Segregation of Data
Necessary data were segregated from the source material for the purpose of preparing
the report
c) Processing of Data
Collected data were compiled and processed for the purpose of preparing the report
d) Presentation of Data
Collected data were presented in charts and tables
4 LIMITATIONS OF THE STUDY
On the way of my study I have faced a number of problems which may be turned
as the limitation of report
Many personnel of the organization due to their pressure of the work were
reluctant to provide much useful information
Sufficient records publications facts and figures are not available These
constraints narrowed the scope of real analysis
Due to time constraint I could not spend sufficient time which was
necessary to make this report more representative of the fact
Page 3 of 46
Lack of experience has also acted as constraint for the exploration of the
topic
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
5 WORKING CAPITAL MANAGEMENT
51 DEFINING WORKING CAPITAL
The term working capital refers to the amount of capital which is readily available to
an organization That is working capital is the difference between resources in cash
or readily convertible into cash (Current Assets) and organizational commitments for
which cash will soon be required (Current Liabilities)
Current Assets are resources which are in cash or will soon be converted into cash in
the ordinary course of business
Current Liabilities are commitments which will soon require cash settlement in the
ordinary course of business
Thus ndash
WORKING CAPITAL = CURRENT ASSETS - CURRENT LIABILITIES
In a firms Statement of Financial position these components of working capital are
reported under the following headings
Current Assets
Liquid Assets (cash and bank deposits)
Inventory
Debtors and Receivables
Current Liabilities
Bank Overdraft
Creditors and Payables
Other Short Term Liabilities
Page 4 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Working capital management involves the relationship between a firms short-term
assets and its short-term liabilities The goal of working capital management is to
ensure that a firm is able to continue its operations and that it has sufficient ability to
satisfy both maturing short-term debt and upcoming operational expenses The
management of working capital involves managing inventories accounts receivable
and payable and cash
52 WORKING CAPITAL POLICIES
The aim of working capital policy is to balance having too little working capital
which can lead to an inability to pay debts as they fall due or the need for expensive
short term borrowings and too much which is wasteful in terms of lost opportunities
for the funds tied up The crucial role of working capital is that it finances the goods
inwards production and sales activities
A firmrsquos working capital policy has two components
1 Policies regarding the appropriate level of current assets (Current Asset Investment Policy)
2 Policies regarding the use of short-term financing (Current Asset Financing Policy)
Alternative Current Asset Investment Policies
These policies are general strategies that firms may follow with regard to their overall
level of current assets investment or holdings There are three types
1 Relaxed Current Asset Investment Policy ndash
Relatively large amounts of cash marketable securities and inventories are carried
and sales are stimulated by a liberal (generous) trade credit policy resulting in high
levels of receivables This is a low risk strategy because the firm always has plenty of
cash and inventory on hand The return is low because more money is invested in
low yielding assets
Page 5 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
2 Restricted Current Asset Investment Policy ndash
Holdings of cash securities inventories and receivables are minimized This is a
high risk strategy because the firm tries to keep the bare minimum of cash and
inventory The potential return is high because less money is invested in low
yielding assets
3 Moderate Current Asset Policy ndash
Balance between relaxed and restricted current asset investment policies (moderate
risk - moderate potential return)
Alternative Current Asset Financing Policies
These policies are general strategies that firms may follow with regard to how current
assets are to be financed Current assets can be classified as permanent or temporary
Permanent current assets are the current assets that the company needs to maintain
throughout the entire year Temporary current assets are those that are due to
seasonal fluctuations With respect to the current asset financing policy the question
is how the permanent current assets will and temporary current assets are financed
(long-term or short-term financing)
Page 6 of 46
Aggressive Moderate Conservative
Cash Minimum holding Prepared to hold
some precautionary
balances
Prepared to hold idle
cash balances
Debtors and
stock
Minimum
consistent with
business needs
Moderate levels High stock and
debtor levels to
maximize sales
Creditors Maximum
available without
compromising
business needs
Moderate level Low level seeking
discounts and
reputation for good
payment
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Future cash
flows
Predictable Reasonably
predictable
Unpredictable
Attitude to
Risk
Accepting Neutral Rejecting
Total assets = Fixed Assets + Permanent Current Assets + Fluctuating Current Assets
53 WORKING CAPITAL CYCLE
Cash flows in a cycle into around and out of a business It is the businesss life blood
and every managers primary task is to help keep it flowing and to use the cash flow
to generate profits If a business is operating profitably then it should in theory
generate cash surpluses If it doesnt generate surpluses the business will eventually
run out of cash and expire
The faster a business expands the more cash it will need for working capital and
investment The cheapest and best sources of cash exist as working capital right
within business Good management of working capital will generate cash will help
improve profits and reduce risks
Working capital can be broken down into the following major components cash (or
bank overdraft) stock debtors creditors Each of these items can have a major
influence on the working capital (or simply cash) that any business requires on an
ongoing basis For example when a business starts up the owner may inject a
certain amount of cash into the business which will enable him to purchase his initial
stock pay his workers their first months wages and cover other overheads such as
rent He then sells his product and this income may be utilized to purchase more
stock pay more wages and overheads and perhaps even have a surplus over for his
own use The quicker he can turn his stock over to receive payment the sooner the
working capital cycle will be completed
Page 7 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Figure Working Capital Cycle
These major components of working capital are discussed below
531 CASH MANAGEMENT
The term cash management refers to the management of cash from the time it starts
its transit to the firm until it leaves the firm in payments Cash management
encompasses the design of collection and disbursement systems for cash and the
temporary investment of cash while it resides with the firm Widely used money
market instruments are-
Treasury bill
Commercial paper
Certificate of deposits
Bankerrsquos acceptance
Page 8 of 46
Repurchase agreement
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
5311 Motives for Holding Cash
Despite the seemingly low returns there are several good reasons why firms hold
cash and marketable securities These reasons are ndash
Cash for transactions
Cash and near cash assets as hedges
Temporary investment and
Compensating balances
5312 Components of Cash Management
A Cash Flow Statement shows the sources and uses of cash and is typically divided
into three components
Operating Cash Flow
Operating cash flow often referred to as working capital is the cash flow generated
from internal operations It comes from sales of the product or service of your
business and because it is generated internally it is under your control
Investing Cash Flow
Investing cash flow is generated internally from non-operating activities This
includes investments in plant and equipment or other fixed assets nonrecurring gains
or losses or other sources and uses of cash outside of normal operations
Financing Cash Flow
Financing cash flow is the cash to and from external sources such as lenders
investors and shareholders
Page 9 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
5313 Tools for Cash Management
Flotation and Check Clearing
Management of cash when it is not in the firmrsquos hands that is in transit to and from
the firm is on important function in the area of finance Transit times for the check
takes in three stages These are mail float at firm float and clearing float Normally
mail float takes 1 to 5 days at firm float takes 025 to 1 day and clearing float takes 0
to 2 days The firm should care about this process because every delay in the receipt
of money by the firm lowers the firmrsquos returns and therefore its shareholdersrsquo wealth
There are several strategies that firm can use to reduce the delay in receiving funds
Each of these strategies addresses one or more of the three float times (mail float
time at time float time and clearing float time) that make up the total transit time of
fund from one firm to another
Other Cash Management Tools
When the economy is strong companies can lapse into sloppy cash-management
practices Firm should try exploring these options
1 Sweep accounts
These bank accounts are the easiest way to generate some income from companys
spare funds however they make sense only if the money youll earn will be greater
than the fees your bank will charge Business owners have two types of sweep
accounts to choose between
Page 10 of 46
Controlled-investment accounts These are the most profitable form of
sweep account but they wont work for company if the firm has any
electronic payments or wire transfers since those may be submitted for
payment later in the day and the account wont have enough cash in it to
cover them
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Page 11 of 46
End-of-day sweep accounts A safer bet for most small-business owners
these accounts wait until a late-hour cutoff to determine how much to
sweep into the firms overnight investments Typically their investment
yields are 10 to 20 basis points (1 to 2 of the investment) lower than
those offered with controlled investments
2 Lock-box accounts
A lock box is a cash-management system that helps the firm collect funds quickly
Generally set up with the assistance of a big money center or regional bank lock
boxes provide the firm with a special zip code and usually quicker deliveries from
regional post offices They are especially important if the firm has clusters of
customers in out-of-state locations and dont want to lose days waiting for their
checks to arrive by long-distance mail
5314 Cash Concentration and Cash Disbursement
Once the remittances from the firmrsquos customers have been received and cleared the
resulting cash balances is available in the firmrsquos lockbox (depository) banks It is
useful for the firm to gather these balances from the lockbox banks into the central
bank account The process of collecting funds is called cash concentration
Several concentration mechanism are available for the firm to use in transferring
funds from its collection banks to regional concentration banks and from there to the
central concentration bank These mechanisms differ in cost and in the availability of
funds that they provide These are ndash
a) Depository Transfer Check
It is the cheapest transfer mechanism This document instructs one bank to
send funds to another and is treated the same as any other check
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
b) Automated Clearing House (ACH) Electronic Transfer
This vehicle is essentially an electronic version of the depository transfer
check and can be used between banks that participate in the automated
clearing house system
c) Wire Transfer
These are electronic message between banks
Decisions regarding concentration mechanism usually hinge on the size and
spread of the firmrsquos deposits Firms with small deposits spread over a
substantial number of banks will tend to have more extensive concentration
systems and will transfer among accounts using low-cost transfer vehicles that
offer only delayed availability (such as depository transfer checks) Firms with
larger deposits will have fewer accounts (since a local deposit for transfer to
an upstream bank is not needed) and will use more expensive and more rapid
transfer mechanisms (such as wire transfers) The concentration systems of
major chemical companies for example tend to be structured in this way ndash
DepositoryLockbox Banks
Regional Concentration Banks
Central Concentrated Bank
Figure A typical Cash Concentration System
(Arrows indicate transfers of collected funds)
Page 12 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Disbursement management addresses the efficient payout out of this cash once it is
concentrated The firmrsquos objective in disbursement management is to retain the cash
for as long as possible In this way the firm will have the maximum amount of funds
available for investment and transactional purposes Certainly this management
means making disbursement only when they are due and not before The firm has
several available set of techniques for disbursement management Included among
these are ndash
a) Management of Disbursement Float
In this set of techniques the disbursing firm attempts to increase the length of
time between the mailing of its checks and the eventual withdrawal of funds
from the banks This involves strategies for increasing mail float at firm float
and clearing float on its outgoing checks For example the disbursing firm
may intentionally address checks to the firmrsquos office address rather than its
lockbox creating at firm float
b) Zero-Balance Accounts
Here the firm holds the cash until the check arrive (or expected to arrive) at
the disbursement bank In this strategy an account for disbursement is first
established at a bank For the zero-balance system to be effective the
participating bank must be one on which most disbursement are made via the
Bangladesh Bankrsquos clearance system (which presents disbursements to banks
early in the morning) and not a bank where disbursements occur throughout
the day (as with a major money-center bank) Consequently the banks used
in zero-balance strategies are usually branches of major banks and not their
main locations
Page 13 of 46
c) Controlled Disbursing
In this system the firm projects the amount of checks to arrive each day at the
disbursement bank (based on the checks written in previous days and historic
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
statistics on disbursement float) and transfers the amount of the expected
checks to the account on that day or just before
5315 Cash Forecasting
Defining Cash Forecasting
The cash forecast is an estimation of the flows in and out of the firmrsquos cash account
over a particular period of time usually a quarter month week or day The cash
forecast is primarily intended to produce a very useful piece of information an
estimation of the firmrsquos borrowing and lending needs and uncertainties regarding
these needs during various future periods Cash forecasting is very crucial to most
firms It enables them to anticipate periods of surplus cash and periods where
financing will be necessary This anticipation is the reason that cash forecasts are
generated Anticipation enables the firm to plan much more effectively for
investment and financing and via this planning produce superior return
Types of Cash Forecasts
The types of cash forecasts generated by firms can be differentiated along two
dimensions the length of the periods included within the cash forecast and the approach
to cash flows used in the cash forecast The length of the period refers to the units of
time into which the cash forecast is divided Firms may make cash flow forecasts
over periods of various lengths yearly flows quarterly flows monthly flows weekly
flows or even daily flows The most popular forecast involves monthly flows but
most firms do not confine themselves to a single forecast Instead they use several
forecasts with periods of various lengths When the firm makes forecasts involving
multiple and overlapping period lengths one forecast relates to another Starting
with data on relatively long periods and breaking it down into smaller periods is
called distribution starting with data on relatively short periods and aggregating into
longer periods is called scheduling
Page 14 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Firms use two common approaches to cash flows in generating the cash forecast the
receipts and disbursements approach and the adjusted net income approach The receipts
and disbursements approach use the amounts of cash expected to be received and
disbursed by the firm over the periods chosen for forecast The adjusted income
statement approach is sometimes called the sources and use approach Here the
forecaster starts with projected net income on an accrual basis and adjusts to a cash
basis This method provides a representation of changes in asset and liability
accounts since the level of these accounts are of interest to the firm this aspect of the
adjusted income statement is an advantage over the receipts and disbursements
method
Items to Be Forecast
In the receipt and disbursements cash forecasting method estimates need to be made
of the numerous major and minor items that the firm collects (receipts) and that it
pays (disbursements) The more individual categories of items the firm includes in its
forecast procedure the more accurate the forecast may be but the more costly in
terms of time and effort it will be to generate
Some Possible Types of Cash Receipts and Cash Disbursements
Cash Disbursements Cash Receipts
Cash Purchases of Materials Payroll
Taxes
Maturing Accounts Payable
Maturing Notes Payable
Miscellaneous Disbursements
Accounts Receivable
Notes Receivable
Rental Income
Interest Income
Miscellaneous Receipts
Methods of Financial Forecasting
Page 15 of 46
Financial forecasting is the estimation of the future level of a financial variable often
a cash flow asset level or liability level It is usually assumed that the relationship
between the financial variable and other variable is linear The general linear model
can then be used
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
nnt xaxaxaaY 22110 ++=
Here
= Financial variable (Y) to be forecast in period t tY
x = Explanatory variable it is assumed to cause the level of Y in period t
0a = Represents a constant unaffected by the x
The other terms are the estimated coefficients of the explanatory x variables
There are n terms with xrsquos in them
There are four common approaches to forecasting financial variables but they
are all special cases of the general linear model These are ndash spot method proportion
to another account compounded growth and multiple dependencies
Using Cash Forecast
The estimate of available funds for investment and needed financing enables the firm
to plan so as to obtain the most advantages borrowing terms for deficits and achieve
the greatest interest income on surplus A useful chart for this planning purpose is a
bar chart eg
Figure Bar Chart of Cash Surpluses and Deficits from hypothetical data
Page 16 of 46
75
50
-60
30
100
-20
-80-60-40-20
020406080
100120
Defic
it
S
urpl
us
January February March April May June
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Sources of Uncertainty in Cash Forecasting and Hedging Uncertainties
There are numerous sources of risk in cash forecasting Among the sources are sales
uncertainty collection rate uncertainty production cost uncertainty and capital
outflow uncertainty
5316 Models for the Management of Cash and Temporary Investments
There are different models for the management of cash and temporary investments
Among these the most popular methods are ndash Baumol model Beranek model
Miller-Orr model and Stone model
Baumol and Beranek use the same model The formula is cited below ndash
Interest Income = iYn
n⎥⎦⎤
⎢⎣⎡ minus
21
Profit = naiYn
nminus⎥⎦
⎤⎢⎣⎡ minus
21
Optimum number of transactions = ⎟⎠⎞
⎜⎝⎛
aiY2
Where n = Optimum number of transactions
i = Interest rate per period
a = Transaction cost
Y = Total inflow for the period
Page 17 of 46
Miller-Orr and Stone use the same model ie R-Statistic The model is ndash
31
43
iav
R ⎟⎠⎞
⎜⎝⎛=
Optimum Control Limit = R + L
Upper Control Limit = 3R + L
Where a = Transaction Cost
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
v = Variance of daily cash flows
i = Daily interest rate
5317 Administration
Cash receipts should be processed and banked as quickly as possible because
They cannot earn interest or reduce overdraft until they are banked
information about the existence and amounts of cash receipts is usually not
available until they are processed
Where possible cash floats (mainly petty cash and advances) should be avoided If
on review the only reason that can be put forward for their existence is that weve
always had them they should be discontinued There may be situations where they
are useful however For example it may be desirable for peripheral parts of
departments to meet urgent local needs from cash floats rather than local bank
accounts
5318 Internal Control
Cash and cash management is part of a firms overall internal control system The
main internal cash control is invariably the bank reconciliation This provides
assurance that the cash balances recorded in the accounting systems are consistent
with the actual bank balances It requires regular clearing of reconciling items
5319 Practicing Good Cash Flow Management
Good cash management is simple It involves
Knowing when where and how firms cash needs will occur
Page 18 of 46
Knowing the best sources for meeting additional cash needs
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Page 19 of 46
Being prepared to meet these needs when they occur by keeping good
relationships with bankers and other creditors
532 INVENTORY MANAGEMENT
Inventory management is necessary for owners who want to maintain a stocking
service for quick turnaround to help ensure total customer satisfaction The fill rate
of an item on a managed inventory list must be maintained to avoid shortages of
frequently used items Even when utilizing an inventory management system
occasional shortages will still occur Inventories are lists of stocks-raw materials
work in progress or finished goods-waiting to be consumed in production or to be
sold The total balance of inventory is the sum of the value of each individual stock
line
Basically firms hold stocks for the following reasons
To act as a buffer in times of unusually high demand
To ensure continuity of production
Avoid high costs of emergency orders
To take advantage of quantity discounts by ordering more at a time
To reduce ordering costs by ordering more items on fewer
As part of the production process eg maturing whisky or keeping oil in
pipelines
Seasonality of demand (eg firework) or supplies
Suppliers insist on minimum order quantities
The key issue for a business is to identify the fast and slow stock movers with the
objectives of establishing optimum stock levels for each category and thereby
minimize the cash tied up in stocks Factors to be considered when determining
optimum stock levels include
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Page 20 of 46
What are the projected sales of each product
How widely available are raw materials components etc
How long does it take for delivery by suppliers
Can the firm remove slow movers from its product range without
compromising best sellers
Inventory management is an important aspect of working capital management
because inventories themselves do not earn any revenue Holding either too little or
too much inventory incurs costs
Costs of carrying too much inventory are
Opportunity cost of foregone interest
Warehousing costs
Damage and pilferage
Obsolescence
Insurance
Costs of carrying too little inventory are
Stock out costs
Lost sales
Delayed service
Ordering costs
Freight
on Order administrati
nts
Loss of quantity discou
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Carrying costs can be minimized by making frequent small orders but this increase
ordering costs and the risk of stock outs Risk of stock-outs can be reduced by
carrying safety stocks (at a cost) and re-ordering ahead of time
The best ordering strategy requires balancing the various cost factors to ensure the
firm incurs minimum inventory costs The optimum inventory position is known as
the Economic Reorder Quantity (ERQ)
Nowadays many large manufacturers operate on a just-in-time (JIT) basis whereby
all the components to be assembled on a particular today arrive at the factory early
that morning no earlier - no later This helps to minimize manufacturing costs as JIT
stocks take up little space minimize stock-holding and virtually eliminate the risks of
obsolete or damaged stock Because JIT manufacturers hold stock for a very short
time they are able to conserve substantial cash JIT is a good model to strive for as it
embraces all the principles of prudent stock management For better stock control
firm may try the following
Review the effectiveness of existing purchasing and inventory systems
Know the stock turn for all major items of inventory
Apply tight controls to the significant few items and simplify controls for the
trivial many
Sell off outdated or slow moving merchandise - it gets more difficult to sell the
longer the firm keeps it
Consider having part of its product outsourced to another manufacturer rather
than make it itself
Review its security procedures to ensure that no stock is going out the back
door
Higher than necessary stock levels tie up cash and cost more in insurance
accommodation costs and interest charges
Page 21 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
However it is important to keep an overall perspective It is not cost-effective to
closely manage a large number of low value inventory lines nor is it necessary A
usual feature of inventories is that a small number of high value lines account for a
large proportion of inventory value The 8020 rule (PARETO) predicts that 80
of the total value of inventory is represented by only 20 of the number of inventory
items Those high value lines need reasonably close management The remaining
80 of inventory lines can be managed using broad-brush strategies
533 MANAGING ACCOUNTS RECEIVABLE (DEBTORS)
Cash flow can be significantly enhanced if the amounts owing to a business are
collected faster Every business needs to know who owes them money how much is
owed how long it is owing for what it is owed
Debtors (Accounts Receivable) are customers who have not yet made payment for
goods or services which the department has provided The objective of debtor
management is to minimize the time-lapse between completion of sales and receipt
of payment The costs of having debtors are
Opportunity costs (cash is not available for other purposes)
Bad debts
If firm doesnt manage debtors they will begin to manage business as the firm will gradually
lose control due to reduced cash flow and of course it could experience an increased
incidence of bad debt The following measures will help manage debtors
Having the right mental attitude to the control of credit and make sure that it
gets the priority it deserves
Establishing clear credit practices as a matter of company policy
Page 22 of 46
Making sure that these practices are clearly understood by staff suppliers and
customers
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Page 23 of 46
Being professional when accepting new accounts and especially larger ones
Checking out each customer thoroughly before the firm offers credit Use
credit agencies bank references industry sources etc
Establishing credit limits for each customer and sticking to them
Continuously reviewing these limits when it suspects tough times are coming
or if operating in a volatile sector
Keeping very close to the firms larger customers
Invoicing promptly and clearly
Considering charging penalties on overdue accounts
Considering accepting credit debit cards as a payment option
Monitoring its debtor balances and ageing schedules and dont let any debts
get too large or too old
Debtor management includes both pre-sale and debt collection strategies
Pre-sale strategies include
Offering cash discounts for early payment andor imposing penalties for late
payment
Agreeing payment terms in advance
Requiring cash before delivery
Setting credit limits
ning credit Setting criteria for obtai
Billing as early as possible
rogress payments
ost-sale strategies include
for collecting the debt upon the center that made the sale
Requiring deposits andor p
P
Placing the responsibility
Identifying long overdue balances and doubtful debts by regular analytical reviews
Having an established procedure for late collections such as
A reminder
A letter
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Page 24 of 46
ion of further credit Cancellat
Telephone calls
n agency Use of a collectio
he firm should recognize that the longer someone owes firm the greater the chance
Legal action
T
it will never get paid If the average age of debtors is getting longer or is already very
long it may need to look for the following possible defects
Weak credit judgment
res Poor collection procedu
ms Lax enforcement of credit ter
Slow issue of invoices or statements
Errors in invoices or statements
Customer dissatisfaction
Debtors due over 90 days (unless within agreed credit terms) should generally
demand immediate attention For example warning signs of a future bad debt ndash
Longer credit terms taken with approval particularly for smaller orders
Use of post-dated checks by debtors who normally settle within agreed terms
Evidence of customers switching to additional suppliers for the same goods
New customers who are reluctant to give credit references
Cre G
Receiving part payments from debtors
dit ranting to Marginal Accounts
Traditional Approach
In the traditional approach to the credit granting decision it is the credit analysts job
rmation that has been collected and reach a judgment
regarding the applicants creditworthiness One traditional way of organizing this
to synthesize all the info
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
information is by characterizing the applicant along five dimensions These
dimensions are called the Five Cs of credit ndash
Capital
Character
Collateral
and Capacity
Conditions
Net Present Value (NPV) Approach
Once a firm has assessed the creditworthiness of a customer it has to decide whether
r not credit should be granted The firm should use the NPV rule to make the
ld be granted
Figure
o
decision If NPV is positive credit shou
Credit Granting Decision
Credit Granting Decision
he act of collecting money is one which most people dislike for many reasons and
therefore put on the long f selves there is something
ore urgent or important that demands their attention now There is nothing more
T
inger because they convince them
m
important than getting paid for firms product or service A customer who does not
Page 25 of 46
Grand Credit
Payment received Payment not received
Benefit of present value of future net cash flow
Cost of present value ment of lost invest
Net Payoff PV of benefit-cost
No Credit
No Payoff
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
pay is not a customer Here are a few ideas that may help the firm in collecting
money from debtors
Firm should develop appropriate procedures for handling late payments
It should track and pursue late payers
It might get external help if its own efforts fail
or money its firms and it is entitled Company shouldnt feel guilty asking f
to it
ction
Firm must make that call now And it should keep asking until it gets some
satisfa
lessens the problem
In difficult circumstances take what the firm can now and agree terms for the
remainder It
paying
When asking for money be hard on the issue - but soft on the person It shouldnt
give the debtor any excuses for not
534 BLE (CREDITORS)
ices for goods or services have
een paid Organizations often regard the
not
to delay all payments until the latest possible date Regular weekly or
The firm make it its objective is to get the money - not to score points or get
even
MANAGING ACCOUNTS PAYA
Creditors (Accounts Payable) are suppliers whose invo
been processed but who have not yet b
amount owing to creditors as a source of free credit However creditor
administration systems are expensive and time-consuming to run The over-riding
concern in this area should be to minimize costs with simple procedures
While it is unnecessary to pay accounts before they fall due it is usually
worthwhile
Page 26 of 46
fortnightly payment of all due accounts is the simplest technique for creditor
management
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Electronic payments (direct credits) are cheaper than check payments considering
that transaction fees and overheads more than balance the advantage of delayed
presentation Some suppliers are reluctant to receive payments by this method but in
view of the substantial cost advantage (and the advantages to the suppliers
themselves) departments may wish to encourage suppliers to accept this option
However electronic payments are likely to be used in conjunction with rather than
as a replacement for check payments
Applying Best Practices in Managing Accounts Payable
f course simply deferring payments to suppliers could have adverse consequences
O
that more than offset the benefits of this additional cash flow Therefore it is
important to develop a holistic approach The firm should consider the following
best practices for payables management
Managing payment dates and terms to maximize cash flow ndash
y reporting on
receivable and
id penalty charges and taking advantage of
wer vendors and negotiate for more
to buying consortia with others even
voices for
payment based on receipt of goods or receipt of invoice whichever
comes later
Calculating and setting performance targets Regularl
AP performance measures such as days in payables
Coordinating the AP processes with accounts
inventory management to ensure that the company is collecting more
cash than it is paying out
Paying bills on time to avo
prompt-payment discounts where the discounts exceed the companyrsquos
cost of working capital
Consolidating purchases with fe
favorable payment terms
Considering entering in
Page 27 of 46
competitors to obtain favorable supplier pricing and terms
Unless contract terms specify otherwise setting up in
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Page 28 of 46
Em
process
-time payments with Electronic Funds Transfer (EFT)
uraging vendors to utilize electronic invoice presentment
a
ndancies and more
ploying technology to automate the accounts payable transaction
es ndash
Making just-in
Using an electronic invoice-matching application
Enco
For companies with multiple locations or business units employing
shared service approach for AP to eliminate redu
quickly implement process improvements
Mainta
vendor
Communicating accounts payable requirements to suppliers at the
m key suppliers
for suggestions on how to improve the
Efficient a
and making th rsquos cash is just good business
ining open communications and building strong relationships with
s to access valuable trade credit ndash
beginning of transactions
Requesting summary invoicing fro
Requiring suppliers to send invoices directly to accounts payable
Asking tier-one suppliers
payment process
nd effective management of accounts payable helps improve cash flow ndash
e most of company
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
6 OVERVIEW OF VIRGIN GROUP
Virgin - one of the most respected brands in Britain - is now becoming the first global
brand name of the 21st century Virgin is involved in planes trains finance soft
drinks music mobile phones holidays cars wines publishing bridal wear - the lot
What tie all these businesses together are the values of its brand and the attitude of its
people Virgin has created over 200 companies worldwide employing over 25000
people Its total revenues around the world in 2002 exceeded pound4 billion (US $72
billion)
In 1970 Richard Branson founded Virgin as a mail order record retailer and not
long after he opened a record shop in Oxford Street London During 1972 a
recording studio was built in Oxfordshire and the first Virgin artist Mike Oldfield
recorded Tubular Bells which was released in 1973
This album went on to sell over 5 million copies Since then many household names
including Belinda Carlisle Genesis Phil Collins Janet Jackson and The Rolling
Stones have helped to make Virgin Music one of the top six record companies in the
world The equity of Virgin Music Group - record labels music publishing and
recording studios was sold to THORN EMI in 1992 in a US$1billion deal
Page 29 of 46
The Virgin Group has now expanded into international music Mega stores air
travel mobile financial retail music internet drinks rail hotels and leisure with
around 200 companies in over 30 countries
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
In Virgins customers eyes Virgin stands for value for money quality innovation
fun and a sense of competitive challenge It delivers a quality service by empowering
its employees and facilitates and monitors customer feedback to continually improve
the customers experience through innovation
When they start a new venture Virgin bases it on hard research and analysis
Typically they review the industry and put themselves in the customers shoes to see
what could make it better Virgin asks fundamental questions
Is this an opportunity for restructuring a market and creating competitive
advantage What are the competitors doing
Is the customer confused or badly served
Is this an opportunity for building the Virgin brand
Can we add value
Will it interact with its other businesses
Is there an appropriate trade-off between risk and reward
Page 30 of 46
Virgin is also able to draw on talented people from throughout the group New
ventures are often steered by people seconded from other parts of Virgin who bring
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
with them the trademark management style skills and experience Virgin frequently
creates partnerships with others to combine skills knowledge and market presence
and so on Contrary to what some people may think their constantly expanding and
eclectic empire is neither random nor reckless Each successive venture demonstrates
its skill in picking the right market and the right opportunity
7 OVERVIEW OF VIRGIN SOFT DRINKS
The Virgin Drinks Group first launched as the Virgin Cola Company in 1994 with
Virgin Cola in the UK Since then the company has ventured across the carbonated
soft drinks arena and beyond into energy drinks tea and flavored Colas This
expansion has lead to the evolution of the Virgin Drinks Company a company
whose aim is to put the excitement back into the world of soft drinks It launched in
Bangladesh in 1999 Virgin Soft Drinks is monitored by Global Beverage Co Ltd in
Bangladesh
Brief history of Virgin Drinks is given below
Page 31 of 46
1994 November Virgin Cola launched in the UK
1996 March Virgin Cola launched in France
1998 June Virgin Cola launched in Belgium
April Virgin Cola launched in the French West Indies
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
August Virgin Cola launched in Switzerland
1999 March Virgin Colours launched in Italy
March Virgin Cola launched in Japan
July Virgin Colours launched in South Africa
December Virgin Colours launched in Bangladesh
2001 January Sweden launched Virgin Colours
November Singapore launched Virgin Colours
2002 February Croatia launched Virgin Colours
June Russia launched Virgin Colours
June Tunisia launched Virgin Colours
2003 May Israel launched Virgin Colours
8 FINDINGS OF WORKING CAPITAL MANAGEMENT MAINTAINED BY
VIRGIN SOFT DRINKS IN BANGLADESH
81 CASH MANAGEMENT
811 Holding Cash and Marketable Securities
Although there are many good reasons why firm hold cash and marketable
securities Virgin Drinks holds cash and marketable securities for two reasons ndash
i) Cash for transactions
ii) Cash as hedges
This indicates that the firm does not hold cash and marketable securities for some
important reasons such as ndash
i) Near cash assets as hedges
Page 32 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
ii) Temporary investment and compensating balances
Virgin Soft Drinks does not invest in money market securities such as Treasury bill
commercial paper certificate of deposits bankerrsquos acceptance and repurchase
agreement This firm deposits its money in bank as currant AC or fixed AC They
say that they do not have enough money to invest in money market instrument
They also say that if they have enough money they will invest it in money market
short term securities We know that near cash interest earning assets can be
substituted for cash when motivation for holding these assets is the hedging of cash
flow uncertainties or is the temporary investment of surplus funds In this point
Virgins position is not good as there is no significant hedging against uncertainty of
cash
812 Floatation and Check Clearing
Virgin is very smart in handling the problem of transit time for checks Here mail
float takes 2 to 3 days at firm takes 025 day and clearing float takes 1-3 days Virgin
uses most of the strategies available for reducing the delay in receiving funds It
(Virgin) has linked Islami Bank which posses an accelerated clearing facility It uses
electronic collection process which ensures faster collection and its at the firm check
processing is satisfactory But Virgin does not use lockbox The reason behind this is
that it is not cost-effective for Virgin to set lockboxes At this point we can say that
Virgins check clearing mechanism is much good
813 Cash Concentration and Disbursement Management
Page 33 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks takes the matter of cash concentration very seriously They use all
the available cash concentration mechanism Virgin is a firm with small deposits
spread over a substantial number of banks and this is why the firm tends to use
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
depository transfer checks extensively If is less costly Virgin also uses automated
clearing house and wire transfer To Virgin wire transfer seems too costly
Like other firm Virgin tries to retain the cash for as long as possible But Virgin
always performs it in an ethical manner Virgin does not try to defeat the receiving
firmrsquos attempts to reduce the float on incoming checks It does not take any strategy
for increasing mail float at firm float and clearing float on its outgoing checks To
Virgin it is deemed to be unethical It thinks that maximization of disbursement float
will not go unnoticed by sophisticated creditors for very long When it is noticed it
will negatively affect relations with these creditors reducing the firmrsquos bargaining
power with them This may ultimately cost Virgin dearly when future prices and
delivery schedules for goods and services purchased from trade creditors are
negotiated Virgin follows ldquoZero-Balance Accountsrdquo methods for managing
disbursement It thinks that in this method the coordination of funds inflows to
disbursement banks with the presentation of checks does not work to the detriment
of creditors since the firmrsquos checks to them are honored as presented and this strategy
does not affect float significantly Controlled disbursing method is less attractive to
Virgin because zero-balance system is already feasible
814 Cash Forecasting
Cash Forecasting and Its Types
Page 34 of 46
Virgin forecasts the future cash inflows and outflows To Virgin cash forecast is an
important part of the firmrsquos cash control system and is one of the forecasts that are
part of the Virginrsquos financial plan Virgin forecasts cash on monthly basis and on
yearly basis Virgin does not forecast on daily basis assuming that the temporary
shortage of funds within these periods can be covered without value cost eg
advance receipts from customers Virginrsquos cash forecasting system involves a
combination of distribution and scheduling The receipts and disbursements
approach of cash forecasting is used in virgin This method is used because it
minutely traces the movement of cash and very close control of cash is possible
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Virgin does not use adjusted net income approach on two grounds First it does not
permit the tracing of the individual types of cash inflows and outflows for any given
period which is often useful information for virgin Second it is not simple to use
Items to be Forecast
Virgin does not forecast all the items It forecasts only major items eg accounts
receivable notes receivable payroll cash purchases of raw materials In this regard
virgin trade off between cost and benefit
Methods of Financial Forecasting
Virgin forecasts the future level of financial variable such as cash level asset level or
liability level We know in short term forecasts many things will result from plans
and events that are already in place (contracts capital budgets long-range financing
plans and so forth) But in the long run most things can vary and are dependent on
outside influences such as the firmrsquos long-term growth rate Since Virginrsquos cash
forecasting deals mostly with near future many of the items on the cash forecasts are
estimated by some variation of the spot method and remaining estimates are mostly
on a ldquoproportion of another accountrdquo basis with this ldquoother accountrdquo often being a
particular periodrsquos sales Virgin uses the other two methods less frequently
Using Cash Forecast
Virgin forecasts cash for meeting general objectives (ie to know the available funds
for investment and need financing) and for meeting some special objectives (eg to
know whether the firm will fulfill its out of debt requirement) But it is matter to note
that Virgin does not make any short term investment of its surplus cash but only keep
this surplus in Bank Account
Page 35 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Sources of Uncertainty in Cash Forecasting and Hedging Uncertainties
Virgin faces uncertainty in cash forecasting mainly from two sources These are ndash
sales and production cost In peak season (hot season like autumn summer) sales
increases but in dull season (eg in winter) sales decreases drastically Production
cost may be increased because of increase of price of sugar chemicals aluminum
can Virgin follows two methods for hedging cash balance uncertainties These are ndash
i) Holding a stock of extra cash and
ii) Extra borrowing capacity
815 Modes for the Management of Cash and Temporary Investments
Virgin does not follow any of these methods wholly Virgin receives cash
continuously and pays salary at steady rate and pays continuously for other
expenses So it neither follows Baumol model nor Beranek model It has no upper
control limit lower control limit return point in case cash management So it neither
follows Miller-Orr model nor Stone model
In Summary
Page 36 of 46
Standard Compliance by Virgin Soft Drinks
Generally all firms hold cash and
marketable securities
Virgin holds only cash
Firms hold cash and marketable
securities for some reasons like
bull Cash for transactions
bull Cash and near-cash assets as
hedges
bull Temporary investments
bull Compensating balances
Virgin holds cash only for
two reasons ndash
bull Cash for transactions
bull Cash as hedges
Available money market instruments Virgin does not invest in any such
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
(short term securities) are ndash
Treasury Bills
Commercial Paper
Certificates of Deposit
Bankerrsquos Acceptance
Repurch menase Agree ts
instruments They only keep cash in
Bank Account
Mail Float
(1 to 5 days)
At Firm
Float
(025 to 1
day)
Clearing
Float
(0 to
2 days)
Mail Float
(2 to 3 days)
At firm
Float
(025
day)
Clearing
Float
(1 to 3
days)
Figure Transit time for a typical check Figure Transit time for a check for
Virgin
Strategies that firms can use to reduce
the delay in receiving funds are ndash
Selecting of Banks with
accelerated clearing capabilities
of check processing Acceleration
at the firm
ectronic collection Use of el
procedures
Use of lockboxes
Virgin follows the first three strategies
but does not use lockboxes
Available cash concentration
mechanisms are ndash
Depository transfer check
ouse Automated Clearing H
(ACH) electronic transfer)
Wire transfer
Virgin uses all these mechanisms of
cash concentration
Available sets of techniques for cash
disbursement management are ndash
ement of disbursement
Page 37 of 46
Manag
float
Virgin uses zero-balance accounts
technique
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Zero-Balance Accounts
Controlled disbursing
Firms may make cash flow forecasts
over periods of various lengths yearly
flows quarterly flows monthly flows
weekly flows or even daily flows
Virgin forecasts cash on yearly basis and
monthly basis
Cash forecasting system may involve ndash
Distribution
Scheduling
Virginrsquos cash forecasting system
involves a combination of distribution
and scheduling
Two common approaches to cash flow
in generating the cash forecast
and disbursement Receipts
approach
Adjusted net income approach
Virgin uses the receipts and
disbursement approach
There are many items to forecast Virgin forecasts only major items like
AR payroll etc
Four common approach to forecasting
fina i ndash nc al variables are
Spot method
Proportion to another account
Compounded growth
Multiple dependencies
Virgin uses spot method for forecasting
cash It uses proportion to another
account method for other variables and
remaining two methods are frequently
used
Sources of uncertainty in cash
forecasting are ndash
Sales uncertainty
Collection rate uncertainty
Production cost uncertainty
Capital outflow uncertainty
Virgin faces uncertainty mainly from
sales and production cost
Methods for hedging cash balance
unc a
Page 38 of 46
ert inties are ndash
i) Holding a stock of extra cash
Virgin two available methods for
hedging cash balance uncertainties
Th ese are ndash
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
ii) stock of near-cash Holding a
assets
iii) Extra borrowing capacity
iv) ary surpluses in Investing tempor
near-cash assets
i) Holding a stock of extra cash
ii) Extra borrowing capacity
(advance receipt from
customers)
Models for the management of cash and
temporary investments are ndash Baumol
model Beranek model Miller-Orr
model and Stone model
Virgin does not follow any method
wholly but a combination of Baumol
model and Beranek model is occurred
82 INVENTORY MANAGEMENT
21 Certainty Approach
isnt used in
irgin because it thinks it is not possible to implement in Bangladesh
d time is one to three days It
oes not use ABC system of inventory management
8
Main item of inventory of Virgin is Can pet chip sugar label chemical artificial
sweet etc Virgin maintains a minimum level of inventory but it does not have to face
problems because inventory is managed efficiently just-in-time (JIT)
V
Virgin maintains buffer stock because of the shortage of work-in-process (WIP)
inventory Its production process may also be hampered Thats why it maintains
safety stock to avoid stock out cost In case of imported goods normal lead time is
about one month and within the country normal lea
d
Page 39 of 46
Inventory Model
In reality Virgin does not use any of models of EOQ ordering and holding strategy
and safety stock strategy They maintain inventory based on their prior experience
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
822 Uncertainty Approach
Virgin does not use any model for handling inventory uncertainty It says that such
decision depends on business cycle and market situation Long before Eid festival
they bought large amount of sugar because of price increase on the occasion of Eid
In summary
Standard Compliance by Virgin Soft Drinks
Firms maintain inventory to guard
against several problems
Virgin maintains a minimum level of
inventory which is managed efficiently
Some firms use JIT to avoid inventory
cost
JIT is not used by Virgin as it thinks it is
impossible to implement in Bangladesh
Firms maintain buffer stock Virgin maintains buffer stock too
Firms maintain safety stock to avoid
shortage cost
Virgin also maintains safety stock
Firms use ABC system to monitor
inventory
Virgin doesnt use ABC system
EOQ model is an appropriate method
for measuring quantity that has to be
ordered per order
Virgin does not use EOQ model rather
makes order based on experience and
market demand
83 MANAGING ACCOUNTS RECEIVABLE (DEBTORS)
831 Terms of Sale Decision
Page 40 of 46
Virgin offers the term 210 net 30 enables the customers to deduct 2 percent from the
face value of the bill when paying within the first 10 days but if the discount is not
taken the customer must remit the full amount within 30 days But Virgin does not
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
offer the same terms of sale to all customers For prime customers it offers special
terms of sale In setting an appropriate term of sale it costs and benefits regarding
this are compared It uses the standard approach of terms of sale decision as it is
simple to use
832 Credit Granting Decisions
In case of Virgin the Capital and Character of Five Cs get more importance
Although there are many problems with the traditional approach Virgin uses it
because of its simplicity Virgin does not use Net Present Value (NPV) method in
credit granting decision It thinks that NPV is an appropriate method and should be
used next time It does not face any severe problem because of bad debts The reason
is that notes receivable is used when credit is granted
833 Monitoring Accounts Receivable
Virgin monitors its accounts receivable Virgin believes that in any case both positive
and negative durations in accounts signal differences from the results that
management believe to be the most advantageous for the firm
Tools for Monitoring Accounts Receivable
Page 41 of 46
For monitoring accounts receivable there are several tools such as aging schedule
the ratios of receivable outstanding to original sales customers payment proportion
and sales weighted DSO (Days Sales Outstanding) For monitoring accounts
receivable Virgin uses aging schedule fractions and traditional DSO statistics
because of their simplicity in use Although payment proportions ratios of
receivables outstanding and sales weighted DSO methods are free from inherent bias
None of these is used because all these are complex to maintain
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
In summary
Page 42 of 46
Standard Compliance by Virgin Soft Drinks
Generals terms of sale is 210 net 30 Normally Virgin also use general terms
of sale ie 210 net 30
Firms do not offer the same terms of
sale to all customers
Yes For prime customers Virgin offers
special terms of sale
Approaches of terms of sale decisions
are ndash
bull Standard approach
bull Multi period approach
Virgin uses standard approach of terms
of sale decision as it is simple to use and
understand
Source of credit information are ndash
Sellers prior experience with the
customer
Credit agency ratings and
reports
Personal contact with the
applicants bank and other
creditors
Analysis of applicants financial
statements
Customer visit
Main source of credit information to
Virgin is its prior experience with the
customer All other sources are not cost-
effective for Virgin
Approaches of credit granting to
marginal accounts are ndash
Traditional approach
Net Present Value (NPV)
approach
It uses traditional approach still now but
thinks that NPV should be used for the
next periods
Firms monitor accounts receivable
because deviations from the expected
levels of turnover and of bad debt can
Virgin also monitors its accounts
receivable
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
signal several different problems
Different tools for monitoring accounts
receivable are ndash
Aging schedule
Ratios of receivables
outstanding to original sales
Customers payment
proportions
Sales-weighted DSO
For monitoring accounts receivable
Virgin uses aging schedule and
traditional sales outstanding statistics
84 MANAGING ACCOUNTS PAYABLE (CREDITORS)
Virgin has almost accounts payable of Tk 8000000 But most of its liabilities are to
the banks rather than suppliers But we dont have any clear information about
Virgins accounts payable
9 RECOMMENDATION
Virgin should invest its surplus cash in short term marketable securities
because it is suitable hedging against cash uncertainties and will also give
some returns (interest income)
Virgin should publish its own annual report which will satisfy information
needs of stakeholders and also increase the credibility of information provided
by Virgin
Page 43 of 46
Virgin should use multi period approach in terms of sale decision because
standard approach which is already exists in Virgin has some inherent
problems
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
It should stop using traditional approach from now It should use NPV
method in credit granting to marginal accounts
In monitoring accounts receivable Virgin should use sales-weighted DSO
method because it has least limitation compared to the others
It should be more flexible in granting credit which will ultimately increase its
sales
To get the appropriate number of quantity to be ordered per order it should
use DSO model
It should be ABC system for proper monitoring of inventory
10 CONCLUSION
The use of other peoples money in business is usually an expensive resource Before
looking outside for finance a firm should examine its own working capital cycle to
make sure that every rand of its own internal funds is being fully utilized Good
management of working capital is part of good financial management Effective use
of working capital will contribute to the operational efficiency of the whole
organization optimum use will help to generate maximum returns Furthermore
working capital management is not an end in itself It is an integral part of the firms
overall management The needs of efficient working capital management must be
considered in relation to other aspects of the Virgins financial and non-financial
performance Thats why when planning the development of a business it is critical
that the impact of working capital be fully assessed
Page 44 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
BIBLIOGRAPHY
Scherr FC (1989) International Edition Prentice-Hall International Inc Modern
Working Capital Management Text and Cases
Hussain Riaz (2002) Working Capital Management
Robertson Lonnie (July 1998) Inventory Management
httpwwwasashoporg visited on March 13 2006
The Art of Cash Management
httpwwwinccom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management
httpwwwstudyfinancecom visited on March 13 2006
White Paper ndash Managing Working Capital
httpwwwplanwareorg visited on March 13 2006
Management of Working Capital
httpwwwbusinesscentralcoza visited on March 13 2006
Cash Management
httpwwwsbagov visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management Objectives
httpwpsprenhallcom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management
Page 45 of 46
httpwwwadvancemecom visited on March 13 2006
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Business Receivables Financing
httpwwwbbtcom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Finance
http wwwfnbcoza visited on March 13 2006
Tips to manage your working capital
httpsmallbusinessninemsncomau visited on March 13 2006
Inventory Financing
httpwwwfranklincapitalnetworkcom visited on March 13 2006
Accounts Receivable Management
httpwwwfranklincapitalnetworkcom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management
httpwwwtreasurygovtnz visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management
httpwwwtreasurystrategiescom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Works
httpwwwinvestopediacom visited on March 13 2006
Treasury Services
httpwwwjpmorganchasecom visited on March 13 2006
what were about
Page 46 of 46
httpwwwvirgincom visited on March 13 2006
Annexure
Annexure
Interview with YASEER RIZVI
Mr Yaseer Rizvi the DMD of Global Beverage Co Ltd obtained his MBA degree
from a reputed university He had been the Director of Ocean Container Ltd before
joining in Global Beverage Co Ltd He possesses a nice personality
I interviewed Yaseer Rizvi Excerpts from his interview are as follows ndash
Shah Kamal Sir would you please tell me do you invest in short term marketable securities
Yaseer Rizvi Basically we do not invest our surplus cash in short term marketable
securities like T-Bill commercial paper certificate of deposit etc But we keep our
surplus cash in Bank
Shah Kamal Would you tell me something about transit time for a typical check
Yaseer Rizvi Well in Virgin the transit time for a typical check is ndash
For mail float 2 to 3 days
At firm float 6 hours
Clearing float 1 to 3 days
Shah Kamal Do you maintain any cash concentration mechanism like depository transfer check automated clearing house and wire transfer
i
Annexure
Yaseer Rizvi Our position in this case is very strong as we use all the mechanisms
you mentioned As Virgin is a firm with small deposits spread over a substantial
number of banks so we tend to use depository transfer checks extensively It is less
costly We also use automated clearing house and wire transfer but later is used in a
less extent
Shah Kamal Sir what techniques of disbursement management is used by your firm
Yaseer Rizvi Like other firms Virgin tries to retain the cash for as long as possible
But we always perform it in an ethical manner We do not use management of
disbursement float as it seems unethical We follow Zero-Balance Accounts method
for managing disbursement We do not prefer Controlled Disbursing method since
Zero-Balance system is already practiced in Virgin
Shah Kamal How do you hedge cash balance uncertainties
Yaseer Rizvi Well you may say that we do not invest in short term securities but for
facing cash difficulties we keep our surplus cash in bank
Shah Kamal Sir would you please tell me the general terms of sale of Virgin
Yaseer Rizvi Though it is difficult to maintain a fixed terms of sale our general terms
of sale is 210 n30 But for prime customers we offer special terms of sale
Shah Kamal What are the sources of credit information in case of your firm
Yaseer Rizvi We grant credit on the basis of prior experience with the customers In
case of a new customer personal contact is weighted
Shah Kamal Does your firm consider 5 Cs in granting credit
ii
Annexure
Yaseer Rizvi In case of Virgin Capital and Character get more importance than the
others Mind one thing personal relationship is the main measure in granting credit
Shah Kamal Do you use NPV method in credit granting decisions
Yaseer Rizvi We do not use NPV method But we think that NPV is a suitable
method and we have to use it from the next period
Shah Kamal Sir how do you handle the problem of bad debt
Yaseer Rizvi Well in this case our position is very strong Yet we do not face any
problem because of bad debt Just note that we make more than 80 of sales in cash
and we monitor accounts receivable very carefully
Shah Kamal What level of inventory is maintained by Virgin
Yaseer Rizvi We maintain a minimum level of inventory but do not have to face
stock out problems because inventory is managed efficiently
Shah Kamal What is the normal lead time
Yaseer Rizvi In case of imported goods normal lead time is about 1 month and when
we purchase raw materials from inside the country lead time is 1 to 3 days
Shah Kamal What method do you use for managing inventory
Yaseer Rizvi We do not use any method particularly rather inventory decision
depends on business cycle and market situation Long before the Eid festival we
bought large amount of sugar because price of sugar was increased on the occasion
of Eid
iii
Annexure
Shah Kamal What are the main items of inventory of your firm
Yaseer Rizvi Well these are ndash aluminum can pet chip sugar label chemical and
artificial sweet
Shah Kamal What are the uncertainties in maintaining appropriate level of stock
Yaseer Rizvi These are ndash
bull Increase in price of raw materials
bull Sales uncertainty
bull Market trends etc
Shah Kamal Thank you for your kind cooperation
Yaseer Rizvi Most Welcome
iv
Global Beverage Company Limited
Table of Contents
Executive Summary
1 Introduction 01
2 Objectives of the Study 02
3 Methodology 02
4 Limitations of the Study 03
5 Working Capital Management 04
51 Defining Working Capital 04
52 Working Capital Policies 05
53 Working Capital Cycle 07
531 Cash Management 08
532 Inventory Management 19
533 Managing Accounts Receivable (Debtors) 22
534 Managing Accounts Payable (Creditors) 26
6 Overview of Virgin Group 29
7 Overview of Virgin Soft Drinks 31
8 Finding of Working Capital Management Maintained by Virgin Soft Drinks in Bangladesh
32
81 Cash Management 32
82 Inventory Management 38
83 Managing Accounts Receivable (Debtors) 40
84 Managing Accounts Payable (Creditors) 43
9 Recommendation
43
10 Conclusion 44
Bibliography
Annexure
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
Working capital is basically an expression of how many in liquid assets the company
currently has to build its business fund its growth and produce value for the owner
The faster a business expands the more cash it will need for working capital and
investment The cheapest and best sources of cash exist as working capital right
within the business Good management of working capital will generate cash and
help improve profits and reduce risks My study is based on the comparison between
theoretical and practical aspects of working capital management For this purpose
Ive collected some information regarding working capital its cycle and its
management from Virgin Soft Drinks It has been found that their major transactions
are handled in cash But one of its major weaknesses is that it keeps its surplus funds
in banks rather than investing in marketable securities Therefore they can earn
optimum profit by implementing effective mechanism which will help to gain
optimum working capital
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
1 INTRODUCTION
Working capital is the life blood of any business big or small However smaller
businesses might find it more trying to maintain a comfortable level of capital
Managing working capital is an important factor for them Working capital
management is important because maintaining a balance of income to debt can be
difficult and owners must be diligent to assure that it is kept Sometimes it takes a
little assistance to maintain levels of fluidity or make major purchases If working
capital dips too low a business risks running out of cash Even very profitable
businesses can run into trouble if they lose the ability to meet their short-term
obligations Working capital financing can be used as a fast cash option to cushion
the periods when the flow is not ideal or readily available Even when owners are
meticulous in managing working capital finding the right levels to remain
comfortable and competitive can be difficult
The analogy has often been made that cash is the lifeblood of any business A
transfusion will miraculously bring the patient back from the brink of death but only
if
The blood is of the right kind
The problem causing the leakage is attended to
In other words the financial requirements of any business must be tailored to suit
that businesss own particular needs For example fixed assets should be financed by
long term loans and capital Working capital requirements should be attended to by
short term finance eg overdrafts
Page 1 of 46
It goes without saying that before capital is injected into the business it should first be
ascertained whether all unnecessary leakages have been plugged Otherwise in time
the transfusion will follow the same route To control and exploit the cash cycle
through any business so that it can continue to function on a day-to-day basis is
therefore the hub of working capital management The fundamental principle of
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
working capital management is having just the right amount of money available
when needed Every rand in the business should be earning its maximum return
wherever employed
2 OBJECTIVES OF THE STUDY
The study has been undertaken with the following objectives
To know the fundamentals of working capital management
To gather practical knowledge about the implementation of working capital
management by Virgin Soft Drinks
To understand the efficiency of Virgin Soft Drinks in managing working
capital
3 METHODOLOGY
In this paper the following methods are used
a) Sources and Data Collection
The major part of this paper is collected from the primary and secondary data
collection method
Conducted formal interview and focus observation and intensive practical
work to collect information
Page 2 of 46
Collected information from companys profiles
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Collected current information from website
b) Segregation of Data
Necessary data were segregated from the source material for the purpose of preparing
the report
c) Processing of Data
Collected data were compiled and processed for the purpose of preparing the report
d) Presentation of Data
Collected data were presented in charts and tables
4 LIMITATIONS OF THE STUDY
On the way of my study I have faced a number of problems which may be turned
as the limitation of report
Many personnel of the organization due to their pressure of the work were
reluctant to provide much useful information
Sufficient records publications facts and figures are not available These
constraints narrowed the scope of real analysis
Due to time constraint I could not spend sufficient time which was
necessary to make this report more representative of the fact
Page 3 of 46
Lack of experience has also acted as constraint for the exploration of the
topic
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
5 WORKING CAPITAL MANAGEMENT
51 DEFINING WORKING CAPITAL
The term working capital refers to the amount of capital which is readily available to
an organization That is working capital is the difference between resources in cash
or readily convertible into cash (Current Assets) and organizational commitments for
which cash will soon be required (Current Liabilities)
Current Assets are resources which are in cash or will soon be converted into cash in
the ordinary course of business
Current Liabilities are commitments which will soon require cash settlement in the
ordinary course of business
Thus ndash
WORKING CAPITAL = CURRENT ASSETS - CURRENT LIABILITIES
In a firms Statement of Financial position these components of working capital are
reported under the following headings
Current Assets
Liquid Assets (cash and bank deposits)
Inventory
Debtors and Receivables
Current Liabilities
Bank Overdraft
Creditors and Payables
Other Short Term Liabilities
Page 4 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Working capital management involves the relationship between a firms short-term
assets and its short-term liabilities The goal of working capital management is to
ensure that a firm is able to continue its operations and that it has sufficient ability to
satisfy both maturing short-term debt and upcoming operational expenses The
management of working capital involves managing inventories accounts receivable
and payable and cash
52 WORKING CAPITAL POLICIES
The aim of working capital policy is to balance having too little working capital
which can lead to an inability to pay debts as they fall due or the need for expensive
short term borrowings and too much which is wasteful in terms of lost opportunities
for the funds tied up The crucial role of working capital is that it finances the goods
inwards production and sales activities
A firmrsquos working capital policy has two components
1 Policies regarding the appropriate level of current assets (Current Asset Investment Policy)
2 Policies regarding the use of short-term financing (Current Asset Financing Policy)
Alternative Current Asset Investment Policies
These policies are general strategies that firms may follow with regard to their overall
level of current assets investment or holdings There are three types
1 Relaxed Current Asset Investment Policy ndash
Relatively large amounts of cash marketable securities and inventories are carried
and sales are stimulated by a liberal (generous) trade credit policy resulting in high
levels of receivables This is a low risk strategy because the firm always has plenty of
cash and inventory on hand The return is low because more money is invested in
low yielding assets
Page 5 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
2 Restricted Current Asset Investment Policy ndash
Holdings of cash securities inventories and receivables are minimized This is a
high risk strategy because the firm tries to keep the bare minimum of cash and
inventory The potential return is high because less money is invested in low
yielding assets
3 Moderate Current Asset Policy ndash
Balance between relaxed and restricted current asset investment policies (moderate
risk - moderate potential return)
Alternative Current Asset Financing Policies
These policies are general strategies that firms may follow with regard to how current
assets are to be financed Current assets can be classified as permanent or temporary
Permanent current assets are the current assets that the company needs to maintain
throughout the entire year Temporary current assets are those that are due to
seasonal fluctuations With respect to the current asset financing policy the question
is how the permanent current assets will and temporary current assets are financed
(long-term or short-term financing)
Page 6 of 46
Aggressive Moderate Conservative
Cash Minimum holding Prepared to hold
some precautionary
balances
Prepared to hold idle
cash balances
Debtors and
stock
Minimum
consistent with
business needs
Moderate levels High stock and
debtor levels to
maximize sales
Creditors Maximum
available without
compromising
business needs
Moderate level Low level seeking
discounts and
reputation for good
payment
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Future cash
flows
Predictable Reasonably
predictable
Unpredictable
Attitude to
Risk
Accepting Neutral Rejecting
Total assets = Fixed Assets + Permanent Current Assets + Fluctuating Current Assets
53 WORKING CAPITAL CYCLE
Cash flows in a cycle into around and out of a business It is the businesss life blood
and every managers primary task is to help keep it flowing and to use the cash flow
to generate profits If a business is operating profitably then it should in theory
generate cash surpluses If it doesnt generate surpluses the business will eventually
run out of cash and expire
The faster a business expands the more cash it will need for working capital and
investment The cheapest and best sources of cash exist as working capital right
within business Good management of working capital will generate cash will help
improve profits and reduce risks
Working capital can be broken down into the following major components cash (or
bank overdraft) stock debtors creditors Each of these items can have a major
influence on the working capital (or simply cash) that any business requires on an
ongoing basis For example when a business starts up the owner may inject a
certain amount of cash into the business which will enable him to purchase his initial
stock pay his workers their first months wages and cover other overheads such as
rent He then sells his product and this income may be utilized to purchase more
stock pay more wages and overheads and perhaps even have a surplus over for his
own use The quicker he can turn his stock over to receive payment the sooner the
working capital cycle will be completed
Page 7 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Figure Working Capital Cycle
These major components of working capital are discussed below
531 CASH MANAGEMENT
The term cash management refers to the management of cash from the time it starts
its transit to the firm until it leaves the firm in payments Cash management
encompasses the design of collection and disbursement systems for cash and the
temporary investment of cash while it resides with the firm Widely used money
market instruments are-
Treasury bill
Commercial paper
Certificate of deposits
Bankerrsquos acceptance
Page 8 of 46
Repurchase agreement
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
5311 Motives for Holding Cash
Despite the seemingly low returns there are several good reasons why firms hold
cash and marketable securities These reasons are ndash
Cash for transactions
Cash and near cash assets as hedges
Temporary investment and
Compensating balances
5312 Components of Cash Management
A Cash Flow Statement shows the sources and uses of cash and is typically divided
into three components
Operating Cash Flow
Operating cash flow often referred to as working capital is the cash flow generated
from internal operations It comes from sales of the product or service of your
business and because it is generated internally it is under your control
Investing Cash Flow
Investing cash flow is generated internally from non-operating activities This
includes investments in plant and equipment or other fixed assets nonrecurring gains
or losses or other sources and uses of cash outside of normal operations
Financing Cash Flow
Financing cash flow is the cash to and from external sources such as lenders
investors and shareholders
Page 9 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
5313 Tools for Cash Management
Flotation and Check Clearing
Management of cash when it is not in the firmrsquos hands that is in transit to and from
the firm is on important function in the area of finance Transit times for the check
takes in three stages These are mail float at firm float and clearing float Normally
mail float takes 1 to 5 days at firm float takes 025 to 1 day and clearing float takes 0
to 2 days The firm should care about this process because every delay in the receipt
of money by the firm lowers the firmrsquos returns and therefore its shareholdersrsquo wealth
There are several strategies that firm can use to reduce the delay in receiving funds
Each of these strategies addresses one or more of the three float times (mail float
time at time float time and clearing float time) that make up the total transit time of
fund from one firm to another
Other Cash Management Tools
When the economy is strong companies can lapse into sloppy cash-management
practices Firm should try exploring these options
1 Sweep accounts
These bank accounts are the easiest way to generate some income from companys
spare funds however they make sense only if the money youll earn will be greater
than the fees your bank will charge Business owners have two types of sweep
accounts to choose between
Page 10 of 46
Controlled-investment accounts These are the most profitable form of
sweep account but they wont work for company if the firm has any
electronic payments or wire transfers since those may be submitted for
payment later in the day and the account wont have enough cash in it to
cover them
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Page 11 of 46
End-of-day sweep accounts A safer bet for most small-business owners
these accounts wait until a late-hour cutoff to determine how much to
sweep into the firms overnight investments Typically their investment
yields are 10 to 20 basis points (1 to 2 of the investment) lower than
those offered with controlled investments
2 Lock-box accounts
A lock box is a cash-management system that helps the firm collect funds quickly
Generally set up with the assistance of a big money center or regional bank lock
boxes provide the firm with a special zip code and usually quicker deliveries from
regional post offices They are especially important if the firm has clusters of
customers in out-of-state locations and dont want to lose days waiting for their
checks to arrive by long-distance mail
5314 Cash Concentration and Cash Disbursement
Once the remittances from the firmrsquos customers have been received and cleared the
resulting cash balances is available in the firmrsquos lockbox (depository) banks It is
useful for the firm to gather these balances from the lockbox banks into the central
bank account The process of collecting funds is called cash concentration
Several concentration mechanism are available for the firm to use in transferring
funds from its collection banks to regional concentration banks and from there to the
central concentration bank These mechanisms differ in cost and in the availability of
funds that they provide These are ndash
a) Depository Transfer Check
It is the cheapest transfer mechanism This document instructs one bank to
send funds to another and is treated the same as any other check
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
b) Automated Clearing House (ACH) Electronic Transfer
This vehicle is essentially an electronic version of the depository transfer
check and can be used between banks that participate in the automated
clearing house system
c) Wire Transfer
These are electronic message between banks
Decisions regarding concentration mechanism usually hinge on the size and
spread of the firmrsquos deposits Firms with small deposits spread over a
substantial number of banks will tend to have more extensive concentration
systems and will transfer among accounts using low-cost transfer vehicles that
offer only delayed availability (such as depository transfer checks) Firms with
larger deposits will have fewer accounts (since a local deposit for transfer to
an upstream bank is not needed) and will use more expensive and more rapid
transfer mechanisms (such as wire transfers) The concentration systems of
major chemical companies for example tend to be structured in this way ndash
DepositoryLockbox Banks
Regional Concentration Banks
Central Concentrated Bank
Figure A typical Cash Concentration System
(Arrows indicate transfers of collected funds)
Page 12 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Disbursement management addresses the efficient payout out of this cash once it is
concentrated The firmrsquos objective in disbursement management is to retain the cash
for as long as possible In this way the firm will have the maximum amount of funds
available for investment and transactional purposes Certainly this management
means making disbursement only when they are due and not before The firm has
several available set of techniques for disbursement management Included among
these are ndash
a) Management of Disbursement Float
In this set of techniques the disbursing firm attempts to increase the length of
time between the mailing of its checks and the eventual withdrawal of funds
from the banks This involves strategies for increasing mail float at firm float
and clearing float on its outgoing checks For example the disbursing firm
may intentionally address checks to the firmrsquos office address rather than its
lockbox creating at firm float
b) Zero-Balance Accounts
Here the firm holds the cash until the check arrive (or expected to arrive) at
the disbursement bank In this strategy an account for disbursement is first
established at a bank For the zero-balance system to be effective the
participating bank must be one on which most disbursement are made via the
Bangladesh Bankrsquos clearance system (which presents disbursements to banks
early in the morning) and not a bank where disbursements occur throughout
the day (as with a major money-center bank) Consequently the banks used
in zero-balance strategies are usually branches of major banks and not their
main locations
Page 13 of 46
c) Controlled Disbursing
In this system the firm projects the amount of checks to arrive each day at the
disbursement bank (based on the checks written in previous days and historic
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
statistics on disbursement float) and transfers the amount of the expected
checks to the account on that day or just before
5315 Cash Forecasting
Defining Cash Forecasting
The cash forecast is an estimation of the flows in and out of the firmrsquos cash account
over a particular period of time usually a quarter month week or day The cash
forecast is primarily intended to produce a very useful piece of information an
estimation of the firmrsquos borrowing and lending needs and uncertainties regarding
these needs during various future periods Cash forecasting is very crucial to most
firms It enables them to anticipate periods of surplus cash and periods where
financing will be necessary This anticipation is the reason that cash forecasts are
generated Anticipation enables the firm to plan much more effectively for
investment and financing and via this planning produce superior return
Types of Cash Forecasts
The types of cash forecasts generated by firms can be differentiated along two
dimensions the length of the periods included within the cash forecast and the approach
to cash flows used in the cash forecast The length of the period refers to the units of
time into which the cash forecast is divided Firms may make cash flow forecasts
over periods of various lengths yearly flows quarterly flows monthly flows weekly
flows or even daily flows The most popular forecast involves monthly flows but
most firms do not confine themselves to a single forecast Instead they use several
forecasts with periods of various lengths When the firm makes forecasts involving
multiple and overlapping period lengths one forecast relates to another Starting
with data on relatively long periods and breaking it down into smaller periods is
called distribution starting with data on relatively short periods and aggregating into
longer periods is called scheduling
Page 14 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Firms use two common approaches to cash flows in generating the cash forecast the
receipts and disbursements approach and the adjusted net income approach The receipts
and disbursements approach use the amounts of cash expected to be received and
disbursed by the firm over the periods chosen for forecast The adjusted income
statement approach is sometimes called the sources and use approach Here the
forecaster starts with projected net income on an accrual basis and adjusts to a cash
basis This method provides a representation of changes in asset and liability
accounts since the level of these accounts are of interest to the firm this aspect of the
adjusted income statement is an advantage over the receipts and disbursements
method
Items to Be Forecast
In the receipt and disbursements cash forecasting method estimates need to be made
of the numerous major and minor items that the firm collects (receipts) and that it
pays (disbursements) The more individual categories of items the firm includes in its
forecast procedure the more accurate the forecast may be but the more costly in
terms of time and effort it will be to generate
Some Possible Types of Cash Receipts and Cash Disbursements
Cash Disbursements Cash Receipts
Cash Purchases of Materials Payroll
Taxes
Maturing Accounts Payable
Maturing Notes Payable
Miscellaneous Disbursements
Accounts Receivable
Notes Receivable
Rental Income
Interest Income
Miscellaneous Receipts
Methods of Financial Forecasting
Page 15 of 46
Financial forecasting is the estimation of the future level of a financial variable often
a cash flow asset level or liability level It is usually assumed that the relationship
between the financial variable and other variable is linear The general linear model
can then be used
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
nnt xaxaxaaY 22110 ++=
Here
= Financial variable (Y) to be forecast in period t tY
x = Explanatory variable it is assumed to cause the level of Y in period t
0a = Represents a constant unaffected by the x
The other terms are the estimated coefficients of the explanatory x variables
There are n terms with xrsquos in them
There are four common approaches to forecasting financial variables but they
are all special cases of the general linear model These are ndash spot method proportion
to another account compounded growth and multiple dependencies
Using Cash Forecast
The estimate of available funds for investment and needed financing enables the firm
to plan so as to obtain the most advantages borrowing terms for deficits and achieve
the greatest interest income on surplus A useful chart for this planning purpose is a
bar chart eg
Figure Bar Chart of Cash Surpluses and Deficits from hypothetical data
Page 16 of 46
75
50
-60
30
100
-20
-80-60-40-20
020406080
100120
Defic
it
S
urpl
us
January February March April May June
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Sources of Uncertainty in Cash Forecasting and Hedging Uncertainties
There are numerous sources of risk in cash forecasting Among the sources are sales
uncertainty collection rate uncertainty production cost uncertainty and capital
outflow uncertainty
5316 Models for the Management of Cash and Temporary Investments
There are different models for the management of cash and temporary investments
Among these the most popular methods are ndash Baumol model Beranek model
Miller-Orr model and Stone model
Baumol and Beranek use the same model The formula is cited below ndash
Interest Income = iYn
n⎥⎦⎤
⎢⎣⎡ minus
21
Profit = naiYn
nminus⎥⎦
⎤⎢⎣⎡ minus
21
Optimum number of transactions = ⎟⎠⎞
⎜⎝⎛
aiY2
Where n = Optimum number of transactions
i = Interest rate per period
a = Transaction cost
Y = Total inflow for the period
Page 17 of 46
Miller-Orr and Stone use the same model ie R-Statistic The model is ndash
31
43
iav
R ⎟⎠⎞
⎜⎝⎛=
Optimum Control Limit = R + L
Upper Control Limit = 3R + L
Where a = Transaction Cost
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
v = Variance of daily cash flows
i = Daily interest rate
5317 Administration
Cash receipts should be processed and banked as quickly as possible because
They cannot earn interest or reduce overdraft until they are banked
information about the existence and amounts of cash receipts is usually not
available until they are processed
Where possible cash floats (mainly petty cash and advances) should be avoided If
on review the only reason that can be put forward for their existence is that weve
always had them they should be discontinued There may be situations where they
are useful however For example it may be desirable for peripheral parts of
departments to meet urgent local needs from cash floats rather than local bank
accounts
5318 Internal Control
Cash and cash management is part of a firms overall internal control system The
main internal cash control is invariably the bank reconciliation This provides
assurance that the cash balances recorded in the accounting systems are consistent
with the actual bank balances It requires regular clearing of reconciling items
5319 Practicing Good Cash Flow Management
Good cash management is simple It involves
Knowing when where and how firms cash needs will occur
Page 18 of 46
Knowing the best sources for meeting additional cash needs
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Page 19 of 46
Being prepared to meet these needs when they occur by keeping good
relationships with bankers and other creditors
532 INVENTORY MANAGEMENT
Inventory management is necessary for owners who want to maintain a stocking
service for quick turnaround to help ensure total customer satisfaction The fill rate
of an item on a managed inventory list must be maintained to avoid shortages of
frequently used items Even when utilizing an inventory management system
occasional shortages will still occur Inventories are lists of stocks-raw materials
work in progress or finished goods-waiting to be consumed in production or to be
sold The total balance of inventory is the sum of the value of each individual stock
line
Basically firms hold stocks for the following reasons
To act as a buffer in times of unusually high demand
To ensure continuity of production
Avoid high costs of emergency orders
To take advantage of quantity discounts by ordering more at a time
To reduce ordering costs by ordering more items on fewer
As part of the production process eg maturing whisky or keeping oil in
pipelines
Seasonality of demand (eg firework) or supplies
Suppliers insist on minimum order quantities
The key issue for a business is to identify the fast and slow stock movers with the
objectives of establishing optimum stock levels for each category and thereby
minimize the cash tied up in stocks Factors to be considered when determining
optimum stock levels include
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Page 20 of 46
What are the projected sales of each product
How widely available are raw materials components etc
How long does it take for delivery by suppliers
Can the firm remove slow movers from its product range without
compromising best sellers
Inventory management is an important aspect of working capital management
because inventories themselves do not earn any revenue Holding either too little or
too much inventory incurs costs
Costs of carrying too much inventory are
Opportunity cost of foregone interest
Warehousing costs
Damage and pilferage
Obsolescence
Insurance
Costs of carrying too little inventory are
Stock out costs
Lost sales
Delayed service
Ordering costs
Freight
on Order administrati
nts
Loss of quantity discou
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Carrying costs can be minimized by making frequent small orders but this increase
ordering costs and the risk of stock outs Risk of stock-outs can be reduced by
carrying safety stocks (at a cost) and re-ordering ahead of time
The best ordering strategy requires balancing the various cost factors to ensure the
firm incurs minimum inventory costs The optimum inventory position is known as
the Economic Reorder Quantity (ERQ)
Nowadays many large manufacturers operate on a just-in-time (JIT) basis whereby
all the components to be assembled on a particular today arrive at the factory early
that morning no earlier - no later This helps to minimize manufacturing costs as JIT
stocks take up little space minimize stock-holding and virtually eliminate the risks of
obsolete or damaged stock Because JIT manufacturers hold stock for a very short
time they are able to conserve substantial cash JIT is a good model to strive for as it
embraces all the principles of prudent stock management For better stock control
firm may try the following
Review the effectiveness of existing purchasing and inventory systems
Know the stock turn for all major items of inventory
Apply tight controls to the significant few items and simplify controls for the
trivial many
Sell off outdated or slow moving merchandise - it gets more difficult to sell the
longer the firm keeps it
Consider having part of its product outsourced to another manufacturer rather
than make it itself
Review its security procedures to ensure that no stock is going out the back
door
Higher than necessary stock levels tie up cash and cost more in insurance
accommodation costs and interest charges
Page 21 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
However it is important to keep an overall perspective It is not cost-effective to
closely manage a large number of low value inventory lines nor is it necessary A
usual feature of inventories is that a small number of high value lines account for a
large proportion of inventory value The 8020 rule (PARETO) predicts that 80
of the total value of inventory is represented by only 20 of the number of inventory
items Those high value lines need reasonably close management The remaining
80 of inventory lines can be managed using broad-brush strategies
533 MANAGING ACCOUNTS RECEIVABLE (DEBTORS)
Cash flow can be significantly enhanced if the amounts owing to a business are
collected faster Every business needs to know who owes them money how much is
owed how long it is owing for what it is owed
Debtors (Accounts Receivable) are customers who have not yet made payment for
goods or services which the department has provided The objective of debtor
management is to minimize the time-lapse between completion of sales and receipt
of payment The costs of having debtors are
Opportunity costs (cash is not available for other purposes)
Bad debts
If firm doesnt manage debtors they will begin to manage business as the firm will gradually
lose control due to reduced cash flow and of course it could experience an increased
incidence of bad debt The following measures will help manage debtors
Having the right mental attitude to the control of credit and make sure that it
gets the priority it deserves
Establishing clear credit practices as a matter of company policy
Page 22 of 46
Making sure that these practices are clearly understood by staff suppliers and
customers
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Page 23 of 46
Being professional when accepting new accounts and especially larger ones
Checking out each customer thoroughly before the firm offers credit Use
credit agencies bank references industry sources etc
Establishing credit limits for each customer and sticking to them
Continuously reviewing these limits when it suspects tough times are coming
or if operating in a volatile sector
Keeping very close to the firms larger customers
Invoicing promptly and clearly
Considering charging penalties on overdue accounts
Considering accepting credit debit cards as a payment option
Monitoring its debtor balances and ageing schedules and dont let any debts
get too large or too old
Debtor management includes both pre-sale and debt collection strategies
Pre-sale strategies include
Offering cash discounts for early payment andor imposing penalties for late
payment
Agreeing payment terms in advance
Requiring cash before delivery
Setting credit limits
ning credit Setting criteria for obtai
Billing as early as possible
rogress payments
ost-sale strategies include
for collecting the debt upon the center that made the sale
Requiring deposits andor p
P
Placing the responsibility
Identifying long overdue balances and doubtful debts by regular analytical reviews
Having an established procedure for late collections such as
A reminder
A letter
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Page 24 of 46
ion of further credit Cancellat
Telephone calls
n agency Use of a collectio
he firm should recognize that the longer someone owes firm the greater the chance
Legal action
T
it will never get paid If the average age of debtors is getting longer or is already very
long it may need to look for the following possible defects
Weak credit judgment
res Poor collection procedu
ms Lax enforcement of credit ter
Slow issue of invoices or statements
Errors in invoices or statements
Customer dissatisfaction
Debtors due over 90 days (unless within agreed credit terms) should generally
demand immediate attention For example warning signs of a future bad debt ndash
Longer credit terms taken with approval particularly for smaller orders
Use of post-dated checks by debtors who normally settle within agreed terms
Evidence of customers switching to additional suppliers for the same goods
New customers who are reluctant to give credit references
Cre G
Receiving part payments from debtors
dit ranting to Marginal Accounts
Traditional Approach
In the traditional approach to the credit granting decision it is the credit analysts job
rmation that has been collected and reach a judgment
regarding the applicants creditworthiness One traditional way of organizing this
to synthesize all the info
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
information is by characterizing the applicant along five dimensions These
dimensions are called the Five Cs of credit ndash
Capital
Character
Collateral
and Capacity
Conditions
Net Present Value (NPV) Approach
Once a firm has assessed the creditworthiness of a customer it has to decide whether
r not credit should be granted The firm should use the NPV rule to make the
ld be granted
Figure
o
decision If NPV is positive credit shou
Credit Granting Decision
Credit Granting Decision
he act of collecting money is one which most people dislike for many reasons and
therefore put on the long f selves there is something
ore urgent or important that demands their attention now There is nothing more
T
inger because they convince them
m
important than getting paid for firms product or service A customer who does not
Page 25 of 46
Grand Credit
Payment received Payment not received
Benefit of present value of future net cash flow
Cost of present value ment of lost invest
Net Payoff PV of benefit-cost
No Credit
No Payoff
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
pay is not a customer Here are a few ideas that may help the firm in collecting
money from debtors
Firm should develop appropriate procedures for handling late payments
It should track and pursue late payers
It might get external help if its own efforts fail
or money its firms and it is entitled Company shouldnt feel guilty asking f
to it
ction
Firm must make that call now And it should keep asking until it gets some
satisfa
lessens the problem
In difficult circumstances take what the firm can now and agree terms for the
remainder It
paying
When asking for money be hard on the issue - but soft on the person It shouldnt
give the debtor any excuses for not
534 BLE (CREDITORS)
ices for goods or services have
een paid Organizations often regard the
not
to delay all payments until the latest possible date Regular weekly or
The firm make it its objective is to get the money - not to score points or get
even
MANAGING ACCOUNTS PAYA
Creditors (Accounts Payable) are suppliers whose invo
been processed but who have not yet b
amount owing to creditors as a source of free credit However creditor
administration systems are expensive and time-consuming to run The over-riding
concern in this area should be to minimize costs with simple procedures
While it is unnecessary to pay accounts before they fall due it is usually
worthwhile
Page 26 of 46
fortnightly payment of all due accounts is the simplest technique for creditor
management
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Electronic payments (direct credits) are cheaper than check payments considering
that transaction fees and overheads more than balance the advantage of delayed
presentation Some suppliers are reluctant to receive payments by this method but in
view of the substantial cost advantage (and the advantages to the suppliers
themselves) departments may wish to encourage suppliers to accept this option
However electronic payments are likely to be used in conjunction with rather than
as a replacement for check payments
Applying Best Practices in Managing Accounts Payable
f course simply deferring payments to suppliers could have adverse consequences
O
that more than offset the benefits of this additional cash flow Therefore it is
important to develop a holistic approach The firm should consider the following
best practices for payables management
Managing payment dates and terms to maximize cash flow ndash
y reporting on
receivable and
id penalty charges and taking advantage of
wer vendors and negotiate for more
to buying consortia with others even
voices for
payment based on receipt of goods or receipt of invoice whichever
comes later
Calculating and setting performance targets Regularl
AP performance measures such as days in payables
Coordinating the AP processes with accounts
inventory management to ensure that the company is collecting more
cash than it is paying out
Paying bills on time to avo
prompt-payment discounts where the discounts exceed the companyrsquos
cost of working capital
Consolidating purchases with fe
favorable payment terms
Considering entering in
Page 27 of 46
competitors to obtain favorable supplier pricing and terms
Unless contract terms specify otherwise setting up in
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Page 28 of 46
Em
process
-time payments with Electronic Funds Transfer (EFT)
uraging vendors to utilize electronic invoice presentment
a
ndancies and more
ploying technology to automate the accounts payable transaction
es ndash
Making just-in
Using an electronic invoice-matching application
Enco
For companies with multiple locations or business units employing
shared service approach for AP to eliminate redu
quickly implement process improvements
Mainta
vendor
Communicating accounts payable requirements to suppliers at the
m key suppliers
for suggestions on how to improve the
Efficient a
and making th rsquos cash is just good business
ining open communications and building strong relationships with
s to access valuable trade credit ndash
beginning of transactions
Requesting summary invoicing fro
Requiring suppliers to send invoices directly to accounts payable
Asking tier-one suppliers
payment process
nd effective management of accounts payable helps improve cash flow ndash
e most of company
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
6 OVERVIEW OF VIRGIN GROUP
Virgin - one of the most respected brands in Britain - is now becoming the first global
brand name of the 21st century Virgin is involved in planes trains finance soft
drinks music mobile phones holidays cars wines publishing bridal wear - the lot
What tie all these businesses together are the values of its brand and the attitude of its
people Virgin has created over 200 companies worldwide employing over 25000
people Its total revenues around the world in 2002 exceeded pound4 billion (US $72
billion)
In 1970 Richard Branson founded Virgin as a mail order record retailer and not
long after he opened a record shop in Oxford Street London During 1972 a
recording studio was built in Oxfordshire and the first Virgin artist Mike Oldfield
recorded Tubular Bells which was released in 1973
This album went on to sell over 5 million copies Since then many household names
including Belinda Carlisle Genesis Phil Collins Janet Jackson and The Rolling
Stones have helped to make Virgin Music one of the top six record companies in the
world The equity of Virgin Music Group - record labels music publishing and
recording studios was sold to THORN EMI in 1992 in a US$1billion deal
Page 29 of 46
The Virgin Group has now expanded into international music Mega stores air
travel mobile financial retail music internet drinks rail hotels and leisure with
around 200 companies in over 30 countries
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
In Virgins customers eyes Virgin stands for value for money quality innovation
fun and a sense of competitive challenge It delivers a quality service by empowering
its employees and facilitates and monitors customer feedback to continually improve
the customers experience through innovation
When they start a new venture Virgin bases it on hard research and analysis
Typically they review the industry and put themselves in the customers shoes to see
what could make it better Virgin asks fundamental questions
Is this an opportunity for restructuring a market and creating competitive
advantage What are the competitors doing
Is the customer confused or badly served
Is this an opportunity for building the Virgin brand
Can we add value
Will it interact with its other businesses
Is there an appropriate trade-off between risk and reward
Page 30 of 46
Virgin is also able to draw on talented people from throughout the group New
ventures are often steered by people seconded from other parts of Virgin who bring
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
with them the trademark management style skills and experience Virgin frequently
creates partnerships with others to combine skills knowledge and market presence
and so on Contrary to what some people may think their constantly expanding and
eclectic empire is neither random nor reckless Each successive venture demonstrates
its skill in picking the right market and the right opportunity
7 OVERVIEW OF VIRGIN SOFT DRINKS
The Virgin Drinks Group first launched as the Virgin Cola Company in 1994 with
Virgin Cola in the UK Since then the company has ventured across the carbonated
soft drinks arena and beyond into energy drinks tea and flavored Colas This
expansion has lead to the evolution of the Virgin Drinks Company a company
whose aim is to put the excitement back into the world of soft drinks It launched in
Bangladesh in 1999 Virgin Soft Drinks is monitored by Global Beverage Co Ltd in
Bangladesh
Brief history of Virgin Drinks is given below
Page 31 of 46
1994 November Virgin Cola launched in the UK
1996 March Virgin Cola launched in France
1998 June Virgin Cola launched in Belgium
April Virgin Cola launched in the French West Indies
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
August Virgin Cola launched in Switzerland
1999 March Virgin Colours launched in Italy
March Virgin Cola launched in Japan
July Virgin Colours launched in South Africa
December Virgin Colours launched in Bangladesh
2001 January Sweden launched Virgin Colours
November Singapore launched Virgin Colours
2002 February Croatia launched Virgin Colours
June Russia launched Virgin Colours
June Tunisia launched Virgin Colours
2003 May Israel launched Virgin Colours
8 FINDINGS OF WORKING CAPITAL MANAGEMENT MAINTAINED BY
VIRGIN SOFT DRINKS IN BANGLADESH
81 CASH MANAGEMENT
811 Holding Cash and Marketable Securities
Although there are many good reasons why firm hold cash and marketable
securities Virgin Drinks holds cash and marketable securities for two reasons ndash
i) Cash for transactions
ii) Cash as hedges
This indicates that the firm does not hold cash and marketable securities for some
important reasons such as ndash
i) Near cash assets as hedges
Page 32 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
ii) Temporary investment and compensating balances
Virgin Soft Drinks does not invest in money market securities such as Treasury bill
commercial paper certificate of deposits bankerrsquos acceptance and repurchase
agreement This firm deposits its money in bank as currant AC or fixed AC They
say that they do not have enough money to invest in money market instrument
They also say that if they have enough money they will invest it in money market
short term securities We know that near cash interest earning assets can be
substituted for cash when motivation for holding these assets is the hedging of cash
flow uncertainties or is the temporary investment of surplus funds In this point
Virgins position is not good as there is no significant hedging against uncertainty of
cash
812 Floatation and Check Clearing
Virgin is very smart in handling the problem of transit time for checks Here mail
float takes 2 to 3 days at firm takes 025 day and clearing float takes 1-3 days Virgin
uses most of the strategies available for reducing the delay in receiving funds It
(Virgin) has linked Islami Bank which posses an accelerated clearing facility It uses
electronic collection process which ensures faster collection and its at the firm check
processing is satisfactory But Virgin does not use lockbox The reason behind this is
that it is not cost-effective for Virgin to set lockboxes At this point we can say that
Virgins check clearing mechanism is much good
813 Cash Concentration and Disbursement Management
Page 33 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks takes the matter of cash concentration very seriously They use all
the available cash concentration mechanism Virgin is a firm with small deposits
spread over a substantial number of banks and this is why the firm tends to use
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
depository transfer checks extensively If is less costly Virgin also uses automated
clearing house and wire transfer To Virgin wire transfer seems too costly
Like other firm Virgin tries to retain the cash for as long as possible But Virgin
always performs it in an ethical manner Virgin does not try to defeat the receiving
firmrsquos attempts to reduce the float on incoming checks It does not take any strategy
for increasing mail float at firm float and clearing float on its outgoing checks To
Virgin it is deemed to be unethical It thinks that maximization of disbursement float
will not go unnoticed by sophisticated creditors for very long When it is noticed it
will negatively affect relations with these creditors reducing the firmrsquos bargaining
power with them This may ultimately cost Virgin dearly when future prices and
delivery schedules for goods and services purchased from trade creditors are
negotiated Virgin follows ldquoZero-Balance Accountsrdquo methods for managing
disbursement It thinks that in this method the coordination of funds inflows to
disbursement banks with the presentation of checks does not work to the detriment
of creditors since the firmrsquos checks to them are honored as presented and this strategy
does not affect float significantly Controlled disbursing method is less attractive to
Virgin because zero-balance system is already feasible
814 Cash Forecasting
Cash Forecasting and Its Types
Page 34 of 46
Virgin forecasts the future cash inflows and outflows To Virgin cash forecast is an
important part of the firmrsquos cash control system and is one of the forecasts that are
part of the Virginrsquos financial plan Virgin forecasts cash on monthly basis and on
yearly basis Virgin does not forecast on daily basis assuming that the temporary
shortage of funds within these periods can be covered without value cost eg
advance receipts from customers Virginrsquos cash forecasting system involves a
combination of distribution and scheduling The receipts and disbursements
approach of cash forecasting is used in virgin This method is used because it
minutely traces the movement of cash and very close control of cash is possible
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Virgin does not use adjusted net income approach on two grounds First it does not
permit the tracing of the individual types of cash inflows and outflows for any given
period which is often useful information for virgin Second it is not simple to use
Items to be Forecast
Virgin does not forecast all the items It forecasts only major items eg accounts
receivable notes receivable payroll cash purchases of raw materials In this regard
virgin trade off between cost and benefit
Methods of Financial Forecasting
Virgin forecasts the future level of financial variable such as cash level asset level or
liability level We know in short term forecasts many things will result from plans
and events that are already in place (contracts capital budgets long-range financing
plans and so forth) But in the long run most things can vary and are dependent on
outside influences such as the firmrsquos long-term growth rate Since Virginrsquos cash
forecasting deals mostly with near future many of the items on the cash forecasts are
estimated by some variation of the spot method and remaining estimates are mostly
on a ldquoproportion of another accountrdquo basis with this ldquoother accountrdquo often being a
particular periodrsquos sales Virgin uses the other two methods less frequently
Using Cash Forecast
Virgin forecasts cash for meeting general objectives (ie to know the available funds
for investment and need financing) and for meeting some special objectives (eg to
know whether the firm will fulfill its out of debt requirement) But it is matter to note
that Virgin does not make any short term investment of its surplus cash but only keep
this surplus in Bank Account
Page 35 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Sources of Uncertainty in Cash Forecasting and Hedging Uncertainties
Virgin faces uncertainty in cash forecasting mainly from two sources These are ndash
sales and production cost In peak season (hot season like autumn summer) sales
increases but in dull season (eg in winter) sales decreases drastically Production
cost may be increased because of increase of price of sugar chemicals aluminum
can Virgin follows two methods for hedging cash balance uncertainties These are ndash
i) Holding a stock of extra cash and
ii) Extra borrowing capacity
815 Modes for the Management of Cash and Temporary Investments
Virgin does not follow any of these methods wholly Virgin receives cash
continuously and pays salary at steady rate and pays continuously for other
expenses So it neither follows Baumol model nor Beranek model It has no upper
control limit lower control limit return point in case cash management So it neither
follows Miller-Orr model nor Stone model
In Summary
Page 36 of 46
Standard Compliance by Virgin Soft Drinks
Generally all firms hold cash and
marketable securities
Virgin holds only cash
Firms hold cash and marketable
securities for some reasons like
bull Cash for transactions
bull Cash and near-cash assets as
hedges
bull Temporary investments
bull Compensating balances
Virgin holds cash only for
two reasons ndash
bull Cash for transactions
bull Cash as hedges
Available money market instruments Virgin does not invest in any such
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
(short term securities) are ndash
Treasury Bills
Commercial Paper
Certificates of Deposit
Bankerrsquos Acceptance
Repurch menase Agree ts
instruments They only keep cash in
Bank Account
Mail Float
(1 to 5 days)
At Firm
Float
(025 to 1
day)
Clearing
Float
(0 to
2 days)
Mail Float
(2 to 3 days)
At firm
Float
(025
day)
Clearing
Float
(1 to 3
days)
Figure Transit time for a typical check Figure Transit time for a check for
Virgin
Strategies that firms can use to reduce
the delay in receiving funds are ndash
Selecting of Banks with
accelerated clearing capabilities
of check processing Acceleration
at the firm
ectronic collection Use of el
procedures
Use of lockboxes
Virgin follows the first three strategies
but does not use lockboxes
Available cash concentration
mechanisms are ndash
Depository transfer check
ouse Automated Clearing H
(ACH) electronic transfer)
Wire transfer
Virgin uses all these mechanisms of
cash concentration
Available sets of techniques for cash
disbursement management are ndash
ement of disbursement
Page 37 of 46
Manag
float
Virgin uses zero-balance accounts
technique
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Zero-Balance Accounts
Controlled disbursing
Firms may make cash flow forecasts
over periods of various lengths yearly
flows quarterly flows monthly flows
weekly flows or even daily flows
Virgin forecasts cash on yearly basis and
monthly basis
Cash forecasting system may involve ndash
Distribution
Scheduling
Virginrsquos cash forecasting system
involves a combination of distribution
and scheduling
Two common approaches to cash flow
in generating the cash forecast
and disbursement Receipts
approach
Adjusted net income approach
Virgin uses the receipts and
disbursement approach
There are many items to forecast Virgin forecasts only major items like
AR payroll etc
Four common approach to forecasting
fina i ndash nc al variables are
Spot method
Proportion to another account
Compounded growth
Multiple dependencies
Virgin uses spot method for forecasting
cash It uses proportion to another
account method for other variables and
remaining two methods are frequently
used
Sources of uncertainty in cash
forecasting are ndash
Sales uncertainty
Collection rate uncertainty
Production cost uncertainty
Capital outflow uncertainty
Virgin faces uncertainty mainly from
sales and production cost
Methods for hedging cash balance
unc a
Page 38 of 46
ert inties are ndash
i) Holding a stock of extra cash
Virgin two available methods for
hedging cash balance uncertainties
Th ese are ndash
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
ii) stock of near-cash Holding a
assets
iii) Extra borrowing capacity
iv) ary surpluses in Investing tempor
near-cash assets
i) Holding a stock of extra cash
ii) Extra borrowing capacity
(advance receipt from
customers)
Models for the management of cash and
temporary investments are ndash Baumol
model Beranek model Miller-Orr
model and Stone model
Virgin does not follow any method
wholly but a combination of Baumol
model and Beranek model is occurred
82 INVENTORY MANAGEMENT
21 Certainty Approach
isnt used in
irgin because it thinks it is not possible to implement in Bangladesh
d time is one to three days It
oes not use ABC system of inventory management
8
Main item of inventory of Virgin is Can pet chip sugar label chemical artificial
sweet etc Virgin maintains a minimum level of inventory but it does not have to face
problems because inventory is managed efficiently just-in-time (JIT)
V
Virgin maintains buffer stock because of the shortage of work-in-process (WIP)
inventory Its production process may also be hampered Thats why it maintains
safety stock to avoid stock out cost In case of imported goods normal lead time is
about one month and within the country normal lea
d
Page 39 of 46
Inventory Model
In reality Virgin does not use any of models of EOQ ordering and holding strategy
and safety stock strategy They maintain inventory based on their prior experience
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
822 Uncertainty Approach
Virgin does not use any model for handling inventory uncertainty It says that such
decision depends on business cycle and market situation Long before Eid festival
they bought large amount of sugar because of price increase on the occasion of Eid
In summary
Standard Compliance by Virgin Soft Drinks
Firms maintain inventory to guard
against several problems
Virgin maintains a minimum level of
inventory which is managed efficiently
Some firms use JIT to avoid inventory
cost
JIT is not used by Virgin as it thinks it is
impossible to implement in Bangladesh
Firms maintain buffer stock Virgin maintains buffer stock too
Firms maintain safety stock to avoid
shortage cost
Virgin also maintains safety stock
Firms use ABC system to monitor
inventory
Virgin doesnt use ABC system
EOQ model is an appropriate method
for measuring quantity that has to be
ordered per order
Virgin does not use EOQ model rather
makes order based on experience and
market demand
83 MANAGING ACCOUNTS RECEIVABLE (DEBTORS)
831 Terms of Sale Decision
Page 40 of 46
Virgin offers the term 210 net 30 enables the customers to deduct 2 percent from the
face value of the bill when paying within the first 10 days but if the discount is not
taken the customer must remit the full amount within 30 days But Virgin does not
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
offer the same terms of sale to all customers For prime customers it offers special
terms of sale In setting an appropriate term of sale it costs and benefits regarding
this are compared It uses the standard approach of terms of sale decision as it is
simple to use
832 Credit Granting Decisions
In case of Virgin the Capital and Character of Five Cs get more importance
Although there are many problems with the traditional approach Virgin uses it
because of its simplicity Virgin does not use Net Present Value (NPV) method in
credit granting decision It thinks that NPV is an appropriate method and should be
used next time It does not face any severe problem because of bad debts The reason
is that notes receivable is used when credit is granted
833 Monitoring Accounts Receivable
Virgin monitors its accounts receivable Virgin believes that in any case both positive
and negative durations in accounts signal differences from the results that
management believe to be the most advantageous for the firm
Tools for Monitoring Accounts Receivable
Page 41 of 46
For monitoring accounts receivable there are several tools such as aging schedule
the ratios of receivable outstanding to original sales customers payment proportion
and sales weighted DSO (Days Sales Outstanding) For monitoring accounts
receivable Virgin uses aging schedule fractions and traditional DSO statistics
because of their simplicity in use Although payment proportions ratios of
receivables outstanding and sales weighted DSO methods are free from inherent bias
None of these is used because all these are complex to maintain
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
In summary
Page 42 of 46
Standard Compliance by Virgin Soft Drinks
Generals terms of sale is 210 net 30 Normally Virgin also use general terms
of sale ie 210 net 30
Firms do not offer the same terms of
sale to all customers
Yes For prime customers Virgin offers
special terms of sale
Approaches of terms of sale decisions
are ndash
bull Standard approach
bull Multi period approach
Virgin uses standard approach of terms
of sale decision as it is simple to use and
understand
Source of credit information are ndash
Sellers prior experience with the
customer
Credit agency ratings and
reports
Personal contact with the
applicants bank and other
creditors
Analysis of applicants financial
statements
Customer visit
Main source of credit information to
Virgin is its prior experience with the
customer All other sources are not cost-
effective for Virgin
Approaches of credit granting to
marginal accounts are ndash
Traditional approach
Net Present Value (NPV)
approach
It uses traditional approach still now but
thinks that NPV should be used for the
next periods
Firms monitor accounts receivable
because deviations from the expected
levels of turnover and of bad debt can
Virgin also monitors its accounts
receivable
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
signal several different problems
Different tools for monitoring accounts
receivable are ndash
Aging schedule
Ratios of receivables
outstanding to original sales
Customers payment
proportions
Sales-weighted DSO
For monitoring accounts receivable
Virgin uses aging schedule and
traditional sales outstanding statistics
84 MANAGING ACCOUNTS PAYABLE (CREDITORS)
Virgin has almost accounts payable of Tk 8000000 But most of its liabilities are to
the banks rather than suppliers But we dont have any clear information about
Virgins accounts payable
9 RECOMMENDATION
Virgin should invest its surplus cash in short term marketable securities
because it is suitable hedging against cash uncertainties and will also give
some returns (interest income)
Virgin should publish its own annual report which will satisfy information
needs of stakeholders and also increase the credibility of information provided
by Virgin
Page 43 of 46
Virgin should use multi period approach in terms of sale decision because
standard approach which is already exists in Virgin has some inherent
problems
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
It should stop using traditional approach from now It should use NPV
method in credit granting to marginal accounts
In monitoring accounts receivable Virgin should use sales-weighted DSO
method because it has least limitation compared to the others
It should be more flexible in granting credit which will ultimately increase its
sales
To get the appropriate number of quantity to be ordered per order it should
use DSO model
It should be ABC system for proper monitoring of inventory
10 CONCLUSION
The use of other peoples money in business is usually an expensive resource Before
looking outside for finance a firm should examine its own working capital cycle to
make sure that every rand of its own internal funds is being fully utilized Good
management of working capital is part of good financial management Effective use
of working capital will contribute to the operational efficiency of the whole
organization optimum use will help to generate maximum returns Furthermore
working capital management is not an end in itself It is an integral part of the firms
overall management The needs of efficient working capital management must be
considered in relation to other aspects of the Virgins financial and non-financial
performance Thats why when planning the development of a business it is critical
that the impact of working capital be fully assessed
Page 44 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
BIBLIOGRAPHY
Scherr FC (1989) International Edition Prentice-Hall International Inc Modern
Working Capital Management Text and Cases
Hussain Riaz (2002) Working Capital Management
Robertson Lonnie (July 1998) Inventory Management
httpwwwasashoporg visited on March 13 2006
The Art of Cash Management
httpwwwinccom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management
httpwwwstudyfinancecom visited on March 13 2006
White Paper ndash Managing Working Capital
httpwwwplanwareorg visited on March 13 2006
Management of Working Capital
httpwwwbusinesscentralcoza visited on March 13 2006
Cash Management
httpwwwsbagov visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management Objectives
httpwpsprenhallcom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management
Page 45 of 46
httpwwwadvancemecom visited on March 13 2006
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Business Receivables Financing
httpwwwbbtcom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Finance
http wwwfnbcoza visited on March 13 2006
Tips to manage your working capital
httpsmallbusinessninemsncomau visited on March 13 2006
Inventory Financing
httpwwwfranklincapitalnetworkcom visited on March 13 2006
Accounts Receivable Management
httpwwwfranklincapitalnetworkcom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management
httpwwwtreasurygovtnz visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management
httpwwwtreasurystrategiescom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Works
httpwwwinvestopediacom visited on March 13 2006
Treasury Services
httpwwwjpmorganchasecom visited on March 13 2006
what were about
Page 46 of 46
httpwwwvirgincom visited on March 13 2006
Annexure
Annexure
Interview with YASEER RIZVI
Mr Yaseer Rizvi the DMD of Global Beverage Co Ltd obtained his MBA degree
from a reputed university He had been the Director of Ocean Container Ltd before
joining in Global Beverage Co Ltd He possesses a nice personality
I interviewed Yaseer Rizvi Excerpts from his interview are as follows ndash
Shah Kamal Sir would you please tell me do you invest in short term marketable securities
Yaseer Rizvi Basically we do not invest our surplus cash in short term marketable
securities like T-Bill commercial paper certificate of deposit etc But we keep our
surplus cash in Bank
Shah Kamal Would you tell me something about transit time for a typical check
Yaseer Rizvi Well in Virgin the transit time for a typical check is ndash
For mail float 2 to 3 days
At firm float 6 hours
Clearing float 1 to 3 days
Shah Kamal Do you maintain any cash concentration mechanism like depository transfer check automated clearing house and wire transfer
i
Annexure
Yaseer Rizvi Our position in this case is very strong as we use all the mechanisms
you mentioned As Virgin is a firm with small deposits spread over a substantial
number of banks so we tend to use depository transfer checks extensively It is less
costly We also use automated clearing house and wire transfer but later is used in a
less extent
Shah Kamal Sir what techniques of disbursement management is used by your firm
Yaseer Rizvi Like other firms Virgin tries to retain the cash for as long as possible
But we always perform it in an ethical manner We do not use management of
disbursement float as it seems unethical We follow Zero-Balance Accounts method
for managing disbursement We do not prefer Controlled Disbursing method since
Zero-Balance system is already practiced in Virgin
Shah Kamal How do you hedge cash balance uncertainties
Yaseer Rizvi Well you may say that we do not invest in short term securities but for
facing cash difficulties we keep our surplus cash in bank
Shah Kamal Sir would you please tell me the general terms of sale of Virgin
Yaseer Rizvi Though it is difficult to maintain a fixed terms of sale our general terms
of sale is 210 n30 But for prime customers we offer special terms of sale
Shah Kamal What are the sources of credit information in case of your firm
Yaseer Rizvi We grant credit on the basis of prior experience with the customers In
case of a new customer personal contact is weighted
Shah Kamal Does your firm consider 5 Cs in granting credit
ii
Annexure
Yaseer Rizvi In case of Virgin Capital and Character get more importance than the
others Mind one thing personal relationship is the main measure in granting credit
Shah Kamal Do you use NPV method in credit granting decisions
Yaseer Rizvi We do not use NPV method But we think that NPV is a suitable
method and we have to use it from the next period
Shah Kamal Sir how do you handle the problem of bad debt
Yaseer Rizvi Well in this case our position is very strong Yet we do not face any
problem because of bad debt Just note that we make more than 80 of sales in cash
and we monitor accounts receivable very carefully
Shah Kamal What level of inventory is maintained by Virgin
Yaseer Rizvi We maintain a minimum level of inventory but do not have to face
stock out problems because inventory is managed efficiently
Shah Kamal What is the normal lead time
Yaseer Rizvi In case of imported goods normal lead time is about 1 month and when
we purchase raw materials from inside the country lead time is 1 to 3 days
Shah Kamal What method do you use for managing inventory
Yaseer Rizvi We do not use any method particularly rather inventory decision
depends on business cycle and market situation Long before the Eid festival we
bought large amount of sugar because price of sugar was increased on the occasion
of Eid
iii
Annexure
Shah Kamal What are the main items of inventory of your firm
Yaseer Rizvi Well these are ndash aluminum can pet chip sugar label chemical and
artificial sweet
Shah Kamal What are the uncertainties in maintaining appropriate level of stock
Yaseer Rizvi These are ndash
bull Increase in price of raw materials
bull Sales uncertainty
bull Market trends etc
Shah Kamal Thank you for your kind cooperation
Yaseer Rizvi Most Welcome
iv
Global Beverage Company Limited
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
Working capital is basically an expression of how many in liquid assets the company
currently has to build its business fund its growth and produce value for the owner
The faster a business expands the more cash it will need for working capital and
investment The cheapest and best sources of cash exist as working capital right
within the business Good management of working capital will generate cash and
help improve profits and reduce risks My study is based on the comparison between
theoretical and practical aspects of working capital management For this purpose
Ive collected some information regarding working capital its cycle and its
management from Virgin Soft Drinks It has been found that their major transactions
are handled in cash But one of its major weaknesses is that it keeps its surplus funds
in banks rather than investing in marketable securities Therefore they can earn
optimum profit by implementing effective mechanism which will help to gain
optimum working capital
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
1 INTRODUCTION
Working capital is the life blood of any business big or small However smaller
businesses might find it more trying to maintain a comfortable level of capital
Managing working capital is an important factor for them Working capital
management is important because maintaining a balance of income to debt can be
difficult and owners must be diligent to assure that it is kept Sometimes it takes a
little assistance to maintain levels of fluidity or make major purchases If working
capital dips too low a business risks running out of cash Even very profitable
businesses can run into trouble if they lose the ability to meet their short-term
obligations Working capital financing can be used as a fast cash option to cushion
the periods when the flow is not ideal or readily available Even when owners are
meticulous in managing working capital finding the right levels to remain
comfortable and competitive can be difficult
The analogy has often been made that cash is the lifeblood of any business A
transfusion will miraculously bring the patient back from the brink of death but only
if
The blood is of the right kind
The problem causing the leakage is attended to
In other words the financial requirements of any business must be tailored to suit
that businesss own particular needs For example fixed assets should be financed by
long term loans and capital Working capital requirements should be attended to by
short term finance eg overdrafts
Page 1 of 46
It goes without saying that before capital is injected into the business it should first be
ascertained whether all unnecessary leakages have been plugged Otherwise in time
the transfusion will follow the same route To control and exploit the cash cycle
through any business so that it can continue to function on a day-to-day basis is
therefore the hub of working capital management The fundamental principle of
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
working capital management is having just the right amount of money available
when needed Every rand in the business should be earning its maximum return
wherever employed
2 OBJECTIVES OF THE STUDY
The study has been undertaken with the following objectives
To know the fundamentals of working capital management
To gather practical knowledge about the implementation of working capital
management by Virgin Soft Drinks
To understand the efficiency of Virgin Soft Drinks in managing working
capital
3 METHODOLOGY
In this paper the following methods are used
a) Sources and Data Collection
The major part of this paper is collected from the primary and secondary data
collection method
Conducted formal interview and focus observation and intensive practical
work to collect information
Page 2 of 46
Collected information from companys profiles
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Collected current information from website
b) Segregation of Data
Necessary data were segregated from the source material for the purpose of preparing
the report
c) Processing of Data
Collected data were compiled and processed for the purpose of preparing the report
d) Presentation of Data
Collected data were presented in charts and tables
4 LIMITATIONS OF THE STUDY
On the way of my study I have faced a number of problems which may be turned
as the limitation of report
Many personnel of the organization due to their pressure of the work were
reluctant to provide much useful information
Sufficient records publications facts and figures are not available These
constraints narrowed the scope of real analysis
Due to time constraint I could not spend sufficient time which was
necessary to make this report more representative of the fact
Page 3 of 46
Lack of experience has also acted as constraint for the exploration of the
topic
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
5 WORKING CAPITAL MANAGEMENT
51 DEFINING WORKING CAPITAL
The term working capital refers to the amount of capital which is readily available to
an organization That is working capital is the difference between resources in cash
or readily convertible into cash (Current Assets) and organizational commitments for
which cash will soon be required (Current Liabilities)
Current Assets are resources which are in cash or will soon be converted into cash in
the ordinary course of business
Current Liabilities are commitments which will soon require cash settlement in the
ordinary course of business
Thus ndash
WORKING CAPITAL = CURRENT ASSETS - CURRENT LIABILITIES
In a firms Statement of Financial position these components of working capital are
reported under the following headings
Current Assets
Liquid Assets (cash and bank deposits)
Inventory
Debtors and Receivables
Current Liabilities
Bank Overdraft
Creditors and Payables
Other Short Term Liabilities
Page 4 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Working capital management involves the relationship between a firms short-term
assets and its short-term liabilities The goal of working capital management is to
ensure that a firm is able to continue its operations and that it has sufficient ability to
satisfy both maturing short-term debt and upcoming operational expenses The
management of working capital involves managing inventories accounts receivable
and payable and cash
52 WORKING CAPITAL POLICIES
The aim of working capital policy is to balance having too little working capital
which can lead to an inability to pay debts as they fall due or the need for expensive
short term borrowings and too much which is wasteful in terms of lost opportunities
for the funds tied up The crucial role of working capital is that it finances the goods
inwards production and sales activities
A firmrsquos working capital policy has two components
1 Policies regarding the appropriate level of current assets (Current Asset Investment Policy)
2 Policies regarding the use of short-term financing (Current Asset Financing Policy)
Alternative Current Asset Investment Policies
These policies are general strategies that firms may follow with regard to their overall
level of current assets investment or holdings There are three types
1 Relaxed Current Asset Investment Policy ndash
Relatively large amounts of cash marketable securities and inventories are carried
and sales are stimulated by a liberal (generous) trade credit policy resulting in high
levels of receivables This is a low risk strategy because the firm always has plenty of
cash and inventory on hand The return is low because more money is invested in
low yielding assets
Page 5 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
2 Restricted Current Asset Investment Policy ndash
Holdings of cash securities inventories and receivables are minimized This is a
high risk strategy because the firm tries to keep the bare minimum of cash and
inventory The potential return is high because less money is invested in low
yielding assets
3 Moderate Current Asset Policy ndash
Balance between relaxed and restricted current asset investment policies (moderate
risk - moderate potential return)
Alternative Current Asset Financing Policies
These policies are general strategies that firms may follow with regard to how current
assets are to be financed Current assets can be classified as permanent or temporary
Permanent current assets are the current assets that the company needs to maintain
throughout the entire year Temporary current assets are those that are due to
seasonal fluctuations With respect to the current asset financing policy the question
is how the permanent current assets will and temporary current assets are financed
(long-term or short-term financing)
Page 6 of 46
Aggressive Moderate Conservative
Cash Minimum holding Prepared to hold
some precautionary
balances
Prepared to hold idle
cash balances
Debtors and
stock
Minimum
consistent with
business needs
Moderate levels High stock and
debtor levels to
maximize sales
Creditors Maximum
available without
compromising
business needs
Moderate level Low level seeking
discounts and
reputation for good
payment
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Future cash
flows
Predictable Reasonably
predictable
Unpredictable
Attitude to
Risk
Accepting Neutral Rejecting
Total assets = Fixed Assets + Permanent Current Assets + Fluctuating Current Assets
53 WORKING CAPITAL CYCLE
Cash flows in a cycle into around and out of a business It is the businesss life blood
and every managers primary task is to help keep it flowing and to use the cash flow
to generate profits If a business is operating profitably then it should in theory
generate cash surpluses If it doesnt generate surpluses the business will eventually
run out of cash and expire
The faster a business expands the more cash it will need for working capital and
investment The cheapest and best sources of cash exist as working capital right
within business Good management of working capital will generate cash will help
improve profits and reduce risks
Working capital can be broken down into the following major components cash (or
bank overdraft) stock debtors creditors Each of these items can have a major
influence on the working capital (or simply cash) that any business requires on an
ongoing basis For example when a business starts up the owner may inject a
certain amount of cash into the business which will enable him to purchase his initial
stock pay his workers their first months wages and cover other overheads such as
rent He then sells his product and this income may be utilized to purchase more
stock pay more wages and overheads and perhaps even have a surplus over for his
own use The quicker he can turn his stock over to receive payment the sooner the
working capital cycle will be completed
Page 7 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Figure Working Capital Cycle
These major components of working capital are discussed below
531 CASH MANAGEMENT
The term cash management refers to the management of cash from the time it starts
its transit to the firm until it leaves the firm in payments Cash management
encompasses the design of collection and disbursement systems for cash and the
temporary investment of cash while it resides with the firm Widely used money
market instruments are-
Treasury bill
Commercial paper
Certificate of deposits
Bankerrsquos acceptance
Page 8 of 46
Repurchase agreement
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
5311 Motives for Holding Cash
Despite the seemingly low returns there are several good reasons why firms hold
cash and marketable securities These reasons are ndash
Cash for transactions
Cash and near cash assets as hedges
Temporary investment and
Compensating balances
5312 Components of Cash Management
A Cash Flow Statement shows the sources and uses of cash and is typically divided
into three components
Operating Cash Flow
Operating cash flow often referred to as working capital is the cash flow generated
from internal operations It comes from sales of the product or service of your
business and because it is generated internally it is under your control
Investing Cash Flow
Investing cash flow is generated internally from non-operating activities This
includes investments in plant and equipment or other fixed assets nonrecurring gains
or losses or other sources and uses of cash outside of normal operations
Financing Cash Flow
Financing cash flow is the cash to and from external sources such as lenders
investors and shareholders
Page 9 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
5313 Tools for Cash Management
Flotation and Check Clearing
Management of cash when it is not in the firmrsquos hands that is in transit to and from
the firm is on important function in the area of finance Transit times for the check
takes in three stages These are mail float at firm float and clearing float Normally
mail float takes 1 to 5 days at firm float takes 025 to 1 day and clearing float takes 0
to 2 days The firm should care about this process because every delay in the receipt
of money by the firm lowers the firmrsquos returns and therefore its shareholdersrsquo wealth
There are several strategies that firm can use to reduce the delay in receiving funds
Each of these strategies addresses one or more of the three float times (mail float
time at time float time and clearing float time) that make up the total transit time of
fund from one firm to another
Other Cash Management Tools
When the economy is strong companies can lapse into sloppy cash-management
practices Firm should try exploring these options
1 Sweep accounts
These bank accounts are the easiest way to generate some income from companys
spare funds however they make sense only if the money youll earn will be greater
than the fees your bank will charge Business owners have two types of sweep
accounts to choose between
Page 10 of 46
Controlled-investment accounts These are the most profitable form of
sweep account but they wont work for company if the firm has any
electronic payments or wire transfers since those may be submitted for
payment later in the day and the account wont have enough cash in it to
cover them
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Page 11 of 46
End-of-day sweep accounts A safer bet for most small-business owners
these accounts wait until a late-hour cutoff to determine how much to
sweep into the firms overnight investments Typically their investment
yields are 10 to 20 basis points (1 to 2 of the investment) lower than
those offered with controlled investments
2 Lock-box accounts
A lock box is a cash-management system that helps the firm collect funds quickly
Generally set up with the assistance of a big money center or regional bank lock
boxes provide the firm with a special zip code and usually quicker deliveries from
regional post offices They are especially important if the firm has clusters of
customers in out-of-state locations and dont want to lose days waiting for their
checks to arrive by long-distance mail
5314 Cash Concentration and Cash Disbursement
Once the remittances from the firmrsquos customers have been received and cleared the
resulting cash balances is available in the firmrsquos lockbox (depository) banks It is
useful for the firm to gather these balances from the lockbox banks into the central
bank account The process of collecting funds is called cash concentration
Several concentration mechanism are available for the firm to use in transferring
funds from its collection banks to regional concentration banks and from there to the
central concentration bank These mechanisms differ in cost and in the availability of
funds that they provide These are ndash
a) Depository Transfer Check
It is the cheapest transfer mechanism This document instructs one bank to
send funds to another and is treated the same as any other check
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
b) Automated Clearing House (ACH) Electronic Transfer
This vehicle is essentially an electronic version of the depository transfer
check and can be used between banks that participate in the automated
clearing house system
c) Wire Transfer
These are electronic message between banks
Decisions regarding concentration mechanism usually hinge on the size and
spread of the firmrsquos deposits Firms with small deposits spread over a
substantial number of banks will tend to have more extensive concentration
systems and will transfer among accounts using low-cost transfer vehicles that
offer only delayed availability (such as depository transfer checks) Firms with
larger deposits will have fewer accounts (since a local deposit for transfer to
an upstream bank is not needed) and will use more expensive and more rapid
transfer mechanisms (such as wire transfers) The concentration systems of
major chemical companies for example tend to be structured in this way ndash
DepositoryLockbox Banks
Regional Concentration Banks
Central Concentrated Bank
Figure A typical Cash Concentration System
(Arrows indicate transfers of collected funds)
Page 12 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Disbursement management addresses the efficient payout out of this cash once it is
concentrated The firmrsquos objective in disbursement management is to retain the cash
for as long as possible In this way the firm will have the maximum amount of funds
available for investment and transactional purposes Certainly this management
means making disbursement only when they are due and not before The firm has
several available set of techniques for disbursement management Included among
these are ndash
a) Management of Disbursement Float
In this set of techniques the disbursing firm attempts to increase the length of
time between the mailing of its checks and the eventual withdrawal of funds
from the banks This involves strategies for increasing mail float at firm float
and clearing float on its outgoing checks For example the disbursing firm
may intentionally address checks to the firmrsquos office address rather than its
lockbox creating at firm float
b) Zero-Balance Accounts
Here the firm holds the cash until the check arrive (or expected to arrive) at
the disbursement bank In this strategy an account for disbursement is first
established at a bank For the zero-balance system to be effective the
participating bank must be one on which most disbursement are made via the
Bangladesh Bankrsquos clearance system (which presents disbursements to banks
early in the morning) and not a bank where disbursements occur throughout
the day (as with a major money-center bank) Consequently the banks used
in zero-balance strategies are usually branches of major banks and not their
main locations
Page 13 of 46
c) Controlled Disbursing
In this system the firm projects the amount of checks to arrive each day at the
disbursement bank (based on the checks written in previous days and historic
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
statistics on disbursement float) and transfers the amount of the expected
checks to the account on that day or just before
5315 Cash Forecasting
Defining Cash Forecasting
The cash forecast is an estimation of the flows in and out of the firmrsquos cash account
over a particular period of time usually a quarter month week or day The cash
forecast is primarily intended to produce a very useful piece of information an
estimation of the firmrsquos borrowing and lending needs and uncertainties regarding
these needs during various future periods Cash forecasting is very crucial to most
firms It enables them to anticipate periods of surplus cash and periods where
financing will be necessary This anticipation is the reason that cash forecasts are
generated Anticipation enables the firm to plan much more effectively for
investment and financing and via this planning produce superior return
Types of Cash Forecasts
The types of cash forecasts generated by firms can be differentiated along two
dimensions the length of the periods included within the cash forecast and the approach
to cash flows used in the cash forecast The length of the period refers to the units of
time into which the cash forecast is divided Firms may make cash flow forecasts
over periods of various lengths yearly flows quarterly flows monthly flows weekly
flows or even daily flows The most popular forecast involves monthly flows but
most firms do not confine themselves to a single forecast Instead they use several
forecasts with periods of various lengths When the firm makes forecasts involving
multiple and overlapping period lengths one forecast relates to another Starting
with data on relatively long periods and breaking it down into smaller periods is
called distribution starting with data on relatively short periods and aggregating into
longer periods is called scheduling
Page 14 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Firms use two common approaches to cash flows in generating the cash forecast the
receipts and disbursements approach and the adjusted net income approach The receipts
and disbursements approach use the amounts of cash expected to be received and
disbursed by the firm over the periods chosen for forecast The adjusted income
statement approach is sometimes called the sources and use approach Here the
forecaster starts with projected net income on an accrual basis and adjusts to a cash
basis This method provides a representation of changes in asset and liability
accounts since the level of these accounts are of interest to the firm this aspect of the
adjusted income statement is an advantage over the receipts and disbursements
method
Items to Be Forecast
In the receipt and disbursements cash forecasting method estimates need to be made
of the numerous major and minor items that the firm collects (receipts) and that it
pays (disbursements) The more individual categories of items the firm includes in its
forecast procedure the more accurate the forecast may be but the more costly in
terms of time and effort it will be to generate
Some Possible Types of Cash Receipts and Cash Disbursements
Cash Disbursements Cash Receipts
Cash Purchases of Materials Payroll
Taxes
Maturing Accounts Payable
Maturing Notes Payable
Miscellaneous Disbursements
Accounts Receivable
Notes Receivable
Rental Income
Interest Income
Miscellaneous Receipts
Methods of Financial Forecasting
Page 15 of 46
Financial forecasting is the estimation of the future level of a financial variable often
a cash flow asset level or liability level It is usually assumed that the relationship
between the financial variable and other variable is linear The general linear model
can then be used
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
nnt xaxaxaaY 22110 ++=
Here
= Financial variable (Y) to be forecast in period t tY
x = Explanatory variable it is assumed to cause the level of Y in period t
0a = Represents a constant unaffected by the x
The other terms are the estimated coefficients of the explanatory x variables
There are n terms with xrsquos in them
There are four common approaches to forecasting financial variables but they
are all special cases of the general linear model These are ndash spot method proportion
to another account compounded growth and multiple dependencies
Using Cash Forecast
The estimate of available funds for investment and needed financing enables the firm
to plan so as to obtain the most advantages borrowing terms for deficits and achieve
the greatest interest income on surplus A useful chart for this planning purpose is a
bar chart eg
Figure Bar Chart of Cash Surpluses and Deficits from hypothetical data
Page 16 of 46
75
50
-60
30
100
-20
-80-60-40-20
020406080
100120
Defic
it
S
urpl
us
January February March April May June
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Sources of Uncertainty in Cash Forecasting and Hedging Uncertainties
There are numerous sources of risk in cash forecasting Among the sources are sales
uncertainty collection rate uncertainty production cost uncertainty and capital
outflow uncertainty
5316 Models for the Management of Cash and Temporary Investments
There are different models for the management of cash and temporary investments
Among these the most popular methods are ndash Baumol model Beranek model
Miller-Orr model and Stone model
Baumol and Beranek use the same model The formula is cited below ndash
Interest Income = iYn
n⎥⎦⎤
⎢⎣⎡ minus
21
Profit = naiYn
nminus⎥⎦
⎤⎢⎣⎡ minus
21
Optimum number of transactions = ⎟⎠⎞
⎜⎝⎛
aiY2
Where n = Optimum number of transactions
i = Interest rate per period
a = Transaction cost
Y = Total inflow for the period
Page 17 of 46
Miller-Orr and Stone use the same model ie R-Statistic The model is ndash
31
43
iav
R ⎟⎠⎞
⎜⎝⎛=
Optimum Control Limit = R + L
Upper Control Limit = 3R + L
Where a = Transaction Cost
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
v = Variance of daily cash flows
i = Daily interest rate
5317 Administration
Cash receipts should be processed and banked as quickly as possible because
They cannot earn interest or reduce overdraft until they are banked
information about the existence and amounts of cash receipts is usually not
available until they are processed
Where possible cash floats (mainly petty cash and advances) should be avoided If
on review the only reason that can be put forward for their existence is that weve
always had them they should be discontinued There may be situations where they
are useful however For example it may be desirable for peripheral parts of
departments to meet urgent local needs from cash floats rather than local bank
accounts
5318 Internal Control
Cash and cash management is part of a firms overall internal control system The
main internal cash control is invariably the bank reconciliation This provides
assurance that the cash balances recorded in the accounting systems are consistent
with the actual bank balances It requires regular clearing of reconciling items
5319 Practicing Good Cash Flow Management
Good cash management is simple It involves
Knowing when where and how firms cash needs will occur
Page 18 of 46
Knowing the best sources for meeting additional cash needs
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Page 19 of 46
Being prepared to meet these needs when they occur by keeping good
relationships with bankers and other creditors
532 INVENTORY MANAGEMENT
Inventory management is necessary for owners who want to maintain a stocking
service for quick turnaround to help ensure total customer satisfaction The fill rate
of an item on a managed inventory list must be maintained to avoid shortages of
frequently used items Even when utilizing an inventory management system
occasional shortages will still occur Inventories are lists of stocks-raw materials
work in progress or finished goods-waiting to be consumed in production or to be
sold The total balance of inventory is the sum of the value of each individual stock
line
Basically firms hold stocks for the following reasons
To act as a buffer in times of unusually high demand
To ensure continuity of production
Avoid high costs of emergency orders
To take advantage of quantity discounts by ordering more at a time
To reduce ordering costs by ordering more items on fewer
As part of the production process eg maturing whisky or keeping oil in
pipelines
Seasonality of demand (eg firework) or supplies
Suppliers insist on minimum order quantities
The key issue for a business is to identify the fast and slow stock movers with the
objectives of establishing optimum stock levels for each category and thereby
minimize the cash tied up in stocks Factors to be considered when determining
optimum stock levels include
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Page 20 of 46
What are the projected sales of each product
How widely available are raw materials components etc
How long does it take for delivery by suppliers
Can the firm remove slow movers from its product range without
compromising best sellers
Inventory management is an important aspect of working capital management
because inventories themselves do not earn any revenue Holding either too little or
too much inventory incurs costs
Costs of carrying too much inventory are
Opportunity cost of foregone interest
Warehousing costs
Damage and pilferage
Obsolescence
Insurance
Costs of carrying too little inventory are
Stock out costs
Lost sales
Delayed service
Ordering costs
Freight
on Order administrati
nts
Loss of quantity discou
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Carrying costs can be minimized by making frequent small orders but this increase
ordering costs and the risk of stock outs Risk of stock-outs can be reduced by
carrying safety stocks (at a cost) and re-ordering ahead of time
The best ordering strategy requires balancing the various cost factors to ensure the
firm incurs minimum inventory costs The optimum inventory position is known as
the Economic Reorder Quantity (ERQ)
Nowadays many large manufacturers operate on a just-in-time (JIT) basis whereby
all the components to be assembled on a particular today arrive at the factory early
that morning no earlier - no later This helps to minimize manufacturing costs as JIT
stocks take up little space minimize stock-holding and virtually eliminate the risks of
obsolete or damaged stock Because JIT manufacturers hold stock for a very short
time they are able to conserve substantial cash JIT is a good model to strive for as it
embraces all the principles of prudent stock management For better stock control
firm may try the following
Review the effectiveness of existing purchasing and inventory systems
Know the stock turn for all major items of inventory
Apply tight controls to the significant few items and simplify controls for the
trivial many
Sell off outdated or slow moving merchandise - it gets more difficult to sell the
longer the firm keeps it
Consider having part of its product outsourced to another manufacturer rather
than make it itself
Review its security procedures to ensure that no stock is going out the back
door
Higher than necessary stock levels tie up cash and cost more in insurance
accommodation costs and interest charges
Page 21 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
However it is important to keep an overall perspective It is not cost-effective to
closely manage a large number of low value inventory lines nor is it necessary A
usual feature of inventories is that a small number of high value lines account for a
large proportion of inventory value The 8020 rule (PARETO) predicts that 80
of the total value of inventory is represented by only 20 of the number of inventory
items Those high value lines need reasonably close management The remaining
80 of inventory lines can be managed using broad-brush strategies
533 MANAGING ACCOUNTS RECEIVABLE (DEBTORS)
Cash flow can be significantly enhanced if the amounts owing to a business are
collected faster Every business needs to know who owes them money how much is
owed how long it is owing for what it is owed
Debtors (Accounts Receivable) are customers who have not yet made payment for
goods or services which the department has provided The objective of debtor
management is to minimize the time-lapse between completion of sales and receipt
of payment The costs of having debtors are
Opportunity costs (cash is not available for other purposes)
Bad debts
If firm doesnt manage debtors they will begin to manage business as the firm will gradually
lose control due to reduced cash flow and of course it could experience an increased
incidence of bad debt The following measures will help manage debtors
Having the right mental attitude to the control of credit and make sure that it
gets the priority it deserves
Establishing clear credit practices as a matter of company policy
Page 22 of 46
Making sure that these practices are clearly understood by staff suppliers and
customers
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Page 23 of 46
Being professional when accepting new accounts and especially larger ones
Checking out each customer thoroughly before the firm offers credit Use
credit agencies bank references industry sources etc
Establishing credit limits for each customer and sticking to them
Continuously reviewing these limits when it suspects tough times are coming
or if operating in a volatile sector
Keeping very close to the firms larger customers
Invoicing promptly and clearly
Considering charging penalties on overdue accounts
Considering accepting credit debit cards as a payment option
Monitoring its debtor balances and ageing schedules and dont let any debts
get too large or too old
Debtor management includes both pre-sale and debt collection strategies
Pre-sale strategies include
Offering cash discounts for early payment andor imposing penalties for late
payment
Agreeing payment terms in advance
Requiring cash before delivery
Setting credit limits
ning credit Setting criteria for obtai
Billing as early as possible
rogress payments
ost-sale strategies include
for collecting the debt upon the center that made the sale
Requiring deposits andor p
P
Placing the responsibility
Identifying long overdue balances and doubtful debts by regular analytical reviews
Having an established procedure for late collections such as
A reminder
A letter
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Page 24 of 46
ion of further credit Cancellat
Telephone calls
n agency Use of a collectio
he firm should recognize that the longer someone owes firm the greater the chance
Legal action
T
it will never get paid If the average age of debtors is getting longer or is already very
long it may need to look for the following possible defects
Weak credit judgment
res Poor collection procedu
ms Lax enforcement of credit ter
Slow issue of invoices or statements
Errors in invoices or statements
Customer dissatisfaction
Debtors due over 90 days (unless within agreed credit terms) should generally
demand immediate attention For example warning signs of a future bad debt ndash
Longer credit terms taken with approval particularly for smaller orders
Use of post-dated checks by debtors who normally settle within agreed terms
Evidence of customers switching to additional suppliers for the same goods
New customers who are reluctant to give credit references
Cre G
Receiving part payments from debtors
dit ranting to Marginal Accounts
Traditional Approach
In the traditional approach to the credit granting decision it is the credit analysts job
rmation that has been collected and reach a judgment
regarding the applicants creditworthiness One traditional way of organizing this
to synthesize all the info
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
information is by characterizing the applicant along five dimensions These
dimensions are called the Five Cs of credit ndash
Capital
Character
Collateral
and Capacity
Conditions
Net Present Value (NPV) Approach
Once a firm has assessed the creditworthiness of a customer it has to decide whether
r not credit should be granted The firm should use the NPV rule to make the
ld be granted
Figure
o
decision If NPV is positive credit shou
Credit Granting Decision
Credit Granting Decision
he act of collecting money is one which most people dislike for many reasons and
therefore put on the long f selves there is something
ore urgent or important that demands their attention now There is nothing more
T
inger because they convince them
m
important than getting paid for firms product or service A customer who does not
Page 25 of 46
Grand Credit
Payment received Payment not received
Benefit of present value of future net cash flow
Cost of present value ment of lost invest
Net Payoff PV of benefit-cost
No Credit
No Payoff
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
pay is not a customer Here are a few ideas that may help the firm in collecting
money from debtors
Firm should develop appropriate procedures for handling late payments
It should track and pursue late payers
It might get external help if its own efforts fail
or money its firms and it is entitled Company shouldnt feel guilty asking f
to it
ction
Firm must make that call now And it should keep asking until it gets some
satisfa
lessens the problem
In difficult circumstances take what the firm can now and agree terms for the
remainder It
paying
When asking for money be hard on the issue - but soft on the person It shouldnt
give the debtor any excuses for not
534 BLE (CREDITORS)
ices for goods or services have
een paid Organizations often regard the
not
to delay all payments until the latest possible date Regular weekly or
The firm make it its objective is to get the money - not to score points or get
even
MANAGING ACCOUNTS PAYA
Creditors (Accounts Payable) are suppliers whose invo
been processed but who have not yet b
amount owing to creditors as a source of free credit However creditor
administration systems are expensive and time-consuming to run The over-riding
concern in this area should be to minimize costs with simple procedures
While it is unnecessary to pay accounts before they fall due it is usually
worthwhile
Page 26 of 46
fortnightly payment of all due accounts is the simplest technique for creditor
management
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Electronic payments (direct credits) are cheaper than check payments considering
that transaction fees and overheads more than balance the advantage of delayed
presentation Some suppliers are reluctant to receive payments by this method but in
view of the substantial cost advantage (and the advantages to the suppliers
themselves) departments may wish to encourage suppliers to accept this option
However electronic payments are likely to be used in conjunction with rather than
as a replacement for check payments
Applying Best Practices in Managing Accounts Payable
f course simply deferring payments to suppliers could have adverse consequences
O
that more than offset the benefits of this additional cash flow Therefore it is
important to develop a holistic approach The firm should consider the following
best practices for payables management
Managing payment dates and terms to maximize cash flow ndash
y reporting on
receivable and
id penalty charges and taking advantage of
wer vendors and negotiate for more
to buying consortia with others even
voices for
payment based on receipt of goods or receipt of invoice whichever
comes later
Calculating and setting performance targets Regularl
AP performance measures such as days in payables
Coordinating the AP processes with accounts
inventory management to ensure that the company is collecting more
cash than it is paying out
Paying bills on time to avo
prompt-payment discounts where the discounts exceed the companyrsquos
cost of working capital
Consolidating purchases with fe
favorable payment terms
Considering entering in
Page 27 of 46
competitors to obtain favorable supplier pricing and terms
Unless contract terms specify otherwise setting up in
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Page 28 of 46
Em
process
-time payments with Electronic Funds Transfer (EFT)
uraging vendors to utilize electronic invoice presentment
a
ndancies and more
ploying technology to automate the accounts payable transaction
es ndash
Making just-in
Using an electronic invoice-matching application
Enco
For companies with multiple locations or business units employing
shared service approach for AP to eliminate redu
quickly implement process improvements
Mainta
vendor
Communicating accounts payable requirements to suppliers at the
m key suppliers
for suggestions on how to improve the
Efficient a
and making th rsquos cash is just good business
ining open communications and building strong relationships with
s to access valuable trade credit ndash
beginning of transactions
Requesting summary invoicing fro
Requiring suppliers to send invoices directly to accounts payable
Asking tier-one suppliers
payment process
nd effective management of accounts payable helps improve cash flow ndash
e most of company
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
6 OVERVIEW OF VIRGIN GROUP
Virgin - one of the most respected brands in Britain - is now becoming the first global
brand name of the 21st century Virgin is involved in planes trains finance soft
drinks music mobile phones holidays cars wines publishing bridal wear - the lot
What tie all these businesses together are the values of its brand and the attitude of its
people Virgin has created over 200 companies worldwide employing over 25000
people Its total revenues around the world in 2002 exceeded pound4 billion (US $72
billion)
In 1970 Richard Branson founded Virgin as a mail order record retailer and not
long after he opened a record shop in Oxford Street London During 1972 a
recording studio was built in Oxfordshire and the first Virgin artist Mike Oldfield
recorded Tubular Bells which was released in 1973
This album went on to sell over 5 million copies Since then many household names
including Belinda Carlisle Genesis Phil Collins Janet Jackson and The Rolling
Stones have helped to make Virgin Music one of the top six record companies in the
world The equity of Virgin Music Group - record labels music publishing and
recording studios was sold to THORN EMI in 1992 in a US$1billion deal
Page 29 of 46
The Virgin Group has now expanded into international music Mega stores air
travel mobile financial retail music internet drinks rail hotels and leisure with
around 200 companies in over 30 countries
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
In Virgins customers eyes Virgin stands for value for money quality innovation
fun and a sense of competitive challenge It delivers a quality service by empowering
its employees and facilitates and monitors customer feedback to continually improve
the customers experience through innovation
When they start a new venture Virgin bases it on hard research and analysis
Typically they review the industry and put themselves in the customers shoes to see
what could make it better Virgin asks fundamental questions
Is this an opportunity for restructuring a market and creating competitive
advantage What are the competitors doing
Is the customer confused or badly served
Is this an opportunity for building the Virgin brand
Can we add value
Will it interact with its other businesses
Is there an appropriate trade-off between risk and reward
Page 30 of 46
Virgin is also able to draw on talented people from throughout the group New
ventures are often steered by people seconded from other parts of Virgin who bring
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
with them the trademark management style skills and experience Virgin frequently
creates partnerships with others to combine skills knowledge and market presence
and so on Contrary to what some people may think their constantly expanding and
eclectic empire is neither random nor reckless Each successive venture demonstrates
its skill in picking the right market and the right opportunity
7 OVERVIEW OF VIRGIN SOFT DRINKS
The Virgin Drinks Group first launched as the Virgin Cola Company in 1994 with
Virgin Cola in the UK Since then the company has ventured across the carbonated
soft drinks arena and beyond into energy drinks tea and flavored Colas This
expansion has lead to the evolution of the Virgin Drinks Company a company
whose aim is to put the excitement back into the world of soft drinks It launched in
Bangladesh in 1999 Virgin Soft Drinks is monitored by Global Beverage Co Ltd in
Bangladesh
Brief history of Virgin Drinks is given below
Page 31 of 46
1994 November Virgin Cola launched in the UK
1996 March Virgin Cola launched in France
1998 June Virgin Cola launched in Belgium
April Virgin Cola launched in the French West Indies
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
August Virgin Cola launched in Switzerland
1999 March Virgin Colours launched in Italy
March Virgin Cola launched in Japan
July Virgin Colours launched in South Africa
December Virgin Colours launched in Bangladesh
2001 January Sweden launched Virgin Colours
November Singapore launched Virgin Colours
2002 February Croatia launched Virgin Colours
June Russia launched Virgin Colours
June Tunisia launched Virgin Colours
2003 May Israel launched Virgin Colours
8 FINDINGS OF WORKING CAPITAL MANAGEMENT MAINTAINED BY
VIRGIN SOFT DRINKS IN BANGLADESH
81 CASH MANAGEMENT
811 Holding Cash and Marketable Securities
Although there are many good reasons why firm hold cash and marketable
securities Virgin Drinks holds cash and marketable securities for two reasons ndash
i) Cash for transactions
ii) Cash as hedges
This indicates that the firm does not hold cash and marketable securities for some
important reasons such as ndash
i) Near cash assets as hedges
Page 32 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
ii) Temporary investment and compensating balances
Virgin Soft Drinks does not invest in money market securities such as Treasury bill
commercial paper certificate of deposits bankerrsquos acceptance and repurchase
agreement This firm deposits its money in bank as currant AC or fixed AC They
say that they do not have enough money to invest in money market instrument
They also say that if they have enough money they will invest it in money market
short term securities We know that near cash interest earning assets can be
substituted for cash when motivation for holding these assets is the hedging of cash
flow uncertainties or is the temporary investment of surplus funds In this point
Virgins position is not good as there is no significant hedging against uncertainty of
cash
812 Floatation and Check Clearing
Virgin is very smart in handling the problem of transit time for checks Here mail
float takes 2 to 3 days at firm takes 025 day and clearing float takes 1-3 days Virgin
uses most of the strategies available for reducing the delay in receiving funds It
(Virgin) has linked Islami Bank which posses an accelerated clearing facility It uses
electronic collection process which ensures faster collection and its at the firm check
processing is satisfactory But Virgin does not use lockbox The reason behind this is
that it is not cost-effective for Virgin to set lockboxes At this point we can say that
Virgins check clearing mechanism is much good
813 Cash Concentration and Disbursement Management
Page 33 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks takes the matter of cash concentration very seriously They use all
the available cash concentration mechanism Virgin is a firm with small deposits
spread over a substantial number of banks and this is why the firm tends to use
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
depository transfer checks extensively If is less costly Virgin also uses automated
clearing house and wire transfer To Virgin wire transfer seems too costly
Like other firm Virgin tries to retain the cash for as long as possible But Virgin
always performs it in an ethical manner Virgin does not try to defeat the receiving
firmrsquos attempts to reduce the float on incoming checks It does not take any strategy
for increasing mail float at firm float and clearing float on its outgoing checks To
Virgin it is deemed to be unethical It thinks that maximization of disbursement float
will not go unnoticed by sophisticated creditors for very long When it is noticed it
will negatively affect relations with these creditors reducing the firmrsquos bargaining
power with them This may ultimately cost Virgin dearly when future prices and
delivery schedules for goods and services purchased from trade creditors are
negotiated Virgin follows ldquoZero-Balance Accountsrdquo methods for managing
disbursement It thinks that in this method the coordination of funds inflows to
disbursement banks with the presentation of checks does not work to the detriment
of creditors since the firmrsquos checks to them are honored as presented and this strategy
does not affect float significantly Controlled disbursing method is less attractive to
Virgin because zero-balance system is already feasible
814 Cash Forecasting
Cash Forecasting and Its Types
Page 34 of 46
Virgin forecasts the future cash inflows and outflows To Virgin cash forecast is an
important part of the firmrsquos cash control system and is one of the forecasts that are
part of the Virginrsquos financial plan Virgin forecasts cash on monthly basis and on
yearly basis Virgin does not forecast on daily basis assuming that the temporary
shortage of funds within these periods can be covered without value cost eg
advance receipts from customers Virginrsquos cash forecasting system involves a
combination of distribution and scheduling The receipts and disbursements
approach of cash forecasting is used in virgin This method is used because it
minutely traces the movement of cash and very close control of cash is possible
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Virgin does not use adjusted net income approach on two grounds First it does not
permit the tracing of the individual types of cash inflows and outflows for any given
period which is often useful information for virgin Second it is not simple to use
Items to be Forecast
Virgin does not forecast all the items It forecasts only major items eg accounts
receivable notes receivable payroll cash purchases of raw materials In this regard
virgin trade off between cost and benefit
Methods of Financial Forecasting
Virgin forecasts the future level of financial variable such as cash level asset level or
liability level We know in short term forecasts many things will result from plans
and events that are already in place (contracts capital budgets long-range financing
plans and so forth) But in the long run most things can vary and are dependent on
outside influences such as the firmrsquos long-term growth rate Since Virginrsquos cash
forecasting deals mostly with near future many of the items on the cash forecasts are
estimated by some variation of the spot method and remaining estimates are mostly
on a ldquoproportion of another accountrdquo basis with this ldquoother accountrdquo often being a
particular periodrsquos sales Virgin uses the other two methods less frequently
Using Cash Forecast
Virgin forecasts cash for meeting general objectives (ie to know the available funds
for investment and need financing) and for meeting some special objectives (eg to
know whether the firm will fulfill its out of debt requirement) But it is matter to note
that Virgin does not make any short term investment of its surplus cash but only keep
this surplus in Bank Account
Page 35 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Sources of Uncertainty in Cash Forecasting and Hedging Uncertainties
Virgin faces uncertainty in cash forecasting mainly from two sources These are ndash
sales and production cost In peak season (hot season like autumn summer) sales
increases but in dull season (eg in winter) sales decreases drastically Production
cost may be increased because of increase of price of sugar chemicals aluminum
can Virgin follows two methods for hedging cash balance uncertainties These are ndash
i) Holding a stock of extra cash and
ii) Extra borrowing capacity
815 Modes for the Management of Cash and Temporary Investments
Virgin does not follow any of these methods wholly Virgin receives cash
continuously and pays salary at steady rate and pays continuously for other
expenses So it neither follows Baumol model nor Beranek model It has no upper
control limit lower control limit return point in case cash management So it neither
follows Miller-Orr model nor Stone model
In Summary
Page 36 of 46
Standard Compliance by Virgin Soft Drinks
Generally all firms hold cash and
marketable securities
Virgin holds only cash
Firms hold cash and marketable
securities for some reasons like
bull Cash for transactions
bull Cash and near-cash assets as
hedges
bull Temporary investments
bull Compensating balances
Virgin holds cash only for
two reasons ndash
bull Cash for transactions
bull Cash as hedges
Available money market instruments Virgin does not invest in any such
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
(short term securities) are ndash
Treasury Bills
Commercial Paper
Certificates of Deposit
Bankerrsquos Acceptance
Repurch menase Agree ts
instruments They only keep cash in
Bank Account
Mail Float
(1 to 5 days)
At Firm
Float
(025 to 1
day)
Clearing
Float
(0 to
2 days)
Mail Float
(2 to 3 days)
At firm
Float
(025
day)
Clearing
Float
(1 to 3
days)
Figure Transit time for a typical check Figure Transit time for a check for
Virgin
Strategies that firms can use to reduce
the delay in receiving funds are ndash
Selecting of Banks with
accelerated clearing capabilities
of check processing Acceleration
at the firm
ectronic collection Use of el
procedures
Use of lockboxes
Virgin follows the first three strategies
but does not use lockboxes
Available cash concentration
mechanisms are ndash
Depository transfer check
ouse Automated Clearing H
(ACH) electronic transfer)
Wire transfer
Virgin uses all these mechanisms of
cash concentration
Available sets of techniques for cash
disbursement management are ndash
ement of disbursement
Page 37 of 46
Manag
float
Virgin uses zero-balance accounts
technique
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Zero-Balance Accounts
Controlled disbursing
Firms may make cash flow forecasts
over periods of various lengths yearly
flows quarterly flows monthly flows
weekly flows or even daily flows
Virgin forecasts cash on yearly basis and
monthly basis
Cash forecasting system may involve ndash
Distribution
Scheduling
Virginrsquos cash forecasting system
involves a combination of distribution
and scheduling
Two common approaches to cash flow
in generating the cash forecast
and disbursement Receipts
approach
Adjusted net income approach
Virgin uses the receipts and
disbursement approach
There are many items to forecast Virgin forecasts only major items like
AR payroll etc
Four common approach to forecasting
fina i ndash nc al variables are
Spot method
Proportion to another account
Compounded growth
Multiple dependencies
Virgin uses spot method for forecasting
cash It uses proportion to another
account method for other variables and
remaining two methods are frequently
used
Sources of uncertainty in cash
forecasting are ndash
Sales uncertainty
Collection rate uncertainty
Production cost uncertainty
Capital outflow uncertainty
Virgin faces uncertainty mainly from
sales and production cost
Methods for hedging cash balance
unc a
Page 38 of 46
ert inties are ndash
i) Holding a stock of extra cash
Virgin two available methods for
hedging cash balance uncertainties
Th ese are ndash
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
ii) stock of near-cash Holding a
assets
iii) Extra borrowing capacity
iv) ary surpluses in Investing tempor
near-cash assets
i) Holding a stock of extra cash
ii) Extra borrowing capacity
(advance receipt from
customers)
Models for the management of cash and
temporary investments are ndash Baumol
model Beranek model Miller-Orr
model and Stone model
Virgin does not follow any method
wholly but a combination of Baumol
model and Beranek model is occurred
82 INVENTORY MANAGEMENT
21 Certainty Approach
isnt used in
irgin because it thinks it is not possible to implement in Bangladesh
d time is one to three days It
oes not use ABC system of inventory management
8
Main item of inventory of Virgin is Can pet chip sugar label chemical artificial
sweet etc Virgin maintains a minimum level of inventory but it does not have to face
problems because inventory is managed efficiently just-in-time (JIT)
V
Virgin maintains buffer stock because of the shortage of work-in-process (WIP)
inventory Its production process may also be hampered Thats why it maintains
safety stock to avoid stock out cost In case of imported goods normal lead time is
about one month and within the country normal lea
d
Page 39 of 46
Inventory Model
In reality Virgin does not use any of models of EOQ ordering and holding strategy
and safety stock strategy They maintain inventory based on their prior experience
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
822 Uncertainty Approach
Virgin does not use any model for handling inventory uncertainty It says that such
decision depends on business cycle and market situation Long before Eid festival
they bought large amount of sugar because of price increase on the occasion of Eid
In summary
Standard Compliance by Virgin Soft Drinks
Firms maintain inventory to guard
against several problems
Virgin maintains a minimum level of
inventory which is managed efficiently
Some firms use JIT to avoid inventory
cost
JIT is not used by Virgin as it thinks it is
impossible to implement in Bangladesh
Firms maintain buffer stock Virgin maintains buffer stock too
Firms maintain safety stock to avoid
shortage cost
Virgin also maintains safety stock
Firms use ABC system to monitor
inventory
Virgin doesnt use ABC system
EOQ model is an appropriate method
for measuring quantity that has to be
ordered per order
Virgin does not use EOQ model rather
makes order based on experience and
market demand
83 MANAGING ACCOUNTS RECEIVABLE (DEBTORS)
831 Terms of Sale Decision
Page 40 of 46
Virgin offers the term 210 net 30 enables the customers to deduct 2 percent from the
face value of the bill when paying within the first 10 days but if the discount is not
taken the customer must remit the full amount within 30 days But Virgin does not
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
offer the same terms of sale to all customers For prime customers it offers special
terms of sale In setting an appropriate term of sale it costs and benefits regarding
this are compared It uses the standard approach of terms of sale decision as it is
simple to use
832 Credit Granting Decisions
In case of Virgin the Capital and Character of Five Cs get more importance
Although there are many problems with the traditional approach Virgin uses it
because of its simplicity Virgin does not use Net Present Value (NPV) method in
credit granting decision It thinks that NPV is an appropriate method and should be
used next time It does not face any severe problem because of bad debts The reason
is that notes receivable is used when credit is granted
833 Monitoring Accounts Receivable
Virgin monitors its accounts receivable Virgin believes that in any case both positive
and negative durations in accounts signal differences from the results that
management believe to be the most advantageous for the firm
Tools for Monitoring Accounts Receivable
Page 41 of 46
For monitoring accounts receivable there are several tools such as aging schedule
the ratios of receivable outstanding to original sales customers payment proportion
and sales weighted DSO (Days Sales Outstanding) For monitoring accounts
receivable Virgin uses aging schedule fractions and traditional DSO statistics
because of their simplicity in use Although payment proportions ratios of
receivables outstanding and sales weighted DSO methods are free from inherent bias
None of these is used because all these are complex to maintain
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
In summary
Page 42 of 46
Standard Compliance by Virgin Soft Drinks
Generals terms of sale is 210 net 30 Normally Virgin also use general terms
of sale ie 210 net 30
Firms do not offer the same terms of
sale to all customers
Yes For prime customers Virgin offers
special terms of sale
Approaches of terms of sale decisions
are ndash
bull Standard approach
bull Multi period approach
Virgin uses standard approach of terms
of sale decision as it is simple to use and
understand
Source of credit information are ndash
Sellers prior experience with the
customer
Credit agency ratings and
reports
Personal contact with the
applicants bank and other
creditors
Analysis of applicants financial
statements
Customer visit
Main source of credit information to
Virgin is its prior experience with the
customer All other sources are not cost-
effective for Virgin
Approaches of credit granting to
marginal accounts are ndash
Traditional approach
Net Present Value (NPV)
approach
It uses traditional approach still now but
thinks that NPV should be used for the
next periods
Firms monitor accounts receivable
because deviations from the expected
levels of turnover and of bad debt can
Virgin also monitors its accounts
receivable
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
signal several different problems
Different tools for monitoring accounts
receivable are ndash
Aging schedule
Ratios of receivables
outstanding to original sales
Customers payment
proportions
Sales-weighted DSO
For monitoring accounts receivable
Virgin uses aging schedule and
traditional sales outstanding statistics
84 MANAGING ACCOUNTS PAYABLE (CREDITORS)
Virgin has almost accounts payable of Tk 8000000 But most of its liabilities are to
the banks rather than suppliers But we dont have any clear information about
Virgins accounts payable
9 RECOMMENDATION
Virgin should invest its surplus cash in short term marketable securities
because it is suitable hedging against cash uncertainties and will also give
some returns (interest income)
Virgin should publish its own annual report which will satisfy information
needs of stakeholders and also increase the credibility of information provided
by Virgin
Page 43 of 46
Virgin should use multi period approach in terms of sale decision because
standard approach which is already exists in Virgin has some inherent
problems
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
It should stop using traditional approach from now It should use NPV
method in credit granting to marginal accounts
In monitoring accounts receivable Virgin should use sales-weighted DSO
method because it has least limitation compared to the others
It should be more flexible in granting credit which will ultimately increase its
sales
To get the appropriate number of quantity to be ordered per order it should
use DSO model
It should be ABC system for proper monitoring of inventory
10 CONCLUSION
The use of other peoples money in business is usually an expensive resource Before
looking outside for finance a firm should examine its own working capital cycle to
make sure that every rand of its own internal funds is being fully utilized Good
management of working capital is part of good financial management Effective use
of working capital will contribute to the operational efficiency of the whole
organization optimum use will help to generate maximum returns Furthermore
working capital management is not an end in itself It is an integral part of the firms
overall management The needs of efficient working capital management must be
considered in relation to other aspects of the Virgins financial and non-financial
performance Thats why when planning the development of a business it is critical
that the impact of working capital be fully assessed
Page 44 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
BIBLIOGRAPHY
Scherr FC (1989) International Edition Prentice-Hall International Inc Modern
Working Capital Management Text and Cases
Hussain Riaz (2002) Working Capital Management
Robertson Lonnie (July 1998) Inventory Management
httpwwwasashoporg visited on March 13 2006
The Art of Cash Management
httpwwwinccom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management
httpwwwstudyfinancecom visited on March 13 2006
White Paper ndash Managing Working Capital
httpwwwplanwareorg visited on March 13 2006
Management of Working Capital
httpwwwbusinesscentralcoza visited on March 13 2006
Cash Management
httpwwwsbagov visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management Objectives
httpwpsprenhallcom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management
Page 45 of 46
httpwwwadvancemecom visited on March 13 2006
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Business Receivables Financing
httpwwwbbtcom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Finance
http wwwfnbcoza visited on March 13 2006
Tips to manage your working capital
httpsmallbusinessninemsncomau visited on March 13 2006
Inventory Financing
httpwwwfranklincapitalnetworkcom visited on March 13 2006
Accounts Receivable Management
httpwwwfranklincapitalnetworkcom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management
httpwwwtreasurygovtnz visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management
httpwwwtreasurystrategiescom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Works
httpwwwinvestopediacom visited on March 13 2006
Treasury Services
httpwwwjpmorganchasecom visited on March 13 2006
what were about
Page 46 of 46
httpwwwvirgincom visited on March 13 2006
Annexure
Annexure
Interview with YASEER RIZVI
Mr Yaseer Rizvi the DMD of Global Beverage Co Ltd obtained his MBA degree
from a reputed university He had been the Director of Ocean Container Ltd before
joining in Global Beverage Co Ltd He possesses a nice personality
I interviewed Yaseer Rizvi Excerpts from his interview are as follows ndash
Shah Kamal Sir would you please tell me do you invest in short term marketable securities
Yaseer Rizvi Basically we do not invest our surplus cash in short term marketable
securities like T-Bill commercial paper certificate of deposit etc But we keep our
surplus cash in Bank
Shah Kamal Would you tell me something about transit time for a typical check
Yaseer Rizvi Well in Virgin the transit time for a typical check is ndash
For mail float 2 to 3 days
At firm float 6 hours
Clearing float 1 to 3 days
Shah Kamal Do you maintain any cash concentration mechanism like depository transfer check automated clearing house and wire transfer
i
Annexure
Yaseer Rizvi Our position in this case is very strong as we use all the mechanisms
you mentioned As Virgin is a firm with small deposits spread over a substantial
number of banks so we tend to use depository transfer checks extensively It is less
costly We also use automated clearing house and wire transfer but later is used in a
less extent
Shah Kamal Sir what techniques of disbursement management is used by your firm
Yaseer Rizvi Like other firms Virgin tries to retain the cash for as long as possible
But we always perform it in an ethical manner We do not use management of
disbursement float as it seems unethical We follow Zero-Balance Accounts method
for managing disbursement We do not prefer Controlled Disbursing method since
Zero-Balance system is already practiced in Virgin
Shah Kamal How do you hedge cash balance uncertainties
Yaseer Rizvi Well you may say that we do not invest in short term securities but for
facing cash difficulties we keep our surplus cash in bank
Shah Kamal Sir would you please tell me the general terms of sale of Virgin
Yaseer Rizvi Though it is difficult to maintain a fixed terms of sale our general terms
of sale is 210 n30 But for prime customers we offer special terms of sale
Shah Kamal What are the sources of credit information in case of your firm
Yaseer Rizvi We grant credit on the basis of prior experience with the customers In
case of a new customer personal contact is weighted
Shah Kamal Does your firm consider 5 Cs in granting credit
ii
Annexure
Yaseer Rizvi In case of Virgin Capital and Character get more importance than the
others Mind one thing personal relationship is the main measure in granting credit
Shah Kamal Do you use NPV method in credit granting decisions
Yaseer Rizvi We do not use NPV method But we think that NPV is a suitable
method and we have to use it from the next period
Shah Kamal Sir how do you handle the problem of bad debt
Yaseer Rizvi Well in this case our position is very strong Yet we do not face any
problem because of bad debt Just note that we make more than 80 of sales in cash
and we monitor accounts receivable very carefully
Shah Kamal What level of inventory is maintained by Virgin
Yaseer Rizvi We maintain a minimum level of inventory but do not have to face
stock out problems because inventory is managed efficiently
Shah Kamal What is the normal lead time
Yaseer Rizvi In case of imported goods normal lead time is about 1 month and when
we purchase raw materials from inside the country lead time is 1 to 3 days
Shah Kamal What method do you use for managing inventory
Yaseer Rizvi We do not use any method particularly rather inventory decision
depends on business cycle and market situation Long before the Eid festival we
bought large amount of sugar because price of sugar was increased on the occasion
of Eid
iii
Annexure
Shah Kamal What are the main items of inventory of your firm
Yaseer Rizvi Well these are ndash aluminum can pet chip sugar label chemical and
artificial sweet
Shah Kamal What are the uncertainties in maintaining appropriate level of stock
Yaseer Rizvi These are ndash
bull Increase in price of raw materials
bull Sales uncertainty
bull Market trends etc
Shah Kamal Thank you for your kind cooperation
Yaseer Rizvi Most Welcome
iv
Global Beverage Company Limited
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
1 INTRODUCTION
Working capital is the life blood of any business big or small However smaller
businesses might find it more trying to maintain a comfortable level of capital
Managing working capital is an important factor for them Working capital
management is important because maintaining a balance of income to debt can be
difficult and owners must be diligent to assure that it is kept Sometimes it takes a
little assistance to maintain levels of fluidity or make major purchases If working
capital dips too low a business risks running out of cash Even very profitable
businesses can run into trouble if they lose the ability to meet their short-term
obligations Working capital financing can be used as a fast cash option to cushion
the periods when the flow is not ideal or readily available Even when owners are
meticulous in managing working capital finding the right levels to remain
comfortable and competitive can be difficult
The analogy has often been made that cash is the lifeblood of any business A
transfusion will miraculously bring the patient back from the brink of death but only
if
The blood is of the right kind
The problem causing the leakage is attended to
In other words the financial requirements of any business must be tailored to suit
that businesss own particular needs For example fixed assets should be financed by
long term loans and capital Working capital requirements should be attended to by
short term finance eg overdrafts
Page 1 of 46
It goes without saying that before capital is injected into the business it should first be
ascertained whether all unnecessary leakages have been plugged Otherwise in time
the transfusion will follow the same route To control and exploit the cash cycle
through any business so that it can continue to function on a day-to-day basis is
therefore the hub of working capital management The fundamental principle of
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
working capital management is having just the right amount of money available
when needed Every rand in the business should be earning its maximum return
wherever employed
2 OBJECTIVES OF THE STUDY
The study has been undertaken with the following objectives
To know the fundamentals of working capital management
To gather practical knowledge about the implementation of working capital
management by Virgin Soft Drinks
To understand the efficiency of Virgin Soft Drinks in managing working
capital
3 METHODOLOGY
In this paper the following methods are used
a) Sources and Data Collection
The major part of this paper is collected from the primary and secondary data
collection method
Conducted formal interview and focus observation and intensive practical
work to collect information
Page 2 of 46
Collected information from companys profiles
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Collected current information from website
b) Segregation of Data
Necessary data were segregated from the source material for the purpose of preparing
the report
c) Processing of Data
Collected data were compiled and processed for the purpose of preparing the report
d) Presentation of Data
Collected data were presented in charts and tables
4 LIMITATIONS OF THE STUDY
On the way of my study I have faced a number of problems which may be turned
as the limitation of report
Many personnel of the organization due to their pressure of the work were
reluctant to provide much useful information
Sufficient records publications facts and figures are not available These
constraints narrowed the scope of real analysis
Due to time constraint I could not spend sufficient time which was
necessary to make this report more representative of the fact
Page 3 of 46
Lack of experience has also acted as constraint for the exploration of the
topic
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
5 WORKING CAPITAL MANAGEMENT
51 DEFINING WORKING CAPITAL
The term working capital refers to the amount of capital which is readily available to
an organization That is working capital is the difference between resources in cash
or readily convertible into cash (Current Assets) and organizational commitments for
which cash will soon be required (Current Liabilities)
Current Assets are resources which are in cash or will soon be converted into cash in
the ordinary course of business
Current Liabilities are commitments which will soon require cash settlement in the
ordinary course of business
Thus ndash
WORKING CAPITAL = CURRENT ASSETS - CURRENT LIABILITIES
In a firms Statement of Financial position these components of working capital are
reported under the following headings
Current Assets
Liquid Assets (cash and bank deposits)
Inventory
Debtors and Receivables
Current Liabilities
Bank Overdraft
Creditors and Payables
Other Short Term Liabilities
Page 4 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Working capital management involves the relationship between a firms short-term
assets and its short-term liabilities The goal of working capital management is to
ensure that a firm is able to continue its operations and that it has sufficient ability to
satisfy both maturing short-term debt and upcoming operational expenses The
management of working capital involves managing inventories accounts receivable
and payable and cash
52 WORKING CAPITAL POLICIES
The aim of working capital policy is to balance having too little working capital
which can lead to an inability to pay debts as they fall due or the need for expensive
short term borrowings and too much which is wasteful in terms of lost opportunities
for the funds tied up The crucial role of working capital is that it finances the goods
inwards production and sales activities
A firmrsquos working capital policy has two components
1 Policies regarding the appropriate level of current assets (Current Asset Investment Policy)
2 Policies regarding the use of short-term financing (Current Asset Financing Policy)
Alternative Current Asset Investment Policies
These policies are general strategies that firms may follow with regard to their overall
level of current assets investment or holdings There are three types
1 Relaxed Current Asset Investment Policy ndash
Relatively large amounts of cash marketable securities and inventories are carried
and sales are stimulated by a liberal (generous) trade credit policy resulting in high
levels of receivables This is a low risk strategy because the firm always has plenty of
cash and inventory on hand The return is low because more money is invested in
low yielding assets
Page 5 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
2 Restricted Current Asset Investment Policy ndash
Holdings of cash securities inventories and receivables are minimized This is a
high risk strategy because the firm tries to keep the bare minimum of cash and
inventory The potential return is high because less money is invested in low
yielding assets
3 Moderate Current Asset Policy ndash
Balance between relaxed and restricted current asset investment policies (moderate
risk - moderate potential return)
Alternative Current Asset Financing Policies
These policies are general strategies that firms may follow with regard to how current
assets are to be financed Current assets can be classified as permanent or temporary
Permanent current assets are the current assets that the company needs to maintain
throughout the entire year Temporary current assets are those that are due to
seasonal fluctuations With respect to the current asset financing policy the question
is how the permanent current assets will and temporary current assets are financed
(long-term or short-term financing)
Page 6 of 46
Aggressive Moderate Conservative
Cash Minimum holding Prepared to hold
some precautionary
balances
Prepared to hold idle
cash balances
Debtors and
stock
Minimum
consistent with
business needs
Moderate levels High stock and
debtor levels to
maximize sales
Creditors Maximum
available without
compromising
business needs
Moderate level Low level seeking
discounts and
reputation for good
payment
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Future cash
flows
Predictable Reasonably
predictable
Unpredictable
Attitude to
Risk
Accepting Neutral Rejecting
Total assets = Fixed Assets + Permanent Current Assets + Fluctuating Current Assets
53 WORKING CAPITAL CYCLE
Cash flows in a cycle into around and out of a business It is the businesss life blood
and every managers primary task is to help keep it flowing and to use the cash flow
to generate profits If a business is operating profitably then it should in theory
generate cash surpluses If it doesnt generate surpluses the business will eventually
run out of cash and expire
The faster a business expands the more cash it will need for working capital and
investment The cheapest and best sources of cash exist as working capital right
within business Good management of working capital will generate cash will help
improve profits and reduce risks
Working capital can be broken down into the following major components cash (or
bank overdraft) stock debtors creditors Each of these items can have a major
influence on the working capital (or simply cash) that any business requires on an
ongoing basis For example when a business starts up the owner may inject a
certain amount of cash into the business which will enable him to purchase his initial
stock pay his workers their first months wages and cover other overheads such as
rent He then sells his product and this income may be utilized to purchase more
stock pay more wages and overheads and perhaps even have a surplus over for his
own use The quicker he can turn his stock over to receive payment the sooner the
working capital cycle will be completed
Page 7 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Figure Working Capital Cycle
These major components of working capital are discussed below
531 CASH MANAGEMENT
The term cash management refers to the management of cash from the time it starts
its transit to the firm until it leaves the firm in payments Cash management
encompasses the design of collection and disbursement systems for cash and the
temporary investment of cash while it resides with the firm Widely used money
market instruments are-
Treasury bill
Commercial paper
Certificate of deposits
Bankerrsquos acceptance
Page 8 of 46
Repurchase agreement
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
5311 Motives for Holding Cash
Despite the seemingly low returns there are several good reasons why firms hold
cash and marketable securities These reasons are ndash
Cash for transactions
Cash and near cash assets as hedges
Temporary investment and
Compensating balances
5312 Components of Cash Management
A Cash Flow Statement shows the sources and uses of cash and is typically divided
into three components
Operating Cash Flow
Operating cash flow often referred to as working capital is the cash flow generated
from internal operations It comes from sales of the product or service of your
business and because it is generated internally it is under your control
Investing Cash Flow
Investing cash flow is generated internally from non-operating activities This
includes investments in plant and equipment or other fixed assets nonrecurring gains
or losses or other sources and uses of cash outside of normal operations
Financing Cash Flow
Financing cash flow is the cash to and from external sources such as lenders
investors and shareholders
Page 9 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
5313 Tools for Cash Management
Flotation and Check Clearing
Management of cash when it is not in the firmrsquos hands that is in transit to and from
the firm is on important function in the area of finance Transit times for the check
takes in three stages These are mail float at firm float and clearing float Normally
mail float takes 1 to 5 days at firm float takes 025 to 1 day and clearing float takes 0
to 2 days The firm should care about this process because every delay in the receipt
of money by the firm lowers the firmrsquos returns and therefore its shareholdersrsquo wealth
There are several strategies that firm can use to reduce the delay in receiving funds
Each of these strategies addresses one or more of the three float times (mail float
time at time float time and clearing float time) that make up the total transit time of
fund from one firm to another
Other Cash Management Tools
When the economy is strong companies can lapse into sloppy cash-management
practices Firm should try exploring these options
1 Sweep accounts
These bank accounts are the easiest way to generate some income from companys
spare funds however they make sense only if the money youll earn will be greater
than the fees your bank will charge Business owners have two types of sweep
accounts to choose between
Page 10 of 46
Controlled-investment accounts These are the most profitable form of
sweep account but they wont work for company if the firm has any
electronic payments or wire transfers since those may be submitted for
payment later in the day and the account wont have enough cash in it to
cover them
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Page 11 of 46
End-of-day sweep accounts A safer bet for most small-business owners
these accounts wait until a late-hour cutoff to determine how much to
sweep into the firms overnight investments Typically their investment
yields are 10 to 20 basis points (1 to 2 of the investment) lower than
those offered with controlled investments
2 Lock-box accounts
A lock box is a cash-management system that helps the firm collect funds quickly
Generally set up with the assistance of a big money center or regional bank lock
boxes provide the firm with a special zip code and usually quicker deliveries from
regional post offices They are especially important if the firm has clusters of
customers in out-of-state locations and dont want to lose days waiting for their
checks to arrive by long-distance mail
5314 Cash Concentration and Cash Disbursement
Once the remittances from the firmrsquos customers have been received and cleared the
resulting cash balances is available in the firmrsquos lockbox (depository) banks It is
useful for the firm to gather these balances from the lockbox banks into the central
bank account The process of collecting funds is called cash concentration
Several concentration mechanism are available for the firm to use in transferring
funds from its collection banks to regional concentration banks and from there to the
central concentration bank These mechanisms differ in cost and in the availability of
funds that they provide These are ndash
a) Depository Transfer Check
It is the cheapest transfer mechanism This document instructs one bank to
send funds to another and is treated the same as any other check
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
b) Automated Clearing House (ACH) Electronic Transfer
This vehicle is essentially an electronic version of the depository transfer
check and can be used between banks that participate in the automated
clearing house system
c) Wire Transfer
These are electronic message between banks
Decisions regarding concentration mechanism usually hinge on the size and
spread of the firmrsquos deposits Firms with small deposits spread over a
substantial number of banks will tend to have more extensive concentration
systems and will transfer among accounts using low-cost transfer vehicles that
offer only delayed availability (such as depository transfer checks) Firms with
larger deposits will have fewer accounts (since a local deposit for transfer to
an upstream bank is not needed) and will use more expensive and more rapid
transfer mechanisms (such as wire transfers) The concentration systems of
major chemical companies for example tend to be structured in this way ndash
DepositoryLockbox Banks
Regional Concentration Banks
Central Concentrated Bank
Figure A typical Cash Concentration System
(Arrows indicate transfers of collected funds)
Page 12 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Disbursement management addresses the efficient payout out of this cash once it is
concentrated The firmrsquos objective in disbursement management is to retain the cash
for as long as possible In this way the firm will have the maximum amount of funds
available for investment and transactional purposes Certainly this management
means making disbursement only when they are due and not before The firm has
several available set of techniques for disbursement management Included among
these are ndash
a) Management of Disbursement Float
In this set of techniques the disbursing firm attempts to increase the length of
time between the mailing of its checks and the eventual withdrawal of funds
from the banks This involves strategies for increasing mail float at firm float
and clearing float on its outgoing checks For example the disbursing firm
may intentionally address checks to the firmrsquos office address rather than its
lockbox creating at firm float
b) Zero-Balance Accounts
Here the firm holds the cash until the check arrive (or expected to arrive) at
the disbursement bank In this strategy an account for disbursement is first
established at a bank For the zero-balance system to be effective the
participating bank must be one on which most disbursement are made via the
Bangladesh Bankrsquos clearance system (which presents disbursements to banks
early in the morning) and not a bank where disbursements occur throughout
the day (as with a major money-center bank) Consequently the banks used
in zero-balance strategies are usually branches of major banks and not their
main locations
Page 13 of 46
c) Controlled Disbursing
In this system the firm projects the amount of checks to arrive each day at the
disbursement bank (based on the checks written in previous days and historic
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
statistics on disbursement float) and transfers the amount of the expected
checks to the account on that day or just before
5315 Cash Forecasting
Defining Cash Forecasting
The cash forecast is an estimation of the flows in and out of the firmrsquos cash account
over a particular period of time usually a quarter month week or day The cash
forecast is primarily intended to produce a very useful piece of information an
estimation of the firmrsquos borrowing and lending needs and uncertainties regarding
these needs during various future periods Cash forecasting is very crucial to most
firms It enables them to anticipate periods of surplus cash and periods where
financing will be necessary This anticipation is the reason that cash forecasts are
generated Anticipation enables the firm to plan much more effectively for
investment and financing and via this planning produce superior return
Types of Cash Forecasts
The types of cash forecasts generated by firms can be differentiated along two
dimensions the length of the periods included within the cash forecast and the approach
to cash flows used in the cash forecast The length of the period refers to the units of
time into which the cash forecast is divided Firms may make cash flow forecasts
over periods of various lengths yearly flows quarterly flows monthly flows weekly
flows or even daily flows The most popular forecast involves monthly flows but
most firms do not confine themselves to a single forecast Instead they use several
forecasts with periods of various lengths When the firm makes forecasts involving
multiple and overlapping period lengths one forecast relates to another Starting
with data on relatively long periods and breaking it down into smaller periods is
called distribution starting with data on relatively short periods and aggregating into
longer periods is called scheduling
Page 14 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Firms use two common approaches to cash flows in generating the cash forecast the
receipts and disbursements approach and the adjusted net income approach The receipts
and disbursements approach use the amounts of cash expected to be received and
disbursed by the firm over the periods chosen for forecast The adjusted income
statement approach is sometimes called the sources and use approach Here the
forecaster starts with projected net income on an accrual basis and adjusts to a cash
basis This method provides a representation of changes in asset and liability
accounts since the level of these accounts are of interest to the firm this aspect of the
adjusted income statement is an advantage over the receipts and disbursements
method
Items to Be Forecast
In the receipt and disbursements cash forecasting method estimates need to be made
of the numerous major and minor items that the firm collects (receipts) and that it
pays (disbursements) The more individual categories of items the firm includes in its
forecast procedure the more accurate the forecast may be but the more costly in
terms of time and effort it will be to generate
Some Possible Types of Cash Receipts and Cash Disbursements
Cash Disbursements Cash Receipts
Cash Purchases of Materials Payroll
Taxes
Maturing Accounts Payable
Maturing Notes Payable
Miscellaneous Disbursements
Accounts Receivable
Notes Receivable
Rental Income
Interest Income
Miscellaneous Receipts
Methods of Financial Forecasting
Page 15 of 46
Financial forecasting is the estimation of the future level of a financial variable often
a cash flow asset level or liability level It is usually assumed that the relationship
between the financial variable and other variable is linear The general linear model
can then be used
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
nnt xaxaxaaY 22110 ++=
Here
= Financial variable (Y) to be forecast in period t tY
x = Explanatory variable it is assumed to cause the level of Y in period t
0a = Represents a constant unaffected by the x
The other terms are the estimated coefficients of the explanatory x variables
There are n terms with xrsquos in them
There are four common approaches to forecasting financial variables but they
are all special cases of the general linear model These are ndash spot method proportion
to another account compounded growth and multiple dependencies
Using Cash Forecast
The estimate of available funds for investment and needed financing enables the firm
to plan so as to obtain the most advantages borrowing terms for deficits and achieve
the greatest interest income on surplus A useful chart for this planning purpose is a
bar chart eg
Figure Bar Chart of Cash Surpluses and Deficits from hypothetical data
Page 16 of 46
75
50
-60
30
100
-20
-80-60-40-20
020406080
100120
Defic
it
S
urpl
us
January February March April May June
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Sources of Uncertainty in Cash Forecasting and Hedging Uncertainties
There are numerous sources of risk in cash forecasting Among the sources are sales
uncertainty collection rate uncertainty production cost uncertainty and capital
outflow uncertainty
5316 Models for the Management of Cash and Temporary Investments
There are different models for the management of cash and temporary investments
Among these the most popular methods are ndash Baumol model Beranek model
Miller-Orr model and Stone model
Baumol and Beranek use the same model The formula is cited below ndash
Interest Income = iYn
n⎥⎦⎤
⎢⎣⎡ minus
21
Profit = naiYn
nminus⎥⎦
⎤⎢⎣⎡ minus
21
Optimum number of transactions = ⎟⎠⎞
⎜⎝⎛
aiY2
Where n = Optimum number of transactions
i = Interest rate per period
a = Transaction cost
Y = Total inflow for the period
Page 17 of 46
Miller-Orr and Stone use the same model ie R-Statistic The model is ndash
31
43
iav
R ⎟⎠⎞
⎜⎝⎛=
Optimum Control Limit = R + L
Upper Control Limit = 3R + L
Where a = Transaction Cost
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
v = Variance of daily cash flows
i = Daily interest rate
5317 Administration
Cash receipts should be processed and banked as quickly as possible because
They cannot earn interest or reduce overdraft until they are banked
information about the existence and amounts of cash receipts is usually not
available until they are processed
Where possible cash floats (mainly petty cash and advances) should be avoided If
on review the only reason that can be put forward for their existence is that weve
always had them they should be discontinued There may be situations where they
are useful however For example it may be desirable for peripheral parts of
departments to meet urgent local needs from cash floats rather than local bank
accounts
5318 Internal Control
Cash and cash management is part of a firms overall internal control system The
main internal cash control is invariably the bank reconciliation This provides
assurance that the cash balances recorded in the accounting systems are consistent
with the actual bank balances It requires regular clearing of reconciling items
5319 Practicing Good Cash Flow Management
Good cash management is simple It involves
Knowing when where and how firms cash needs will occur
Page 18 of 46
Knowing the best sources for meeting additional cash needs
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Page 19 of 46
Being prepared to meet these needs when they occur by keeping good
relationships with bankers and other creditors
532 INVENTORY MANAGEMENT
Inventory management is necessary for owners who want to maintain a stocking
service for quick turnaround to help ensure total customer satisfaction The fill rate
of an item on a managed inventory list must be maintained to avoid shortages of
frequently used items Even when utilizing an inventory management system
occasional shortages will still occur Inventories are lists of stocks-raw materials
work in progress or finished goods-waiting to be consumed in production or to be
sold The total balance of inventory is the sum of the value of each individual stock
line
Basically firms hold stocks for the following reasons
To act as a buffer in times of unusually high demand
To ensure continuity of production
Avoid high costs of emergency orders
To take advantage of quantity discounts by ordering more at a time
To reduce ordering costs by ordering more items on fewer
As part of the production process eg maturing whisky or keeping oil in
pipelines
Seasonality of demand (eg firework) or supplies
Suppliers insist on minimum order quantities
The key issue for a business is to identify the fast and slow stock movers with the
objectives of establishing optimum stock levels for each category and thereby
minimize the cash tied up in stocks Factors to be considered when determining
optimum stock levels include
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Page 20 of 46
What are the projected sales of each product
How widely available are raw materials components etc
How long does it take for delivery by suppliers
Can the firm remove slow movers from its product range without
compromising best sellers
Inventory management is an important aspect of working capital management
because inventories themselves do not earn any revenue Holding either too little or
too much inventory incurs costs
Costs of carrying too much inventory are
Opportunity cost of foregone interest
Warehousing costs
Damage and pilferage
Obsolescence
Insurance
Costs of carrying too little inventory are
Stock out costs
Lost sales
Delayed service
Ordering costs
Freight
on Order administrati
nts
Loss of quantity discou
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Carrying costs can be minimized by making frequent small orders but this increase
ordering costs and the risk of stock outs Risk of stock-outs can be reduced by
carrying safety stocks (at a cost) and re-ordering ahead of time
The best ordering strategy requires balancing the various cost factors to ensure the
firm incurs minimum inventory costs The optimum inventory position is known as
the Economic Reorder Quantity (ERQ)
Nowadays many large manufacturers operate on a just-in-time (JIT) basis whereby
all the components to be assembled on a particular today arrive at the factory early
that morning no earlier - no later This helps to minimize manufacturing costs as JIT
stocks take up little space minimize stock-holding and virtually eliminate the risks of
obsolete or damaged stock Because JIT manufacturers hold stock for a very short
time they are able to conserve substantial cash JIT is a good model to strive for as it
embraces all the principles of prudent stock management For better stock control
firm may try the following
Review the effectiveness of existing purchasing and inventory systems
Know the stock turn for all major items of inventory
Apply tight controls to the significant few items and simplify controls for the
trivial many
Sell off outdated or slow moving merchandise - it gets more difficult to sell the
longer the firm keeps it
Consider having part of its product outsourced to another manufacturer rather
than make it itself
Review its security procedures to ensure that no stock is going out the back
door
Higher than necessary stock levels tie up cash and cost more in insurance
accommodation costs and interest charges
Page 21 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
However it is important to keep an overall perspective It is not cost-effective to
closely manage a large number of low value inventory lines nor is it necessary A
usual feature of inventories is that a small number of high value lines account for a
large proportion of inventory value The 8020 rule (PARETO) predicts that 80
of the total value of inventory is represented by only 20 of the number of inventory
items Those high value lines need reasonably close management The remaining
80 of inventory lines can be managed using broad-brush strategies
533 MANAGING ACCOUNTS RECEIVABLE (DEBTORS)
Cash flow can be significantly enhanced if the amounts owing to a business are
collected faster Every business needs to know who owes them money how much is
owed how long it is owing for what it is owed
Debtors (Accounts Receivable) are customers who have not yet made payment for
goods or services which the department has provided The objective of debtor
management is to minimize the time-lapse between completion of sales and receipt
of payment The costs of having debtors are
Opportunity costs (cash is not available for other purposes)
Bad debts
If firm doesnt manage debtors they will begin to manage business as the firm will gradually
lose control due to reduced cash flow and of course it could experience an increased
incidence of bad debt The following measures will help manage debtors
Having the right mental attitude to the control of credit and make sure that it
gets the priority it deserves
Establishing clear credit practices as a matter of company policy
Page 22 of 46
Making sure that these practices are clearly understood by staff suppliers and
customers
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Page 23 of 46
Being professional when accepting new accounts and especially larger ones
Checking out each customer thoroughly before the firm offers credit Use
credit agencies bank references industry sources etc
Establishing credit limits for each customer and sticking to them
Continuously reviewing these limits when it suspects tough times are coming
or if operating in a volatile sector
Keeping very close to the firms larger customers
Invoicing promptly and clearly
Considering charging penalties on overdue accounts
Considering accepting credit debit cards as a payment option
Monitoring its debtor balances and ageing schedules and dont let any debts
get too large or too old
Debtor management includes both pre-sale and debt collection strategies
Pre-sale strategies include
Offering cash discounts for early payment andor imposing penalties for late
payment
Agreeing payment terms in advance
Requiring cash before delivery
Setting credit limits
ning credit Setting criteria for obtai
Billing as early as possible
rogress payments
ost-sale strategies include
for collecting the debt upon the center that made the sale
Requiring deposits andor p
P
Placing the responsibility
Identifying long overdue balances and doubtful debts by regular analytical reviews
Having an established procedure for late collections such as
A reminder
A letter
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Page 24 of 46
ion of further credit Cancellat
Telephone calls
n agency Use of a collectio
he firm should recognize that the longer someone owes firm the greater the chance
Legal action
T
it will never get paid If the average age of debtors is getting longer or is already very
long it may need to look for the following possible defects
Weak credit judgment
res Poor collection procedu
ms Lax enforcement of credit ter
Slow issue of invoices or statements
Errors in invoices or statements
Customer dissatisfaction
Debtors due over 90 days (unless within agreed credit terms) should generally
demand immediate attention For example warning signs of a future bad debt ndash
Longer credit terms taken with approval particularly for smaller orders
Use of post-dated checks by debtors who normally settle within agreed terms
Evidence of customers switching to additional suppliers for the same goods
New customers who are reluctant to give credit references
Cre G
Receiving part payments from debtors
dit ranting to Marginal Accounts
Traditional Approach
In the traditional approach to the credit granting decision it is the credit analysts job
rmation that has been collected and reach a judgment
regarding the applicants creditworthiness One traditional way of organizing this
to synthesize all the info
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
information is by characterizing the applicant along five dimensions These
dimensions are called the Five Cs of credit ndash
Capital
Character
Collateral
and Capacity
Conditions
Net Present Value (NPV) Approach
Once a firm has assessed the creditworthiness of a customer it has to decide whether
r not credit should be granted The firm should use the NPV rule to make the
ld be granted
Figure
o
decision If NPV is positive credit shou
Credit Granting Decision
Credit Granting Decision
he act of collecting money is one which most people dislike for many reasons and
therefore put on the long f selves there is something
ore urgent or important that demands their attention now There is nothing more
T
inger because they convince them
m
important than getting paid for firms product or service A customer who does not
Page 25 of 46
Grand Credit
Payment received Payment not received
Benefit of present value of future net cash flow
Cost of present value ment of lost invest
Net Payoff PV of benefit-cost
No Credit
No Payoff
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
pay is not a customer Here are a few ideas that may help the firm in collecting
money from debtors
Firm should develop appropriate procedures for handling late payments
It should track and pursue late payers
It might get external help if its own efforts fail
or money its firms and it is entitled Company shouldnt feel guilty asking f
to it
ction
Firm must make that call now And it should keep asking until it gets some
satisfa
lessens the problem
In difficult circumstances take what the firm can now and agree terms for the
remainder It
paying
When asking for money be hard on the issue - but soft on the person It shouldnt
give the debtor any excuses for not
534 BLE (CREDITORS)
ices for goods or services have
een paid Organizations often regard the
not
to delay all payments until the latest possible date Regular weekly or
The firm make it its objective is to get the money - not to score points or get
even
MANAGING ACCOUNTS PAYA
Creditors (Accounts Payable) are suppliers whose invo
been processed but who have not yet b
amount owing to creditors as a source of free credit However creditor
administration systems are expensive and time-consuming to run The over-riding
concern in this area should be to minimize costs with simple procedures
While it is unnecessary to pay accounts before they fall due it is usually
worthwhile
Page 26 of 46
fortnightly payment of all due accounts is the simplest technique for creditor
management
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Electronic payments (direct credits) are cheaper than check payments considering
that transaction fees and overheads more than balance the advantage of delayed
presentation Some suppliers are reluctant to receive payments by this method but in
view of the substantial cost advantage (and the advantages to the suppliers
themselves) departments may wish to encourage suppliers to accept this option
However electronic payments are likely to be used in conjunction with rather than
as a replacement for check payments
Applying Best Practices in Managing Accounts Payable
f course simply deferring payments to suppliers could have adverse consequences
O
that more than offset the benefits of this additional cash flow Therefore it is
important to develop a holistic approach The firm should consider the following
best practices for payables management
Managing payment dates and terms to maximize cash flow ndash
y reporting on
receivable and
id penalty charges and taking advantage of
wer vendors and negotiate for more
to buying consortia with others even
voices for
payment based on receipt of goods or receipt of invoice whichever
comes later
Calculating and setting performance targets Regularl
AP performance measures such as days in payables
Coordinating the AP processes with accounts
inventory management to ensure that the company is collecting more
cash than it is paying out
Paying bills on time to avo
prompt-payment discounts where the discounts exceed the companyrsquos
cost of working capital
Consolidating purchases with fe
favorable payment terms
Considering entering in
Page 27 of 46
competitors to obtain favorable supplier pricing and terms
Unless contract terms specify otherwise setting up in
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Page 28 of 46
Em
process
-time payments with Electronic Funds Transfer (EFT)
uraging vendors to utilize electronic invoice presentment
a
ndancies and more
ploying technology to automate the accounts payable transaction
es ndash
Making just-in
Using an electronic invoice-matching application
Enco
For companies with multiple locations or business units employing
shared service approach for AP to eliminate redu
quickly implement process improvements
Mainta
vendor
Communicating accounts payable requirements to suppliers at the
m key suppliers
for suggestions on how to improve the
Efficient a
and making th rsquos cash is just good business
ining open communications and building strong relationships with
s to access valuable trade credit ndash
beginning of transactions
Requesting summary invoicing fro
Requiring suppliers to send invoices directly to accounts payable
Asking tier-one suppliers
payment process
nd effective management of accounts payable helps improve cash flow ndash
e most of company
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
6 OVERVIEW OF VIRGIN GROUP
Virgin - one of the most respected brands in Britain - is now becoming the first global
brand name of the 21st century Virgin is involved in planes trains finance soft
drinks music mobile phones holidays cars wines publishing bridal wear - the lot
What tie all these businesses together are the values of its brand and the attitude of its
people Virgin has created over 200 companies worldwide employing over 25000
people Its total revenues around the world in 2002 exceeded pound4 billion (US $72
billion)
In 1970 Richard Branson founded Virgin as a mail order record retailer and not
long after he opened a record shop in Oxford Street London During 1972 a
recording studio was built in Oxfordshire and the first Virgin artist Mike Oldfield
recorded Tubular Bells which was released in 1973
This album went on to sell over 5 million copies Since then many household names
including Belinda Carlisle Genesis Phil Collins Janet Jackson and The Rolling
Stones have helped to make Virgin Music one of the top six record companies in the
world The equity of Virgin Music Group - record labels music publishing and
recording studios was sold to THORN EMI in 1992 in a US$1billion deal
Page 29 of 46
The Virgin Group has now expanded into international music Mega stores air
travel mobile financial retail music internet drinks rail hotels and leisure with
around 200 companies in over 30 countries
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
In Virgins customers eyes Virgin stands for value for money quality innovation
fun and a sense of competitive challenge It delivers a quality service by empowering
its employees and facilitates and monitors customer feedback to continually improve
the customers experience through innovation
When they start a new venture Virgin bases it on hard research and analysis
Typically they review the industry and put themselves in the customers shoes to see
what could make it better Virgin asks fundamental questions
Is this an opportunity for restructuring a market and creating competitive
advantage What are the competitors doing
Is the customer confused or badly served
Is this an opportunity for building the Virgin brand
Can we add value
Will it interact with its other businesses
Is there an appropriate trade-off between risk and reward
Page 30 of 46
Virgin is also able to draw on talented people from throughout the group New
ventures are often steered by people seconded from other parts of Virgin who bring
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
with them the trademark management style skills and experience Virgin frequently
creates partnerships with others to combine skills knowledge and market presence
and so on Contrary to what some people may think their constantly expanding and
eclectic empire is neither random nor reckless Each successive venture demonstrates
its skill in picking the right market and the right opportunity
7 OVERVIEW OF VIRGIN SOFT DRINKS
The Virgin Drinks Group first launched as the Virgin Cola Company in 1994 with
Virgin Cola in the UK Since then the company has ventured across the carbonated
soft drinks arena and beyond into energy drinks tea and flavored Colas This
expansion has lead to the evolution of the Virgin Drinks Company a company
whose aim is to put the excitement back into the world of soft drinks It launched in
Bangladesh in 1999 Virgin Soft Drinks is monitored by Global Beverage Co Ltd in
Bangladesh
Brief history of Virgin Drinks is given below
Page 31 of 46
1994 November Virgin Cola launched in the UK
1996 March Virgin Cola launched in France
1998 June Virgin Cola launched in Belgium
April Virgin Cola launched in the French West Indies
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
August Virgin Cola launched in Switzerland
1999 March Virgin Colours launched in Italy
March Virgin Cola launched in Japan
July Virgin Colours launched in South Africa
December Virgin Colours launched in Bangladesh
2001 January Sweden launched Virgin Colours
November Singapore launched Virgin Colours
2002 February Croatia launched Virgin Colours
June Russia launched Virgin Colours
June Tunisia launched Virgin Colours
2003 May Israel launched Virgin Colours
8 FINDINGS OF WORKING CAPITAL MANAGEMENT MAINTAINED BY
VIRGIN SOFT DRINKS IN BANGLADESH
81 CASH MANAGEMENT
811 Holding Cash and Marketable Securities
Although there are many good reasons why firm hold cash and marketable
securities Virgin Drinks holds cash and marketable securities for two reasons ndash
i) Cash for transactions
ii) Cash as hedges
This indicates that the firm does not hold cash and marketable securities for some
important reasons such as ndash
i) Near cash assets as hedges
Page 32 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
ii) Temporary investment and compensating balances
Virgin Soft Drinks does not invest in money market securities such as Treasury bill
commercial paper certificate of deposits bankerrsquos acceptance and repurchase
agreement This firm deposits its money in bank as currant AC or fixed AC They
say that they do not have enough money to invest in money market instrument
They also say that if they have enough money they will invest it in money market
short term securities We know that near cash interest earning assets can be
substituted for cash when motivation for holding these assets is the hedging of cash
flow uncertainties or is the temporary investment of surplus funds In this point
Virgins position is not good as there is no significant hedging against uncertainty of
cash
812 Floatation and Check Clearing
Virgin is very smart in handling the problem of transit time for checks Here mail
float takes 2 to 3 days at firm takes 025 day and clearing float takes 1-3 days Virgin
uses most of the strategies available for reducing the delay in receiving funds It
(Virgin) has linked Islami Bank which posses an accelerated clearing facility It uses
electronic collection process which ensures faster collection and its at the firm check
processing is satisfactory But Virgin does not use lockbox The reason behind this is
that it is not cost-effective for Virgin to set lockboxes At this point we can say that
Virgins check clearing mechanism is much good
813 Cash Concentration and Disbursement Management
Page 33 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks takes the matter of cash concentration very seriously They use all
the available cash concentration mechanism Virgin is a firm with small deposits
spread over a substantial number of banks and this is why the firm tends to use
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
depository transfer checks extensively If is less costly Virgin also uses automated
clearing house and wire transfer To Virgin wire transfer seems too costly
Like other firm Virgin tries to retain the cash for as long as possible But Virgin
always performs it in an ethical manner Virgin does not try to defeat the receiving
firmrsquos attempts to reduce the float on incoming checks It does not take any strategy
for increasing mail float at firm float and clearing float on its outgoing checks To
Virgin it is deemed to be unethical It thinks that maximization of disbursement float
will not go unnoticed by sophisticated creditors for very long When it is noticed it
will negatively affect relations with these creditors reducing the firmrsquos bargaining
power with them This may ultimately cost Virgin dearly when future prices and
delivery schedules for goods and services purchased from trade creditors are
negotiated Virgin follows ldquoZero-Balance Accountsrdquo methods for managing
disbursement It thinks that in this method the coordination of funds inflows to
disbursement banks with the presentation of checks does not work to the detriment
of creditors since the firmrsquos checks to them are honored as presented and this strategy
does not affect float significantly Controlled disbursing method is less attractive to
Virgin because zero-balance system is already feasible
814 Cash Forecasting
Cash Forecasting and Its Types
Page 34 of 46
Virgin forecasts the future cash inflows and outflows To Virgin cash forecast is an
important part of the firmrsquos cash control system and is one of the forecasts that are
part of the Virginrsquos financial plan Virgin forecasts cash on monthly basis and on
yearly basis Virgin does not forecast on daily basis assuming that the temporary
shortage of funds within these periods can be covered without value cost eg
advance receipts from customers Virginrsquos cash forecasting system involves a
combination of distribution and scheduling The receipts and disbursements
approach of cash forecasting is used in virgin This method is used because it
minutely traces the movement of cash and very close control of cash is possible
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Virgin does not use adjusted net income approach on two grounds First it does not
permit the tracing of the individual types of cash inflows and outflows for any given
period which is often useful information for virgin Second it is not simple to use
Items to be Forecast
Virgin does not forecast all the items It forecasts only major items eg accounts
receivable notes receivable payroll cash purchases of raw materials In this regard
virgin trade off between cost and benefit
Methods of Financial Forecasting
Virgin forecasts the future level of financial variable such as cash level asset level or
liability level We know in short term forecasts many things will result from plans
and events that are already in place (contracts capital budgets long-range financing
plans and so forth) But in the long run most things can vary and are dependent on
outside influences such as the firmrsquos long-term growth rate Since Virginrsquos cash
forecasting deals mostly with near future many of the items on the cash forecasts are
estimated by some variation of the spot method and remaining estimates are mostly
on a ldquoproportion of another accountrdquo basis with this ldquoother accountrdquo often being a
particular periodrsquos sales Virgin uses the other two methods less frequently
Using Cash Forecast
Virgin forecasts cash for meeting general objectives (ie to know the available funds
for investment and need financing) and for meeting some special objectives (eg to
know whether the firm will fulfill its out of debt requirement) But it is matter to note
that Virgin does not make any short term investment of its surplus cash but only keep
this surplus in Bank Account
Page 35 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Sources of Uncertainty in Cash Forecasting and Hedging Uncertainties
Virgin faces uncertainty in cash forecasting mainly from two sources These are ndash
sales and production cost In peak season (hot season like autumn summer) sales
increases but in dull season (eg in winter) sales decreases drastically Production
cost may be increased because of increase of price of sugar chemicals aluminum
can Virgin follows two methods for hedging cash balance uncertainties These are ndash
i) Holding a stock of extra cash and
ii) Extra borrowing capacity
815 Modes for the Management of Cash and Temporary Investments
Virgin does not follow any of these methods wholly Virgin receives cash
continuously and pays salary at steady rate and pays continuously for other
expenses So it neither follows Baumol model nor Beranek model It has no upper
control limit lower control limit return point in case cash management So it neither
follows Miller-Orr model nor Stone model
In Summary
Page 36 of 46
Standard Compliance by Virgin Soft Drinks
Generally all firms hold cash and
marketable securities
Virgin holds only cash
Firms hold cash and marketable
securities for some reasons like
bull Cash for transactions
bull Cash and near-cash assets as
hedges
bull Temporary investments
bull Compensating balances
Virgin holds cash only for
two reasons ndash
bull Cash for transactions
bull Cash as hedges
Available money market instruments Virgin does not invest in any such
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
(short term securities) are ndash
Treasury Bills
Commercial Paper
Certificates of Deposit
Bankerrsquos Acceptance
Repurch menase Agree ts
instruments They only keep cash in
Bank Account
Mail Float
(1 to 5 days)
At Firm
Float
(025 to 1
day)
Clearing
Float
(0 to
2 days)
Mail Float
(2 to 3 days)
At firm
Float
(025
day)
Clearing
Float
(1 to 3
days)
Figure Transit time for a typical check Figure Transit time for a check for
Virgin
Strategies that firms can use to reduce
the delay in receiving funds are ndash
Selecting of Banks with
accelerated clearing capabilities
of check processing Acceleration
at the firm
ectronic collection Use of el
procedures
Use of lockboxes
Virgin follows the first three strategies
but does not use lockboxes
Available cash concentration
mechanisms are ndash
Depository transfer check
ouse Automated Clearing H
(ACH) electronic transfer)
Wire transfer
Virgin uses all these mechanisms of
cash concentration
Available sets of techniques for cash
disbursement management are ndash
ement of disbursement
Page 37 of 46
Manag
float
Virgin uses zero-balance accounts
technique
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Zero-Balance Accounts
Controlled disbursing
Firms may make cash flow forecasts
over periods of various lengths yearly
flows quarterly flows monthly flows
weekly flows or even daily flows
Virgin forecasts cash on yearly basis and
monthly basis
Cash forecasting system may involve ndash
Distribution
Scheduling
Virginrsquos cash forecasting system
involves a combination of distribution
and scheduling
Two common approaches to cash flow
in generating the cash forecast
and disbursement Receipts
approach
Adjusted net income approach
Virgin uses the receipts and
disbursement approach
There are many items to forecast Virgin forecasts only major items like
AR payroll etc
Four common approach to forecasting
fina i ndash nc al variables are
Spot method
Proportion to another account
Compounded growth
Multiple dependencies
Virgin uses spot method for forecasting
cash It uses proportion to another
account method for other variables and
remaining two methods are frequently
used
Sources of uncertainty in cash
forecasting are ndash
Sales uncertainty
Collection rate uncertainty
Production cost uncertainty
Capital outflow uncertainty
Virgin faces uncertainty mainly from
sales and production cost
Methods for hedging cash balance
unc a
Page 38 of 46
ert inties are ndash
i) Holding a stock of extra cash
Virgin two available methods for
hedging cash balance uncertainties
Th ese are ndash
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
ii) stock of near-cash Holding a
assets
iii) Extra borrowing capacity
iv) ary surpluses in Investing tempor
near-cash assets
i) Holding a stock of extra cash
ii) Extra borrowing capacity
(advance receipt from
customers)
Models for the management of cash and
temporary investments are ndash Baumol
model Beranek model Miller-Orr
model and Stone model
Virgin does not follow any method
wholly but a combination of Baumol
model and Beranek model is occurred
82 INVENTORY MANAGEMENT
21 Certainty Approach
isnt used in
irgin because it thinks it is not possible to implement in Bangladesh
d time is one to three days It
oes not use ABC system of inventory management
8
Main item of inventory of Virgin is Can pet chip sugar label chemical artificial
sweet etc Virgin maintains a minimum level of inventory but it does not have to face
problems because inventory is managed efficiently just-in-time (JIT)
V
Virgin maintains buffer stock because of the shortage of work-in-process (WIP)
inventory Its production process may also be hampered Thats why it maintains
safety stock to avoid stock out cost In case of imported goods normal lead time is
about one month and within the country normal lea
d
Page 39 of 46
Inventory Model
In reality Virgin does not use any of models of EOQ ordering and holding strategy
and safety stock strategy They maintain inventory based on their prior experience
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
822 Uncertainty Approach
Virgin does not use any model for handling inventory uncertainty It says that such
decision depends on business cycle and market situation Long before Eid festival
they bought large amount of sugar because of price increase on the occasion of Eid
In summary
Standard Compliance by Virgin Soft Drinks
Firms maintain inventory to guard
against several problems
Virgin maintains a minimum level of
inventory which is managed efficiently
Some firms use JIT to avoid inventory
cost
JIT is not used by Virgin as it thinks it is
impossible to implement in Bangladesh
Firms maintain buffer stock Virgin maintains buffer stock too
Firms maintain safety stock to avoid
shortage cost
Virgin also maintains safety stock
Firms use ABC system to monitor
inventory
Virgin doesnt use ABC system
EOQ model is an appropriate method
for measuring quantity that has to be
ordered per order
Virgin does not use EOQ model rather
makes order based on experience and
market demand
83 MANAGING ACCOUNTS RECEIVABLE (DEBTORS)
831 Terms of Sale Decision
Page 40 of 46
Virgin offers the term 210 net 30 enables the customers to deduct 2 percent from the
face value of the bill when paying within the first 10 days but if the discount is not
taken the customer must remit the full amount within 30 days But Virgin does not
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
offer the same terms of sale to all customers For prime customers it offers special
terms of sale In setting an appropriate term of sale it costs and benefits regarding
this are compared It uses the standard approach of terms of sale decision as it is
simple to use
832 Credit Granting Decisions
In case of Virgin the Capital and Character of Five Cs get more importance
Although there are many problems with the traditional approach Virgin uses it
because of its simplicity Virgin does not use Net Present Value (NPV) method in
credit granting decision It thinks that NPV is an appropriate method and should be
used next time It does not face any severe problem because of bad debts The reason
is that notes receivable is used when credit is granted
833 Monitoring Accounts Receivable
Virgin monitors its accounts receivable Virgin believes that in any case both positive
and negative durations in accounts signal differences from the results that
management believe to be the most advantageous for the firm
Tools for Monitoring Accounts Receivable
Page 41 of 46
For monitoring accounts receivable there are several tools such as aging schedule
the ratios of receivable outstanding to original sales customers payment proportion
and sales weighted DSO (Days Sales Outstanding) For monitoring accounts
receivable Virgin uses aging schedule fractions and traditional DSO statistics
because of their simplicity in use Although payment proportions ratios of
receivables outstanding and sales weighted DSO methods are free from inherent bias
None of these is used because all these are complex to maintain
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
In summary
Page 42 of 46
Standard Compliance by Virgin Soft Drinks
Generals terms of sale is 210 net 30 Normally Virgin also use general terms
of sale ie 210 net 30
Firms do not offer the same terms of
sale to all customers
Yes For prime customers Virgin offers
special terms of sale
Approaches of terms of sale decisions
are ndash
bull Standard approach
bull Multi period approach
Virgin uses standard approach of terms
of sale decision as it is simple to use and
understand
Source of credit information are ndash
Sellers prior experience with the
customer
Credit agency ratings and
reports
Personal contact with the
applicants bank and other
creditors
Analysis of applicants financial
statements
Customer visit
Main source of credit information to
Virgin is its prior experience with the
customer All other sources are not cost-
effective for Virgin
Approaches of credit granting to
marginal accounts are ndash
Traditional approach
Net Present Value (NPV)
approach
It uses traditional approach still now but
thinks that NPV should be used for the
next periods
Firms monitor accounts receivable
because deviations from the expected
levels of turnover and of bad debt can
Virgin also monitors its accounts
receivable
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
signal several different problems
Different tools for monitoring accounts
receivable are ndash
Aging schedule
Ratios of receivables
outstanding to original sales
Customers payment
proportions
Sales-weighted DSO
For monitoring accounts receivable
Virgin uses aging schedule and
traditional sales outstanding statistics
84 MANAGING ACCOUNTS PAYABLE (CREDITORS)
Virgin has almost accounts payable of Tk 8000000 But most of its liabilities are to
the banks rather than suppliers But we dont have any clear information about
Virgins accounts payable
9 RECOMMENDATION
Virgin should invest its surplus cash in short term marketable securities
because it is suitable hedging against cash uncertainties and will also give
some returns (interest income)
Virgin should publish its own annual report which will satisfy information
needs of stakeholders and also increase the credibility of information provided
by Virgin
Page 43 of 46
Virgin should use multi period approach in terms of sale decision because
standard approach which is already exists in Virgin has some inherent
problems
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
It should stop using traditional approach from now It should use NPV
method in credit granting to marginal accounts
In monitoring accounts receivable Virgin should use sales-weighted DSO
method because it has least limitation compared to the others
It should be more flexible in granting credit which will ultimately increase its
sales
To get the appropriate number of quantity to be ordered per order it should
use DSO model
It should be ABC system for proper monitoring of inventory
10 CONCLUSION
The use of other peoples money in business is usually an expensive resource Before
looking outside for finance a firm should examine its own working capital cycle to
make sure that every rand of its own internal funds is being fully utilized Good
management of working capital is part of good financial management Effective use
of working capital will contribute to the operational efficiency of the whole
organization optimum use will help to generate maximum returns Furthermore
working capital management is not an end in itself It is an integral part of the firms
overall management The needs of efficient working capital management must be
considered in relation to other aspects of the Virgins financial and non-financial
performance Thats why when planning the development of a business it is critical
that the impact of working capital be fully assessed
Page 44 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
BIBLIOGRAPHY
Scherr FC (1989) International Edition Prentice-Hall International Inc Modern
Working Capital Management Text and Cases
Hussain Riaz (2002) Working Capital Management
Robertson Lonnie (July 1998) Inventory Management
httpwwwasashoporg visited on March 13 2006
The Art of Cash Management
httpwwwinccom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management
httpwwwstudyfinancecom visited on March 13 2006
White Paper ndash Managing Working Capital
httpwwwplanwareorg visited on March 13 2006
Management of Working Capital
httpwwwbusinesscentralcoza visited on March 13 2006
Cash Management
httpwwwsbagov visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management Objectives
httpwpsprenhallcom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management
Page 45 of 46
httpwwwadvancemecom visited on March 13 2006
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Business Receivables Financing
httpwwwbbtcom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Finance
http wwwfnbcoza visited on March 13 2006
Tips to manage your working capital
httpsmallbusinessninemsncomau visited on March 13 2006
Inventory Financing
httpwwwfranklincapitalnetworkcom visited on March 13 2006
Accounts Receivable Management
httpwwwfranklincapitalnetworkcom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management
httpwwwtreasurygovtnz visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management
httpwwwtreasurystrategiescom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Works
httpwwwinvestopediacom visited on March 13 2006
Treasury Services
httpwwwjpmorganchasecom visited on March 13 2006
what were about
Page 46 of 46
httpwwwvirgincom visited on March 13 2006
Annexure
Annexure
Interview with YASEER RIZVI
Mr Yaseer Rizvi the DMD of Global Beverage Co Ltd obtained his MBA degree
from a reputed university He had been the Director of Ocean Container Ltd before
joining in Global Beverage Co Ltd He possesses a nice personality
I interviewed Yaseer Rizvi Excerpts from his interview are as follows ndash
Shah Kamal Sir would you please tell me do you invest in short term marketable securities
Yaseer Rizvi Basically we do not invest our surplus cash in short term marketable
securities like T-Bill commercial paper certificate of deposit etc But we keep our
surplus cash in Bank
Shah Kamal Would you tell me something about transit time for a typical check
Yaseer Rizvi Well in Virgin the transit time for a typical check is ndash
For mail float 2 to 3 days
At firm float 6 hours
Clearing float 1 to 3 days
Shah Kamal Do you maintain any cash concentration mechanism like depository transfer check automated clearing house and wire transfer
i
Annexure
Yaseer Rizvi Our position in this case is very strong as we use all the mechanisms
you mentioned As Virgin is a firm with small deposits spread over a substantial
number of banks so we tend to use depository transfer checks extensively It is less
costly We also use automated clearing house and wire transfer but later is used in a
less extent
Shah Kamal Sir what techniques of disbursement management is used by your firm
Yaseer Rizvi Like other firms Virgin tries to retain the cash for as long as possible
But we always perform it in an ethical manner We do not use management of
disbursement float as it seems unethical We follow Zero-Balance Accounts method
for managing disbursement We do not prefer Controlled Disbursing method since
Zero-Balance system is already practiced in Virgin
Shah Kamal How do you hedge cash balance uncertainties
Yaseer Rizvi Well you may say that we do not invest in short term securities but for
facing cash difficulties we keep our surplus cash in bank
Shah Kamal Sir would you please tell me the general terms of sale of Virgin
Yaseer Rizvi Though it is difficult to maintain a fixed terms of sale our general terms
of sale is 210 n30 But for prime customers we offer special terms of sale
Shah Kamal What are the sources of credit information in case of your firm
Yaseer Rizvi We grant credit on the basis of prior experience with the customers In
case of a new customer personal contact is weighted
Shah Kamal Does your firm consider 5 Cs in granting credit
ii
Annexure
Yaseer Rizvi In case of Virgin Capital and Character get more importance than the
others Mind one thing personal relationship is the main measure in granting credit
Shah Kamal Do you use NPV method in credit granting decisions
Yaseer Rizvi We do not use NPV method But we think that NPV is a suitable
method and we have to use it from the next period
Shah Kamal Sir how do you handle the problem of bad debt
Yaseer Rizvi Well in this case our position is very strong Yet we do not face any
problem because of bad debt Just note that we make more than 80 of sales in cash
and we monitor accounts receivable very carefully
Shah Kamal What level of inventory is maintained by Virgin
Yaseer Rizvi We maintain a minimum level of inventory but do not have to face
stock out problems because inventory is managed efficiently
Shah Kamal What is the normal lead time
Yaseer Rizvi In case of imported goods normal lead time is about 1 month and when
we purchase raw materials from inside the country lead time is 1 to 3 days
Shah Kamal What method do you use for managing inventory
Yaseer Rizvi We do not use any method particularly rather inventory decision
depends on business cycle and market situation Long before the Eid festival we
bought large amount of sugar because price of sugar was increased on the occasion
of Eid
iii
Annexure
Shah Kamal What are the main items of inventory of your firm
Yaseer Rizvi Well these are ndash aluminum can pet chip sugar label chemical and
artificial sweet
Shah Kamal What are the uncertainties in maintaining appropriate level of stock
Yaseer Rizvi These are ndash
bull Increase in price of raw materials
bull Sales uncertainty
bull Market trends etc
Shah Kamal Thank you for your kind cooperation
Yaseer Rizvi Most Welcome
iv
Global Beverage Company Limited
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
working capital management is having just the right amount of money available
when needed Every rand in the business should be earning its maximum return
wherever employed
2 OBJECTIVES OF THE STUDY
The study has been undertaken with the following objectives
To know the fundamentals of working capital management
To gather practical knowledge about the implementation of working capital
management by Virgin Soft Drinks
To understand the efficiency of Virgin Soft Drinks in managing working
capital
3 METHODOLOGY
In this paper the following methods are used
a) Sources and Data Collection
The major part of this paper is collected from the primary and secondary data
collection method
Conducted formal interview and focus observation and intensive practical
work to collect information
Page 2 of 46
Collected information from companys profiles
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Collected current information from website
b) Segregation of Data
Necessary data were segregated from the source material for the purpose of preparing
the report
c) Processing of Data
Collected data were compiled and processed for the purpose of preparing the report
d) Presentation of Data
Collected data were presented in charts and tables
4 LIMITATIONS OF THE STUDY
On the way of my study I have faced a number of problems which may be turned
as the limitation of report
Many personnel of the organization due to their pressure of the work were
reluctant to provide much useful information
Sufficient records publications facts and figures are not available These
constraints narrowed the scope of real analysis
Due to time constraint I could not spend sufficient time which was
necessary to make this report more representative of the fact
Page 3 of 46
Lack of experience has also acted as constraint for the exploration of the
topic
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
5 WORKING CAPITAL MANAGEMENT
51 DEFINING WORKING CAPITAL
The term working capital refers to the amount of capital which is readily available to
an organization That is working capital is the difference between resources in cash
or readily convertible into cash (Current Assets) and organizational commitments for
which cash will soon be required (Current Liabilities)
Current Assets are resources which are in cash or will soon be converted into cash in
the ordinary course of business
Current Liabilities are commitments which will soon require cash settlement in the
ordinary course of business
Thus ndash
WORKING CAPITAL = CURRENT ASSETS - CURRENT LIABILITIES
In a firms Statement of Financial position these components of working capital are
reported under the following headings
Current Assets
Liquid Assets (cash and bank deposits)
Inventory
Debtors and Receivables
Current Liabilities
Bank Overdraft
Creditors and Payables
Other Short Term Liabilities
Page 4 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Working capital management involves the relationship between a firms short-term
assets and its short-term liabilities The goal of working capital management is to
ensure that a firm is able to continue its operations and that it has sufficient ability to
satisfy both maturing short-term debt and upcoming operational expenses The
management of working capital involves managing inventories accounts receivable
and payable and cash
52 WORKING CAPITAL POLICIES
The aim of working capital policy is to balance having too little working capital
which can lead to an inability to pay debts as they fall due or the need for expensive
short term borrowings and too much which is wasteful in terms of lost opportunities
for the funds tied up The crucial role of working capital is that it finances the goods
inwards production and sales activities
A firmrsquos working capital policy has two components
1 Policies regarding the appropriate level of current assets (Current Asset Investment Policy)
2 Policies regarding the use of short-term financing (Current Asset Financing Policy)
Alternative Current Asset Investment Policies
These policies are general strategies that firms may follow with regard to their overall
level of current assets investment or holdings There are three types
1 Relaxed Current Asset Investment Policy ndash
Relatively large amounts of cash marketable securities and inventories are carried
and sales are stimulated by a liberal (generous) trade credit policy resulting in high
levels of receivables This is a low risk strategy because the firm always has plenty of
cash and inventory on hand The return is low because more money is invested in
low yielding assets
Page 5 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
2 Restricted Current Asset Investment Policy ndash
Holdings of cash securities inventories and receivables are minimized This is a
high risk strategy because the firm tries to keep the bare minimum of cash and
inventory The potential return is high because less money is invested in low
yielding assets
3 Moderate Current Asset Policy ndash
Balance between relaxed and restricted current asset investment policies (moderate
risk - moderate potential return)
Alternative Current Asset Financing Policies
These policies are general strategies that firms may follow with regard to how current
assets are to be financed Current assets can be classified as permanent or temporary
Permanent current assets are the current assets that the company needs to maintain
throughout the entire year Temporary current assets are those that are due to
seasonal fluctuations With respect to the current asset financing policy the question
is how the permanent current assets will and temporary current assets are financed
(long-term or short-term financing)
Page 6 of 46
Aggressive Moderate Conservative
Cash Minimum holding Prepared to hold
some precautionary
balances
Prepared to hold idle
cash balances
Debtors and
stock
Minimum
consistent with
business needs
Moderate levels High stock and
debtor levels to
maximize sales
Creditors Maximum
available without
compromising
business needs
Moderate level Low level seeking
discounts and
reputation for good
payment
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Future cash
flows
Predictable Reasonably
predictable
Unpredictable
Attitude to
Risk
Accepting Neutral Rejecting
Total assets = Fixed Assets + Permanent Current Assets + Fluctuating Current Assets
53 WORKING CAPITAL CYCLE
Cash flows in a cycle into around and out of a business It is the businesss life blood
and every managers primary task is to help keep it flowing and to use the cash flow
to generate profits If a business is operating profitably then it should in theory
generate cash surpluses If it doesnt generate surpluses the business will eventually
run out of cash and expire
The faster a business expands the more cash it will need for working capital and
investment The cheapest and best sources of cash exist as working capital right
within business Good management of working capital will generate cash will help
improve profits and reduce risks
Working capital can be broken down into the following major components cash (or
bank overdraft) stock debtors creditors Each of these items can have a major
influence on the working capital (or simply cash) that any business requires on an
ongoing basis For example when a business starts up the owner may inject a
certain amount of cash into the business which will enable him to purchase his initial
stock pay his workers their first months wages and cover other overheads such as
rent He then sells his product and this income may be utilized to purchase more
stock pay more wages and overheads and perhaps even have a surplus over for his
own use The quicker he can turn his stock over to receive payment the sooner the
working capital cycle will be completed
Page 7 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Figure Working Capital Cycle
These major components of working capital are discussed below
531 CASH MANAGEMENT
The term cash management refers to the management of cash from the time it starts
its transit to the firm until it leaves the firm in payments Cash management
encompasses the design of collection and disbursement systems for cash and the
temporary investment of cash while it resides with the firm Widely used money
market instruments are-
Treasury bill
Commercial paper
Certificate of deposits
Bankerrsquos acceptance
Page 8 of 46
Repurchase agreement
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
5311 Motives for Holding Cash
Despite the seemingly low returns there are several good reasons why firms hold
cash and marketable securities These reasons are ndash
Cash for transactions
Cash and near cash assets as hedges
Temporary investment and
Compensating balances
5312 Components of Cash Management
A Cash Flow Statement shows the sources and uses of cash and is typically divided
into three components
Operating Cash Flow
Operating cash flow often referred to as working capital is the cash flow generated
from internal operations It comes from sales of the product or service of your
business and because it is generated internally it is under your control
Investing Cash Flow
Investing cash flow is generated internally from non-operating activities This
includes investments in plant and equipment or other fixed assets nonrecurring gains
or losses or other sources and uses of cash outside of normal operations
Financing Cash Flow
Financing cash flow is the cash to and from external sources such as lenders
investors and shareholders
Page 9 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
5313 Tools for Cash Management
Flotation and Check Clearing
Management of cash when it is not in the firmrsquos hands that is in transit to and from
the firm is on important function in the area of finance Transit times for the check
takes in three stages These are mail float at firm float and clearing float Normally
mail float takes 1 to 5 days at firm float takes 025 to 1 day and clearing float takes 0
to 2 days The firm should care about this process because every delay in the receipt
of money by the firm lowers the firmrsquos returns and therefore its shareholdersrsquo wealth
There are several strategies that firm can use to reduce the delay in receiving funds
Each of these strategies addresses one or more of the three float times (mail float
time at time float time and clearing float time) that make up the total transit time of
fund from one firm to another
Other Cash Management Tools
When the economy is strong companies can lapse into sloppy cash-management
practices Firm should try exploring these options
1 Sweep accounts
These bank accounts are the easiest way to generate some income from companys
spare funds however they make sense only if the money youll earn will be greater
than the fees your bank will charge Business owners have two types of sweep
accounts to choose between
Page 10 of 46
Controlled-investment accounts These are the most profitable form of
sweep account but they wont work for company if the firm has any
electronic payments or wire transfers since those may be submitted for
payment later in the day and the account wont have enough cash in it to
cover them
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Page 11 of 46
End-of-day sweep accounts A safer bet for most small-business owners
these accounts wait until a late-hour cutoff to determine how much to
sweep into the firms overnight investments Typically their investment
yields are 10 to 20 basis points (1 to 2 of the investment) lower than
those offered with controlled investments
2 Lock-box accounts
A lock box is a cash-management system that helps the firm collect funds quickly
Generally set up with the assistance of a big money center or regional bank lock
boxes provide the firm with a special zip code and usually quicker deliveries from
regional post offices They are especially important if the firm has clusters of
customers in out-of-state locations and dont want to lose days waiting for their
checks to arrive by long-distance mail
5314 Cash Concentration and Cash Disbursement
Once the remittances from the firmrsquos customers have been received and cleared the
resulting cash balances is available in the firmrsquos lockbox (depository) banks It is
useful for the firm to gather these balances from the lockbox banks into the central
bank account The process of collecting funds is called cash concentration
Several concentration mechanism are available for the firm to use in transferring
funds from its collection banks to regional concentration banks and from there to the
central concentration bank These mechanisms differ in cost and in the availability of
funds that they provide These are ndash
a) Depository Transfer Check
It is the cheapest transfer mechanism This document instructs one bank to
send funds to another and is treated the same as any other check
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
b) Automated Clearing House (ACH) Electronic Transfer
This vehicle is essentially an electronic version of the depository transfer
check and can be used between banks that participate in the automated
clearing house system
c) Wire Transfer
These are electronic message between banks
Decisions regarding concentration mechanism usually hinge on the size and
spread of the firmrsquos deposits Firms with small deposits spread over a
substantial number of banks will tend to have more extensive concentration
systems and will transfer among accounts using low-cost transfer vehicles that
offer only delayed availability (such as depository transfer checks) Firms with
larger deposits will have fewer accounts (since a local deposit for transfer to
an upstream bank is not needed) and will use more expensive and more rapid
transfer mechanisms (such as wire transfers) The concentration systems of
major chemical companies for example tend to be structured in this way ndash
DepositoryLockbox Banks
Regional Concentration Banks
Central Concentrated Bank
Figure A typical Cash Concentration System
(Arrows indicate transfers of collected funds)
Page 12 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Disbursement management addresses the efficient payout out of this cash once it is
concentrated The firmrsquos objective in disbursement management is to retain the cash
for as long as possible In this way the firm will have the maximum amount of funds
available for investment and transactional purposes Certainly this management
means making disbursement only when they are due and not before The firm has
several available set of techniques for disbursement management Included among
these are ndash
a) Management of Disbursement Float
In this set of techniques the disbursing firm attempts to increase the length of
time between the mailing of its checks and the eventual withdrawal of funds
from the banks This involves strategies for increasing mail float at firm float
and clearing float on its outgoing checks For example the disbursing firm
may intentionally address checks to the firmrsquos office address rather than its
lockbox creating at firm float
b) Zero-Balance Accounts
Here the firm holds the cash until the check arrive (or expected to arrive) at
the disbursement bank In this strategy an account for disbursement is first
established at a bank For the zero-balance system to be effective the
participating bank must be one on which most disbursement are made via the
Bangladesh Bankrsquos clearance system (which presents disbursements to banks
early in the morning) and not a bank where disbursements occur throughout
the day (as with a major money-center bank) Consequently the banks used
in zero-balance strategies are usually branches of major banks and not their
main locations
Page 13 of 46
c) Controlled Disbursing
In this system the firm projects the amount of checks to arrive each day at the
disbursement bank (based on the checks written in previous days and historic
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
statistics on disbursement float) and transfers the amount of the expected
checks to the account on that day or just before
5315 Cash Forecasting
Defining Cash Forecasting
The cash forecast is an estimation of the flows in and out of the firmrsquos cash account
over a particular period of time usually a quarter month week or day The cash
forecast is primarily intended to produce a very useful piece of information an
estimation of the firmrsquos borrowing and lending needs and uncertainties regarding
these needs during various future periods Cash forecasting is very crucial to most
firms It enables them to anticipate periods of surplus cash and periods where
financing will be necessary This anticipation is the reason that cash forecasts are
generated Anticipation enables the firm to plan much more effectively for
investment and financing and via this planning produce superior return
Types of Cash Forecasts
The types of cash forecasts generated by firms can be differentiated along two
dimensions the length of the periods included within the cash forecast and the approach
to cash flows used in the cash forecast The length of the period refers to the units of
time into which the cash forecast is divided Firms may make cash flow forecasts
over periods of various lengths yearly flows quarterly flows monthly flows weekly
flows or even daily flows The most popular forecast involves monthly flows but
most firms do not confine themselves to a single forecast Instead they use several
forecasts with periods of various lengths When the firm makes forecasts involving
multiple and overlapping period lengths one forecast relates to another Starting
with data on relatively long periods and breaking it down into smaller periods is
called distribution starting with data on relatively short periods and aggregating into
longer periods is called scheduling
Page 14 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Firms use two common approaches to cash flows in generating the cash forecast the
receipts and disbursements approach and the adjusted net income approach The receipts
and disbursements approach use the amounts of cash expected to be received and
disbursed by the firm over the periods chosen for forecast The adjusted income
statement approach is sometimes called the sources and use approach Here the
forecaster starts with projected net income on an accrual basis and adjusts to a cash
basis This method provides a representation of changes in asset and liability
accounts since the level of these accounts are of interest to the firm this aspect of the
adjusted income statement is an advantage over the receipts and disbursements
method
Items to Be Forecast
In the receipt and disbursements cash forecasting method estimates need to be made
of the numerous major and minor items that the firm collects (receipts) and that it
pays (disbursements) The more individual categories of items the firm includes in its
forecast procedure the more accurate the forecast may be but the more costly in
terms of time and effort it will be to generate
Some Possible Types of Cash Receipts and Cash Disbursements
Cash Disbursements Cash Receipts
Cash Purchases of Materials Payroll
Taxes
Maturing Accounts Payable
Maturing Notes Payable
Miscellaneous Disbursements
Accounts Receivable
Notes Receivable
Rental Income
Interest Income
Miscellaneous Receipts
Methods of Financial Forecasting
Page 15 of 46
Financial forecasting is the estimation of the future level of a financial variable often
a cash flow asset level or liability level It is usually assumed that the relationship
between the financial variable and other variable is linear The general linear model
can then be used
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
nnt xaxaxaaY 22110 ++=
Here
= Financial variable (Y) to be forecast in period t tY
x = Explanatory variable it is assumed to cause the level of Y in period t
0a = Represents a constant unaffected by the x
The other terms are the estimated coefficients of the explanatory x variables
There are n terms with xrsquos in them
There are four common approaches to forecasting financial variables but they
are all special cases of the general linear model These are ndash spot method proportion
to another account compounded growth and multiple dependencies
Using Cash Forecast
The estimate of available funds for investment and needed financing enables the firm
to plan so as to obtain the most advantages borrowing terms for deficits and achieve
the greatest interest income on surplus A useful chart for this planning purpose is a
bar chart eg
Figure Bar Chart of Cash Surpluses and Deficits from hypothetical data
Page 16 of 46
75
50
-60
30
100
-20
-80-60-40-20
020406080
100120
Defic
it
S
urpl
us
January February March April May June
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Sources of Uncertainty in Cash Forecasting and Hedging Uncertainties
There are numerous sources of risk in cash forecasting Among the sources are sales
uncertainty collection rate uncertainty production cost uncertainty and capital
outflow uncertainty
5316 Models for the Management of Cash and Temporary Investments
There are different models for the management of cash and temporary investments
Among these the most popular methods are ndash Baumol model Beranek model
Miller-Orr model and Stone model
Baumol and Beranek use the same model The formula is cited below ndash
Interest Income = iYn
n⎥⎦⎤
⎢⎣⎡ minus
21
Profit = naiYn
nminus⎥⎦
⎤⎢⎣⎡ minus
21
Optimum number of transactions = ⎟⎠⎞
⎜⎝⎛
aiY2
Where n = Optimum number of transactions
i = Interest rate per period
a = Transaction cost
Y = Total inflow for the period
Page 17 of 46
Miller-Orr and Stone use the same model ie R-Statistic The model is ndash
31
43
iav
R ⎟⎠⎞
⎜⎝⎛=
Optimum Control Limit = R + L
Upper Control Limit = 3R + L
Where a = Transaction Cost
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
v = Variance of daily cash flows
i = Daily interest rate
5317 Administration
Cash receipts should be processed and banked as quickly as possible because
They cannot earn interest or reduce overdraft until they are banked
information about the existence and amounts of cash receipts is usually not
available until they are processed
Where possible cash floats (mainly petty cash and advances) should be avoided If
on review the only reason that can be put forward for their existence is that weve
always had them they should be discontinued There may be situations where they
are useful however For example it may be desirable for peripheral parts of
departments to meet urgent local needs from cash floats rather than local bank
accounts
5318 Internal Control
Cash and cash management is part of a firms overall internal control system The
main internal cash control is invariably the bank reconciliation This provides
assurance that the cash balances recorded in the accounting systems are consistent
with the actual bank balances It requires regular clearing of reconciling items
5319 Practicing Good Cash Flow Management
Good cash management is simple It involves
Knowing when where and how firms cash needs will occur
Page 18 of 46
Knowing the best sources for meeting additional cash needs
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Page 19 of 46
Being prepared to meet these needs when they occur by keeping good
relationships with bankers and other creditors
532 INVENTORY MANAGEMENT
Inventory management is necessary for owners who want to maintain a stocking
service for quick turnaround to help ensure total customer satisfaction The fill rate
of an item on a managed inventory list must be maintained to avoid shortages of
frequently used items Even when utilizing an inventory management system
occasional shortages will still occur Inventories are lists of stocks-raw materials
work in progress or finished goods-waiting to be consumed in production or to be
sold The total balance of inventory is the sum of the value of each individual stock
line
Basically firms hold stocks for the following reasons
To act as a buffer in times of unusually high demand
To ensure continuity of production
Avoid high costs of emergency orders
To take advantage of quantity discounts by ordering more at a time
To reduce ordering costs by ordering more items on fewer
As part of the production process eg maturing whisky or keeping oil in
pipelines
Seasonality of demand (eg firework) or supplies
Suppliers insist on minimum order quantities
The key issue for a business is to identify the fast and slow stock movers with the
objectives of establishing optimum stock levels for each category and thereby
minimize the cash tied up in stocks Factors to be considered when determining
optimum stock levels include
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Page 20 of 46
What are the projected sales of each product
How widely available are raw materials components etc
How long does it take for delivery by suppliers
Can the firm remove slow movers from its product range without
compromising best sellers
Inventory management is an important aspect of working capital management
because inventories themselves do not earn any revenue Holding either too little or
too much inventory incurs costs
Costs of carrying too much inventory are
Opportunity cost of foregone interest
Warehousing costs
Damage and pilferage
Obsolescence
Insurance
Costs of carrying too little inventory are
Stock out costs
Lost sales
Delayed service
Ordering costs
Freight
on Order administrati
nts
Loss of quantity discou
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Carrying costs can be minimized by making frequent small orders but this increase
ordering costs and the risk of stock outs Risk of stock-outs can be reduced by
carrying safety stocks (at a cost) and re-ordering ahead of time
The best ordering strategy requires balancing the various cost factors to ensure the
firm incurs minimum inventory costs The optimum inventory position is known as
the Economic Reorder Quantity (ERQ)
Nowadays many large manufacturers operate on a just-in-time (JIT) basis whereby
all the components to be assembled on a particular today arrive at the factory early
that morning no earlier - no later This helps to minimize manufacturing costs as JIT
stocks take up little space minimize stock-holding and virtually eliminate the risks of
obsolete or damaged stock Because JIT manufacturers hold stock for a very short
time they are able to conserve substantial cash JIT is a good model to strive for as it
embraces all the principles of prudent stock management For better stock control
firm may try the following
Review the effectiveness of existing purchasing and inventory systems
Know the stock turn for all major items of inventory
Apply tight controls to the significant few items and simplify controls for the
trivial many
Sell off outdated or slow moving merchandise - it gets more difficult to sell the
longer the firm keeps it
Consider having part of its product outsourced to another manufacturer rather
than make it itself
Review its security procedures to ensure that no stock is going out the back
door
Higher than necessary stock levels tie up cash and cost more in insurance
accommodation costs and interest charges
Page 21 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
However it is important to keep an overall perspective It is not cost-effective to
closely manage a large number of low value inventory lines nor is it necessary A
usual feature of inventories is that a small number of high value lines account for a
large proportion of inventory value The 8020 rule (PARETO) predicts that 80
of the total value of inventory is represented by only 20 of the number of inventory
items Those high value lines need reasonably close management The remaining
80 of inventory lines can be managed using broad-brush strategies
533 MANAGING ACCOUNTS RECEIVABLE (DEBTORS)
Cash flow can be significantly enhanced if the amounts owing to a business are
collected faster Every business needs to know who owes them money how much is
owed how long it is owing for what it is owed
Debtors (Accounts Receivable) are customers who have not yet made payment for
goods or services which the department has provided The objective of debtor
management is to minimize the time-lapse between completion of sales and receipt
of payment The costs of having debtors are
Opportunity costs (cash is not available for other purposes)
Bad debts
If firm doesnt manage debtors they will begin to manage business as the firm will gradually
lose control due to reduced cash flow and of course it could experience an increased
incidence of bad debt The following measures will help manage debtors
Having the right mental attitude to the control of credit and make sure that it
gets the priority it deserves
Establishing clear credit practices as a matter of company policy
Page 22 of 46
Making sure that these practices are clearly understood by staff suppliers and
customers
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Page 23 of 46
Being professional when accepting new accounts and especially larger ones
Checking out each customer thoroughly before the firm offers credit Use
credit agencies bank references industry sources etc
Establishing credit limits for each customer and sticking to them
Continuously reviewing these limits when it suspects tough times are coming
or if operating in a volatile sector
Keeping very close to the firms larger customers
Invoicing promptly and clearly
Considering charging penalties on overdue accounts
Considering accepting credit debit cards as a payment option
Monitoring its debtor balances and ageing schedules and dont let any debts
get too large or too old
Debtor management includes both pre-sale and debt collection strategies
Pre-sale strategies include
Offering cash discounts for early payment andor imposing penalties for late
payment
Agreeing payment terms in advance
Requiring cash before delivery
Setting credit limits
ning credit Setting criteria for obtai
Billing as early as possible
rogress payments
ost-sale strategies include
for collecting the debt upon the center that made the sale
Requiring deposits andor p
P
Placing the responsibility
Identifying long overdue balances and doubtful debts by regular analytical reviews
Having an established procedure for late collections such as
A reminder
A letter
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Page 24 of 46
ion of further credit Cancellat
Telephone calls
n agency Use of a collectio
he firm should recognize that the longer someone owes firm the greater the chance
Legal action
T
it will never get paid If the average age of debtors is getting longer or is already very
long it may need to look for the following possible defects
Weak credit judgment
res Poor collection procedu
ms Lax enforcement of credit ter
Slow issue of invoices or statements
Errors in invoices or statements
Customer dissatisfaction
Debtors due over 90 days (unless within agreed credit terms) should generally
demand immediate attention For example warning signs of a future bad debt ndash
Longer credit terms taken with approval particularly for smaller orders
Use of post-dated checks by debtors who normally settle within agreed terms
Evidence of customers switching to additional suppliers for the same goods
New customers who are reluctant to give credit references
Cre G
Receiving part payments from debtors
dit ranting to Marginal Accounts
Traditional Approach
In the traditional approach to the credit granting decision it is the credit analysts job
rmation that has been collected and reach a judgment
regarding the applicants creditworthiness One traditional way of organizing this
to synthesize all the info
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
information is by characterizing the applicant along five dimensions These
dimensions are called the Five Cs of credit ndash
Capital
Character
Collateral
and Capacity
Conditions
Net Present Value (NPV) Approach
Once a firm has assessed the creditworthiness of a customer it has to decide whether
r not credit should be granted The firm should use the NPV rule to make the
ld be granted
Figure
o
decision If NPV is positive credit shou
Credit Granting Decision
Credit Granting Decision
he act of collecting money is one which most people dislike for many reasons and
therefore put on the long f selves there is something
ore urgent or important that demands their attention now There is nothing more
T
inger because they convince them
m
important than getting paid for firms product or service A customer who does not
Page 25 of 46
Grand Credit
Payment received Payment not received
Benefit of present value of future net cash flow
Cost of present value ment of lost invest
Net Payoff PV of benefit-cost
No Credit
No Payoff
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
pay is not a customer Here are a few ideas that may help the firm in collecting
money from debtors
Firm should develop appropriate procedures for handling late payments
It should track and pursue late payers
It might get external help if its own efforts fail
or money its firms and it is entitled Company shouldnt feel guilty asking f
to it
ction
Firm must make that call now And it should keep asking until it gets some
satisfa
lessens the problem
In difficult circumstances take what the firm can now and agree terms for the
remainder It
paying
When asking for money be hard on the issue - but soft on the person It shouldnt
give the debtor any excuses for not
534 BLE (CREDITORS)
ices for goods or services have
een paid Organizations often regard the
not
to delay all payments until the latest possible date Regular weekly or
The firm make it its objective is to get the money - not to score points or get
even
MANAGING ACCOUNTS PAYA
Creditors (Accounts Payable) are suppliers whose invo
been processed but who have not yet b
amount owing to creditors as a source of free credit However creditor
administration systems are expensive and time-consuming to run The over-riding
concern in this area should be to minimize costs with simple procedures
While it is unnecessary to pay accounts before they fall due it is usually
worthwhile
Page 26 of 46
fortnightly payment of all due accounts is the simplest technique for creditor
management
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Electronic payments (direct credits) are cheaper than check payments considering
that transaction fees and overheads more than balance the advantage of delayed
presentation Some suppliers are reluctant to receive payments by this method but in
view of the substantial cost advantage (and the advantages to the suppliers
themselves) departments may wish to encourage suppliers to accept this option
However electronic payments are likely to be used in conjunction with rather than
as a replacement for check payments
Applying Best Practices in Managing Accounts Payable
f course simply deferring payments to suppliers could have adverse consequences
O
that more than offset the benefits of this additional cash flow Therefore it is
important to develop a holistic approach The firm should consider the following
best practices for payables management
Managing payment dates and terms to maximize cash flow ndash
y reporting on
receivable and
id penalty charges and taking advantage of
wer vendors and negotiate for more
to buying consortia with others even
voices for
payment based on receipt of goods or receipt of invoice whichever
comes later
Calculating and setting performance targets Regularl
AP performance measures such as days in payables
Coordinating the AP processes with accounts
inventory management to ensure that the company is collecting more
cash than it is paying out
Paying bills on time to avo
prompt-payment discounts where the discounts exceed the companyrsquos
cost of working capital
Consolidating purchases with fe
favorable payment terms
Considering entering in
Page 27 of 46
competitors to obtain favorable supplier pricing and terms
Unless contract terms specify otherwise setting up in
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Page 28 of 46
Em
process
-time payments with Electronic Funds Transfer (EFT)
uraging vendors to utilize electronic invoice presentment
a
ndancies and more
ploying technology to automate the accounts payable transaction
es ndash
Making just-in
Using an electronic invoice-matching application
Enco
For companies with multiple locations or business units employing
shared service approach for AP to eliminate redu
quickly implement process improvements
Mainta
vendor
Communicating accounts payable requirements to suppliers at the
m key suppliers
for suggestions on how to improve the
Efficient a
and making th rsquos cash is just good business
ining open communications and building strong relationships with
s to access valuable trade credit ndash
beginning of transactions
Requesting summary invoicing fro
Requiring suppliers to send invoices directly to accounts payable
Asking tier-one suppliers
payment process
nd effective management of accounts payable helps improve cash flow ndash
e most of company
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
6 OVERVIEW OF VIRGIN GROUP
Virgin - one of the most respected brands in Britain - is now becoming the first global
brand name of the 21st century Virgin is involved in planes trains finance soft
drinks music mobile phones holidays cars wines publishing bridal wear - the lot
What tie all these businesses together are the values of its brand and the attitude of its
people Virgin has created over 200 companies worldwide employing over 25000
people Its total revenues around the world in 2002 exceeded pound4 billion (US $72
billion)
In 1970 Richard Branson founded Virgin as a mail order record retailer and not
long after he opened a record shop in Oxford Street London During 1972 a
recording studio was built in Oxfordshire and the first Virgin artist Mike Oldfield
recorded Tubular Bells which was released in 1973
This album went on to sell over 5 million copies Since then many household names
including Belinda Carlisle Genesis Phil Collins Janet Jackson and The Rolling
Stones have helped to make Virgin Music one of the top six record companies in the
world The equity of Virgin Music Group - record labels music publishing and
recording studios was sold to THORN EMI in 1992 in a US$1billion deal
Page 29 of 46
The Virgin Group has now expanded into international music Mega stores air
travel mobile financial retail music internet drinks rail hotels and leisure with
around 200 companies in over 30 countries
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
In Virgins customers eyes Virgin stands for value for money quality innovation
fun and a sense of competitive challenge It delivers a quality service by empowering
its employees and facilitates and monitors customer feedback to continually improve
the customers experience through innovation
When they start a new venture Virgin bases it on hard research and analysis
Typically they review the industry and put themselves in the customers shoes to see
what could make it better Virgin asks fundamental questions
Is this an opportunity for restructuring a market and creating competitive
advantage What are the competitors doing
Is the customer confused or badly served
Is this an opportunity for building the Virgin brand
Can we add value
Will it interact with its other businesses
Is there an appropriate trade-off between risk and reward
Page 30 of 46
Virgin is also able to draw on talented people from throughout the group New
ventures are often steered by people seconded from other parts of Virgin who bring
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
with them the trademark management style skills and experience Virgin frequently
creates partnerships with others to combine skills knowledge and market presence
and so on Contrary to what some people may think their constantly expanding and
eclectic empire is neither random nor reckless Each successive venture demonstrates
its skill in picking the right market and the right opportunity
7 OVERVIEW OF VIRGIN SOFT DRINKS
The Virgin Drinks Group first launched as the Virgin Cola Company in 1994 with
Virgin Cola in the UK Since then the company has ventured across the carbonated
soft drinks arena and beyond into energy drinks tea and flavored Colas This
expansion has lead to the evolution of the Virgin Drinks Company a company
whose aim is to put the excitement back into the world of soft drinks It launched in
Bangladesh in 1999 Virgin Soft Drinks is monitored by Global Beverage Co Ltd in
Bangladesh
Brief history of Virgin Drinks is given below
Page 31 of 46
1994 November Virgin Cola launched in the UK
1996 March Virgin Cola launched in France
1998 June Virgin Cola launched in Belgium
April Virgin Cola launched in the French West Indies
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
August Virgin Cola launched in Switzerland
1999 March Virgin Colours launched in Italy
March Virgin Cola launched in Japan
July Virgin Colours launched in South Africa
December Virgin Colours launched in Bangladesh
2001 January Sweden launched Virgin Colours
November Singapore launched Virgin Colours
2002 February Croatia launched Virgin Colours
June Russia launched Virgin Colours
June Tunisia launched Virgin Colours
2003 May Israel launched Virgin Colours
8 FINDINGS OF WORKING CAPITAL MANAGEMENT MAINTAINED BY
VIRGIN SOFT DRINKS IN BANGLADESH
81 CASH MANAGEMENT
811 Holding Cash and Marketable Securities
Although there are many good reasons why firm hold cash and marketable
securities Virgin Drinks holds cash and marketable securities for two reasons ndash
i) Cash for transactions
ii) Cash as hedges
This indicates that the firm does not hold cash and marketable securities for some
important reasons such as ndash
i) Near cash assets as hedges
Page 32 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
ii) Temporary investment and compensating balances
Virgin Soft Drinks does not invest in money market securities such as Treasury bill
commercial paper certificate of deposits bankerrsquos acceptance and repurchase
agreement This firm deposits its money in bank as currant AC or fixed AC They
say that they do not have enough money to invest in money market instrument
They also say that if they have enough money they will invest it in money market
short term securities We know that near cash interest earning assets can be
substituted for cash when motivation for holding these assets is the hedging of cash
flow uncertainties or is the temporary investment of surplus funds In this point
Virgins position is not good as there is no significant hedging against uncertainty of
cash
812 Floatation and Check Clearing
Virgin is very smart in handling the problem of transit time for checks Here mail
float takes 2 to 3 days at firm takes 025 day and clearing float takes 1-3 days Virgin
uses most of the strategies available for reducing the delay in receiving funds It
(Virgin) has linked Islami Bank which posses an accelerated clearing facility It uses
electronic collection process which ensures faster collection and its at the firm check
processing is satisfactory But Virgin does not use lockbox The reason behind this is
that it is not cost-effective for Virgin to set lockboxes At this point we can say that
Virgins check clearing mechanism is much good
813 Cash Concentration and Disbursement Management
Page 33 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks takes the matter of cash concentration very seriously They use all
the available cash concentration mechanism Virgin is a firm with small deposits
spread over a substantial number of banks and this is why the firm tends to use
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
depository transfer checks extensively If is less costly Virgin also uses automated
clearing house and wire transfer To Virgin wire transfer seems too costly
Like other firm Virgin tries to retain the cash for as long as possible But Virgin
always performs it in an ethical manner Virgin does not try to defeat the receiving
firmrsquos attempts to reduce the float on incoming checks It does not take any strategy
for increasing mail float at firm float and clearing float on its outgoing checks To
Virgin it is deemed to be unethical It thinks that maximization of disbursement float
will not go unnoticed by sophisticated creditors for very long When it is noticed it
will negatively affect relations with these creditors reducing the firmrsquos bargaining
power with them This may ultimately cost Virgin dearly when future prices and
delivery schedules for goods and services purchased from trade creditors are
negotiated Virgin follows ldquoZero-Balance Accountsrdquo methods for managing
disbursement It thinks that in this method the coordination of funds inflows to
disbursement banks with the presentation of checks does not work to the detriment
of creditors since the firmrsquos checks to them are honored as presented and this strategy
does not affect float significantly Controlled disbursing method is less attractive to
Virgin because zero-balance system is already feasible
814 Cash Forecasting
Cash Forecasting and Its Types
Page 34 of 46
Virgin forecasts the future cash inflows and outflows To Virgin cash forecast is an
important part of the firmrsquos cash control system and is one of the forecasts that are
part of the Virginrsquos financial plan Virgin forecasts cash on monthly basis and on
yearly basis Virgin does not forecast on daily basis assuming that the temporary
shortage of funds within these periods can be covered without value cost eg
advance receipts from customers Virginrsquos cash forecasting system involves a
combination of distribution and scheduling The receipts and disbursements
approach of cash forecasting is used in virgin This method is used because it
minutely traces the movement of cash and very close control of cash is possible
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Virgin does not use adjusted net income approach on two grounds First it does not
permit the tracing of the individual types of cash inflows and outflows for any given
period which is often useful information for virgin Second it is not simple to use
Items to be Forecast
Virgin does not forecast all the items It forecasts only major items eg accounts
receivable notes receivable payroll cash purchases of raw materials In this regard
virgin trade off between cost and benefit
Methods of Financial Forecasting
Virgin forecasts the future level of financial variable such as cash level asset level or
liability level We know in short term forecasts many things will result from plans
and events that are already in place (contracts capital budgets long-range financing
plans and so forth) But in the long run most things can vary and are dependent on
outside influences such as the firmrsquos long-term growth rate Since Virginrsquos cash
forecasting deals mostly with near future many of the items on the cash forecasts are
estimated by some variation of the spot method and remaining estimates are mostly
on a ldquoproportion of another accountrdquo basis with this ldquoother accountrdquo often being a
particular periodrsquos sales Virgin uses the other two methods less frequently
Using Cash Forecast
Virgin forecasts cash for meeting general objectives (ie to know the available funds
for investment and need financing) and for meeting some special objectives (eg to
know whether the firm will fulfill its out of debt requirement) But it is matter to note
that Virgin does not make any short term investment of its surplus cash but only keep
this surplus in Bank Account
Page 35 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Sources of Uncertainty in Cash Forecasting and Hedging Uncertainties
Virgin faces uncertainty in cash forecasting mainly from two sources These are ndash
sales and production cost In peak season (hot season like autumn summer) sales
increases but in dull season (eg in winter) sales decreases drastically Production
cost may be increased because of increase of price of sugar chemicals aluminum
can Virgin follows two methods for hedging cash balance uncertainties These are ndash
i) Holding a stock of extra cash and
ii) Extra borrowing capacity
815 Modes for the Management of Cash and Temporary Investments
Virgin does not follow any of these methods wholly Virgin receives cash
continuously and pays salary at steady rate and pays continuously for other
expenses So it neither follows Baumol model nor Beranek model It has no upper
control limit lower control limit return point in case cash management So it neither
follows Miller-Orr model nor Stone model
In Summary
Page 36 of 46
Standard Compliance by Virgin Soft Drinks
Generally all firms hold cash and
marketable securities
Virgin holds only cash
Firms hold cash and marketable
securities for some reasons like
bull Cash for transactions
bull Cash and near-cash assets as
hedges
bull Temporary investments
bull Compensating balances
Virgin holds cash only for
two reasons ndash
bull Cash for transactions
bull Cash as hedges
Available money market instruments Virgin does not invest in any such
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
(short term securities) are ndash
Treasury Bills
Commercial Paper
Certificates of Deposit
Bankerrsquos Acceptance
Repurch menase Agree ts
instruments They only keep cash in
Bank Account
Mail Float
(1 to 5 days)
At Firm
Float
(025 to 1
day)
Clearing
Float
(0 to
2 days)
Mail Float
(2 to 3 days)
At firm
Float
(025
day)
Clearing
Float
(1 to 3
days)
Figure Transit time for a typical check Figure Transit time for a check for
Virgin
Strategies that firms can use to reduce
the delay in receiving funds are ndash
Selecting of Banks with
accelerated clearing capabilities
of check processing Acceleration
at the firm
ectronic collection Use of el
procedures
Use of lockboxes
Virgin follows the first three strategies
but does not use lockboxes
Available cash concentration
mechanisms are ndash
Depository transfer check
ouse Automated Clearing H
(ACH) electronic transfer)
Wire transfer
Virgin uses all these mechanisms of
cash concentration
Available sets of techniques for cash
disbursement management are ndash
ement of disbursement
Page 37 of 46
Manag
float
Virgin uses zero-balance accounts
technique
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Zero-Balance Accounts
Controlled disbursing
Firms may make cash flow forecasts
over periods of various lengths yearly
flows quarterly flows monthly flows
weekly flows or even daily flows
Virgin forecasts cash on yearly basis and
monthly basis
Cash forecasting system may involve ndash
Distribution
Scheduling
Virginrsquos cash forecasting system
involves a combination of distribution
and scheduling
Two common approaches to cash flow
in generating the cash forecast
and disbursement Receipts
approach
Adjusted net income approach
Virgin uses the receipts and
disbursement approach
There are many items to forecast Virgin forecasts only major items like
AR payroll etc
Four common approach to forecasting
fina i ndash nc al variables are
Spot method
Proportion to another account
Compounded growth
Multiple dependencies
Virgin uses spot method for forecasting
cash It uses proportion to another
account method for other variables and
remaining two methods are frequently
used
Sources of uncertainty in cash
forecasting are ndash
Sales uncertainty
Collection rate uncertainty
Production cost uncertainty
Capital outflow uncertainty
Virgin faces uncertainty mainly from
sales and production cost
Methods for hedging cash balance
unc a
Page 38 of 46
ert inties are ndash
i) Holding a stock of extra cash
Virgin two available methods for
hedging cash balance uncertainties
Th ese are ndash
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
ii) stock of near-cash Holding a
assets
iii) Extra borrowing capacity
iv) ary surpluses in Investing tempor
near-cash assets
i) Holding a stock of extra cash
ii) Extra borrowing capacity
(advance receipt from
customers)
Models for the management of cash and
temporary investments are ndash Baumol
model Beranek model Miller-Orr
model and Stone model
Virgin does not follow any method
wholly but a combination of Baumol
model and Beranek model is occurred
82 INVENTORY MANAGEMENT
21 Certainty Approach
isnt used in
irgin because it thinks it is not possible to implement in Bangladesh
d time is one to three days It
oes not use ABC system of inventory management
8
Main item of inventory of Virgin is Can pet chip sugar label chemical artificial
sweet etc Virgin maintains a minimum level of inventory but it does not have to face
problems because inventory is managed efficiently just-in-time (JIT)
V
Virgin maintains buffer stock because of the shortage of work-in-process (WIP)
inventory Its production process may also be hampered Thats why it maintains
safety stock to avoid stock out cost In case of imported goods normal lead time is
about one month and within the country normal lea
d
Page 39 of 46
Inventory Model
In reality Virgin does not use any of models of EOQ ordering and holding strategy
and safety stock strategy They maintain inventory based on their prior experience
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
822 Uncertainty Approach
Virgin does not use any model for handling inventory uncertainty It says that such
decision depends on business cycle and market situation Long before Eid festival
they bought large amount of sugar because of price increase on the occasion of Eid
In summary
Standard Compliance by Virgin Soft Drinks
Firms maintain inventory to guard
against several problems
Virgin maintains a minimum level of
inventory which is managed efficiently
Some firms use JIT to avoid inventory
cost
JIT is not used by Virgin as it thinks it is
impossible to implement in Bangladesh
Firms maintain buffer stock Virgin maintains buffer stock too
Firms maintain safety stock to avoid
shortage cost
Virgin also maintains safety stock
Firms use ABC system to monitor
inventory
Virgin doesnt use ABC system
EOQ model is an appropriate method
for measuring quantity that has to be
ordered per order
Virgin does not use EOQ model rather
makes order based on experience and
market demand
83 MANAGING ACCOUNTS RECEIVABLE (DEBTORS)
831 Terms of Sale Decision
Page 40 of 46
Virgin offers the term 210 net 30 enables the customers to deduct 2 percent from the
face value of the bill when paying within the first 10 days but if the discount is not
taken the customer must remit the full amount within 30 days But Virgin does not
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
offer the same terms of sale to all customers For prime customers it offers special
terms of sale In setting an appropriate term of sale it costs and benefits regarding
this are compared It uses the standard approach of terms of sale decision as it is
simple to use
832 Credit Granting Decisions
In case of Virgin the Capital and Character of Five Cs get more importance
Although there are many problems with the traditional approach Virgin uses it
because of its simplicity Virgin does not use Net Present Value (NPV) method in
credit granting decision It thinks that NPV is an appropriate method and should be
used next time It does not face any severe problem because of bad debts The reason
is that notes receivable is used when credit is granted
833 Monitoring Accounts Receivable
Virgin monitors its accounts receivable Virgin believes that in any case both positive
and negative durations in accounts signal differences from the results that
management believe to be the most advantageous for the firm
Tools for Monitoring Accounts Receivable
Page 41 of 46
For monitoring accounts receivable there are several tools such as aging schedule
the ratios of receivable outstanding to original sales customers payment proportion
and sales weighted DSO (Days Sales Outstanding) For monitoring accounts
receivable Virgin uses aging schedule fractions and traditional DSO statistics
because of their simplicity in use Although payment proportions ratios of
receivables outstanding and sales weighted DSO methods are free from inherent bias
None of these is used because all these are complex to maintain
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
In summary
Page 42 of 46
Standard Compliance by Virgin Soft Drinks
Generals terms of sale is 210 net 30 Normally Virgin also use general terms
of sale ie 210 net 30
Firms do not offer the same terms of
sale to all customers
Yes For prime customers Virgin offers
special terms of sale
Approaches of terms of sale decisions
are ndash
bull Standard approach
bull Multi period approach
Virgin uses standard approach of terms
of sale decision as it is simple to use and
understand
Source of credit information are ndash
Sellers prior experience with the
customer
Credit agency ratings and
reports
Personal contact with the
applicants bank and other
creditors
Analysis of applicants financial
statements
Customer visit
Main source of credit information to
Virgin is its prior experience with the
customer All other sources are not cost-
effective for Virgin
Approaches of credit granting to
marginal accounts are ndash
Traditional approach
Net Present Value (NPV)
approach
It uses traditional approach still now but
thinks that NPV should be used for the
next periods
Firms monitor accounts receivable
because deviations from the expected
levels of turnover and of bad debt can
Virgin also monitors its accounts
receivable
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
signal several different problems
Different tools for monitoring accounts
receivable are ndash
Aging schedule
Ratios of receivables
outstanding to original sales
Customers payment
proportions
Sales-weighted DSO
For monitoring accounts receivable
Virgin uses aging schedule and
traditional sales outstanding statistics
84 MANAGING ACCOUNTS PAYABLE (CREDITORS)
Virgin has almost accounts payable of Tk 8000000 But most of its liabilities are to
the banks rather than suppliers But we dont have any clear information about
Virgins accounts payable
9 RECOMMENDATION
Virgin should invest its surplus cash in short term marketable securities
because it is suitable hedging against cash uncertainties and will also give
some returns (interest income)
Virgin should publish its own annual report which will satisfy information
needs of stakeholders and also increase the credibility of information provided
by Virgin
Page 43 of 46
Virgin should use multi period approach in terms of sale decision because
standard approach which is already exists in Virgin has some inherent
problems
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
It should stop using traditional approach from now It should use NPV
method in credit granting to marginal accounts
In monitoring accounts receivable Virgin should use sales-weighted DSO
method because it has least limitation compared to the others
It should be more flexible in granting credit which will ultimately increase its
sales
To get the appropriate number of quantity to be ordered per order it should
use DSO model
It should be ABC system for proper monitoring of inventory
10 CONCLUSION
The use of other peoples money in business is usually an expensive resource Before
looking outside for finance a firm should examine its own working capital cycle to
make sure that every rand of its own internal funds is being fully utilized Good
management of working capital is part of good financial management Effective use
of working capital will contribute to the operational efficiency of the whole
organization optimum use will help to generate maximum returns Furthermore
working capital management is not an end in itself It is an integral part of the firms
overall management The needs of efficient working capital management must be
considered in relation to other aspects of the Virgins financial and non-financial
performance Thats why when planning the development of a business it is critical
that the impact of working capital be fully assessed
Page 44 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
BIBLIOGRAPHY
Scherr FC (1989) International Edition Prentice-Hall International Inc Modern
Working Capital Management Text and Cases
Hussain Riaz (2002) Working Capital Management
Robertson Lonnie (July 1998) Inventory Management
httpwwwasashoporg visited on March 13 2006
The Art of Cash Management
httpwwwinccom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management
httpwwwstudyfinancecom visited on March 13 2006
White Paper ndash Managing Working Capital
httpwwwplanwareorg visited on March 13 2006
Management of Working Capital
httpwwwbusinesscentralcoza visited on March 13 2006
Cash Management
httpwwwsbagov visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management Objectives
httpwpsprenhallcom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management
Page 45 of 46
httpwwwadvancemecom visited on March 13 2006
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Business Receivables Financing
httpwwwbbtcom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Finance
http wwwfnbcoza visited on March 13 2006
Tips to manage your working capital
httpsmallbusinessninemsncomau visited on March 13 2006
Inventory Financing
httpwwwfranklincapitalnetworkcom visited on March 13 2006
Accounts Receivable Management
httpwwwfranklincapitalnetworkcom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management
httpwwwtreasurygovtnz visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management
httpwwwtreasurystrategiescom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Works
httpwwwinvestopediacom visited on March 13 2006
Treasury Services
httpwwwjpmorganchasecom visited on March 13 2006
what were about
Page 46 of 46
httpwwwvirgincom visited on March 13 2006
Annexure
Annexure
Interview with YASEER RIZVI
Mr Yaseer Rizvi the DMD of Global Beverage Co Ltd obtained his MBA degree
from a reputed university He had been the Director of Ocean Container Ltd before
joining in Global Beverage Co Ltd He possesses a nice personality
I interviewed Yaseer Rizvi Excerpts from his interview are as follows ndash
Shah Kamal Sir would you please tell me do you invest in short term marketable securities
Yaseer Rizvi Basically we do not invest our surplus cash in short term marketable
securities like T-Bill commercial paper certificate of deposit etc But we keep our
surplus cash in Bank
Shah Kamal Would you tell me something about transit time for a typical check
Yaseer Rizvi Well in Virgin the transit time for a typical check is ndash
For mail float 2 to 3 days
At firm float 6 hours
Clearing float 1 to 3 days
Shah Kamal Do you maintain any cash concentration mechanism like depository transfer check automated clearing house and wire transfer
i
Annexure
Yaseer Rizvi Our position in this case is very strong as we use all the mechanisms
you mentioned As Virgin is a firm with small deposits spread over a substantial
number of banks so we tend to use depository transfer checks extensively It is less
costly We also use automated clearing house and wire transfer but later is used in a
less extent
Shah Kamal Sir what techniques of disbursement management is used by your firm
Yaseer Rizvi Like other firms Virgin tries to retain the cash for as long as possible
But we always perform it in an ethical manner We do not use management of
disbursement float as it seems unethical We follow Zero-Balance Accounts method
for managing disbursement We do not prefer Controlled Disbursing method since
Zero-Balance system is already practiced in Virgin
Shah Kamal How do you hedge cash balance uncertainties
Yaseer Rizvi Well you may say that we do not invest in short term securities but for
facing cash difficulties we keep our surplus cash in bank
Shah Kamal Sir would you please tell me the general terms of sale of Virgin
Yaseer Rizvi Though it is difficult to maintain a fixed terms of sale our general terms
of sale is 210 n30 But for prime customers we offer special terms of sale
Shah Kamal What are the sources of credit information in case of your firm
Yaseer Rizvi We grant credit on the basis of prior experience with the customers In
case of a new customer personal contact is weighted
Shah Kamal Does your firm consider 5 Cs in granting credit
ii
Annexure
Yaseer Rizvi In case of Virgin Capital and Character get more importance than the
others Mind one thing personal relationship is the main measure in granting credit
Shah Kamal Do you use NPV method in credit granting decisions
Yaseer Rizvi We do not use NPV method But we think that NPV is a suitable
method and we have to use it from the next period
Shah Kamal Sir how do you handle the problem of bad debt
Yaseer Rizvi Well in this case our position is very strong Yet we do not face any
problem because of bad debt Just note that we make more than 80 of sales in cash
and we monitor accounts receivable very carefully
Shah Kamal What level of inventory is maintained by Virgin
Yaseer Rizvi We maintain a minimum level of inventory but do not have to face
stock out problems because inventory is managed efficiently
Shah Kamal What is the normal lead time
Yaseer Rizvi In case of imported goods normal lead time is about 1 month and when
we purchase raw materials from inside the country lead time is 1 to 3 days
Shah Kamal What method do you use for managing inventory
Yaseer Rizvi We do not use any method particularly rather inventory decision
depends on business cycle and market situation Long before the Eid festival we
bought large amount of sugar because price of sugar was increased on the occasion
of Eid
iii
Annexure
Shah Kamal What are the main items of inventory of your firm
Yaseer Rizvi Well these are ndash aluminum can pet chip sugar label chemical and
artificial sweet
Shah Kamal What are the uncertainties in maintaining appropriate level of stock
Yaseer Rizvi These are ndash
bull Increase in price of raw materials
bull Sales uncertainty
bull Market trends etc
Shah Kamal Thank you for your kind cooperation
Yaseer Rizvi Most Welcome
iv
Global Beverage Company Limited
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Collected current information from website
b) Segregation of Data
Necessary data were segregated from the source material for the purpose of preparing
the report
c) Processing of Data
Collected data were compiled and processed for the purpose of preparing the report
d) Presentation of Data
Collected data were presented in charts and tables
4 LIMITATIONS OF THE STUDY
On the way of my study I have faced a number of problems which may be turned
as the limitation of report
Many personnel of the organization due to their pressure of the work were
reluctant to provide much useful information
Sufficient records publications facts and figures are not available These
constraints narrowed the scope of real analysis
Due to time constraint I could not spend sufficient time which was
necessary to make this report more representative of the fact
Page 3 of 46
Lack of experience has also acted as constraint for the exploration of the
topic
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
5 WORKING CAPITAL MANAGEMENT
51 DEFINING WORKING CAPITAL
The term working capital refers to the amount of capital which is readily available to
an organization That is working capital is the difference between resources in cash
or readily convertible into cash (Current Assets) and organizational commitments for
which cash will soon be required (Current Liabilities)
Current Assets are resources which are in cash or will soon be converted into cash in
the ordinary course of business
Current Liabilities are commitments which will soon require cash settlement in the
ordinary course of business
Thus ndash
WORKING CAPITAL = CURRENT ASSETS - CURRENT LIABILITIES
In a firms Statement of Financial position these components of working capital are
reported under the following headings
Current Assets
Liquid Assets (cash and bank deposits)
Inventory
Debtors and Receivables
Current Liabilities
Bank Overdraft
Creditors and Payables
Other Short Term Liabilities
Page 4 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Working capital management involves the relationship between a firms short-term
assets and its short-term liabilities The goal of working capital management is to
ensure that a firm is able to continue its operations and that it has sufficient ability to
satisfy both maturing short-term debt and upcoming operational expenses The
management of working capital involves managing inventories accounts receivable
and payable and cash
52 WORKING CAPITAL POLICIES
The aim of working capital policy is to balance having too little working capital
which can lead to an inability to pay debts as they fall due or the need for expensive
short term borrowings and too much which is wasteful in terms of lost opportunities
for the funds tied up The crucial role of working capital is that it finances the goods
inwards production and sales activities
A firmrsquos working capital policy has two components
1 Policies regarding the appropriate level of current assets (Current Asset Investment Policy)
2 Policies regarding the use of short-term financing (Current Asset Financing Policy)
Alternative Current Asset Investment Policies
These policies are general strategies that firms may follow with regard to their overall
level of current assets investment or holdings There are three types
1 Relaxed Current Asset Investment Policy ndash
Relatively large amounts of cash marketable securities and inventories are carried
and sales are stimulated by a liberal (generous) trade credit policy resulting in high
levels of receivables This is a low risk strategy because the firm always has plenty of
cash and inventory on hand The return is low because more money is invested in
low yielding assets
Page 5 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
2 Restricted Current Asset Investment Policy ndash
Holdings of cash securities inventories and receivables are minimized This is a
high risk strategy because the firm tries to keep the bare minimum of cash and
inventory The potential return is high because less money is invested in low
yielding assets
3 Moderate Current Asset Policy ndash
Balance between relaxed and restricted current asset investment policies (moderate
risk - moderate potential return)
Alternative Current Asset Financing Policies
These policies are general strategies that firms may follow with regard to how current
assets are to be financed Current assets can be classified as permanent or temporary
Permanent current assets are the current assets that the company needs to maintain
throughout the entire year Temporary current assets are those that are due to
seasonal fluctuations With respect to the current asset financing policy the question
is how the permanent current assets will and temporary current assets are financed
(long-term or short-term financing)
Page 6 of 46
Aggressive Moderate Conservative
Cash Minimum holding Prepared to hold
some precautionary
balances
Prepared to hold idle
cash balances
Debtors and
stock
Minimum
consistent with
business needs
Moderate levels High stock and
debtor levels to
maximize sales
Creditors Maximum
available without
compromising
business needs
Moderate level Low level seeking
discounts and
reputation for good
payment
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Future cash
flows
Predictable Reasonably
predictable
Unpredictable
Attitude to
Risk
Accepting Neutral Rejecting
Total assets = Fixed Assets + Permanent Current Assets + Fluctuating Current Assets
53 WORKING CAPITAL CYCLE
Cash flows in a cycle into around and out of a business It is the businesss life blood
and every managers primary task is to help keep it flowing and to use the cash flow
to generate profits If a business is operating profitably then it should in theory
generate cash surpluses If it doesnt generate surpluses the business will eventually
run out of cash and expire
The faster a business expands the more cash it will need for working capital and
investment The cheapest and best sources of cash exist as working capital right
within business Good management of working capital will generate cash will help
improve profits and reduce risks
Working capital can be broken down into the following major components cash (or
bank overdraft) stock debtors creditors Each of these items can have a major
influence on the working capital (or simply cash) that any business requires on an
ongoing basis For example when a business starts up the owner may inject a
certain amount of cash into the business which will enable him to purchase his initial
stock pay his workers their first months wages and cover other overheads such as
rent He then sells his product and this income may be utilized to purchase more
stock pay more wages and overheads and perhaps even have a surplus over for his
own use The quicker he can turn his stock over to receive payment the sooner the
working capital cycle will be completed
Page 7 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Figure Working Capital Cycle
These major components of working capital are discussed below
531 CASH MANAGEMENT
The term cash management refers to the management of cash from the time it starts
its transit to the firm until it leaves the firm in payments Cash management
encompasses the design of collection and disbursement systems for cash and the
temporary investment of cash while it resides with the firm Widely used money
market instruments are-
Treasury bill
Commercial paper
Certificate of deposits
Bankerrsquos acceptance
Page 8 of 46
Repurchase agreement
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
5311 Motives for Holding Cash
Despite the seemingly low returns there are several good reasons why firms hold
cash and marketable securities These reasons are ndash
Cash for transactions
Cash and near cash assets as hedges
Temporary investment and
Compensating balances
5312 Components of Cash Management
A Cash Flow Statement shows the sources and uses of cash and is typically divided
into three components
Operating Cash Flow
Operating cash flow often referred to as working capital is the cash flow generated
from internal operations It comes from sales of the product or service of your
business and because it is generated internally it is under your control
Investing Cash Flow
Investing cash flow is generated internally from non-operating activities This
includes investments in plant and equipment or other fixed assets nonrecurring gains
or losses or other sources and uses of cash outside of normal operations
Financing Cash Flow
Financing cash flow is the cash to and from external sources such as lenders
investors and shareholders
Page 9 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
5313 Tools for Cash Management
Flotation and Check Clearing
Management of cash when it is not in the firmrsquos hands that is in transit to and from
the firm is on important function in the area of finance Transit times for the check
takes in three stages These are mail float at firm float and clearing float Normally
mail float takes 1 to 5 days at firm float takes 025 to 1 day and clearing float takes 0
to 2 days The firm should care about this process because every delay in the receipt
of money by the firm lowers the firmrsquos returns and therefore its shareholdersrsquo wealth
There are several strategies that firm can use to reduce the delay in receiving funds
Each of these strategies addresses one or more of the three float times (mail float
time at time float time and clearing float time) that make up the total transit time of
fund from one firm to another
Other Cash Management Tools
When the economy is strong companies can lapse into sloppy cash-management
practices Firm should try exploring these options
1 Sweep accounts
These bank accounts are the easiest way to generate some income from companys
spare funds however they make sense only if the money youll earn will be greater
than the fees your bank will charge Business owners have two types of sweep
accounts to choose between
Page 10 of 46
Controlled-investment accounts These are the most profitable form of
sweep account but they wont work for company if the firm has any
electronic payments or wire transfers since those may be submitted for
payment later in the day and the account wont have enough cash in it to
cover them
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Page 11 of 46
End-of-day sweep accounts A safer bet for most small-business owners
these accounts wait until a late-hour cutoff to determine how much to
sweep into the firms overnight investments Typically their investment
yields are 10 to 20 basis points (1 to 2 of the investment) lower than
those offered with controlled investments
2 Lock-box accounts
A lock box is a cash-management system that helps the firm collect funds quickly
Generally set up with the assistance of a big money center or regional bank lock
boxes provide the firm with a special zip code and usually quicker deliveries from
regional post offices They are especially important if the firm has clusters of
customers in out-of-state locations and dont want to lose days waiting for their
checks to arrive by long-distance mail
5314 Cash Concentration and Cash Disbursement
Once the remittances from the firmrsquos customers have been received and cleared the
resulting cash balances is available in the firmrsquos lockbox (depository) banks It is
useful for the firm to gather these balances from the lockbox banks into the central
bank account The process of collecting funds is called cash concentration
Several concentration mechanism are available for the firm to use in transferring
funds from its collection banks to regional concentration banks and from there to the
central concentration bank These mechanisms differ in cost and in the availability of
funds that they provide These are ndash
a) Depository Transfer Check
It is the cheapest transfer mechanism This document instructs one bank to
send funds to another and is treated the same as any other check
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
b) Automated Clearing House (ACH) Electronic Transfer
This vehicle is essentially an electronic version of the depository transfer
check and can be used between banks that participate in the automated
clearing house system
c) Wire Transfer
These are electronic message between banks
Decisions regarding concentration mechanism usually hinge on the size and
spread of the firmrsquos deposits Firms with small deposits spread over a
substantial number of banks will tend to have more extensive concentration
systems and will transfer among accounts using low-cost transfer vehicles that
offer only delayed availability (such as depository transfer checks) Firms with
larger deposits will have fewer accounts (since a local deposit for transfer to
an upstream bank is not needed) and will use more expensive and more rapid
transfer mechanisms (such as wire transfers) The concentration systems of
major chemical companies for example tend to be structured in this way ndash
DepositoryLockbox Banks
Regional Concentration Banks
Central Concentrated Bank
Figure A typical Cash Concentration System
(Arrows indicate transfers of collected funds)
Page 12 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Disbursement management addresses the efficient payout out of this cash once it is
concentrated The firmrsquos objective in disbursement management is to retain the cash
for as long as possible In this way the firm will have the maximum amount of funds
available for investment and transactional purposes Certainly this management
means making disbursement only when they are due and not before The firm has
several available set of techniques for disbursement management Included among
these are ndash
a) Management of Disbursement Float
In this set of techniques the disbursing firm attempts to increase the length of
time between the mailing of its checks and the eventual withdrawal of funds
from the banks This involves strategies for increasing mail float at firm float
and clearing float on its outgoing checks For example the disbursing firm
may intentionally address checks to the firmrsquos office address rather than its
lockbox creating at firm float
b) Zero-Balance Accounts
Here the firm holds the cash until the check arrive (or expected to arrive) at
the disbursement bank In this strategy an account for disbursement is first
established at a bank For the zero-balance system to be effective the
participating bank must be one on which most disbursement are made via the
Bangladesh Bankrsquos clearance system (which presents disbursements to banks
early in the morning) and not a bank where disbursements occur throughout
the day (as with a major money-center bank) Consequently the banks used
in zero-balance strategies are usually branches of major banks and not their
main locations
Page 13 of 46
c) Controlled Disbursing
In this system the firm projects the amount of checks to arrive each day at the
disbursement bank (based on the checks written in previous days and historic
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
statistics on disbursement float) and transfers the amount of the expected
checks to the account on that day or just before
5315 Cash Forecasting
Defining Cash Forecasting
The cash forecast is an estimation of the flows in and out of the firmrsquos cash account
over a particular period of time usually a quarter month week or day The cash
forecast is primarily intended to produce a very useful piece of information an
estimation of the firmrsquos borrowing and lending needs and uncertainties regarding
these needs during various future periods Cash forecasting is very crucial to most
firms It enables them to anticipate periods of surplus cash and periods where
financing will be necessary This anticipation is the reason that cash forecasts are
generated Anticipation enables the firm to plan much more effectively for
investment and financing and via this planning produce superior return
Types of Cash Forecasts
The types of cash forecasts generated by firms can be differentiated along two
dimensions the length of the periods included within the cash forecast and the approach
to cash flows used in the cash forecast The length of the period refers to the units of
time into which the cash forecast is divided Firms may make cash flow forecasts
over periods of various lengths yearly flows quarterly flows monthly flows weekly
flows or even daily flows The most popular forecast involves monthly flows but
most firms do not confine themselves to a single forecast Instead they use several
forecasts with periods of various lengths When the firm makes forecasts involving
multiple and overlapping period lengths one forecast relates to another Starting
with data on relatively long periods and breaking it down into smaller periods is
called distribution starting with data on relatively short periods and aggregating into
longer periods is called scheduling
Page 14 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Firms use two common approaches to cash flows in generating the cash forecast the
receipts and disbursements approach and the adjusted net income approach The receipts
and disbursements approach use the amounts of cash expected to be received and
disbursed by the firm over the periods chosen for forecast The adjusted income
statement approach is sometimes called the sources and use approach Here the
forecaster starts with projected net income on an accrual basis and adjusts to a cash
basis This method provides a representation of changes in asset and liability
accounts since the level of these accounts are of interest to the firm this aspect of the
adjusted income statement is an advantage over the receipts and disbursements
method
Items to Be Forecast
In the receipt and disbursements cash forecasting method estimates need to be made
of the numerous major and minor items that the firm collects (receipts) and that it
pays (disbursements) The more individual categories of items the firm includes in its
forecast procedure the more accurate the forecast may be but the more costly in
terms of time and effort it will be to generate
Some Possible Types of Cash Receipts and Cash Disbursements
Cash Disbursements Cash Receipts
Cash Purchases of Materials Payroll
Taxes
Maturing Accounts Payable
Maturing Notes Payable
Miscellaneous Disbursements
Accounts Receivable
Notes Receivable
Rental Income
Interest Income
Miscellaneous Receipts
Methods of Financial Forecasting
Page 15 of 46
Financial forecasting is the estimation of the future level of a financial variable often
a cash flow asset level or liability level It is usually assumed that the relationship
between the financial variable and other variable is linear The general linear model
can then be used
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
nnt xaxaxaaY 22110 ++=
Here
= Financial variable (Y) to be forecast in period t tY
x = Explanatory variable it is assumed to cause the level of Y in period t
0a = Represents a constant unaffected by the x
The other terms are the estimated coefficients of the explanatory x variables
There are n terms with xrsquos in them
There are four common approaches to forecasting financial variables but they
are all special cases of the general linear model These are ndash spot method proportion
to another account compounded growth and multiple dependencies
Using Cash Forecast
The estimate of available funds for investment and needed financing enables the firm
to plan so as to obtain the most advantages borrowing terms for deficits and achieve
the greatest interest income on surplus A useful chart for this planning purpose is a
bar chart eg
Figure Bar Chart of Cash Surpluses and Deficits from hypothetical data
Page 16 of 46
75
50
-60
30
100
-20
-80-60-40-20
020406080
100120
Defic
it
S
urpl
us
January February March April May June
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Sources of Uncertainty in Cash Forecasting and Hedging Uncertainties
There are numerous sources of risk in cash forecasting Among the sources are sales
uncertainty collection rate uncertainty production cost uncertainty and capital
outflow uncertainty
5316 Models for the Management of Cash and Temporary Investments
There are different models for the management of cash and temporary investments
Among these the most popular methods are ndash Baumol model Beranek model
Miller-Orr model and Stone model
Baumol and Beranek use the same model The formula is cited below ndash
Interest Income = iYn
n⎥⎦⎤
⎢⎣⎡ minus
21
Profit = naiYn
nminus⎥⎦
⎤⎢⎣⎡ minus
21
Optimum number of transactions = ⎟⎠⎞
⎜⎝⎛
aiY2
Where n = Optimum number of transactions
i = Interest rate per period
a = Transaction cost
Y = Total inflow for the period
Page 17 of 46
Miller-Orr and Stone use the same model ie R-Statistic The model is ndash
31
43
iav
R ⎟⎠⎞
⎜⎝⎛=
Optimum Control Limit = R + L
Upper Control Limit = 3R + L
Where a = Transaction Cost
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
v = Variance of daily cash flows
i = Daily interest rate
5317 Administration
Cash receipts should be processed and banked as quickly as possible because
They cannot earn interest or reduce overdraft until they are banked
information about the existence and amounts of cash receipts is usually not
available until they are processed
Where possible cash floats (mainly petty cash and advances) should be avoided If
on review the only reason that can be put forward for their existence is that weve
always had them they should be discontinued There may be situations where they
are useful however For example it may be desirable for peripheral parts of
departments to meet urgent local needs from cash floats rather than local bank
accounts
5318 Internal Control
Cash and cash management is part of a firms overall internal control system The
main internal cash control is invariably the bank reconciliation This provides
assurance that the cash balances recorded in the accounting systems are consistent
with the actual bank balances It requires regular clearing of reconciling items
5319 Practicing Good Cash Flow Management
Good cash management is simple It involves
Knowing when where and how firms cash needs will occur
Page 18 of 46
Knowing the best sources for meeting additional cash needs
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Page 19 of 46
Being prepared to meet these needs when they occur by keeping good
relationships with bankers and other creditors
532 INVENTORY MANAGEMENT
Inventory management is necessary for owners who want to maintain a stocking
service for quick turnaround to help ensure total customer satisfaction The fill rate
of an item on a managed inventory list must be maintained to avoid shortages of
frequently used items Even when utilizing an inventory management system
occasional shortages will still occur Inventories are lists of stocks-raw materials
work in progress or finished goods-waiting to be consumed in production or to be
sold The total balance of inventory is the sum of the value of each individual stock
line
Basically firms hold stocks for the following reasons
To act as a buffer in times of unusually high demand
To ensure continuity of production
Avoid high costs of emergency orders
To take advantage of quantity discounts by ordering more at a time
To reduce ordering costs by ordering more items on fewer
As part of the production process eg maturing whisky or keeping oil in
pipelines
Seasonality of demand (eg firework) or supplies
Suppliers insist on minimum order quantities
The key issue for a business is to identify the fast and slow stock movers with the
objectives of establishing optimum stock levels for each category and thereby
minimize the cash tied up in stocks Factors to be considered when determining
optimum stock levels include
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Page 20 of 46
What are the projected sales of each product
How widely available are raw materials components etc
How long does it take for delivery by suppliers
Can the firm remove slow movers from its product range without
compromising best sellers
Inventory management is an important aspect of working capital management
because inventories themselves do not earn any revenue Holding either too little or
too much inventory incurs costs
Costs of carrying too much inventory are
Opportunity cost of foregone interest
Warehousing costs
Damage and pilferage
Obsolescence
Insurance
Costs of carrying too little inventory are
Stock out costs
Lost sales
Delayed service
Ordering costs
Freight
on Order administrati
nts
Loss of quantity discou
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Carrying costs can be minimized by making frequent small orders but this increase
ordering costs and the risk of stock outs Risk of stock-outs can be reduced by
carrying safety stocks (at a cost) and re-ordering ahead of time
The best ordering strategy requires balancing the various cost factors to ensure the
firm incurs minimum inventory costs The optimum inventory position is known as
the Economic Reorder Quantity (ERQ)
Nowadays many large manufacturers operate on a just-in-time (JIT) basis whereby
all the components to be assembled on a particular today arrive at the factory early
that morning no earlier - no later This helps to minimize manufacturing costs as JIT
stocks take up little space minimize stock-holding and virtually eliminate the risks of
obsolete or damaged stock Because JIT manufacturers hold stock for a very short
time they are able to conserve substantial cash JIT is a good model to strive for as it
embraces all the principles of prudent stock management For better stock control
firm may try the following
Review the effectiveness of existing purchasing and inventory systems
Know the stock turn for all major items of inventory
Apply tight controls to the significant few items and simplify controls for the
trivial many
Sell off outdated or slow moving merchandise - it gets more difficult to sell the
longer the firm keeps it
Consider having part of its product outsourced to another manufacturer rather
than make it itself
Review its security procedures to ensure that no stock is going out the back
door
Higher than necessary stock levels tie up cash and cost more in insurance
accommodation costs and interest charges
Page 21 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
However it is important to keep an overall perspective It is not cost-effective to
closely manage a large number of low value inventory lines nor is it necessary A
usual feature of inventories is that a small number of high value lines account for a
large proportion of inventory value The 8020 rule (PARETO) predicts that 80
of the total value of inventory is represented by only 20 of the number of inventory
items Those high value lines need reasonably close management The remaining
80 of inventory lines can be managed using broad-brush strategies
533 MANAGING ACCOUNTS RECEIVABLE (DEBTORS)
Cash flow can be significantly enhanced if the amounts owing to a business are
collected faster Every business needs to know who owes them money how much is
owed how long it is owing for what it is owed
Debtors (Accounts Receivable) are customers who have not yet made payment for
goods or services which the department has provided The objective of debtor
management is to minimize the time-lapse between completion of sales and receipt
of payment The costs of having debtors are
Opportunity costs (cash is not available for other purposes)
Bad debts
If firm doesnt manage debtors they will begin to manage business as the firm will gradually
lose control due to reduced cash flow and of course it could experience an increased
incidence of bad debt The following measures will help manage debtors
Having the right mental attitude to the control of credit and make sure that it
gets the priority it deserves
Establishing clear credit practices as a matter of company policy
Page 22 of 46
Making sure that these practices are clearly understood by staff suppliers and
customers
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Page 23 of 46
Being professional when accepting new accounts and especially larger ones
Checking out each customer thoroughly before the firm offers credit Use
credit agencies bank references industry sources etc
Establishing credit limits for each customer and sticking to them
Continuously reviewing these limits when it suspects tough times are coming
or if operating in a volatile sector
Keeping very close to the firms larger customers
Invoicing promptly and clearly
Considering charging penalties on overdue accounts
Considering accepting credit debit cards as a payment option
Monitoring its debtor balances and ageing schedules and dont let any debts
get too large or too old
Debtor management includes both pre-sale and debt collection strategies
Pre-sale strategies include
Offering cash discounts for early payment andor imposing penalties for late
payment
Agreeing payment terms in advance
Requiring cash before delivery
Setting credit limits
ning credit Setting criteria for obtai
Billing as early as possible
rogress payments
ost-sale strategies include
for collecting the debt upon the center that made the sale
Requiring deposits andor p
P
Placing the responsibility
Identifying long overdue balances and doubtful debts by regular analytical reviews
Having an established procedure for late collections such as
A reminder
A letter
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Page 24 of 46
ion of further credit Cancellat
Telephone calls
n agency Use of a collectio
he firm should recognize that the longer someone owes firm the greater the chance
Legal action
T
it will never get paid If the average age of debtors is getting longer or is already very
long it may need to look for the following possible defects
Weak credit judgment
res Poor collection procedu
ms Lax enforcement of credit ter
Slow issue of invoices or statements
Errors in invoices or statements
Customer dissatisfaction
Debtors due over 90 days (unless within agreed credit terms) should generally
demand immediate attention For example warning signs of a future bad debt ndash
Longer credit terms taken with approval particularly for smaller orders
Use of post-dated checks by debtors who normally settle within agreed terms
Evidence of customers switching to additional suppliers for the same goods
New customers who are reluctant to give credit references
Cre G
Receiving part payments from debtors
dit ranting to Marginal Accounts
Traditional Approach
In the traditional approach to the credit granting decision it is the credit analysts job
rmation that has been collected and reach a judgment
regarding the applicants creditworthiness One traditional way of organizing this
to synthesize all the info
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
information is by characterizing the applicant along five dimensions These
dimensions are called the Five Cs of credit ndash
Capital
Character
Collateral
and Capacity
Conditions
Net Present Value (NPV) Approach
Once a firm has assessed the creditworthiness of a customer it has to decide whether
r not credit should be granted The firm should use the NPV rule to make the
ld be granted
Figure
o
decision If NPV is positive credit shou
Credit Granting Decision
Credit Granting Decision
he act of collecting money is one which most people dislike for many reasons and
therefore put on the long f selves there is something
ore urgent or important that demands their attention now There is nothing more
T
inger because they convince them
m
important than getting paid for firms product or service A customer who does not
Page 25 of 46
Grand Credit
Payment received Payment not received
Benefit of present value of future net cash flow
Cost of present value ment of lost invest
Net Payoff PV of benefit-cost
No Credit
No Payoff
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
pay is not a customer Here are a few ideas that may help the firm in collecting
money from debtors
Firm should develop appropriate procedures for handling late payments
It should track and pursue late payers
It might get external help if its own efforts fail
or money its firms and it is entitled Company shouldnt feel guilty asking f
to it
ction
Firm must make that call now And it should keep asking until it gets some
satisfa
lessens the problem
In difficult circumstances take what the firm can now and agree terms for the
remainder It
paying
When asking for money be hard on the issue - but soft on the person It shouldnt
give the debtor any excuses for not
534 BLE (CREDITORS)
ices for goods or services have
een paid Organizations often regard the
not
to delay all payments until the latest possible date Regular weekly or
The firm make it its objective is to get the money - not to score points or get
even
MANAGING ACCOUNTS PAYA
Creditors (Accounts Payable) are suppliers whose invo
been processed but who have not yet b
amount owing to creditors as a source of free credit However creditor
administration systems are expensive and time-consuming to run The over-riding
concern in this area should be to minimize costs with simple procedures
While it is unnecessary to pay accounts before they fall due it is usually
worthwhile
Page 26 of 46
fortnightly payment of all due accounts is the simplest technique for creditor
management
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Electronic payments (direct credits) are cheaper than check payments considering
that transaction fees and overheads more than balance the advantage of delayed
presentation Some suppliers are reluctant to receive payments by this method but in
view of the substantial cost advantage (and the advantages to the suppliers
themselves) departments may wish to encourage suppliers to accept this option
However electronic payments are likely to be used in conjunction with rather than
as a replacement for check payments
Applying Best Practices in Managing Accounts Payable
f course simply deferring payments to suppliers could have adverse consequences
O
that more than offset the benefits of this additional cash flow Therefore it is
important to develop a holistic approach The firm should consider the following
best practices for payables management
Managing payment dates and terms to maximize cash flow ndash
y reporting on
receivable and
id penalty charges and taking advantage of
wer vendors and negotiate for more
to buying consortia with others even
voices for
payment based on receipt of goods or receipt of invoice whichever
comes later
Calculating and setting performance targets Regularl
AP performance measures such as days in payables
Coordinating the AP processes with accounts
inventory management to ensure that the company is collecting more
cash than it is paying out
Paying bills on time to avo
prompt-payment discounts where the discounts exceed the companyrsquos
cost of working capital
Consolidating purchases with fe
favorable payment terms
Considering entering in
Page 27 of 46
competitors to obtain favorable supplier pricing and terms
Unless contract terms specify otherwise setting up in
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Page 28 of 46
Em
process
-time payments with Electronic Funds Transfer (EFT)
uraging vendors to utilize electronic invoice presentment
a
ndancies and more
ploying technology to automate the accounts payable transaction
es ndash
Making just-in
Using an electronic invoice-matching application
Enco
For companies with multiple locations or business units employing
shared service approach for AP to eliminate redu
quickly implement process improvements
Mainta
vendor
Communicating accounts payable requirements to suppliers at the
m key suppliers
for suggestions on how to improve the
Efficient a
and making th rsquos cash is just good business
ining open communications and building strong relationships with
s to access valuable trade credit ndash
beginning of transactions
Requesting summary invoicing fro
Requiring suppliers to send invoices directly to accounts payable
Asking tier-one suppliers
payment process
nd effective management of accounts payable helps improve cash flow ndash
e most of company
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
6 OVERVIEW OF VIRGIN GROUP
Virgin - one of the most respected brands in Britain - is now becoming the first global
brand name of the 21st century Virgin is involved in planes trains finance soft
drinks music mobile phones holidays cars wines publishing bridal wear - the lot
What tie all these businesses together are the values of its brand and the attitude of its
people Virgin has created over 200 companies worldwide employing over 25000
people Its total revenues around the world in 2002 exceeded pound4 billion (US $72
billion)
In 1970 Richard Branson founded Virgin as a mail order record retailer and not
long after he opened a record shop in Oxford Street London During 1972 a
recording studio was built in Oxfordshire and the first Virgin artist Mike Oldfield
recorded Tubular Bells which was released in 1973
This album went on to sell over 5 million copies Since then many household names
including Belinda Carlisle Genesis Phil Collins Janet Jackson and The Rolling
Stones have helped to make Virgin Music one of the top six record companies in the
world The equity of Virgin Music Group - record labels music publishing and
recording studios was sold to THORN EMI in 1992 in a US$1billion deal
Page 29 of 46
The Virgin Group has now expanded into international music Mega stores air
travel mobile financial retail music internet drinks rail hotels and leisure with
around 200 companies in over 30 countries
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
In Virgins customers eyes Virgin stands for value for money quality innovation
fun and a sense of competitive challenge It delivers a quality service by empowering
its employees and facilitates and monitors customer feedback to continually improve
the customers experience through innovation
When they start a new venture Virgin bases it on hard research and analysis
Typically they review the industry and put themselves in the customers shoes to see
what could make it better Virgin asks fundamental questions
Is this an opportunity for restructuring a market and creating competitive
advantage What are the competitors doing
Is the customer confused or badly served
Is this an opportunity for building the Virgin brand
Can we add value
Will it interact with its other businesses
Is there an appropriate trade-off between risk and reward
Page 30 of 46
Virgin is also able to draw on talented people from throughout the group New
ventures are often steered by people seconded from other parts of Virgin who bring
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
with them the trademark management style skills and experience Virgin frequently
creates partnerships with others to combine skills knowledge and market presence
and so on Contrary to what some people may think their constantly expanding and
eclectic empire is neither random nor reckless Each successive venture demonstrates
its skill in picking the right market and the right opportunity
7 OVERVIEW OF VIRGIN SOFT DRINKS
The Virgin Drinks Group first launched as the Virgin Cola Company in 1994 with
Virgin Cola in the UK Since then the company has ventured across the carbonated
soft drinks arena and beyond into energy drinks tea and flavored Colas This
expansion has lead to the evolution of the Virgin Drinks Company a company
whose aim is to put the excitement back into the world of soft drinks It launched in
Bangladesh in 1999 Virgin Soft Drinks is monitored by Global Beverage Co Ltd in
Bangladesh
Brief history of Virgin Drinks is given below
Page 31 of 46
1994 November Virgin Cola launched in the UK
1996 March Virgin Cola launched in France
1998 June Virgin Cola launched in Belgium
April Virgin Cola launched in the French West Indies
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
August Virgin Cola launched in Switzerland
1999 March Virgin Colours launched in Italy
March Virgin Cola launched in Japan
July Virgin Colours launched in South Africa
December Virgin Colours launched in Bangladesh
2001 January Sweden launched Virgin Colours
November Singapore launched Virgin Colours
2002 February Croatia launched Virgin Colours
June Russia launched Virgin Colours
June Tunisia launched Virgin Colours
2003 May Israel launched Virgin Colours
8 FINDINGS OF WORKING CAPITAL MANAGEMENT MAINTAINED BY
VIRGIN SOFT DRINKS IN BANGLADESH
81 CASH MANAGEMENT
811 Holding Cash and Marketable Securities
Although there are many good reasons why firm hold cash and marketable
securities Virgin Drinks holds cash and marketable securities for two reasons ndash
i) Cash for transactions
ii) Cash as hedges
This indicates that the firm does not hold cash and marketable securities for some
important reasons such as ndash
i) Near cash assets as hedges
Page 32 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
ii) Temporary investment and compensating balances
Virgin Soft Drinks does not invest in money market securities such as Treasury bill
commercial paper certificate of deposits bankerrsquos acceptance and repurchase
agreement This firm deposits its money in bank as currant AC or fixed AC They
say that they do not have enough money to invest in money market instrument
They also say that if they have enough money they will invest it in money market
short term securities We know that near cash interest earning assets can be
substituted for cash when motivation for holding these assets is the hedging of cash
flow uncertainties or is the temporary investment of surplus funds In this point
Virgins position is not good as there is no significant hedging against uncertainty of
cash
812 Floatation and Check Clearing
Virgin is very smart in handling the problem of transit time for checks Here mail
float takes 2 to 3 days at firm takes 025 day and clearing float takes 1-3 days Virgin
uses most of the strategies available for reducing the delay in receiving funds It
(Virgin) has linked Islami Bank which posses an accelerated clearing facility It uses
electronic collection process which ensures faster collection and its at the firm check
processing is satisfactory But Virgin does not use lockbox The reason behind this is
that it is not cost-effective for Virgin to set lockboxes At this point we can say that
Virgins check clearing mechanism is much good
813 Cash Concentration and Disbursement Management
Page 33 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks takes the matter of cash concentration very seriously They use all
the available cash concentration mechanism Virgin is a firm with small deposits
spread over a substantial number of banks and this is why the firm tends to use
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
depository transfer checks extensively If is less costly Virgin also uses automated
clearing house and wire transfer To Virgin wire transfer seems too costly
Like other firm Virgin tries to retain the cash for as long as possible But Virgin
always performs it in an ethical manner Virgin does not try to defeat the receiving
firmrsquos attempts to reduce the float on incoming checks It does not take any strategy
for increasing mail float at firm float and clearing float on its outgoing checks To
Virgin it is deemed to be unethical It thinks that maximization of disbursement float
will not go unnoticed by sophisticated creditors for very long When it is noticed it
will negatively affect relations with these creditors reducing the firmrsquos bargaining
power with them This may ultimately cost Virgin dearly when future prices and
delivery schedules for goods and services purchased from trade creditors are
negotiated Virgin follows ldquoZero-Balance Accountsrdquo methods for managing
disbursement It thinks that in this method the coordination of funds inflows to
disbursement banks with the presentation of checks does not work to the detriment
of creditors since the firmrsquos checks to them are honored as presented and this strategy
does not affect float significantly Controlled disbursing method is less attractive to
Virgin because zero-balance system is already feasible
814 Cash Forecasting
Cash Forecasting and Its Types
Page 34 of 46
Virgin forecasts the future cash inflows and outflows To Virgin cash forecast is an
important part of the firmrsquos cash control system and is one of the forecasts that are
part of the Virginrsquos financial plan Virgin forecasts cash on monthly basis and on
yearly basis Virgin does not forecast on daily basis assuming that the temporary
shortage of funds within these periods can be covered without value cost eg
advance receipts from customers Virginrsquos cash forecasting system involves a
combination of distribution and scheduling The receipts and disbursements
approach of cash forecasting is used in virgin This method is used because it
minutely traces the movement of cash and very close control of cash is possible
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Virgin does not use adjusted net income approach on two grounds First it does not
permit the tracing of the individual types of cash inflows and outflows for any given
period which is often useful information for virgin Second it is not simple to use
Items to be Forecast
Virgin does not forecast all the items It forecasts only major items eg accounts
receivable notes receivable payroll cash purchases of raw materials In this regard
virgin trade off between cost and benefit
Methods of Financial Forecasting
Virgin forecasts the future level of financial variable such as cash level asset level or
liability level We know in short term forecasts many things will result from plans
and events that are already in place (contracts capital budgets long-range financing
plans and so forth) But in the long run most things can vary and are dependent on
outside influences such as the firmrsquos long-term growth rate Since Virginrsquos cash
forecasting deals mostly with near future many of the items on the cash forecasts are
estimated by some variation of the spot method and remaining estimates are mostly
on a ldquoproportion of another accountrdquo basis with this ldquoother accountrdquo often being a
particular periodrsquos sales Virgin uses the other two methods less frequently
Using Cash Forecast
Virgin forecasts cash for meeting general objectives (ie to know the available funds
for investment and need financing) and for meeting some special objectives (eg to
know whether the firm will fulfill its out of debt requirement) But it is matter to note
that Virgin does not make any short term investment of its surplus cash but only keep
this surplus in Bank Account
Page 35 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Sources of Uncertainty in Cash Forecasting and Hedging Uncertainties
Virgin faces uncertainty in cash forecasting mainly from two sources These are ndash
sales and production cost In peak season (hot season like autumn summer) sales
increases but in dull season (eg in winter) sales decreases drastically Production
cost may be increased because of increase of price of sugar chemicals aluminum
can Virgin follows two methods for hedging cash balance uncertainties These are ndash
i) Holding a stock of extra cash and
ii) Extra borrowing capacity
815 Modes for the Management of Cash and Temporary Investments
Virgin does not follow any of these methods wholly Virgin receives cash
continuously and pays salary at steady rate and pays continuously for other
expenses So it neither follows Baumol model nor Beranek model It has no upper
control limit lower control limit return point in case cash management So it neither
follows Miller-Orr model nor Stone model
In Summary
Page 36 of 46
Standard Compliance by Virgin Soft Drinks
Generally all firms hold cash and
marketable securities
Virgin holds only cash
Firms hold cash and marketable
securities for some reasons like
bull Cash for transactions
bull Cash and near-cash assets as
hedges
bull Temporary investments
bull Compensating balances
Virgin holds cash only for
two reasons ndash
bull Cash for transactions
bull Cash as hedges
Available money market instruments Virgin does not invest in any such
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
(short term securities) are ndash
Treasury Bills
Commercial Paper
Certificates of Deposit
Bankerrsquos Acceptance
Repurch menase Agree ts
instruments They only keep cash in
Bank Account
Mail Float
(1 to 5 days)
At Firm
Float
(025 to 1
day)
Clearing
Float
(0 to
2 days)
Mail Float
(2 to 3 days)
At firm
Float
(025
day)
Clearing
Float
(1 to 3
days)
Figure Transit time for a typical check Figure Transit time for a check for
Virgin
Strategies that firms can use to reduce
the delay in receiving funds are ndash
Selecting of Banks with
accelerated clearing capabilities
of check processing Acceleration
at the firm
ectronic collection Use of el
procedures
Use of lockboxes
Virgin follows the first three strategies
but does not use lockboxes
Available cash concentration
mechanisms are ndash
Depository transfer check
ouse Automated Clearing H
(ACH) electronic transfer)
Wire transfer
Virgin uses all these mechanisms of
cash concentration
Available sets of techniques for cash
disbursement management are ndash
ement of disbursement
Page 37 of 46
Manag
float
Virgin uses zero-balance accounts
technique
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Zero-Balance Accounts
Controlled disbursing
Firms may make cash flow forecasts
over periods of various lengths yearly
flows quarterly flows monthly flows
weekly flows or even daily flows
Virgin forecasts cash on yearly basis and
monthly basis
Cash forecasting system may involve ndash
Distribution
Scheduling
Virginrsquos cash forecasting system
involves a combination of distribution
and scheduling
Two common approaches to cash flow
in generating the cash forecast
and disbursement Receipts
approach
Adjusted net income approach
Virgin uses the receipts and
disbursement approach
There are many items to forecast Virgin forecasts only major items like
AR payroll etc
Four common approach to forecasting
fina i ndash nc al variables are
Spot method
Proportion to another account
Compounded growth
Multiple dependencies
Virgin uses spot method for forecasting
cash It uses proportion to another
account method for other variables and
remaining two methods are frequently
used
Sources of uncertainty in cash
forecasting are ndash
Sales uncertainty
Collection rate uncertainty
Production cost uncertainty
Capital outflow uncertainty
Virgin faces uncertainty mainly from
sales and production cost
Methods for hedging cash balance
unc a
Page 38 of 46
ert inties are ndash
i) Holding a stock of extra cash
Virgin two available methods for
hedging cash balance uncertainties
Th ese are ndash
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
ii) stock of near-cash Holding a
assets
iii) Extra borrowing capacity
iv) ary surpluses in Investing tempor
near-cash assets
i) Holding a stock of extra cash
ii) Extra borrowing capacity
(advance receipt from
customers)
Models for the management of cash and
temporary investments are ndash Baumol
model Beranek model Miller-Orr
model and Stone model
Virgin does not follow any method
wholly but a combination of Baumol
model and Beranek model is occurred
82 INVENTORY MANAGEMENT
21 Certainty Approach
isnt used in
irgin because it thinks it is not possible to implement in Bangladesh
d time is one to three days It
oes not use ABC system of inventory management
8
Main item of inventory of Virgin is Can pet chip sugar label chemical artificial
sweet etc Virgin maintains a minimum level of inventory but it does not have to face
problems because inventory is managed efficiently just-in-time (JIT)
V
Virgin maintains buffer stock because of the shortage of work-in-process (WIP)
inventory Its production process may also be hampered Thats why it maintains
safety stock to avoid stock out cost In case of imported goods normal lead time is
about one month and within the country normal lea
d
Page 39 of 46
Inventory Model
In reality Virgin does not use any of models of EOQ ordering and holding strategy
and safety stock strategy They maintain inventory based on their prior experience
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
822 Uncertainty Approach
Virgin does not use any model for handling inventory uncertainty It says that such
decision depends on business cycle and market situation Long before Eid festival
they bought large amount of sugar because of price increase on the occasion of Eid
In summary
Standard Compliance by Virgin Soft Drinks
Firms maintain inventory to guard
against several problems
Virgin maintains a minimum level of
inventory which is managed efficiently
Some firms use JIT to avoid inventory
cost
JIT is not used by Virgin as it thinks it is
impossible to implement in Bangladesh
Firms maintain buffer stock Virgin maintains buffer stock too
Firms maintain safety stock to avoid
shortage cost
Virgin also maintains safety stock
Firms use ABC system to monitor
inventory
Virgin doesnt use ABC system
EOQ model is an appropriate method
for measuring quantity that has to be
ordered per order
Virgin does not use EOQ model rather
makes order based on experience and
market demand
83 MANAGING ACCOUNTS RECEIVABLE (DEBTORS)
831 Terms of Sale Decision
Page 40 of 46
Virgin offers the term 210 net 30 enables the customers to deduct 2 percent from the
face value of the bill when paying within the first 10 days but if the discount is not
taken the customer must remit the full amount within 30 days But Virgin does not
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
offer the same terms of sale to all customers For prime customers it offers special
terms of sale In setting an appropriate term of sale it costs and benefits regarding
this are compared It uses the standard approach of terms of sale decision as it is
simple to use
832 Credit Granting Decisions
In case of Virgin the Capital and Character of Five Cs get more importance
Although there are many problems with the traditional approach Virgin uses it
because of its simplicity Virgin does not use Net Present Value (NPV) method in
credit granting decision It thinks that NPV is an appropriate method and should be
used next time It does not face any severe problem because of bad debts The reason
is that notes receivable is used when credit is granted
833 Monitoring Accounts Receivable
Virgin monitors its accounts receivable Virgin believes that in any case both positive
and negative durations in accounts signal differences from the results that
management believe to be the most advantageous for the firm
Tools for Monitoring Accounts Receivable
Page 41 of 46
For monitoring accounts receivable there are several tools such as aging schedule
the ratios of receivable outstanding to original sales customers payment proportion
and sales weighted DSO (Days Sales Outstanding) For monitoring accounts
receivable Virgin uses aging schedule fractions and traditional DSO statistics
because of their simplicity in use Although payment proportions ratios of
receivables outstanding and sales weighted DSO methods are free from inherent bias
None of these is used because all these are complex to maintain
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
In summary
Page 42 of 46
Standard Compliance by Virgin Soft Drinks
Generals terms of sale is 210 net 30 Normally Virgin also use general terms
of sale ie 210 net 30
Firms do not offer the same terms of
sale to all customers
Yes For prime customers Virgin offers
special terms of sale
Approaches of terms of sale decisions
are ndash
bull Standard approach
bull Multi period approach
Virgin uses standard approach of terms
of sale decision as it is simple to use and
understand
Source of credit information are ndash
Sellers prior experience with the
customer
Credit agency ratings and
reports
Personal contact with the
applicants bank and other
creditors
Analysis of applicants financial
statements
Customer visit
Main source of credit information to
Virgin is its prior experience with the
customer All other sources are not cost-
effective for Virgin
Approaches of credit granting to
marginal accounts are ndash
Traditional approach
Net Present Value (NPV)
approach
It uses traditional approach still now but
thinks that NPV should be used for the
next periods
Firms monitor accounts receivable
because deviations from the expected
levels of turnover and of bad debt can
Virgin also monitors its accounts
receivable
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
signal several different problems
Different tools for monitoring accounts
receivable are ndash
Aging schedule
Ratios of receivables
outstanding to original sales
Customers payment
proportions
Sales-weighted DSO
For monitoring accounts receivable
Virgin uses aging schedule and
traditional sales outstanding statistics
84 MANAGING ACCOUNTS PAYABLE (CREDITORS)
Virgin has almost accounts payable of Tk 8000000 But most of its liabilities are to
the banks rather than suppliers But we dont have any clear information about
Virgins accounts payable
9 RECOMMENDATION
Virgin should invest its surplus cash in short term marketable securities
because it is suitable hedging against cash uncertainties and will also give
some returns (interest income)
Virgin should publish its own annual report which will satisfy information
needs of stakeholders and also increase the credibility of information provided
by Virgin
Page 43 of 46
Virgin should use multi period approach in terms of sale decision because
standard approach which is already exists in Virgin has some inherent
problems
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
It should stop using traditional approach from now It should use NPV
method in credit granting to marginal accounts
In monitoring accounts receivable Virgin should use sales-weighted DSO
method because it has least limitation compared to the others
It should be more flexible in granting credit which will ultimately increase its
sales
To get the appropriate number of quantity to be ordered per order it should
use DSO model
It should be ABC system for proper monitoring of inventory
10 CONCLUSION
The use of other peoples money in business is usually an expensive resource Before
looking outside for finance a firm should examine its own working capital cycle to
make sure that every rand of its own internal funds is being fully utilized Good
management of working capital is part of good financial management Effective use
of working capital will contribute to the operational efficiency of the whole
organization optimum use will help to generate maximum returns Furthermore
working capital management is not an end in itself It is an integral part of the firms
overall management The needs of efficient working capital management must be
considered in relation to other aspects of the Virgins financial and non-financial
performance Thats why when planning the development of a business it is critical
that the impact of working capital be fully assessed
Page 44 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
BIBLIOGRAPHY
Scherr FC (1989) International Edition Prentice-Hall International Inc Modern
Working Capital Management Text and Cases
Hussain Riaz (2002) Working Capital Management
Robertson Lonnie (July 1998) Inventory Management
httpwwwasashoporg visited on March 13 2006
The Art of Cash Management
httpwwwinccom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management
httpwwwstudyfinancecom visited on March 13 2006
White Paper ndash Managing Working Capital
httpwwwplanwareorg visited on March 13 2006
Management of Working Capital
httpwwwbusinesscentralcoza visited on March 13 2006
Cash Management
httpwwwsbagov visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management Objectives
httpwpsprenhallcom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management
Page 45 of 46
httpwwwadvancemecom visited on March 13 2006
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Business Receivables Financing
httpwwwbbtcom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Finance
http wwwfnbcoza visited on March 13 2006
Tips to manage your working capital
httpsmallbusinessninemsncomau visited on March 13 2006
Inventory Financing
httpwwwfranklincapitalnetworkcom visited on March 13 2006
Accounts Receivable Management
httpwwwfranklincapitalnetworkcom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management
httpwwwtreasurygovtnz visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management
httpwwwtreasurystrategiescom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Works
httpwwwinvestopediacom visited on March 13 2006
Treasury Services
httpwwwjpmorganchasecom visited on March 13 2006
what were about
Page 46 of 46
httpwwwvirgincom visited on March 13 2006
Annexure
Annexure
Interview with YASEER RIZVI
Mr Yaseer Rizvi the DMD of Global Beverage Co Ltd obtained his MBA degree
from a reputed university He had been the Director of Ocean Container Ltd before
joining in Global Beverage Co Ltd He possesses a nice personality
I interviewed Yaseer Rizvi Excerpts from his interview are as follows ndash
Shah Kamal Sir would you please tell me do you invest in short term marketable securities
Yaseer Rizvi Basically we do not invest our surplus cash in short term marketable
securities like T-Bill commercial paper certificate of deposit etc But we keep our
surplus cash in Bank
Shah Kamal Would you tell me something about transit time for a typical check
Yaseer Rizvi Well in Virgin the transit time for a typical check is ndash
For mail float 2 to 3 days
At firm float 6 hours
Clearing float 1 to 3 days
Shah Kamal Do you maintain any cash concentration mechanism like depository transfer check automated clearing house and wire transfer
i
Annexure
Yaseer Rizvi Our position in this case is very strong as we use all the mechanisms
you mentioned As Virgin is a firm with small deposits spread over a substantial
number of banks so we tend to use depository transfer checks extensively It is less
costly We also use automated clearing house and wire transfer but later is used in a
less extent
Shah Kamal Sir what techniques of disbursement management is used by your firm
Yaseer Rizvi Like other firms Virgin tries to retain the cash for as long as possible
But we always perform it in an ethical manner We do not use management of
disbursement float as it seems unethical We follow Zero-Balance Accounts method
for managing disbursement We do not prefer Controlled Disbursing method since
Zero-Balance system is already practiced in Virgin
Shah Kamal How do you hedge cash balance uncertainties
Yaseer Rizvi Well you may say that we do not invest in short term securities but for
facing cash difficulties we keep our surplus cash in bank
Shah Kamal Sir would you please tell me the general terms of sale of Virgin
Yaseer Rizvi Though it is difficult to maintain a fixed terms of sale our general terms
of sale is 210 n30 But for prime customers we offer special terms of sale
Shah Kamal What are the sources of credit information in case of your firm
Yaseer Rizvi We grant credit on the basis of prior experience with the customers In
case of a new customer personal contact is weighted
Shah Kamal Does your firm consider 5 Cs in granting credit
ii
Annexure
Yaseer Rizvi In case of Virgin Capital and Character get more importance than the
others Mind one thing personal relationship is the main measure in granting credit
Shah Kamal Do you use NPV method in credit granting decisions
Yaseer Rizvi We do not use NPV method But we think that NPV is a suitable
method and we have to use it from the next period
Shah Kamal Sir how do you handle the problem of bad debt
Yaseer Rizvi Well in this case our position is very strong Yet we do not face any
problem because of bad debt Just note that we make more than 80 of sales in cash
and we monitor accounts receivable very carefully
Shah Kamal What level of inventory is maintained by Virgin
Yaseer Rizvi We maintain a minimum level of inventory but do not have to face
stock out problems because inventory is managed efficiently
Shah Kamal What is the normal lead time
Yaseer Rizvi In case of imported goods normal lead time is about 1 month and when
we purchase raw materials from inside the country lead time is 1 to 3 days
Shah Kamal What method do you use for managing inventory
Yaseer Rizvi We do not use any method particularly rather inventory decision
depends on business cycle and market situation Long before the Eid festival we
bought large amount of sugar because price of sugar was increased on the occasion
of Eid
iii
Annexure
Shah Kamal What are the main items of inventory of your firm
Yaseer Rizvi Well these are ndash aluminum can pet chip sugar label chemical and
artificial sweet
Shah Kamal What are the uncertainties in maintaining appropriate level of stock
Yaseer Rizvi These are ndash
bull Increase in price of raw materials
bull Sales uncertainty
bull Market trends etc
Shah Kamal Thank you for your kind cooperation
Yaseer Rizvi Most Welcome
iv
Global Beverage Company Limited
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
5 WORKING CAPITAL MANAGEMENT
51 DEFINING WORKING CAPITAL
The term working capital refers to the amount of capital which is readily available to
an organization That is working capital is the difference between resources in cash
or readily convertible into cash (Current Assets) and organizational commitments for
which cash will soon be required (Current Liabilities)
Current Assets are resources which are in cash or will soon be converted into cash in
the ordinary course of business
Current Liabilities are commitments which will soon require cash settlement in the
ordinary course of business
Thus ndash
WORKING CAPITAL = CURRENT ASSETS - CURRENT LIABILITIES
In a firms Statement of Financial position these components of working capital are
reported under the following headings
Current Assets
Liquid Assets (cash and bank deposits)
Inventory
Debtors and Receivables
Current Liabilities
Bank Overdraft
Creditors and Payables
Other Short Term Liabilities
Page 4 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Working capital management involves the relationship between a firms short-term
assets and its short-term liabilities The goal of working capital management is to
ensure that a firm is able to continue its operations and that it has sufficient ability to
satisfy both maturing short-term debt and upcoming operational expenses The
management of working capital involves managing inventories accounts receivable
and payable and cash
52 WORKING CAPITAL POLICIES
The aim of working capital policy is to balance having too little working capital
which can lead to an inability to pay debts as they fall due or the need for expensive
short term borrowings and too much which is wasteful in terms of lost opportunities
for the funds tied up The crucial role of working capital is that it finances the goods
inwards production and sales activities
A firmrsquos working capital policy has two components
1 Policies regarding the appropriate level of current assets (Current Asset Investment Policy)
2 Policies regarding the use of short-term financing (Current Asset Financing Policy)
Alternative Current Asset Investment Policies
These policies are general strategies that firms may follow with regard to their overall
level of current assets investment or holdings There are three types
1 Relaxed Current Asset Investment Policy ndash
Relatively large amounts of cash marketable securities and inventories are carried
and sales are stimulated by a liberal (generous) trade credit policy resulting in high
levels of receivables This is a low risk strategy because the firm always has plenty of
cash and inventory on hand The return is low because more money is invested in
low yielding assets
Page 5 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
2 Restricted Current Asset Investment Policy ndash
Holdings of cash securities inventories and receivables are minimized This is a
high risk strategy because the firm tries to keep the bare minimum of cash and
inventory The potential return is high because less money is invested in low
yielding assets
3 Moderate Current Asset Policy ndash
Balance between relaxed and restricted current asset investment policies (moderate
risk - moderate potential return)
Alternative Current Asset Financing Policies
These policies are general strategies that firms may follow with regard to how current
assets are to be financed Current assets can be classified as permanent or temporary
Permanent current assets are the current assets that the company needs to maintain
throughout the entire year Temporary current assets are those that are due to
seasonal fluctuations With respect to the current asset financing policy the question
is how the permanent current assets will and temporary current assets are financed
(long-term or short-term financing)
Page 6 of 46
Aggressive Moderate Conservative
Cash Minimum holding Prepared to hold
some precautionary
balances
Prepared to hold idle
cash balances
Debtors and
stock
Minimum
consistent with
business needs
Moderate levels High stock and
debtor levels to
maximize sales
Creditors Maximum
available without
compromising
business needs
Moderate level Low level seeking
discounts and
reputation for good
payment
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Future cash
flows
Predictable Reasonably
predictable
Unpredictable
Attitude to
Risk
Accepting Neutral Rejecting
Total assets = Fixed Assets + Permanent Current Assets + Fluctuating Current Assets
53 WORKING CAPITAL CYCLE
Cash flows in a cycle into around and out of a business It is the businesss life blood
and every managers primary task is to help keep it flowing and to use the cash flow
to generate profits If a business is operating profitably then it should in theory
generate cash surpluses If it doesnt generate surpluses the business will eventually
run out of cash and expire
The faster a business expands the more cash it will need for working capital and
investment The cheapest and best sources of cash exist as working capital right
within business Good management of working capital will generate cash will help
improve profits and reduce risks
Working capital can be broken down into the following major components cash (or
bank overdraft) stock debtors creditors Each of these items can have a major
influence on the working capital (or simply cash) that any business requires on an
ongoing basis For example when a business starts up the owner may inject a
certain amount of cash into the business which will enable him to purchase his initial
stock pay his workers their first months wages and cover other overheads such as
rent He then sells his product and this income may be utilized to purchase more
stock pay more wages and overheads and perhaps even have a surplus over for his
own use The quicker he can turn his stock over to receive payment the sooner the
working capital cycle will be completed
Page 7 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Figure Working Capital Cycle
These major components of working capital are discussed below
531 CASH MANAGEMENT
The term cash management refers to the management of cash from the time it starts
its transit to the firm until it leaves the firm in payments Cash management
encompasses the design of collection and disbursement systems for cash and the
temporary investment of cash while it resides with the firm Widely used money
market instruments are-
Treasury bill
Commercial paper
Certificate of deposits
Bankerrsquos acceptance
Page 8 of 46
Repurchase agreement
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
5311 Motives for Holding Cash
Despite the seemingly low returns there are several good reasons why firms hold
cash and marketable securities These reasons are ndash
Cash for transactions
Cash and near cash assets as hedges
Temporary investment and
Compensating balances
5312 Components of Cash Management
A Cash Flow Statement shows the sources and uses of cash and is typically divided
into three components
Operating Cash Flow
Operating cash flow often referred to as working capital is the cash flow generated
from internal operations It comes from sales of the product or service of your
business and because it is generated internally it is under your control
Investing Cash Flow
Investing cash flow is generated internally from non-operating activities This
includes investments in plant and equipment or other fixed assets nonrecurring gains
or losses or other sources and uses of cash outside of normal operations
Financing Cash Flow
Financing cash flow is the cash to and from external sources such as lenders
investors and shareholders
Page 9 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
5313 Tools for Cash Management
Flotation and Check Clearing
Management of cash when it is not in the firmrsquos hands that is in transit to and from
the firm is on important function in the area of finance Transit times for the check
takes in three stages These are mail float at firm float and clearing float Normally
mail float takes 1 to 5 days at firm float takes 025 to 1 day and clearing float takes 0
to 2 days The firm should care about this process because every delay in the receipt
of money by the firm lowers the firmrsquos returns and therefore its shareholdersrsquo wealth
There are several strategies that firm can use to reduce the delay in receiving funds
Each of these strategies addresses one or more of the three float times (mail float
time at time float time and clearing float time) that make up the total transit time of
fund from one firm to another
Other Cash Management Tools
When the economy is strong companies can lapse into sloppy cash-management
practices Firm should try exploring these options
1 Sweep accounts
These bank accounts are the easiest way to generate some income from companys
spare funds however they make sense only if the money youll earn will be greater
than the fees your bank will charge Business owners have two types of sweep
accounts to choose between
Page 10 of 46
Controlled-investment accounts These are the most profitable form of
sweep account but they wont work for company if the firm has any
electronic payments or wire transfers since those may be submitted for
payment later in the day and the account wont have enough cash in it to
cover them
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Page 11 of 46
End-of-day sweep accounts A safer bet for most small-business owners
these accounts wait until a late-hour cutoff to determine how much to
sweep into the firms overnight investments Typically their investment
yields are 10 to 20 basis points (1 to 2 of the investment) lower than
those offered with controlled investments
2 Lock-box accounts
A lock box is a cash-management system that helps the firm collect funds quickly
Generally set up with the assistance of a big money center or regional bank lock
boxes provide the firm with a special zip code and usually quicker deliveries from
regional post offices They are especially important if the firm has clusters of
customers in out-of-state locations and dont want to lose days waiting for their
checks to arrive by long-distance mail
5314 Cash Concentration and Cash Disbursement
Once the remittances from the firmrsquos customers have been received and cleared the
resulting cash balances is available in the firmrsquos lockbox (depository) banks It is
useful for the firm to gather these balances from the lockbox banks into the central
bank account The process of collecting funds is called cash concentration
Several concentration mechanism are available for the firm to use in transferring
funds from its collection banks to regional concentration banks and from there to the
central concentration bank These mechanisms differ in cost and in the availability of
funds that they provide These are ndash
a) Depository Transfer Check
It is the cheapest transfer mechanism This document instructs one bank to
send funds to another and is treated the same as any other check
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
b) Automated Clearing House (ACH) Electronic Transfer
This vehicle is essentially an electronic version of the depository transfer
check and can be used between banks that participate in the automated
clearing house system
c) Wire Transfer
These are electronic message between banks
Decisions regarding concentration mechanism usually hinge on the size and
spread of the firmrsquos deposits Firms with small deposits spread over a
substantial number of banks will tend to have more extensive concentration
systems and will transfer among accounts using low-cost transfer vehicles that
offer only delayed availability (such as depository transfer checks) Firms with
larger deposits will have fewer accounts (since a local deposit for transfer to
an upstream bank is not needed) and will use more expensive and more rapid
transfer mechanisms (such as wire transfers) The concentration systems of
major chemical companies for example tend to be structured in this way ndash
DepositoryLockbox Banks
Regional Concentration Banks
Central Concentrated Bank
Figure A typical Cash Concentration System
(Arrows indicate transfers of collected funds)
Page 12 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Disbursement management addresses the efficient payout out of this cash once it is
concentrated The firmrsquos objective in disbursement management is to retain the cash
for as long as possible In this way the firm will have the maximum amount of funds
available for investment and transactional purposes Certainly this management
means making disbursement only when they are due and not before The firm has
several available set of techniques for disbursement management Included among
these are ndash
a) Management of Disbursement Float
In this set of techniques the disbursing firm attempts to increase the length of
time between the mailing of its checks and the eventual withdrawal of funds
from the banks This involves strategies for increasing mail float at firm float
and clearing float on its outgoing checks For example the disbursing firm
may intentionally address checks to the firmrsquos office address rather than its
lockbox creating at firm float
b) Zero-Balance Accounts
Here the firm holds the cash until the check arrive (or expected to arrive) at
the disbursement bank In this strategy an account for disbursement is first
established at a bank For the zero-balance system to be effective the
participating bank must be one on which most disbursement are made via the
Bangladesh Bankrsquos clearance system (which presents disbursements to banks
early in the morning) and not a bank where disbursements occur throughout
the day (as with a major money-center bank) Consequently the banks used
in zero-balance strategies are usually branches of major banks and not their
main locations
Page 13 of 46
c) Controlled Disbursing
In this system the firm projects the amount of checks to arrive each day at the
disbursement bank (based on the checks written in previous days and historic
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
statistics on disbursement float) and transfers the amount of the expected
checks to the account on that day or just before
5315 Cash Forecasting
Defining Cash Forecasting
The cash forecast is an estimation of the flows in and out of the firmrsquos cash account
over a particular period of time usually a quarter month week or day The cash
forecast is primarily intended to produce a very useful piece of information an
estimation of the firmrsquos borrowing and lending needs and uncertainties regarding
these needs during various future periods Cash forecasting is very crucial to most
firms It enables them to anticipate periods of surplus cash and periods where
financing will be necessary This anticipation is the reason that cash forecasts are
generated Anticipation enables the firm to plan much more effectively for
investment and financing and via this planning produce superior return
Types of Cash Forecasts
The types of cash forecasts generated by firms can be differentiated along two
dimensions the length of the periods included within the cash forecast and the approach
to cash flows used in the cash forecast The length of the period refers to the units of
time into which the cash forecast is divided Firms may make cash flow forecasts
over periods of various lengths yearly flows quarterly flows monthly flows weekly
flows or even daily flows The most popular forecast involves monthly flows but
most firms do not confine themselves to a single forecast Instead they use several
forecasts with periods of various lengths When the firm makes forecasts involving
multiple and overlapping period lengths one forecast relates to another Starting
with data on relatively long periods and breaking it down into smaller periods is
called distribution starting with data on relatively short periods and aggregating into
longer periods is called scheduling
Page 14 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Firms use two common approaches to cash flows in generating the cash forecast the
receipts and disbursements approach and the adjusted net income approach The receipts
and disbursements approach use the amounts of cash expected to be received and
disbursed by the firm over the periods chosen for forecast The adjusted income
statement approach is sometimes called the sources and use approach Here the
forecaster starts with projected net income on an accrual basis and adjusts to a cash
basis This method provides a representation of changes in asset and liability
accounts since the level of these accounts are of interest to the firm this aspect of the
adjusted income statement is an advantage over the receipts and disbursements
method
Items to Be Forecast
In the receipt and disbursements cash forecasting method estimates need to be made
of the numerous major and minor items that the firm collects (receipts) and that it
pays (disbursements) The more individual categories of items the firm includes in its
forecast procedure the more accurate the forecast may be but the more costly in
terms of time and effort it will be to generate
Some Possible Types of Cash Receipts and Cash Disbursements
Cash Disbursements Cash Receipts
Cash Purchases of Materials Payroll
Taxes
Maturing Accounts Payable
Maturing Notes Payable
Miscellaneous Disbursements
Accounts Receivable
Notes Receivable
Rental Income
Interest Income
Miscellaneous Receipts
Methods of Financial Forecasting
Page 15 of 46
Financial forecasting is the estimation of the future level of a financial variable often
a cash flow asset level or liability level It is usually assumed that the relationship
between the financial variable and other variable is linear The general linear model
can then be used
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
nnt xaxaxaaY 22110 ++=
Here
= Financial variable (Y) to be forecast in period t tY
x = Explanatory variable it is assumed to cause the level of Y in period t
0a = Represents a constant unaffected by the x
The other terms are the estimated coefficients of the explanatory x variables
There are n terms with xrsquos in them
There are four common approaches to forecasting financial variables but they
are all special cases of the general linear model These are ndash spot method proportion
to another account compounded growth and multiple dependencies
Using Cash Forecast
The estimate of available funds for investment and needed financing enables the firm
to plan so as to obtain the most advantages borrowing terms for deficits and achieve
the greatest interest income on surplus A useful chart for this planning purpose is a
bar chart eg
Figure Bar Chart of Cash Surpluses and Deficits from hypothetical data
Page 16 of 46
75
50
-60
30
100
-20
-80-60-40-20
020406080
100120
Defic
it
S
urpl
us
January February March April May June
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Sources of Uncertainty in Cash Forecasting and Hedging Uncertainties
There are numerous sources of risk in cash forecasting Among the sources are sales
uncertainty collection rate uncertainty production cost uncertainty and capital
outflow uncertainty
5316 Models for the Management of Cash and Temporary Investments
There are different models for the management of cash and temporary investments
Among these the most popular methods are ndash Baumol model Beranek model
Miller-Orr model and Stone model
Baumol and Beranek use the same model The formula is cited below ndash
Interest Income = iYn
n⎥⎦⎤
⎢⎣⎡ minus
21
Profit = naiYn
nminus⎥⎦
⎤⎢⎣⎡ minus
21
Optimum number of transactions = ⎟⎠⎞
⎜⎝⎛
aiY2
Where n = Optimum number of transactions
i = Interest rate per period
a = Transaction cost
Y = Total inflow for the period
Page 17 of 46
Miller-Orr and Stone use the same model ie R-Statistic The model is ndash
31
43
iav
R ⎟⎠⎞
⎜⎝⎛=
Optimum Control Limit = R + L
Upper Control Limit = 3R + L
Where a = Transaction Cost
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
v = Variance of daily cash flows
i = Daily interest rate
5317 Administration
Cash receipts should be processed and banked as quickly as possible because
They cannot earn interest or reduce overdraft until they are banked
information about the existence and amounts of cash receipts is usually not
available until they are processed
Where possible cash floats (mainly petty cash and advances) should be avoided If
on review the only reason that can be put forward for their existence is that weve
always had them they should be discontinued There may be situations where they
are useful however For example it may be desirable for peripheral parts of
departments to meet urgent local needs from cash floats rather than local bank
accounts
5318 Internal Control
Cash and cash management is part of a firms overall internal control system The
main internal cash control is invariably the bank reconciliation This provides
assurance that the cash balances recorded in the accounting systems are consistent
with the actual bank balances It requires regular clearing of reconciling items
5319 Practicing Good Cash Flow Management
Good cash management is simple It involves
Knowing when where and how firms cash needs will occur
Page 18 of 46
Knowing the best sources for meeting additional cash needs
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Page 19 of 46
Being prepared to meet these needs when they occur by keeping good
relationships with bankers and other creditors
532 INVENTORY MANAGEMENT
Inventory management is necessary for owners who want to maintain a stocking
service for quick turnaround to help ensure total customer satisfaction The fill rate
of an item on a managed inventory list must be maintained to avoid shortages of
frequently used items Even when utilizing an inventory management system
occasional shortages will still occur Inventories are lists of stocks-raw materials
work in progress or finished goods-waiting to be consumed in production or to be
sold The total balance of inventory is the sum of the value of each individual stock
line
Basically firms hold stocks for the following reasons
To act as a buffer in times of unusually high demand
To ensure continuity of production
Avoid high costs of emergency orders
To take advantage of quantity discounts by ordering more at a time
To reduce ordering costs by ordering more items on fewer
As part of the production process eg maturing whisky or keeping oil in
pipelines
Seasonality of demand (eg firework) or supplies
Suppliers insist on minimum order quantities
The key issue for a business is to identify the fast and slow stock movers with the
objectives of establishing optimum stock levels for each category and thereby
minimize the cash tied up in stocks Factors to be considered when determining
optimum stock levels include
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Page 20 of 46
What are the projected sales of each product
How widely available are raw materials components etc
How long does it take for delivery by suppliers
Can the firm remove slow movers from its product range without
compromising best sellers
Inventory management is an important aspect of working capital management
because inventories themselves do not earn any revenue Holding either too little or
too much inventory incurs costs
Costs of carrying too much inventory are
Opportunity cost of foregone interest
Warehousing costs
Damage and pilferage
Obsolescence
Insurance
Costs of carrying too little inventory are
Stock out costs
Lost sales
Delayed service
Ordering costs
Freight
on Order administrati
nts
Loss of quantity discou
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Carrying costs can be minimized by making frequent small orders but this increase
ordering costs and the risk of stock outs Risk of stock-outs can be reduced by
carrying safety stocks (at a cost) and re-ordering ahead of time
The best ordering strategy requires balancing the various cost factors to ensure the
firm incurs minimum inventory costs The optimum inventory position is known as
the Economic Reorder Quantity (ERQ)
Nowadays many large manufacturers operate on a just-in-time (JIT) basis whereby
all the components to be assembled on a particular today arrive at the factory early
that morning no earlier - no later This helps to minimize manufacturing costs as JIT
stocks take up little space minimize stock-holding and virtually eliminate the risks of
obsolete or damaged stock Because JIT manufacturers hold stock for a very short
time they are able to conserve substantial cash JIT is a good model to strive for as it
embraces all the principles of prudent stock management For better stock control
firm may try the following
Review the effectiveness of existing purchasing and inventory systems
Know the stock turn for all major items of inventory
Apply tight controls to the significant few items and simplify controls for the
trivial many
Sell off outdated or slow moving merchandise - it gets more difficult to sell the
longer the firm keeps it
Consider having part of its product outsourced to another manufacturer rather
than make it itself
Review its security procedures to ensure that no stock is going out the back
door
Higher than necessary stock levels tie up cash and cost more in insurance
accommodation costs and interest charges
Page 21 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
However it is important to keep an overall perspective It is not cost-effective to
closely manage a large number of low value inventory lines nor is it necessary A
usual feature of inventories is that a small number of high value lines account for a
large proportion of inventory value The 8020 rule (PARETO) predicts that 80
of the total value of inventory is represented by only 20 of the number of inventory
items Those high value lines need reasonably close management The remaining
80 of inventory lines can be managed using broad-brush strategies
533 MANAGING ACCOUNTS RECEIVABLE (DEBTORS)
Cash flow can be significantly enhanced if the amounts owing to a business are
collected faster Every business needs to know who owes them money how much is
owed how long it is owing for what it is owed
Debtors (Accounts Receivable) are customers who have not yet made payment for
goods or services which the department has provided The objective of debtor
management is to minimize the time-lapse between completion of sales and receipt
of payment The costs of having debtors are
Opportunity costs (cash is not available for other purposes)
Bad debts
If firm doesnt manage debtors they will begin to manage business as the firm will gradually
lose control due to reduced cash flow and of course it could experience an increased
incidence of bad debt The following measures will help manage debtors
Having the right mental attitude to the control of credit and make sure that it
gets the priority it deserves
Establishing clear credit practices as a matter of company policy
Page 22 of 46
Making sure that these practices are clearly understood by staff suppliers and
customers
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Page 23 of 46
Being professional when accepting new accounts and especially larger ones
Checking out each customer thoroughly before the firm offers credit Use
credit agencies bank references industry sources etc
Establishing credit limits for each customer and sticking to them
Continuously reviewing these limits when it suspects tough times are coming
or if operating in a volatile sector
Keeping very close to the firms larger customers
Invoicing promptly and clearly
Considering charging penalties on overdue accounts
Considering accepting credit debit cards as a payment option
Monitoring its debtor balances and ageing schedules and dont let any debts
get too large or too old
Debtor management includes both pre-sale and debt collection strategies
Pre-sale strategies include
Offering cash discounts for early payment andor imposing penalties for late
payment
Agreeing payment terms in advance
Requiring cash before delivery
Setting credit limits
ning credit Setting criteria for obtai
Billing as early as possible
rogress payments
ost-sale strategies include
for collecting the debt upon the center that made the sale
Requiring deposits andor p
P
Placing the responsibility
Identifying long overdue balances and doubtful debts by regular analytical reviews
Having an established procedure for late collections such as
A reminder
A letter
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Page 24 of 46
ion of further credit Cancellat
Telephone calls
n agency Use of a collectio
he firm should recognize that the longer someone owes firm the greater the chance
Legal action
T
it will never get paid If the average age of debtors is getting longer or is already very
long it may need to look for the following possible defects
Weak credit judgment
res Poor collection procedu
ms Lax enforcement of credit ter
Slow issue of invoices or statements
Errors in invoices or statements
Customer dissatisfaction
Debtors due over 90 days (unless within agreed credit terms) should generally
demand immediate attention For example warning signs of a future bad debt ndash
Longer credit terms taken with approval particularly for smaller orders
Use of post-dated checks by debtors who normally settle within agreed terms
Evidence of customers switching to additional suppliers for the same goods
New customers who are reluctant to give credit references
Cre G
Receiving part payments from debtors
dit ranting to Marginal Accounts
Traditional Approach
In the traditional approach to the credit granting decision it is the credit analysts job
rmation that has been collected and reach a judgment
regarding the applicants creditworthiness One traditional way of organizing this
to synthesize all the info
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
information is by characterizing the applicant along five dimensions These
dimensions are called the Five Cs of credit ndash
Capital
Character
Collateral
and Capacity
Conditions
Net Present Value (NPV) Approach
Once a firm has assessed the creditworthiness of a customer it has to decide whether
r not credit should be granted The firm should use the NPV rule to make the
ld be granted
Figure
o
decision If NPV is positive credit shou
Credit Granting Decision
Credit Granting Decision
he act of collecting money is one which most people dislike for many reasons and
therefore put on the long f selves there is something
ore urgent or important that demands their attention now There is nothing more
T
inger because they convince them
m
important than getting paid for firms product or service A customer who does not
Page 25 of 46
Grand Credit
Payment received Payment not received
Benefit of present value of future net cash flow
Cost of present value ment of lost invest
Net Payoff PV of benefit-cost
No Credit
No Payoff
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
pay is not a customer Here are a few ideas that may help the firm in collecting
money from debtors
Firm should develop appropriate procedures for handling late payments
It should track and pursue late payers
It might get external help if its own efforts fail
or money its firms and it is entitled Company shouldnt feel guilty asking f
to it
ction
Firm must make that call now And it should keep asking until it gets some
satisfa
lessens the problem
In difficult circumstances take what the firm can now and agree terms for the
remainder It
paying
When asking for money be hard on the issue - but soft on the person It shouldnt
give the debtor any excuses for not
534 BLE (CREDITORS)
ices for goods or services have
een paid Organizations often regard the
not
to delay all payments until the latest possible date Regular weekly or
The firm make it its objective is to get the money - not to score points or get
even
MANAGING ACCOUNTS PAYA
Creditors (Accounts Payable) are suppliers whose invo
been processed but who have not yet b
amount owing to creditors as a source of free credit However creditor
administration systems are expensive and time-consuming to run The over-riding
concern in this area should be to minimize costs with simple procedures
While it is unnecessary to pay accounts before they fall due it is usually
worthwhile
Page 26 of 46
fortnightly payment of all due accounts is the simplest technique for creditor
management
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Electronic payments (direct credits) are cheaper than check payments considering
that transaction fees and overheads more than balance the advantage of delayed
presentation Some suppliers are reluctant to receive payments by this method but in
view of the substantial cost advantage (and the advantages to the suppliers
themselves) departments may wish to encourage suppliers to accept this option
However electronic payments are likely to be used in conjunction with rather than
as a replacement for check payments
Applying Best Practices in Managing Accounts Payable
f course simply deferring payments to suppliers could have adverse consequences
O
that more than offset the benefits of this additional cash flow Therefore it is
important to develop a holistic approach The firm should consider the following
best practices for payables management
Managing payment dates and terms to maximize cash flow ndash
y reporting on
receivable and
id penalty charges and taking advantage of
wer vendors and negotiate for more
to buying consortia with others even
voices for
payment based on receipt of goods or receipt of invoice whichever
comes later
Calculating and setting performance targets Regularl
AP performance measures such as days in payables
Coordinating the AP processes with accounts
inventory management to ensure that the company is collecting more
cash than it is paying out
Paying bills on time to avo
prompt-payment discounts where the discounts exceed the companyrsquos
cost of working capital
Consolidating purchases with fe
favorable payment terms
Considering entering in
Page 27 of 46
competitors to obtain favorable supplier pricing and terms
Unless contract terms specify otherwise setting up in
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Page 28 of 46
Em
process
-time payments with Electronic Funds Transfer (EFT)
uraging vendors to utilize electronic invoice presentment
a
ndancies and more
ploying technology to automate the accounts payable transaction
es ndash
Making just-in
Using an electronic invoice-matching application
Enco
For companies with multiple locations or business units employing
shared service approach for AP to eliminate redu
quickly implement process improvements
Mainta
vendor
Communicating accounts payable requirements to suppliers at the
m key suppliers
for suggestions on how to improve the
Efficient a
and making th rsquos cash is just good business
ining open communications and building strong relationships with
s to access valuable trade credit ndash
beginning of transactions
Requesting summary invoicing fro
Requiring suppliers to send invoices directly to accounts payable
Asking tier-one suppliers
payment process
nd effective management of accounts payable helps improve cash flow ndash
e most of company
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
6 OVERVIEW OF VIRGIN GROUP
Virgin - one of the most respected brands in Britain - is now becoming the first global
brand name of the 21st century Virgin is involved in planes trains finance soft
drinks music mobile phones holidays cars wines publishing bridal wear - the lot
What tie all these businesses together are the values of its brand and the attitude of its
people Virgin has created over 200 companies worldwide employing over 25000
people Its total revenues around the world in 2002 exceeded pound4 billion (US $72
billion)
In 1970 Richard Branson founded Virgin as a mail order record retailer and not
long after he opened a record shop in Oxford Street London During 1972 a
recording studio was built in Oxfordshire and the first Virgin artist Mike Oldfield
recorded Tubular Bells which was released in 1973
This album went on to sell over 5 million copies Since then many household names
including Belinda Carlisle Genesis Phil Collins Janet Jackson and The Rolling
Stones have helped to make Virgin Music one of the top six record companies in the
world The equity of Virgin Music Group - record labels music publishing and
recording studios was sold to THORN EMI in 1992 in a US$1billion deal
Page 29 of 46
The Virgin Group has now expanded into international music Mega stores air
travel mobile financial retail music internet drinks rail hotels and leisure with
around 200 companies in over 30 countries
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
In Virgins customers eyes Virgin stands for value for money quality innovation
fun and a sense of competitive challenge It delivers a quality service by empowering
its employees and facilitates and monitors customer feedback to continually improve
the customers experience through innovation
When they start a new venture Virgin bases it on hard research and analysis
Typically they review the industry and put themselves in the customers shoes to see
what could make it better Virgin asks fundamental questions
Is this an opportunity for restructuring a market and creating competitive
advantage What are the competitors doing
Is the customer confused or badly served
Is this an opportunity for building the Virgin brand
Can we add value
Will it interact with its other businesses
Is there an appropriate trade-off between risk and reward
Page 30 of 46
Virgin is also able to draw on talented people from throughout the group New
ventures are often steered by people seconded from other parts of Virgin who bring
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
with them the trademark management style skills and experience Virgin frequently
creates partnerships with others to combine skills knowledge and market presence
and so on Contrary to what some people may think their constantly expanding and
eclectic empire is neither random nor reckless Each successive venture demonstrates
its skill in picking the right market and the right opportunity
7 OVERVIEW OF VIRGIN SOFT DRINKS
The Virgin Drinks Group first launched as the Virgin Cola Company in 1994 with
Virgin Cola in the UK Since then the company has ventured across the carbonated
soft drinks arena and beyond into energy drinks tea and flavored Colas This
expansion has lead to the evolution of the Virgin Drinks Company a company
whose aim is to put the excitement back into the world of soft drinks It launched in
Bangladesh in 1999 Virgin Soft Drinks is monitored by Global Beverage Co Ltd in
Bangladesh
Brief history of Virgin Drinks is given below
Page 31 of 46
1994 November Virgin Cola launched in the UK
1996 March Virgin Cola launched in France
1998 June Virgin Cola launched in Belgium
April Virgin Cola launched in the French West Indies
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
August Virgin Cola launched in Switzerland
1999 March Virgin Colours launched in Italy
March Virgin Cola launched in Japan
July Virgin Colours launched in South Africa
December Virgin Colours launched in Bangladesh
2001 January Sweden launched Virgin Colours
November Singapore launched Virgin Colours
2002 February Croatia launched Virgin Colours
June Russia launched Virgin Colours
June Tunisia launched Virgin Colours
2003 May Israel launched Virgin Colours
8 FINDINGS OF WORKING CAPITAL MANAGEMENT MAINTAINED BY
VIRGIN SOFT DRINKS IN BANGLADESH
81 CASH MANAGEMENT
811 Holding Cash and Marketable Securities
Although there are many good reasons why firm hold cash and marketable
securities Virgin Drinks holds cash and marketable securities for two reasons ndash
i) Cash for transactions
ii) Cash as hedges
This indicates that the firm does not hold cash and marketable securities for some
important reasons such as ndash
i) Near cash assets as hedges
Page 32 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
ii) Temporary investment and compensating balances
Virgin Soft Drinks does not invest in money market securities such as Treasury bill
commercial paper certificate of deposits bankerrsquos acceptance and repurchase
agreement This firm deposits its money in bank as currant AC or fixed AC They
say that they do not have enough money to invest in money market instrument
They also say that if they have enough money they will invest it in money market
short term securities We know that near cash interest earning assets can be
substituted for cash when motivation for holding these assets is the hedging of cash
flow uncertainties or is the temporary investment of surplus funds In this point
Virgins position is not good as there is no significant hedging against uncertainty of
cash
812 Floatation and Check Clearing
Virgin is very smart in handling the problem of transit time for checks Here mail
float takes 2 to 3 days at firm takes 025 day and clearing float takes 1-3 days Virgin
uses most of the strategies available for reducing the delay in receiving funds It
(Virgin) has linked Islami Bank which posses an accelerated clearing facility It uses
electronic collection process which ensures faster collection and its at the firm check
processing is satisfactory But Virgin does not use lockbox The reason behind this is
that it is not cost-effective for Virgin to set lockboxes At this point we can say that
Virgins check clearing mechanism is much good
813 Cash Concentration and Disbursement Management
Page 33 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks takes the matter of cash concentration very seriously They use all
the available cash concentration mechanism Virgin is a firm with small deposits
spread over a substantial number of banks and this is why the firm tends to use
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
depository transfer checks extensively If is less costly Virgin also uses automated
clearing house and wire transfer To Virgin wire transfer seems too costly
Like other firm Virgin tries to retain the cash for as long as possible But Virgin
always performs it in an ethical manner Virgin does not try to defeat the receiving
firmrsquos attempts to reduce the float on incoming checks It does not take any strategy
for increasing mail float at firm float and clearing float on its outgoing checks To
Virgin it is deemed to be unethical It thinks that maximization of disbursement float
will not go unnoticed by sophisticated creditors for very long When it is noticed it
will negatively affect relations with these creditors reducing the firmrsquos bargaining
power with them This may ultimately cost Virgin dearly when future prices and
delivery schedules for goods and services purchased from trade creditors are
negotiated Virgin follows ldquoZero-Balance Accountsrdquo methods for managing
disbursement It thinks that in this method the coordination of funds inflows to
disbursement banks with the presentation of checks does not work to the detriment
of creditors since the firmrsquos checks to them are honored as presented and this strategy
does not affect float significantly Controlled disbursing method is less attractive to
Virgin because zero-balance system is already feasible
814 Cash Forecasting
Cash Forecasting and Its Types
Page 34 of 46
Virgin forecasts the future cash inflows and outflows To Virgin cash forecast is an
important part of the firmrsquos cash control system and is one of the forecasts that are
part of the Virginrsquos financial plan Virgin forecasts cash on monthly basis and on
yearly basis Virgin does not forecast on daily basis assuming that the temporary
shortage of funds within these periods can be covered without value cost eg
advance receipts from customers Virginrsquos cash forecasting system involves a
combination of distribution and scheduling The receipts and disbursements
approach of cash forecasting is used in virgin This method is used because it
minutely traces the movement of cash and very close control of cash is possible
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Virgin does not use adjusted net income approach on two grounds First it does not
permit the tracing of the individual types of cash inflows and outflows for any given
period which is often useful information for virgin Second it is not simple to use
Items to be Forecast
Virgin does not forecast all the items It forecasts only major items eg accounts
receivable notes receivable payroll cash purchases of raw materials In this regard
virgin trade off between cost and benefit
Methods of Financial Forecasting
Virgin forecasts the future level of financial variable such as cash level asset level or
liability level We know in short term forecasts many things will result from plans
and events that are already in place (contracts capital budgets long-range financing
plans and so forth) But in the long run most things can vary and are dependent on
outside influences such as the firmrsquos long-term growth rate Since Virginrsquos cash
forecasting deals mostly with near future many of the items on the cash forecasts are
estimated by some variation of the spot method and remaining estimates are mostly
on a ldquoproportion of another accountrdquo basis with this ldquoother accountrdquo often being a
particular periodrsquos sales Virgin uses the other two methods less frequently
Using Cash Forecast
Virgin forecasts cash for meeting general objectives (ie to know the available funds
for investment and need financing) and for meeting some special objectives (eg to
know whether the firm will fulfill its out of debt requirement) But it is matter to note
that Virgin does not make any short term investment of its surplus cash but only keep
this surplus in Bank Account
Page 35 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Sources of Uncertainty in Cash Forecasting and Hedging Uncertainties
Virgin faces uncertainty in cash forecasting mainly from two sources These are ndash
sales and production cost In peak season (hot season like autumn summer) sales
increases but in dull season (eg in winter) sales decreases drastically Production
cost may be increased because of increase of price of sugar chemicals aluminum
can Virgin follows two methods for hedging cash balance uncertainties These are ndash
i) Holding a stock of extra cash and
ii) Extra borrowing capacity
815 Modes for the Management of Cash and Temporary Investments
Virgin does not follow any of these methods wholly Virgin receives cash
continuously and pays salary at steady rate and pays continuously for other
expenses So it neither follows Baumol model nor Beranek model It has no upper
control limit lower control limit return point in case cash management So it neither
follows Miller-Orr model nor Stone model
In Summary
Page 36 of 46
Standard Compliance by Virgin Soft Drinks
Generally all firms hold cash and
marketable securities
Virgin holds only cash
Firms hold cash and marketable
securities for some reasons like
bull Cash for transactions
bull Cash and near-cash assets as
hedges
bull Temporary investments
bull Compensating balances
Virgin holds cash only for
two reasons ndash
bull Cash for transactions
bull Cash as hedges
Available money market instruments Virgin does not invest in any such
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
(short term securities) are ndash
Treasury Bills
Commercial Paper
Certificates of Deposit
Bankerrsquos Acceptance
Repurch menase Agree ts
instruments They only keep cash in
Bank Account
Mail Float
(1 to 5 days)
At Firm
Float
(025 to 1
day)
Clearing
Float
(0 to
2 days)
Mail Float
(2 to 3 days)
At firm
Float
(025
day)
Clearing
Float
(1 to 3
days)
Figure Transit time for a typical check Figure Transit time for a check for
Virgin
Strategies that firms can use to reduce
the delay in receiving funds are ndash
Selecting of Banks with
accelerated clearing capabilities
of check processing Acceleration
at the firm
ectronic collection Use of el
procedures
Use of lockboxes
Virgin follows the first three strategies
but does not use lockboxes
Available cash concentration
mechanisms are ndash
Depository transfer check
ouse Automated Clearing H
(ACH) electronic transfer)
Wire transfer
Virgin uses all these mechanisms of
cash concentration
Available sets of techniques for cash
disbursement management are ndash
ement of disbursement
Page 37 of 46
Manag
float
Virgin uses zero-balance accounts
technique
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Zero-Balance Accounts
Controlled disbursing
Firms may make cash flow forecasts
over periods of various lengths yearly
flows quarterly flows monthly flows
weekly flows or even daily flows
Virgin forecasts cash on yearly basis and
monthly basis
Cash forecasting system may involve ndash
Distribution
Scheduling
Virginrsquos cash forecasting system
involves a combination of distribution
and scheduling
Two common approaches to cash flow
in generating the cash forecast
and disbursement Receipts
approach
Adjusted net income approach
Virgin uses the receipts and
disbursement approach
There are many items to forecast Virgin forecasts only major items like
AR payroll etc
Four common approach to forecasting
fina i ndash nc al variables are
Spot method
Proportion to another account
Compounded growth
Multiple dependencies
Virgin uses spot method for forecasting
cash It uses proportion to another
account method for other variables and
remaining two methods are frequently
used
Sources of uncertainty in cash
forecasting are ndash
Sales uncertainty
Collection rate uncertainty
Production cost uncertainty
Capital outflow uncertainty
Virgin faces uncertainty mainly from
sales and production cost
Methods for hedging cash balance
unc a
Page 38 of 46
ert inties are ndash
i) Holding a stock of extra cash
Virgin two available methods for
hedging cash balance uncertainties
Th ese are ndash
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
ii) stock of near-cash Holding a
assets
iii) Extra borrowing capacity
iv) ary surpluses in Investing tempor
near-cash assets
i) Holding a stock of extra cash
ii) Extra borrowing capacity
(advance receipt from
customers)
Models for the management of cash and
temporary investments are ndash Baumol
model Beranek model Miller-Orr
model and Stone model
Virgin does not follow any method
wholly but a combination of Baumol
model and Beranek model is occurred
82 INVENTORY MANAGEMENT
21 Certainty Approach
isnt used in
irgin because it thinks it is not possible to implement in Bangladesh
d time is one to three days It
oes not use ABC system of inventory management
8
Main item of inventory of Virgin is Can pet chip sugar label chemical artificial
sweet etc Virgin maintains a minimum level of inventory but it does not have to face
problems because inventory is managed efficiently just-in-time (JIT)
V
Virgin maintains buffer stock because of the shortage of work-in-process (WIP)
inventory Its production process may also be hampered Thats why it maintains
safety stock to avoid stock out cost In case of imported goods normal lead time is
about one month and within the country normal lea
d
Page 39 of 46
Inventory Model
In reality Virgin does not use any of models of EOQ ordering and holding strategy
and safety stock strategy They maintain inventory based on their prior experience
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
822 Uncertainty Approach
Virgin does not use any model for handling inventory uncertainty It says that such
decision depends on business cycle and market situation Long before Eid festival
they bought large amount of sugar because of price increase on the occasion of Eid
In summary
Standard Compliance by Virgin Soft Drinks
Firms maintain inventory to guard
against several problems
Virgin maintains a minimum level of
inventory which is managed efficiently
Some firms use JIT to avoid inventory
cost
JIT is not used by Virgin as it thinks it is
impossible to implement in Bangladesh
Firms maintain buffer stock Virgin maintains buffer stock too
Firms maintain safety stock to avoid
shortage cost
Virgin also maintains safety stock
Firms use ABC system to monitor
inventory
Virgin doesnt use ABC system
EOQ model is an appropriate method
for measuring quantity that has to be
ordered per order
Virgin does not use EOQ model rather
makes order based on experience and
market demand
83 MANAGING ACCOUNTS RECEIVABLE (DEBTORS)
831 Terms of Sale Decision
Page 40 of 46
Virgin offers the term 210 net 30 enables the customers to deduct 2 percent from the
face value of the bill when paying within the first 10 days but if the discount is not
taken the customer must remit the full amount within 30 days But Virgin does not
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
offer the same terms of sale to all customers For prime customers it offers special
terms of sale In setting an appropriate term of sale it costs and benefits regarding
this are compared It uses the standard approach of terms of sale decision as it is
simple to use
832 Credit Granting Decisions
In case of Virgin the Capital and Character of Five Cs get more importance
Although there are many problems with the traditional approach Virgin uses it
because of its simplicity Virgin does not use Net Present Value (NPV) method in
credit granting decision It thinks that NPV is an appropriate method and should be
used next time It does not face any severe problem because of bad debts The reason
is that notes receivable is used when credit is granted
833 Monitoring Accounts Receivable
Virgin monitors its accounts receivable Virgin believes that in any case both positive
and negative durations in accounts signal differences from the results that
management believe to be the most advantageous for the firm
Tools for Monitoring Accounts Receivable
Page 41 of 46
For monitoring accounts receivable there are several tools such as aging schedule
the ratios of receivable outstanding to original sales customers payment proportion
and sales weighted DSO (Days Sales Outstanding) For monitoring accounts
receivable Virgin uses aging schedule fractions and traditional DSO statistics
because of their simplicity in use Although payment proportions ratios of
receivables outstanding and sales weighted DSO methods are free from inherent bias
None of these is used because all these are complex to maintain
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
In summary
Page 42 of 46
Standard Compliance by Virgin Soft Drinks
Generals terms of sale is 210 net 30 Normally Virgin also use general terms
of sale ie 210 net 30
Firms do not offer the same terms of
sale to all customers
Yes For prime customers Virgin offers
special terms of sale
Approaches of terms of sale decisions
are ndash
bull Standard approach
bull Multi period approach
Virgin uses standard approach of terms
of sale decision as it is simple to use and
understand
Source of credit information are ndash
Sellers prior experience with the
customer
Credit agency ratings and
reports
Personal contact with the
applicants bank and other
creditors
Analysis of applicants financial
statements
Customer visit
Main source of credit information to
Virgin is its prior experience with the
customer All other sources are not cost-
effective for Virgin
Approaches of credit granting to
marginal accounts are ndash
Traditional approach
Net Present Value (NPV)
approach
It uses traditional approach still now but
thinks that NPV should be used for the
next periods
Firms monitor accounts receivable
because deviations from the expected
levels of turnover and of bad debt can
Virgin also monitors its accounts
receivable
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
signal several different problems
Different tools for monitoring accounts
receivable are ndash
Aging schedule
Ratios of receivables
outstanding to original sales
Customers payment
proportions
Sales-weighted DSO
For monitoring accounts receivable
Virgin uses aging schedule and
traditional sales outstanding statistics
84 MANAGING ACCOUNTS PAYABLE (CREDITORS)
Virgin has almost accounts payable of Tk 8000000 But most of its liabilities are to
the banks rather than suppliers But we dont have any clear information about
Virgins accounts payable
9 RECOMMENDATION
Virgin should invest its surplus cash in short term marketable securities
because it is suitable hedging against cash uncertainties and will also give
some returns (interest income)
Virgin should publish its own annual report which will satisfy information
needs of stakeholders and also increase the credibility of information provided
by Virgin
Page 43 of 46
Virgin should use multi period approach in terms of sale decision because
standard approach which is already exists in Virgin has some inherent
problems
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
It should stop using traditional approach from now It should use NPV
method in credit granting to marginal accounts
In monitoring accounts receivable Virgin should use sales-weighted DSO
method because it has least limitation compared to the others
It should be more flexible in granting credit which will ultimately increase its
sales
To get the appropriate number of quantity to be ordered per order it should
use DSO model
It should be ABC system for proper monitoring of inventory
10 CONCLUSION
The use of other peoples money in business is usually an expensive resource Before
looking outside for finance a firm should examine its own working capital cycle to
make sure that every rand of its own internal funds is being fully utilized Good
management of working capital is part of good financial management Effective use
of working capital will contribute to the operational efficiency of the whole
organization optimum use will help to generate maximum returns Furthermore
working capital management is not an end in itself It is an integral part of the firms
overall management The needs of efficient working capital management must be
considered in relation to other aspects of the Virgins financial and non-financial
performance Thats why when planning the development of a business it is critical
that the impact of working capital be fully assessed
Page 44 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
BIBLIOGRAPHY
Scherr FC (1989) International Edition Prentice-Hall International Inc Modern
Working Capital Management Text and Cases
Hussain Riaz (2002) Working Capital Management
Robertson Lonnie (July 1998) Inventory Management
httpwwwasashoporg visited on March 13 2006
The Art of Cash Management
httpwwwinccom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management
httpwwwstudyfinancecom visited on March 13 2006
White Paper ndash Managing Working Capital
httpwwwplanwareorg visited on March 13 2006
Management of Working Capital
httpwwwbusinesscentralcoza visited on March 13 2006
Cash Management
httpwwwsbagov visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management Objectives
httpwpsprenhallcom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management
Page 45 of 46
httpwwwadvancemecom visited on March 13 2006
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Business Receivables Financing
httpwwwbbtcom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Finance
http wwwfnbcoza visited on March 13 2006
Tips to manage your working capital
httpsmallbusinessninemsncomau visited on March 13 2006
Inventory Financing
httpwwwfranklincapitalnetworkcom visited on March 13 2006
Accounts Receivable Management
httpwwwfranklincapitalnetworkcom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management
httpwwwtreasurygovtnz visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management
httpwwwtreasurystrategiescom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Works
httpwwwinvestopediacom visited on March 13 2006
Treasury Services
httpwwwjpmorganchasecom visited on March 13 2006
what were about
Page 46 of 46
httpwwwvirgincom visited on March 13 2006
Annexure
Annexure
Interview with YASEER RIZVI
Mr Yaseer Rizvi the DMD of Global Beverage Co Ltd obtained his MBA degree
from a reputed university He had been the Director of Ocean Container Ltd before
joining in Global Beverage Co Ltd He possesses a nice personality
I interviewed Yaseer Rizvi Excerpts from his interview are as follows ndash
Shah Kamal Sir would you please tell me do you invest in short term marketable securities
Yaseer Rizvi Basically we do not invest our surplus cash in short term marketable
securities like T-Bill commercial paper certificate of deposit etc But we keep our
surplus cash in Bank
Shah Kamal Would you tell me something about transit time for a typical check
Yaseer Rizvi Well in Virgin the transit time for a typical check is ndash
For mail float 2 to 3 days
At firm float 6 hours
Clearing float 1 to 3 days
Shah Kamal Do you maintain any cash concentration mechanism like depository transfer check automated clearing house and wire transfer
i
Annexure
Yaseer Rizvi Our position in this case is very strong as we use all the mechanisms
you mentioned As Virgin is a firm with small deposits spread over a substantial
number of banks so we tend to use depository transfer checks extensively It is less
costly We also use automated clearing house and wire transfer but later is used in a
less extent
Shah Kamal Sir what techniques of disbursement management is used by your firm
Yaseer Rizvi Like other firms Virgin tries to retain the cash for as long as possible
But we always perform it in an ethical manner We do not use management of
disbursement float as it seems unethical We follow Zero-Balance Accounts method
for managing disbursement We do not prefer Controlled Disbursing method since
Zero-Balance system is already practiced in Virgin
Shah Kamal How do you hedge cash balance uncertainties
Yaseer Rizvi Well you may say that we do not invest in short term securities but for
facing cash difficulties we keep our surplus cash in bank
Shah Kamal Sir would you please tell me the general terms of sale of Virgin
Yaseer Rizvi Though it is difficult to maintain a fixed terms of sale our general terms
of sale is 210 n30 But for prime customers we offer special terms of sale
Shah Kamal What are the sources of credit information in case of your firm
Yaseer Rizvi We grant credit on the basis of prior experience with the customers In
case of a new customer personal contact is weighted
Shah Kamal Does your firm consider 5 Cs in granting credit
ii
Annexure
Yaseer Rizvi In case of Virgin Capital and Character get more importance than the
others Mind one thing personal relationship is the main measure in granting credit
Shah Kamal Do you use NPV method in credit granting decisions
Yaseer Rizvi We do not use NPV method But we think that NPV is a suitable
method and we have to use it from the next period
Shah Kamal Sir how do you handle the problem of bad debt
Yaseer Rizvi Well in this case our position is very strong Yet we do not face any
problem because of bad debt Just note that we make more than 80 of sales in cash
and we monitor accounts receivable very carefully
Shah Kamal What level of inventory is maintained by Virgin
Yaseer Rizvi We maintain a minimum level of inventory but do not have to face
stock out problems because inventory is managed efficiently
Shah Kamal What is the normal lead time
Yaseer Rizvi In case of imported goods normal lead time is about 1 month and when
we purchase raw materials from inside the country lead time is 1 to 3 days
Shah Kamal What method do you use for managing inventory
Yaseer Rizvi We do not use any method particularly rather inventory decision
depends on business cycle and market situation Long before the Eid festival we
bought large amount of sugar because price of sugar was increased on the occasion
of Eid
iii
Annexure
Shah Kamal What are the main items of inventory of your firm
Yaseer Rizvi Well these are ndash aluminum can pet chip sugar label chemical and
artificial sweet
Shah Kamal What are the uncertainties in maintaining appropriate level of stock
Yaseer Rizvi These are ndash
bull Increase in price of raw materials
bull Sales uncertainty
bull Market trends etc
Shah Kamal Thank you for your kind cooperation
Yaseer Rizvi Most Welcome
iv
Global Beverage Company Limited
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Working capital management involves the relationship between a firms short-term
assets and its short-term liabilities The goal of working capital management is to
ensure that a firm is able to continue its operations and that it has sufficient ability to
satisfy both maturing short-term debt and upcoming operational expenses The
management of working capital involves managing inventories accounts receivable
and payable and cash
52 WORKING CAPITAL POLICIES
The aim of working capital policy is to balance having too little working capital
which can lead to an inability to pay debts as they fall due or the need for expensive
short term borrowings and too much which is wasteful in terms of lost opportunities
for the funds tied up The crucial role of working capital is that it finances the goods
inwards production and sales activities
A firmrsquos working capital policy has two components
1 Policies regarding the appropriate level of current assets (Current Asset Investment Policy)
2 Policies regarding the use of short-term financing (Current Asset Financing Policy)
Alternative Current Asset Investment Policies
These policies are general strategies that firms may follow with regard to their overall
level of current assets investment or holdings There are three types
1 Relaxed Current Asset Investment Policy ndash
Relatively large amounts of cash marketable securities and inventories are carried
and sales are stimulated by a liberal (generous) trade credit policy resulting in high
levels of receivables This is a low risk strategy because the firm always has plenty of
cash and inventory on hand The return is low because more money is invested in
low yielding assets
Page 5 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
2 Restricted Current Asset Investment Policy ndash
Holdings of cash securities inventories and receivables are minimized This is a
high risk strategy because the firm tries to keep the bare minimum of cash and
inventory The potential return is high because less money is invested in low
yielding assets
3 Moderate Current Asset Policy ndash
Balance between relaxed and restricted current asset investment policies (moderate
risk - moderate potential return)
Alternative Current Asset Financing Policies
These policies are general strategies that firms may follow with regard to how current
assets are to be financed Current assets can be classified as permanent or temporary
Permanent current assets are the current assets that the company needs to maintain
throughout the entire year Temporary current assets are those that are due to
seasonal fluctuations With respect to the current asset financing policy the question
is how the permanent current assets will and temporary current assets are financed
(long-term or short-term financing)
Page 6 of 46
Aggressive Moderate Conservative
Cash Minimum holding Prepared to hold
some precautionary
balances
Prepared to hold idle
cash balances
Debtors and
stock
Minimum
consistent with
business needs
Moderate levels High stock and
debtor levels to
maximize sales
Creditors Maximum
available without
compromising
business needs
Moderate level Low level seeking
discounts and
reputation for good
payment
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Future cash
flows
Predictable Reasonably
predictable
Unpredictable
Attitude to
Risk
Accepting Neutral Rejecting
Total assets = Fixed Assets + Permanent Current Assets + Fluctuating Current Assets
53 WORKING CAPITAL CYCLE
Cash flows in a cycle into around and out of a business It is the businesss life blood
and every managers primary task is to help keep it flowing and to use the cash flow
to generate profits If a business is operating profitably then it should in theory
generate cash surpluses If it doesnt generate surpluses the business will eventually
run out of cash and expire
The faster a business expands the more cash it will need for working capital and
investment The cheapest and best sources of cash exist as working capital right
within business Good management of working capital will generate cash will help
improve profits and reduce risks
Working capital can be broken down into the following major components cash (or
bank overdraft) stock debtors creditors Each of these items can have a major
influence on the working capital (or simply cash) that any business requires on an
ongoing basis For example when a business starts up the owner may inject a
certain amount of cash into the business which will enable him to purchase his initial
stock pay his workers their first months wages and cover other overheads such as
rent He then sells his product and this income may be utilized to purchase more
stock pay more wages and overheads and perhaps even have a surplus over for his
own use The quicker he can turn his stock over to receive payment the sooner the
working capital cycle will be completed
Page 7 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Figure Working Capital Cycle
These major components of working capital are discussed below
531 CASH MANAGEMENT
The term cash management refers to the management of cash from the time it starts
its transit to the firm until it leaves the firm in payments Cash management
encompasses the design of collection and disbursement systems for cash and the
temporary investment of cash while it resides with the firm Widely used money
market instruments are-
Treasury bill
Commercial paper
Certificate of deposits
Bankerrsquos acceptance
Page 8 of 46
Repurchase agreement
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
5311 Motives for Holding Cash
Despite the seemingly low returns there are several good reasons why firms hold
cash and marketable securities These reasons are ndash
Cash for transactions
Cash and near cash assets as hedges
Temporary investment and
Compensating balances
5312 Components of Cash Management
A Cash Flow Statement shows the sources and uses of cash and is typically divided
into three components
Operating Cash Flow
Operating cash flow often referred to as working capital is the cash flow generated
from internal operations It comes from sales of the product or service of your
business and because it is generated internally it is under your control
Investing Cash Flow
Investing cash flow is generated internally from non-operating activities This
includes investments in plant and equipment or other fixed assets nonrecurring gains
or losses or other sources and uses of cash outside of normal operations
Financing Cash Flow
Financing cash flow is the cash to and from external sources such as lenders
investors and shareholders
Page 9 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
5313 Tools for Cash Management
Flotation and Check Clearing
Management of cash when it is not in the firmrsquos hands that is in transit to and from
the firm is on important function in the area of finance Transit times for the check
takes in three stages These are mail float at firm float and clearing float Normally
mail float takes 1 to 5 days at firm float takes 025 to 1 day and clearing float takes 0
to 2 days The firm should care about this process because every delay in the receipt
of money by the firm lowers the firmrsquos returns and therefore its shareholdersrsquo wealth
There are several strategies that firm can use to reduce the delay in receiving funds
Each of these strategies addresses one or more of the three float times (mail float
time at time float time and clearing float time) that make up the total transit time of
fund from one firm to another
Other Cash Management Tools
When the economy is strong companies can lapse into sloppy cash-management
practices Firm should try exploring these options
1 Sweep accounts
These bank accounts are the easiest way to generate some income from companys
spare funds however they make sense only if the money youll earn will be greater
than the fees your bank will charge Business owners have two types of sweep
accounts to choose between
Page 10 of 46
Controlled-investment accounts These are the most profitable form of
sweep account but they wont work for company if the firm has any
electronic payments or wire transfers since those may be submitted for
payment later in the day and the account wont have enough cash in it to
cover them
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Page 11 of 46
End-of-day sweep accounts A safer bet for most small-business owners
these accounts wait until a late-hour cutoff to determine how much to
sweep into the firms overnight investments Typically their investment
yields are 10 to 20 basis points (1 to 2 of the investment) lower than
those offered with controlled investments
2 Lock-box accounts
A lock box is a cash-management system that helps the firm collect funds quickly
Generally set up with the assistance of a big money center or regional bank lock
boxes provide the firm with a special zip code and usually quicker deliveries from
regional post offices They are especially important if the firm has clusters of
customers in out-of-state locations and dont want to lose days waiting for their
checks to arrive by long-distance mail
5314 Cash Concentration and Cash Disbursement
Once the remittances from the firmrsquos customers have been received and cleared the
resulting cash balances is available in the firmrsquos lockbox (depository) banks It is
useful for the firm to gather these balances from the lockbox banks into the central
bank account The process of collecting funds is called cash concentration
Several concentration mechanism are available for the firm to use in transferring
funds from its collection banks to regional concentration banks and from there to the
central concentration bank These mechanisms differ in cost and in the availability of
funds that they provide These are ndash
a) Depository Transfer Check
It is the cheapest transfer mechanism This document instructs one bank to
send funds to another and is treated the same as any other check
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
b) Automated Clearing House (ACH) Electronic Transfer
This vehicle is essentially an electronic version of the depository transfer
check and can be used between banks that participate in the automated
clearing house system
c) Wire Transfer
These are electronic message between banks
Decisions regarding concentration mechanism usually hinge on the size and
spread of the firmrsquos deposits Firms with small deposits spread over a
substantial number of banks will tend to have more extensive concentration
systems and will transfer among accounts using low-cost transfer vehicles that
offer only delayed availability (such as depository transfer checks) Firms with
larger deposits will have fewer accounts (since a local deposit for transfer to
an upstream bank is not needed) and will use more expensive and more rapid
transfer mechanisms (such as wire transfers) The concentration systems of
major chemical companies for example tend to be structured in this way ndash
DepositoryLockbox Banks
Regional Concentration Banks
Central Concentrated Bank
Figure A typical Cash Concentration System
(Arrows indicate transfers of collected funds)
Page 12 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Disbursement management addresses the efficient payout out of this cash once it is
concentrated The firmrsquos objective in disbursement management is to retain the cash
for as long as possible In this way the firm will have the maximum amount of funds
available for investment and transactional purposes Certainly this management
means making disbursement only when they are due and not before The firm has
several available set of techniques for disbursement management Included among
these are ndash
a) Management of Disbursement Float
In this set of techniques the disbursing firm attempts to increase the length of
time between the mailing of its checks and the eventual withdrawal of funds
from the banks This involves strategies for increasing mail float at firm float
and clearing float on its outgoing checks For example the disbursing firm
may intentionally address checks to the firmrsquos office address rather than its
lockbox creating at firm float
b) Zero-Balance Accounts
Here the firm holds the cash until the check arrive (or expected to arrive) at
the disbursement bank In this strategy an account for disbursement is first
established at a bank For the zero-balance system to be effective the
participating bank must be one on which most disbursement are made via the
Bangladesh Bankrsquos clearance system (which presents disbursements to banks
early in the morning) and not a bank where disbursements occur throughout
the day (as with a major money-center bank) Consequently the banks used
in zero-balance strategies are usually branches of major banks and not their
main locations
Page 13 of 46
c) Controlled Disbursing
In this system the firm projects the amount of checks to arrive each day at the
disbursement bank (based on the checks written in previous days and historic
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
statistics on disbursement float) and transfers the amount of the expected
checks to the account on that day or just before
5315 Cash Forecasting
Defining Cash Forecasting
The cash forecast is an estimation of the flows in and out of the firmrsquos cash account
over a particular period of time usually a quarter month week or day The cash
forecast is primarily intended to produce a very useful piece of information an
estimation of the firmrsquos borrowing and lending needs and uncertainties regarding
these needs during various future periods Cash forecasting is very crucial to most
firms It enables them to anticipate periods of surplus cash and periods where
financing will be necessary This anticipation is the reason that cash forecasts are
generated Anticipation enables the firm to plan much more effectively for
investment and financing and via this planning produce superior return
Types of Cash Forecasts
The types of cash forecasts generated by firms can be differentiated along two
dimensions the length of the periods included within the cash forecast and the approach
to cash flows used in the cash forecast The length of the period refers to the units of
time into which the cash forecast is divided Firms may make cash flow forecasts
over periods of various lengths yearly flows quarterly flows monthly flows weekly
flows or even daily flows The most popular forecast involves monthly flows but
most firms do not confine themselves to a single forecast Instead they use several
forecasts with periods of various lengths When the firm makes forecasts involving
multiple and overlapping period lengths one forecast relates to another Starting
with data on relatively long periods and breaking it down into smaller periods is
called distribution starting with data on relatively short periods and aggregating into
longer periods is called scheduling
Page 14 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Firms use two common approaches to cash flows in generating the cash forecast the
receipts and disbursements approach and the adjusted net income approach The receipts
and disbursements approach use the amounts of cash expected to be received and
disbursed by the firm over the periods chosen for forecast The adjusted income
statement approach is sometimes called the sources and use approach Here the
forecaster starts with projected net income on an accrual basis and adjusts to a cash
basis This method provides a representation of changes in asset and liability
accounts since the level of these accounts are of interest to the firm this aspect of the
adjusted income statement is an advantage over the receipts and disbursements
method
Items to Be Forecast
In the receipt and disbursements cash forecasting method estimates need to be made
of the numerous major and minor items that the firm collects (receipts) and that it
pays (disbursements) The more individual categories of items the firm includes in its
forecast procedure the more accurate the forecast may be but the more costly in
terms of time and effort it will be to generate
Some Possible Types of Cash Receipts and Cash Disbursements
Cash Disbursements Cash Receipts
Cash Purchases of Materials Payroll
Taxes
Maturing Accounts Payable
Maturing Notes Payable
Miscellaneous Disbursements
Accounts Receivable
Notes Receivable
Rental Income
Interest Income
Miscellaneous Receipts
Methods of Financial Forecasting
Page 15 of 46
Financial forecasting is the estimation of the future level of a financial variable often
a cash flow asset level or liability level It is usually assumed that the relationship
between the financial variable and other variable is linear The general linear model
can then be used
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
nnt xaxaxaaY 22110 ++=
Here
= Financial variable (Y) to be forecast in period t tY
x = Explanatory variable it is assumed to cause the level of Y in period t
0a = Represents a constant unaffected by the x
The other terms are the estimated coefficients of the explanatory x variables
There are n terms with xrsquos in them
There are four common approaches to forecasting financial variables but they
are all special cases of the general linear model These are ndash spot method proportion
to another account compounded growth and multiple dependencies
Using Cash Forecast
The estimate of available funds for investment and needed financing enables the firm
to plan so as to obtain the most advantages borrowing terms for deficits and achieve
the greatest interest income on surplus A useful chart for this planning purpose is a
bar chart eg
Figure Bar Chart of Cash Surpluses and Deficits from hypothetical data
Page 16 of 46
75
50
-60
30
100
-20
-80-60-40-20
020406080
100120
Defic
it
S
urpl
us
January February March April May June
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Sources of Uncertainty in Cash Forecasting and Hedging Uncertainties
There are numerous sources of risk in cash forecasting Among the sources are sales
uncertainty collection rate uncertainty production cost uncertainty and capital
outflow uncertainty
5316 Models for the Management of Cash and Temporary Investments
There are different models for the management of cash and temporary investments
Among these the most popular methods are ndash Baumol model Beranek model
Miller-Orr model and Stone model
Baumol and Beranek use the same model The formula is cited below ndash
Interest Income = iYn
n⎥⎦⎤
⎢⎣⎡ minus
21
Profit = naiYn
nminus⎥⎦
⎤⎢⎣⎡ minus
21
Optimum number of transactions = ⎟⎠⎞
⎜⎝⎛
aiY2
Where n = Optimum number of transactions
i = Interest rate per period
a = Transaction cost
Y = Total inflow for the period
Page 17 of 46
Miller-Orr and Stone use the same model ie R-Statistic The model is ndash
31
43
iav
R ⎟⎠⎞
⎜⎝⎛=
Optimum Control Limit = R + L
Upper Control Limit = 3R + L
Where a = Transaction Cost
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
v = Variance of daily cash flows
i = Daily interest rate
5317 Administration
Cash receipts should be processed and banked as quickly as possible because
They cannot earn interest or reduce overdraft until they are banked
information about the existence and amounts of cash receipts is usually not
available until they are processed
Where possible cash floats (mainly petty cash and advances) should be avoided If
on review the only reason that can be put forward for their existence is that weve
always had them they should be discontinued There may be situations where they
are useful however For example it may be desirable for peripheral parts of
departments to meet urgent local needs from cash floats rather than local bank
accounts
5318 Internal Control
Cash and cash management is part of a firms overall internal control system The
main internal cash control is invariably the bank reconciliation This provides
assurance that the cash balances recorded in the accounting systems are consistent
with the actual bank balances It requires regular clearing of reconciling items
5319 Practicing Good Cash Flow Management
Good cash management is simple It involves
Knowing when where and how firms cash needs will occur
Page 18 of 46
Knowing the best sources for meeting additional cash needs
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Page 19 of 46
Being prepared to meet these needs when they occur by keeping good
relationships with bankers and other creditors
532 INVENTORY MANAGEMENT
Inventory management is necessary for owners who want to maintain a stocking
service for quick turnaround to help ensure total customer satisfaction The fill rate
of an item on a managed inventory list must be maintained to avoid shortages of
frequently used items Even when utilizing an inventory management system
occasional shortages will still occur Inventories are lists of stocks-raw materials
work in progress or finished goods-waiting to be consumed in production or to be
sold The total balance of inventory is the sum of the value of each individual stock
line
Basically firms hold stocks for the following reasons
To act as a buffer in times of unusually high demand
To ensure continuity of production
Avoid high costs of emergency orders
To take advantage of quantity discounts by ordering more at a time
To reduce ordering costs by ordering more items on fewer
As part of the production process eg maturing whisky or keeping oil in
pipelines
Seasonality of demand (eg firework) or supplies
Suppliers insist on minimum order quantities
The key issue for a business is to identify the fast and slow stock movers with the
objectives of establishing optimum stock levels for each category and thereby
minimize the cash tied up in stocks Factors to be considered when determining
optimum stock levels include
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Page 20 of 46
What are the projected sales of each product
How widely available are raw materials components etc
How long does it take for delivery by suppliers
Can the firm remove slow movers from its product range without
compromising best sellers
Inventory management is an important aspect of working capital management
because inventories themselves do not earn any revenue Holding either too little or
too much inventory incurs costs
Costs of carrying too much inventory are
Opportunity cost of foregone interest
Warehousing costs
Damage and pilferage
Obsolescence
Insurance
Costs of carrying too little inventory are
Stock out costs
Lost sales
Delayed service
Ordering costs
Freight
on Order administrati
nts
Loss of quantity discou
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Carrying costs can be minimized by making frequent small orders but this increase
ordering costs and the risk of stock outs Risk of stock-outs can be reduced by
carrying safety stocks (at a cost) and re-ordering ahead of time
The best ordering strategy requires balancing the various cost factors to ensure the
firm incurs minimum inventory costs The optimum inventory position is known as
the Economic Reorder Quantity (ERQ)
Nowadays many large manufacturers operate on a just-in-time (JIT) basis whereby
all the components to be assembled on a particular today arrive at the factory early
that morning no earlier - no later This helps to minimize manufacturing costs as JIT
stocks take up little space minimize stock-holding and virtually eliminate the risks of
obsolete or damaged stock Because JIT manufacturers hold stock for a very short
time they are able to conserve substantial cash JIT is a good model to strive for as it
embraces all the principles of prudent stock management For better stock control
firm may try the following
Review the effectiveness of existing purchasing and inventory systems
Know the stock turn for all major items of inventory
Apply tight controls to the significant few items and simplify controls for the
trivial many
Sell off outdated or slow moving merchandise - it gets more difficult to sell the
longer the firm keeps it
Consider having part of its product outsourced to another manufacturer rather
than make it itself
Review its security procedures to ensure that no stock is going out the back
door
Higher than necessary stock levels tie up cash and cost more in insurance
accommodation costs and interest charges
Page 21 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
However it is important to keep an overall perspective It is not cost-effective to
closely manage a large number of low value inventory lines nor is it necessary A
usual feature of inventories is that a small number of high value lines account for a
large proportion of inventory value The 8020 rule (PARETO) predicts that 80
of the total value of inventory is represented by only 20 of the number of inventory
items Those high value lines need reasonably close management The remaining
80 of inventory lines can be managed using broad-brush strategies
533 MANAGING ACCOUNTS RECEIVABLE (DEBTORS)
Cash flow can be significantly enhanced if the amounts owing to a business are
collected faster Every business needs to know who owes them money how much is
owed how long it is owing for what it is owed
Debtors (Accounts Receivable) are customers who have not yet made payment for
goods or services which the department has provided The objective of debtor
management is to minimize the time-lapse between completion of sales and receipt
of payment The costs of having debtors are
Opportunity costs (cash is not available for other purposes)
Bad debts
If firm doesnt manage debtors they will begin to manage business as the firm will gradually
lose control due to reduced cash flow and of course it could experience an increased
incidence of bad debt The following measures will help manage debtors
Having the right mental attitude to the control of credit and make sure that it
gets the priority it deserves
Establishing clear credit practices as a matter of company policy
Page 22 of 46
Making sure that these practices are clearly understood by staff suppliers and
customers
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Page 23 of 46
Being professional when accepting new accounts and especially larger ones
Checking out each customer thoroughly before the firm offers credit Use
credit agencies bank references industry sources etc
Establishing credit limits for each customer and sticking to them
Continuously reviewing these limits when it suspects tough times are coming
or if operating in a volatile sector
Keeping very close to the firms larger customers
Invoicing promptly and clearly
Considering charging penalties on overdue accounts
Considering accepting credit debit cards as a payment option
Monitoring its debtor balances and ageing schedules and dont let any debts
get too large or too old
Debtor management includes both pre-sale and debt collection strategies
Pre-sale strategies include
Offering cash discounts for early payment andor imposing penalties for late
payment
Agreeing payment terms in advance
Requiring cash before delivery
Setting credit limits
ning credit Setting criteria for obtai
Billing as early as possible
rogress payments
ost-sale strategies include
for collecting the debt upon the center that made the sale
Requiring deposits andor p
P
Placing the responsibility
Identifying long overdue balances and doubtful debts by regular analytical reviews
Having an established procedure for late collections such as
A reminder
A letter
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Page 24 of 46
ion of further credit Cancellat
Telephone calls
n agency Use of a collectio
he firm should recognize that the longer someone owes firm the greater the chance
Legal action
T
it will never get paid If the average age of debtors is getting longer or is already very
long it may need to look for the following possible defects
Weak credit judgment
res Poor collection procedu
ms Lax enforcement of credit ter
Slow issue of invoices or statements
Errors in invoices or statements
Customer dissatisfaction
Debtors due over 90 days (unless within agreed credit terms) should generally
demand immediate attention For example warning signs of a future bad debt ndash
Longer credit terms taken with approval particularly for smaller orders
Use of post-dated checks by debtors who normally settle within agreed terms
Evidence of customers switching to additional suppliers for the same goods
New customers who are reluctant to give credit references
Cre G
Receiving part payments from debtors
dit ranting to Marginal Accounts
Traditional Approach
In the traditional approach to the credit granting decision it is the credit analysts job
rmation that has been collected and reach a judgment
regarding the applicants creditworthiness One traditional way of organizing this
to synthesize all the info
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
information is by characterizing the applicant along five dimensions These
dimensions are called the Five Cs of credit ndash
Capital
Character
Collateral
and Capacity
Conditions
Net Present Value (NPV) Approach
Once a firm has assessed the creditworthiness of a customer it has to decide whether
r not credit should be granted The firm should use the NPV rule to make the
ld be granted
Figure
o
decision If NPV is positive credit shou
Credit Granting Decision
Credit Granting Decision
he act of collecting money is one which most people dislike for many reasons and
therefore put on the long f selves there is something
ore urgent or important that demands their attention now There is nothing more
T
inger because they convince them
m
important than getting paid for firms product or service A customer who does not
Page 25 of 46
Grand Credit
Payment received Payment not received
Benefit of present value of future net cash flow
Cost of present value ment of lost invest
Net Payoff PV of benefit-cost
No Credit
No Payoff
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
pay is not a customer Here are a few ideas that may help the firm in collecting
money from debtors
Firm should develop appropriate procedures for handling late payments
It should track and pursue late payers
It might get external help if its own efforts fail
or money its firms and it is entitled Company shouldnt feel guilty asking f
to it
ction
Firm must make that call now And it should keep asking until it gets some
satisfa
lessens the problem
In difficult circumstances take what the firm can now and agree terms for the
remainder It
paying
When asking for money be hard on the issue - but soft on the person It shouldnt
give the debtor any excuses for not
534 BLE (CREDITORS)
ices for goods or services have
een paid Organizations often regard the
not
to delay all payments until the latest possible date Regular weekly or
The firm make it its objective is to get the money - not to score points or get
even
MANAGING ACCOUNTS PAYA
Creditors (Accounts Payable) are suppliers whose invo
been processed but who have not yet b
amount owing to creditors as a source of free credit However creditor
administration systems are expensive and time-consuming to run The over-riding
concern in this area should be to minimize costs with simple procedures
While it is unnecessary to pay accounts before they fall due it is usually
worthwhile
Page 26 of 46
fortnightly payment of all due accounts is the simplest technique for creditor
management
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Electronic payments (direct credits) are cheaper than check payments considering
that transaction fees and overheads more than balance the advantage of delayed
presentation Some suppliers are reluctant to receive payments by this method but in
view of the substantial cost advantage (and the advantages to the suppliers
themselves) departments may wish to encourage suppliers to accept this option
However electronic payments are likely to be used in conjunction with rather than
as a replacement for check payments
Applying Best Practices in Managing Accounts Payable
f course simply deferring payments to suppliers could have adverse consequences
O
that more than offset the benefits of this additional cash flow Therefore it is
important to develop a holistic approach The firm should consider the following
best practices for payables management
Managing payment dates and terms to maximize cash flow ndash
y reporting on
receivable and
id penalty charges and taking advantage of
wer vendors and negotiate for more
to buying consortia with others even
voices for
payment based on receipt of goods or receipt of invoice whichever
comes later
Calculating and setting performance targets Regularl
AP performance measures such as days in payables
Coordinating the AP processes with accounts
inventory management to ensure that the company is collecting more
cash than it is paying out
Paying bills on time to avo
prompt-payment discounts where the discounts exceed the companyrsquos
cost of working capital
Consolidating purchases with fe
favorable payment terms
Considering entering in
Page 27 of 46
competitors to obtain favorable supplier pricing and terms
Unless contract terms specify otherwise setting up in
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Page 28 of 46
Em
process
-time payments with Electronic Funds Transfer (EFT)
uraging vendors to utilize electronic invoice presentment
a
ndancies and more
ploying technology to automate the accounts payable transaction
es ndash
Making just-in
Using an electronic invoice-matching application
Enco
For companies with multiple locations or business units employing
shared service approach for AP to eliminate redu
quickly implement process improvements
Mainta
vendor
Communicating accounts payable requirements to suppliers at the
m key suppliers
for suggestions on how to improve the
Efficient a
and making th rsquos cash is just good business
ining open communications and building strong relationships with
s to access valuable trade credit ndash
beginning of transactions
Requesting summary invoicing fro
Requiring suppliers to send invoices directly to accounts payable
Asking tier-one suppliers
payment process
nd effective management of accounts payable helps improve cash flow ndash
e most of company
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
6 OVERVIEW OF VIRGIN GROUP
Virgin - one of the most respected brands in Britain - is now becoming the first global
brand name of the 21st century Virgin is involved in planes trains finance soft
drinks music mobile phones holidays cars wines publishing bridal wear - the lot
What tie all these businesses together are the values of its brand and the attitude of its
people Virgin has created over 200 companies worldwide employing over 25000
people Its total revenues around the world in 2002 exceeded pound4 billion (US $72
billion)
In 1970 Richard Branson founded Virgin as a mail order record retailer and not
long after he opened a record shop in Oxford Street London During 1972 a
recording studio was built in Oxfordshire and the first Virgin artist Mike Oldfield
recorded Tubular Bells which was released in 1973
This album went on to sell over 5 million copies Since then many household names
including Belinda Carlisle Genesis Phil Collins Janet Jackson and The Rolling
Stones have helped to make Virgin Music one of the top six record companies in the
world The equity of Virgin Music Group - record labels music publishing and
recording studios was sold to THORN EMI in 1992 in a US$1billion deal
Page 29 of 46
The Virgin Group has now expanded into international music Mega stores air
travel mobile financial retail music internet drinks rail hotels and leisure with
around 200 companies in over 30 countries
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
In Virgins customers eyes Virgin stands for value for money quality innovation
fun and a sense of competitive challenge It delivers a quality service by empowering
its employees and facilitates and monitors customer feedback to continually improve
the customers experience through innovation
When they start a new venture Virgin bases it on hard research and analysis
Typically they review the industry and put themselves in the customers shoes to see
what could make it better Virgin asks fundamental questions
Is this an opportunity for restructuring a market and creating competitive
advantage What are the competitors doing
Is the customer confused or badly served
Is this an opportunity for building the Virgin brand
Can we add value
Will it interact with its other businesses
Is there an appropriate trade-off between risk and reward
Page 30 of 46
Virgin is also able to draw on talented people from throughout the group New
ventures are often steered by people seconded from other parts of Virgin who bring
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
with them the trademark management style skills and experience Virgin frequently
creates partnerships with others to combine skills knowledge and market presence
and so on Contrary to what some people may think their constantly expanding and
eclectic empire is neither random nor reckless Each successive venture demonstrates
its skill in picking the right market and the right opportunity
7 OVERVIEW OF VIRGIN SOFT DRINKS
The Virgin Drinks Group first launched as the Virgin Cola Company in 1994 with
Virgin Cola in the UK Since then the company has ventured across the carbonated
soft drinks arena and beyond into energy drinks tea and flavored Colas This
expansion has lead to the evolution of the Virgin Drinks Company a company
whose aim is to put the excitement back into the world of soft drinks It launched in
Bangladesh in 1999 Virgin Soft Drinks is monitored by Global Beverage Co Ltd in
Bangladesh
Brief history of Virgin Drinks is given below
Page 31 of 46
1994 November Virgin Cola launched in the UK
1996 March Virgin Cola launched in France
1998 June Virgin Cola launched in Belgium
April Virgin Cola launched in the French West Indies
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
August Virgin Cola launched in Switzerland
1999 March Virgin Colours launched in Italy
March Virgin Cola launched in Japan
July Virgin Colours launched in South Africa
December Virgin Colours launched in Bangladesh
2001 January Sweden launched Virgin Colours
November Singapore launched Virgin Colours
2002 February Croatia launched Virgin Colours
June Russia launched Virgin Colours
June Tunisia launched Virgin Colours
2003 May Israel launched Virgin Colours
8 FINDINGS OF WORKING CAPITAL MANAGEMENT MAINTAINED BY
VIRGIN SOFT DRINKS IN BANGLADESH
81 CASH MANAGEMENT
811 Holding Cash and Marketable Securities
Although there are many good reasons why firm hold cash and marketable
securities Virgin Drinks holds cash and marketable securities for two reasons ndash
i) Cash for transactions
ii) Cash as hedges
This indicates that the firm does not hold cash and marketable securities for some
important reasons such as ndash
i) Near cash assets as hedges
Page 32 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
ii) Temporary investment and compensating balances
Virgin Soft Drinks does not invest in money market securities such as Treasury bill
commercial paper certificate of deposits bankerrsquos acceptance and repurchase
agreement This firm deposits its money in bank as currant AC or fixed AC They
say that they do not have enough money to invest in money market instrument
They also say that if they have enough money they will invest it in money market
short term securities We know that near cash interest earning assets can be
substituted for cash when motivation for holding these assets is the hedging of cash
flow uncertainties or is the temporary investment of surplus funds In this point
Virgins position is not good as there is no significant hedging against uncertainty of
cash
812 Floatation and Check Clearing
Virgin is very smart in handling the problem of transit time for checks Here mail
float takes 2 to 3 days at firm takes 025 day and clearing float takes 1-3 days Virgin
uses most of the strategies available for reducing the delay in receiving funds It
(Virgin) has linked Islami Bank which posses an accelerated clearing facility It uses
electronic collection process which ensures faster collection and its at the firm check
processing is satisfactory But Virgin does not use lockbox The reason behind this is
that it is not cost-effective for Virgin to set lockboxes At this point we can say that
Virgins check clearing mechanism is much good
813 Cash Concentration and Disbursement Management
Page 33 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks takes the matter of cash concentration very seriously They use all
the available cash concentration mechanism Virgin is a firm with small deposits
spread over a substantial number of banks and this is why the firm tends to use
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
depository transfer checks extensively If is less costly Virgin also uses automated
clearing house and wire transfer To Virgin wire transfer seems too costly
Like other firm Virgin tries to retain the cash for as long as possible But Virgin
always performs it in an ethical manner Virgin does not try to defeat the receiving
firmrsquos attempts to reduce the float on incoming checks It does not take any strategy
for increasing mail float at firm float and clearing float on its outgoing checks To
Virgin it is deemed to be unethical It thinks that maximization of disbursement float
will not go unnoticed by sophisticated creditors for very long When it is noticed it
will negatively affect relations with these creditors reducing the firmrsquos bargaining
power with them This may ultimately cost Virgin dearly when future prices and
delivery schedules for goods and services purchased from trade creditors are
negotiated Virgin follows ldquoZero-Balance Accountsrdquo methods for managing
disbursement It thinks that in this method the coordination of funds inflows to
disbursement banks with the presentation of checks does not work to the detriment
of creditors since the firmrsquos checks to them are honored as presented and this strategy
does not affect float significantly Controlled disbursing method is less attractive to
Virgin because zero-balance system is already feasible
814 Cash Forecasting
Cash Forecasting and Its Types
Page 34 of 46
Virgin forecasts the future cash inflows and outflows To Virgin cash forecast is an
important part of the firmrsquos cash control system and is one of the forecasts that are
part of the Virginrsquos financial plan Virgin forecasts cash on monthly basis and on
yearly basis Virgin does not forecast on daily basis assuming that the temporary
shortage of funds within these periods can be covered without value cost eg
advance receipts from customers Virginrsquos cash forecasting system involves a
combination of distribution and scheduling The receipts and disbursements
approach of cash forecasting is used in virgin This method is used because it
minutely traces the movement of cash and very close control of cash is possible
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Virgin does not use adjusted net income approach on two grounds First it does not
permit the tracing of the individual types of cash inflows and outflows for any given
period which is often useful information for virgin Second it is not simple to use
Items to be Forecast
Virgin does not forecast all the items It forecasts only major items eg accounts
receivable notes receivable payroll cash purchases of raw materials In this regard
virgin trade off between cost and benefit
Methods of Financial Forecasting
Virgin forecasts the future level of financial variable such as cash level asset level or
liability level We know in short term forecasts many things will result from plans
and events that are already in place (contracts capital budgets long-range financing
plans and so forth) But in the long run most things can vary and are dependent on
outside influences such as the firmrsquos long-term growth rate Since Virginrsquos cash
forecasting deals mostly with near future many of the items on the cash forecasts are
estimated by some variation of the spot method and remaining estimates are mostly
on a ldquoproportion of another accountrdquo basis with this ldquoother accountrdquo often being a
particular periodrsquos sales Virgin uses the other two methods less frequently
Using Cash Forecast
Virgin forecasts cash for meeting general objectives (ie to know the available funds
for investment and need financing) and for meeting some special objectives (eg to
know whether the firm will fulfill its out of debt requirement) But it is matter to note
that Virgin does not make any short term investment of its surplus cash but only keep
this surplus in Bank Account
Page 35 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Sources of Uncertainty in Cash Forecasting and Hedging Uncertainties
Virgin faces uncertainty in cash forecasting mainly from two sources These are ndash
sales and production cost In peak season (hot season like autumn summer) sales
increases but in dull season (eg in winter) sales decreases drastically Production
cost may be increased because of increase of price of sugar chemicals aluminum
can Virgin follows two methods for hedging cash balance uncertainties These are ndash
i) Holding a stock of extra cash and
ii) Extra borrowing capacity
815 Modes for the Management of Cash and Temporary Investments
Virgin does not follow any of these methods wholly Virgin receives cash
continuously and pays salary at steady rate and pays continuously for other
expenses So it neither follows Baumol model nor Beranek model It has no upper
control limit lower control limit return point in case cash management So it neither
follows Miller-Orr model nor Stone model
In Summary
Page 36 of 46
Standard Compliance by Virgin Soft Drinks
Generally all firms hold cash and
marketable securities
Virgin holds only cash
Firms hold cash and marketable
securities for some reasons like
bull Cash for transactions
bull Cash and near-cash assets as
hedges
bull Temporary investments
bull Compensating balances
Virgin holds cash only for
two reasons ndash
bull Cash for transactions
bull Cash as hedges
Available money market instruments Virgin does not invest in any such
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
(short term securities) are ndash
Treasury Bills
Commercial Paper
Certificates of Deposit
Bankerrsquos Acceptance
Repurch menase Agree ts
instruments They only keep cash in
Bank Account
Mail Float
(1 to 5 days)
At Firm
Float
(025 to 1
day)
Clearing
Float
(0 to
2 days)
Mail Float
(2 to 3 days)
At firm
Float
(025
day)
Clearing
Float
(1 to 3
days)
Figure Transit time for a typical check Figure Transit time for a check for
Virgin
Strategies that firms can use to reduce
the delay in receiving funds are ndash
Selecting of Banks with
accelerated clearing capabilities
of check processing Acceleration
at the firm
ectronic collection Use of el
procedures
Use of lockboxes
Virgin follows the first three strategies
but does not use lockboxes
Available cash concentration
mechanisms are ndash
Depository transfer check
ouse Automated Clearing H
(ACH) electronic transfer)
Wire transfer
Virgin uses all these mechanisms of
cash concentration
Available sets of techniques for cash
disbursement management are ndash
ement of disbursement
Page 37 of 46
Manag
float
Virgin uses zero-balance accounts
technique
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Zero-Balance Accounts
Controlled disbursing
Firms may make cash flow forecasts
over periods of various lengths yearly
flows quarterly flows monthly flows
weekly flows or even daily flows
Virgin forecasts cash on yearly basis and
monthly basis
Cash forecasting system may involve ndash
Distribution
Scheduling
Virginrsquos cash forecasting system
involves a combination of distribution
and scheduling
Two common approaches to cash flow
in generating the cash forecast
and disbursement Receipts
approach
Adjusted net income approach
Virgin uses the receipts and
disbursement approach
There are many items to forecast Virgin forecasts only major items like
AR payroll etc
Four common approach to forecasting
fina i ndash nc al variables are
Spot method
Proportion to another account
Compounded growth
Multiple dependencies
Virgin uses spot method for forecasting
cash It uses proportion to another
account method for other variables and
remaining two methods are frequently
used
Sources of uncertainty in cash
forecasting are ndash
Sales uncertainty
Collection rate uncertainty
Production cost uncertainty
Capital outflow uncertainty
Virgin faces uncertainty mainly from
sales and production cost
Methods for hedging cash balance
unc a
Page 38 of 46
ert inties are ndash
i) Holding a stock of extra cash
Virgin two available methods for
hedging cash balance uncertainties
Th ese are ndash
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
ii) stock of near-cash Holding a
assets
iii) Extra borrowing capacity
iv) ary surpluses in Investing tempor
near-cash assets
i) Holding a stock of extra cash
ii) Extra borrowing capacity
(advance receipt from
customers)
Models for the management of cash and
temporary investments are ndash Baumol
model Beranek model Miller-Orr
model and Stone model
Virgin does not follow any method
wholly but a combination of Baumol
model and Beranek model is occurred
82 INVENTORY MANAGEMENT
21 Certainty Approach
isnt used in
irgin because it thinks it is not possible to implement in Bangladesh
d time is one to three days It
oes not use ABC system of inventory management
8
Main item of inventory of Virgin is Can pet chip sugar label chemical artificial
sweet etc Virgin maintains a minimum level of inventory but it does not have to face
problems because inventory is managed efficiently just-in-time (JIT)
V
Virgin maintains buffer stock because of the shortage of work-in-process (WIP)
inventory Its production process may also be hampered Thats why it maintains
safety stock to avoid stock out cost In case of imported goods normal lead time is
about one month and within the country normal lea
d
Page 39 of 46
Inventory Model
In reality Virgin does not use any of models of EOQ ordering and holding strategy
and safety stock strategy They maintain inventory based on their prior experience
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
822 Uncertainty Approach
Virgin does not use any model for handling inventory uncertainty It says that such
decision depends on business cycle and market situation Long before Eid festival
they bought large amount of sugar because of price increase on the occasion of Eid
In summary
Standard Compliance by Virgin Soft Drinks
Firms maintain inventory to guard
against several problems
Virgin maintains a minimum level of
inventory which is managed efficiently
Some firms use JIT to avoid inventory
cost
JIT is not used by Virgin as it thinks it is
impossible to implement in Bangladesh
Firms maintain buffer stock Virgin maintains buffer stock too
Firms maintain safety stock to avoid
shortage cost
Virgin also maintains safety stock
Firms use ABC system to monitor
inventory
Virgin doesnt use ABC system
EOQ model is an appropriate method
for measuring quantity that has to be
ordered per order
Virgin does not use EOQ model rather
makes order based on experience and
market demand
83 MANAGING ACCOUNTS RECEIVABLE (DEBTORS)
831 Terms of Sale Decision
Page 40 of 46
Virgin offers the term 210 net 30 enables the customers to deduct 2 percent from the
face value of the bill when paying within the first 10 days but if the discount is not
taken the customer must remit the full amount within 30 days But Virgin does not
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
offer the same terms of sale to all customers For prime customers it offers special
terms of sale In setting an appropriate term of sale it costs and benefits regarding
this are compared It uses the standard approach of terms of sale decision as it is
simple to use
832 Credit Granting Decisions
In case of Virgin the Capital and Character of Five Cs get more importance
Although there are many problems with the traditional approach Virgin uses it
because of its simplicity Virgin does not use Net Present Value (NPV) method in
credit granting decision It thinks that NPV is an appropriate method and should be
used next time It does not face any severe problem because of bad debts The reason
is that notes receivable is used when credit is granted
833 Monitoring Accounts Receivable
Virgin monitors its accounts receivable Virgin believes that in any case both positive
and negative durations in accounts signal differences from the results that
management believe to be the most advantageous for the firm
Tools for Monitoring Accounts Receivable
Page 41 of 46
For monitoring accounts receivable there are several tools such as aging schedule
the ratios of receivable outstanding to original sales customers payment proportion
and sales weighted DSO (Days Sales Outstanding) For monitoring accounts
receivable Virgin uses aging schedule fractions and traditional DSO statistics
because of their simplicity in use Although payment proportions ratios of
receivables outstanding and sales weighted DSO methods are free from inherent bias
None of these is used because all these are complex to maintain
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
In summary
Page 42 of 46
Standard Compliance by Virgin Soft Drinks
Generals terms of sale is 210 net 30 Normally Virgin also use general terms
of sale ie 210 net 30
Firms do not offer the same terms of
sale to all customers
Yes For prime customers Virgin offers
special terms of sale
Approaches of terms of sale decisions
are ndash
bull Standard approach
bull Multi period approach
Virgin uses standard approach of terms
of sale decision as it is simple to use and
understand
Source of credit information are ndash
Sellers prior experience with the
customer
Credit agency ratings and
reports
Personal contact with the
applicants bank and other
creditors
Analysis of applicants financial
statements
Customer visit
Main source of credit information to
Virgin is its prior experience with the
customer All other sources are not cost-
effective for Virgin
Approaches of credit granting to
marginal accounts are ndash
Traditional approach
Net Present Value (NPV)
approach
It uses traditional approach still now but
thinks that NPV should be used for the
next periods
Firms monitor accounts receivable
because deviations from the expected
levels of turnover and of bad debt can
Virgin also monitors its accounts
receivable
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
signal several different problems
Different tools for monitoring accounts
receivable are ndash
Aging schedule
Ratios of receivables
outstanding to original sales
Customers payment
proportions
Sales-weighted DSO
For monitoring accounts receivable
Virgin uses aging schedule and
traditional sales outstanding statistics
84 MANAGING ACCOUNTS PAYABLE (CREDITORS)
Virgin has almost accounts payable of Tk 8000000 But most of its liabilities are to
the banks rather than suppliers But we dont have any clear information about
Virgins accounts payable
9 RECOMMENDATION
Virgin should invest its surplus cash in short term marketable securities
because it is suitable hedging against cash uncertainties and will also give
some returns (interest income)
Virgin should publish its own annual report which will satisfy information
needs of stakeholders and also increase the credibility of information provided
by Virgin
Page 43 of 46
Virgin should use multi period approach in terms of sale decision because
standard approach which is already exists in Virgin has some inherent
problems
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
It should stop using traditional approach from now It should use NPV
method in credit granting to marginal accounts
In monitoring accounts receivable Virgin should use sales-weighted DSO
method because it has least limitation compared to the others
It should be more flexible in granting credit which will ultimately increase its
sales
To get the appropriate number of quantity to be ordered per order it should
use DSO model
It should be ABC system for proper monitoring of inventory
10 CONCLUSION
The use of other peoples money in business is usually an expensive resource Before
looking outside for finance a firm should examine its own working capital cycle to
make sure that every rand of its own internal funds is being fully utilized Good
management of working capital is part of good financial management Effective use
of working capital will contribute to the operational efficiency of the whole
organization optimum use will help to generate maximum returns Furthermore
working capital management is not an end in itself It is an integral part of the firms
overall management The needs of efficient working capital management must be
considered in relation to other aspects of the Virgins financial and non-financial
performance Thats why when planning the development of a business it is critical
that the impact of working capital be fully assessed
Page 44 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
BIBLIOGRAPHY
Scherr FC (1989) International Edition Prentice-Hall International Inc Modern
Working Capital Management Text and Cases
Hussain Riaz (2002) Working Capital Management
Robertson Lonnie (July 1998) Inventory Management
httpwwwasashoporg visited on March 13 2006
The Art of Cash Management
httpwwwinccom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management
httpwwwstudyfinancecom visited on March 13 2006
White Paper ndash Managing Working Capital
httpwwwplanwareorg visited on March 13 2006
Management of Working Capital
httpwwwbusinesscentralcoza visited on March 13 2006
Cash Management
httpwwwsbagov visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management Objectives
httpwpsprenhallcom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management
Page 45 of 46
httpwwwadvancemecom visited on March 13 2006
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Business Receivables Financing
httpwwwbbtcom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Finance
http wwwfnbcoza visited on March 13 2006
Tips to manage your working capital
httpsmallbusinessninemsncomau visited on March 13 2006
Inventory Financing
httpwwwfranklincapitalnetworkcom visited on March 13 2006
Accounts Receivable Management
httpwwwfranklincapitalnetworkcom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management
httpwwwtreasurygovtnz visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management
httpwwwtreasurystrategiescom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Works
httpwwwinvestopediacom visited on March 13 2006
Treasury Services
httpwwwjpmorganchasecom visited on March 13 2006
what were about
Page 46 of 46
httpwwwvirgincom visited on March 13 2006
Annexure
Annexure
Interview with YASEER RIZVI
Mr Yaseer Rizvi the DMD of Global Beverage Co Ltd obtained his MBA degree
from a reputed university He had been the Director of Ocean Container Ltd before
joining in Global Beverage Co Ltd He possesses a nice personality
I interviewed Yaseer Rizvi Excerpts from his interview are as follows ndash
Shah Kamal Sir would you please tell me do you invest in short term marketable securities
Yaseer Rizvi Basically we do not invest our surplus cash in short term marketable
securities like T-Bill commercial paper certificate of deposit etc But we keep our
surplus cash in Bank
Shah Kamal Would you tell me something about transit time for a typical check
Yaseer Rizvi Well in Virgin the transit time for a typical check is ndash
For mail float 2 to 3 days
At firm float 6 hours
Clearing float 1 to 3 days
Shah Kamal Do you maintain any cash concentration mechanism like depository transfer check automated clearing house and wire transfer
i
Annexure
Yaseer Rizvi Our position in this case is very strong as we use all the mechanisms
you mentioned As Virgin is a firm with small deposits spread over a substantial
number of banks so we tend to use depository transfer checks extensively It is less
costly We also use automated clearing house and wire transfer but later is used in a
less extent
Shah Kamal Sir what techniques of disbursement management is used by your firm
Yaseer Rizvi Like other firms Virgin tries to retain the cash for as long as possible
But we always perform it in an ethical manner We do not use management of
disbursement float as it seems unethical We follow Zero-Balance Accounts method
for managing disbursement We do not prefer Controlled Disbursing method since
Zero-Balance system is already practiced in Virgin
Shah Kamal How do you hedge cash balance uncertainties
Yaseer Rizvi Well you may say that we do not invest in short term securities but for
facing cash difficulties we keep our surplus cash in bank
Shah Kamal Sir would you please tell me the general terms of sale of Virgin
Yaseer Rizvi Though it is difficult to maintain a fixed terms of sale our general terms
of sale is 210 n30 But for prime customers we offer special terms of sale
Shah Kamal What are the sources of credit information in case of your firm
Yaseer Rizvi We grant credit on the basis of prior experience with the customers In
case of a new customer personal contact is weighted
Shah Kamal Does your firm consider 5 Cs in granting credit
ii
Annexure
Yaseer Rizvi In case of Virgin Capital and Character get more importance than the
others Mind one thing personal relationship is the main measure in granting credit
Shah Kamal Do you use NPV method in credit granting decisions
Yaseer Rizvi We do not use NPV method But we think that NPV is a suitable
method and we have to use it from the next period
Shah Kamal Sir how do you handle the problem of bad debt
Yaseer Rizvi Well in this case our position is very strong Yet we do not face any
problem because of bad debt Just note that we make more than 80 of sales in cash
and we monitor accounts receivable very carefully
Shah Kamal What level of inventory is maintained by Virgin
Yaseer Rizvi We maintain a minimum level of inventory but do not have to face
stock out problems because inventory is managed efficiently
Shah Kamal What is the normal lead time
Yaseer Rizvi In case of imported goods normal lead time is about 1 month and when
we purchase raw materials from inside the country lead time is 1 to 3 days
Shah Kamal What method do you use for managing inventory
Yaseer Rizvi We do not use any method particularly rather inventory decision
depends on business cycle and market situation Long before the Eid festival we
bought large amount of sugar because price of sugar was increased on the occasion
of Eid
iii
Annexure
Shah Kamal What are the main items of inventory of your firm
Yaseer Rizvi Well these are ndash aluminum can pet chip sugar label chemical and
artificial sweet
Shah Kamal What are the uncertainties in maintaining appropriate level of stock
Yaseer Rizvi These are ndash
bull Increase in price of raw materials
bull Sales uncertainty
bull Market trends etc
Shah Kamal Thank you for your kind cooperation
Yaseer Rizvi Most Welcome
iv
Global Beverage Company Limited
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
2 Restricted Current Asset Investment Policy ndash
Holdings of cash securities inventories and receivables are minimized This is a
high risk strategy because the firm tries to keep the bare minimum of cash and
inventory The potential return is high because less money is invested in low
yielding assets
3 Moderate Current Asset Policy ndash
Balance between relaxed and restricted current asset investment policies (moderate
risk - moderate potential return)
Alternative Current Asset Financing Policies
These policies are general strategies that firms may follow with regard to how current
assets are to be financed Current assets can be classified as permanent or temporary
Permanent current assets are the current assets that the company needs to maintain
throughout the entire year Temporary current assets are those that are due to
seasonal fluctuations With respect to the current asset financing policy the question
is how the permanent current assets will and temporary current assets are financed
(long-term or short-term financing)
Page 6 of 46
Aggressive Moderate Conservative
Cash Minimum holding Prepared to hold
some precautionary
balances
Prepared to hold idle
cash balances
Debtors and
stock
Minimum
consistent with
business needs
Moderate levels High stock and
debtor levels to
maximize sales
Creditors Maximum
available without
compromising
business needs
Moderate level Low level seeking
discounts and
reputation for good
payment
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Future cash
flows
Predictable Reasonably
predictable
Unpredictable
Attitude to
Risk
Accepting Neutral Rejecting
Total assets = Fixed Assets + Permanent Current Assets + Fluctuating Current Assets
53 WORKING CAPITAL CYCLE
Cash flows in a cycle into around and out of a business It is the businesss life blood
and every managers primary task is to help keep it flowing and to use the cash flow
to generate profits If a business is operating profitably then it should in theory
generate cash surpluses If it doesnt generate surpluses the business will eventually
run out of cash and expire
The faster a business expands the more cash it will need for working capital and
investment The cheapest and best sources of cash exist as working capital right
within business Good management of working capital will generate cash will help
improve profits and reduce risks
Working capital can be broken down into the following major components cash (or
bank overdraft) stock debtors creditors Each of these items can have a major
influence on the working capital (or simply cash) that any business requires on an
ongoing basis For example when a business starts up the owner may inject a
certain amount of cash into the business which will enable him to purchase his initial
stock pay his workers their first months wages and cover other overheads such as
rent He then sells his product and this income may be utilized to purchase more
stock pay more wages and overheads and perhaps even have a surplus over for his
own use The quicker he can turn his stock over to receive payment the sooner the
working capital cycle will be completed
Page 7 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Figure Working Capital Cycle
These major components of working capital are discussed below
531 CASH MANAGEMENT
The term cash management refers to the management of cash from the time it starts
its transit to the firm until it leaves the firm in payments Cash management
encompasses the design of collection and disbursement systems for cash and the
temporary investment of cash while it resides with the firm Widely used money
market instruments are-
Treasury bill
Commercial paper
Certificate of deposits
Bankerrsquos acceptance
Page 8 of 46
Repurchase agreement
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
5311 Motives for Holding Cash
Despite the seemingly low returns there are several good reasons why firms hold
cash and marketable securities These reasons are ndash
Cash for transactions
Cash and near cash assets as hedges
Temporary investment and
Compensating balances
5312 Components of Cash Management
A Cash Flow Statement shows the sources and uses of cash and is typically divided
into three components
Operating Cash Flow
Operating cash flow often referred to as working capital is the cash flow generated
from internal operations It comes from sales of the product or service of your
business and because it is generated internally it is under your control
Investing Cash Flow
Investing cash flow is generated internally from non-operating activities This
includes investments in plant and equipment or other fixed assets nonrecurring gains
or losses or other sources and uses of cash outside of normal operations
Financing Cash Flow
Financing cash flow is the cash to and from external sources such as lenders
investors and shareholders
Page 9 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
5313 Tools for Cash Management
Flotation and Check Clearing
Management of cash when it is not in the firmrsquos hands that is in transit to and from
the firm is on important function in the area of finance Transit times for the check
takes in three stages These are mail float at firm float and clearing float Normally
mail float takes 1 to 5 days at firm float takes 025 to 1 day and clearing float takes 0
to 2 days The firm should care about this process because every delay in the receipt
of money by the firm lowers the firmrsquos returns and therefore its shareholdersrsquo wealth
There are several strategies that firm can use to reduce the delay in receiving funds
Each of these strategies addresses one or more of the three float times (mail float
time at time float time and clearing float time) that make up the total transit time of
fund from one firm to another
Other Cash Management Tools
When the economy is strong companies can lapse into sloppy cash-management
practices Firm should try exploring these options
1 Sweep accounts
These bank accounts are the easiest way to generate some income from companys
spare funds however they make sense only if the money youll earn will be greater
than the fees your bank will charge Business owners have two types of sweep
accounts to choose between
Page 10 of 46
Controlled-investment accounts These are the most profitable form of
sweep account but they wont work for company if the firm has any
electronic payments or wire transfers since those may be submitted for
payment later in the day and the account wont have enough cash in it to
cover them
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Page 11 of 46
End-of-day sweep accounts A safer bet for most small-business owners
these accounts wait until a late-hour cutoff to determine how much to
sweep into the firms overnight investments Typically their investment
yields are 10 to 20 basis points (1 to 2 of the investment) lower than
those offered with controlled investments
2 Lock-box accounts
A lock box is a cash-management system that helps the firm collect funds quickly
Generally set up with the assistance of a big money center or regional bank lock
boxes provide the firm with a special zip code and usually quicker deliveries from
regional post offices They are especially important if the firm has clusters of
customers in out-of-state locations and dont want to lose days waiting for their
checks to arrive by long-distance mail
5314 Cash Concentration and Cash Disbursement
Once the remittances from the firmrsquos customers have been received and cleared the
resulting cash balances is available in the firmrsquos lockbox (depository) banks It is
useful for the firm to gather these balances from the lockbox banks into the central
bank account The process of collecting funds is called cash concentration
Several concentration mechanism are available for the firm to use in transferring
funds from its collection banks to regional concentration banks and from there to the
central concentration bank These mechanisms differ in cost and in the availability of
funds that they provide These are ndash
a) Depository Transfer Check
It is the cheapest transfer mechanism This document instructs one bank to
send funds to another and is treated the same as any other check
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
b) Automated Clearing House (ACH) Electronic Transfer
This vehicle is essentially an electronic version of the depository transfer
check and can be used between banks that participate in the automated
clearing house system
c) Wire Transfer
These are electronic message between banks
Decisions regarding concentration mechanism usually hinge on the size and
spread of the firmrsquos deposits Firms with small deposits spread over a
substantial number of banks will tend to have more extensive concentration
systems and will transfer among accounts using low-cost transfer vehicles that
offer only delayed availability (such as depository transfer checks) Firms with
larger deposits will have fewer accounts (since a local deposit for transfer to
an upstream bank is not needed) and will use more expensive and more rapid
transfer mechanisms (such as wire transfers) The concentration systems of
major chemical companies for example tend to be structured in this way ndash
DepositoryLockbox Banks
Regional Concentration Banks
Central Concentrated Bank
Figure A typical Cash Concentration System
(Arrows indicate transfers of collected funds)
Page 12 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Disbursement management addresses the efficient payout out of this cash once it is
concentrated The firmrsquos objective in disbursement management is to retain the cash
for as long as possible In this way the firm will have the maximum amount of funds
available for investment and transactional purposes Certainly this management
means making disbursement only when they are due and not before The firm has
several available set of techniques for disbursement management Included among
these are ndash
a) Management of Disbursement Float
In this set of techniques the disbursing firm attempts to increase the length of
time between the mailing of its checks and the eventual withdrawal of funds
from the banks This involves strategies for increasing mail float at firm float
and clearing float on its outgoing checks For example the disbursing firm
may intentionally address checks to the firmrsquos office address rather than its
lockbox creating at firm float
b) Zero-Balance Accounts
Here the firm holds the cash until the check arrive (or expected to arrive) at
the disbursement bank In this strategy an account for disbursement is first
established at a bank For the zero-balance system to be effective the
participating bank must be one on which most disbursement are made via the
Bangladesh Bankrsquos clearance system (which presents disbursements to banks
early in the morning) and not a bank where disbursements occur throughout
the day (as with a major money-center bank) Consequently the banks used
in zero-balance strategies are usually branches of major banks and not their
main locations
Page 13 of 46
c) Controlled Disbursing
In this system the firm projects the amount of checks to arrive each day at the
disbursement bank (based on the checks written in previous days and historic
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
statistics on disbursement float) and transfers the amount of the expected
checks to the account on that day or just before
5315 Cash Forecasting
Defining Cash Forecasting
The cash forecast is an estimation of the flows in and out of the firmrsquos cash account
over a particular period of time usually a quarter month week or day The cash
forecast is primarily intended to produce a very useful piece of information an
estimation of the firmrsquos borrowing and lending needs and uncertainties regarding
these needs during various future periods Cash forecasting is very crucial to most
firms It enables them to anticipate periods of surplus cash and periods where
financing will be necessary This anticipation is the reason that cash forecasts are
generated Anticipation enables the firm to plan much more effectively for
investment and financing and via this planning produce superior return
Types of Cash Forecasts
The types of cash forecasts generated by firms can be differentiated along two
dimensions the length of the periods included within the cash forecast and the approach
to cash flows used in the cash forecast The length of the period refers to the units of
time into which the cash forecast is divided Firms may make cash flow forecasts
over periods of various lengths yearly flows quarterly flows monthly flows weekly
flows or even daily flows The most popular forecast involves monthly flows but
most firms do not confine themselves to a single forecast Instead they use several
forecasts with periods of various lengths When the firm makes forecasts involving
multiple and overlapping period lengths one forecast relates to another Starting
with data on relatively long periods and breaking it down into smaller periods is
called distribution starting with data on relatively short periods and aggregating into
longer periods is called scheduling
Page 14 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Firms use two common approaches to cash flows in generating the cash forecast the
receipts and disbursements approach and the adjusted net income approach The receipts
and disbursements approach use the amounts of cash expected to be received and
disbursed by the firm over the periods chosen for forecast The adjusted income
statement approach is sometimes called the sources and use approach Here the
forecaster starts with projected net income on an accrual basis and adjusts to a cash
basis This method provides a representation of changes in asset and liability
accounts since the level of these accounts are of interest to the firm this aspect of the
adjusted income statement is an advantage over the receipts and disbursements
method
Items to Be Forecast
In the receipt and disbursements cash forecasting method estimates need to be made
of the numerous major and minor items that the firm collects (receipts) and that it
pays (disbursements) The more individual categories of items the firm includes in its
forecast procedure the more accurate the forecast may be but the more costly in
terms of time and effort it will be to generate
Some Possible Types of Cash Receipts and Cash Disbursements
Cash Disbursements Cash Receipts
Cash Purchases of Materials Payroll
Taxes
Maturing Accounts Payable
Maturing Notes Payable
Miscellaneous Disbursements
Accounts Receivable
Notes Receivable
Rental Income
Interest Income
Miscellaneous Receipts
Methods of Financial Forecasting
Page 15 of 46
Financial forecasting is the estimation of the future level of a financial variable often
a cash flow asset level or liability level It is usually assumed that the relationship
between the financial variable and other variable is linear The general linear model
can then be used
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
nnt xaxaxaaY 22110 ++=
Here
= Financial variable (Y) to be forecast in period t tY
x = Explanatory variable it is assumed to cause the level of Y in period t
0a = Represents a constant unaffected by the x
The other terms are the estimated coefficients of the explanatory x variables
There are n terms with xrsquos in them
There are four common approaches to forecasting financial variables but they
are all special cases of the general linear model These are ndash spot method proportion
to another account compounded growth and multiple dependencies
Using Cash Forecast
The estimate of available funds for investment and needed financing enables the firm
to plan so as to obtain the most advantages borrowing terms for deficits and achieve
the greatest interest income on surplus A useful chart for this planning purpose is a
bar chart eg
Figure Bar Chart of Cash Surpluses and Deficits from hypothetical data
Page 16 of 46
75
50
-60
30
100
-20
-80-60-40-20
020406080
100120
Defic
it
S
urpl
us
January February March April May June
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Sources of Uncertainty in Cash Forecasting and Hedging Uncertainties
There are numerous sources of risk in cash forecasting Among the sources are sales
uncertainty collection rate uncertainty production cost uncertainty and capital
outflow uncertainty
5316 Models for the Management of Cash and Temporary Investments
There are different models for the management of cash and temporary investments
Among these the most popular methods are ndash Baumol model Beranek model
Miller-Orr model and Stone model
Baumol and Beranek use the same model The formula is cited below ndash
Interest Income = iYn
n⎥⎦⎤
⎢⎣⎡ minus
21
Profit = naiYn
nminus⎥⎦
⎤⎢⎣⎡ minus
21
Optimum number of transactions = ⎟⎠⎞
⎜⎝⎛
aiY2
Where n = Optimum number of transactions
i = Interest rate per period
a = Transaction cost
Y = Total inflow for the period
Page 17 of 46
Miller-Orr and Stone use the same model ie R-Statistic The model is ndash
31
43
iav
R ⎟⎠⎞
⎜⎝⎛=
Optimum Control Limit = R + L
Upper Control Limit = 3R + L
Where a = Transaction Cost
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
v = Variance of daily cash flows
i = Daily interest rate
5317 Administration
Cash receipts should be processed and banked as quickly as possible because
They cannot earn interest or reduce overdraft until they are banked
information about the existence and amounts of cash receipts is usually not
available until they are processed
Where possible cash floats (mainly petty cash and advances) should be avoided If
on review the only reason that can be put forward for their existence is that weve
always had them they should be discontinued There may be situations where they
are useful however For example it may be desirable for peripheral parts of
departments to meet urgent local needs from cash floats rather than local bank
accounts
5318 Internal Control
Cash and cash management is part of a firms overall internal control system The
main internal cash control is invariably the bank reconciliation This provides
assurance that the cash balances recorded in the accounting systems are consistent
with the actual bank balances It requires regular clearing of reconciling items
5319 Practicing Good Cash Flow Management
Good cash management is simple It involves
Knowing when where and how firms cash needs will occur
Page 18 of 46
Knowing the best sources for meeting additional cash needs
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Page 19 of 46
Being prepared to meet these needs when they occur by keeping good
relationships with bankers and other creditors
532 INVENTORY MANAGEMENT
Inventory management is necessary for owners who want to maintain a stocking
service for quick turnaround to help ensure total customer satisfaction The fill rate
of an item on a managed inventory list must be maintained to avoid shortages of
frequently used items Even when utilizing an inventory management system
occasional shortages will still occur Inventories are lists of stocks-raw materials
work in progress or finished goods-waiting to be consumed in production or to be
sold The total balance of inventory is the sum of the value of each individual stock
line
Basically firms hold stocks for the following reasons
To act as a buffer in times of unusually high demand
To ensure continuity of production
Avoid high costs of emergency orders
To take advantage of quantity discounts by ordering more at a time
To reduce ordering costs by ordering more items on fewer
As part of the production process eg maturing whisky or keeping oil in
pipelines
Seasonality of demand (eg firework) or supplies
Suppliers insist on minimum order quantities
The key issue for a business is to identify the fast and slow stock movers with the
objectives of establishing optimum stock levels for each category and thereby
minimize the cash tied up in stocks Factors to be considered when determining
optimum stock levels include
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Page 20 of 46
What are the projected sales of each product
How widely available are raw materials components etc
How long does it take for delivery by suppliers
Can the firm remove slow movers from its product range without
compromising best sellers
Inventory management is an important aspect of working capital management
because inventories themselves do not earn any revenue Holding either too little or
too much inventory incurs costs
Costs of carrying too much inventory are
Opportunity cost of foregone interest
Warehousing costs
Damage and pilferage
Obsolescence
Insurance
Costs of carrying too little inventory are
Stock out costs
Lost sales
Delayed service
Ordering costs
Freight
on Order administrati
nts
Loss of quantity discou
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Carrying costs can be minimized by making frequent small orders but this increase
ordering costs and the risk of stock outs Risk of stock-outs can be reduced by
carrying safety stocks (at a cost) and re-ordering ahead of time
The best ordering strategy requires balancing the various cost factors to ensure the
firm incurs minimum inventory costs The optimum inventory position is known as
the Economic Reorder Quantity (ERQ)
Nowadays many large manufacturers operate on a just-in-time (JIT) basis whereby
all the components to be assembled on a particular today arrive at the factory early
that morning no earlier - no later This helps to minimize manufacturing costs as JIT
stocks take up little space minimize stock-holding and virtually eliminate the risks of
obsolete or damaged stock Because JIT manufacturers hold stock for a very short
time they are able to conserve substantial cash JIT is a good model to strive for as it
embraces all the principles of prudent stock management For better stock control
firm may try the following
Review the effectiveness of existing purchasing and inventory systems
Know the stock turn for all major items of inventory
Apply tight controls to the significant few items and simplify controls for the
trivial many
Sell off outdated or slow moving merchandise - it gets more difficult to sell the
longer the firm keeps it
Consider having part of its product outsourced to another manufacturer rather
than make it itself
Review its security procedures to ensure that no stock is going out the back
door
Higher than necessary stock levels tie up cash and cost more in insurance
accommodation costs and interest charges
Page 21 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
However it is important to keep an overall perspective It is not cost-effective to
closely manage a large number of low value inventory lines nor is it necessary A
usual feature of inventories is that a small number of high value lines account for a
large proportion of inventory value The 8020 rule (PARETO) predicts that 80
of the total value of inventory is represented by only 20 of the number of inventory
items Those high value lines need reasonably close management The remaining
80 of inventory lines can be managed using broad-brush strategies
533 MANAGING ACCOUNTS RECEIVABLE (DEBTORS)
Cash flow can be significantly enhanced if the amounts owing to a business are
collected faster Every business needs to know who owes them money how much is
owed how long it is owing for what it is owed
Debtors (Accounts Receivable) are customers who have not yet made payment for
goods or services which the department has provided The objective of debtor
management is to minimize the time-lapse between completion of sales and receipt
of payment The costs of having debtors are
Opportunity costs (cash is not available for other purposes)
Bad debts
If firm doesnt manage debtors they will begin to manage business as the firm will gradually
lose control due to reduced cash flow and of course it could experience an increased
incidence of bad debt The following measures will help manage debtors
Having the right mental attitude to the control of credit and make sure that it
gets the priority it deserves
Establishing clear credit practices as a matter of company policy
Page 22 of 46
Making sure that these practices are clearly understood by staff suppliers and
customers
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Page 23 of 46
Being professional when accepting new accounts and especially larger ones
Checking out each customer thoroughly before the firm offers credit Use
credit agencies bank references industry sources etc
Establishing credit limits for each customer and sticking to them
Continuously reviewing these limits when it suspects tough times are coming
or if operating in a volatile sector
Keeping very close to the firms larger customers
Invoicing promptly and clearly
Considering charging penalties on overdue accounts
Considering accepting credit debit cards as a payment option
Monitoring its debtor balances and ageing schedules and dont let any debts
get too large or too old
Debtor management includes both pre-sale and debt collection strategies
Pre-sale strategies include
Offering cash discounts for early payment andor imposing penalties for late
payment
Agreeing payment terms in advance
Requiring cash before delivery
Setting credit limits
ning credit Setting criteria for obtai
Billing as early as possible
rogress payments
ost-sale strategies include
for collecting the debt upon the center that made the sale
Requiring deposits andor p
P
Placing the responsibility
Identifying long overdue balances and doubtful debts by regular analytical reviews
Having an established procedure for late collections such as
A reminder
A letter
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Page 24 of 46
ion of further credit Cancellat
Telephone calls
n agency Use of a collectio
he firm should recognize that the longer someone owes firm the greater the chance
Legal action
T
it will never get paid If the average age of debtors is getting longer or is already very
long it may need to look for the following possible defects
Weak credit judgment
res Poor collection procedu
ms Lax enforcement of credit ter
Slow issue of invoices or statements
Errors in invoices or statements
Customer dissatisfaction
Debtors due over 90 days (unless within agreed credit terms) should generally
demand immediate attention For example warning signs of a future bad debt ndash
Longer credit terms taken with approval particularly for smaller orders
Use of post-dated checks by debtors who normally settle within agreed terms
Evidence of customers switching to additional suppliers for the same goods
New customers who are reluctant to give credit references
Cre G
Receiving part payments from debtors
dit ranting to Marginal Accounts
Traditional Approach
In the traditional approach to the credit granting decision it is the credit analysts job
rmation that has been collected and reach a judgment
regarding the applicants creditworthiness One traditional way of organizing this
to synthesize all the info
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
information is by characterizing the applicant along five dimensions These
dimensions are called the Five Cs of credit ndash
Capital
Character
Collateral
and Capacity
Conditions
Net Present Value (NPV) Approach
Once a firm has assessed the creditworthiness of a customer it has to decide whether
r not credit should be granted The firm should use the NPV rule to make the
ld be granted
Figure
o
decision If NPV is positive credit shou
Credit Granting Decision
Credit Granting Decision
he act of collecting money is one which most people dislike for many reasons and
therefore put on the long f selves there is something
ore urgent or important that demands their attention now There is nothing more
T
inger because they convince them
m
important than getting paid for firms product or service A customer who does not
Page 25 of 46
Grand Credit
Payment received Payment not received
Benefit of present value of future net cash flow
Cost of present value ment of lost invest
Net Payoff PV of benefit-cost
No Credit
No Payoff
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
pay is not a customer Here are a few ideas that may help the firm in collecting
money from debtors
Firm should develop appropriate procedures for handling late payments
It should track and pursue late payers
It might get external help if its own efforts fail
or money its firms and it is entitled Company shouldnt feel guilty asking f
to it
ction
Firm must make that call now And it should keep asking until it gets some
satisfa
lessens the problem
In difficult circumstances take what the firm can now and agree terms for the
remainder It
paying
When asking for money be hard on the issue - but soft on the person It shouldnt
give the debtor any excuses for not
534 BLE (CREDITORS)
ices for goods or services have
een paid Organizations often regard the
not
to delay all payments until the latest possible date Regular weekly or
The firm make it its objective is to get the money - not to score points or get
even
MANAGING ACCOUNTS PAYA
Creditors (Accounts Payable) are suppliers whose invo
been processed but who have not yet b
amount owing to creditors as a source of free credit However creditor
administration systems are expensive and time-consuming to run The over-riding
concern in this area should be to minimize costs with simple procedures
While it is unnecessary to pay accounts before they fall due it is usually
worthwhile
Page 26 of 46
fortnightly payment of all due accounts is the simplest technique for creditor
management
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Electronic payments (direct credits) are cheaper than check payments considering
that transaction fees and overheads more than balance the advantage of delayed
presentation Some suppliers are reluctant to receive payments by this method but in
view of the substantial cost advantage (and the advantages to the suppliers
themselves) departments may wish to encourage suppliers to accept this option
However electronic payments are likely to be used in conjunction with rather than
as a replacement for check payments
Applying Best Practices in Managing Accounts Payable
f course simply deferring payments to suppliers could have adverse consequences
O
that more than offset the benefits of this additional cash flow Therefore it is
important to develop a holistic approach The firm should consider the following
best practices for payables management
Managing payment dates and terms to maximize cash flow ndash
y reporting on
receivable and
id penalty charges and taking advantage of
wer vendors and negotiate for more
to buying consortia with others even
voices for
payment based on receipt of goods or receipt of invoice whichever
comes later
Calculating and setting performance targets Regularl
AP performance measures such as days in payables
Coordinating the AP processes with accounts
inventory management to ensure that the company is collecting more
cash than it is paying out
Paying bills on time to avo
prompt-payment discounts where the discounts exceed the companyrsquos
cost of working capital
Consolidating purchases with fe
favorable payment terms
Considering entering in
Page 27 of 46
competitors to obtain favorable supplier pricing and terms
Unless contract terms specify otherwise setting up in
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Page 28 of 46
Em
process
-time payments with Electronic Funds Transfer (EFT)
uraging vendors to utilize electronic invoice presentment
a
ndancies and more
ploying technology to automate the accounts payable transaction
es ndash
Making just-in
Using an electronic invoice-matching application
Enco
For companies with multiple locations or business units employing
shared service approach for AP to eliminate redu
quickly implement process improvements
Mainta
vendor
Communicating accounts payable requirements to suppliers at the
m key suppliers
for suggestions on how to improve the
Efficient a
and making th rsquos cash is just good business
ining open communications and building strong relationships with
s to access valuable trade credit ndash
beginning of transactions
Requesting summary invoicing fro
Requiring suppliers to send invoices directly to accounts payable
Asking tier-one suppliers
payment process
nd effective management of accounts payable helps improve cash flow ndash
e most of company
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
6 OVERVIEW OF VIRGIN GROUP
Virgin - one of the most respected brands in Britain - is now becoming the first global
brand name of the 21st century Virgin is involved in planes trains finance soft
drinks music mobile phones holidays cars wines publishing bridal wear - the lot
What tie all these businesses together are the values of its brand and the attitude of its
people Virgin has created over 200 companies worldwide employing over 25000
people Its total revenues around the world in 2002 exceeded pound4 billion (US $72
billion)
In 1970 Richard Branson founded Virgin as a mail order record retailer and not
long after he opened a record shop in Oxford Street London During 1972 a
recording studio was built in Oxfordshire and the first Virgin artist Mike Oldfield
recorded Tubular Bells which was released in 1973
This album went on to sell over 5 million copies Since then many household names
including Belinda Carlisle Genesis Phil Collins Janet Jackson and The Rolling
Stones have helped to make Virgin Music one of the top six record companies in the
world The equity of Virgin Music Group - record labels music publishing and
recording studios was sold to THORN EMI in 1992 in a US$1billion deal
Page 29 of 46
The Virgin Group has now expanded into international music Mega stores air
travel mobile financial retail music internet drinks rail hotels and leisure with
around 200 companies in over 30 countries
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
In Virgins customers eyes Virgin stands for value for money quality innovation
fun and a sense of competitive challenge It delivers a quality service by empowering
its employees and facilitates and monitors customer feedback to continually improve
the customers experience through innovation
When they start a new venture Virgin bases it on hard research and analysis
Typically they review the industry and put themselves in the customers shoes to see
what could make it better Virgin asks fundamental questions
Is this an opportunity for restructuring a market and creating competitive
advantage What are the competitors doing
Is the customer confused or badly served
Is this an opportunity for building the Virgin brand
Can we add value
Will it interact with its other businesses
Is there an appropriate trade-off between risk and reward
Page 30 of 46
Virgin is also able to draw on talented people from throughout the group New
ventures are often steered by people seconded from other parts of Virgin who bring
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
with them the trademark management style skills and experience Virgin frequently
creates partnerships with others to combine skills knowledge and market presence
and so on Contrary to what some people may think their constantly expanding and
eclectic empire is neither random nor reckless Each successive venture demonstrates
its skill in picking the right market and the right opportunity
7 OVERVIEW OF VIRGIN SOFT DRINKS
The Virgin Drinks Group first launched as the Virgin Cola Company in 1994 with
Virgin Cola in the UK Since then the company has ventured across the carbonated
soft drinks arena and beyond into energy drinks tea and flavored Colas This
expansion has lead to the evolution of the Virgin Drinks Company a company
whose aim is to put the excitement back into the world of soft drinks It launched in
Bangladesh in 1999 Virgin Soft Drinks is monitored by Global Beverage Co Ltd in
Bangladesh
Brief history of Virgin Drinks is given below
Page 31 of 46
1994 November Virgin Cola launched in the UK
1996 March Virgin Cola launched in France
1998 June Virgin Cola launched in Belgium
April Virgin Cola launched in the French West Indies
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
August Virgin Cola launched in Switzerland
1999 March Virgin Colours launched in Italy
March Virgin Cola launched in Japan
July Virgin Colours launched in South Africa
December Virgin Colours launched in Bangladesh
2001 January Sweden launched Virgin Colours
November Singapore launched Virgin Colours
2002 February Croatia launched Virgin Colours
June Russia launched Virgin Colours
June Tunisia launched Virgin Colours
2003 May Israel launched Virgin Colours
8 FINDINGS OF WORKING CAPITAL MANAGEMENT MAINTAINED BY
VIRGIN SOFT DRINKS IN BANGLADESH
81 CASH MANAGEMENT
811 Holding Cash and Marketable Securities
Although there are many good reasons why firm hold cash and marketable
securities Virgin Drinks holds cash and marketable securities for two reasons ndash
i) Cash for transactions
ii) Cash as hedges
This indicates that the firm does not hold cash and marketable securities for some
important reasons such as ndash
i) Near cash assets as hedges
Page 32 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
ii) Temporary investment and compensating balances
Virgin Soft Drinks does not invest in money market securities such as Treasury bill
commercial paper certificate of deposits bankerrsquos acceptance and repurchase
agreement This firm deposits its money in bank as currant AC or fixed AC They
say that they do not have enough money to invest in money market instrument
They also say that if they have enough money they will invest it in money market
short term securities We know that near cash interest earning assets can be
substituted for cash when motivation for holding these assets is the hedging of cash
flow uncertainties or is the temporary investment of surplus funds In this point
Virgins position is not good as there is no significant hedging against uncertainty of
cash
812 Floatation and Check Clearing
Virgin is very smart in handling the problem of transit time for checks Here mail
float takes 2 to 3 days at firm takes 025 day and clearing float takes 1-3 days Virgin
uses most of the strategies available for reducing the delay in receiving funds It
(Virgin) has linked Islami Bank which posses an accelerated clearing facility It uses
electronic collection process which ensures faster collection and its at the firm check
processing is satisfactory But Virgin does not use lockbox The reason behind this is
that it is not cost-effective for Virgin to set lockboxes At this point we can say that
Virgins check clearing mechanism is much good
813 Cash Concentration and Disbursement Management
Page 33 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks takes the matter of cash concentration very seriously They use all
the available cash concentration mechanism Virgin is a firm with small deposits
spread over a substantial number of banks and this is why the firm tends to use
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
depository transfer checks extensively If is less costly Virgin also uses automated
clearing house and wire transfer To Virgin wire transfer seems too costly
Like other firm Virgin tries to retain the cash for as long as possible But Virgin
always performs it in an ethical manner Virgin does not try to defeat the receiving
firmrsquos attempts to reduce the float on incoming checks It does not take any strategy
for increasing mail float at firm float and clearing float on its outgoing checks To
Virgin it is deemed to be unethical It thinks that maximization of disbursement float
will not go unnoticed by sophisticated creditors for very long When it is noticed it
will negatively affect relations with these creditors reducing the firmrsquos bargaining
power with them This may ultimately cost Virgin dearly when future prices and
delivery schedules for goods and services purchased from trade creditors are
negotiated Virgin follows ldquoZero-Balance Accountsrdquo methods for managing
disbursement It thinks that in this method the coordination of funds inflows to
disbursement banks with the presentation of checks does not work to the detriment
of creditors since the firmrsquos checks to them are honored as presented and this strategy
does not affect float significantly Controlled disbursing method is less attractive to
Virgin because zero-balance system is already feasible
814 Cash Forecasting
Cash Forecasting and Its Types
Page 34 of 46
Virgin forecasts the future cash inflows and outflows To Virgin cash forecast is an
important part of the firmrsquos cash control system and is one of the forecasts that are
part of the Virginrsquos financial plan Virgin forecasts cash on monthly basis and on
yearly basis Virgin does not forecast on daily basis assuming that the temporary
shortage of funds within these periods can be covered without value cost eg
advance receipts from customers Virginrsquos cash forecasting system involves a
combination of distribution and scheduling The receipts and disbursements
approach of cash forecasting is used in virgin This method is used because it
minutely traces the movement of cash and very close control of cash is possible
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Virgin does not use adjusted net income approach on two grounds First it does not
permit the tracing of the individual types of cash inflows and outflows for any given
period which is often useful information for virgin Second it is not simple to use
Items to be Forecast
Virgin does not forecast all the items It forecasts only major items eg accounts
receivable notes receivable payroll cash purchases of raw materials In this regard
virgin trade off between cost and benefit
Methods of Financial Forecasting
Virgin forecasts the future level of financial variable such as cash level asset level or
liability level We know in short term forecasts many things will result from plans
and events that are already in place (contracts capital budgets long-range financing
plans and so forth) But in the long run most things can vary and are dependent on
outside influences such as the firmrsquos long-term growth rate Since Virginrsquos cash
forecasting deals mostly with near future many of the items on the cash forecasts are
estimated by some variation of the spot method and remaining estimates are mostly
on a ldquoproportion of another accountrdquo basis with this ldquoother accountrdquo often being a
particular periodrsquos sales Virgin uses the other two methods less frequently
Using Cash Forecast
Virgin forecasts cash for meeting general objectives (ie to know the available funds
for investment and need financing) and for meeting some special objectives (eg to
know whether the firm will fulfill its out of debt requirement) But it is matter to note
that Virgin does not make any short term investment of its surplus cash but only keep
this surplus in Bank Account
Page 35 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Sources of Uncertainty in Cash Forecasting and Hedging Uncertainties
Virgin faces uncertainty in cash forecasting mainly from two sources These are ndash
sales and production cost In peak season (hot season like autumn summer) sales
increases but in dull season (eg in winter) sales decreases drastically Production
cost may be increased because of increase of price of sugar chemicals aluminum
can Virgin follows two methods for hedging cash balance uncertainties These are ndash
i) Holding a stock of extra cash and
ii) Extra borrowing capacity
815 Modes for the Management of Cash and Temporary Investments
Virgin does not follow any of these methods wholly Virgin receives cash
continuously and pays salary at steady rate and pays continuously for other
expenses So it neither follows Baumol model nor Beranek model It has no upper
control limit lower control limit return point in case cash management So it neither
follows Miller-Orr model nor Stone model
In Summary
Page 36 of 46
Standard Compliance by Virgin Soft Drinks
Generally all firms hold cash and
marketable securities
Virgin holds only cash
Firms hold cash and marketable
securities for some reasons like
bull Cash for transactions
bull Cash and near-cash assets as
hedges
bull Temporary investments
bull Compensating balances
Virgin holds cash only for
two reasons ndash
bull Cash for transactions
bull Cash as hedges
Available money market instruments Virgin does not invest in any such
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
(short term securities) are ndash
Treasury Bills
Commercial Paper
Certificates of Deposit
Bankerrsquos Acceptance
Repurch menase Agree ts
instruments They only keep cash in
Bank Account
Mail Float
(1 to 5 days)
At Firm
Float
(025 to 1
day)
Clearing
Float
(0 to
2 days)
Mail Float
(2 to 3 days)
At firm
Float
(025
day)
Clearing
Float
(1 to 3
days)
Figure Transit time for a typical check Figure Transit time for a check for
Virgin
Strategies that firms can use to reduce
the delay in receiving funds are ndash
Selecting of Banks with
accelerated clearing capabilities
of check processing Acceleration
at the firm
ectronic collection Use of el
procedures
Use of lockboxes
Virgin follows the first three strategies
but does not use lockboxes
Available cash concentration
mechanisms are ndash
Depository transfer check
ouse Automated Clearing H
(ACH) electronic transfer)
Wire transfer
Virgin uses all these mechanisms of
cash concentration
Available sets of techniques for cash
disbursement management are ndash
ement of disbursement
Page 37 of 46
Manag
float
Virgin uses zero-balance accounts
technique
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Zero-Balance Accounts
Controlled disbursing
Firms may make cash flow forecasts
over periods of various lengths yearly
flows quarterly flows monthly flows
weekly flows or even daily flows
Virgin forecasts cash on yearly basis and
monthly basis
Cash forecasting system may involve ndash
Distribution
Scheduling
Virginrsquos cash forecasting system
involves a combination of distribution
and scheduling
Two common approaches to cash flow
in generating the cash forecast
and disbursement Receipts
approach
Adjusted net income approach
Virgin uses the receipts and
disbursement approach
There are many items to forecast Virgin forecasts only major items like
AR payroll etc
Four common approach to forecasting
fina i ndash nc al variables are
Spot method
Proportion to another account
Compounded growth
Multiple dependencies
Virgin uses spot method for forecasting
cash It uses proportion to another
account method for other variables and
remaining two methods are frequently
used
Sources of uncertainty in cash
forecasting are ndash
Sales uncertainty
Collection rate uncertainty
Production cost uncertainty
Capital outflow uncertainty
Virgin faces uncertainty mainly from
sales and production cost
Methods for hedging cash balance
unc a
Page 38 of 46
ert inties are ndash
i) Holding a stock of extra cash
Virgin two available methods for
hedging cash balance uncertainties
Th ese are ndash
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
ii) stock of near-cash Holding a
assets
iii) Extra borrowing capacity
iv) ary surpluses in Investing tempor
near-cash assets
i) Holding a stock of extra cash
ii) Extra borrowing capacity
(advance receipt from
customers)
Models for the management of cash and
temporary investments are ndash Baumol
model Beranek model Miller-Orr
model and Stone model
Virgin does not follow any method
wholly but a combination of Baumol
model and Beranek model is occurred
82 INVENTORY MANAGEMENT
21 Certainty Approach
isnt used in
irgin because it thinks it is not possible to implement in Bangladesh
d time is one to three days It
oes not use ABC system of inventory management
8
Main item of inventory of Virgin is Can pet chip sugar label chemical artificial
sweet etc Virgin maintains a minimum level of inventory but it does not have to face
problems because inventory is managed efficiently just-in-time (JIT)
V
Virgin maintains buffer stock because of the shortage of work-in-process (WIP)
inventory Its production process may also be hampered Thats why it maintains
safety stock to avoid stock out cost In case of imported goods normal lead time is
about one month and within the country normal lea
d
Page 39 of 46
Inventory Model
In reality Virgin does not use any of models of EOQ ordering and holding strategy
and safety stock strategy They maintain inventory based on their prior experience
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
822 Uncertainty Approach
Virgin does not use any model for handling inventory uncertainty It says that such
decision depends on business cycle and market situation Long before Eid festival
they bought large amount of sugar because of price increase on the occasion of Eid
In summary
Standard Compliance by Virgin Soft Drinks
Firms maintain inventory to guard
against several problems
Virgin maintains a minimum level of
inventory which is managed efficiently
Some firms use JIT to avoid inventory
cost
JIT is not used by Virgin as it thinks it is
impossible to implement in Bangladesh
Firms maintain buffer stock Virgin maintains buffer stock too
Firms maintain safety stock to avoid
shortage cost
Virgin also maintains safety stock
Firms use ABC system to monitor
inventory
Virgin doesnt use ABC system
EOQ model is an appropriate method
for measuring quantity that has to be
ordered per order
Virgin does not use EOQ model rather
makes order based on experience and
market demand
83 MANAGING ACCOUNTS RECEIVABLE (DEBTORS)
831 Terms of Sale Decision
Page 40 of 46
Virgin offers the term 210 net 30 enables the customers to deduct 2 percent from the
face value of the bill when paying within the first 10 days but if the discount is not
taken the customer must remit the full amount within 30 days But Virgin does not
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
offer the same terms of sale to all customers For prime customers it offers special
terms of sale In setting an appropriate term of sale it costs and benefits regarding
this are compared It uses the standard approach of terms of sale decision as it is
simple to use
832 Credit Granting Decisions
In case of Virgin the Capital and Character of Five Cs get more importance
Although there are many problems with the traditional approach Virgin uses it
because of its simplicity Virgin does not use Net Present Value (NPV) method in
credit granting decision It thinks that NPV is an appropriate method and should be
used next time It does not face any severe problem because of bad debts The reason
is that notes receivable is used when credit is granted
833 Monitoring Accounts Receivable
Virgin monitors its accounts receivable Virgin believes that in any case both positive
and negative durations in accounts signal differences from the results that
management believe to be the most advantageous for the firm
Tools for Monitoring Accounts Receivable
Page 41 of 46
For monitoring accounts receivable there are several tools such as aging schedule
the ratios of receivable outstanding to original sales customers payment proportion
and sales weighted DSO (Days Sales Outstanding) For monitoring accounts
receivable Virgin uses aging schedule fractions and traditional DSO statistics
because of their simplicity in use Although payment proportions ratios of
receivables outstanding and sales weighted DSO methods are free from inherent bias
None of these is used because all these are complex to maintain
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
In summary
Page 42 of 46
Standard Compliance by Virgin Soft Drinks
Generals terms of sale is 210 net 30 Normally Virgin also use general terms
of sale ie 210 net 30
Firms do not offer the same terms of
sale to all customers
Yes For prime customers Virgin offers
special terms of sale
Approaches of terms of sale decisions
are ndash
bull Standard approach
bull Multi period approach
Virgin uses standard approach of terms
of sale decision as it is simple to use and
understand
Source of credit information are ndash
Sellers prior experience with the
customer
Credit agency ratings and
reports
Personal contact with the
applicants bank and other
creditors
Analysis of applicants financial
statements
Customer visit
Main source of credit information to
Virgin is its prior experience with the
customer All other sources are not cost-
effective for Virgin
Approaches of credit granting to
marginal accounts are ndash
Traditional approach
Net Present Value (NPV)
approach
It uses traditional approach still now but
thinks that NPV should be used for the
next periods
Firms monitor accounts receivable
because deviations from the expected
levels of turnover and of bad debt can
Virgin also monitors its accounts
receivable
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
signal several different problems
Different tools for monitoring accounts
receivable are ndash
Aging schedule
Ratios of receivables
outstanding to original sales
Customers payment
proportions
Sales-weighted DSO
For monitoring accounts receivable
Virgin uses aging schedule and
traditional sales outstanding statistics
84 MANAGING ACCOUNTS PAYABLE (CREDITORS)
Virgin has almost accounts payable of Tk 8000000 But most of its liabilities are to
the banks rather than suppliers But we dont have any clear information about
Virgins accounts payable
9 RECOMMENDATION
Virgin should invest its surplus cash in short term marketable securities
because it is suitable hedging against cash uncertainties and will also give
some returns (interest income)
Virgin should publish its own annual report which will satisfy information
needs of stakeholders and also increase the credibility of information provided
by Virgin
Page 43 of 46
Virgin should use multi period approach in terms of sale decision because
standard approach which is already exists in Virgin has some inherent
problems
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
It should stop using traditional approach from now It should use NPV
method in credit granting to marginal accounts
In monitoring accounts receivable Virgin should use sales-weighted DSO
method because it has least limitation compared to the others
It should be more flexible in granting credit which will ultimately increase its
sales
To get the appropriate number of quantity to be ordered per order it should
use DSO model
It should be ABC system for proper monitoring of inventory
10 CONCLUSION
The use of other peoples money in business is usually an expensive resource Before
looking outside for finance a firm should examine its own working capital cycle to
make sure that every rand of its own internal funds is being fully utilized Good
management of working capital is part of good financial management Effective use
of working capital will contribute to the operational efficiency of the whole
organization optimum use will help to generate maximum returns Furthermore
working capital management is not an end in itself It is an integral part of the firms
overall management The needs of efficient working capital management must be
considered in relation to other aspects of the Virgins financial and non-financial
performance Thats why when planning the development of a business it is critical
that the impact of working capital be fully assessed
Page 44 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
BIBLIOGRAPHY
Scherr FC (1989) International Edition Prentice-Hall International Inc Modern
Working Capital Management Text and Cases
Hussain Riaz (2002) Working Capital Management
Robertson Lonnie (July 1998) Inventory Management
httpwwwasashoporg visited on March 13 2006
The Art of Cash Management
httpwwwinccom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management
httpwwwstudyfinancecom visited on March 13 2006
White Paper ndash Managing Working Capital
httpwwwplanwareorg visited on March 13 2006
Management of Working Capital
httpwwwbusinesscentralcoza visited on March 13 2006
Cash Management
httpwwwsbagov visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management Objectives
httpwpsprenhallcom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management
Page 45 of 46
httpwwwadvancemecom visited on March 13 2006
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Business Receivables Financing
httpwwwbbtcom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Finance
http wwwfnbcoza visited on March 13 2006
Tips to manage your working capital
httpsmallbusinessninemsncomau visited on March 13 2006
Inventory Financing
httpwwwfranklincapitalnetworkcom visited on March 13 2006
Accounts Receivable Management
httpwwwfranklincapitalnetworkcom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management
httpwwwtreasurygovtnz visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management
httpwwwtreasurystrategiescom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Works
httpwwwinvestopediacom visited on March 13 2006
Treasury Services
httpwwwjpmorganchasecom visited on March 13 2006
what were about
Page 46 of 46
httpwwwvirgincom visited on March 13 2006
Annexure
Annexure
Interview with YASEER RIZVI
Mr Yaseer Rizvi the DMD of Global Beverage Co Ltd obtained his MBA degree
from a reputed university He had been the Director of Ocean Container Ltd before
joining in Global Beverage Co Ltd He possesses a nice personality
I interviewed Yaseer Rizvi Excerpts from his interview are as follows ndash
Shah Kamal Sir would you please tell me do you invest in short term marketable securities
Yaseer Rizvi Basically we do not invest our surplus cash in short term marketable
securities like T-Bill commercial paper certificate of deposit etc But we keep our
surplus cash in Bank
Shah Kamal Would you tell me something about transit time for a typical check
Yaseer Rizvi Well in Virgin the transit time for a typical check is ndash
For mail float 2 to 3 days
At firm float 6 hours
Clearing float 1 to 3 days
Shah Kamal Do you maintain any cash concentration mechanism like depository transfer check automated clearing house and wire transfer
i
Annexure
Yaseer Rizvi Our position in this case is very strong as we use all the mechanisms
you mentioned As Virgin is a firm with small deposits spread over a substantial
number of banks so we tend to use depository transfer checks extensively It is less
costly We also use automated clearing house and wire transfer but later is used in a
less extent
Shah Kamal Sir what techniques of disbursement management is used by your firm
Yaseer Rizvi Like other firms Virgin tries to retain the cash for as long as possible
But we always perform it in an ethical manner We do not use management of
disbursement float as it seems unethical We follow Zero-Balance Accounts method
for managing disbursement We do not prefer Controlled Disbursing method since
Zero-Balance system is already practiced in Virgin
Shah Kamal How do you hedge cash balance uncertainties
Yaseer Rizvi Well you may say that we do not invest in short term securities but for
facing cash difficulties we keep our surplus cash in bank
Shah Kamal Sir would you please tell me the general terms of sale of Virgin
Yaseer Rizvi Though it is difficult to maintain a fixed terms of sale our general terms
of sale is 210 n30 But for prime customers we offer special terms of sale
Shah Kamal What are the sources of credit information in case of your firm
Yaseer Rizvi We grant credit on the basis of prior experience with the customers In
case of a new customer personal contact is weighted
Shah Kamal Does your firm consider 5 Cs in granting credit
ii
Annexure
Yaseer Rizvi In case of Virgin Capital and Character get more importance than the
others Mind one thing personal relationship is the main measure in granting credit
Shah Kamal Do you use NPV method in credit granting decisions
Yaseer Rizvi We do not use NPV method But we think that NPV is a suitable
method and we have to use it from the next period
Shah Kamal Sir how do you handle the problem of bad debt
Yaseer Rizvi Well in this case our position is very strong Yet we do not face any
problem because of bad debt Just note that we make more than 80 of sales in cash
and we monitor accounts receivable very carefully
Shah Kamal What level of inventory is maintained by Virgin
Yaseer Rizvi We maintain a minimum level of inventory but do not have to face
stock out problems because inventory is managed efficiently
Shah Kamal What is the normal lead time
Yaseer Rizvi In case of imported goods normal lead time is about 1 month and when
we purchase raw materials from inside the country lead time is 1 to 3 days
Shah Kamal What method do you use for managing inventory
Yaseer Rizvi We do not use any method particularly rather inventory decision
depends on business cycle and market situation Long before the Eid festival we
bought large amount of sugar because price of sugar was increased on the occasion
of Eid
iii
Annexure
Shah Kamal What are the main items of inventory of your firm
Yaseer Rizvi Well these are ndash aluminum can pet chip sugar label chemical and
artificial sweet
Shah Kamal What are the uncertainties in maintaining appropriate level of stock
Yaseer Rizvi These are ndash
bull Increase in price of raw materials
bull Sales uncertainty
bull Market trends etc
Shah Kamal Thank you for your kind cooperation
Yaseer Rizvi Most Welcome
iv
Global Beverage Company Limited
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Future cash
flows
Predictable Reasonably
predictable
Unpredictable
Attitude to
Risk
Accepting Neutral Rejecting
Total assets = Fixed Assets + Permanent Current Assets + Fluctuating Current Assets
53 WORKING CAPITAL CYCLE
Cash flows in a cycle into around and out of a business It is the businesss life blood
and every managers primary task is to help keep it flowing and to use the cash flow
to generate profits If a business is operating profitably then it should in theory
generate cash surpluses If it doesnt generate surpluses the business will eventually
run out of cash and expire
The faster a business expands the more cash it will need for working capital and
investment The cheapest and best sources of cash exist as working capital right
within business Good management of working capital will generate cash will help
improve profits and reduce risks
Working capital can be broken down into the following major components cash (or
bank overdraft) stock debtors creditors Each of these items can have a major
influence on the working capital (or simply cash) that any business requires on an
ongoing basis For example when a business starts up the owner may inject a
certain amount of cash into the business which will enable him to purchase his initial
stock pay his workers their first months wages and cover other overheads such as
rent He then sells his product and this income may be utilized to purchase more
stock pay more wages and overheads and perhaps even have a surplus over for his
own use The quicker he can turn his stock over to receive payment the sooner the
working capital cycle will be completed
Page 7 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Figure Working Capital Cycle
These major components of working capital are discussed below
531 CASH MANAGEMENT
The term cash management refers to the management of cash from the time it starts
its transit to the firm until it leaves the firm in payments Cash management
encompasses the design of collection and disbursement systems for cash and the
temporary investment of cash while it resides with the firm Widely used money
market instruments are-
Treasury bill
Commercial paper
Certificate of deposits
Bankerrsquos acceptance
Page 8 of 46
Repurchase agreement
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
5311 Motives for Holding Cash
Despite the seemingly low returns there are several good reasons why firms hold
cash and marketable securities These reasons are ndash
Cash for transactions
Cash and near cash assets as hedges
Temporary investment and
Compensating balances
5312 Components of Cash Management
A Cash Flow Statement shows the sources and uses of cash and is typically divided
into three components
Operating Cash Flow
Operating cash flow often referred to as working capital is the cash flow generated
from internal operations It comes from sales of the product or service of your
business and because it is generated internally it is under your control
Investing Cash Flow
Investing cash flow is generated internally from non-operating activities This
includes investments in plant and equipment or other fixed assets nonrecurring gains
or losses or other sources and uses of cash outside of normal operations
Financing Cash Flow
Financing cash flow is the cash to and from external sources such as lenders
investors and shareholders
Page 9 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
5313 Tools for Cash Management
Flotation and Check Clearing
Management of cash when it is not in the firmrsquos hands that is in transit to and from
the firm is on important function in the area of finance Transit times for the check
takes in three stages These are mail float at firm float and clearing float Normally
mail float takes 1 to 5 days at firm float takes 025 to 1 day and clearing float takes 0
to 2 days The firm should care about this process because every delay in the receipt
of money by the firm lowers the firmrsquos returns and therefore its shareholdersrsquo wealth
There are several strategies that firm can use to reduce the delay in receiving funds
Each of these strategies addresses one or more of the three float times (mail float
time at time float time and clearing float time) that make up the total transit time of
fund from one firm to another
Other Cash Management Tools
When the economy is strong companies can lapse into sloppy cash-management
practices Firm should try exploring these options
1 Sweep accounts
These bank accounts are the easiest way to generate some income from companys
spare funds however they make sense only if the money youll earn will be greater
than the fees your bank will charge Business owners have two types of sweep
accounts to choose between
Page 10 of 46
Controlled-investment accounts These are the most profitable form of
sweep account but they wont work for company if the firm has any
electronic payments or wire transfers since those may be submitted for
payment later in the day and the account wont have enough cash in it to
cover them
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Page 11 of 46
End-of-day sweep accounts A safer bet for most small-business owners
these accounts wait until a late-hour cutoff to determine how much to
sweep into the firms overnight investments Typically their investment
yields are 10 to 20 basis points (1 to 2 of the investment) lower than
those offered with controlled investments
2 Lock-box accounts
A lock box is a cash-management system that helps the firm collect funds quickly
Generally set up with the assistance of a big money center or regional bank lock
boxes provide the firm with a special zip code and usually quicker deliveries from
regional post offices They are especially important if the firm has clusters of
customers in out-of-state locations and dont want to lose days waiting for their
checks to arrive by long-distance mail
5314 Cash Concentration and Cash Disbursement
Once the remittances from the firmrsquos customers have been received and cleared the
resulting cash balances is available in the firmrsquos lockbox (depository) banks It is
useful for the firm to gather these balances from the lockbox banks into the central
bank account The process of collecting funds is called cash concentration
Several concentration mechanism are available for the firm to use in transferring
funds from its collection banks to regional concentration banks and from there to the
central concentration bank These mechanisms differ in cost and in the availability of
funds that they provide These are ndash
a) Depository Transfer Check
It is the cheapest transfer mechanism This document instructs one bank to
send funds to another and is treated the same as any other check
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
b) Automated Clearing House (ACH) Electronic Transfer
This vehicle is essentially an electronic version of the depository transfer
check and can be used between banks that participate in the automated
clearing house system
c) Wire Transfer
These are electronic message between banks
Decisions regarding concentration mechanism usually hinge on the size and
spread of the firmrsquos deposits Firms with small deposits spread over a
substantial number of banks will tend to have more extensive concentration
systems and will transfer among accounts using low-cost transfer vehicles that
offer only delayed availability (such as depository transfer checks) Firms with
larger deposits will have fewer accounts (since a local deposit for transfer to
an upstream bank is not needed) and will use more expensive and more rapid
transfer mechanisms (such as wire transfers) The concentration systems of
major chemical companies for example tend to be structured in this way ndash
DepositoryLockbox Banks
Regional Concentration Banks
Central Concentrated Bank
Figure A typical Cash Concentration System
(Arrows indicate transfers of collected funds)
Page 12 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Disbursement management addresses the efficient payout out of this cash once it is
concentrated The firmrsquos objective in disbursement management is to retain the cash
for as long as possible In this way the firm will have the maximum amount of funds
available for investment and transactional purposes Certainly this management
means making disbursement only when they are due and not before The firm has
several available set of techniques for disbursement management Included among
these are ndash
a) Management of Disbursement Float
In this set of techniques the disbursing firm attempts to increase the length of
time between the mailing of its checks and the eventual withdrawal of funds
from the banks This involves strategies for increasing mail float at firm float
and clearing float on its outgoing checks For example the disbursing firm
may intentionally address checks to the firmrsquos office address rather than its
lockbox creating at firm float
b) Zero-Balance Accounts
Here the firm holds the cash until the check arrive (or expected to arrive) at
the disbursement bank In this strategy an account for disbursement is first
established at a bank For the zero-balance system to be effective the
participating bank must be one on which most disbursement are made via the
Bangladesh Bankrsquos clearance system (which presents disbursements to banks
early in the morning) and not a bank where disbursements occur throughout
the day (as with a major money-center bank) Consequently the banks used
in zero-balance strategies are usually branches of major banks and not their
main locations
Page 13 of 46
c) Controlled Disbursing
In this system the firm projects the amount of checks to arrive each day at the
disbursement bank (based on the checks written in previous days and historic
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
statistics on disbursement float) and transfers the amount of the expected
checks to the account on that day or just before
5315 Cash Forecasting
Defining Cash Forecasting
The cash forecast is an estimation of the flows in and out of the firmrsquos cash account
over a particular period of time usually a quarter month week or day The cash
forecast is primarily intended to produce a very useful piece of information an
estimation of the firmrsquos borrowing and lending needs and uncertainties regarding
these needs during various future periods Cash forecasting is very crucial to most
firms It enables them to anticipate periods of surplus cash and periods where
financing will be necessary This anticipation is the reason that cash forecasts are
generated Anticipation enables the firm to plan much more effectively for
investment and financing and via this planning produce superior return
Types of Cash Forecasts
The types of cash forecasts generated by firms can be differentiated along two
dimensions the length of the periods included within the cash forecast and the approach
to cash flows used in the cash forecast The length of the period refers to the units of
time into which the cash forecast is divided Firms may make cash flow forecasts
over periods of various lengths yearly flows quarterly flows monthly flows weekly
flows or even daily flows The most popular forecast involves monthly flows but
most firms do not confine themselves to a single forecast Instead they use several
forecasts with periods of various lengths When the firm makes forecasts involving
multiple and overlapping period lengths one forecast relates to another Starting
with data on relatively long periods and breaking it down into smaller periods is
called distribution starting with data on relatively short periods and aggregating into
longer periods is called scheduling
Page 14 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Firms use two common approaches to cash flows in generating the cash forecast the
receipts and disbursements approach and the adjusted net income approach The receipts
and disbursements approach use the amounts of cash expected to be received and
disbursed by the firm over the periods chosen for forecast The adjusted income
statement approach is sometimes called the sources and use approach Here the
forecaster starts with projected net income on an accrual basis and adjusts to a cash
basis This method provides a representation of changes in asset and liability
accounts since the level of these accounts are of interest to the firm this aspect of the
adjusted income statement is an advantage over the receipts and disbursements
method
Items to Be Forecast
In the receipt and disbursements cash forecasting method estimates need to be made
of the numerous major and minor items that the firm collects (receipts) and that it
pays (disbursements) The more individual categories of items the firm includes in its
forecast procedure the more accurate the forecast may be but the more costly in
terms of time and effort it will be to generate
Some Possible Types of Cash Receipts and Cash Disbursements
Cash Disbursements Cash Receipts
Cash Purchases of Materials Payroll
Taxes
Maturing Accounts Payable
Maturing Notes Payable
Miscellaneous Disbursements
Accounts Receivable
Notes Receivable
Rental Income
Interest Income
Miscellaneous Receipts
Methods of Financial Forecasting
Page 15 of 46
Financial forecasting is the estimation of the future level of a financial variable often
a cash flow asset level or liability level It is usually assumed that the relationship
between the financial variable and other variable is linear The general linear model
can then be used
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
nnt xaxaxaaY 22110 ++=
Here
= Financial variable (Y) to be forecast in period t tY
x = Explanatory variable it is assumed to cause the level of Y in period t
0a = Represents a constant unaffected by the x
The other terms are the estimated coefficients of the explanatory x variables
There are n terms with xrsquos in them
There are four common approaches to forecasting financial variables but they
are all special cases of the general linear model These are ndash spot method proportion
to another account compounded growth and multiple dependencies
Using Cash Forecast
The estimate of available funds for investment and needed financing enables the firm
to plan so as to obtain the most advantages borrowing terms for deficits and achieve
the greatest interest income on surplus A useful chart for this planning purpose is a
bar chart eg
Figure Bar Chart of Cash Surpluses and Deficits from hypothetical data
Page 16 of 46
75
50
-60
30
100
-20
-80-60-40-20
020406080
100120
Defic
it
S
urpl
us
January February March April May June
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Sources of Uncertainty in Cash Forecasting and Hedging Uncertainties
There are numerous sources of risk in cash forecasting Among the sources are sales
uncertainty collection rate uncertainty production cost uncertainty and capital
outflow uncertainty
5316 Models for the Management of Cash and Temporary Investments
There are different models for the management of cash and temporary investments
Among these the most popular methods are ndash Baumol model Beranek model
Miller-Orr model and Stone model
Baumol and Beranek use the same model The formula is cited below ndash
Interest Income = iYn
n⎥⎦⎤
⎢⎣⎡ minus
21
Profit = naiYn
nminus⎥⎦
⎤⎢⎣⎡ minus
21
Optimum number of transactions = ⎟⎠⎞
⎜⎝⎛
aiY2
Where n = Optimum number of transactions
i = Interest rate per period
a = Transaction cost
Y = Total inflow for the period
Page 17 of 46
Miller-Orr and Stone use the same model ie R-Statistic The model is ndash
31
43
iav
R ⎟⎠⎞
⎜⎝⎛=
Optimum Control Limit = R + L
Upper Control Limit = 3R + L
Where a = Transaction Cost
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
v = Variance of daily cash flows
i = Daily interest rate
5317 Administration
Cash receipts should be processed and banked as quickly as possible because
They cannot earn interest or reduce overdraft until they are banked
information about the existence and amounts of cash receipts is usually not
available until they are processed
Where possible cash floats (mainly petty cash and advances) should be avoided If
on review the only reason that can be put forward for their existence is that weve
always had them they should be discontinued There may be situations where they
are useful however For example it may be desirable for peripheral parts of
departments to meet urgent local needs from cash floats rather than local bank
accounts
5318 Internal Control
Cash and cash management is part of a firms overall internal control system The
main internal cash control is invariably the bank reconciliation This provides
assurance that the cash balances recorded in the accounting systems are consistent
with the actual bank balances It requires regular clearing of reconciling items
5319 Practicing Good Cash Flow Management
Good cash management is simple It involves
Knowing when where and how firms cash needs will occur
Page 18 of 46
Knowing the best sources for meeting additional cash needs
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Page 19 of 46
Being prepared to meet these needs when they occur by keeping good
relationships with bankers and other creditors
532 INVENTORY MANAGEMENT
Inventory management is necessary for owners who want to maintain a stocking
service for quick turnaround to help ensure total customer satisfaction The fill rate
of an item on a managed inventory list must be maintained to avoid shortages of
frequently used items Even when utilizing an inventory management system
occasional shortages will still occur Inventories are lists of stocks-raw materials
work in progress or finished goods-waiting to be consumed in production or to be
sold The total balance of inventory is the sum of the value of each individual stock
line
Basically firms hold stocks for the following reasons
To act as a buffer in times of unusually high demand
To ensure continuity of production
Avoid high costs of emergency orders
To take advantage of quantity discounts by ordering more at a time
To reduce ordering costs by ordering more items on fewer
As part of the production process eg maturing whisky or keeping oil in
pipelines
Seasonality of demand (eg firework) or supplies
Suppliers insist on minimum order quantities
The key issue for a business is to identify the fast and slow stock movers with the
objectives of establishing optimum stock levels for each category and thereby
minimize the cash tied up in stocks Factors to be considered when determining
optimum stock levels include
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Page 20 of 46
What are the projected sales of each product
How widely available are raw materials components etc
How long does it take for delivery by suppliers
Can the firm remove slow movers from its product range without
compromising best sellers
Inventory management is an important aspect of working capital management
because inventories themselves do not earn any revenue Holding either too little or
too much inventory incurs costs
Costs of carrying too much inventory are
Opportunity cost of foregone interest
Warehousing costs
Damage and pilferage
Obsolescence
Insurance
Costs of carrying too little inventory are
Stock out costs
Lost sales
Delayed service
Ordering costs
Freight
on Order administrati
nts
Loss of quantity discou
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Carrying costs can be minimized by making frequent small orders but this increase
ordering costs and the risk of stock outs Risk of stock-outs can be reduced by
carrying safety stocks (at a cost) and re-ordering ahead of time
The best ordering strategy requires balancing the various cost factors to ensure the
firm incurs minimum inventory costs The optimum inventory position is known as
the Economic Reorder Quantity (ERQ)
Nowadays many large manufacturers operate on a just-in-time (JIT) basis whereby
all the components to be assembled on a particular today arrive at the factory early
that morning no earlier - no later This helps to minimize manufacturing costs as JIT
stocks take up little space minimize stock-holding and virtually eliminate the risks of
obsolete or damaged stock Because JIT manufacturers hold stock for a very short
time they are able to conserve substantial cash JIT is a good model to strive for as it
embraces all the principles of prudent stock management For better stock control
firm may try the following
Review the effectiveness of existing purchasing and inventory systems
Know the stock turn for all major items of inventory
Apply tight controls to the significant few items and simplify controls for the
trivial many
Sell off outdated or slow moving merchandise - it gets more difficult to sell the
longer the firm keeps it
Consider having part of its product outsourced to another manufacturer rather
than make it itself
Review its security procedures to ensure that no stock is going out the back
door
Higher than necessary stock levels tie up cash and cost more in insurance
accommodation costs and interest charges
Page 21 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
However it is important to keep an overall perspective It is not cost-effective to
closely manage a large number of low value inventory lines nor is it necessary A
usual feature of inventories is that a small number of high value lines account for a
large proportion of inventory value The 8020 rule (PARETO) predicts that 80
of the total value of inventory is represented by only 20 of the number of inventory
items Those high value lines need reasonably close management The remaining
80 of inventory lines can be managed using broad-brush strategies
533 MANAGING ACCOUNTS RECEIVABLE (DEBTORS)
Cash flow can be significantly enhanced if the amounts owing to a business are
collected faster Every business needs to know who owes them money how much is
owed how long it is owing for what it is owed
Debtors (Accounts Receivable) are customers who have not yet made payment for
goods or services which the department has provided The objective of debtor
management is to minimize the time-lapse between completion of sales and receipt
of payment The costs of having debtors are
Opportunity costs (cash is not available for other purposes)
Bad debts
If firm doesnt manage debtors they will begin to manage business as the firm will gradually
lose control due to reduced cash flow and of course it could experience an increased
incidence of bad debt The following measures will help manage debtors
Having the right mental attitude to the control of credit and make sure that it
gets the priority it deserves
Establishing clear credit practices as a matter of company policy
Page 22 of 46
Making sure that these practices are clearly understood by staff suppliers and
customers
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Page 23 of 46
Being professional when accepting new accounts and especially larger ones
Checking out each customer thoroughly before the firm offers credit Use
credit agencies bank references industry sources etc
Establishing credit limits for each customer and sticking to them
Continuously reviewing these limits when it suspects tough times are coming
or if operating in a volatile sector
Keeping very close to the firms larger customers
Invoicing promptly and clearly
Considering charging penalties on overdue accounts
Considering accepting credit debit cards as a payment option
Monitoring its debtor balances and ageing schedules and dont let any debts
get too large or too old
Debtor management includes both pre-sale and debt collection strategies
Pre-sale strategies include
Offering cash discounts for early payment andor imposing penalties for late
payment
Agreeing payment terms in advance
Requiring cash before delivery
Setting credit limits
ning credit Setting criteria for obtai
Billing as early as possible
rogress payments
ost-sale strategies include
for collecting the debt upon the center that made the sale
Requiring deposits andor p
P
Placing the responsibility
Identifying long overdue balances and doubtful debts by regular analytical reviews
Having an established procedure for late collections such as
A reminder
A letter
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Page 24 of 46
ion of further credit Cancellat
Telephone calls
n agency Use of a collectio
he firm should recognize that the longer someone owes firm the greater the chance
Legal action
T
it will never get paid If the average age of debtors is getting longer or is already very
long it may need to look for the following possible defects
Weak credit judgment
res Poor collection procedu
ms Lax enforcement of credit ter
Slow issue of invoices or statements
Errors in invoices or statements
Customer dissatisfaction
Debtors due over 90 days (unless within agreed credit terms) should generally
demand immediate attention For example warning signs of a future bad debt ndash
Longer credit terms taken with approval particularly for smaller orders
Use of post-dated checks by debtors who normally settle within agreed terms
Evidence of customers switching to additional suppliers for the same goods
New customers who are reluctant to give credit references
Cre G
Receiving part payments from debtors
dit ranting to Marginal Accounts
Traditional Approach
In the traditional approach to the credit granting decision it is the credit analysts job
rmation that has been collected and reach a judgment
regarding the applicants creditworthiness One traditional way of organizing this
to synthesize all the info
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
information is by characterizing the applicant along five dimensions These
dimensions are called the Five Cs of credit ndash
Capital
Character
Collateral
and Capacity
Conditions
Net Present Value (NPV) Approach
Once a firm has assessed the creditworthiness of a customer it has to decide whether
r not credit should be granted The firm should use the NPV rule to make the
ld be granted
Figure
o
decision If NPV is positive credit shou
Credit Granting Decision
Credit Granting Decision
he act of collecting money is one which most people dislike for many reasons and
therefore put on the long f selves there is something
ore urgent or important that demands their attention now There is nothing more
T
inger because they convince them
m
important than getting paid for firms product or service A customer who does not
Page 25 of 46
Grand Credit
Payment received Payment not received
Benefit of present value of future net cash flow
Cost of present value ment of lost invest
Net Payoff PV of benefit-cost
No Credit
No Payoff
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
pay is not a customer Here are a few ideas that may help the firm in collecting
money from debtors
Firm should develop appropriate procedures for handling late payments
It should track and pursue late payers
It might get external help if its own efforts fail
or money its firms and it is entitled Company shouldnt feel guilty asking f
to it
ction
Firm must make that call now And it should keep asking until it gets some
satisfa
lessens the problem
In difficult circumstances take what the firm can now and agree terms for the
remainder It
paying
When asking for money be hard on the issue - but soft on the person It shouldnt
give the debtor any excuses for not
534 BLE (CREDITORS)
ices for goods or services have
een paid Organizations often regard the
not
to delay all payments until the latest possible date Regular weekly or
The firm make it its objective is to get the money - not to score points or get
even
MANAGING ACCOUNTS PAYA
Creditors (Accounts Payable) are suppliers whose invo
been processed but who have not yet b
amount owing to creditors as a source of free credit However creditor
administration systems are expensive and time-consuming to run The over-riding
concern in this area should be to minimize costs with simple procedures
While it is unnecessary to pay accounts before they fall due it is usually
worthwhile
Page 26 of 46
fortnightly payment of all due accounts is the simplest technique for creditor
management
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Electronic payments (direct credits) are cheaper than check payments considering
that transaction fees and overheads more than balance the advantage of delayed
presentation Some suppliers are reluctant to receive payments by this method but in
view of the substantial cost advantage (and the advantages to the suppliers
themselves) departments may wish to encourage suppliers to accept this option
However electronic payments are likely to be used in conjunction with rather than
as a replacement for check payments
Applying Best Practices in Managing Accounts Payable
f course simply deferring payments to suppliers could have adverse consequences
O
that more than offset the benefits of this additional cash flow Therefore it is
important to develop a holistic approach The firm should consider the following
best practices for payables management
Managing payment dates and terms to maximize cash flow ndash
y reporting on
receivable and
id penalty charges and taking advantage of
wer vendors and negotiate for more
to buying consortia with others even
voices for
payment based on receipt of goods or receipt of invoice whichever
comes later
Calculating and setting performance targets Regularl
AP performance measures such as days in payables
Coordinating the AP processes with accounts
inventory management to ensure that the company is collecting more
cash than it is paying out
Paying bills on time to avo
prompt-payment discounts where the discounts exceed the companyrsquos
cost of working capital
Consolidating purchases with fe
favorable payment terms
Considering entering in
Page 27 of 46
competitors to obtain favorable supplier pricing and terms
Unless contract terms specify otherwise setting up in
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Page 28 of 46
Em
process
-time payments with Electronic Funds Transfer (EFT)
uraging vendors to utilize electronic invoice presentment
a
ndancies and more
ploying technology to automate the accounts payable transaction
es ndash
Making just-in
Using an electronic invoice-matching application
Enco
For companies with multiple locations or business units employing
shared service approach for AP to eliminate redu
quickly implement process improvements
Mainta
vendor
Communicating accounts payable requirements to suppliers at the
m key suppliers
for suggestions on how to improve the
Efficient a
and making th rsquos cash is just good business
ining open communications and building strong relationships with
s to access valuable trade credit ndash
beginning of transactions
Requesting summary invoicing fro
Requiring suppliers to send invoices directly to accounts payable
Asking tier-one suppliers
payment process
nd effective management of accounts payable helps improve cash flow ndash
e most of company
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
6 OVERVIEW OF VIRGIN GROUP
Virgin - one of the most respected brands in Britain - is now becoming the first global
brand name of the 21st century Virgin is involved in planes trains finance soft
drinks music mobile phones holidays cars wines publishing bridal wear - the lot
What tie all these businesses together are the values of its brand and the attitude of its
people Virgin has created over 200 companies worldwide employing over 25000
people Its total revenues around the world in 2002 exceeded pound4 billion (US $72
billion)
In 1970 Richard Branson founded Virgin as a mail order record retailer and not
long after he opened a record shop in Oxford Street London During 1972 a
recording studio was built in Oxfordshire and the first Virgin artist Mike Oldfield
recorded Tubular Bells which was released in 1973
This album went on to sell over 5 million copies Since then many household names
including Belinda Carlisle Genesis Phil Collins Janet Jackson and The Rolling
Stones have helped to make Virgin Music one of the top six record companies in the
world The equity of Virgin Music Group - record labels music publishing and
recording studios was sold to THORN EMI in 1992 in a US$1billion deal
Page 29 of 46
The Virgin Group has now expanded into international music Mega stores air
travel mobile financial retail music internet drinks rail hotels and leisure with
around 200 companies in over 30 countries
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
In Virgins customers eyes Virgin stands for value for money quality innovation
fun and a sense of competitive challenge It delivers a quality service by empowering
its employees and facilitates and monitors customer feedback to continually improve
the customers experience through innovation
When they start a new venture Virgin bases it on hard research and analysis
Typically they review the industry and put themselves in the customers shoes to see
what could make it better Virgin asks fundamental questions
Is this an opportunity for restructuring a market and creating competitive
advantage What are the competitors doing
Is the customer confused or badly served
Is this an opportunity for building the Virgin brand
Can we add value
Will it interact with its other businesses
Is there an appropriate trade-off between risk and reward
Page 30 of 46
Virgin is also able to draw on talented people from throughout the group New
ventures are often steered by people seconded from other parts of Virgin who bring
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
with them the trademark management style skills and experience Virgin frequently
creates partnerships with others to combine skills knowledge and market presence
and so on Contrary to what some people may think their constantly expanding and
eclectic empire is neither random nor reckless Each successive venture demonstrates
its skill in picking the right market and the right opportunity
7 OVERVIEW OF VIRGIN SOFT DRINKS
The Virgin Drinks Group first launched as the Virgin Cola Company in 1994 with
Virgin Cola in the UK Since then the company has ventured across the carbonated
soft drinks arena and beyond into energy drinks tea and flavored Colas This
expansion has lead to the evolution of the Virgin Drinks Company a company
whose aim is to put the excitement back into the world of soft drinks It launched in
Bangladesh in 1999 Virgin Soft Drinks is monitored by Global Beverage Co Ltd in
Bangladesh
Brief history of Virgin Drinks is given below
Page 31 of 46
1994 November Virgin Cola launched in the UK
1996 March Virgin Cola launched in France
1998 June Virgin Cola launched in Belgium
April Virgin Cola launched in the French West Indies
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
August Virgin Cola launched in Switzerland
1999 March Virgin Colours launched in Italy
March Virgin Cola launched in Japan
July Virgin Colours launched in South Africa
December Virgin Colours launched in Bangladesh
2001 January Sweden launched Virgin Colours
November Singapore launched Virgin Colours
2002 February Croatia launched Virgin Colours
June Russia launched Virgin Colours
June Tunisia launched Virgin Colours
2003 May Israel launched Virgin Colours
8 FINDINGS OF WORKING CAPITAL MANAGEMENT MAINTAINED BY
VIRGIN SOFT DRINKS IN BANGLADESH
81 CASH MANAGEMENT
811 Holding Cash and Marketable Securities
Although there are many good reasons why firm hold cash and marketable
securities Virgin Drinks holds cash and marketable securities for two reasons ndash
i) Cash for transactions
ii) Cash as hedges
This indicates that the firm does not hold cash and marketable securities for some
important reasons such as ndash
i) Near cash assets as hedges
Page 32 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
ii) Temporary investment and compensating balances
Virgin Soft Drinks does not invest in money market securities such as Treasury bill
commercial paper certificate of deposits bankerrsquos acceptance and repurchase
agreement This firm deposits its money in bank as currant AC or fixed AC They
say that they do not have enough money to invest in money market instrument
They also say that if they have enough money they will invest it in money market
short term securities We know that near cash interest earning assets can be
substituted for cash when motivation for holding these assets is the hedging of cash
flow uncertainties or is the temporary investment of surplus funds In this point
Virgins position is not good as there is no significant hedging against uncertainty of
cash
812 Floatation and Check Clearing
Virgin is very smart in handling the problem of transit time for checks Here mail
float takes 2 to 3 days at firm takes 025 day and clearing float takes 1-3 days Virgin
uses most of the strategies available for reducing the delay in receiving funds It
(Virgin) has linked Islami Bank which posses an accelerated clearing facility It uses
electronic collection process which ensures faster collection and its at the firm check
processing is satisfactory But Virgin does not use lockbox The reason behind this is
that it is not cost-effective for Virgin to set lockboxes At this point we can say that
Virgins check clearing mechanism is much good
813 Cash Concentration and Disbursement Management
Page 33 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks takes the matter of cash concentration very seriously They use all
the available cash concentration mechanism Virgin is a firm with small deposits
spread over a substantial number of banks and this is why the firm tends to use
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
depository transfer checks extensively If is less costly Virgin also uses automated
clearing house and wire transfer To Virgin wire transfer seems too costly
Like other firm Virgin tries to retain the cash for as long as possible But Virgin
always performs it in an ethical manner Virgin does not try to defeat the receiving
firmrsquos attempts to reduce the float on incoming checks It does not take any strategy
for increasing mail float at firm float and clearing float on its outgoing checks To
Virgin it is deemed to be unethical It thinks that maximization of disbursement float
will not go unnoticed by sophisticated creditors for very long When it is noticed it
will negatively affect relations with these creditors reducing the firmrsquos bargaining
power with them This may ultimately cost Virgin dearly when future prices and
delivery schedules for goods and services purchased from trade creditors are
negotiated Virgin follows ldquoZero-Balance Accountsrdquo methods for managing
disbursement It thinks that in this method the coordination of funds inflows to
disbursement banks with the presentation of checks does not work to the detriment
of creditors since the firmrsquos checks to them are honored as presented and this strategy
does not affect float significantly Controlled disbursing method is less attractive to
Virgin because zero-balance system is already feasible
814 Cash Forecasting
Cash Forecasting and Its Types
Page 34 of 46
Virgin forecasts the future cash inflows and outflows To Virgin cash forecast is an
important part of the firmrsquos cash control system and is one of the forecasts that are
part of the Virginrsquos financial plan Virgin forecasts cash on monthly basis and on
yearly basis Virgin does not forecast on daily basis assuming that the temporary
shortage of funds within these periods can be covered without value cost eg
advance receipts from customers Virginrsquos cash forecasting system involves a
combination of distribution and scheduling The receipts and disbursements
approach of cash forecasting is used in virgin This method is used because it
minutely traces the movement of cash and very close control of cash is possible
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Virgin does not use adjusted net income approach on two grounds First it does not
permit the tracing of the individual types of cash inflows and outflows for any given
period which is often useful information for virgin Second it is not simple to use
Items to be Forecast
Virgin does not forecast all the items It forecasts only major items eg accounts
receivable notes receivable payroll cash purchases of raw materials In this regard
virgin trade off between cost and benefit
Methods of Financial Forecasting
Virgin forecasts the future level of financial variable such as cash level asset level or
liability level We know in short term forecasts many things will result from plans
and events that are already in place (contracts capital budgets long-range financing
plans and so forth) But in the long run most things can vary and are dependent on
outside influences such as the firmrsquos long-term growth rate Since Virginrsquos cash
forecasting deals mostly with near future many of the items on the cash forecasts are
estimated by some variation of the spot method and remaining estimates are mostly
on a ldquoproportion of another accountrdquo basis with this ldquoother accountrdquo often being a
particular periodrsquos sales Virgin uses the other two methods less frequently
Using Cash Forecast
Virgin forecasts cash for meeting general objectives (ie to know the available funds
for investment and need financing) and for meeting some special objectives (eg to
know whether the firm will fulfill its out of debt requirement) But it is matter to note
that Virgin does not make any short term investment of its surplus cash but only keep
this surplus in Bank Account
Page 35 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Sources of Uncertainty in Cash Forecasting and Hedging Uncertainties
Virgin faces uncertainty in cash forecasting mainly from two sources These are ndash
sales and production cost In peak season (hot season like autumn summer) sales
increases but in dull season (eg in winter) sales decreases drastically Production
cost may be increased because of increase of price of sugar chemicals aluminum
can Virgin follows two methods for hedging cash balance uncertainties These are ndash
i) Holding a stock of extra cash and
ii) Extra borrowing capacity
815 Modes for the Management of Cash and Temporary Investments
Virgin does not follow any of these methods wholly Virgin receives cash
continuously and pays salary at steady rate and pays continuously for other
expenses So it neither follows Baumol model nor Beranek model It has no upper
control limit lower control limit return point in case cash management So it neither
follows Miller-Orr model nor Stone model
In Summary
Page 36 of 46
Standard Compliance by Virgin Soft Drinks
Generally all firms hold cash and
marketable securities
Virgin holds only cash
Firms hold cash and marketable
securities for some reasons like
bull Cash for transactions
bull Cash and near-cash assets as
hedges
bull Temporary investments
bull Compensating balances
Virgin holds cash only for
two reasons ndash
bull Cash for transactions
bull Cash as hedges
Available money market instruments Virgin does not invest in any such
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
(short term securities) are ndash
Treasury Bills
Commercial Paper
Certificates of Deposit
Bankerrsquos Acceptance
Repurch menase Agree ts
instruments They only keep cash in
Bank Account
Mail Float
(1 to 5 days)
At Firm
Float
(025 to 1
day)
Clearing
Float
(0 to
2 days)
Mail Float
(2 to 3 days)
At firm
Float
(025
day)
Clearing
Float
(1 to 3
days)
Figure Transit time for a typical check Figure Transit time for a check for
Virgin
Strategies that firms can use to reduce
the delay in receiving funds are ndash
Selecting of Banks with
accelerated clearing capabilities
of check processing Acceleration
at the firm
ectronic collection Use of el
procedures
Use of lockboxes
Virgin follows the first three strategies
but does not use lockboxes
Available cash concentration
mechanisms are ndash
Depository transfer check
ouse Automated Clearing H
(ACH) electronic transfer)
Wire transfer
Virgin uses all these mechanisms of
cash concentration
Available sets of techniques for cash
disbursement management are ndash
ement of disbursement
Page 37 of 46
Manag
float
Virgin uses zero-balance accounts
technique
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Zero-Balance Accounts
Controlled disbursing
Firms may make cash flow forecasts
over periods of various lengths yearly
flows quarterly flows monthly flows
weekly flows or even daily flows
Virgin forecasts cash on yearly basis and
monthly basis
Cash forecasting system may involve ndash
Distribution
Scheduling
Virginrsquos cash forecasting system
involves a combination of distribution
and scheduling
Two common approaches to cash flow
in generating the cash forecast
and disbursement Receipts
approach
Adjusted net income approach
Virgin uses the receipts and
disbursement approach
There are many items to forecast Virgin forecasts only major items like
AR payroll etc
Four common approach to forecasting
fina i ndash nc al variables are
Spot method
Proportion to another account
Compounded growth
Multiple dependencies
Virgin uses spot method for forecasting
cash It uses proportion to another
account method for other variables and
remaining two methods are frequently
used
Sources of uncertainty in cash
forecasting are ndash
Sales uncertainty
Collection rate uncertainty
Production cost uncertainty
Capital outflow uncertainty
Virgin faces uncertainty mainly from
sales and production cost
Methods for hedging cash balance
unc a
Page 38 of 46
ert inties are ndash
i) Holding a stock of extra cash
Virgin two available methods for
hedging cash balance uncertainties
Th ese are ndash
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
ii) stock of near-cash Holding a
assets
iii) Extra borrowing capacity
iv) ary surpluses in Investing tempor
near-cash assets
i) Holding a stock of extra cash
ii) Extra borrowing capacity
(advance receipt from
customers)
Models for the management of cash and
temporary investments are ndash Baumol
model Beranek model Miller-Orr
model and Stone model
Virgin does not follow any method
wholly but a combination of Baumol
model and Beranek model is occurred
82 INVENTORY MANAGEMENT
21 Certainty Approach
isnt used in
irgin because it thinks it is not possible to implement in Bangladesh
d time is one to three days It
oes not use ABC system of inventory management
8
Main item of inventory of Virgin is Can pet chip sugar label chemical artificial
sweet etc Virgin maintains a minimum level of inventory but it does not have to face
problems because inventory is managed efficiently just-in-time (JIT)
V
Virgin maintains buffer stock because of the shortage of work-in-process (WIP)
inventory Its production process may also be hampered Thats why it maintains
safety stock to avoid stock out cost In case of imported goods normal lead time is
about one month and within the country normal lea
d
Page 39 of 46
Inventory Model
In reality Virgin does not use any of models of EOQ ordering and holding strategy
and safety stock strategy They maintain inventory based on their prior experience
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
822 Uncertainty Approach
Virgin does not use any model for handling inventory uncertainty It says that such
decision depends on business cycle and market situation Long before Eid festival
they bought large amount of sugar because of price increase on the occasion of Eid
In summary
Standard Compliance by Virgin Soft Drinks
Firms maintain inventory to guard
against several problems
Virgin maintains a minimum level of
inventory which is managed efficiently
Some firms use JIT to avoid inventory
cost
JIT is not used by Virgin as it thinks it is
impossible to implement in Bangladesh
Firms maintain buffer stock Virgin maintains buffer stock too
Firms maintain safety stock to avoid
shortage cost
Virgin also maintains safety stock
Firms use ABC system to monitor
inventory
Virgin doesnt use ABC system
EOQ model is an appropriate method
for measuring quantity that has to be
ordered per order
Virgin does not use EOQ model rather
makes order based on experience and
market demand
83 MANAGING ACCOUNTS RECEIVABLE (DEBTORS)
831 Terms of Sale Decision
Page 40 of 46
Virgin offers the term 210 net 30 enables the customers to deduct 2 percent from the
face value of the bill when paying within the first 10 days but if the discount is not
taken the customer must remit the full amount within 30 days But Virgin does not
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
offer the same terms of sale to all customers For prime customers it offers special
terms of sale In setting an appropriate term of sale it costs and benefits regarding
this are compared It uses the standard approach of terms of sale decision as it is
simple to use
832 Credit Granting Decisions
In case of Virgin the Capital and Character of Five Cs get more importance
Although there are many problems with the traditional approach Virgin uses it
because of its simplicity Virgin does not use Net Present Value (NPV) method in
credit granting decision It thinks that NPV is an appropriate method and should be
used next time It does not face any severe problem because of bad debts The reason
is that notes receivable is used when credit is granted
833 Monitoring Accounts Receivable
Virgin monitors its accounts receivable Virgin believes that in any case both positive
and negative durations in accounts signal differences from the results that
management believe to be the most advantageous for the firm
Tools for Monitoring Accounts Receivable
Page 41 of 46
For monitoring accounts receivable there are several tools such as aging schedule
the ratios of receivable outstanding to original sales customers payment proportion
and sales weighted DSO (Days Sales Outstanding) For monitoring accounts
receivable Virgin uses aging schedule fractions and traditional DSO statistics
because of their simplicity in use Although payment proportions ratios of
receivables outstanding and sales weighted DSO methods are free from inherent bias
None of these is used because all these are complex to maintain
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
In summary
Page 42 of 46
Standard Compliance by Virgin Soft Drinks
Generals terms of sale is 210 net 30 Normally Virgin also use general terms
of sale ie 210 net 30
Firms do not offer the same terms of
sale to all customers
Yes For prime customers Virgin offers
special terms of sale
Approaches of terms of sale decisions
are ndash
bull Standard approach
bull Multi period approach
Virgin uses standard approach of terms
of sale decision as it is simple to use and
understand
Source of credit information are ndash
Sellers prior experience with the
customer
Credit agency ratings and
reports
Personal contact with the
applicants bank and other
creditors
Analysis of applicants financial
statements
Customer visit
Main source of credit information to
Virgin is its prior experience with the
customer All other sources are not cost-
effective for Virgin
Approaches of credit granting to
marginal accounts are ndash
Traditional approach
Net Present Value (NPV)
approach
It uses traditional approach still now but
thinks that NPV should be used for the
next periods
Firms monitor accounts receivable
because deviations from the expected
levels of turnover and of bad debt can
Virgin also monitors its accounts
receivable
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
signal several different problems
Different tools for monitoring accounts
receivable are ndash
Aging schedule
Ratios of receivables
outstanding to original sales
Customers payment
proportions
Sales-weighted DSO
For monitoring accounts receivable
Virgin uses aging schedule and
traditional sales outstanding statistics
84 MANAGING ACCOUNTS PAYABLE (CREDITORS)
Virgin has almost accounts payable of Tk 8000000 But most of its liabilities are to
the banks rather than suppliers But we dont have any clear information about
Virgins accounts payable
9 RECOMMENDATION
Virgin should invest its surplus cash in short term marketable securities
because it is suitable hedging against cash uncertainties and will also give
some returns (interest income)
Virgin should publish its own annual report which will satisfy information
needs of stakeholders and also increase the credibility of information provided
by Virgin
Page 43 of 46
Virgin should use multi period approach in terms of sale decision because
standard approach which is already exists in Virgin has some inherent
problems
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
It should stop using traditional approach from now It should use NPV
method in credit granting to marginal accounts
In monitoring accounts receivable Virgin should use sales-weighted DSO
method because it has least limitation compared to the others
It should be more flexible in granting credit which will ultimately increase its
sales
To get the appropriate number of quantity to be ordered per order it should
use DSO model
It should be ABC system for proper monitoring of inventory
10 CONCLUSION
The use of other peoples money in business is usually an expensive resource Before
looking outside for finance a firm should examine its own working capital cycle to
make sure that every rand of its own internal funds is being fully utilized Good
management of working capital is part of good financial management Effective use
of working capital will contribute to the operational efficiency of the whole
organization optimum use will help to generate maximum returns Furthermore
working capital management is not an end in itself It is an integral part of the firms
overall management The needs of efficient working capital management must be
considered in relation to other aspects of the Virgins financial and non-financial
performance Thats why when planning the development of a business it is critical
that the impact of working capital be fully assessed
Page 44 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
BIBLIOGRAPHY
Scherr FC (1989) International Edition Prentice-Hall International Inc Modern
Working Capital Management Text and Cases
Hussain Riaz (2002) Working Capital Management
Robertson Lonnie (July 1998) Inventory Management
httpwwwasashoporg visited on March 13 2006
The Art of Cash Management
httpwwwinccom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management
httpwwwstudyfinancecom visited on March 13 2006
White Paper ndash Managing Working Capital
httpwwwplanwareorg visited on March 13 2006
Management of Working Capital
httpwwwbusinesscentralcoza visited on March 13 2006
Cash Management
httpwwwsbagov visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management Objectives
httpwpsprenhallcom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management
Page 45 of 46
httpwwwadvancemecom visited on March 13 2006
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Business Receivables Financing
httpwwwbbtcom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Finance
http wwwfnbcoza visited on March 13 2006
Tips to manage your working capital
httpsmallbusinessninemsncomau visited on March 13 2006
Inventory Financing
httpwwwfranklincapitalnetworkcom visited on March 13 2006
Accounts Receivable Management
httpwwwfranklincapitalnetworkcom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management
httpwwwtreasurygovtnz visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management
httpwwwtreasurystrategiescom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Works
httpwwwinvestopediacom visited on March 13 2006
Treasury Services
httpwwwjpmorganchasecom visited on March 13 2006
what were about
Page 46 of 46
httpwwwvirgincom visited on March 13 2006
Annexure
Annexure
Interview with YASEER RIZVI
Mr Yaseer Rizvi the DMD of Global Beverage Co Ltd obtained his MBA degree
from a reputed university He had been the Director of Ocean Container Ltd before
joining in Global Beverage Co Ltd He possesses a nice personality
I interviewed Yaseer Rizvi Excerpts from his interview are as follows ndash
Shah Kamal Sir would you please tell me do you invest in short term marketable securities
Yaseer Rizvi Basically we do not invest our surplus cash in short term marketable
securities like T-Bill commercial paper certificate of deposit etc But we keep our
surplus cash in Bank
Shah Kamal Would you tell me something about transit time for a typical check
Yaseer Rizvi Well in Virgin the transit time for a typical check is ndash
For mail float 2 to 3 days
At firm float 6 hours
Clearing float 1 to 3 days
Shah Kamal Do you maintain any cash concentration mechanism like depository transfer check automated clearing house and wire transfer
i
Annexure
Yaseer Rizvi Our position in this case is very strong as we use all the mechanisms
you mentioned As Virgin is a firm with small deposits spread over a substantial
number of banks so we tend to use depository transfer checks extensively It is less
costly We also use automated clearing house and wire transfer but later is used in a
less extent
Shah Kamal Sir what techniques of disbursement management is used by your firm
Yaseer Rizvi Like other firms Virgin tries to retain the cash for as long as possible
But we always perform it in an ethical manner We do not use management of
disbursement float as it seems unethical We follow Zero-Balance Accounts method
for managing disbursement We do not prefer Controlled Disbursing method since
Zero-Balance system is already practiced in Virgin
Shah Kamal How do you hedge cash balance uncertainties
Yaseer Rizvi Well you may say that we do not invest in short term securities but for
facing cash difficulties we keep our surplus cash in bank
Shah Kamal Sir would you please tell me the general terms of sale of Virgin
Yaseer Rizvi Though it is difficult to maintain a fixed terms of sale our general terms
of sale is 210 n30 But for prime customers we offer special terms of sale
Shah Kamal What are the sources of credit information in case of your firm
Yaseer Rizvi We grant credit on the basis of prior experience with the customers In
case of a new customer personal contact is weighted
Shah Kamal Does your firm consider 5 Cs in granting credit
ii
Annexure
Yaseer Rizvi In case of Virgin Capital and Character get more importance than the
others Mind one thing personal relationship is the main measure in granting credit
Shah Kamal Do you use NPV method in credit granting decisions
Yaseer Rizvi We do not use NPV method But we think that NPV is a suitable
method and we have to use it from the next period
Shah Kamal Sir how do you handle the problem of bad debt
Yaseer Rizvi Well in this case our position is very strong Yet we do not face any
problem because of bad debt Just note that we make more than 80 of sales in cash
and we monitor accounts receivable very carefully
Shah Kamal What level of inventory is maintained by Virgin
Yaseer Rizvi We maintain a minimum level of inventory but do not have to face
stock out problems because inventory is managed efficiently
Shah Kamal What is the normal lead time
Yaseer Rizvi In case of imported goods normal lead time is about 1 month and when
we purchase raw materials from inside the country lead time is 1 to 3 days
Shah Kamal What method do you use for managing inventory
Yaseer Rizvi We do not use any method particularly rather inventory decision
depends on business cycle and market situation Long before the Eid festival we
bought large amount of sugar because price of sugar was increased on the occasion
of Eid
iii
Annexure
Shah Kamal What are the main items of inventory of your firm
Yaseer Rizvi Well these are ndash aluminum can pet chip sugar label chemical and
artificial sweet
Shah Kamal What are the uncertainties in maintaining appropriate level of stock
Yaseer Rizvi These are ndash
bull Increase in price of raw materials
bull Sales uncertainty
bull Market trends etc
Shah Kamal Thank you for your kind cooperation
Yaseer Rizvi Most Welcome
iv
Global Beverage Company Limited
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Figure Working Capital Cycle
These major components of working capital are discussed below
531 CASH MANAGEMENT
The term cash management refers to the management of cash from the time it starts
its transit to the firm until it leaves the firm in payments Cash management
encompasses the design of collection and disbursement systems for cash and the
temporary investment of cash while it resides with the firm Widely used money
market instruments are-
Treasury bill
Commercial paper
Certificate of deposits
Bankerrsquos acceptance
Page 8 of 46
Repurchase agreement
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
5311 Motives for Holding Cash
Despite the seemingly low returns there are several good reasons why firms hold
cash and marketable securities These reasons are ndash
Cash for transactions
Cash and near cash assets as hedges
Temporary investment and
Compensating balances
5312 Components of Cash Management
A Cash Flow Statement shows the sources and uses of cash and is typically divided
into three components
Operating Cash Flow
Operating cash flow often referred to as working capital is the cash flow generated
from internal operations It comes from sales of the product or service of your
business and because it is generated internally it is under your control
Investing Cash Flow
Investing cash flow is generated internally from non-operating activities This
includes investments in plant and equipment or other fixed assets nonrecurring gains
or losses or other sources and uses of cash outside of normal operations
Financing Cash Flow
Financing cash flow is the cash to and from external sources such as lenders
investors and shareholders
Page 9 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
5313 Tools for Cash Management
Flotation and Check Clearing
Management of cash when it is not in the firmrsquos hands that is in transit to and from
the firm is on important function in the area of finance Transit times for the check
takes in three stages These are mail float at firm float and clearing float Normally
mail float takes 1 to 5 days at firm float takes 025 to 1 day and clearing float takes 0
to 2 days The firm should care about this process because every delay in the receipt
of money by the firm lowers the firmrsquos returns and therefore its shareholdersrsquo wealth
There are several strategies that firm can use to reduce the delay in receiving funds
Each of these strategies addresses one or more of the three float times (mail float
time at time float time and clearing float time) that make up the total transit time of
fund from one firm to another
Other Cash Management Tools
When the economy is strong companies can lapse into sloppy cash-management
practices Firm should try exploring these options
1 Sweep accounts
These bank accounts are the easiest way to generate some income from companys
spare funds however they make sense only if the money youll earn will be greater
than the fees your bank will charge Business owners have two types of sweep
accounts to choose between
Page 10 of 46
Controlled-investment accounts These are the most profitable form of
sweep account but they wont work for company if the firm has any
electronic payments or wire transfers since those may be submitted for
payment later in the day and the account wont have enough cash in it to
cover them
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Page 11 of 46
End-of-day sweep accounts A safer bet for most small-business owners
these accounts wait until a late-hour cutoff to determine how much to
sweep into the firms overnight investments Typically their investment
yields are 10 to 20 basis points (1 to 2 of the investment) lower than
those offered with controlled investments
2 Lock-box accounts
A lock box is a cash-management system that helps the firm collect funds quickly
Generally set up with the assistance of a big money center or regional bank lock
boxes provide the firm with a special zip code and usually quicker deliveries from
regional post offices They are especially important if the firm has clusters of
customers in out-of-state locations and dont want to lose days waiting for their
checks to arrive by long-distance mail
5314 Cash Concentration and Cash Disbursement
Once the remittances from the firmrsquos customers have been received and cleared the
resulting cash balances is available in the firmrsquos lockbox (depository) banks It is
useful for the firm to gather these balances from the lockbox banks into the central
bank account The process of collecting funds is called cash concentration
Several concentration mechanism are available for the firm to use in transferring
funds from its collection banks to regional concentration banks and from there to the
central concentration bank These mechanisms differ in cost and in the availability of
funds that they provide These are ndash
a) Depository Transfer Check
It is the cheapest transfer mechanism This document instructs one bank to
send funds to another and is treated the same as any other check
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
b) Automated Clearing House (ACH) Electronic Transfer
This vehicle is essentially an electronic version of the depository transfer
check and can be used between banks that participate in the automated
clearing house system
c) Wire Transfer
These are electronic message between banks
Decisions regarding concentration mechanism usually hinge on the size and
spread of the firmrsquos deposits Firms with small deposits spread over a
substantial number of banks will tend to have more extensive concentration
systems and will transfer among accounts using low-cost transfer vehicles that
offer only delayed availability (such as depository transfer checks) Firms with
larger deposits will have fewer accounts (since a local deposit for transfer to
an upstream bank is not needed) and will use more expensive and more rapid
transfer mechanisms (such as wire transfers) The concentration systems of
major chemical companies for example tend to be structured in this way ndash
DepositoryLockbox Banks
Regional Concentration Banks
Central Concentrated Bank
Figure A typical Cash Concentration System
(Arrows indicate transfers of collected funds)
Page 12 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Disbursement management addresses the efficient payout out of this cash once it is
concentrated The firmrsquos objective in disbursement management is to retain the cash
for as long as possible In this way the firm will have the maximum amount of funds
available for investment and transactional purposes Certainly this management
means making disbursement only when they are due and not before The firm has
several available set of techniques for disbursement management Included among
these are ndash
a) Management of Disbursement Float
In this set of techniques the disbursing firm attempts to increase the length of
time between the mailing of its checks and the eventual withdrawal of funds
from the banks This involves strategies for increasing mail float at firm float
and clearing float on its outgoing checks For example the disbursing firm
may intentionally address checks to the firmrsquos office address rather than its
lockbox creating at firm float
b) Zero-Balance Accounts
Here the firm holds the cash until the check arrive (or expected to arrive) at
the disbursement bank In this strategy an account for disbursement is first
established at a bank For the zero-balance system to be effective the
participating bank must be one on which most disbursement are made via the
Bangladesh Bankrsquos clearance system (which presents disbursements to banks
early in the morning) and not a bank where disbursements occur throughout
the day (as with a major money-center bank) Consequently the banks used
in zero-balance strategies are usually branches of major banks and not their
main locations
Page 13 of 46
c) Controlled Disbursing
In this system the firm projects the amount of checks to arrive each day at the
disbursement bank (based on the checks written in previous days and historic
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
statistics on disbursement float) and transfers the amount of the expected
checks to the account on that day or just before
5315 Cash Forecasting
Defining Cash Forecasting
The cash forecast is an estimation of the flows in and out of the firmrsquos cash account
over a particular period of time usually a quarter month week or day The cash
forecast is primarily intended to produce a very useful piece of information an
estimation of the firmrsquos borrowing and lending needs and uncertainties regarding
these needs during various future periods Cash forecasting is very crucial to most
firms It enables them to anticipate periods of surplus cash and periods where
financing will be necessary This anticipation is the reason that cash forecasts are
generated Anticipation enables the firm to plan much more effectively for
investment and financing and via this planning produce superior return
Types of Cash Forecasts
The types of cash forecasts generated by firms can be differentiated along two
dimensions the length of the periods included within the cash forecast and the approach
to cash flows used in the cash forecast The length of the period refers to the units of
time into which the cash forecast is divided Firms may make cash flow forecasts
over periods of various lengths yearly flows quarterly flows monthly flows weekly
flows or even daily flows The most popular forecast involves monthly flows but
most firms do not confine themselves to a single forecast Instead they use several
forecasts with periods of various lengths When the firm makes forecasts involving
multiple and overlapping period lengths one forecast relates to another Starting
with data on relatively long periods and breaking it down into smaller periods is
called distribution starting with data on relatively short periods and aggregating into
longer periods is called scheduling
Page 14 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Firms use two common approaches to cash flows in generating the cash forecast the
receipts and disbursements approach and the adjusted net income approach The receipts
and disbursements approach use the amounts of cash expected to be received and
disbursed by the firm over the periods chosen for forecast The adjusted income
statement approach is sometimes called the sources and use approach Here the
forecaster starts with projected net income on an accrual basis and adjusts to a cash
basis This method provides a representation of changes in asset and liability
accounts since the level of these accounts are of interest to the firm this aspect of the
adjusted income statement is an advantage over the receipts and disbursements
method
Items to Be Forecast
In the receipt and disbursements cash forecasting method estimates need to be made
of the numerous major and minor items that the firm collects (receipts) and that it
pays (disbursements) The more individual categories of items the firm includes in its
forecast procedure the more accurate the forecast may be but the more costly in
terms of time and effort it will be to generate
Some Possible Types of Cash Receipts and Cash Disbursements
Cash Disbursements Cash Receipts
Cash Purchases of Materials Payroll
Taxes
Maturing Accounts Payable
Maturing Notes Payable
Miscellaneous Disbursements
Accounts Receivable
Notes Receivable
Rental Income
Interest Income
Miscellaneous Receipts
Methods of Financial Forecasting
Page 15 of 46
Financial forecasting is the estimation of the future level of a financial variable often
a cash flow asset level or liability level It is usually assumed that the relationship
between the financial variable and other variable is linear The general linear model
can then be used
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
nnt xaxaxaaY 22110 ++=
Here
= Financial variable (Y) to be forecast in period t tY
x = Explanatory variable it is assumed to cause the level of Y in period t
0a = Represents a constant unaffected by the x
The other terms are the estimated coefficients of the explanatory x variables
There are n terms with xrsquos in them
There are four common approaches to forecasting financial variables but they
are all special cases of the general linear model These are ndash spot method proportion
to another account compounded growth and multiple dependencies
Using Cash Forecast
The estimate of available funds for investment and needed financing enables the firm
to plan so as to obtain the most advantages borrowing terms for deficits and achieve
the greatest interest income on surplus A useful chart for this planning purpose is a
bar chart eg
Figure Bar Chart of Cash Surpluses and Deficits from hypothetical data
Page 16 of 46
75
50
-60
30
100
-20
-80-60-40-20
020406080
100120
Defic
it
S
urpl
us
January February March April May June
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Sources of Uncertainty in Cash Forecasting and Hedging Uncertainties
There are numerous sources of risk in cash forecasting Among the sources are sales
uncertainty collection rate uncertainty production cost uncertainty and capital
outflow uncertainty
5316 Models for the Management of Cash and Temporary Investments
There are different models for the management of cash and temporary investments
Among these the most popular methods are ndash Baumol model Beranek model
Miller-Orr model and Stone model
Baumol and Beranek use the same model The formula is cited below ndash
Interest Income = iYn
n⎥⎦⎤
⎢⎣⎡ minus
21
Profit = naiYn
nminus⎥⎦
⎤⎢⎣⎡ minus
21
Optimum number of transactions = ⎟⎠⎞
⎜⎝⎛
aiY2
Where n = Optimum number of transactions
i = Interest rate per period
a = Transaction cost
Y = Total inflow for the period
Page 17 of 46
Miller-Orr and Stone use the same model ie R-Statistic The model is ndash
31
43
iav
R ⎟⎠⎞
⎜⎝⎛=
Optimum Control Limit = R + L
Upper Control Limit = 3R + L
Where a = Transaction Cost
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
v = Variance of daily cash flows
i = Daily interest rate
5317 Administration
Cash receipts should be processed and banked as quickly as possible because
They cannot earn interest or reduce overdraft until they are banked
information about the existence and amounts of cash receipts is usually not
available until they are processed
Where possible cash floats (mainly petty cash and advances) should be avoided If
on review the only reason that can be put forward for their existence is that weve
always had them they should be discontinued There may be situations where they
are useful however For example it may be desirable for peripheral parts of
departments to meet urgent local needs from cash floats rather than local bank
accounts
5318 Internal Control
Cash and cash management is part of a firms overall internal control system The
main internal cash control is invariably the bank reconciliation This provides
assurance that the cash balances recorded in the accounting systems are consistent
with the actual bank balances It requires regular clearing of reconciling items
5319 Practicing Good Cash Flow Management
Good cash management is simple It involves
Knowing when where and how firms cash needs will occur
Page 18 of 46
Knowing the best sources for meeting additional cash needs
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Page 19 of 46
Being prepared to meet these needs when they occur by keeping good
relationships with bankers and other creditors
532 INVENTORY MANAGEMENT
Inventory management is necessary for owners who want to maintain a stocking
service for quick turnaround to help ensure total customer satisfaction The fill rate
of an item on a managed inventory list must be maintained to avoid shortages of
frequently used items Even when utilizing an inventory management system
occasional shortages will still occur Inventories are lists of stocks-raw materials
work in progress or finished goods-waiting to be consumed in production or to be
sold The total balance of inventory is the sum of the value of each individual stock
line
Basically firms hold stocks for the following reasons
To act as a buffer in times of unusually high demand
To ensure continuity of production
Avoid high costs of emergency orders
To take advantage of quantity discounts by ordering more at a time
To reduce ordering costs by ordering more items on fewer
As part of the production process eg maturing whisky or keeping oil in
pipelines
Seasonality of demand (eg firework) or supplies
Suppliers insist on minimum order quantities
The key issue for a business is to identify the fast and slow stock movers with the
objectives of establishing optimum stock levels for each category and thereby
minimize the cash tied up in stocks Factors to be considered when determining
optimum stock levels include
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Page 20 of 46
What are the projected sales of each product
How widely available are raw materials components etc
How long does it take for delivery by suppliers
Can the firm remove slow movers from its product range without
compromising best sellers
Inventory management is an important aspect of working capital management
because inventories themselves do not earn any revenue Holding either too little or
too much inventory incurs costs
Costs of carrying too much inventory are
Opportunity cost of foregone interest
Warehousing costs
Damage and pilferage
Obsolescence
Insurance
Costs of carrying too little inventory are
Stock out costs
Lost sales
Delayed service
Ordering costs
Freight
on Order administrati
nts
Loss of quantity discou
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Carrying costs can be minimized by making frequent small orders but this increase
ordering costs and the risk of stock outs Risk of stock-outs can be reduced by
carrying safety stocks (at a cost) and re-ordering ahead of time
The best ordering strategy requires balancing the various cost factors to ensure the
firm incurs minimum inventory costs The optimum inventory position is known as
the Economic Reorder Quantity (ERQ)
Nowadays many large manufacturers operate on a just-in-time (JIT) basis whereby
all the components to be assembled on a particular today arrive at the factory early
that morning no earlier - no later This helps to minimize manufacturing costs as JIT
stocks take up little space minimize stock-holding and virtually eliminate the risks of
obsolete or damaged stock Because JIT manufacturers hold stock for a very short
time they are able to conserve substantial cash JIT is a good model to strive for as it
embraces all the principles of prudent stock management For better stock control
firm may try the following
Review the effectiveness of existing purchasing and inventory systems
Know the stock turn for all major items of inventory
Apply tight controls to the significant few items and simplify controls for the
trivial many
Sell off outdated or slow moving merchandise - it gets more difficult to sell the
longer the firm keeps it
Consider having part of its product outsourced to another manufacturer rather
than make it itself
Review its security procedures to ensure that no stock is going out the back
door
Higher than necessary stock levels tie up cash and cost more in insurance
accommodation costs and interest charges
Page 21 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
However it is important to keep an overall perspective It is not cost-effective to
closely manage a large number of low value inventory lines nor is it necessary A
usual feature of inventories is that a small number of high value lines account for a
large proportion of inventory value The 8020 rule (PARETO) predicts that 80
of the total value of inventory is represented by only 20 of the number of inventory
items Those high value lines need reasonably close management The remaining
80 of inventory lines can be managed using broad-brush strategies
533 MANAGING ACCOUNTS RECEIVABLE (DEBTORS)
Cash flow can be significantly enhanced if the amounts owing to a business are
collected faster Every business needs to know who owes them money how much is
owed how long it is owing for what it is owed
Debtors (Accounts Receivable) are customers who have not yet made payment for
goods or services which the department has provided The objective of debtor
management is to minimize the time-lapse between completion of sales and receipt
of payment The costs of having debtors are
Opportunity costs (cash is not available for other purposes)
Bad debts
If firm doesnt manage debtors they will begin to manage business as the firm will gradually
lose control due to reduced cash flow and of course it could experience an increased
incidence of bad debt The following measures will help manage debtors
Having the right mental attitude to the control of credit and make sure that it
gets the priority it deserves
Establishing clear credit practices as a matter of company policy
Page 22 of 46
Making sure that these practices are clearly understood by staff suppliers and
customers
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Page 23 of 46
Being professional when accepting new accounts and especially larger ones
Checking out each customer thoroughly before the firm offers credit Use
credit agencies bank references industry sources etc
Establishing credit limits for each customer and sticking to them
Continuously reviewing these limits when it suspects tough times are coming
or if operating in a volatile sector
Keeping very close to the firms larger customers
Invoicing promptly and clearly
Considering charging penalties on overdue accounts
Considering accepting credit debit cards as a payment option
Monitoring its debtor balances and ageing schedules and dont let any debts
get too large or too old
Debtor management includes both pre-sale and debt collection strategies
Pre-sale strategies include
Offering cash discounts for early payment andor imposing penalties for late
payment
Agreeing payment terms in advance
Requiring cash before delivery
Setting credit limits
ning credit Setting criteria for obtai
Billing as early as possible
rogress payments
ost-sale strategies include
for collecting the debt upon the center that made the sale
Requiring deposits andor p
P
Placing the responsibility
Identifying long overdue balances and doubtful debts by regular analytical reviews
Having an established procedure for late collections such as
A reminder
A letter
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Page 24 of 46
ion of further credit Cancellat
Telephone calls
n agency Use of a collectio
he firm should recognize that the longer someone owes firm the greater the chance
Legal action
T
it will never get paid If the average age of debtors is getting longer or is already very
long it may need to look for the following possible defects
Weak credit judgment
res Poor collection procedu
ms Lax enforcement of credit ter
Slow issue of invoices or statements
Errors in invoices or statements
Customer dissatisfaction
Debtors due over 90 days (unless within agreed credit terms) should generally
demand immediate attention For example warning signs of a future bad debt ndash
Longer credit terms taken with approval particularly for smaller orders
Use of post-dated checks by debtors who normally settle within agreed terms
Evidence of customers switching to additional suppliers for the same goods
New customers who are reluctant to give credit references
Cre G
Receiving part payments from debtors
dit ranting to Marginal Accounts
Traditional Approach
In the traditional approach to the credit granting decision it is the credit analysts job
rmation that has been collected and reach a judgment
regarding the applicants creditworthiness One traditional way of organizing this
to synthesize all the info
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
information is by characterizing the applicant along five dimensions These
dimensions are called the Five Cs of credit ndash
Capital
Character
Collateral
and Capacity
Conditions
Net Present Value (NPV) Approach
Once a firm has assessed the creditworthiness of a customer it has to decide whether
r not credit should be granted The firm should use the NPV rule to make the
ld be granted
Figure
o
decision If NPV is positive credit shou
Credit Granting Decision
Credit Granting Decision
he act of collecting money is one which most people dislike for many reasons and
therefore put on the long f selves there is something
ore urgent or important that demands their attention now There is nothing more
T
inger because they convince them
m
important than getting paid for firms product or service A customer who does not
Page 25 of 46
Grand Credit
Payment received Payment not received
Benefit of present value of future net cash flow
Cost of present value ment of lost invest
Net Payoff PV of benefit-cost
No Credit
No Payoff
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
pay is not a customer Here are a few ideas that may help the firm in collecting
money from debtors
Firm should develop appropriate procedures for handling late payments
It should track and pursue late payers
It might get external help if its own efforts fail
or money its firms and it is entitled Company shouldnt feel guilty asking f
to it
ction
Firm must make that call now And it should keep asking until it gets some
satisfa
lessens the problem
In difficult circumstances take what the firm can now and agree terms for the
remainder It
paying
When asking for money be hard on the issue - but soft on the person It shouldnt
give the debtor any excuses for not
534 BLE (CREDITORS)
ices for goods or services have
een paid Organizations often regard the
not
to delay all payments until the latest possible date Regular weekly or
The firm make it its objective is to get the money - not to score points or get
even
MANAGING ACCOUNTS PAYA
Creditors (Accounts Payable) are suppliers whose invo
been processed but who have not yet b
amount owing to creditors as a source of free credit However creditor
administration systems are expensive and time-consuming to run The over-riding
concern in this area should be to minimize costs with simple procedures
While it is unnecessary to pay accounts before they fall due it is usually
worthwhile
Page 26 of 46
fortnightly payment of all due accounts is the simplest technique for creditor
management
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Electronic payments (direct credits) are cheaper than check payments considering
that transaction fees and overheads more than balance the advantage of delayed
presentation Some suppliers are reluctant to receive payments by this method but in
view of the substantial cost advantage (and the advantages to the suppliers
themselves) departments may wish to encourage suppliers to accept this option
However electronic payments are likely to be used in conjunction with rather than
as a replacement for check payments
Applying Best Practices in Managing Accounts Payable
f course simply deferring payments to suppliers could have adverse consequences
O
that more than offset the benefits of this additional cash flow Therefore it is
important to develop a holistic approach The firm should consider the following
best practices for payables management
Managing payment dates and terms to maximize cash flow ndash
y reporting on
receivable and
id penalty charges and taking advantage of
wer vendors and negotiate for more
to buying consortia with others even
voices for
payment based on receipt of goods or receipt of invoice whichever
comes later
Calculating and setting performance targets Regularl
AP performance measures such as days in payables
Coordinating the AP processes with accounts
inventory management to ensure that the company is collecting more
cash than it is paying out
Paying bills on time to avo
prompt-payment discounts where the discounts exceed the companyrsquos
cost of working capital
Consolidating purchases with fe
favorable payment terms
Considering entering in
Page 27 of 46
competitors to obtain favorable supplier pricing and terms
Unless contract terms specify otherwise setting up in
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Page 28 of 46
Em
process
-time payments with Electronic Funds Transfer (EFT)
uraging vendors to utilize electronic invoice presentment
a
ndancies and more
ploying technology to automate the accounts payable transaction
es ndash
Making just-in
Using an electronic invoice-matching application
Enco
For companies with multiple locations or business units employing
shared service approach for AP to eliminate redu
quickly implement process improvements
Mainta
vendor
Communicating accounts payable requirements to suppliers at the
m key suppliers
for suggestions on how to improve the
Efficient a
and making th rsquos cash is just good business
ining open communications and building strong relationships with
s to access valuable trade credit ndash
beginning of transactions
Requesting summary invoicing fro
Requiring suppliers to send invoices directly to accounts payable
Asking tier-one suppliers
payment process
nd effective management of accounts payable helps improve cash flow ndash
e most of company
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
6 OVERVIEW OF VIRGIN GROUP
Virgin - one of the most respected brands in Britain - is now becoming the first global
brand name of the 21st century Virgin is involved in planes trains finance soft
drinks music mobile phones holidays cars wines publishing bridal wear - the lot
What tie all these businesses together are the values of its brand and the attitude of its
people Virgin has created over 200 companies worldwide employing over 25000
people Its total revenues around the world in 2002 exceeded pound4 billion (US $72
billion)
In 1970 Richard Branson founded Virgin as a mail order record retailer and not
long after he opened a record shop in Oxford Street London During 1972 a
recording studio was built in Oxfordshire and the first Virgin artist Mike Oldfield
recorded Tubular Bells which was released in 1973
This album went on to sell over 5 million copies Since then many household names
including Belinda Carlisle Genesis Phil Collins Janet Jackson and The Rolling
Stones have helped to make Virgin Music one of the top six record companies in the
world The equity of Virgin Music Group - record labels music publishing and
recording studios was sold to THORN EMI in 1992 in a US$1billion deal
Page 29 of 46
The Virgin Group has now expanded into international music Mega stores air
travel mobile financial retail music internet drinks rail hotels and leisure with
around 200 companies in over 30 countries
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
In Virgins customers eyes Virgin stands for value for money quality innovation
fun and a sense of competitive challenge It delivers a quality service by empowering
its employees and facilitates and monitors customer feedback to continually improve
the customers experience through innovation
When they start a new venture Virgin bases it on hard research and analysis
Typically they review the industry and put themselves in the customers shoes to see
what could make it better Virgin asks fundamental questions
Is this an opportunity for restructuring a market and creating competitive
advantage What are the competitors doing
Is the customer confused or badly served
Is this an opportunity for building the Virgin brand
Can we add value
Will it interact with its other businesses
Is there an appropriate trade-off between risk and reward
Page 30 of 46
Virgin is also able to draw on talented people from throughout the group New
ventures are often steered by people seconded from other parts of Virgin who bring
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
with them the trademark management style skills and experience Virgin frequently
creates partnerships with others to combine skills knowledge and market presence
and so on Contrary to what some people may think their constantly expanding and
eclectic empire is neither random nor reckless Each successive venture demonstrates
its skill in picking the right market and the right opportunity
7 OVERVIEW OF VIRGIN SOFT DRINKS
The Virgin Drinks Group first launched as the Virgin Cola Company in 1994 with
Virgin Cola in the UK Since then the company has ventured across the carbonated
soft drinks arena and beyond into energy drinks tea and flavored Colas This
expansion has lead to the evolution of the Virgin Drinks Company a company
whose aim is to put the excitement back into the world of soft drinks It launched in
Bangladesh in 1999 Virgin Soft Drinks is monitored by Global Beverage Co Ltd in
Bangladesh
Brief history of Virgin Drinks is given below
Page 31 of 46
1994 November Virgin Cola launched in the UK
1996 March Virgin Cola launched in France
1998 June Virgin Cola launched in Belgium
April Virgin Cola launched in the French West Indies
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
August Virgin Cola launched in Switzerland
1999 March Virgin Colours launched in Italy
March Virgin Cola launched in Japan
July Virgin Colours launched in South Africa
December Virgin Colours launched in Bangladesh
2001 January Sweden launched Virgin Colours
November Singapore launched Virgin Colours
2002 February Croatia launched Virgin Colours
June Russia launched Virgin Colours
June Tunisia launched Virgin Colours
2003 May Israel launched Virgin Colours
8 FINDINGS OF WORKING CAPITAL MANAGEMENT MAINTAINED BY
VIRGIN SOFT DRINKS IN BANGLADESH
81 CASH MANAGEMENT
811 Holding Cash and Marketable Securities
Although there are many good reasons why firm hold cash and marketable
securities Virgin Drinks holds cash and marketable securities for two reasons ndash
i) Cash for transactions
ii) Cash as hedges
This indicates that the firm does not hold cash and marketable securities for some
important reasons such as ndash
i) Near cash assets as hedges
Page 32 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
ii) Temporary investment and compensating balances
Virgin Soft Drinks does not invest in money market securities such as Treasury bill
commercial paper certificate of deposits bankerrsquos acceptance and repurchase
agreement This firm deposits its money in bank as currant AC or fixed AC They
say that they do not have enough money to invest in money market instrument
They also say that if they have enough money they will invest it in money market
short term securities We know that near cash interest earning assets can be
substituted for cash when motivation for holding these assets is the hedging of cash
flow uncertainties or is the temporary investment of surplus funds In this point
Virgins position is not good as there is no significant hedging against uncertainty of
cash
812 Floatation and Check Clearing
Virgin is very smart in handling the problem of transit time for checks Here mail
float takes 2 to 3 days at firm takes 025 day and clearing float takes 1-3 days Virgin
uses most of the strategies available for reducing the delay in receiving funds It
(Virgin) has linked Islami Bank which posses an accelerated clearing facility It uses
electronic collection process which ensures faster collection and its at the firm check
processing is satisfactory But Virgin does not use lockbox The reason behind this is
that it is not cost-effective for Virgin to set lockboxes At this point we can say that
Virgins check clearing mechanism is much good
813 Cash Concentration and Disbursement Management
Page 33 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks takes the matter of cash concentration very seriously They use all
the available cash concentration mechanism Virgin is a firm with small deposits
spread over a substantial number of banks and this is why the firm tends to use
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
depository transfer checks extensively If is less costly Virgin also uses automated
clearing house and wire transfer To Virgin wire transfer seems too costly
Like other firm Virgin tries to retain the cash for as long as possible But Virgin
always performs it in an ethical manner Virgin does not try to defeat the receiving
firmrsquos attempts to reduce the float on incoming checks It does not take any strategy
for increasing mail float at firm float and clearing float on its outgoing checks To
Virgin it is deemed to be unethical It thinks that maximization of disbursement float
will not go unnoticed by sophisticated creditors for very long When it is noticed it
will negatively affect relations with these creditors reducing the firmrsquos bargaining
power with them This may ultimately cost Virgin dearly when future prices and
delivery schedules for goods and services purchased from trade creditors are
negotiated Virgin follows ldquoZero-Balance Accountsrdquo methods for managing
disbursement It thinks that in this method the coordination of funds inflows to
disbursement banks with the presentation of checks does not work to the detriment
of creditors since the firmrsquos checks to them are honored as presented and this strategy
does not affect float significantly Controlled disbursing method is less attractive to
Virgin because zero-balance system is already feasible
814 Cash Forecasting
Cash Forecasting and Its Types
Page 34 of 46
Virgin forecasts the future cash inflows and outflows To Virgin cash forecast is an
important part of the firmrsquos cash control system and is one of the forecasts that are
part of the Virginrsquos financial plan Virgin forecasts cash on monthly basis and on
yearly basis Virgin does not forecast on daily basis assuming that the temporary
shortage of funds within these periods can be covered without value cost eg
advance receipts from customers Virginrsquos cash forecasting system involves a
combination of distribution and scheduling The receipts and disbursements
approach of cash forecasting is used in virgin This method is used because it
minutely traces the movement of cash and very close control of cash is possible
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Virgin does not use adjusted net income approach on two grounds First it does not
permit the tracing of the individual types of cash inflows and outflows for any given
period which is often useful information for virgin Second it is not simple to use
Items to be Forecast
Virgin does not forecast all the items It forecasts only major items eg accounts
receivable notes receivable payroll cash purchases of raw materials In this regard
virgin trade off between cost and benefit
Methods of Financial Forecasting
Virgin forecasts the future level of financial variable such as cash level asset level or
liability level We know in short term forecasts many things will result from plans
and events that are already in place (contracts capital budgets long-range financing
plans and so forth) But in the long run most things can vary and are dependent on
outside influences such as the firmrsquos long-term growth rate Since Virginrsquos cash
forecasting deals mostly with near future many of the items on the cash forecasts are
estimated by some variation of the spot method and remaining estimates are mostly
on a ldquoproportion of another accountrdquo basis with this ldquoother accountrdquo often being a
particular periodrsquos sales Virgin uses the other two methods less frequently
Using Cash Forecast
Virgin forecasts cash for meeting general objectives (ie to know the available funds
for investment and need financing) and for meeting some special objectives (eg to
know whether the firm will fulfill its out of debt requirement) But it is matter to note
that Virgin does not make any short term investment of its surplus cash but only keep
this surplus in Bank Account
Page 35 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Sources of Uncertainty in Cash Forecasting and Hedging Uncertainties
Virgin faces uncertainty in cash forecasting mainly from two sources These are ndash
sales and production cost In peak season (hot season like autumn summer) sales
increases but in dull season (eg in winter) sales decreases drastically Production
cost may be increased because of increase of price of sugar chemicals aluminum
can Virgin follows two methods for hedging cash balance uncertainties These are ndash
i) Holding a stock of extra cash and
ii) Extra borrowing capacity
815 Modes for the Management of Cash and Temporary Investments
Virgin does not follow any of these methods wholly Virgin receives cash
continuously and pays salary at steady rate and pays continuously for other
expenses So it neither follows Baumol model nor Beranek model It has no upper
control limit lower control limit return point in case cash management So it neither
follows Miller-Orr model nor Stone model
In Summary
Page 36 of 46
Standard Compliance by Virgin Soft Drinks
Generally all firms hold cash and
marketable securities
Virgin holds only cash
Firms hold cash and marketable
securities for some reasons like
bull Cash for transactions
bull Cash and near-cash assets as
hedges
bull Temporary investments
bull Compensating balances
Virgin holds cash only for
two reasons ndash
bull Cash for transactions
bull Cash as hedges
Available money market instruments Virgin does not invest in any such
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
(short term securities) are ndash
Treasury Bills
Commercial Paper
Certificates of Deposit
Bankerrsquos Acceptance
Repurch menase Agree ts
instruments They only keep cash in
Bank Account
Mail Float
(1 to 5 days)
At Firm
Float
(025 to 1
day)
Clearing
Float
(0 to
2 days)
Mail Float
(2 to 3 days)
At firm
Float
(025
day)
Clearing
Float
(1 to 3
days)
Figure Transit time for a typical check Figure Transit time for a check for
Virgin
Strategies that firms can use to reduce
the delay in receiving funds are ndash
Selecting of Banks with
accelerated clearing capabilities
of check processing Acceleration
at the firm
ectronic collection Use of el
procedures
Use of lockboxes
Virgin follows the first three strategies
but does not use lockboxes
Available cash concentration
mechanisms are ndash
Depository transfer check
ouse Automated Clearing H
(ACH) electronic transfer)
Wire transfer
Virgin uses all these mechanisms of
cash concentration
Available sets of techniques for cash
disbursement management are ndash
ement of disbursement
Page 37 of 46
Manag
float
Virgin uses zero-balance accounts
technique
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Zero-Balance Accounts
Controlled disbursing
Firms may make cash flow forecasts
over periods of various lengths yearly
flows quarterly flows monthly flows
weekly flows or even daily flows
Virgin forecasts cash on yearly basis and
monthly basis
Cash forecasting system may involve ndash
Distribution
Scheduling
Virginrsquos cash forecasting system
involves a combination of distribution
and scheduling
Two common approaches to cash flow
in generating the cash forecast
and disbursement Receipts
approach
Adjusted net income approach
Virgin uses the receipts and
disbursement approach
There are many items to forecast Virgin forecasts only major items like
AR payroll etc
Four common approach to forecasting
fina i ndash nc al variables are
Spot method
Proportion to another account
Compounded growth
Multiple dependencies
Virgin uses spot method for forecasting
cash It uses proportion to another
account method for other variables and
remaining two methods are frequently
used
Sources of uncertainty in cash
forecasting are ndash
Sales uncertainty
Collection rate uncertainty
Production cost uncertainty
Capital outflow uncertainty
Virgin faces uncertainty mainly from
sales and production cost
Methods for hedging cash balance
unc a
Page 38 of 46
ert inties are ndash
i) Holding a stock of extra cash
Virgin two available methods for
hedging cash balance uncertainties
Th ese are ndash
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
ii) stock of near-cash Holding a
assets
iii) Extra borrowing capacity
iv) ary surpluses in Investing tempor
near-cash assets
i) Holding a stock of extra cash
ii) Extra borrowing capacity
(advance receipt from
customers)
Models for the management of cash and
temporary investments are ndash Baumol
model Beranek model Miller-Orr
model and Stone model
Virgin does not follow any method
wholly but a combination of Baumol
model and Beranek model is occurred
82 INVENTORY MANAGEMENT
21 Certainty Approach
isnt used in
irgin because it thinks it is not possible to implement in Bangladesh
d time is one to three days It
oes not use ABC system of inventory management
8
Main item of inventory of Virgin is Can pet chip sugar label chemical artificial
sweet etc Virgin maintains a minimum level of inventory but it does not have to face
problems because inventory is managed efficiently just-in-time (JIT)
V
Virgin maintains buffer stock because of the shortage of work-in-process (WIP)
inventory Its production process may also be hampered Thats why it maintains
safety stock to avoid stock out cost In case of imported goods normal lead time is
about one month and within the country normal lea
d
Page 39 of 46
Inventory Model
In reality Virgin does not use any of models of EOQ ordering and holding strategy
and safety stock strategy They maintain inventory based on their prior experience
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
822 Uncertainty Approach
Virgin does not use any model for handling inventory uncertainty It says that such
decision depends on business cycle and market situation Long before Eid festival
they bought large amount of sugar because of price increase on the occasion of Eid
In summary
Standard Compliance by Virgin Soft Drinks
Firms maintain inventory to guard
against several problems
Virgin maintains a minimum level of
inventory which is managed efficiently
Some firms use JIT to avoid inventory
cost
JIT is not used by Virgin as it thinks it is
impossible to implement in Bangladesh
Firms maintain buffer stock Virgin maintains buffer stock too
Firms maintain safety stock to avoid
shortage cost
Virgin also maintains safety stock
Firms use ABC system to monitor
inventory
Virgin doesnt use ABC system
EOQ model is an appropriate method
for measuring quantity that has to be
ordered per order
Virgin does not use EOQ model rather
makes order based on experience and
market demand
83 MANAGING ACCOUNTS RECEIVABLE (DEBTORS)
831 Terms of Sale Decision
Page 40 of 46
Virgin offers the term 210 net 30 enables the customers to deduct 2 percent from the
face value of the bill when paying within the first 10 days but if the discount is not
taken the customer must remit the full amount within 30 days But Virgin does not
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
offer the same terms of sale to all customers For prime customers it offers special
terms of sale In setting an appropriate term of sale it costs and benefits regarding
this are compared It uses the standard approach of terms of sale decision as it is
simple to use
832 Credit Granting Decisions
In case of Virgin the Capital and Character of Five Cs get more importance
Although there are many problems with the traditional approach Virgin uses it
because of its simplicity Virgin does not use Net Present Value (NPV) method in
credit granting decision It thinks that NPV is an appropriate method and should be
used next time It does not face any severe problem because of bad debts The reason
is that notes receivable is used when credit is granted
833 Monitoring Accounts Receivable
Virgin monitors its accounts receivable Virgin believes that in any case both positive
and negative durations in accounts signal differences from the results that
management believe to be the most advantageous for the firm
Tools for Monitoring Accounts Receivable
Page 41 of 46
For monitoring accounts receivable there are several tools such as aging schedule
the ratios of receivable outstanding to original sales customers payment proportion
and sales weighted DSO (Days Sales Outstanding) For monitoring accounts
receivable Virgin uses aging schedule fractions and traditional DSO statistics
because of their simplicity in use Although payment proportions ratios of
receivables outstanding and sales weighted DSO methods are free from inherent bias
None of these is used because all these are complex to maintain
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
In summary
Page 42 of 46
Standard Compliance by Virgin Soft Drinks
Generals terms of sale is 210 net 30 Normally Virgin also use general terms
of sale ie 210 net 30
Firms do not offer the same terms of
sale to all customers
Yes For prime customers Virgin offers
special terms of sale
Approaches of terms of sale decisions
are ndash
bull Standard approach
bull Multi period approach
Virgin uses standard approach of terms
of sale decision as it is simple to use and
understand
Source of credit information are ndash
Sellers prior experience with the
customer
Credit agency ratings and
reports
Personal contact with the
applicants bank and other
creditors
Analysis of applicants financial
statements
Customer visit
Main source of credit information to
Virgin is its prior experience with the
customer All other sources are not cost-
effective for Virgin
Approaches of credit granting to
marginal accounts are ndash
Traditional approach
Net Present Value (NPV)
approach
It uses traditional approach still now but
thinks that NPV should be used for the
next periods
Firms monitor accounts receivable
because deviations from the expected
levels of turnover and of bad debt can
Virgin also monitors its accounts
receivable
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
signal several different problems
Different tools for monitoring accounts
receivable are ndash
Aging schedule
Ratios of receivables
outstanding to original sales
Customers payment
proportions
Sales-weighted DSO
For monitoring accounts receivable
Virgin uses aging schedule and
traditional sales outstanding statistics
84 MANAGING ACCOUNTS PAYABLE (CREDITORS)
Virgin has almost accounts payable of Tk 8000000 But most of its liabilities are to
the banks rather than suppliers But we dont have any clear information about
Virgins accounts payable
9 RECOMMENDATION
Virgin should invest its surplus cash in short term marketable securities
because it is suitable hedging against cash uncertainties and will also give
some returns (interest income)
Virgin should publish its own annual report which will satisfy information
needs of stakeholders and also increase the credibility of information provided
by Virgin
Page 43 of 46
Virgin should use multi period approach in terms of sale decision because
standard approach which is already exists in Virgin has some inherent
problems
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
It should stop using traditional approach from now It should use NPV
method in credit granting to marginal accounts
In monitoring accounts receivable Virgin should use sales-weighted DSO
method because it has least limitation compared to the others
It should be more flexible in granting credit which will ultimately increase its
sales
To get the appropriate number of quantity to be ordered per order it should
use DSO model
It should be ABC system for proper monitoring of inventory
10 CONCLUSION
The use of other peoples money in business is usually an expensive resource Before
looking outside for finance a firm should examine its own working capital cycle to
make sure that every rand of its own internal funds is being fully utilized Good
management of working capital is part of good financial management Effective use
of working capital will contribute to the operational efficiency of the whole
organization optimum use will help to generate maximum returns Furthermore
working capital management is not an end in itself It is an integral part of the firms
overall management The needs of efficient working capital management must be
considered in relation to other aspects of the Virgins financial and non-financial
performance Thats why when planning the development of a business it is critical
that the impact of working capital be fully assessed
Page 44 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
BIBLIOGRAPHY
Scherr FC (1989) International Edition Prentice-Hall International Inc Modern
Working Capital Management Text and Cases
Hussain Riaz (2002) Working Capital Management
Robertson Lonnie (July 1998) Inventory Management
httpwwwasashoporg visited on March 13 2006
The Art of Cash Management
httpwwwinccom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management
httpwwwstudyfinancecom visited on March 13 2006
White Paper ndash Managing Working Capital
httpwwwplanwareorg visited on March 13 2006
Management of Working Capital
httpwwwbusinesscentralcoza visited on March 13 2006
Cash Management
httpwwwsbagov visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management Objectives
httpwpsprenhallcom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management
Page 45 of 46
httpwwwadvancemecom visited on March 13 2006
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Business Receivables Financing
httpwwwbbtcom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Finance
http wwwfnbcoza visited on March 13 2006
Tips to manage your working capital
httpsmallbusinessninemsncomau visited on March 13 2006
Inventory Financing
httpwwwfranklincapitalnetworkcom visited on March 13 2006
Accounts Receivable Management
httpwwwfranklincapitalnetworkcom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management
httpwwwtreasurygovtnz visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management
httpwwwtreasurystrategiescom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Works
httpwwwinvestopediacom visited on March 13 2006
Treasury Services
httpwwwjpmorganchasecom visited on March 13 2006
what were about
Page 46 of 46
httpwwwvirgincom visited on March 13 2006
Annexure
Annexure
Interview with YASEER RIZVI
Mr Yaseer Rizvi the DMD of Global Beverage Co Ltd obtained his MBA degree
from a reputed university He had been the Director of Ocean Container Ltd before
joining in Global Beverage Co Ltd He possesses a nice personality
I interviewed Yaseer Rizvi Excerpts from his interview are as follows ndash
Shah Kamal Sir would you please tell me do you invest in short term marketable securities
Yaseer Rizvi Basically we do not invest our surplus cash in short term marketable
securities like T-Bill commercial paper certificate of deposit etc But we keep our
surplus cash in Bank
Shah Kamal Would you tell me something about transit time for a typical check
Yaseer Rizvi Well in Virgin the transit time for a typical check is ndash
For mail float 2 to 3 days
At firm float 6 hours
Clearing float 1 to 3 days
Shah Kamal Do you maintain any cash concentration mechanism like depository transfer check automated clearing house and wire transfer
i
Annexure
Yaseer Rizvi Our position in this case is very strong as we use all the mechanisms
you mentioned As Virgin is a firm with small deposits spread over a substantial
number of banks so we tend to use depository transfer checks extensively It is less
costly We also use automated clearing house and wire transfer but later is used in a
less extent
Shah Kamal Sir what techniques of disbursement management is used by your firm
Yaseer Rizvi Like other firms Virgin tries to retain the cash for as long as possible
But we always perform it in an ethical manner We do not use management of
disbursement float as it seems unethical We follow Zero-Balance Accounts method
for managing disbursement We do not prefer Controlled Disbursing method since
Zero-Balance system is already practiced in Virgin
Shah Kamal How do you hedge cash balance uncertainties
Yaseer Rizvi Well you may say that we do not invest in short term securities but for
facing cash difficulties we keep our surplus cash in bank
Shah Kamal Sir would you please tell me the general terms of sale of Virgin
Yaseer Rizvi Though it is difficult to maintain a fixed terms of sale our general terms
of sale is 210 n30 But for prime customers we offer special terms of sale
Shah Kamal What are the sources of credit information in case of your firm
Yaseer Rizvi We grant credit on the basis of prior experience with the customers In
case of a new customer personal contact is weighted
Shah Kamal Does your firm consider 5 Cs in granting credit
ii
Annexure
Yaseer Rizvi In case of Virgin Capital and Character get more importance than the
others Mind one thing personal relationship is the main measure in granting credit
Shah Kamal Do you use NPV method in credit granting decisions
Yaseer Rizvi We do not use NPV method But we think that NPV is a suitable
method and we have to use it from the next period
Shah Kamal Sir how do you handle the problem of bad debt
Yaseer Rizvi Well in this case our position is very strong Yet we do not face any
problem because of bad debt Just note that we make more than 80 of sales in cash
and we monitor accounts receivable very carefully
Shah Kamal What level of inventory is maintained by Virgin
Yaseer Rizvi We maintain a minimum level of inventory but do not have to face
stock out problems because inventory is managed efficiently
Shah Kamal What is the normal lead time
Yaseer Rizvi In case of imported goods normal lead time is about 1 month and when
we purchase raw materials from inside the country lead time is 1 to 3 days
Shah Kamal What method do you use for managing inventory
Yaseer Rizvi We do not use any method particularly rather inventory decision
depends on business cycle and market situation Long before the Eid festival we
bought large amount of sugar because price of sugar was increased on the occasion
of Eid
iii
Annexure
Shah Kamal What are the main items of inventory of your firm
Yaseer Rizvi Well these are ndash aluminum can pet chip sugar label chemical and
artificial sweet
Shah Kamal What are the uncertainties in maintaining appropriate level of stock
Yaseer Rizvi These are ndash
bull Increase in price of raw materials
bull Sales uncertainty
bull Market trends etc
Shah Kamal Thank you for your kind cooperation
Yaseer Rizvi Most Welcome
iv
Global Beverage Company Limited
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
5311 Motives for Holding Cash
Despite the seemingly low returns there are several good reasons why firms hold
cash and marketable securities These reasons are ndash
Cash for transactions
Cash and near cash assets as hedges
Temporary investment and
Compensating balances
5312 Components of Cash Management
A Cash Flow Statement shows the sources and uses of cash and is typically divided
into three components
Operating Cash Flow
Operating cash flow often referred to as working capital is the cash flow generated
from internal operations It comes from sales of the product or service of your
business and because it is generated internally it is under your control
Investing Cash Flow
Investing cash flow is generated internally from non-operating activities This
includes investments in plant and equipment or other fixed assets nonrecurring gains
or losses or other sources and uses of cash outside of normal operations
Financing Cash Flow
Financing cash flow is the cash to and from external sources such as lenders
investors and shareholders
Page 9 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
5313 Tools for Cash Management
Flotation and Check Clearing
Management of cash when it is not in the firmrsquos hands that is in transit to and from
the firm is on important function in the area of finance Transit times for the check
takes in three stages These are mail float at firm float and clearing float Normally
mail float takes 1 to 5 days at firm float takes 025 to 1 day and clearing float takes 0
to 2 days The firm should care about this process because every delay in the receipt
of money by the firm lowers the firmrsquos returns and therefore its shareholdersrsquo wealth
There are several strategies that firm can use to reduce the delay in receiving funds
Each of these strategies addresses one or more of the three float times (mail float
time at time float time and clearing float time) that make up the total transit time of
fund from one firm to another
Other Cash Management Tools
When the economy is strong companies can lapse into sloppy cash-management
practices Firm should try exploring these options
1 Sweep accounts
These bank accounts are the easiest way to generate some income from companys
spare funds however they make sense only if the money youll earn will be greater
than the fees your bank will charge Business owners have two types of sweep
accounts to choose between
Page 10 of 46
Controlled-investment accounts These are the most profitable form of
sweep account but they wont work for company if the firm has any
electronic payments or wire transfers since those may be submitted for
payment later in the day and the account wont have enough cash in it to
cover them
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Page 11 of 46
End-of-day sweep accounts A safer bet for most small-business owners
these accounts wait until a late-hour cutoff to determine how much to
sweep into the firms overnight investments Typically their investment
yields are 10 to 20 basis points (1 to 2 of the investment) lower than
those offered with controlled investments
2 Lock-box accounts
A lock box is a cash-management system that helps the firm collect funds quickly
Generally set up with the assistance of a big money center or regional bank lock
boxes provide the firm with a special zip code and usually quicker deliveries from
regional post offices They are especially important if the firm has clusters of
customers in out-of-state locations and dont want to lose days waiting for their
checks to arrive by long-distance mail
5314 Cash Concentration and Cash Disbursement
Once the remittances from the firmrsquos customers have been received and cleared the
resulting cash balances is available in the firmrsquos lockbox (depository) banks It is
useful for the firm to gather these balances from the lockbox banks into the central
bank account The process of collecting funds is called cash concentration
Several concentration mechanism are available for the firm to use in transferring
funds from its collection banks to regional concentration banks and from there to the
central concentration bank These mechanisms differ in cost and in the availability of
funds that they provide These are ndash
a) Depository Transfer Check
It is the cheapest transfer mechanism This document instructs one bank to
send funds to another and is treated the same as any other check
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
b) Automated Clearing House (ACH) Electronic Transfer
This vehicle is essentially an electronic version of the depository transfer
check and can be used between banks that participate in the automated
clearing house system
c) Wire Transfer
These are electronic message between banks
Decisions regarding concentration mechanism usually hinge on the size and
spread of the firmrsquos deposits Firms with small deposits spread over a
substantial number of banks will tend to have more extensive concentration
systems and will transfer among accounts using low-cost transfer vehicles that
offer only delayed availability (such as depository transfer checks) Firms with
larger deposits will have fewer accounts (since a local deposit for transfer to
an upstream bank is not needed) and will use more expensive and more rapid
transfer mechanisms (such as wire transfers) The concentration systems of
major chemical companies for example tend to be structured in this way ndash
DepositoryLockbox Banks
Regional Concentration Banks
Central Concentrated Bank
Figure A typical Cash Concentration System
(Arrows indicate transfers of collected funds)
Page 12 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Disbursement management addresses the efficient payout out of this cash once it is
concentrated The firmrsquos objective in disbursement management is to retain the cash
for as long as possible In this way the firm will have the maximum amount of funds
available for investment and transactional purposes Certainly this management
means making disbursement only when they are due and not before The firm has
several available set of techniques for disbursement management Included among
these are ndash
a) Management of Disbursement Float
In this set of techniques the disbursing firm attempts to increase the length of
time between the mailing of its checks and the eventual withdrawal of funds
from the banks This involves strategies for increasing mail float at firm float
and clearing float on its outgoing checks For example the disbursing firm
may intentionally address checks to the firmrsquos office address rather than its
lockbox creating at firm float
b) Zero-Balance Accounts
Here the firm holds the cash until the check arrive (or expected to arrive) at
the disbursement bank In this strategy an account for disbursement is first
established at a bank For the zero-balance system to be effective the
participating bank must be one on which most disbursement are made via the
Bangladesh Bankrsquos clearance system (which presents disbursements to banks
early in the morning) and not a bank where disbursements occur throughout
the day (as with a major money-center bank) Consequently the banks used
in zero-balance strategies are usually branches of major banks and not their
main locations
Page 13 of 46
c) Controlled Disbursing
In this system the firm projects the amount of checks to arrive each day at the
disbursement bank (based on the checks written in previous days and historic
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
statistics on disbursement float) and transfers the amount of the expected
checks to the account on that day or just before
5315 Cash Forecasting
Defining Cash Forecasting
The cash forecast is an estimation of the flows in and out of the firmrsquos cash account
over a particular period of time usually a quarter month week or day The cash
forecast is primarily intended to produce a very useful piece of information an
estimation of the firmrsquos borrowing and lending needs and uncertainties regarding
these needs during various future periods Cash forecasting is very crucial to most
firms It enables them to anticipate periods of surplus cash and periods where
financing will be necessary This anticipation is the reason that cash forecasts are
generated Anticipation enables the firm to plan much more effectively for
investment and financing and via this planning produce superior return
Types of Cash Forecasts
The types of cash forecasts generated by firms can be differentiated along two
dimensions the length of the periods included within the cash forecast and the approach
to cash flows used in the cash forecast The length of the period refers to the units of
time into which the cash forecast is divided Firms may make cash flow forecasts
over periods of various lengths yearly flows quarterly flows monthly flows weekly
flows or even daily flows The most popular forecast involves monthly flows but
most firms do not confine themselves to a single forecast Instead they use several
forecasts with periods of various lengths When the firm makes forecasts involving
multiple and overlapping period lengths one forecast relates to another Starting
with data on relatively long periods and breaking it down into smaller periods is
called distribution starting with data on relatively short periods and aggregating into
longer periods is called scheduling
Page 14 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Firms use two common approaches to cash flows in generating the cash forecast the
receipts and disbursements approach and the adjusted net income approach The receipts
and disbursements approach use the amounts of cash expected to be received and
disbursed by the firm over the periods chosen for forecast The adjusted income
statement approach is sometimes called the sources and use approach Here the
forecaster starts with projected net income on an accrual basis and adjusts to a cash
basis This method provides a representation of changes in asset and liability
accounts since the level of these accounts are of interest to the firm this aspect of the
adjusted income statement is an advantage over the receipts and disbursements
method
Items to Be Forecast
In the receipt and disbursements cash forecasting method estimates need to be made
of the numerous major and minor items that the firm collects (receipts) and that it
pays (disbursements) The more individual categories of items the firm includes in its
forecast procedure the more accurate the forecast may be but the more costly in
terms of time and effort it will be to generate
Some Possible Types of Cash Receipts and Cash Disbursements
Cash Disbursements Cash Receipts
Cash Purchases of Materials Payroll
Taxes
Maturing Accounts Payable
Maturing Notes Payable
Miscellaneous Disbursements
Accounts Receivable
Notes Receivable
Rental Income
Interest Income
Miscellaneous Receipts
Methods of Financial Forecasting
Page 15 of 46
Financial forecasting is the estimation of the future level of a financial variable often
a cash flow asset level or liability level It is usually assumed that the relationship
between the financial variable and other variable is linear The general linear model
can then be used
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
nnt xaxaxaaY 22110 ++=
Here
= Financial variable (Y) to be forecast in period t tY
x = Explanatory variable it is assumed to cause the level of Y in period t
0a = Represents a constant unaffected by the x
The other terms are the estimated coefficients of the explanatory x variables
There are n terms with xrsquos in them
There are four common approaches to forecasting financial variables but they
are all special cases of the general linear model These are ndash spot method proportion
to another account compounded growth and multiple dependencies
Using Cash Forecast
The estimate of available funds for investment and needed financing enables the firm
to plan so as to obtain the most advantages borrowing terms for deficits and achieve
the greatest interest income on surplus A useful chart for this planning purpose is a
bar chart eg
Figure Bar Chart of Cash Surpluses and Deficits from hypothetical data
Page 16 of 46
75
50
-60
30
100
-20
-80-60-40-20
020406080
100120
Defic
it
S
urpl
us
January February March April May June
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Sources of Uncertainty in Cash Forecasting and Hedging Uncertainties
There are numerous sources of risk in cash forecasting Among the sources are sales
uncertainty collection rate uncertainty production cost uncertainty and capital
outflow uncertainty
5316 Models for the Management of Cash and Temporary Investments
There are different models for the management of cash and temporary investments
Among these the most popular methods are ndash Baumol model Beranek model
Miller-Orr model and Stone model
Baumol and Beranek use the same model The formula is cited below ndash
Interest Income = iYn
n⎥⎦⎤
⎢⎣⎡ minus
21
Profit = naiYn
nminus⎥⎦
⎤⎢⎣⎡ minus
21
Optimum number of transactions = ⎟⎠⎞
⎜⎝⎛
aiY2
Where n = Optimum number of transactions
i = Interest rate per period
a = Transaction cost
Y = Total inflow for the period
Page 17 of 46
Miller-Orr and Stone use the same model ie R-Statistic The model is ndash
31
43
iav
R ⎟⎠⎞
⎜⎝⎛=
Optimum Control Limit = R + L
Upper Control Limit = 3R + L
Where a = Transaction Cost
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
v = Variance of daily cash flows
i = Daily interest rate
5317 Administration
Cash receipts should be processed and banked as quickly as possible because
They cannot earn interest or reduce overdraft until they are banked
information about the existence and amounts of cash receipts is usually not
available until they are processed
Where possible cash floats (mainly petty cash and advances) should be avoided If
on review the only reason that can be put forward for their existence is that weve
always had them they should be discontinued There may be situations where they
are useful however For example it may be desirable for peripheral parts of
departments to meet urgent local needs from cash floats rather than local bank
accounts
5318 Internal Control
Cash and cash management is part of a firms overall internal control system The
main internal cash control is invariably the bank reconciliation This provides
assurance that the cash balances recorded in the accounting systems are consistent
with the actual bank balances It requires regular clearing of reconciling items
5319 Practicing Good Cash Flow Management
Good cash management is simple It involves
Knowing when where and how firms cash needs will occur
Page 18 of 46
Knowing the best sources for meeting additional cash needs
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Page 19 of 46
Being prepared to meet these needs when they occur by keeping good
relationships with bankers and other creditors
532 INVENTORY MANAGEMENT
Inventory management is necessary for owners who want to maintain a stocking
service for quick turnaround to help ensure total customer satisfaction The fill rate
of an item on a managed inventory list must be maintained to avoid shortages of
frequently used items Even when utilizing an inventory management system
occasional shortages will still occur Inventories are lists of stocks-raw materials
work in progress or finished goods-waiting to be consumed in production or to be
sold The total balance of inventory is the sum of the value of each individual stock
line
Basically firms hold stocks for the following reasons
To act as a buffer in times of unusually high demand
To ensure continuity of production
Avoid high costs of emergency orders
To take advantage of quantity discounts by ordering more at a time
To reduce ordering costs by ordering more items on fewer
As part of the production process eg maturing whisky or keeping oil in
pipelines
Seasonality of demand (eg firework) or supplies
Suppliers insist on minimum order quantities
The key issue for a business is to identify the fast and slow stock movers with the
objectives of establishing optimum stock levels for each category and thereby
minimize the cash tied up in stocks Factors to be considered when determining
optimum stock levels include
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Page 20 of 46
What are the projected sales of each product
How widely available are raw materials components etc
How long does it take for delivery by suppliers
Can the firm remove slow movers from its product range without
compromising best sellers
Inventory management is an important aspect of working capital management
because inventories themselves do not earn any revenue Holding either too little or
too much inventory incurs costs
Costs of carrying too much inventory are
Opportunity cost of foregone interest
Warehousing costs
Damage and pilferage
Obsolescence
Insurance
Costs of carrying too little inventory are
Stock out costs
Lost sales
Delayed service
Ordering costs
Freight
on Order administrati
nts
Loss of quantity discou
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Carrying costs can be minimized by making frequent small orders but this increase
ordering costs and the risk of stock outs Risk of stock-outs can be reduced by
carrying safety stocks (at a cost) and re-ordering ahead of time
The best ordering strategy requires balancing the various cost factors to ensure the
firm incurs minimum inventory costs The optimum inventory position is known as
the Economic Reorder Quantity (ERQ)
Nowadays many large manufacturers operate on a just-in-time (JIT) basis whereby
all the components to be assembled on a particular today arrive at the factory early
that morning no earlier - no later This helps to minimize manufacturing costs as JIT
stocks take up little space minimize stock-holding and virtually eliminate the risks of
obsolete or damaged stock Because JIT manufacturers hold stock for a very short
time they are able to conserve substantial cash JIT is a good model to strive for as it
embraces all the principles of prudent stock management For better stock control
firm may try the following
Review the effectiveness of existing purchasing and inventory systems
Know the stock turn for all major items of inventory
Apply tight controls to the significant few items and simplify controls for the
trivial many
Sell off outdated or slow moving merchandise - it gets more difficult to sell the
longer the firm keeps it
Consider having part of its product outsourced to another manufacturer rather
than make it itself
Review its security procedures to ensure that no stock is going out the back
door
Higher than necessary stock levels tie up cash and cost more in insurance
accommodation costs and interest charges
Page 21 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
However it is important to keep an overall perspective It is not cost-effective to
closely manage a large number of low value inventory lines nor is it necessary A
usual feature of inventories is that a small number of high value lines account for a
large proportion of inventory value The 8020 rule (PARETO) predicts that 80
of the total value of inventory is represented by only 20 of the number of inventory
items Those high value lines need reasonably close management The remaining
80 of inventory lines can be managed using broad-brush strategies
533 MANAGING ACCOUNTS RECEIVABLE (DEBTORS)
Cash flow can be significantly enhanced if the amounts owing to a business are
collected faster Every business needs to know who owes them money how much is
owed how long it is owing for what it is owed
Debtors (Accounts Receivable) are customers who have not yet made payment for
goods or services which the department has provided The objective of debtor
management is to minimize the time-lapse between completion of sales and receipt
of payment The costs of having debtors are
Opportunity costs (cash is not available for other purposes)
Bad debts
If firm doesnt manage debtors they will begin to manage business as the firm will gradually
lose control due to reduced cash flow and of course it could experience an increased
incidence of bad debt The following measures will help manage debtors
Having the right mental attitude to the control of credit and make sure that it
gets the priority it deserves
Establishing clear credit practices as a matter of company policy
Page 22 of 46
Making sure that these practices are clearly understood by staff suppliers and
customers
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Page 23 of 46
Being professional when accepting new accounts and especially larger ones
Checking out each customer thoroughly before the firm offers credit Use
credit agencies bank references industry sources etc
Establishing credit limits for each customer and sticking to them
Continuously reviewing these limits when it suspects tough times are coming
or if operating in a volatile sector
Keeping very close to the firms larger customers
Invoicing promptly and clearly
Considering charging penalties on overdue accounts
Considering accepting credit debit cards as a payment option
Monitoring its debtor balances and ageing schedules and dont let any debts
get too large or too old
Debtor management includes both pre-sale and debt collection strategies
Pre-sale strategies include
Offering cash discounts for early payment andor imposing penalties for late
payment
Agreeing payment terms in advance
Requiring cash before delivery
Setting credit limits
ning credit Setting criteria for obtai
Billing as early as possible
rogress payments
ost-sale strategies include
for collecting the debt upon the center that made the sale
Requiring deposits andor p
P
Placing the responsibility
Identifying long overdue balances and doubtful debts by regular analytical reviews
Having an established procedure for late collections such as
A reminder
A letter
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Page 24 of 46
ion of further credit Cancellat
Telephone calls
n agency Use of a collectio
he firm should recognize that the longer someone owes firm the greater the chance
Legal action
T
it will never get paid If the average age of debtors is getting longer or is already very
long it may need to look for the following possible defects
Weak credit judgment
res Poor collection procedu
ms Lax enforcement of credit ter
Slow issue of invoices or statements
Errors in invoices or statements
Customer dissatisfaction
Debtors due over 90 days (unless within agreed credit terms) should generally
demand immediate attention For example warning signs of a future bad debt ndash
Longer credit terms taken with approval particularly for smaller orders
Use of post-dated checks by debtors who normally settle within agreed terms
Evidence of customers switching to additional suppliers for the same goods
New customers who are reluctant to give credit references
Cre G
Receiving part payments from debtors
dit ranting to Marginal Accounts
Traditional Approach
In the traditional approach to the credit granting decision it is the credit analysts job
rmation that has been collected and reach a judgment
regarding the applicants creditworthiness One traditional way of organizing this
to synthesize all the info
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
information is by characterizing the applicant along five dimensions These
dimensions are called the Five Cs of credit ndash
Capital
Character
Collateral
and Capacity
Conditions
Net Present Value (NPV) Approach
Once a firm has assessed the creditworthiness of a customer it has to decide whether
r not credit should be granted The firm should use the NPV rule to make the
ld be granted
Figure
o
decision If NPV is positive credit shou
Credit Granting Decision
Credit Granting Decision
he act of collecting money is one which most people dislike for many reasons and
therefore put on the long f selves there is something
ore urgent or important that demands their attention now There is nothing more
T
inger because they convince them
m
important than getting paid for firms product or service A customer who does not
Page 25 of 46
Grand Credit
Payment received Payment not received
Benefit of present value of future net cash flow
Cost of present value ment of lost invest
Net Payoff PV of benefit-cost
No Credit
No Payoff
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
pay is not a customer Here are a few ideas that may help the firm in collecting
money from debtors
Firm should develop appropriate procedures for handling late payments
It should track and pursue late payers
It might get external help if its own efforts fail
or money its firms and it is entitled Company shouldnt feel guilty asking f
to it
ction
Firm must make that call now And it should keep asking until it gets some
satisfa
lessens the problem
In difficult circumstances take what the firm can now and agree terms for the
remainder It
paying
When asking for money be hard on the issue - but soft on the person It shouldnt
give the debtor any excuses for not
534 BLE (CREDITORS)
ices for goods or services have
een paid Organizations often regard the
not
to delay all payments until the latest possible date Regular weekly or
The firm make it its objective is to get the money - not to score points or get
even
MANAGING ACCOUNTS PAYA
Creditors (Accounts Payable) are suppliers whose invo
been processed but who have not yet b
amount owing to creditors as a source of free credit However creditor
administration systems are expensive and time-consuming to run The over-riding
concern in this area should be to minimize costs with simple procedures
While it is unnecessary to pay accounts before they fall due it is usually
worthwhile
Page 26 of 46
fortnightly payment of all due accounts is the simplest technique for creditor
management
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Electronic payments (direct credits) are cheaper than check payments considering
that transaction fees and overheads more than balance the advantage of delayed
presentation Some suppliers are reluctant to receive payments by this method but in
view of the substantial cost advantage (and the advantages to the suppliers
themselves) departments may wish to encourage suppliers to accept this option
However electronic payments are likely to be used in conjunction with rather than
as a replacement for check payments
Applying Best Practices in Managing Accounts Payable
f course simply deferring payments to suppliers could have adverse consequences
O
that more than offset the benefits of this additional cash flow Therefore it is
important to develop a holistic approach The firm should consider the following
best practices for payables management
Managing payment dates and terms to maximize cash flow ndash
y reporting on
receivable and
id penalty charges and taking advantage of
wer vendors and negotiate for more
to buying consortia with others even
voices for
payment based on receipt of goods or receipt of invoice whichever
comes later
Calculating and setting performance targets Regularl
AP performance measures such as days in payables
Coordinating the AP processes with accounts
inventory management to ensure that the company is collecting more
cash than it is paying out
Paying bills on time to avo
prompt-payment discounts where the discounts exceed the companyrsquos
cost of working capital
Consolidating purchases with fe
favorable payment terms
Considering entering in
Page 27 of 46
competitors to obtain favorable supplier pricing and terms
Unless contract terms specify otherwise setting up in
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Page 28 of 46
Em
process
-time payments with Electronic Funds Transfer (EFT)
uraging vendors to utilize electronic invoice presentment
a
ndancies and more
ploying technology to automate the accounts payable transaction
es ndash
Making just-in
Using an electronic invoice-matching application
Enco
For companies with multiple locations or business units employing
shared service approach for AP to eliminate redu
quickly implement process improvements
Mainta
vendor
Communicating accounts payable requirements to suppliers at the
m key suppliers
for suggestions on how to improve the
Efficient a
and making th rsquos cash is just good business
ining open communications and building strong relationships with
s to access valuable trade credit ndash
beginning of transactions
Requesting summary invoicing fro
Requiring suppliers to send invoices directly to accounts payable
Asking tier-one suppliers
payment process
nd effective management of accounts payable helps improve cash flow ndash
e most of company
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
6 OVERVIEW OF VIRGIN GROUP
Virgin - one of the most respected brands in Britain - is now becoming the first global
brand name of the 21st century Virgin is involved in planes trains finance soft
drinks music mobile phones holidays cars wines publishing bridal wear - the lot
What tie all these businesses together are the values of its brand and the attitude of its
people Virgin has created over 200 companies worldwide employing over 25000
people Its total revenues around the world in 2002 exceeded pound4 billion (US $72
billion)
In 1970 Richard Branson founded Virgin as a mail order record retailer and not
long after he opened a record shop in Oxford Street London During 1972 a
recording studio was built in Oxfordshire and the first Virgin artist Mike Oldfield
recorded Tubular Bells which was released in 1973
This album went on to sell over 5 million copies Since then many household names
including Belinda Carlisle Genesis Phil Collins Janet Jackson and The Rolling
Stones have helped to make Virgin Music one of the top six record companies in the
world The equity of Virgin Music Group - record labels music publishing and
recording studios was sold to THORN EMI in 1992 in a US$1billion deal
Page 29 of 46
The Virgin Group has now expanded into international music Mega stores air
travel mobile financial retail music internet drinks rail hotels and leisure with
around 200 companies in over 30 countries
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
In Virgins customers eyes Virgin stands for value for money quality innovation
fun and a sense of competitive challenge It delivers a quality service by empowering
its employees and facilitates and monitors customer feedback to continually improve
the customers experience through innovation
When they start a new venture Virgin bases it on hard research and analysis
Typically they review the industry and put themselves in the customers shoes to see
what could make it better Virgin asks fundamental questions
Is this an opportunity for restructuring a market and creating competitive
advantage What are the competitors doing
Is the customer confused or badly served
Is this an opportunity for building the Virgin brand
Can we add value
Will it interact with its other businesses
Is there an appropriate trade-off between risk and reward
Page 30 of 46
Virgin is also able to draw on talented people from throughout the group New
ventures are often steered by people seconded from other parts of Virgin who bring
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
with them the trademark management style skills and experience Virgin frequently
creates partnerships with others to combine skills knowledge and market presence
and so on Contrary to what some people may think their constantly expanding and
eclectic empire is neither random nor reckless Each successive venture demonstrates
its skill in picking the right market and the right opportunity
7 OVERVIEW OF VIRGIN SOFT DRINKS
The Virgin Drinks Group first launched as the Virgin Cola Company in 1994 with
Virgin Cola in the UK Since then the company has ventured across the carbonated
soft drinks arena and beyond into energy drinks tea and flavored Colas This
expansion has lead to the evolution of the Virgin Drinks Company a company
whose aim is to put the excitement back into the world of soft drinks It launched in
Bangladesh in 1999 Virgin Soft Drinks is monitored by Global Beverage Co Ltd in
Bangladesh
Brief history of Virgin Drinks is given below
Page 31 of 46
1994 November Virgin Cola launched in the UK
1996 March Virgin Cola launched in France
1998 June Virgin Cola launched in Belgium
April Virgin Cola launched in the French West Indies
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
August Virgin Cola launched in Switzerland
1999 March Virgin Colours launched in Italy
March Virgin Cola launched in Japan
July Virgin Colours launched in South Africa
December Virgin Colours launched in Bangladesh
2001 January Sweden launched Virgin Colours
November Singapore launched Virgin Colours
2002 February Croatia launched Virgin Colours
June Russia launched Virgin Colours
June Tunisia launched Virgin Colours
2003 May Israel launched Virgin Colours
8 FINDINGS OF WORKING CAPITAL MANAGEMENT MAINTAINED BY
VIRGIN SOFT DRINKS IN BANGLADESH
81 CASH MANAGEMENT
811 Holding Cash and Marketable Securities
Although there are many good reasons why firm hold cash and marketable
securities Virgin Drinks holds cash and marketable securities for two reasons ndash
i) Cash for transactions
ii) Cash as hedges
This indicates that the firm does not hold cash and marketable securities for some
important reasons such as ndash
i) Near cash assets as hedges
Page 32 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
ii) Temporary investment and compensating balances
Virgin Soft Drinks does not invest in money market securities such as Treasury bill
commercial paper certificate of deposits bankerrsquos acceptance and repurchase
agreement This firm deposits its money in bank as currant AC or fixed AC They
say that they do not have enough money to invest in money market instrument
They also say that if they have enough money they will invest it in money market
short term securities We know that near cash interest earning assets can be
substituted for cash when motivation for holding these assets is the hedging of cash
flow uncertainties or is the temporary investment of surplus funds In this point
Virgins position is not good as there is no significant hedging against uncertainty of
cash
812 Floatation and Check Clearing
Virgin is very smart in handling the problem of transit time for checks Here mail
float takes 2 to 3 days at firm takes 025 day and clearing float takes 1-3 days Virgin
uses most of the strategies available for reducing the delay in receiving funds It
(Virgin) has linked Islami Bank which posses an accelerated clearing facility It uses
electronic collection process which ensures faster collection and its at the firm check
processing is satisfactory But Virgin does not use lockbox The reason behind this is
that it is not cost-effective for Virgin to set lockboxes At this point we can say that
Virgins check clearing mechanism is much good
813 Cash Concentration and Disbursement Management
Page 33 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks takes the matter of cash concentration very seriously They use all
the available cash concentration mechanism Virgin is a firm with small deposits
spread over a substantial number of banks and this is why the firm tends to use
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
depository transfer checks extensively If is less costly Virgin also uses automated
clearing house and wire transfer To Virgin wire transfer seems too costly
Like other firm Virgin tries to retain the cash for as long as possible But Virgin
always performs it in an ethical manner Virgin does not try to defeat the receiving
firmrsquos attempts to reduce the float on incoming checks It does not take any strategy
for increasing mail float at firm float and clearing float on its outgoing checks To
Virgin it is deemed to be unethical It thinks that maximization of disbursement float
will not go unnoticed by sophisticated creditors for very long When it is noticed it
will negatively affect relations with these creditors reducing the firmrsquos bargaining
power with them This may ultimately cost Virgin dearly when future prices and
delivery schedules for goods and services purchased from trade creditors are
negotiated Virgin follows ldquoZero-Balance Accountsrdquo methods for managing
disbursement It thinks that in this method the coordination of funds inflows to
disbursement banks with the presentation of checks does not work to the detriment
of creditors since the firmrsquos checks to them are honored as presented and this strategy
does not affect float significantly Controlled disbursing method is less attractive to
Virgin because zero-balance system is already feasible
814 Cash Forecasting
Cash Forecasting and Its Types
Page 34 of 46
Virgin forecasts the future cash inflows and outflows To Virgin cash forecast is an
important part of the firmrsquos cash control system and is one of the forecasts that are
part of the Virginrsquos financial plan Virgin forecasts cash on monthly basis and on
yearly basis Virgin does not forecast on daily basis assuming that the temporary
shortage of funds within these periods can be covered without value cost eg
advance receipts from customers Virginrsquos cash forecasting system involves a
combination of distribution and scheduling The receipts and disbursements
approach of cash forecasting is used in virgin This method is used because it
minutely traces the movement of cash and very close control of cash is possible
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Virgin does not use adjusted net income approach on two grounds First it does not
permit the tracing of the individual types of cash inflows and outflows for any given
period which is often useful information for virgin Second it is not simple to use
Items to be Forecast
Virgin does not forecast all the items It forecasts only major items eg accounts
receivable notes receivable payroll cash purchases of raw materials In this regard
virgin trade off between cost and benefit
Methods of Financial Forecasting
Virgin forecasts the future level of financial variable such as cash level asset level or
liability level We know in short term forecasts many things will result from plans
and events that are already in place (contracts capital budgets long-range financing
plans and so forth) But in the long run most things can vary and are dependent on
outside influences such as the firmrsquos long-term growth rate Since Virginrsquos cash
forecasting deals mostly with near future many of the items on the cash forecasts are
estimated by some variation of the spot method and remaining estimates are mostly
on a ldquoproportion of another accountrdquo basis with this ldquoother accountrdquo often being a
particular periodrsquos sales Virgin uses the other two methods less frequently
Using Cash Forecast
Virgin forecasts cash for meeting general objectives (ie to know the available funds
for investment and need financing) and for meeting some special objectives (eg to
know whether the firm will fulfill its out of debt requirement) But it is matter to note
that Virgin does not make any short term investment of its surplus cash but only keep
this surplus in Bank Account
Page 35 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Sources of Uncertainty in Cash Forecasting and Hedging Uncertainties
Virgin faces uncertainty in cash forecasting mainly from two sources These are ndash
sales and production cost In peak season (hot season like autumn summer) sales
increases but in dull season (eg in winter) sales decreases drastically Production
cost may be increased because of increase of price of sugar chemicals aluminum
can Virgin follows two methods for hedging cash balance uncertainties These are ndash
i) Holding a stock of extra cash and
ii) Extra borrowing capacity
815 Modes for the Management of Cash and Temporary Investments
Virgin does not follow any of these methods wholly Virgin receives cash
continuously and pays salary at steady rate and pays continuously for other
expenses So it neither follows Baumol model nor Beranek model It has no upper
control limit lower control limit return point in case cash management So it neither
follows Miller-Orr model nor Stone model
In Summary
Page 36 of 46
Standard Compliance by Virgin Soft Drinks
Generally all firms hold cash and
marketable securities
Virgin holds only cash
Firms hold cash and marketable
securities for some reasons like
bull Cash for transactions
bull Cash and near-cash assets as
hedges
bull Temporary investments
bull Compensating balances
Virgin holds cash only for
two reasons ndash
bull Cash for transactions
bull Cash as hedges
Available money market instruments Virgin does not invest in any such
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
(short term securities) are ndash
Treasury Bills
Commercial Paper
Certificates of Deposit
Bankerrsquos Acceptance
Repurch menase Agree ts
instruments They only keep cash in
Bank Account
Mail Float
(1 to 5 days)
At Firm
Float
(025 to 1
day)
Clearing
Float
(0 to
2 days)
Mail Float
(2 to 3 days)
At firm
Float
(025
day)
Clearing
Float
(1 to 3
days)
Figure Transit time for a typical check Figure Transit time for a check for
Virgin
Strategies that firms can use to reduce
the delay in receiving funds are ndash
Selecting of Banks with
accelerated clearing capabilities
of check processing Acceleration
at the firm
ectronic collection Use of el
procedures
Use of lockboxes
Virgin follows the first three strategies
but does not use lockboxes
Available cash concentration
mechanisms are ndash
Depository transfer check
ouse Automated Clearing H
(ACH) electronic transfer)
Wire transfer
Virgin uses all these mechanisms of
cash concentration
Available sets of techniques for cash
disbursement management are ndash
ement of disbursement
Page 37 of 46
Manag
float
Virgin uses zero-balance accounts
technique
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Zero-Balance Accounts
Controlled disbursing
Firms may make cash flow forecasts
over periods of various lengths yearly
flows quarterly flows monthly flows
weekly flows or even daily flows
Virgin forecasts cash on yearly basis and
monthly basis
Cash forecasting system may involve ndash
Distribution
Scheduling
Virginrsquos cash forecasting system
involves a combination of distribution
and scheduling
Two common approaches to cash flow
in generating the cash forecast
and disbursement Receipts
approach
Adjusted net income approach
Virgin uses the receipts and
disbursement approach
There are many items to forecast Virgin forecasts only major items like
AR payroll etc
Four common approach to forecasting
fina i ndash nc al variables are
Spot method
Proportion to another account
Compounded growth
Multiple dependencies
Virgin uses spot method for forecasting
cash It uses proportion to another
account method for other variables and
remaining two methods are frequently
used
Sources of uncertainty in cash
forecasting are ndash
Sales uncertainty
Collection rate uncertainty
Production cost uncertainty
Capital outflow uncertainty
Virgin faces uncertainty mainly from
sales and production cost
Methods for hedging cash balance
unc a
Page 38 of 46
ert inties are ndash
i) Holding a stock of extra cash
Virgin two available methods for
hedging cash balance uncertainties
Th ese are ndash
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
ii) stock of near-cash Holding a
assets
iii) Extra borrowing capacity
iv) ary surpluses in Investing tempor
near-cash assets
i) Holding a stock of extra cash
ii) Extra borrowing capacity
(advance receipt from
customers)
Models for the management of cash and
temporary investments are ndash Baumol
model Beranek model Miller-Orr
model and Stone model
Virgin does not follow any method
wholly but a combination of Baumol
model and Beranek model is occurred
82 INVENTORY MANAGEMENT
21 Certainty Approach
isnt used in
irgin because it thinks it is not possible to implement in Bangladesh
d time is one to three days It
oes not use ABC system of inventory management
8
Main item of inventory of Virgin is Can pet chip sugar label chemical artificial
sweet etc Virgin maintains a minimum level of inventory but it does not have to face
problems because inventory is managed efficiently just-in-time (JIT)
V
Virgin maintains buffer stock because of the shortage of work-in-process (WIP)
inventory Its production process may also be hampered Thats why it maintains
safety stock to avoid stock out cost In case of imported goods normal lead time is
about one month and within the country normal lea
d
Page 39 of 46
Inventory Model
In reality Virgin does not use any of models of EOQ ordering and holding strategy
and safety stock strategy They maintain inventory based on their prior experience
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
822 Uncertainty Approach
Virgin does not use any model for handling inventory uncertainty It says that such
decision depends on business cycle and market situation Long before Eid festival
they bought large amount of sugar because of price increase on the occasion of Eid
In summary
Standard Compliance by Virgin Soft Drinks
Firms maintain inventory to guard
against several problems
Virgin maintains a minimum level of
inventory which is managed efficiently
Some firms use JIT to avoid inventory
cost
JIT is not used by Virgin as it thinks it is
impossible to implement in Bangladesh
Firms maintain buffer stock Virgin maintains buffer stock too
Firms maintain safety stock to avoid
shortage cost
Virgin also maintains safety stock
Firms use ABC system to monitor
inventory
Virgin doesnt use ABC system
EOQ model is an appropriate method
for measuring quantity that has to be
ordered per order
Virgin does not use EOQ model rather
makes order based on experience and
market demand
83 MANAGING ACCOUNTS RECEIVABLE (DEBTORS)
831 Terms of Sale Decision
Page 40 of 46
Virgin offers the term 210 net 30 enables the customers to deduct 2 percent from the
face value of the bill when paying within the first 10 days but if the discount is not
taken the customer must remit the full amount within 30 days But Virgin does not
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
offer the same terms of sale to all customers For prime customers it offers special
terms of sale In setting an appropriate term of sale it costs and benefits regarding
this are compared It uses the standard approach of terms of sale decision as it is
simple to use
832 Credit Granting Decisions
In case of Virgin the Capital and Character of Five Cs get more importance
Although there are many problems with the traditional approach Virgin uses it
because of its simplicity Virgin does not use Net Present Value (NPV) method in
credit granting decision It thinks that NPV is an appropriate method and should be
used next time It does not face any severe problem because of bad debts The reason
is that notes receivable is used when credit is granted
833 Monitoring Accounts Receivable
Virgin monitors its accounts receivable Virgin believes that in any case both positive
and negative durations in accounts signal differences from the results that
management believe to be the most advantageous for the firm
Tools for Monitoring Accounts Receivable
Page 41 of 46
For monitoring accounts receivable there are several tools such as aging schedule
the ratios of receivable outstanding to original sales customers payment proportion
and sales weighted DSO (Days Sales Outstanding) For monitoring accounts
receivable Virgin uses aging schedule fractions and traditional DSO statistics
because of their simplicity in use Although payment proportions ratios of
receivables outstanding and sales weighted DSO methods are free from inherent bias
None of these is used because all these are complex to maintain
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
In summary
Page 42 of 46
Standard Compliance by Virgin Soft Drinks
Generals terms of sale is 210 net 30 Normally Virgin also use general terms
of sale ie 210 net 30
Firms do not offer the same terms of
sale to all customers
Yes For prime customers Virgin offers
special terms of sale
Approaches of terms of sale decisions
are ndash
bull Standard approach
bull Multi period approach
Virgin uses standard approach of terms
of sale decision as it is simple to use and
understand
Source of credit information are ndash
Sellers prior experience with the
customer
Credit agency ratings and
reports
Personal contact with the
applicants bank and other
creditors
Analysis of applicants financial
statements
Customer visit
Main source of credit information to
Virgin is its prior experience with the
customer All other sources are not cost-
effective for Virgin
Approaches of credit granting to
marginal accounts are ndash
Traditional approach
Net Present Value (NPV)
approach
It uses traditional approach still now but
thinks that NPV should be used for the
next periods
Firms monitor accounts receivable
because deviations from the expected
levels of turnover and of bad debt can
Virgin also monitors its accounts
receivable
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
signal several different problems
Different tools for monitoring accounts
receivable are ndash
Aging schedule
Ratios of receivables
outstanding to original sales
Customers payment
proportions
Sales-weighted DSO
For monitoring accounts receivable
Virgin uses aging schedule and
traditional sales outstanding statistics
84 MANAGING ACCOUNTS PAYABLE (CREDITORS)
Virgin has almost accounts payable of Tk 8000000 But most of its liabilities are to
the banks rather than suppliers But we dont have any clear information about
Virgins accounts payable
9 RECOMMENDATION
Virgin should invest its surplus cash in short term marketable securities
because it is suitable hedging against cash uncertainties and will also give
some returns (interest income)
Virgin should publish its own annual report which will satisfy information
needs of stakeholders and also increase the credibility of information provided
by Virgin
Page 43 of 46
Virgin should use multi period approach in terms of sale decision because
standard approach which is already exists in Virgin has some inherent
problems
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
It should stop using traditional approach from now It should use NPV
method in credit granting to marginal accounts
In monitoring accounts receivable Virgin should use sales-weighted DSO
method because it has least limitation compared to the others
It should be more flexible in granting credit which will ultimately increase its
sales
To get the appropriate number of quantity to be ordered per order it should
use DSO model
It should be ABC system for proper monitoring of inventory
10 CONCLUSION
The use of other peoples money in business is usually an expensive resource Before
looking outside for finance a firm should examine its own working capital cycle to
make sure that every rand of its own internal funds is being fully utilized Good
management of working capital is part of good financial management Effective use
of working capital will contribute to the operational efficiency of the whole
organization optimum use will help to generate maximum returns Furthermore
working capital management is not an end in itself It is an integral part of the firms
overall management The needs of efficient working capital management must be
considered in relation to other aspects of the Virgins financial and non-financial
performance Thats why when planning the development of a business it is critical
that the impact of working capital be fully assessed
Page 44 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
BIBLIOGRAPHY
Scherr FC (1989) International Edition Prentice-Hall International Inc Modern
Working Capital Management Text and Cases
Hussain Riaz (2002) Working Capital Management
Robertson Lonnie (July 1998) Inventory Management
httpwwwasashoporg visited on March 13 2006
The Art of Cash Management
httpwwwinccom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management
httpwwwstudyfinancecom visited on March 13 2006
White Paper ndash Managing Working Capital
httpwwwplanwareorg visited on March 13 2006
Management of Working Capital
httpwwwbusinesscentralcoza visited on March 13 2006
Cash Management
httpwwwsbagov visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management Objectives
httpwpsprenhallcom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management
Page 45 of 46
httpwwwadvancemecom visited on March 13 2006
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Business Receivables Financing
httpwwwbbtcom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Finance
http wwwfnbcoza visited on March 13 2006
Tips to manage your working capital
httpsmallbusinessninemsncomau visited on March 13 2006
Inventory Financing
httpwwwfranklincapitalnetworkcom visited on March 13 2006
Accounts Receivable Management
httpwwwfranklincapitalnetworkcom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management
httpwwwtreasurygovtnz visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management
httpwwwtreasurystrategiescom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Works
httpwwwinvestopediacom visited on March 13 2006
Treasury Services
httpwwwjpmorganchasecom visited on March 13 2006
what were about
Page 46 of 46
httpwwwvirgincom visited on March 13 2006
Annexure
Annexure
Interview with YASEER RIZVI
Mr Yaseer Rizvi the DMD of Global Beverage Co Ltd obtained his MBA degree
from a reputed university He had been the Director of Ocean Container Ltd before
joining in Global Beverage Co Ltd He possesses a nice personality
I interviewed Yaseer Rizvi Excerpts from his interview are as follows ndash
Shah Kamal Sir would you please tell me do you invest in short term marketable securities
Yaseer Rizvi Basically we do not invest our surplus cash in short term marketable
securities like T-Bill commercial paper certificate of deposit etc But we keep our
surplus cash in Bank
Shah Kamal Would you tell me something about transit time for a typical check
Yaseer Rizvi Well in Virgin the transit time for a typical check is ndash
For mail float 2 to 3 days
At firm float 6 hours
Clearing float 1 to 3 days
Shah Kamal Do you maintain any cash concentration mechanism like depository transfer check automated clearing house and wire transfer
i
Annexure
Yaseer Rizvi Our position in this case is very strong as we use all the mechanisms
you mentioned As Virgin is a firm with small deposits spread over a substantial
number of banks so we tend to use depository transfer checks extensively It is less
costly We also use automated clearing house and wire transfer but later is used in a
less extent
Shah Kamal Sir what techniques of disbursement management is used by your firm
Yaseer Rizvi Like other firms Virgin tries to retain the cash for as long as possible
But we always perform it in an ethical manner We do not use management of
disbursement float as it seems unethical We follow Zero-Balance Accounts method
for managing disbursement We do not prefer Controlled Disbursing method since
Zero-Balance system is already practiced in Virgin
Shah Kamal How do you hedge cash balance uncertainties
Yaseer Rizvi Well you may say that we do not invest in short term securities but for
facing cash difficulties we keep our surplus cash in bank
Shah Kamal Sir would you please tell me the general terms of sale of Virgin
Yaseer Rizvi Though it is difficult to maintain a fixed terms of sale our general terms
of sale is 210 n30 But for prime customers we offer special terms of sale
Shah Kamal What are the sources of credit information in case of your firm
Yaseer Rizvi We grant credit on the basis of prior experience with the customers In
case of a new customer personal contact is weighted
Shah Kamal Does your firm consider 5 Cs in granting credit
ii
Annexure
Yaseer Rizvi In case of Virgin Capital and Character get more importance than the
others Mind one thing personal relationship is the main measure in granting credit
Shah Kamal Do you use NPV method in credit granting decisions
Yaseer Rizvi We do not use NPV method But we think that NPV is a suitable
method and we have to use it from the next period
Shah Kamal Sir how do you handle the problem of bad debt
Yaseer Rizvi Well in this case our position is very strong Yet we do not face any
problem because of bad debt Just note that we make more than 80 of sales in cash
and we monitor accounts receivable very carefully
Shah Kamal What level of inventory is maintained by Virgin
Yaseer Rizvi We maintain a minimum level of inventory but do not have to face
stock out problems because inventory is managed efficiently
Shah Kamal What is the normal lead time
Yaseer Rizvi In case of imported goods normal lead time is about 1 month and when
we purchase raw materials from inside the country lead time is 1 to 3 days
Shah Kamal What method do you use for managing inventory
Yaseer Rizvi We do not use any method particularly rather inventory decision
depends on business cycle and market situation Long before the Eid festival we
bought large amount of sugar because price of sugar was increased on the occasion
of Eid
iii
Annexure
Shah Kamal What are the main items of inventory of your firm
Yaseer Rizvi Well these are ndash aluminum can pet chip sugar label chemical and
artificial sweet
Shah Kamal What are the uncertainties in maintaining appropriate level of stock
Yaseer Rizvi These are ndash
bull Increase in price of raw materials
bull Sales uncertainty
bull Market trends etc
Shah Kamal Thank you for your kind cooperation
Yaseer Rizvi Most Welcome
iv
Global Beverage Company Limited
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
5313 Tools for Cash Management
Flotation and Check Clearing
Management of cash when it is not in the firmrsquos hands that is in transit to and from
the firm is on important function in the area of finance Transit times for the check
takes in three stages These are mail float at firm float and clearing float Normally
mail float takes 1 to 5 days at firm float takes 025 to 1 day and clearing float takes 0
to 2 days The firm should care about this process because every delay in the receipt
of money by the firm lowers the firmrsquos returns and therefore its shareholdersrsquo wealth
There are several strategies that firm can use to reduce the delay in receiving funds
Each of these strategies addresses one or more of the three float times (mail float
time at time float time and clearing float time) that make up the total transit time of
fund from one firm to another
Other Cash Management Tools
When the economy is strong companies can lapse into sloppy cash-management
practices Firm should try exploring these options
1 Sweep accounts
These bank accounts are the easiest way to generate some income from companys
spare funds however they make sense only if the money youll earn will be greater
than the fees your bank will charge Business owners have two types of sweep
accounts to choose between
Page 10 of 46
Controlled-investment accounts These are the most profitable form of
sweep account but they wont work for company if the firm has any
electronic payments or wire transfers since those may be submitted for
payment later in the day and the account wont have enough cash in it to
cover them
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Page 11 of 46
End-of-day sweep accounts A safer bet for most small-business owners
these accounts wait until a late-hour cutoff to determine how much to
sweep into the firms overnight investments Typically their investment
yields are 10 to 20 basis points (1 to 2 of the investment) lower than
those offered with controlled investments
2 Lock-box accounts
A lock box is a cash-management system that helps the firm collect funds quickly
Generally set up with the assistance of a big money center or regional bank lock
boxes provide the firm with a special zip code and usually quicker deliveries from
regional post offices They are especially important if the firm has clusters of
customers in out-of-state locations and dont want to lose days waiting for their
checks to arrive by long-distance mail
5314 Cash Concentration and Cash Disbursement
Once the remittances from the firmrsquos customers have been received and cleared the
resulting cash balances is available in the firmrsquos lockbox (depository) banks It is
useful for the firm to gather these balances from the lockbox banks into the central
bank account The process of collecting funds is called cash concentration
Several concentration mechanism are available for the firm to use in transferring
funds from its collection banks to regional concentration banks and from there to the
central concentration bank These mechanisms differ in cost and in the availability of
funds that they provide These are ndash
a) Depository Transfer Check
It is the cheapest transfer mechanism This document instructs one bank to
send funds to another and is treated the same as any other check
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
b) Automated Clearing House (ACH) Electronic Transfer
This vehicle is essentially an electronic version of the depository transfer
check and can be used between banks that participate in the automated
clearing house system
c) Wire Transfer
These are electronic message between banks
Decisions regarding concentration mechanism usually hinge on the size and
spread of the firmrsquos deposits Firms with small deposits spread over a
substantial number of banks will tend to have more extensive concentration
systems and will transfer among accounts using low-cost transfer vehicles that
offer only delayed availability (such as depository transfer checks) Firms with
larger deposits will have fewer accounts (since a local deposit for transfer to
an upstream bank is not needed) and will use more expensive and more rapid
transfer mechanisms (such as wire transfers) The concentration systems of
major chemical companies for example tend to be structured in this way ndash
DepositoryLockbox Banks
Regional Concentration Banks
Central Concentrated Bank
Figure A typical Cash Concentration System
(Arrows indicate transfers of collected funds)
Page 12 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Disbursement management addresses the efficient payout out of this cash once it is
concentrated The firmrsquos objective in disbursement management is to retain the cash
for as long as possible In this way the firm will have the maximum amount of funds
available for investment and transactional purposes Certainly this management
means making disbursement only when they are due and not before The firm has
several available set of techniques for disbursement management Included among
these are ndash
a) Management of Disbursement Float
In this set of techniques the disbursing firm attempts to increase the length of
time between the mailing of its checks and the eventual withdrawal of funds
from the banks This involves strategies for increasing mail float at firm float
and clearing float on its outgoing checks For example the disbursing firm
may intentionally address checks to the firmrsquos office address rather than its
lockbox creating at firm float
b) Zero-Balance Accounts
Here the firm holds the cash until the check arrive (or expected to arrive) at
the disbursement bank In this strategy an account for disbursement is first
established at a bank For the zero-balance system to be effective the
participating bank must be one on which most disbursement are made via the
Bangladesh Bankrsquos clearance system (which presents disbursements to banks
early in the morning) and not a bank where disbursements occur throughout
the day (as with a major money-center bank) Consequently the banks used
in zero-balance strategies are usually branches of major banks and not their
main locations
Page 13 of 46
c) Controlled Disbursing
In this system the firm projects the amount of checks to arrive each day at the
disbursement bank (based on the checks written in previous days and historic
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
statistics on disbursement float) and transfers the amount of the expected
checks to the account on that day or just before
5315 Cash Forecasting
Defining Cash Forecasting
The cash forecast is an estimation of the flows in and out of the firmrsquos cash account
over a particular period of time usually a quarter month week or day The cash
forecast is primarily intended to produce a very useful piece of information an
estimation of the firmrsquos borrowing and lending needs and uncertainties regarding
these needs during various future periods Cash forecasting is very crucial to most
firms It enables them to anticipate periods of surplus cash and periods where
financing will be necessary This anticipation is the reason that cash forecasts are
generated Anticipation enables the firm to plan much more effectively for
investment and financing and via this planning produce superior return
Types of Cash Forecasts
The types of cash forecasts generated by firms can be differentiated along two
dimensions the length of the periods included within the cash forecast and the approach
to cash flows used in the cash forecast The length of the period refers to the units of
time into which the cash forecast is divided Firms may make cash flow forecasts
over periods of various lengths yearly flows quarterly flows monthly flows weekly
flows or even daily flows The most popular forecast involves monthly flows but
most firms do not confine themselves to a single forecast Instead they use several
forecasts with periods of various lengths When the firm makes forecasts involving
multiple and overlapping period lengths one forecast relates to another Starting
with data on relatively long periods and breaking it down into smaller periods is
called distribution starting with data on relatively short periods and aggregating into
longer periods is called scheduling
Page 14 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Firms use two common approaches to cash flows in generating the cash forecast the
receipts and disbursements approach and the adjusted net income approach The receipts
and disbursements approach use the amounts of cash expected to be received and
disbursed by the firm over the periods chosen for forecast The adjusted income
statement approach is sometimes called the sources and use approach Here the
forecaster starts with projected net income on an accrual basis and adjusts to a cash
basis This method provides a representation of changes in asset and liability
accounts since the level of these accounts are of interest to the firm this aspect of the
adjusted income statement is an advantage over the receipts and disbursements
method
Items to Be Forecast
In the receipt and disbursements cash forecasting method estimates need to be made
of the numerous major and minor items that the firm collects (receipts) and that it
pays (disbursements) The more individual categories of items the firm includes in its
forecast procedure the more accurate the forecast may be but the more costly in
terms of time and effort it will be to generate
Some Possible Types of Cash Receipts and Cash Disbursements
Cash Disbursements Cash Receipts
Cash Purchases of Materials Payroll
Taxes
Maturing Accounts Payable
Maturing Notes Payable
Miscellaneous Disbursements
Accounts Receivable
Notes Receivable
Rental Income
Interest Income
Miscellaneous Receipts
Methods of Financial Forecasting
Page 15 of 46
Financial forecasting is the estimation of the future level of a financial variable often
a cash flow asset level or liability level It is usually assumed that the relationship
between the financial variable and other variable is linear The general linear model
can then be used
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
nnt xaxaxaaY 22110 ++=
Here
= Financial variable (Y) to be forecast in period t tY
x = Explanatory variable it is assumed to cause the level of Y in period t
0a = Represents a constant unaffected by the x
The other terms are the estimated coefficients of the explanatory x variables
There are n terms with xrsquos in them
There are four common approaches to forecasting financial variables but they
are all special cases of the general linear model These are ndash spot method proportion
to another account compounded growth and multiple dependencies
Using Cash Forecast
The estimate of available funds for investment and needed financing enables the firm
to plan so as to obtain the most advantages borrowing terms for deficits and achieve
the greatest interest income on surplus A useful chart for this planning purpose is a
bar chart eg
Figure Bar Chart of Cash Surpluses and Deficits from hypothetical data
Page 16 of 46
75
50
-60
30
100
-20
-80-60-40-20
020406080
100120
Defic
it
S
urpl
us
January February March April May June
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Sources of Uncertainty in Cash Forecasting and Hedging Uncertainties
There are numerous sources of risk in cash forecasting Among the sources are sales
uncertainty collection rate uncertainty production cost uncertainty and capital
outflow uncertainty
5316 Models for the Management of Cash and Temporary Investments
There are different models for the management of cash and temporary investments
Among these the most popular methods are ndash Baumol model Beranek model
Miller-Orr model and Stone model
Baumol and Beranek use the same model The formula is cited below ndash
Interest Income = iYn
n⎥⎦⎤
⎢⎣⎡ minus
21
Profit = naiYn
nminus⎥⎦
⎤⎢⎣⎡ minus
21
Optimum number of transactions = ⎟⎠⎞
⎜⎝⎛
aiY2
Where n = Optimum number of transactions
i = Interest rate per period
a = Transaction cost
Y = Total inflow for the period
Page 17 of 46
Miller-Orr and Stone use the same model ie R-Statistic The model is ndash
31
43
iav
R ⎟⎠⎞
⎜⎝⎛=
Optimum Control Limit = R + L
Upper Control Limit = 3R + L
Where a = Transaction Cost
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
v = Variance of daily cash flows
i = Daily interest rate
5317 Administration
Cash receipts should be processed and banked as quickly as possible because
They cannot earn interest or reduce overdraft until they are banked
information about the existence and amounts of cash receipts is usually not
available until they are processed
Where possible cash floats (mainly petty cash and advances) should be avoided If
on review the only reason that can be put forward for their existence is that weve
always had them they should be discontinued There may be situations where they
are useful however For example it may be desirable for peripheral parts of
departments to meet urgent local needs from cash floats rather than local bank
accounts
5318 Internal Control
Cash and cash management is part of a firms overall internal control system The
main internal cash control is invariably the bank reconciliation This provides
assurance that the cash balances recorded in the accounting systems are consistent
with the actual bank balances It requires regular clearing of reconciling items
5319 Practicing Good Cash Flow Management
Good cash management is simple It involves
Knowing when where and how firms cash needs will occur
Page 18 of 46
Knowing the best sources for meeting additional cash needs
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Page 19 of 46
Being prepared to meet these needs when they occur by keeping good
relationships with bankers and other creditors
532 INVENTORY MANAGEMENT
Inventory management is necessary for owners who want to maintain a stocking
service for quick turnaround to help ensure total customer satisfaction The fill rate
of an item on a managed inventory list must be maintained to avoid shortages of
frequently used items Even when utilizing an inventory management system
occasional shortages will still occur Inventories are lists of stocks-raw materials
work in progress or finished goods-waiting to be consumed in production or to be
sold The total balance of inventory is the sum of the value of each individual stock
line
Basically firms hold stocks for the following reasons
To act as a buffer in times of unusually high demand
To ensure continuity of production
Avoid high costs of emergency orders
To take advantage of quantity discounts by ordering more at a time
To reduce ordering costs by ordering more items on fewer
As part of the production process eg maturing whisky or keeping oil in
pipelines
Seasonality of demand (eg firework) or supplies
Suppliers insist on minimum order quantities
The key issue for a business is to identify the fast and slow stock movers with the
objectives of establishing optimum stock levels for each category and thereby
minimize the cash tied up in stocks Factors to be considered when determining
optimum stock levels include
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Page 20 of 46
What are the projected sales of each product
How widely available are raw materials components etc
How long does it take for delivery by suppliers
Can the firm remove slow movers from its product range without
compromising best sellers
Inventory management is an important aspect of working capital management
because inventories themselves do not earn any revenue Holding either too little or
too much inventory incurs costs
Costs of carrying too much inventory are
Opportunity cost of foregone interest
Warehousing costs
Damage and pilferage
Obsolescence
Insurance
Costs of carrying too little inventory are
Stock out costs
Lost sales
Delayed service
Ordering costs
Freight
on Order administrati
nts
Loss of quantity discou
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Carrying costs can be minimized by making frequent small orders but this increase
ordering costs and the risk of stock outs Risk of stock-outs can be reduced by
carrying safety stocks (at a cost) and re-ordering ahead of time
The best ordering strategy requires balancing the various cost factors to ensure the
firm incurs minimum inventory costs The optimum inventory position is known as
the Economic Reorder Quantity (ERQ)
Nowadays many large manufacturers operate on a just-in-time (JIT) basis whereby
all the components to be assembled on a particular today arrive at the factory early
that morning no earlier - no later This helps to minimize manufacturing costs as JIT
stocks take up little space minimize stock-holding and virtually eliminate the risks of
obsolete or damaged stock Because JIT manufacturers hold stock for a very short
time they are able to conserve substantial cash JIT is a good model to strive for as it
embraces all the principles of prudent stock management For better stock control
firm may try the following
Review the effectiveness of existing purchasing and inventory systems
Know the stock turn for all major items of inventory
Apply tight controls to the significant few items and simplify controls for the
trivial many
Sell off outdated or slow moving merchandise - it gets more difficult to sell the
longer the firm keeps it
Consider having part of its product outsourced to another manufacturer rather
than make it itself
Review its security procedures to ensure that no stock is going out the back
door
Higher than necessary stock levels tie up cash and cost more in insurance
accommodation costs and interest charges
Page 21 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
However it is important to keep an overall perspective It is not cost-effective to
closely manage a large number of low value inventory lines nor is it necessary A
usual feature of inventories is that a small number of high value lines account for a
large proportion of inventory value The 8020 rule (PARETO) predicts that 80
of the total value of inventory is represented by only 20 of the number of inventory
items Those high value lines need reasonably close management The remaining
80 of inventory lines can be managed using broad-brush strategies
533 MANAGING ACCOUNTS RECEIVABLE (DEBTORS)
Cash flow can be significantly enhanced if the amounts owing to a business are
collected faster Every business needs to know who owes them money how much is
owed how long it is owing for what it is owed
Debtors (Accounts Receivable) are customers who have not yet made payment for
goods or services which the department has provided The objective of debtor
management is to minimize the time-lapse between completion of sales and receipt
of payment The costs of having debtors are
Opportunity costs (cash is not available for other purposes)
Bad debts
If firm doesnt manage debtors they will begin to manage business as the firm will gradually
lose control due to reduced cash flow and of course it could experience an increased
incidence of bad debt The following measures will help manage debtors
Having the right mental attitude to the control of credit and make sure that it
gets the priority it deserves
Establishing clear credit practices as a matter of company policy
Page 22 of 46
Making sure that these practices are clearly understood by staff suppliers and
customers
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Page 23 of 46
Being professional when accepting new accounts and especially larger ones
Checking out each customer thoroughly before the firm offers credit Use
credit agencies bank references industry sources etc
Establishing credit limits for each customer and sticking to them
Continuously reviewing these limits when it suspects tough times are coming
or if operating in a volatile sector
Keeping very close to the firms larger customers
Invoicing promptly and clearly
Considering charging penalties on overdue accounts
Considering accepting credit debit cards as a payment option
Monitoring its debtor balances and ageing schedules and dont let any debts
get too large or too old
Debtor management includes both pre-sale and debt collection strategies
Pre-sale strategies include
Offering cash discounts for early payment andor imposing penalties for late
payment
Agreeing payment terms in advance
Requiring cash before delivery
Setting credit limits
ning credit Setting criteria for obtai
Billing as early as possible
rogress payments
ost-sale strategies include
for collecting the debt upon the center that made the sale
Requiring deposits andor p
P
Placing the responsibility
Identifying long overdue balances and doubtful debts by regular analytical reviews
Having an established procedure for late collections such as
A reminder
A letter
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Page 24 of 46
ion of further credit Cancellat
Telephone calls
n agency Use of a collectio
he firm should recognize that the longer someone owes firm the greater the chance
Legal action
T
it will never get paid If the average age of debtors is getting longer or is already very
long it may need to look for the following possible defects
Weak credit judgment
res Poor collection procedu
ms Lax enforcement of credit ter
Slow issue of invoices or statements
Errors in invoices or statements
Customer dissatisfaction
Debtors due over 90 days (unless within agreed credit terms) should generally
demand immediate attention For example warning signs of a future bad debt ndash
Longer credit terms taken with approval particularly for smaller orders
Use of post-dated checks by debtors who normally settle within agreed terms
Evidence of customers switching to additional suppliers for the same goods
New customers who are reluctant to give credit references
Cre G
Receiving part payments from debtors
dit ranting to Marginal Accounts
Traditional Approach
In the traditional approach to the credit granting decision it is the credit analysts job
rmation that has been collected and reach a judgment
regarding the applicants creditworthiness One traditional way of organizing this
to synthesize all the info
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
information is by characterizing the applicant along five dimensions These
dimensions are called the Five Cs of credit ndash
Capital
Character
Collateral
and Capacity
Conditions
Net Present Value (NPV) Approach
Once a firm has assessed the creditworthiness of a customer it has to decide whether
r not credit should be granted The firm should use the NPV rule to make the
ld be granted
Figure
o
decision If NPV is positive credit shou
Credit Granting Decision
Credit Granting Decision
he act of collecting money is one which most people dislike for many reasons and
therefore put on the long f selves there is something
ore urgent or important that demands their attention now There is nothing more
T
inger because they convince them
m
important than getting paid for firms product or service A customer who does not
Page 25 of 46
Grand Credit
Payment received Payment not received
Benefit of present value of future net cash flow
Cost of present value ment of lost invest
Net Payoff PV of benefit-cost
No Credit
No Payoff
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
pay is not a customer Here are a few ideas that may help the firm in collecting
money from debtors
Firm should develop appropriate procedures for handling late payments
It should track and pursue late payers
It might get external help if its own efforts fail
or money its firms and it is entitled Company shouldnt feel guilty asking f
to it
ction
Firm must make that call now And it should keep asking until it gets some
satisfa
lessens the problem
In difficult circumstances take what the firm can now and agree terms for the
remainder It
paying
When asking for money be hard on the issue - but soft on the person It shouldnt
give the debtor any excuses for not
534 BLE (CREDITORS)
ices for goods or services have
een paid Organizations often regard the
not
to delay all payments until the latest possible date Regular weekly or
The firm make it its objective is to get the money - not to score points or get
even
MANAGING ACCOUNTS PAYA
Creditors (Accounts Payable) are suppliers whose invo
been processed but who have not yet b
amount owing to creditors as a source of free credit However creditor
administration systems are expensive and time-consuming to run The over-riding
concern in this area should be to minimize costs with simple procedures
While it is unnecessary to pay accounts before they fall due it is usually
worthwhile
Page 26 of 46
fortnightly payment of all due accounts is the simplest technique for creditor
management
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Electronic payments (direct credits) are cheaper than check payments considering
that transaction fees and overheads more than balance the advantage of delayed
presentation Some suppliers are reluctant to receive payments by this method but in
view of the substantial cost advantage (and the advantages to the suppliers
themselves) departments may wish to encourage suppliers to accept this option
However electronic payments are likely to be used in conjunction with rather than
as a replacement for check payments
Applying Best Practices in Managing Accounts Payable
f course simply deferring payments to suppliers could have adverse consequences
O
that more than offset the benefits of this additional cash flow Therefore it is
important to develop a holistic approach The firm should consider the following
best practices for payables management
Managing payment dates and terms to maximize cash flow ndash
y reporting on
receivable and
id penalty charges and taking advantage of
wer vendors and negotiate for more
to buying consortia with others even
voices for
payment based on receipt of goods or receipt of invoice whichever
comes later
Calculating and setting performance targets Regularl
AP performance measures such as days in payables
Coordinating the AP processes with accounts
inventory management to ensure that the company is collecting more
cash than it is paying out
Paying bills on time to avo
prompt-payment discounts where the discounts exceed the companyrsquos
cost of working capital
Consolidating purchases with fe
favorable payment terms
Considering entering in
Page 27 of 46
competitors to obtain favorable supplier pricing and terms
Unless contract terms specify otherwise setting up in
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Page 28 of 46
Em
process
-time payments with Electronic Funds Transfer (EFT)
uraging vendors to utilize electronic invoice presentment
a
ndancies and more
ploying technology to automate the accounts payable transaction
es ndash
Making just-in
Using an electronic invoice-matching application
Enco
For companies with multiple locations or business units employing
shared service approach for AP to eliminate redu
quickly implement process improvements
Mainta
vendor
Communicating accounts payable requirements to suppliers at the
m key suppliers
for suggestions on how to improve the
Efficient a
and making th rsquos cash is just good business
ining open communications and building strong relationships with
s to access valuable trade credit ndash
beginning of transactions
Requesting summary invoicing fro
Requiring suppliers to send invoices directly to accounts payable
Asking tier-one suppliers
payment process
nd effective management of accounts payable helps improve cash flow ndash
e most of company
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
6 OVERVIEW OF VIRGIN GROUP
Virgin - one of the most respected brands in Britain - is now becoming the first global
brand name of the 21st century Virgin is involved in planes trains finance soft
drinks music mobile phones holidays cars wines publishing bridal wear - the lot
What tie all these businesses together are the values of its brand and the attitude of its
people Virgin has created over 200 companies worldwide employing over 25000
people Its total revenues around the world in 2002 exceeded pound4 billion (US $72
billion)
In 1970 Richard Branson founded Virgin as a mail order record retailer and not
long after he opened a record shop in Oxford Street London During 1972 a
recording studio was built in Oxfordshire and the first Virgin artist Mike Oldfield
recorded Tubular Bells which was released in 1973
This album went on to sell over 5 million copies Since then many household names
including Belinda Carlisle Genesis Phil Collins Janet Jackson and The Rolling
Stones have helped to make Virgin Music one of the top six record companies in the
world The equity of Virgin Music Group - record labels music publishing and
recording studios was sold to THORN EMI in 1992 in a US$1billion deal
Page 29 of 46
The Virgin Group has now expanded into international music Mega stores air
travel mobile financial retail music internet drinks rail hotels and leisure with
around 200 companies in over 30 countries
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
In Virgins customers eyes Virgin stands for value for money quality innovation
fun and a sense of competitive challenge It delivers a quality service by empowering
its employees and facilitates and monitors customer feedback to continually improve
the customers experience through innovation
When they start a new venture Virgin bases it on hard research and analysis
Typically they review the industry and put themselves in the customers shoes to see
what could make it better Virgin asks fundamental questions
Is this an opportunity for restructuring a market and creating competitive
advantage What are the competitors doing
Is the customer confused or badly served
Is this an opportunity for building the Virgin brand
Can we add value
Will it interact with its other businesses
Is there an appropriate trade-off between risk and reward
Page 30 of 46
Virgin is also able to draw on talented people from throughout the group New
ventures are often steered by people seconded from other parts of Virgin who bring
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
with them the trademark management style skills and experience Virgin frequently
creates partnerships with others to combine skills knowledge and market presence
and so on Contrary to what some people may think their constantly expanding and
eclectic empire is neither random nor reckless Each successive venture demonstrates
its skill in picking the right market and the right opportunity
7 OVERVIEW OF VIRGIN SOFT DRINKS
The Virgin Drinks Group first launched as the Virgin Cola Company in 1994 with
Virgin Cola in the UK Since then the company has ventured across the carbonated
soft drinks arena and beyond into energy drinks tea and flavored Colas This
expansion has lead to the evolution of the Virgin Drinks Company a company
whose aim is to put the excitement back into the world of soft drinks It launched in
Bangladesh in 1999 Virgin Soft Drinks is monitored by Global Beverage Co Ltd in
Bangladesh
Brief history of Virgin Drinks is given below
Page 31 of 46
1994 November Virgin Cola launched in the UK
1996 March Virgin Cola launched in France
1998 June Virgin Cola launched in Belgium
April Virgin Cola launched in the French West Indies
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
August Virgin Cola launched in Switzerland
1999 March Virgin Colours launched in Italy
March Virgin Cola launched in Japan
July Virgin Colours launched in South Africa
December Virgin Colours launched in Bangladesh
2001 January Sweden launched Virgin Colours
November Singapore launched Virgin Colours
2002 February Croatia launched Virgin Colours
June Russia launched Virgin Colours
June Tunisia launched Virgin Colours
2003 May Israel launched Virgin Colours
8 FINDINGS OF WORKING CAPITAL MANAGEMENT MAINTAINED BY
VIRGIN SOFT DRINKS IN BANGLADESH
81 CASH MANAGEMENT
811 Holding Cash and Marketable Securities
Although there are many good reasons why firm hold cash and marketable
securities Virgin Drinks holds cash and marketable securities for two reasons ndash
i) Cash for transactions
ii) Cash as hedges
This indicates that the firm does not hold cash and marketable securities for some
important reasons such as ndash
i) Near cash assets as hedges
Page 32 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
ii) Temporary investment and compensating balances
Virgin Soft Drinks does not invest in money market securities such as Treasury bill
commercial paper certificate of deposits bankerrsquos acceptance and repurchase
agreement This firm deposits its money in bank as currant AC or fixed AC They
say that they do not have enough money to invest in money market instrument
They also say that if they have enough money they will invest it in money market
short term securities We know that near cash interest earning assets can be
substituted for cash when motivation for holding these assets is the hedging of cash
flow uncertainties or is the temporary investment of surplus funds In this point
Virgins position is not good as there is no significant hedging against uncertainty of
cash
812 Floatation and Check Clearing
Virgin is very smart in handling the problem of transit time for checks Here mail
float takes 2 to 3 days at firm takes 025 day and clearing float takes 1-3 days Virgin
uses most of the strategies available for reducing the delay in receiving funds It
(Virgin) has linked Islami Bank which posses an accelerated clearing facility It uses
electronic collection process which ensures faster collection and its at the firm check
processing is satisfactory But Virgin does not use lockbox The reason behind this is
that it is not cost-effective for Virgin to set lockboxes At this point we can say that
Virgins check clearing mechanism is much good
813 Cash Concentration and Disbursement Management
Page 33 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks takes the matter of cash concentration very seriously They use all
the available cash concentration mechanism Virgin is a firm with small deposits
spread over a substantial number of banks and this is why the firm tends to use
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
depository transfer checks extensively If is less costly Virgin also uses automated
clearing house and wire transfer To Virgin wire transfer seems too costly
Like other firm Virgin tries to retain the cash for as long as possible But Virgin
always performs it in an ethical manner Virgin does not try to defeat the receiving
firmrsquos attempts to reduce the float on incoming checks It does not take any strategy
for increasing mail float at firm float and clearing float on its outgoing checks To
Virgin it is deemed to be unethical It thinks that maximization of disbursement float
will not go unnoticed by sophisticated creditors for very long When it is noticed it
will negatively affect relations with these creditors reducing the firmrsquos bargaining
power with them This may ultimately cost Virgin dearly when future prices and
delivery schedules for goods and services purchased from trade creditors are
negotiated Virgin follows ldquoZero-Balance Accountsrdquo methods for managing
disbursement It thinks that in this method the coordination of funds inflows to
disbursement banks with the presentation of checks does not work to the detriment
of creditors since the firmrsquos checks to them are honored as presented and this strategy
does not affect float significantly Controlled disbursing method is less attractive to
Virgin because zero-balance system is already feasible
814 Cash Forecasting
Cash Forecasting and Its Types
Page 34 of 46
Virgin forecasts the future cash inflows and outflows To Virgin cash forecast is an
important part of the firmrsquos cash control system and is one of the forecasts that are
part of the Virginrsquos financial plan Virgin forecasts cash on monthly basis and on
yearly basis Virgin does not forecast on daily basis assuming that the temporary
shortage of funds within these periods can be covered without value cost eg
advance receipts from customers Virginrsquos cash forecasting system involves a
combination of distribution and scheduling The receipts and disbursements
approach of cash forecasting is used in virgin This method is used because it
minutely traces the movement of cash and very close control of cash is possible
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Virgin does not use adjusted net income approach on two grounds First it does not
permit the tracing of the individual types of cash inflows and outflows for any given
period which is often useful information for virgin Second it is not simple to use
Items to be Forecast
Virgin does not forecast all the items It forecasts only major items eg accounts
receivable notes receivable payroll cash purchases of raw materials In this regard
virgin trade off between cost and benefit
Methods of Financial Forecasting
Virgin forecasts the future level of financial variable such as cash level asset level or
liability level We know in short term forecasts many things will result from plans
and events that are already in place (contracts capital budgets long-range financing
plans and so forth) But in the long run most things can vary and are dependent on
outside influences such as the firmrsquos long-term growth rate Since Virginrsquos cash
forecasting deals mostly with near future many of the items on the cash forecasts are
estimated by some variation of the spot method and remaining estimates are mostly
on a ldquoproportion of another accountrdquo basis with this ldquoother accountrdquo often being a
particular periodrsquos sales Virgin uses the other two methods less frequently
Using Cash Forecast
Virgin forecasts cash for meeting general objectives (ie to know the available funds
for investment and need financing) and for meeting some special objectives (eg to
know whether the firm will fulfill its out of debt requirement) But it is matter to note
that Virgin does not make any short term investment of its surplus cash but only keep
this surplus in Bank Account
Page 35 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Sources of Uncertainty in Cash Forecasting and Hedging Uncertainties
Virgin faces uncertainty in cash forecasting mainly from two sources These are ndash
sales and production cost In peak season (hot season like autumn summer) sales
increases but in dull season (eg in winter) sales decreases drastically Production
cost may be increased because of increase of price of sugar chemicals aluminum
can Virgin follows two methods for hedging cash balance uncertainties These are ndash
i) Holding a stock of extra cash and
ii) Extra borrowing capacity
815 Modes for the Management of Cash and Temporary Investments
Virgin does not follow any of these methods wholly Virgin receives cash
continuously and pays salary at steady rate and pays continuously for other
expenses So it neither follows Baumol model nor Beranek model It has no upper
control limit lower control limit return point in case cash management So it neither
follows Miller-Orr model nor Stone model
In Summary
Page 36 of 46
Standard Compliance by Virgin Soft Drinks
Generally all firms hold cash and
marketable securities
Virgin holds only cash
Firms hold cash and marketable
securities for some reasons like
bull Cash for transactions
bull Cash and near-cash assets as
hedges
bull Temporary investments
bull Compensating balances
Virgin holds cash only for
two reasons ndash
bull Cash for transactions
bull Cash as hedges
Available money market instruments Virgin does not invest in any such
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
(short term securities) are ndash
Treasury Bills
Commercial Paper
Certificates of Deposit
Bankerrsquos Acceptance
Repurch menase Agree ts
instruments They only keep cash in
Bank Account
Mail Float
(1 to 5 days)
At Firm
Float
(025 to 1
day)
Clearing
Float
(0 to
2 days)
Mail Float
(2 to 3 days)
At firm
Float
(025
day)
Clearing
Float
(1 to 3
days)
Figure Transit time for a typical check Figure Transit time for a check for
Virgin
Strategies that firms can use to reduce
the delay in receiving funds are ndash
Selecting of Banks with
accelerated clearing capabilities
of check processing Acceleration
at the firm
ectronic collection Use of el
procedures
Use of lockboxes
Virgin follows the first three strategies
but does not use lockboxes
Available cash concentration
mechanisms are ndash
Depository transfer check
ouse Automated Clearing H
(ACH) electronic transfer)
Wire transfer
Virgin uses all these mechanisms of
cash concentration
Available sets of techniques for cash
disbursement management are ndash
ement of disbursement
Page 37 of 46
Manag
float
Virgin uses zero-balance accounts
technique
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Zero-Balance Accounts
Controlled disbursing
Firms may make cash flow forecasts
over periods of various lengths yearly
flows quarterly flows monthly flows
weekly flows or even daily flows
Virgin forecasts cash on yearly basis and
monthly basis
Cash forecasting system may involve ndash
Distribution
Scheduling
Virginrsquos cash forecasting system
involves a combination of distribution
and scheduling
Two common approaches to cash flow
in generating the cash forecast
and disbursement Receipts
approach
Adjusted net income approach
Virgin uses the receipts and
disbursement approach
There are many items to forecast Virgin forecasts only major items like
AR payroll etc
Four common approach to forecasting
fina i ndash nc al variables are
Spot method
Proportion to another account
Compounded growth
Multiple dependencies
Virgin uses spot method for forecasting
cash It uses proportion to another
account method for other variables and
remaining two methods are frequently
used
Sources of uncertainty in cash
forecasting are ndash
Sales uncertainty
Collection rate uncertainty
Production cost uncertainty
Capital outflow uncertainty
Virgin faces uncertainty mainly from
sales and production cost
Methods for hedging cash balance
unc a
Page 38 of 46
ert inties are ndash
i) Holding a stock of extra cash
Virgin two available methods for
hedging cash balance uncertainties
Th ese are ndash
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
ii) stock of near-cash Holding a
assets
iii) Extra borrowing capacity
iv) ary surpluses in Investing tempor
near-cash assets
i) Holding a stock of extra cash
ii) Extra borrowing capacity
(advance receipt from
customers)
Models for the management of cash and
temporary investments are ndash Baumol
model Beranek model Miller-Orr
model and Stone model
Virgin does not follow any method
wholly but a combination of Baumol
model and Beranek model is occurred
82 INVENTORY MANAGEMENT
21 Certainty Approach
isnt used in
irgin because it thinks it is not possible to implement in Bangladesh
d time is one to three days It
oes not use ABC system of inventory management
8
Main item of inventory of Virgin is Can pet chip sugar label chemical artificial
sweet etc Virgin maintains a minimum level of inventory but it does not have to face
problems because inventory is managed efficiently just-in-time (JIT)
V
Virgin maintains buffer stock because of the shortage of work-in-process (WIP)
inventory Its production process may also be hampered Thats why it maintains
safety stock to avoid stock out cost In case of imported goods normal lead time is
about one month and within the country normal lea
d
Page 39 of 46
Inventory Model
In reality Virgin does not use any of models of EOQ ordering and holding strategy
and safety stock strategy They maintain inventory based on their prior experience
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
822 Uncertainty Approach
Virgin does not use any model for handling inventory uncertainty It says that such
decision depends on business cycle and market situation Long before Eid festival
they bought large amount of sugar because of price increase on the occasion of Eid
In summary
Standard Compliance by Virgin Soft Drinks
Firms maintain inventory to guard
against several problems
Virgin maintains a minimum level of
inventory which is managed efficiently
Some firms use JIT to avoid inventory
cost
JIT is not used by Virgin as it thinks it is
impossible to implement in Bangladesh
Firms maintain buffer stock Virgin maintains buffer stock too
Firms maintain safety stock to avoid
shortage cost
Virgin also maintains safety stock
Firms use ABC system to monitor
inventory
Virgin doesnt use ABC system
EOQ model is an appropriate method
for measuring quantity that has to be
ordered per order
Virgin does not use EOQ model rather
makes order based on experience and
market demand
83 MANAGING ACCOUNTS RECEIVABLE (DEBTORS)
831 Terms of Sale Decision
Page 40 of 46
Virgin offers the term 210 net 30 enables the customers to deduct 2 percent from the
face value of the bill when paying within the first 10 days but if the discount is not
taken the customer must remit the full amount within 30 days But Virgin does not
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
offer the same terms of sale to all customers For prime customers it offers special
terms of sale In setting an appropriate term of sale it costs and benefits regarding
this are compared It uses the standard approach of terms of sale decision as it is
simple to use
832 Credit Granting Decisions
In case of Virgin the Capital and Character of Five Cs get more importance
Although there are many problems with the traditional approach Virgin uses it
because of its simplicity Virgin does not use Net Present Value (NPV) method in
credit granting decision It thinks that NPV is an appropriate method and should be
used next time It does not face any severe problem because of bad debts The reason
is that notes receivable is used when credit is granted
833 Monitoring Accounts Receivable
Virgin monitors its accounts receivable Virgin believes that in any case both positive
and negative durations in accounts signal differences from the results that
management believe to be the most advantageous for the firm
Tools for Monitoring Accounts Receivable
Page 41 of 46
For monitoring accounts receivable there are several tools such as aging schedule
the ratios of receivable outstanding to original sales customers payment proportion
and sales weighted DSO (Days Sales Outstanding) For monitoring accounts
receivable Virgin uses aging schedule fractions and traditional DSO statistics
because of their simplicity in use Although payment proportions ratios of
receivables outstanding and sales weighted DSO methods are free from inherent bias
None of these is used because all these are complex to maintain
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
In summary
Page 42 of 46
Standard Compliance by Virgin Soft Drinks
Generals terms of sale is 210 net 30 Normally Virgin also use general terms
of sale ie 210 net 30
Firms do not offer the same terms of
sale to all customers
Yes For prime customers Virgin offers
special terms of sale
Approaches of terms of sale decisions
are ndash
bull Standard approach
bull Multi period approach
Virgin uses standard approach of terms
of sale decision as it is simple to use and
understand
Source of credit information are ndash
Sellers prior experience with the
customer
Credit agency ratings and
reports
Personal contact with the
applicants bank and other
creditors
Analysis of applicants financial
statements
Customer visit
Main source of credit information to
Virgin is its prior experience with the
customer All other sources are not cost-
effective for Virgin
Approaches of credit granting to
marginal accounts are ndash
Traditional approach
Net Present Value (NPV)
approach
It uses traditional approach still now but
thinks that NPV should be used for the
next periods
Firms monitor accounts receivable
because deviations from the expected
levels of turnover and of bad debt can
Virgin also monitors its accounts
receivable
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
signal several different problems
Different tools for monitoring accounts
receivable are ndash
Aging schedule
Ratios of receivables
outstanding to original sales
Customers payment
proportions
Sales-weighted DSO
For monitoring accounts receivable
Virgin uses aging schedule and
traditional sales outstanding statistics
84 MANAGING ACCOUNTS PAYABLE (CREDITORS)
Virgin has almost accounts payable of Tk 8000000 But most of its liabilities are to
the banks rather than suppliers But we dont have any clear information about
Virgins accounts payable
9 RECOMMENDATION
Virgin should invest its surplus cash in short term marketable securities
because it is suitable hedging against cash uncertainties and will also give
some returns (interest income)
Virgin should publish its own annual report which will satisfy information
needs of stakeholders and also increase the credibility of information provided
by Virgin
Page 43 of 46
Virgin should use multi period approach in terms of sale decision because
standard approach which is already exists in Virgin has some inherent
problems
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
It should stop using traditional approach from now It should use NPV
method in credit granting to marginal accounts
In monitoring accounts receivable Virgin should use sales-weighted DSO
method because it has least limitation compared to the others
It should be more flexible in granting credit which will ultimately increase its
sales
To get the appropriate number of quantity to be ordered per order it should
use DSO model
It should be ABC system for proper monitoring of inventory
10 CONCLUSION
The use of other peoples money in business is usually an expensive resource Before
looking outside for finance a firm should examine its own working capital cycle to
make sure that every rand of its own internal funds is being fully utilized Good
management of working capital is part of good financial management Effective use
of working capital will contribute to the operational efficiency of the whole
organization optimum use will help to generate maximum returns Furthermore
working capital management is not an end in itself It is an integral part of the firms
overall management The needs of efficient working capital management must be
considered in relation to other aspects of the Virgins financial and non-financial
performance Thats why when planning the development of a business it is critical
that the impact of working capital be fully assessed
Page 44 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
BIBLIOGRAPHY
Scherr FC (1989) International Edition Prentice-Hall International Inc Modern
Working Capital Management Text and Cases
Hussain Riaz (2002) Working Capital Management
Robertson Lonnie (July 1998) Inventory Management
httpwwwasashoporg visited on March 13 2006
The Art of Cash Management
httpwwwinccom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management
httpwwwstudyfinancecom visited on March 13 2006
White Paper ndash Managing Working Capital
httpwwwplanwareorg visited on March 13 2006
Management of Working Capital
httpwwwbusinesscentralcoza visited on March 13 2006
Cash Management
httpwwwsbagov visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management Objectives
httpwpsprenhallcom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management
Page 45 of 46
httpwwwadvancemecom visited on March 13 2006
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Business Receivables Financing
httpwwwbbtcom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Finance
http wwwfnbcoza visited on March 13 2006
Tips to manage your working capital
httpsmallbusinessninemsncomau visited on March 13 2006
Inventory Financing
httpwwwfranklincapitalnetworkcom visited on March 13 2006
Accounts Receivable Management
httpwwwfranklincapitalnetworkcom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management
httpwwwtreasurygovtnz visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management
httpwwwtreasurystrategiescom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Works
httpwwwinvestopediacom visited on March 13 2006
Treasury Services
httpwwwjpmorganchasecom visited on March 13 2006
what were about
Page 46 of 46
httpwwwvirgincom visited on March 13 2006
Annexure
Annexure
Interview with YASEER RIZVI
Mr Yaseer Rizvi the DMD of Global Beverage Co Ltd obtained his MBA degree
from a reputed university He had been the Director of Ocean Container Ltd before
joining in Global Beverage Co Ltd He possesses a nice personality
I interviewed Yaseer Rizvi Excerpts from his interview are as follows ndash
Shah Kamal Sir would you please tell me do you invest in short term marketable securities
Yaseer Rizvi Basically we do not invest our surplus cash in short term marketable
securities like T-Bill commercial paper certificate of deposit etc But we keep our
surplus cash in Bank
Shah Kamal Would you tell me something about transit time for a typical check
Yaseer Rizvi Well in Virgin the transit time for a typical check is ndash
For mail float 2 to 3 days
At firm float 6 hours
Clearing float 1 to 3 days
Shah Kamal Do you maintain any cash concentration mechanism like depository transfer check automated clearing house and wire transfer
i
Annexure
Yaseer Rizvi Our position in this case is very strong as we use all the mechanisms
you mentioned As Virgin is a firm with small deposits spread over a substantial
number of banks so we tend to use depository transfer checks extensively It is less
costly We also use automated clearing house and wire transfer but later is used in a
less extent
Shah Kamal Sir what techniques of disbursement management is used by your firm
Yaseer Rizvi Like other firms Virgin tries to retain the cash for as long as possible
But we always perform it in an ethical manner We do not use management of
disbursement float as it seems unethical We follow Zero-Balance Accounts method
for managing disbursement We do not prefer Controlled Disbursing method since
Zero-Balance system is already practiced in Virgin
Shah Kamal How do you hedge cash balance uncertainties
Yaseer Rizvi Well you may say that we do not invest in short term securities but for
facing cash difficulties we keep our surplus cash in bank
Shah Kamal Sir would you please tell me the general terms of sale of Virgin
Yaseer Rizvi Though it is difficult to maintain a fixed terms of sale our general terms
of sale is 210 n30 But for prime customers we offer special terms of sale
Shah Kamal What are the sources of credit information in case of your firm
Yaseer Rizvi We grant credit on the basis of prior experience with the customers In
case of a new customer personal contact is weighted
Shah Kamal Does your firm consider 5 Cs in granting credit
ii
Annexure
Yaseer Rizvi In case of Virgin Capital and Character get more importance than the
others Mind one thing personal relationship is the main measure in granting credit
Shah Kamal Do you use NPV method in credit granting decisions
Yaseer Rizvi We do not use NPV method But we think that NPV is a suitable
method and we have to use it from the next period
Shah Kamal Sir how do you handle the problem of bad debt
Yaseer Rizvi Well in this case our position is very strong Yet we do not face any
problem because of bad debt Just note that we make more than 80 of sales in cash
and we monitor accounts receivable very carefully
Shah Kamal What level of inventory is maintained by Virgin
Yaseer Rizvi We maintain a minimum level of inventory but do not have to face
stock out problems because inventory is managed efficiently
Shah Kamal What is the normal lead time
Yaseer Rizvi In case of imported goods normal lead time is about 1 month and when
we purchase raw materials from inside the country lead time is 1 to 3 days
Shah Kamal What method do you use for managing inventory
Yaseer Rizvi We do not use any method particularly rather inventory decision
depends on business cycle and market situation Long before the Eid festival we
bought large amount of sugar because price of sugar was increased on the occasion
of Eid
iii
Annexure
Shah Kamal What are the main items of inventory of your firm
Yaseer Rizvi Well these are ndash aluminum can pet chip sugar label chemical and
artificial sweet
Shah Kamal What are the uncertainties in maintaining appropriate level of stock
Yaseer Rizvi These are ndash
bull Increase in price of raw materials
bull Sales uncertainty
bull Market trends etc
Shah Kamal Thank you for your kind cooperation
Yaseer Rizvi Most Welcome
iv
Global Beverage Company Limited
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Page 11 of 46
End-of-day sweep accounts A safer bet for most small-business owners
these accounts wait until a late-hour cutoff to determine how much to
sweep into the firms overnight investments Typically their investment
yields are 10 to 20 basis points (1 to 2 of the investment) lower than
those offered with controlled investments
2 Lock-box accounts
A lock box is a cash-management system that helps the firm collect funds quickly
Generally set up with the assistance of a big money center or regional bank lock
boxes provide the firm with a special zip code and usually quicker deliveries from
regional post offices They are especially important if the firm has clusters of
customers in out-of-state locations and dont want to lose days waiting for their
checks to arrive by long-distance mail
5314 Cash Concentration and Cash Disbursement
Once the remittances from the firmrsquos customers have been received and cleared the
resulting cash balances is available in the firmrsquos lockbox (depository) banks It is
useful for the firm to gather these balances from the lockbox banks into the central
bank account The process of collecting funds is called cash concentration
Several concentration mechanism are available for the firm to use in transferring
funds from its collection banks to regional concentration banks and from there to the
central concentration bank These mechanisms differ in cost and in the availability of
funds that they provide These are ndash
a) Depository Transfer Check
It is the cheapest transfer mechanism This document instructs one bank to
send funds to another and is treated the same as any other check
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
b) Automated Clearing House (ACH) Electronic Transfer
This vehicle is essentially an electronic version of the depository transfer
check and can be used between banks that participate in the automated
clearing house system
c) Wire Transfer
These are electronic message between banks
Decisions regarding concentration mechanism usually hinge on the size and
spread of the firmrsquos deposits Firms with small deposits spread over a
substantial number of banks will tend to have more extensive concentration
systems and will transfer among accounts using low-cost transfer vehicles that
offer only delayed availability (such as depository transfer checks) Firms with
larger deposits will have fewer accounts (since a local deposit for transfer to
an upstream bank is not needed) and will use more expensive and more rapid
transfer mechanisms (such as wire transfers) The concentration systems of
major chemical companies for example tend to be structured in this way ndash
DepositoryLockbox Banks
Regional Concentration Banks
Central Concentrated Bank
Figure A typical Cash Concentration System
(Arrows indicate transfers of collected funds)
Page 12 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Disbursement management addresses the efficient payout out of this cash once it is
concentrated The firmrsquos objective in disbursement management is to retain the cash
for as long as possible In this way the firm will have the maximum amount of funds
available for investment and transactional purposes Certainly this management
means making disbursement only when they are due and not before The firm has
several available set of techniques for disbursement management Included among
these are ndash
a) Management of Disbursement Float
In this set of techniques the disbursing firm attempts to increase the length of
time between the mailing of its checks and the eventual withdrawal of funds
from the banks This involves strategies for increasing mail float at firm float
and clearing float on its outgoing checks For example the disbursing firm
may intentionally address checks to the firmrsquos office address rather than its
lockbox creating at firm float
b) Zero-Balance Accounts
Here the firm holds the cash until the check arrive (or expected to arrive) at
the disbursement bank In this strategy an account for disbursement is first
established at a bank For the zero-balance system to be effective the
participating bank must be one on which most disbursement are made via the
Bangladesh Bankrsquos clearance system (which presents disbursements to banks
early in the morning) and not a bank where disbursements occur throughout
the day (as with a major money-center bank) Consequently the banks used
in zero-balance strategies are usually branches of major banks and not their
main locations
Page 13 of 46
c) Controlled Disbursing
In this system the firm projects the amount of checks to arrive each day at the
disbursement bank (based on the checks written in previous days and historic
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
statistics on disbursement float) and transfers the amount of the expected
checks to the account on that day or just before
5315 Cash Forecasting
Defining Cash Forecasting
The cash forecast is an estimation of the flows in and out of the firmrsquos cash account
over a particular period of time usually a quarter month week or day The cash
forecast is primarily intended to produce a very useful piece of information an
estimation of the firmrsquos borrowing and lending needs and uncertainties regarding
these needs during various future periods Cash forecasting is very crucial to most
firms It enables them to anticipate periods of surplus cash and periods where
financing will be necessary This anticipation is the reason that cash forecasts are
generated Anticipation enables the firm to plan much more effectively for
investment and financing and via this planning produce superior return
Types of Cash Forecasts
The types of cash forecasts generated by firms can be differentiated along two
dimensions the length of the periods included within the cash forecast and the approach
to cash flows used in the cash forecast The length of the period refers to the units of
time into which the cash forecast is divided Firms may make cash flow forecasts
over periods of various lengths yearly flows quarterly flows monthly flows weekly
flows or even daily flows The most popular forecast involves monthly flows but
most firms do not confine themselves to a single forecast Instead they use several
forecasts with periods of various lengths When the firm makes forecasts involving
multiple and overlapping period lengths one forecast relates to another Starting
with data on relatively long periods and breaking it down into smaller periods is
called distribution starting with data on relatively short periods and aggregating into
longer periods is called scheduling
Page 14 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Firms use two common approaches to cash flows in generating the cash forecast the
receipts and disbursements approach and the adjusted net income approach The receipts
and disbursements approach use the amounts of cash expected to be received and
disbursed by the firm over the periods chosen for forecast The adjusted income
statement approach is sometimes called the sources and use approach Here the
forecaster starts with projected net income on an accrual basis and adjusts to a cash
basis This method provides a representation of changes in asset and liability
accounts since the level of these accounts are of interest to the firm this aspect of the
adjusted income statement is an advantage over the receipts and disbursements
method
Items to Be Forecast
In the receipt and disbursements cash forecasting method estimates need to be made
of the numerous major and minor items that the firm collects (receipts) and that it
pays (disbursements) The more individual categories of items the firm includes in its
forecast procedure the more accurate the forecast may be but the more costly in
terms of time and effort it will be to generate
Some Possible Types of Cash Receipts and Cash Disbursements
Cash Disbursements Cash Receipts
Cash Purchases of Materials Payroll
Taxes
Maturing Accounts Payable
Maturing Notes Payable
Miscellaneous Disbursements
Accounts Receivable
Notes Receivable
Rental Income
Interest Income
Miscellaneous Receipts
Methods of Financial Forecasting
Page 15 of 46
Financial forecasting is the estimation of the future level of a financial variable often
a cash flow asset level or liability level It is usually assumed that the relationship
between the financial variable and other variable is linear The general linear model
can then be used
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
nnt xaxaxaaY 22110 ++=
Here
= Financial variable (Y) to be forecast in period t tY
x = Explanatory variable it is assumed to cause the level of Y in period t
0a = Represents a constant unaffected by the x
The other terms are the estimated coefficients of the explanatory x variables
There are n terms with xrsquos in them
There are four common approaches to forecasting financial variables but they
are all special cases of the general linear model These are ndash spot method proportion
to another account compounded growth and multiple dependencies
Using Cash Forecast
The estimate of available funds for investment and needed financing enables the firm
to plan so as to obtain the most advantages borrowing terms for deficits and achieve
the greatest interest income on surplus A useful chart for this planning purpose is a
bar chart eg
Figure Bar Chart of Cash Surpluses and Deficits from hypothetical data
Page 16 of 46
75
50
-60
30
100
-20
-80-60-40-20
020406080
100120
Defic
it
S
urpl
us
January February March April May June
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Sources of Uncertainty in Cash Forecasting and Hedging Uncertainties
There are numerous sources of risk in cash forecasting Among the sources are sales
uncertainty collection rate uncertainty production cost uncertainty and capital
outflow uncertainty
5316 Models for the Management of Cash and Temporary Investments
There are different models for the management of cash and temporary investments
Among these the most popular methods are ndash Baumol model Beranek model
Miller-Orr model and Stone model
Baumol and Beranek use the same model The formula is cited below ndash
Interest Income = iYn
n⎥⎦⎤
⎢⎣⎡ minus
21
Profit = naiYn
nminus⎥⎦
⎤⎢⎣⎡ minus
21
Optimum number of transactions = ⎟⎠⎞
⎜⎝⎛
aiY2
Where n = Optimum number of transactions
i = Interest rate per period
a = Transaction cost
Y = Total inflow for the period
Page 17 of 46
Miller-Orr and Stone use the same model ie R-Statistic The model is ndash
31
43
iav
R ⎟⎠⎞
⎜⎝⎛=
Optimum Control Limit = R + L
Upper Control Limit = 3R + L
Where a = Transaction Cost
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
v = Variance of daily cash flows
i = Daily interest rate
5317 Administration
Cash receipts should be processed and banked as quickly as possible because
They cannot earn interest or reduce overdraft until they are banked
information about the existence and amounts of cash receipts is usually not
available until they are processed
Where possible cash floats (mainly petty cash and advances) should be avoided If
on review the only reason that can be put forward for their existence is that weve
always had them they should be discontinued There may be situations where they
are useful however For example it may be desirable for peripheral parts of
departments to meet urgent local needs from cash floats rather than local bank
accounts
5318 Internal Control
Cash and cash management is part of a firms overall internal control system The
main internal cash control is invariably the bank reconciliation This provides
assurance that the cash balances recorded in the accounting systems are consistent
with the actual bank balances It requires regular clearing of reconciling items
5319 Practicing Good Cash Flow Management
Good cash management is simple It involves
Knowing when where and how firms cash needs will occur
Page 18 of 46
Knowing the best sources for meeting additional cash needs
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Page 19 of 46
Being prepared to meet these needs when they occur by keeping good
relationships with bankers and other creditors
532 INVENTORY MANAGEMENT
Inventory management is necessary for owners who want to maintain a stocking
service for quick turnaround to help ensure total customer satisfaction The fill rate
of an item on a managed inventory list must be maintained to avoid shortages of
frequently used items Even when utilizing an inventory management system
occasional shortages will still occur Inventories are lists of stocks-raw materials
work in progress or finished goods-waiting to be consumed in production or to be
sold The total balance of inventory is the sum of the value of each individual stock
line
Basically firms hold stocks for the following reasons
To act as a buffer in times of unusually high demand
To ensure continuity of production
Avoid high costs of emergency orders
To take advantage of quantity discounts by ordering more at a time
To reduce ordering costs by ordering more items on fewer
As part of the production process eg maturing whisky or keeping oil in
pipelines
Seasonality of demand (eg firework) or supplies
Suppliers insist on minimum order quantities
The key issue for a business is to identify the fast and slow stock movers with the
objectives of establishing optimum stock levels for each category and thereby
minimize the cash tied up in stocks Factors to be considered when determining
optimum stock levels include
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Page 20 of 46
What are the projected sales of each product
How widely available are raw materials components etc
How long does it take for delivery by suppliers
Can the firm remove slow movers from its product range without
compromising best sellers
Inventory management is an important aspect of working capital management
because inventories themselves do not earn any revenue Holding either too little or
too much inventory incurs costs
Costs of carrying too much inventory are
Opportunity cost of foregone interest
Warehousing costs
Damage and pilferage
Obsolescence
Insurance
Costs of carrying too little inventory are
Stock out costs
Lost sales
Delayed service
Ordering costs
Freight
on Order administrati
nts
Loss of quantity discou
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Carrying costs can be minimized by making frequent small orders but this increase
ordering costs and the risk of stock outs Risk of stock-outs can be reduced by
carrying safety stocks (at a cost) and re-ordering ahead of time
The best ordering strategy requires balancing the various cost factors to ensure the
firm incurs minimum inventory costs The optimum inventory position is known as
the Economic Reorder Quantity (ERQ)
Nowadays many large manufacturers operate on a just-in-time (JIT) basis whereby
all the components to be assembled on a particular today arrive at the factory early
that morning no earlier - no later This helps to minimize manufacturing costs as JIT
stocks take up little space minimize stock-holding and virtually eliminate the risks of
obsolete or damaged stock Because JIT manufacturers hold stock for a very short
time they are able to conserve substantial cash JIT is a good model to strive for as it
embraces all the principles of prudent stock management For better stock control
firm may try the following
Review the effectiveness of existing purchasing and inventory systems
Know the stock turn for all major items of inventory
Apply tight controls to the significant few items and simplify controls for the
trivial many
Sell off outdated or slow moving merchandise - it gets more difficult to sell the
longer the firm keeps it
Consider having part of its product outsourced to another manufacturer rather
than make it itself
Review its security procedures to ensure that no stock is going out the back
door
Higher than necessary stock levels tie up cash and cost more in insurance
accommodation costs and interest charges
Page 21 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
However it is important to keep an overall perspective It is not cost-effective to
closely manage a large number of low value inventory lines nor is it necessary A
usual feature of inventories is that a small number of high value lines account for a
large proportion of inventory value The 8020 rule (PARETO) predicts that 80
of the total value of inventory is represented by only 20 of the number of inventory
items Those high value lines need reasonably close management The remaining
80 of inventory lines can be managed using broad-brush strategies
533 MANAGING ACCOUNTS RECEIVABLE (DEBTORS)
Cash flow can be significantly enhanced if the amounts owing to a business are
collected faster Every business needs to know who owes them money how much is
owed how long it is owing for what it is owed
Debtors (Accounts Receivable) are customers who have not yet made payment for
goods or services which the department has provided The objective of debtor
management is to minimize the time-lapse between completion of sales and receipt
of payment The costs of having debtors are
Opportunity costs (cash is not available for other purposes)
Bad debts
If firm doesnt manage debtors they will begin to manage business as the firm will gradually
lose control due to reduced cash flow and of course it could experience an increased
incidence of bad debt The following measures will help manage debtors
Having the right mental attitude to the control of credit and make sure that it
gets the priority it deserves
Establishing clear credit practices as a matter of company policy
Page 22 of 46
Making sure that these practices are clearly understood by staff suppliers and
customers
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Page 23 of 46
Being professional when accepting new accounts and especially larger ones
Checking out each customer thoroughly before the firm offers credit Use
credit agencies bank references industry sources etc
Establishing credit limits for each customer and sticking to them
Continuously reviewing these limits when it suspects tough times are coming
or if operating in a volatile sector
Keeping very close to the firms larger customers
Invoicing promptly and clearly
Considering charging penalties on overdue accounts
Considering accepting credit debit cards as a payment option
Monitoring its debtor balances and ageing schedules and dont let any debts
get too large or too old
Debtor management includes both pre-sale and debt collection strategies
Pre-sale strategies include
Offering cash discounts for early payment andor imposing penalties for late
payment
Agreeing payment terms in advance
Requiring cash before delivery
Setting credit limits
ning credit Setting criteria for obtai
Billing as early as possible
rogress payments
ost-sale strategies include
for collecting the debt upon the center that made the sale
Requiring deposits andor p
P
Placing the responsibility
Identifying long overdue balances and doubtful debts by regular analytical reviews
Having an established procedure for late collections such as
A reminder
A letter
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Page 24 of 46
ion of further credit Cancellat
Telephone calls
n agency Use of a collectio
he firm should recognize that the longer someone owes firm the greater the chance
Legal action
T
it will never get paid If the average age of debtors is getting longer or is already very
long it may need to look for the following possible defects
Weak credit judgment
res Poor collection procedu
ms Lax enforcement of credit ter
Slow issue of invoices or statements
Errors in invoices or statements
Customer dissatisfaction
Debtors due over 90 days (unless within agreed credit terms) should generally
demand immediate attention For example warning signs of a future bad debt ndash
Longer credit terms taken with approval particularly for smaller orders
Use of post-dated checks by debtors who normally settle within agreed terms
Evidence of customers switching to additional suppliers for the same goods
New customers who are reluctant to give credit references
Cre G
Receiving part payments from debtors
dit ranting to Marginal Accounts
Traditional Approach
In the traditional approach to the credit granting decision it is the credit analysts job
rmation that has been collected and reach a judgment
regarding the applicants creditworthiness One traditional way of organizing this
to synthesize all the info
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
information is by characterizing the applicant along five dimensions These
dimensions are called the Five Cs of credit ndash
Capital
Character
Collateral
and Capacity
Conditions
Net Present Value (NPV) Approach
Once a firm has assessed the creditworthiness of a customer it has to decide whether
r not credit should be granted The firm should use the NPV rule to make the
ld be granted
Figure
o
decision If NPV is positive credit shou
Credit Granting Decision
Credit Granting Decision
he act of collecting money is one which most people dislike for many reasons and
therefore put on the long f selves there is something
ore urgent or important that demands their attention now There is nothing more
T
inger because they convince them
m
important than getting paid for firms product or service A customer who does not
Page 25 of 46
Grand Credit
Payment received Payment not received
Benefit of present value of future net cash flow
Cost of present value ment of lost invest
Net Payoff PV of benefit-cost
No Credit
No Payoff
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
pay is not a customer Here are a few ideas that may help the firm in collecting
money from debtors
Firm should develop appropriate procedures for handling late payments
It should track and pursue late payers
It might get external help if its own efforts fail
or money its firms and it is entitled Company shouldnt feel guilty asking f
to it
ction
Firm must make that call now And it should keep asking until it gets some
satisfa
lessens the problem
In difficult circumstances take what the firm can now and agree terms for the
remainder It
paying
When asking for money be hard on the issue - but soft on the person It shouldnt
give the debtor any excuses for not
534 BLE (CREDITORS)
ices for goods or services have
een paid Organizations often regard the
not
to delay all payments until the latest possible date Regular weekly or
The firm make it its objective is to get the money - not to score points or get
even
MANAGING ACCOUNTS PAYA
Creditors (Accounts Payable) are suppliers whose invo
been processed but who have not yet b
amount owing to creditors as a source of free credit However creditor
administration systems are expensive and time-consuming to run The over-riding
concern in this area should be to minimize costs with simple procedures
While it is unnecessary to pay accounts before they fall due it is usually
worthwhile
Page 26 of 46
fortnightly payment of all due accounts is the simplest technique for creditor
management
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Electronic payments (direct credits) are cheaper than check payments considering
that transaction fees and overheads more than balance the advantage of delayed
presentation Some suppliers are reluctant to receive payments by this method but in
view of the substantial cost advantage (and the advantages to the suppliers
themselves) departments may wish to encourage suppliers to accept this option
However electronic payments are likely to be used in conjunction with rather than
as a replacement for check payments
Applying Best Practices in Managing Accounts Payable
f course simply deferring payments to suppliers could have adverse consequences
O
that more than offset the benefits of this additional cash flow Therefore it is
important to develop a holistic approach The firm should consider the following
best practices for payables management
Managing payment dates and terms to maximize cash flow ndash
y reporting on
receivable and
id penalty charges and taking advantage of
wer vendors and negotiate for more
to buying consortia with others even
voices for
payment based on receipt of goods or receipt of invoice whichever
comes later
Calculating and setting performance targets Regularl
AP performance measures such as days in payables
Coordinating the AP processes with accounts
inventory management to ensure that the company is collecting more
cash than it is paying out
Paying bills on time to avo
prompt-payment discounts where the discounts exceed the companyrsquos
cost of working capital
Consolidating purchases with fe
favorable payment terms
Considering entering in
Page 27 of 46
competitors to obtain favorable supplier pricing and terms
Unless contract terms specify otherwise setting up in
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Page 28 of 46
Em
process
-time payments with Electronic Funds Transfer (EFT)
uraging vendors to utilize electronic invoice presentment
a
ndancies and more
ploying technology to automate the accounts payable transaction
es ndash
Making just-in
Using an electronic invoice-matching application
Enco
For companies with multiple locations or business units employing
shared service approach for AP to eliminate redu
quickly implement process improvements
Mainta
vendor
Communicating accounts payable requirements to suppliers at the
m key suppliers
for suggestions on how to improve the
Efficient a
and making th rsquos cash is just good business
ining open communications and building strong relationships with
s to access valuable trade credit ndash
beginning of transactions
Requesting summary invoicing fro
Requiring suppliers to send invoices directly to accounts payable
Asking tier-one suppliers
payment process
nd effective management of accounts payable helps improve cash flow ndash
e most of company
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
6 OVERVIEW OF VIRGIN GROUP
Virgin - one of the most respected brands in Britain - is now becoming the first global
brand name of the 21st century Virgin is involved in planes trains finance soft
drinks music mobile phones holidays cars wines publishing bridal wear - the lot
What tie all these businesses together are the values of its brand and the attitude of its
people Virgin has created over 200 companies worldwide employing over 25000
people Its total revenues around the world in 2002 exceeded pound4 billion (US $72
billion)
In 1970 Richard Branson founded Virgin as a mail order record retailer and not
long after he opened a record shop in Oxford Street London During 1972 a
recording studio was built in Oxfordshire and the first Virgin artist Mike Oldfield
recorded Tubular Bells which was released in 1973
This album went on to sell over 5 million copies Since then many household names
including Belinda Carlisle Genesis Phil Collins Janet Jackson and The Rolling
Stones have helped to make Virgin Music one of the top six record companies in the
world The equity of Virgin Music Group - record labels music publishing and
recording studios was sold to THORN EMI in 1992 in a US$1billion deal
Page 29 of 46
The Virgin Group has now expanded into international music Mega stores air
travel mobile financial retail music internet drinks rail hotels and leisure with
around 200 companies in over 30 countries
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
In Virgins customers eyes Virgin stands for value for money quality innovation
fun and a sense of competitive challenge It delivers a quality service by empowering
its employees and facilitates and monitors customer feedback to continually improve
the customers experience through innovation
When they start a new venture Virgin bases it on hard research and analysis
Typically they review the industry and put themselves in the customers shoes to see
what could make it better Virgin asks fundamental questions
Is this an opportunity for restructuring a market and creating competitive
advantage What are the competitors doing
Is the customer confused or badly served
Is this an opportunity for building the Virgin brand
Can we add value
Will it interact with its other businesses
Is there an appropriate trade-off between risk and reward
Page 30 of 46
Virgin is also able to draw on talented people from throughout the group New
ventures are often steered by people seconded from other parts of Virgin who bring
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
with them the trademark management style skills and experience Virgin frequently
creates partnerships with others to combine skills knowledge and market presence
and so on Contrary to what some people may think their constantly expanding and
eclectic empire is neither random nor reckless Each successive venture demonstrates
its skill in picking the right market and the right opportunity
7 OVERVIEW OF VIRGIN SOFT DRINKS
The Virgin Drinks Group first launched as the Virgin Cola Company in 1994 with
Virgin Cola in the UK Since then the company has ventured across the carbonated
soft drinks arena and beyond into energy drinks tea and flavored Colas This
expansion has lead to the evolution of the Virgin Drinks Company a company
whose aim is to put the excitement back into the world of soft drinks It launched in
Bangladesh in 1999 Virgin Soft Drinks is monitored by Global Beverage Co Ltd in
Bangladesh
Brief history of Virgin Drinks is given below
Page 31 of 46
1994 November Virgin Cola launched in the UK
1996 March Virgin Cola launched in France
1998 June Virgin Cola launched in Belgium
April Virgin Cola launched in the French West Indies
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
August Virgin Cola launched in Switzerland
1999 March Virgin Colours launched in Italy
March Virgin Cola launched in Japan
July Virgin Colours launched in South Africa
December Virgin Colours launched in Bangladesh
2001 January Sweden launched Virgin Colours
November Singapore launched Virgin Colours
2002 February Croatia launched Virgin Colours
June Russia launched Virgin Colours
June Tunisia launched Virgin Colours
2003 May Israel launched Virgin Colours
8 FINDINGS OF WORKING CAPITAL MANAGEMENT MAINTAINED BY
VIRGIN SOFT DRINKS IN BANGLADESH
81 CASH MANAGEMENT
811 Holding Cash and Marketable Securities
Although there are many good reasons why firm hold cash and marketable
securities Virgin Drinks holds cash and marketable securities for two reasons ndash
i) Cash for transactions
ii) Cash as hedges
This indicates that the firm does not hold cash and marketable securities for some
important reasons such as ndash
i) Near cash assets as hedges
Page 32 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
ii) Temporary investment and compensating balances
Virgin Soft Drinks does not invest in money market securities such as Treasury bill
commercial paper certificate of deposits bankerrsquos acceptance and repurchase
agreement This firm deposits its money in bank as currant AC or fixed AC They
say that they do not have enough money to invest in money market instrument
They also say that if they have enough money they will invest it in money market
short term securities We know that near cash interest earning assets can be
substituted for cash when motivation for holding these assets is the hedging of cash
flow uncertainties or is the temporary investment of surplus funds In this point
Virgins position is not good as there is no significant hedging against uncertainty of
cash
812 Floatation and Check Clearing
Virgin is very smart in handling the problem of transit time for checks Here mail
float takes 2 to 3 days at firm takes 025 day and clearing float takes 1-3 days Virgin
uses most of the strategies available for reducing the delay in receiving funds It
(Virgin) has linked Islami Bank which posses an accelerated clearing facility It uses
electronic collection process which ensures faster collection and its at the firm check
processing is satisfactory But Virgin does not use lockbox The reason behind this is
that it is not cost-effective for Virgin to set lockboxes At this point we can say that
Virgins check clearing mechanism is much good
813 Cash Concentration and Disbursement Management
Page 33 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks takes the matter of cash concentration very seriously They use all
the available cash concentration mechanism Virgin is a firm with small deposits
spread over a substantial number of banks and this is why the firm tends to use
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
depository transfer checks extensively If is less costly Virgin also uses automated
clearing house and wire transfer To Virgin wire transfer seems too costly
Like other firm Virgin tries to retain the cash for as long as possible But Virgin
always performs it in an ethical manner Virgin does not try to defeat the receiving
firmrsquos attempts to reduce the float on incoming checks It does not take any strategy
for increasing mail float at firm float and clearing float on its outgoing checks To
Virgin it is deemed to be unethical It thinks that maximization of disbursement float
will not go unnoticed by sophisticated creditors for very long When it is noticed it
will negatively affect relations with these creditors reducing the firmrsquos bargaining
power with them This may ultimately cost Virgin dearly when future prices and
delivery schedules for goods and services purchased from trade creditors are
negotiated Virgin follows ldquoZero-Balance Accountsrdquo methods for managing
disbursement It thinks that in this method the coordination of funds inflows to
disbursement banks with the presentation of checks does not work to the detriment
of creditors since the firmrsquos checks to them are honored as presented and this strategy
does not affect float significantly Controlled disbursing method is less attractive to
Virgin because zero-balance system is already feasible
814 Cash Forecasting
Cash Forecasting and Its Types
Page 34 of 46
Virgin forecasts the future cash inflows and outflows To Virgin cash forecast is an
important part of the firmrsquos cash control system and is one of the forecasts that are
part of the Virginrsquos financial plan Virgin forecasts cash on monthly basis and on
yearly basis Virgin does not forecast on daily basis assuming that the temporary
shortage of funds within these periods can be covered without value cost eg
advance receipts from customers Virginrsquos cash forecasting system involves a
combination of distribution and scheduling The receipts and disbursements
approach of cash forecasting is used in virgin This method is used because it
minutely traces the movement of cash and very close control of cash is possible
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Virgin does not use adjusted net income approach on two grounds First it does not
permit the tracing of the individual types of cash inflows and outflows for any given
period which is often useful information for virgin Second it is not simple to use
Items to be Forecast
Virgin does not forecast all the items It forecasts only major items eg accounts
receivable notes receivable payroll cash purchases of raw materials In this regard
virgin trade off between cost and benefit
Methods of Financial Forecasting
Virgin forecasts the future level of financial variable such as cash level asset level or
liability level We know in short term forecasts many things will result from plans
and events that are already in place (contracts capital budgets long-range financing
plans and so forth) But in the long run most things can vary and are dependent on
outside influences such as the firmrsquos long-term growth rate Since Virginrsquos cash
forecasting deals mostly with near future many of the items on the cash forecasts are
estimated by some variation of the spot method and remaining estimates are mostly
on a ldquoproportion of another accountrdquo basis with this ldquoother accountrdquo often being a
particular periodrsquos sales Virgin uses the other two methods less frequently
Using Cash Forecast
Virgin forecasts cash for meeting general objectives (ie to know the available funds
for investment and need financing) and for meeting some special objectives (eg to
know whether the firm will fulfill its out of debt requirement) But it is matter to note
that Virgin does not make any short term investment of its surplus cash but only keep
this surplus in Bank Account
Page 35 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Sources of Uncertainty in Cash Forecasting and Hedging Uncertainties
Virgin faces uncertainty in cash forecasting mainly from two sources These are ndash
sales and production cost In peak season (hot season like autumn summer) sales
increases but in dull season (eg in winter) sales decreases drastically Production
cost may be increased because of increase of price of sugar chemicals aluminum
can Virgin follows two methods for hedging cash balance uncertainties These are ndash
i) Holding a stock of extra cash and
ii) Extra borrowing capacity
815 Modes for the Management of Cash and Temporary Investments
Virgin does not follow any of these methods wholly Virgin receives cash
continuously and pays salary at steady rate and pays continuously for other
expenses So it neither follows Baumol model nor Beranek model It has no upper
control limit lower control limit return point in case cash management So it neither
follows Miller-Orr model nor Stone model
In Summary
Page 36 of 46
Standard Compliance by Virgin Soft Drinks
Generally all firms hold cash and
marketable securities
Virgin holds only cash
Firms hold cash and marketable
securities for some reasons like
bull Cash for transactions
bull Cash and near-cash assets as
hedges
bull Temporary investments
bull Compensating balances
Virgin holds cash only for
two reasons ndash
bull Cash for transactions
bull Cash as hedges
Available money market instruments Virgin does not invest in any such
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
(short term securities) are ndash
Treasury Bills
Commercial Paper
Certificates of Deposit
Bankerrsquos Acceptance
Repurch menase Agree ts
instruments They only keep cash in
Bank Account
Mail Float
(1 to 5 days)
At Firm
Float
(025 to 1
day)
Clearing
Float
(0 to
2 days)
Mail Float
(2 to 3 days)
At firm
Float
(025
day)
Clearing
Float
(1 to 3
days)
Figure Transit time for a typical check Figure Transit time for a check for
Virgin
Strategies that firms can use to reduce
the delay in receiving funds are ndash
Selecting of Banks with
accelerated clearing capabilities
of check processing Acceleration
at the firm
ectronic collection Use of el
procedures
Use of lockboxes
Virgin follows the first three strategies
but does not use lockboxes
Available cash concentration
mechanisms are ndash
Depository transfer check
ouse Automated Clearing H
(ACH) electronic transfer)
Wire transfer
Virgin uses all these mechanisms of
cash concentration
Available sets of techniques for cash
disbursement management are ndash
ement of disbursement
Page 37 of 46
Manag
float
Virgin uses zero-balance accounts
technique
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Zero-Balance Accounts
Controlled disbursing
Firms may make cash flow forecasts
over periods of various lengths yearly
flows quarterly flows monthly flows
weekly flows or even daily flows
Virgin forecasts cash on yearly basis and
monthly basis
Cash forecasting system may involve ndash
Distribution
Scheduling
Virginrsquos cash forecasting system
involves a combination of distribution
and scheduling
Two common approaches to cash flow
in generating the cash forecast
and disbursement Receipts
approach
Adjusted net income approach
Virgin uses the receipts and
disbursement approach
There are many items to forecast Virgin forecasts only major items like
AR payroll etc
Four common approach to forecasting
fina i ndash nc al variables are
Spot method
Proportion to another account
Compounded growth
Multiple dependencies
Virgin uses spot method for forecasting
cash It uses proportion to another
account method for other variables and
remaining two methods are frequently
used
Sources of uncertainty in cash
forecasting are ndash
Sales uncertainty
Collection rate uncertainty
Production cost uncertainty
Capital outflow uncertainty
Virgin faces uncertainty mainly from
sales and production cost
Methods for hedging cash balance
unc a
Page 38 of 46
ert inties are ndash
i) Holding a stock of extra cash
Virgin two available methods for
hedging cash balance uncertainties
Th ese are ndash
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
ii) stock of near-cash Holding a
assets
iii) Extra borrowing capacity
iv) ary surpluses in Investing tempor
near-cash assets
i) Holding a stock of extra cash
ii) Extra borrowing capacity
(advance receipt from
customers)
Models for the management of cash and
temporary investments are ndash Baumol
model Beranek model Miller-Orr
model and Stone model
Virgin does not follow any method
wholly but a combination of Baumol
model and Beranek model is occurred
82 INVENTORY MANAGEMENT
21 Certainty Approach
isnt used in
irgin because it thinks it is not possible to implement in Bangladesh
d time is one to three days It
oes not use ABC system of inventory management
8
Main item of inventory of Virgin is Can pet chip sugar label chemical artificial
sweet etc Virgin maintains a minimum level of inventory but it does not have to face
problems because inventory is managed efficiently just-in-time (JIT)
V
Virgin maintains buffer stock because of the shortage of work-in-process (WIP)
inventory Its production process may also be hampered Thats why it maintains
safety stock to avoid stock out cost In case of imported goods normal lead time is
about one month and within the country normal lea
d
Page 39 of 46
Inventory Model
In reality Virgin does not use any of models of EOQ ordering and holding strategy
and safety stock strategy They maintain inventory based on their prior experience
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
822 Uncertainty Approach
Virgin does not use any model for handling inventory uncertainty It says that such
decision depends on business cycle and market situation Long before Eid festival
they bought large amount of sugar because of price increase on the occasion of Eid
In summary
Standard Compliance by Virgin Soft Drinks
Firms maintain inventory to guard
against several problems
Virgin maintains a minimum level of
inventory which is managed efficiently
Some firms use JIT to avoid inventory
cost
JIT is not used by Virgin as it thinks it is
impossible to implement in Bangladesh
Firms maintain buffer stock Virgin maintains buffer stock too
Firms maintain safety stock to avoid
shortage cost
Virgin also maintains safety stock
Firms use ABC system to monitor
inventory
Virgin doesnt use ABC system
EOQ model is an appropriate method
for measuring quantity that has to be
ordered per order
Virgin does not use EOQ model rather
makes order based on experience and
market demand
83 MANAGING ACCOUNTS RECEIVABLE (DEBTORS)
831 Terms of Sale Decision
Page 40 of 46
Virgin offers the term 210 net 30 enables the customers to deduct 2 percent from the
face value of the bill when paying within the first 10 days but if the discount is not
taken the customer must remit the full amount within 30 days But Virgin does not
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
offer the same terms of sale to all customers For prime customers it offers special
terms of sale In setting an appropriate term of sale it costs and benefits regarding
this are compared It uses the standard approach of terms of sale decision as it is
simple to use
832 Credit Granting Decisions
In case of Virgin the Capital and Character of Five Cs get more importance
Although there are many problems with the traditional approach Virgin uses it
because of its simplicity Virgin does not use Net Present Value (NPV) method in
credit granting decision It thinks that NPV is an appropriate method and should be
used next time It does not face any severe problem because of bad debts The reason
is that notes receivable is used when credit is granted
833 Monitoring Accounts Receivable
Virgin monitors its accounts receivable Virgin believes that in any case both positive
and negative durations in accounts signal differences from the results that
management believe to be the most advantageous for the firm
Tools for Monitoring Accounts Receivable
Page 41 of 46
For monitoring accounts receivable there are several tools such as aging schedule
the ratios of receivable outstanding to original sales customers payment proportion
and sales weighted DSO (Days Sales Outstanding) For monitoring accounts
receivable Virgin uses aging schedule fractions and traditional DSO statistics
because of their simplicity in use Although payment proportions ratios of
receivables outstanding and sales weighted DSO methods are free from inherent bias
None of these is used because all these are complex to maintain
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
In summary
Page 42 of 46
Standard Compliance by Virgin Soft Drinks
Generals terms of sale is 210 net 30 Normally Virgin also use general terms
of sale ie 210 net 30
Firms do not offer the same terms of
sale to all customers
Yes For prime customers Virgin offers
special terms of sale
Approaches of terms of sale decisions
are ndash
bull Standard approach
bull Multi period approach
Virgin uses standard approach of terms
of sale decision as it is simple to use and
understand
Source of credit information are ndash
Sellers prior experience with the
customer
Credit agency ratings and
reports
Personal contact with the
applicants bank and other
creditors
Analysis of applicants financial
statements
Customer visit
Main source of credit information to
Virgin is its prior experience with the
customer All other sources are not cost-
effective for Virgin
Approaches of credit granting to
marginal accounts are ndash
Traditional approach
Net Present Value (NPV)
approach
It uses traditional approach still now but
thinks that NPV should be used for the
next periods
Firms monitor accounts receivable
because deviations from the expected
levels of turnover and of bad debt can
Virgin also monitors its accounts
receivable
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
signal several different problems
Different tools for monitoring accounts
receivable are ndash
Aging schedule
Ratios of receivables
outstanding to original sales
Customers payment
proportions
Sales-weighted DSO
For monitoring accounts receivable
Virgin uses aging schedule and
traditional sales outstanding statistics
84 MANAGING ACCOUNTS PAYABLE (CREDITORS)
Virgin has almost accounts payable of Tk 8000000 But most of its liabilities are to
the banks rather than suppliers But we dont have any clear information about
Virgins accounts payable
9 RECOMMENDATION
Virgin should invest its surplus cash in short term marketable securities
because it is suitable hedging against cash uncertainties and will also give
some returns (interest income)
Virgin should publish its own annual report which will satisfy information
needs of stakeholders and also increase the credibility of information provided
by Virgin
Page 43 of 46
Virgin should use multi period approach in terms of sale decision because
standard approach which is already exists in Virgin has some inherent
problems
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
It should stop using traditional approach from now It should use NPV
method in credit granting to marginal accounts
In monitoring accounts receivable Virgin should use sales-weighted DSO
method because it has least limitation compared to the others
It should be more flexible in granting credit which will ultimately increase its
sales
To get the appropriate number of quantity to be ordered per order it should
use DSO model
It should be ABC system for proper monitoring of inventory
10 CONCLUSION
The use of other peoples money in business is usually an expensive resource Before
looking outside for finance a firm should examine its own working capital cycle to
make sure that every rand of its own internal funds is being fully utilized Good
management of working capital is part of good financial management Effective use
of working capital will contribute to the operational efficiency of the whole
organization optimum use will help to generate maximum returns Furthermore
working capital management is not an end in itself It is an integral part of the firms
overall management The needs of efficient working capital management must be
considered in relation to other aspects of the Virgins financial and non-financial
performance Thats why when planning the development of a business it is critical
that the impact of working capital be fully assessed
Page 44 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
BIBLIOGRAPHY
Scherr FC (1989) International Edition Prentice-Hall International Inc Modern
Working Capital Management Text and Cases
Hussain Riaz (2002) Working Capital Management
Robertson Lonnie (July 1998) Inventory Management
httpwwwasashoporg visited on March 13 2006
The Art of Cash Management
httpwwwinccom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management
httpwwwstudyfinancecom visited on March 13 2006
White Paper ndash Managing Working Capital
httpwwwplanwareorg visited on March 13 2006
Management of Working Capital
httpwwwbusinesscentralcoza visited on March 13 2006
Cash Management
httpwwwsbagov visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management Objectives
httpwpsprenhallcom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management
Page 45 of 46
httpwwwadvancemecom visited on March 13 2006
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Business Receivables Financing
httpwwwbbtcom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Finance
http wwwfnbcoza visited on March 13 2006
Tips to manage your working capital
httpsmallbusinessninemsncomau visited on March 13 2006
Inventory Financing
httpwwwfranklincapitalnetworkcom visited on March 13 2006
Accounts Receivable Management
httpwwwfranklincapitalnetworkcom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management
httpwwwtreasurygovtnz visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management
httpwwwtreasurystrategiescom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Works
httpwwwinvestopediacom visited on March 13 2006
Treasury Services
httpwwwjpmorganchasecom visited on March 13 2006
what were about
Page 46 of 46
httpwwwvirgincom visited on March 13 2006
Annexure
Annexure
Interview with YASEER RIZVI
Mr Yaseer Rizvi the DMD of Global Beverage Co Ltd obtained his MBA degree
from a reputed university He had been the Director of Ocean Container Ltd before
joining in Global Beverage Co Ltd He possesses a nice personality
I interviewed Yaseer Rizvi Excerpts from his interview are as follows ndash
Shah Kamal Sir would you please tell me do you invest in short term marketable securities
Yaseer Rizvi Basically we do not invest our surplus cash in short term marketable
securities like T-Bill commercial paper certificate of deposit etc But we keep our
surplus cash in Bank
Shah Kamal Would you tell me something about transit time for a typical check
Yaseer Rizvi Well in Virgin the transit time for a typical check is ndash
For mail float 2 to 3 days
At firm float 6 hours
Clearing float 1 to 3 days
Shah Kamal Do you maintain any cash concentration mechanism like depository transfer check automated clearing house and wire transfer
i
Annexure
Yaseer Rizvi Our position in this case is very strong as we use all the mechanisms
you mentioned As Virgin is a firm with small deposits spread over a substantial
number of banks so we tend to use depository transfer checks extensively It is less
costly We also use automated clearing house and wire transfer but later is used in a
less extent
Shah Kamal Sir what techniques of disbursement management is used by your firm
Yaseer Rizvi Like other firms Virgin tries to retain the cash for as long as possible
But we always perform it in an ethical manner We do not use management of
disbursement float as it seems unethical We follow Zero-Balance Accounts method
for managing disbursement We do not prefer Controlled Disbursing method since
Zero-Balance system is already practiced in Virgin
Shah Kamal How do you hedge cash balance uncertainties
Yaseer Rizvi Well you may say that we do not invest in short term securities but for
facing cash difficulties we keep our surplus cash in bank
Shah Kamal Sir would you please tell me the general terms of sale of Virgin
Yaseer Rizvi Though it is difficult to maintain a fixed terms of sale our general terms
of sale is 210 n30 But for prime customers we offer special terms of sale
Shah Kamal What are the sources of credit information in case of your firm
Yaseer Rizvi We grant credit on the basis of prior experience with the customers In
case of a new customer personal contact is weighted
Shah Kamal Does your firm consider 5 Cs in granting credit
ii
Annexure
Yaseer Rizvi In case of Virgin Capital and Character get more importance than the
others Mind one thing personal relationship is the main measure in granting credit
Shah Kamal Do you use NPV method in credit granting decisions
Yaseer Rizvi We do not use NPV method But we think that NPV is a suitable
method and we have to use it from the next period
Shah Kamal Sir how do you handle the problem of bad debt
Yaseer Rizvi Well in this case our position is very strong Yet we do not face any
problem because of bad debt Just note that we make more than 80 of sales in cash
and we monitor accounts receivable very carefully
Shah Kamal What level of inventory is maintained by Virgin
Yaseer Rizvi We maintain a minimum level of inventory but do not have to face
stock out problems because inventory is managed efficiently
Shah Kamal What is the normal lead time
Yaseer Rizvi In case of imported goods normal lead time is about 1 month and when
we purchase raw materials from inside the country lead time is 1 to 3 days
Shah Kamal What method do you use for managing inventory
Yaseer Rizvi We do not use any method particularly rather inventory decision
depends on business cycle and market situation Long before the Eid festival we
bought large amount of sugar because price of sugar was increased on the occasion
of Eid
iii
Annexure
Shah Kamal What are the main items of inventory of your firm
Yaseer Rizvi Well these are ndash aluminum can pet chip sugar label chemical and
artificial sweet
Shah Kamal What are the uncertainties in maintaining appropriate level of stock
Yaseer Rizvi These are ndash
bull Increase in price of raw materials
bull Sales uncertainty
bull Market trends etc
Shah Kamal Thank you for your kind cooperation
Yaseer Rizvi Most Welcome
iv
Global Beverage Company Limited
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
b) Automated Clearing House (ACH) Electronic Transfer
This vehicle is essentially an electronic version of the depository transfer
check and can be used between banks that participate in the automated
clearing house system
c) Wire Transfer
These are electronic message between banks
Decisions regarding concentration mechanism usually hinge on the size and
spread of the firmrsquos deposits Firms with small deposits spread over a
substantial number of banks will tend to have more extensive concentration
systems and will transfer among accounts using low-cost transfer vehicles that
offer only delayed availability (such as depository transfer checks) Firms with
larger deposits will have fewer accounts (since a local deposit for transfer to
an upstream bank is not needed) and will use more expensive and more rapid
transfer mechanisms (such as wire transfers) The concentration systems of
major chemical companies for example tend to be structured in this way ndash
DepositoryLockbox Banks
Regional Concentration Banks
Central Concentrated Bank
Figure A typical Cash Concentration System
(Arrows indicate transfers of collected funds)
Page 12 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Disbursement management addresses the efficient payout out of this cash once it is
concentrated The firmrsquos objective in disbursement management is to retain the cash
for as long as possible In this way the firm will have the maximum amount of funds
available for investment and transactional purposes Certainly this management
means making disbursement only when they are due and not before The firm has
several available set of techniques for disbursement management Included among
these are ndash
a) Management of Disbursement Float
In this set of techniques the disbursing firm attempts to increase the length of
time between the mailing of its checks and the eventual withdrawal of funds
from the banks This involves strategies for increasing mail float at firm float
and clearing float on its outgoing checks For example the disbursing firm
may intentionally address checks to the firmrsquos office address rather than its
lockbox creating at firm float
b) Zero-Balance Accounts
Here the firm holds the cash until the check arrive (or expected to arrive) at
the disbursement bank In this strategy an account for disbursement is first
established at a bank For the zero-balance system to be effective the
participating bank must be one on which most disbursement are made via the
Bangladesh Bankrsquos clearance system (which presents disbursements to banks
early in the morning) and not a bank where disbursements occur throughout
the day (as with a major money-center bank) Consequently the banks used
in zero-balance strategies are usually branches of major banks and not their
main locations
Page 13 of 46
c) Controlled Disbursing
In this system the firm projects the amount of checks to arrive each day at the
disbursement bank (based on the checks written in previous days and historic
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
statistics on disbursement float) and transfers the amount of the expected
checks to the account on that day or just before
5315 Cash Forecasting
Defining Cash Forecasting
The cash forecast is an estimation of the flows in and out of the firmrsquos cash account
over a particular period of time usually a quarter month week or day The cash
forecast is primarily intended to produce a very useful piece of information an
estimation of the firmrsquos borrowing and lending needs and uncertainties regarding
these needs during various future periods Cash forecasting is very crucial to most
firms It enables them to anticipate periods of surplus cash and periods where
financing will be necessary This anticipation is the reason that cash forecasts are
generated Anticipation enables the firm to plan much more effectively for
investment and financing and via this planning produce superior return
Types of Cash Forecasts
The types of cash forecasts generated by firms can be differentiated along two
dimensions the length of the periods included within the cash forecast and the approach
to cash flows used in the cash forecast The length of the period refers to the units of
time into which the cash forecast is divided Firms may make cash flow forecasts
over periods of various lengths yearly flows quarterly flows monthly flows weekly
flows or even daily flows The most popular forecast involves monthly flows but
most firms do not confine themselves to a single forecast Instead they use several
forecasts with periods of various lengths When the firm makes forecasts involving
multiple and overlapping period lengths one forecast relates to another Starting
with data on relatively long periods and breaking it down into smaller periods is
called distribution starting with data on relatively short periods and aggregating into
longer periods is called scheduling
Page 14 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Firms use two common approaches to cash flows in generating the cash forecast the
receipts and disbursements approach and the adjusted net income approach The receipts
and disbursements approach use the amounts of cash expected to be received and
disbursed by the firm over the periods chosen for forecast The adjusted income
statement approach is sometimes called the sources and use approach Here the
forecaster starts with projected net income on an accrual basis and adjusts to a cash
basis This method provides a representation of changes in asset and liability
accounts since the level of these accounts are of interest to the firm this aspect of the
adjusted income statement is an advantage over the receipts and disbursements
method
Items to Be Forecast
In the receipt and disbursements cash forecasting method estimates need to be made
of the numerous major and minor items that the firm collects (receipts) and that it
pays (disbursements) The more individual categories of items the firm includes in its
forecast procedure the more accurate the forecast may be but the more costly in
terms of time and effort it will be to generate
Some Possible Types of Cash Receipts and Cash Disbursements
Cash Disbursements Cash Receipts
Cash Purchases of Materials Payroll
Taxes
Maturing Accounts Payable
Maturing Notes Payable
Miscellaneous Disbursements
Accounts Receivable
Notes Receivable
Rental Income
Interest Income
Miscellaneous Receipts
Methods of Financial Forecasting
Page 15 of 46
Financial forecasting is the estimation of the future level of a financial variable often
a cash flow asset level or liability level It is usually assumed that the relationship
between the financial variable and other variable is linear The general linear model
can then be used
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
nnt xaxaxaaY 22110 ++=
Here
= Financial variable (Y) to be forecast in period t tY
x = Explanatory variable it is assumed to cause the level of Y in period t
0a = Represents a constant unaffected by the x
The other terms are the estimated coefficients of the explanatory x variables
There are n terms with xrsquos in them
There are four common approaches to forecasting financial variables but they
are all special cases of the general linear model These are ndash spot method proportion
to another account compounded growth and multiple dependencies
Using Cash Forecast
The estimate of available funds for investment and needed financing enables the firm
to plan so as to obtain the most advantages borrowing terms for deficits and achieve
the greatest interest income on surplus A useful chart for this planning purpose is a
bar chart eg
Figure Bar Chart of Cash Surpluses and Deficits from hypothetical data
Page 16 of 46
75
50
-60
30
100
-20
-80-60-40-20
020406080
100120
Defic
it
S
urpl
us
January February March April May June
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Sources of Uncertainty in Cash Forecasting and Hedging Uncertainties
There are numerous sources of risk in cash forecasting Among the sources are sales
uncertainty collection rate uncertainty production cost uncertainty and capital
outflow uncertainty
5316 Models for the Management of Cash and Temporary Investments
There are different models for the management of cash and temporary investments
Among these the most popular methods are ndash Baumol model Beranek model
Miller-Orr model and Stone model
Baumol and Beranek use the same model The formula is cited below ndash
Interest Income = iYn
n⎥⎦⎤
⎢⎣⎡ minus
21
Profit = naiYn
nminus⎥⎦
⎤⎢⎣⎡ minus
21
Optimum number of transactions = ⎟⎠⎞
⎜⎝⎛
aiY2
Where n = Optimum number of transactions
i = Interest rate per period
a = Transaction cost
Y = Total inflow for the period
Page 17 of 46
Miller-Orr and Stone use the same model ie R-Statistic The model is ndash
31
43
iav
R ⎟⎠⎞
⎜⎝⎛=
Optimum Control Limit = R + L
Upper Control Limit = 3R + L
Where a = Transaction Cost
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
v = Variance of daily cash flows
i = Daily interest rate
5317 Administration
Cash receipts should be processed and banked as quickly as possible because
They cannot earn interest or reduce overdraft until they are banked
information about the existence and amounts of cash receipts is usually not
available until they are processed
Where possible cash floats (mainly petty cash and advances) should be avoided If
on review the only reason that can be put forward for their existence is that weve
always had them they should be discontinued There may be situations where they
are useful however For example it may be desirable for peripheral parts of
departments to meet urgent local needs from cash floats rather than local bank
accounts
5318 Internal Control
Cash and cash management is part of a firms overall internal control system The
main internal cash control is invariably the bank reconciliation This provides
assurance that the cash balances recorded in the accounting systems are consistent
with the actual bank balances It requires regular clearing of reconciling items
5319 Practicing Good Cash Flow Management
Good cash management is simple It involves
Knowing when where and how firms cash needs will occur
Page 18 of 46
Knowing the best sources for meeting additional cash needs
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Page 19 of 46
Being prepared to meet these needs when they occur by keeping good
relationships with bankers and other creditors
532 INVENTORY MANAGEMENT
Inventory management is necessary for owners who want to maintain a stocking
service for quick turnaround to help ensure total customer satisfaction The fill rate
of an item on a managed inventory list must be maintained to avoid shortages of
frequently used items Even when utilizing an inventory management system
occasional shortages will still occur Inventories are lists of stocks-raw materials
work in progress or finished goods-waiting to be consumed in production or to be
sold The total balance of inventory is the sum of the value of each individual stock
line
Basically firms hold stocks for the following reasons
To act as a buffer in times of unusually high demand
To ensure continuity of production
Avoid high costs of emergency orders
To take advantage of quantity discounts by ordering more at a time
To reduce ordering costs by ordering more items on fewer
As part of the production process eg maturing whisky or keeping oil in
pipelines
Seasonality of demand (eg firework) or supplies
Suppliers insist on minimum order quantities
The key issue for a business is to identify the fast and slow stock movers with the
objectives of establishing optimum stock levels for each category and thereby
minimize the cash tied up in stocks Factors to be considered when determining
optimum stock levels include
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Page 20 of 46
What are the projected sales of each product
How widely available are raw materials components etc
How long does it take for delivery by suppliers
Can the firm remove slow movers from its product range without
compromising best sellers
Inventory management is an important aspect of working capital management
because inventories themselves do not earn any revenue Holding either too little or
too much inventory incurs costs
Costs of carrying too much inventory are
Opportunity cost of foregone interest
Warehousing costs
Damage and pilferage
Obsolescence
Insurance
Costs of carrying too little inventory are
Stock out costs
Lost sales
Delayed service
Ordering costs
Freight
on Order administrati
nts
Loss of quantity discou
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Carrying costs can be minimized by making frequent small orders but this increase
ordering costs and the risk of stock outs Risk of stock-outs can be reduced by
carrying safety stocks (at a cost) and re-ordering ahead of time
The best ordering strategy requires balancing the various cost factors to ensure the
firm incurs minimum inventory costs The optimum inventory position is known as
the Economic Reorder Quantity (ERQ)
Nowadays many large manufacturers operate on a just-in-time (JIT) basis whereby
all the components to be assembled on a particular today arrive at the factory early
that morning no earlier - no later This helps to minimize manufacturing costs as JIT
stocks take up little space minimize stock-holding and virtually eliminate the risks of
obsolete or damaged stock Because JIT manufacturers hold stock for a very short
time they are able to conserve substantial cash JIT is a good model to strive for as it
embraces all the principles of prudent stock management For better stock control
firm may try the following
Review the effectiveness of existing purchasing and inventory systems
Know the stock turn for all major items of inventory
Apply tight controls to the significant few items and simplify controls for the
trivial many
Sell off outdated or slow moving merchandise - it gets more difficult to sell the
longer the firm keeps it
Consider having part of its product outsourced to another manufacturer rather
than make it itself
Review its security procedures to ensure that no stock is going out the back
door
Higher than necessary stock levels tie up cash and cost more in insurance
accommodation costs and interest charges
Page 21 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
However it is important to keep an overall perspective It is not cost-effective to
closely manage a large number of low value inventory lines nor is it necessary A
usual feature of inventories is that a small number of high value lines account for a
large proportion of inventory value The 8020 rule (PARETO) predicts that 80
of the total value of inventory is represented by only 20 of the number of inventory
items Those high value lines need reasonably close management The remaining
80 of inventory lines can be managed using broad-brush strategies
533 MANAGING ACCOUNTS RECEIVABLE (DEBTORS)
Cash flow can be significantly enhanced if the amounts owing to a business are
collected faster Every business needs to know who owes them money how much is
owed how long it is owing for what it is owed
Debtors (Accounts Receivable) are customers who have not yet made payment for
goods or services which the department has provided The objective of debtor
management is to minimize the time-lapse between completion of sales and receipt
of payment The costs of having debtors are
Opportunity costs (cash is not available for other purposes)
Bad debts
If firm doesnt manage debtors they will begin to manage business as the firm will gradually
lose control due to reduced cash flow and of course it could experience an increased
incidence of bad debt The following measures will help manage debtors
Having the right mental attitude to the control of credit and make sure that it
gets the priority it deserves
Establishing clear credit practices as a matter of company policy
Page 22 of 46
Making sure that these practices are clearly understood by staff suppliers and
customers
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Page 23 of 46
Being professional when accepting new accounts and especially larger ones
Checking out each customer thoroughly before the firm offers credit Use
credit agencies bank references industry sources etc
Establishing credit limits for each customer and sticking to them
Continuously reviewing these limits when it suspects tough times are coming
or if operating in a volatile sector
Keeping very close to the firms larger customers
Invoicing promptly and clearly
Considering charging penalties on overdue accounts
Considering accepting credit debit cards as a payment option
Monitoring its debtor balances and ageing schedules and dont let any debts
get too large or too old
Debtor management includes both pre-sale and debt collection strategies
Pre-sale strategies include
Offering cash discounts for early payment andor imposing penalties for late
payment
Agreeing payment terms in advance
Requiring cash before delivery
Setting credit limits
ning credit Setting criteria for obtai
Billing as early as possible
rogress payments
ost-sale strategies include
for collecting the debt upon the center that made the sale
Requiring deposits andor p
P
Placing the responsibility
Identifying long overdue balances and doubtful debts by regular analytical reviews
Having an established procedure for late collections such as
A reminder
A letter
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Page 24 of 46
ion of further credit Cancellat
Telephone calls
n agency Use of a collectio
he firm should recognize that the longer someone owes firm the greater the chance
Legal action
T
it will never get paid If the average age of debtors is getting longer or is already very
long it may need to look for the following possible defects
Weak credit judgment
res Poor collection procedu
ms Lax enforcement of credit ter
Slow issue of invoices or statements
Errors in invoices or statements
Customer dissatisfaction
Debtors due over 90 days (unless within agreed credit terms) should generally
demand immediate attention For example warning signs of a future bad debt ndash
Longer credit terms taken with approval particularly for smaller orders
Use of post-dated checks by debtors who normally settle within agreed terms
Evidence of customers switching to additional suppliers for the same goods
New customers who are reluctant to give credit references
Cre G
Receiving part payments from debtors
dit ranting to Marginal Accounts
Traditional Approach
In the traditional approach to the credit granting decision it is the credit analysts job
rmation that has been collected and reach a judgment
regarding the applicants creditworthiness One traditional way of organizing this
to synthesize all the info
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
information is by characterizing the applicant along five dimensions These
dimensions are called the Five Cs of credit ndash
Capital
Character
Collateral
and Capacity
Conditions
Net Present Value (NPV) Approach
Once a firm has assessed the creditworthiness of a customer it has to decide whether
r not credit should be granted The firm should use the NPV rule to make the
ld be granted
Figure
o
decision If NPV is positive credit shou
Credit Granting Decision
Credit Granting Decision
he act of collecting money is one which most people dislike for many reasons and
therefore put on the long f selves there is something
ore urgent or important that demands their attention now There is nothing more
T
inger because they convince them
m
important than getting paid for firms product or service A customer who does not
Page 25 of 46
Grand Credit
Payment received Payment not received
Benefit of present value of future net cash flow
Cost of present value ment of lost invest
Net Payoff PV of benefit-cost
No Credit
No Payoff
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
pay is not a customer Here are a few ideas that may help the firm in collecting
money from debtors
Firm should develop appropriate procedures for handling late payments
It should track and pursue late payers
It might get external help if its own efforts fail
or money its firms and it is entitled Company shouldnt feel guilty asking f
to it
ction
Firm must make that call now And it should keep asking until it gets some
satisfa
lessens the problem
In difficult circumstances take what the firm can now and agree terms for the
remainder It
paying
When asking for money be hard on the issue - but soft on the person It shouldnt
give the debtor any excuses for not
534 BLE (CREDITORS)
ices for goods or services have
een paid Organizations often regard the
not
to delay all payments until the latest possible date Regular weekly or
The firm make it its objective is to get the money - not to score points or get
even
MANAGING ACCOUNTS PAYA
Creditors (Accounts Payable) are suppliers whose invo
been processed but who have not yet b
amount owing to creditors as a source of free credit However creditor
administration systems are expensive and time-consuming to run The over-riding
concern in this area should be to minimize costs with simple procedures
While it is unnecessary to pay accounts before they fall due it is usually
worthwhile
Page 26 of 46
fortnightly payment of all due accounts is the simplest technique for creditor
management
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Electronic payments (direct credits) are cheaper than check payments considering
that transaction fees and overheads more than balance the advantage of delayed
presentation Some suppliers are reluctant to receive payments by this method but in
view of the substantial cost advantage (and the advantages to the suppliers
themselves) departments may wish to encourage suppliers to accept this option
However electronic payments are likely to be used in conjunction with rather than
as a replacement for check payments
Applying Best Practices in Managing Accounts Payable
f course simply deferring payments to suppliers could have adverse consequences
O
that more than offset the benefits of this additional cash flow Therefore it is
important to develop a holistic approach The firm should consider the following
best practices for payables management
Managing payment dates and terms to maximize cash flow ndash
y reporting on
receivable and
id penalty charges and taking advantage of
wer vendors and negotiate for more
to buying consortia with others even
voices for
payment based on receipt of goods or receipt of invoice whichever
comes later
Calculating and setting performance targets Regularl
AP performance measures such as days in payables
Coordinating the AP processes with accounts
inventory management to ensure that the company is collecting more
cash than it is paying out
Paying bills on time to avo
prompt-payment discounts where the discounts exceed the companyrsquos
cost of working capital
Consolidating purchases with fe
favorable payment terms
Considering entering in
Page 27 of 46
competitors to obtain favorable supplier pricing and terms
Unless contract terms specify otherwise setting up in
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Page 28 of 46
Em
process
-time payments with Electronic Funds Transfer (EFT)
uraging vendors to utilize electronic invoice presentment
a
ndancies and more
ploying technology to automate the accounts payable transaction
es ndash
Making just-in
Using an electronic invoice-matching application
Enco
For companies with multiple locations or business units employing
shared service approach for AP to eliminate redu
quickly implement process improvements
Mainta
vendor
Communicating accounts payable requirements to suppliers at the
m key suppliers
for suggestions on how to improve the
Efficient a
and making th rsquos cash is just good business
ining open communications and building strong relationships with
s to access valuable trade credit ndash
beginning of transactions
Requesting summary invoicing fro
Requiring suppliers to send invoices directly to accounts payable
Asking tier-one suppliers
payment process
nd effective management of accounts payable helps improve cash flow ndash
e most of company
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
6 OVERVIEW OF VIRGIN GROUP
Virgin - one of the most respected brands in Britain - is now becoming the first global
brand name of the 21st century Virgin is involved in planes trains finance soft
drinks music mobile phones holidays cars wines publishing bridal wear - the lot
What tie all these businesses together are the values of its brand and the attitude of its
people Virgin has created over 200 companies worldwide employing over 25000
people Its total revenues around the world in 2002 exceeded pound4 billion (US $72
billion)
In 1970 Richard Branson founded Virgin as a mail order record retailer and not
long after he opened a record shop in Oxford Street London During 1972 a
recording studio was built in Oxfordshire and the first Virgin artist Mike Oldfield
recorded Tubular Bells which was released in 1973
This album went on to sell over 5 million copies Since then many household names
including Belinda Carlisle Genesis Phil Collins Janet Jackson and The Rolling
Stones have helped to make Virgin Music one of the top six record companies in the
world The equity of Virgin Music Group - record labels music publishing and
recording studios was sold to THORN EMI in 1992 in a US$1billion deal
Page 29 of 46
The Virgin Group has now expanded into international music Mega stores air
travel mobile financial retail music internet drinks rail hotels and leisure with
around 200 companies in over 30 countries
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
In Virgins customers eyes Virgin stands for value for money quality innovation
fun and a sense of competitive challenge It delivers a quality service by empowering
its employees and facilitates and monitors customer feedback to continually improve
the customers experience through innovation
When they start a new venture Virgin bases it on hard research and analysis
Typically they review the industry and put themselves in the customers shoes to see
what could make it better Virgin asks fundamental questions
Is this an opportunity for restructuring a market and creating competitive
advantage What are the competitors doing
Is the customer confused or badly served
Is this an opportunity for building the Virgin brand
Can we add value
Will it interact with its other businesses
Is there an appropriate trade-off between risk and reward
Page 30 of 46
Virgin is also able to draw on talented people from throughout the group New
ventures are often steered by people seconded from other parts of Virgin who bring
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
with them the trademark management style skills and experience Virgin frequently
creates partnerships with others to combine skills knowledge and market presence
and so on Contrary to what some people may think their constantly expanding and
eclectic empire is neither random nor reckless Each successive venture demonstrates
its skill in picking the right market and the right opportunity
7 OVERVIEW OF VIRGIN SOFT DRINKS
The Virgin Drinks Group first launched as the Virgin Cola Company in 1994 with
Virgin Cola in the UK Since then the company has ventured across the carbonated
soft drinks arena and beyond into energy drinks tea and flavored Colas This
expansion has lead to the evolution of the Virgin Drinks Company a company
whose aim is to put the excitement back into the world of soft drinks It launched in
Bangladesh in 1999 Virgin Soft Drinks is monitored by Global Beverage Co Ltd in
Bangladesh
Brief history of Virgin Drinks is given below
Page 31 of 46
1994 November Virgin Cola launched in the UK
1996 March Virgin Cola launched in France
1998 June Virgin Cola launched in Belgium
April Virgin Cola launched in the French West Indies
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
August Virgin Cola launched in Switzerland
1999 March Virgin Colours launched in Italy
March Virgin Cola launched in Japan
July Virgin Colours launched in South Africa
December Virgin Colours launched in Bangladesh
2001 January Sweden launched Virgin Colours
November Singapore launched Virgin Colours
2002 February Croatia launched Virgin Colours
June Russia launched Virgin Colours
June Tunisia launched Virgin Colours
2003 May Israel launched Virgin Colours
8 FINDINGS OF WORKING CAPITAL MANAGEMENT MAINTAINED BY
VIRGIN SOFT DRINKS IN BANGLADESH
81 CASH MANAGEMENT
811 Holding Cash and Marketable Securities
Although there are many good reasons why firm hold cash and marketable
securities Virgin Drinks holds cash and marketable securities for two reasons ndash
i) Cash for transactions
ii) Cash as hedges
This indicates that the firm does not hold cash and marketable securities for some
important reasons such as ndash
i) Near cash assets as hedges
Page 32 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
ii) Temporary investment and compensating balances
Virgin Soft Drinks does not invest in money market securities such as Treasury bill
commercial paper certificate of deposits bankerrsquos acceptance and repurchase
agreement This firm deposits its money in bank as currant AC or fixed AC They
say that they do not have enough money to invest in money market instrument
They also say that if they have enough money they will invest it in money market
short term securities We know that near cash interest earning assets can be
substituted for cash when motivation for holding these assets is the hedging of cash
flow uncertainties or is the temporary investment of surplus funds In this point
Virgins position is not good as there is no significant hedging against uncertainty of
cash
812 Floatation and Check Clearing
Virgin is very smart in handling the problem of transit time for checks Here mail
float takes 2 to 3 days at firm takes 025 day and clearing float takes 1-3 days Virgin
uses most of the strategies available for reducing the delay in receiving funds It
(Virgin) has linked Islami Bank which posses an accelerated clearing facility It uses
electronic collection process which ensures faster collection and its at the firm check
processing is satisfactory But Virgin does not use lockbox The reason behind this is
that it is not cost-effective for Virgin to set lockboxes At this point we can say that
Virgins check clearing mechanism is much good
813 Cash Concentration and Disbursement Management
Page 33 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks takes the matter of cash concentration very seriously They use all
the available cash concentration mechanism Virgin is a firm with small deposits
spread over a substantial number of banks and this is why the firm tends to use
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
depository transfer checks extensively If is less costly Virgin also uses automated
clearing house and wire transfer To Virgin wire transfer seems too costly
Like other firm Virgin tries to retain the cash for as long as possible But Virgin
always performs it in an ethical manner Virgin does not try to defeat the receiving
firmrsquos attempts to reduce the float on incoming checks It does not take any strategy
for increasing mail float at firm float and clearing float on its outgoing checks To
Virgin it is deemed to be unethical It thinks that maximization of disbursement float
will not go unnoticed by sophisticated creditors for very long When it is noticed it
will negatively affect relations with these creditors reducing the firmrsquos bargaining
power with them This may ultimately cost Virgin dearly when future prices and
delivery schedules for goods and services purchased from trade creditors are
negotiated Virgin follows ldquoZero-Balance Accountsrdquo methods for managing
disbursement It thinks that in this method the coordination of funds inflows to
disbursement banks with the presentation of checks does not work to the detriment
of creditors since the firmrsquos checks to them are honored as presented and this strategy
does not affect float significantly Controlled disbursing method is less attractive to
Virgin because zero-balance system is already feasible
814 Cash Forecasting
Cash Forecasting and Its Types
Page 34 of 46
Virgin forecasts the future cash inflows and outflows To Virgin cash forecast is an
important part of the firmrsquos cash control system and is one of the forecasts that are
part of the Virginrsquos financial plan Virgin forecasts cash on monthly basis and on
yearly basis Virgin does not forecast on daily basis assuming that the temporary
shortage of funds within these periods can be covered without value cost eg
advance receipts from customers Virginrsquos cash forecasting system involves a
combination of distribution and scheduling The receipts and disbursements
approach of cash forecasting is used in virgin This method is used because it
minutely traces the movement of cash and very close control of cash is possible
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Virgin does not use adjusted net income approach on two grounds First it does not
permit the tracing of the individual types of cash inflows and outflows for any given
period which is often useful information for virgin Second it is not simple to use
Items to be Forecast
Virgin does not forecast all the items It forecasts only major items eg accounts
receivable notes receivable payroll cash purchases of raw materials In this regard
virgin trade off between cost and benefit
Methods of Financial Forecasting
Virgin forecasts the future level of financial variable such as cash level asset level or
liability level We know in short term forecasts many things will result from plans
and events that are already in place (contracts capital budgets long-range financing
plans and so forth) But in the long run most things can vary and are dependent on
outside influences such as the firmrsquos long-term growth rate Since Virginrsquos cash
forecasting deals mostly with near future many of the items on the cash forecasts are
estimated by some variation of the spot method and remaining estimates are mostly
on a ldquoproportion of another accountrdquo basis with this ldquoother accountrdquo often being a
particular periodrsquos sales Virgin uses the other two methods less frequently
Using Cash Forecast
Virgin forecasts cash for meeting general objectives (ie to know the available funds
for investment and need financing) and for meeting some special objectives (eg to
know whether the firm will fulfill its out of debt requirement) But it is matter to note
that Virgin does not make any short term investment of its surplus cash but only keep
this surplus in Bank Account
Page 35 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Sources of Uncertainty in Cash Forecasting and Hedging Uncertainties
Virgin faces uncertainty in cash forecasting mainly from two sources These are ndash
sales and production cost In peak season (hot season like autumn summer) sales
increases but in dull season (eg in winter) sales decreases drastically Production
cost may be increased because of increase of price of sugar chemicals aluminum
can Virgin follows two methods for hedging cash balance uncertainties These are ndash
i) Holding a stock of extra cash and
ii) Extra borrowing capacity
815 Modes for the Management of Cash and Temporary Investments
Virgin does not follow any of these methods wholly Virgin receives cash
continuously and pays salary at steady rate and pays continuously for other
expenses So it neither follows Baumol model nor Beranek model It has no upper
control limit lower control limit return point in case cash management So it neither
follows Miller-Orr model nor Stone model
In Summary
Page 36 of 46
Standard Compliance by Virgin Soft Drinks
Generally all firms hold cash and
marketable securities
Virgin holds only cash
Firms hold cash and marketable
securities for some reasons like
bull Cash for transactions
bull Cash and near-cash assets as
hedges
bull Temporary investments
bull Compensating balances
Virgin holds cash only for
two reasons ndash
bull Cash for transactions
bull Cash as hedges
Available money market instruments Virgin does not invest in any such
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
(short term securities) are ndash
Treasury Bills
Commercial Paper
Certificates of Deposit
Bankerrsquos Acceptance
Repurch menase Agree ts
instruments They only keep cash in
Bank Account
Mail Float
(1 to 5 days)
At Firm
Float
(025 to 1
day)
Clearing
Float
(0 to
2 days)
Mail Float
(2 to 3 days)
At firm
Float
(025
day)
Clearing
Float
(1 to 3
days)
Figure Transit time for a typical check Figure Transit time for a check for
Virgin
Strategies that firms can use to reduce
the delay in receiving funds are ndash
Selecting of Banks with
accelerated clearing capabilities
of check processing Acceleration
at the firm
ectronic collection Use of el
procedures
Use of lockboxes
Virgin follows the first three strategies
but does not use lockboxes
Available cash concentration
mechanisms are ndash
Depository transfer check
ouse Automated Clearing H
(ACH) electronic transfer)
Wire transfer
Virgin uses all these mechanisms of
cash concentration
Available sets of techniques for cash
disbursement management are ndash
ement of disbursement
Page 37 of 46
Manag
float
Virgin uses zero-balance accounts
technique
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Zero-Balance Accounts
Controlled disbursing
Firms may make cash flow forecasts
over periods of various lengths yearly
flows quarterly flows monthly flows
weekly flows or even daily flows
Virgin forecasts cash on yearly basis and
monthly basis
Cash forecasting system may involve ndash
Distribution
Scheduling
Virginrsquos cash forecasting system
involves a combination of distribution
and scheduling
Two common approaches to cash flow
in generating the cash forecast
and disbursement Receipts
approach
Adjusted net income approach
Virgin uses the receipts and
disbursement approach
There are many items to forecast Virgin forecasts only major items like
AR payroll etc
Four common approach to forecasting
fina i ndash nc al variables are
Spot method
Proportion to another account
Compounded growth
Multiple dependencies
Virgin uses spot method for forecasting
cash It uses proportion to another
account method for other variables and
remaining two methods are frequently
used
Sources of uncertainty in cash
forecasting are ndash
Sales uncertainty
Collection rate uncertainty
Production cost uncertainty
Capital outflow uncertainty
Virgin faces uncertainty mainly from
sales and production cost
Methods for hedging cash balance
unc a
Page 38 of 46
ert inties are ndash
i) Holding a stock of extra cash
Virgin two available methods for
hedging cash balance uncertainties
Th ese are ndash
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
ii) stock of near-cash Holding a
assets
iii) Extra borrowing capacity
iv) ary surpluses in Investing tempor
near-cash assets
i) Holding a stock of extra cash
ii) Extra borrowing capacity
(advance receipt from
customers)
Models for the management of cash and
temporary investments are ndash Baumol
model Beranek model Miller-Orr
model and Stone model
Virgin does not follow any method
wholly but a combination of Baumol
model and Beranek model is occurred
82 INVENTORY MANAGEMENT
21 Certainty Approach
isnt used in
irgin because it thinks it is not possible to implement in Bangladesh
d time is one to three days It
oes not use ABC system of inventory management
8
Main item of inventory of Virgin is Can pet chip sugar label chemical artificial
sweet etc Virgin maintains a minimum level of inventory but it does not have to face
problems because inventory is managed efficiently just-in-time (JIT)
V
Virgin maintains buffer stock because of the shortage of work-in-process (WIP)
inventory Its production process may also be hampered Thats why it maintains
safety stock to avoid stock out cost In case of imported goods normal lead time is
about one month and within the country normal lea
d
Page 39 of 46
Inventory Model
In reality Virgin does not use any of models of EOQ ordering and holding strategy
and safety stock strategy They maintain inventory based on their prior experience
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
822 Uncertainty Approach
Virgin does not use any model for handling inventory uncertainty It says that such
decision depends on business cycle and market situation Long before Eid festival
they bought large amount of sugar because of price increase on the occasion of Eid
In summary
Standard Compliance by Virgin Soft Drinks
Firms maintain inventory to guard
against several problems
Virgin maintains a minimum level of
inventory which is managed efficiently
Some firms use JIT to avoid inventory
cost
JIT is not used by Virgin as it thinks it is
impossible to implement in Bangladesh
Firms maintain buffer stock Virgin maintains buffer stock too
Firms maintain safety stock to avoid
shortage cost
Virgin also maintains safety stock
Firms use ABC system to monitor
inventory
Virgin doesnt use ABC system
EOQ model is an appropriate method
for measuring quantity that has to be
ordered per order
Virgin does not use EOQ model rather
makes order based on experience and
market demand
83 MANAGING ACCOUNTS RECEIVABLE (DEBTORS)
831 Terms of Sale Decision
Page 40 of 46
Virgin offers the term 210 net 30 enables the customers to deduct 2 percent from the
face value of the bill when paying within the first 10 days but if the discount is not
taken the customer must remit the full amount within 30 days But Virgin does not
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
offer the same terms of sale to all customers For prime customers it offers special
terms of sale In setting an appropriate term of sale it costs and benefits regarding
this are compared It uses the standard approach of terms of sale decision as it is
simple to use
832 Credit Granting Decisions
In case of Virgin the Capital and Character of Five Cs get more importance
Although there are many problems with the traditional approach Virgin uses it
because of its simplicity Virgin does not use Net Present Value (NPV) method in
credit granting decision It thinks that NPV is an appropriate method and should be
used next time It does not face any severe problem because of bad debts The reason
is that notes receivable is used when credit is granted
833 Monitoring Accounts Receivable
Virgin monitors its accounts receivable Virgin believes that in any case both positive
and negative durations in accounts signal differences from the results that
management believe to be the most advantageous for the firm
Tools for Monitoring Accounts Receivable
Page 41 of 46
For monitoring accounts receivable there are several tools such as aging schedule
the ratios of receivable outstanding to original sales customers payment proportion
and sales weighted DSO (Days Sales Outstanding) For monitoring accounts
receivable Virgin uses aging schedule fractions and traditional DSO statistics
because of their simplicity in use Although payment proportions ratios of
receivables outstanding and sales weighted DSO methods are free from inherent bias
None of these is used because all these are complex to maintain
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
In summary
Page 42 of 46
Standard Compliance by Virgin Soft Drinks
Generals terms of sale is 210 net 30 Normally Virgin also use general terms
of sale ie 210 net 30
Firms do not offer the same terms of
sale to all customers
Yes For prime customers Virgin offers
special terms of sale
Approaches of terms of sale decisions
are ndash
bull Standard approach
bull Multi period approach
Virgin uses standard approach of terms
of sale decision as it is simple to use and
understand
Source of credit information are ndash
Sellers prior experience with the
customer
Credit agency ratings and
reports
Personal contact with the
applicants bank and other
creditors
Analysis of applicants financial
statements
Customer visit
Main source of credit information to
Virgin is its prior experience with the
customer All other sources are not cost-
effective for Virgin
Approaches of credit granting to
marginal accounts are ndash
Traditional approach
Net Present Value (NPV)
approach
It uses traditional approach still now but
thinks that NPV should be used for the
next periods
Firms monitor accounts receivable
because deviations from the expected
levels of turnover and of bad debt can
Virgin also monitors its accounts
receivable
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
signal several different problems
Different tools for monitoring accounts
receivable are ndash
Aging schedule
Ratios of receivables
outstanding to original sales
Customers payment
proportions
Sales-weighted DSO
For monitoring accounts receivable
Virgin uses aging schedule and
traditional sales outstanding statistics
84 MANAGING ACCOUNTS PAYABLE (CREDITORS)
Virgin has almost accounts payable of Tk 8000000 But most of its liabilities are to
the banks rather than suppliers But we dont have any clear information about
Virgins accounts payable
9 RECOMMENDATION
Virgin should invest its surplus cash in short term marketable securities
because it is suitable hedging against cash uncertainties and will also give
some returns (interest income)
Virgin should publish its own annual report which will satisfy information
needs of stakeholders and also increase the credibility of information provided
by Virgin
Page 43 of 46
Virgin should use multi period approach in terms of sale decision because
standard approach which is already exists in Virgin has some inherent
problems
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
It should stop using traditional approach from now It should use NPV
method in credit granting to marginal accounts
In monitoring accounts receivable Virgin should use sales-weighted DSO
method because it has least limitation compared to the others
It should be more flexible in granting credit which will ultimately increase its
sales
To get the appropriate number of quantity to be ordered per order it should
use DSO model
It should be ABC system for proper monitoring of inventory
10 CONCLUSION
The use of other peoples money in business is usually an expensive resource Before
looking outside for finance a firm should examine its own working capital cycle to
make sure that every rand of its own internal funds is being fully utilized Good
management of working capital is part of good financial management Effective use
of working capital will contribute to the operational efficiency of the whole
organization optimum use will help to generate maximum returns Furthermore
working capital management is not an end in itself It is an integral part of the firms
overall management The needs of efficient working capital management must be
considered in relation to other aspects of the Virgins financial and non-financial
performance Thats why when planning the development of a business it is critical
that the impact of working capital be fully assessed
Page 44 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
BIBLIOGRAPHY
Scherr FC (1989) International Edition Prentice-Hall International Inc Modern
Working Capital Management Text and Cases
Hussain Riaz (2002) Working Capital Management
Robertson Lonnie (July 1998) Inventory Management
httpwwwasashoporg visited on March 13 2006
The Art of Cash Management
httpwwwinccom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management
httpwwwstudyfinancecom visited on March 13 2006
White Paper ndash Managing Working Capital
httpwwwplanwareorg visited on March 13 2006
Management of Working Capital
httpwwwbusinesscentralcoza visited on March 13 2006
Cash Management
httpwwwsbagov visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management Objectives
httpwpsprenhallcom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management
Page 45 of 46
httpwwwadvancemecom visited on March 13 2006
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Business Receivables Financing
httpwwwbbtcom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Finance
http wwwfnbcoza visited on March 13 2006
Tips to manage your working capital
httpsmallbusinessninemsncomau visited on March 13 2006
Inventory Financing
httpwwwfranklincapitalnetworkcom visited on March 13 2006
Accounts Receivable Management
httpwwwfranklincapitalnetworkcom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management
httpwwwtreasurygovtnz visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management
httpwwwtreasurystrategiescom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Works
httpwwwinvestopediacom visited on March 13 2006
Treasury Services
httpwwwjpmorganchasecom visited on March 13 2006
what were about
Page 46 of 46
httpwwwvirgincom visited on March 13 2006
Annexure
Annexure
Interview with YASEER RIZVI
Mr Yaseer Rizvi the DMD of Global Beverage Co Ltd obtained his MBA degree
from a reputed university He had been the Director of Ocean Container Ltd before
joining in Global Beverage Co Ltd He possesses a nice personality
I interviewed Yaseer Rizvi Excerpts from his interview are as follows ndash
Shah Kamal Sir would you please tell me do you invest in short term marketable securities
Yaseer Rizvi Basically we do not invest our surplus cash in short term marketable
securities like T-Bill commercial paper certificate of deposit etc But we keep our
surplus cash in Bank
Shah Kamal Would you tell me something about transit time for a typical check
Yaseer Rizvi Well in Virgin the transit time for a typical check is ndash
For mail float 2 to 3 days
At firm float 6 hours
Clearing float 1 to 3 days
Shah Kamal Do you maintain any cash concentration mechanism like depository transfer check automated clearing house and wire transfer
i
Annexure
Yaseer Rizvi Our position in this case is very strong as we use all the mechanisms
you mentioned As Virgin is a firm with small deposits spread over a substantial
number of banks so we tend to use depository transfer checks extensively It is less
costly We also use automated clearing house and wire transfer but later is used in a
less extent
Shah Kamal Sir what techniques of disbursement management is used by your firm
Yaseer Rizvi Like other firms Virgin tries to retain the cash for as long as possible
But we always perform it in an ethical manner We do not use management of
disbursement float as it seems unethical We follow Zero-Balance Accounts method
for managing disbursement We do not prefer Controlled Disbursing method since
Zero-Balance system is already practiced in Virgin
Shah Kamal How do you hedge cash balance uncertainties
Yaseer Rizvi Well you may say that we do not invest in short term securities but for
facing cash difficulties we keep our surplus cash in bank
Shah Kamal Sir would you please tell me the general terms of sale of Virgin
Yaseer Rizvi Though it is difficult to maintain a fixed terms of sale our general terms
of sale is 210 n30 But for prime customers we offer special terms of sale
Shah Kamal What are the sources of credit information in case of your firm
Yaseer Rizvi We grant credit on the basis of prior experience with the customers In
case of a new customer personal contact is weighted
Shah Kamal Does your firm consider 5 Cs in granting credit
ii
Annexure
Yaseer Rizvi In case of Virgin Capital and Character get more importance than the
others Mind one thing personal relationship is the main measure in granting credit
Shah Kamal Do you use NPV method in credit granting decisions
Yaseer Rizvi We do not use NPV method But we think that NPV is a suitable
method and we have to use it from the next period
Shah Kamal Sir how do you handle the problem of bad debt
Yaseer Rizvi Well in this case our position is very strong Yet we do not face any
problem because of bad debt Just note that we make more than 80 of sales in cash
and we monitor accounts receivable very carefully
Shah Kamal What level of inventory is maintained by Virgin
Yaseer Rizvi We maintain a minimum level of inventory but do not have to face
stock out problems because inventory is managed efficiently
Shah Kamal What is the normal lead time
Yaseer Rizvi In case of imported goods normal lead time is about 1 month and when
we purchase raw materials from inside the country lead time is 1 to 3 days
Shah Kamal What method do you use for managing inventory
Yaseer Rizvi We do not use any method particularly rather inventory decision
depends on business cycle and market situation Long before the Eid festival we
bought large amount of sugar because price of sugar was increased on the occasion
of Eid
iii
Annexure
Shah Kamal What are the main items of inventory of your firm
Yaseer Rizvi Well these are ndash aluminum can pet chip sugar label chemical and
artificial sweet
Shah Kamal What are the uncertainties in maintaining appropriate level of stock
Yaseer Rizvi These are ndash
bull Increase in price of raw materials
bull Sales uncertainty
bull Market trends etc
Shah Kamal Thank you for your kind cooperation
Yaseer Rizvi Most Welcome
iv
Global Beverage Company Limited
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Disbursement management addresses the efficient payout out of this cash once it is
concentrated The firmrsquos objective in disbursement management is to retain the cash
for as long as possible In this way the firm will have the maximum amount of funds
available for investment and transactional purposes Certainly this management
means making disbursement only when they are due and not before The firm has
several available set of techniques for disbursement management Included among
these are ndash
a) Management of Disbursement Float
In this set of techniques the disbursing firm attempts to increase the length of
time between the mailing of its checks and the eventual withdrawal of funds
from the banks This involves strategies for increasing mail float at firm float
and clearing float on its outgoing checks For example the disbursing firm
may intentionally address checks to the firmrsquos office address rather than its
lockbox creating at firm float
b) Zero-Balance Accounts
Here the firm holds the cash until the check arrive (or expected to arrive) at
the disbursement bank In this strategy an account for disbursement is first
established at a bank For the zero-balance system to be effective the
participating bank must be one on which most disbursement are made via the
Bangladesh Bankrsquos clearance system (which presents disbursements to banks
early in the morning) and not a bank where disbursements occur throughout
the day (as with a major money-center bank) Consequently the banks used
in zero-balance strategies are usually branches of major banks and not their
main locations
Page 13 of 46
c) Controlled Disbursing
In this system the firm projects the amount of checks to arrive each day at the
disbursement bank (based on the checks written in previous days and historic
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
statistics on disbursement float) and transfers the amount of the expected
checks to the account on that day or just before
5315 Cash Forecasting
Defining Cash Forecasting
The cash forecast is an estimation of the flows in and out of the firmrsquos cash account
over a particular period of time usually a quarter month week or day The cash
forecast is primarily intended to produce a very useful piece of information an
estimation of the firmrsquos borrowing and lending needs and uncertainties regarding
these needs during various future periods Cash forecasting is very crucial to most
firms It enables them to anticipate periods of surplus cash and periods where
financing will be necessary This anticipation is the reason that cash forecasts are
generated Anticipation enables the firm to plan much more effectively for
investment and financing and via this planning produce superior return
Types of Cash Forecasts
The types of cash forecasts generated by firms can be differentiated along two
dimensions the length of the periods included within the cash forecast and the approach
to cash flows used in the cash forecast The length of the period refers to the units of
time into which the cash forecast is divided Firms may make cash flow forecasts
over periods of various lengths yearly flows quarterly flows monthly flows weekly
flows or even daily flows The most popular forecast involves monthly flows but
most firms do not confine themselves to a single forecast Instead they use several
forecasts with periods of various lengths When the firm makes forecasts involving
multiple and overlapping period lengths one forecast relates to another Starting
with data on relatively long periods and breaking it down into smaller periods is
called distribution starting with data on relatively short periods and aggregating into
longer periods is called scheduling
Page 14 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Firms use two common approaches to cash flows in generating the cash forecast the
receipts and disbursements approach and the adjusted net income approach The receipts
and disbursements approach use the amounts of cash expected to be received and
disbursed by the firm over the periods chosen for forecast The adjusted income
statement approach is sometimes called the sources and use approach Here the
forecaster starts with projected net income on an accrual basis and adjusts to a cash
basis This method provides a representation of changes in asset and liability
accounts since the level of these accounts are of interest to the firm this aspect of the
adjusted income statement is an advantage over the receipts and disbursements
method
Items to Be Forecast
In the receipt and disbursements cash forecasting method estimates need to be made
of the numerous major and minor items that the firm collects (receipts) and that it
pays (disbursements) The more individual categories of items the firm includes in its
forecast procedure the more accurate the forecast may be but the more costly in
terms of time and effort it will be to generate
Some Possible Types of Cash Receipts and Cash Disbursements
Cash Disbursements Cash Receipts
Cash Purchases of Materials Payroll
Taxes
Maturing Accounts Payable
Maturing Notes Payable
Miscellaneous Disbursements
Accounts Receivable
Notes Receivable
Rental Income
Interest Income
Miscellaneous Receipts
Methods of Financial Forecasting
Page 15 of 46
Financial forecasting is the estimation of the future level of a financial variable often
a cash flow asset level or liability level It is usually assumed that the relationship
between the financial variable and other variable is linear The general linear model
can then be used
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
nnt xaxaxaaY 22110 ++=
Here
= Financial variable (Y) to be forecast in period t tY
x = Explanatory variable it is assumed to cause the level of Y in period t
0a = Represents a constant unaffected by the x
The other terms are the estimated coefficients of the explanatory x variables
There are n terms with xrsquos in them
There are four common approaches to forecasting financial variables but they
are all special cases of the general linear model These are ndash spot method proportion
to another account compounded growth and multiple dependencies
Using Cash Forecast
The estimate of available funds for investment and needed financing enables the firm
to plan so as to obtain the most advantages borrowing terms for deficits and achieve
the greatest interest income on surplus A useful chart for this planning purpose is a
bar chart eg
Figure Bar Chart of Cash Surpluses and Deficits from hypothetical data
Page 16 of 46
75
50
-60
30
100
-20
-80-60-40-20
020406080
100120
Defic
it
S
urpl
us
January February March April May June
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Sources of Uncertainty in Cash Forecasting and Hedging Uncertainties
There are numerous sources of risk in cash forecasting Among the sources are sales
uncertainty collection rate uncertainty production cost uncertainty and capital
outflow uncertainty
5316 Models for the Management of Cash and Temporary Investments
There are different models for the management of cash and temporary investments
Among these the most popular methods are ndash Baumol model Beranek model
Miller-Orr model and Stone model
Baumol and Beranek use the same model The formula is cited below ndash
Interest Income = iYn
n⎥⎦⎤
⎢⎣⎡ minus
21
Profit = naiYn
nminus⎥⎦
⎤⎢⎣⎡ minus
21
Optimum number of transactions = ⎟⎠⎞
⎜⎝⎛
aiY2
Where n = Optimum number of transactions
i = Interest rate per period
a = Transaction cost
Y = Total inflow for the period
Page 17 of 46
Miller-Orr and Stone use the same model ie R-Statistic The model is ndash
31
43
iav
R ⎟⎠⎞
⎜⎝⎛=
Optimum Control Limit = R + L
Upper Control Limit = 3R + L
Where a = Transaction Cost
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
v = Variance of daily cash flows
i = Daily interest rate
5317 Administration
Cash receipts should be processed and banked as quickly as possible because
They cannot earn interest or reduce overdraft until they are banked
information about the existence and amounts of cash receipts is usually not
available until they are processed
Where possible cash floats (mainly petty cash and advances) should be avoided If
on review the only reason that can be put forward for their existence is that weve
always had them they should be discontinued There may be situations where they
are useful however For example it may be desirable for peripheral parts of
departments to meet urgent local needs from cash floats rather than local bank
accounts
5318 Internal Control
Cash and cash management is part of a firms overall internal control system The
main internal cash control is invariably the bank reconciliation This provides
assurance that the cash balances recorded in the accounting systems are consistent
with the actual bank balances It requires regular clearing of reconciling items
5319 Practicing Good Cash Flow Management
Good cash management is simple It involves
Knowing when where and how firms cash needs will occur
Page 18 of 46
Knowing the best sources for meeting additional cash needs
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Page 19 of 46
Being prepared to meet these needs when they occur by keeping good
relationships with bankers and other creditors
532 INVENTORY MANAGEMENT
Inventory management is necessary for owners who want to maintain a stocking
service for quick turnaround to help ensure total customer satisfaction The fill rate
of an item on a managed inventory list must be maintained to avoid shortages of
frequently used items Even when utilizing an inventory management system
occasional shortages will still occur Inventories are lists of stocks-raw materials
work in progress or finished goods-waiting to be consumed in production or to be
sold The total balance of inventory is the sum of the value of each individual stock
line
Basically firms hold stocks for the following reasons
To act as a buffer in times of unusually high demand
To ensure continuity of production
Avoid high costs of emergency orders
To take advantage of quantity discounts by ordering more at a time
To reduce ordering costs by ordering more items on fewer
As part of the production process eg maturing whisky or keeping oil in
pipelines
Seasonality of demand (eg firework) or supplies
Suppliers insist on minimum order quantities
The key issue for a business is to identify the fast and slow stock movers with the
objectives of establishing optimum stock levels for each category and thereby
minimize the cash tied up in stocks Factors to be considered when determining
optimum stock levels include
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Page 20 of 46
What are the projected sales of each product
How widely available are raw materials components etc
How long does it take for delivery by suppliers
Can the firm remove slow movers from its product range without
compromising best sellers
Inventory management is an important aspect of working capital management
because inventories themselves do not earn any revenue Holding either too little or
too much inventory incurs costs
Costs of carrying too much inventory are
Opportunity cost of foregone interest
Warehousing costs
Damage and pilferage
Obsolescence
Insurance
Costs of carrying too little inventory are
Stock out costs
Lost sales
Delayed service
Ordering costs
Freight
on Order administrati
nts
Loss of quantity discou
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Carrying costs can be minimized by making frequent small orders but this increase
ordering costs and the risk of stock outs Risk of stock-outs can be reduced by
carrying safety stocks (at a cost) and re-ordering ahead of time
The best ordering strategy requires balancing the various cost factors to ensure the
firm incurs minimum inventory costs The optimum inventory position is known as
the Economic Reorder Quantity (ERQ)
Nowadays many large manufacturers operate on a just-in-time (JIT) basis whereby
all the components to be assembled on a particular today arrive at the factory early
that morning no earlier - no later This helps to minimize manufacturing costs as JIT
stocks take up little space minimize stock-holding and virtually eliminate the risks of
obsolete or damaged stock Because JIT manufacturers hold stock for a very short
time they are able to conserve substantial cash JIT is a good model to strive for as it
embraces all the principles of prudent stock management For better stock control
firm may try the following
Review the effectiveness of existing purchasing and inventory systems
Know the stock turn for all major items of inventory
Apply tight controls to the significant few items and simplify controls for the
trivial many
Sell off outdated or slow moving merchandise - it gets more difficult to sell the
longer the firm keeps it
Consider having part of its product outsourced to another manufacturer rather
than make it itself
Review its security procedures to ensure that no stock is going out the back
door
Higher than necessary stock levels tie up cash and cost more in insurance
accommodation costs and interest charges
Page 21 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
However it is important to keep an overall perspective It is not cost-effective to
closely manage a large number of low value inventory lines nor is it necessary A
usual feature of inventories is that a small number of high value lines account for a
large proportion of inventory value The 8020 rule (PARETO) predicts that 80
of the total value of inventory is represented by only 20 of the number of inventory
items Those high value lines need reasonably close management The remaining
80 of inventory lines can be managed using broad-brush strategies
533 MANAGING ACCOUNTS RECEIVABLE (DEBTORS)
Cash flow can be significantly enhanced if the amounts owing to a business are
collected faster Every business needs to know who owes them money how much is
owed how long it is owing for what it is owed
Debtors (Accounts Receivable) are customers who have not yet made payment for
goods or services which the department has provided The objective of debtor
management is to minimize the time-lapse between completion of sales and receipt
of payment The costs of having debtors are
Opportunity costs (cash is not available for other purposes)
Bad debts
If firm doesnt manage debtors they will begin to manage business as the firm will gradually
lose control due to reduced cash flow and of course it could experience an increased
incidence of bad debt The following measures will help manage debtors
Having the right mental attitude to the control of credit and make sure that it
gets the priority it deserves
Establishing clear credit practices as a matter of company policy
Page 22 of 46
Making sure that these practices are clearly understood by staff suppliers and
customers
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Page 23 of 46
Being professional when accepting new accounts and especially larger ones
Checking out each customer thoroughly before the firm offers credit Use
credit agencies bank references industry sources etc
Establishing credit limits for each customer and sticking to them
Continuously reviewing these limits when it suspects tough times are coming
or if operating in a volatile sector
Keeping very close to the firms larger customers
Invoicing promptly and clearly
Considering charging penalties on overdue accounts
Considering accepting credit debit cards as a payment option
Monitoring its debtor balances and ageing schedules and dont let any debts
get too large or too old
Debtor management includes both pre-sale and debt collection strategies
Pre-sale strategies include
Offering cash discounts for early payment andor imposing penalties for late
payment
Agreeing payment terms in advance
Requiring cash before delivery
Setting credit limits
ning credit Setting criteria for obtai
Billing as early as possible
rogress payments
ost-sale strategies include
for collecting the debt upon the center that made the sale
Requiring deposits andor p
P
Placing the responsibility
Identifying long overdue balances and doubtful debts by regular analytical reviews
Having an established procedure for late collections such as
A reminder
A letter
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Page 24 of 46
ion of further credit Cancellat
Telephone calls
n agency Use of a collectio
he firm should recognize that the longer someone owes firm the greater the chance
Legal action
T
it will never get paid If the average age of debtors is getting longer or is already very
long it may need to look for the following possible defects
Weak credit judgment
res Poor collection procedu
ms Lax enforcement of credit ter
Slow issue of invoices or statements
Errors in invoices or statements
Customer dissatisfaction
Debtors due over 90 days (unless within agreed credit terms) should generally
demand immediate attention For example warning signs of a future bad debt ndash
Longer credit terms taken with approval particularly for smaller orders
Use of post-dated checks by debtors who normally settle within agreed terms
Evidence of customers switching to additional suppliers for the same goods
New customers who are reluctant to give credit references
Cre G
Receiving part payments from debtors
dit ranting to Marginal Accounts
Traditional Approach
In the traditional approach to the credit granting decision it is the credit analysts job
rmation that has been collected and reach a judgment
regarding the applicants creditworthiness One traditional way of organizing this
to synthesize all the info
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
information is by characterizing the applicant along five dimensions These
dimensions are called the Five Cs of credit ndash
Capital
Character
Collateral
and Capacity
Conditions
Net Present Value (NPV) Approach
Once a firm has assessed the creditworthiness of a customer it has to decide whether
r not credit should be granted The firm should use the NPV rule to make the
ld be granted
Figure
o
decision If NPV is positive credit shou
Credit Granting Decision
Credit Granting Decision
he act of collecting money is one which most people dislike for many reasons and
therefore put on the long f selves there is something
ore urgent or important that demands their attention now There is nothing more
T
inger because they convince them
m
important than getting paid for firms product or service A customer who does not
Page 25 of 46
Grand Credit
Payment received Payment not received
Benefit of present value of future net cash flow
Cost of present value ment of lost invest
Net Payoff PV of benefit-cost
No Credit
No Payoff
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
pay is not a customer Here are a few ideas that may help the firm in collecting
money from debtors
Firm should develop appropriate procedures for handling late payments
It should track and pursue late payers
It might get external help if its own efforts fail
or money its firms and it is entitled Company shouldnt feel guilty asking f
to it
ction
Firm must make that call now And it should keep asking until it gets some
satisfa
lessens the problem
In difficult circumstances take what the firm can now and agree terms for the
remainder It
paying
When asking for money be hard on the issue - but soft on the person It shouldnt
give the debtor any excuses for not
534 BLE (CREDITORS)
ices for goods or services have
een paid Organizations often regard the
not
to delay all payments until the latest possible date Regular weekly or
The firm make it its objective is to get the money - not to score points or get
even
MANAGING ACCOUNTS PAYA
Creditors (Accounts Payable) are suppliers whose invo
been processed but who have not yet b
amount owing to creditors as a source of free credit However creditor
administration systems are expensive and time-consuming to run The over-riding
concern in this area should be to minimize costs with simple procedures
While it is unnecessary to pay accounts before they fall due it is usually
worthwhile
Page 26 of 46
fortnightly payment of all due accounts is the simplest technique for creditor
management
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Electronic payments (direct credits) are cheaper than check payments considering
that transaction fees and overheads more than balance the advantage of delayed
presentation Some suppliers are reluctant to receive payments by this method but in
view of the substantial cost advantage (and the advantages to the suppliers
themselves) departments may wish to encourage suppliers to accept this option
However electronic payments are likely to be used in conjunction with rather than
as a replacement for check payments
Applying Best Practices in Managing Accounts Payable
f course simply deferring payments to suppliers could have adverse consequences
O
that more than offset the benefits of this additional cash flow Therefore it is
important to develop a holistic approach The firm should consider the following
best practices for payables management
Managing payment dates and terms to maximize cash flow ndash
y reporting on
receivable and
id penalty charges and taking advantage of
wer vendors and negotiate for more
to buying consortia with others even
voices for
payment based on receipt of goods or receipt of invoice whichever
comes later
Calculating and setting performance targets Regularl
AP performance measures such as days in payables
Coordinating the AP processes with accounts
inventory management to ensure that the company is collecting more
cash than it is paying out
Paying bills on time to avo
prompt-payment discounts where the discounts exceed the companyrsquos
cost of working capital
Consolidating purchases with fe
favorable payment terms
Considering entering in
Page 27 of 46
competitors to obtain favorable supplier pricing and terms
Unless contract terms specify otherwise setting up in
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Page 28 of 46
Em
process
-time payments with Electronic Funds Transfer (EFT)
uraging vendors to utilize electronic invoice presentment
a
ndancies and more
ploying technology to automate the accounts payable transaction
es ndash
Making just-in
Using an electronic invoice-matching application
Enco
For companies with multiple locations or business units employing
shared service approach for AP to eliminate redu
quickly implement process improvements
Mainta
vendor
Communicating accounts payable requirements to suppliers at the
m key suppliers
for suggestions on how to improve the
Efficient a
and making th rsquos cash is just good business
ining open communications and building strong relationships with
s to access valuable trade credit ndash
beginning of transactions
Requesting summary invoicing fro
Requiring suppliers to send invoices directly to accounts payable
Asking tier-one suppliers
payment process
nd effective management of accounts payable helps improve cash flow ndash
e most of company
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
6 OVERVIEW OF VIRGIN GROUP
Virgin - one of the most respected brands in Britain - is now becoming the first global
brand name of the 21st century Virgin is involved in planes trains finance soft
drinks music mobile phones holidays cars wines publishing bridal wear - the lot
What tie all these businesses together are the values of its brand and the attitude of its
people Virgin has created over 200 companies worldwide employing over 25000
people Its total revenues around the world in 2002 exceeded pound4 billion (US $72
billion)
In 1970 Richard Branson founded Virgin as a mail order record retailer and not
long after he opened a record shop in Oxford Street London During 1972 a
recording studio was built in Oxfordshire and the first Virgin artist Mike Oldfield
recorded Tubular Bells which was released in 1973
This album went on to sell over 5 million copies Since then many household names
including Belinda Carlisle Genesis Phil Collins Janet Jackson and The Rolling
Stones have helped to make Virgin Music one of the top six record companies in the
world The equity of Virgin Music Group - record labels music publishing and
recording studios was sold to THORN EMI in 1992 in a US$1billion deal
Page 29 of 46
The Virgin Group has now expanded into international music Mega stores air
travel mobile financial retail music internet drinks rail hotels and leisure with
around 200 companies in over 30 countries
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
In Virgins customers eyes Virgin stands for value for money quality innovation
fun and a sense of competitive challenge It delivers a quality service by empowering
its employees and facilitates and monitors customer feedback to continually improve
the customers experience through innovation
When they start a new venture Virgin bases it on hard research and analysis
Typically they review the industry and put themselves in the customers shoes to see
what could make it better Virgin asks fundamental questions
Is this an opportunity for restructuring a market and creating competitive
advantage What are the competitors doing
Is the customer confused or badly served
Is this an opportunity for building the Virgin brand
Can we add value
Will it interact with its other businesses
Is there an appropriate trade-off between risk and reward
Page 30 of 46
Virgin is also able to draw on talented people from throughout the group New
ventures are often steered by people seconded from other parts of Virgin who bring
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
with them the trademark management style skills and experience Virgin frequently
creates partnerships with others to combine skills knowledge and market presence
and so on Contrary to what some people may think their constantly expanding and
eclectic empire is neither random nor reckless Each successive venture demonstrates
its skill in picking the right market and the right opportunity
7 OVERVIEW OF VIRGIN SOFT DRINKS
The Virgin Drinks Group first launched as the Virgin Cola Company in 1994 with
Virgin Cola in the UK Since then the company has ventured across the carbonated
soft drinks arena and beyond into energy drinks tea and flavored Colas This
expansion has lead to the evolution of the Virgin Drinks Company a company
whose aim is to put the excitement back into the world of soft drinks It launched in
Bangladesh in 1999 Virgin Soft Drinks is monitored by Global Beverage Co Ltd in
Bangladesh
Brief history of Virgin Drinks is given below
Page 31 of 46
1994 November Virgin Cola launched in the UK
1996 March Virgin Cola launched in France
1998 June Virgin Cola launched in Belgium
April Virgin Cola launched in the French West Indies
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
August Virgin Cola launched in Switzerland
1999 March Virgin Colours launched in Italy
March Virgin Cola launched in Japan
July Virgin Colours launched in South Africa
December Virgin Colours launched in Bangladesh
2001 January Sweden launched Virgin Colours
November Singapore launched Virgin Colours
2002 February Croatia launched Virgin Colours
June Russia launched Virgin Colours
June Tunisia launched Virgin Colours
2003 May Israel launched Virgin Colours
8 FINDINGS OF WORKING CAPITAL MANAGEMENT MAINTAINED BY
VIRGIN SOFT DRINKS IN BANGLADESH
81 CASH MANAGEMENT
811 Holding Cash and Marketable Securities
Although there are many good reasons why firm hold cash and marketable
securities Virgin Drinks holds cash and marketable securities for two reasons ndash
i) Cash for transactions
ii) Cash as hedges
This indicates that the firm does not hold cash and marketable securities for some
important reasons such as ndash
i) Near cash assets as hedges
Page 32 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
ii) Temporary investment and compensating balances
Virgin Soft Drinks does not invest in money market securities such as Treasury bill
commercial paper certificate of deposits bankerrsquos acceptance and repurchase
agreement This firm deposits its money in bank as currant AC or fixed AC They
say that they do not have enough money to invest in money market instrument
They also say that if they have enough money they will invest it in money market
short term securities We know that near cash interest earning assets can be
substituted for cash when motivation for holding these assets is the hedging of cash
flow uncertainties or is the temporary investment of surplus funds In this point
Virgins position is not good as there is no significant hedging against uncertainty of
cash
812 Floatation and Check Clearing
Virgin is very smart in handling the problem of transit time for checks Here mail
float takes 2 to 3 days at firm takes 025 day and clearing float takes 1-3 days Virgin
uses most of the strategies available for reducing the delay in receiving funds It
(Virgin) has linked Islami Bank which posses an accelerated clearing facility It uses
electronic collection process which ensures faster collection and its at the firm check
processing is satisfactory But Virgin does not use lockbox The reason behind this is
that it is not cost-effective for Virgin to set lockboxes At this point we can say that
Virgins check clearing mechanism is much good
813 Cash Concentration and Disbursement Management
Page 33 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks takes the matter of cash concentration very seriously They use all
the available cash concentration mechanism Virgin is a firm with small deposits
spread over a substantial number of banks and this is why the firm tends to use
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
depository transfer checks extensively If is less costly Virgin also uses automated
clearing house and wire transfer To Virgin wire transfer seems too costly
Like other firm Virgin tries to retain the cash for as long as possible But Virgin
always performs it in an ethical manner Virgin does not try to defeat the receiving
firmrsquos attempts to reduce the float on incoming checks It does not take any strategy
for increasing mail float at firm float and clearing float on its outgoing checks To
Virgin it is deemed to be unethical It thinks that maximization of disbursement float
will not go unnoticed by sophisticated creditors for very long When it is noticed it
will negatively affect relations with these creditors reducing the firmrsquos bargaining
power with them This may ultimately cost Virgin dearly when future prices and
delivery schedules for goods and services purchased from trade creditors are
negotiated Virgin follows ldquoZero-Balance Accountsrdquo methods for managing
disbursement It thinks that in this method the coordination of funds inflows to
disbursement banks with the presentation of checks does not work to the detriment
of creditors since the firmrsquos checks to them are honored as presented and this strategy
does not affect float significantly Controlled disbursing method is less attractive to
Virgin because zero-balance system is already feasible
814 Cash Forecasting
Cash Forecasting and Its Types
Page 34 of 46
Virgin forecasts the future cash inflows and outflows To Virgin cash forecast is an
important part of the firmrsquos cash control system and is one of the forecasts that are
part of the Virginrsquos financial plan Virgin forecasts cash on monthly basis and on
yearly basis Virgin does not forecast on daily basis assuming that the temporary
shortage of funds within these periods can be covered without value cost eg
advance receipts from customers Virginrsquos cash forecasting system involves a
combination of distribution and scheduling The receipts and disbursements
approach of cash forecasting is used in virgin This method is used because it
minutely traces the movement of cash and very close control of cash is possible
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Virgin does not use adjusted net income approach on two grounds First it does not
permit the tracing of the individual types of cash inflows and outflows for any given
period which is often useful information for virgin Second it is not simple to use
Items to be Forecast
Virgin does not forecast all the items It forecasts only major items eg accounts
receivable notes receivable payroll cash purchases of raw materials In this regard
virgin trade off between cost and benefit
Methods of Financial Forecasting
Virgin forecasts the future level of financial variable such as cash level asset level or
liability level We know in short term forecasts many things will result from plans
and events that are already in place (contracts capital budgets long-range financing
plans and so forth) But in the long run most things can vary and are dependent on
outside influences such as the firmrsquos long-term growth rate Since Virginrsquos cash
forecasting deals mostly with near future many of the items on the cash forecasts are
estimated by some variation of the spot method and remaining estimates are mostly
on a ldquoproportion of another accountrdquo basis with this ldquoother accountrdquo often being a
particular periodrsquos sales Virgin uses the other two methods less frequently
Using Cash Forecast
Virgin forecasts cash for meeting general objectives (ie to know the available funds
for investment and need financing) and for meeting some special objectives (eg to
know whether the firm will fulfill its out of debt requirement) But it is matter to note
that Virgin does not make any short term investment of its surplus cash but only keep
this surplus in Bank Account
Page 35 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Sources of Uncertainty in Cash Forecasting and Hedging Uncertainties
Virgin faces uncertainty in cash forecasting mainly from two sources These are ndash
sales and production cost In peak season (hot season like autumn summer) sales
increases but in dull season (eg in winter) sales decreases drastically Production
cost may be increased because of increase of price of sugar chemicals aluminum
can Virgin follows two methods for hedging cash balance uncertainties These are ndash
i) Holding a stock of extra cash and
ii) Extra borrowing capacity
815 Modes for the Management of Cash and Temporary Investments
Virgin does not follow any of these methods wholly Virgin receives cash
continuously and pays salary at steady rate and pays continuously for other
expenses So it neither follows Baumol model nor Beranek model It has no upper
control limit lower control limit return point in case cash management So it neither
follows Miller-Orr model nor Stone model
In Summary
Page 36 of 46
Standard Compliance by Virgin Soft Drinks
Generally all firms hold cash and
marketable securities
Virgin holds only cash
Firms hold cash and marketable
securities for some reasons like
bull Cash for transactions
bull Cash and near-cash assets as
hedges
bull Temporary investments
bull Compensating balances
Virgin holds cash only for
two reasons ndash
bull Cash for transactions
bull Cash as hedges
Available money market instruments Virgin does not invest in any such
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
(short term securities) are ndash
Treasury Bills
Commercial Paper
Certificates of Deposit
Bankerrsquos Acceptance
Repurch menase Agree ts
instruments They only keep cash in
Bank Account
Mail Float
(1 to 5 days)
At Firm
Float
(025 to 1
day)
Clearing
Float
(0 to
2 days)
Mail Float
(2 to 3 days)
At firm
Float
(025
day)
Clearing
Float
(1 to 3
days)
Figure Transit time for a typical check Figure Transit time for a check for
Virgin
Strategies that firms can use to reduce
the delay in receiving funds are ndash
Selecting of Banks with
accelerated clearing capabilities
of check processing Acceleration
at the firm
ectronic collection Use of el
procedures
Use of lockboxes
Virgin follows the first three strategies
but does not use lockboxes
Available cash concentration
mechanisms are ndash
Depository transfer check
ouse Automated Clearing H
(ACH) electronic transfer)
Wire transfer
Virgin uses all these mechanisms of
cash concentration
Available sets of techniques for cash
disbursement management are ndash
ement of disbursement
Page 37 of 46
Manag
float
Virgin uses zero-balance accounts
technique
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Zero-Balance Accounts
Controlled disbursing
Firms may make cash flow forecasts
over periods of various lengths yearly
flows quarterly flows monthly flows
weekly flows or even daily flows
Virgin forecasts cash on yearly basis and
monthly basis
Cash forecasting system may involve ndash
Distribution
Scheduling
Virginrsquos cash forecasting system
involves a combination of distribution
and scheduling
Two common approaches to cash flow
in generating the cash forecast
and disbursement Receipts
approach
Adjusted net income approach
Virgin uses the receipts and
disbursement approach
There are many items to forecast Virgin forecasts only major items like
AR payroll etc
Four common approach to forecasting
fina i ndash nc al variables are
Spot method
Proportion to another account
Compounded growth
Multiple dependencies
Virgin uses spot method for forecasting
cash It uses proportion to another
account method for other variables and
remaining two methods are frequently
used
Sources of uncertainty in cash
forecasting are ndash
Sales uncertainty
Collection rate uncertainty
Production cost uncertainty
Capital outflow uncertainty
Virgin faces uncertainty mainly from
sales and production cost
Methods for hedging cash balance
unc a
Page 38 of 46
ert inties are ndash
i) Holding a stock of extra cash
Virgin two available methods for
hedging cash balance uncertainties
Th ese are ndash
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
ii) stock of near-cash Holding a
assets
iii) Extra borrowing capacity
iv) ary surpluses in Investing tempor
near-cash assets
i) Holding a stock of extra cash
ii) Extra borrowing capacity
(advance receipt from
customers)
Models for the management of cash and
temporary investments are ndash Baumol
model Beranek model Miller-Orr
model and Stone model
Virgin does not follow any method
wholly but a combination of Baumol
model and Beranek model is occurred
82 INVENTORY MANAGEMENT
21 Certainty Approach
isnt used in
irgin because it thinks it is not possible to implement in Bangladesh
d time is one to three days It
oes not use ABC system of inventory management
8
Main item of inventory of Virgin is Can pet chip sugar label chemical artificial
sweet etc Virgin maintains a minimum level of inventory but it does not have to face
problems because inventory is managed efficiently just-in-time (JIT)
V
Virgin maintains buffer stock because of the shortage of work-in-process (WIP)
inventory Its production process may also be hampered Thats why it maintains
safety stock to avoid stock out cost In case of imported goods normal lead time is
about one month and within the country normal lea
d
Page 39 of 46
Inventory Model
In reality Virgin does not use any of models of EOQ ordering and holding strategy
and safety stock strategy They maintain inventory based on their prior experience
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
822 Uncertainty Approach
Virgin does not use any model for handling inventory uncertainty It says that such
decision depends on business cycle and market situation Long before Eid festival
they bought large amount of sugar because of price increase on the occasion of Eid
In summary
Standard Compliance by Virgin Soft Drinks
Firms maintain inventory to guard
against several problems
Virgin maintains a minimum level of
inventory which is managed efficiently
Some firms use JIT to avoid inventory
cost
JIT is not used by Virgin as it thinks it is
impossible to implement in Bangladesh
Firms maintain buffer stock Virgin maintains buffer stock too
Firms maintain safety stock to avoid
shortage cost
Virgin also maintains safety stock
Firms use ABC system to monitor
inventory
Virgin doesnt use ABC system
EOQ model is an appropriate method
for measuring quantity that has to be
ordered per order
Virgin does not use EOQ model rather
makes order based on experience and
market demand
83 MANAGING ACCOUNTS RECEIVABLE (DEBTORS)
831 Terms of Sale Decision
Page 40 of 46
Virgin offers the term 210 net 30 enables the customers to deduct 2 percent from the
face value of the bill when paying within the first 10 days but if the discount is not
taken the customer must remit the full amount within 30 days But Virgin does not
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
offer the same terms of sale to all customers For prime customers it offers special
terms of sale In setting an appropriate term of sale it costs and benefits regarding
this are compared It uses the standard approach of terms of sale decision as it is
simple to use
832 Credit Granting Decisions
In case of Virgin the Capital and Character of Five Cs get more importance
Although there are many problems with the traditional approach Virgin uses it
because of its simplicity Virgin does not use Net Present Value (NPV) method in
credit granting decision It thinks that NPV is an appropriate method and should be
used next time It does not face any severe problem because of bad debts The reason
is that notes receivable is used when credit is granted
833 Monitoring Accounts Receivable
Virgin monitors its accounts receivable Virgin believes that in any case both positive
and negative durations in accounts signal differences from the results that
management believe to be the most advantageous for the firm
Tools for Monitoring Accounts Receivable
Page 41 of 46
For monitoring accounts receivable there are several tools such as aging schedule
the ratios of receivable outstanding to original sales customers payment proportion
and sales weighted DSO (Days Sales Outstanding) For monitoring accounts
receivable Virgin uses aging schedule fractions and traditional DSO statistics
because of their simplicity in use Although payment proportions ratios of
receivables outstanding and sales weighted DSO methods are free from inherent bias
None of these is used because all these are complex to maintain
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
In summary
Page 42 of 46
Standard Compliance by Virgin Soft Drinks
Generals terms of sale is 210 net 30 Normally Virgin also use general terms
of sale ie 210 net 30
Firms do not offer the same terms of
sale to all customers
Yes For prime customers Virgin offers
special terms of sale
Approaches of terms of sale decisions
are ndash
bull Standard approach
bull Multi period approach
Virgin uses standard approach of terms
of sale decision as it is simple to use and
understand
Source of credit information are ndash
Sellers prior experience with the
customer
Credit agency ratings and
reports
Personal contact with the
applicants bank and other
creditors
Analysis of applicants financial
statements
Customer visit
Main source of credit information to
Virgin is its prior experience with the
customer All other sources are not cost-
effective for Virgin
Approaches of credit granting to
marginal accounts are ndash
Traditional approach
Net Present Value (NPV)
approach
It uses traditional approach still now but
thinks that NPV should be used for the
next periods
Firms monitor accounts receivable
because deviations from the expected
levels of turnover and of bad debt can
Virgin also monitors its accounts
receivable
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
signal several different problems
Different tools for monitoring accounts
receivable are ndash
Aging schedule
Ratios of receivables
outstanding to original sales
Customers payment
proportions
Sales-weighted DSO
For monitoring accounts receivable
Virgin uses aging schedule and
traditional sales outstanding statistics
84 MANAGING ACCOUNTS PAYABLE (CREDITORS)
Virgin has almost accounts payable of Tk 8000000 But most of its liabilities are to
the banks rather than suppliers But we dont have any clear information about
Virgins accounts payable
9 RECOMMENDATION
Virgin should invest its surplus cash in short term marketable securities
because it is suitable hedging against cash uncertainties and will also give
some returns (interest income)
Virgin should publish its own annual report which will satisfy information
needs of stakeholders and also increase the credibility of information provided
by Virgin
Page 43 of 46
Virgin should use multi period approach in terms of sale decision because
standard approach which is already exists in Virgin has some inherent
problems
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
It should stop using traditional approach from now It should use NPV
method in credit granting to marginal accounts
In monitoring accounts receivable Virgin should use sales-weighted DSO
method because it has least limitation compared to the others
It should be more flexible in granting credit which will ultimately increase its
sales
To get the appropriate number of quantity to be ordered per order it should
use DSO model
It should be ABC system for proper monitoring of inventory
10 CONCLUSION
The use of other peoples money in business is usually an expensive resource Before
looking outside for finance a firm should examine its own working capital cycle to
make sure that every rand of its own internal funds is being fully utilized Good
management of working capital is part of good financial management Effective use
of working capital will contribute to the operational efficiency of the whole
organization optimum use will help to generate maximum returns Furthermore
working capital management is not an end in itself It is an integral part of the firms
overall management The needs of efficient working capital management must be
considered in relation to other aspects of the Virgins financial and non-financial
performance Thats why when planning the development of a business it is critical
that the impact of working capital be fully assessed
Page 44 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
BIBLIOGRAPHY
Scherr FC (1989) International Edition Prentice-Hall International Inc Modern
Working Capital Management Text and Cases
Hussain Riaz (2002) Working Capital Management
Robertson Lonnie (July 1998) Inventory Management
httpwwwasashoporg visited on March 13 2006
The Art of Cash Management
httpwwwinccom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management
httpwwwstudyfinancecom visited on March 13 2006
White Paper ndash Managing Working Capital
httpwwwplanwareorg visited on March 13 2006
Management of Working Capital
httpwwwbusinesscentralcoza visited on March 13 2006
Cash Management
httpwwwsbagov visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management Objectives
httpwpsprenhallcom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management
Page 45 of 46
httpwwwadvancemecom visited on March 13 2006
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Business Receivables Financing
httpwwwbbtcom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Finance
http wwwfnbcoza visited on March 13 2006
Tips to manage your working capital
httpsmallbusinessninemsncomau visited on March 13 2006
Inventory Financing
httpwwwfranklincapitalnetworkcom visited on March 13 2006
Accounts Receivable Management
httpwwwfranklincapitalnetworkcom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management
httpwwwtreasurygovtnz visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management
httpwwwtreasurystrategiescom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Works
httpwwwinvestopediacom visited on March 13 2006
Treasury Services
httpwwwjpmorganchasecom visited on March 13 2006
what were about
Page 46 of 46
httpwwwvirgincom visited on March 13 2006
Annexure
Annexure
Interview with YASEER RIZVI
Mr Yaseer Rizvi the DMD of Global Beverage Co Ltd obtained his MBA degree
from a reputed university He had been the Director of Ocean Container Ltd before
joining in Global Beverage Co Ltd He possesses a nice personality
I interviewed Yaseer Rizvi Excerpts from his interview are as follows ndash
Shah Kamal Sir would you please tell me do you invest in short term marketable securities
Yaseer Rizvi Basically we do not invest our surplus cash in short term marketable
securities like T-Bill commercial paper certificate of deposit etc But we keep our
surplus cash in Bank
Shah Kamal Would you tell me something about transit time for a typical check
Yaseer Rizvi Well in Virgin the transit time for a typical check is ndash
For mail float 2 to 3 days
At firm float 6 hours
Clearing float 1 to 3 days
Shah Kamal Do you maintain any cash concentration mechanism like depository transfer check automated clearing house and wire transfer
i
Annexure
Yaseer Rizvi Our position in this case is very strong as we use all the mechanisms
you mentioned As Virgin is a firm with small deposits spread over a substantial
number of banks so we tend to use depository transfer checks extensively It is less
costly We also use automated clearing house and wire transfer but later is used in a
less extent
Shah Kamal Sir what techniques of disbursement management is used by your firm
Yaseer Rizvi Like other firms Virgin tries to retain the cash for as long as possible
But we always perform it in an ethical manner We do not use management of
disbursement float as it seems unethical We follow Zero-Balance Accounts method
for managing disbursement We do not prefer Controlled Disbursing method since
Zero-Balance system is already practiced in Virgin
Shah Kamal How do you hedge cash balance uncertainties
Yaseer Rizvi Well you may say that we do not invest in short term securities but for
facing cash difficulties we keep our surplus cash in bank
Shah Kamal Sir would you please tell me the general terms of sale of Virgin
Yaseer Rizvi Though it is difficult to maintain a fixed terms of sale our general terms
of sale is 210 n30 But for prime customers we offer special terms of sale
Shah Kamal What are the sources of credit information in case of your firm
Yaseer Rizvi We grant credit on the basis of prior experience with the customers In
case of a new customer personal contact is weighted
Shah Kamal Does your firm consider 5 Cs in granting credit
ii
Annexure
Yaseer Rizvi In case of Virgin Capital and Character get more importance than the
others Mind one thing personal relationship is the main measure in granting credit
Shah Kamal Do you use NPV method in credit granting decisions
Yaseer Rizvi We do not use NPV method But we think that NPV is a suitable
method and we have to use it from the next period
Shah Kamal Sir how do you handle the problem of bad debt
Yaseer Rizvi Well in this case our position is very strong Yet we do not face any
problem because of bad debt Just note that we make more than 80 of sales in cash
and we monitor accounts receivable very carefully
Shah Kamal What level of inventory is maintained by Virgin
Yaseer Rizvi We maintain a minimum level of inventory but do not have to face
stock out problems because inventory is managed efficiently
Shah Kamal What is the normal lead time
Yaseer Rizvi In case of imported goods normal lead time is about 1 month and when
we purchase raw materials from inside the country lead time is 1 to 3 days
Shah Kamal What method do you use for managing inventory
Yaseer Rizvi We do not use any method particularly rather inventory decision
depends on business cycle and market situation Long before the Eid festival we
bought large amount of sugar because price of sugar was increased on the occasion
of Eid
iii
Annexure
Shah Kamal What are the main items of inventory of your firm
Yaseer Rizvi Well these are ndash aluminum can pet chip sugar label chemical and
artificial sweet
Shah Kamal What are the uncertainties in maintaining appropriate level of stock
Yaseer Rizvi These are ndash
bull Increase in price of raw materials
bull Sales uncertainty
bull Market trends etc
Shah Kamal Thank you for your kind cooperation
Yaseer Rizvi Most Welcome
iv
Global Beverage Company Limited
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
statistics on disbursement float) and transfers the amount of the expected
checks to the account on that day or just before
5315 Cash Forecasting
Defining Cash Forecasting
The cash forecast is an estimation of the flows in and out of the firmrsquos cash account
over a particular period of time usually a quarter month week or day The cash
forecast is primarily intended to produce a very useful piece of information an
estimation of the firmrsquos borrowing and lending needs and uncertainties regarding
these needs during various future periods Cash forecasting is very crucial to most
firms It enables them to anticipate periods of surplus cash and periods where
financing will be necessary This anticipation is the reason that cash forecasts are
generated Anticipation enables the firm to plan much more effectively for
investment and financing and via this planning produce superior return
Types of Cash Forecasts
The types of cash forecasts generated by firms can be differentiated along two
dimensions the length of the periods included within the cash forecast and the approach
to cash flows used in the cash forecast The length of the period refers to the units of
time into which the cash forecast is divided Firms may make cash flow forecasts
over periods of various lengths yearly flows quarterly flows monthly flows weekly
flows or even daily flows The most popular forecast involves monthly flows but
most firms do not confine themselves to a single forecast Instead they use several
forecasts with periods of various lengths When the firm makes forecasts involving
multiple and overlapping period lengths one forecast relates to another Starting
with data on relatively long periods and breaking it down into smaller periods is
called distribution starting with data on relatively short periods and aggregating into
longer periods is called scheduling
Page 14 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Firms use two common approaches to cash flows in generating the cash forecast the
receipts and disbursements approach and the adjusted net income approach The receipts
and disbursements approach use the amounts of cash expected to be received and
disbursed by the firm over the periods chosen for forecast The adjusted income
statement approach is sometimes called the sources and use approach Here the
forecaster starts with projected net income on an accrual basis and adjusts to a cash
basis This method provides a representation of changes in asset and liability
accounts since the level of these accounts are of interest to the firm this aspect of the
adjusted income statement is an advantage over the receipts and disbursements
method
Items to Be Forecast
In the receipt and disbursements cash forecasting method estimates need to be made
of the numerous major and minor items that the firm collects (receipts) and that it
pays (disbursements) The more individual categories of items the firm includes in its
forecast procedure the more accurate the forecast may be but the more costly in
terms of time and effort it will be to generate
Some Possible Types of Cash Receipts and Cash Disbursements
Cash Disbursements Cash Receipts
Cash Purchases of Materials Payroll
Taxes
Maturing Accounts Payable
Maturing Notes Payable
Miscellaneous Disbursements
Accounts Receivable
Notes Receivable
Rental Income
Interest Income
Miscellaneous Receipts
Methods of Financial Forecasting
Page 15 of 46
Financial forecasting is the estimation of the future level of a financial variable often
a cash flow asset level or liability level It is usually assumed that the relationship
between the financial variable and other variable is linear The general linear model
can then be used
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
nnt xaxaxaaY 22110 ++=
Here
= Financial variable (Y) to be forecast in period t tY
x = Explanatory variable it is assumed to cause the level of Y in period t
0a = Represents a constant unaffected by the x
The other terms are the estimated coefficients of the explanatory x variables
There are n terms with xrsquos in them
There are four common approaches to forecasting financial variables but they
are all special cases of the general linear model These are ndash spot method proportion
to another account compounded growth and multiple dependencies
Using Cash Forecast
The estimate of available funds for investment and needed financing enables the firm
to plan so as to obtain the most advantages borrowing terms for deficits and achieve
the greatest interest income on surplus A useful chart for this planning purpose is a
bar chart eg
Figure Bar Chart of Cash Surpluses and Deficits from hypothetical data
Page 16 of 46
75
50
-60
30
100
-20
-80-60-40-20
020406080
100120
Defic
it
S
urpl
us
January February March April May June
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Sources of Uncertainty in Cash Forecasting and Hedging Uncertainties
There are numerous sources of risk in cash forecasting Among the sources are sales
uncertainty collection rate uncertainty production cost uncertainty and capital
outflow uncertainty
5316 Models for the Management of Cash and Temporary Investments
There are different models for the management of cash and temporary investments
Among these the most popular methods are ndash Baumol model Beranek model
Miller-Orr model and Stone model
Baumol and Beranek use the same model The formula is cited below ndash
Interest Income = iYn
n⎥⎦⎤
⎢⎣⎡ minus
21
Profit = naiYn
nminus⎥⎦
⎤⎢⎣⎡ minus
21
Optimum number of transactions = ⎟⎠⎞
⎜⎝⎛
aiY2
Where n = Optimum number of transactions
i = Interest rate per period
a = Transaction cost
Y = Total inflow for the period
Page 17 of 46
Miller-Orr and Stone use the same model ie R-Statistic The model is ndash
31
43
iav
R ⎟⎠⎞
⎜⎝⎛=
Optimum Control Limit = R + L
Upper Control Limit = 3R + L
Where a = Transaction Cost
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
v = Variance of daily cash flows
i = Daily interest rate
5317 Administration
Cash receipts should be processed and banked as quickly as possible because
They cannot earn interest or reduce overdraft until they are banked
information about the existence and amounts of cash receipts is usually not
available until they are processed
Where possible cash floats (mainly petty cash and advances) should be avoided If
on review the only reason that can be put forward for their existence is that weve
always had them they should be discontinued There may be situations where they
are useful however For example it may be desirable for peripheral parts of
departments to meet urgent local needs from cash floats rather than local bank
accounts
5318 Internal Control
Cash and cash management is part of a firms overall internal control system The
main internal cash control is invariably the bank reconciliation This provides
assurance that the cash balances recorded in the accounting systems are consistent
with the actual bank balances It requires regular clearing of reconciling items
5319 Practicing Good Cash Flow Management
Good cash management is simple It involves
Knowing when where and how firms cash needs will occur
Page 18 of 46
Knowing the best sources for meeting additional cash needs
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Page 19 of 46
Being prepared to meet these needs when they occur by keeping good
relationships with bankers and other creditors
532 INVENTORY MANAGEMENT
Inventory management is necessary for owners who want to maintain a stocking
service for quick turnaround to help ensure total customer satisfaction The fill rate
of an item on a managed inventory list must be maintained to avoid shortages of
frequently used items Even when utilizing an inventory management system
occasional shortages will still occur Inventories are lists of stocks-raw materials
work in progress or finished goods-waiting to be consumed in production or to be
sold The total balance of inventory is the sum of the value of each individual stock
line
Basically firms hold stocks for the following reasons
To act as a buffer in times of unusually high demand
To ensure continuity of production
Avoid high costs of emergency orders
To take advantage of quantity discounts by ordering more at a time
To reduce ordering costs by ordering more items on fewer
As part of the production process eg maturing whisky or keeping oil in
pipelines
Seasonality of demand (eg firework) or supplies
Suppliers insist on minimum order quantities
The key issue for a business is to identify the fast and slow stock movers with the
objectives of establishing optimum stock levels for each category and thereby
minimize the cash tied up in stocks Factors to be considered when determining
optimum stock levels include
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Page 20 of 46
What are the projected sales of each product
How widely available are raw materials components etc
How long does it take for delivery by suppliers
Can the firm remove slow movers from its product range without
compromising best sellers
Inventory management is an important aspect of working capital management
because inventories themselves do not earn any revenue Holding either too little or
too much inventory incurs costs
Costs of carrying too much inventory are
Opportunity cost of foregone interest
Warehousing costs
Damage and pilferage
Obsolescence
Insurance
Costs of carrying too little inventory are
Stock out costs
Lost sales
Delayed service
Ordering costs
Freight
on Order administrati
nts
Loss of quantity discou
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Carrying costs can be minimized by making frequent small orders but this increase
ordering costs and the risk of stock outs Risk of stock-outs can be reduced by
carrying safety stocks (at a cost) and re-ordering ahead of time
The best ordering strategy requires balancing the various cost factors to ensure the
firm incurs minimum inventory costs The optimum inventory position is known as
the Economic Reorder Quantity (ERQ)
Nowadays many large manufacturers operate on a just-in-time (JIT) basis whereby
all the components to be assembled on a particular today arrive at the factory early
that morning no earlier - no later This helps to minimize manufacturing costs as JIT
stocks take up little space minimize stock-holding and virtually eliminate the risks of
obsolete or damaged stock Because JIT manufacturers hold stock for a very short
time they are able to conserve substantial cash JIT is a good model to strive for as it
embraces all the principles of prudent stock management For better stock control
firm may try the following
Review the effectiveness of existing purchasing and inventory systems
Know the stock turn for all major items of inventory
Apply tight controls to the significant few items and simplify controls for the
trivial many
Sell off outdated or slow moving merchandise - it gets more difficult to sell the
longer the firm keeps it
Consider having part of its product outsourced to another manufacturer rather
than make it itself
Review its security procedures to ensure that no stock is going out the back
door
Higher than necessary stock levels tie up cash and cost more in insurance
accommodation costs and interest charges
Page 21 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
However it is important to keep an overall perspective It is not cost-effective to
closely manage a large number of low value inventory lines nor is it necessary A
usual feature of inventories is that a small number of high value lines account for a
large proportion of inventory value The 8020 rule (PARETO) predicts that 80
of the total value of inventory is represented by only 20 of the number of inventory
items Those high value lines need reasonably close management The remaining
80 of inventory lines can be managed using broad-brush strategies
533 MANAGING ACCOUNTS RECEIVABLE (DEBTORS)
Cash flow can be significantly enhanced if the amounts owing to a business are
collected faster Every business needs to know who owes them money how much is
owed how long it is owing for what it is owed
Debtors (Accounts Receivable) are customers who have not yet made payment for
goods or services which the department has provided The objective of debtor
management is to minimize the time-lapse between completion of sales and receipt
of payment The costs of having debtors are
Opportunity costs (cash is not available for other purposes)
Bad debts
If firm doesnt manage debtors they will begin to manage business as the firm will gradually
lose control due to reduced cash flow and of course it could experience an increased
incidence of bad debt The following measures will help manage debtors
Having the right mental attitude to the control of credit and make sure that it
gets the priority it deserves
Establishing clear credit practices as a matter of company policy
Page 22 of 46
Making sure that these practices are clearly understood by staff suppliers and
customers
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Page 23 of 46
Being professional when accepting new accounts and especially larger ones
Checking out each customer thoroughly before the firm offers credit Use
credit agencies bank references industry sources etc
Establishing credit limits for each customer and sticking to them
Continuously reviewing these limits when it suspects tough times are coming
or if operating in a volatile sector
Keeping very close to the firms larger customers
Invoicing promptly and clearly
Considering charging penalties on overdue accounts
Considering accepting credit debit cards as a payment option
Monitoring its debtor balances and ageing schedules and dont let any debts
get too large or too old
Debtor management includes both pre-sale and debt collection strategies
Pre-sale strategies include
Offering cash discounts for early payment andor imposing penalties for late
payment
Agreeing payment terms in advance
Requiring cash before delivery
Setting credit limits
ning credit Setting criteria for obtai
Billing as early as possible
rogress payments
ost-sale strategies include
for collecting the debt upon the center that made the sale
Requiring deposits andor p
P
Placing the responsibility
Identifying long overdue balances and doubtful debts by regular analytical reviews
Having an established procedure for late collections such as
A reminder
A letter
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Page 24 of 46
ion of further credit Cancellat
Telephone calls
n agency Use of a collectio
he firm should recognize that the longer someone owes firm the greater the chance
Legal action
T
it will never get paid If the average age of debtors is getting longer or is already very
long it may need to look for the following possible defects
Weak credit judgment
res Poor collection procedu
ms Lax enforcement of credit ter
Slow issue of invoices or statements
Errors in invoices or statements
Customer dissatisfaction
Debtors due over 90 days (unless within agreed credit terms) should generally
demand immediate attention For example warning signs of a future bad debt ndash
Longer credit terms taken with approval particularly for smaller orders
Use of post-dated checks by debtors who normally settle within agreed terms
Evidence of customers switching to additional suppliers for the same goods
New customers who are reluctant to give credit references
Cre G
Receiving part payments from debtors
dit ranting to Marginal Accounts
Traditional Approach
In the traditional approach to the credit granting decision it is the credit analysts job
rmation that has been collected and reach a judgment
regarding the applicants creditworthiness One traditional way of organizing this
to synthesize all the info
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
information is by characterizing the applicant along five dimensions These
dimensions are called the Five Cs of credit ndash
Capital
Character
Collateral
and Capacity
Conditions
Net Present Value (NPV) Approach
Once a firm has assessed the creditworthiness of a customer it has to decide whether
r not credit should be granted The firm should use the NPV rule to make the
ld be granted
Figure
o
decision If NPV is positive credit shou
Credit Granting Decision
Credit Granting Decision
he act of collecting money is one which most people dislike for many reasons and
therefore put on the long f selves there is something
ore urgent or important that demands their attention now There is nothing more
T
inger because they convince them
m
important than getting paid for firms product or service A customer who does not
Page 25 of 46
Grand Credit
Payment received Payment not received
Benefit of present value of future net cash flow
Cost of present value ment of lost invest
Net Payoff PV of benefit-cost
No Credit
No Payoff
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
pay is not a customer Here are a few ideas that may help the firm in collecting
money from debtors
Firm should develop appropriate procedures for handling late payments
It should track and pursue late payers
It might get external help if its own efforts fail
or money its firms and it is entitled Company shouldnt feel guilty asking f
to it
ction
Firm must make that call now And it should keep asking until it gets some
satisfa
lessens the problem
In difficult circumstances take what the firm can now and agree terms for the
remainder It
paying
When asking for money be hard on the issue - but soft on the person It shouldnt
give the debtor any excuses for not
534 BLE (CREDITORS)
ices for goods or services have
een paid Organizations often regard the
not
to delay all payments until the latest possible date Regular weekly or
The firm make it its objective is to get the money - not to score points or get
even
MANAGING ACCOUNTS PAYA
Creditors (Accounts Payable) are suppliers whose invo
been processed but who have not yet b
amount owing to creditors as a source of free credit However creditor
administration systems are expensive and time-consuming to run The over-riding
concern in this area should be to minimize costs with simple procedures
While it is unnecessary to pay accounts before they fall due it is usually
worthwhile
Page 26 of 46
fortnightly payment of all due accounts is the simplest technique for creditor
management
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Electronic payments (direct credits) are cheaper than check payments considering
that transaction fees and overheads more than balance the advantage of delayed
presentation Some suppliers are reluctant to receive payments by this method but in
view of the substantial cost advantage (and the advantages to the suppliers
themselves) departments may wish to encourage suppliers to accept this option
However electronic payments are likely to be used in conjunction with rather than
as a replacement for check payments
Applying Best Practices in Managing Accounts Payable
f course simply deferring payments to suppliers could have adverse consequences
O
that more than offset the benefits of this additional cash flow Therefore it is
important to develop a holistic approach The firm should consider the following
best practices for payables management
Managing payment dates and terms to maximize cash flow ndash
y reporting on
receivable and
id penalty charges and taking advantage of
wer vendors and negotiate for more
to buying consortia with others even
voices for
payment based on receipt of goods or receipt of invoice whichever
comes later
Calculating and setting performance targets Regularl
AP performance measures such as days in payables
Coordinating the AP processes with accounts
inventory management to ensure that the company is collecting more
cash than it is paying out
Paying bills on time to avo
prompt-payment discounts where the discounts exceed the companyrsquos
cost of working capital
Consolidating purchases with fe
favorable payment terms
Considering entering in
Page 27 of 46
competitors to obtain favorable supplier pricing and terms
Unless contract terms specify otherwise setting up in
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Page 28 of 46
Em
process
-time payments with Electronic Funds Transfer (EFT)
uraging vendors to utilize electronic invoice presentment
a
ndancies and more
ploying technology to automate the accounts payable transaction
es ndash
Making just-in
Using an electronic invoice-matching application
Enco
For companies with multiple locations or business units employing
shared service approach for AP to eliminate redu
quickly implement process improvements
Mainta
vendor
Communicating accounts payable requirements to suppliers at the
m key suppliers
for suggestions on how to improve the
Efficient a
and making th rsquos cash is just good business
ining open communications and building strong relationships with
s to access valuable trade credit ndash
beginning of transactions
Requesting summary invoicing fro
Requiring suppliers to send invoices directly to accounts payable
Asking tier-one suppliers
payment process
nd effective management of accounts payable helps improve cash flow ndash
e most of company
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
6 OVERVIEW OF VIRGIN GROUP
Virgin - one of the most respected brands in Britain - is now becoming the first global
brand name of the 21st century Virgin is involved in planes trains finance soft
drinks music mobile phones holidays cars wines publishing bridal wear - the lot
What tie all these businesses together are the values of its brand and the attitude of its
people Virgin has created over 200 companies worldwide employing over 25000
people Its total revenues around the world in 2002 exceeded pound4 billion (US $72
billion)
In 1970 Richard Branson founded Virgin as a mail order record retailer and not
long after he opened a record shop in Oxford Street London During 1972 a
recording studio was built in Oxfordshire and the first Virgin artist Mike Oldfield
recorded Tubular Bells which was released in 1973
This album went on to sell over 5 million copies Since then many household names
including Belinda Carlisle Genesis Phil Collins Janet Jackson and The Rolling
Stones have helped to make Virgin Music one of the top six record companies in the
world The equity of Virgin Music Group - record labels music publishing and
recording studios was sold to THORN EMI in 1992 in a US$1billion deal
Page 29 of 46
The Virgin Group has now expanded into international music Mega stores air
travel mobile financial retail music internet drinks rail hotels and leisure with
around 200 companies in over 30 countries
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
In Virgins customers eyes Virgin stands for value for money quality innovation
fun and a sense of competitive challenge It delivers a quality service by empowering
its employees and facilitates and monitors customer feedback to continually improve
the customers experience through innovation
When they start a new venture Virgin bases it on hard research and analysis
Typically they review the industry and put themselves in the customers shoes to see
what could make it better Virgin asks fundamental questions
Is this an opportunity for restructuring a market and creating competitive
advantage What are the competitors doing
Is the customer confused or badly served
Is this an opportunity for building the Virgin brand
Can we add value
Will it interact with its other businesses
Is there an appropriate trade-off between risk and reward
Page 30 of 46
Virgin is also able to draw on talented people from throughout the group New
ventures are often steered by people seconded from other parts of Virgin who bring
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
with them the trademark management style skills and experience Virgin frequently
creates partnerships with others to combine skills knowledge and market presence
and so on Contrary to what some people may think their constantly expanding and
eclectic empire is neither random nor reckless Each successive venture demonstrates
its skill in picking the right market and the right opportunity
7 OVERVIEW OF VIRGIN SOFT DRINKS
The Virgin Drinks Group first launched as the Virgin Cola Company in 1994 with
Virgin Cola in the UK Since then the company has ventured across the carbonated
soft drinks arena and beyond into energy drinks tea and flavored Colas This
expansion has lead to the evolution of the Virgin Drinks Company a company
whose aim is to put the excitement back into the world of soft drinks It launched in
Bangladesh in 1999 Virgin Soft Drinks is monitored by Global Beverage Co Ltd in
Bangladesh
Brief history of Virgin Drinks is given below
Page 31 of 46
1994 November Virgin Cola launched in the UK
1996 March Virgin Cola launched in France
1998 June Virgin Cola launched in Belgium
April Virgin Cola launched in the French West Indies
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
August Virgin Cola launched in Switzerland
1999 March Virgin Colours launched in Italy
March Virgin Cola launched in Japan
July Virgin Colours launched in South Africa
December Virgin Colours launched in Bangladesh
2001 January Sweden launched Virgin Colours
November Singapore launched Virgin Colours
2002 February Croatia launched Virgin Colours
June Russia launched Virgin Colours
June Tunisia launched Virgin Colours
2003 May Israel launched Virgin Colours
8 FINDINGS OF WORKING CAPITAL MANAGEMENT MAINTAINED BY
VIRGIN SOFT DRINKS IN BANGLADESH
81 CASH MANAGEMENT
811 Holding Cash and Marketable Securities
Although there are many good reasons why firm hold cash and marketable
securities Virgin Drinks holds cash and marketable securities for two reasons ndash
i) Cash for transactions
ii) Cash as hedges
This indicates that the firm does not hold cash and marketable securities for some
important reasons such as ndash
i) Near cash assets as hedges
Page 32 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
ii) Temporary investment and compensating balances
Virgin Soft Drinks does not invest in money market securities such as Treasury bill
commercial paper certificate of deposits bankerrsquos acceptance and repurchase
agreement This firm deposits its money in bank as currant AC or fixed AC They
say that they do not have enough money to invest in money market instrument
They also say that if they have enough money they will invest it in money market
short term securities We know that near cash interest earning assets can be
substituted for cash when motivation for holding these assets is the hedging of cash
flow uncertainties or is the temporary investment of surplus funds In this point
Virgins position is not good as there is no significant hedging against uncertainty of
cash
812 Floatation and Check Clearing
Virgin is very smart in handling the problem of transit time for checks Here mail
float takes 2 to 3 days at firm takes 025 day and clearing float takes 1-3 days Virgin
uses most of the strategies available for reducing the delay in receiving funds It
(Virgin) has linked Islami Bank which posses an accelerated clearing facility It uses
electronic collection process which ensures faster collection and its at the firm check
processing is satisfactory But Virgin does not use lockbox The reason behind this is
that it is not cost-effective for Virgin to set lockboxes At this point we can say that
Virgins check clearing mechanism is much good
813 Cash Concentration and Disbursement Management
Page 33 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks takes the matter of cash concentration very seriously They use all
the available cash concentration mechanism Virgin is a firm with small deposits
spread over a substantial number of banks and this is why the firm tends to use
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
depository transfer checks extensively If is less costly Virgin also uses automated
clearing house and wire transfer To Virgin wire transfer seems too costly
Like other firm Virgin tries to retain the cash for as long as possible But Virgin
always performs it in an ethical manner Virgin does not try to defeat the receiving
firmrsquos attempts to reduce the float on incoming checks It does not take any strategy
for increasing mail float at firm float and clearing float on its outgoing checks To
Virgin it is deemed to be unethical It thinks that maximization of disbursement float
will not go unnoticed by sophisticated creditors for very long When it is noticed it
will negatively affect relations with these creditors reducing the firmrsquos bargaining
power with them This may ultimately cost Virgin dearly when future prices and
delivery schedules for goods and services purchased from trade creditors are
negotiated Virgin follows ldquoZero-Balance Accountsrdquo methods for managing
disbursement It thinks that in this method the coordination of funds inflows to
disbursement banks with the presentation of checks does not work to the detriment
of creditors since the firmrsquos checks to them are honored as presented and this strategy
does not affect float significantly Controlled disbursing method is less attractive to
Virgin because zero-balance system is already feasible
814 Cash Forecasting
Cash Forecasting and Its Types
Page 34 of 46
Virgin forecasts the future cash inflows and outflows To Virgin cash forecast is an
important part of the firmrsquos cash control system and is one of the forecasts that are
part of the Virginrsquos financial plan Virgin forecasts cash on monthly basis and on
yearly basis Virgin does not forecast on daily basis assuming that the temporary
shortage of funds within these periods can be covered without value cost eg
advance receipts from customers Virginrsquos cash forecasting system involves a
combination of distribution and scheduling The receipts and disbursements
approach of cash forecasting is used in virgin This method is used because it
minutely traces the movement of cash and very close control of cash is possible
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Virgin does not use adjusted net income approach on two grounds First it does not
permit the tracing of the individual types of cash inflows and outflows for any given
period which is often useful information for virgin Second it is not simple to use
Items to be Forecast
Virgin does not forecast all the items It forecasts only major items eg accounts
receivable notes receivable payroll cash purchases of raw materials In this regard
virgin trade off between cost and benefit
Methods of Financial Forecasting
Virgin forecasts the future level of financial variable such as cash level asset level or
liability level We know in short term forecasts many things will result from plans
and events that are already in place (contracts capital budgets long-range financing
plans and so forth) But in the long run most things can vary and are dependent on
outside influences such as the firmrsquos long-term growth rate Since Virginrsquos cash
forecasting deals mostly with near future many of the items on the cash forecasts are
estimated by some variation of the spot method and remaining estimates are mostly
on a ldquoproportion of another accountrdquo basis with this ldquoother accountrdquo often being a
particular periodrsquos sales Virgin uses the other two methods less frequently
Using Cash Forecast
Virgin forecasts cash for meeting general objectives (ie to know the available funds
for investment and need financing) and for meeting some special objectives (eg to
know whether the firm will fulfill its out of debt requirement) But it is matter to note
that Virgin does not make any short term investment of its surplus cash but only keep
this surplus in Bank Account
Page 35 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Sources of Uncertainty in Cash Forecasting and Hedging Uncertainties
Virgin faces uncertainty in cash forecasting mainly from two sources These are ndash
sales and production cost In peak season (hot season like autumn summer) sales
increases but in dull season (eg in winter) sales decreases drastically Production
cost may be increased because of increase of price of sugar chemicals aluminum
can Virgin follows two methods for hedging cash balance uncertainties These are ndash
i) Holding a stock of extra cash and
ii) Extra borrowing capacity
815 Modes for the Management of Cash and Temporary Investments
Virgin does not follow any of these methods wholly Virgin receives cash
continuously and pays salary at steady rate and pays continuously for other
expenses So it neither follows Baumol model nor Beranek model It has no upper
control limit lower control limit return point in case cash management So it neither
follows Miller-Orr model nor Stone model
In Summary
Page 36 of 46
Standard Compliance by Virgin Soft Drinks
Generally all firms hold cash and
marketable securities
Virgin holds only cash
Firms hold cash and marketable
securities for some reasons like
bull Cash for transactions
bull Cash and near-cash assets as
hedges
bull Temporary investments
bull Compensating balances
Virgin holds cash only for
two reasons ndash
bull Cash for transactions
bull Cash as hedges
Available money market instruments Virgin does not invest in any such
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
(short term securities) are ndash
Treasury Bills
Commercial Paper
Certificates of Deposit
Bankerrsquos Acceptance
Repurch menase Agree ts
instruments They only keep cash in
Bank Account
Mail Float
(1 to 5 days)
At Firm
Float
(025 to 1
day)
Clearing
Float
(0 to
2 days)
Mail Float
(2 to 3 days)
At firm
Float
(025
day)
Clearing
Float
(1 to 3
days)
Figure Transit time for a typical check Figure Transit time for a check for
Virgin
Strategies that firms can use to reduce
the delay in receiving funds are ndash
Selecting of Banks with
accelerated clearing capabilities
of check processing Acceleration
at the firm
ectronic collection Use of el
procedures
Use of lockboxes
Virgin follows the first three strategies
but does not use lockboxes
Available cash concentration
mechanisms are ndash
Depository transfer check
ouse Automated Clearing H
(ACH) electronic transfer)
Wire transfer
Virgin uses all these mechanisms of
cash concentration
Available sets of techniques for cash
disbursement management are ndash
ement of disbursement
Page 37 of 46
Manag
float
Virgin uses zero-balance accounts
technique
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Zero-Balance Accounts
Controlled disbursing
Firms may make cash flow forecasts
over periods of various lengths yearly
flows quarterly flows monthly flows
weekly flows or even daily flows
Virgin forecasts cash on yearly basis and
monthly basis
Cash forecasting system may involve ndash
Distribution
Scheduling
Virginrsquos cash forecasting system
involves a combination of distribution
and scheduling
Two common approaches to cash flow
in generating the cash forecast
and disbursement Receipts
approach
Adjusted net income approach
Virgin uses the receipts and
disbursement approach
There are many items to forecast Virgin forecasts only major items like
AR payroll etc
Four common approach to forecasting
fina i ndash nc al variables are
Spot method
Proportion to another account
Compounded growth
Multiple dependencies
Virgin uses spot method for forecasting
cash It uses proportion to another
account method for other variables and
remaining two methods are frequently
used
Sources of uncertainty in cash
forecasting are ndash
Sales uncertainty
Collection rate uncertainty
Production cost uncertainty
Capital outflow uncertainty
Virgin faces uncertainty mainly from
sales and production cost
Methods for hedging cash balance
unc a
Page 38 of 46
ert inties are ndash
i) Holding a stock of extra cash
Virgin two available methods for
hedging cash balance uncertainties
Th ese are ndash
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
ii) stock of near-cash Holding a
assets
iii) Extra borrowing capacity
iv) ary surpluses in Investing tempor
near-cash assets
i) Holding a stock of extra cash
ii) Extra borrowing capacity
(advance receipt from
customers)
Models for the management of cash and
temporary investments are ndash Baumol
model Beranek model Miller-Orr
model and Stone model
Virgin does not follow any method
wholly but a combination of Baumol
model and Beranek model is occurred
82 INVENTORY MANAGEMENT
21 Certainty Approach
isnt used in
irgin because it thinks it is not possible to implement in Bangladesh
d time is one to three days It
oes not use ABC system of inventory management
8
Main item of inventory of Virgin is Can pet chip sugar label chemical artificial
sweet etc Virgin maintains a minimum level of inventory but it does not have to face
problems because inventory is managed efficiently just-in-time (JIT)
V
Virgin maintains buffer stock because of the shortage of work-in-process (WIP)
inventory Its production process may also be hampered Thats why it maintains
safety stock to avoid stock out cost In case of imported goods normal lead time is
about one month and within the country normal lea
d
Page 39 of 46
Inventory Model
In reality Virgin does not use any of models of EOQ ordering and holding strategy
and safety stock strategy They maintain inventory based on their prior experience
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
822 Uncertainty Approach
Virgin does not use any model for handling inventory uncertainty It says that such
decision depends on business cycle and market situation Long before Eid festival
they bought large amount of sugar because of price increase on the occasion of Eid
In summary
Standard Compliance by Virgin Soft Drinks
Firms maintain inventory to guard
against several problems
Virgin maintains a minimum level of
inventory which is managed efficiently
Some firms use JIT to avoid inventory
cost
JIT is not used by Virgin as it thinks it is
impossible to implement in Bangladesh
Firms maintain buffer stock Virgin maintains buffer stock too
Firms maintain safety stock to avoid
shortage cost
Virgin also maintains safety stock
Firms use ABC system to monitor
inventory
Virgin doesnt use ABC system
EOQ model is an appropriate method
for measuring quantity that has to be
ordered per order
Virgin does not use EOQ model rather
makes order based on experience and
market demand
83 MANAGING ACCOUNTS RECEIVABLE (DEBTORS)
831 Terms of Sale Decision
Page 40 of 46
Virgin offers the term 210 net 30 enables the customers to deduct 2 percent from the
face value of the bill when paying within the first 10 days but if the discount is not
taken the customer must remit the full amount within 30 days But Virgin does not
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
offer the same terms of sale to all customers For prime customers it offers special
terms of sale In setting an appropriate term of sale it costs and benefits regarding
this are compared It uses the standard approach of terms of sale decision as it is
simple to use
832 Credit Granting Decisions
In case of Virgin the Capital and Character of Five Cs get more importance
Although there are many problems with the traditional approach Virgin uses it
because of its simplicity Virgin does not use Net Present Value (NPV) method in
credit granting decision It thinks that NPV is an appropriate method and should be
used next time It does not face any severe problem because of bad debts The reason
is that notes receivable is used when credit is granted
833 Monitoring Accounts Receivable
Virgin monitors its accounts receivable Virgin believes that in any case both positive
and negative durations in accounts signal differences from the results that
management believe to be the most advantageous for the firm
Tools for Monitoring Accounts Receivable
Page 41 of 46
For monitoring accounts receivable there are several tools such as aging schedule
the ratios of receivable outstanding to original sales customers payment proportion
and sales weighted DSO (Days Sales Outstanding) For monitoring accounts
receivable Virgin uses aging schedule fractions and traditional DSO statistics
because of their simplicity in use Although payment proportions ratios of
receivables outstanding and sales weighted DSO methods are free from inherent bias
None of these is used because all these are complex to maintain
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
In summary
Page 42 of 46
Standard Compliance by Virgin Soft Drinks
Generals terms of sale is 210 net 30 Normally Virgin also use general terms
of sale ie 210 net 30
Firms do not offer the same terms of
sale to all customers
Yes For prime customers Virgin offers
special terms of sale
Approaches of terms of sale decisions
are ndash
bull Standard approach
bull Multi period approach
Virgin uses standard approach of terms
of sale decision as it is simple to use and
understand
Source of credit information are ndash
Sellers prior experience with the
customer
Credit agency ratings and
reports
Personal contact with the
applicants bank and other
creditors
Analysis of applicants financial
statements
Customer visit
Main source of credit information to
Virgin is its prior experience with the
customer All other sources are not cost-
effective for Virgin
Approaches of credit granting to
marginal accounts are ndash
Traditional approach
Net Present Value (NPV)
approach
It uses traditional approach still now but
thinks that NPV should be used for the
next periods
Firms monitor accounts receivable
because deviations from the expected
levels of turnover and of bad debt can
Virgin also monitors its accounts
receivable
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
signal several different problems
Different tools for monitoring accounts
receivable are ndash
Aging schedule
Ratios of receivables
outstanding to original sales
Customers payment
proportions
Sales-weighted DSO
For monitoring accounts receivable
Virgin uses aging schedule and
traditional sales outstanding statistics
84 MANAGING ACCOUNTS PAYABLE (CREDITORS)
Virgin has almost accounts payable of Tk 8000000 But most of its liabilities are to
the banks rather than suppliers But we dont have any clear information about
Virgins accounts payable
9 RECOMMENDATION
Virgin should invest its surplus cash in short term marketable securities
because it is suitable hedging against cash uncertainties and will also give
some returns (interest income)
Virgin should publish its own annual report which will satisfy information
needs of stakeholders and also increase the credibility of information provided
by Virgin
Page 43 of 46
Virgin should use multi period approach in terms of sale decision because
standard approach which is already exists in Virgin has some inherent
problems
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
It should stop using traditional approach from now It should use NPV
method in credit granting to marginal accounts
In monitoring accounts receivable Virgin should use sales-weighted DSO
method because it has least limitation compared to the others
It should be more flexible in granting credit which will ultimately increase its
sales
To get the appropriate number of quantity to be ordered per order it should
use DSO model
It should be ABC system for proper monitoring of inventory
10 CONCLUSION
The use of other peoples money in business is usually an expensive resource Before
looking outside for finance a firm should examine its own working capital cycle to
make sure that every rand of its own internal funds is being fully utilized Good
management of working capital is part of good financial management Effective use
of working capital will contribute to the operational efficiency of the whole
organization optimum use will help to generate maximum returns Furthermore
working capital management is not an end in itself It is an integral part of the firms
overall management The needs of efficient working capital management must be
considered in relation to other aspects of the Virgins financial and non-financial
performance Thats why when planning the development of a business it is critical
that the impact of working capital be fully assessed
Page 44 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
BIBLIOGRAPHY
Scherr FC (1989) International Edition Prentice-Hall International Inc Modern
Working Capital Management Text and Cases
Hussain Riaz (2002) Working Capital Management
Robertson Lonnie (July 1998) Inventory Management
httpwwwasashoporg visited on March 13 2006
The Art of Cash Management
httpwwwinccom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management
httpwwwstudyfinancecom visited on March 13 2006
White Paper ndash Managing Working Capital
httpwwwplanwareorg visited on March 13 2006
Management of Working Capital
httpwwwbusinesscentralcoza visited on March 13 2006
Cash Management
httpwwwsbagov visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management Objectives
httpwpsprenhallcom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management
Page 45 of 46
httpwwwadvancemecom visited on March 13 2006
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Business Receivables Financing
httpwwwbbtcom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Finance
http wwwfnbcoza visited on March 13 2006
Tips to manage your working capital
httpsmallbusinessninemsncomau visited on March 13 2006
Inventory Financing
httpwwwfranklincapitalnetworkcom visited on March 13 2006
Accounts Receivable Management
httpwwwfranklincapitalnetworkcom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management
httpwwwtreasurygovtnz visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management
httpwwwtreasurystrategiescom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Works
httpwwwinvestopediacom visited on March 13 2006
Treasury Services
httpwwwjpmorganchasecom visited on March 13 2006
what were about
Page 46 of 46
httpwwwvirgincom visited on March 13 2006
Annexure
Annexure
Interview with YASEER RIZVI
Mr Yaseer Rizvi the DMD of Global Beverage Co Ltd obtained his MBA degree
from a reputed university He had been the Director of Ocean Container Ltd before
joining in Global Beverage Co Ltd He possesses a nice personality
I interviewed Yaseer Rizvi Excerpts from his interview are as follows ndash
Shah Kamal Sir would you please tell me do you invest in short term marketable securities
Yaseer Rizvi Basically we do not invest our surplus cash in short term marketable
securities like T-Bill commercial paper certificate of deposit etc But we keep our
surplus cash in Bank
Shah Kamal Would you tell me something about transit time for a typical check
Yaseer Rizvi Well in Virgin the transit time for a typical check is ndash
For mail float 2 to 3 days
At firm float 6 hours
Clearing float 1 to 3 days
Shah Kamal Do you maintain any cash concentration mechanism like depository transfer check automated clearing house and wire transfer
i
Annexure
Yaseer Rizvi Our position in this case is very strong as we use all the mechanisms
you mentioned As Virgin is a firm with small deposits spread over a substantial
number of banks so we tend to use depository transfer checks extensively It is less
costly We also use automated clearing house and wire transfer but later is used in a
less extent
Shah Kamal Sir what techniques of disbursement management is used by your firm
Yaseer Rizvi Like other firms Virgin tries to retain the cash for as long as possible
But we always perform it in an ethical manner We do not use management of
disbursement float as it seems unethical We follow Zero-Balance Accounts method
for managing disbursement We do not prefer Controlled Disbursing method since
Zero-Balance system is already practiced in Virgin
Shah Kamal How do you hedge cash balance uncertainties
Yaseer Rizvi Well you may say that we do not invest in short term securities but for
facing cash difficulties we keep our surplus cash in bank
Shah Kamal Sir would you please tell me the general terms of sale of Virgin
Yaseer Rizvi Though it is difficult to maintain a fixed terms of sale our general terms
of sale is 210 n30 But for prime customers we offer special terms of sale
Shah Kamal What are the sources of credit information in case of your firm
Yaseer Rizvi We grant credit on the basis of prior experience with the customers In
case of a new customer personal contact is weighted
Shah Kamal Does your firm consider 5 Cs in granting credit
ii
Annexure
Yaseer Rizvi In case of Virgin Capital and Character get more importance than the
others Mind one thing personal relationship is the main measure in granting credit
Shah Kamal Do you use NPV method in credit granting decisions
Yaseer Rizvi We do not use NPV method But we think that NPV is a suitable
method and we have to use it from the next period
Shah Kamal Sir how do you handle the problem of bad debt
Yaseer Rizvi Well in this case our position is very strong Yet we do not face any
problem because of bad debt Just note that we make more than 80 of sales in cash
and we monitor accounts receivable very carefully
Shah Kamal What level of inventory is maintained by Virgin
Yaseer Rizvi We maintain a minimum level of inventory but do not have to face
stock out problems because inventory is managed efficiently
Shah Kamal What is the normal lead time
Yaseer Rizvi In case of imported goods normal lead time is about 1 month and when
we purchase raw materials from inside the country lead time is 1 to 3 days
Shah Kamal What method do you use for managing inventory
Yaseer Rizvi We do not use any method particularly rather inventory decision
depends on business cycle and market situation Long before the Eid festival we
bought large amount of sugar because price of sugar was increased on the occasion
of Eid
iii
Annexure
Shah Kamal What are the main items of inventory of your firm
Yaseer Rizvi Well these are ndash aluminum can pet chip sugar label chemical and
artificial sweet
Shah Kamal What are the uncertainties in maintaining appropriate level of stock
Yaseer Rizvi These are ndash
bull Increase in price of raw materials
bull Sales uncertainty
bull Market trends etc
Shah Kamal Thank you for your kind cooperation
Yaseer Rizvi Most Welcome
iv
Global Beverage Company Limited
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Firms use two common approaches to cash flows in generating the cash forecast the
receipts and disbursements approach and the adjusted net income approach The receipts
and disbursements approach use the amounts of cash expected to be received and
disbursed by the firm over the periods chosen for forecast The adjusted income
statement approach is sometimes called the sources and use approach Here the
forecaster starts with projected net income on an accrual basis and adjusts to a cash
basis This method provides a representation of changes in asset and liability
accounts since the level of these accounts are of interest to the firm this aspect of the
adjusted income statement is an advantage over the receipts and disbursements
method
Items to Be Forecast
In the receipt and disbursements cash forecasting method estimates need to be made
of the numerous major and minor items that the firm collects (receipts) and that it
pays (disbursements) The more individual categories of items the firm includes in its
forecast procedure the more accurate the forecast may be but the more costly in
terms of time and effort it will be to generate
Some Possible Types of Cash Receipts and Cash Disbursements
Cash Disbursements Cash Receipts
Cash Purchases of Materials Payroll
Taxes
Maturing Accounts Payable
Maturing Notes Payable
Miscellaneous Disbursements
Accounts Receivable
Notes Receivable
Rental Income
Interest Income
Miscellaneous Receipts
Methods of Financial Forecasting
Page 15 of 46
Financial forecasting is the estimation of the future level of a financial variable often
a cash flow asset level or liability level It is usually assumed that the relationship
between the financial variable and other variable is linear The general linear model
can then be used
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
nnt xaxaxaaY 22110 ++=
Here
= Financial variable (Y) to be forecast in period t tY
x = Explanatory variable it is assumed to cause the level of Y in period t
0a = Represents a constant unaffected by the x
The other terms are the estimated coefficients of the explanatory x variables
There are n terms with xrsquos in them
There are four common approaches to forecasting financial variables but they
are all special cases of the general linear model These are ndash spot method proportion
to another account compounded growth and multiple dependencies
Using Cash Forecast
The estimate of available funds for investment and needed financing enables the firm
to plan so as to obtain the most advantages borrowing terms for deficits and achieve
the greatest interest income on surplus A useful chart for this planning purpose is a
bar chart eg
Figure Bar Chart of Cash Surpluses and Deficits from hypothetical data
Page 16 of 46
75
50
-60
30
100
-20
-80-60-40-20
020406080
100120
Defic
it
S
urpl
us
January February March April May June
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Sources of Uncertainty in Cash Forecasting and Hedging Uncertainties
There are numerous sources of risk in cash forecasting Among the sources are sales
uncertainty collection rate uncertainty production cost uncertainty and capital
outflow uncertainty
5316 Models for the Management of Cash and Temporary Investments
There are different models for the management of cash and temporary investments
Among these the most popular methods are ndash Baumol model Beranek model
Miller-Orr model and Stone model
Baumol and Beranek use the same model The formula is cited below ndash
Interest Income = iYn
n⎥⎦⎤
⎢⎣⎡ minus
21
Profit = naiYn
nminus⎥⎦
⎤⎢⎣⎡ minus
21
Optimum number of transactions = ⎟⎠⎞
⎜⎝⎛
aiY2
Where n = Optimum number of transactions
i = Interest rate per period
a = Transaction cost
Y = Total inflow for the period
Page 17 of 46
Miller-Orr and Stone use the same model ie R-Statistic The model is ndash
31
43
iav
R ⎟⎠⎞
⎜⎝⎛=
Optimum Control Limit = R + L
Upper Control Limit = 3R + L
Where a = Transaction Cost
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
v = Variance of daily cash flows
i = Daily interest rate
5317 Administration
Cash receipts should be processed and banked as quickly as possible because
They cannot earn interest or reduce overdraft until they are banked
information about the existence and amounts of cash receipts is usually not
available until they are processed
Where possible cash floats (mainly petty cash and advances) should be avoided If
on review the only reason that can be put forward for their existence is that weve
always had them they should be discontinued There may be situations where they
are useful however For example it may be desirable for peripheral parts of
departments to meet urgent local needs from cash floats rather than local bank
accounts
5318 Internal Control
Cash and cash management is part of a firms overall internal control system The
main internal cash control is invariably the bank reconciliation This provides
assurance that the cash balances recorded in the accounting systems are consistent
with the actual bank balances It requires regular clearing of reconciling items
5319 Practicing Good Cash Flow Management
Good cash management is simple It involves
Knowing when where and how firms cash needs will occur
Page 18 of 46
Knowing the best sources for meeting additional cash needs
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Page 19 of 46
Being prepared to meet these needs when they occur by keeping good
relationships with bankers and other creditors
532 INVENTORY MANAGEMENT
Inventory management is necessary for owners who want to maintain a stocking
service for quick turnaround to help ensure total customer satisfaction The fill rate
of an item on a managed inventory list must be maintained to avoid shortages of
frequently used items Even when utilizing an inventory management system
occasional shortages will still occur Inventories are lists of stocks-raw materials
work in progress or finished goods-waiting to be consumed in production or to be
sold The total balance of inventory is the sum of the value of each individual stock
line
Basically firms hold stocks for the following reasons
To act as a buffer in times of unusually high demand
To ensure continuity of production
Avoid high costs of emergency orders
To take advantage of quantity discounts by ordering more at a time
To reduce ordering costs by ordering more items on fewer
As part of the production process eg maturing whisky or keeping oil in
pipelines
Seasonality of demand (eg firework) or supplies
Suppliers insist on minimum order quantities
The key issue for a business is to identify the fast and slow stock movers with the
objectives of establishing optimum stock levels for each category and thereby
minimize the cash tied up in stocks Factors to be considered when determining
optimum stock levels include
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Page 20 of 46
What are the projected sales of each product
How widely available are raw materials components etc
How long does it take for delivery by suppliers
Can the firm remove slow movers from its product range without
compromising best sellers
Inventory management is an important aspect of working capital management
because inventories themselves do not earn any revenue Holding either too little or
too much inventory incurs costs
Costs of carrying too much inventory are
Opportunity cost of foregone interest
Warehousing costs
Damage and pilferage
Obsolescence
Insurance
Costs of carrying too little inventory are
Stock out costs
Lost sales
Delayed service
Ordering costs
Freight
on Order administrati
nts
Loss of quantity discou
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Carrying costs can be minimized by making frequent small orders but this increase
ordering costs and the risk of stock outs Risk of stock-outs can be reduced by
carrying safety stocks (at a cost) and re-ordering ahead of time
The best ordering strategy requires balancing the various cost factors to ensure the
firm incurs minimum inventory costs The optimum inventory position is known as
the Economic Reorder Quantity (ERQ)
Nowadays many large manufacturers operate on a just-in-time (JIT) basis whereby
all the components to be assembled on a particular today arrive at the factory early
that morning no earlier - no later This helps to minimize manufacturing costs as JIT
stocks take up little space minimize stock-holding and virtually eliminate the risks of
obsolete or damaged stock Because JIT manufacturers hold stock for a very short
time they are able to conserve substantial cash JIT is a good model to strive for as it
embraces all the principles of prudent stock management For better stock control
firm may try the following
Review the effectiveness of existing purchasing and inventory systems
Know the stock turn for all major items of inventory
Apply tight controls to the significant few items and simplify controls for the
trivial many
Sell off outdated or slow moving merchandise - it gets more difficult to sell the
longer the firm keeps it
Consider having part of its product outsourced to another manufacturer rather
than make it itself
Review its security procedures to ensure that no stock is going out the back
door
Higher than necessary stock levels tie up cash and cost more in insurance
accommodation costs and interest charges
Page 21 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
However it is important to keep an overall perspective It is not cost-effective to
closely manage a large number of low value inventory lines nor is it necessary A
usual feature of inventories is that a small number of high value lines account for a
large proportion of inventory value The 8020 rule (PARETO) predicts that 80
of the total value of inventory is represented by only 20 of the number of inventory
items Those high value lines need reasonably close management The remaining
80 of inventory lines can be managed using broad-brush strategies
533 MANAGING ACCOUNTS RECEIVABLE (DEBTORS)
Cash flow can be significantly enhanced if the amounts owing to a business are
collected faster Every business needs to know who owes them money how much is
owed how long it is owing for what it is owed
Debtors (Accounts Receivable) are customers who have not yet made payment for
goods or services which the department has provided The objective of debtor
management is to minimize the time-lapse between completion of sales and receipt
of payment The costs of having debtors are
Opportunity costs (cash is not available for other purposes)
Bad debts
If firm doesnt manage debtors they will begin to manage business as the firm will gradually
lose control due to reduced cash flow and of course it could experience an increased
incidence of bad debt The following measures will help manage debtors
Having the right mental attitude to the control of credit and make sure that it
gets the priority it deserves
Establishing clear credit practices as a matter of company policy
Page 22 of 46
Making sure that these practices are clearly understood by staff suppliers and
customers
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Page 23 of 46
Being professional when accepting new accounts and especially larger ones
Checking out each customer thoroughly before the firm offers credit Use
credit agencies bank references industry sources etc
Establishing credit limits for each customer and sticking to them
Continuously reviewing these limits when it suspects tough times are coming
or if operating in a volatile sector
Keeping very close to the firms larger customers
Invoicing promptly and clearly
Considering charging penalties on overdue accounts
Considering accepting credit debit cards as a payment option
Monitoring its debtor balances and ageing schedules and dont let any debts
get too large or too old
Debtor management includes both pre-sale and debt collection strategies
Pre-sale strategies include
Offering cash discounts for early payment andor imposing penalties for late
payment
Agreeing payment terms in advance
Requiring cash before delivery
Setting credit limits
ning credit Setting criteria for obtai
Billing as early as possible
rogress payments
ost-sale strategies include
for collecting the debt upon the center that made the sale
Requiring deposits andor p
P
Placing the responsibility
Identifying long overdue balances and doubtful debts by regular analytical reviews
Having an established procedure for late collections such as
A reminder
A letter
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Page 24 of 46
ion of further credit Cancellat
Telephone calls
n agency Use of a collectio
he firm should recognize that the longer someone owes firm the greater the chance
Legal action
T
it will never get paid If the average age of debtors is getting longer or is already very
long it may need to look for the following possible defects
Weak credit judgment
res Poor collection procedu
ms Lax enforcement of credit ter
Slow issue of invoices or statements
Errors in invoices or statements
Customer dissatisfaction
Debtors due over 90 days (unless within agreed credit terms) should generally
demand immediate attention For example warning signs of a future bad debt ndash
Longer credit terms taken with approval particularly for smaller orders
Use of post-dated checks by debtors who normally settle within agreed terms
Evidence of customers switching to additional suppliers for the same goods
New customers who are reluctant to give credit references
Cre G
Receiving part payments from debtors
dit ranting to Marginal Accounts
Traditional Approach
In the traditional approach to the credit granting decision it is the credit analysts job
rmation that has been collected and reach a judgment
regarding the applicants creditworthiness One traditional way of organizing this
to synthesize all the info
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
information is by characterizing the applicant along five dimensions These
dimensions are called the Five Cs of credit ndash
Capital
Character
Collateral
and Capacity
Conditions
Net Present Value (NPV) Approach
Once a firm has assessed the creditworthiness of a customer it has to decide whether
r not credit should be granted The firm should use the NPV rule to make the
ld be granted
Figure
o
decision If NPV is positive credit shou
Credit Granting Decision
Credit Granting Decision
he act of collecting money is one which most people dislike for many reasons and
therefore put on the long f selves there is something
ore urgent or important that demands their attention now There is nothing more
T
inger because they convince them
m
important than getting paid for firms product or service A customer who does not
Page 25 of 46
Grand Credit
Payment received Payment not received
Benefit of present value of future net cash flow
Cost of present value ment of lost invest
Net Payoff PV of benefit-cost
No Credit
No Payoff
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
pay is not a customer Here are a few ideas that may help the firm in collecting
money from debtors
Firm should develop appropriate procedures for handling late payments
It should track and pursue late payers
It might get external help if its own efforts fail
or money its firms and it is entitled Company shouldnt feel guilty asking f
to it
ction
Firm must make that call now And it should keep asking until it gets some
satisfa
lessens the problem
In difficult circumstances take what the firm can now and agree terms for the
remainder It
paying
When asking for money be hard on the issue - but soft on the person It shouldnt
give the debtor any excuses for not
534 BLE (CREDITORS)
ices for goods or services have
een paid Organizations often regard the
not
to delay all payments until the latest possible date Regular weekly or
The firm make it its objective is to get the money - not to score points or get
even
MANAGING ACCOUNTS PAYA
Creditors (Accounts Payable) are suppliers whose invo
been processed but who have not yet b
amount owing to creditors as a source of free credit However creditor
administration systems are expensive and time-consuming to run The over-riding
concern in this area should be to minimize costs with simple procedures
While it is unnecessary to pay accounts before they fall due it is usually
worthwhile
Page 26 of 46
fortnightly payment of all due accounts is the simplest technique for creditor
management
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Electronic payments (direct credits) are cheaper than check payments considering
that transaction fees and overheads more than balance the advantage of delayed
presentation Some suppliers are reluctant to receive payments by this method but in
view of the substantial cost advantage (and the advantages to the suppliers
themselves) departments may wish to encourage suppliers to accept this option
However electronic payments are likely to be used in conjunction with rather than
as a replacement for check payments
Applying Best Practices in Managing Accounts Payable
f course simply deferring payments to suppliers could have adverse consequences
O
that more than offset the benefits of this additional cash flow Therefore it is
important to develop a holistic approach The firm should consider the following
best practices for payables management
Managing payment dates and terms to maximize cash flow ndash
y reporting on
receivable and
id penalty charges and taking advantage of
wer vendors and negotiate for more
to buying consortia with others even
voices for
payment based on receipt of goods or receipt of invoice whichever
comes later
Calculating and setting performance targets Regularl
AP performance measures such as days in payables
Coordinating the AP processes with accounts
inventory management to ensure that the company is collecting more
cash than it is paying out
Paying bills on time to avo
prompt-payment discounts where the discounts exceed the companyrsquos
cost of working capital
Consolidating purchases with fe
favorable payment terms
Considering entering in
Page 27 of 46
competitors to obtain favorable supplier pricing and terms
Unless contract terms specify otherwise setting up in
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Page 28 of 46
Em
process
-time payments with Electronic Funds Transfer (EFT)
uraging vendors to utilize electronic invoice presentment
a
ndancies and more
ploying technology to automate the accounts payable transaction
es ndash
Making just-in
Using an electronic invoice-matching application
Enco
For companies with multiple locations or business units employing
shared service approach for AP to eliminate redu
quickly implement process improvements
Mainta
vendor
Communicating accounts payable requirements to suppliers at the
m key suppliers
for suggestions on how to improve the
Efficient a
and making th rsquos cash is just good business
ining open communications and building strong relationships with
s to access valuable trade credit ndash
beginning of transactions
Requesting summary invoicing fro
Requiring suppliers to send invoices directly to accounts payable
Asking tier-one suppliers
payment process
nd effective management of accounts payable helps improve cash flow ndash
e most of company
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
6 OVERVIEW OF VIRGIN GROUP
Virgin - one of the most respected brands in Britain - is now becoming the first global
brand name of the 21st century Virgin is involved in planes trains finance soft
drinks music mobile phones holidays cars wines publishing bridal wear - the lot
What tie all these businesses together are the values of its brand and the attitude of its
people Virgin has created over 200 companies worldwide employing over 25000
people Its total revenues around the world in 2002 exceeded pound4 billion (US $72
billion)
In 1970 Richard Branson founded Virgin as a mail order record retailer and not
long after he opened a record shop in Oxford Street London During 1972 a
recording studio was built in Oxfordshire and the first Virgin artist Mike Oldfield
recorded Tubular Bells which was released in 1973
This album went on to sell over 5 million copies Since then many household names
including Belinda Carlisle Genesis Phil Collins Janet Jackson and The Rolling
Stones have helped to make Virgin Music one of the top six record companies in the
world The equity of Virgin Music Group - record labels music publishing and
recording studios was sold to THORN EMI in 1992 in a US$1billion deal
Page 29 of 46
The Virgin Group has now expanded into international music Mega stores air
travel mobile financial retail music internet drinks rail hotels and leisure with
around 200 companies in over 30 countries
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
In Virgins customers eyes Virgin stands for value for money quality innovation
fun and a sense of competitive challenge It delivers a quality service by empowering
its employees and facilitates and monitors customer feedback to continually improve
the customers experience through innovation
When they start a new venture Virgin bases it on hard research and analysis
Typically they review the industry and put themselves in the customers shoes to see
what could make it better Virgin asks fundamental questions
Is this an opportunity for restructuring a market and creating competitive
advantage What are the competitors doing
Is the customer confused or badly served
Is this an opportunity for building the Virgin brand
Can we add value
Will it interact with its other businesses
Is there an appropriate trade-off between risk and reward
Page 30 of 46
Virgin is also able to draw on talented people from throughout the group New
ventures are often steered by people seconded from other parts of Virgin who bring
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
with them the trademark management style skills and experience Virgin frequently
creates partnerships with others to combine skills knowledge and market presence
and so on Contrary to what some people may think their constantly expanding and
eclectic empire is neither random nor reckless Each successive venture demonstrates
its skill in picking the right market and the right opportunity
7 OVERVIEW OF VIRGIN SOFT DRINKS
The Virgin Drinks Group first launched as the Virgin Cola Company in 1994 with
Virgin Cola in the UK Since then the company has ventured across the carbonated
soft drinks arena and beyond into energy drinks tea and flavored Colas This
expansion has lead to the evolution of the Virgin Drinks Company a company
whose aim is to put the excitement back into the world of soft drinks It launched in
Bangladesh in 1999 Virgin Soft Drinks is monitored by Global Beverage Co Ltd in
Bangladesh
Brief history of Virgin Drinks is given below
Page 31 of 46
1994 November Virgin Cola launched in the UK
1996 March Virgin Cola launched in France
1998 June Virgin Cola launched in Belgium
April Virgin Cola launched in the French West Indies
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
August Virgin Cola launched in Switzerland
1999 March Virgin Colours launched in Italy
March Virgin Cola launched in Japan
July Virgin Colours launched in South Africa
December Virgin Colours launched in Bangladesh
2001 January Sweden launched Virgin Colours
November Singapore launched Virgin Colours
2002 February Croatia launched Virgin Colours
June Russia launched Virgin Colours
June Tunisia launched Virgin Colours
2003 May Israel launched Virgin Colours
8 FINDINGS OF WORKING CAPITAL MANAGEMENT MAINTAINED BY
VIRGIN SOFT DRINKS IN BANGLADESH
81 CASH MANAGEMENT
811 Holding Cash and Marketable Securities
Although there are many good reasons why firm hold cash and marketable
securities Virgin Drinks holds cash and marketable securities for two reasons ndash
i) Cash for transactions
ii) Cash as hedges
This indicates that the firm does not hold cash and marketable securities for some
important reasons such as ndash
i) Near cash assets as hedges
Page 32 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
ii) Temporary investment and compensating balances
Virgin Soft Drinks does not invest in money market securities such as Treasury bill
commercial paper certificate of deposits bankerrsquos acceptance and repurchase
agreement This firm deposits its money in bank as currant AC or fixed AC They
say that they do not have enough money to invest in money market instrument
They also say that if they have enough money they will invest it in money market
short term securities We know that near cash interest earning assets can be
substituted for cash when motivation for holding these assets is the hedging of cash
flow uncertainties or is the temporary investment of surplus funds In this point
Virgins position is not good as there is no significant hedging against uncertainty of
cash
812 Floatation and Check Clearing
Virgin is very smart in handling the problem of transit time for checks Here mail
float takes 2 to 3 days at firm takes 025 day and clearing float takes 1-3 days Virgin
uses most of the strategies available for reducing the delay in receiving funds It
(Virgin) has linked Islami Bank which posses an accelerated clearing facility It uses
electronic collection process which ensures faster collection and its at the firm check
processing is satisfactory But Virgin does not use lockbox The reason behind this is
that it is not cost-effective for Virgin to set lockboxes At this point we can say that
Virgins check clearing mechanism is much good
813 Cash Concentration and Disbursement Management
Page 33 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks takes the matter of cash concentration very seriously They use all
the available cash concentration mechanism Virgin is a firm with small deposits
spread over a substantial number of banks and this is why the firm tends to use
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
depository transfer checks extensively If is less costly Virgin also uses automated
clearing house and wire transfer To Virgin wire transfer seems too costly
Like other firm Virgin tries to retain the cash for as long as possible But Virgin
always performs it in an ethical manner Virgin does not try to defeat the receiving
firmrsquos attempts to reduce the float on incoming checks It does not take any strategy
for increasing mail float at firm float and clearing float on its outgoing checks To
Virgin it is deemed to be unethical It thinks that maximization of disbursement float
will not go unnoticed by sophisticated creditors for very long When it is noticed it
will negatively affect relations with these creditors reducing the firmrsquos bargaining
power with them This may ultimately cost Virgin dearly when future prices and
delivery schedules for goods and services purchased from trade creditors are
negotiated Virgin follows ldquoZero-Balance Accountsrdquo methods for managing
disbursement It thinks that in this method the coordination of funds inflows to
disbursement banks with the presentation of checks does not work to the detriment
of creditors since the firmrsquos checks to them are honored as presented and this strategy
does not affect float significantly Controlled disbursing method is less attractive to
Virgin because zero-balance system is already feasible
814 Cash Forecasting
Cash Forecasting and Its Types
Page 34 of 46
Virgin forecasts the future cash inflows and outflows To Virgin cash forecast is an
important part of the firmrsquos cash control system and is one of the forecasts that are
part of the Virginrsquos financial plan Virgin forecasts cash on monthly basis and on
yearly basis Virgin does not forecast on daily basis assuming that the temporary
shortage of funds within these periods can be covered without value cost eg
advance receipts from customers Virginrsquos cash forecasting system involves a
combination of distribution and scheduling The receipts and disbursements
approach of cash forecasting is used in virgin This method is used because it
minutely traces the movement of cash and very close control of cash is possible
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Virgin does not use adjusted net income approach on two grounds First it does not
permit the tracing of the individual types of cash inflows and outflows for any given
period which is often useful information for virgin Second it is not simple to use
Items to be Forecast
Virgin does not forecast all the items It forecasts only major items eg accounts
receivable notes receivable payroll cash purchases of raw materials In this regard
virgin trade off between cost and benefit
Methods of Financial Forecasting
Virgin forecasts the future level of financial variable such as cash level asset level or
liability level We know in short term forecasts many things will result from plans
and events that are already in place (contracts capital budgets long-range financing
plans and so forth) But in the long run most things can vary and are dependent on
outside influences such as the firmrsquos long-term growth rate Since Virginrsquos cash
forecasting deals mostly with near future many of the items on the cash forecasts are
estimated by some variation of the spot method and remaining estimates are mostly
on a ldquoproportion of another accountrdquo basis with this ldquoother accountrdquo often being a
particular periodrsquos sales Virgin uses the other two methods less frequently
Using Cash Forecast
Virgin forecasts cash for meeting general objectives (ie to know the available funds
for investment and need financing) and for meeting some special objectives (eg to
know whether the firm will fulfill its out of debt requirement) But it is matter to note
that Virgin does not make any short term investment of its surplus cash but only keep
this surplus in Bank Account
Page 35 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Sources of Uncertainty in Cash Forecasting and Hedging Uncertainties
Virgin faces uncertainty in cash forecasting mainly from two sources These are ndash
sales and production cost In peak season (hot season like autumn summer) sales
increases but in dull season (eg in winter) sales decreases drastically Production
cost may be increased because of increase of price of sugar chemicals aluminum
can Virgin follows two methods for hedging cash balance uncertainties These are ndash
i) Holding a stock of extra cash and
ii) Extra borrowing capacity
815 Modes for the Management of Cash and Temporary Investments
Virgin does not follow any of these methods wholly Virgin receives cash
continuously and pays salary at steady rate and pays continuously for other
expenses So it neither follows Baumol model nor Beranek model It has no upper
control limit lower control limit return point in case cash management So it neither
follows Miller-Orr model nor Stone model
In Summary
Page 36 of 46
Standard Compliance by Virgin Soft Drinks
Generally all firms hold cash and
marketable securities
Virgin holds only cash
Firms hold cash and marketable
securities for some reasons like
bull Cash for transactions
bull Cash and near-cash assets as
hedges
bull Temporary investments
bull Compensating balances
Virgin holds cash only for
two reasons ndash
bull Cash for transactions
bull Cash as hedges
Available money market instruments Virgin does not invest in any such
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
(short term securities) are ndash
Treasury Bills
Commercial Paper
Certificates of Deposit
Bankerrsquos Acceptance
Repurch menase Agree ts
instruments They only keep cash in
Bank Account
Mail Float
(1 to 5 days)
At Firm
Float
(025 to 1
day)
Clearing
Float
(0 to
2 days)
Mail Float
(2 to 3 days)
At firm
Float
(025
day)
Clearing
Float
(1 to 3
days)
Figure Transit time for a typical check Figure Transit time for a check for
Virgin
Strategies that firms can use to reduce
the delay in receiving funds are ndash
Selecting of Banks with
accelerated clearing capabilities
of check processing Acceleration
at the firm
ectronic collection Use of el
procedures
Use of lockboxes
Virgin follows the first three strategies
but does not use lockboxes
Available cash concentration
mechanisms are ndash
Depository transfer check
ouse Automated Clearing H
(ACH) electronic transfer)
Wire transfer
Virgin uses all these mechanisms of
cash concentration
Available sets of techniques for cash
disbursement management are ndash
ement of disbursement
Page 37 of 46
Manag
float
Virgin uses zero-balance accounts
technique
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Zero-Balance Accounts
Controlled disbursing
Firms may make cash flow forecasts
over periods of various lengths yearly
flows quarterly flows monthly flows
weekly flows or even daily flows
Virgin forecasts cash on yearly basis and
monthly basis
Cash forecasting system may involve ndash
Distribution
Scheduling
Virginrsquos cash forecasting system
involves a combination of distribution
and scheduling
Two common approaches to cash flow
in generating the cash forecast
and disbursement Receipts
approach
Adjusted net income approach
Virgin uses the receipts and
disbursement approach
There are many items to forecast Virgin forecasts only major items like
AR payroll etc
Four common approach to forecasting
fina i ndash nc al variables are
Spot method
Proportion to another account
Compounded growth
Multiple dependencies
Virgin uses spot method for forecasting
cash It uses proportion to another
account method for other variables and
remaining two methods are frequently
used
Sources of uncertainty in cash
forecasting are ndash
Sales uncertainty
Collection rate uncertainty
Production cost uncertainty
Capital outflow uncertainty
Virgin faces uncertainty mainly from
sales and production cost
Methods for hedging cash balance
unc a
Page 38 of 46
ert inties are ndash
i) Holding a stock of extra cash
Virgin two available methods for
hedging cash balance uncertainties
Th ese are ndash
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
ii) stock of near-cash Holding a
assets
iii) Extra borrowing capacity
iv) ary surpluses in Investing tempor
near-cash assets
i) Holding a stock of extra cash
ii) Extra borrowing capacity
(advance receipt from
customers)
Models for the management of cash and
temporary investments are ndash Baumol
model Beranek model Miller-Orr
model and Stone model
Virgin does not follow any method
wholly but a combination of Baumol
model and Beranek model is occurred
82 INVENTORY MANAGEMENT
21 Certainty Approach
isnt used in
irgin because it thinks it is not possible to implement in Bangladesh
d time is one to three days It
oes not use ABC system of inventory management
8
Main item of inventory of Virgin is Can pet chip sugar label chemical artificial
sweet etc Virgin maintains a minimum level of inventory but it does not have to face
problems because inventory is managed efficiently just-in-time (JIT)
V
Virgin maintains buffer stock because of the shortage of work-in-process (WIP)
inventory Its production process may also be hampered Thats why it maintains
safety stock to avoid stock out cost In case of imported goods normal lead time is
about one month and within the country normal lea
d
Page 39 of 46
Inventory Model
In reality Virgin does not use any of models of EOQ ordering and holding strategy
and safety stock strategy They maintain inventory based on their prior experience
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
822 Uncertainty Approach
Virgin does not use any model for handling inventory uncertainty It says that such
decision depends on business cycle and market situation Long before Eid festival
they bought large amount of sugar because of price increase on the occasion of Eid
In summary
Standard Compliance by Virgin Soft Drinks
Firms maintain inventory to guard
against several problems
Virgin maintains a minimum level of
inventory which is managed efficiently
Some firms use JIT to avoid inventory
cost
JIT is not used by Virgin as it thinks it is
impossible to implement in Bangladesh
Firms maintain buffer stock Virgin maintains buffer stock too
Firms maintain safety stock to avoid
shortage cost
Virgin also maintains safety stock
Firms use ABC system to monitor
inventory
Virgin doesnt use ABC system
EOQ model is an appropriate method
for measuring quantity that has to be
ordered per order
Virgin does not use EOQ model rather
makes order based on experience and
market demand
83 MANAGING ACCOUNTS RECEIVABLE (DEBTORS)
831 Terms of Sale Decision
Page 40 of 46
Virgin offers the term 210 net 30 enables the customers to deduct 2 percent from the
face value of the bill when paying within the first 10 days but if the discount is not
taken the customer must remit the full amount within 30 days But Virgin does not
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
offer the same terms of sale to all customers For prime customers it offers special
terms of sale In setting an appropriate term of sale it costs and benefits regarding
this are compared It uses the standard approach of terms of sale decision as it is
simple to use
832 Credit Granting Decisions
In case of Virgin the Capital and Character of Five Cs get more importance
Although there are many problems with the traditional approach Virgin uses it
because of its simplicity Virgin does not use Net Present Value (NPV) method in
credit granting decision It thinks that NPV is an appropriate method and should be
used next time It does not face any severe problem because of bad debts The reason
is that notes receivable is used when credit is granted
833 Monitoring Accounts Receivable
Virgin monitors its accounts receivable Virgin believes that in any case both positive
and negative durations in accounts signal differences from the results that
management believe to be the most advantageous for the firm
Tools for Monitoring Accounts Receivable
Page 41 of 46
For monitoring accounts receivable there are several tools such as aging schedule
the ratios of receivable outstanding to original sales customers payment proportion
and sales weighted DSO (Days Sales Outstanding) For monitoring accounts
receivable Virgin uses aging schedule fractions and traditional DSO statistics
because of their simplicity in use Although payment proportions ratios of
receivables outstanding and sales weighted DSO methods are free from inherent bias
None of these is used because all these are complex to maintain
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
In summary
Page 42 of 46
Standard Compliance by Virgin Soft Drinks
Generals terms of sale is 210 net 30 Normally Virgin also use general terms
of sale ie 210 net 30
Firms do not offer the same terms of
sale to all customers
Yes For prime customers Virgin offers
special terms of sale
Approaches of terms of sale decisions
are ndash
bull Standard approach
bull Multi period approach
Virgin uses standard approach of terms
of sale decision as it is simple to use and
understand
Source of credit information are ndash
Sellers prior experience with the
customer
Credit agency ratings and
reports
Personal contact with the
applicants bank and other
creditors
Analysis of applicants financial
statements
Customer visit
Main source of credit information to
Virgin is its prior experience with the
customer All other sources are not cost-
effective for Virgin
Approaches of credit granting to
marginal accounts are ndash
Traditional approach
Net Present Value (NPV)
approach
It uses traditional approach still now but
thinks that NPV should be used for the
next periods
Firms monitor accounts receivable
because deviations from the expected
levels of turnover and of bad debt can
Virgin also monitors its accounts
receivable
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
signal several different problems
Different tools for monitoring accounts
receivable are ndash
Aging schedule
Ratios of receivables
outstanding to original sales
Customers payment
proportions
Sales-weighted DSO
For monitoring accounts receivable
Virgin uses aging schedule and
traditional sales outstanding statistics
84 MANAGING ACCOUNTS PAYABLE (CREDITORS)
Virgin has almost accounts payable of Tk 8000000 But most of its liabilities are to
the banks rather than suppliers But we dont have any clear information about
Virgins accounts payable
9 RECOMMENDATION
Virgin should invest its surplus cash in short term marketable securities
because it is suitable hedging against cash uncertainties and will also give
some returns (interest income)
Virgin should publish its own annual report which will satisfy information
needs of stakeholders and also increase the credibility of information provided
by Virgin
Page 43 of 46
Virgin should use multi period approach in terms of sale decision because
standard approach which is already exists in Virgin has some inherent
problems
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
It should stop using traditional approach from now It should use NPV
method in credit granting to marginal accounts
In monitoring accounts receivable Virgin should use sales-weighted DSO
method because it has least limitation compared to the others
It should be more flexible in granting credit which will ultimately increase its
sales
To get the appropriate number of quantity to be ordered per order it should
use DSO model
It should be ABC system for proper monitoring of inventory
10 CONCLUSION
The use of other peoples money in business is usually an expensive resource Before
looking outside for finance a firm should examine its own working capital cycle to
make sure that every rand of its own internal funds is being fully utilized Good
management of working capital is part of good financial management Effective use
of working capital will contribute to the operational efficiency of the whole
organization optimum use will help to generate maximum returns Furthermore
working capital management is not an end in itself It is an integral part of the firms
overall management The needs of efficient working capital management must be
considered in relation to other aspects of the Virgins financial and non-financial
performance Thats why when planning the development of a business it is critical
that the impact of working capital be fully assessed
Page 44 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
BIBLIOGRAPHY
Scherr FC (1989) International Edition Prentice-Hall International Inc Modern
Working Capital Management Text and Cases
Hussain Riaz (2002) Working Capital Management
Robertson Lonnie (July 1998) Inventory Management
httpwwwasashoporg visited on March 13 2006
The Art of Cash Management
httpwwwinccom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management
httpwwwstudyfinancecom visited on March 13 2006
White Paper ndash Managing Working Capital
httpwwwplanwareorg visited on March 13 2006
Management of Working Capital
httpwwwbusinesscentralcoza visited on March 13 2006
Cash Management
httpwwwsbagov visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management Objectives
httpwpsprenhallcom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management
Page 45 of 46
httpwwwadvancemecom visited on March 13 2006
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Business Receivables Financing
httpwwwbbtcom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Finance
http wwwfnbcoza visited on March 13 2006
Tips to manage your working capital
httpsmallbusinessninemsncomau visited on March 13 2006
Inventory Financing
httpwwwfranklincapitalnetworkcom visited on March 13 2006
Accounts Receivable Management
httpwwwfranklincapitalnetworkcom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management
httpwwwtreasurygovtnz visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management
httpwwwtreasurystrategiescom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Works
httpwwwinvestopediacom visited on March 13 2006
Treasury Services
httpwwwjpmorganchasecom visited on March 13 2006
what were about
Page 46 of 46
httpwwwvirgincom visited on March 13 2006
Annexure
Annexure
Interview with YASEER RIZVI
Mr Yaseer Rizvi the DMD of Global Beverage Co Ltd obtained his MBA degree
from a reputed university He had been the Director of Ocean Container Ltd before
joining in Global Beverage Co Ltd He possesses a nice personality
I interviewed Yaseer Rizvi Excerpts from his interview are as follows ndash
Shah Kamal Sir would you please tell me do you invest in short term marketable securities
Yaseer Rizvi Basically we do not invest our surplus cash in short term marketable
securities like T-Bill commercial paper certificate of deposit etc But we keep our
surplus cash in Bank
Shah Kamal Would you tell me something about transit time for a typical check
Yaseer Rizvi Well in Virgin the transit time for a typical check is ndash
For mail float 2 to 3 days
At firm float 6 hours
Clearing float 1 to 3 days
Shah Kamal Do you maintain any cash concentration mechanism like depository transfer check automated clearing house and wire transfer
i
Annexure
Yaseer Rizvi Our position in this case is very strong as we use all the mechanisms
you mentioned As Virgin is a firm with small deposits spread over a substantial
number of banks so we tend to use depository transfer checks extensively It is less
costly We also use automated clearing house and wire transfer but later is used in a
less extent
Shah Kamal Sir what techniques of disbursement management is used by your firm
Yaseer Rizvi Like other firms Virgin tries to retain the cash for as long as possible
But we always perform it in an ethical manner We do not use management of
disbursement float as it seems unethical We follow Zero-Balance Accounts method
for managing disbursement We do not prefer Controlled Disbursing method since
Zero-Balance system is already practiced in Virgin
Shah Kamal How do you hedge cash balance uncertainties
Yaseer Rizvi Well you may say that we do not invest in short term securities but for
facing cash difficulties we keep our surplus cash in bank
Shah Kamal Sir would you please tell me the general terms of sale of Virgin
Yaseer Rizvi Though it is difficult to maintain a fixed terms of sale our general terms
of sale is 210 n30 But for prime customers we offer special terms of sale
Shah Kamal What are the sources of credit information in case of your firm
Yaseer Rizvi We grant credit on the basis of prior experience with the customers In
case of a new customer personal contact is weighted
Shah Kamal Does your firm consider 5 Cs in granting credit
ii
Annexure
Yaseer Rizvi In case of Virgin Capital and Character get more importance than the
others Mind one thing personal relationship is the main measure in granting credit
Shah Kamal Do you use NPV method in credit granting decisions
Yaseer Rizvi We do not use NPV method But we think that NPV is a suitable
method and we have to use it from the next period
Shah Kamal Sir how do you handle the problem of bad debt
Yaseer Rizvi Well in this case our position is very strong Yet we do not face any
problem because of bad debt Just note that we make more than 80 of sales in cash
and we monitor accounts receivable very carefully
Shah Kamal What level of inventory is maintained by Virgin
Yaseer Rizvi We maintain a minimum level of inventory but do not have to face
stock out problems because inventory is managed efficiently
Shah Kamal What is the normal lead time
Yaseer Rizvi In case of imported goods normal lead time is about 1 month and when
we purchase raw materials from inside the country lead time is 1 to 3 days
Shah Kamal What method do you use for managing inventory
Yaseer Rizvi We do not use any method particularly rather inventory decision
depends on business cycle and market situation Long before the Eid festival we
bought large amount of sugar because price of sugar was increased on the occasion
of Eid
iii
Annexure
Shah Kamal What are the main items of inventory of your firm
Yaseer Rizvi Well these are ndash aluminum can pet chip sugar label chemical and
artificial sweet
Shah Kamal What are the uncertainties in maintaining appropriate level of stock
Yaseer Rizvi These are ndash
bull Increase in price of raw materials
bull Sales uncertainty
bull Market trends etc
Shah Kamal Thank you for your kind cooperation
Yaseer Rizvi Most Welcome
iv
Global Beverage Company Limited
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
nnt xaxaxaaY 22110 ++=
Here
= Financial variable (Y) to be forecast in period t tY
x = Explanatory variable it is assumed to cause the level of Y in period t
0a = Represents a constant unaffected by the x
The other terms are the estimated coefficients of the explanatory x variables
There are n terms with xrsquos in them
There are four common approaches to forecasting financial variables but they
are all special cases of the general linear model These are ndash spot method proportion
to another account compounded growth and multiple dependencies
Using Cash Forecast
The estimate of available funds for investment and needed financing enables the firm
to plan so as to obtain the most advantages borrowing terms for deficits and achieve
the greatest interest income on surplus A useful chart for this planning purpose is a
bar chart eg
Figure Bar Chart of Cash Surpluses and Deficits from hypothetical data
Page 16 of 46
75
50
-60
30
100
-20
-80-60-40-20
020406080
100120
Defic
it
S
urpl
us
January February March April May June
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Sources of Uncertainty in Cash Forecasting and Hedging Uncertainties
There are numerous sources of risk in cash forecasting Among the sources are sales
uncertainty collection rate uncertainty production cost uncertainty and capital
outflow uncertainty
5316 Models for the Management of Cash and Temporary Investments
There are different models for the management of cash and temporary investments
Among these the most popular methods are ndash Baumol model Beranek model
Miller-Orr model and Stone model
Baumol and Beranek use the same model The formula is cited below ndash
Interest Income = iYn
n⎥⎦⎤
⎢⎣⎡ minus
21
Profit = naiYn
nminus⎥⎦
⎤⎢⎣⎡ minus
21
Optimum number of transactions = ⎟⎠⎞
⎜⎝⎛
aiY2
Where n = Optimum number of transactions
i = Interest rate per period
a = Transaction cost
Y = Total inflow for the period
Page 17 of 46
Miller-Orr and Stone use the same model ie R-Statistic The model is ndash
31
43
iav
R ⎟⎠⎞
⎜⎝⎛=
Optimum Control Limit = R + L
Upper Control Limit = 3R + L
Where a = Transaction Cost
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
v = Variance of daily cash flows
i = Daily interest rate
5317 Administration
Cash receipts should be processed and banked as quickly as possible because
They cannot earn interest or reduce overdraft until they are banked
information about the existence and amounts of cash receipts is usually not
available until they are processed
Where possible cash floats (mainly petty cash and advances) should be avoided If
on review the only reason that can be put forward for their existence is that weve
always had them they should be discontinued There may be situations where they
are useful however For example it may be desirable for peripheral parts of
departments to meet urgent local needs from cash floats rather than local bank
accounts
5318 Internal Control
Cash and cash management is part of a firms overall internal control system The
main internal cash control is invariably the bank reconciliation This provides
assurance that the cash balances recorded in the accounting systems are consistent
with the actual bank balances It requires regular clearing of reconciling items
5319 Practicing Good Cash Flow Management
Good cash management is simple It involves
Knowing when where and how firms cash needs will occur
Page 18 of 46
Knowing the best sources for meeting additional cash needs
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Page 19 of 46
Being prepared to meet these needs when they occur by keeping good
relationships with bankers and other creditors
532 INVENTORY MANAGEMENT
Inventory management is necessary for owners who want to maintain a stocking
service for quick turnaround to help ensure total customer satisfaction The fill rate
of an item on a managed inventory list must be maintained to avoid shortages of
frequently used items Even when utilizing an inventory management system
occasional shortages will still occur Inventories are lists of stocks-raw materials
work in progress or finished goods-waiting to be consumed in production or to be
sold The total balance of inventory is the sum of the value of each individual stock
line
Basically firms hold stocks for the following reasons
To act as a buffer in times of unusually high demand
To ensure continuity of production
Avoid high costs of emergency orders
To take advantage of quantity discounts by ordering more at a time
To reduce ordering costs by ordering more items on fewer
As part of the production process eg maturing whisky or keeping oil in
pipelines
Seasonality of demand (eg firework) or supplies
Suppliers insist on minimum order quantities
The key issue for a business is to identify the fast and slow stock movers with the
objectives of establishing optimum stock levels for each category and thereby
minimize the cash tied up in stocks Factors to be considered when determining
optimum stock levels include
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Page 20 of 46
What are the projected sales of each product
How widely available are raw materials components etc
How long does it take for delivery by suppliers
Can the firm remove slow movers from its product range without
compromising best sellers
Inventory management is an important aspect of working capital management
because inventories themselves do not earn any revenue Holding either too little or
too much inventory incurs costs
Costs of carrying too much inventory are
Opportunity cost of foregone interest
Warehousing costs
Damage and pilferage
Obsolescence
Insurance
Costs of carrying too little inventory are
Stock out costs
Lost sales
Delayed service
Ordering costs
Freight
on Order administrati
nts
Loss of quantity discou
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Carrying costs can be minimized by making frequent small orders but this increase
ordering costs and the risk of stock outs Risk of stock-outs can be reduced by
carrying safety stocks (at a cost) and re-ordering ahead of time
The best ordering strategy requires balancing the various cost factors to ensure the
firm incurs minimum inventory costs The optimum inventory position is known as
the Economic Reorder Quantity (ERQ)
Nowadays many large manufacturers operate on a just-in-time (JIT) basis whereby
all the components to be assembled on a particular today arrive at the factory early
that morning no earlier - no later This helps to minimize manufacturing costs as JIT
stocks take up little space minimize stock-holding and virtually eliminate the risks of
obsolete or damaged stock Because JIT manufacturers hold stock for a very short
time they are able to conserve substantial cash JIT is a good model to strive for as it
embraces all the principles of prudent stock management For better stock control
firm may try the following
Review the effectiveness of existing purchasing and inventory systems
Know the stock turn for all major items of inventory
Apply tight controls to the significant few items and simplify controls for the
trivial many
Sell off outdated or slow moving merchandise - it gets more difficult to sell the
longer the firm keeps it
Consider having part of its product outsourced to another manufacturer rather
than make it itself
Review its security procedures to ensure that no stock is going out the back
door
Higher than necessary stock levels tie up cash and cost more in insurance
accommodation costs and interest charges
Page 21 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
However it is important to keep an overall perspective It is not cost-effective to
closely manage a large number of low value inventory lines nor is it necessary A
usual feature of inventories is that a small number of high value lines account for a
large proportion of inventory value The 8020 rule (PARETO) predicts that 80
of the total value of inventory is represented by only 20 of the number of inventory
items Those high value lines need reasonably close management The remaining
80 of inventory lines can be managed using broad-brush strategies
533 MANAGING ACCOUNTS RECEIVABLE (DEBTORS)
Cash flow can be significantly enhanced if the amounts owing to a business are
collected faster Every business needs to know who owes them money how much is
owed how long it is owing for what it is owed
Debtors (Accounts Receivable) are customers who have not yet made payment for
goods or services which the department has provided The objective of debtor
management is to minimize the time-lapse between completion of sales and receipt
of payment The costs of having debtors are
Opportunity costs (cash is not available for other purposes)
Bad debts
If firm doesnt manage debtors they will begin to manage business as the firm will gradually
lose control due to reduced cash flow and of course it could experience an increased
incidence of bad debt The following measures will help manage debtors
Having the right mental attitude to the control of credit and make sure that it
gets the priority it deserves
Establishing clear credit practices as a matter of company policy
Page 22 of 46
Making sure that these practices are clearly understood by staff suppliers and
customers
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Page 23 of 46
Being professional when accepting new accounts and especially larger ones
Checking out each customer thoroughly before the firm offers credit Use
credit agencies bank references industry sources etc
Establishing credit limits for each customer and sticking to them
Continuously reviewing these limits when it suspects tough times are coming
or if operating in a volatile sector
Keeping very close to the firms larger customers
Invoicing promptly and clearly
Considering charging penalties on overdue accounts
Considering accepting credit debit cards as a payment option
Monitoring its debtor balances and ageing schedules and dont let any debts
get too large or too old
Debtor management includes both pre-sale and debt collection strategies
Pre-sale strategies include
Offering cash discounts for early payment andor imposing penalties for late
payment
Agreeing payment terms in advance
Requiring cash before delivery
Setting credit limits
ning credit Setting criteria for obtai
Billing as early as possible
rogress payments
ost-sale strategies include
for collecting the debt upon the center that made the sale
Requiring deposits andor p
P
Placing the responsibility
Identifying long overdue balances and doubtful debts by regular analytical reviews
Having an established procedure for late collections such as
A reminder
A letter
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Page 24 of 46
ion of further credit Cancellat
Telephone calls
n agency Use of a collectio
he firm should recognize that the longer someone owes firm the greater the chance
Legal action
T
it will never get paid If the average age of debtors is getting longer or is already very
long it may need to look for the following possible defects
Weak credit judgment
res Poor collection procedu
ms Lax enforcement of credit ter
Slow issue of invoices or statements
Errors in invoices or statements
Customer dissatisfaction
Debtors due over 90 days (unless within agreed credit terms) should generally
demand immediate attention For example warning signs of a future bad debt ndash
Longer credit terms taken with approval particularly for smaller orders
Use of post-dated checks by debtors who normally settle within agreed terms
Evidence of customers switching to additional suppliers for the same goods
New customers who are reluctant to give credit references
Cre G
Receiving part payments from debtors
dit ranting to Marginal Accounts
Traditional Approach
In the traditional approach to the credit granting decision it is the credit analysts job
rmation that has been collected and reach a judgment
regarding the applicants creditworthiness One traditional way of organizing this
to synthesize all the info
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
information is by characterizing the applicant along five dimensions These
dimensions are called the Five Cs of credit ndash
Capital
Character
Collateral
and Capacity
Conditions
Net Present Value (NPV) Approach
Once a firm has assessed the creditworthiness of a customer it has to decide whether
r not credit should be granted The firm should use the NPV rule to make the
ld be granted
Figure
o
decision If NPV is positive credit shou
Credit Granting Decision
Credit Granting Decision
he act of collecting money is one which most people dislike for many reasons and
therefore put on the long f selves there is something
ore urgent or important that demands their attention now There is nothing more
T
inger because they convince them
m
important than getting paid for firms product or service A customer who does not
Page 25 of 46
Grand Credit
Payment received Payment not received
Benefit of present value of future net cash flow
Cost of present value ment of lost invest
Net Payoff PV of benefit-cost
No Credit
No Payoff
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
pay is not a customer Here are a few ideas that may help the firm in collecting
money from debtors
Firm should develop appropriate procedures for handling late payments
It should track and pursue late payers
It might get external help if its own efforts fail
or money its firms and it is entitled Company shouldnt feel guilty asking f
to it
ction
Firm must make that call now And it should keep asking until it gets some
satisfa
lessens the problem
In difficult circumstances take what the firm can now and agree terms for the
remainder It
paying
When asking for money be hard on the issue - but soft on the person It shouldnt
give the debtor any excuses for not
534 BLE (CREDITORS)
ices for goods or services have
een paid Organizations often regard the
not
to delay all payments until the latest possible date Regular weekly or
The firm make it its objective is to get the money - not to score points or get
even
MANAGING ACCOUNTS PAYA
Creditors (Accounts Payable) are suppliers whose invo
been processed but who have not yet b
amount owing to creditors as a source of free credit However creditor
administration systems are expensive and time-consuming to run The over-riding
concern in this area should be to minimize costs with simple procedures
While it is unnecessary to pay accounts before they fall due it is usually
worthwhile
Page 26 of 46
fortnightly payment of all due accounts is the simplest technique for creditor
management
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Electronic payments (direct credits) are cheaper than check payments considering
that transaction fees and overheads more than balance the advantage of delayed
presentation Some suppliers are reluctant to receive payments by this method but in
view of the substantial cost advantage (and the advantages to the suppliers
themselves) departments may wish to encourage suppliers to accept this option
However electronic payments are likely to be used in conjunction with rather than
as a replacement for check payments
Applying Best Practices in Managing Accounts Payable
f course simply deferring payments to suppliers could have adverse consequences
O
that more than offset the benefits of this additional cash flow Therefore it is
important to develop a holistic approach The firm should consider the following
best practices for payables management
Managing payment dates and terms to maximize cash flow ndash
y reporting on
receivable and
id penalty charges and taking advantage of
wer vendors and negotiate for more
to buying consortia with others even
voices for
payment based on receipt of goods or receipt of invoice whichever
comes later
Calculating and setting performance targets Regularl
AP performance measures such as days in payables
Coordinating the AP processes with accounts
inventory management to ensure that the company is collecting more
cash than it is paying out
Paying bills on time to avo
prompt-payment discounts where the discounts exceed the companyrsquos
cost of working capital
Consolidating purchases with fe
favorable payment terms
Considering entering in
Page 27 of 46
competitors to obtain favorable supplier pricing and terms
Unless contract terms specify otherwise setting up in
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Page 28 of 46
Em
process
-time payments with Electronic Funds Transfer (EFT)
uraging vendors to utilize electronic invoice presentment
a
ndancies and more
ploying technology to automate the accounts payable transaction
es ndash
Making just-in
Using an electronic invoice-matching application
Enco
For companies with multiple locations or business units employing
shared service approach for AP to eliminate redu
quickly implement process improvements
Mainta
vendor
Communicating accounts payable requirements to suppliers at the
m key suppliers
for suggestions on how to improve the
Efficient a
and making th rsquos cash is just good business
ining open communications and building strong relationships with
s to access valuable trade credit ndash
beginning of transactions
Requesting summary invoicing fro
Requiring suppliers to send invoices directly to accounts payable
Asking tier-one suppliers
payment process
nd effective management of accounts payable helps improve cash flow ndash
e most of company
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
6 OVERVIEW OF VIRGIN GROUP
Virgin - one of the most respected brands in Britain - is now becoming the first global
brand name of the 21st century Virgin is involved in planes trains finance soft
drinks music mobile phones holidays cars wines publishing bridal wear - the lot
What tie all these businesses together are the values of its brand and the attitude of its
people Virgin has created over 200 companies worldwide employing over 25000
people Its total revenues around the world in 2002 exceeded pound4 billion (US $72
billion)
In 1970 Richard Branson founded Virgin as a mail order record retailer and not
long after he opened a record shop in Oxford Street London During 1972 a
recording studio was built in Oxfordshire and the first Virgin artist Mike Oldfield
recorded Tubular Bells which was released in 1973
This album went on to sell over 5 million copies Since then many household names
including Belinda Carlisle Genesis Phil Collins Janet Jackson and The Rolling
Stones have helped to make Virgin Music one of the top six record companies in the
world The equity of Virgin Music Group - record labels music publishing and
recording studios was sold to THORN EMI in 1992 in a US$1billion deal
Page 29 of 46
The Virgin Group has now expanded into international music Mega stores air
travel mobile financial retail music internet drinks rail hotels and leisure with
around 200 companies in over 30 countries
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
In Virgins customers eyes Virgin stands for value for money quality innovation
fun and a sense of competitive challenge It delivers a quality service by empowering
its employees and facilitates and monitors customer feedback to continually improve
the customers experience through innovation
When they start a new venture Virgin bases it on hard research and analysis
Typically they review the industry and put themselves in the customers shoes to see
what could make it better Virgin asks fundamental questions
Is this an opportunity for restructuring a market and creating competitive
advantage What are the competitors doing
Is the customer confused or badly served
Is this an opportunity for building the Virgin brand
Can we add value
Will it interact with its other businesses
Is there an appropriate trade-off between risk and reward
Page 30 of 46
Virgin is also able to draw on talented people from throughout the group New
ventures are often steered by people seconded from other parts of Virgin who bring
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
with them the trademark management style skills and experience Virgin frequently
creates partnerships with others to combine skills knowledge and market presence
and so on Contrary to what some people may think their constantly expanding and
eclectic empire is neither random nor reckless Each successive venture demonstrates
its skill in picking the right market and the right opportunity
7 OVERVIEW OF VIRGIN SOFT DRINKS
The Virgin Drinks Group first launched as the Virgin Cola Company in 1994 with
Virgin Cola in the UK Since then the company has ventured across the carbonated
soft drinks arena and beyond into energy drinks tea and flavored Colas This
expansion has lead to the evolution of the Virgin Drinks Company a company
whose aim is to put the excitement back into the world of soft drinks It launched in
Bangladesh in 1999 Virgin Soft Drinks is monitored by Global Beverage Co Ltd in
Bangladesh
Brief history of Virgin Drinks is given below
Page 31 of 46
1994 November Virgin Cola launched in the UK
1996 March Virgin Cola launched in France
1998 June Virgin Cola launched in Belgium
April Virgin Cola launched in the French West Indies
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
August Virgin Cola launched in Switzerland
1999 March Virgin Colours launched in Italy
March Virgin Cola launched in Japan
July Virgin Colours launched in South Africa
December Virgin Colours launched in Bangladesh
2001 January Sweden launched Virgin Colours
November Singapore launched Virgin Colours
2002 February Croatia launched Virgin Colours
June Russia launched Virgin Colours
June Tunisia launched Virgin Colours
2003 May Israel launched Virgin Colours
8 FINDINGS OF WORKING CAPITAL MANAGEMENT MAINTAINED BY
VIRGIN SOFT DRINKS IN BANGLADESH
81 CASH MANAGEMENT
811 Holding Cash and Marketable Securities
Although there are many good reasons why firm hold cash and marketable
securities Virgin Drinks holds cash and marketable securities for two reasons ndash
i) Cash for transactions
ii) Cash as hedges
This indicates that the firm does not hold cash and marketable securities for some
important reasons such as ndash
i) Near cash assets as hedges
Page 32 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
ii) Temporary investment and compensating balances
Virgin Soft Drinks does not invest in money market securities such as Treasury bill
commercial paper certificate of deposits bankerrsquos acceptance and repurchase
agreement This firm deposits its money in bank as currant AC or fixed AC They
say that they do not have enough money to invest in money market instrument
They also say that if they have enough money they will invest it in money market
short term securities We know that near cash interest earning assets can be
substituted for cash when motivation for holding these assets is the hedging of cash
flow uncertainties or is the temporary investment of surplus funds In this point
Virgins position is not good as there is no significant hedging against uncertainty of
cash
812 Floatation and Check Clearing
Virgin is very smart in handling the problem of transit time for checks Here mail
float takes 2 to 3 days at firm takes 025 day and clearing float takes 1-3 days Virgin
uses most of the strategies available for reducing the delay in receiving funds It
(Virgin) has linked Islami Bank which posses an accelerated clearing facility It uses
electronic collection process which ensures faster collection and its at the firm check
processing is satisfactory But Virgin does not use lockbox The reason behind this is
that it is not cost-effective for Virgin to set lockboxes At this point we can say that
Virgins check clearing mechanism is much good
813 Cash Concentration and Disbursement Management
Page 33 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks takes the matter of cash concentration very seriously They use all
the available cash concentration mechanism Virgin is a firm with small deposits
spread over a substantial number of banks and this is why the firm tends to use
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
depository transfer checks extensively If is less costly Virgin also uses automated
clearing house and wire transfer To Virgin wire transfer seems too costly
Like other firm Virgin tries to retain the cash for as long as possible But Virgin
always performs it in an ethical manner Virgin does not try to defeat the receiving
firmrsquos attempts to reduce the float on incoming checks It does not take any strategy
for increasing mail float at firm float and clearing float on its outgoing checks To
Virgin it is deemed to be unethical It thinks that maximization of disbursement float
will not go unnoticed by sophisticated creditors for very long When it is noticed it
will negatively affect relations with these creditors reducing the firmrsquos bargaining
power with them This may ultimately cost Virgin dearly when future prices and
delivery schedules for goods and services purchased from trade creditors are
negotiated Virgin follows ldquoZero-Balance Accountsrdquo methods for managing
disbursement It thinks that in this method the coordination of funds inflows to
disbursement banks with the presentation of checks does not work to the detriment
of creditors since the firmrsquos checks to them are honored as presented and this strategy
does not affect float significantly Controlled disbursing method is less attractive to
Virgin because zero-balance system is already feasible
814 Cash Forecasting
Cash Forecasting and Its Types
Page 34 of 46
Virgin forecasts the future cash inflows and outflows To Virgin cash forecast is an
important part of the firmrsquos cash control system and is one of the forecasts that are
part of the Virginrsquos financial plan Virgin forecasts cash on monthly basis and on
yearly basis Virgin does not forecast on daily basis assuming that the temporary
shortage of funds within these periods can be covered without value cost eg
advance receipts from customers Virginrsquos cash forecasting system involves a
combination of distribution and scheduling The receipts and disbursements
approach of cash forecasting is used in virgin This method is used because it
minutely traces the movement of cash and very close control of cash is possible
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Virgin does not use adjusted net income approach on two grounds First it does not
permit the tracing of the individual types of cash inflows and outflows for any given
period which is often useful information for virgin Second it is not simple to use
Items to be Forecast
Virgin does not forecast all the items It forecasts only major items eg accounts
receivable notes receivable payroll cash purchases of raw materials In this regard
virgin trade off between cost and benefit
Methods of Financial Forecasting
Virgin forecasts the future level of financial variable such as cash level asset level or
liability level We know in short term forecasts many things will result from plans
and events that are already in place (contracts capital budgets long-range financing
plans and so forth) But in the long run most things can vary and are dependent on
outside influences such as the firmrsquos long-term growth rate Since Virginrsquos cash
forecasting deals mostly with near future many of the items on the cash forecasts are
estimated by some variation of the spot method and remaining estimates are mostly
on a ldquoproportion of another accountrdquo basis with this ldquoother accountrdquo often being a
particular periodrsquos sales Virgin uses the other two methods less frequently
Using Cash Forecast
Virgin forecasts cash for meeting general objectives (ie to know the available funds
for investment and need financing) and for meeting some special objectives (eg to
know whether the firm will fulfill its out of debt requirement) But it is matter to note
that Virgin does not make any short term investment of its surplus cash but only keep
this surplus in Bank Account
Page 35 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Sources of Uncertainty in Cash Forecasting and Hedging Uncertainties
Virgin faces uncertainty in cash forecasting mainly from two sources These are ndash
sales and production cost In peak season (hot season like autumn summer) sales
increases but in dull season (eg in winter) sales decreases drastically Production
cost may be increased because of increase of price of sugar chemicals aluminum
can Virgin follows two methods for hedging cash balance uncertainties These are ndash
i) Holding a stock of extra cash and
ii) Extra borrowing capacity
815 Modes for the Management of Cash and Temporary Investments
Virgin does not follow any of these methods wholly Virgin receives cash
continuously and pays salary at steady rate and pays continuously for other
expenses So it neither follows Baumol model nor Beranek model It has no upper
control limit lower control limit return point in case cash management So it neither
follows Miller-Orr model nor Stone model
In Summary
Page 36 of 46
Standard Compliance by Virgin Soft Drinks
Generally all firms hold cash and
marketable securities
Virgin holds only cash
Firms hold cash and marketable
securities for some reasons like
bull Cash for transactions
bull Cash and near-cash assets as
hedges
bull Temporary investments
bull Compensating balances
Virgin holds cash only for
two reasons ndash
bull Cash for transactions
bull Cash as hedges
Available money market instruments Virgin does not invest in any such
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
(short term securities) are ndash
Treasury Bills
Commercial Paper
Certificates of Deposit
Bankerrsquos Acceptance
Repurch menase Agree ts
instruments They only keep cash in
Bank Account
Mail Float
(1 to 5 days)
At Firm
Float
(025 to 1
day)
Clearing
Float
(0 to
2 days)
Mail Float
(2 to 3 days)
At firm
Float
(025
day)
Clearing
Float
(1 to 3
days)
Figure Transit time for a typical check Figure Transit time for a check for
Virgin
Strategies that firms can use to reduce
the delay in receiving funds are ndash
Selecting of Banks with
accelerated clearing capabilities
of check processing Acceleration
at the firm
ectronic collection Use of el
procedures
Use of lockboxes
Virgin follows the first three strategies
but does not use lockboxes
Available cash concentration
mechanisms are ndash
Depository transfer check
ouse Automated Clearing H
(ACH) electronic transfer)
Wire transfer
Virgin uses all these mechanisms of
cash concentration
Available sets of techniques for cash
disbursement management are ndash
ement of disbursement
Page 37 of 46
Manag
float
Virgin uses zero-balance accounts
technique
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Zero-Balance Accounts
Controlled disbursing
Firms may make cash flow forecasts
over periods of various lengths yearly
flows quarterly flows monthly flows
weekly flows or even daily flows
Virgin forecasts cash on yearly basis and
monthly basis
Cash forecasting system may involve ndash
Distribution
Scheduling
Virginrsquos cash forecasting system
involves a combination of distribution
and scheduling
Two common approaches to cash flow
in generating the cash forecast
and disbursement Receipts
approach
Adjusted net income approach
Virgin uses the receipts and
disbursement approach
There are many items to forecast Virgin forecasts only major items like
AR payroll etc
Four common approach to forecasting
fina i ndash nc al variables are
Spot method
Proportion to another account
Compounded growth
Multiple dependencies
Virgin uses spot method for forecasting
cash It uses proportion to another
account method for other variables and
remaining two methods are frequently
used
Sources of uncertainty in cash
forecasting are ndash
Sales uncertainty
Collection rate uncertainty
Production cost uncertainty
Capital outflow uncertainty
Virgin faces uncertainty mainly from
sales and production cost
Methods for hedging cash balance
unc a
Page 38 of 46
ert inties are ndash
i) Holding a stock of extra cash
Virgin two available methods for
hedging cash balance uncertainties
Th ese are ndash
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
ii) stock of near-cash Holding a
assets
iii) Extra borrowing capacity
iv) ary surpluses in Investing tempor
near-cash assets
i) Holding a stock of extra cash
ii) Extra borrowing capacity
(advance receipt from
customers)
Models for the management of cash and
temporary investments are ndash Baumol
model Beranek model Miller-Orr
model and Stone model
Virgin does not follow any method
wholly but a combination of Baumol
model and Beranek model is occurred
82 INVENTORY MANAGEMENT
21 Certainty Approach
isnt used in
irgin because it thinks it is not possible to implement in Bangladesh
d time is one to three days It
oes not use ABC system of inventory management
8
Main item of inventory of Virgin is Can pet chip sugar label chemical artificial
sweet etc Virgin maintains a minimum level of inventory but it does not have to face
problems because inventory is managed efficiently just-in-time (JIT)
V
Virgin maintains buffer stock because of the shortage of work-in-process (WIP)
inventory Its production process may also be hampered Thats why it maintains
safety stock to avoid stock out cost In case of imported goods normal lead time is
about one month and within the country normal lea
d
Page 39 of 46
Inventory Model
In reality Virgin does not use any of models of EOQ ordering and holding strategy
and safety stock strategy They maintain inventory based on their prior experience
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
822 Uncertainty Approach
Virgin does not use any model for handling inventory uncertainty It says that such
decision depends on business cycle and market situation Long before Eid festival
they bought large amount of sugar because of price increase on the occasion of Eid
In summary
Standard Compliance by Virgin Soft Drinks
Firms maintain inventory to guard
against several problems
Virgin maintains a minimum level of
inventory which is managed efficiently
Some firms use JIT to avoid inventory
cost
JIT is not used by Virgin as it thinks it is
impossible to implement in Bangladesh
Firms maintain buffer stock Virgin maintains buffer stock too
Firms maintain safety stock to avoid
shortage cost
Virgin also maintains safety stock
Firms use ABC system to monitor
inventory
Virgin doesnt use ABC system
EOQ model is an appropriate method
for measuring quantity that has to be
ordered per order
Virgin does not use EOQ model rather
makes order based on experience and
market demand
83 MANAGING ACCOUNTS RECEIVABLE (DEBTORS)
831 Terms of Sale Decision
Page 40 of 46
Virgin offers the term 210 net 30 enables the customers to deduct 2 percent from the
face value of the bill when paying within the first 10 days but if the discount is not
taken the customer must remit the full amount within 30 days But Virgin does not
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
offer the same terms of sale to all customers For prime customers it offers special
terms of sale In setting an appropriate term of sale it costs and benefits regarding
this are compared It uses the standard approach of terms of sale decision as it is
simple to use
832 Credit Granting Decisions
In case of Virgin the Capital and Character of Five Cs get more importance
Although there are many problems with the traditional approach Virgin uses it
because of its simplicity Virgin does not use Net Present Value (NPV) method in
credit granting decision It thinks that NPV is an appropriate method and should be
used next time It does not face any severe problem because of bad debts The reason
is that notes receivable is used when credit is granted
833 Monitoring Accounts Receivable
Virgin monitors its accounts receivable Virgin believes that in any case both positive
and negative durations in accounts signal differences from the results that
management believe to be the most advantageous for the firm
Tools for Monitoring Accounts Receivable
Page 41 of 46
For monitoring accounts receivable there are several tools such as aging schedule
the ratios of receivable outstanding to original sales customers payment proportion
and sales weighted DSO (Days Sales Outstanding) For monitoring accounts
receivable Virgin uses aging schedule fractions and traditional DSO statistics
because of their simplicity in use Although payment proportions ratios of
receivables outstanding and sales weighted DSO methods are free from inherent bias
None of these is used because all these are complex to maintain
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
In summary
Page 42 of 46
Standard Compliance by Virgin Soft Drinks
Generals terms of sale is 210 net 30 Normally Virgin also use general terms
of sale ie 210 net 30
Firms do not offer the same terms of
sale to all customers
Yes For prime customers Virgin offers
special terms of sale
Approaches of terms of sale decisions
are ndash
bull Standard approach
bull Multi period approach
Virgin uses standard approach of terms
of sale decision as it is simple to use and
understand
Source of credit information are ndash
Sellers prior experience with the
customer
Credit agency ratings and
reports
Personal contact with the
applicants bank and other
creditors
Analysis of applicants financial
statements
Customer visit
Main source of credit information to
Virgin is its prior experience with the
customer All other sources are not cost-
effective for Virgin
Approaches of credit granting to
marginal accounts are ndash
Traditional approach
Net Present Value (NPV)
approach
It uses traditional approach still now but
thinks that NPV should be used for the
next periods
Firms monitor accounts receivable
because deviations from the expected
levels of turnover and of bad debt can
Virgin also monitors its accounts
receivable
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
signal several different problems
Different tools for monitoring accounts
receivable are ndash
Aging schedule
Ratios of receivables
outstanding to original sales
Customers payment
proportions
Sales-weighted DSO
For monitoring accounts receivable
Virgin uses aging schedule and
traditional sales outstanding statistics
84 MANAGING ACCOUNTS PAYABLE (CREDITORS)
Virgin has almost accounts payable of Tk 8000000 But most of its liabilities are to
the banks rather than suppliers But we dont have any clear information about
Virgins accounts payable
9 RECOMMENDATION
Virgin should invest its surplus cash in short term marketable securities
because it is suitable hedging against cash uncertainties and will also give
some returns (interest income)
Virgin should publish its own annual report which will satisfy information
needs of stakeholders and also increase the credibility of information provided
by Virgin
Page 43 of 46
Virgin should use multi period approach in terms of sale decision because
standard approach which is already exists in Virgin has some inherent
problems
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
It should stop using traditional approach from now It should use NPV
method in credit granting to marginal accounts
In monitoring accounts receivable Virgin should use sales-weighted DSO
method because it has least limitation compared to the others
It should be more flexible in granting credit which will ultimately increase its
sales
To get the appropriate number of quantity to be ordered per order it should
use DSO model
It should be ABC system for proper monitoring of inventory
10 CONCLUSION
The use of other peoples money in business is usually an expensive resource Before
looking outside for finance a firm should examine its own working capital cycle to
make sure that every rand of its own internal funds is being fully utilized Good
management of working capital is part of good financial management Effective use
of working capital will contribute to the operational efficiency of the whole
organization optimum use will help to generate maximum returns Furthermore
working capital management is not an end in itself It is an integral part of the firms
overall management The needs of efficient working capital management must be
considered in relation to other aspects of the Virgins financial and non-financial
performance Thats why when planning the development of a business it is critical
that the impact of working capital be fully assessed
Page 44 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
BIBLIOGRAPHY
Scherr FC (1989) International Edition Prentice-Hall International Inc Modern
Working Capital Management Text and Cases
Hussain Riaz (2002) Working Capital Management
Robertson Lonnie (July 1998) Inventory Management
httpwwwasashoporg visited on March 13 2006
The Art of Cash Management
httpwwwinccom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management
httpwwwstudyfinancecom visited on March 13 2006
White Paper ndash Managing Working Capital
httpwwwplanwareorg visited on March 13 2006
Management of Working Capital
httpwwwbusinesscentralcoza visited on March 13 2006
Cash Management
httpwwwsbagov visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management Objectives
httpwpsprenhallcom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management
Page 45 of 46
httpwwwadvancemecom visited on March 13 2006
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Business Receivables Financing
httpwwwbbtcom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Finance
http wwwfnbcoza visited on March 13 2006
Tips to manage your working capital
httpsmallbusinessninemsncomau visited on March 13 2006
Inventory Financing
httpwwwfranklincapitalnetworkcom visited on March 13 2006
Accounts Receivable Management
httpwwwfranklincapitalnetworkcom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management
httpwwwtreasurygovtnz visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management
httpwwwtreasurystrategiescom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Works
httpwwwinvestopediacom visited on March 13 2006
Treasury Services
httpwwwjpmorganchasecom visited on March 13 2006
what were about
Page 46 of 46
httpwwwvirgincom visited on March 13 2006
Annexure
Annexure
Interview with YASEER RIZVI
Mr Yaseer Rizvi the DMD of Global Beverage Co Ltd obtained his MBA degree
from a reputed university He had been the Director of Ocean Container Ltd before
joining in Global Beverage Co Ltd He possesses a nice personality
I interviewed Yaseer Rizvi Excerpts from his interview are as follows ndash
Shah Kamal Sir would you please tell me do you invest in short term marketable securities
Yaseer Rizvi Basically we do not invest our surplus cash in short term marketable
securities like T-Bill commercial paper certificate of deposit etc But we keep our
surplus cash in Bank
Shah Kamal Would you tell me something about transit time for a typical check
Yaseer Rizvi Well in Virgin the transit time for a typical check is ndash
For mail float 2 to 3 days
At firm float 6 hours
Clearing float 1 to 3 days
Shah Kamal Do you maintain any cash concentration mechanism like depository transfer check automated clearing house and wire transfer
i
Annexure
Yaseer Rizvi Our position in this case is very strong as we use all the mechanisms
you mentioned As Virgin is a firm with small deposits spread over a substantial
number of banks so we tend to use depository transfer checks extensively It is less
costly We also use automated clearing house and wire transfer but later is used in a
less extent
Shah Kamal Sir what techniques of disbursement management is used by your firm
Yaseer Rizvi Like other firms Virgin tries to retain the cash for as long as possible
But we always perform it in an ethical manner We do not use management of
disbursement float as it seems unethical We follow Zero-Balance Accounts method
for managing disbursement We do not prefer Controlled Disbursing method since
Zero-Balance system is already practiced in Virgin
Shah Kamal How do you hedge cash balance uncertainties
Yaseer Rizvi Well you may say that we do not invest in short term securities but for
facing cash difficulties we keep our surplus cash in bank
Shah Kamal Sir would you please tell me the general terms of sale of Virgin
Yaseer Rizvi Though it is difficult to maintain a fixed terms of sale our general terms
of sale is 210 n30 But for prime customers we offer special terms of sale
Shah Kamal What are the sources of credit information in case of your firm
Yaseer Rizvi We grant credit on the basis of prior experience with the customers In
case of a new customer personal contact is weighted
Shah Kamal Does your firm consider 5 Cs in granting credit
ii
Annexure
Yaseer Rizvi In case of Virgin Capital and Character get more importance than the
others Mind one thing personal relationship is the main measure in granting credit
Shah Kamal Do you use NPV method in credit granting decisions
Yaseer Rizvi We do not use NPV method But we think that NPV is a suitable
method and we have to use it from the next period
Shah Kamal Sir how do you handle the problem of bad debt
Yaseer Rizvi Well in this case our position is very strong Yet we do not face any
problem because of bad debt Just note that we make more than 80 of sales in cash
and we monitor accounts receivable very carefully
Shah Kamal What level of inventory is maintained by Virgin
Yaseer Rizvi We maintain a minimum level of inventory but do not have to face
stock out problems because inventory is managed efficiently
Shah Kamal What is the normal lead time
Yaseer Rizvi In case of imported goods normal lead time is about 1 month and when
we purchase raw materials from inside the country lead time is 1 to 3 days
Shah Kamal What method do you use for managing inventory
Yaseer Rizvi We do not use any method particularly rather inventory decision
depends on business cycle and market situation Long before the Eid festival we
bought large amount of sugar because price of sugar was increased on the occasion
of Eid
iii
Annexure
Shah Kamal What are the main items of inventory of your firm
Yaseer Rizvi Well these are ndash aluminum can pet chip sugar label chemical and
artificial sweet
Shah Kamal What are the uncertainties in maintaining appropriate level of stock
Yaseer Rizvi These are ndash
bull Increase in price of raw materials
bull Sales uncertainty
bull Market trends etc
Shah Kamal Thank you for your kind cooperation
Yaseer Rizvi Most Welcome
iv
Global Beverage Company Limited
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Sources of Uncertainty in Cash Forecasting and Hedging Uncertainties
There are numerous sources of risk in cash forecasting Among the sources are sales
uncertainty collection rate uncertainty production cost uncertainty and capital
outflow uncertainty
5316 Models for the Management of Cash and Temporary Investments
There are different models for the management of cash and temporary investments
Among these the most popular methods are ndash Baumol model Beranek model
Miller-Orr model and Stone model
Baumol and Beranek use the same model The formula is cited below ndash
Interest Income = iYn
n⎥⎦⎤
⎢⎣⎡ minus
21
Profit = naiYn
nminus⎥⎦
⎤⎢⎣⎡ minus
21
Optimum number of transactions = ⎟⎠⎞
⎜⎝⎛
aiY2
Where n = Optimum number of transactions
i = Interest rate per period
a = Transaction cost
Y = Total inflow for the period
Page 17 of 46
Miller-Orr and Stone use the same model ie R-Statistic The model is ndash
31
43
iav
R ⎟⎠⎞
⎜⎝⎛=
Optimum Control Limit = R + L
Upper Control Limit = 3R + L
Where a = Transaction Cost
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
v = Variance of daily cash flows
i = Daily interest rate
5317 Administration
Cash receipts should be processed and banked as quickly as possible because
They cannot earn interest or reduce overdraft until they are banked
information about the existence and amounts of cash receipts is usually not
available until they are processed
Where possible cash floats (mainly petty cash and advances) should be avoided If
on review the only reason that can be put forward for their existence is that weve
always had them they should be discontinued There may be situations where they
are useful however For example it may be desirable for peripheral parts of
departments to meet urgent local needs from cash floats rather than local bank
accounts
5318 Internal Control
Cash and cash management is part of a firms overall internal control system The
main internal cash control is invariably the bank reconciliation This provides
assurance that the cash balances recorded in the accounting systems are consistent
with the actual bank balances It requires regular clearing of reconciling items
5319 Practicing Good Cash Flow Management
Good cash management is simple It involves
Knowing when where and how firms cash needs will occur
Page 18 of 46
Knowing the best sources for meeting additional cash needs
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Page 19 of 46
Being prepared to meet these needs when they occur by keeping good
relationships with bankers and other creditors
532 INVENTORY MANAGEMENT
Inventory management is necessary for owners who want to maintain a stocking
service for quick turnaround to help ensure total customer satisfaction The fill rate
of an item on a managed inventory list must be maintained to avoid shortages of
frequently used items Even when utilizing an inventory management system
occasional shortages will still occur Inventories are lists of stocks-raw materials
work in progress or finished goods-waiting to be consumed in production or to be
sold The total balance of inventory is the sum of the value of each individual stock
line
Basically firms hold stocks for the following reasons
To act as a buffer in times of unusually high demand
To ensure continuity of production
Avoid high costs of emergency orders
To take advantage of quantity discounts by ordering more at a time
To reduce ordering costs by ordering more items on fewer
As part of the production process eg maturing whisky or keeping oil in
pipelines
Seasonality of demand (eg firework) or supplies
Suppliers insist on minimum order quantities
The key issue for a business is to identify the fast and slow stock movers with the
objectives of establishing optimum stock levels for each category and thereby
minimize the cash tied up in stocks Factors to be considered when determining
optimum stock levels include
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Page 20 of 46
What are the projected sales of each product
How widely available are raw materials components etc
How long does it take for delivery by suppliers
Can the firm remove slow movers from its product range without
compromising best sellers
Inventory management is an important aspect of working capital management
because inventories themselves do not earn any revenue Holding either too little or
too much inventory incurs costs
Costs of carrying too much inventory are
Opportunity cost of foregone interest
Warehousing costs
Damage and pilferage
Obsolescence
Insurance
Costs of carrying too little inventory are
Stock out costs
Lost sales
Delayed service
Ordering costs
Freight
on Order administrati
nts
Loss of quantity discou
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Carrying costs can be minimized by making frequent small orders but this increase
ordering costs and the risk of stock outs Risk of stock-outs can be reduced by
carrying safety stocks (at a cost) and re-ordering ahead of time
The best ordering strategy requires balancing the various cost factors to ensure the
firm incurs minimum inventory costs The optimum inventory position is known as
the Economic Reorder Quantity (ERQ)
Nowadays many large manufacturers operate on a just-in-time (JIT) basis whereby
all the components to be assembled on a particular today arrive at the factory early
that morning no earlier - no later This helps to minimize manufacturing costs as JIT
stocks take up little space minimize stock-holding and virtually eliminate the risks of
obsolete or damaged stock Because JIT manufacturers hold stock for a very short
time they are able to conserve substantial cash JIT is a good model to strive for as it
embraces all the principles of prudent stock management For better stock control
firm may try the following
Review the effectiveness of existing purchasing and inventory systems
Know the stock turn for all major items of inventory
Apply tight controls to the significant few items and simplify controls for the
trivial many
Sell off outdated or slow moving merchandise - it gets more difficult to sell the
longer the firm keeps it
Consider having part of its product outsourced to another manufacturer rather
than make it itself
Review its security procedures to ensure that no stock is going out the back
door
Higher than necessary stock levels tie up cash and cost more in insurance
accommodation costs and interest charges
Page 21 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
However it is important to keep an overall perspective It is not cost-effective to
closely manage a large number of low value inventory lines nor is it necessary A
usual feature of inventories is that a small number of high value lines account for a
large proportion of inventory value The 8020 rule (PARETO) predicts that 80
of the total value of inventory is represented by only 20 of the number of inventory
items Those high value lines need reasonably close management The remaining
80 of inventory lines can be managed using broad-brush strategies
533 MANAGING ACCOUNTS RECEIVABLE (DEBTORS)
Cash flow can be significantly enhanced if the amounts owing to a business are
collected faster Every business needs to know who owes them money how much is
owed how long it is owing for what it is owed
Debtors (Accounts Receivable) are customers who have not yet made payment for
goods or services which the department has provided The objective of debtor
management is to minimize the time-lapse between completion of sales and receipt
of payment The costs of having debtors are
Opportunity costs (cash is not available for other purposes)
Bad debts
If firm doesnt manage debtors they will begin to manage business as the firm will gradually
lose control due to reduced cash flow and of course it could experience an increased
incidence of bad debt The following measures will help manage debtors
Having the right mental attitude to the control of credit and make sure that it
gets the priority it deserves
Establishing clear credit practices as a matter of company policy
Page 22 of 46
Making sure that these practices are clearly understood by staff suppliers and
customers
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Page 23 of 46
Being professional when accepting new accounts and especially larger ones
Checking out each customer thoroughly before the firm offers credit Use
credit agencies bank references industry sources etc
Establishing credit limits for each customer and sticking to them
Continuously reviewing these limits when it suspects tough times are coming
or if operating in a volatile sector
Keeping very close to the firms larger customers
Invoicing promptly and clearly
Considering charging penalties on overdue accounts
Considering accepting credit debit cards as a payment option
Monitoring its debtor balances and ageing schedules and dont let any debts
get too large or too old
Debtor management includes both pre-sale and debt collection strategies
Pre-sale strategies include
Offering cash discounts for early payment andor imposing penalties for late
payment
Agreeing payment terms in advance
Requiring cash before delivery
Setting credit limits
ning credit Setting criteria for obtai
Billing as early as possible
rogress payments
ost-sale strategies include
for collecting the debt upon the center that made the sale
Requiring deposits andor p
P
Placing the responsibility
Identifying long overdue balances and doubtful debts by regular analytical reviews
Having an established procedure for late collections such as
A reminder
A letter
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Page 24 of 46
ion of further credit Cancellat
Telephone calls
n agency Use of a collectio
he firm should recognize that the longer someone owes firm the greater the chance
Legal action
T
it will never get paid If the average age of debtors is getting longer or is already very
long it may need to look for the following possible defects
Weak credit judgment
res Poor collection procedu
ms Lax enforcement of credit ter
Slow issue of invoices or statements
Errors in invoices or statements
Customer dissatisfaction
Debtors due over 90 days (unless within agreed credit terms) should generally
demand immediate attention For example warning signs of a future bad debt ndash
Longer credit terms taken with approval particularly for smaller orders
Use of post-dated checks by debtors who normally settle within agreed terms
Evidence of customers switching to additional suppliers for the same goods
New customers who are reluctant to give credit references
Cre G
Receiving part payments from debtors
dit ranting to Marginal Accounts
Traditional Approach
In the traditional approach to the credit granting decision it is the credit analysts job
rmation that has been collected and reach a judgment
regarding the applicants creditworthiness One traditional way of organizing this
to synthesize all the info
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
information is by characterizing the applicant along five dimensions These
dimensions are called the Five Cs of credit ndash
Capital
Character
Collateral
and Capacity
Conditions
Net Present Value (NPV) Approach
Once a firm has assessed the creditworthiness of a customer it has to decide whether
r not credit should be granted The firm should use the NPV rule to make the
ld be granted
Figure
o
decision If NPV is positive credit shou
Credit Granting Decision
Credit Granting Decision
he act of collecting money is one which most people dislike for many reasons and
therefore put on the long f selves there is something
ore urgent or important that demands their attention now There is nothing more
T
inger because they convince them
m
important than getting paid for firms product or service A customer who does not
Page 25 of 46
Grand Credit
Payment received Payment not received
Benefit of present value of future net cash flow
Cost of present value ment of lost invest
Net Payoff PV of benefit-cost
No Credit
No Payoff
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
pay is not a customer Here are a few ideas that may help the firm in collecting
money from debtors
Firm should develop appropriate procedures for handling late payments
It should track and pursue late payers
It might get external help if its own efforts fail
or money its firms and it is entitled Company shouldnt feel guilty asking f
to it
ction
Firm must make that call now And it should keep asking until it gets some
satisfa
lessens the problem
In difficult circumstances take what the firm can now and agree terms for the
remainder It
paying
When asking for money be hard on the issue - but soft on the person It shouldnt
give the debtor any excuses for not
534 BLE (CREDITORS)
ices for goods or services have
een paid Organizations often regard the
not
to delay all payments until the latest possible date Regular weekly or
The firm make it its objective is to get the money - not to score points or get
even
MANAGING ACCOUNTS PAYA
Creditors (Accounts Payable) are suppliers whose invo
been processed but who have not yet b
amount owing to creditors as a source of free credit However creditor
administration systems are expensive and time-consuming to run The over-riding
concern in this area should be to minimize costs with simple procedures
While it is unnecessary to pay accounts before they fall due it is usually
worthwhile
Page 26 of 46
fortnightly payment of all due accounts is the simplest technique for creditor
management
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Electronic payments (direct credits) are cheaper than check payments considering
that transaction fees and overheads more than balance the advantage of delayed
presentation Some suppliers are reluctant to receive payments by this method but in
view of the substantial cost advantage (and the advantages to the suppliers
themselves) departments may wish to encourage suppliers to accept this option
However electronic payments are likely to be used in conjunction with rather than
as a replacement for check payments
Applying Best Practices in Managing Accounts Payable
f course simply deferring payments to suppliers could have adverse consequences
O
that more than offset the benefits of this additional cash flow Therefore it is
important to develop a holistic approach The firm should consider the following
best practices for payables management
Managing payment dates and terms to maximize cash flow ndash
y reporting on
receivable and
id penalty charges and taking advantage of
wer vendors and negotiate for more
to buying consortia with others even
voices for
payment based on receipt of goods or receipt of invoice whichever
comes later
Calculating and setting performance targets Regularl
AP performance measures such as days in payables
Coordinating the AP processes with accounts
inventory management to ensure that the company is collecting more
cash than it is paying out
Paying bills on time to avo
prompt-payment discounts where the discounts exceed the companyrsquos
cost of working capital
Consolidating purchases with fe
favorable payment terms
Considering entering in
Page 27 of 46
competitors to obtain favorable supplier pricing and terms
Unless contract terms specify otherwise setting up in
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Page 28 of 46
Em
process
-time payments with Electronic Funds Transfer (EFT)
uraging vendors to utilize electronic invoice presentment
a
ndancies and more
ploying technology to automate the accounts payable transaction
es ndash
Making just-in
Using an electronic invoice-matching application
Enco
For companies with multiple locations or business units employing
shared service approach for AP to eliminate redu
quickly implement process improvements
Mainta
vendor
Communicating accounts payable requirements to suppliers at the
m key suppliers
for suggestions on how to improve the
Efficient a
and making th rsquos cash is just good business
ining open communications and building strong relationships with
s to access valuable trade credit ndash
beginning of transactions
Requesting summary invoicing fro
Requiring suppliers to send invoices directly to accounts payable
Asking tier-one suppliers
payment process
nd effective management of accounts payable helps improve cash flow ndash
e most of company
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
6 OVERVIEW OF VIRGIN GROUP
Virgin - one of the most respected brands in Britain - is now becoming the first global
brand name of the 21st century Virgin is involved in planes trains finance soft
drinks music mobile phones holidays cars wines publishing bridal wear - the lot
What tie all these businesses together are the values of its brand and the attitude of its
people Virgin has created over 200 companies worldwide employing over 25000
people Its total revenues around the world in 2002 exceeded pound4 billion (US $72
billion)
In 1970 Richard Branson founded Virgin as a mail order record retailer and not
long after he opened a record shop in Oxford Street London During 1972 a
recording studio was built in Oxfordshire and the first Virgin artist Mike Oldfield
recorded Tubular Bells which was released in 1973
This album went on to sell over 5 million copies Since then many household names
including Belinda Carlisle Genesis Phil Collins Janet Jackson and The Rolling
Stones have helped to make Virgin Music one of the top six record companies in the
world The equity of Virgin Music Group - record labels music publishing and
recording studios was sold to THORN EMI in 1992 in a US$1billion deal
Page 29 of 46
The Virgin Group has now expanded into international music Mega stores air
travel mobile financial retail music internet drinks rail hotels and leisure with
around 200 companies in over 30 countries
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
In Virgins customers eyes Virgin stands for value for money quality innovation
fun and a sense of competitive challenge It delivers a quality service by empowering
its employees and facilitates and monitors customer feedback to continually improve
the customers experience through innovation
When they start a new venture Virgin bases it on hard research and analysis
Typically they review the industry and put themselves in the customers shoes to see
what could make it better Virgin asks fundamental questions
Is this an opportunity for restructuring a market and creating competitive
advantage What are the competitors doing
Is the customer confused or badly served
Is this an opportunity for building the Virgin brand
Can we add value
Will it interact with its other businesses
Is there an appropriate trade-off between risk and reward
Page 30 of 46
Virgin is also able to draw on talented people from throughout the group New
ventures are often steered by people seconded from other parts of Virgin who bring
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
with them the trademark management style skills and experience Virgin frequently
creates partnerships with others to combine skills knowledge and market presence
and so on Contrary to what some people may think their constantly expanding and
eclectic empire is neither random nor reckless Each successive venture demonstrates
its skill in picking the right market and the right opportunity
7 OVERVIEW OF VIRGIN SOFT DRINKS
The Virgin Drinks Group first launched as the Virgin Cola Company in 1994 with
Virgin Cola in the UK Since then the company has ventured across the carbonated
soft drinks arena and beyond into energy drinks tea and flavored Colas This
expansion has lead to the evolution of the Virgin Drinks Company a company
whose aim is to put the excitement back into the world of soft drinks It launched in
Bangladesh in 1999 Virgin Soft Drinks is monitored by Global Beverage Co Ltd in
Bangladesh
Brief history of Virgin Drinks is given below
Page 31 of 46
1994 November Virgin Cola launched in the UK
1996 March Virgin Cola launched in France
1998 June Virgin Cola launched in Belgium
April Virgin Cola launched in the French West Indies
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
August Virgin Cola launched in Switzerland
1999 March Virgin Colours launched in Italy
March Virgin Cola launched in Japan
July Virgin Colours launched in South Africa
December Virgin Colours launched in Bangladesh
2001 January Sweden launched Virgin Colours
November Singapore launched Virgin Colours
2002 February Croatia launched Virgin Colours
June Russia launched Virgin Colours
June Tunisia launched Virgin Colours
2003 May Israel launched Virgin Colours
8 FINDINGS OF WORKING CAPITAL MANAGEMENT MAINTAINED BY
VIRGIN SOFT DRINKS IN BANGLADESH
81 CASH MANAGEMENT
811 Holding Cash and Marketable Securities
Although there are many good reasons why firm hold cash and marketable
securities Virgin Drinks holds cash and marketable securities for two reasons ndash
i) Cash for transactions
ii) Cash as hedges
This indicates that the firm does not hold cash and marketable securities for some
important reasons such as ndash
i) Near cash assets as hedges
Page 32 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
ii) Temporary investment and compensating balances
Virgin Soft Drinks does not invest in money market securities such as Treasury bill
commercial paper certificate of deposits bankerrsquos acceptance and repurchase
agreement This firm deposits its money in bank as currant AC or fixed AC They
say that they do not have enough money to invest in money market instrument
They also say that if they have enough money they will invest it in money market
short term securities We know that near cash interest earning assets can be
substituted for cash when motivation for holding these assets is the hedging of cash
flow uncertainties or is the temporary investment of surplus funds In this point
Virgins position is not good as there is no significant hedging against uncertainty of
cash
812 Floatation and Check Clearing
Virgin is very smart in handling the problem of transit time for checks Here mail
float takes 2 to 3 days at firm takes 025 day and clearing float takes 1-3 days Virgin
uses most of the strategies available for reducing the delay in receiving funds It
(Virgin) has linked Islami Bank which posses an accelerated clearing facility It uses
electronic collection process which ensures faster collection and its at the firm check
processing is satisfactory But Virgin does not use lockbox The reason behind this is
that it is not cost-effective for Virgin to set lockboxes At this point we can say that
Virgins check clearing mechanism is much good
813 Cash Concentration and Disbursement Management
Page 33 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks takes the matter of cash concentration very seriously They use all
the available cash concentration mechanism Virgin is a firm with small deposits
spread over a substantial number of banks and this is why the firm tends to use
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
depository transfer checks extensively If is less costly Virgin also uses automated
clearing house and wire transfer To Virgin wire transfer seems too costly
Like other firm Virgin tries to retain the cash for as long as possible But Virgin
always performs it in an ethical manner Virgin does not try to defeat the receiving
firmrsquos attempts to reduce the float on incoming checks It does not take any strategy
for increasing mail float at firm float and clearing float on its outgoing checks To
Virgin it is deemed to be unethical It thinks that maximization of disbursement float
will not go unnoticed by sophisticated creditors for very long When it is noticed it
will negatively affect relations with these creditors reducing the firmrsquos bargaining
power with them This may ultimately cost Virgin dearly when future prices and
delivery schedules for goods and services purchased from trade creditors are
negotiated Virgin follows ldquoZero-Balance Accountsrdquo methods for managing
disbursement It thinks that in this method the coordination of funds inflows to
disbursement banks with the presentation of checks does not work to the detriment
of creditors since the firmrsquos checks to them are honored as presented and this strategy
does not affect float significantly Controlled disbursing method is less attractive to
Virgin because zero-balance system is already feasible
814 Cash Forecasting
Cash Forecasting and Its Types
Page 34 of 46
Virgin forecasts the future cash inflows and outflows To Virgin cash forecast is an
important part of the firmrsquos cash control system and is one of the forecasts that are
part of the Virginrsquos financial plan Virgin forecasts cash on monthly basis and on
yearly basis Virgin does not forecast on daily basis assuming that the temporary
shortage of funds within these periods can be covered without value cost eg
advance receipts from customers Virginrsquos cash forecasting system involves a
combination of distribution and scheduling The receipts and disbursements
approach of cash forecasting is used in virgin This method is used because it
minutely traces the movement of cash and very close control of cash is possible
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Virgin does not use adjusted net income approach on two grounds First it does not
permit the tracing of the individual types of cash inflows and outflows for any given
period which is often useful information for virgin Second it is not simple to use
Items to be Forecast
Virgin does not forecast all the items It forecasts only major items eg accounts
receivable notes receivable payroll cash purchases of raw materials In this regard
virgin trade off between cost and benefit
Methods of Financial Forecasting
Virgin forecasts the future level of financial variable such as cash level asset level or
liability level We know in short term forecasts many things will result from plans
and events that are already in place (contracts capital budgets long-range financing
plans and so forth) But in the long run most things can vary and are dependent on
outside influences such as the firmrsquos long-term growth rate Since Virginrsquos cash
forecasting deals mostly with near future many of the items on the cash forecasts are
estimated by some variation of the spot method and remaining estimates are mostly
on a ldquoproportion of another accountrdquo basis with this ldquoother accountrdquo often being a
particular periodrsquos sales Virgin uses the other two methods less frequently
Using Cash Forecast
Virgin forecasts cash for meeting general objectives (ie to know the available funds
for investment and need financing) and for meeting some special objectives (eg to
know whether the firm will fulfill its out of debt requirement) But it is matter to note
that Virgin does not make any short term investment of its surplus cash but only keep
this surplus in Bank Account
Page 35 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Sources of Uncertainty in Cash Forecasting and Hedging Uncertainties
Virgin faces uncertainty in cash forecasting mainly from two sources These are ndash
sales and production cost In peak season (hot season like autumn summer) sales
increases but in dull season (eg in winter) sales decreases drastically Production
cost may be increased because of increase of price of sugar chemicals aluminum
can Virgin follows two methods for hedging cash balance uncertainties These are ndash
i) Holding a stock of extra cash and
ii) Extra borrowing capacity
815 Modes for the Management of Cash and Temporary Investments
Virgin does not follow any of these methods wholly Virgin receives cash
continuously and pays salary at steady rate and pays continuously for other
expenses So it neither follows Baumol model nor Beranek model It has no upper
control limit lower control limit return point in case cash management So it neither
follows Miller-Orr model nor Stone model
In Summary
Page 36 of 46
Standard Compliance by Virgin Soft Drinks
Generally all firms hold cash and
marketable securities
Virgin holds only cash
Firms hold cash and marketable
securities for some reasons like
bull Cash for transactions
bull Cash and near-cash assets as
hedges
bull Temporary investments
bull Compensating balances
Virgin holds cash only for
two reasons ndash
bull Cash for transactions
bull Cash as hedges
Available money market instruments Virgin does not invest in any such
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
(short term securities) are ndash
Treasury Bills
Commercial Paper
Certificates of Deposit
Bankerrsquos Acceptance
Repurch menase Agree ts
instruments They only keep cash in
Bank Account
Mail Float
(1 to 5 days)
At Firm
Float
(025 to 1
day)
Clearing
Float
(0 to
2 days)
Mail Float
(2 to 3 days)
At firm
Float
(025
day)
Clearing
Float
(1 to 3
days)
Figure Transit time for a typical check Figure Transit time for a check for
Virgin
Strategies that firms can use to reduce
the delay in receiving funds are ndash
Selecting of Banks with
accelerated clearing capabilities
of check processing Acceleration
at the firm
ectronic collection Use of el
procedures
Use of lockboxes
Virgin follows the first three strategies
but does not use lockboxes
Available cash concentration
mechanisms are ndash
Depository transfer check
ouse Automated Clearing H
(ACH) electronic transfer)
Wire transfer
Virgin uses all these mechanisms of
cash concentration
Available sets of techniques for cash
disbursement management are ndash
ement of disbursement
Page 37 of 46
Manag
float
Virgin uses zero-balance accounts
technique
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Zero-Balance Accounts
Controlled disbursing
Firms may make cash flow forecasts
over periods of various lengths yearly
flows quarterly flows monthly flows
weekly flows or even daily flows
Virgin forecasts cash on yearly basis and
monthly basis
Cash forecasting system may involve ndash
Distribution
Scheduling
Virginrsquos cash forecasting system
involves a combination of distribution
and scheduling
Two common approaches to cash flow
in generating the cash forecast
and disbursement Receipts
approach
Adjusted net income approach
Virgin uses the receipts and
disbursement approach
There are many items to forecast Virgin forecasts only major items like
AR payroll etc
Four common approach to forecasting
fina i ndash nc al variables are
Spot method
Proportion to another account
Compounded growth
Multiple dependencies
Virgin uses spot method for forecasting
cash It uses proportion to another
account method for other variables and
remaining two methods are frequently
used
Sources of uncertainty in cash
forecasting are ndash
Sales uncertainty
Collection rate uncertainty
Production cost uncertainty
Capital outflow uncertainty
Virgin faces uncertainty mainly from
sales and production cost
Methods for hedging cash balance
unc a
Page 38 of 46
ert inties are ndash
i) Holding a stock of extra cash
Virgin two available methods for
hedging cash balance uncertainties
Th ese are ndash
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
ii) stock of near-cash Holding a
assets
iii) Extra borrowing capacity
iv) ary surpluses in Investing tempor
near-cash assets
i) Holding a stock of extra cash
ii) Extra borrowing capacity
(advance receipt from
customers)
Models for the management of cash and
temporary investments are ndash Baumol
model Beranek model Miller-Orr
model and Stone model
Virgin does not follow any method
wholly but a combination of Baumol
model and Beranek model is occurred
82 INVENTORY MANAGEMENT
21 Certainty Approach
isnt used in
irgin because it thinks it is not possible to implement in Bangladesh
d time is one to three days It
oes not use ABC system of inventory management
8
Main item of inventory of Virgin is Can pet chip sugar label chemical artificial
sweet etc Virgin maintains a minimum level of inventory but it does not have to face
problems because inventory is managed efficiently just-in-time (JIT)
V
Virgin maintains buffer stock because of the shortage of work-in-process (WIP)
inventory Its production process may also be hampered Thats why it maintains
safety stock to avoid stock out cost In case of imported goods normal lead time is
about one month and within the country normal lea
d
Page 39 of 46
Inventory Model
In reality Virgin does not use any of models of EOQ ordering and holding strategy
and safety stock strategy They maintain inventory based on their prior experience
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
822 Uncertainty Approach
Virgin does not use any model for handling inventory uncertainty It says that such
decision depends on business cycle and market situation Long before Eid festival
they bought large amount of sugar because of price increase on the occasion of Eid
In summary
Standard Compliance by Virgin Soft Drinks
Firms maintain inventory to guard
against several problems
Virgin maintains a minimum level of
inventory which is managed efficiently
Some firms use JIT to avoid inventory
cost
JIT is not used by Virgin as it thinks it is
impossible to implement in Bangladesh
Firms maintain buffer stock Virgin maintains buffer stock too
Firms maintain safety stock to avoid
shortage cost
Virgin also maintains safety stock
Firms use ABC system to monitor
inventory
Virgin doesnt use ABC system
EOQ model is an appropriate method
for measuring quantity that has to be
ordered per order
Virgin does not use EOQ model rather
makes order based on experience and
market demand
83 MANAGING ACCOUNTS RECEIVABLE (DEBTORS)
831 Terms of Sale Decision
Page 40 of 46
Virgin offers the term 210 net 30 enables the customers to deduct 2 percent from the
face value of the bill when paying within the first 10 days but if the discount is not
taken the customer must remit the full amount within 30 days But Virgin does not
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
offer the same terms of sale to all customers For prime customers it offers special
terms of sale In setting an appropriate term of sale it costs and benefits regarding
this are compared It uses the standard approach of terms of sale decision as it is
simple to use
832 Credit Granting Decisions
In case of Virgin the Capital and Character of Five Cs get more importance
Although there are many problems with the traditional approach Virgin uses it
because of its simplicity Virgin does not use Net Present Value (NPV) method in
credit granting decision It thinks that NPV is an appropriate method and should be
used next time It does not face any severe problem because of bad debts The reason
is that notes receivable is used when credit is granted
833 Monitoring Accounts Receivable
Virgin monitors its accounts receivable Virgin believes that in any case both positive
and negative durations in accounts signal differences from the results that
management believe to be the most advantageous for the firm
Tools for Monitoring Accounts Receivable
Page 41 of 46
For monitoring accounts receivable there are several tools such as aging schedule
the ratios of receivable outstanding to original sales customers payment proportion
and sales weighted DSO (Days Sales Outstanding) For monitoring accounts
receivable Virgin uses aging schedule fractions and traditional DSO statistics
because of their simplicity in use Although payment proportions ratios of
receivables outstanding and sales weighted DSO methods are free from inherent bias
None of these is used because all these are complex to maintain
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
In summary
Page 42 of 46
Standard Compliance by Virgin Soft Drinks
Generals terms of sale is 210 net 30 Normally Virgin also use general terms
of sale ie 210 net 30
Firms do not offer the same terms of
sale to all customers
Yes For prime customers Virgin offers
special terms of sale
Approaches of terms of sale decisions
are ndash
bull Standard approach
bull Multi period approach
Virgin uses standard approach of terms
of sale decision as it is simple to use and
understand
Source of credit information are ndash
Sellers prior experience with the
customer
Credit agency ratings and
reports
Personal contact with the
applicants bank and other
creditors
Analysis of applicants financial
statements
Customer visit
Main source of credit information to
Virgin is its prior experience with the
customer All other sources are not cost-
effective for Virgin
Approaches of credit granting to
marginal accounts are ndash
Traditional approach
Net Present Value (NPV)
approach
It uses traditional approach still now but
thinks that NPV should be used for the
next periods
Firms monitor accounts receivable
because deviations from the expected
levels of turnover and of bad debt can
Virgin also monitors its accounts
receivable
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
signal several different problems
Different tools for monitoring accounts
receivable are ndash
Aging schedule
Ratios of receivables
outstanding to original sales
Customers payment
proportions
Sales-weighted DSO
For monitoring accounts receivable
Virgin uses aging schedule and
traditional sales outstanding statistics
84 MANAGING ACCOUNTS PAYABLE (CREDITORS)
Virgin has almost accounts payable of Tk 8000000 But most of its liabilities are to
the banks rather than suppliers But we dont have any clear information about
Virgins accounts payable
9 RECOMMENDATION
Virgin should invest its surplus cash in short term marketable securities
because it is suitable hedging against cash uncertainties and will also give
some returns (interest income)
Virgin should publish its own annual report which will satisfy information
needs of stakeholders and also increase the credibility of information provided
by Virgin
Page 43 of 46
Virgin should use multi period approach in terms of sale decision because
standard approach which is already exists in Virgin has some inherent
problems
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
It should stop using traditional approach from now It should use NPV
method in credit granting to marginal accounts
In monitoring accounts receivable Virgin should use sales-weighted DSO
method because it has least limitation compared to the others
It should be more flexible in granting credit which will ultimately increase its
sales
To get the appropriate number of quantity to be ordered per order it should
use DSO model
It should be ABC system for proper monitoring of inventory
10 CONCLUSION
The use of other peoples money in business is usually an expensive resource Before
looking outside for finance a firm should examine its own working capital cycle to
make sure that every rand of its own internal funds is being fully utilized Good
management of working capital is part of good financial management Effective use
of working capital will contribute to the operational efficiency of the whole
organization optimum use will help to generate maximum returns Furthermore
working capital management is not an end in itself It is an integral part of the firms
overall management The needs of efficient working capital management must be
considered in relation to other aspects of the Virgins financial and non-financial
performance Thats why when planning the development of a business it is critical
that the impact of working capital be fully assessed
Page 44 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
BIBLIOGRAPHY
Scherr FC (1989) International Edition Prentice-Hall International Inc Modern
Working Capital Management Text and Cases
Hussain Riaz (2002) Working Capital Management
Robertson Lonnie (July 1998) Inventory Management
httpwwwasashoporg visited on March 13 2006
The Art of Cash Management
httpwwwinccom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management
httpwwwstudyfinancecom visited on March 13 2006
White Paper ndash Managing Working Capital
httpwwwplanwareorg visited on March 13 2006
Management of Working Capital
httpwwwbusinesscentralcoza visited on March 13 2006
Cash Management
httpwwwsbagov visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management Objectives
httpwpsprenhallcom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management
Page 45 of 46
httpwwwadvancemecom visited on March 13 2006
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Business Receivables Financing
httpwwwbbtcom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Finance
http wwwfnbcoza visited on March 13 2006
Tips to manage your working capital
httpsmallbusinessninemsncomau visited on March 13 2006
Inventory Financing
httpwwwfranklincapitalnetworkcom visited on March 13 2006
Accounts Receivable Management
httpwwwfranklincapitalnetworkcom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management
httpwwwtreasurygovtnz visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management
httpwwwtreasurystrategiescom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Works
httpwwwinvestopediacom visited on March 13 2006
Treasury Services
httpwwwjpmorganchasecom visited on March 13 2006
what were about
Page 46 of 46
httpwwwvirgincom visited on March 13 2006
Annexure
Annexure
Interview with YASEER RIZVI
Mr Yaseer Rizvi the DMD of Global Beverage Co Ltd obtained his MBA degree
from a reputed university He had been the Director of Ocean Container Ltd before
joining in Global Beverage Co Ltd He possesses a nice personality
I interviewed Yaseer Rizvi Excerpts from his interview are as follows ndash
Shah Kamal Sir would you please tell me do you invest in short term marketable securities
Yaseer Rizvi Basically we do not invest our surplus cash in short term marketable
securities like T-Bill commercial paper certificate of deposit etc But we keep our
surplus cash in Bank
Shah Kamal Would you tell me something about transit time for a typical check
Yaseer Rizvi Well in Virgin the transit time for a typical check is ndash
For mail float 2 to 3 days
At firm float 6 hours
Clearing float 1 to 3 days
Shah Kamal Do you maintain any cash concentration mechanism like depository transfer check automated clearing house and wire transfer
i
Annexure
Yaseer Rizvi Our position in this case is very strong as we use all the mechanisms
you mentioned As Virgin is a firm with small deposits spread over a substantial
number of banks so we tend to use depository transfer checks extensively It is less
costly We also use automated clearing house and wire transfer but later is used in a
less extent
Shah Kamal Sir what techniques of disbursement management is used by your firm
Yaseer Rizvi Like other firms Virgin tries to retain the cash for as long as possible
But we always perform it in an ethical manner We do not use management of
disbursement float as it seems unethical We follow Zero-Balance Accounts method
for managing disbursement We do not prefer Controlled Disbursing method since
Zero-Balance system is already practiced in Virgin
Shah Kamal How do you hedge cash balance uncertainties
Yaseer Rizvi Well you may say that we do not invest in short term securities but for
facing cash difficulties we keep our surplus cash in bank
Shah Kamal Sir would you please tell me the general terms of sale of Virgin
Yaseer Rizvi Though it is difficult to maintain a fixed terms of sale our general terms
of sale is 210 n30 But for prime customers we offer special terms of sale
Shah Kamal What are the sources of credit information in case of your firm
Yaseer Rizvi We grant credit on the basis of prior experience with the customers In
case of a new customer personal contact is weighted
Shah Kamal Does your firm consider 5 Cs in granting credit
ii
Annexure
Yaseer Rizvi In case of Virgin Capital and Character get more importance than the
others Mind one thing personal relationship is the main measure in granting credit
Shah Kamal Do you use NPV method in credit granting decisions
Yaseer Rizvi We do not use NPV method But we think that NPV is a suitable
method and we have to use it from the next period
Shah Kamal Sir how do you handle the problem of bad debt
Yaseer Rizvi Well in this case our position is very strong Yet we do not face any
problem because of bad debt Just note that we make more than 80 of sales in cash
and we monitor accounts receivable very carefully
Shah Kamal What level of inventory is maintained by Virgin
Yaseer Rizvi We maintain a minimum level of inventory but do not have to face
stock out problems because inventory is managed efficiently
Shah Kamal What is the normal lead time
Yaseer Rizvi In case of imported goods normal lead time is about 1 month and when
we purchase raw materials from inside the country lead time is 1 to 3 days
Shah Kamal What method do you use for managing inventory
Yaseer Rizvi We do not use any method particularly rather inventory decision
depends on business cycle and market situation Long before the Eid festival we
bought large amount of sugar because price of sugar was increased on the occasion
of Eid
iii
Annexure
Shah Kamal What are the main items of inventory of your firm
Yaseer Rizvi Well these are ndash aluminum can pet chip sugar label chemical and
artificial sweet
Shah Kamal What are the uncertainties in maintaining appropriate level of stock
Yaseer Rizvi These are ndash
bull Increase in price of raw materials
bull Sales uncertainty
bull Market trends etc
Shah Kamal Thank you for your kind cooperation
Yaseer Rizvi Most Welcome
iv
Global Beverage Company Limited
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
v = Variance of daily cash flows
i = Daily interest rate
5317 Administration
Cash receipts should be processed and banked as quickly as possible because
They cannot earn interest or reduce overdraft until they are banked
information about the existence and amounts of cash receipts is usually not
available until they are processed
Where possible cash floats (mainly petty cash and advances) should be avoided If
on review the only reason that can be put forward for their existence is that weve
always had them they should be discontinued There may be situations where they
are useful however For example it may be desirable for peripheral parts of
departments to meet urgent local needs from cash floats rather than local bank
accounts
5318 Internal Control
Cash and cash management is part of a firms overall internal control system The
main internal cash control is invariably the bank reconciliation This provides
assurance that the cash balances recorded in the accounting systems are consistent
with the actual bank balances It requires regular clearing of reconciling items
5319 Practicing Good Cash Flow Management
Good cash management is simple It involves
Knowing when where and how firms cash needs will occur
Page 18 of 46
Knowing the best sources for meeting additional cash needs
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Page 19 of 46
Being prepared to meet these needs when they occur by keeping good
relationships with bankers and other creditors
532 INVENTORY MANAGEMENT
Inventory management is necessary for owners who want to maintain a stocking
service for quick turnaround to help ensure total customer satisfaction The fill rate
of an item on a managed inventory list must be maintained to avoid shortages of
frequently used items Even when utilizing an inventory management system
occasional shortages will still occur Inventories are lists of stocks-raw materials
work in progress or finished goods-waiting to be consumed in production or to be
sold The total balance of inventory is the sum of the value of each individual stock
line
Basically firms hold stocks for the following reasons
To act as a buffer in times of unusually high demand
To ensure continuity of production
Avoid high costs of emergency orders
To take advantage of quantity discounts by ordering more at a time
To reduce ordering costs by ordering more items on fewer
As part of the production process eg maturing whisky or keeping oil in
pipelines
Seasonality of demand (eg firework) or supplies
Suppliers insist on minimum order quantities
The key issue for a business is to identify the fast and slow stock movers with the
objectives of establishing optimum stock levels for each category and thereby
minimize the cash tied up in stocks Factors to be considered when determining
optimum stock levels include
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Page 20 of 46
What are the projected sales of each product
How widely available are raw materials components etc
How long does it take for delivery by suppliers
Can the firm remove slow movers from its product range without
compromising best sellers
Inventory management is an important aspect of working capital management
because inventories themselves do not earn any revenue Holding either too little or
too much inventory incurs costs
Costs of carrying too much inventory are
Opportunity cost of foregone interest
Warehousing costs
Damage and pilferage
Obsolescence
Insurance
Costs of carrying too little inventory are
Stock out costs
Lost sales
Delayed service
Ordering costs
Freight
on Order administrati
nts
Loss of quantity discou
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Carrying costs can be minimized by making frequent small orders but this increase
ordering costs and the risk of stock outs Risk of stock-outs can be reduced by
carrying safety stocks (at a cost) and re-ordering ahead of time
The best ordering strategy requires balancing the various cost factors to ensure the
firm incurs minimum inventory costs The optimum inventory position is known as
the Economic Reorder Quantity (ERQ)
Nowadays many large manufacturers operate on a just-in-time (JIT) basis whereby
all the components to be assembled on a particular today arrive at the factory early
that morning no earlier - no later This helps to minimize manufacturing costs as JIT
stocks take up little space minimize stock-holding and virtually eliminate the risks of
obsolete or damaged stock Because JIT manufacturers hold stock for a very short
time they are able to conserve substantial cash JIT is a good model to strive for as it
embraces all the principles of prudent stock management For better stock control
firm may try the following
Review the effectiveness of existing purchasing and inventory systems
Know the stock turn for all major items of inventory
Apply tight controls to the significant few items and simplify controls for the
trivial many
Sell off outdated or slow moving merchandise - it gets more difficult to sell the
longer the firm keeps it
Consider having part of its product outsourced to another manufacturer rather
than make it itself
Review its security procedures to ensure that no stock is going out the back
door
Higher than necessary stock levels tie up cash and cost more in insurance
accommodation costs and interest charges
Page 21 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
However it is important to keep an overall perspective It is not cost-effective to
closely manage a large number of low value inventory lines nor is it necessary A
usual feature of inventories is that a small number of high value lines account for a
large proportion of inventory value The 8020 rule (PARETO) predicts that 80
of the total value of inventory is represented by only 20 of the number of inventory
items Those high value lines need reasonably close management The remaining
80 of inventory lines can be managed using broad-brush strategies
533 MANAGING ACCOUNTS RECEIVABLE (DEBTORS)
Cash flow can be significantly enhanced if the amounts owing to a business are
collected faster Every business needs to know who owes them money how much is
owed how long it is owing for what it is owed
Debtors (Accounts Receivable) are customers who have not yet made payment for
goods or services which the department has provided The objective of debtor
management is to minimize the time-lapse between completion of sales and receipt
of payment The costs of having debtors are
Opportunity costs (cash is not available for other purposes)
Bad debts
If firm doesnt manage debtors they will begin to manage business as the firm will gradually
lose control due to reduced cash flow and of course it could experience an increased
incidence of bad debt The following measures will help manage debtors
Having the right mental attitude to the control of credit and make sure that it
gets the priority it deserves
Establishing clear credit practices as a matter of company policy
Page 22 of 46
Making sure that these practices are clearly understood by staff suppliers and
customers
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Page 23 of 46
Being professional when accepting new accounts and especially larger ones
Checking out each customer thoroughly before the firm offers credit Use
credit agencies bank references industry sources etc
Establishing credit limits for each customer and sticking to them
Continuously reviewing these limits when it suspects tough times are coming
or if operating in a volatile sector
Keeping very close to the firms larger customers
Invoicing promptly and clearly
Considering charging penalties on overdue accounts
Considering accepting credit debit cards as a payment option
Monitoring its debtor balances and ageing schedules and dont let any debts
get too large or too old
Debtor management includes both pre-sale and debt collection strategies
Pre-sale strategies include
Offering cash discounts for early payment andor imposing penalties for late
payment
Agreeing payment terms in advance
Requiring cash before delivery
Setting credit limits
ning credit Setting criteria for obtai
Billing as early as possible
rogress payments
ost-sale strategies include
for collecting the debt upon the center that made the sale
Requiring deposits andor p
P
Placing the responsibility
Identifying long overdue balances and doubtful debts by regular analytical reviews
Having an established procedure for late collections such as
A reminder
A letter
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Page 24 of 46
ion of further credit Cancellat
Telephone calls
n agency Use of a collectio
he firm should recognize that the longer someone owes firm the greater the chance
Legal action
T
it will never get paid If the average age of debtors is getting longer or is already very
long it may need to look for the following possible defects
Weak credit judgment
res Poor collection procedu
ms Lax enforcement of credit ter
Slow issue of invoices or statements
Errors in invoices or statements
Customer dissatisfaction
Debtors due over 90 days (unless within agreed credit terms) should generally
demand immediate attention For example warning signs of a future bad debt ndash
Longer credit terms taken with approval particularly for smaller orders
Use of post-dated checks by debtors who normally settle within agreed terms
Evidence of customers switching to additional suppliers for the same goods
New customers who are reluctant to give credit references
Cre G
Receiving part payments from debtors
dit ranting to Marginal Accounts
Traditional Approach
In the traditional approach to the credit granting decision it is the credit analysts job
rmation that has been collected and reach a judgment
regarding the applicants creditworthiness One traditional way of organizing this
to synthesize all the info
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
information is by characterizing the applicant along five dimensions These
dimensions are called the Five Cs of credit ndash
Capital
Character
Collateral
and Capacity
Conditions
Net Present Value (NPV) Approach
Once a firm has assessed the creditworthiness of a customer it has to decide whether
r not credit should be granted The firm should use the NPV rule to make the
ld be granted
Figure
o
decision If NPV is positive credit shou
Credit Granting Decision
Credit Granting Decision
he act of collecting money is one which most people dislike for many reasons and
therefore put on the long f selves there is something
ore urgent or important that demands their attention now There is nothing more
T
inger because they convince them
m
important than getting paid for firms product or service A customer who does not
Page 25 of 46
Grand Credit
Payment received Payment not received
Benefit of present value of future net cash flow
Cost of present value ment of lost invest
Net Payoff PV of benefit-cost
No Credit
No Payoff
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
pay is not a customer Here are a few ideas that may help the firm in collecting
money from debtors
Firm should develop appropriate procedures for handling late payments
It should track and pursue late payers
It might get external help if its own efforts fail
or money its firms and it is entitled Company shouldnt feel guilty asking f
to it
ction
Firm must make that call now And it should keep asking until it gets some
satisfa
lessens the problem
In difficult circumstances take what the firm can now and agree terms for the
remainder It
paying
When asking for money be hard on the issue - but soft on the person It shouldnt
give the debtor any excuses for not
534 BLE (CREDITORS)
ices for goods or services have
een paid Organizations often regard the
not
to delay all payments until the latest possible date Regular weekly or
The firm make it its objective is to get the money - not to score points or get
even
MANAGING ACCOUNTS PAYA
Creditors (Accounts Payable) are suppliers whose invo
been processed but who have not yet b
amount owing to creditors as a source of free credit However creditor
administration systems are expensive and time-consuming to run The over-riding
concern in this area should be to minimize costs with simple procedures
While it is unnecessary to pay accounts before they fall due it is usually
worthwhile
Page 26 of 46
fortnightly payment of all due accounts is the simplest technique for creditor
management
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Electronic payments (direct credits) are cheaper than check payments considering
that transaction fees and overheads more than balance the advantage of delayed
presentation Some suppliers are reluctant to receive payments by this method but in
view of the substantial cost advantage (and the advantages to the suppliers
themselves) departments may wish to encourage suppliers to accept this option
However electronic payments are likely to be used in conjunction with rather than
as a replacement for check payments
Applying Best Practices in Managing Accounts Payable
f course simply deferring payments to suppliers could have adverse consequences
O
that more than offset the benefits of this additional cash flow Therefore it is
important to develop a holistic approach The firm should consider the following
best practices for payables management
Managing payment dates and terms to maximize cash flow ndash
y reporting on
receivable and
id penalty charges and taking advantage of
wer vendors and negotiate for more
to buying consortia with others even
voices for
payment based on receipt of goods or receipt of invoice whichever
comes later
Calculating and setting performance targets Regularl
AP performance measures such as days in payables
Coordinating the AP processes with accounts
inventory management to ensure that the company is collecting more
cash than it is paying out
Paying bills on time to avo
prompt-payment discounts where the discounts exceed the companyrsquos
cost of working capital
Consolidating purchases with fe
favorable payment terms
Considering entering in
Page 27 of 46
competitors to obtain favorable supplier pricing and terms
Unless contract terms specify otherwise setting up in
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Page 28 of 46
Em
process
-time payments with Electronic Funds Transfer (EFT)
uraging vendors to utilize electronic invoice presentment
a
ndancies and more
ploying technology to automate the accounts payable transaction
es ndash
Making just-in
Using an electronic invoice-matching application
Enco
For companies with multiple locations or business units employing
shared service approach for AP to eliminate redu
quickly implement process improvements
Mainta
vendor
Communicating accounts payable requirements to suppliers at the
m key suppliers
for suggestions on how to improve the
Efficient a
and making th rsquos cash is just good business
ining open communications and building strong relationships with
s to access valuable trade credit ndash
beginning of transactions
Requesting summary invoicing fro
Requiring suppliers to send invoices directly to accounts payable
Asking tier-one suppliers
payment process
nd effective management of accounts payable helps improve cash flow ndash
e most of company
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
6 OVERVIEW OF VIRGIN GROUP
Virgin - one of the most respected brands in Britain - is now becoming the first global
brand name of the 21st century Virgin is involved in planes trains finance soft
drinks music mobile phones holidays cars wines publishing bridal wear - the lot
What tie all these businesses together are the values of its brand and the attitude of its
people Virgin has created over 200 companies worldwide employing over 25000
people Its total revenues around the world in 2002 exceeded pound4 billion (US $72
billion)
In 1970 Richard Branson founded Virgin as a mail order record retailer and not
long after he opened a record shop in Oxford Street London During 1972 a
recording studio was built in Oxfordshire and the first Virgin artist Mike Oldfield
recorded Tubular Bells which was released in 1973
This album went on to sell over 5 million copies Since then many household names
including Belinda Carlisle Genesis Phil Collins Janet Jackson and The Rolling
Stones have helped to make Virgin Music one of the top six record companies in the
world The equity of Virgin Music Group - record labels music publishing and
recording studios was sold to THORN EMI in 1992 in a US$1billion deal
Page 29 of 46
The Virgin Group has now expanded into international music Mega stores air
travel mobile financial retail music internet drinks rail hotels and leisure with
around 200 companies in over 30 countries
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
In Virgins customers eyes Virgin stands for value for money quality innovation
fun and a sense of competitive challenge It delivers a quality service by empowering
its employees and facilitates and monitors customer feedback to continually improve
the customers experience through innovation
When they start a new venture Virgin bases it on hard research and analysis
Typically they review the industry and put themselves in the customers shoes to see
what could make it better Virgin asks fundamental questions
Is this an opportunity for restructuring a market and creating competitive
advantage What are the competitors doing
Is the customer confused or badly served
Is this an opportunity for building the Virgin brand
Can we add value
Will it interact with its other businesses
Is there an appropriate trade-off between risk and reward
Page 30 of 46
Virgin is also able to draw on talented people from throughout the group New
ventures are often steered by people seconded from other parts of Virgin who bring
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
with them the trademark management style skills and experience Virgin frequently
creates partnerships with others to combine skills knowledge and market presence
and so on Contrary to what some people may think their constantly expanding and
eclectic empire is neither random nor reckless Each successive venture demonstrates
its skill in picking the right market and the right opportunity
7 OVERVIEW OF VIRGIN SOFT DRINKS
The Virgin Drinks Group first launched as the Virgin Cola Company in 1994 with
Virgin Cola in the UK Since then the company has ventured across the carbonated
soft drinks arena and beyond into energy drinks tea and flavored Colas This
expansion has lead to the evolution of the Virgin Drinks Company a company
whose aim is to put the excitement back into the world of soft drinks It launched in
Bangladesh in 1999 Virgin Soft Drinks is monitored by Global Beverage Co Ltd in
Bangladesh
Brief history of Virgin Drinks is given below
Page 31 of 46
1994 November Virgin Cola launched in the UK
1996 March Virgin Cola launched in France
1998 June Virgin Cola launched in Belgium
April Virgin Cola launched in the French West Indies
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
August Virgin Cola launched in Switzerland
1999 March Virgin Colours launched in Italy
March Virgin Cola launched in Japan
July Virgin Colours launched in South Africa
December Virgin Colours launched in Bangladesh
2001 January Sweden launched Virgin Colours
November Singapore launched Virgin Colours
2002 February Croatia launched Virgin Colours
June Russia launched Virgin Colours
June Tunisia launched Virgin Colours
2003 May Israel launched Virgin Colours
8 FINDINGS OF WORKING CAPITAL MANAGEMENT MAINTAINED BY
VIRGIN SOFT DRINKS IN BANGLADESH
81 CASH MANAGEMENT
811 Holding Cash and Marketable Securities
Although there are many good reasons why firm hold cash and marketable
securities Virgin Drinks holds cash and marketable securities for two reasons ndash
i) Cash for transactions
ii) Cash as hedges
This indicates that the firm does not hold cash and marketable securities for some
important reasons such as ndash
i) Near cash assets as hedges
Page 32 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
ii) Temporary investment and compensating balances
Virgin Soft Drinks does not invest in money market securities such as Treasury bill
commercial paper certificate of deposits bankerrsquos acceptance and repurchase
agreement This firm deposits its money in bank as currant AC or fixed AC They
say that they do not have enough money to invest in money market instrument
They also say that if they have enough money they will invest it in money market
short term securities We know that near cash interest earning assets can be
substituted for cash when motivation for holding these assets is the hedging of cash
flow uncertainties or is the temporary investment of surplus funds In this point
Virgins position is not good as there is no significant hedging against uncertainty of
cash
812 Floatation and Check Clearing
Virgin is very smart in handling the problem of transit time for checks Here mail
float takes 2 to 3 days at firm takes 025 day and clearing float takes 1-3 days Virgin
uses most of the strategies available for reducing the delay in receiving funds It
(Virgin) has linked Islami Bank which posses an accelerated clearing facility It uses
electronic collection process which ensures faster collection and its at the firm check
processing is satisfactory But Virgin does not use lockbox The reason behind this is
that it is not cost-effective for Virgin to set lockboxes At this point we can say that
Virgins check clearing mechanism is much good
813 Cash Concentration and Disbursement Management
Page 33 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks takes the matter of cash concentration very seriously They use all
the available cash concentration mechanism Virgin is a firm with small deposits
spread over a substantial number of banks and this is why the firm tends to use
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
depository transfer checks extensively If is less costly Virgin also uses automated
clearing house and wire transfer To Virgin wire transfer seems too costly
Like other firm Virgin tries to retain the cash for as long as possible But Virgin
always performs it in an ethical manner Virgin does not try to defeat the receiving
firmrsquos attempts to reduce the float on incoming checks It does not take any strategy
for increasing mail float at firm float and clearing float on its outgoing checks To
Virgin it is deemed to be unethical It thinks that maximization of disbursement float
will not go unnoticed by sophisticated creditors for very long When it is noticed it
will negatively affect relations with these creditors reducing the firmrsquos bargaining
power with them This may ultimately cost Virgin dearly when future prices and
delivery schedules for goods and services purchased from trade creditors are
negotiated Virgin follows ldquoZero-Balance Accountsrdquo methods for managing
disbursement It thinks that in this method the coordination of funds inflows to
disbursement banks with the presentation of checks does not work to the detriment
of creditors since the firmrsquos checks to them are honored as presented and this strategy
does not affect float significantly Controlled disbursing method is less attractive to
Virgin because zero-balance system is already feasible
814 Cash Forecasting
Cash Forecasting and Its Types
Page 34 of 46
Virgin forecasts the future cash inflows and outflows To Virgin cash forecast is an
important part of the firmrsquos cash control system and is one of the forecasts that are
part of the Virginrsquos financial plan Virgin forecasts cash on monthly basis and on
yearly basis Virgin does not forecast on daily basis assuming that the temporary
shortage of funds within these periods can be covered without value cost eg
advance receipts from customers Virginrsquos cash forecasting system involves a
combination of distribution and scheduling The receipts and disbursements
approach of cash forecasting is used in virgin This method is used because it
minutely traces the movement of cash and very close control of cash is possible
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Virgin does not use adjusted net income approach on two grounds First it does not
permit the tracing of the individual types of cash inflows and outflows for any given
period which is often useful information for virgin Second it is not simple to use
Items to be Forecast
Virgin does not forecast all the items It forecasts only major items eg accounts
receivable notes receivable payroll cash purchases of raw materials In this regard
virgin trade off between cost and benefit
Methods of Financial Forecasting
Virgin forecasts the future level of financial variable such as cash level asset level or
liability level We know in short term forecasts many things will result from plans
and events that are already in place (contracts capital budgets long-range financing
plans and so forth) But in the long run most things can vary and are dependent on
outside influences such as the firmrsquos long-term growth rate Since Virginrsquos cash
forecasting deals mostly with near future many of the items on the cash forecasts are
estimated by some variation of the spot method and remaining estimates are mostly
on a ldquoproportion of another accountrdquo basis with this ldquoother accountrdquo often being a
particular periodrsquos sales Virgin uses the other two methods less frequently
Using Cash Forecast
Virgin forecasts cash for meeting general objectives (ie to know the available funds
for investment and need financing) and for meeting some special objectives (eg to
know whether the firm will fulfill its out of debt requirement) But it is matter to note
that Virgin does not make any short term investment of its surplus cash but only keep
this surplus in Bank Account
Page 35 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Sources of Uncertainty in Cash Forecasting and Hedging Uncertainties
Virgin faces uncertainty in cash forecasting mainly from two sources These are ndash
sales and production cost In peak season (hot season like autumn summer) sales
increases but in dull season (eg in winter) sales decreases drastically Production
cost may be increased because of increase of price of sugar chemicals aluminum
can Virgin follows two methods for hedging cash balance uncertainties These are ndash
i) Holding a stock of extra cash and
ii) Extra borrowing capacity
815 Modes for the Management of Cash and Temporary Investments
Virgin does not follow any of these methods wholly Virgin receives cash
continuously and pays salary at steady rate and pays continuously for other
expenses So it neither follows Baumol model nor Beranek model It has no upper
control limit lower control limit return point in case cash management So it neither
follows Miller-Orr model nor Stone model
In Summary
Page 36 of 46
Standard Compliance by Virgin Soft Drinks
Generally all firms hold cash and
marketable securities
Virgin holds only cash
Firms hold cash and marketable
securities for some reasons like
bull Cash for transactions
bull Cash and near-cash assets as
hedges
bull Temporary investments
bull Compensating balances
Virgin holds cash only for
two reasons ndash
bull Cash for transactions
bull Cash as hedges
Available money market instruments Virgin does not invest in any such
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
(short term securities) are ndash
Treasury Bills
Commercial Paper
Certificates of Deposit
Bankerrsquos Acceptance
Repurch menase Agree ts
instruments They only keep cash in
Bank Account
Mail Float
(1 to 5 days)
At Firm
Float
(025 to 1
day)
Clearing
Float
(0 to
2 days)
Mail Float
(2 to 3 days)
At firm
Float
(025
day)
Clearing
Float
(1 to 3
days)
Figure Transit time for a typical check Figure Transit time for a check for
Virgin
Strategies that firms can use to reduce
the delay in receiving funds are ndash
Selecting of Banks with
accelerated clearing capabilities
of check processing Acceleration
at the firm
ectronic collection Use of el
procedures
Use of lockboxes
Virgin follows the first three strategies
but does not use lockboxes
Available cash concentration
mechanisms are ndash
Depository transfer check
ouse Automated Clearing H
(ACH) electronic transfer)
Wire transfer
Virgin uses all these mechanisms of
cash concentration
Available sets of techniques for cash
disbursement management are ndash
ement of disbursement
Page 37 of 46
Manag
float
Virgin uses zero-balance accounts
technique
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Zero-Balance Accounts
Controlled disbursing
Firms may make cash flow forecasts
over periods of various lengths yearly
flows quarterly flows monthly flows
weekly flows or even daily flows
Virgin forecasts cash on yearly basis and
monthly basis
Cash forecasting system may involve ndash
Distribution
Scheduling
Virginrsquos cash forecasting system
involves a combination of distribution
and scheduling
Two common approaches to cash flow
in generating the cash forecast
and disbursement Receipts
approach
Adjusted net income approach
Virgin uses the receipts and
disbursement approach
There are many items to forecast Virgin forecasts only major items like
AR payroll etc
Four common approach to forecasting
fina i ndash nc al variables are
Spot method
Proportion to another account
Compounded growth
Multiple dependencies
Virgin uses spot method for forecasting
cash It uses proportion to another
account method for other variables and
remaining two methods are frequently
used
Sources of uncertainty in cash
forecasting are ndash
Sales uncertainty
Collection rate uncertainty
Production cost uncertainty
Capital outflow uncertainty
Virgin faces uncertainty mainly from
sales and production cost
Methods for hedging cash balance
unc a
Page 38 of 46
ert inties are ndash
i) Holding a stock of extra cash
Virgin two available methods for
hedging cash balance uncertainties
Th ese are ndash
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
ii) stock of near-cash Holding a
assets
iii) Extra borrowing capacity
iv) ary surpluses in Investing tempor
near-cash assets
i) Holding a stock of extra cash
ii) Extra borrowing capacity
(advance receipt from
customers)
Models for the management of cash and
temporary investments are ndash Baumol
model Beranek model Miller-Orr
model and Stone model
Virgin does not follow any method
wholly but a combination of Baumol
model and Beranek model is occurred
82 INVENTORY MANAGEMENT
21 Certainty Approach
isnt used in
irgin because it thinks it is not possible to implement in Bangladesh
d time is one to three days It
oes not use ABC system of inventory management
8
Main item of inventory of Virgin is Can pet chip sugar label chemical artificial
sweet etc Virgin maintains a minimum level of inventory but it does not have to face
problems because inventory is managed efficiently just-in-time (JIT)
V
Virgin maintains buffer stock because of the shortage of work-in-process (WIP)
inventory Its production process may also be hampered Thats why it maintains
safety stock to avoid stock out cost In case of imported goods normal lead time is
about one month and within the country normal lea
d
Page 39 of 46
Inventory Model
In reality Virgin does not use any of models of EOQ ordering and holding strategy
and safety stock strategy They maintain inventory based on their prior experience
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
822 Uncertainty Approach
Virgin does not use any model for handling inventory uncertainty It says that such
decision depends on business cycle and market situation Long before Eid festival
they bought large amount of sugar because of price increase on the occasion of Eid
In summary
Standard Compliance by Virgin Soft Drinks
Firms maintain inventory to guard
against several problems
Virgin maintains a minimum level of
inventory which is managed efficiently
Some firms use JIT to avoid inventory
cost
JIT is not used by Virgin as it thinks it is
impossible to implement in Bangladesh
Firms maintain buffer stock Virgin maintains buffer stock too
Firms maintain safety stock to avoid
shortage cost
Virgin also maintains safety stock
Firms use ABC system to monitor
inventory
Virgin doesnt use ABC system
EOQ model is an appropriate method
for measuring quantity that has to be
ordered per order
Virgin does not use EOQ model rather
makes order based on experience and
market demand
83 MANAGING ACCOUNTS RECEIVABLE (DEBTORS)
831 Terms of Sale Decision
Page 40 of 46
Virgin offers the term 210 net 30 enables the customers to deduct 2 percent from the
face value of the bill when paying within the first 10 days but if the discount is not
taken the customer must remit the full amount within 30 days But Virgin does not
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
offer the same terms of sale to all customers For prime customers it offers special
terms of sale In setting an appropriate term of sale it costs and benefits regarding
this are compared It uses the standard approach of terms of sale decision as it is
simple to use
832 Credit Granting Decisions
In case of Virgin the Capital and Character of Five Cs get more importance
Although there are many problems with the traditional approach Virgin uses it
because of its simplicity Virgin does not use Net Present Value (NPV) method in
credit granting decision It thinks that NPV is an appropriate method and should be
used next time It does not face any severe problem because of bad debts The reason
is that notes receivable is used when credit is granted
833 Monitoring Accounts Receivable
Virgin monitors its accounts receivable Virgin believes that in any case both positive
and negative durations in accounts signal differences from the results that
management believe to be the most advantageous for the firm
Tools for Monitoring Accounts Receivable
Page 41 of 46
For monitoring accounts receivable there are several tools such as aging schedule
the ratios of receivable outstanding to original sales customers payment proportion
and sales weighted DSO (Days Sales Outstanding) For monitoring accounts
receivable Virgin uses aging schedule fractions and traditional DSO statistics
because of their simplicity in use Although payment proportions ratios of
receivables outstanding and sales weighted DSO methods are free from inherent bias
None of these is used because all these are complex to maintain
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
In summary
Page 42 of 46
Standard Compliance by Virgin Soft Drinks
Generals terms of sale is 210 net 30 Normally Virgin also use general terms
of sale ie 210 net 30
Firms do not offer the same terms of
sale to all customers
Yes For prime customers Virgin offers
special terms of sale
Approaches of terms of sale decisions
are ndash
bull Standard approach
bull Multi period approach
Virgin uses standard approach of terms
of sale decision as it is simple to use and
understand
Source of credit information are ndash
Sellers prior experience with the
customer
Credit agency ratings and
reports
Personal contact with the
applicants bank and other
creditors
Analysis of applicants financial
statements
Customer visit
Main source of credit information to
Virgin is its prior experience with the
customer All other sources are not cost-
effective for Virgin
Approaches of credit granting to
marginal accounts are ndash
Traditional approach
Net Present Value (NPV)
approach
It uses traditional approach still now but
thinks that NPV should be used for the
next periods
Firms monitor accounts receivable
because deviations from the expected
levels of turnover and of bad debt can
Virgin also monitors its accounts
receivable
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
signal several different problems
Different tools for monitoring accounts
receivable are ndash
Aging schedule
Ratios of receivables
outstanding to original sales
Customers payment
proportions
Sales-weighted DSO
For monitoring accounts receivable
Virgin uses aging schedule and
traditional sales outstanding statistics
84 MANAGING ACCOUNTS PAYABLE (CREDITORS)
Virgin has almost accounts payable of Tk 8000000 But most of its liabilities are to
the banks rather than suppliers But we dont have any clear information about
Virgins accounts payable
9 RECOMMENDATION
Virgin should invest its surplus cash in short term marketable securities
because it is suitable hedging against cash uncertainties and will also give
some returns (interest income)
Virgin should publish its own annual report which will satisfy information
needs of stakeholders and also increase the credibility of information provided
by Virgin
Page 43 of 46
Virgin should use multi period approach in terms of sale decision because
standard approach which is already exists in Virgin has some inherent
problems
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
It should stop using traditional approach from now It should use NPV
method in credit granting to marginal accounts
In monitoring accounts receivable Virgin should use sales-weighted DSO
method because it has least limitation compared to the others
It should be more flexible in granting credit which will ultimately increase its
sales
To get the appropriate number of quantity to be ordered per order it should
use DSO model
It should be ABC system for proper monitoring of inventory
10 CONCLUSION
The use of other peoples money in business is usually an expensive resource Before
looking outside for finance a firm should examine its own working capital cycle to
make sure that every rand of its own internal funds is being fully utilized Good
management of working capital is part of good financial management Effective use
of working capital will contribute to the operational efficiency of the whole
organization optimum use will help to generate maximum returns Furthermore
working capital management is not an end in itself It is an integral part of the firms
overall management The needs of efficient working capital management must be
considered in relation to other aspects of the Virgins financial and non-financial
performance Thats why when planning the development of a business it is critical
that the impact of working capital be fully assessed
Page 44 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
BIBLIOGRAPHY
Scherr FC (1989) International Edition Prentice-Hall International Inc Modern
Working Capital Management Text and Cases
Hussain Riaz (2002) Working Capital Management
Robertson Lonnie (July 1998) Inventory Management
httpwwwasashoporg visited on March 13 2006
The Art of Cash Management
httpwwwinccom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management
httpwwwstudyfinancecom visited on March 13 2006
White Paper ndash Managing Working Capital
httpwwwplanwareorg visited on March 13 2006
Management of Working Capital
httpwwwbusinesscentralcoza visited on March 13 2006
Cash Management
httpwwwsbagov visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management Objectives
httpwpsprenhallcom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management
Page 45 of 46
httpwwwadvancemecom visited on March 13 2006
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Business Receivables Financing
httpwwwbbtcom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Finance
http wwwfnbcoza visited on March 13 2006
Tips to manage your working capital
httpsmallbusinessninemsncomau visited on March 13 2006
Inventory Financing
httpwwwfranklincapitalnetworkcom visited on March 13 2006
Accounts Receivable Management
httpwwwfranklincapitalnetworkcom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management
httpwwwtreasurygovtnz visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management
httpwwwtreasurystrategiescom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Works
httpwwwinvestopediacom visited on March 13 2006
Treasury Services
httpwwwjpmorganchasecom visited on March 13 2006
what were about
Page 46 of 46
httpwwwvirgincom visited on March 13 2006
Annexure
Annexure
Interview with YASEER RIZVI
Mr Yaseer Rizvi the DMD of Global Beverage Co Ltd obtained his MBA degree
from a reputed university He had been the Director of Ocean Container Ltd before
joining in Global Beverage Co Ltd He possesses a nice personality
I interviewed Yaseer Rizvi Excerpts from his interview are as follows ndash
Shah Kamal Sir would you please tell me do you invest in short term marketable securities
Yaseer Rizvi Basically we do not invest our surplus cash in short term marketable
securities like T-Bill commercial paper certificate of deposit etc But we keep our
surplus cash in Bank
Shah Kamal Would you tell me something about transit time for a typical check
Yaseer Rizvi Well in Virgin the transit time for a typical check is ndash
For mail float 2 to 3 days
At firm float 6 hours
Clearing float 1 to 3 days
Shah Kamal Do you maintain any cash concentration mechanism like depository transfer check automated clearing house and wire transfer
i
Annexure
Yaseer Rizvi Our position in this case is very strong as we use all the mechanisms
you mentioned As Virgin is a firm with small deposits spread over a substantial
number of banks so we tend to use depository transfer checks extensively It is less
costly We also use automated clearing house and wire transfer but later is used in a
less extent
Shah Kamal Sir what techniques of disbursement management is used by your firm
Yaseer Rizvi Like other firms Virgin tries to retain the cash for as long as possible
But we always perform it in an ethical manner We do not use management of
disbursement float as it seems unethical We follow Zero-Balance Accounts method
for managing disbursement We do not prefer Controlled Disbursing method since
Zero-Balance system is already practiced in Virgin
Shah Kamal How do you hedge cash balance uncertainties
Yaseer Rizvi Well you may say that we do not invest in short term securities but for
facing cash difficulties we keep our surplus cash in bank
Shah Kamal Sir would you please tell me the general terms of sale of Virgin
Yaseer Rizvi Though it is difficult to maintain a fixed terms of sale our general terms
of sale is 210 n30 But for prime customers we offer special terms of sale
Shah Kamal What are the sources of credit information in case of your firm
Yaseer Rizvi We grant credit on the basis of prior experience with the customers In
case of a new customer personal contact is weighted
Shah Kamal Does your firm consider 5 Cs in granting credit
ii
Annexure
Yaseer Rizvi In case of Virgin Capital and Character get more importance than the
others Mind one thing personal relationship is the main measure in granting credit
Shah Kamal Do you use NPV method in credit granting decisions
Yaseer Rizvi We do not use NPV method But we think that NPV is a suitable
method and we have to use it from the next period
Shah Kamal Sir how do you handle the problem of bad debt
Yaseer Rizvi Well in this case our position is very strong Yet we do not face any
problem because of bad debt Just note that we make more than 80 of sales in cash
and we monitor accounts receivable very carefully
Shah Kamal What level of inventory is maintained by Virgin
Yaseer Rizvi We maintain a minimum level of inventory but do not have to face
stock out problems because inventory is managed efficiently
Shah Kamal What is the normal lead time
Yaseer Rizvi In case of imported goods normal lead time is about 1 month and when
we purchase raw materials from inside the country lead time is 1 to 3 days
Shah Kamal What method do you use for managing inventory
Yaseer Rizvi We do not use any method particularly rather inventory decision
depends on business cycle and market situation Long before the Eid festival we
bought large amount of sugar because price of sugar was increased on the occasion
of Eid
iii
Annexure
Shah Kamal What are the main items of inventory of your firm
Yaseer Rizvi Well these are ndash aluminum can pet chip sugar label chemical and
artificial sweet
Shah Kamal What are the uncertainties in maintaining appropriate level of stock
Yaseer Rizvi These are ndash
bull Increase in price of raw materials
bull Sales uncertainty
bull Market trends etc
Shah Kamal Thank you for your kind cooperation
Yaseer Rizvi Most Welcome
iv
Global Beverage Company Limited
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Page 19 of 46
Being prepared to meet these needs when they occur by keeping good
relationships with bankers and other creditors
532 INVENTORY MANAGEMENT
Inventory management is necessary for owners who want to maintain a stocking
service for quick turnaround to help ensure total customer satisfaction The fill rate
of an item on a managed inventory list must be maintained to avoid shortages of
frequently used items Even when utilizing an inventory management system
occasional shortages will still occur Inventories are lists of stocks-raw materials
work in progress or finished goods-waiting to be consumed in production or to be
sold The total balance of inventory is the sum of the value of each individual stock
line
Basically firms hold stocks for the following reasons
To act as a buffer in times of unusually high demand
To ensure continuity of production
Avoid high costs of emergency orders
To take advantage of quantity discounts by ordering more at a time
To reduce ordering costs by ordering more items on fewer
As part of the production process eg maturing whisky or keeping oil in
pipelines
Seasonality of demand (eg firework) or supplies
Suppliers insist on minimum order quantities
The key issue for a business is to identify the fast and slow stock movers with the
objectives of establishing optimum stock levels for each category and thereby
minimize the cash tied up in stocks Factors to be considered when determining
optimum stock levels include
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Page 20 of 46
What are the projected sales of each product
How widely available are raw materials components etc
How long does it take for delivery by suppliers
Can the firm remove slow movers from its product range without
compromising best sellers
Inventory management is an important aspect of working capital management
because inventories themselves do not earn any revenue Holding either too little or
too much inventory incurs costs
Costs of carrying too much inventory are
Opportunity cost of foregone interest
Warehousing costs
Damage and pilferage
Obsolescence
Insurance
Costs of carrying too little inventory are
Stock out costs
Lost sales
Delayed service
Ordering costs
Freight
on Order administrati
nts
Loss of quantity discou
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Carrying costs can be minimized by making frequent small orders but this increase
ordering costs and the risk of stock outs Risk of stock-outs can be reduced by
carrying safety stocks (at a cost) and re-ordering ahead of time
The best ordering strategy requires balancing the various cost factors to ensure the
firm incurs minimum inventory costs The optimum inventory position is known as
the Economic Reorder Quantity (ERQ)
Nowadays many large manufacturers operate on a just-in-time (JIT) basis whereby
all the components to be assembled on a particular today arrive at the factory early
that morning no earlier - no later This helps to minimize manufacturing costs as JIT
stocks take up little space minimize stock-holding and virtually eliminate the risks of
obsolete or damaged stock Because JIT manufacturers hold stock for a very short
time they are able to conserve substantial cash JIT is a good model to strive for as it
embraces all the principles of prudent stock management For better stock control
firm may try the following
Review the effectiveness of existing purchasing and inventory systems
Know the stock turn for all major items of inventory
Apply tight controls to the significant few items and simplify controls for the
trivial many
Sell off outdated or slow moving merchandise - it gets more difficult to sell the
longer the firm keeps it
Consider having part of its product outsourced to another manufacturer rather
than make it itself
Review its security procedures to ensure that no stock is going out the back
door
Higher than necessary stock levels tie up cash and cost more in insurance
accommodation costs and interest charges
Page 21 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
However it is important to keep an overall perspective It is not cost-effective to
closely manage a large number of low value inventory lines nor is it necessary A
usual feature of inventories is that a small number of high value lines account for a
large proportion of inventory value The 8020 rule (PARETO) predicts that 80
of the total value of inventory is represented by only 20 of the number of inventory
items Those high value lines need reasonably close management The remaining
80 of inventory lines can be managed using broad-brush strategies
533 MANAGING ACCOUNTS RECEIVABLE (DEBTORS)
Cash flow can be significantly enhanced if the amounts owing to a business are
collected faster Every business needs to know who owes them money how much is
owed how long it is owing for what it is owed
Debtors (Accounts Receivable) are customers who have not yet made payment for
goods or services which the department has provided The objective of debtor
management is to minimize the time-lapse between completion of sales and receipt
of payment The costs of having debtors are
Opportunity costs (cash is not available for other purposes)
Bad debts
If firm doesnt manage debtors they will begin to manage business as the firm will gradually
lose control due to reduced cash flow and of course it could experience an increased
incidence of bad debt The following measures will help manage debtors
Having the right mental attitude to the control of credit and make sure that it
gets the priority it deserves
Establishing clear credit practices as a matter of company policy
Page 22 of 46
Making sure that these practices are clearly understood by staff suppliers and
customers
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Page 23 of 46
Being professional when accepting new accounts and especially larger ones
Checking out each customer thoroughly before the firm offers credit Use
credit agencies bank references industry sources etc
Establishing credit limits for each customer and sticking to them
Continuously reviewing these limits when it suspects tough times are coming
or if operating in a volatile sector
Keeping very close to the firms larger customers
Invoicing promptly and clearly
Considering charging penalties on overdue accounts
Considering accepting credit debit cards as a payment option
Monitoring its debtor balances and ageing schedules and dont let any debts
get too large or too old
Debtor management includes both pre-sale and debt collection strategies
Pre-sale strategies include
Offering cash discounts for early payment andor imposing penalties for late
payment
Agreeing payment terms in advance
Requiring cash before delivery
Setting credit limits
ning credit Setting criteria for obtai
Billing as early as possible
rogress payments
ost-sale strategies include
for collecting the debt upon the center that made the sale
Requiring deposits andor p
P
Placing the responsibility
Identifying long overdue balances and doubtful debts by regular analytical reviews
Having an established procedure for late collections such as
A reminder
A letter
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Page 24 of 46
ion of further credit Cancellat
Telephone calls
n agency Use of a collectio
he firm should recognize that the longer someone owes firm the greater the chance
Legal action
T
it will never get paid If the average age of debtors is getting longer or is already very
long it may need to look for the following possible defects
Weak credit judgment
res Poor collection procedu
ms Lax enforcement of credit ter
Slow issue of invoices or statements
Errors in invoices or statements
Customer dissatisfaction
Debtors due over 90 days (unless within agreed credit terms) should generally
demand immediate attention For example warning signs of a future bad debt ndash
Longer credit terms taken with approval particularly for smaller orders
Use of post-dated checks by debtors who normally settle within agreed terms
Evidence of customers switching to additional suppliers for the same goods
New customers who are reluctant to give credit references
Cre G
Receiving part payments from debtors
dit ranting to Marginal Accounts
Traditional Approach
In the traditional approach to the credit granting decision it is the credit analysts job
rmation that has been collected and reach a judgment
regarding the applicants creditworthiness One traditional way of organizing this
to synthesize all the info
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
information is by characterizing the applicant along five dimensions These
dimensions are called the Five Cs of credit ndash
Capital
Character
Collateral
and Capacity
Conditions
Net Present Value (NPV) Approach
Once a firm has assessed the creditworthiness of a customer it has to decide whether
r not credit should be granted The firm should use the NPV rule to make the
ld be granted
Figure
o
decision If NPV is positive credit shou
Credit Granting Decision
Credit Granting Decision
he act of collecting money is one which most people dislike for many reasons and
therefore put on the long f selves there is something
ore urgent or important that demands their attention now There is nothing more
T
inger because they convince them
m
important than getting paid for firms product or service A customer who does not
Page 25 of 46
Grand Credit
Payment received Payment not received
Benefit of present value of future net cash flow
Cost of present value ment of lost invest
Net Payoff PV of benefit-cost
No Credit
No Payoff
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
pay is not a customer Here are a few ideas that may help the firm in collecting
money from debtors
Firm should develop appropriate procedures for handling late payments
It should track and pursue late payers
It might get external help if its own efforts fail
or money its firms and it is entitled Company shouldnt feel guilty asking f
to it
ction
Firm must make that call now And it should keep asking until it gets some
satisfa
lessens the problem
In difficult circumstances take what the firm can now and agree terms for the
remainder It
paying
When asking for money be hard on the issue - but soft on the person It shouldnt
give the debtor any excuses for not
534 BLE (CREDITORS)
ices for goods or services have
een paid Organizations often regard the
not
to delay all payments until the latest possible date Regular weekly or
The firm make it its objective is to get the money - not to score points or get
even
MANAGING ACCOUNTS PAYA
Creditors (Accounts Payable) are suppliers whose invo
been processed but who have not yet b
amount owing to creditors as a source of free credit However creditor
administration systems are expensive and time-consuming to run The over-riding
concern in this area should be to minimize costs with simple procedures
While it is unnecessary to pay accounts before they fall due it is usually
worthwhile
Page 26 of 46
fortnightly payment of all due accounts is the simplest technique for creditor
management
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Electronic payments (direct credits) are cheaper than check payments considering
that transaction fees and overheads more than balance the advantage of delayed
presentation Some suppliers are reluctant to receive payments by this method but in
view of the substantial cost advantage (and the advantages to the suppliers
themselves) departments may wish to encourage suppliers to accept this option
However electronic payments are likely to be used in conjunction with rather than
as a replacement for check payments
Applying Best Practices in Managing Accounts Payable
f course simply deferring payments to suppliers could have adverse consequences
O
that more than offset the benefits of this additional cash flow Therefore it is
important to develop a holistic approach The firm should consider the following
best practices for payables management
Managing payment dates and terms to maximize cash flow ndash
y reporting on
receivable and
id penalty charges and taking advantage of
wer vendors and negotiate for more
to buying consortia with others even
voices for
payment based on receipt of goods or receipt of invoice whichever
comes later
Calculating and setting performance targets Regularl
AP performance measures such as days in payables
Coordinating the AP processes with accounts
inventory management to ensure that the company is collecting more
cash than it is paying out
Paying bills on time to avo
prompt-payment discounts where the discounts exceed the companyrsquos
cost of working capital
Consolidating purchases with fe
favorable payment terms
Considering entering in
Page 27 of 46
competitors to obtain favorable supplier pricing and terms
Unless contract terms specify otherwise setting up in
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Page 28 of 46
Em
process
-time payments with Electronic Funds Transfer (EFT)
uraging vendors to utilize electronic invoice presentment
a
ndancies and more
ploying technology to automate the accounts payable transaction
es ndash
Making just-in
Using an electronic invoice-matching application
Enco
For companies with multiple locations or business units employing
shared service approach for AP to eliminate redu
quickly implement process improvements
Mainta
vendor
Communicating accounts payable requirements to suppliers at the
m key suppliers
for suggestions on how to improve the
Efficient a
and making th rsquos cash is just good business
ining open communications and building strong relationships with
s to access valuable trade credit ndash
beginning of transactions
Requesting summary invoicing fro
Requiring suppliers to send invoices directly to accounts payable
Asking tier-one suppliers
payment process
nd effective management of accounts payable helps improve cash flow ndash
e most of company
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
6 OVERVIEW OF VIRGIN GROUP
Virgin - one of the most respected brands in Britain - is now becoming the first global
brand name of the 21st century Virgin is involved in planes trains finance soft
drinks music mobile phones holidays cars wines publishing bridal wear - the lot
What tie all these businesses together are the values of its brand and the attitude of its
people Virgin has created over 200 companies worldwide employing over 25000
people Its total revenues around the world in 2002 exceeded pound4 billion (US $72
billion)
In 1970 Richard Branson founded Virgin as a mail order record retailer and not
long after he opened a record shop in Oxford Street London During 1972 a
recording studio was built in Oxfordshire and the first Virgin artist Mike Oldfield
recorded Tubular Bells which was released in 1973
This album went on to sell over 5 million copies Since then many household names
including Belinda Carlisle Genesis Phil Collins Janet Jackson and The Rolling
Stones have helped to make Virgin Music one of the top six record companies in the
world The equity of Virgin Music Group - record labels music publishing and
recording studios was sold to THORN EMI in 1992 in a US$1billion deal
Page 29 of 46
The Virgin Group has now expanded into international music Mega stores air
travel mobile financial retail music internet drinks rail hotels and leisure with
around 200 companies in over 30 countries
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
In Virgins customers eyes Virgin stands for value for money quality innovation
fun and a sense of competitive challenge It delivers a quality service by empowering
its employees and facilitates and monitors customer feedback to continually improve
the customers experience through innovation
When they start a new venture Virgin bases it on hard research and analysis
Typically they review the industry and put themselves in the customers shoes to see
what could make it better Virgin asks fundamental questions
Is this an opportunity for restructuring a market and creating competitive
advantage What are the competitors doing
Is the customer confused or badly served
Is this an opportunity for building the Virgin brand
Can we add value
Will it interact with its other businesses
Is there an appropriate trade-off between risk and reward
Page 30 of 46
Virgin is also able to draw on talented people from throughout the group New
ventures are often steered by people seconded from other parts of Virgin who bring
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
with them the trademark management style skills and experience Virgin frequently
creates partnerships with others to combine skills knowledge and market presence
and so on Contrary to what some people may think their constantly expanding and
eclectic empire is neither random nor reckless Each successive venture demonstrates
its skill in picking the right market and the right opportunity
7 OVERVIEW OF VIRGIN SOFT DRINKS
The Virgin Drinks Group first launched as the Virgin Cola Company in 1994 with
Virgin Cola in the UK Since then the company has ventured across the carbonated
soft drinks arena and beyond into energy drinks tea and flavored Colas This
expansion has lead to the evolution of the Virgin Drinks Company a company
whose aim is to put the excitement back into the world of soft drinks It launched in
Bangladesh in 1999 Virgin Soft Drinks is monitored by Global Beverage Co Ltd in
Bangladesh
Brief history of Virgin Drinks is given below
Page 31 of 46
1994 November Virgin Cola launched in the UK
1996 March Virgin Cola launched in France
1998 June Virgin Cola launched in Belgium
April Virgin Cola launched in the French West Indies
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
August Virgin Cola launched in Switzerland
1999 March Virgin Colours launched in Italy
March Virgin Cola launched in Japan
July Virgin Colours launched in South Africa
December Virgin Colours launched in Bangladesh
2001 January Sweden launched Virgin Colours
November Singapore launched Virgin Colours
2002 February Croatia launched Virgin Colours
June Russia launched Virgin Colours
June Tunisia launched Virgin Colours
2003 May Israel launched Virgin Colours
8 FINDINGS OF WORKING CAPITAL MANAGEMENT MAINTAINED BY
VIRGIN SOFT DRINKS IN BANGLADESH
81 CASH MANAGEMENT
811 Holding Cash and Marketable Securities
Although there are many good reasons why firm hold cash and marketable
securities Virgin Drinks holds cash and marketable securities for two reasons ndash
i) Cash for transactions
ii) Cash as hedges
This indicates that the firm does not hold cash and marketable securities for some
important reasons such as ndash
i) Near cash assets as hedges
Page 32 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
ii) Temporary investment and compensating balances
Virgin Soft Drinks does not invest in money market securities such as Treasury bill
commercial paper certificate of deposits bankerrsquos acceptance and repurchase
agreement This firm deposits its money in bank as currant AC or fixed AC They
say that they do not have enough money to invest in money market instrument
They also say that if they have enough money they will invest it in money market
short term securities We know that near cash interest earning assets can be
substituted for cash when motivation for holding these assets is the hedging of cash
flow uncertainties or is the temporary investment of surplus funds In this point
Virgins position is not good as there is no significant hedging against uncertainty of
cash
812 Floatation and Check Clearing
Virgin is very smart in handling the problem of transit time for checks Here mail
float takes 2 to 3 days at firm takes 025 day and clearing float takes 1-3 days Virgin
uses most of the strategies available for reducing the delay in receiving funds It
(Virgin) has linked Islami Bank which posses an accelerated clearing facility It uses
electronic collection process which ensures faster collection and its at the firm check
processing is satisfactory But Virgin does not use lockbox The reason behind this is
that it is not cost-effective for Virgin to set lockboxes At this point we can say that
Virgins check clearing mechanism is much good
813 Cash Concentration and Disbursement Management
Page 33 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks takes the matter of cash concentration very seriously They use all
the available cash concentration mechanism Virgin is a firm with small deposits
spread over a substantial number of banks and this is why the firm tends to use
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
depository transfer checks extensively If is less costly Virgin also uses automated
clearing house and wire transfer To Virgin wire transfer seems too costly
Like other firm Virgin tries to retain the cash for as long as possible But Virgin
always performs it in an ethical manner Virgin does not try to defeat the receiving
firmrsquos attempts to reduce the float on incoming checks It does not take any strategy
for increasing mail float at firm float and clearing float on its outgoing checks To
Virgin it is deemed to be unethical It thinks that maximization of disbursement float
will not go unnoticed by sophisticated creditors for very long When it is noticed it
will negatively affect relations with these creditors reducing the firmrsquos bargaining
power with them This may ultimately cost Virgin dearly when future prices and
delivery schedules for goods and services purchased from trade creditors are
negotiated Virgin follows ldquoZero-Balance Accountsrdquo methods for managing
disbursement It thinks that in this method the coordination of funds inflows to
disbursement banks with the presentation of checks does not work to the detriment
of creditors since the firmrsquos checks to them are honored as presented and this strategy
does not affect float significantly Controlled disbursing method is less attractive to
Virgin because zero-balance system is already feasible
814 Cash Forecasting
Cash Forecasting and Its Types
Page 34 of 46
Virgin forecasts the future cash inflows and outflows To Virgin cash forecast is an
important part of the firmrsquos cash control system and is one of the forecasts that are
part of the Virginrsquos financial plan Virgin forecasts cash on monthly basis and on
yearly basis Virgin does not forecast on daily basis assuming that the temporary
shortage of funds within these periods can be covered without value cost eg
advance receipts from customers Virginrsquos cash forecasting system involves a
combination of distribution and scheduling The receipts and disbursements
approach of cash forecasting is used in virgin This method is used because it
minutely traces the movement of cash and very close control of cash is possible
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Virgin does not use adjusted net income approach on two grounds First it does not
permit the tracing of the individual types of cash inflows and outflows for any given
period which is often useful information for virgin Second it is not simple to use
Items to be Forecast
Virgin does not forecast all the items It forecasts only major items eg accounts
receivable notes receivable payroll cash purchases of raw materials In this regard
virgin trade off between cost and benefit
Methods of Financial Forecasting
Virgin forecasts the future level of financial variable such as cash level asset level or
liability level We know in short term forecasts many things will result from plans
and events that are already in place (contracts capital budgets long-range financing
plans and so forth) But in the long run most things can vary and are dependent on
outside influences such as the firmrsquos long-term growth rate Since Virginrsquos cash
forecasting deals mostly with near future many of the items on the cash forecasts are
estimated by some variation of the spot method and remaining estimates are mostly
on a ldquoproportion of another accountrdquo basis with this ldquoother accountrdquo often being a
particular periodrsquos sales Virgin uses the other two methods less frequently
Using Cash Forecast
Virgin forecasts cash for meeting general objectives (ie to know the available funds
for investment and need financing) and for meeting some special objectives (eg to
know whether the firm will fulfill its out of debt requirement) But it is matter to note
that Virgin does not make any short term investment of its surplus cash but only keep
this surplus in Bank Account
Page 35 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Sources of Uncertainty in Cash Forecasting and Hedging Uncertainties
Virgin faces uncertainty in cash forecasting mainly from two sources These are ndash
sales and production cost In peak season (hot season like autumn summer) sales
increases but in dull season (eg in winter) sales decreases drastically Production
cost may be increased because of increase of price of sugar chemicals aluminum
can Virgin follows two methods for hedging cash balance uncertainties These are ndash
i) Holding a stock of extra cash and
ii) Extra borrowing capacity
815 Modes for the Management of Cash and Temporary Investments
Virgin does not follow any of these methods wholly Virgin receives cash
continuously and pays salary at steady rate and pays continuously for other
expenses So it neither follows Baumol model nor Beranek model It has no upper
control limit lower control limit return point in case cash management So it neither
follows Miller-Orr model nor Stone model
In Summary
Page 36 of 46
Standard Compliance by Virgin Soft Drinks
Generally all firms hold cash and
marketable securities
Virgin holds only cash
Firms hold cash and marketable
securities for some reasons like
bull Cash for transactions
bull Cash and near-cash assets as
hedges
bull Temporary investments
bull Compensating balances
Virgin holds cash only for
two reasons ndash
bull Cash for transactions
bull Cash as hedges
Available money market instruments Virgin does not invest in any such
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
(short term securities) are ndash
Treasury Bills
Commercial Paper
Certificates of Deposit
Bankerrsquos Acceptance
Repurch menase Agree ts
instruments They only keep cash in
Bank Account
Mail Float
(1 to 5 days)
At Firm
Float
(025 to 1
day)
Clearing
Float
(0 to
2 days)
Mail Float
(2 to 3 days)
At firm
Float
(025
day)
Clearing
Float
(1 to 3
days)
Figure Transit time for a typical check Figure Transit time for a check for
Virgin
Strategies that firms can use to reduce
the delay in receiving funds are ndash
Selecting of Banks with
accelerated clearing capabilities
of check processing Acceleration
at the firm
ectronic collection Use of el
procedures
Use of lockboxes
Virgin follows the first three strategies
but does not use lockboxes
Available cash concentration
mechanisms are ndash
Depository transfer check
ouse Automated Clearing H
(ACH) electronic transfer)
Wire transfer
Virgin uses all these mechanisms of
cash concentration
Available sets of techniques for cash
disbursement management are ndash
ement of disbursement
Page 37 of 46
Manag
float
Virgin uses zero-balance accounts
technique
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Zero-Balance Accounts
Controlled disbursing
Firms may make cash flow forecasts
over periods of various lengths yearly
flows quarterly flows monthly flows
weekly flows or even daily flows
Virgin forecasts cash on yearly basis and
monthly basis
Cash forecasting system may involve ndash
Distribution
Scheduling
Virginrsquos cash forecasting system
involves a combination of distribution
and scheduling
Two common approaches to cash flow
in generating the cash forecast
and disbursement Receipts
approach
Adjusted net income approach
Virgin uses the receipts and
disbursement approach
There are many items to forecast Virgin forecasts only major items like
AR payroll etc
Four common approach to forecasting
fina i ndash nc al variables are
Spot method
Proportion to another account
Compounded growth
Multiple dependencies
Virgin uses spot method for forecasting
cash It uses proportion to another
account method for other variables and
remaining two methods are frequently
used
Sources of uncertainty in cash
forecasting are ndash
Sales uncertainty
Collection rate uncertainty
Production cost uncertainty
Capital outflow uncertainty
Virgin faces uncertainty mainly from
sales and production cost
Methods for hedging cash balance
unc a
Page 38 of 46
ert inties are ndash
i) Holding a stock of extra cash
Virgin two available methods for
hedging cash balance uncertainties
Th ese are ndash
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
ii) stock of near-cash Holding a
assets
iii) Extra borrowing capacity
iv) ary surpluses in Investing tempor
near-cash assets
i) Holding a stock of extra cash
ii) Extra borrowing capacity
(advance receipt from
customers)
Models for the management of cash and
temporary investments are ndash Baumol
model Beranek model Miller-Orr
model and Stone model
Virgin does not follow any method
wholly but a combination of Baumol
model and Beranek model is occurred
82 INVENTORY MANAGEMENT
21 Certainty Approach
isnt used in
irgin because it thinks it is not possible to implement in Bangladesh
d time is one to three days It
oes not use ABC system of inventory management
8
Main item of inventory of Virgin is Can pet chip sugar label chemical artificial
sweet etc Virgin maintains a minimum level of inventory but it does not have to face
problems because inventory is managed efficiently just-in-time (JIT)
V
Virgin maintains buffer stock because of the shortage of work-in-process (WIP)
inventory Its production process may also be hampered Thats why it maintains
safety stock to avoid stock out cost In case of imported goods normal lead time is
about one month and within the country normal lea
d
Page 39 of 46
Inventory Model
In reality Virgin does not use any of models of EOQ ordering and holding strategy
and safety stock strategy They maintain inventory based on their prior experience
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
822 Uncertainty Approach
Virgin does not use any model for handling inventory uncertainty It says that such
decision depends on business cycle and market situation Long before Eid festival
they bought large amount of sugar because of price increase on the occasion of Eid
In summary
Standard Compliance by Virgin Soft Drinks
Firms maintain inventory to guard
against several problems
Virgin maintains a minimum level of
inventory which is managed efficiently
Some firms use JIT to avoid inventory
cost
JIT is not used by Virgin as it thinks it is
impossible to implement in Bangladesh
Firms maintain buffer stock Virgin maintains buffer stock too
Firms maintain safety stock to avoid
shortage cost
Virgin also maintains safety stock
Firms use ABC system to monitor
inventory
Virgin doesnt use ABC system
EOQ model is an appropriate method
for measuring quantity that has to be
ordered per order
Virgin does not use EOQ model rather
makes order based on experience and
market demand
83 MANAGING ACCOUNTS RECEIVABLE (DEBTORS)
831 Terms of Sale Decision
Page 40 of 46
Virgin offers the term 210 net 30 enables the customers to deduct 2 percent from the
face value of the bill when paying within the first 10 days but if the discount is not
taken the customer must remit the full amount within 30 days But Virgin does not
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
offer the same terms of sale to all customers For prime customers it offers special
terms of sale In setting an appropriate term of sale it costs and benefits regarding
this are compared It uses the standard approach of terms of sale decision as it is
simple to use
832 Credit Granting Decisions
In case of Virgin the Capital and Character of Five Cs get more importance
Although there are many problems with the traditional approach Virgin uses it
because of its simplicity Virgin does not use Net Present Value (NPV) method in
credit granting decision It thinks that NPV is an appropriate method and should be
used next time It does not face any severe problem because of bad debts The reason
is that notes receivable is used when credit is granted
833 Monitoring Accounts Receivable
Virgin monitors its accounts receivable Virgin believes that in any case both positive
and negative durations in accounts signal differences from the results that
management believe to be the most advantageous for the firm
Tools for Monitoring Accounts Receivable
Page 41 of 46
For monitoring accounts receivable there are several tools such as aging schedule
the ratios of receivable outstanding to original sales customers payment proportion
and sales weighted DSO (Days Sales Outstanding) For monitoring accounts
receivable Virgin uses aging schedule fractions and traditional DSO statistics
because of their simplicity in use Although payment proportions ratios of
receivables outstanding and sales weighted DSO methods are free from inherent bias
None of these is used because all these are complex to maintain
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
In summary
Page 42 of 46
Standard Compliance by Virgin Soft Drinks
Generals terms of sale is 210 net 30 Normally Virgin also use general terms
of sale ie 210 net 30
Firms do not offer the same terms of
sale to all customers
Yes For prime customers Virgin offers
special terms of sale
Approaches of terms of sale decisions
are ndash
bull Standard approach
bull Multi period approach
Virgin uses standard approach of terms
of sale decision as it is simple to use and
understand
Source of credit information are ndash
Sellers prior experience with the
customer
Credit agency ratings and
reports
Personal contact with the
applicants bank and other
creditors
Analysis of applicants financial
statements
Customer visit
Main source of credit information to
Virgin is its prior experience with the
customer All other sources are not cost-
effective for Virgin
Approaches of credit granting to
marginal accounts are ndash
Traditional approach
Net Present Value (NPV)
approach
It uses traditional approach still now but
thinks that NPV should be used for the
next periods
Firms monitor accounts receivable
because deviations from the expected
levels of turnover and of bad debt can
Virgin also monitors its accounts
receivable
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
signal several different problems
Different tools for monitoring accounts
receivable are ndash
Aging schedule
Ratios of receivables
outstanding to original sales
Customers payment
proportions
Sales-weighted DSO
For monitoring accounts receivable
Virgin uses aging schedule and
traditional sales outstanding statistics
84 MANAGING ACCOUNTS PAYABLE (CREDITORS)
Virgin has almost accounts payable of Tk 8000000 But most of its liabilities are to
the banks rather than suppliers But we dont have any clear information about
Virgins accounts payable
9 RECOMMENDATION
Virgin should invest its surplus cash in short term marketable securities
because it is suitable hedging against cash uncertainties and will also give
some returns (interest income)
Virgin should publish its own annual report which will satisfy information
needs of stakeholders and also increase the credibility of information provided
by Virgin
Page 43 of 46
Virgin should use multi period approach in terms of sale decision because
standard approach which is already exists in Virgin has some inherent
problems
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
It should stop using traditional approach from now It should use NPV
method in credit granting to marginal accounts
In monitoring accounts receivable Virgin should use sales-weighted DSO
method because it has least limitation compared to the others
It should be more flexible in granting credit which will ultimately increase its
sales
To get the appropriate number of quantity to be ordered per order it should
use DSO model
It should be ABC system for proper monitoring of inventory
10 CONCLUSION
The use of other peoples money in business is usually an expensive resource Before
looking outside for finance a firm should examine its own working capital cycle to
make sure that every rand of its own internal funds is being fully utilized Good
management of working capital is part of good financial management Effective use
of working capital will contribute to the operational efficiency of the whole
organization optimum use will help to generate maximum returns Furthermore
working capital management is not an end in itself It is an integral part of the firms
overall management The needs of efficient working capital management must be
considered in relation to other aspects of the Virgins financial and non-financial
performance Thats why when planning the development of a business it is critical
that the impact of working capital be fully assessed
Page 44 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
BIBLIOGRAPHY
Scherr FC (1989) International Edition Prentice-Hall International Inc Modern
Working Capital Management Text and Cases
Hussain Riaz (2002) Working Capital Management
Robertson Lonnie (July 1998) Inventory Management
httpwwwasashoporg visited on March 13 2006
The Art of Cash Management
httpwwwinccom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management
httpwwwstudyfinancecom visited on March 13 2006
White Paper ndash Managing Working Capital
httpwwwplanwareorg visited on March 13 2006
Management of Working Capital
httpwwwbusinesscentralcoza visited on March 13 2006
Cash Management
httpwwwsbagov visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management Objectives
httpwpsprenhallcom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management
Page 45 of 46
httpwwwadvancemecom visited on March 13 2006
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Business Receivables Financing
httpwwwbbtcom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Finance
http wwwfnbcoza visited on March 13 2006
Tips to manage your working capital
httpsmallbusinessninemsncomau visited on March 13 2006
Inventory Financing
httpwwwfranklincapitalnetworkcom visited on March 13 2006
Accounts Receivable Management
httpwwwfranklincapitalnetworkcom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management
httpwwwtreasurygovtnz visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management
httpwwwtreasurystrategiescom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Works
httpwwwinvestopediacom visited on March 13 2006
Treasury Services
httpwwwjpmorganchasecom visited on March 13 2006
what were about
Page 46 of 46
httpwwwvirgincom visited on March 13 2006
Annexure
Annexure
Interview with YASEER RIZVI
Mr Yaseer Rizvi the DMD of Global Beverage Co Ltd obtained his MBA degree
from a reputed university He had been the Director of Ocean Container Ltd before
joining in Global Beverage Co Ltd He possesses a nice personality
I interviewed Yaseer Rizvi Excerpts from his interview are as follows ndash
Shah Kamal Sir would you please tell me do you invest in short term marketable securities
Yaseer Rizvi Basically we do not invest our surplus cash in short term marketable
securities like T-Bill commercial paper certificate of deposit etc But we keep our
surplus cash in Bank
Shah Kamal Would you tell me something about transit time for a typical check
Yaseer Rizvi Well in Virgin the transit time for a typical check is ndash
For mail float 2 to 3 days
At firm float 6 hours
Clearing float 1 to 3 days
Shah Kamal Do you maintain any cash concentration mechanism like depository transfer check automated clearing house and wire transfer
i
Annexure
Yaseer Rizvi Our position in this case is very strong as we use all the mechanisms
you mentioned As Virgin is a firm with small deposits spread over a substantial
number of banks so we tend to use depository transfer checks extensively It is less
costly We also use automated clearing house and wire transfer but later is used in a
less extent
Shah Kamal Sir what techniques of disbursement management is used by your firm
Yaseer Rizvi Like other firms Virgin tries to retain the cash for as long as possible
But we always perform it in an ethical manner We do not use management of
disbursement float as it seems unethical We follow Zero-Balance Accounts method
for managing disbursement We do not prefer Controlled Disbursing method since
Zero-Balance system is already practiced in Virgin
Shah Kamal How do you hedge cash balance uncertainties
Yaseer Rizvi Well you may say that we do not invest in short term securities but for
facing cash difficulties we keep our surplus cash in bank
Shah Kamal Sir would you please tell me the general terms of sale of Virgin
Yaseer Rizvi Though it is difficult to maintain a fixed terms of sale our general terms
of sale is 210 n30 But for prime customers we offer special terms of sale
Shah Kamal What are the sources of credit information in case of your firm
Yaseer Rizvi We grant credit on the basis of prior experience with the customers In
case of a new customer personal contact is weighted
Shah Kamal Does your firm consider 5 Cs in granting credit
ii
Annexure
Yaseer Rizvi In case of Virgin Capital and Character get more importance than the
others Mind one thing personal relationship is the main measure in granting credit
Shah Kamal Do you use NPV method in credit granting decisions
Yaseer Rizvi We do not use NPV method But we think that NPV is a suitable
method and we have to use it from the next period
Shah Kamal Sir how do you handle the problem of bad debt
Yaseer Rizvi Well in this case our position is very strong Yet we do not face any
problem because of bad debt Just note that we make more than 80 of sales in cash
and we monitor accounts receivable very carefully
Shah Kamal What level of inventory is maintained by Virgin
Yaseer Rizvi We maintain a minimum level of inventory but do not have to face
stock out problems because inventory is managed efficiently
Shah Kamal What is the normal lead time
Yaseer Rizvi In case of imported goods normal lead time is about 1 month and when
we purchase raw materials from inside the country lead time is 1 to 3 days
Shah Kamal What method do you use for managing inventory
Yaseer Rizvi We do not use any method particularly rather inventory decision
depends on business cycle and market situation Long before the Eid festival we
bought large amount of sugar because price of sugar was increased on the occasion
of Eid
iii
Annexure
Shah Kamal What are the main items of inventory of your firm
Yaseer Rizvi Well these are ndash aluminum can pet chip sugar label chemical and
artificial sweet
Shah Kamal What are the uncertainties in maintaining appropriate level of stock
Yaseer Rizvi These are ndash
bull Increase in price of raw materials
bull Sales uncertainty
bull Market trends etc
Shah Kamal Thank you for your kind cooperation
Yaseer Rizvi Most Welcome
iv
Global Beverage Company Limited
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Page 20 of 46
What are the projected sales of each product
How widely available are raw materials components etc
How long does it take for delivery by suppliers
Can the firm remove slow movers from its product range without
compromising best sellers
Inventory management is an important aspect of working capital management
because inventories themselves do not earn any revenue Holding either too little or
too much inventory incurs costs
Costs of carrying too much inventory are
Opportunity cost of foregone interest
Warehousing costs
Damage and pilferage
Obsolescence
Insurance
Costs of carrying too little inventory are
Stock out costs
Lost sales
Delayed service
Ordering costs
Freight
on Order administrati
nts
Loss of quantity discou
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Carrying costs can be minimized by making frequent small orders but this increase
ordering costs and the risk of stock outs Risk of stock-outs can be reduced by
carrying safety stocks (at a cost) and re-ordering ahead of time
The best ordering strategy requires balancing the various cost factors to ensure the
firm incurs minimum inventory costs The optimum inventory position is known as
the Economic Reorder Quantity (ERQ)
Nowadays many large manufacturers operate on a just-in-time (JIT) basis whereby
all the components to be assembled on a particular today arrive at the factory early
that morning no earlier - no later This helps to minimize manufacturing costs as JIT
stocks take up little space minimize stock-holding and virtually eliminate the risks of
obsolete or damaged stock Because JIT manufacturers hold stock for a very short
time they are able to conserve substantial cash JIT is a good model to strive for as it
embraces all the principles of prudent stock management For better stock control
firm may try the following
Review the effectiveness of existing purchasing and inventory systems
Know the stock turn for all major items of inventory
Apply tight controls to the significant few items and simplify controls for the
trivial many
Sell off outdated or slow moving merchandise - it gets more difficult to sell the
longer the firm keeps it
Consider having part of its product outsourced to another manufacturer rather
than make it itself
Review its security procedures to ensure that no stock is going out the back
door
Higher than necessary stock levels tie up cash and cost more in insurance
accommodation costs and interest charges
Page 21 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
However it is important to keep an overall perspective It is not cost-effective to
closely manage a large number of low value inventory lines nor is it necessary A
usual feature of inventories is that a small number of high value lines account for a
large proportion of inventory value The 8020 rule (PARETO) predicts that 80
of the total value of inventory is represented by only 20 of the number of inventory
items Those high value lines need reasonably close management The remaining
80 of inventory lines can be managed using broad-brush strategies
533 MANAGING ACCOUNTS RECEIVABLE (DEBTORS)
Cash flow can be significantly enhanced if the amounts owing to a business are
collected faster Every business needs to know who owes them money how much is
owed how long it is owing for what it is owed
Debtors (Accounts Receivable) are customers who have not yet made payment for
goods or services which the department has provided The objective of debtor
management is to minimize the time-lapse between completion of sales and receipt
of payment The costs of having debtors are
Opportunity costs (cash is not available for other purposes)
Bad debts
If firm doesnt manage debtors they will begin to manage business as the firm will gradually
lose control due to reduced cash flow and of course it could experience an increased
incidence of bad debt The following measures will help manage debtors
Having the right mental attitude to the control of credit and make sure that it
gets the priority it deserves
Establishing clear credit practices as a matter of company policy
Page 22 of 46
Making sure that these practices are clearly understood by staff suppliers and
customers
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Page 23 of 46
Being professional when accepting new accounts and especially larger ones
Checking out each customer thoroughly before the firm offers credit Use
credit agencies bank references industry sources etc
Establishing credit limits for each customer and sticking to them
Continuously reviewing these limits when it suspects tough times are coming
or if operating in a volatile sector
Keeping very close to the firms larger customers
Invoicing promptly and clearly
Considering charging penalties on overdue accounts
Considering accepting credit debit cards as a payment option
Monitoring its debtor balances and ageing schedules and dont let any debts
get too large or too old
Debtor management includes both pre-sale and debt collection strategies
Pre-sale strategies include
Offering cash discounts for early payment andor imposing penalties for late
payment
Agreeing payment terms in advance
Requiring cash before delivery
Setting credit limits
ning credit Setting criteria for obtai
Billing as early as possible
rogress payments
ost-sale strategies include
for collecting the debt upon the center that made the sale
Requiring deposits andor p
P
Placing the responsibility
Identifying long overdue balances and doubtful debts by regular analytical reviews
Having an established procedure for late collections such as
A reminder
A letter
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Page 24 of 46
ion of further credit Cancellat
Telephone calls
n agency Use of a collectio
he firm should recognize that the longer someone owes firm the greater the chance
Legal action
T
it will never get paid If the average age of debtors is getting longer or is already very
long it may need to look for the following possible defects
Weak credit judgment
res Poor collection procedu
ms Lax enforcement of credit ter
Slow issue of invoices or statements
Errors in invoices or statements
Customer dissatisfaction
Debtors due over 90 days (unless within agreed credit terms) should generally
demand immediate attention For example warning signs of a future bad debt ndash
Longer credit terms taken with approval particularly for smaller orders
Use of post-dated checks by debtors who normally settle within agreed terms
Evidence of customers switching to additional suppliers for the same goods
New customers who are reluctant to give credit references
Cre G
Receiving part payments from debtors
dit ranting to Marginal Accounts
Traditional Approach
In the traditional approach to the credit granting decision it is the credit analysts job
rmation that has been collected and reach a judgment
regarding the applicants creditworthiness One traditional way of organizing this
to synthesize all the info
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
information is by characterizing the applicant along five dimensions These
dimensions are called the Five Cs of credit ndash
Capital
Character
Collateral
and Capacity
Conditions
Net Present Value (NPV) Approach
Once a firm has assessed the creditworthiness of a customer it has to decide whether
r not credit should be granted The firm should use the NPV rule to make the
ld be granted
Figure
o
decision If NPV is positive credit shou
Credit Granting Decision
Credit Granting Decision
he act of collecting money is one which most people dislike for many reasons and
therefore put on the long f selves there is something
ore urgent or important that demands their attention now There is nothing more
T
inger because they convince them
m
important than getting paid for firms product or service A customer who does not
Page 25 of 46
Grand Credit
Payment received Payment not received
Benefit of present value of future net cash flow
Cost of present value ment of lost invest
Net Payoff PV of benefit-cost
No Credit
No Payoff
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
pay is not a customer Here are a few ideas that may help the firm in collecting
money from debtors
Firm should develop appropriate procedures for handling late payments
It should track and pursue late payers
It might get external help if its own efforts fail
or money its firms and it is entitled Company shouldnt feel guilty asking f
to it
ction
Firm must make that call now And it should keep asking until it gets some
satisfa
lessens the problem
In difficult circumstances take what the firm can now and agree terms for the
remainder It
paying
When asking for money be hard on the issue - but soft on the person It shouldnt
give the debtor any excuses for not
534 BLE (CREDITORS)
ices for goods or services have
een paid Organizations often regard the
not
to delay all payments until the latest possible date Regular weekly or
The firm make it its objective is to get the money - not to score points or get
even
MANAGING ACCOUNTS PAYA
Creditors (Accounts Payable) are suppliers whose invo
been processed but who have not yet b
amount owing to creditors as a source of free credit However creditor
administration systems are expensive and time-consuming to run The over-riding
concern in this area should be to minimize costs with simple procedures
While it is unnecessary to pay accounts before they fall due it is usually
worthwhile
Page 26 of 46
fortnightly payment of all due accounts is the simplest technique for creditor
management
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Electronic payments (direct credits) are cheaper than check payments considering
that transaction fees and overheads more than balance the advantage of delayed
presentation Some suppliers are reluctant to receive payments by this method but in
view of the substantial cost advantage (and the advantages to the suppliers
themselves) departments may wish to encourage suppliers to accept this option
However electronic payments are likely to be used in conjunction with rather than
as a replacement for check payments
Applying Best Practices in Managing Accounts Payable
f course simply deferring payments to suppliers could have adverse consequences
O
that more than offset the benefits of this additional cash flow Therefore it is
important to develop a holistic approach The firm should consider the following
best practices for payables management
Managing payment dates and terms to maximize cash flow ndash
y reporting on
receivable and
id penalty charges and taking advantage of
wer vendors and negotiate for more
to buying consortia with others even
voices for
payment based on receipt of goods or receipt of invoice whichever
comes later
Calculating and setting performance targets Regularl
AP performance measures such as days in payables
Coordinating the AP processes with accounts
inventory management to ensure that the company is collecting more
cash than it is paying out
Paying bills on time to avo
prompt-payment discounts where the discounts exceed the companyrsquos
cost of working capital
Consolidating purchases with fe
favorable payment terms
Considering entering in
Page 27 of 46
competitors to obtain favorable supplier pricing and terms
Unless contract terms specify otherwise setting up in
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Page 28 of 46
Em
process
-time payments with Electronic Funds Transfer (EFT)
uraging vendors to utilize electronic invoice presentment
a
ndancies and more
ploying technology to automate the accounts payable transaction
es ndash
Making just-in
Using an electronic invoice-matching application
Enco
For companies with multiple locations or business units employing
shared service approach for AP to eliminate redu
quickly implement process improvements
Mainta
vendor
Communicating accounts payable requirements to suppliers at the
m key suppliers
for suggestions on how to improve the
Efficient a
and making th rsquos cash is just good business
ining open communications and building strong relationships with
s to access valuable trade credit ndash
beginning of transactions
Requesting summary invoicing fro
Requiring suppliers to send invoices directly to accounts payable
Asking tier-one suppliers
payment process
nd effective management of accounts payable helps improve cash flow ndash
e most of company
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
6 OVERVIEW OF VIRGIN GROUP
Virgin - one of the most respected brands in Britain - is now becoming the first global
brand name of the 21st century Virgin is involved in planes trains finance soft
drinks music mobile phones holidays cars wines publishing bridal wear - the lot
What tie all these businesses together are the values of its brand and the attitude of its
people Virgin has created over 200 companies worldwide employing over 25000
people Its total revenues around the world in 2002 exceeded pound4 billion (US $72
billion)
In 1970 Richard Branson founded Virgin as a mail order record retailer and not
long after he opened a record shop in Oxford Street London During 1972 a
recording studio was built in Oxfordshire and the first Virgin artist Mike Oldfield
recorded Tubular Bells which was released in 1973
This album went on to sell over 5 million copies Since then many household names
including Belinda Carlisle Genesis Phil Collins Janet Jackson and The Rolling
Stones have helped to make Virgin Music one of the top six record companies in the
world The equity of Virgin Music Group - record labels music publishing and
recording studios was sold to THORN EMI in 1992 in a US$1billion deal
Page 29 of 46
The Virgin Group has now expanded into international music Mega stores air
travel mobile financial retail music internet drinks rail hotels and leisure with
around 200 companies in over 30 countries
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
In Virgins customers eyes Virgin stands for value for money quality innovation
fun and a sense of competitive challenge It delivers a quality service by empowering
its employees and facilitates and monitors customer feedback to continually improve
the customers experience through innovation
When they start a new venture Virgin bases it on hard research and analysis
Typically they review the industry and put themselves in the customers shoes to see
what could make it better Virgin asks fundamental questions
Is this an opportunity for restructuring a market and creating competitive
advantage What are the competitors doing
Is the customer confused or badly served
Is this an opportunity for building the Virgin brand
Can we add value
Will it interact with its other businesses
Is there an appropriate trade-off between risk and reward
Page 30 of 46
Virgin is also able to draw on talented people from throughout the group New
ventures are often steered by people seconded from other parts of Virgin who bring
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
with them the trademark management style skills and experience Virgin frequently
creates partnerships with others to combine skills knowledge and market presence
and so on Contrary to what some people may think their constantly expanding and
eclectic empire is neither random nor reckless Each successive venture demonstrates
its skill in picking the right market and the right opportunity
7 OVERVIEW OF VIRGIN SOFT DRINKS
The Virgin Drinks Group first launched as the Virgin Cola Company in 1994 with
Virgin Cola in the UK Since then the company has ventured across the carbonated
soft drinks arena and beyond into energy drinks tea and flavored Colas This
expansion has lead to the evolution of the Virgin Drinks Company a company
whose aim is to put the excitement back into the world of soft drinks It launched in
Bangladesh in 1999 Virgin Soft Drinks is monitored by Global Beverage Co Ltd in
Bangladesh
Brief history of Virgin Drinks is given below
Page 31 of 46
1994 November Virgin Cola launched in the UK
1996 March Virgin Cola launched in France
1998 June Virgin Cola launched in Belgium
April Virgin Cola launched in the French West Indies
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
August Virgin Cola launched in Switzerland
1999 March Virgin Colours launched in Italy
March Virgin Cola launched in Japan
July Virgin Colours launched in South Africa
December Virgin Colours launched in Bangladesh
2001 January Sweden launched Virgin Colours
November Singapore launched Virgin Colours
2002 February Croatia launched Virgin Colours
June Russia launched Virgin Colours
June Tunisia launched Virgin Colours
2003 May Israel launched Virgin Colours
8 FINDINGS OF WORKING CAPITAL MANAGEMENT MAINTAINED BY
VIRGIN SOFT DRINKS IN BANGLADESH
81 CASH MANAGEMENT
811 Holding Cash and Marketable Securities
Although there are many good reasons why firm hold cash and marketable
securities Virgin Drinks holds cash and marketable securities for two reasons ndash
i) Cash for transactions
ii) Cash as hedges
This indicates that the firm does not hold cash and marketable securities for some
important reasons such as ndash
i) Near cash assets as hedges
Page 32 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
ii) Temporary investment and compensating balances
Virgin Soft Drinks does not invest in money market securities such as Treasury bill
commercial paper certificate of deposits bankerrsquos acceptance and repurchase
agreement This firm deposits its money in bank as currant AC or fixed AC They
say that they do not have enough money to invest in money market instrument
They also say that if they have enough money they will invest it in money market
short term securities We know that near cash interest earning assets can be
substituted for cash when motivation for holding these assets is the hedging of cash
flow uncertainties or is the temporary investment of surplus funds In this point
Virgins position is not good as there is no significant hedging against uncertainty of
cash
812 Floatation and Check Clearing
Virgin is very smart in handling the problem of transit time for checks Here mail
float takes 2 to 3 days at firm takes 025 day and clearing float takes 1-3 days Virgin
uses most of the strategies available for reducing the delay in receiving funds It
(Virgin) has linked Islami Bank which posses an accelerated clearing facility It uses
electronic collection process which ensures faster collection and its at the firm check
processing is satisfactory But Virgin does not use lockbox The reason behind this is
that it is not cost-effective for Virgin to set lockboxes At this point we can say that
Virgins check clearing mechanism is much good
813 Cash Concentration and Disbursement Management
Page 33 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks takes the matter of cash concentration very seriously They use all
the available cash concentration mechanism Virgin is a firm with small deposits
spread over a substantial number of banks and this is why the firm tends to use
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
depository transfer checks extensively If is less costly Virgin also uses automated
clearing house and wire transfer To Virgin wire transfer seems too costly
Like other firm Virgin tries to retain the cash for as long as possible But Virgin
always performs it in an ethical manner Virgin does not try to defeat the receiving
firmrsquos attempts to reduce the float on incoming checks It does not take any strategy
for increasing mail float at firm float and clearing float on its outgoing checks To
Virgin it is deemed to be unethical It thinks that maximization of disbursement float
will not go unnoticed by sophisticated creditors for very long When it is noticed it
will negatively affect relations with these creditors reducing the firmrsquos bargaining
power with them This may ultimately cost Virgin dearly when future prices and
delivery schedules for goods and services purchased from trade creditors are
negotiated Virgin follows ldquoZero-Balance Accountsrdquo methods for managing
disbursement It thinks that in this method the coordination of funds inflows to
disbursement banks with the presentation of checks does not work to the detriment
of creditors since the firmrsquos checks to them are honored as presented and this strategy
does not affect float significantly Controlled disbursing method is less attractive to
Virgin because zero-balance system is already feasible
814 Cash Forecasting
Cash Forecasting and Its Types
Page 34 of 46
Virgin forecasts the future cash inflows and outflows To Virgin cash forecast is an
important part of the firmrsquos cash control system and is one of the forecasts that are
part of the Virginrsquos financial plan Virgin forecasts cash on monthly basis and on
yearly basis Virgin does not forecast on daily basis assuming that the temporary
shortage of funds within these periods can be covered without value cost eg
advance receipts from customers Virginrsquos cash forecasting system involves a
combination of distribution and scheduling The receipts and disbursements
approach of cash forecasting is used in virgin This method is used because it
minutely traces the movement of cash and very close control of cash is possible
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Virgin does not use adjusted net income approach on two grounds First it does not
permit the tracing of the individual types of cash inflows and outflows for any given
period which is often useful information for virgin Second it is not simple to use
Items to be Forecast
Virgin does not forecast all the items It forecasts only major items eg accounts
receivable notes receivable payroll cash purchases of raw materials In this regard
virgin trade off between cost and benefit
Methods of Financial Forecasting
Virgin forecasts the future level of financial variable such as cash level asset level or
liability level We know in short term forecasts many things will result from plans
and events that are already in place (contracts capital budgets long-range financing
plans and so forth) But in the long run most things can vary and are dependent on
outside influences such as the firmrsquos long-term growth rate Since Virginrsquos cash
forecasting deals mostly with near future many of the items on the cash forecasts are
estimated by some variation of the spot method and remaining estimates are mostly
on a ldquoproportion of another accountrdquo basis with this ldquoother accountrdquo often being a
particular periodrsquos sales Virgin uses the other two methods less frequently
Using Cash Forecast
Virgin forecasts cash for meeting general objectives (ie to know the available funds
for investment and need financing) and for meeting some special objectives (eg to
know whether the firm will fulfill its out of debt requirement) But it is matter to note
that Virgin does not make any short term investment of its surplus cash but only keep
this surplus in Bank Account
Page 35 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Sources of Uncertainty in Cash Forecasting and Hedging Uncertainties
Virgin faces uncertainty in cash forecasting mainly from two sources These are ndash
sales and production cost In peak season (hot season like autumn summer) sales
increases but in dull season (eg in winter) sales decreases drastically Production
cost may be increased because of increase of price of sugar chemicals aluminum
can Virgin follows two methods for hedging cash balance uncertainties These are ndash
i) Holding a stock of extra cash and
ii) Extra borrowing capacity
815 Modes for the Management of Cash and Temporary Investments
Virgin does not follow any of these methods wholly Virgin receives cash
continuously and pays salary at steady rate and pays continuously for other
expenses So it neither follows Baumol model nor Beranek model It has no upper
control limit lower control limit return point in case cash management So it neither
follows Miller-Orr model nor Stone model
In Summary
Page 36 of 46
Standard Compliance by Virgin Soft Drinks
Generally all firms hold cash and
marketable securities
Virgin holds only cash
Firms hold cash and marketable
securities for some reasons like
bull Cash for transactions
bull Cash and near-cash assets as
hedges
bull Temporary investments
bull Compensating balances
Virgin holds cash only for
two reasons ndash
bull Cash for transactions
bull Cash as hedges
Available money market instruments Virgin does not invest in any such
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
(short term securities) are ndash
Treasury Bills
Commercial Paper
Certificates of Deposit
Bankerrsquos Acceptance
Repurch menase Agree ts
instruments They only keep cash in
Bank Account
Mail Float
(1 to 5 days)
At Firm
Float
(025 to 1
day)
Clearing
Float
(0 to
2 days)
Mail Float
(2 to 3 days)
At firm
Float
(025
day)
Clearing
Float
(1 to 3
days)
Figure Transit time for a typical check Figure Transit time for a check for
Virgin
Strategies that firms can use to reduce
the delay in receiving funds are ndash
Selecting of Banks with
accelerated clearing capabilities
of check processing Acceleration
at the firm
ectronic collection Use of el
procedures
Use of lockboxes
Virgin follows the first three strategies
but does not use lockboxes
Available cash concentration
mechanisms are ndash
Depository transfer check
ouse Automated Clearing H
(ACH) electronic transfer)
Wire transfer
Virgin uses all these mechanisms of
cash concentration
Available sets of techniques for cash
disbursement management are ndash
ement of disbursement
Page 37 of 46
Manag
float
Virgin uses zero-balance accounts
technique
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Zero-Balance Accounts
Controlled disbursing
Firms may make cash flow forecasts
over periods of various lengths yearly
flows quarterly flows monthly flows
weekly flows or even daily flows
Virgin forecasts cash on yearly basis and
monthly basis
Cash forecasting system may involve ndash
Distribution
Scheduling
Virginrsquos cash forecasting system
involves a combination of distribution
and scheduling
Two common approaches to cash flow
in generating the cash forecast
and disbursement Receipts
approach
Adjusted net income approach
Virgin uses the receipts and
disbursement approach
There are many items to forecast Virgin forecasts only major items like
AR payroll etc
Four common approach to forecasting
fina i ndash nc al variables are
Spot method
Proportion to another account
Compounded growth
Multiple dependencies
Virgin uses spot method for forecasting
cash It uses proportion to another
account method for other variables and
remaining two methods are frequently
used
Sources of uncertainty in cash
forecasting are ndash
Sales uncertainty
Collection rate uncertainty
Production cost uncertainty
Capital outflow uncertainty
Virgin faces uncertainty mainly from
sales and production cost
Methods for hedging cash balance
unc a
Page 38 of 46
ert inties are ndash
i) Holding a stock of extra cash
Virgin two available methods for
hedging cash balance uncertainties
Th ese are ndash
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
ii) stock of near-cash Holding a
assets
iii) Extra borrowing capacity
iv) ary surpluses in Investing tempor
near-cash assets
i) Holding a stock of extra cash
ii) Extra borrowing capacity
(advance receipt from
customers)
Models for the management of cash and
temporary investments are ndash Baumol
model Beranek model Miller-Orr
model and Stone model
Virgin does not follow any method
wholly but a combination of Baumol
model and Beranek model is occurred
82 INVENTORY MANAGEMENT
21 Certainty Approach
isnt used in
irgin because it thinks it is not possible to implement in Bangladesh
d time is one to three days It
oes not use ABC system of inventory management
8
Main item of inventory of Virgin is Can pet chip sugar label chemical artificial
sweet etc Virgin maintains a minimum level of inventory but it does not have to face
problems because inventory is managed efficiently just-in-time (JIT)
V
Virgin maintains buffer stock because of the shortage of work-in-process (WIP)
inventory Its production process may also be hampered Thats why it maintains
safety stock to avoid stock out cost In case of imported goods normal lead time is
about one month and within the country normal lea
d
Page 39 of 46
Inventory Model
In reality Virgin does not use any of models of EOQ ordering and holding strategy
and safety stock strategy They maintain inventory based on their prior experience
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
822 Uncertainty Approach
Virgin does not use any model for handling inventory uncertainty It says that such
decision depends on business cycle and market situation Long before Eid festival
they bought large amount of sugar because of price increase on the occasion of Eid
In summary
Standard Compliance by Virgin Soft Drinks
Firms maintain inventory to guard
against several problems
Virgin maintains a minimum level of
inventory which is managed efficiently
Some firms use JIT to avoid inventory
cost
JIT is not used by Virgin as it thinks it is
impossible to implement in Bangladesh
Firms maintain buffer stock Virgin maintains buffer stock too
Firms maintain safety stock to avoid
shortage cost
Virgin also maintains safety stock
Firms use ABC system to monitor
inventory
Virgin doesnt use ABC system
EOQ model is an appropriate method
for measuring quantity that has to be
ordered per order
Virgin does not use EOQ model rather
makes order based on experience and
market demand
83 MANAGING ACCOUNTS RECEIVABLE (DEBTORS)
831 Terms of Sale Decision
Page 40 of 46
Virgin offers the term 210 net 30 enables the customers to deduct 2 percent from the
face value of the bill when paying within the first 10 days but if the discount is not
taken the customer must remit the full amount within 30 days But Virgin does not
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
offer the same terms of sale to all customers For prime customers it offers special
terms of sale In setting an appropriate term of sale it costs and benefits regarding
this are compared It uses the standard approach of terms of sale decision as it is
simple to use
832 Credit Granting Decisions
In case of Virgin the Capital and Character of Five Cs get more importance
Although there are many problems with the traditional approach Virgin uses it
because of its simplicity Virgin does not use Net Present Value (NPV) method in
credit granting decision It thinks that NPV is an appropriate method and should be
used next time It does not face any severe problem because of bad debts The reason
is that notes receivable is used when credit is granted
833 Monitoring Accounts Receivable
Virgin monitors its accounts receivable Virgin believes that in any case both positive
and negative durations in accounts signal differences from the results that
management believe to be the most advantageous for the firm
Tools for Monitoring Accounts Receivable
Page 41 of 46
For monitoring accounts receivable there are several tools such as aging schedule
the ratios of receivable outstanding to original sales customers payment proportion
and sales weighted DSO (Days Sales Outstanding) For monitoring accounts
receivable Virgin uses aging schedule fractions and traditional DSO statistics
because of their simplicity in use Although payment proportions ratios of
receivables outstanding and sales weighted DSO methods are free from inherent bias
None of these is used because all these are complex to maintain
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
In summary
Page 42 of 46
Standard Compliance by Virgin Soft Drinks
Generals terms of sale is 210 net 30 Normally Virgin also use general terms
of sale ie 210 net 30
Firms do not offer the same terms of
sale to all customers
Yes For prime customers Virgin offers
special terms of sale
Approaches of terms of sale decisions
are ndash
bull Standard approach
bull Multi period approach
Virgin uses standard approach of terms
of sale decision as it is simple to use and
understand
Source of credit information are ndash
Sellers prior experience with the
customer
Credit agency ratings and
reports
Personal contact with the
applicants bank and other
creditors
Analysis of applicants financial
statements
Customer visit
Main source of credit information to
Virgin is its prior experience with the
customer All other sources are not cost-
effective for Virgin
Approaches of credit granting to
marginal accounts are ndash
Traditional approach
Net Present Value (NPV)
approach
It uses traditional approach still now but
thinks that NPV should be used for the
next periods
Firms monitor accounts receivable
because deviations from the expected
levels of turnover and of bad debt can
Virgin also monitors its accounts
receivable
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
signal several different problems
Different tools for monitoring accounts
receivable are ndash
Aging schedule
Ratios of receivables
outstanding to original sales
Customers payment
proportions
Sales-weighted DSO
For monitoring accounts receivable
Virgin uses aging schedule and
traditional sales outstanding statistics
84 MANAGING ACCOUNTS PAYABLE (CREDITORS)
Virgin has almost accounts payable of Tk 8000000 But most of its liabilities are to
the banks rather than suppliers But we dont have any clear information about
Virgins accounts payable
9 RECOMMENDATION
Virgin should invest its surplus cash in short term marketable securities
because it is suitable hedging against cash uncertainties and will also give
some returns (interest income)
Virgin should publish its own annual report which will satisfy information
needs of stakeholders and also increase the credibility of information provided
by Virgin
Page 43 of 46
Virgin should use multi period approach in terms of sale decision because
standard approach which is already exists in Virgin has some inherent
problems
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
It should stop using traditional approach from now It should use NPV
method in credit granting to marginal accounts
In monitoring accounts receivable Virgin should use sales-weighted DSO
method because it has least limitation compared to the others
It should be more flexible in granting credit which will ultimately increase its
sales
To get the appropriate number of quantity to be ordered per order it should
use DSO model
It should be ABC system for proper monitoring of inventory
10 CONCLUSION
The use of other peoples money in business is usually an expensive resource Before
looking outside for finance a firm should examine its own working capital cycle to
make sure that every rand of its own internal funds is being fully utilized Good
management of working capital is part of good financial management Effective use
of working capital will contribute to the operational efficiency of the whole
organization optimum use will help to generate maximum returns Furthermore
working capital management is not an end in itself It is an integral part of the firms
overall management The needs of efficient working capital management must be
considered in relation to other aspects of the Virgins financial and non-financial
performance Thats why when planning the development of a business it is critical
that the impact of working capital be fully assessed
Page 44 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
BIBLIOGRAPHY
Scherr FC (1989) International Edition Prentice-Hall International Inc Modern
Working Capital Management Text and Cases
Hussain Riaz (2002) Working Capital Management
Robertson Lonnie (July 1998) Inventory Management
httpwwwasashoporg visited on March 13 2006
The Art of Cash Management
httpwwwinccom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management
httpwwwstudyfinancecom visited on March 13 2006
White Paper ndash Managing Working Capital
httpwwwplanwareorg visited on March 13 2006
Management of Working Capital
httpwwwbusinesscentralcoza visited on March 13 2006
Cash Management
httpwwwsbagov visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management Objectives
httpwpsprenhallcom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management
Page 45 of 46
httpwwwadvancemecom visited on March 13 2006
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Business Receivables Financing
httpwwwbbtcom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Finance
http wwwfnbcoza visited on March 13 2006
Tips to manage your working capital
httpsmallbusinessninemsncomau visited on March 13 2006
Inventory Financing
httpwwwfranklincapitalnetworkcom visited on March 13 2006
Accounts Receivable Management
httpwwwfranklincapitalnetworkcom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management
httpwwwtreasurygovtnz visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management
httpwwwtreasurystrategiescom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Works
httpwwwinvestopediacom visited on March 13 2006
Treasury Services
httpwwwjpmorganchasecom visited on March 13 2006
what were about
Page 46 of 46
httpwwwvirgincom visited on March 13 2006
Annexure
Annexure
Interview with YASEER RIZVI
Mr Yaseer Rizvi the DMD of Global Beverage Co Ltd obtained his MBA degree
from a reputed university He had been the Director of Ocean Container Ltd before
joining in Global Beverage Co Ltd He possesses a nice personality
I interviewed Yaseer Rizvi Excerpts from his interview are as follows ndash
Shah Kamal Sir would you please tell me do you invest in short term marketable securities
Yaseer Rizvi Basically we do not invest our surplus cash in short term marketable
securities like T-Bill commercial paper certificate of deposit etc But we keep our
surplus cash in Bank
Shah Kamal Would you tell me something about transit time for a typical check
Yaseer Rizvi Well in Virgin the transit time for a typical check is ndash
For mail float 2 to 3 days
At firm float 6 hours
Clearing float 1 to 3 days
Shah Kamal Do you maintain any cash concentration mechanism like depository transfer check automated clearing house and wire transfer
i
Annexure
Yaseer Rizvi Our position in this case is very strong as we use all the mechanisms
you mentioned As Virgin is a firm with small deposits spread over a substantial
number of banks so we tend to use depository transfer checks extensively It is less
costly We also use automated clearing house and wire transfer but later is used in a
less extent
Shah Kamal Sir what techniques of disbursement management is used by your firm
Yaseer Rizvi Like other firms Virgin tries to retain the cash for as long as possible
But we always perform it in an ethical manner We do not use management of
disbursement float as it seems unethical We follow Zero-Balance Accounts method
for managing disbursement We do not prefer Controlled Disbursing method since
Zero-Balance system is already practiced in Virgin
Shah Kamal How do you hedge cash balance uncertainties
Yaseer Rizvi Well you may say that we do not invest in short term securities but for
facing cash difficulties we keep our surplus cash in bank
Shah Kamal Sir would you please tell me the general terms of sale of Virgin
Yaseer Rizvi Though it is difficult to maintain a fixed terms of sale our general terms
of sale is 210 n30 But for prime customers we offer special terms of sale
Shah Kamal What are the sources of credit information in case of your firm
Yaseer Rizvi We grant credit on the basis of prior experience with the customers In
case of a new customer personal contact is weighted
Shah Kamal Does your firm consider 5 Cs in granting credit
ii
Annexure
Yaseer Rizvi In case of Virgin Capital and Character get more importance than the
others Mind one thing personal relationship is the main measure in granting credit
Shah Kamal Do you use NPV method in credit granting decisions
Yaseer Rizvi We do not use NPV method But we think that NPV is a suitable
method and we have to use it from the next period
Shah Kamal Sir how do you handle the problem of bad debt
Yaseer Rizvi Well in this case our position is very strong Yet we do not face any
problem because of bad debt Just note that we make more than 80 of sales in cash
and we monitor accounts receivable very carefully
Shah Kamal What level of inventory is maintained by Virgin
Yaseer Rizvi We maintain a minimum level of inventory but do not have to face
stock out problems because inventory is managed efficiently
Shah Kamal What is the normal lead time
Yaseer Rizvi In case of imported goods normal lead time is about 1 month and when
we purchase raw materials from inside the country lead time is 1 to 3 days
Shah Kamal What method do you use for managing inventory
Yaseer Rizvi We do not use any method particularly rather inventory decision
depends on business cycle and market situation Long before the Eid festival we
bought large amount of sugar because price of sugar was increased on the occasion
of Eid
iii
Annexure
Shah Kamal What are the main items of inventory of your firm
Yaseer Rizvi Well these are ndash aluminum can pet chip sugar label chemical and
artificial sweet
Shah Kamal What are the uncertainties in maintaining appropriate level of stock
Yaseer Rizvi These are ndash
bull Increase in price of raw materials
bull Sales uncertainty
bull Market trends etc
Shah Kamal Thank you for your kind cooperation
Yaseer Rizvi Most Welcome
iv
Global Beverage Company Limited
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Carrying costs can be minimized by making frequent small orders but this increase
ordering costs and the risk of stock outs Risk of stock-outs can be reduced by
carrying safety stocks (at a cost) and re-ordering ahead of time
The best ordering strategy requires balancing the various cost factors to ensure the
firm incurs minimum inventory costs The optimum inventory position is known as
the Economic Reorder Quantity (ERQ)
Nowadays many large manufacturers operate on a just-in-time (JIT) basis whereby
all the components to be assembled on a particular today arrive at the factory early
that morning no earlier - no later This helps to minimize manufacturing costs as JIT
stocks take up little space minimize stock-holding and virtually eliminate the risks of
obsolete or damaged stock Because JIT manufacturers hold stock for a very short
time they are able to conserve substantial cash JIT is a good model to strive for as it
embraces all the principles of prudent stock management For better stock control
firm may try the following
Review the effectiveness of existing purchasing and inventory systems
Know the stock turn for all major items of inventory
Apply tight controls to the significant few items and simplify controls for the
trivial many
Sell off outdated or slow moving merchandise - it gets more difficult to sell the
longer the firm keeps it
Consider having part of its product outsourced to another manufacturer rather
than make it itself
Review its security procedures to ensure that no stock is going out the back
door
Higher than necessary stock levels tie up cash and cost more in insurance
accommodation costs and interest charges
Page 21 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
However it is important to keep an overall perspective It is not cost-effective to
closely manage a large number of low value inventory lines nor is it necessary A
usual feature of inventories is that a small number of high value lines account for a
large proportion of inventory value The 8020 rule (PARETO) predicts that 80
of the total value of inventory is represented by only 20 of the number of inventory
items Those high value lines need reasonably close management The remaining
80 of inventory lines can be managed using broad-brush strategies
533 MANAGING ACCOUNTS RECEIVABLE (DEBTORS)
Cash flow can be significantly enhanced if the amounts owing to a business are
collected faster Every business needs to know who owes them money how much is
owed how long it is owing for what it is owed
Debtors (Accounts Receivable) are customers who have not yet made payment for
goods or services which the department has provided The objective of debtor
management is to minimize the time-lapse between completion of sales and receipt
of payment The costs of having debtors are
Opportunity costs (cash is not available for other purposes)
Bad debts
If firm doesnt manage debtors they will begin to manage business as the firm will gradually
lose control due to reduced cash flow and of course it could experience an increased
incidence of bad debt The following measures will help manage debtors
Having the right mental attitude to the control of credit and make sure that it
gets the priority it deserves
Establishing clear credit practices as a matter of company policy
Page 22 of 46
Making sure that these practices are clearly understood by staff suppliers and
customers
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Page 23 of 46
Being professional when accepting new accounts and especially larger ones
Checking out each customer thoroughly before the firm offers credit Use
credit agencies bank references industry sources etc
Establishing credit limits for each customer and sticking to them
Continuously reviewing these limits when it suspects tough times are coming
or if operating in a volatile sector
Keeping very close to the firms larger customers
Invoicing promptly and clearly
Considering charging penalties on overdue accounts
Considering accepting credit debit cards as a payment option
Monitoring its debtor balances and ageing schedules and dont let any debts
get too large or too old
Debtor management includes both pre-sale and debt collection strategies
Pre-sale strategies include
Offering cash discounts for early payment andor imposing penalties for late
payment
Agreeing payment terms in advance
Requiring cash before delivery
Setting credit limits
ning credit Setting criteria for obtai
Billing as early as possible
rogress payments
ost-sale strategies include
for collecting the debt upon the center that made the sale
Requiring deposits andor p
P
Placing the responsibility
Identifying long overdue balances and doubtful debts by regular analytical reviews
Having an established procedure for late collections such as
A reminder
A letter
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Page 24 of 46
ion of further credit Cancellat
Telephone calls
n agency Use of a collectio
he firm should recognize that the longer someone owes firm the greater the chance
Legal action
T
it will never get paid If the average age of debtors is getting longer or is already very
long it may need to look for the following possible defects
Weak credit judgment
res Poor collection procedu
ms Lax enforcement of credit ter
Slow issue of invoices or statements
Errors in invoices or statements
Customer dissatisfaction
Debtors due over 90 days (unless within agreed credit terms) should generally
demand immediate attention For example warning signs of a future bad debt ndash
Longer credit terms taken with approval particularly for smaller orders
Use of post-dated checks by debtors who normally settle within agreed terms
Evidence of customers switching to additional suppliers for the same goods
New customers who are reluctant to give credit references
Cre G
Receiving part payments from debtors
dit ranting to Marginal Accounts
Traditional Approach
In the traditional approach to the credit granting decision it is the credit analysts job
rmation that has been collected and reach a judgment
regarding the applicants creditworthiness One traditional way of organizing this
to synthesize all the info
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
information is by characterizing the applicant along five dimensions These
dimensions are called the Five Cs of credit ndash
Capital
Character
Collateral
and Capacity
Conditions
Net Present Value (NPV) Approach
Once a firm has assessed the creditworthiness of a customer it has to decide whether
r not credit should be granted The firm should use the NPV rule to make the
ld be granted
Figure
o
decision If NPV is positive credit shou
Credit Granting Decision
Credit Granting Decision
he act of collecting money is one which most people dislike for many reasons and
therefore put on the long f selves there is something
ore urgent or important that demands their attention now There is nothing more
T
inger because they convince them
m
important than getting paid for firms product or service A customer who does not
Page 25 of 46
Grand Credit
Payment received Payment not received
Benefit of present value of future net cash flow
Cost of present value ment of lost invest
Net Payoff PV of benefit-cost
No Credit
No Payoff
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
pay is not a customer Here are a few ideas that may help the firm in collecting
money from debtors
Firm should develop appropriate procedures for handling late payments
It should track and pursue late payers
It might get external help if its own efforts fail
or money its firms and it is entitled Company shouldnt feel guilty asking f
to it
ction
Firm must make that call now And it should keep asking until it gets some
satisfa
lessens the problem
In difficult circumstances take what the firm can now and agree terms for the
remainder It
paying
When asking for money be hard on the issue - but soft on the person It shouldnt
give the debtor any excuses for not
534 BLE (CREDITORS)
ices for goods or services have
een paid Organizations often regard the
not
to delay all payments until the latest possible date Regular weekly or
The firm make it its objective is to get the money - not to score points or get
even
MANAGING ACCOUNTS PAYA
Creditors (Accounts Payable) are suppliers whose invo
been processed but who have not yet b
amount owing to creditors as a source of free credit However creditor
administration systems are expensive and time-consuming to run The over-riding
concern in this area should be to minimize costs with simple procedures
While it is unnecessary to pay accounts before they fall due it is usually
worthwhile
Page 26 of 46
fortnightly payment of all due accounts is the simplest technique for creditor
management
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Electronic payments (direct credits) are cheaper than check payments considering
that transaction fees and overheads more than balance the advantage of delayed
presentation Some suppliers are reluctant to receive payments by this method but in
view of the substantial cost advantage (and the advantages to the suppliers
themselves) departments may wish to encourage suppliers to accept this option
However electronic payments are likely to be used in conjunction with rather than
as a replacement for check payments
Applying Best Practices in Managing Accounts Payable
f course simply deferring payments to suppliers could have adverse consequences
O
that more than offset the benefits of this additional cash flow Therefore it is
important to develop a holistic approach The firm should consider the following
best practices for payables management
Managing payment dates and terms to maximize cash flow ndash
y reporting on
receivable and
id penalty charges and taking advantage of
wer vendors and negotiate for more
to buying consortia with others even
voices for
payment based on receipt of goods or receipt of invoice whichever
comes later
Calculating and setting performance targets Regularl
AP performance measures such as days in payables
Coordinating the AP processes with accounts
inventory management to ensure that the company is collecting more
cash than it is paying out
Paying bills on time to avo
prompt-payment discounts where the discounts exceed the companyrsquos
cost of working capital
Consolidating purchases with fe
favorable payment terms
Considering entering in
Page 27 of 46
competitors to obtain favorable supplier pricing and terms
Unless contract terms specify otherwise setting up in
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Page 28 of 46
Em
process
-time payments with Electronic Funds Transfer (EFT)
uraging vendors to utilize electronic invoice presentment
a
ndancies and more
ploying technology to automate the accounts payable transaction
es ndash
Making just-in
Using an electronic invoice-matching application
Enco
For companies with multiple locations or business units employing
shared service approach for AP to eliminate redu
quickly implement process improvements
Mainta
vendor
Communicating accounts payable requirements to suppliers at the
m key suppliers
for suggestions on how to improve the
Efficient a
and making th rsquos cash is just good business
ining open communications and building strong relationships with
s to access valuable trade credit ndash
beginning of transactions
Requesting summary invoicing fro
Requiring suppliers to send invoices directly to accounts payable
Asking tier-one suppliers
payment process
nd effective management of accounts payable helps improve cash flow ndash
e most of company
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
6 OVERVIEW OF VIRGIN GROUP
Virgin - one of the most respected brands in Britain - is now becoming the first global
brand name of the 21st century Virgin is involved in planes trains finance soft
drinks music mobile phones holidays cars wines publishing bridal wear - the lot
What tie all these businesses together are the values of its brand and the attitude of its
people Virgin has created over 200 companies worldwide employing over 25000
people Its total revenues around the world in 2002 exceeded pound4 billion (US $72
billion)
In 1970 Richard Branson founded Virgin as a mail order record retailer and not
long after he opened a record shop in Oxford Street London During 1972 a
recording studio was built in Oxfordshire and the first Virgin artist Mike Oldfield
recorded Tubular Bells which was released in 1973
This album went on to sell over 5 million copies Since then many household names
including Belinda Carlisle Genesis Phil Collins Janet Jackson and The Rolling
Stones have helped to make Virgin Music one of the top six record companies in the
world The equity of Virgin Music Group - record labels music publishing and
recording studios was sold to THORN EMI in 1992 in a US$1billion deal
Page 29 of 46
The Virgin Group has now expanded into international music Mega stores air
travel mobile financial retail music internet drinks rail hotels and leisure with
around 200 companies in over 30 countries
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
In Virgins customers eyes Virgin stands for value for money quality innovation
fun and a sense of competitive challenge It delivers a quality service by empowering
its employees and facilitates and monitors customer feedback to continually improve
the customers experience through innovation
When they start a new venture Virgin bases it on hard research and analysis
Typically they review the industry and put themselves in the customers shoes to see
what could make it better Virgin asks fundamental questions
Is this an opportunity for restructuring a market and creating competitive
advantage What are the competitors doing
Is the customer confused or badly served
Is this an opportunity for building the Virgin brand
Can we add value
Will it interact with its other businesses
Is there an appropriate trade-off between risk and reward
Page 30 of 46
Virgin is also able to draw on talented people from throughout the group New
ventures are often steered by people seconded from other parts of Virgin who bring
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
with them the trademark management style skills and experience Virgin frequently
creates partnerships with others to combine skills knowledge and market presence
and so on Contrary to what some people may think their constantly expanding and
eclectic empire is neither random nor reckless Each successive venture demonstrates
its skill in picking the right market and the right opportunity
7 OVERVIEW OF VIRGIN SOFT DRINKS
The Virgin Drinks Group first launched as the Virgin Cola Company in 1994 with
Virgin Cola in the UK Since then the company has ventured across the carbonated
soft drinks arena and beyond into energy drinks tea and flavored Colas This
expansion has lead to the evolution of the Virgin Drinks Company a company
whose aim is to put the excitement back into the world of soft drinks It launched in
Bangladesh in 1999 Virgin Soft Drinks is monitored by Global Beverage Co Ltd in
Bangladesh
Brief history of Virgin Drinks is given below
Page 31 of 46
1994 November Virgin Cola launched in the UK
1996 March Virgin Cola launched in France
1998 June Virgin Cola launched in Belgium
April Virgin Cola launched in the French West Indies
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
August Virgin Cola launched in Switzerland
1999 March Virgin Colours launched in Italy
March Virgin Cola launched in Japan
July Virgin Colours launched in South Africa
December Virgin Colours launched in Bangladesh
2001 January Sweden launched Virgin Colours
November Singapore launched Virgin Colours
2002 February Croatia launched Virgin Colours
June Russia launched Virgin Colours
June Tunisia launched Virgin Colours
2003 May Israel launched Virgin Colours
8 FINDINGS OF WORKING CAPITAL MANAGEMENT MAINTAINED BY
VIRGIN SOFT DRINKS IN BANGLADESH
81 CASH MANAGEMENT
811 Holding Cash and Marketable Securities
Although there are many good reasons why firm hold cash and marketable
securities Virgin Drinks holds cash and marketable securities for two reasons ndash
i) Cash for transactions
ii) Cash as hedges
This indicates that the firm does not hold cash and marketable securities for some
important reasons such as ndash
i) Near cash assets as hedges
Page 32 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
ii) Temporary investment and compensating balances
Virgin Soft Drinks does not invest in money market securities such as Treasury bill
commercial paper certificate of deposits bankerrsquos acceptance and repurchase
agreement This firm deposits its money in bank as currant AC or fixed AC They
say that they do not have enough money to invest in money market instrument
They also say that if they have enough money they will invest it in money market
short term securities We know that near cash interest earning assets can be
substituted for cash when motivation for holding these assets is the hedging of cash
flow uncertainties or is the temporary investment of surplus funds In this point
Virgins position is not good as there is no significant hedging against uncertainty of
cash
812 Floatation and Check Clearing
Virgin is very smart in handling the problem of transit time for checks Here mail
float takes 2 to 3 days at firm takes 025 day and clearing float takes 1-3 days Virgin
uses most of the strategies available for reducing the delay in receiving funds It
(Virgin) has linked Islami Bank which posses an accelerated clearing facility It uses
electronic collection process which ensures faster collection and its at the firm check
processing is satisfactory But Virgin does not use lockbox The reason behind this is
that it is not cost-effective for Virgin to set lockboxes At this point we can say that
Virgins check clearing mechanism is much good
813 Cash Concentration and Disbursement Management
Page 33 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks takes the matter of cash concentration very seriously They use all
the available cash concentration mechanism Virgin is a firm with small deposits
spread over a substantial number of banks and this is why the firm tends to use
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
depository transfer checks extensively If is less costly Virgin also uses automated
clearing house and wire transfer To Virgin wire transfer seems too costly
Like other firm Virgin tries to retain the cash for as long as possible But Virgin
always performs it in an ethical manner Virgin does not try to defeat the receiving
firmrsquos attempts to reduce the float on incoming checks It does not take any strategy
for increasing mail float at firm float and clearing float on its outgoing checks To
Virgin it is deemed to be unethical It thinks that maximization of disbursement float
will not go unnoticed by sophisticated creditors for very long When it is noticed it
will negatively affect relations with these creditors reducing the firmrsquos bargaining
power with them This may ultimately cost Virgin dearly when future prices and
delivery schedules for goods and services purchased from trade creditors are
negotiated Virgin follows ldquoZero-Balance Accountsrdquo methods for managing
disbursement It thinks that in this method the coordination of funds inflows to
disbursement banks with the presentation of checks does not work to the detriment
of creditors since the firmrsquos checks to them are honored as presented and this strategy
does not affect float significantly Controlled disbursing method is less attractive to
Virgin because zero-balance system is already feasible
814 Cash Forecasting
Cash Forecasting and Its Types
Page 34 of 46
Virgin forecasts the future cash inflows and outflows To Virgin cash forecast is an
important part of the firmrsquos cash control system and is one of the forecasts that are
part of the Virginrsquos financial plan Virgin forecasts cash on monthly basis and on
yearly basis Virgin does not forecast on daily basis assuming that the temporary
shortage of funds within these periods can be covered without value cost eg
advance receipts from customers Virginrsquos cash forecasting system involves a
combination of distribution and scheduling The receipts and disbursements
approach of cash forecasting is used in virgin This method is used because it
minutely traces the movement of cash and very close control of cash is possible
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Virgin does not use adjusted net income approach on two grounds First it does not
permit the tracing of the individual types of cash inflows and outflows for any given
period which is often useful information for virgin Second it is not simple to use
Items to be Forecast
Virgin does not forecast all the items It forecasts only major items eg accounts
receivable notes receivable payroll cash purchases of raw materials In this regard
virgin trade off between cost and benefit
Methods of Financial Forecasting
Virgin forecasts the future level of financial variable such as cash level asset level or
liability level We know in short term forecasts many things will result from plans
and events that are already in place (contracts capital budgets long-range financing
plans and so forth) But in the long run most things can vary and are dependent on
outside influences such as the firmrsquos long-term growth rate Since Virginrsquos cash
forecasting deals mostly with near future many of the items on the cash forecasts are
estimated by some variation of the spot method and remaining estimates are mostly
on a ldquoproportion of another accountrdquo basis with this ldquoother accountrdquo often being a
particular periodrsquos sales Virgin uses the other two methods less frequently
Using Cash Forecast
Virgin forecasts cash for meeting general objectives (ie to know the available funds
for investment and need financing) and for meeting some special objectives (eg to
know whether the firm will fulfill its out of debt requirement) But it is matter to note
that Virgin does not make any short term investment of its surplus cash but only keep
this surplus in Bank Account
Page 35 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Sources of Uncertainty in Cash Forecasting and Hedging Uncertainties
Virgin faces uncertainty in cash forecasting mainly from two sources These are ndash
sales and production cost In peak season (hot season like autumn summer) sales
increases but in dull season (eg in winter) sales decreases drastically Production
cost may be increased because of increase of price of sugar chemicals aluminum
can Virgin follows two methods for hedging cash balance uncertainties These are ndash
i) Holding a stock of extra cash and
ii) Extra borrowing capacity
815 Modes for the Management of Cash and Temporary Investments
Virgin does not follow any of these methods wholly Virgin receives cash
continuously and pays salary at steady rate and pays continuously for other
expenses So it neither follows Baumol model nor Beranek model It has no upper
control limit lower control limit return point in case cash management So it neither
follows Miller-Orr model nor Stone model
In Summary
Page 36 of 46
Standard Compliance by Virgin Soft Drinks
Generally all firms hold cash and
marketable securities
Virgin holds only cash
Firms hold cash and marketable
securities for some reasons like
bull Cash for transactions
bull Cash and near-cash assets as
hedges
bull Temporary investments
bull Compensating balances
Virgin holds cash only for
two reasons ndash
bull Cash for transactions
bull Cash as hedges
Available money market instruments Virgin does not invest in any such
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
(short term securities) are ndash
Treasury Bills
Commercial Paper
Certificates of Deposit
Bankerrsquos Acceptance
Repurch menase Agree ts
instruments They only keep cash in
Bank Account
Mail Float
(1 to 5 days)
At Firm
Float
(025 to 1
day)
Clearing
Float
(0 to
2 days)
Mail Float
(2 to 3 days)
At firm
Float
(025
day)
Clearing
Float
(1 to 3
days)
Figure Transit time for a typical check Figure Transit time for a check for
Virgin
Strategies that firms can use to reduce
the delay in receiving funds are ndash
Selecting of Banks with
accelerated clearing capabilities
of check processing Acceleration
at the firm
ectronic collection Use of el
procedures
Use of lockboxes
Virgin follows the first three strategies
but does not use lockboxes
Available cash concentration
mechanisms are ndash
Depository transfer check
ouse Automated Clearing H
(ACH) electronic transfer)
Wire transfer
Virgin uses all these mechanisms of
cash concentration
Available sets of techniques for cash
disbursement management are ndash
ement of disbursement
Page 37 of 46
Manag
float
Virgin uses zero-balance accounts
technique
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Zero-Balance Accounts
Controlled disbursing
Firms may make cash flow forecasts
over periods of various lengths yearly
flows quarterly flows monthly flows
weekly flows or even daily flows
Virgin forecasts cash on yearly basis and
monthly basis
Cash forecasting system may involve ndash
Distribution
Scheduling
Virginrsquos cash forecasting system
involves a combination of distribution
and scheduling
Two common approaches to cash flow
in generating the cash forecast
and disbursement Receipts
approach
Adjusted net income approach
Virgin uses the receipts and
disbursement approach
There are many items to forecast Virgin forecasts only major items like
AR payroll etc
Four common approach to forecasting
fina i ndash nc al variables are
Spot method
Proportion to another account
Compounded growth
Multiple dependencies
Virgin uses spot method for forecasting
cash It uses proportion to another
account method for other variables and
remaining two methods are frequently
used
Sources of uncertainty in cash
forecasting are ndash
Sales uncertainty
Collection rate uncertainty
Production cost uncertainty
Capital outflow uncertainty
Virgin faces uncertainty mainly from
sales and production cost
Methods for hedging cash balance
unc a
Page 38 of 46
ert inties are ndash
i) Holding a stock of extra cash
Virgin two available methods for
hedging cash balance uncertainties
Th ese are ndash
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
ii) stock of near-cash Holding a
assets
iii) Extra borrowing capacity
iv) ary surpluses in Investing tempor
near-cash assets
i) Holding a stock of extra cash
ii) Extra borrowing capacity
(advance receipt from
customers)
Models for the management of cash and
temporary investments are ndash Baumol
model Beranek model Miller-Orr
model and Stone model
Virgin does not follow any method
wholly but a combination of Baumol
model and Beranek model is occurred
82 INVENTORY MANAGEMENT
21 Certainty Approach
isnt used in
irgin because it thinks it is not possible to implement in Bangladesh
d time is one to three days It
oes not use ABC system of inventory management
8
Main item of inventory of Virgin is Can pet chip sugar label chemical artificial
sweet etc Virgin maintains a minimum level of inventory but it does not have to face
problems because inventory is managed efficiently just-in-time (JIT)
V
Virgin maintains buffer stock because of the shortage of work-in-process (WIP)
inventory Its production process may also be hampered Thats why it maintains
safety stock to avoid stock out cost In case of imported goods normal lead time is
about one month and within the country normal lea
d
Page 39 of 46
Inventory Model
In reality Virgin does not use any of models of EOQ ordering and holding strategy
and safety stock strategy They maintain inventory based on their prior experience
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
822 Uncertainty Approach
Virgin does not use any model for handling inventory uncertainty It says that such
decision depends on business cycle and market situation Long before Eid festival
they bought large amount of sugar because of price increase on the occasion of Eid
In summary
Standard Compliance by Virgin Soft Drinks
Firms maintain inventory to guard
against several problems
Virgin maintains a minimum level of
inventory which is managed efficiently
Some firms use JIT to avoid inventory
cost
JIT is not used by Virgin as it thinks it is
impossible to implement in Bangladesh
Firms maintain buffer stock Virgin maintains buffer stock too
Firms maintain safety stock to avoid
shortage cost
Virgin also maintains safety stock
Firms use ABC system to monitor
inventory
Virgin doesnt use ABC system
EOQ model is an appropriate method
for measuring quantity that has to be
ordered per order
Virgin does not use EOQ model rather
makes order based on experience and
market demand
83 MANAGING ACCOUNTS RECEIVABLE (DEBTORS)
831 Terms of Sale Decision
Page 40 of 46
Virgin offers the term 210 net 30 enables the customers to deduct 2 percent from the
face value of the bill when paying within the first 10 days but if the discount is not
taken the customer must remit the full amount within 30 days But Virgin does not
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
offer the same terms of sale to all customers For prime customers it offers special
terms of sale In setting an appropriate term of sale it costs and benefits regarding
this are compared It uses the standard approach of terms of sale decision as it is
simple to use
832 Credit Granting Decisions
In case of Virgin the Capital and Character of Five Cs get more importance
Although there are many problems with the traditional approach Virgin uses it
because of its simplicity Virgin does not use Net Present Value (NPV) method in
credit granting decision It thinks that NPV is an appropriate method and should be
used next time It does not face any severe problem because of bad debts The reason
is that notes receivable is used when credit is granted
833 Monitoring Accounts Receivable
Virgin monitors its accounts receivable Virgin believes that in any case both positive
and negative durations in accounts signal differences from the results that
management believe to be the most advantageous for the firm
Tools for Monitoring Accounts Receivable
Page 41 of 46
For monitoring accounts receivable there are several tools such as aging schedule
the ratios of receivable outstanding to original sales customers payment proportion
and sales weighted DSO (Days Sales Outstanding) For monitoring accounts
receivable Virgin uses aging schedule fractions and traditional DSO statistics
because of their simplicity in use Although payment proportions ratios of
receivables outstanding and sales weighted DSO methods are free from inherent bias
None of these is used because all these are complex to maintain
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
In summary
Page 42 of 46
Standard Compliance by Virgin Soft Drinks
Generals terms of sale is 210 net 30 Normally Virgin also use general terms
of sale ie 210 net 30
Firms do not offer the same terms of
sale to all customers
Yes For prime customers Virgin offers
special terms of sale
Approaches of terms of sale decisions
are ndash
bull Standard approach
bull Multi period approach
Virgin uses standard approach of terms
of sale decision as it is simple to use and
understand
Source of credit information are ndash
Sellers prior experience with the
customer
Credit agency ratings and
reports
Personal contact with the
applicants bank and other
creditors
Analysis of applicants financial
statements
Customer visit
Main source of credit information to
Virgin is its prior experience with the
customer All other sources are not cost-
effective for Virgin
Approaches of credit granting to
marginal accounts are ndash
Traditional approach
Net Present Value (NPV)
approach
It uses traditional approach still now but
thinks that NPV should be used for the
next periods
Firms monitor accounts receivable
because deviations from the expected
levels of turnover and of bad debt can
Virgin also monitors its accounts
receivable
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
signal several different problems
Different tools for monitoring accounts
receivable are ndash
Aging schedule
Ratios of receivables
outstanding to original sales
Customers payment
proportions
Sales-weighted DSO
For monitoring accounts receivable
Virgin uses aging schedule and
traditional sales outstanding statistics
84 MANAGING ACCOUNTS PAYABLE (CREDITORS)
Virgin has almost accounts payable of Tk 8000000 But most of its liabilities are to
the banks rather than suppliers But we dont have any clear information about
Virgins accounts payable
9 RECOMMENDATION
Virgin should invest its surplus cash in short term marketable securities
because it is suitable hedging against cash uncertainties and will also give
some returns (interest income)
Virgin should publish its own annual report which will satisfy information
needs of stakeholders and also increase the credibility of information provided
by Virgin
Page 43 of 46
Virgin should use multi period approach in terms of sale decision because
standard approach which is already exists in Virgin has some inherent
problems
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
It should stop using traditional approach from now It should use NPV
method in credit granting to marginal accounts
In monitoring accounts receivable Virgin should use sales-weighted DSO
method because it has least limitation compared to the others
It should be more flexible in granting credit which will ultimately increase its
sales
To get the appropriate number of quantity to be ordered per order it should
use DSO model
It should be ABC system for proper monitoring of inventory
10 CONCLUSION
The use of other peoples money in business is usually an expensive resource Before
looking outside for finance a firm should examine its own working capital cycle to
make sure that every rand of its own internal funds is being fully utilized Good
management of working capital is part of good financial management Effective use
of working capital will contribute to the operational efficiency of the whole
organization optimum use will help to generate maximum returns Furthermore
working capital management is not an end in itself It is an integral part of the firms
overall management The needs of efficient working capital management must be
considered in relation to other aspects of the Virgins financial and non-financial
performance Thats why when planning the development of a business it is critical
that the impact of working capital be fully assessed
Page 44 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
BIBLIOGRAPHY
Scherr FC (1989) International Edition Prentice-Hall International Inc Modern
Working Capital Management Text and Cases
Hussain Riaz (2002) Working Capital Management
Robertson Lonnie (July 1998) Inventory Management
httpwwwasashoporg visited on March 13 2006
The Art of Cash Management
httpwwwinccom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management
httpwwwstudyfinancecom visited on March 13 2006
White Paper ndash Managing Working Capital
httpwwwplanwareorg visited on March 13 2006
Management of Working Capital
httpwwwbusinesscentralcoza visited on March 13 2006
Cash Management
httpwwwsbagov visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management Objectives
httpwpsprenhallcom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management
Page 45 of 46
httpwwwadvancemecom visited on March 13 2006
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Business Receivables Financing
httpwwwbbtcom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Finance
http wwwfnbcoza visited on March 13 2006
Tips to manage your working capital
httpsmallbusinessninemsncomau visited on March 13 2006
Inventory Financing
httpwwwfranklincapitalnetworkcom visited on March 13 2006
Accounts Receivable Management
httpwwwfranklincapitalnetworkcom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management
httpwwwtreasurygovtnz visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management
httpwwwtreasurystrategiescom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Works
httpwwwinvestopediacom visited on March 13 2006
Treasury Services
httpwwwjpmorganchasecom visited on March 13 2006
what were about
Page 46 of 46
httpwwwvirgincom visited on March 13 2006
Annexure
Annexure
Interview with YASEER RIZVI
Mr Yaseer Rizvi the DMD of Global Beverage Co Ltd obtained his MBA degree
from a reputed university He had been the Director of Ocean Container Ltd before
joining in Global Beverage Co Ltd He possesses a nice personality
I interviewed Yaseer Rizvi Excerpts from his interview are as follows ndash
Shah Kamal Sir would you please tell me do you invest in short term marketable securities
Yaseer Rizvi Basically we do not invest our surplus cash in short term marketable
securities like T-Bill commercial paper certificate of deposit etc But we keep our
surplus cash in Bank
Shah Kamal Would you tell me something about transit time for a typical check
Yaseer Rizvi Well in Virgin the transit time for a typical check is ndash
For mail float 2 to 3 days
At firm float 6 hours
Clearing float 1 to 3 days
Shah Kamal Do you maintain any cash concentration mechanism like depository transfer check automated clearing house and wire transfer
i
Annexure
Yaseer Rizvi Our position in this case is very strong as we use all the mechanisms
you mentioned As Virgin is a firm with small deposits spread over a substantial
number of banks so we tend to use depository transfer checks extensively It is less
costly We also use automated clearing house and wire transfer but later is used in a
less extent
Shah Kamal Sir what techniques of disbursement management is used by your firm
Yaseer Rizvi Like other firms Virgin tries to retain the cash for as long as possible
But we always perform it in an ethical manner We do not use management of
disbursement float as it seems unethical We follow Zero-Balance Accounts method
for managing disbursement We do not prefer Controlled Disbursing method since
Zero-Balance system is already practiced in Virgin
Shah Kamal How do you hedge cash balance uncertainties
Yaseer Rizvi Well you may say that we do not invest in short term securities but for
facing cash difficulties we keep our surplus cash in bank
Shah Kamal Sir would you please tell me the general terms of sale of Virgin
Yaseer Rizvi Though it is difficult to maintain a fixed terms of sale our general terms
of sale is 210 n30 But for prime customers we offer special terms of sale
Shah Kamal What are the sources of credit information in case of your firm
Yaseer Rizvi We grant credit on the basis of prior experience with the customers In
case of a new customer personal contact is weighted
Shah Kamal Does your firm consider 5 Cs in granting credit
ii
Annexure
Yaseer Rizvi In case of Virgin Capital and Character get more importance than the
others Mind one thing personal relationship is the main measure in granting credit
Shah Kamal Do you use NPV method in credit granting decisions
Yaseer Rizvi We do not use NPV method But we think that NPV is a suitable
method and we have to use it from the next period
Shah Kamal Sir how do you handle the problem of bad debt
Yaseer Rizvi Well in this case our position is very strong Yet we do not face any
problem because of bad debt Just note that we make more than 80 of sales in cash
and we monitor accounts receivable very carefully
Shah Kamal What level of inventory is maintained by Virgin
Yaseer Rizvi We maintain a minimum level of inventory but do not have to face
stock out problems because inventory is managed efficiently
Shah Kamal What is the normal lead time
Yaseer Rizvi In case of imported goods normal lead time is about 1 month and when
we purchase raw materials from inside the country lead time is 1 to 3 days
Shah Kamal What method do you use for managing inventory
Yaseer Rizvi We do not use any method particularly rather inventory decision
depends on business cycle and market situation Long before the Eid festival we
bought large amount of sugar because price of sugar was increased on the occasion
of Eid
iii
Annexure
Shah Kamal What are the main items of inventory of your firm
Yaseer Rizvi Well these are ndash aluminum can pet chip sugar label chemical and
artificial sweet
Shah Kamal What are the uncertainties in maintaining appropriate level of stock
Yaseer Rizvi These are ndash
bull Increase in price of raw materials
bull Sales uncertainty
bull Market trends etc
Shah Kamal Thank you for your kind cooperation
Yaseer Rizvi Most Welcome
iv
Global Beverage Company Limited
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
However it is important to keep an overall perspective It is not cost-effective to
closely manage a large number of low value inventory lines nor is it necessary A
usual feature of inventories is that a small number of high value lines account for a
large proportion of inventory value The 8020 rule (PARETO) predicts that 80
of the total value of inventory is represented by only 20 of the number of inventory
items Those high value lines need reasonably close management The remaining
80 of inventory lines can be managed using broad-brush strategies
533 MANAGING ACCOUNTS RECEIVABLE (DEBTORS)
Cash flow can be significantly enhanced if the amounts owing to a business are
collected faster Every business needs to know who owes them money how much is
owed how long it is owing for what it is owed
Debtors (Accounts Receivable) are customers who have not yet made payment for
goods or services which the department has provided The objective of debtor
management is to minimize the time-lapse between completion of sales and receipt
of payment The costs of having debtors are
Opportunity costs (cash is not available for other purposes)
Bad debts
If firm doesnt manage debtors they will begin to manage business as the firm will gradually
lose control due to reduced cash flow and of course it could experience an increased
incidence of bad debt The following measures will help manage debtors
Having the right mental attitude to the control of credit and make sure that it
gets the priority it deserves
Establishing clear credit practices as a matter of company policy
Page 22 of 46
Making sure that these practices are clearly understood by staff suppliers and
customers
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Page 23 of 46
Being professional when accepting new accounts and especially larger ones
Checking out each customer thoroughly before the firm offers credit Use
credit agencies bank references industry sources etc
Establishing credit limits for each customer and sticking to them
Continuously reviewing these limits when it suspects tough times are coming
or if operating in a volatile sector
Keeping very close to the firms larger customers
Invoicing promptly and clearly
Considering charging penalties on overdue accounts
Considering accepting credit debit cards as a payment option
Monitoring its debtor balances and ageing schedules and dont let any debts
get too large or too old
Debtor management includes both pre-sale and debt collection strategies
Pre-sale strategies include
Offering cash discounts for early payment andor imposing penalties for late
payment
Agreeing payment terms in advance
Requiring cash before delivery
Setting credit limits
ning credit Setting criteria for obtai
Billing as early as possible
rogress payments
ost-sale strategies include
for collecting the debt upon the center that made the sale
Requiring deposits andor p
P
Placing the responsibility
Identifying long overdue balances and doubtful debts by regular analytical reviews
Having an established procedure for late collections such as
A reminder
A letter
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Page 24 of 46
ion of further credit Cancellat
Telephone calls
n agency Use of a collectio
he firm should recognize that the longer someone owes firm the greater the chance
Legal action
T
it will never get paid If the average age of debtors is getting longer or is already very
long it may need to look for the following possible defects
Weak credit judgment
res Poor collection procedu
ms Lax enforcement of credit ter
Slow issue of invoices or statements
Errors in invoices or statements
Customer dissatisfaction
Debtors due over 90 days (unless within agreed credit terms) should generally
demand immediate attention For example warning signs of a future bad debt ndash
Longer credit terms taken with approval particularly for smaller orders
Use of post-dated checks by debtors who normally settle within agreed terms
Evidence of customers switching to additional suppliers for the same goods
New customers who are reluctant to give credit references
Cre G
Receiving part payments from debtors
dit ranting to Marginal Accounts
Traditional Approach
In the traditional approach to the credit granting decision it is the credit analysts job
rmation that has been collected and reach a judgment
regarding the applicants creditworthiness One traditional way of organizing this
to synthesize all the info
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
information is by characterizing the applicant along five dimensions These
dimensions are called the Five Cs of credit ndash
Capital
Character
Collateral
and Capacity
Conditions
Net Present Value (NPV) Approach
Once a firm has assessed the creditworthiness of a customer it has to decide whether
r not credit should be granted The firm should use the NPV rule to make the
ld be granted
Figure
o
decision If NPV is positive credit shou
Credit Granting Decision
Credit Granting Decision
he act of collecting money is one which most people dislike for many reasons and
therefore put on the long f selves there is something
ore urgent or important that demands their attention now There is nothing more
T
inger because they convince them
m
important than getting paid for firms product or service A customer who does not
Page 25 of 46
Grand Credit
Payment received Payment not received
Benefit of present value of future net cash flow
Cost of present value ment of lost invest
Net Payoff PV of benefit-cost
No Credit
No Payoff
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
pay is not a customer Here are a few ideas that may help the firm in collecting
money from debtors
Firm should develop appropriate procedures for handling late payments
It should track and pursue late payers
It might get external help if its own efforts fail
or money its firms and it is entitled Company shouldnt feel guilty asking f
to it
ction
Firm must make that call now And it should keep asking until it gets some
satisfa
lessens the problem
In difficult circumstances take what the firm can now and agree terms for the
remainder It
paying
When asking for money be hard on the issue - but soft on the person It shouldnt
give the debtor any excuses for not
534 BLE (CREDITORS)
ices for goods or services have
een paid Organizations often regard the
not
to delay all payments until the latest possible date Regular weekly or
The firm make it its objective is to get the money - not to score points or get
even
MANAGING ACCOUNTS PAYA
Creditors (Accounts Payable) are suppliers whose invo
been processed but who have not yet b
amount owing to creditors as a source of free credit However creditor
administration systems are expensive and time-consuming to run The over-riding
concern in this area should be to minimize costs with simple procedures
While it is unnecessary to pay accounts before they fall due it is usually
worthwhile
Page 26 of 46
fortnightly payment of all due accounts is the simplest technique for creditor
management
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Electronic payments (direct credits) are cheaper than check payments considering
that transaction fees and overheads more than balance the advantage of delayed
presentation Some suppliers are reluctant to receive payments by this method but in
view of the substantial cost advantage (and the advantages to the suppliers
themselves) departments may wish to encourage suppliers to accept this option
However electronic payments are likely to be used in conjunction with rather than
as a replacement for check payments
Applying Best Practices in Managing Accounts Payable
f course simply deferring payments to suppliers could have adverse consequences
O
that more than offset the benefits of this additional cash flow Therefore it is
important to develop a holistic approach The firm should consider the following
best practices for payables management
Managing payment dates and terms to maximize cash flow ndash
y reporting on
receivable and
id penalty charges and taking advantage of
wer vendors and negotiate for more
to buying consortia with others even
voices for
payment based on receipt of goods or receipt of invoice whichever
comes later
Calculating and setting performance targets Regularl
AP performance measures such as days in payables
Coordinating the AP processes with accounts
inventory management to ensure that the company is collecting more
cash than it is paying out
Paying bills on time to avo
prompt-payment discounts where the discounts exceed the companyrsquos
cost of working capital
Consolidating purchases with fe
favorable payment terms
Considering entering in
Page 27 of 46
competitors to obtain favorable supplier pricing and terms
Unless contract terms specify otherwise setting up in
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Page 28 of 46
Em
process
-time payments with Electronic Funds Transfer (EFT)
uraging vendors to utilize electronic invoice presentment
a
ndancies and more
ploying technology to automate the accounts payable transaction
es ndash
Making just-in
Using an electronic invoice-matching application
Enco
For companies with multiple locations or business units employing
shared service approach for AP to eliminate redu
quickly implement process improvements
Mainta
vendor
Communicating accounts payable requirements to suppliers at the
m key suppliers
for suggestions on how to improve the
Efficient a
and making th rsquos cash is just good business
ining open communications and building strong relationships with
s to access valuable trade credit ndash
beginning of transactions
Requesting summary invoicing fro
Requiring suppliers to send invoices directly to accounts payable
Asking tier-one suppliers
payment process
nd effective management of accounts payable helps improve cash flow ndash
e most of company
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
6 OVERVIEW OF VIRGIN GROUP
Virgin - one of the most respected brands in Britain - is now becoming the first global
brand name of the 21st century Virgin is involved in planes trains finance soft
drinks music mobile phones holidays cars wines publishing bridal wear - the lot
What tie all these businesses together are the values of its brand and the attitude of its
people Virgin has created over 200 companies worldwide employing over 25000
people Its total revenues around the world in 2002 exceeded pound4 billion (US $72
billion)
In 1970 Richard Branson founded Virgin as a mail order record retailer and not
long after he opened a record shop in Oxford Street London During 1972 a
recording studio was built in Oxfordshire and the first Virgin artist Mike Oldfield
recorded Tubular Bells which was released in 1973
This album went on to sell over 5 million copies Since then many household names
including Belinda Carlisle Genesis Phil Collins Janet Jackson and The Rolling
Stones have helped to make Virgin Music one of the top six record companies in the
world The equity of Virgin Music Group - record labels music publishing and
recording studios was sold to THORN EMI in 1992 in a US$1billion deal
Page 29 of 46
The Virgin Group has now expanded into international music Mega stores air
travel mobile financial retail music internet drinks rail hotels and leisure with
around 200 companies in over 30 countries
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
In Virgins customers eyes Virgin stands for value for money quality innovation
fun and a sense of competitive challenge It delivers a quality service by empowering
its employees and facilitates and monitors customer feedback to continually improve
the customers experience through innovation
When they start a new venture Virgin bases it on hard research and analysis
Typically they review the industry and put themselves in the customers shoes to see
what could make it better Virgin asks fundamental questions
Is this an opportunity for restructuring a market and creating competitive
advantage What are the competitors doing
Is the customer confused or badly served
Is this an opportunity for building the Virgin brand
Can we add value
Will it interact with its other businesses
Is there an appropriate trade-off between risk and reward
Page 30 of 46
Virgin is also able to draw on talented people from throughout the group New
ventures are often steered by people seconded from other parts of Virgin who bring
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
with them the trademark management style skills and experience Virgin frequently
creates partnerships with others to combine skills knowledge and market presence
and so on Contrary to what some people may think their constantly expanding and
eclectic empire is neither random nor reckless Each successive venture demonstrates
its skill in picking the right market and the right opportunity
7 OVERVIEW OF VIRGIN SOFT DRINKS
The Virgin Drinks Group first launched as the Virgin Cola Company in 1994 with
Virgin Cola in the UK Since then the company has ventured across the carbonated
soft drinks arena and beyond into energy drinks tea and flavored Colas This
expansion has lead to the evolution of the Virgin Drinks Company a company
whose aim is to put the excitement back into the world of soft drinks It launched in
Bangladesh in 1999 Virgin Soft Drinks is monitored by Global Beverage Co Ltd in
Bangladesh
Brief history of Virgin Drinks is given below
Page 31 of 46
1994 November Virgin Cola launched in the UK
1996 March Virgin Cola launched in France
1998 June Virgin Cola launched in Belgium
April Virgin Cola launched in the French West Indies
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
August Virgin Cola launched in Switzerland
1999 March Virgin Colours launched in Italy
March Virgin Cola launched in Japan
July Virgin Colours launched in South Africa
December Virgin Colours launched in Bangladesh
2001 January Sweden launched Virgin Colours
November Singapore launched Virgin Colours
2002 February Croatia launched Virgin Colours
June Russia launched Virgin Colours
June Tunisia launched Virgin Colours
2003 May Israel launched Virgin Colours
8 FINDINGS OF WORKING CAPITAL MANAGEMENT MAINTAINED BY
VIRGIN SOFT DRINKS IN BANGLADESH
81 CASH MANAGEMENT
811 Holding Cash and Marketable Securities
Although there are many good reasons why firm hold cash and marketable
securities Virgin Drinks holds cash and marketable securities for two reasons ndash
i) Cash for transactions
ii) Cash as hedges
This indicates that the firm does not hold cash and marketable securities for some
important reasons such as ndash
i) Near cash assets as hedges
Page 32 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
ii) Temporary investment and compensating balances
Virgin Soft Drinks does not invest in money market securities such as Treasury bill
commercial paper certificate of deposits bankerrsquos acceptance and repurchase
agreement This firm deposits its money in bank as currant AC or fixed AC They
say that they do not have enough money to invest in money market instrument
They also say that if they have enough money they will invest it in money market
short term securities We know that near cash interest earning assets can be
substituted for cash when motivation for holding these assets is the hedging of cash
flow uncertainties or is the temporary investment of surplus funds In this point
Virgins position is not good as there is no significant hedging against uncertainty of
cash
812 Floatation and Check Clearing
Virgin is very smart in handling the problem of transit time for checks Here mail
float takes 2 to 3 days at firm takes 025 day and clearing float takes 1-3 days Virgin
uses most of the strategies available for reducing the delay in receiving funds It
(Virgin) has linked Islami Bank which posses an accelerated clearing facility It uses
electronic collection process which ensures faster collection and its at the firm check
processing is satisfactory But Virgin does not use lockbox The reason behind this is
that it is not cost-effective for Virgin to set lockboxes At this point we can say that
Virgins check clearing mechanism is much good
813 Cash Concentration and Disbursement Management
Page 33 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks takes the matter of cash concentration very seriously They use all
the available cash concentration mechanism Virgin is a firm with small deposits
spread over a substantial number of banks and this is why the firm tends to use
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
depository transfer checks extensively If is less costly Virgin also uses automated
clearing house and wire transfer To Virgin wire transfer seems too costly
Like other firm Virgin tries to retain the cash for as long as possible But Virgin
always performs it in an ethical manner Virgin does not try to defeat the receiving
firmrsquos attempts to reduce the float on incoming checks It does not take any strategy
for increasing mail float at firm float and clearing float on its outgoing checks To
Virgin it is deemed to be unethical It thinks that maximization of disbursement float
will not go unnoticed by sophisticated creditors for very long When it is noticed it
will negatively affect relations with these creditors reducing the firmrsquos bargaining
power with them This may ultimately cost Virgin dearly when future prices and
delivery schedules for goods and services purchased from trade creditors are
negotiated Virgin follows ldquoZero-Balance Accountsrdquo methods for managing
disbursement It thinks that in this method the coordination of funds inflows to
disbursement banks with the presentation of checks does not work to the detriment
of creditors since the firmrsquos checks to them are honored as presented and this strategy
does not affect float significantly Controlled disbursing method is less attractive to
Virgin because zero-balance system is already feasible
814 Cash Forecasting
Cash Forecasting and Its Types
Page 34 of 46
Virgin forecasts the future cash inflows and outflows To Virgin cash forecast is an
important part of the firmrsquos cash control system and is one of the forecasts that are
part of the Virginrsquos financial plan Virgin forecasts cash on monthly basis and on
yearly basis Virgin does not forecast on daily basis assuming that the temporary
shortage of funds within these periods can be covered without value cost eg
advance receipts from customers Virginrsquos cash forecasting system involves a
combination of distribution and scheduling The receipts and disbursements
approach of cash forecasting is used in virgin This method is used because it
minutely traces the movement of cash and very close control of cash is possible
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Virgin does not use adjusted net income approach on two grounds First it does not
permit the tracing of the individual types of cash inflows and outflows for any given
period which is often useful information for virgin Second it is not simple to use
Items to be Forecast
Virgin does not forecast all the items It forecasts only major items eg accounts
receivable notes receivable payroll cash purchases of raw materials In this regard
virgin trade off between cost and benefit
Methods of Financial Forecasting
Virgin forecasts the future level of financial variable such as cash level asset level or
liability level We know in short term forecasts many things will result from plans
and events that are already in place (contracts capital budgets long-range financing
plans and so forth) But in the long run most things can vary and are dependent on
outside influences such as the firmrsquos long-term growth rate Since Virginrsquos cash
forecasting deals mostly with near future many of the items on the cash forecasts are
estimated by some variation of the spot method and remaining estimates are mostly
on a ldquoproportion of another accountrdquo basis with this ldquoother accountrdquo often being a
particular periodrsquos sales Virgin uses the other two methods less frequently
Using Cash Forecast
Virgin forecasts cash for meeting general objectives (ie to know the available funds
for investment and need financing) and for meeting some special objectives (eg to
know whether the firm will fulfill its out of debt requirement) But it is matter to note
that Virgin does not make any short term investment of its surplus cash but only keep
this surplus in Bank Account
Page 35 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Sources of Uncertainty in Cash Forecasting and Hedging Uncertainties
Virgin faces uncertainty in cash forecasting mainly from two sources These are ndash
sales and production cost In peak season (hot season like autumn summer) sales
increases but in dull season (eg in winter) sales decreases drastically Production
cost may be increased because of increase of price of sugar chemicals aluminum
can Virgin follows two methods for hedging cash balance uncertainties These are ndash
i) Holding a stock of extra cash and
ii) Extra borrowing capacity
815 Modes for the Management of Cash and Temporary Investments
Virgin does not follow any of these methods wholly Virgin receives cash
continuously and pays salary at steady rate and pays continuously for other
expenses So it neither follows Baumol model nor Beranek model It has no upper
control limit lower control limit return point in case cash management So it neither
follows Miller-Orr model nor Stone model
In Summary
Page 36 of 46
Standard Compliance by Virgin Soft Drinks
Generally all firms hold cash and
marketable securities
Virgin holds only cash
Firms hold cash and marketable
securities for some reasons like
bull Cash for transactions
bull Cash and near-cash assets as
hedges
bull Temporary investments
bull Compensating balances
Virgin holds cash only for
two reasons ndash
bull Cash for transactions
bull Cash as hedges
Available money market instruments Virgin does not invest in any such
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
(short term securities) are ndash
Treasury Bills
Commercial Paper
Certificates of Deposit
Bankerrsquos Acceptance
Repurch menase Agree ts
instruments They only keep cash in
Bank Account
Mail Float
(1 to 5 days)
At Firm
Float
(025 to 1
day)
Clearing
Float
(0 to
2 days)
Mail Float
(2 to 3 days)
At firm
Float
(025
day)
Clearing
Float
(1 to 3
days)
Figure Transit time for a typical check Figure Transit time for a check for
Virgin
Strategies that firms can use to reduce
the delay in receiving funds are ndash
Selecting of Banks with
accelerated clearing capabilities
of check processing Acceleration
at the firm
ectronic collection Use of el
procedures
Use of lockboxes
Virgin follows the first three strategies
but does not use lockboxes
Available cash concentration
mechanisms are ndash
Depository transfer check
ouse Automated Clearing H
(ACH) electronic transfer)
Wire transfer
Virgin uses all these mechanisms of
cash concentration
Available sets of techniques for cash
disbursement management are ndash
ement of disbursement
Page 37 of 46
Manag
float
Virgin uses zero-balance accounts
technique
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Zero-Balance Accounts
Controlled disbursing
Firms may make cash flow forecasts
over periods of various lengths yearly
flows quarterly flows monthly flows
weekly flows or even daily flows
Virgin forecasts cash on yearly basis and
monthly basis
Cash forecasting system may involve ndash
Distribution
Scheduling
Virginrsquos cash forecasting system
involves a combination of distribution
and scheduling
Two common approaches to cash flow
in generating the cash forecast
and disbursement Receipts
approach
Adjusted net income approach
Virgin uses the receipts and
disbursement approach
There are many items to forecast Virgin forecasts only major items like
AR payroll etc
Four common approach to forecasting
fina i ndash nc al variables are
Spot method
Proportion to another account
Compounded growth
Multiple dependencies
Virgin uses spot method for forecasting
cash It uses proportion to another
account method for other variables and
remaining two methods are frequently
used
Sources of uncertainty in cash
forecasting are ndash
Sales uncertainty
Collection rate uncertainty
Production cost uncertainty
Capital outflow uncertainty
Virgin faces uncertainty mainly from
sales and production cost
Methods for hedging cash balance
unc a
Page 38 of 46
ert inties are ndash
i) Holding a stock of extra cash
Virgin two available methods for
hedging cash balance uncertainties
Th ese are ndash
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
ii) stock of near-cash Holding a
assets
iii) Extra borrowing capacity
iv) ary surpluses in Investing tempor
near-cash assets
i) Holding a stock of extra cash
ii) Extra borrowing capacity
(advance receipt from
customers)
Models for the management of cash and
temporary investments are ndash Baumol
model Beranek model Miller-Orr
model and Stone model
Virgin does not follow any method
wholly but a combination of Baumol
model and Beranek model is occurred
82 INVENTORY MANAGEMENT
21 Certainty Approach
isnt used in
irgin because it thinks it is not possible to implement in Bangladesh
d time is one to three days It
oes not use ABC system of inventory management
8
Main item of inventory of Virgin is Can pet chip sugar label chemical artificial
sweet etc Virgin maintains a minimum level of inventory but it does not have to face
problems because inventory is managed efficiently just-in-time (JIT)
V
Virgin maintains buffer stock because of the shortage of work-in-process (WIP)
inventory Its production process may also be hampered Thats why it maintains
safety stock to avoid stock out cost In case of imported goods normal lead time is
about one month and within the country normal lea
d
Page 39 of 46
Inventory Model
In reality Virgin does not use any of models of EOQ ordering and holding strategy
and safety stock strategy They maintain inventory based on their prior experience
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
822 Uncertainty Approach
Virgin does not use any model for handling inventory uncertainty It says that such
decision depends on business cycle and market situation Long before Eid festival
they bought large amount of sugar because of price increase on the occasion of Eid
In summary
Standard Compliance by Virgin Soft Drinks
Firms maintain inventory to guard
against several problems
Virgin maintains a minimum level of
inventory which is managed efficiently
Some firms use JIT to avoid inventory
cost
JIT is not used by Virgin as it thinks it is
impossible to implement in Bangladesh
Firms maintain buffer stock Virgin maintains buffer stock too
Firms maintain safety stock to avoid
shortage cost
Virgin also maintains safety stock
Firms use ABC system to monitor
inventory
Virgin doesnt use ABC system
EOQ model is an appropriate method
for measuring quantity that has to be
ordered per order
Virgin does not use EOQ model rather
makes order based on experience and
market demand
83 MANAGING ACCOUNTS RECEIVABLE (DEBTORS)
831 Terms of Sale Decision
Page 40 of 46
Virgin offers the term 210 net 30 enables the customers to deduct 2 percent from the
face value of the bill when paying within the first 10 days but if the discount is not
taken the customer must remit the full amount within 30 days But Virgin does not
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
offer the same terms of sale to all customers For prime customers it offers special
terms of sale In setting an appropriate term of sale it costs and benefits regarding
this are compared It uses the standard approach of terms of sale decision as it is
simple to use
832 Credit Granting Decisions
In case of Virgin the Capital and Character of Five Cs get more importance
Although there are many problems with the traditional approach Virgin uses it
because of its simplicity Virgin does not use Net Present Value (NPV) method in
credit granting decision It thinks that NPV is an appropriate method and should be
used next time It does not face any severe problem because of bad debts The reason
is that notes receivable is used when credit is granted
833 Monitoring Accounts Receivable
Virgin monitors its accounts receivable Virgin believes that in any case both positive
and negative durations in accounts signal differences from the results that
management believe to be the most advantageous for the firm
Tools for Monitoring Accounts Receivable
Page 41 of 46
For monitoring accounts receivable there are several tools such as aging schedule
the ratios of receivable outstanding to original sales customers payment proportion
and sales weighted DSO (Days Sales Outstanding) For monitoring accounts
receivable Virgin uses aging schedule fractions and traditional DSO statistics
because of their simplicity in use Although payment proportions ratios of
receivables outstanding and sales weighted DSO methods are free from inherent bias
None of these is used because all these are complex to maintain
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
In summary
Page 42 of 46
Standard Compliance by Virgin Soft Drinks
Generals terms of sale is 210 net 30 Normally Virgin also use general terms
of sale ie 210 net 30
Firms do not offer the same terms of
sale to all customers
Yes For prime customers Virgin offers
special terms of sale
Approaches of terms of sale decisions
are ndash
bull Standard approach
bull Multi period approach
Virgin uses standard approach of terms
of sale decision as it is simple to use and
understand
Source of credit information are ndash
Sellers prior experience with the
customer
Credit agency ratings and
reports
Personal contact with the
applicants bank and other
creditors
Analysis of applicants financial
statements
Customer visit
Main source of credit information to
Virgin is its prior experience with the
customer All other sources are not cost-
effective for Virgin
Approaches of credit granting to
marginal accounts are ndash
Traditional approach
Net Present Value (NPV)
approach
It uses traditional approach still now but
thinks that NPV should be used for the
next periods
Firms monitor accounts receivable
because deviations from the expected
levels of turnover and of bad debt can
Virgin also monitors its accounts
receivable
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
signal several different problems
Different tools for monitoring accounts
receivable are ndash
Aging schedule
Ratios of receivables
outstanding to original sales
Customers payment
proportions
Sales-weighted DSO
For monitoring accounts receivable
Virgin uses aging schedule and
traditional sales outstanding statistics
84 MANAGING ACCOUNTS PAYABLE (CREDITORS)
Virgin has almost accounts payable of Tk 8000000 But most of its liabilities are to
the banks rather than suppliers But we dont have any clear information about
Virgins accounts payable
9 RECOMMENDATION
Virgin should invest its surplus cash in short term marketable securities
because it is suitable hedging against cash uncertainties and will also give
some returns (interest income)
Virgin should publish its own annual report which will satisfy information
needs of stakeholders and also increase the credibility of information provided
by Virgin
Page 43 of 46
Virgin should use multi period approach in terms of sale decision because
standard approach which is already exists in Virgin has some inherent
problems
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
It should stop using traditional approach from now It should use NPV
method in credit granting to marginal accounts
In monitoring accounts receivable Virgin should use sales-weighted DSO
method because it has least limitation compared to the others
It should be more flexible in granting credit which will ultimately increase its
sales
To get the appropriate number of quantity to be ordered per order it should
use DSO model
It should be ABC system for proper monitoring of inventory
10 CONCLUSION
The use of other peoples money in business is usually an expensive resource Before
looking outside for finance a firm should examine its own working capital cycle to
make sure that every rand of its own internal funds is being fully utilized Good
management of working capital is part of good financial management Effective use
of working capital will contribute to the operational efficiency of the whole
organization optimum use will help to generate maximum returns Furthermore
working capital management is not an end in itself It is an integral part of the firms
overall management The needs of efficient working capital management must be
considered in relation to other aspects of the Virgins financial and non-financial
performance Thats why when planning the development of a business it is critical
that the impact of working capital be fully assessed
Page 44 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
BIBLIOGRAPHY
Scherr FC (1989) International Edition Prentice-Hall International Inc Modern
Working Capital Management Text and Cases
Hussain Riaz (2002) Working Capital Management
Robertson Lonnie (July 1998) Inventory Management
httpwwwasashoporg visited on March 13 2006
The Art of Cash Management
httpwwwinccom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management
httpwwwstudyfinancecom visited on March 13 2006
White Paper ndash Managing Working Capital
httpwwwplanwareorg visited on March 13 2006
Management of Working Capital
httpwwwbusinesscentralcoza visited on March 13 2006
Cash Management
httpwwwsbagov visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management Objectives
httpwpsprenhallcom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management
Page 45 of 46
httpwwwadvancemecom visited on March 13 2006
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Business Receivables Financing
httpwwwbbtcom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Finance
http wwwfnbcoza visited on March 13 2006
Tips to manage your working capital
httpsmallbusinessninemsncomau visited on March 13 2006
Inventory Financing
httpwwwfranklincapitalnetworkcom visited on March 13 2006
Accounts Receivable Management
httpwwwfranklincapitalnetworkcom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management
httpwwwtreasurygovtnz visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management
httpwwwtreasurystrategiescom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Works
httpwwwinvestopediacom visited on March 13 2006
Treasury Services
httpwwwjpmorganchasecom visited on March 13 2006
what were about
Page 46 of 46
httpwwwvirgincom visited on March 13 2006
Annexure
Annexure
Interview with YASEER RIZVI
Mr Yaseer Rizvi the DMD of Global Beverage Co Ltd obtained his MBA degree
from a reputed university He had been the Director of Ocean Container Ltd before
joining in Global Beverage Co Ltd He possesses a nice personality
I interviewed Yaseer Rizvi Excerpts from his interview are as follows ndash
Shah Kamal Sir would you please tell me do you invest in short term marketable securities
Yaseer Rizvi Basically we do not invest our surplus cash in short term marketable
securities like T-Bill commercial paper certificate of deposit etc But we keep our
surplus cash in Bank
Shah Kamal Would you tell me something about transit time for a typical check
Yaseer Rizvi Well in Virgin the transit time for a typical check is ndash
For mail float 2 to 3 days
At firm float 6 hours
Clearing float 1 to 3 days
Shah Kamal Do you maintain any cash concentration mechanism like depository transfer check automated clearing house and wire transfer
i
Annexure
Yaseer Rizvi Our position in this case is very strong as we use all the mechanisms
you mentioned As Virgin is a firm with small deposits spread over a substantial
number of banks so we tend to use depository transfer checks extensively It is less
costly We also use automated clearing house and wire transfer but later is used in a
less extent
Shah Kamal Sir what techniques of disbursement management is used by your firm
Yaseer Rizvi Like other firms Virgin tries to retain the cash for as long as possible
But we always perform it in an ethical manner We do not use management of
disbursement float as it seems unethical We follow Zero-Balance Accounts method
for managing disbursement We do not prefer Controlled Disbursing method since
Zero-Balance system is already practiced in Virgin
Shah Kamal How do you hedge cash balance uncertainties
Yaseer Rizvi Well you may say that we do not invest in short term securities but for
facing cash difficulties we keep our surplus cash in bank
Shah Kamal Sir would you please tell me the general terms of sale of Virgin
Yaseer Rizvi Though it is difficult to maintain a fixed terms of sale our general terms
of sale is 210 n30 But for prime customers we offer special terms of sale
Shah Kamal What are the sources of credit information in case of your firm
Yaseer Rizvi We grant credit on the basis of prior experience with the customers In
case of a new customer personal contact is weighted
Shah Kamal Does your firm consider 5 Cs in granting credit
ii
Annexure
Yaseer Rizvi In case of Virgin Capital and Character get more importance than the
others Mind one thing personal relationship is the main measure in granting credit
Shah Kamal Do you use NPV method in credit granting decisions
Yaseer Rizvi We do not use NPV method But we think that NPV is a suitable
method and we have to use it from the next period
Shah Kamal Sir how do you handle the problem of bad debt
Yaseer Rizvi Well in this case our position is very strong Yet we do not face any
problem because of bad debt Just note that we make more than 80 of sales in cash
and we monitor accounts receivable very carefully
Shah Kamal What level of inventory is maintained by Virgin
Yaseer Rizvi We maintain a minimum level of inventory but do not have to face
stock out problems because inventory is managed efficiently
Shah Kamal What is the normal lead time
Yaseer Rizvi In case of imported goods normal lead time is about 1 month and when
we purchase raw materials from inside the country lead time is 1 to 3 days
Shah Kamal What method do you use for managing inventory
Yaseer Rizvi We do not use any method particularly rather inventory decision
depends on business cycle and market situation Long before the Eid festival we
bought large amount of sugar because price of sugar was increased on the occasion
of Eid
iii
Annexure
Shah Kamal What are the main items of inventory of your firm
Yaseer Rizvi Well these are ndash aluminum can pet chip sugar label chemical and
artificial sweet
Shah Kamal What are the uncertainties in maintaining appropriate level of stock
Yaseer Rizvi These are ndash
bull Increase in price of raw materials
bull Sales uncertainty
bull Market trends etc
Shah Kamal Thank you for your kind cooperation
Yaseer Rizvi Most Welcome
iv
Global Beverage Company Limited
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Page 23 of 46
Being professional when accepting new accounts and especially larger ones
Checking out each customer thoroughly before the firm offers credit Use
credit agencies bank references industry sources etc
Establishing credit limits for each customer and sticking to them
Continuously reviewing these limits when it suspects tough times are coming
or if operating in a volatile sector
Keeping very close to the firms larger customers
Invoicing promptly and clearly
Considering charging penalties on overdue accounts
Considering accepting credit debit cards as a payment option
Monitoring its debtor balances and ageing schedules and dont let any debts
get too large or too old
Debtor management includes both pre-sale and debt collection strategies
Pre-sale strategies include
Offering cash discounts for early payment andor imposing penalties for late
payment
Agreeing payment terms in advance
Requiring cash before delivery
Setting credit limits
ning credit Setting criteria for obtai
Billing as early as possible
rogress payments
ost-sale strategies include
for collecting the debt upon the center that made the sale
Requiring deposits andor p
P
Placing the responsibility
Identifying long overdue balances and doubtful debts by regular analytical reviews
Having an established procedure for late collections such as
A reminder
A letter
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Page 24 of 46
ion of further credit Cancellat
Telephone calls
n agency Use of a collectio
he firm should recognize that the longer someone owes firm the greater the chance
Legal action
T
it will never get paid If the average age of debtors is getting longer or is already very
long it may need to look for the following possible defects
Weak credit judgment
res Poor collection procedu
ms Lax enforcement of credit ter
Slow issue of invoices or statements
Errors in invoices or statements
Customer dissatisfaction
Debtors due over 90 days (unless within agreed credit terms) should generally
demand immediate attention For example warning signs of a future bad debt ndash
Longer credit terms taken with approval particularly for smaller orders
Use of post-dated checks by debtors who normally settle within agreed terms
Evidence of customers switching to additional suppliers for the same goods
New customers who are reluctant to give credit references
Cre G
Receiving part payments from debtors
dit ranting to Marginal Accounts
Traditional Approach
In the traditional approach to the credit granting decision it is the credit analysts job
rmation that has been collected and reach a judgment
regarding the applicants creditworthiness One traditional way of organizing this
to synthesize all the info
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
information is by characterizing the applicant along five dimensions These
dimensions are called the Five Cs of credit ndash
Capital
Character
Collateral
and Capacity
Conditions
Net Present Value (NPV) Approach
Once a firm has assessed the creditworthiness of a customer it has to decide whether
r not credit should be granted The firm should use the NPV rule to make the
ld be granted
Figure
o
decision If NPV is positive credit shou
Credit Granting Decision
Credit Granting Decision
he act of collecting money is one which most people dislike for many reasons and
therefore put on the long f selves there is something
ore urgent or important that demands their attention now There is nothing more
T
inger because they convince them
m
important than getting paid for firms product or service A customer who does not
Page 25 of 46
Grand Credit
Payment received Payment not received
Benefit of present value of future net cash flow
Cost of present value ment of lost invest
Net Payoff PV of benefit-cost
No Credit
No Payoff
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
pay is not a customer Here are a few ideas that may help the firm in collecting
money from debtors
Firm should develop appropriate procedures for handling late payments
It should track and pursue late payers
It might get external help if its own efforts fail
or money its firms and it is entitled Company shouldnt feel guilty asking f
to it
ction
Firm must make that call now And it should keep asking until it gets some
satisfa
lessens the problem
In difficult circumstances take what the firm can now and agree terms for the
remainder It
paying
When asking for money be hard on the issue - but soft on the person It shouldnt
give the debtor any excuses for not
534 BLE (CREDITORS)
ices for goods or services have
een paid Organizations often regard the
not
to delay all payments until the latest possible date Regular weekly or
The firm make it its objective is to get the money - not to score points or get
even
MANAGING ACCOUNTS PAYA
Creditors (Accounts Payable) are suppliers whose invo
been processed but who have not yet b
amount owing to creditors as a source of free credit However creditor
administration systems are expensive and time-consuming to run The over-riding
concern in this area should be to minimize costs with simple procedures
While it is unnecessary to pay accounts before they fall due it is usually
worthwhile
Page 26 of 46
fortnightly payment of all due accounts is the simplest technique for creditor
management
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Electronic payments (direct credits) are cheaper than check payments considering
that transaction fees and overheads more than balance the advantage of delayed
presentation Some suppliers are reluctant to receive payments by this method but in
view of the substantial cost advantage (and the advantages to the suppliers
themselves) departments may wish to encourage suppliers to accept this option
However electronic payments are likely to be used in conjunction with rather than
as a replacement for check payments
Applying Best Practices in Managing Accounts Payable
f course simply deferring payments to suppliers could have adverse consequences
O
that more than offset the benefits of this additional cash flow Therefore it is
important to develop a holistic approach The firm should consider the following
best practices for payables management
Managing payment dates and terms to maximize cash flow ndash
y reporting on
receivable and
id penalty charges and taking advantage of
wer vendors and negotiate for more
to buying consortia with others even
voices for
payment based on receipt of goods or receipt of invoice whichever
comes later
Calculating and setting performance targets Regularl
AP performance measures such as days in payables
Coordinating the AP processes with accounts
inventory management to ensure that the company is collecting more
cash than it is paying out
Paying bills on time to avo
prompt-payment discounts where the discounts exceed the companyrsquos
cost of working capital
Consolidating purchases with fe
favorable payment terms
Considering entering in
Page 27 of 46
competitors to obtain favorable supplier pricing and terms
Unless contract terms specify otherwise setting up in
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Page 28 of 46
Em
process
-time payments with Electronic Funds Transfer (EFT)
uraging vendors to utilize electronic invoice presentment
a
ndancies and more
ploying technology to automate the accounts payable transaction
es ndash
Making just-in
Using an electronic invoice-matching application
Enco
For companies with multiple locations or business units employing
shared service approach for AP to eliminate redu
quickly implement process improvements
Mainta
vendor
Communicating accounts payable requirements to suppliers at the
m key suppliers
for suggestions on how to improve the
Efficient a
and making th rsquos cash is just good business
ining open communications and building strong relationships with
s to access valuable trade credit ndash
beginning of transactions
Requesting summary invoicing fro
Requiring suppliers to send invoices directly to accounts payable
Asking tier-one suppliers
payment process
nd effective management of accounts payable helps improve cash flow ndash
e most of company
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
6 OVERVIEW OF VIRGIN GROUP
Virgin - one of the most respected brands in Britain - is now becoming the first global
brand name of the 21st century Virgin is involved in planes trains finance soft
drinks music mobile phones holidays cars wines publishing bridal wear - the lot
What tie all these businesses together are the values of its brand and the attitude of its
people Virgin has created over 200 companies worldwide employing over 25000
people Its total revenues around the world in 2002 exceeded pound4 billion (US $72
billion)
In 1970 Richard Branson founded Virgin as a mail order record retailer and not
long after he opened a record shop in Oxford Street London During 1972 a
recording studio was built in Oxfordshire and the first Virgin artist Mike Oldfield
recorded Tubular Bells which was released in 1973
This album went on to sell over 5 million copies Since then many household names
including Belinda Carlisle Genesis Phil Collins Janet Jackson and The Rolling
Stones have helped to make Virgin Music one of the top six record companies in the
world The equity of Virgin Music Group - record labels music publishing and
recording studios was sold to THORN EMI in 1992 in a US$1billion deal
Page 29 of 46
The Virgin Group has now expanded into international music Mega stores air
travel mobile financial retail music internet drinks rail hotels and leisure with
around 200 companies in over 30 countries
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
In Virgins customers eyes Virgin stands for value for money quality innovation
fun and a sense of competitive challenge It delivers a quality service by empowering
its employees and facilitates and monitors customer feedback to continually improve
the customers experience through innovation
When they start a new venture Virgin bases it on hard research and analysis
Typically they review the industry and put themselves in the customers shoes to see
what could make it better Virgin asks fundamental questions
Is this an opportunity for restructuring a market and creating competitive
advantage What are the competitors doing
Is the customer confused or badly served
Is this an opportunity for building the Virgin brand
Can we add value
Will it interact with its other businesses
Is there an appropriate trade-off between risk and reward
Page 30 of 46
Virgin is also able to draw on talented people from throughout the group New
ventures are often steered by people seconded from other parts of Virgin who bring
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
with them the trademark management style skills and experience Virgin frequently
creates partnerships with others to combine skills knowledge and market presence
and so on Contrary to what some people may think their constantly expanding and
eclectic empire is neither random nor reckless Each successive venture demonstrates
its skill in picking the right market and the right opportunity
7 OVERVIEW OF VIRGIN SOFT DRINKS
The Virgin Drinks Group first launched as the Virgin Cola Company in 1994 with
Virgin Cola in the UK Since then the company has ventured across the carbonated
soft drinks arena and beyond into energy drinks tea and flavored Colas This
expansion has lead to the evolution of the Virgin Drinks Company a company
whose aim is to put the excitement back into the world of soft drinks It launched in
Bangladesh in 1999 Virgin Soft Drinks is monitored by Global Beverage Co Ltd in
Bangladesh
Brief history of Virgin Drinks is given below
Page 31 of 46
1994 November Virgin Cola launched in the UK
1996 March Virgin Cola launched in France
1998 June Virgin Cola launched in Belgium
April Virgin Cola launched in the French West Indies
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
August Virgin Cola launched in Switzerland
1999 March Virgin Colours launched in Italy
March Virgin Cola launched in Japan
July Virgin Colours launched in South Africa
December Virgin Colours launched in Bangladesh
2001 January Sweden launched Virgin Colours
November Singapore launched Virgin Colours
2002 February Croatia launched Virgin Colours
June Russia launched Virgin Colours
June Tunisia launched Virgin Colours
2003 May Israel launched Virgin Colours
8 FINDINGS OF WORKING CAPITAL MANAGEMENT MAINTAINED BY
VIRGIN SOFT DRINKS IN BANGLADESH
81 CASH MANAGEMENT
811 Holding Cash and Marketable Securities
Although there are many good reasons why firm hold cash and marketable
securities Virgin Drinks holds cash and marketable securities for two reasons ndash
i) Cash for transactions
ii) Cash as hedges
This indicates that the firm does not hold cash and marketable securities for some
important reasons such as ndash
i) Near cash assets as hedges
Page 32 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
ii) Temporary investment and compensating balances
Virgin Soft Drinks does not invest in money market securities such as Treasury bill
commercial paper certificate of deposits bankerrsquos acceptance and repurchase
agreement This firm deposits its money in bank as currant AC or fixed AC They
say that they do not have enough money to invest in money market instrument
They also say that if they have enough money they will invest it in money market
short term securities We know that near cash interest earning assets can be
substituted for cash when motivation for holding these assets is the hedging of cash
flow uncertainties or is the temporary investment of surplus funds In this point
Virgins position is not good as there is no significant hedging against uncertainty of
cash
812 Floatation and Check Clearing
Virgin is very smart in handling the problem of transit time for checks Here mail
float takes 2 to 3 days at firm takes 025 day and clearing float takes 1-3 days Virgin
uses most of the strategies available for reducing the delay in receiving funds It
(Virgin) has linked Islami Bank which posses an accelerated clearing facility It uses
electronic collection process which ensures faster collection and its at the firm check
processing is satisfactory But Virgin does not use lockbox The reason behind this is
that it is not cost-effective for Virgin to set lockboxes At this point we can say that
Virgins check clearing mechanism is much good
813 Cash Concentration and Disbursement Management
Page 33 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks takes the matter of cash concentration very seriously They use all
the available cash concentration mechanism Virgin is a firm with small deposits
spread over a substantial number of banks and this is why the firm tends to use
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
depository transfer checks extensively If is less costly Virgin also uses automated
clearing house and wire transfer To Virgin wire transfer seems too costly
Like other firm Virgin tries to retain the cash for as long as possible But Virgin
always performs it in an ethical manner Virgin does not try to defeat the receiving
firmrsquos attempts to reduce the float on incoming checks It does not take any strategy
for increasing mail float at firm float and clearing float on its outgoing checks To
Virgin it is deemed to be unethical It thinks that maximization of disbursement float
will not go unnoticed by sophisticated creditors for very long When it is noticed it
will negatively affect relations with these creditors reducing the firmrsquos bargaining
power with them This may ultimately cost Virgin dearly when future prices and
delivery schedules for goods and services purchased from trade creditors are
negotiated Virgin follows ldquoZero-Balance Accountsrdquo methods for managing
disbursement It thinks that in this method the coordination of funds inflows to
disbursement banks with the presentation of checks does not work to the detriment
of creditors since the firmrsquos checks to them are honored as presented and this strategy
does not affect float significantly Controlled disbursing method is less attractive to
Virgin because zero-balance system is already feasible
814 Cash Forecasting
Cash Forecasting and Its Types
Page 34 of 46
Virgin forecasts the future cash inflows and outflows To Virgin cash forecast is an
important part of the firmrsquos cash control system and is one of the forecasts that are
part of the Virginrsquos financial plan Virgin forecasts cash on monthly basis and on
yearly basis Virgin does not forecast on daily basis assuming that the temporary
shortage of funds within these periods can be covered without value cost eg
advance receipts from customers Virginrsquos cash forecasting system involves a
combination of distribution and scheduling The receipts and disbursements
approach of cash forecasting is used in virgin This method is used because it
minutely traces the movement of cash and very close control of cash is possible
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Virgin does not use adjusted net income approach on two grounds First it does not
permit the tracing of the individual types of cash inflows and outflows for any given
period which is often useful information for virgin Second it is not simple to use
Items to be Forecast
Virgin does not forecast all the items It forecasts only major items eg accounts
receivable notes receivable payroll cash purchases of raw materials In this regard
virgin trade off between cost and benefit
Methods of Financial Forecasting
Virgin forecasts the future level of financial variable such as cash level asset level or
liability level We know in short term forecasts many things will result from plans
and events that are already in place (contracts capital budgets long-range financing
plans and so forth) But in the long run most things can vary and are dependent on
outside influences such as the firmrsquos long-term growth rate Since Virginrsquos cash
forecasting deals mostly with near future many of the items on the cash forecasts are
estimated by some variation of the spot method and remaining estimates are mostly
on a ldquoproportion of another accountrdquo basis with this ldquoother accountrdquo often being a
particular periodrsquos sales Virgin uses the other two methods less frequently
Using Cash Forecast
Virgin forecasts cash for meeting general objectives (ie to know the available funds
for investment and need financing) and for meeting some special objectives (eg to
know whether the firm will fulfill its out of debt requirement) But it is matter to note
that Virgin does not make any short term investment of its surplus cash but only keep
this surplus in Bank Account
Page 35 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Sources of Uncertainty in Cash Forecasting and Hedging Uncertainties
Virgin faces uncertainty in cash forecasting mainly from two sources These are ndash
sales and production cost In peak season (hot season like autumn summer) sales
increases but in dull season (eg in winter) sales decreases drastically Production
cost may be increased because of increase of price of sugar chemicals aluminum
can Virgin follows two methods for hedging cash balance uncertainties These are ndash
i) Holding a stock of extra cash and
ii) Extra borrowing capacity
815 Modes for the Management of Cash and Temporary Investments
Virgin does not follow any of these methods wholly Virgin receives cash
continuously and pays salary at steady rate and pays continuously for other
expenses So it neither follows Baumol model nor Beranek model It has no upper
control limit lower control limit return point in case cash management So it neither
follows Miller-Orr model nor Stone model
In Summary
Page 36 of 46
Standard Compliance by Virgin Soft Drinks
Generally all firms hold cash and
marketable securities
Virgin holds only cash
Firms hold cash and marketable
securities for some reasons like
bull Cash for transactions
bull Cash and near-cash assets as
hedges
bull Temporary investments
bull Compensating balances
Virgin holds cash only for
two reasons ndash
bull Cash for transactions
bull Cash as hedges
Available money market instruments Virgin does not invest in any such
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
(short term securities) are ndash
Treasury Bills
Commercial Paper
Certificates of Deposit
Bankerrsquos Acceptance
Repurch menase Agree ts
instruments They only keep cash in
Bank Account
Mail Float
(1 to 5 days)
At Firm
Float
(025 to 1
day)
Clearing
Float
(0 to
2 days)
Mail Float
(2 to 3 days)
At firm
Float
(025
day)
Clearing
Float
(1 to 3
days)
Figure Transit time for a typical check Figure Transit time for a check for
Virgin
Strategies that firms can use to reduce
the delay in receiving funds are ndash
Selecting of Banks with
accelerated clearing capabilities
of check processing Acceleration
at the firm
ectronic collection Use of el
procedures
Use of lockboxes
Virgin follows the first three strategies
but does not use lockboxes
Available cash concentration
mechanisms are ndash
Depository transfer check
ouse Automated Clearing H
(ACH) electronic transfer)
Wire transfer
Virgin uses all these mechanisms of
cash concentration
Available sets of techniques for cash
disbursement management are ndash
ement of disbursement
Page 37 of 46
Manag
float
Virgin uses zero-balance accounts
technique
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Zero-Balance Accounts
Controlled disbursing
Firms may make cash flow forecasts
over periods of various lengths yearly
flows quarterly flows monthly flows
weekly flows or even daily flows
Virgin forecasts cash on yearly basis and
monthly basis
Cash forecasting system may involve ndash
Distribution
Scheduling
Virginrsquos cash forecasting system
involves a combination of distribution
and scheduling
Two common approaches to cash flow
in generating the cash forecast
and disbursement Receipts
approach
Adjusted net income approach
Virgin uses the receipts and
disbursement approach
There are many items to forecast Virgin forecasts only major items like
AR payroll etc
Four common approach to forecasting
fina i ndash nc al variables are
Spot method
Proportion to another account
Compounded growth
Multiple dependencies
Virgin uses spot method for forecasting
cash It uses proportion to another
account method for other variables and
remaining two methods are frequently
used
Sources of uncertainty in cash
forecasting are ndash
Sales uncertainty
Collection rate uncertainty
Production cost uncertainty
Capital outflow uncertainty
Virgin faces uncertainty mainly from
sales and production cost
Methods for hedging cash balance
unc a
Page 38 of 46
ert inties are ndash
i) Holding a stock of extra cash
Virgin two available methods for
hedging cash balance uncertainties
Th ese are ndash
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
ii) stock of near-cash Holding a
assets
iii) Extra borrowing capacity
iv) ary surpluses in Investing tempor
near-cash assets
i) Holding a stock of extra cash
ii) Extra borrowing capacity
(advance receipt from
customers)
Models for the management of cash and
temporary investments are ndash Baumol
model Beranek model Miller-Orr
model and Stone model
Virgin does not follow any method
wholly but a combination of Baumol
model and Beranek model is occurred
82 INVENTORY MANAGEMENT
21 Certainty Approach
isnt used in
irgin because it thinks it is not possible to implement in Bangladesh
d time is one to three days It
oes not use ABC system of inventory management
8
Main item of inventory of Virgin is Can pet chip sugar label chemical artificial
sweet etc Virgin maintains a minimum level of inventory but it does not have to face
problems because inventory is managed efficiently just-in-time (JIT)
V
Virgin maintains buffer stock because of the shortage of work-in-process (WIP)
inventory Its production process may also be hampered Thats why it maintains
safety stock to avoid stock out cost In case of imported goods normal lead time is
about one month and within the country normal lea
d
Page 39 of 46
Inventory Model
In reality Virgin does not use any of models of EOQ ordering and holding strategy
and safety stock strategy They maintain inventory based on their prior experience
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
822 Uncertainty Approach
Virgin does not use any model for handling inventory uncertainty It says that such
decision depends on business cycle and market situation Long before Eid festival
they bought large amount of sugar because of price increase on the occasion of Eid
In summary
Standard Compliance by Virgin Soft Drinks
Firms maintain inventory to guard
against several problems
Virgin maintains a minimum level of
inventory which is managed efficiently
Some firms use JIT to avoid inventory
cost
JIT is not used by Virgin as it thinks it is
impossible to implement in Bangladesh
Firms maintain buffer stock Virgin maintains buffer stock too
Firms maintain safety stock to avoid
shortage cost
Virgin also maintains safety stock
Firms use ABC system to monitor
inventory
Virgin doesnt use ABC system
EOQ model is an appropriate method
for measuring quantity that has to be
ordered per order
Virgin does not use EOQ model rather
makes order based on experience and
market demand
83 MANAGING ACCOUNTS RECEIVABLE (DEBTORS)
831 Terms of Sale Decision
Page 40 of 46
Virgin offers the term 210 net 30 enables the customers to deduct 2 percent from the
face value of the bill when paying within the first 10 days but if the discount is not
taken the customer must remit the full amount within 30 days But Virgin does not
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
offer the same terms of sale to all customers For prime customers it offers special
terms of sale In setting an appropriate term of sale it costs and benefits regarding
this are compared It uses the standard approach of terms of sale decision as it is
simple to use
832 Credit Granting Decisions
In case of Virgin the Capital and Character of Five Cs get more importance
Although there are many problems with the traditional approach Virgin uses it
because of its simplicity Virgin does not use Net Present Value (NPV) method in
credit granting decision It thinks that NPV is an appropriate method and should be
used next time It does not face any severe problem because of bad debts The reason
is that notes receivable is used when credit is granted
833 Monitoring Accounts Receivable
Virgin monitors its accounts receivable Virgin believes that in any case both positive
and negative durations in accounts signal differences from the results that
management believe to be the most advantageous for the firm
Tools for Monitoring Accounts Receivable
Page 41 of 46
For monitoring accounts receivable there are several tools such as aging schedule
the ratios of receivable outstanding to original sales customers payment proportion
and sales weighted DSO (Days Sales Outstanding) For monitoring accounts
receivable Virgin uses aging schedule fractions and traditional DSO statistics
because of their simplicity in use Although payment proportions ratios of
receivables outstanding and sales weighted DSO methods are free from inherent bias
None of these is used because all these are complex to maintain
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
In summary
Page 42 of 46
Standard Compliance by Virgin Soft Drinks
Generals terms of sale is 210 net 30 Normally Virgin also use general terms
of sale ie 210 net 30
Firms do not offer the same terms of
sale to all customers
Yes For prime customers Virgin offers
special terms of sale
Approaches of terms of sale decisions
are ndash
bull Standard approach
bull Multi period approach
Virgin uses standard approach of terms
of sale decision as it is simple to use and
understand
Source of credit information are ndash
Sellers prior experience with the
customer
Credit agency ratings and
reports
Personal contact with the
applicants bank and other
creditors
Analysis of applicants financial
statements
Customer visit
Main source of credit information to
Virgin is its prior experience with the
customer All other sources are not cost-
effective for Virgin
Approaches of credit granting to
marginal accounts are ndash
Traditional approach
Net Present Value (NPV)
approach
It uses traditional approach still now but
thinks that NPV should be used for the
next periods
Firms monitor accounts receivable
because deviations from the expected
levels of turnover and of bad debt can
Virgin also monitors its accounts
receivable
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
signal several different problems
Different tools for monitoring accounts
receivable are ndash
Aging schedule
Ratios of receivables
outstanding to original sales
Customers payment
proportions
Sales-weighted DSO
For monitoring accounts receivable
Virgin uses aging schedule and
traditional sales outstanding statistics
84 MANAGING ACCOUNTS PAYABLE (CREDITORS)
Virgin has almost accounts payable of Tk 8000000 But most of its liabilities are to
the banks rather than suppliers But we dont have any clear information about
Virgins accounts payable
9 RECOMMENDATION
Virgin should invest its surplus cash in short term marketable securities
because it is suitable hedging against cash uncertainties and will also give
some returns (interest income)
Virgin should publish its own annual report which will satisfy information
needs of stakeholders and also increase the credibility of information provided
by Virgin
Page 43 of 46
Virgin should use multi period approach in terms of sale decision because
standard approach which is already exists in Virgin has some inherent
problems
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
It should stop using traditional approach from now It should use NPV
method in credit granting to marginal accounts
In monitoring accounts receivable Virgin should use sales-weighted DSO
method because it has least limitation compared to the others
It should be more flexible in granting credit which will ultimately increase its
sales
To get the appropriate number of quantity to be ordered per order it should
use DSO model
It should be ABC system for proper monitoring of inventory
10 CONCLUSION
The use of other peoples money in business is usually an expensive resource Before
looking outside for finance a firm should examine its own working capital cycle to
make sure that every rand of its own internal funds is being fully utilized Good
management of working capital is part of good financial management Effective use
of working capital will contribute to the operational efficiency of the whole
organization optimum use will help to generate maximum returns Furthermore
working capital management is not an end in itself It is an integral part of the firms
overall management The needs of efficient working capital management must be
considered in relation to other aspects of the Virgins financial and non-financial
performance Thats why when planning the development of a business it is critical
that the impact of working capital be fully assessed
Page 44 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
BIBLIOGRAPHY
Scherr FC (1989) International Edition Prentice-Hall International Inc Modern
Working Capital Management Text and Cases
Hussain Riaz (2002) Working Capital Management
Robertson Lonnie (July 1998) Inventory Management
httpwwwasashoporg visited on March 13 2006
The Art of Cash Management
httpwwwinccom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management
httpwwwstudyfinancecom visited on March 13 2006
White Paper ndash Managing Working Capital
httpwwwplanwareorg visited on March 13 2006
Management of Working Capital
httpwwwbusinesscentralcoza visited on March 13 2006
Cash Management
httpwwwsbagov visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management Objectives
httpwpsprenhallcom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management
Page 45 of 46
httpwwwadvancemecom visited on March 13 2006
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Business Receivables Financing
httpwwwbbtcom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Finance
http wwwfnbcoza visited on March 13 2006
Tips to manage your working capital
httpsmallbusinessninemsncomau visited on March 13 2006
Inventory Financing
httpwwwfranklincapitalnetworkcom visited on March 13 2006
Accounts Receivable Management
httpwwwfranklincapitalnetworkcom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management
httpwwwtreasurygovtnz visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management
httpwwwtreasurystrategiescom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Works
httpwwwinvestopediacom visited on March 13 2006
Treasury Services
httpwwwjpmorganchasecom visited on March 13 2006
what were about
Page 46 of 46
httpwwwvirgincom visited on March 13 2006
Annexure
Annexure
Interview with YASEER RIZVI
Mr Yaseer Rizvi the DMD of Global Beverage Co Ltd obtained his MBA degree
from a reputed university He had been the Director of Ocean Container Ltd before
joining in Global Beverage Co Ltd He possesses a nice personality
I interviewed Yaseer Rizvi Excerpts from his interview are as follows ndash
Shah Kamal Sir would you please tell me do you invest in short term marketable securities
Yaseer Rizvi Basically we do not invest our surplus cash in short term marketable
securities like T-Bill commercial paper certificate of deposit etc But we keep our
surplus cash in Bank
Shah Kamal Would you tell me something about transit time for a typical check
Yaseer Rizvi Well in Virgin the transit time for a typical check is ndash
For mail float 2 to 3 days
At firm float 6 hours
Clearing float 1 to 3 days
Shah Kamal Do you maintain any cash concentration mechanism like depository transfer check automated clearing house and wire transfer
i
Annexure
Yaseer Rizvi Our position in this case is very strong as we use all the mechanisms
you mentioned As Virgin is a firm with small deposits spread over a substantial
number of banks so we tend to use depository transfer checks extensively It is less
costly We also use automated clearing house and wire transfer but later is used in a
less extent
Shah Kamal Sir what techniques of disbursement management is used by your firm
Yaseer Rizvi Like other firms Virgin tries to retain the cash for as long as possible
But we always perform it in an ethical manner We do not use management of
disbursement float as it seems unethical We follow Zero-Balance Accounts method
for managing disbursement We do not prefer Controlled Disbursing method since
Zero-Balance system is already practiced in Virgin
Shah Kamal How do you hedge cash balance uncertainties
Yaseer Rizvi Well you may say that we do not invest in short term securities but for
facing cash difficulties we keep our surplus cash in bank
Shah Kamal Sir would you please tell me the general terms of sale of Virgin
Yaseer Rizvi Though it is difficult to maintain a fixed terms of sale our general terms
of sale is 210 n30 But for prime customers we offer special terms of sale
Shah Kamal What are the sources of credit information in case of your firm
Yaseer Rizvi We grant credit on the basis of prior experience with the customers In
case of a new customer personal contact is weighted
Shah Kamal Does your firm consider 5 Cs in granting credit
ii
Annexure
Yaseer Rizvi In case of Virgin Capital and Character get more importance than the
others Mind one thing personal relationship is the main measure in granting credit
Shah Kamal Do you use NPV method in credit granting decisions
Yaseer Rizvi We do not use NPV method But we think that NPV is a suitable
method and we have to use it from the next period
Shah Kamal Sir how do you handle the problem of bad debt
Yaseer Rizvi Well in this case our position is very strong Yet we do not face any
problem because of bad debt Just note that we make more than 80 of sales in cash
and we monitor accounts receivable very carefully
Shah Kamal What level of inventory is maintained by Virgin
Yaseer Rizvi We maintain a minimum level of inventory but do not have to face
stock out problems because inventory is managed efficiently
Shah Kamal What is the normal lead time
Yaseer Rizvi In case of imported goods normal lead time is about 1 month and when
we purchase raw materials from inside the country lead time is 1 to 3 days
Shah Kamal What method do you use for managing inventory
Yaseer Rizvi We do not use any method particularly rather inventory decision
depends on business cycle and market situation Long before the Eid festival we
bought large amount of sugar because price of sugar was increased on the occasion
of Eid
iii
Annexure
Shah Kamal What are the main items of inventory of your firm
Yaseer Rizvi Well these are ndash aluminum can pet chip sugar label chemical and
artificial sweet
Shah Kamal What are the uncertainties in maintaining appropriate level of stock
Yaseer Rizvi These are ndash
bull Increase in price of raw materials
bull Sales uncertainty
bull Market trends etc
Shah Kamal Thank you for your kind cooperation
Yaseer Rizvi Most Welcome
iv
Global Beverage Company Limited
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Page 24 of 46
ion of further credit Cancellat
Telephone calls
n agency Use of a collectio
he firm should recognize that the longer someone owes firm the greater the chance
Legal action
T
it will never get paid If the average age of debtors is getting longer or is already very
long it may need to look for the following possible defects
Weak credit judgment
res Poor collection procedu
ms Lax enforcement of credit ter
Slow issue of invoices or statements
Errors in invoices or statements
Customer dissatisfaction
Debtors due over 90 days (unless within agreed credit terms) should generally
demand immediate attention For example warning signs of a future bad debt ndash
Longer credit terms taken with approval particularly for smaller orders
Use of post-dated checks by debtors who normally settle within agreed terms
Evidence of customers switching to additional suppliers for the same goods
New customers who are reluctant to give credit references
Cre G
Receiving part payments from debtors
dit ranting to Marginal Accounts
Traditional Approach
In the traditional approach to the credit granting decision it is the credit analysts job
rmation that has been collected and reach a judgment
regarding the applicants creditworthiness One traditional way of organizing this
to synthesize all the info
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
information is by characterizing the applicant along five dimensions These
dimensions are called the Five Cs of credit ndash
Capital
Character
Collateral
and Capacity
Conditions
Net Present Value (NPV) Approach
Once a firm has assessed the creditworthiness of a customer it has to decide whether
r not credit should be granted The firm should use the NPV rule to make the
ld be granted
Figure
o
decision If NPV is positive credit shou
Credit Granting Decision
Credit Granting Decision
he act of collecting money is one which most people dislike for many reasons and
therefore put on the long f selves there is something
ore urgent or important that demands their attention now There is nothing more
T
inger because they convince them
m
important than getting paid for firms product or service A customer who does not
Page 25 of 46
Grand Credit
Payment received Payment not received
Benefit of present value of future net cash flow
Cost of present value ment of lost invest
Net Payoff PV of benefit-cost
No Credit
No Payoff
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
pay is not a customer Here are a few ideas that may help the firm in collecting
money from debtors
Firm should develop appropriate procedures for handling late payments
It should track and pursue late payers
It might get external help if its own efforts fail
or money its firms and it is entitled Company shouldnt feel guilty asking f
to it
ction
Firm must make that call now And it should keep asking until it gets some
satisfa
lessens the problem
In difficult circumstances take what the firm can now and agree terms for the
remainder It
paying
When asking for money be hard on the issue - but soft on the person It shouldnt
give the debtor any excuses for not
534 BLE (CREDITORS)
ices for goods or services have
een paid Organizations often regard the
not
to delay all payments until the latest possible date Regular weekly or
The firm make it its objective is to get the money - not to score points or get
even
MANAGING ACCOUNTS PAYA
Creditors (Accounts Payable) are suppliers whose invo
been processed but who have not yet b
amount owing to creditors as a source of free credit However creditor
administration systems are expensive and time-consuming to run The over-riding
concern in this area should be to minimize costs with simple procedures
While it is unnecessary to pay accounts before they fall due it is usually
worthwhile
Page 26 of 46
fortnightly payment of all due accounts is the simplest technique for creditor
management
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Electronic payments (direct credits) are cheaper than check payments considering
that transaction fees and overheads more than balance the advantage of delayed
presentation Some suppliers are reluctant to receive payments by this method but in
view of the substantial cost advantage (and the advantages to the suppliers
themselves) departments may wish to encourage suppliers to accept this option
However electronic payments are likely to be used in conjunction with rather than
as a replacement for check payments
Applying Best Practices in Managing Accounts Payable
f course simply deferring payments to suppliers could have adverse consequences
O
that more than offset the benefits of this additional cash flow Therefore it is
important to develop a holistic approach The firm should consider the following
best practices for payables management
Managing payment dates and terms to maximize cash flow ndash
y reporting on
receivable and
id penalty charges and taking advantage of
wer vendors and negotiate for more
to buying consortia with others even
voices for
payment based on receipt of goods or receipt of invoice whichever
comes later
Calculating and setting performance targets Regularl
AP performance measures such as days in payables
Coordinating the AP processes with accounts
inventory management to ensure that the company is collecting more
cash than it is paying out
Paying bills on time to avo
prompt-payment discounts where the discounts exceed the companyrsquos
cost of working capital
Consolidating purchases with fe
favorable payment terms
Considering entering in
Page 27 of 46
competitors to obtain favorable supplier pricing and terms
Unless contract terms specify otherwise setting up in
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Page 28 of 46
Em
process
-time payments with Electronic Funds Transfer (EFT)
uraging vendors to utilize electronic invoice presentment
a
ndancies and more
ploying technology to automate the accounts payable transaction
es ndash
Making just-in
Using an electronic invoice-matching application
Enco
For companies with multiple locations or business units employing
shared service approach for AP to eliminate redu
quickly implement process improvements
Mainta
vendor
Communicating accounts payable requirements to suppliers at the
m key suppliers
for suggestions on how to improve the
Efficient a
and making th rsquos cash is just good business
ining open communications and building strong relationships with
s to access valuable trade credit ndash
beginning of transactions
Requesting summary invoicing fro
Requiring suppliers to send invoices directly to accounts payable
Asking tier-one suppliers
payment process
nd effective management of accounts payable helps improve cash flow ndash
e most of company
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
6 OVERVIEW OF VIRGIN GROUP
Virgin - one of the most respected brands in Britain - is now becoming the first global
brand name of the 21st century Virgin is involved in planes trains finance soft
drinks music mobile phones holidays cars wines publishing bridal wear - the lot
What tie all these businesses together are the values of its brand and the attitude of its
people Virgin has created over 200 companies worldwide employing over 25000
people Its total revenues around the world in 2002 exceeded pound4 billion (US $72
billion)
In 1970 Richard Branson founded Virgin as a mail order record retailer and not
long after he opened a record shop in Oxford Street London During 1972 a
recording studio was built in Oxfordshire and the first Virgin artist Mike Oldfield
recorded Tubular Bells which was released in 1973
This album went on to sell over 5 million copies Since then many household names
including Belinda Carlisle Genesis Phil Collins Janet Jackson and The Rolling
Stones have helped to make Virgin Music one of the top six record companies in the
world The equity of Virgin Music Group - record labels music publishing and
recording studios was sold to THORN EMI in 1992 in a US$1billion deal
Page 29 of 46
The Virgin Group has now expanded into international music Mega stores air
travel mobile financial retail music internet drinks rail hotels and leisure with
around 200 companies in over 30 countries
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
In Virgins customers eyes Virgin stands for value for money quality innovation
fun and a sense of competitive challenge It delivers a quality service by empowering
its employees and facilitates and monitors customer feedback to continually improve
the customers experience through innovation
When they start a new venture Virgin bases it on hard research and analysis
Typically they review the industry and put themselves in the customers shoes to see
what could make it better Virgin asks fundamental questions
Is this an opportunity for restructuring a market and creating competitive
advantage What are the competitors doing
Is the customer confused or badly served
Is this an opportunity for building the Virgin brand
Can we add value
Will it interact with its other businesses
Is there an appropriate trade-off between risk and reward
Page 30 of 46
Virgin is also able to draw on talented people from throughout the group New
ventures are often steered by people seconded from other parts of Virgin who bring
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
with them the trademark management style skills and experience Virgin frequently
creates partnerships with others to combine skills knowledge and market presence
and so on Contrary to what some people may think their constantly expanding and
eclectic empire is neither random nor reckless Each successive venture demonstrates
its skill in picking the right market and the right opportunity
7 OVERVIEW OF VIRGIN SOFT DRINKS
The Virgin Drinks Group first launched as the Virgin Cola Company in 1994 with
Virgin Cola in the UK Since then the company has ventured across the carbonated
soft drinks arena and beyond into energy drinks tea and flavored Colas This
expansion has lead to the evolution of the Virgin Drinks Company a company
whose aim is to put the excitement back into the world of soft drinks It launched in
Bangladesh in 1999 Virgin Soft Drinks is monitored by Global Beverage Co Ltd in
Bangladesh
Brief history of Virgin Drinks is given below
Page 31 of 46
1994 November Virgin Cola launched in the UK
1996 March Virgin Cola launched in France
1998 June Virgin Cola launched in Belgium
April Virgin Cola launched in the French West Indies
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
August Virgin Cola launched in Switzerland
1999 March Virgin Colours launched in Italy
March Virgin Cola launched in Japan
July Virgin Colours launched in South Africa
December Virgin Colours launched in Bangladesh
2001 January Sweden launched Virgin Colours
November Singapore launched Virgin Colours
2002 February Croatia launched Virgin Colours
June Russia launched Virgin Colours
June Tunisia launched Virgin Colours
2003 May Israel launched Virgin Colours
8 FINDINGS OF WORKING CAPITAL MANAGEMENT MAINTAINED BY
VIRGIN SOFT DRINKS IN BANGLADESH
81 CASH MANAGEMENT
811 Holding Cash and Marketable Securities
Although there are many good reasons why firm hold cash and marketable
securities Virgin Drinks holds cash and marketable securities for two reasons ndash
i) Cash for transactions
ii) Cash as hedges
This indicates that the firm does not hold cash and marketable securities for some
important reasons such as ndash
i) Near cash assets as hedges
Page 32 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
ii) Temporary investment and compensating balances
Virgin Soft Drinks does not invest in money market securities such as Treasury bill
commercial paper certificate of deposits bankerrsquos acceptance and repurchase
agreement This firm deposits its money in bank as currant AC or fixed AC They
say that they do not have enough money to invest in money market instrument
They also say that if they have enough money they will invest it in money market
short term securities We know that near cash interest earning assets can be
substituted for cash when motivation for holding these assets is the hedging of cash
flow uncertainties or is the temporary investment of surplus funds In this point
Virgins position is not good as there is no significant hedging against uncertainty of
cash
812 Floatation and Check Clearing
Virgin is very smart in handling the problem of transit time for checks Here mail
float takes 2 to 3 days at firm takes 025 day and clearing float takes 1-3 days Virgin
uses most of the strategies available for reducing the delay in receiving funds It
(Virgin) has linked Islami Bank which posses an accelerated clearing facility It uses
electronic collection process which ensures faster collection and its at the firm check
processing is satisfactory But Virgin does not use lockbox The reason behind this is
that it is not cost-effective for Virgin to set lockboxes At this point we can say that
Virgins check clearing mechanism is much good
813 Cash Concentration and Disbursement Management
Page 33 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks takes the matter of cash concentration very seriously They use all
the available cash concentration mechanism Virgin is a firm with small deposits
spread over a substantial number of banks and this is why the firm tends to use
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
depository transfer checks extensively If is less costly Virgin also uses automated
clearing house and wire transfer To Virgin wire transfer seems too costly
Like other firm Virgin tries to retain the cash for as long as possible But Virgin
always performs it in an ethical manner Virgin does not try to defeat the receiving
firmrsquos attempts to reduce the float on incoming checks It does not take any strategy
for increasing mail float at firm float and clearing float on its outgoing checks To
Virgin it is deemed to be unethical It thinks that maximization of disbursement float
will not go unnoticed by sophisticated creditors for very long When it is noticed it
will negatively affect relations with these creditors reducing the firmrsquos bargaining
power with them This may ultimately cost Virgin dearly when future prices and
delivery schedules for goods and services purchased from trade creditors are
negotiated Virgin follows ldquoZero-Balance Accountsrdquo methods for managing
disbursement It thinks that in this method the coordination of funds inflows to
disbursement banks with the presentation of checks does not work to the detriment
of creditors since the firmrsquos checks to them are honored as presented and this strategy
does not affect float significantly Controlled disbursing method is less attractive to
Virgin because zero-balance system is already feasible
814 Cash Forecasting
Cash Forecasting and Its Types
Page 34 of 46
Virgin forecasts the future cash inflows and outflows To Virgin cash forecast is an
important part of the firmrsquos cash control system and is one of the forecasts that are
part of the Virginrsquos financial plan Virgin forecasts cash on monthly basis and on
yearly basis Virgin does not forecast on daily basis assuming that the temporary
shortage of funds within these periods can be covered without value cost eg
advance receipts from customers Virginrsquos cash forecasting system involves a
combination of distribution and scheduling The receipts and disbursements
approach of cash forecasting is used in virgin This method is used because it
minutely traces the movement of cash and very close control of cash is possible
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Virgin does not use adjusted net income approach on two grounds First it does not
permit the tracing of the individual types of cash inflows and outflows for any given
period which is often useful information for virgin Second it is not simple to use
Items to be Forecast
Virgin does not forecast all the items It forecasts only major items eg accounts
receivable notes receivable payroll cash purchases of raw materials In this regard
virgin trade off between cost and benefit
Methods of Financial Forecasting
Virgin forecasts the future level of financial variable such as cash level asset level or
liability level We know in short term forecasts many things will result from plans
and events that are already in place (contracts capital budgets long-range financing
plans and so forth) But in the long run most things can vary and are dependent on
outside influences such as the firmrsquos long-term growth rate Since Virginrsquos cash
forecasting deals mostly with near future many of the items on the cash forecasts are
estimated by some variation of the spot method and remaining estimates are mostly
on a ldquoproportion of another accountrdquo basis with this ldquoother accountrdquo often being a
particular periodrsquos sales Virgin uses the other two methods less frequently
Using Cash Forecast
Virgin forecasts cash for meeting general objectives (ie to know the available funds
for investment and need financing) and for meeting some special objectives (eg to
know whether the firm will fulfill its out of debt requirement) But it is matter to note
that Virgin does not make any short term investment of its surplus cash but only keep
this surplus in Bank Account
Page 35 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Sources of Uncertainty in Cash Forecasting and Hedging Uncertainties
Virgin faces uncertainty in cash forecasting mainly from two sources These are ndash
sales and production cost In peak season (hot season like autumn summer) sales
increases but in dull season (eg in winter) sales decreases drastically Production
cost may be increased because of increase of price of sugar chemicals aluminum
can Virgin follows two methods for hedging cash balance uncertainties These are ndash
i) Holding a stock of extra cash and
ii) Extra borrowing capacity
815 Modes for the Management of Cash and Temporary Investments
Virgin does not follow any of these methods wholly Virgin receives cash
continuously and pays salary at steady rate and pays continuously for other
expenses So it neither follows Baumol model nor Beranek model It has no upper
control limit lower control limit return point in case cash management So it neither
follows Miller-Orr model nor Stone model
In Summary
Page 36 of 46
Standard Compliance by Virgin Soft Drinks
Generally all firms hold cash and
marketable securities
Virgin holds only cash
Firms hold cash and marketable
securities for some reasons like
bull Cash for transactions
bull Cash and near-cash assets as
hedges
bull Temporary investments
bull Compensating balances
Virgin holds cash only for
two reasons ndash
bull Cash for transactions
bull Cash as hedges
Available money market instruments Virgin does not invest in any such
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
(short term securities) are ndash
Treasury Bills
Commercial Paper
Certificates of Deposit
Bankerrsquos Acceptance
Repurch menase Agree ts
instruments They only keep cash in
Bank Account
Mail Float
(1 to 5 days)
At Firm
Float
(025 to 1
day)
Clearing
Float
(0 to
2 days)
Mail Float
(2 to 3 days)
At firm
Float
(025
day)
Clearing
Float
(1 to 3
days)
Figure Transit time for a typical check Figure Transit time for a check for
Virgin
Strategies that firms can use to reduce
the delay in receiving funds are ndash
Selecting of Banks with
accelerated clearing capabilities
of check processing Acceleration
at the firm
ectronic collection Use of el
procedures
Use of lockboxes
Virgin follows the first three strategies
but does not use lockboxes
Available cash concentration
mechanisms are ndash
Depository transfer check
ouse Automated Clearing H
(ACH) electronic transfer)
Wire transfer
Virgin uses all these mechanisms of
cash concentration
Available sets of techniques for cash
disbursement management are ndash
ement of disbursement
Page 37 of 46
Manag
float
Virgin uses zero-balance accounts
technique
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Zero-Balance Accounts
Controlled disbursing
Firms may make cash flow forecasts
over periods of various lengths yearly
flows quarterly flows monthly flows
weekly flows or even daily flows
Virgin forecasts cash on yearly basis and
monthly basis
Cash forecasting system may involve ndash
Distribution
Scheduling
Virginrsquos cash forecasting system
involves a combination of distribution
and scheduling
Two common approaches to cash flow
in generating the cash forecast
and disbursement Receipts
approach
Adjusted net income approach
Virgin uses the receipts and
disbursement approach
There are many items to forecast Virgin forecasts only major items like
AR payroll etc
Four common approach to forecasting
fina i ndash nc al variables are
Spot method
Proportion to another account
Compounded growth
Multiple dependencies
Virgin uses spot method for forecasting
cash It uses proportion to another
account method for other variables and
remaining two methods are frequently
used
Sources of uncertainty in cash
forecasting are ndash
Sales uncertainty
Collection rate uncertainty
Production cost uncertainty
Capital outflow uncertainty
Virgin faces uncertainty mainly from
sales and production cost
Methods for hedging cash balance
unc a
Page 38 of 46
ert inties are ndash
i) Holding a stock of extra cash
Virgin two available methods for
hedging cash balance uncertainties
Th ese are ndash
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
ii) stock of near-cash Holding a
assets
iii) Extra borrowing capacity
iv) ary surpluses in Investing tempor
near-cash assets
i) Holding a stock of extra cash
ii) Extra borrowing capacity
(advance receipt from
customers)
Models for the management of cash and
temporary investments are ndash Baumol
model Beranek model Miller-Orr
model and Stone model
Virgin does not follow any method
wholly but a combination of Baumol
model and Beranek model is occurred
82 INVENTORY MANAGEMENT
21 Certainty Approach
isnt used in
irgin because it thinks it is not possible to implement in Bangladesh
d time is one to three days It
oes not use ABC system of inventory management
8
Main item of inventory of Virgin is Can pet chip sugar label chemical artificial
sweet etc Virgin maintains a minimum level of inventory but it does not have to face
problems because inventory is managed efficiently just-in-time (JIT)
V
Virgin maintains buffer stock because of the shortage of work-in-process (WIP)
inventory Its production process may also be hampered Thats why it maintains
safety stock to avoid stock out cost In case of imported goods normal lead time is
about one month and within the country normal lea
d
Page 39 of 46
Inventory Model
In reality Virgin does not use any of models of EOQ ordering and holding strategy
and safety stock strategy They maintain inventory based on their prior experience
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
822 Uncertainty Approach
Virgin does not use any model for handling inventory uncertainty It says that such
decision depends on business cycle and market situation Long before Eid festival
they bought large amount of sugar because of price increase on the occasion of Eid
In summary
Standard Compliance by Virgin Soft Drinks
Firms maintain inventory to guard
against several problems
Virgin maintains a minimum level of
inventory which is managed efficiently
Some firms use JIT to avoid inventory
cost
JIT is not used by Virgin as it thinks it is
impossible to implement in Bangladesh
Firms maintain buffer stock Virgin maintains buffer stock too
Firms maintain safety stock to avoid
shortage cost
Virgin also maintains safety stock
Firms use ABC system to monitor
inventory
Virgin doesnt use ABC system
EOQ model is an appropriate method
for measuring quantity that has to be
ordered per order
Virgin does not use EOQ model rather
makes order based on experience and
market demand
83 MANAGING ACCOUNTS RECEIVABLE (DEBTORS)
831 Terms of Sale Decision
Page 40 of 46
Virgin offers the term 210 net 30 enables the customers to deduct 2 percent from the
face value of the bill when paying within the first 10 days but if the discount is not
taken the customer must remit the full amount within 30 days But Virgin does not
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
offer the same terms of sale to all customers For prime customers it offers special
terms of sale In setting an appropriate term of sale it costs and benefits regarding
this are compared It uses the standard approach of terms of sale decision as it is
simple to use
832 Credit Granting Decisions
In case of Virgin the Capital and Character of Five Cs get more importance
Although there are many problems with the traditional approach Virgin uses it
because of its simplicity Virgin does not use Net Present Value (NPV) method in
credit granting decision It thinks that NPV is an appropriate method and should be
used next time It does not face any severe problem because of bad debts The reason
is that notes receivable is used when credit is granted
833 Monitoring Accounts Receivable
Virgin monitors its accounts receivable Virgin believes that in any case both positive
and negative durations in accounts signal differences from the results that
management believe to be the most advantageous for the firm
Tools for Monitoring Accounts Receivable
Page 41 of 46
For monitoring accounts receivable there are several tools such as aging schedule
the ratios of receivable outstanding to original sales customers payment proportion
and sales weighted DSO (Days Sales Outstanding) For monitoring accounts
receivable Virgin uses aging schedule fractions and traditional DSO statistics
because of their simplicity in use Although payment proportions ratios of
receivables outstanding and sales weighted DSO methods are free from inherent bias
None of these is used because all these are complex to maintain
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
In summary
Page 42 of 46
Standard Compliance by Virgin Soft Drinks
Generals terms of sale is 210 net 30 Normally Virgin also use general terms
of sale ie 210 net 30
Firms do not offer the same terms of
sale to all customers
Yes For prime customers Virgin offers
special terms of sale
Approaches of terms of sale decisions
are ndash
bull Standard approach
bull Multi period approach
Virgin uses standard approach of terms
of sale decision as it is simple to use and
understand
Source of credit information are ndash
Sellers prior experience with the
customer
Credit agency ratings and
reports
Personal contact with the
applicants bank and other
creditors
Analysis of applicants financial
statements
Customer visit
Main source of credit information to
Virgin is its prior experience with the
customer All other sources are not cost-
effective for Virgin
Approaches of credit granting to
marginal accounts are ndash
Traditional approach
Net Present Value (NPV)
approach
It uses traditional approach still now but
thinks that NPV should be used for the
next periods
Firms monitor accounts receivable
because deviations from the expected
levels of turnover and of bad debt can
Virgin also monitors its accounts
receivable
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
signal several different problems
Different tools for monitoring accounts
receivable are ndash
Aging schedule
Ratios of receivables
outstanding to original sales
Customers payment
proportions
Sales-weighted DSO
For monitoring accounts receivable
Virgin uses aging schedule and
traditional sales outstanding statistics
84 MANAGING ACCOUNTS PAYABLE (CREDITORS)
Virgin has almost accounts payable of Tk 8000000 But most of its liabilities are to
the banks rather than suppliers But we dont have any clear information about
Virgins accounts payable
9 RECOMMENDATION
Virgin should invest its surplus cash in short term marketable securities
because it is suitable hedging against cash uncertainties and will also give
some returns (interest income)
Virgin should publish its own annual report which will satisfy information
needs of stakeholders and also increase the credibility of information provided
by Virgin
Page 43 of 46
Virgin should use multi period approach in terms of sale decision because
standard approach which is already exists in Virgin has some inherent
problems
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
It should stop using traditional approach from now It should use NPV
method in credit granting to marginal accounts
In monitoring accounts receivable Virgin should use sales-weighted DSO
method because it has least limitation compared to the others
It should be more flexible in granting credit which will ultimately increase its
sales
To get the appropriate number of quantity to be ordered per order it should
use DSO model
It should be ABC system for proper monitoring of inventory
10 CONCLUSION
The use of other peoples money in business is usually an expensive resource Before
looking outside for finance a firm should examine its own working capital cycle to
make sure that every rand of its own internal funds is being fully utilized Good
management of working capital is part of good financial management Effective use
of working capital will contribute to the operational efficiency of the whole
organization optimum use will help to generate maximum returns Furthermore
working capital management is not an end in itself It is an integral part of the firms
overall management The needs of efficient working capital management must be
considered in relation to other aspects of the Virgins financial and non-financial
performance Thats why when planning the development of a business it is critical
that the impact of working capital be fully assessed
Page 44 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
BIBLIOGRAPHY
Scherr FC (1989) International Edition Prentice-Hall International Inc Modern
Working Capital Management Text and Cases
Hussain Riaz (2002) Working Capital Management
Robertson Lonnie (July 1998) Inventory Management
httpwwwasashoporg visited on March 13 2006
The Art of Cash Management
httpwwwinccom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management
httpwwwstudyfinancecom visited on March 13 2006
White Paper ndash Managing Working Capital
httpwwwplanwareorg visited on March 13 2006
Management of Working Capital
httpwwwbusinesscentralcoza visited on March 13 2006
Cash Management
httpwwwsbagov visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management Objectives
httpwpsprenhallcom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management
Page 45 of 46
httpwwwadvancemecom visited on March 13 2006
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Business Receivables Financing
httpwwwbbtcom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Finance
http wwwfnbcoza visited on March 13 2006
Tips to manage your working capital
httpsmallbusinessninemsncomau visited on March 13 2006
Inventory Financing
httpwwwfranklincapitalnetworkcom visited on March 13 2006
Accounts Receivable Management
httpwwwfranklincapitalnetworkcom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management
httpwwwtreasurygovtnz visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management
httpwwwtreasurystrategiescom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Works
httpwwwinvestopediacom visited on March 13 2006
Treasury Services
httpwwwjpmorganchasecom visited on March 13 2006
what were about
Page 46 of 46
httpwwwvirgincom visited on March 13 2006
Annexure
Annexure
Interview with YASEER RIZVI
Mr Yaseer Rizvi the DMD of Global Beverage Co Ltd obtained his MBA degree
from a reputed university He had been the Director of Ocean Container Ltd before
joining in Global Beverage Co Ltd He possesses a nice personality
I interviewed Yaseer Rizvi Excerpts from his interview are as follows ndash
Shah Kamal Sir would you please tell me do you invest in short term marketable securities
Yaseer Rizvi Basically we do not invest our surplus cash in short term marketable
securities like T-Bill commercial paper certificate of deposit etc But we keep our
surplus cash in Bank
Shah Kamal Would you tell me something about transit time for a typical check
Yaseer Rizvi Well in Virgin the transit time for a typical check is ndash
For mail float 2 to 3 days
At firm float 6 hours
Clearing float 1 to 3 days
Shah Kamal Do you maintain any cash concentration mechanism like depository transfer check automated clearing house and wire transfer
i
Annexure
Yaseer Rizvi Our position in this case is very strong as we use all the mechanisms
you mentioned As Virgin is a firm with small deposits spread over a substantial
number of banks so we tend to use depository transfer checks extensively It is less
costly We also use automated clearing house and wire transfer but later is used in a
less extent
Shah Kamal Sir what techniques of disbursement management is used by your firm
Yaseer Rizvi Like other firms Virgin tries to retain the cash for as long as possible
But we always perform it in an ethical manner We do not use management of
disbursement float as it seems unethical We follow Zero-Balance Accounts method
for managing disbursement We do not prefer Controlled Disbursing method since
Zero-Balance system is already practiced in Virgin
Shah Kamal How do you hedge cash balance uncertainties
Yaseer Rizvi Well you may say that we do not invest in short term securities but for
facing cash difficulties we keep our surplus cash in bank
Shah Kamal Sir would you please tell me the general terms of sale of Virgin
Yaseer Rizvi Though it is difficult to maintain a fixed terms of sale our general terms
of sale is 210 n30 But for prime customers we offer special terms of sale
Shah Kamal What are the sources of credit information in case of your firm
Yaseer Rizvi We grant credit on the basis of prior experience with the customers In
case of a new customer personal contact is weighted
Shah Kamal Does your firm consider 5 Cs in granting credit
ii
Annexure
Yaseer Rizvi In case of Virgin Capital and Character get more importance than the
others Mind one thing personal relationship is the main measure in granting credit
Shah Kamal Do you use NPV method in credit granting decisions
Yaseer Rizvi We do not use NPV method But we think that NPV is a suitable
method and we have to use it from the next period
Shah Kamal Sir how do you handle the problem of bad debt
Yaseer Rizvi Well in this case our position is very strong Yet we do not face any
problem because of bad debt Just note that we make more than 80 of sales in cash
and we monitor accounts receivable very carefully
Shah Kamal What level of inventory is maintained by Virgin
Yaseer Rizvi We maintain a minimum level of inventory but do not have to face
stock out problems because inventory is managed efficiently
Shah Kamal What is the normal lead time
Yaseer Rizvi In case of imported goods normal lead time is about 1 month and when
we purchase raw materials from inside the country lead time is 1 to 3 days
Shah Kamal What method do you use for managing inventory
Yaseer Rizvi We do not use any method particularly rather inventory decision
depends on business cycle and market situation Long before the Eid festival we
bought large amount of sugar because price of sugar was increased on the occasion
of Eid
iii
Annexure
Shah Kamal What are the main items of inventory of your firm
Yaseer Rizvi Well these are ndash aluminum can pet chip sugar label chemical and
artificial sweet
Shah Kamal What are the uncertainties in maintaining appropriate level of stock
Yaseer Rizvi These are ndash
bull Increase in price of raw materials
bull Sales uncertainty
bull Market trends etc
Shah Kamal Thank you for your kind cooperation
Yaseer Rizvi Most Welcome
iv
Global Beverage Company Limited
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
information is by characterizing the applicant along five dimensions These
dimensions are called the Five Cs of credit ndash
Capital
Character
Collateral
and Capacity
Conditions
Net Present Value (NPV) Approach
Once a firm has assessed the creditworthiness of a customer it has to decide whether
r not credit should be granted The firm should use the NPV rule to make the
ld be granted
Figure
o
decision If NPV is positive credit shou
Credit Granting Decision
Credit Granting Decision
he act of collecting money is one which most people dislike for many reasons and
therefore put on the long f selves there is something
ore urgent or important that demands their attention now There is nothing more
T
inger because they convince them
m
important than getting paid for firms product or service A customer who does not
Page 25 of 46
Grand Credit
Payment received Payment not received
Benefit of present value of future net cash flow
Cost of present value ment of lost invest
Net Payoff PV of benefit-cost
No Credit
No Payoff
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
pay is not a customer Here are a few ideas that may help the firm in collecting
money from debtors
Firm should develop appropriate procedures for handling late payments
It should track and pursue late payers
It might get external help if its own efforts fail
or money its firms and it is entitled Company shouldnt feel guilty asking f
to it
ction
Firm must make that call now And it should keep asking until it gets some
satisfa
lessens the problem
In difficult circumstances take what the firm can now and agree terms for the
remainder It
paying
When asking for money be hard on the issue - but soft on the person It shouldnt
give the debtor any excuses for not
534 BLE (CREDITORS)
ices for goods or services have
een paid Organizations often regard the
not
to delay all payments until the latest possible date Regular weekly or
The firm make it its objective is to get the money - not to score points or get
even
MANAGING ACCOUNTS PAYA
Creditors (Accounts Payable) are suppliers whose invo
been processed but who have not yet b
amount owing to creditors as a source of free credit However creditor
administration systems are expensive and time-consuming to run The over-riding
concern in this area should be to minimize costs with simple procedures
While it is unnecessary to pay accounts before they fall due it is usually
worthwhile
Page 26 of 46
fortnightly payment of all due accounts is the simplest technique for creditor
management
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Electronic payments (direct credits) are cheaper than check payments considering
that transaction fees and overheads more than balance the advantage of delayed
presentation Some suppliers are reluctant to receive payments by this method but in
view of the substantial cost advantage (and the advantages to the suppliers
themselves) departments may wish to encourage suppliers to accept this option
However electronic payments are likely to be used in conjunction with rather than
as a replacement for check payments
Applying Best Practices in Managing Accounts Payable
f course simply deferring payments to suppliers could have adverse consequences
O
that more than offset the benefits of this additional cash flow Therefore it is
important to develop a holistic approach The firm should consider the following
best practices for payables management
Managing payment dates and terms to maximize cash flow ndash
y reporting on
receivable and
id penalty charges and taking advantage of
wer vendors and negotiate for more
to buying consortia with others even
voices for
payment based on receipt of goods or receipt of invoice whichever
comes later
Calculating and setting performance targets Regularl
AP performance measures such as days in payables
Coordinating the AP processes with accounts
inventory management to ensure that the company is collecting more
cash than it is paying out
Paying bills on time to avo
prompt-payment discounts where the discounts exceed the companyrsquos
cost of working capital
Consolidating purchases with fe
favorable payment terms
Considering entering in
Page 27 of 46
competitors to obtain favorable supplier pricing and terms
Unless contract terms specify otherwise setting up in
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Page 28 of 46
Em
process
-time payments with Electronic Funds Transfer (EFT)
uraging vendors to utilize electronic invoice presentment
a
ndancies and more
ploying technology to automate the accounts payable transaction
es ndash
Making just-in
Using an electronic invoice-matching application
Enco
For companies with multiple locations or business units employing
shared service approach for AP to eliminate redu
quickly implement process improvements
Mainta
vendor
Communicating accounts payable requirements to suppliers at the
m key suppliers
for suggestions on how to improve the
Efficient a
and making th rsquos cash is just good business
ining open communications and building strong relationships with
s to access valuable trade credit ndash
beginning of transactions
Requesting summary invoicing fro
Requiring suppliers to send invoices directly to accounts payable
Asking tier-one suppliers
payment process
nd effective management of accounts payable helps improve cash flow ndash
e most of company
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
6 OVERVIEW OF VIRGIN GROUP
Virgin - one of the most respected brands in Britain - is now becoming the first global
brand name of the 21st century Virgin is involved in planes trains finance soft
drinks music mobile phones holidays cars wines publishing bridal wear - the lot
What tie all these businesses together are the values of its brand and the attitude of its
people Virgin has created over 200 companies worldwide employing over 25000
people Its total revenues around the world in 2002 exceeded pound4 billion (US $72
billion)
In 1970 Richard Branson founded Virgin as a mail order record retailer and not
long after he opened a record shop in Oxford Street London During 1972 a
recording studio was built in Oxfordshire and the first Virgin artist Mike Oldfield
recorded Tubular Bells which was released in 1973
This album went on to sell over 5 million copies Since then many household names
including Belinda Carlisle Genesis Phil Collins Janet Jackson and The Rolling
Stones have helped to make Virgin Music one of the top six record companies in the
world The equity of Virgin Music Group - record labels music publishing and
recording studios was sold to THORN EMI in 1992 in a US$1billion deal
Page 29 of 46
The Virgin Group has now expanded into international music Mega stores air
travel mobile financial retail music internet drinks rail hotels and leisure with
around 200 companies in over 30 countries
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
In Virgins customers eyes Virgin stands for value for money quality innovation
fun and a sense of competitive challenge It delivers a quality service by empowering
its employees and facilitates and monitors customer feedback to continually improve
the customers experience through innovation
When they start a new venture Virgin bases it on hard research and analysis
Typically they review the industry and put themselves in the customers shoes to see
what could make it better Virgin asks fundamental questions
Is this an opportunity for restructuring a market and creating competitive
advantage What are the competitors doing
Is the customer confused or badly served
Is this an opportunity for building the Virgin brand
Can we add value
Will it interact with its other businesses
Is there an appropriate trade-off between risk and reward
Page 30 of 46
Virgin is also able to draw on talented people from throughout the group New
ventures are often steered by people seconded from other parts of Virgin who bring
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
with them the trademark management style skills and experience Virgin frequently
creates partnerships with others to combine skills knowledge and market presence
and so on Contrary to what some people may think their constantly expanding and
eclectic empire is neither random nor reckless Each successive venture demonstrates
its skill in picking the right market and the right opportunity
7 OVERVIEW OF VIRGIN SOFT DRINKS
The Virgin Drinks Group first launched as the Virgin Cola Company in 1994 with
Virgin Cola in the UK Since then the company has ventured across the carbonated
soft drinks arena and beyond into energy drinks tea and flavored Colas This
expansion has lead to the evolution of the Virgin Drinks Company a company
whose aim is to put the excitement back into the world of soft drinks It launched in
Bangladesh in 1999 Virgin Soft Drinks is monitored by Global Beverage Co Ltd in
Bangladesh
Brief history of Virgin Drinks is given below
Page 31 of 46
1994 November Virgin Cola launched in the UK
1996 March Virgin Cola launched in France
1998 June Virgin Cola launched in Belgium
April Virgin Cola launched in the French West Indies
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
August Virgin Cola launched in Switzerland
1999 March Virgin Colours launched in Italy
March Virgin Cola launched in Japan
July Virgin Colours launched in South Africa
December Virgin Colours launched in Bangladesh
2001 January Sweden launched Virgin Colours
November Singapore launched Virgin Colours
2002 February Croatia launched Virgin Colours
June Russia launched Virgin Colours
June Tunisia launched Virgin Colours
2003 May Israel launched Virgin Colours
8 FINDINGS OF WORKING CAPITAL MANAGEMENT MAINTAINED BY
VIRGIN SOFT DRINKS IN BANGLADESH
81 CASH MANAGEMENT
811 Holding Cash and Marketable Securities
Although there are many good reasons why firm hold cash and marketable
securities Virgin Drinks holds cash and marketable securities for two reasons ndash
i) Cash for transactions
ii) Cash as hedges
This indicates that the firm does not hold cash and marketable securities for some
important reasons such as ndash
i) Near cash assets as hedges
Page 32 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
ii) Temporary investment and compensating balances
Virgin Soft Drinks does not invest in money market securities such as Treasury bill
commercial paper certificate of deposits bankerrsquos acceptance and repurchase
agreement This firm deposits its money in bank as currant AC or fixed AC They
say that they do not have enough money to invest in money market instrument
They also say that if they have enough money they will invest it in money market
short term securities We know that near cash interest earning assets can be
substituted for cash when motivation for holding these assets is the hedging of cash
flow uncertainties or is the temporary investment of surplus funds In this point
Virgins position is not good as there is no significant hedging against uncertainty of
cash
812 Floatation and Check Clearing
Virgin is very smart in handling the problem of transit time for checks Here mail
float takes 2 to 3 days at firm takes 025 day and clearing float takes 1-3 days Virgin
uses most of the strategies available for reducing the delay in receiving funds It
(Virgin) has linked Islami Bank which posses an accelerated clearing facility It uses
electronic collection process which ensures faster collection and its at the firm check
processing is satisfactory But Virgin does not use lockbox The reason behind this is
that it is not cost-effective for Virgin to set lockboxes At this point we can say that
Virgins check clearing mechanism is much good
813 Cash Concentration and Disbursement Management
Page 33 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks takes the matter of cash concentration very seriously They use all
the available cash concentration mechanism Virgin is a firm with small deposits
spread over a substantial number of banks and this is why the firm tends to use
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
depository transfer checks extensively If is less costly Virgin also uses automated
clearing house and wire transfer To Virgin wire transfer seems too costly
Like other firm Virgin tries to retain the cash for as long as possible But Virgin
always performs it in an ethical manner Virgin does not try to defeat the receiving
firmrsquos attempts to reduce the float on incoming checks It does not take any strategy
for increasing mail float at firm float and clearing float on its outgoing checks To
Virgin it is deemed to be unethical It thinks that maximization of disbursement float
will not go unnoticed by sophisticated creditors for very long When it is noticed it
will negatively affect relations with these creditors reducing the firmrsquos bargaining
power with them This may ultimately cost Virgin dearly when future prices and
delivery schedules for goods and services purchased from trade creditors are
negotiated Virgin follows ldquoZero-Balance Accountsrdquo methods for managing
disbursement It thinks that in this method the coordination of funds inflows to
disbursement banks with the presentation of checks does not work to the detriment
of creditors since the firmrsquos checks to them are honored as presented and this strategy
does not affect float significantly Controlled disbursing method is less attractive to
Virgin because zero-balance system is already feasible
814 Cash Forecasting
Cash Forecasting and Its Types
Page 34 of 46
Virgin forecasts the future cash inflows and outflows To Virgin cash forecast is an
important part of the firmrsquos cash control system and is one of the forecasts that are
part of the Virginrsquos financial plan Virgin forecasts cash on monthly basis and on
yearly basis Virgin does not forecast on daily basis assuming that the temporary
shortage of funds within these periods can be covered without value cost eg
advance receipts from customers Virginrsquos cash forecasting system involves a
combination of distribution and scheduling The receipts and disbursements
approach of cash forecasting is used in virgin This method is used because it
minutely traces the movement of cash and very close control of cash is possible
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Virgin does not use adjusted net income approach on two grounds First it does not
permit the tracing of the individual types of cash inflows and outflows for any given
period which is often useful information for virgin Second it is not simple to use
Items to be Forecast
Virgin does not forecast all the items It forecasts only major items eg accounts
receivable notes receivable payroll cash purchases of raw materials In this regard
virgin trade off between cost and benefit
Methods of Financial Forecasting
Virgin forecasts the future level of financial variable such as cash level asset level or
liability level We know in short term forecasts many things will result from plans
and events that are already in place (contracts capital budgets long-range financing
plans and so forth) But in the long run most things can vary and are dependent on
outside influences such as the firmrsquos long-term growth rate Since Virginrsquos cash
forecasting deals mostly with near future many of the items on the cash forecasts are
estimated by some variation of the spot method and remaining estimates are mostly
on a ldquoproportion of another accountrdquo basis with this ldquoother accountrdquo often being a
particular periodrsquos sales Virgin uses the other two methods less frequently
Using Cash Forecast
Virgin forecasts cash for meeting general objectives (ie to know the available funds
for investment and need financing) and for meeting some special objectives (eg to
know whether the firm will fulfill its out of debt requirement) But it is matter to note
that Virgin does not make any short term investment of its surplus cash but only keep
this surplus in Bank Account
Page 35 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Sources of Uncertainty in Cash Forecasting and Hedging Uncertainties
Virgin faces uncertainty in cash forecasting mainly from two sources These are ndash
sales and production cost In peak season (hot season like autumn summer) sales
increases but in dull season (eg in winter) sales decreases drastically Production
cost may be increased because of increase of price of sugar chemicals aluminum
can Virgin follows two methods for hedging cash balance uncertainties These are ndash
i) Holding a stock of extra cash and
ii) Extra borrowing capacity
815 Modes for the Management of Cash and Temporary Investments
Virgin does not follow any of these methods wholly Virgin receives cash
continuously and pays salary at steady rate and pays continuously for other
expenses So it neither follows Baumol model nor Beranek model It has no upper
control limit lower control limit return point in case cash management So it neither
follows Miller-Orr model nor Stone model
In Summary
Page 36 of 46
Standard Compliance by Virgin Soft Drinks
Generally all firms hold cash and
marketable securities
Virgin holds only cash
Firms hold cash and marketable
securities for some reasons like
bull Cash for transactions
bull Cash and near-cash assets as
hedges
bull Temporary investments
bull Compensating balances
Virgin holds cash only for
two reasons ndash
bull Cash for transactions
bull Cash as hedges
Available money market instruments Virgin does not invest in any such
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
(short term securities) are ndash
Treasury Bills
Commercial Paper
Certificates of Deposit
Bankerrsquos Acceptance
Repurch menase Agree ts
instruments They only keep cash in
Bank Account
Mail Float
(1 to 5 days)
At Firm
Float
(025 to 1
day)
Clearing
Float
(0 to
2 days)
Mail Float
(2 to 3 days)
At firm
Float
(025
day)
Clearing
Float
(1 to 3
days)
Figure Transit time for a typical check Figure Transit time for a check for
Virgin
Strategies that firms can use to reduce
the delay in receiving funds are ndash
Selecting of Banks with
accelerated clearing capabilities
of check processing Acceleration
at the firm
ectronic collection Use of el
procedures
Use of lockboxes
Virgin follows the first three strategies
but does not use lockboxes
Available cash concentration
mechanisms are ndash
Depository transfer check
ouse Automated Clearing H
(ACH) electronic transfer)
Wire transfer
Virgin uses all these mechanisms of
cash concentration
Available sets of techniques for cash
disbursement management are ndash
ement of disbursement
Page 37 of 46
Manag
float
Virgin uses zero-balance accounts
technique
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Zero-Balance Accounts
Controlled disbursing
Firms may make cash flow forecasts
over periods of various lengths yearly
flows quarterly flows monthly flows
weekly flows or even daily flows
Virgin forecasts cash on yearly basis and
monthly basis
Cash forecasting system may involve ndash
Distribution
Scheduling
Virginrsquos cash forecasting system
involves a combination of distribution
and scheduling
Two common approaches to cash flow
in generating the cash forecast
and disbursement Receipts
approach
Adjusted net income approach
Virgin uses the receipts and
disbursement approach
There are many items to forecast Virgin forecasts only major items like
AR payroll etc
Four common approach to forecasting
fina i ndash nc al variables are
Spot method
Proportion to another account
Compounded growth
Multiple dependencies
Virgin uses spot method for forecasting
cash It uses proportion to another
account method for other variables and
remaining two methods are frequently
used
Sources of uncertainty in cash
forecasting are ndash
Sales uncertainty
Collection rate uncertainty
Production cost uncertainty
Capital outflow uncertainty
Virgin faces uncertainty mainly from
sales and production cost
Methods for hedging cash balance
unc a
Page 38 of 46
ert inties are ndash
i) Holding a stock of extra cash
Virgin two available methods for
hedging cash balance uncertainties
Th ese are ndash
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
ii) stock of near-cash Holding a
assets
iii) Extra borrowing capacity
iv) ary surpluses in Investing tempor
near-cash assets
i) Holding a stock of extra cash
ii) Extra borrowing capacity
(advance receipt from
customers)
Models for the management of cash and
temporary investments are ndash Baumol
model Beranek model Miller-Orr
model and Stone model
Virgin does not follow any method
wholly but a combination of Baumol
model and Beranek model is occurred
82 INVENTORY MANAGEMENT
21 Certainty Approach
isnt used in
irgin because it thinks it is not possible to implement in Bangladesh
d time is one to three days It
oes not use ABC system of inventory management
8
Main item of inventory of Virgin is Can pet chip sugar label chemical artificial
sweet etc Virgin maintains a minimum level of inventory but it does not have to face
problems because inventory is managed efficiently just-in-time (JIT)
V
Virgin maintains buffer stock because of the shortage of work-in-process (WIP)
inventory Its production process may also be hampered Thats why it maintains
safety stock to avoid stock out cost In case of imported goods normal lead time is
about one month and within the country normal lea
d
Page 39 of 46
Inventory Model
In reality Virgin does not use any of models of EOQ ordering and holding strategy
and safety stock strategy They maintain inventory based on their prior experience
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
822 Uncertainty Approach
Virgin does not use any model for handling inventory uncertainty It says that such
decision depends on business cycle and market situation Long before Eid festival
they bought large amount of sugar because of price increase on the occasion of Eid
In summary
Standard Compliance by Virgin Soft Drinks
Firms maintain inventory to guard
against several problems
Virgin maintains a minimum level of
inventory which is managed efficiently
Some firms use JIT to avoid inventory
cost
JIT is not used by Virgin as it thinks it is
impossible to implement in Bangladesh
Firms maintain buffer stock Virgin maintains buffer stock too
Firms maintain safety stock to avoid
shortage cost
Virgin also maintains safety stock
Firms use ABC system to monitor
inventory
Virgin doesnt use ABC system
EOQ model is an appropriate method
for measuring quantity that has to be
ordered per order
Virgin does not use EOQ model rather
makes order based on experience and
market demand
83 MANAGING ACCOUNTS RECEIVABLE (DEBTORS)
831 Terms of Sale Decision
Page 40 of 46
Virgin offers the term 210 net 30 enables the customers to deduct 2 percent from the
face value of the bill when paying within the first 10 days but if the discount is not
taken the customer must remit the full amount within 30 days But Virgin does not
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
offer the same terms of sale to all customers For prime customers it offers special
terms of sale In setting an appropriate term of sale it costs and benefits regarding
this are compared It uses the standard approach of terms of sale decision as it is
simple to use
832 Credit Granting Decisions
In case of Virgin the Capital and Character of Five Cs get more importance
Although there are many problems with the traditional approach Virgin uses it
because of its simplicity Virgin does not use Net Present Value (NPV) method in
credit granting decision It thinks that NPV is an appropriate method and should be
used next time It does not face any severe problem because of bad debts The reason
is that notes receivable is used when credit is granted
833 Monitoring Accounts Receivable
Virgin monitors its accounts receivable Virgin believes that in any case both positive
and negative durations in accounts signal differences from the results that
management believe to be the most advantageous for the firm
Tools for Monitoring Accounts Receivable
Page 41 of 46
For monitoring accounts receivable there are several tools such as aging schedule
the ratios of receivable outstanding to original sales customers payment proportion
and sales weighted DSO (Days Sales Outstanding) For monitoring accounts
receivable Virgin uses aging schedule fractions and traditional DSO statistics
because of their simplicity in use Although payment proportions ratios of
receivables outstanding and sales weighted DSO methods are free from inherent bias
None of these is used because all these are complex to maintain
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
In summary
Page 42 of 46
Standard Compliance by Virgin Soft Drinks
Generals terms of sale is 210 net 30 Normally Virgin also use general terms
of sale ie 210 net 30
Firms do not offer the same terms of
sale to all customers
Yes For prime customers Virgin offers
special terms of sale
Approaches of terms of sale decisions
are ndash
bull Standard approach
bull Multi period approach
Virgin uses standard approach of terms
of sale decision as it is simple to use and
understand
Source of credit information are ndash
Sellers prior experience with the
customer
Credit agency ratings and
reports
Personal contact with the
applicants bank and other
creditors
Analysis of applicants financial
statements
Customer visit
Main source of credit information to
Virgin is its prior experience with the
customer All other sources are not cost-
effective for Virgin
Approaches of credit granting to
marginal accounts are ndash
Traditional approach
Net Present Value (NPV)
approach
It uses traditional approach still now but
thinks that NPV should be used for the
next periods
Firms monitor accounts receivable
because deviations from the expected
levels of turnover and of bad debt can
Virgin also monitors its accounts
receivable
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
signal several different problems
Different tools for monitoring accounts
receivable are ndash
Aging schedule
Ratios of receivables
outstanding to original sales
Customers payment
proportions
Sales-weighted DSO
For monitoring accounts receivable
Virgin uses aging schedule and
traditional sales outstanding statistics
84 MANAGING ACCOUNTS PAYABLE (CREDITORS)
Virgin has almost accounts payable of Tk 8000000 But most of its liabilities are to
the banks rather than suppliers But we dont have any clear information about
Virgins accounts payable
9 RECOMMENDATION
Virgin should invest its surplus cash in short term marketable securities
because it is suitable hedging against cash uncertainties and will also give
some returns (interest income)
Virgin should publish its own annual report which will satisfy information
needs of stakeholders and also increase the credibility of information provided
by Virgin
Page 43 of 46
Virgin should use multi period approach in terms of sale decision because
standard approach which is already exists in Virgin has some inherent
problems
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
It should stop using traditional approach from now It should use NPV
method in credit granting to marginal accounts
In monitoring accounts receivable Virgin should use sales-weighted DSO
method because it has least limitation compared to the others
It should be more flexible in granting credit which will ultimately increase its
sales
To get the appropriate number of quantity to be ordered per order it should
use DSO model
It should be ABC system for proper monitoring of inventory
10 CONCLUSION
The use of other peoples money in business is usually an expensive resource Before
looking outside for finance a firm should examine its own working capital cycle to
make sure that every rand of its own internal funds is being fully utilized Good
management of working capital is part of good financial management Effective use
of working capital will contribute to the operational efficiency of the whole
organization optimum use will help to generate maximum returns Furthermore
working capital management is not an end in itself It is an integral part of the firms
overall management The needs of efficient working capital management must be
considered in relation to other aspects of the Virgins financial and non-financial
performance Thats why when planning the development of a business it is critical
that the impact of working capital be fully assessed
Page 44 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
BIBLIOGRAPHY
Scherr FC (1989) International Edition Prentice-Hall International Inc Modern
Working Capital Management Text and Cases
Hussain Riaz (2002) Working Capital Management
Robertson Lonnie (July 1998) Inventory Management
httpwwwasashoporg visited on March 13 2006
The Art of Cash Management
httpwwwinccom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management
httpwwwstudyfinancecom visited on March 13 2006
White Paper ndash Managing Working Capital
httpwwwplanwareorg visited on March 13 2006
Management of Working Capital
httpwwwbusinesscentralcoza visited on March 13 2006
Cash Management
httpwwwsbagov visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management Objectives
httpwpsprenhallcom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management
Page 45 of 46
httpwwwadvancemecom visited on March 13 2006
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Business Receivables Financing
httpwwwbbtcom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Finance
http wwwfnbcoza visited on March 13 2006
Tips to manage your working capital
httpsmallbusinessninemsncomau visited on March 13 2006
Inventory Financing
httpwwwfranklincapitalnetworkcom visited on March 13 2006
Accounts Receivable Management
httpwwwfranklincapitalnetworkcom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management
httpwwwtreasurygovtnz visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management
httpwwwtreasurystrategiescom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Works
httpwwwinvestopediacom visited on March 13 2006
Treasury Services
httpwwwjpmorganchasecom visited on March 13 2006
what were about
Page 46 of 46
httpwwwvirgincom visited on March 13 2006
Annexure
Annexure
Interview with YASEER RIZVI
Mr Yaseer Rizvi the DMD of Global Beverage Co Ltd obtained his MBA degree
from a reputed university He had been the Director of Ocean Container Ltd before
joining in Global Beverage Co Ltd He possesses a nice personality
I interviewed Yaseer Rizvi Excerpts from his interview are as follows ndash
Shah Kamal Sir would you please tell me do you invest in short term marketable securities
Yaseer Rizvi Basically we do not invest our surplus cash in short term marketable
securities like T-Bill commercial paper certificate of deposit etc But we keep our
surplus cash in Bank
Shah Kamal Would you tell me something about transit time for a typical check
Yaseer Rizvi Well in Virgin the transit time for a typical check is ndash
For mail float 2 to 3 days
At firm float 6 hours
Clearing float 1 to 3 days
Shah Kamal Do you maintain any cash concentration mechanism like depository transfer check automated clearing house and wire transfer
i
Annexure
Yaseer Rizvi Our position in this case is very strong as we use all the mechanisms
you mentioned As Virgin is a firm with small deposits spread over a substantial
number of banks so we tend to use depository transfer checks extensively It is less
costly We also use automated clearing house and wire transfer but later is used in a
less extent
Shah Kamal Sir what techniques of disbursement management is used by your firm
Yaseer Rizvi Like other firms Virgin tries to retain the cash for as long as possible
But we always perform it in an ethical manner We do not use management of
disbursement float as it seems unethical We follow Zero-Balance Accounts method
for managing disbursement We do not prefer Controlled Disbursing method since
Zero-Balance system is already practiced in Virgin
Shah Kamal How do you hedge cash balance uncertainties
Yaseer Rizvi Well you may say that we do not invest in short term securities but for
facing cash difficulties we keep our surplus cash in bank
Shah Kamal Sir would you please tell me the general terms of sale of Virgin
Yaseer Rizvi Though it is difficult to maintain a fixed terms of sale our general terms
of sale is 210 n30 But for prime customers we offer special terms of sale
Shah Kamal What are the sources of credit information in case of your firm
Yaseer Rizvi We grant credit on the basis of prior experience with the customers In
case of a new customer personal contact is weighted
Shah Kamal Does your firm consider 5 Cs in granting credit
ii
Annexure
Yaseer Rizvi In case of Virgin Capital and Character get more importance than the
others Mind one thing personal relationship is the main measure in granting credit
Shah Kamal Do you use NPV method in credit granting decisions
Yaseer Rizvi We do not use NPV method But we think that NPV is a suitable
method and we have to use it from the next period
Shah Kamal Sir how do you handle the problem of bad debt
Yaseer Rizvi Well in this case our position is very strong Yet we do not face any
problem because of bad debt Just note that we make more than 80 of sales in cash
and we monitor accounts receivable very carefully
Shah Kamal What level of inventory is maintained by Virgin
Yaseer Rizvi We maintain a minimum level of inventory but do not have to face
stock out problems because inventory is managed efficiently
Shah Kamal What is the normal lead time
Yaseer Rizvi In case of imported goods normal lead time is about 1 month and when
we purchase raw materials from inside the country lead time is 1 to 3 days
Shah Kamal What method do you use for managing inventory
Yaseer Rizvi We do not use any method particularly rather inventory decision
depends on business cycle and market situation Long before the Eid festival we
bought large amount of sugar because price of sugar was increased on the occasion
of Eid
iii
Annexure
Shah Kamal What are the main items of inventory of your firm
Yaseer Rizvi Well these are ndash aluminum can pet chip sugar label chemical and
artificial sweet
Shah Kamal What are the uncertainties in maintaining appropriate level of stock
Yaseer Rizvi These are ndash
bull Increase in price of raw materials
bull Sales uncertainty
bull Market trends etc
Shah Kamal Thank you for your kind cooperation
Yaseer Rizvi Most Welcome
iv
Global Beverage Company Limited
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
pay is not a customer Here are a few ideas that may help the firm in collecting
money from debtors
Firm should develop appropriate procedures for handling late payments
It should track and pursue late payers
It might get external help if its own efforts fail
or money its firms and it is entitled Company shouldnt feel guilty asking f
to it
ction
Firm must make that call now And it should keep asking until it gets some
satisfa
lessens the problem
In difficult circumstances take what the firm can now and agree terms for the
remainder It
paying
When asking for money be hard on the issue - but soft on the person It shouldnt
give the debtor any excuses for not
534 BLE (CREDITORS)
ices for goods or services have
een paid Organizations often regard the
not
to delay all payments until the latest possible date Regular weekly or
The firm make it its objective is to get the money - not to score points or get
even
MANAGING ACCOUNTS PAYA
Creditors (Accounts Payable) are suppliers whose invo
been processed but who have not yet b
amount owing to creditors as a source of free credit However creditor
administration systems are expensive and time-consuming to run The over-riding
concern in this area should be to minimize costs with simple procedures
While it is unnecessary to pay accounts before they fall due it is usually
worthwhile
Page 26 of 46
fortnightly payment of all due accounts is the simplest technique for creditor
management
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Electronic payments (direct credits) are cheaper than check payments considering
that transaction fees and overheads more than balance the advantage of delayed
presentation Some suppliers are reluctant to receive payments by this method but in
view of the substantial cost advantage (and the advantages to the suppliers
themselves) departments may wish to encourage suppliers to accept this option
However electronic payments are likely to be used in conjunction with rather than
as a replacement for check payments
Applying Best Practices in Managing Accounts Payable
f course simply deferring payments to suppliers could have adverse consequences
O
that more than offset the benefits of this additional cash flow Therefore it is
important to develop a holistic approach The firm should consider the following
best practices for payables management
Managing payment dates and terms to maximize cash flow ndash
y reporting on
receivable and
id penalty charges and taking advantage of
wer vendors and negotiate for more
to buying consortia with others even
voices for
payment based on receipt of goods or receipt of invoice whichever
comes later
Calculating and setting performance targets Regularl
AP performance measures such as days in payables
Coordinating the AP processes with accounts
inventory management to ensure that the company is collecting more
cash than it is paying out
Paying bills on time to avo
prompt-payment discounts where the discounts exceed the companyrsquos
cost of working capital
Consolidating purchases with fe
favorable payment terms
Considering entering in
Page 27 of 46
competitors to obtain favorable supplier pricing and terms
Unless contract terms specify otherwise setting up in
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Page 28 of 46
Em
process
-time payments with Electronic Funds Transfer (EFT)
uraging vendors to utilize electronic invoice presentment
a
ndancies and more
ploying technology to automate the accounts payable transaction
es ndash
Making just-in
Using an electronic invoice-matching application
Enco
For companies with multiple locations or business units employing
shared service approach for AP to eliminate redu
quickly implement process improvements
Mainta
vendor
Communicating accounts payable requirements to suppliers at the
m key suppliers
for suggestions on how to improve the
Efficient a
and making th rsquos cash is just good business
ining open communications and building strong relationships with
s to access valuable trade credit ndash
beginning of transactions
Requesting summary invoicing fro
Requiring suppliers to send invoices directly to accounts payable
Asking tier-one suppliers
payment process
nd effective management of accounts payable helps improve cash flow ndash
e most of company
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
6 OVERVIEW OF VIRGIN GROUP
Virgin - one of the most respected brands in Britain - is now becoming the first global
brand name of the 21st century Virgin is involved in planes trains finance soft
drinks music mobile phones holidays cars wines publishing bridal wear - the lot
What tie all these businesses together are the values of its brand and the attitude of its
people Virgin has created over 200 companies worldwide employing over 25000
people Its total revenues around the world in 2002 exceeded pound4 billion (US $72
billion)
In 1970 Richard Branson founded Virgin as a mail order record retailer and not
long after he opened a record shop in Oxford Street London During 1972 a
recording studio was built in Oxfordshire and the first Virgin artist Mike Oldfield
recorded Tubular Bells which was released in 1973
This album went on to sell over 5 million copies Since then many household names
including Belinda Carlisle Genesis Phil Collins Janet Jackson and The Rolling
Stones have helped to make Virgin Music one of the top six record companies in the
world The equity of Virgin Music Group - record labels music publishing and
recording studios was sold to THORN EMI in 1992 in a US$1billion deal
Page 29 of 46
The Virgin Group has now expanded into international music Mega stores air
travel mobile financial retail music internet drinks rail hotels and leisure with
around 200 companies in over 30 countries
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
In Virgins customers eyes Virgin stands for value for money quality innovation
fun and a sense of competitive challenge It delivers a quality service by empowering
its employees and facilitates and monitors customer feedback to continually improve
the customers experience through innovation
When they start a new venture Virgin bases it on hard research and analysis
Typically they review the industry and put themselves in the customers shoes to see
what could make it better Virgin asks fundamental questions
Is this an opportunity for restructuring a market and creating competitive
advantage What are the competitors doing
Is the customer confused or badly served
Is this an opportunity for building the Virgin brand
Can we add value
Will it interact with its other businesses
Is there an appropriate trade-off between risk and reward
Page 30 of 46
Virgin is also able to draw on talented people from throughout the group New
ventures are often steered by people seconded from other parts of Virgin who bring
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
with them the trademark management style skills and experience Virgin frequently
creates partnerships with others to combine skills knowledge and market presence
and so on Contrary to what some people may think their constantly expanding and
eclectic empire is neither random nor reckless Each successive venture demonstrates
its skill in picking the right market and the right opportunity
7 OVERVIEW OF VIRGIN SOFT DRINKS
The Virgin Drinks Group first launched as the Virgin Cola Company in 1994 with
Virgin Cola in the UK Since then the company has ventured across the carbonated
soft drinks arena and beyond into energy drinks tea and flavored Colas This
expansion has lead to the evolution of the Virgin Drinks Company a company
whose aim is to put the excitement back into the world of soft drinks It launched in
Bangladesh in 1999 Virgin Soft Drinks is monitored by Global Beverage Co Ltd in
Bangladesh
Brief history of Virgin Drinks is given below
Page 31 of 46
1994 November Virgin Cola launched in the UK
1996 March Virgin Cola launched in France
1998 June Virgin Cola launched in Belgium
April Virgin Cola launched in the French West Indies
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
August Virgin Cola launched in Switzerland
1999 March Virgin Colours launched in Italy
March Virgin Cola launched in Japan
July Virgin Colours launched in South Africa
December Virgin Colours launched in Bangladesh
2001 January Sweden launched Virgin Colours
November Singapore launched Virgin Colours
2002 February Croatia launched Virgin Colours
June Russia launched Virgin Colours
June Tunisia launched Virgin Colours
2003 May Israel launched Virgin Colours
8 FINDINGS OF WORKING CAPITAL MANAGEMENT MAINTAINED BY
VIRGIN SOFT DRINKS IN BANGLADESH
81 CASH MANAGEMENT
811 Holding Cash and Marketable Securities
Although there are many good reasons why firm hold cash and marketable
securities Virgin Drinks holds cash and marketable securities for two reasons ndash
i) Cash for transactions
ii) Cash as hedges
This indicates that the firm does not hold cash and marketable securities for some
important reasons such as ndash
i) Near cash assets as hedges
Page 32 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
ii) Temporary investment and compensating balances
Virgin Soft Drinks does not invest in money market securities such as Treasury bill
commercial paper certificate of deposits bankerrsquos acceptance and repurchase
agreement This firm deposits its money in bank as currant AC or fixed AC They
say that they do not have enough money to invest in money market instrument
They also say that if they have enough money they will invest it in money market
short term securities We know that near cash interest earning assets can be
substituted for cash when motivation for holding these assets is the hedging of cash
flow uncertainties or is the temporary investment of surplus funds In this point
Virgins position is not good as there is no significant hedging against uncertainty of
cash
812 Floatation and Check Clearing
Virgin is very smart in handling the problem of transit time for checks Here mail
float takes 2 to 3 days at firm takes 025 day and clearing float takes 1-3 days Virgin
uses most of the strategies available for reducing the delay in receiving funds It
(Virgin) has linked Islami Bank which posses an accelerated clearing facility It uses
electronic collection process which ensures faster collection and its at the firm check
processing is satisfactory But Virgin does not use lockbox The reason behind this is
that it is not cost-effective for Virgin to set lockboxes At this point we can say that
Virgins check clearing mechanism is much good
813 Cash Concentration and Disbursement Management
Page 33 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks takes the matter of cash concentration very seriously They use all
the available cash concentration mechanism Virgin is a firm with small deposits
spread over a substantial number of banks and this is why the firm tends to use
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
depository transfer checks extensively If is less costly Virgin also uses automated
clearing house and wire transfer To Virgin wire transfer seems too costly
Like other firm Virgin tries to retain the cash for as long as possible But Virgin
always performs it in an ethical manner Virgin does not try to defeat the receiving
firmrsquos attempts to reduce the float on incoming checks It does not take any strategy
for increasing mail float at firm float and clearing float on its outgoing checks To
Virgin it is deemed to be unethical It thinks that maximization of disbursement float
will not go unnoticed by sophisticated creditors for very long When it is noticed it
will negatively affect relations with these creditors reducing the firmrsquos bargaining
power with them This may ultimately cost Virgin dearly when future prices and
delivery schedules for goods and services purchased from trade creditors are
negotiated Virgin follows ldquoZero-Balance Accountsrdquo methods for managing
disbursement It thinks that in this method the coordination of funds inflows to
disbursement banks with the presentation of checks does not work to the detriment
of creditors since the firmrsquos checks to them are honored as presented and this strategy
does not affect float significantly Controlled disbursing method is less attractive to
Virgin because zero-balance system is already feasible
814 Cash Forecasting
Cash Forecasting and Its Types
Page 34 of 46
Virgin forecasts the future cash inflows and outflows To Virgin cash forecast is an
important part of the firmrsquos cash control system and is one of the forecasts that are
part of the Virginrsquos financial plan Virgin forecasts cash on monthly basis and on
yearly basis Virgin does not forecast on daily basis assuming that the temporary
shortage of funds within these periods can be covered without value cost eg
advance receipts from customers Virginrsquos cash forecasting system involves a
combination of distribution and scheduling The receipts and disbursements
approach of cash forecasting is used in virgin This method is used because it
minutely traces the movement of cash and very close control of cash is possible
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Virgin does not use adjusted net income approach on two grounds First it does not
permit the tracing of the individual types of cash inflows and outflows for any given
period which is often useful information for virgin Second it is not simple to use
Items to be Forecast
Virgin does not forecast all the items It forecasts only major items eg accounts
receivable notes receivable payroll cash purchases of raw materials In this regard
virgin trade off between cost and benefit
Methods of Financial Forecasting
Virgin forecasts the future level of financial variable such as cash level asset level or
liability level We know in short term forecasts many things will result from plans
and events that are already in place (contracts capital budgets long-range financing
plans and so forth) But in the long run most things can vary and are dependent on
outside influences such as the firmrsquos long-term growth rate Since Virginrsquos cash
forecasting deals mostly with near future many of the items on the cash forecasts are
estimated by some variation of the spot method and remaining estimates are mostly
on a ldquoproportion of another accountrdquo basis with this ldquoother accountrdquo often being a
particular periodrsquos sales Virgin uses the other two methods less frequently
Using Cash Forecast
Virgin forecasts cash for meeting general objectives (ie to know the available funds
for investment and need financing) and for meeting some special objectives (eg to
know whether the firm will fulfill its out of debt requirement) But it is matter to note
that Virgin does not make any short term investment of its surplus cash but only keep
this surplus in Bank Account
Page 35 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Sources of Uncertainty in Cash Forecasting and Hedging Uncertainties
Virgin faces uncertainty in cash forecasting mainly from two sources These are ndash
sales and production cost In peak season (hot season like autumn summer) sales
increases but in dull season (eg in winter) sales decreases drastically Production
cost may be increased because of increase of price of sugar chemicals aluminum
can Virgin follows two methods for hedging cash balance uncertainties These are ndash
i) Holding a stock of extra cash and
ii) Extra borrowing capacity
815 Modes for the Management of Cash and Temporary Investments
Virgin does not follow any of these methods wholly Virgin receives cash
continuously and pays salary at steady rate and pays continuously for other
expenses So it neither follows Baumol model nor Beranek model It has no upper
control limit lower control limit return point in case cash management So it neither
follows Miller-Orr model nor Stone model
In Summary
Page 36 of 46
Standard Compliance by Virgin Soft Drinks
Generally all firms hold cash and
marketable securities
Virgin holds only cash
Firms hold cash and marketable
securities for some reasons like
bull Cash for transactions
bull Cash and near-cash assets as
hedges
bull Temporary investments
bull Compensating balances
Virgin holds cash only for
two reasons ndash
bull Cash for transactions
bull Cash as hedges
Available money market instruments Virgin does not invest in any such
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
(short term securities) are ndash
Treasury Bills
Commercial Paper
Certificates of Deposit
Bankerrsquos Acceptance
Repurch menase Agree ts
instruments They only keep cash in
Bank Account
Mail Float
(1 to 5 days)
At Firm
Float
(025 to 1
day)
Clearing
Float
(0 to
2 days)
Mail Float
(2 to 3 days)
At firm
Float
(025
day)
Clearing
Float
(1 to 3
days)
Figure Transit time for a typical check Figure Transit time for a check for
Virgin
Strategies that firms can use to reduce
the delay in receiving funds are ndash
Selecting of Banks with
accelerated clearing capabilities
of check processing Acceleration
at the firm
ectronic collection Use of el
procedures
Use of lockboxes
Virgin follows the first three strategies
but does not use lockboxes
Available cash concentration
mechanisms are ndash
Depository transfer check
ouse Automated Clearing H
(ACH) electronic transfer)
Wire transfer
Virgin uses all these mechanisms of
cash concentration
Available sets of techniques for cash
disbursement management are ndash
ement of disbursement
Page 37 of 46
Manag
float
Virgin uses zero-balance accounts
technique
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Zero-Balance Accounts
Controlled disbursing
Firms may make cash flow forecasts
over periods of various lengths yearly
flows quarterly flows monthly flows
weekly flows or even daily flows
Virgin forecasts cash on yearly basis and
monthly basis
Cash forecasting system may involve ndash
Distribution
Scheduling
Virginrsquos cash forecasting system
involves a combination of distribution
and scheduling
Two common approaches to cash flow
in generating the cash forecast
and disbursement Receipts
approach
Adjusted net income approach
Virgin uses the receipts and
disbursement approach
There are many items to forecast Virgin forecasts only major items like
AR payroll etc
Four common approach to forecasting
fina i ndash nc al variables are
Spot method
Proportion to another account
Compounded growth
Multiple dependencies
Virgin uses spot method for forecasting
cash It uses proportion to another
account method for other variables and
remaining two methods are frequently
used
Sources of uncertainty in cash
forecasting are ndash
Sales uncertainty
Collection rate uncertainty
Production cost uncertainty
Capital outflow uncertainty
Virgin faces uncertainty mainly from
sales and production cost
Methods for hedging cash balance
unc a
Page 38 of 46
ert inties are ndash
i) Holding a stock of extra cash
Virgin two available methods for
hedging cash balance uncertainties
Th ese are ndash
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
ii) stock of near-cash Holding a
assets
iii) Extra borrowing capacity
iv) ary surpluses in Investing tempor
near-cash assets
i) Holding a stock of extra cash
ii) Extra borrowing capacity
(advance receipt from
customers)
Models for the management of cash and
temporary investments are ndash Baumol
model Beranek model Miller-Orr
model and Stone model
Virgin does not follow any method
wholly but a combination of Baumol
model and Beranek model is occurred
82 INVENTORY MANAGEMENT
21 Certainty Approach
isnt used in
irgin because it thinks it is not possible to implement in Bangladesh
d time is one to three days It
oes not use ABC system of inventory management
8
Main item of inventory of Virgin is Can pet chip sugar label chemical artificial
sweet etc Virgin maintains a minimum level of inventory but it does not have to face
problems because inventory is managed efficiently just-in-time (JIT)
V
Virgin maintains buffer stock because of the shortage of work-in-process (WIP)
inventory Its production process may also be hampered Thats why it maintains
safety stock to avoid stock out cost In case of imported goods normal lead time is
about one month and within the country normal lea
d
Page 39 of 46
Inventory Model
In reality Virgin does not use any of models of EOQ ordering and holding strategy
and safety stock strategy They maintain inventory based on their prior experience
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
822 Uncertainty Approach
Virgin does not use any model for handling inventory uncertainty It says that such
decision depends on business cycle and market situation Long before Eid festival
they bought large amount of sugar because of price increase on the occasion of Eid
In summary
Standard Compliance by Virgin Soft Drinks
Firms maintain inventory to guard
against several problems
Virgin maintains a minimum level of
inventory which is managed efficiently
Some firms use JIT to avoid inventory
cost
JIT is not used by Virgin as it thinks it is
impossible to implement in Bangladesh
Firms maintain buffer stock Virgin maintains buffer stock too
Firms maintain safety stock to avoid
shortage cost
Virgin also maintains safety stock
Firms use ABC system to monitor
inventory
Virgin doesnt use ABC system
EOQ model is an appropriate method
for measuring quantity that has to be
ordered per order
Virgin does not use EOQ model rather
makes order based on experience and
market demand
83 MANAGING ACCOUNTS RECEIVABLE (DEBTORS)
831 Terms of Sale Decision
Page 40 of 46
Virgin offers the term 210 net 30 enables the customers to deduct 2 percent from the
face value of the bill when paying within the first 10 days but if the discount is not
taken the customer must remit the full amount within 30 days But Virgin does not
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
offer the same terms of sale to all customers For prime customers it offers special
terms of sale In setting an appropriate term of sale it costs and benefits regarding
this are compared It uses the standard approach of terms of sale decision as it is
simple to use
832 Credit Granting Decisions
In case of Virgin the Capital and Character of Five Cs get more importance
Although there are many problems with the traditional approach Virgin uses it
because of its simplicity Virgin does not use Net Present Value (NPV) method in
credit granting decision It thinks that NPV is an appropriate method and should be
used next time It does not face any severe problem because of bad debts The reason
is that notes receivable is used when credit is granted
833 Monitoring Accounts Receivable
Virgin monitors its accounts receivable Virgin believes that in any case both positive
and negative durations in accounts signal differences from the results that
management believe to be the most advantageous for the firm
Tools for Monitoring Accounts Receivable
Page 41 of 46
For monitoring accounts receivable there are several tools such as aging schedule
the ratios of receivable outstanding to original sales customers payment proportion
and sales weighted DSO (Days Sales Outstanding) For monitoring accounts
receivable Virgin uses aging schedule fractions and traditional DSO statistics
because of their simplicity in use Although payment proportions ratios of
receivables outstanding and sales weighted DSO methods are free from inherent bias
None of these is used because all these are complex to maintain
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
In summary
Page 42 of 46
Standard Compliance by Virgin Soft Drinks
Generals terms of sale is 210 net 30 Normally Virgin also use general terms
of sale ie 210 net 30
Firms do not offer the same terms of
sale to all customers
Yes For prime customers Virgin offers
special terms of sale
Approaches of terms of sale decisions
are ndash
bull Standard approach
bull Multi period approach
Virgin uses standard approach of terms
of sale decision as it is simple to use and
understand
Source of credit information are ndash
Sellers prior experience with the
customer
Credit agency ratings and
reports
Personal contact with the
applicants bank and other
creditors
Analysis of applicants financial
statements
Customer visit
Main source of credit information to
Virgin is its prior experience with the
customer All other sources are not cost-
effective for Virgin
Approaches of credit granting to
marginal accounts are ndash
Traditional approach
Net Present Value (NPV)
approach
It uses traditional approach still now but
thinks that NPV should be used for the
next periods
Firms monitor accounts receivable
because deviations from the expected
levels of turnover and of bad debt can
Virgin also monitors its accounts
receivable
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
signal several different problems
Different tools for monitoring accounts
receivable are ndash
Aging schedule
Ratios of receivables
outstanding to original sales
Customers payment
proportions
Sales-weighted DSO
For monitoring accounts receivable
Virgin uses aging schedule and
traditional sales outstanding statistics
84 MANAGING ACCOUNTS PAYABLE (CREDITORS)
Virgin has almost accounts payable of Tk 8000000 But most of its liabilities are to
the banks rather than suppliers But we dont have any clear information about
Virgins accounts payable
9 RECOMMENDATION
Virgin should invest its surplus cash in short term marketable securities
because it is suitable hedging against cash uncertainties and will also give
some returns (interest income)
Virgin should publish its own annual report which will satisfy information
needs of stakeholders and also increase the credibility of information provided
by Virgin
Page 43 of 46
Virgin should use multi period approach in terms of sale decision because
standard approach which is already exists in Virgin has some inherent
problems
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
It should stop using traditional approach from now It should use NPV
method in credit granting to marginal accounts
In monitoring accounts receivable Virgin should use sales-weighted DSO
method because it has least limitation compared to the others
It should be more flexible in granting credit which will ultimately increase its
sales
To get the appropriate number of quantity to be ordered per order it should
use DSO model
It should be ABC system for proper monitoring of inventory
10 CONCLUSION
The use of other peoples money in business is usually an expensive resource Before
looking outside for finance a firm should examine its own working capital cycle to
make sure that every rand of its own internal funds is being fully utilized Good
management of working capital is part of good financial management Effective use
of working capital will contribute to the operational efficiency of the whole
organization optimum use will help to generate maximum returns Furthermore
working capital management is not an end in itself It is an integral part of the firms
overall management The needs of efficient working capital management must be
considered in relation to other aspects of the Virgins financial and non-financial
performance Thats why when planning the development of a business it is critical
that the impact of working capital be fully assessed
Page 44 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
BIBLIOGRAPHY
Scherr FC (1989) International Edition Prentice-Hall International Inc Modern
Working Capital Management Text and Cases
Hussain Riaz (2002) Working Capital Management
Robertson Lonnie (July 1998) Inventory Management
httpwwwasashoporg visited on March 13 2006
The Art of Cash Management
httpwwwinccom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management
httpwwwstudyfinancecom visited on March 13 2006
White Paper ndash Managing Working Capital
httpwwwplanwareorg visited on March 13 2006
Management of Working Capital
httpwwwbusinesscentralcoza visited on March 13 2006
Cash Management
httpwwwsbagov visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management Objectives
httpwpsprenhallcom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management
Page 45 of 46
httpwwwadvancemecom visited on March 13 2006
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Business Receivables Financing
httpwwwbbtcom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Finance
http wwwfnbcoza visited on March 13 2006
Tips to manage your working capital
httpsmallbusinessninemsncomau visited on March 13 2006
Inventory Financing
httpwwwfranklincapitalnetworkcom visited on March 13 2006
Accounts Receivable Management
httpwwwfranklincapitalnetworkcom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management
httpwwwtreasurygovtnz visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management
httpwwwtreasurystrategiescom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Works
httpwwwinvestopediacom visited on March 13 2006
Treasury Services
httpwwwjpmorganchasecom visited on March 13 2006
what were about
Page 46 of 46
httpwwwvirgincom visited on March 13 2006
Annexure
Annexure
Interview with YASEER RIZVI
Mr Yaseer Rizvi the DMD of Global Beverage Co Ltd obtained his MBA degree
from a reputed university He had been the Director of Ocean Container Ltd before
joining in Global Beverage Co Ltd He possesses a nice personality
I interviewed Yaseer Rizvi Excerpts from his interview are as follows ndash
Shah Kamal Sir would you please tell me do you invest in short term marketable securities
Yaseer Rizvi Basically we do not invest our surplus cash in short term marketable
securities like T-Bill commercial paper certificate of deposit etc But we keep our
surplus cash in Bank
Shah Kamal Would you tell me something about transit time for a typical check
Yaseer Rizvi Well in Virgin the transit time for a typical check is ndash
For mail float 2 to 3 days
At firm float 6 hours
Clearing float 1 to 3 days
Shah Kamal Do you maintain any cash concentration mechanism like depository transfer check automated clearing house and wire transfer
i
Annexure
Yaseer Rizvi Our position in this case is very strong as we use all the mechanisms
you mentioned As Virgin is a firm with small deposits spread over a substantial
number of banks so we tend to use depository transfer checks extensively It is less
costly We also use automated clearing house and wire transfer but later is used in a
less extent
Shah Kamal Sir what techniques of disbursement management is used by your firm
Yaseer Rizvi Like other firms Virgin tries to retain the cash for as long as possible
But we always perform it in an ethical manner We do not use management of
disbursement float as it seems unethical We follow Zero-Balance Accounts method
for managing disbursement We do not prefer Controlled Disbursing method since
Zero-Balance system is already practiced in Virgin
Shah Kamal How do you hedge cash balance uncertainties
Yaseer Rizvi Well you may say that we do not invest in short term securities but for
facing cash difficulties we keep our surplus cash in bank
Shah Kamal Sir would you please tell me the general terms of sale of Virgin
Yaseer Rizvi Though it is difficult to maintain a fixed terms of sale our general terms
of sale is 210 n30 But for prime customers we offer special terms of sale
Shah Kamal What are the sources of credit information in case of your firm
Yaseer Rizvi We grant credit on the basis of prior experience with the customers In
case of a new customer personal contact is weighted
Shah Kamal Does your firm consider 5 Cs in granting credit
ii
Annexure
Yaseer Rizvi In case of Virgin Capital and Character get more importance than the
others Mind one thing personal relationship is the main measure in granting credit
Shah Kamal Do you use NPV method in credit granting decisions
Yaseer Rizvi We do not use NPV method But we think that NPV is a suitable
method and we have to use it from the next period
Shah Kamal Sir how do you handle the problem of bad debt
Yaseer Rizvi Well in this case our position is very strong Yet we do not face any
problem because of bad debt Just note that we make more than 80 of sales in cash
and we monitor accounts receivable very carefully
Shah Kamal What level of inventory is maintained by Virgin
Yaseer Rizvi We maintain a minimum level of inventory but do not have to face
stock out problems because inventory is managed efficiently
Shah Kamal What is the normal lead time
Yaseer Rizvi In case of imported goods normal lead time is about 1 month and when
we purchase raw materials from inside the country lead time is 1 to 3 days
Shah Kamal What method do you use for managing inventory
Yaseer Rizvi We do not use any method particularly rather inventory decision
depends on business cycle and market situation Long before the Eid festival we
bought large amount of sugar because price of sugar was increased on the occasion
of Eid
iii
Annexure
Shah Kamal What are the main items of inventory of your firm
Yaseer Rizvi Well these are ndash aluminum can pet chip sugar label chemical and
artificial sweet
Shah Kamal What are the uncertainties in maintaining appropriate level of stock
Yaseer Rizvi These are ndash
bull Increase in price of raw materials
bull Sales uncertainty
bull Market trends etc
Shah Kamal Thank you for your kind cooperation
Yaseer Rizvi Most Welcome
iv
Global Beverage Company Limited
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Electronic payments (direct credits) are cheaper than check payments considering
that transaction fees and overheads more than balance the advantage of delayed
presentation Some suppliers are reluctant to receive payments by this method but in
view of the substantial cost advantage (and the advantages to the suppliers
themselves) departments may wish to encourage suppliers to accept this option
However electronic payments are likely to be used in conjunction with rather than
as a replacement for check payments
Applying Best Practices in Managing Accounts Payable
f course simply deferring payments to suppliers could have adverse consequences
O
that more than offset the benefits of this additional cash flow Therefore it is
important to develop a holistic approach The firm should consider the following
best practices for payables management
Managing payment dates and terms to maximize cash flow ndash
y reporting on
receivable and
id penalty charges and taking advantage of
wer vendors and negotiate for more
to buying consortia with others even
voices for
payment based on receipt of goods or receipt of invoice whichever
comes later
Calculating and setting performance targets Regularl
AP performance measures such as days in payables
Coordinating the AP processes with accounts
inventory management to ensure that the company is collecting more
cash than it is paying out
Paying bills on time to avo
prompt-payment discounts where the discounts exceed the companyrsquos
cost of working capital
Consolidating purchases with fe
favorable payment terms
Considering entering in
Page 27 of 46
competitors to obtain favorable supplier pricing and terms
Unless contract terms specify otherwise setting up in
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Page 28 of 46
Em
process
-time payments with Electronic Funds Transfer (EFT)
uraging vendors to utilize electronic invoice presentment
a
ndancies and more
ploying technology to automate the accounts payable transaction
es ndash
Making just-in
Using an electronic invoice-matching application
Enco
For companies with multiple locations or business units employing
shared service approach for AP to eliminate redu
quickly implement process improvements
Mainta
vendor
Communicating accounts payable requirements to suppliers at the
m key suppliers
for suggestions on how to improve the
Efficient a
and making th rsquos cash is just good business
ining open communications and building strong relationships with
s to access valuable trade credit ndash
beginning of transactions
Requesting summary invoicing fro
Requiring suppliers to send invoices directly to accounts payable
Asking tier-one suppliers
payment process
nd effective management of accounts payable helps improve cash flow ndash
e most of company
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
6 OVERVIEW OF VIRGIN GROUP
Virgin - one of the most respected brands in Britain - is now becoming the first global
brand name of the 21st century Virgin is involved in planes trains finance soft
drinks music mobile phones holidays cars wines publishing bridal wear - the lot
What tie all these businesses together are the values of its brand and the attitude of its
people Virgin has created over 200 companies worldwide employing over 25000
people Its total revenues around the world in 2002 exceeded pound4 billion (US $72
billion)
In 1970 Richard Branson founded Virgin as a mail order record retailer and not
long after he opened a record shop in Oxford Street London During 1972 a
recording studio was built in Oxfordshire and the first Virgin artist Mike Oldfield
recorded Tubular Bells which was released in 1973
This album went on to sell over 5 million copies Since then many household names
including Belinda Carlisle Genesis Phil Collins Janet Jackson and The Rolling
Stones have helped to make Virgin Music one of the top six record companies in the
world The equity of Virgin Music Group - record labels music publishing and
recording studios was sold to THORN EMI in 1992 in a US$1billion deal
Page 29 of 46
The Virgin Group has now expanded into international music Mega stores air
travel mobile financial retail music internet drinks rail hotels and leisure with
around 200 companies in over 30 countries
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
In Virgins customers eyes Virgin stands for value for money quality innovation
fun and a sense of competitive challenge It delivers a quality service by empowering
its employees and facilitates and monitors customer feedback to continually improve
the customers experience through innovation
When they start a new venture Virgin bases it on hard research and analysis
Typically they review the industry and put themselves in the customers shoes to see
what could make it better Virgin asks fundamental questions
Is this an opportunity for restructuring a market and creating competitive
advantage What are the competitors doing
Is the customer confused or badly served
Is this an opportunity for building the Virgin brand
Can we add value
Will it interact with its other businesses
Is there an appropriate trade-off between risk and reward
Page 30 of 46
Virgin is also able to draw on talented people from throughout the group New
ventures are often steered by people seconded from other parts of Virgin who bring
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
with them the trademark management style skills and experience Virgin frequently
creates partnerships with others to combine skills knowledge and market presence
and so on Contrary to what some people may think their constantly expanding and
eclectic empire is neither random nor reckless Each successive venture demonstrates
its skill in picking the right market and the right opportunity
7 OVERVIEW OF VIRGIN SOFT DRINKS
The Virgin Drinks Group first launched as the Virgin Cola Company in 1994 with
Virgin Cola in the UK Since then the company has ventured across the carbonated
soft drinks arena and beyond into energy drinks tea and flavored Colas This
expansion has lead to the evolution of the Virgin Drinks Company a company
whose aim is to put the excitement back into the world of soft drinks It launched in
Bangladesh in 1999 Virgin Soft Drinks is monitored by Global Beverage Co Ltd in
Bangladesh
Brief history of Virgin Drinks is given below
Page 31 of 46
1994 November Virgin Cola launched in the UK
1996 March Virgin Cola launched in France
1998 June Virgin Cola launched in Belgium
April Virgin Cola launched in the French West Indies
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
August Virgin Cola launched in Switzerland
1999 March Virgin Colours launched in Italy
March Virgin Cola launched in Japan
July Virgin Colours launched in South Africa
December Virgin Colours launched in Bangladesh
2001 January Sweden launched Virgin Colours
November Singapore launched Virgin Colours
2002 February Croatia launched Virgin Colours
June Russia launched Virgin Colours
June Tunisia launched Virgin Colours
2003 May Israel launched Virgin Colours
8 FINDINGS OF WORKING CAPITAL MANAGEMENT MAINTAINED BY
VIRGIN SOFT DRINKS IN BANGLADESH
81 CASH MANAGEMENT
811 Holding Cash and Marketable Securities
Although there are many good reasons why firm hold cash and marketable
securities Virgin Drinks holds cash and marketable securities for two reasons ndash
i) Cash for transactions
ii) Cash as hedges
This indicates that the firm does not hold cash and marketable securities for some
important reasons such as ndash
i) Near cash assets as hedges
Page 32 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
ii) Temporary investment and compensating balances
Virgin Soft Drinks does not invest in money market securities such as Treasury bill
commercial paper certificate of deposits bankerrsquos acceptance and repurchase
agreement This firm deposits its money in bank as currant AC or fixed AC They
say that they do not have enough money to invest in money market instrument
They also say that if they have enough money they will invest it in money market
short term securities We know that near cash interest earning assets can be
substituted for cash when motivation for holding these assets is the hedging of cash
flow uncertainties or is the temporary investment of surplus funds In this point
Virgins position is not good as there is no significant hedging against uncertainty of
cash
812 Floatation and Check Clearing
Virgin is very smart in handling the problem of transit time for checks Here mail
float takes 2 to 3 days at firm takes 025 day and clearing float takes 1-3 days Virgin
uses most of the strategies available for reducing the delay in receiving funds It
(Virgin) has linked Islami Bank which posses an accelerated clearing facility It uses
electronic collection process which ensures faster collection and its at the firm check
processing is satisfactory But Virgin does not use lockbox The reason behind this is
that it is not cost-effective for Virgin to set lockboxes At this point we can say that
Virgins check clearing mechanism is much good
813 Cash Concentration and Disbursement Management
Page 33 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks takes the matter of cash concentration very seriously They use all
the available cash concentration mechanism Virgin is a firm with small deposits
spread over a substantial number of banks and this is why the firm tends to use
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
depository transfer checks extensively If is less costly Virgin also uses automated
clearing house and wire transfer To Virgin wire transfer seems too costly
Like other firm Virgin tries to retain the cash for as long as possible But Virgin
always performs it in an ethical manner Virgin does not try to defeat the receiving
firmrsquos attempts to reduce the float on incoming checks It does not take any strategy
for increasing mail float at firm float and clearing float on its outgoing checks To
Virgin it is deemed to be unethical It thinks that maximization of disbursement float
will not go unnoticed by sophisticated creditors for very long When it is noticed it
will negatively affect relations with these creditors reducing the firmrsquos bargaining
power with them This may ultimately cost Virgin dearly when future prices and
delivery schedules for goods and services purchased from trade creditors are
negotiated Virgin follows ldquoZero-Balance Accountsrdquo methods for managing
disbursement It thinks that in this method the coordination of funds inflows to
disbursement banks with the presentation of checks does not work to the detriment
of creditors since the firmrsquos checks to them are honored as presented and this strategy
does not affect float significantly Controlled disbursing method is less attractive to
Virgin because zero-balance system is already feasible
814 Cash Forecasting
Cash Forecasting and Its Types
Page 34 of 46
Virgin forecasts the future cash inflows and outflows To Virgin cash forecast is an
important part of the firmrsquos cash control system and is one of the forecasts that are
part of the Virginrsquos financial plan Virgin forecasts cash on monthly basis and on
yearly basis Virgin does not forecast on daily basis assuming that the temporary
shortage of funds within these periods can be covered without value cost eg
advance receipts from customers Virginrsquos cash forecasting system involves a
combination of distribution and scheduling The receipts and disbursements
approach of cash forecasting is used in virgin This method is used because it
minutely traces the movement of cash and very close control of cash is possible
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Virgin does not use adjusted net income approach on two grounds First it does not
permit the tracing of the individual types of cash inflows and outflows for any given
period which is often useful information for virgin Second it is not simple to use
Items to be Forecast
Virgin does not forecast all the items It forecasts only major items eg accounts
receivable notes receivable payroll cash purchases of raw materials In this regard
virgin trade off between cost and benefit
Methods of Financial Forecasting
Virgin forecasts the future level of financial variable such as cash level asset level or
liability level We know in short term forecasts many things will result from plans
and events that are already in place (contracts capital budgets long-range financing
plans and so forth) But in the long run most things can vary and are dependent on
outside influences such as the firmrsquos long-term growth rate Since Virginrsquos cash
forecasting deals mostly with near future many of the items on the cash forecasts are
estimated by some variation of the spot method and remaining estimates are mostly
on a ldquoproportion of another accountrdquo basis with this ldquoother accountrdquo often being a
particular periodrsquos sales Virgin uses the other two methods less frequently
Using Cash Forecast
Virgin forecasts cash for meeting general objectives (ie to know the available funds
for investment and need financing) and for meeting some special objectives (eg to
know whether the firm will fulfill its out of debt requirement) But it is matter to note
that Virgin does not make any short term investment of its surplus cash but only keep
this surplus in Bank Account
Page 35 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Sources of Uncertainty in Cash Forecasting and Hedging Uncertainties
Virgin faces uncertainty in cash forecasting mainly from two sources These are ndash
sales and production cost In peak season (hot season like autumn summer) sales
increases but in dull season (eg in winter) sales decreases drastically Production
cost may be increased because of increase of price of sugar chemicals aluminum
can Virgin follows two methods for hedging cash balance uncertainties These are ndash
i) Holding a stock of extra cash and
ii) Extra borrowing capacity
815 Modes for the Management of Cash and Temporary Investments
Virgin does not follow any of these methods wholly Virgin receives cash
continuously and pays salary at steady rate and pays continuously for other
expenses So it neither follows Baumol model nor Beranek model It has no upper
control limit lower control limit return point in case cash management So it neither
follows Miller-Orr model nor Stone model
In Summary
Page 36 of 46
Standard Compliance by Virgin Soft Drinks
Generally all firms hold cash and
marketable securities
Virgin holds only cash
Firms hold cash and marketable
securities for some reasons like
bull Cash for transactions
bull Cash and near-cash assets as
hedges
bull Temporary investments
bull Compensating balances
Virgin holds cash only for
two reasons ndash
bull Cash for transactions
bull Cash as hedges
Available money market instruments Virgin does not invest in any such
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
(short term securities) are ndash
Treasury Bills
Commercial Paper
Certificates of Deposit
Bankerrsquos Acceptance
Repurch menase Agree ts
instruments They only keep cash in
Bank Account
Mail Float
(1 to 5 days)
At Firm
Float
(025 to 1
day)
Clearing
Float
(0 to
2 days)
Mail Float
(2 to 3 days)
At firm
Float
(025
day)
Clearing
Float
(1 to 3
days)
Figure Transit time for a typical check Figure Transit time for a check for
Virgin
Strategies that firms can use to reduce
the delay in receiving funds are ndash
Selecting of Banks with
accelerated clearing capabilities
of check processing Acceleration
at the firm
ectronic collection Use of el
procedures
Use of lockboxes
Virgin follows the first three strategies
but does not use lockboxes
Available cash concentration
mechanisms are ndash
Depository transfer check
ouse Automated Clearing H
(ACH) electronic transfer)
Wire transfer
Virgin uses all these mechanisms of
cash concentration
Available sets of techniques for cash
disbursement management are ndash
ement of disbursement
Page 37 of 46
Manag
float
Virgin uses zero-balance accounts
technique
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Zero-Balance Accounts
Controlled disbursing
Firms may make cash flow forecasts
over periods of various lengths yearly
flows quarterly flows monthly flows
weekly flows or even daily flows
Virgin forecasts cash on yearly basis and
monthly basis
Cash forecasting system may involve ndash
Distribution
Scheduling
Virginrsquos cash forecasting system
involves a combination of distribution
and scheduling
Two common approaches to cash flow
in generating the cash forecast
and disbursement Receipts
approach
Adjusted net income approach
Virgin uses the receipts and
disbursement approach
There are many items to forecast Virgin forecasts only major items like
AR payroll etc
Four common approach to forecasting
fina i ndash nc al variables are
Spot method
Proportion to another account
Compounded growth
Multiple dependencies
Virgin uses spot method for forecasting
cash It uses proportion to another
account method for other variables and
remaining two methods are frequently
used
Sources of uncertainty in cash
forecasting are ndash
Sales uncertainty
Collection rate uncertainty
Production cost uncertainty
Capital outflow uncertainty
Virgin faces uncertainty mainly from
sales and production cost
Methods for hedging cash balance
unc a
Page 38 of 46
ert inties are ndash
i) Holding a stock of extra cash
Virgin two available methods for
hedging cash balance uncertainties
Th ese are ndash
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
ii) stock of near-cash Holding a
assets
iii) Extra borrowing capacity
iv) ary surpluses in Investing tempor
near-cash assets
i) Holding a stock of extra cash
ii) Extra borrowing capacity
(advance receipt from
customers)
Models for the management of cash and
temporary investments are ndash Baumol
model Beranek model Miller-Orr
model and Stone model
Virgin does not follow any method
wholly but a combination of Baumol
model and Beranek model is occurred
82 INVENTORY MANAGEMENT
21 Certainty Approach
isnt used in
irgin because it thinks it is not possible to implement in Bangladesh
d time is one to three days It
oes not use ABC system of inventory management
8
Main item of inventory of Virgin is Can pet chip sugar label chemical artificial
sweet etc Virgin maintains a minimum level of inventory but it does not have to face
problems because inventory is managed efficiently just-in-time (JIT)
V
Virgin maintains buffer stock because of the shortage of work-in-process (WIP)
inventory Its production process may also be hampered Thats why it maintains
safety stock to avoid stock out cost In case of imported goods normal lead time is
about one month and within the country normal lea
d
Page 39 of 46
Inventory Model
In reality Virgin does not use any of models of EOQ ordering and holding strategy
and safety stock strategy They maintain inventory based on their prior experience
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
822 Uncertainty Approach
Virgin does not use any model for handling inventory uncertainty It says that such
decision depends on business cycle and market situation Long before Eid festival
they bought large amount of sugar because of price increase on the occasion of Eid
In summary
Standard Compliance by Virgin Soft Drinks
Firms maintain inventory to guard
against several problems
Virgin maintains a minimum level of
inventory which is managed efficiently
Some firms use JIT to avoid inventory
cost
JIT is not used by Virgin as it thinks it is
impossible to implement in Bangladesh
Firms maintain buffer stock Virgin maintains buffer stock too
Firms maintain safety stock to avoid
shortage cost
Virgin also maintains safety stock
Firms use ABC system to monitor
inventory
Virgin doesnt use ABC system
EOQ model is an appropriate method
for measuring quantity that has to be
ordered per order
Virgin does not use EOQ model rather
makes order based on experience and
market demand
83 MANAGING ACCOUNTS RECEIVABLE (DEBTORS)
831 Terms of Sale Decision
Page 40 of 46
Virgin offers the term 210 net 30 enables the customers to deduct 2 percent from the
face value of the bill when paying within the first 10 days but if the discount is not
taken the customer must remit the full amount within 30 days But Virgin does not
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
offer the same terms of sale to all customers For prime customers it offers special
terms of sale In setting an appropriate term of sale it costs and benefits regarding
this are compared It uses the standard approach of terms of sale decision as it is
simple to use
832 Credit Granting Decisions
In case of Virgin the Capital and Character of Five Cs get more importance
Although there are many problems with the traditional approach Virgin uses it
because of its simplicity Virgin does not use Net Present Value (NPV) method in
credit granting decision It thinks that NPV is an appropriate method and should be
used next time It does not face any severe problem because of bad debts The reason
is that notes receivable is used when credit is granted
833 Monitoring Accounts Receivable
Virgin monitors its accounts receivable Virgin believes that in any case both positive
and negative durations in accounts signal differences from the results that
management believe to be the most advantageous for the firm
Tools for Monitoring Accounts Receivable
Page 41 of 46
For monitoring accounts receivable there are several tools such as aging schedule
the ratios of receivable outstanding to original sales customers payment proportion
and sales weighted DSO (Days Sales Outstanding) For monitoring accounts
receivable Virgin uses aging schedule fractions and traditional DSO statistics
because of their simplicity in use Although payment proportions ratios of
receivables outstanding and sales weighted DSO methods are free from inherent bias
None of these is used because all these are complex to maintain
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
In summary
Page 42 of 46
Standard Compliance by Virgin Soft Drinks
Generals terms of sale is 210 net 30 Normally Virgin also use general terms
of sale ie 210 net 30
Firms do not offer the same terms of
sale to all customers
Yes For prime customers Virgin offers
special terms of sale
Approaches of terms of sale decisions
are ndash
bull Standard approach
bull Multi period approach
Virgin uses standard approach of terms
of sale decision as it is simple to use and
understand
Source of credit information are ndash
Sellers prior experience with the
customer
Credit agency ratings and
reports
Personal contact with the
applicants bank and other
creditors
Analysis of applicants financial
statements
Customer visit
Main source of credit information to
Virgin is its prior experience with the
customer All other sources are not cost-
effective for Virgin
Approaches of credit granting to
marginal accounts are ndash
Traditional approach
Net Present Value (NPV)
approach
It uses traditional approach still now but
thinks that NPV should be used for the
next periods
Firms monitor accounts receivable
because deviations from the expected
levels of turnover and of bad debt can
Virgin also monitors its accounts
receivable
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
signal several different problems
Different tools for monitoring accounts
receivable are ndash
Aging schedule
Ratios of receivables
outstanding to original sales
Customers payment
proportions
Sales-weighted DSO
For monitoring accounts receivable
Virgin uses aging schedule and
traditional sales outstanding statistics
84 MANAGING ACCOUNTS PAYABLE (CREDITORS)
Virgin has almost accounts payable of Tk 8000000 But most of its liabilities are to
the banks rather than suppliers But we dont have any clear information about
Virgins accounts payable
9 RECOMMENDATION
Virgin should invest its surplus cash in short term marketable securities
because it is suitable hedging against cash uncertainties and will also give
some returns (interest income)
Virgin should publish its own annual report which will satisfy information
needs of stakeholders and also increase the credibility of information provided
by Virgin
Page 43 of 46
Virgin should use multi period approach in terms of sale decision because
standard approach which is already exists in Virgin has some inherent
problems
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
It should stop using traditional approach from now It should use NPV
method in credit granting to marginal accounts
In monitoring accounts receivable Virgin should use sales-weighted DSO
method because it has least limitation compared to the others
It should be more flexible in granting credit which will ultimately increase its
sales
To get the appropriate number of quantity to be ordered per order it should
use DSO model
It should be ABC system for proper monitoring of inventory
10 CONCLUSION
The use of other peoples money in business is usually an expensive resource Before
looking outside for finance a firm should examine its own working capital cycle to
make sure that every rand of its own internal funds is being fully utilized Good
management of working capital is part of good financial management Effective use
of working capital will contribute to the operational efficiency of the whole
organization optimum use will help to generate maximum returns Furthermore
working capital management is not an end in itself It is an integral part of the firms
overall management The needs of efficient working capital management must be
considered in relation to other aspects of the Virgins financial and non-financial
performance Thats why when planning the development of a business it is critical
that the impact of working capital be fully assessed
Page 44 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
BIBLIOGRAPHY
Scherr FC (1989) International Edition Prentice-Hall International Inc Modern
Working Capital Management Text and Cases
Hussain Riaz (2002) Working Capital Management
Robertson Lonnie (July 1998) Inventory Management
httpwwwasashoporg visited on March 13 2006
The Art of Cash Management
httpwwwinccom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management
httpwwwstudyfinancecom visited on March 13 2006
White Paper ndash Managing Working Capital
httpwwwplanwareorg visited on March 13 2006
Management of Working Capital
httpwwwbusinesscentralcoza visited on March 13 2006
Cash Management
httpwwwsbagov visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management Objectives
httpwpsprenhallcom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management
Page 45 of 46
httpwwwadvancemecom visited on March 13 2006
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Business Receivables Financing
httpwwwbbtcom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Finance
http wwwfnbcoza visited on March 13 2006
Tips to manage your working capital
httpsmallbusinessninemsncomau visited on March 13 2006
Inventory Financing
httpwwwfranklincapitalnetworkcom visited on March 13 2006
Accounts Receivable Management
httpwwwfranklincapitalnetworkcom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management
httpwwwtreasurygovtnz visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management
httpwwwtreasurystrategiescom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Works
httpwwwinvestopediacom visited on March 13 2006
Treasury Services
httpwwwjpmorganchasecom visited on March 13 2006
what were about
Page 46 of 46
httpwwwvirgincom visited on March 13 2006
Annexure
Annexure
Interview with YASEER RIZVI
Mr Yaseer Rizvi the DMD of Global Beverage Co Ltd obtained his MBA degree
from a reputed university He had been the Director of Ocean Container Ltd before
joining in Global Beverage Co Ltd He possesses a nice personality
I interviewed Yaseer Rizvi Excerpts from his interview are as follows ndash
Shah Kamal Sir would you please tell me do you invest in short term marketable securities
Yaseer Rizvi Basically we do not invest our surplus cash in short term marketable
securities like T-Bill commercial paper certificate of deposit etc But we keep our
surplus cash in Bank
Shah Kamal Would you tell me something about transit time for a typical check
Yaseer Rizvi Well in Virgin the transit time for a typical check is ndash
For mail float 2 to 3 days
At firm float 6 hours
Clearing float 1 to 3 days
Shah Kamal Do you maintain any cash concentration mechanism like depository transfer check automated clearing house and wire transfer
i
Annexure
Yaseer Rizvi Our position in this case is very strong as we use all the mechanisms
you mentioned As Virgin is a firm with small deposits spread over a substantial
number of banks so we tend to use depository transfer checks extensively It is less
costly We also use automated clearing house and wire transfer but later is used in a
less extent
Shah Kamal Sir what techniques of disbursement management is used by your firm
Yaseer Rizvi Like other firms Virgin tries to retain the cash for as long as possible
But we always perform it in an ethical manner We do not use management of
disbursement float as it seems unethical We follow Zero-Balance Accounts method
for managing disbursement We do not prefer Controlled Disbursing method since
Zero-Balance system is already practiced in Virgin
Shah Kamal How do you hedge cash balance uncertainties
Yaseer Rizvi Well you may say that we do not invest in short term securities but for
facing cash difficulties we keep our surplus cash in bank
Shah Kamal Sir would you please tell me the general terms of sale of Virgin
Yaseer Rizvi Though it is difficult to maintain a fixed terms of sale our general terms
of sale is 210 n30 But for prime customers we offer special terms of sale
Shah Kamal What are the sources of credit information in case of your firm
Yaseer Rizvi We grant credit on the basis of prior experience with the customers In
case of a new customer personal contact is weighted
Shah Kamal Does your firm consider 5 Cs in granting credit
ii
Annexure
Yaseer Rizvi In case of Virgin Capital and Character get more importance than the
others Mind one thing personal relationship is the main measure in granting credit
Shah Kamal Do you use NPV method in credit granting decisions
Yaseer Rizvi We do not use NPV method But we think that NPV is a suitable
method and we have to use it from the next period
Shah Kamal Sir how do you handle the problem of bad debt
Yaseer Rizvi Well in this case our position is very strong Yet we do not face any
problem because of bad debt Just note that we make more than 80 of sales in cash
and we monitor accounts receivable very carefully
Shah Kamal What level of inventory is maintained by Virgin
Yaseer Rizvi We maintain a minimum level of inventory but do not have to face
stock out problems because inventory is managed efficiently
Shah Kamal What is the normal lead time
Yaseer Rizvi In case of imported goods normal lead time is about 1 month and when
we purchase raw materials from inside the country lead time is 1 to 3 days
Shah Kamal What method do you use for managing inventory
Yaseer Rizvi We do not use any method particularly rather inventory decision
depends on business cycle and market situation Long before the Eid festival we
bought large amount of sugar because price of sugar was increased on the occasion
of Eid
iii
Annexure
Shah Kamal What are the main items of inventory of your firm
Yaseer Rizvi Well these are ndash aluminum can pet chip sugar label chemical and
artificial sweet
Shah Kamal What are the uncertainties in maintaining appropriate level of stock
Yaseer Rizvi These are ndash
bull Increase in price of raw materials
bull Sales uncertainty
bull Market trends etc
Shah Kamal Thank you for your kind cooperation
Yaseer Rizvi Most Welcome
iv
Global Beverage Company Limited
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Page 28 of 46
Em
process
-time payments with Electronic Funds Transfer (EFT)
uraging vendors to utilize electronic invoice presentment
a
ndancies and more
ploying technology to automate the accounts payable transaction
es ndash
Making just-in
Using an electronic invoice-matching application
Enco
For companies with multiple locations or business units employing
shared service approach for AP to eliminate redu
quickly implement process improvements
Mainta
vendor
Communicating accounts payable requirements to suppliers at the
m key suppliers
for suggestions on how to improve the
Efficient a
and making th rsquos cash is just good business
ining open communications and building strong relationships with
s to access valuable trade credit ndash
beginning of transactions
Requesting summary invoicing fro
Requiring suppliers to send invoices directly to accounts payable
Asking tier-one suppliers
payment process
nd effective management of accounts payable helps improve cash flow ndash
e most of company
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
6 OVERVIEW OF VIRGIN GROUP
Virgin - one of the most respected brands in Britain - is now becoming the first global
brand name of the 21st century Virgin is involved in planes trains finance soft
drinks music mobile phones holidays cars wines publishing bridal wear - the lot
What tie all these businesses together are the values of its brand and the attitude of its
people Virgin has created over 200 companies worldwide employing over 25000
people Its total revenues around the world in 2002 exceeded pound4 billion (US $72
billion)
In 1970 Richard Branson founded Virgin as a mail order record retailer and not
long after he opened a record shop in Oxford Street London During 1972 a
recording studio was built in Oxfordshire and the first Virgin artist Mike Oldfield
recorded Tubular Bells which was released in 1973
This album went on to sell over 5 million copies Since then many household names
including Belinda Carlisle Genesis Phil Collins Janet Jackson and The Rolling
Stones have helped to make Virgin Music one of the top six record companies in the
world The equity of Virgin Music Group - record labels music publishing and
recording studios was sold to THORN EMI in 1992 in a US$1billion deal
Page 29 of 46
The Virgin Group has now expanded into international music Mega stores air
travel mobile financial retail music internet drinks rail hotels and leisure with
around 200 companies in over 30 countries
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
In Virgins customers eyes Virgin stands for value for money quality innovation
fun and a sense of competitive challenge It delivers a quality service by empowering
its employees and facilitates and monitors customer feedback to continually improve
the customers experience through innovation
When they start a new venture Virgin bases it on hard research and analysis
Typically they review the industry and put themselves in the customers shoes to see
what could make it better Virgin asks fundamental questions
Is this an opportunity for restructuring a market and creating competitive
advantage What are the competitors doing
Is the customer confused or badly served
Is this an opportunity for building the Virgin brand
Can we add value
Will it interact with its other businesses
Is there an appropriate trade-off between risk and reward
Page 30 of 46
Virgin is also able to draw on talented people from throughout the group New
ventures are often steered by people seconded from other parts of Virgin who bring
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
with them the trademark management style skills and experience Virgin frequently
creates partnerships with others to combine skills knowledge and market presence
and so on Contrary to what some people may think their constantly expanding and
eclectic empire is neither random nor reckless Each successive venture demonstrates
its skill in picking the right market and the right opportunity
7 OVERVIEW OF VIRGIN SOFT DRINKS
The Virgin Drinks Group first launched as the Virgin Cola Company in 1994 with
Virgin Cola in the UK Since then the company has ventured across the carbonated
soft drinks arena and beyond into energy drinks tea and flavored Colas This
expansion has lead to the evolution of the Virgin Drinks Company a company
whose aim is to put the excitement back into the world of soft drinks It launched in
Bangladesh in 1999 Virgin Soft Drinks is monitored by Global Beverage Co Ltd in
Bangladesh
Brief history of Virgin Drinks is given below
Page 31 of 46
1994 November Virgin Cola launched in the UK
1996 March Virgin Cola launched in France
1998 June Virgin Cola launched in Belgium
April Virgin Cola launched in the French West Indies
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
August Virgin Cola launched in Switzerland
1999 March Virgin Colours launched in Italy
March Virgin Cola launched in Japan
July Virgin Colours launched in South Africa
December Virgin Colours launched in Bangladesh
2001 January Sweden launched Virgin Colours
November Singapore launched Virgin Colours
2002 February Croatia launched Virgin Colours
June Russia launched Virgin Colours
June Tunisia launched Virgin Colours
2003 May Israel launched Virgin Colours
8 FINDINGS OF WORKING CAPITAL MANAGEMENT MAINTAINED BY
VIRGIN SOFT DRINKS IN BANGLADESH
81 CASH MANAGEMENT
811 Holding Cash and Marketable Securities
Although there are many good reasons why firm hold cash and marketable
securities Virgin Drinks holds cash and marketable securities for two reasons ndash
i) Cash for transactions
ii) Cash as hedges
This indicates that the firm does not hold cash and marketable securities for some
important reasons such as ndash
i) Near cash assets as hedges
Page 32 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
ii) Temporary investment and compensating balances
Virgin Soft Drinks does not invest in money market securities such as Treasury bill
commercial paper certificate of deposits bankerrsquos acceptance and repurchase
agreement This firm deposits its money in bank as currant AC or fixed AC They
say that they do not have enough money to invest in money market instrument
They also say that if they have enough money they will invest it in money market
short term securities We know that near cash interest earning assets can be
substituted for cash when motivation for holding these assets is the hedging of cash
flow uncertainties or is the temporary investment of surplus funds In this point
Virgins position is not good as there is no significant hedging against uncertainty of
cash
812 Floatation and Check Clearing
Virgin is very smart in handling the problem of transit time for checks Here mail
float takes 2 to 3 days at firm takes 025 day and clearing float takes 1-3 days Virgin
uses most of the strategies available for reducing the delay in receiving funds It
(Virgin) has linked Islami Bank which posses an accelerated clearing facility It uses
electronic collection process which ensures faster collection and its at the firm check
processing is satisfactory But Virgin does not use lockbox The reason behind this is
that it is not cost-effective for Virgin to set lockboxes At this point we can say that
Virgins check clearing mechanism is much good
813 Cash Concentration and Disbursement Management
Page 33 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks takes the matter of cash concentration very seriously They use all
the available cash concentration mechanism Virgin is a firm with small deposits
spread over a substantial number of banks and this is why the firm tends to use
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
depository transfer checks extensively If is less costly Virgin also uses automated
clearing house and wire transfer To Virgin wire transfer seems too costly
Like other firm Virgin tries to retain the cash for as long as possible But Virgin
always performs it in an ethical manner Virgin does not try to defeat the receiving
firmrsquos attempts to reduce the float on incoming checks It does not take any strategy
for increasing mail float at firm float and clearing float on its outgoing checks To
Virgin it is deemed to be unethical It thinks that maximization of disbursement float
will not go unnoticed by sophisticated creditors for very long When it is noticed it
will negatively affect relations with these creditors reducing the firmrsquos bargaining
power with them This may ultimately cost Virgin dearly when future prices and
delivery schedules for goods and services purchased from trade creditors are
negotiated Virgin follows ldquoZero-Balance Accountsrdquo methods for managing
disbursement It thinks that in this method the coordination of funds inflows to
disbursement banks with the presentation of checks does not work to the detriment
of creditors since the firmrsquos checks to them are honored as presented and this strategy
does not affect float significantly Controlled disbursing method is less attractive to
Virgin because zero-balance system is already feasible
814 Cash Forecasting
Cash Forecasting and Its Types
Page 34 of 46
Virgin forecasts the future cash inflows and outflows To Virgin cash forecast is an
important part of the firmrsquos cash control system and is one of the forecasts that are
part of the Virginrsquos financial plan Virgin forecasts cash on monthly basis and on
yearly basis Virgin does not forecast on daily basis assuming that the temporary
shortage of funds within these periods can be covered without value cost eg
advance receipts from customers Virginrsquos cash forecasting system involves a
combination of distribution and scheduling The receipts and disbursements
approach of cash forecasting is used in virgin This method is used because it
minutely traces the movement of cash and very close control of cash is possible
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Virgin does not use adjusted net income approach on two grounds First it does not
permit the tracing of the individual types of cash inflows and outflows for any given
period which is often useful information for virgin Second it is not simple to use
Items to be Forecast
Virgin does not forecast all the items It forecasts only major items eg accounts
receivable notes receivable payroll cash purchases of raw materials In this regard
virgin trade off between cost and benefit
Methods of Financial Forecasting
Virgin forecasts the future level of financial variable such as cash level asset level or
liability level We know in short term forecasts many things will result from plans
and events that are already in place (contracts capital budgets long-range financing
plans and so forth) But in the long run most things can vary and are dependent on
outside influences such as the firmrsquos long-term growth rate Since Virginrsquos cash
forecasting deals mostly with near future many of the items on the cash forecasts are
estimated by some variation of the spot method and remaining estimates are mostly
on a ldquoproportion of another accountrdquo basis with this ldquoother accountrdquo often being a
particular periodrsquos sales Virgin uses the other two methods less frequently
Using Cash Forecast
Virgin forecasts cash for meeting general objectives (ie to know the available funds
for investment and need financing) and for meeting some special objectives (eg to
know whether the firm will fulfill its out of debt requirement) But it is matter to note
that Virgin does not make any short term investment of its surplus cash but only keep
this surplus in Bank Account
Page 35 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Sources of Uncertainty in Cash Forecasting and Hedging Uncertainties
Virgin faces uncertainty in cash forecasting mainly from two sources These are ndash
sales and production cost In peak season (hot season like autumn summer) sales
increases but in dull season (eg in winter) sales decreases drastically Production
cost may be increased because of increase of price of sugar chemicals aluminum
can Virgin follows two methods for hedging cash balance uncertainties These are ndash
i) Holding a stock of extra cash and
ii) Extra borrowing capacity
815 Modes for the Management of Cash and Temporary Investments
Virgin does not follow any of these methods wholly Virgin receives cash
continuously and pays salary at steady rate and pays continuously for other
expenses So it neither follows Baumol model nor Beranek model It has no upper
control limit lower control limit return point in case cash management So it neither
follows Miller-Orr model nor Stone model
In Summary
Page 36 of 46
Standard Compliance by Virgin Soft Drinks
Generally all firms hold cash and
marketable securities
Virgin holds only cash
Firms hold cash and marketable
securities for some reasons like
bull Cash for transactions
bull Cash and near-cash assets as
hedges
bull Temporary investments
bull Compensating balances
Virgin holds cash only for
two reasons ndash
bull Cash for transactions
bull Cash as hedges
Available money market instruments Virgin does not invest in any such
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
(short term securities) are ndash
Treasury Bills
Commercial Paper
Certificates of Deposit
Bankerrsquos Acceptance
Repurch menase Agree ts
instruments They only keep cash in
Bank Account
Mail Float
(1 to 5 days)
At Firm
Float
(025 to 1
day)
Clearing
Float
(0 to
2 days)
Mail Float
(2 to 3 days)
At firm
Float
(025
day)
Clearing
Float
(1 to 3
days)
Figure Transit time for a typical check Figure Transit time for a check for
Virgin
Strategies that firms can use to reduce
the delay in receiving funds are ndash
Selecting of Banks with
accelerated clearing capabilities
of check processing Acceleration
at the firm
ectronic collection Use of el
procedures
Use of lockboxes
Virgin follows the first three strategies
but does not use lockboxes
Available cash concentration
mechanisms are ndash
Depository transfer check
ouse Automated Clearing H
(ACH) electronic transfer)
Wire transfer
Virgin uses all these mechanisms of
cash concentration
Available sets of techniques for cash
disbursement management are ndash
ement of disbursement
Page 37 of 46
Manag
float
Virgin uses zero-balance accounts
technique
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Zero-Balance Accounts
Controlled disbursing
Firms may make cash flow forecasts
over periods of various lengths yearly
flows quarterly flows monthly flows
weekly flows or even daily flows
Virgin forecasts cash on yearly basis and
monthly basis
Cash forecasting system may involve ndash
Distribution
Scheduling
Virginrsquos cash forecasting system
involves a combination of distribution
and scheduling
Two common approaches to cash flow
in generating the cash forecast
and disbursement Receipts
approach
Adjusted net income approach
Virgin uses the receipts and
disbursement approach
There are many items to forecast Virgin forecasts only major items like
AR payroll etc
Four common approach to forecasting
fina i ndash nc al variables are
Spot method
Proportion to another account
Compounded growth
Multiple dependencies
Virgin uses spot method for forecasting
cash It uses proportion to another
account method for other variables and
remaining two methods are frequently
used
Sources of uncertainty in cash
forecasting are ndash
Sales uncertainty
Collection rate uncertainty
Production cost uncertainty
Capital outflow uncertainty
Virgin faces uncertainty mainly from
sales and production cost
Methods for hedging cash balance
unc a
Page 38 of 46
ert inties are ndash
i) Holding a stock of extra cash
Virgin two available methods for
hedging cash balance uncertainties
Th ese are ndash
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
ii) stock of near-cash Holding a
assets
iii) Extra borrowing capacity
iv) ary surpluses in Investing tempor
near-cash assets
i) Holding a stock of extra cash
ii) Extra borrowing capacity
(advance receipt from
customers)
Models for the management of cash and
temporary investments are ndash Baumol
model Beranek model Miller-Orr
model and Stone model
Virgin does not follow any method
wholly but a combination of Baumol
model and Beranek model is occurred
82 INVENTORY MANAGEMENT
21 Certainty Approach
isnt used in
irgin because it thinks it is not possible to implement in Bangladesh
d time is one to three days It
oes not use ABC system of inventory management
8
Main item of inventory of Virgin is Can pet chip sugar label chemical artificial
sweet etc Virgin maintains a minimum level of inventory but it does not have to face
problems because inventory is managed efficiently just-in-time (JIT)
V
Virgin maintains buffer stock because of the shortage of work-in-process (WIP)
inventory Its production process may also be hampered Thats why it maintains
safety stock to avoid stock out cost In case of imported goods normal lead time is
about one month and within the country normal lea
d
Page 39 of 46
Inventory Model
In reality Virgin does not use any of models of EOQ ordering and holding strategy
and safety stock strategy They maintain inventory based on their prior experience
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
822 Uncertainty Approach
Virgin does not use any model for handling inventory uncertainty It says that such
decision depends on business cycle and market situation Long before Eid festival
they bought large amount of sugar because of price increase on the occasion of Eid
In summary
Standard Compliance by Virgin Soft Drinks
Firms maintain inventory to guard
against several problems
Virgin maintains a minimum level of
inventory which is managed efficiently
Some firms use JIT to avoid inventory
cost
JIT is not used by Virgin as it thinks it is
impossible to implement in Bangladesh
Firms maintain buffer stock Virgin maintains buffer stock too
Firms maintain safety stock to avoid
shortage cost
Virgin also maintains safety stock
Firms use ABC system to monitor
inventory
Virgin doesnt use ABC system
EOQ model is an appropriate method
for measuring quantity that has to be
ordered per order
Virgin does not use EOQ model rather
makes order based on experience and
market demand
83 MANAGING ACCOUNTS RECEIVABLE (DEBTORS)
831 Terms of Sale Decision
Page 40 of 46
Virgin offers the term 210 net 30 enables the customers to deduct 2 percent from the
face value of the bill when paying within the first 10 days but if the discount is not
taken the customer must remit the full amount within 30 days But Virgin does not
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
offer the same terms of sale to all customers For prime customers it offers special
terms of sale In setting an appropriate term of sale it costs and benefits regarding
this are compared It uses the standard approach of terms of sale decision as it is
simple to use
832 Credit Granting Decisions
In case of Virgin the Capital and Character of Five Cs get more importance
Although there are many problems with the traditional approach Virgin uses it
because of its simplicity Virgin does not use Net Present Value (NPV) method in
credit granting decision It thinks that NPV is an appropriate method and should be
used next time It does not face any severe problem because of bad debts The reason
is that notes receivable is used when credit is granted
833 Monitoring Accounts Receivable
Virgin monitors its accounts receivable Virgin believes that in any case both positive
and negative durations in accounts signal differences from the results that
management believe to be the most advantageous for the firm
Tools for Monitoring Accounts Receivable
Page 41 of 46
For monitoring accounts receivable there are several tools such as aging schedule
the ratios of receivable outstanding to original sales customers payment proportion
and sales weighted DSO (Days Sales Outstanding) For monitoring accounts
receivable Virgin uses aging schedule fractions and traditional DSO statistics
because of their simplicity in use Although payment proportions ratios of
receivables outstanding and sales weighted DSO methods are free from inherent bias
None of these is used because all these are complex to maintain
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
In summary
Page 42 of 46
Standard Compliance by Virgin Soft Drinks
Generals terms of sale is 210 net 30 Normally Virgin also use general terms
of sale ie 210 net 30
Firms do not offer the same terms of
sale to all customers
Yes For prime customers Virgin offers
special terms of sale
Approaches of terms of sale decisions
are ndash
bull Standard approach
bull Multi period approach
Virgin uses standard approach of terms
of sale decision as it is simple to use and
understand
Source of credit information are ndash
Sellers prior experience with the
customer
Credit agency ratings and
reports
Personal contact with the
applicants bank and other
creditors
Analysis of applicants financial
statements
Customer visit
Main source of credit information to
Virgin is its prior experience with the
customer All other sources are not cost-
effective for Virgin
Approaches of credit granting to
marginal accounts are ndash
Traditional approach
Net Present Value (NPV)
approach
It uses traditional approach still now but
thinks that NPV should be used for the
next periods
Firms monitor accounts receivable
because deviations from the expected
levels of turnover and of bad debt can
Virgin also monitors its accounts
receivable
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
signal several different problems
Different tools for monitoring accounts
receivable are ndash
Aging schedule
Ratios of receivables
outstanding to original sales
Customers payment
proportions
Sales-weighted DSO
For monitoring accounts receivable
Virgin uses aging schedule and
traditional sales outstanding statistics
84 MANAGING ACCOUNTS PAYABLE (CREDITORS)
Virgin has almost accounts payable of Tk 8000000 But most of its liabilities are to
the banks rather than suppliers But we dont have any clear information about
Virgins accounts payable
9 RECOMMENDATION
Virgin should invest its surplus cash in short term marketable securities
because it is suitable hedging against cash uncertainties and will also give
some returns (interest income)
Virgin should publish its own annual report which will satisfy information
needs of stakeholders and also increase the credibility of information provided
by Virgin
Page 43 of 46
Virgin should use multi period approach in terms of sale decision because
standard approach which is already exists in Virgin has some inherent
problems
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
It should stop using traditional approach from now It should use NPV
method in credit granting to marginal accounts
In monitoring accounts receivable Virgin should use sales-weighted DSO
method because it has least limitation compared to the others
It should be more flexible in granting credit which will ultimately increase its
sales
To get the appropriate number of quantity to be ordered per order it should
use DSO model
It should be ABC system for proper monitoring of inventory
10 CONCLUSION
The use of other peoples money in business is usually an expensive resource Before
looking outside for finance a firm should examine its own working capital cycle to
make sure that every rand of its own internal funds is being fully utilized Good
management of working capital is part of good financial management Effective use
of working capital will contribute to the operational efficiency of the whole
organization optimum use will help to generate maximum returns Furthermore
working capital management is not an end in itself It is an integral part of the firms
overall management The needs of efficient working capital management must be
considered in relation to other aspects of the Virgins financial and non-financial
performance Thats why when planning the development of a business it is critical
that the impact of working capital be fully assessed
Page 44 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
BIBLIOGRAPHY
Scherr FC (1989) International Edition Prentice-Hall International Inc Modern
Working Capital Management Text and Cases
Hussain Riaz (2002) Working Capital Management
Robertson Lonnie (July 1998) Inventory Management
httpwwwasashoporg visited on March 13 2006
The Art of Cash Management
httpwwwinccom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management
httpwwwstudyfinancecom visited on March 13 2006
White Paper ndash Managing Working Capital
httpwwwplanwareorg visited on March 13 2006
Management of Working Capital
httpwwwbusinesscentralcoza visited on March 13 2006
Cash Management
httpwwwsbagov visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management Objectives
httpwpsprenhallcom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management
Page 45 of 46
httpwwwadvancemecom visited on March 13 2006
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Business Receivables Financing
httpwwwbbtcom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Finance
http wwwfnbcoza visited on March 13 2006
Tips to manage your working capital
httpsmallbusinessninemsncomau visited on March 13 2006
Inventory Financing
httpwwwfranklincapitalnetworkcom visited on March 13 2006
Accounts Receivable Management
httpwwwfranklincapitalnetworkcom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management
httpwwwtreasurygovtnz visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management
httpwwwtreasurystrategiescom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Works
httpwwwinvestopediacom visited on March 13 2006
Treasury Services
httpwwwjpmorganchasecom visited on March 13 2006
what were about
Page 46 of 46
httpwwwvirgincom visited on March 13 2006
Annexure
Annexure
Interview with YASEER RIZVI
Mr Yaseer Rizvi the DMD of Global Beverage Co Ltd obtained his MBA degree
from a reputed university He had been the Director of Ocean Container Ltd before
joining in Global Beverage Co Ltd He possesses a nice personality
I interviewed Yaseer Rizvi Excerpts from his interview are as follows ndash
Shah Kamal Sir would you please tell me do you invest in short term marketable securities
Yaseer Rizvi Basically we do not invest our surplus cash in short term marketable
securities like T-Bill commercial paper certificate of deposit etc But we keep our
surplus cash in Bank
Shah Kamal Would you tell me something about transit time for a typical check
Yaseer Rizvi Well in Virgin the transit time for a typical check is ndash
For mail float 2 to 3 days
At firm float 6 hours
Clearing float 1 to 3 days
Shah Kamal Do you maintain any cash concentration mechanism like depository transfer check automated clearing house and wire transfer
i
Annexure
Yaseer Rizvi Our position in this case is very strong as we use all the mechanisms
you mentioned As Virgin is a firm with small deposits spread over a substantial
number of banks so we tend to use depository transfer checks extensively It is less
costly We also use automated clearing house and wire transfer but later is used in a
less extent
Shah Kamal Sir what techniques of disbursement management is used by your firm
Yaseer Rizvi Like other firms Virgin tries to retain the cash for as long as possible
But we always perform it in an ethical manner We do not use management of
disbursement float as it seems unethical We follow Zero-Balance Accounts method
for managing disbursement We do not prefer Controlled Disbursing method since
Zero-Balance system is already practiced in Virgin
Shah Kamal How do you hedge cash balance uncertainties
Yaseer Rizvi Well you may say that we do not invest in short term securities but for
facing cash difficulties we keep our surplus cash in bank
Shah Kamal Sir would you please tell me the general terms of sale of Virgin
Yaseer Rizvi Though it is difficult to maintain a fixed terms of sale our general terms
of sale is 210 n30 But for prime customers we offer special terms of sale
Shah Kamal What are the sources of credit information in case of your firm
Yaseer Rizvi We grant credit on the basis of prior experience with the customers In
case of a new customer personal contact is weighted
Shah Kamal Does your firm consider 5 Cs in granting credit
ii
Annexure
Yaseer Rizvi In case of Virgin Capital and Character get more importance than the
others Mind one thing personal relationship is the main measure in granting credit
Shah Kamal Do you use NPV method in credit granting decisions
Yaseer Rizvi We do not use NPV method But we think that NPV is a suitable
method and we have to use it from the next period
Shah Kamal Sir how do you handle the problem of bad debt
Yaseer Rizvi Well in this case our position is very strong Yet we do not face any
problem because of bad debt Just note that we make more than 80 of sales in cash
and we monitor accounts receivable very carefully
Shah Kamal What level of inventory is maintained by Virgin
Yaseer Rizvi We maintain a minimum level of inventory but do not have to face
stock out problems because inventory is managed efficiently
Shah Kamal What is the normal lead time
Yaseer Rizvi In case of imported goods normal lead time is about 1 month and when
we purchase raw materials from inside the country lead time is 1 to 3 days
Shah Kamal What method do you use for managing inventory
Yaseer Rizvi We do not use any method particularly rather inventory decision
depends on business cycle and market situation Long before the Eid festival we
bought large amount of sugar because price of sugar was increased on the occasion
of Eid
iii
Annexure
Shah Kamal What are the main items of inventory of your firm
Yaseer Rizvi Well these are ndash aluminum can pet chip sugar label chemical and
artificial sweet
Shah Kamal What are the uncertainties in maintaining appropriate level of stock
Yaseer Rizvi These are ndash
bull Increase in price of raw materials
bull Sales uncertainty
bull Market trends etc
Shah Kamal Thank you for your kind cooperation
Yaseer Rizvi Most Welcome
iv
Global Beverage Company Limited
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
6 OVERVIEW OF VIRGIN GROUP
Virgin - one of the most respected brands in Britain - is now becoming the first global
brand name of the 21st century Virgin is involved in planes trains finance soft
drinks music mobile phones holidays cars wines publishing bridal wear - the lot
What tie all these businesses together are the values of its brand and the attitude of its
people Virgin has created over 200 companies worldwide employing over 25000
people Its total revenues around the world in 2002 exceeded pound4 billion (US $72
billion)
In 1970 Richard Branson founded Virgin as a mail order record retailer and not
long after he opened a record shop in Oxford Street London During 1972 a
recording studio was built in Oxfordshire and the first Virgin artist Mike Oldfield
recorded Tubular Bells which was released in 1973
This album went on to sell over 5 million copies Since then many household names
including Belinda Carlisle Genesis Phil Collins Janet Jackson and The Rolling
Stones have helped to make Virgin Music one of the top six record companies in the
world The equity of Virgin Music Group - record labels music publishing and
recording studios was sold to THORN EMI in 1992 in a US$1billion deal
Page 29 of 46
The Virgin Group has now expanded into international music Mega stores air
travel mobile financial retail music internet drinks rail hotels and leisure with
around 200 companies in over 30 countries
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
In Virgins customers eyes Virgin stands for value for money quality innovation
fun and a sense of competitive challenge It delivers a quality service by empowering
its employees and facilitates and monitors customer feedback to continually improve
the customers experience through innovation
When they start a new venture Virgin bases it on hard research and analysis
Typically they review the industry and put themselves in the customers shoes to see
what could make it better Virgin asks fundamental questions
Is this an opportunity for restructuring a market and creating competitive
advantage What are the competitors doing
Is the customer confused or badly served
Is this an opportunity for building the Virgin brand
Can we add value
Will it interact with its other businesses
Is there an appropriate trade-off between risk and reward
Page 30 of 46
Virgin is also able to draw on talented people from throughout the group New
ventures are often steered by people seconded from other parts of Virgin who bring
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
with them the trademark management style skills and experience Virgin frequently
creates partnerships with others to combine skills knowledge and market presence
and so on Contrary to what some people may think their constantly expanding and
eclectic empire is neither random nor reckless Each successive venture demonstrates
its skill in picking the right market and the right opportunity
7 OVERVIEW OF VIRGIN SOFT DRINKS
The Virgin Drinks Group first launched as the Virgin Cola Company in 1994 with
Virgin Cola in the UK Since then the company has ventured across the carbonated
soft drinks arena and beyond into energy drinks tea and flavored Colas This
expansion has lead to the evolution of the Virgin Drinks Company a company
whose aim is to put the excitement back into the world of soft drinks It launched in
Bangladesh in 1999 Virgin Soft Drinks is monitored by Global Beverage Co Ltd in
Bangladesh
Brief history of Virgin Drinks is given below
Page 31 of 46
1994 November Virgin Cola launched in the UK
1996 March Virgin Cola launched in France
1998 June Virgin Cola launched in Belgium
April Virgin Cola launched in the French West Indies
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
August Virgin Cola launched in Switzerland
1999 March Virgin Colours launched in Italy
March Virgin Cola launched in Japan
July Virgin Colours launched in South Africa
December Virgin Colours launched in Bangladesh
2001 January Sweden launched Virgin Colours
November Singapore launched Virgin Colours
2002 February Croatia launched Virgin Colours
June Russia launched Virgin Colours
June Tunisia launched Virgin Colours
2003 May Israel launched Virgin Colours
8 FINDINGS OF WORKING CAPITAL MANAGEMENT MAINTAINED BY
VIRGIN SOFT DRINKS IN BANGLADESH
81 CASH MANAGEMENT
811 Holding Cash and Marketable Securities
Although there are many good reasons why firm hold cash and marketable
securities Virgin Drinks holds cash and marketable securities for two reasons ndash
i) Cash for transactions
ii) Cash as hedges
This indicates that the firm does not hold cash and marketable securities for some
important reasons such as ndash
i) Near cash assets as hedges
Page 32 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
ii) Temporary investment and compensating balances
Virgin Soft Drinks does not invest in money market securities such as Treasury bill
commercial paper certificate of deposits bankerrsquos acceptance and repurchase
agreement This firm deposits its money in bank as currant AC or fixed AC They
say that they do not have enough money to invest in money market instrument
They also say that if they have enough money they will invest it in money market
short term securities We know that near cash interest earning assets can be
substituted for cash when motivation for holding these assets is the hedging of cash
flow uncertainties or is the temporary investment of surplus funds In this point
Virgins position is not good as there is no significant hedging against uncertainty of
cash
812 Floatation and Check Clearing
Virgin is very smart in handling the problem of transit time for checks Here mail
float takes 2 to 3 days at firm takes 025 day and clearing float takes 1-3 days Virgin
uses most of the strategies available for reducing the delay in receiving funds It
(Virgin) has linked Islami Bank which posses an accelerated clearing facility It uses
electronic collection process which ensures faster collection and its at the firm check
processing is satisfactory But Virgin does not use lockbox The reason behind this is
that it is not cost-effective for Virgin to set lockboxes At this point we can say that
Virgins check clearing mechanism is much good
813 Cash Concentration and Disbursement Management
Page 33 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks takes the matter of cash concentration very seriously They use all
the available cash concentration mechanism Virgin is a firm with small deposits
spread over a substantial number of banks and this is why the firm tends to use
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
depository transfer checks extensively If is less costly Virgin also uses automated
clearing house and wire transfer To Virgin wire transfer seems too costly
Like other firm Virgin tries to retain the cash for as long as possible But Virgin
always performs it in an ethical manner Virgin does not try to defeat the receiving
firmrsquos attempts to reduce the float on incoming checks It does not take any strategy
for increasing mail float at firm float and clearing float on its outgoing checks To
Virgin it is deemed to be unethical It thinks that maximization of disbursement float
will not go unnoticed by sophisticated creditors for very long When it is noticed it
will negatively affect relations with these creditors reducing the firmrsquos bargaining
power with them This may ultimately cost Virgin dearly when future prices and
delivery schedules for goods and services purchased from trade creditors are
negotiated Virgin follows ldquoZero-Balance Accountsrdquo methods for managing
disbursement It thinks that in this method the coordination of funds inflows to
disbursement banks with the presentation of checks does not work to the detriment
of creditors since the firmrsquos checks to them are honored as presented and this strategy
does not affect float significantly Controlled disbursing method is less attractive to
Virgin because zero-balance system is already feasible
814 Cash Forecasting
Cash Forecasting and Its Types
Page 34 of 46
Virgin forecasts the future cash inflows and outflows To Virgin cash forecast is an
important part of the firmrsquos cash control system and is one of the forecasts that are
part of the Virginrsquos financial plan Virgin forecasts cash on monthly basis and on
yearly basis Virgin does not forecast on daily basis assuming that the temporary
shortage of funds within these periods can be covered without value cost eg
advance receipts from customers Virginrsquos cash forecasting system involves a
combination of distribution and scheduling The receipts and disbursements
approach of cash forecasting is used in virgin This method is used because it
minutely traces the movement of cash and very close control of cash is possible
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Virgin does not use adjusted net income approach on two grounds First it does not
permit the tracing of the individual types of cash inflows and outflows for any given
period which is often useful information for virgin Second it is not simple to use
Items to be Forecast
Virgin does not forecast all the items It forecasts only major items eg accounts
receivable notes receivable payroll cash purchases of raw materials In this regard
virgin trade off between cost and benefit
Methods of Financial Forecasting
Virgin forecasts the future level of financial variable such as cash level asset level or
liability level We know in short term forecasts many things will result from plans
and events that are already in place (contracts capital budgets long-range financing
plans and so forth) But in the long run most things can vary and are dependent on
outside influences such as the firmrsquos long-term growth rate Since Virginrsquos cash
forecasting deals mostly with near future many of the items on the cash forecasts are
estimated by some variation of the spot method and remaining estimates are mostly
on a ldquoproportion of another accountrdquo basis with this ldquoother accountrdquo often being a
particular periodrsquos sales Virgin uses the other two methods less frequently
Using Cash Forecast
Virgin forecasts cash for meeting general objectives (ie to know the available funds
for investment and need financing) and for meeting some special objectives (eg to
know whether the firm will fulfill its out of debt requirement) But it is matter to note
that Virgin does not make any short term investment of its surplus cash but only keep
this surplus in Bank Account
Page 35 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Sources of Uncertainty in Cash Forecasting and Hedging Uncertainties
Virgin faces uncertainty in cash forecasting mainly from two sources These are ndash
sales and production cost In peak season (hot season like autumn summer) sales
increases but in dull season (eg in winter) sales decreases drastically Production
cost may be increased because of increase of price of sugar chemicals aluminum
can Virgin follows two methods for hedging cash balance uncertainties These are ndash
i) Holding a stock of extra cash and
ii) Extra borrowing capacity
815 Modes for the Management of Cash and Temporary Investments
Virgin does not follow any of these methods wholly Virgin receives cash
continuously and pays salary at steady rate and pays continuously for other
expenses So it neither follows Baumol model nor Beranek model It has no upper
control limit lower control limit return point in case cash management So it neither
follows Miller-Orr model nor Stone model
In Summary
Page 36 of 46
Standard Compliance by Virgin Soft Drinks
Generally all firms hold cash and
marketable securities
Virgin holds only cash
Firms hold cash and marketable
securities for some reasons like
bull Cash for transactions
bull Cash and near-cash assets as
hedges
bull Temporary investments
bull Compensating balances
Virgin holds cash only for
two reasons ndash
bull Cash for transactions
bull Cash as hedges
Available money market instruments Virgin does not invest in any such
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
(short term securities) are ndash
Treasury Bills
Commercial Paper
Certificates of Deposit
Bankerrsquos Acceptance
Repurch menase Agree ts
instruments They only keep cash in
Bank Account
Mail Float
(1 to 5 days)
At Firm
Float
(025 to 1
day)
Clearing
Float
(0 to
2 days)
Mail Float
(2 to 3 days)
At firm
Float
(025
day)
Clearing
Float
(1 to 3
days)
Figure Transit time for a typical check Figure Transit time for a check for
Virgin
Strategies that firms can use to reduce
the delay in receiving funds are ndash
Selecting of Banks with
accelerated clearing capabilities
of check processing Acceleration
at the firm
ectronic collection Use of el
procedures
Use of lockboxes
Virgin follows the first three strategies
but does not use lockboxes
Available cash concentration
mechanisms are ndash
Depository transfer check
ouse Automated Clearing H
(ACH) electronic transfer)
Wire transfer
Virgin uses all these mechanisms of
cash concentration
Available sets of techniques for cash
disbursement management are ndash
ement of disbursement
Page 37 of 46
Manag
float
Virgin uses zero-balance accounts
technique
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Zero-Balance Accounts
Controlled disbursing
Firms may make cash flow forecasts
over periods of various lengths yearly
flows quarterly flows monthly flows
weekly flows or even daily flows
Virgin forecasts cash on yearly basis and
monthly basis
Cash forecasting system may involve ndash
Distribution
Scheduling
Virginrsquos cash forecasting system
involves a combination of distribution
and scheduling
Two common approaches to cash flow
in generating the cash forecast
and disbursement Receipts
approach
Adjusted net income approach
Virgin uses the receipts and
disbursement approach
There are many items to forecast Virgin forecasts only major items like
AR payroll etc
Four common approach to forecasting
fina i ndash nc al variables are
Spot method
Proportion to another account
Compounded growth
Multiple dependencies
Virgin uses spot method for forecasting
cash It uses proportion to another
account method for other variables and
remaining two methods are frequently
used
Sources of uncertainty in cash
forecasting are ndash
Sales uncertainty
Collection rate uncertainty
Production cost uncertainty
Capital outflow uncertainty
Virgin faces uncertainty mainly from
sales and production cost
Methods for hedging cash balance
unc a
Page 38 of 46
ert inties are ndash
i) Holding a stock of extra cash
Virgin two available methods for
hedging cash balance uncertainties
Th ese are ndash
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
ii) stock of near-cash Holding a
assets
iii) Extra borrowing capacity
iv) ary surpluses in Investing tempor
near-cash assets
i) Holding a stock of extra cash
ii) Extra borrowing capacity
(advance receipt from
customers)
Models for the management of cash and
temporary investments are ndash Baumol
model Beranek model Miller-Orr
model and Stone model
Virgin does not follow any method
wholly but a combination of Baumol
model and Beranek model is occurred
82 INVENTORY MANAGEMENT
21 Certainty Approach
isnt used in
irgin because it thinks it is not possible to implement in Bangladesh
d time is one to three days It
oes not use ABC system of inventory management
8
Main item of inventory of Virgin is Can pet chip sugar label chemical artificial
sweet etc Virgin maintains a minimum level of inventory but it does not have to face
problems because inventory is managed efficiently just-in-time (JIT)
V
Virgin maintains buffer stock because of the shortage of work-in-process (WIP)
inventory Its production process may also be hampered Thats why it maintains
safety stock to avoid stock out cost In case of imported goods normal lead time is
about one month and within the country normal lea
d
Page 39 of 46
Inventory Model
In reality Virgin does not use any of models of EOQ ordering and holding strategy
and safety stock strategy They maintain inventory based on their prior experience
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
822 Uncertainty Approach
Virgin does not use any model for handling inventory uncertainty It says that such
decision depends on business cycle and market situation Long before Eid festival
they bought large amount of sugar because of price increase on the occasion of Eid
In summary
Standard Compliance by Virgin Soft Drinks
Firms maintain inventory to guard
against several problems
Virgin maintains a minimum level of
inventory which is managed efficiently
Some firms use JIT to avoid inventory
cost
JIT is not used by Virgin as it thinks it is
impossible to implement in Bangladesh
Firms maintain buffer stock Virgin maintains buffer stock too
Firms maintain safety stock to avoid
shortage cost
Virgin also maintains safety stock
Firms use ABC system to monitor
inventory
Virgin doesnt use ABC system
EOQ model is an appropriate method
for measuring quantity that has to be
ordered per order
Virgin does not use EOQ model rather
makes order based on experience and
market demand
83 MANAGING ACCOUNTS RECEIVABLE (DEBTORS)
831 Terms of Sale Decision
Page 40 of 46
Virgin offers the term 210 net 30 enables the customers to deduct 2 percent from the
face value of the bill when paying within the first 10 days but if the discount is not
taken the customer must remit the full amount within 30 days But Virgin does not
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
offer the same terms of sale to all customers For prime customers it offers special
terms of sale In setting an appropriate term of sale it costs and benefits regarding
this are compared It uses the standard approach of terms of sale decision as it is
simple to use
832 Credit Granting Decisions
In case of Virgin the Capital and Character of Five Cs get more importance
Although there are many problems with the traditional approach Virgin uses it
because of its simplicity Virgin does not use Net Present Value (NPV) method in
credit granting decision It thinks that NPV is an appropriate method and should be
used next time It does not face any severe problem because of bad debts The reason
is that notes receivable is used when credit is granted
833 Monitoring Accounts Receivable
Virgin monitors its accounts receivable Virgin believes that in any case both positive
and negative durations in accounts signal differences from the results that
management believe to be the most advantageous for the firm
Tools for Monitoring Accounts Receivable
Page 41 of 46
For monitoring accounts receivable there are several tools such as aging schedule
the ratios of receivable outstanding to original sales customers payment proportion
and sales weighted DSO (Days Sales Outstanding) For monitoring accounts
receivable Virgin uses aging schedule fractions and traditional DSO statistics
because of their simplicity in use Although payment proportions ratios of
receivables outstanding and sales weighted DSO methods are free from inherent bias
None of these is used because all these are complex to maintain
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
In summary
Page 42 of 46
Standard Compliance by Virgin Soft Drinks
Generals terms of sale is 210 net 30 Normally Virgin also use general terms
of sale ie 210 net 30
Firms do not offer the same terms of
sale to all customers
Yes For prime customers Virgin offers
special terms of sale
Approaches of terms of sale decisions
are ndash
bull Standard approach
bull Multi period approach
Virgin uses standard approach of terms
of sale decision as it is simple to use and
understand
Source of credit information are ndash
Sellers prior experience with the
customer
Credit agency ratings and
reports
Personal contact with the
applicants bank and other
creditors
Analysis of applicants financial
statements
Customer visit
Main source of credit information to
Virgin is its prior experience with the
customer All other sources are not cost-
effective for Virgin
Approaches of credit granting to
marginal accounts are ndash
Traditional approach
Net Present Value (NPV)
approach
It uses traditional approach still now but
thinks that NPV should be used for the
next periods
Firms monitor accounts receivable
because deviations from the expected
levels of turnover and of bad debt can
Virgin also monitors its accounts
receivable
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
signal several different problems
Different tools for monitoring accounts
receivable are ndash
Aging schedule
Ratios of receivables
outstanding to original sales
Customers payment
proportions
Sales-weighted DSO
For monitoring accounts receivable
Virgin uses aging schedule and
traditional sales outstanding statistics
84 MANAGING ACCOUNTS PAYABLE (CREDITORS)
Virgin has almost accounts payable of Tk 8000000 But most of its liabilities are to
the banks rather than suppliers But we dont have any clear information about
Virgins accounts payable
9 RECOMMENDATION
Virgin should invest its surplus cash in short term marketable securities
because it is suitable hedging against cash uncertainties and will also give
some returns (interest income)
Virgin should publish its own annual report which will satisfy information
needs of stakeholders and also increase the credibility of information provided
by Virgin
Page 43 of 46
Virgin should use multi period approach in terms of sale decision because
standard approach which is already exists in Virgin has some inherent
problems
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
It should stop using traditional approach from now It should use NPV
method in credit granting to marginal accounts
In monitoring accounts receivable Virgin should use sales-weighted DSO
method because it has least limitation compared to the others
It should be more flexible in granting credit which will ultimately increase its
sales
To get the appropriate number of quantity to be ordered per order it should
use DSO model
It should be ABC system for proper monitoring of inventory
10 CONCLUSION
The use of other peoples money in business is usually an expensive resource Before
looking outside for finance a firm should examine its own working capital cycle to
make sure that every rand of its own internal funds is being fully utilized Good
management of working capital is part of good financial management Effective use
of working capital will contribute to the operational efficiency of the whole
organization optimum use will help to generate maximum returns Furthermore
working capital management is not an end in itself It is an integral part of the firms
overall management The needs of efficient working capital management must be
considered in relation to other aspects of the Virgins financial and non-financial
performance Thats why when planning the development of a business it is critical
that the impact of working capital be fully assessed
Page 44 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
BIBLIOGRAPHY
Scherr FC (1989) International Edition Prentice-Hall International Inc Modern
Working Capital Management Text and Cases
Hussain Riaz (2002) Working Capital Management
Robertson Lonnie (July 1998) Inventory Management
httpwwwasashoporg visited on March 13 2006
The Art of Cash Management
httpwwwinccom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management
httpwwwstudyfinancecom visited on March 13 2006
White Paper ndash Managing Working Capital
httpwwwplanwareorg visited on March 13 2006
Management of Working Capital
httpwwwbusinesscentralcoza visited on March 13 2006
Cash Management
httpwwwsbagov visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management Objectives
httpwpsprenhallcom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management
Page 45 of 46
httpwwwadvancemecom visited on March 13 2006
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Business Receivables Financing
httpwwwbbtcom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Finance
http wwwfnbcoza visited on March 13 2006
Tips to manage your working capital
httpsmallbusinessninemsncomau visited on March 13 2006
Inventory Financing
httpwwwfranklincapitalnetworkcom visited on March 13 2006
Accounts Receivable Management
httpwwwfranklincapitalnetworkcom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management
httpwwwtreasurygovtnz visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management
httpwwwtreasurystrategiescom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Works
httpwwwinvestopediacom visited on March 13 2006
Treasury Services
httpwwwjpmorganchasecom visited on March 13 2006
what were about
Page 46 of 46
httpwwwvirgincom visited on March 13 2006
Annexure
Annexure
Interview with YASEER RIZVI
Mr Yaseer Rizvi the DMD of Global Beverage Co Ltd obtained his MBA degree
from a reputed university He had been the Director of Ocean Container Ltd before
joining in Global Beverage Co Ltd He possesses a nice personality
I interviewed Yaseer Rizvi Excerpts from his interview are as follows ndash
Shah Kamal Sir would you please tell me do you invest in short term marketable securities
Yaseer Rizvi Basically we do not invest our surplus cash in short term marketable
securities like T-Bill commercial paper certificate of deposit etc But we keep our
surplus cash in Bank
Shah Kamal Would you tell me something about transit time for a typical check
Yaseer Rizvi Well in Virgin the transit time for a typical check is ndash
For mail float 2 to 3 days
At firm float 6 hours
Clearing float 1 to 3 days
Shah Kamal Do you maintain any cash concentration mechanism like depository transfer check automated clearing house and wire transfer
i
Annexure
Yaseer Rizvi Our position in this case is very strong as we use all the mechanisms
you mentioned As Virgin is a firm with small deposits spread over a substantial
number of banks so we tend to use depository transfer checks extensively It is less
costly We also use automated clearing house and wire transfer but later is used in a
less extent
Shah Kamal Sir what techniques of disbursement management is used by your firm
Yaseer Rizvi Like other firms Virgin tries to retain the cash for as long as possible
But we always perform it in an ethical manner We do not use management of
disbursement float as it seems unethical We follow Zero-Balance Accounts method
for managing disbursement We do not prefer Controlled Disbursing method since
Zero-Balance system is already practiced in Virgin
Shah Kamal How do you hedge cash balance uncertainties
Yaseer Rizvi Well you may say that we do not invest in short term securities but for
facing cash difficulties we keep our surplus cash in bank
Shah Kamal Sir would you please tell me the general terms of sale of Virgin
Yaseer Rizvi Though it is difficult to maintain a fixed terms of sale our general terms
of sale is 210 n30 But for prime customers we offer special terms of sale
Shah Kamal What are the sources of credit information in case of your firm
Yaseer Rizvi We grant credit on the basis of prior experience with the customers In
case of a new customer personal contact is weighted
Shah Kamal Does your firm consider 5 Cs in granting credit
ii
Annexure
Yaseer Rizvi In case of Virgin Capital and Character get more importance than the
others Mind one thing personal relationship is the main measure in granting credit
Shah Kamal Do you use NPV method in credit granting decisions
Yaseer Rizvi We do not use NPV method But we think that NPV is a suitable
method and we have to use it from the next period
Shah Kamal Sir how do you handle the problem of bad debt
Yaseer Rizvi Well in this case our position is very strong Yet we do not face any
problem because of bad debt Just note that we make more than 80 of sales in cash
and we monitor accounts receivable very carefully
Shah Kamal What level of inventory is maintained by Virgin
Yaseer Rizvi We maintain a minimum level of inventory but do not have to face
stock out problems because inventory is managed efficiently
Shah Kamal What is the normal lead time
Yaseer Rizvi In case of imported goods normal lead time is about 1 month and when
we purchase raw materials from inside the country lead time is 1 to 3 days
Shah Kamal What method do you use for managing inventory
Yaseer Rizvi We do not use any method particularly rather inventory decision
depends on business cycle and market situation Long before the Eid festival we
bought large amount of sugar because price of sugar was increased on the occasion
of Eid
iii
Annexure
Shah Kamal What are the main items of inventory of your firm
Yaseer Rizvi Well these are ndash aluminum can pet chip sugar label chemical and
artificial sweet
Shah Kamal What are the uncertainties in maintaining appropriate level of stock
Yaseer Rizvi These are ndash
bull Increase in price of raw materials
bull Sales uncertainty
bull Market trends etc
Shah Kamal Thank you for your kind cooperation
Yaseer Rizvi Most Welcome
iv
Global Beverage Company Limited
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
In Virgins customers eyes Virgin stands for value for money quality innovation
fun and a sense of competitive challenge It delivers a quality service by empowering
its employees and facilitates and monitors customer feedback to continually improve
the customers experience through innovation
When they start a new venture Virgin bases it on hard research and analysis
Typically they review the industry and put themselves in the customers shoes to see
what could make it better Virgin asks fundamental questions
Is this an opportunity for restructuring a market and creating competitive
advantage What are the competitors doing
Is the customer confused or badly served
Is this an opportunity for building the Virgin brand
Can we add value
Will it interact with its other businesses
Is there an appropriate trade-off between risk and reward
Page 30 of 46
Virgin is also able to draw on talented people from throughout the group New
ventures are often steered by people seconded from other parts of Virgin who bring
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
with them the trademark management style skills and experience Virgin frequently
creates partnerships with others to combine skills knowledge and market presence
and so on Contrary to what some people may think their constantly expanding and
eclectic empire is neither random nor reckless Each successive venture demonstrates
its skill in picking the right market and the right opportunity
7 OVERVIEW OF VIRGIN SOFT DRINKS
The Virgin Drinks Group first launched as the Virgin Cola Company in 1994 with
Virgin Cola in the UK Since then the company has ventured across the carbonated
soft drinks arena and beyond into energy drinks tea and flavored Colas This
expansion has lead to the evolution of the Virgin Drinks Company a company
whose aim is to put the excitement back into the world of soft drinks It launched in
Bangladesh in 1999 Virgin Soft Drinks is monitored by Global Beverage Co Ltd in
Bangladesh
Brief history of Virgin Drinks is given below
Page 31 of 46
1994 November Virgin Cola launched in the UK
1996 March Virgin Cola launched in France
1998 June Virgin Cola launched in Belgium
April Virgin Cola launched in the French West Indies
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
August Virgin Cola launched in Switzerland
1999 March Virgin Colours launched in Italy
March Virgin Cola launched in Japan
July Virgin Colours launched in South Africa
December Virgin Colours launched in Bangladesh
2001 January Sweden launched Virgin Colours
November Singapore launched Virgin Colours
2002 February Croatia launched Virgin Colours
June Russia launched Virgin Colours
June Tunisia launched Virgin Colours
2003 May Israel launched Virgin Colours
8 FINDINGS OF WORKING CAPITAL MANAGEMENT MAINTAINED BY
VIRGIN SOFT DRINKS IN BANGLADESH
81 CASH MANAGEMENT
811 Holding Cash and Marketable Securities
Although there are many good reasons why firm hold cash and marketable
securities Virgin Drinks holds cash and marketable securities for two reasons ndash
i) Cash for transactions
ii) Cash as hedges
This indicates that the firm does not hold cash and marketable securities for some
important reasons such as ndash
i) Near cash assets as hedges
Page 32 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
ii) Temporary investment and compensating balances
Virgin Soft Drinks does not invest in money market securities such as Treasury bill
commercial paper certificate of deposits bankerrsquos acceptance and repurchase
agreement This firm deposits its money in bank as currant AC or fixed AC They
say that they do not have enough money to invest in money market instrument
They also say that if they have enough money they will invest it in money market
short term securities We know that near cash interest earning assets can be
substituted for cash when motivation for holding these assets is the hedging of cash
flow uncertainties or is the temporary investment of surplus funds In this point
Virgins position is not good as there is no significant hedging against uncertainty of
cash
812 Floatation and Check Clearing
Virgin is very smart in handling the problem of transit time for checks Here mail
float takes 2 to 3 days at firm takes 025 day and clearing float takes 1-3 days Virgin
uses most of the strategies available for reducing the delay in receiving funds It
(Virgin) has linked Islami Bank which posses an accelerated clearing facility It uses
electronic collection process which ensures faster collection and its at the firm check
processing is satisfactory But Virgin does not use lockbox The reason behind this is
that it is not cost-effective for Virgin to set lockboxes At this point we can say that
Virgins check clearing mechanism is much good
813 Cash Concentration and Disbursement Management
Page 33 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks takes the matter of cash concentration very seriously They use all
the available cash concentration mechanism Virgin is a firm with small deposits
spread over a substantial number of banks and this is why the firm tends to use
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
depository transfer checks extensively If is less costly Virgin also uses automated
clearing house and wire transfer To Virgin wire transfer seems too costly
Like other firm Virgin tries to retain the cash for as long as possible But Virgin
always performs it in an ethical manner Virgin does not try to defeat the receiving
firmrsquos attempts to reduce the float on incoming checks It does not take any strategy
for increasing mail float at firm float and clearing float on its outgoing checks To
Virgin it is deemed to be unethical It thinks that maximization of disbursement float
will not go unnoticed by sophisticated creditors for very long When it is noticed it
will negatively affect relations with these creditors reducing the firmrsquos bargaining
power with them This may ultimately cost Virgin dearly when future prices and
delivery schedules for goods and services purchased from trade creditors are
negotiated Virgin follows ldquoZero-Balance Accountsrdquo methods for managing
disbursement It thinks that in this method the coordination of funds inflows to
disbursement banks with the presentation of checks does not work to the detriment
of creditors since the firmrsquos checks to them are honored as presented and this strategy
does not affect float significantly Controlled disbursing method is less attractive to
Virgin because zero-balance system is already feasible
814 Cash Forecasting
Cash Forecasting and Its Types
Page 34 of 46
Virgin forecasts the future cash inflows and outflows To Virgin cash forecast is an
important part of the firmrsquos cash control system and is one of the forecasts that are
part of the Virginrsquos financial plan Virgin forecasts cash on monthly basis and on
yearly basis Virgin does not forecast on daily basis assuming that the temporary
shortage of funds within these periods can be covered without value cost eg
advance receipts from customers Virginrsquos cash forecasting system involves a
combination of distribution and scheduling The receipts and disbursements
approach of cash forecasting is used in virgin This method is used because it
minutely traces the movement of cash and very close control of cash is possible
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Virgin does not use adjusted net income approach on two grounds First it does not
permit the tracing of the individual types of cash inflows and outflows for any given
period which is often useful information for virgin Second it is not simple to use
Items to be Forecast
Virgin does not forecast all the items It forecasts only major items eg accounts
receivable notes receivable payroll cash purchases of raw materials In this regard
virgin trade off between cost and benefit
Methods of Financial Forecasting
Virgin forecasts the future level of financial variable such as cash level asset level or
liability level We know in short term forecasts many things will result from plans
and events that are already in place (contracts capital budgets long-range financing
plans and so forth) But in the long run most things can vary and are dependent on
outside influences such as the firmrsquos long-term growth rate Since Virginrsquos cash
forecasting deals mostly with near future many of the items on the cash forecasts are
estimated by some variation of the spot method and remaining estimates are mostly
on a ldquoproportion of another accountrdquo basis with this ldquoother accountrdquo often being a
particular periodrsquos sales Virgin uses the other two methods less frequently
Using Cash Forecast
Virgin forecasts cash for meeting general objectives (ie to know the available funds
for investment and need financing) and for meeting some special objectives (eg to
know whether the firm will fulfill its out of debt requirement) But it is matter to note
that Virgin does not make any short term investment of its surplus cash but only keep
this surplus in Bank Account
Page 35 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Sources of Uncertainty in Cash Forecasting and Hedging Uncertainties
Virgin faces uncertainty in cash forecasting mainly from two sources These are ndash
sales and production cost In peak season (hot season like autumn summer) sales
increases but in dull season (eg in winter) sales decreases drastically Production
cost may be increased because of increase of price of sugar chemicals aluminum
can Virgin follows two methods for hedging cash balance uncertainties These are ndash
i) Holding a stock of extra cash and
ii) Extra borrowing capacity
815 Modes for the Management of Cash and Temporary Investments
Virgin does not follow any of these methods wholly Virgin receives cash
continuously and pays salary at steady rate and pays continuously for other
expenses So it neither follows Baumol model nor Beranek model It has no upper
control limit lower control limit return point in case cash management So it neither
follows Miller-Orr model nor Stone model
In Summary
Page 36 of 46
Standard Compliance by Virgin Soft Drinks
Generally all firms hold cash and
marketable securities
Virgin holds only cash
Firms hold cash and marketable
securities for some reasons like
bull Cash for transactions
bull Cash and near-cash assets as
hedges
bull Temporary investments
bull Compensating balances
Virgin holds cash only for
two reasons ndash
bull Cash for transactions
bull Cash as hedges
Available money market instruments Virgin does not invest in any such
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
(short term securities) are ndash
Treasury Bills
Commercial Paper
Certificates of Deposit
Bankerrsquos Acceptance
Repurch menase Agree ts
instruments They only keep cash in
Bank Account
Mail Float
(1 to 5 days)
At Firm
Float
(025 to 1
day)
Clearing
Float
(0 to
2 days)
Mail Float
(2 to 3 days)
At firm
Float
(025
day)
Clearing
Float
(1 to 3
days)
Figure Transit time for a typical check Figure Transit time for a check for
Virgin
Strategies that firms can use to reduce
the delay in receiving funds are ndash
Selecting of Banks with
accelerated clearing capabilities
of check processing Acceleration
at the firm
ectronic collection Use of el
procedures
Use of lockboxes
Virgin follows the first three strategies
but does not use lockboxes
Available cash concentration
mechanisms are ndash
Depository transfer check
ouse Automated Clearing H
(ACH) electronic transfer)
Wire transfer
Virgin uses all these mechanisms of
cash concentration
Available sets of techniques for cash
disbursement management are ndash
ement of disbursement
Page 37 of 46
Manag
float
Virgin uses zero-balance accounts
technique
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Zero-Balance Accounts
Controlled disbursing
Firms may make cash flow forecasts
over periods of various lengths yearly
flows quarterly flows monthly flows
weekly flows or even daily flows
Virgin forecasts cash on yearly basis and
monthly basis
Cash forecasting system may involve ndash
Distribution
Scheduling
Virginrsquos cash forecasting system
involves a combination of distribution
and scheduling
Two common approaches to cash flow
in generating the cash forecast
and disbursement Receipts
approach
Adjusted net income approach
Virgin uses the receipts and
disbursement approach
There are many items to forecast Virgin forecasts only major items like
AR payroll etc
Four common approach to forecasting
fina i ndash nc al variables are
Spot method
Proportion to another account
Compounded growth
Multiple dependencies
Virgin uses spot method for forecasting
cash It uses proportion to another
account method for other variables and
remaining two methods are frequently
used
Sources of uncertainty in cash
forecasting are ndash
Sales uncertainty
Collection rate uncertainty
Production cost uncertainty
Capital outflow uncertainty
Virgin faces uncertainty mainly from
sales and production cost
Methods for hedging cash balance
unc a
Page 38 of 46
ert inties are ndash
i) Holding a stock of extra cash
Virgin two available methods for
hedging cash balance uncertainties
Th ese are ndash
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
ii) stock of near-cash Holding a
assets
iii) Extra borrowing capacity
iv) ary surpluses in Investing tempor
near-cash assets
i) Holding a stock of extra cash
ii) Extra borrowing capacity
(advance receipt from
customers)
Models for the management of cash and
temporary investments are ndash Baumol
model Beranek model Miller-Orr
model and Stone model
Virgin does not follow any method
wholly but a combination of Baumol
model and Beranek model is occurred
82 INVENTORY MANAGEMENT
21 Certainty Approach
isnt used in
irgin because it thinks it is not possible to implement in Bangladesh
d time is one to three days It
oes not use ABC system of inventory management
8
Main item of inventory of Virgin is Can pet chip sugar label chemical artificial
sweet etc Virgin maintains a minimum level of inventory but it does not have to face
problems because inventory is managed efficiently just-in-time (JIT)
V
Virgin maintains buffer stock because of the shortage of work-in-process (WIP)
inventory Its production process may also be hampered Thats why it maintains
safety stock to avoid stock out cost In case of imported goods normal lead time is
about one month and within the country normal lea
d
Page 39 of 46
Inventory Model
In reality Virgin does not use any of models of EOQ ordering and holding strategy
and safety stock strategy They maintain inventory based on their prior experience
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
822 Uncertainty Approach
Virgin does not use any model for handling inventory uncertainty It says that such
decision depends on business cycle and market situation Long before Eid festival
they bought large amount of sugar because of price increase on the occasion of Eid
In summary
Standard Compliance by Virgin Soft Drinks
Firms maintain inventory to guard
against several problems
Virgin maintains a minimum level of
inventory which is managed efficiently
Some firms use JIT to avoid inventory
cost
JIT is not used by Virgin as it thinks it is
impossible to implement in Bangladesh
Firms maintain buffer stock Virgin maintains buffer stock too
Firms maintain safety stock to avoid
shortage cost
Virgin also maintains safety stock
Firms use ABC system to monitor
inventory
Virgin doesnt use ABC system
EOQ model is an appropriate method
for measuring quantity that has to be
ordered per order
Virgin does not use EOQ model rather
makes order based on experience and
market demand
83 MANAGING ACCOUNTS RECEIVABLE (DEBTORS)
831 Terms of Sale Decision
Page 40 of 46
Virgin offers the term 210 net 30 enables the customers to deduct 2 percent from the
face value of the bill when paying within the first 10 days but if the discount is not
taken the customer must remit the full amount within 30 days But Virgin does not
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
offer the same terms of sale to all customers For prime customers it offers special
terms of sale In setting an appropriate term of sale it costs and benefits regarding
this are compared It uses the standard approach of terms of sale decision as it is
simple to use
832 Credit Granting Decisions
In case of Virgin the Capital and Character of Five Cs get more importance
Although there are many problems with the traditional approach Virgin uses it
because of its simplicity Virgin does not use Net Present Value (NPV) method in
credit granting decision It thinks that NPV is an appropriate method and should be
used next time It does not face any severe problem because of bad debts The reason
is that notes receivable is used when credit is granted
833 Monitoring Accounts Receivable
Virgin monitors its accounts receivable Virgin believes that in any case both positive
and negative durations in accounts signal differences from the results that
management believe to be the most advantageous for the firm
Tools for Monitoring Accounts Receivable
Page 41 of 46
For monitoring accounts receivable there are several tools such as aging schedule
the ratios of receivable outstanding to original sales customers payment proportion
and sales weighted DSO (Days Sales Outstanding) For monitoring accounts
receivable Virgin uses aging schedule fractions and traditional DSO statistics
because of their simplicity in use Although payment proportions ratios of
receivables outstanding and sales weighted DSO methods are free from inherent bias
None of these is used because all these are complex to maintain
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
In summary
Page 42 of 46
Standard Compliance by Virgin Soft Drinks
Generals terms of sale is 210 net 30 Normally Virgin also use general terms
of sale ie 210 net 30
Firms do not offer the same terms of
sale to all customers
Yes For prime customers Virgin offers
special terms of sale
Approaches of terms of sale decisions
are ndash
bull Standard approach
bull Multi period approach
Virgin uses standard approach of terms
of sale decision as it is simple to use and
understand
Source of credit information are ndash
Sellers prior experience with the
customer
Credit agency ratings and
reports
Personal contact with the
applicants bank and other
creditors
Analysis of applicants financial
statements
Customer visit
Main source of credit information to
Virgin is its prior experience with the
customer All other sources are not cost-
effective for Virgin
Approaches of credit granting to
marginal accounts are ndash
Traditional approach
Net Present Value (NPV)
approach
It uses traditional approach still now but
thinks that NPV should be used for the
next periods
Firms monitor accounts receivable
because deviations from the expected
levels of turnover and of bad debt can
Virgin also monitors its accounts
receivable
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
signal several different problems
Different tools for monitoring accounts
receivable are ndash
Aging schedule
Ratios of receivables
outstanding to original sales
Customers payment
proportions
Sales-weighted DSO
For monitoring accounts receivable
Virgin uses aging schedule and
traditional sales outstanding statistics
84 MANAGING ACCOUNTS PAYABLE (CREDITORS)
Virgin has almost accounts payable of Tk 8000000 But most of its liabilities are to
the banks rather than suppliers But we dont have any clear information about
Virgins accounts payable
9 RECOMMENDATION
Virgin should invest its surplus cash in short term marketable securities
because it is suitable hedging against cash uncertainties and will also give
some returns (interest income)
Virgin should publish its own annual report which will satisfy information
needs of stakeholders and also increase the credibility of information provided
by Virgin
Page 43 of 46
Virgin should use multi period approach in terms of sale decision because
standard approach which is already exists in Virgin has some inherent
problems
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
It should stop using traditional approach from now It should use NPV
method in credit granting to marginal accounts
In monitoring accounts receivable Virgin should use sales-weighted DSO
method because it has least limitation compared to the others
It should be more flexible in granting credit which will ultimately increase its
sales
To get the appropriate number of quantity to be ordered per order it should
use DSO model
It should be ABC system for proper monitoring of inventory
10 CONCLUSION
The use of other peoples money in business is usually an expensive resource Before
looking outside for finance a firm should examine its own working capital cycle to
make sure that every rand of its own internal funds is being fully utilized Good
management of working capital is part of good financial management Effective use
of working capital will contribute to the operational efficiency of the whole
organization optimum use will help to generate maximum returns Furthermore
working capital management is not an end in itself It is an integral part of the firms
overall management The needs of efficient working capital management must be
considered in relation to other aspects of the Virgins financial and non-financial
performance Thats why when planning the development of a business it is critical
that the impact of working capital be fully assessed
Page 44 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
BIBLIOGRAPHY
Scherr FC (1989) International Edition Prentice-Hall International Inc Modern
Working Capital Management Text and Cases
Hussain Riaz (2002) Working Capital Management
Robertson Lonnie (July 1998) Inventory Management
httpwwwasashoporg visited on March 13 2006
The Art of Cash Management
httpwwwinccom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management
httpwwwstudyfinancecom visited on March 13 2006
White Paper ndash Managing Working Capital
httpwwwplanwareorg visited on March 13 2006
Management of Working Capital
httpwwwbusinesscentralcoza visited on March 13 2006
Cash Management
httpwwwsbagov visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management Objectives
httpwpsprenhallcom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management
Page 45 of 46
httpwwwadvancemecom visited on March 13 2006
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Business Receivables Financing
httpwwwbbtcom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Finance
http wwwfnbcoza visited on March 13 2006
Tips to manage your working capital
httpsmallbusinessninemsncomau visited on March 13 2006
Inventory Financing
httpwwwfranklincapitalnetworkcom visited on March 13 2006
Accounts Receivable Management
httpwwwfranklincapitalnetworkcom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management
httpwwwtreasurygovtnz visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management
httpwwwtreasurystrategiescom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Works
httpwwwinvestopediacom visited on March 13 2006
Treasury Services
httpwwwjpmorganchasecom visited on March 13 2006
what were about
Page 46 of 46
httpwwwvirgincom visited on March 13 2006
Annexure
Annexure
Interview with YASEER RIZVI
Mr Yaseer Rizvi the DMD of Global Beverage Co Ltd obtained his MBA degree
from a reputed university He had been the Director of Ocean Container Ltd before
joining in Global Beverage Co Ltd He possesses a nice personality
I interviewed Yaseer Rizvi Excerpts from his interview are as follows ndash
Shah Kamal Sir would you please tell me do you invest in short term marketable securities
Yaseer Rizvi Basically we do not invest our surplus cash in short term marketable
securities like T-Bill commercial paper certificate of deposit etc But we keep our
surplus cash in Bank
Shah Kamal Would you tell me something about transit time for a typical check
Yaseer Rizvi Well in Virgin the transit time for a typical check is ndash
For mail float 2 to 3 days
At firm float 6 hours
Clearing float 1 to 3 days
Shah Kamal Do you maintain any cash concentration mechanism like depository transfer check automated clearing house and wire transfer
i
Annexure
Yaseer Rizvi Our position in this case is very strong as we use all the mechanisms
you mentioned As Virgin is a firm with small deposits spread over a substantial
number of banks so we tend to use depository transfer checks extensively It is less
costly We also use automated clearing house and wire transfer but later is used in a
less extent
Shah Kamal Sir what techniques of disbursement management is used by your firm
Yaseer Rizvi Like other firms Virgin tries to retain the cash for as long as possible
But we always perform it in an ethical manner We do not use management of
disbursement float as it seems unethical We follow Zero-Balance Accounts method
for managing disbursement We do not prefer Controlled Disbursing method since
Zero-Balance system is already practiced in Virgin
Shah Kamal How do you hedge cash balance uncertainties
Yaseer Rizvi Well you may say that we do not invest in short term securities but for
facing cash difficulties we keep our surplus cash in bank
Shah Kamal Sir would you please tell me the general terms of sale of Virgin
Yaseer Rizvi Though it is difficult to maintain a fixed terms of sale our general terms
of sale is 210 n30 But for prime customers we offer special terms of sale
Shah Kamal What are the sources of credit information in case of your firm
Yaseer Rizvi We grant credit on the basis of prior experience with the customers In
case of a new customer personal contact is weighted
Shah Kamal Does your firm consider 5 Cs in granting credit
ii
Annexure
Yaseer Rizvi In case of Virgin Capital and Character get more importance than the
others Mind one thing personal relationship is the main measure in granting credit
Shah Kamal Do you use NPV method in credit granting decisions
Yaseer Rizvi We do not use NPV method But we think that NPV is a suitable
method and we have to use it from the next period
Shah Kamal Sir how do you handle the problem of bad debt
Yaseer Rizvi Well in this case our position is very strong Yet we do not face any
problem because of bad debt Just note that we make more than 80 of sales in cash
and we monitor accounts receivable very carefully
Shah Kamal What level of inventory is maintained by Virgin
Yaseer Rizvi We maintain a minimum level of inventory but do not have to face
stock out problems because inventory is managed efficiently
Shah Kamal What is the normal lead time
Yaseer Rizvi In case of imported goods normal lead time is about 1 month and when
we purchase raw materials from inside the country lead time is 1 to 3 days
Shah Kamal What method do you use for managing inventory
Yaseer Rizvi We do not use any method particularly rather inventory decision
depends on business cycle and market situation Long before the Eid festival we
bought large amount of sugar because price of sugar was increased on the occasion
of Eid
iii
Annexure
Shah Kamal What are the main items of inventory of your firm
Yaseer Rizvi Well these are ndash aluminum can pet chip sugar label chemical and
artificial sweet
Shah Kamal What are the uncertainties in maintaining appropriate level of stock
Yaseer Rizvi These are ndash
bull Increase in price of raw materials
bull Sales uncertainty
bull Market trends etc
Shah Kamal Thank you for your kind cooperation
Yaseer Rizvi Most Welcome
iv
Global Beverage Company Limited
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
with them the trademark management style skills and experience Virgin frequently
creates partnerships with others to combine skills knowledge and market presence
and so on Contrary to what some people may think their constantly expanding and
eclectic empire is neither random nor reckless Each successive venture demonstrates
its skill in picking the right market and the right opportunity
7 OVERVIEW OF VIRGIN SOFT DRINKS
The Virgin Drinks Group first launched as the Virgin Cola Company in 1994 with
Virgin Cola in the UK Since then the company has ventured across the carbonated
soft drinks arena and beyond into energy drinks tea and flavored Colas This
expansion has lead to the evolution of the Virgin Drinks Company a company
whose aim is to put the excitement back into the world of soft drinks It launched in
Bangladesh in 1999 Virgin Soft Drinks is monitored by Global Beverage Co Ltd in
Bangladesh
Brief history of Virgin Drinks is given below
Page 31 of 46
1994 November Virgin Cola launched in the UK
1996 March Virgin Cola launched in France
1998 June Virgin Cola launched in Belgium
April Virgin Cola launched in the French West Indies
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
August Virgin Cola launched in Switzerland
1999 March Virgin Colours launched in Italy
March Virgin Cola launched in Japan
July Virgin Colours launched in South Africa
December Virgin Colours launched in Bangladesh
2001 January Sweden launched Virgin Colours
November Singapore launched Virgin Colours
2002 February Croatia launched Virgin Colours
June Russia launched Virgin Colours
June Tunisia launched Virgin Colours
2003 May Israel launched Virgin Colours
8 FINDINGS OF WORKING CAPITAL MANAGEMENT MAINTAINED BY
VIRGIN SOFT DRINKS IN BANGLADESH
81 CASH MANAGEMENT
811 Holding Cash and Marketable Securities
Although there are many good reasons why firm hold cash and marketable
securities Virgin Drinks holds cash and marketable securities for two reasons ndash
i) Cash for transactions
ii) Cash as hedges
This indicates that the firm does not hold cash and marketable securities for some
important reasons such as ndash
i) Near cash assets as hedges
Page 32 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
ii) Temporary investment and compensating balances
Virgin Soft Drinks does not invest in money market securities such as Treasury bill
commercial paper certificate of deposits bankerrsquos acceptance and repurchase
agreement This firm deposits its money in bank as currant AC or fixed AC They
say that they do not have enough money to invest in money market instrument
They also say that if they have enough money they will invest it in money market
short term securities We know that near cash interest earning assets can be
substituted for cash when motivation for holding these assets is the hedging of cash
flow uncertainties or is the temporary investment of surplus funds In this point
Virgins position is not good as there is no significant hedging against uncertainty of
cash
812 Floatation and Check Clearing
Virgin is very smart in handling the problem of transit time for checks Here mail
float takes 2 to 3 days at firm takes 025 day and clearing float takes 1-3 days Virgin
uses most of the strategies available for reducing the delay in receiving funds It
(Virgin) has linked Islami Bank which posses an accelerated clearing facility It uses
electronic collection process which ensures faster collection and its at the firm check
processing is satisfactory But Virgin does not use lockbox The reason behind this is
that it is not cost-effective for Virgin to set lockboxes At this point we can say that
Virgins check clearing mechanism is much good
813 Cash Concentration and Disbursement Management
Page 33 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks takes the matter of cash concentration very seriously They use all
the available cash concentration mechanism Virgin is a firm with small deposits
spread over a substantial number of banks and this is why the firm tends to use
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
depository transfer checks extensively If is less costly Virgin also uses automated
clearing house and wire transfer To Virgin wire transfer seems too costly
Like other firm Virgin tries to retain the cash for as long as possible But Virgin
always performs it in an ethical manner Virgin does not try to defeat the receiving
firmrsquos attempts to reduce the float on incoming checks It does not take any strategy
for increasing mail float at firm float and clearing float on its outgoing checks To
Virgin it is deemed to be unethical It thinks that maximization of disbursement float
will not go unnoticed by sophisticated creditors for very long When it is noticed it
will negatively affect relations with these creditors reducing the firmrsquos bargaining
power with them This may ultimately cost Virgin dearly when future prices and
delivery schedules for goods and services purchased from trade creditors are
negotiated Virgin follows ldquoZero-Balance Accountsrdquo methods for managing
disbursement It thinks that in this method the coordination of funds inflows to
disbursement banks with the presentation of checks does not work to the detriment
of creditors since the firmrsquos checks to them are honored as presented and this strategy
does not affect float significantly Controlled disbursing method is less attractive to
Virgin because zero-balance system is already feasible
814 Cash Forecasting
Cash Forecasting and Its Types
Page 34 of 46
Virgin forecasts the future cash inflows and outflows To Virgin cash forecast is an
important part of the firmrsquos cash control system and is one of the forecasts that are
part of the Virginrsquos financial plan Virgin forecasts cash on monthly basis and on
yearly basis Virgin does not forecast on daily basis assuming that the temporary
shortage of funds within these periods can be covered without value cost eg
advance receipts from customers Virginrsquos cash forecasting system involves a
combination of distribution and scheduling The receipts and disbursements
approach of cash forecasting is used in virgin This method is used because it
minutely traces the movement of cash and very close control of cash is possible
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Virgin does not use adjusted net income approach on two grounds First it does not
permit the tracing of the individual types of cash inflows and outflows for any given
period which is often useful information for virgin Second it is not simple to use
Items to be Forecast
Virgin does not forecast all the items It forecasts only major items eg accounts
receivable notes receivable payroll cash purchases of raw materials In this regard
virgin trade off between cost and benefit
Methods of Financial Forecasting
Virgin forecasts the future level of financial variable such as cash level asset level or
liability level We know in short term forecasts many things will result from plans
and events that are already in place (contracts capital budgets long-range financing
plans and so forth) But in the long run most things can vary and are dependent on
outside influences such as the firmrsquos long-term growth rate Since Virginrsquos cash
forecasting deals mostly with near future many of the items on the cash forecasts are
estimated by some variation of the spot method and remaining estimates are mostly
on a ldquoproportion of another accountrdquo basis with this ldquoother accountrdquo often being a
particular periodrsquos sales Virgin uses the other two methods less frequently
Using Cash Forecast
Virgin forecasts cash for meeting general objectives (ie to know the available funds
for investment and need financing) and for meeting some special objectives (eg to
know whether the firm will fulfill its out of debt requirement) But it is matter to note
that Virgin does not make any short term investment of its surplus cash but only keep
this surplus in Bank Account
Page 35 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Sources of Uncertainty in Cash Forecasting and Hedging Uncertainties
Virgin faces uncertainty in cash forecasting mainly from two sources These are ndash
sales and production cost In peak season (hot season like autumn summer) sales
increases but in dull season (eg in winter) sales decreases drastically Production
cost may be increased because of increase of price of sugar chemicals aluminum
can Virgin follows two methods for hedging cash balance uncertainties These are ndash
i) Holding a stock of extra cash and
ii) Extra borrowing capacity
815 Modes for the Management of Cash and Temporary Investments
Virgin does not follow any of these methods wholly Virgin receives cash
continuously and pays salary at steady rate and pays continuously for other
expenses So it neither follows Baumol model nor Beranek model It has no upper
control limit lower control limit return point in case cash management So it neither
follows Miller-Orr model nor Stone model
In Summary
Page 36 of 46
Standard Compliance by Virgin Soft Drinks
Generally all firms hold cash and
marketable securities
Virgin holds only cash
Firms hold cash and marketable
securities for some reasons like
bull Cash for transactions
bull Cash and near-cash assets as
hedges
bull Temporary investments
bull Compensating balances
Virgin holds cash only for
two reasons ndash
bull Cash for transactions
bull Cash as hedges
Available money market instruments Virgin does not invest in any such
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
(short term securities) are ndash
Treasury Bills
Commercial Paper
Certificates of Deposit
Bankerrsquos Acceptance
Repurch menase Agree ts
instruments They only keep cash in
Bank Account
Mail Float
(1 to 5 days)
At Firm
Float
(025 to 1
day)
Clearing
Float
(0 to
2 days)
Mail Float
(2 to 3 days)
At firm
Float
(025
day)
Clearing
Float
(1 to 3
days)
Figure Transit time for a typical check Figure Transit time for a check for
Virgin
Strategies that firms can use to reduce
the delay in receiving funds are ndash
Selecting of Banks with
accelerated clearing capabilities
of check processing Acceleration
at the firm
ectronic collection Use of el
procedures
Use of lockboxes
Virgin follows the first three strategies
but does not use lockboxes
Available cash concentration
mechanisms are ndash
Depository transfer check
ouse Automated Clearing H
(ACH) electronic transfer)
Wire transfer
Virgin uses all these mechanisms of
cash concentration
Available sets of techniques for cash
disbursement management are ndash
ement of disbursement
Page 37 of 46
Manag
float
Virgin uses zero-balance accounts
technique
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Zero-Balance Accounts
Controlled disbursing
Firms may make cash flow forecasts
over periods of various lengths yearly
flows quarterly flows monthly flows
weekly flows or even daily flows
Virgin forecasts cash on yearly basis and
monthly basis
Cash forecasting system may involve ndash
Distribution
Scheduling
Virginrsquos cash forecasting system
involves a combination of distribution
and scheduling
Two common approaches to cash flow
in generating the cash forecast
and disbursement Receipts
approach
Adjusted net income approach
Virgin uses the receipts and
disbursement approach
There are many items to forecast Virgin forecasts only major items like
AR payroll etc
Four common approach to forecasting
fina i ndash nc al variables are
Spot method
Proportion to another account
Compounded growth
Multiple dependencies
Virgin uses spot method for forecasting
cash It uses proportion to another
account method for other variables and
remaining two methods are frequently
used
Sources of uncertainty in cash
forecasting are ndash
Sales uncertainty
Collection rate uncertainty
Production cost uncertainty
Capital outflow uncertainty
Virgin faces uncertainty mainly from
sales and production cost
Methods for hedging cash balance
unc a
Page 38 of 46
ert inties are ndash
i) Holding a stock of extra cash
Virgin two available methods for
hedging cash balance uncertainties
Th ese are ndash
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
ii) stock of near-cash Holding a
assets
iii) Extra borrowing capacity
iv) ary surpluses in Investing tempor
near-cash assets
i) Holding a stock of extra cash
ii) Extra borrowing capacity
(advance receipt from
customers)
Models for the management of cash and
temporary investments are ndash Baumol
model Beranek model Miller-Orr
model and Stone model
Virgin does not follow any method
wholly but a combination of Baumol
model and Beranek model is occurred
82 INVENTORY MANAGEMENT
21 Certainty Approach
isnt used in
irgin because it thinks it is not possible to implement in Bangladesh
d time is one to three days It
oes not use ABC system of inventory management
8
Main item of inventory of Virgin is Can pet chip sugar label chemical artificial
sweet etc Virgin maintains a minimum level of inventory but it does not have to face
problems because inventory is managed efficiently just-in-time (JIT)
V
Virgin maintains buffer stock because of the shortage of work-in-process (WIP)
inventory Its production process may also be hampered Thats why it maintains
safety stock to avoid stock out cost In case of imported goods normal lead time is
about one month and within the country normal lea
d
Page 39 of 46
Inventory Model
In reality Virgin does not use any of models of EOQ ordering and holding strategy
and safety stock strategy They maintain inventory based on their prior experience
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
822 Uncertainty Approach
Virgin does not use any model for handling inventory uncertainty It says that such
decision depends on business cycle and market situation Long before Eid festival
they bought large amount of sugar because of price increase on the occasion of Eid
In summary
Standard Compliance by Virgin Soft Drinks
Firms maintain inventory to guard
against several problems
Virgin maintains a minimum level of
inventory which is managed efficiently
Some firms use JIT to avoid inventory
cost
JIT is not used by Virgin as it thinks it is
impossible to implement in Bangladesh
Firms maintain buffer stock Virgin maintains buffer stock too
Firms maintain safety stock to avoid
shortage cost
Virgin also maintains safety stock
Firms use ABC system to monitor
inventory
Virgin doesnt use ABC system
EOQ model is an appropriate method
for measuring quantity that has to be
ordered per order
Virgin does not use EOQ model rather
makes order based on experience and
market demand
83 MANAGING ACCOUNTS RECEIVABLE (DEBTORS)
831 Terms of Sale Decision
Page 40 of 46
Virgin offers the term 210 net 30 enables the customers to deduct 2 percent from the
face value of the bill when paying within the first 10 days but if the discount is not
taken the customer must remit the full amount within 30 days But Virgin does not
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
offer the same terms of sale to all customers For prime customers it offers special
terms of sale In setting an appropriate term of sale it costs and benefits regarding
this are compared It uses the standard approach of terms of sale decision as it is
simple to use
832 Credit Granting Decisions
In case of Virgin the Capital and Character of Five Cs get more importance
Although there are many problems with the traditional approach Virgin uses it
because of its simplicity Virgin does not use Net Present Value (NPV) method in
credit granting decision It thinks that NPV is an appropriate method and should be
used next time It does not face any severe problem because of bad debts The reason
is that notes receivable is used when credit is granted
833 Monitoring Accounts Receivable
Virgin monitors its accounts receivable Virgin believes that in any case both positive
and negative durations in accounts signal differences from the results that
management believe to be the most advantageous for the firm
Tools for Monitoring Accounts Receivable
Page 41 of 46
For monitoring accounts receivable there are several tools such as aging schedule
the ratios of receivable outstanding to original sales customers payment proportion
and sales weighted DSO (Days Sales Outstanding) For monitoring accounts
receivable Virgin uses aging schedule fractions and traditional DSO statistics
because of their simplicity in use Although payment proportions ratios of
receivables outstanding and sales weighted DSO methods are free from inherent bias
None of these is used because all these are complex to maintain
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
In summary
Page 42 of 46
Standard Compliance by Virgin Soft Drinks
Generals terms of sale is 210 net 30 Normally Virgin also use general terms
of sale ie 210 net 30
Firms do not offer the same terms of
sale to all customers
Yes For prime customers Virgin offers
special terms of sale
Approaches of terms of sale decisions
are ndash
bull Standard approach
bull Multi period approach
Virgin uses standard approach of terms
of sale decision as it is simple to use and
understand
Source of credit information are ndash
Sellers prior experience with the
customer
Credit agency ratings and
reports
Personal contact with the
applicants bank and other
creditors
Analysis of applicants financial
statements
Customer visit
Main source of credit information to
Virgin is its prior experience with the
customer All other sources are not cost-
effective for Virgin
Approaches of credit granting to
marginal accounts are ndash
Traditional approach
Net Present Value (NPV)
approach
It uses traditional approach still now but
thinks that NPV should be used for the
next periods
Firms monitor accounts receivable
because deviations from the expected
levels of turnover and of bad debt can
Virgin also monitors its accounts
receivable
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
signal several different problems
Different tools for monitoring accounts
receivable are ndash
Aging schedule
Ratios of receivables
outstanding to original sales
Customers payment
proportions
Sales-weighted DSO
For monitoring accounts receivable
Virgin uses aging schedule and
traditional sales outstanding statistics
84 MANAGING ACCOUNTS PAYABLE (CREDITORS)
Virgin has almost accounts payable of Tk 8000000 But most of its liabilities are to
the banks rather than suppliers But we dont have any clear information about
Virgins accounts payable
9 RECOMMENDATION
Virgin should invest its surplus cash in short term marketable securities
because it is suitable hedging against cash uncertainties and will also give
some returns (interest income)
Virgin should publish its own annual report which will satisfy information
needs of stakeholders and also increase the credibility of information provided
by Virgin
Page 43 of 46
Virgin should use multi period approach in terms of sale decision because
standard approach which is already exists in Virgin has some inherent
problems
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
It should stop using traditional approach from now It should use NPV
method in credit granting to marginal accounts
In monitoring accounts receivable Virgin should use sales-weighted DSO
method because it has least limitation compared to the others
It should be more flexible in granting credit which will ultimately increase its
sales
To get the appropriate number of quantity to be ordered per order it should
use DSO model
It should be ABC system for proper monitoring of inventory
10 CONCLUSION
The use of other peoples money in business is usually an expensive resource Before
looking outside for finance a firm should examine its own working capital cycle to
make sure that every rand of its own internal funds is being fully utilized Good
management of working capital is part of good financial management Effective use
of working capital will contribute to the operational efficiency of the whole
organization optimum use will help to generate maximum returns Furthermore
working capital management is not an end in itself It is an integral part of the firms
overall management The needs of efficient working capital management must be
considered in relation to other aspects of the Virgins financial and non-financial
performance Thats why when planning the development of a business it is critical
that the impact of working capital be fully assessed
Page 44 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
BIBLIOGRAPHY
Scherr FC (1989) International Edition Prentice-Hall International Inc Modern
Working Capital Management Text and Cases
Hussain Riaz (2002) Working Capital Management
Robertson Lonnie (July 1998) Inventory Management
httpwwwasashoporg visited on March 13 2006
The Art of Cash Management
httpwwwinccom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management
httpwwwstudyfinancecom visited on March 13 2006
White Paper ndash Managing Working Capital
httpwwwplanwareorg visited on March 13 2006
Management of Working Capital
httpwwwbusinesscentralcoza visited on March 13 2006
Cash Management
httpwwwsbagov visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management Objectives
httpwpsprenhallcom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management
Page 45 of 46
httpwwwadvancemecom visited on March 13 2006
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Business Receivables Financing
httpwwwbbtcom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Finance
http wwwfnbcoza visited on March 13 2006
Tips to manage your working capital
httpsmallbusinessninemsncomau visited on March 13 2006
Inventory Financing
httpwwwfranklincapitalnetworkcom visited on March 13 2006
Accounts Receivable Management
httpwwwfranklincapitalnetworkcom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management
httpwwwtreasurygovtnz visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management
httpwwwtreasurystrategiescom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Works
httpwwwinvestopediacom visited on March 13 2006
Treasury Services
httpwwwjpmorganchasecom visited on March 13 2006
what were about
Page 46 of 46
httpwwwvirgincom visited on March 13 2006
Annexure
Annexure
Interview with YASEER RIZVI
Mr Yaseer Rizvi the DMD of Global Beverage Co Ltd obtained his MBA degree
from a reputed university He had been the Director of Ocean Container Ltd before
joining in Global Beverage Co Ltd He possesses a nice personality
I interviewed Yaseer Rizvi Excerpts from his interview are as follows ndash
Shah Kamal Sir would you please tell me do you invest in short term marketable securities
Yaseer Rizvi Basically we do not invest our surplus cash in short term marketable
securities like T-Bill commercial paper certificate of deposit etc But we keep our
surplus cash in Bank
Shah Kamal Would you tell me something about transit time for a typical check
Yaseer Rizvi Well in Virgin the transit time for a typical check is ndash
For mail float 2 to 3 days
At firm float 6 hours
Clearing float 1 to 3 days
Shah Kamal Do you maintain any cash concentration mechanism like depository transfer check automated clearing house and wire transfer
i
Annexure
Yaseer Rizvi Our position in this case is very strong as we use all the mechanisms
you mentioned As Virgin is a firm with small deposits spread over a substantial
number of banks so we tend to use depository transfer checks extensively It is less
costly We also use automated clearing house and wire transfer but later is used in a
less extent
Shah Kamal Sir what techniques of disbursement management is used by your firm
Yaseer Rizvi Like other firms Virgin tries to retain the cash for as long as possible
But we always perform it in an ethical manner We do not use management of
disbursement float as it seems unethical We follow Zero-Balance Accounts method
for managing disbursement We do not prefer Controlled Disbursing method since
Zero-Balance system is already practiced in Virgin
Shah Kamal How do you hedge cash balance uncertainties
Yaseer Rizvi Well you may say that we do not invest in short term securities but for
facing cash difficulties we keep our surplus cash in bank
Shah Kamal Sir would you please tell me the general terms of sale of Virgin
Yaseer Rizvi Though it is difficult to maintain a fixed terms of sale our general terms
of sale is 210 n30 But for prime customers we offer special terms of sale
Shah Kamal What are the sources of credit information in case of your firm
Yaseer Rizvi We grant credit on the basis of prior experience with the customers In
case of a new customer personal contact is weighted
Shah Kamal Does your firm consider 5 Cs in granting credit
ii
Annexure
Yaseer Rizvi In case of Virgin Capital and Character get more importance than the
others Mind one thing personal relationship is the main measure in granting credit
Shah Kamal Do you use NPV method in credit granting decisions
Yaseer Rizvi We do not use NPV method But we think that NPV is a suitable
method and we have to use it from the next period
Shah Kamal Sir how do you handle the problem of bad debt
Yaseer Rizvi Well in this case our position is very strong Yet we do not face any
problem because of bad debt Just note that we make more than 80 of sales in cash
and we monitor accounts receivable very carefully
Shah Kamal What level of inventory is maintained by Virgin
Yaseer Rizvi We maintain a minimum level of inventory but do not have to face
stock out problems because inventory is managed efficiently
Shah Kamal What is the normal lead time
Yaseer Rizvi In case of imported goods normal lead time is about 1 month and when
we purchase raw materials from inside the country lead time is 1 to 3 days
Shah Kamal What method do you use for managing inventory
Yaseer Rizvi We do not use any method particularly rather inventory decision
depends on business cycle and market situation Long before the Eid festival we
bought large amount of sugar because price of sugar was increased on the occasion
of Eid
iii
Annexure
Shah Kamal What are the main items of inventory of your firm
Yaseer Rizvi Well these are ndash aluminum can pet chip sugar label chemical and
artificial sweet
Shah Kamal What are the uncertainties in maintaining appropriate level of stock
Yaseer Rizvi These are ndash
bull Increase in price of raw materials
bull Sales uncertainty
bull Market trends etc
Shah Kamal Thank you for your kind cooperation
Yaseer Rizvi Most Welcome
iv
Global Beverage Company Limited
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
August Virgin Cola launched in Switzerland
1999 March Virgin Colours launched in Italy
March Virgin Cola launched in Japan
July Virgin Colours launched in South Africa
December Virgin Colours launched in Bangladesh
2001 January Sweden launched Virgin Colours
November Singapore launched Virgin Colours
2002 February Croatia launched Virgin Colours
June Russia launched Virgin Colours
June Tunisia launched Virgin Colours
2003 May Israel launched Virgin Colours
8 FINDINGS OF WORKING CAPITAL MANAGEMENT MAINTAINED BY
VIRGIN SOFT DRINKS IN BANGLADESH
81 CASH MANAGEMENT
811 Holding Cash and Marketable Securities
Although there are many good reasons why firm hold cash and marketable
securities Virgin Drinks holds cash and marketable securities for two reasons ndash
i) Cash for transactions
ii) Cash as hedges
This indicates that the firm does not hold cash and marketable securities for some
important reasons such as ndash
i) Near cash assets as hedges
Page 32 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
ii) Temporary investment and compensating balances
Virgin Soft Drinks does not invest in money market securities such as Treasury bill
commercial paper certificate of deposits bankerrsquos acceptance and repurchase
agreement This firm deposits its money in bank as currant AC or fixed AC They
say that they do not have enough money to invest in money market instrument
They also say that if they have enough money they will invest it in money market
short term securities We know that near cash interest earning assets can be
substituted for cash when motivation for holding these assets is the hedging of cash
flow uncertainties or is the temporary investment of surplus funds In this point
Virgins position is not good as there is no significant hedging against uncertainty of
cash
812 Floatation and Check Clearing
Virgin is very smart in handling the problem of transit time for checks Here mail
float takes 2 to 3 days at firm takes 025 day and clearing float takes 1-3 days Virgin
uses most of the strategies available for reducing the delay in receiving funds It
(Virgin) has linked Islami Bank which posses an accelerated clearing facility It uses
electronic collection process which ensures faster collection and its at the firm check
processing is satisfactory But Virgin does not use lockbox The reason behind this is
that it is not cost-effective for Virgin to set lockboxes At this point we can say that
Virgins check clearing mechanism is much good
813 Cash Concentration and Disbursement Management
Page 33 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks takes the matter of cash concentration very seriously They use all
the available cash concentration mechanism Virgin is a firm with small deposits
spread over a substantial number of banks and this is why the firm tends to use
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
depository transfer checks extensively If is less costly Virgin also uses automated
clearing house and wire transfer To Virgin wire transfer seems too costly
Like other firm Virgin tries to retain the cash for as long as possible But Virgin
always performs it in an ethical manner Virgin does not try to defeat the receiving
firmrsquos attempts to reduce the float on incoming checks It does not take any strategy
for increasing mail float at firm float and clearing float on its outgoing checks To
Virgin it is deemed to be unethical It thinks that maximization of disbursement float
will not go unnoticed by sophisticated creditors for very long When it is noticed it
will negatively affect relations with these creditors reducing the firmrsquos bargaining
power with them This may ultimately cost Virgin dearly when future prices and
delivery schedules for goods and services purchased from trade creditors are
negotiated Virgin follows ldquoZero-Balance Accountsrdquo methods for managing
disbursement It thinks that in this method the coordination of funds inflows to
disbursement banks with the presentation of checks does not work to the detriment
of creditors since the firmrsquos checks to them are honored as presented and this strategy
does not affect float significantly Controlled disbursing method is less attractive to
Virgin because zero-balance system is already feasible
814 Cash Forecasting
Cash Forecasting and Its Types
Page 34 of 46
Virgin forecasts the future cash inflows and outflows To Virgin cash forecast is an
important part of the firmrsquos cash control system and is one of the forecasts that are
part of the Virginrsquos financial plan Virgin forecasts cash on monthly basis and on
yearly basis Virgin does not forecast on daily basis assuming that the temporary
shortage of funds within these periods can be covered without value cost eg
advance receipts from customers Virginrsquos cash forecasting system involves a
combination of distribution and scheduling The receipts and disbursements
approach of cash forecasting is used in virgin This method is used because it
minutely traces the movement of cash and very close control of cash is possible
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Virgin does not use adjusted net income approach on two grounds First it does not
permit the tracing of the individual types of cash inflows and outflows for any given
period which is often useful information for virgin Second it is not simple to use
Items to be Forecast
Virgin does not forecast all the items It forecasts only major items eg accounts
receivable notes receivable payroll cash purchases of raw materials In this regard
virgin trade off between cost and benefit
Methods of Financial Forecasting
Virgin forecasts the future level of financial variable such as cash level asset level or
liability level We know in short term forecasts many things will result from plans
and events that are already in place (contracts capital budgets long-range financing
plans and so forth) But in the long run most things can vary and are dependent on
outside influences such as the firmrsquos long-term growth rate Since Virginrsquos cash
forecasting deals mostly with near future many of the items on the cash forecasts are
estimated by some variation of the spot method and remaining estimates are mostly
on a ldquoproportion of another accountrdquo basis with this ldquoother accountrdquo often being a
particular periodrsquos sales Virgin uses the other two methods less frequently
Using Cash Forecast
Virgin forecasts cash for meeting general objectives (ie to know the available funds
for investment and need financing) and for meeting some special objectives (eg to
know whether the firm will fulfill its out of debt requirement) But it is matter to note
that Virgin does not make any short term investment of its surplus cash but only keep
this surplus in Bank Account
Page 35 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Sources of Uncertainty in Cash Forecasting and Hedging Uncertainties
Virgin faces uncertainty in cash forecasting mainly from two sources These are ndash
sales and production cost In peak season (hot season like autumn summer) sales
increases but in dull season (eg in winter) sales decreases drastically Production
cost may be increased because of increase of price of sugar chemicals aluminum
can Virgin follows two methods for hedging cash balance uncertainties These are ndash
i) Holding a stock of extra cash and
ii) Extra borrowing capacity
815 Modes for the Management of Cash and Temporary Investments
Virgin does not follow any of these methods wholly Virgin receives cash
continuously and pays salary at steady rate and pays continuously for other
expenses So it neither follows Baumol model nor Beranek model It has no upper
control limit lower control limit return point in case cash management So it neither
follows Miller-Orr model nor Stone model
In Summary
Page 36 of 46
Standard Compliance by Virgin Soft Drinks
Generally all firms hold cash and
marketable securities
Virgin holds only cash
Firms hold cash and marketable
securities for some reasons like
bull Cash for transactions
bull Cash and near-cash assets as
hedges
bull Temporary investments
bull Compensating balances
Virgin holds cash only for
two reasons ndash
bull Cash for transactions
bull Cash as hedges
Available money market instruments Virgin does not invest in any such
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
(short term securities) are ndash
Treasury Bills
Commercial Paper
Certificates of Deposit
Bankerrsquos Acceptance
Repurch menase Agree ts
instruments They only keep cash in
Bank Account
Mail Float
(1 to 5 days)
At Firm
Float
(025 to 1
day)
Clearing
Float
(0 to
2 days)
Mail Float
(2 to 3 days)
At firm
Float
(025
day)
Clearing
Float
(1 to 3
days)
Figure Transit time for a typical check Figure Transit time for a check for
Virgin
Strategies that firms can use to reduce
the delay in receiving funds are ndash
Selecting of Banks with
accelerated clearing capabilities
of check processing Acceleration
at the firm
ectronic collection Use of el
procedures
Use of lockboxes
Virgin follows the first three strategies
but does not use lockboxes
Available cash concentration
mechanisms are ndash
Depository transfer check
ouse Automated Clearing H
(ACH) electronic transfer)
Wire transfer
Virgin uses all these mechanisms of
cash concentration
Available sets of techniques for cash
disbursement management are ndash
ement of disbursement
Page 37 of 46
Manag
float
Virgin uses zero-balance accounts
technique
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Zero-Balance Accounts
Controlled disbursing
Firms may make cash flow forecasts
over periods of various lengths yearly
flows quarterly flows monthly flows
weekly flows or even daily flows
Virgin forecasts cash on yearly basis and
monthly basis
Cash forecasting system may involve ndash
Distribution
Scheduling
Virginrsquos cash forecasting system
involves a combination of distribution
and scheduling
Two common approaches to cash flow
in generating the cash forecast
and disbursement Receipts
approach
Adjusted net income approach
Virgin uses the receipts and
disbursement approach
There are many items to forecast Virgin forecasts only major items like
AR payroll etc
Four common approach to forecasting
fina i ndash nc al variables are
Spot method
Proportion to another account
Compounded growth
Multiple dependencies
Virgin uses spot method for forecasting
cash It uses proportion to another
account method for other variables and
remaining two methods are frequently
used
Sources of uncertainty in cash
forecasting are ndash
Sales uncertainty
Collection rate uncertainty
Production cost uncertainty
Capital outflow uncertainty
Virgin faces uncertainty mainly from
sales and production cost
Methods for hedging cash balance
unc a
Page 38 of 46
ert inties are ndash
i) Holding a stock of extra cash
Virgin two available methods for
hedging cash balance uncertainties
Th ese are ndash
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
ii) stock of near-cash Holding a
assets
iii) Extra borrowing capacity
iv) ary surpluses in Investing tempor
near-cash assets
i) Holding a stock of extra cash
ii) Extra borrowing capacity
(advance receipt from
customers)
Models for the management of cash and
temporary investments are ndash Baumol
model Beranek model Miller-Orr
model and Stone model
Virgin does not follow any method
wholly but a combination of Baumol
model and Beranek model is occurred
82 INVENTORY MANAGEMENT
21 Certainty Approach
isnt used in
irgin because it thinks it is not possible to implement in Bangladesh
d time is one to three days It
oes not use ABC system of inventory management
8
Main item of inventory of Virgin is Can pet chip sugar label chemical artificial
sweet etc Virgin maintains a minimum level of inventory but it does not have to face
problems because inventory is managed efficiently just-in-time (JIT)
V
Virgin maintains buffer stock because of the shortage of work-in-process (WIP)
inventory Its production process may also be hampered Thats why it maintains
safety stock to avoid stock out cost In case of imported goods normal lead time is
about one month and within the country normal lea
d
Page 39 of 46
Inventory Model
In reality Virgin does not use any of models of EOQ ordering and holding strategy
and safety stock strategy They maintain inventory based on their prior experience
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
822 Uncertainty Approach
Virgin does not use any model for handling inventory uncertainty It says that such
decision depends on business cycle and market situation Long before Eid festival
they bought large amount of sugar because of price increase on the occasion of Eid
In summary
Standard Compliance by Virgin Soft Drinks
Firms maintain inventory to guard
against several problems
Virgin maintains a minimum level of
inventory which is managed efficiently
Some firms use JIT to avoid inventory
cost
JIT is not used by Virgin as it thinks it is
impossible to implement in Bangladesh
Firms maintain buffer stock Virgin maintains buffer stock too
Firms maintain safety stock to avoid
shortage cost
Virgin also maintains safety stock
Firms use ABC system to monitor
inventory
Virgin doesnt use ABC system
EOQ model is an appropriate method
for measuring quantity that has to be
ordered per order
Virgin does not use EOQ model rather
makes order based on experience and
market demand
83 MANAGING ACCOUNTS RECEIVABLE (DEBTORS)
831 Terms of Sale Decision
Page 40 of 46
Virgin offers the term 210 net 30 enables the customers to deduct 2 percent from the
face value of the bill when paying within the first 10 days but if the discount is not
taken the customer must remit the full amount within 30 days But Virgin does not
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
offer the same terms of sale to all customers For prime customers it offers special
terms of sale In setting an appropriate term of sale it costs and benefits regarding
this are compared It uses the standard approach of terms of sale decision as it is
simple to use
832 Credit Granting Decisions
In case of Virgin the Capital and Character of Five Cs get more importance
Although there are many problems with the traditional approach Virgin uses it
because of its simplicity Virgin does not use Net Present Value (NPV) method in
credit granting decision It thinks that NPV is an appropriate method and should be
used next time It does not face any severe problem because of bad debts The reason
is that notes receivable is used when credit is granted
833 Monitoring Accounts Receivable
Virgin monitors its accounts receivable Virgin believes that in any case both positive
and negative durations in accounts signal differences from the results that
management believe to be the most advantageous for the firm
Tools for Monitoring Accounts Receivable
Page 41 of 46
For monitoring accounts receivable there are several tools such as aging schedule
the ratios of receivable outstanding to original sales customers payment proportion
and sales weighted DSO (Days Sales Outstanding) For monitoring accounts
receivable Virgin uses aging schedule fractions and traditional DSO statistics
because of their simplicity in use Although payment proportions ratios of
receivables outstanding and sales weighted DSO methods are free from inherent bias
None of these is used because all these are complex to maintain
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
In summary
Page 42 of 46
Standard Compliance by Virgin Soft Drinks
Generals terms of sale is 210 net 30 Normally Virgin also use general terms
of sale ie 210 net 30
Firms do not offer the same terms of
sale to all customers
Yes For prime customers Virgin offers
special terms of sale
Approaches of terms of sale decisions
are ndash
bull Standard approach
bull Multi period approach
Virgin uses standard approach of terms
of sale decision as it is simple to use and
understand
Source of credit information are ndash
Sellers prior experience with the
customer
Credit agency ratings and
reports
Personal contact with the
applicants bank and other
creditors
Analysis of applicants financial
statements
Customer visit
Main source of credit information to
Virgin is its prior experience with the
customer All other sources are not cost-
effective for Virgin
Approaches of credit granting to
marginal accounts are ndash
Traditional approach
Net Present Value (NPV)
approach
It uses traditional approach still now but
thinks that NPV should be used for the
next periods
Firms monitor accounts receivable
because deviations from the expected
levels of turnover and of bad debt can
Virgin also monitors its accounts
receivable
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
signal several different problems
Different tools for monitoring accounts
receivable are ndash
Aging schedule
Ratios of receivables
outstanding to original sales
Customers payment
proportions
Sales-weighted DSO
For monitoring accounts receivable
Virgin uses aging schedule and
traditional sales outstanding statistics
84 MANAGING ACCOUNTS PAYABLE (CREDITORS)
Virgin has almost accounts payable of Tk 8000000 But most of its liabilities are to
the banks rather than suppliers But we dont have any clear information about
Virgins accounts payable
9 RECOMMENDATION
Virgin should invest its surplus cash in short term marketable securities
because it is suitable hedging against cash uncertainties and will also give
some returns (interest income)
Virgin should publish its own annual report which will satisfy information
needs of stakeholders and also increase the credibility of information provided
by Virgin
Page 43 of 46
Virgin should use multi period approach in terms of sale decision because
standard approach which is already exists in Virgin has some inherent
problems
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
It should stop using traditional approach from now It should use NPV
method in credit granting to marginal accounts
In monitoring accounts receivable Virgin should use sales-weighted DSO
method because it has least limitation compared to the others
It should be more flexible in granting credit which will ultimately increase its
sales
To get the appropriate number of quantity to be ordered per order it should
use DSO model
It should be ABC system for proper monitoring of inventory
10 CONCLUSION
The use of other peoples money in business is usually an expensive resource Before
looking outside for finance a firm should examine its own working capital cycle to
make sure that every rand of its own internal funds is being fully utilized Good
management of working capital is part of good financial management Effective use
of working capital will contribute to the operational efficiency of the whole
organization optimum use will help to generate maximum returns Furthermore
working capital management is not an end in itself It is an integral part of the firms
overall management The needs of efficient working capital management must be
considered in relation to other aspects of the Virgins financial and non-financial
performance Thats why when planning the development of a business it is critical
that the impact of working capital be fully assessed
Page 44 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
BIBLIOGRAPHY
Scherr FC (1989) International Edition Prentice-Hall International Inc Modern
Working Capital Management Text and Cases
Hussain Riaz (2002) Working Capital Management
Robertson Lonnie (July 1998) Inventory Management
httpwwwasashoporg visited on March 13 2006
The Art of Cash Management
httpwwwinccom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management
httpwwwstudyfinancecom visited on March 13 2006
White Paper ndash Managing Working Capital
httpwwwplanwareorg visited on March 13 2006
Management of Working Capital
httpwwwbusinesscentralcoza visited on March 13 2006
Cash Management
httpwwwsbagov visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management Objectives
httpwpsprenhallcom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management
Page 45 of 46
httpwwwadvancemecom visited on March 13 2006
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Business Receivables Financing
httpwwwbbtcom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Finance
http wwwfnbcoza visited on March 13 2006
Tips to manage your working capital
httpsmallbusinessninemsncomau visited on March 13 2006
Inventory Financing
httpwwwfranklincapitalnetworkcom visited on March 13 2006
Accounts Receivable Management
httpwwwfranklincapitalnetworkcom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management
httpwwwtreasurygovtnz visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management
httpwwwtreasurystrategiescom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Works
httpwwwinvestopediacom visited on March 13 2006
Treasury Services
httpwwwjpmorganchasecom visited on March 13 2006
what were about
Page 46 of 46
httpwwwvirgincom visited on March 13 2006
Annexure
Annexure
Interview with YASEER RIZVI
Mr Yaseer Rizvi the DMD of Global Beverage Co Ltd obtained his MBA degree
from a reputed university He had been the Director of Ocean Container Ltd before
joining in Global Beverage Co Ltd He possesses a nice personality
I interviewed Yaseer Rizvi Excerpts from his interview are as follows ndash
Shah Kamal Sir would you please tell me do you invest in short term marketable securities
Yaseer Rizvi Basically we do not invest our surplus cash in short term marketable
securities like T-Bill commercial paper certificate of deposit etc But we keep our
surplus cash in Bank
Shah Kamal Would you tell me something about transit time for a typical check
Yaseer Rizvi Well in Virgin the transit time for a typical check is ndash
For mail float 2 to 3 days
At firm float 6 hours
Clearing float 1 to 3 days
Shah Kamal Do you maintain any cash concentration mechanism like depository transfer check automated clearing house and wire transfer
i
Annexure
Yaseer Rizvi Our position in this case is very strong as we use all the mechanisms
you mentioned As Virgin is a firm with small deposits spread over a substantial
number of banks so we tend to use depository transfer checks extensively It is less
costly We also use automated clearing house and wire transfer but later is used in a
less extent
Shah Kamal Sir what techniques of disbursement management is used by your firm
Yaseer Rizvi Like other firms Virgin tries to retain the cash for as long as possible
But we always perform it in an ethical manner We do not use management of
disbursement float as it seems unethical We follow Zero-Balance Accounts method
for managing disbursement We do not prefer Controlled Disbursing method since
Zero-Balance system is already practiced in Virgin
Shah Kamal How do you hedge cash balance uncertainties
Yaseer Rizvi Well you may say that we do not invest in short term securities but for
facing cash difficulties we keep our surplus cash in bank
Shah Kamal Sir would you please tell me the general terms of sale of Virgin
Yaseer Rizvi Though it is difficult to maintain a fixed terms of sale our general terms
of sale is 210 n30 But for prime customers we offer special terms of sale
Shah Kamal What are the sources of credit information in case of your firm
Yaseer Rizvi We grant credit on the basis of prior experience with the customers In
case of a new customer personal contact is weighted
Shah Kamal Does your firm consider 5 Cs in granting credit
ii
Annexure
Yaseer Rizvi In case of Virgin Capital and Character get more importance than the
others Mind one thing personal relationship is the main measure in granting credit
Shah Kamal Do you use NPV method in credit granting decisions
Yaseer Rizvi We do not use NPV method But we think that NPV is a suitable
method and we have to use it from the next period
Shah Kamal Sir how do you handle the problem of bad debt
Yaseer Rizvi Well in this case our position is very strong Yet we do not face any
problem because of bad debt Just note that we make more than 80 of sales in cash
and we monitor accounts receivable very carefully
Shah Kamal What level of inventory is maintained by Virgin
Yaseer Rizvi We maintain a minimum level of inventory but do not have to face
stock out problems because inventory is managed efficiently
Shah Kamal What is the normal lead time
Yaseer Rizvi In case of imported goods normal lead time is about 1 month and when
we purchase raw materials from inside the country lead time is 1 to 3 days
Shah Kamal What method do you use for managing inventory
Yaseer Rizvi We do not use any method particularly rather inventory decision
depends on business cycle and market situation Long before the Eid festival we
bought large amount of sugar because price of sugar was increased on the occasion
of Eid
iii
Annexure
Shah Kamal What are the main items of inventory of your firm
Yaseer Rizvi Well these are ndash aluminum can pet chip sugar label chemical and
artificial sweet
Shah Kamal What are the uncertainties in maintaining appropriate level of stock
Yaseer Rizvi These are ndash
bull Increase in price of raw materials
bull Sales uncertainty
bull Market trends etc
Shah Kamal Thank you for your kind cooperation
Yaseer Rizvi Most Welcome
iv
Global Beverage Company Limited
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
ii) Temporary investment and compensating balances
Virgin Soft Drinks does not invest in money market securities such as Treasury bill
commercial paper certificate of deposits bankerrsquos acceptance and repurchase
agreement This firm deposits its money in bank as currant AC or fixed AC They
say that they do not have enough money to invest in money market instrument
They also say that if they have enough money they will invest it in money market
short term securities We know that near cash interest earning assets can be
substituted for cash when motivation for holding these assets is the hedging of cash
flow uncertainties or is the temporary investment of surplus funds In this point
Virgins position is not good as there is no significant hedging against uncertainty of
cash
812 Floatation and Check Clearing
Virgin is very smart in handling the problem of transit time for checks Here mail
float takes 2 to 3 days at firm takes 025 day and clearing float takes 1-3 days Virgin
uses most of the strategies available for reducing the delay in receiving funds It
(Virgin) has linked Islami Bank which posses an accelerated clearing facility It uses
electronic collection process which ensures faster collection and its at the firm check
processing is satisfactory But Virgin does not use lockbox The reason behind this is
that it is not cost-effective for Virgin to set lockboxes At this point we can say that
Virgins check clearing mechanism is much good
813 Cash Concentration and Disbursement Management
Page 33 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks takes the matter of cash concentration very seriously They use all
the available cash concentration mechanism Virgin is a firm with small deposits
spread over a substantial number of banks and this is why the firm tends to use
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
depository transfer checks extensively If is less costly Virgin also uses automated
clearing house and wire transfer To Virgin wire transfer seems too costly
Like other firm Virgin tries to retain the cash for as long as possible But Virgin
always performs it in an ethical manner Virgin does not try to defeat the receiving
firmrsquos attempts to reduce the float on incoming checks It does not take any strategy
for increasing mail float at firm float and clearing float on its outgoing checks To
Virgin it is deemed to be unethical It thinks that maximization of disbursement float
will not go unnoticed by sophisticated creditors for very long When it is noticed it
will negatively affect relations with these creditors reducing the firmrsquos bargaining
power with them This may ultimately cost Virgin dearly when future prices and
delivery schedules for goods and services purchased from trade creditors are
negotiated Virgin follows ldquoZero-Balance Accountsrdquo methods for managing
disbursement It thinks that in this method the coordination of funds inflows to
disbursement banks with the presentation of checks does not work to the detriment
of creditors since the firmrsquos checks to them are honored as presented and this strategy
does not affect float significantly Controlled disbursing method is less attractive to
Virgin because zero-balance system is already feasible
814 Cash Forecasting
Cash Forecasting and Its Types
Page 34 of 46
Virgin forecasts the future cash inflows and outflows To Virgin cash forecast is an
important part of the firmrsquos cash control system and is one of the forecasts that are
part of the Virginrsquos financial plan Virgin forecasts cash on monthly basis and on
yearly basis Virgin does not forecast on daily basis assuming that the temporary
shortage of funds within these periods can be covered without value cost eg
advance receipts from customers Virginrsquos cash forecasting system involves a
combination of distribution and scheduling The receipts and disbursements
approach of cash forecasting is used in virgin This method is used because it
minutely traces the movement of cash and very close control of cash is possible
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Virgin does not use adjusted net income approach on two grounds First it does not
permit the tracing of the individual types of cash inflows and outflows for any given
period which is often useful information for virgin Second it is not simple to use
Items to be Forecast
Virgin does not forecast all the items It forecasts only major items eg accounts
receivable notes receivable payroll cash purchases of raw materials In this regard
virgin trade off between cost and benefit
Methods of Financial Forecasting
Virgin forecasts the future level of financial variable such as cash level asset level or
liability level We know in short term forecasts many things will result from plans
and events that are already in place (contracts capital budgets long-range financing
plans and so forth) But in the long run most things can vary and are dependent on
outside influences such as the firmrsquos long-term growth rate Since Virginrsquos cash
forecasting deals mostly with near future many of the items on the cash forecasts are
estimated by some variation of the spot method and remaining estimates are mostly
on a ldquoproportion of another accountrdquo basis with this ldquoother accountrdquo often being a
particular periodrsquos sales Virgin uses the other two methods less frequently
Using Cash Forecast
Virgin forecasts cash for meeting general objectives (ie to know the available funds
for investment and need financing) and for meeting some special objectives (eg to
know whether the firm will fulfill its out of debt requirement) But it is matter to note
that Virgin does not make any short term investment of its surplus cash but only keep
this surplus in Bank Account
Page 35 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Sources of Uncertainty in Cash Forecasting and Hedging Uncertainties
Virgin faces uncertainty in cash forecasting mainly from two sources These are ndash
sales and production cost In peak season (hot season like autumn summer) sales
increases but in dull season (eg in winter) sales decreases drastically Production
cost may be increased because of increase of price of sugar chemicals aluminum
can Virgin follows two methods for hedging cash balance uncertainties These are ndash
i) Holding a stock of extra cash and
ii) Extra borrowing capacity
815 Modes for the Management of Cash and Temporary Investments
Virgin does not follow any of these methods wholly Virgin receives cash
continuously and pays salary at steady rate and pays continuously for other
expenses So it neither follows Baumol model nor Beranek model It has no upper
control limit lower control limit return point in case cash management So it neither
follows Miller-Orr model nor Stone model
In Summary
Page 36 of 46
Standard Compliance by Virgin Soft Drinks
Generally all firms hold cash and
marketable securities
Virgin holds only cash
Firms hold cash and marketable
securities for some reasons like
bull Cash for transactions
bull Cash and near-cash assets as
hedges
bull Temporary investments
bull Compensating balances
Virgin holds cash only for
two reasons ndash
bull Cash for transactions
bull Cash as hedges
Available money market instruments Virgin does not invest in any such
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
(short term securities) are ndash
Treasury Bills
Commercial Paper
Certificates of Deposit
Bankerrsquos Acceptance
Repurch menase Agree ts
instruments They only keep cash in
Bank Account
Mail Float
(1 to 5 days)
At Firm
Float
(025 to 1
day)
Clearing
Float
(0 to
2 days)
Mail Float
(2 to 3 days)
At firm
Float
(025
day)
Clearing
Float
(1 to 3
days)
Figure Transit time for a typical check Figure Transit time for a check for
Virgin
Strategies that firms can use to reduce
the delay in receiving funds are ndash
Selecting of Banks with
accelerated clearing capabilities
of check processing Acceleration
at the firm
ectronic collection Use of el
procedures
Use of lockboxes
Virgin follows the first three strategies
but does not use lockboxes
Available cash concentration
mechanisms are ndash
Depository transfer check
ouse Automated Clearing H
(ACH) electronic transfer)
Wire transfer
Virgin uses all these mechanisms of
cash concentration
Available sets of techniques for cash
disbursement management are ndash
ement of disbursement
Page 37 of 46
Manag
float
Virgin uses zero-balance accounts
technique
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Zero-Balance Accounts
Controlled disbursing
Firms may make cash flow forecasts
over periods of various lengths yearly
flows quarterly flows monthly flows
weekly flows or even daily flows
Virgin forecasts cash on yearly basis and
monthly basis
Cash forecasting system may involve ndash
Distribution
Scheduling
Virginrsquos cash forecasting system
involves a combination of distribution
and scheduling
Two common approaches to cash flow
in generating the cash forecast
and disbursement Receipts
approach
Adjusted net income approach
Virgin uses the receipts and
disbursement approach
There are many items to forecast Virgin forecasts only major items like
AR payroll etc
Four common approach to forecasting
fina i ndash nc al variables are
Spot method
Proportion to another account
Compounded growth
Multiple dependencies
Virgin uses spot method for forecasting
cash It uses proportion to another
account method for other variables and
remaining two methods are frequently
used
Sources of uncertainty in cash
forecasting are ndash
Sales uncertainty
Collection rate uncertainty
Production cost uncertainty
Capital outflow uncertainty
Virgin faces uncertainty mainly from
sales and production cost
Methods for hedging cash balance
unc a
Page 38 of 46
ert inties are ndash
i) Holding a stock of extra cash
Virgin two available methods for
hedging cash balance uncertainties
Th ese are ndash
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
ii) stock of near-cash Holding a
assets
iii) Extra borrowing capacity
iv) ary surpluses in Investing tempor
near-cash assets
i) Holding a stock of extra cash
ii) Extra borrowing capacity
(advance receipt from
customers)
Models for the management of cash and
temporary investments are ndash Baumol
model Beranek model Miller-Orr
model and Stone model
Virgin does not follow any method
wholly but a combination of Baumol
model and Beranek model is occurred
82 INVENTORY MANAGEMENT
21 Certainty Approach
isnt used in
irgin because it thinks it is not possible to implement in Bangladesh
d time is one to three days It
oes not use ABC system of inventory management
8
Main item of inventory of Virgin is Can pet chip sugar label chemical artificial
sweet etc Virgin maintains a minimum level of inventory but it does not have to face
problems because inventory is managed efficiently just-in-time (JIT)
V
Virgin maintains buffer stock because of the shortage of work-in-process (WIP)
inventory Its production process may also be hampered Thats why it maintains
safety stock to avoid stock out cost In case of imported goods normal lead time is
about one month and within the country normal lea
d
Page 39 of 46
Inventory Model
In reality Virgin does not use any of models of EOQ ordering and holding strategy
and safety stock strategy They maintain inventory based on their prior experience
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
822 Uncertainty Approach
Virgin does not use any model for handling inventory uncertainty It says that such
decision depends on business cycle and market situation Long before Eid festival
they bought large amount of sugar because of price increase on the occasion of Eid
In summary
Standard Compliance by Virgin Soft Drinks
Firms maintain inventory to guard
against several problems
Virgin maintains a minimum level of
inventory which is managed efficiently
Some firms use JIT to avoid inventory
cost
JIT is not used by Virgin as it thinks it is
impossible to implement in Bangladesh
Firms maintain buffer stock Virgin maintains buffer stock too
Firms maintain safety stock to avoid
shortage cost
Virgin also maintains safety stock
Firms use ABC system to monitor
inventory
Virgin doesnt use ABC system
EOQ model is an appropriate method
for measuring quantity that has to be
ordered per order
Virgin does not use EOQ model rather
makes order based on experience and
market demand
83 MANAGING ACCOUNTS RECEIVABLE (DEBTORS)
831 Terms of Sale Decision
Page 40 of 46
Virgin offers the term 210 net 30 enables the customers to deduct 2 percent from the
face value of the bill when paying within the first 10 days but if the discount is not
taken the customer must remit the full amount within 30 days But Virgin does not
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
offer the same terms of sale to all customers For prime customers it offers special
terms of sale In setting an appropriate term of sale it costs and benefits regarding
this are compared It uses the standard approach of terms of sale decision as it is
simple to use
832 Credit Granting Decisions
In case of Virgin the Capital and Character of Five Cs get more importance
Although there are many problems with the traditional approach Virgin uses it
because of its simplicity Virgin does not use Net Present Value (NPV) method in
credit granting decision It thinks that NPV is an appropriate method and should be
used next time It does not face any severe problem because of bad debts The reason
is that notes receivable is used when credit is granted
833 Monitoring Accounts Receivable
Virgin monitors its accounts receivable Virgin believes that in any case both positive
and negative durations in accounts signal differences from the results that
management believe to be the most advantageous for the firm
Tools for Monitoring Accounts Receivable
Page 41 of 46
For monitoring accounts receivable there are several tools such as aging schedule
the ratios of receivable outstanding to original sales customers payment proportion
and sales weighted DSO (Days Sales Outstanding) For monitoring accounts
receivable Virgin uses aging schedule fractions and traditional DSO statistics
because of their simplicity in use Although payment proportions ratios of
receivables outstanding and sales weighted DSO methods are free from inherent bias
None of these is used because all these are complex to maintain
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
In summary
Page 42 of 46
Standard Compliance by Virgin Soft Drinks
Generals terms of sale is 210 net 30 Normally Virgin also use general terms
of sale ie 210 net 30
Firms do not offer the same terms of
sale to all customers
Yes For prime customers Virgin offers
special terms of sale
Approaches of terms of sale decisions
are ndash
bull Standard approach
bull Multi period approach
Virgin uses standard approach of terms
of sale decision as it is simple to use and
understand
Source of credit information are ndash
Sellers prior experience with the
customer
Credit agency ratings and
reports
Personal contact with the
applicants bank and other
creditors
Analysis of applicants financial
statements
Customer visit
Main source of credit information to
Virgin is its prior experience with the
customer All other sources are not cost-
effective for Virgin
Approaches of credit granting to
marginal accounts are ndash
Traditional approach
Net Present Value (NPV)
approach
It uses traditional approach still now but
thinks that NPV should be used for the
next periods
Firms monitor accounts receivable
because deviations from the expected
levels of turnover and of bad debt can
Virgin also monitors its accounts
receivable
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
signal several different problems
Different tools for monitoring accounts
receivable are ndash
Aging schedule
Ratios of receivables
outstanding to original sales
Customers payment
proportions
Sales-weighted DSO
For monitoring accounts receivable
Virgin uses aging schedule and
traditional sales outstanding statistics
84 MANAGING ACCOUNTS PAYABLE (CREDITORS)
Virgin has almost accounts payable of Tk 8000000 But most of its liabilities are to
the banks rather than suppliers But we dont have any clear information about
Virgins accounts payable
9 RECOMMENDATION
Virgin should invest its surplus cash in short term marketable securities
because it is suitable hedging against cash uncertainties and will also give
some returns (interest income)
Virgin should publish its own annual report which will satisfy information
needs of stakeholders and also increase the credibility of information provided
by Virgin
Page 43 of 46
Virgin should use multi period approach in terms of sale decision because
standard approach which is already exists in Virgin has some inherent
problems
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
It should stop using traditional approach from now It should use NPV
method in credit granting to marginal accounts
In monitoring accounts receivable Virgin should use sales-weighted DSO
method because it has least limitation compared to the others
It should be more flexible in granting credit which will ultimately increase its
sales
To get the appropriate number of quantity to be ordered per order it should
use DSO model
It should be ABC system for proper monitoring of inventory
10 CONCLUSION
The use of other peoples money in business is usually an expensive resource Before
looking outside for finance a firm should examine its own working capital cycle to
make sure that every rand of its own internal funds is being fully utilized Good
management of working capital is part of good financial management Effective use
of working capital will contribute to the operational efficiency of the whole
organization optimum use will help to generate maximum returns Furthermore
working capital management is not an end in itself It is an integral part of the firms
overall management The needs of efficient working capital management must be
considered in relation to other aspects of the Virgins financial and non-financial
performance Thats why when planning the development of a business it is critical
that the impact of working capital be fully assessed
Page 44 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
BIBLIOGRAPHY
Scherr FC (1989) International Edition Prentice-Hall International Inc Modern
Working Capital Management Text and Cases
Hussain Riaz (2002) Working Capital Management
Robertson Lonnie (July 1998) Inventory Management
httpwwwasashoporg visited on March 13 2006
The Art of Cash Management
httpwwwinccom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management
httpwwwstudyfinancecom visited on March 13 2006
White Paper ndash Managing Working Capital
httpwwwplanwareorg visited on March 13 2006
Management of Working Capital
httpwwwbusinesscentralcoza visited on March 13 2006
Cash Management
httpwwwsbagov visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management Objectives
httpwpsprenhallcom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management
Page 45 of 46
httpwwwadvancemecom visited on March 13 2006
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Business Receivables Financing
httpwwwbbtcom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Finance
http wwwfnbcoza visited on March 13 2006
Tips to manage your working capital
httpsmallbusinessninemsncomau visited on March 13 2006
Inventory Financing
httpwwwfranklincapitalnetworkcom visited on March 13 2006
Accounts Receivable Management
httpwwwfranklincapitalnetworkcom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management
httpwwwtreasurygovtnz visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management
httpwwwtreasurystrategiescom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Works
httpwwwinvestopediacom visited on March 13 2006
Treasury Services
httpwwwjpmorganchasecom visited on March 13 2006
what were about
Page 46 of 46
httpwwwvirgincom visited on March 13 2006
Annexure
Annexure
Interview with YASEER RIZVI
Mr Yaseer Rizvi the DMD of Global Beverage Co Ltd obtained his MBA degree
from a reputed university He had been the Director of Ocean Container Ltd before
joining in Global Beverage Co Ltd He possesses a nice personality
I interviewed Yaseer Rizvi Excerpts from his interview are as follows ndash
Shah Kamal Sir would you please tell me do you invest in short term marketable securities
Yaseer Rizvi Basically we do not invest our surplus cash in short term marketable
securities like T-Bill commercial paper certificate of deposit etc But we keep our
surplus cash in Bank
Shah Kamal Would you tell me something about transit time for a typical check
Yaseer Rizvi Well in Virgin the transit time for a typical check is ndash
For mail float 2 to 3 days
At firm float 6 hours
Clearing float 1 to 3 days
Shah Kamal Do you maintain any cash concentration mechanism like depository transfer check automated clearing house and wire transfer
i
Annexure
Yaseer Rizvi Our position in this case is very strong as we use all the mechanisms
you mentioned As Virgin is a firm with small deposits spread over a substantial
number of banks so we tend to use depository transfer checks extensively It is less
costly We also use automated clearing house and wire transfer but later is used in a
less extent
Shah Kamal Sir what techniques of disbursement management is used by your firm
Yaseer Rizvi Like other firms Virgin tries to retain the cash for as long as possible
But we always perform it in an ethical manner We do not use management of
disbursement float as it seems unethical We follow Zero-Balance Accounts method
for managing disbursement We do not prefer Controlled Disbursing method since
Zero-Balance system is already practiced in Virgin
Shah Kamal How do you hedge cash balance uncertainties
Yaseer Rizvi Well you may say that we do not invest in short term securities but for
facing cash difficulties we keep our surplus cash in bank
Shah Kamal Sir would you please tell me the general terms of sale of Virgin
Yaseer Rizvi Though it is difficult to maintain a fixed terms of sale our general terms
of sale is 210 n30 But for prime customers we offer special terms of sale
Shah Kamal What are the sources of credit information in case of your firm
Yaseer Rizvi We grant credit on the basis of prior experience with the customers In
case of a new customer personal contact is weighted
Shah Kamal Does your firm consider 5 Cs in granting credit
ii
Annexure
Yaseer Rizvi In case of Virgin Capital and Character get more importance than the
others Mind one thing personal relationship is the main measure in granting credit
Shah Kamal Do you use NPV method in credit granting decisions
Yaseer Rizvi We do not use NPV method But we think that NPV is a suitable
method and we have to use it from the next period
Shah Kamal Sir how do you handle the problem of bad debt
Yaseer Rizvi Well in this case our position is very strong Yet we do not face any
problem because of bad debt Just note that we make more than 80 of sales in cash
and we monitor accounts receivable very carefully
Shah Kamal What level of inventory is maintained by Virgin
Yaseer Rizvi We maintain a minimum level of inventory but do not have to face
stock out problems because inventory is managed efficiently
Shah Kamal What is the normal lead time
Yaseer Rizvi In case of imported goods normal lead time is about 1 month and when
we purchase raw materials from inside the country lead time is 1 to 3 days
Shah Kamal What method do you use for managing inventory
Yaseer Rizvi We do not use any method particularly rather inventory decision
depends on business cycle and market situation Long before the Eid festival we
bought large amount of sugar because price of sugar was increased on the occasion
of Eid
iii
Annexure
Shah Kamal What are the main items of inventory of your firm
Yaseer Rizvi Well these are ndash aluminum can pet chip sugar label chemical and
artificial sweet
Shah Kamal What are the uncertainties in maintaining appropriate level of stock
Yaseer Rizvi These are ndash
bull Increase in price of raw materials
bull Sales uncertainty
bull Market trends etc
Shah Kamal Thank you for your kind cooperation
Yaseer Rizvi Most Welcome
iv
Global Beverage Company Limited
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
depository transfer checks extensively If is less costly Virgin also uses automated
clearing house and wire transfer To Virgin wire transfer seems too costly
Like other firm Virgin tries to retain the cash for as long as possible But Virgin
always performs it in an ethical manner Virgin does not try to defeat the receiving
firmrsquos attempts to reduce the float on incoming checks It does not take any strategy
for increasing mail float at firm float and clearing float on its outgoing checks To
Virgin it is deemed to be unethical It thinks that maximization of disbursement float
will not go unnoticed by sophisticated creditors for very long When it is noticed it
will negatively affect relations with these creditors reducing the firmrsquos bargaining
power with them This may ultimately cost Virgin dearly when future prices and
delivery schedules for goods and services purchased from trade creditors are
negotiated Virgin follows ldquoZero-Balance Accountsrdquo methods for managing
disbursement It thinks that in this method the coordination of funds inflows to
disbursement banks with the presentation of checks does not work to the detriment
of creditors since the firmrsquos checks to them are honored as presented and this strategy
does not affect float significantly Controlled disbursing method is less attractive to
Virgin because zero-balance system is already feasible
814 Cash Forecasting
Cash Forecasting and Its Types
Page 34 of 46
Virgin forecasts the future cash inflows and outflows To Virgin cash forecast is an
important part of the firmrsquos cash control system and is one of the forecasts that are
part of the Virginrsquos financial plan Virgin forecasts cash on monthly basis and on
yearly basis Virgin does not forecast on daily basis assuming that the temporary
shortage of funds within these periods can be covered without value cost eg
advance receipts from customers Virginrsquos cash forecasting system involves a
combination of distribution and scheduling The receipts and disbursements
approach of cash forecasting is used in virgin This method is used because it
minutely traces the movement of cash and very close control of cash is possible
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Virgin does not use adjusted net income approach on two grounds First it does not
permit the tracing of the individual types of cash inflows and outflows for any given
period which is often useful information for virgin Second it is not simple to use
Items to be Forecast
Virgin does not forecast all the items It forecasts only major items eg accounts
receivable notes receivable payroll cash purchases of raw materials In this regard
virgin trade off between cost and benefit
Methods of Financial Forecasting
Virgin forecasts the future level of financial variable such as cash level asset level or
liability level We know in short term forecasts many things will result from plans
and events that are already in place (contracts capital budgets long-range financing
plans and so forth) But in the long run most things can vary and are dependent on
outside influences such as the firmrsquos long-term growth rate Since Virginrsquos cash
forecasting deals mostly with near future many of the items on the cash forecasts are
estimated by some variation of the spot method and remaining estimates are mostly
on a ldquoproportion of another accountrdquo basis with this ldquoother accountrdquo often being a
particular periodrsquos sales Virgin uses the other two methods less frequently
Using Cash Forecast
Virgin forecasts cash for meeting general objectives (ie to know the available funds
for investment and need financing) and for meeting some special objectives (eg to
know whether the firm will fulfill its out of debt requirement) But it is matter to note
that Virgin does not make any short term investment of its surplus cash but only keep
this surplus in Bank Account
Page 35 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Sources of Uncertainty in Cash Forecasting and Hedging Uncertainties
Virgin faces uncertainty in cash forecasting mainly from two sources These are ndash
sales and production cost In peak season (hot season like autumn summer) sales
increases but in dull season (eg in winter) sales decreases drastically Production
cost may be increased because of increase of price of sugar chemicals aluminum
can Virgin follows two methods for hedging cash balance uncertainties These are ndash
i) Holding a stock of extra cash and
ii) Extra borrowing capacity
815 Modes for the Management of Cash and Temporary Investments
Virgin does not follow any of these methods wholly Virgin receives cash
continuously and pays salary at steady rate and pays continuously for other
expenses So it neither follows Baumol model nor Beranek model It has no upper
control limit lower control limit return point in case cash management So it neither
follows Miller-Orr model nor Stone model
In Summary
Page 36 of 46
Standard Compliance by Virgin Soft Drinks
Generally all firms hold cash and
marketable securities
Virgin holds only cash
Firms hold cash and marketable
securities for some reasons like
bull Cash for transactions
bull Cash and near-cash assets as
hedges
bull Temporary investments
bull Compensating balances
Virgin holds cash only for
two reasons ndash
bull Cash for transactions
bull Cash as hedges
Available money market instruments Virgin does not invest in any such
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
(short term securities) are ndash
Treasury Bills
Commercial Paper
Certificates of Deposit
Bankerrsquos Acceptance
Repurch menase Agree ts
instruments They only keep cash in
Bank Account
Mail Float
(1 to 5 days)
At Firm
Float
(025 to 1
day)
Clearing
Float
(0 to
2 days)
Mail Float
(2 to 3 days)
At firm
Float
(025
day)
Clearing
Float
(1 to 3
days)
Figure Transit time for a typical check Figure Transit time for a check for
Virgin
Strategies that firms can use to reduce
the delay in receiving funds are ndash
Selecting of Banks with
accelerated clearing capabilities
of check processing Acceleration
at the firm
ectronic collection Use of el
procedures
Use of lockboxes
Virgin follows the first three strategies
but does not use lockboxes
Available cash concentration
mechanisms are ndash
Depository transfer check
ouse Automated Clearing H
(ACH) electronic transfer)
Wire transfer
Virgin uses all these mechanisms of
cash concentration
Available sets of techniques for cash
disbursement management are ndash
ement of disbursement
Page 37 of 46
Manag
float
Virgin uses zero-balance accounts
technique
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Zero-Balance Accounts
Controlled disbursing
Firms may make cash flow forecasts
over periods of various lengths yearly
flows quarterly flows monthly flows
weekly flows or even daily flows
Virgin forecasts cash on yearly basis and
monthly basis
Cash forecasting system may involve ndash
Distribution
Scheduling
Virginrsquos cash forecasting system
involves a combination of distribution
and scheduling
Two common approaches to cash flow
in generating the cash forecast
and disbursement Receipts
approach
Adjusted net income approach
Virgin uses the receipts and
disbursement approach
There are many items to forecast Virgin forecasts only major items like
AR payroll etc
Four common approach to forecasting
fina i ndash nc al variables are
Spot method
Proportion to another account
Compounded growth
Multiple dependencies
Virgin uses spot method for forecasting
cash It uses proportion to another
account method for other variables and
remaining two methods are frequently
used
Sources of uncertainty in cash
forecasting are ndash
Sales uncertainty
Collection rate uncertainty
Production cost uncertainty
Capital outflow uncertainty
Virgin faces uncertainty mainly from
sales and production cost
Methods for hedging cash balance
unc a
Page 38 of 46
ert inties are ndash
i) Holding a stock of extra cash
Virgin two available methods for
hedging cash balance uncertainties
Th ese are ndash
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
ii) stock of near-cash Holding a
assets
iii) Extra borrowing capacity
iv) ary surpluses in Investing tempor
near-cash assets
i) Holding a stock of extra cash
ii) Extra borrowing capacity
(advance receipt from
customers)
Models for the management of cash and
temporary investments are ndash Baumol
model Beranek model Miller-Orr
model and Stone model
Virgin does not follow any method
wholly but a combination of Baumol
model and Beranek model is occurred
82 INVENTORY MANAGEMENT
21 Certainty Approach
isnt used in
irgin because it thinks it is not possible to implement in Bangladesh
d time is one to three days It
oes not use ABC system of inventory management
8
Main item of inventory of Virgin is Can pet chip sugar label chemical artificial
sweet etc Virgin maintains a minimum level of inventory but it does not have to face
problems because inventory is managed efficiently just-in-time (JIT)
V
Virgin maintains buffer stock because of the shortage of work-in-process (WIP)
inventory Its production process may also be hampered Thats why it maintains
safety stock to avoid stock out cost In case of imported goods normal lead time is
about one month and within the country normal lea
d
Page 39 of 46
Inventory Model
In reality Virgin does not use any of models of EOQ ordering and holding strategy
and safety stock strategy They maintain inventory based on their prior experience
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
822 Uncertainty Approach
Virgin does not use any model for handling inventory uncertainty It says that such
decision depends on business cycle and market situation Long before Eid festival
they bought large amount of sugar because of price increase on the occasion of Eid
In summary
Standard Compliance by Virgin Soft Drinks
Firms maintain inventory to guard
against several problems
Virgin maintains a minimum level of
inventory which is managed efficiently
Some firms use JIT to avoid inventory
cost
JIT is not used by Virgin as it thinks it is
impossible to implement in Bangladesh
Firms maintain buffer stock Virgin maintains buffer stock too
Firms maintain safety stock to avoid
shortage cost
Virgin also maintains safety stock
Firms use ABC system to monitor
inventory
Virgin doesnt use ABC system
EOQ model is an appropriate method
for measuring quantity that has to be
ordered per order
Virgin does not use EOQ model rather
makes order based on experience and
market demand
83 MANAGING ACCOUNTS RECEIVABLE (DEBTORS)
831 Terms of Sale Decision
Page 40 of 46
Virgin offers the term 210 net 30 enables the customers to deduct 2 percent from the
face value of the bill when paying within the first 10 days but if the discount is not
taken the customer must remit the full amount within 30 days But Virgin does not
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
offer the same terms of sale to all customers For prime customers it offers special
terms of sale In setting an appropriate term of sale it costs and benefits regarding
this are compared It uses the standard approach of terms of sale decision as it is
simple to use
832 Credit Granting Decisions
In case of Virgin the Capital and Character of Five Cs get more importance
Although there are many problems with the traditional approach Virgin uses it
because of its simplicity Virgin does not use Net Present Value (NPV) method in
credit granting decision It thinks that NPV is an appropriate method and should be
used next time It does not face any severe problem because of bad debts The reason
is that notes receivable is used when credit is granted
833 Monitoring Accounts Receivable
Virgin monitors its accounts receivable Virgin believes that in any case both positive
and negative durations in accounts signal differences from the results that
management believe to be the most advantageous for the firm
Tools for Monitoring Accounts Receivable
Page 41 of 46
For monitoring accounts receivable there are several tools such as aging schedule
the ratios of receivable outstanding to original sales customers payment proportion
and sales weighted DSO (Days Sales Outstanding) For monitoring accounts
receivable Virgin uses aging schedule fractions and traditional DSO statistics
because of their simplicity in use Although payment proportions ratios of
receivables outstanding and sales weighted DSO methods are free from inherent bias
None of these is used because all these are complex to maintain
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
In summary
Page 42 of 46
Standard Compliance by Virgin Soft Drinks
Generals terms of sale is 210 net 30 Normally Virgin also use general terms
of sale ie 210 net 30
Firms do not offer the same terms of
sale to all customers
Yes For prime customers Virgin offers
special terms of sale
Approaches of terms of sale decisions
are ndash
bull Standard approach
bull Multi period approach
Virgin uses standard approach of terms
of sale decision as it is simple to use and
understand
Source of credit information are ndash
Sellers prior experience with the
customer
Credit agency ratings and
reports
Personal contact with the
applicants bank and other
creditors
Analysis of applicants financial
statements
Customer visit
Main source of credit information to
Virgin is its prior experience with the
customer All other sources are not cost-
effective for Virgin
Approaches of credit granting to
marginal accounts are ndash
Traditional approach
Net Present Value (NPV)
approach
It uses traditional approach still now but
thinks that NPV should be used for the
next periods
Firms monitor accounts receivable
because deviations from the expected
levels of turnover and of bad debt can
Virgin also monitors its accounts
receivable
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
signal several different problems
Different tools for monitoring accounts
receivable are ndash
Aging schedule
Ratios of receivables
outstanding to original sales
Customers payment
proportions
Sales-weighted DSO
For monitoring accounts receivable
Virgin uses aging schedule and
traditional sales outstanding statistics
84 MANAGING ACCOUNTS PAYABLE (CREDITORS)
Virgin has almost accounts payable of Tk 8000000 But most of its liabilities are to
the banks rather than suppliers But we dont have any clear information about
Virgins accounts payable
9 RECOMMENDATION
Virgin should invest its surplus cash in short term marketable securities
because it is suitable hedging against cash uncertainties and will also give
some returns (interest income)
Virgin should publish its own annual report which will satisfy information
needs of stakeholders and also increase the credibility of information provided
by Virgin
Page 43 of 46
Virgin should use multi period approach in terms of sale decision because
standard approach which is already exists in Virgin has some inherent
problems
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
It should stop using traditional approach from now It should use NPV
method in credit granting to marginal accounts
In monitoring accounts receivable Virgin should use sales-weighted DSO
method because it has least limitation compared to the others
It should be more flexible in granting credit which will ultimately increase its
sales
To get the appropriate number of quantity to be ordered per order it should
use DSO model
It should be ABC system for proper monitoring of inventory
10 CONCLUSION
The use of other peoples money in business is usually an expensive resource Before
looking outside for finance a firm should examine its own working capital cycle to
make sure that every rand of its own internal funds is being fully utilized Good
management of working capital is part of good financial management Effective use
of working capital will contribute to the operational efficiency of the whole
organization optimum use will help to generate maximum returns Furthermore
working capital management is not an end in itself It is an integral part of the firms
overall management The needs of efficient working capital management must be
considered in relation to other aspects of the Virgins financial and non-financial
performance Thats why when planning the development of a business it is critical
that the impact of working capital be fully assessed
Page 44 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
BIBLIOGRAPHY
Scherr FC (1989) International Edition Prentice-Hall International Inc Modern
Working Capital Management Text and Cases
Hussain Riaz (2002) Working Capital Management
Robertson Lonnie (July 1998) Inventory Management
httpwwwasashoporg visited on March 13 2006
The Art of Cash Management
httpwwwinccom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management
httpwwwstudyfinancecom visited on March 13 2006
White Paper ndash Managing Working Capital
httpwwwplanwareorg visited on March 13 2006
Management of Working Capital
httpwwwbusinesscentralcoza visited on March 13 2006
Cash Management
httpwwwsbagov visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management Objectives
httpwpsprenhallcom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management
Page 45 of 46
httpwwwadvancemecom visited on March 13 2006
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Business Receivables Financing
httpwwwbbtcom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Finance
http wwwfnbcoza visited on March 13 2006
Tips to manage your working capital
httpsmallbusinessninemsncomau visited on March 13 2006
Inventory Financing
httpwwwfranklincapitalnetworkcom visited on March 13 2006
Accounts Receivable Management
httpwwwfranklincapitalnetworkcom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management
httpwwwtreasurygovtnz visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management
httpwwwtreasurystrategiescom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Works
httpwwwinvestopediacom visited on March 13 2006
Treasury Services
httpwwwjpmorganchasecom visited on March 13 2006
what were about
Page 46 of 46
httpwwwvirgincom visited on March 13 2006
Annexure
Annexure
Interview with YASEER RIZVI
Mr Yaseer Rizvi the DMD of Global Beverage Co Ltd obtained his MBA degree
from a reputed university He had been the Director of Ocean Container Ltd before
joining in Global Beverage Co Ltd He possesses a nice personality
I interviewed Yaseer Rizvi Excerpts from his interview are as follows ndash
Shah Kamal Sir would you please tell me do you invest in short term marketable securities
Yaseer Rizvi Basically we do not invest our surplus cash in short term marketable
securities like T-Bill commercial paper certificate of deposit etc But we keep our
surplus cash in Bank
Shah Kamal Would you tell me something about transit time for a typical check
Yaseer Rizvi Well in Virgin the transit time for a typical check is ndash
For mail float 2 to 3 days
At firm float 6 hours
Clearing float 1 to 3 days
Shah Kamal Do you maintain any cash concentration mechanism like depository transfer check automated clearing house and wire transfer
i
Annexure
Yaseer Rizvi Our position in this case is very strong as we use all the mechanisms
you mentioned As Virgin is a firm with small deposits spread over a substantial
number of banks so we tend to use depository transfer checks extensively It is less
costly We also use automated clearing house and wire transfer but later is used in a
less extent
Shah Kamal Sir what techniques of disbursement management is used by your firm
Yaseer Rizvi Like other firms Virgin tries to retain the cash for as long as possible
But we always perform it in an ethical manner We do not use management of
disbursement float as it seems unethical We follow Zero-Balance Accounts method
for managing disbursement We do not prefer Controlled Disbursing method since
Zero-Balance system is already practiced in Virgin
Shah Kamal How do you hedge cash balance uncertainties
Yaseer Rizvi Well you may say that we do not invest in short term securities but for
facing cash difficulties we keep our surplus cash in bank
Shah Kamal Sir would you please tell me the general terms of sale of Virgin
Yaseer Rizvi Though it is difficult to maintain a fixed terms of sale our general terms
of sale is 210 n30 But for prime customers we offer special terms of sale
Shah Kamal What are the sources of credit information in case of your firm
Yaseer Rizvi We grant credit on the basis of prior experience with the customers In
case of a new customer personal contact is weighted
Shah Kamal Does your firm consider 5 Cs in granting credit
ii
Annexure
Yaseer Rizvi In case of Virgin Capital and Character get more importance than the
others Mind one thing personal relationship is the main measure in granting credit
Shah Kamal Do you use NPV method in credit granting decisions
Yaseer Rizvi We do not use NPV method But we think that NPV is a suitable
method and we have to use it from the next period
Shah Kamal Sir how do you handle the problem of bad debt
Yaseer Rizvi Well in this case our position is very strong Yet we do not face any
problem because of bad debt Just note that we make more than 80 of sales in cash
and we monitor accounts receivable very carefully
Shah Kamal What level of inventory is maintained by Virgin
Yaseer Rizvi We maintain a minimum level of inventory but do not have to face
stock out problems because inventory is managed efficiently
Shah Kamal What is the normal lead time
Yaseer Rizvi In case of imported goods normal lead time is about 1 month and when
we purchase raw materials from inside the country lead time is 1 to 3 days
Shah Kamal What method do you use for managing inventory
Yaseer Rizvi We do not use any method particularly rather inventory decision
depends on business cycle and market situation Long before the Eid festival we
bought large amount of sugar because price of sugar was increased on the occasion
of Eid
iii
Annexure
Shah Kamal What are the main items of inventory of your firm
Yaseer Rizvi Well these are ndash aluminum can pet chip sugar label chemical and
artificial sweet
Shah Kamal What are the uncertainties in maintaining appropriate level of stock
Yaseer Rizvi These are ndash
bull Increase in price of raw materials
bull Sales uncertainty
bull Market trends etc
Shah Kamal Thank you for your kind cooperation
Yaseer Rizvi Most Welcome
iv
Global Beverage Company Limited
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Virgin does not use adjusted net income approach on two grounds First it does not
permit the tracing of the individual types of cash inflows and outflows for any given
period which is often useful information for virgin Second it is not simple to use
Items to be Forecast
Virgin does not forecast all the items It forecasts only major items eg accounts
receivable notes receivable payroll cash purchases of raw materials In this regard
virgin trade off between cost and benefit
Methods of Financial Forecasting
Virgin forecasts the future level of financial variable such as cash level asset level or
liability level We know in short term forecasts many things will result from plans
and events that are already in place (contracts capital budgets long-range financing
plans and so forth) But in the long run most things can vary and are dependent on
outside influences such as the firmrsquos long-term growth rate Since Virginrsquos cash
forecasting deals mostly with near future many of the items on the cash forecasts are
estimated by some variation of the spot method and remaining estimates are mostly
on a ldquoproportion of another accountrdquo basis with this ldquoother accountrdquo often being a
particular periodrsquos sales Virgin uses the other two methods less frequently
Using Cash Forecast
Virgin forecasts cash for meeting general objectives (ie to know the available funds
for investment and need financing) and for meeting some special objectives (eg to
know whether the firm will fulfill its out of debt requirement) But it is matter to note
that Virgin does not make any short term investment of its surplus cash but only keep
this surplus in Bank Account
Page 35 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Sources of Uncertainty in Cash Forecasting and Hedging Uncertainties
Virgin faces uncertainty in cash forecasting mainly from two sources These are ndash
sales and production cost In peak season (hot season like autumn summer) sales
increases but in dull season (eg in winter) sales decreases drastically Production
cost may be increased because of increase of price of sugar chemicals aluminum
can Virgin follows two methods for hedging cash balance uncertainties These are ndash
i) Holding a stock of extra cash and
ii) Extra borrowing capacity
815 Modes for the Management of Cash and Temporary Investments
Virgin does not follow any of these methods wholly Virgin receives cash
continuously and pays salary at steady rate and pays continuously for other
expenses So it neither follows Baumol model nor Beranek model It has no upper
control limit lower control limit return point in case cash management So it neither
follows Miller-Orr model nor Stone model
In Summary
Page 36 of 46
Standard Compliance by Virgin Soft Drinks
Generally all firms hold cash and
marketable securities
Virgin holds only cash
Firms hold cash and marketable
securities for some reasons like
bull Cash for transactions
bull Cash and near-cash assets as
hedges
bull Temporary investments
bull Compensating balances
Virgin holds cash only for
two reasons ndash
bull Cash for transactions
bull Cash as hedges
Available money market instruments Virgin does not invest in any such
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
(short term securities) are ndash
Treasury Bills
Commercial Paper
Certificates of Deposit
Bankerrsquos Acceptance
Repurch menase Agree ts
instruments They only keep cash in
Bank Account
Mail Float
(1 to 5 days)
At Firm
Float
(025 to 1
day)
Clearing
Float
(0 to
2 days)
Mail Float
(2 to 3 days)
At firm
Float
(025
day)
Clearing
Float
(1 to 3
days)
Figure Transit time for a typical check Figure Transit time for a check for
Virgin
Strategies that firms can use to reduce
the delay in receiving funds are ndash
Selecting of Banks with
accelerated clearing capabilities
of check processing Acceleration
at the firm
ectronic collection Use of el
procedures
Use of lockboxes
Virgin follows the first three strategies
but does not use lockboxes
Available cash concentration
mechanisms are ndash
Depository transfer check
ouse Automated Clearing H
(ACH) electronic transfer)
Wire transfer
Virgin uses all these mechanisms of
cash concentration
Available sets of techniques for cash
disbursement management are ndash
ement of disbursement
Page 37 of 46
Manag
float
Virgin uses zero-balance accounts
technique
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Zero-Balance Accounts
Controlled disbursing
Firms may make cash flow forecasts
over periods of various lengths yearly
flows quarterly flows monthly flows
weekly flows or even daily flows
Virgin forecasts cash on yearly basis and
monthly basis
Cash forecasting system may involve ndash
Distribution
Scheduling
Virginrsquos cash forecasting system
involves a combination of distribution
and scheduling
Two common approaches to cash flow
in generating the cash forecast
and disbursement Receipts
approach
Adjusted net income approach
Virgin uses the receipts and
disbursement approach
There are many items to forecast Virgin forecasts only major items like
AR payroll etc
Four common approach to forecasting
fina i ndash nc al variables are
Spot method
Proportion to another account
Compounded growth
Multiple dependencies
Virgin uses spot method for forecasting
cash It uses proportion to another
account method for other variables and
remaining two methods are frequently
used
Sources of uncertainty in cash
forecasting are ndash
Sales uncertainty
Collection rate uncertainty
Production cost uncertainty
Capital outflow uncertainty
Virgin faces uncertainty mainly from
sales and production cost
Methods for hedging cash balance
unc a
Page 38 of 46
ert inties are ndash
i) Holding a stock of extra cash
Virgin two available methods for
hedging cash balance uncertainties
Th ese are ndash
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
ii) stock of near-cash Holding a
assets
iii) Extra borrowing capacity
iv) ary surpluses in Investing tempor
near-cash assets
i) Holding a stock of extra cash
ii) Extra borrowing capacity
(advance receipt from
customers)
Models for the management of cash and
temporary investments are ndash Baumol
model Beranek model Miller-Orr
model and Stone model
Virgin does not follow any method
wholly but a combination of Baumol
model and Beranek model is occurred
82 INVENTORY MANAGEMENT
21 Certainty Approach
isnt used in
irgin because it thinks it is not possible to implement in Bangladesh
d time is one to three days It
oes not use ABC system of inventory management
8
Main item of inventory of Virgin is Can pet chip sugar label chemical artificial
sweet etc Virgin maintains a minimum level of inventory but it does not have to face
problems because inventory is managed efficiently just-in-time (JIT)
V
Virgin maintains buffer stock because of the shortage of work-in-process (WIP)
inventory Its production process may also be hampered Thats why it maintains
safety stock to avoid stock out cost In case of imported goods normal lead time is
about one month and within the country normal lea
d
Page 39 of 46
Inventory Model
In reality Virgin does not use any of models of EOQ ordering and holding strategy
and safety stock strategy They maintain inventory based on their prior experience
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
822 Uncertainty Approach
Virgin does not use any model for handling inventory uncertainty It says that such
decision depends on business cycle and market situation Long before Eid festival
they bought large amount of sugar because of price increase on the occasion of Eid
In summary
Standard Compliance by Virgin Soft Drinks
Firms maintain inventory to guard
against several problems
Virgin maintains a minimum level of
inventory which is managed efficiently
Some firms use JIT to avoid inventory
cost
JIT is not used by Virgin as it thinks it is
impossible to implement in Bangladesh
Firms maintain buffer stock Virgin maintains buffer stock too
Firms maintain safety stock to avoid
shortage cost
Virgin also maintains safety stock
Firms use ABC system to monitor
inventory
Virgin doesnt use ABC system
EOQ model is an appropriate method
for measuring quantity that has to be
ordered per order
Virgin does not use EOQ model rather
makes order based on experience and
market demand
83 MANAGING ACCOUNTS RECEIVABLE (DEBTORS)
831 Terms of Sale Decision
Page 40 of 46
Virgin offers the term 210 net 30 enables the customers to deduct 2 percent from the
face value of the bill when paying within the first 10 days but if the discount is not
taken the customer must remit the full amount within 30 days But Virgin does not
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
offer the same terms of sale to all customers For prime customers it offers special
terms of sale In setting an appropriate term of sale it costs and benefits regarding
this are compared It uses the standard approach of terms of sale decision as it is
simple to use
832 Credit Granting Decisions
In case of Virgin the Capital and Character of Five Cs get more importance
Although there are many problems with the traditional approach Virgin uses it
because of its simplicity Virgin does not use Net Present Value (NPV) method in
credit granting decision It thinks that NPV is an appropriate method and should be
used next time It does not face any severe problem because of bad debts The reason
is that notes receivable is used when credit is granted
833 Monitoring Accounts Receivable
Virgin monitors its accounts receivable Virgin believes that in any case both positive
and negative durations in accounts signal differences from the results that
management believe to be the most advantageous for the firm
Tools for Monitoring Accounts Receivable
Page 41 of 46
For monitoring accounts receivable there are several tools such as aging schedule
the ratios of receivable outstanding to original sales customers payment proportion
and sales weighted DSO (Days Sales Outstanding) For monitoring accounts
receivable Virgin uses aging schedule fractions and traditional DSO statistics
because of their simplicity in use Although payment proportions ratios of
receivables outstanding and sales weighted DSO methods are free from inherent bias
None of these is used because all these are complex to maintain
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
In summary
Page 42 of 46
Standard Compliance by Virgin Soft Drinks
Generals terms of sale is 210 net 30 Normally Virgin also use general terms
of sale ie 210 net 30
Firms do not offer the same terms of
sale to all customers
Yes For prime customers Virgin offers
special terms of sale
Approaches of terms of sale decisions
are ndash
bull Standard approach
bull Multi period approach
Virgin uses standard approach of terms
of sale decision as it is simple to use and
understand
Source of credit information are ndash
Sellers prior experience with the
customer
Credit agency ratings and
reports
Personal contact with the
applicants bank and other
creditors
Analysis of applicants financial
statements
Customer visit
Main source of credit information to
Virgin is its prior experience with the
customer All other sources are not cost-
effective for Virgin
Approaches of credit granting to
marginal accounts are ndash
Traditional approach
Net Present Value (NPV)
approach
It uses traditional approach still now but
thinks that NPV should be used for the
next periods
Firms monitor accounts receivable
because deviations from the expected
levels of turnover and of bad debt can
Virgin also monitors its accounts
receivable
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
signal several different problems
Different tools for monitoring accounts
receivable are ndash
Aging schedule
Ratios of receivables
outstanding to original sales
Customers payment
proportions
Sales-weighted DSO
For monitoring accounts receivable
Virgin uses aging schedule and
traditional sales outstanding statistics
84 MANAGING ACCOUNTS PAYABLE (CREDITORS)
Virgin has almost accounts payable of Tk 8000000 But most of its liabilities are to
the banks rather than suppliers But we dont have any clear information about
Virgins accounts payable
9 RECOMMENDATION
Virgin should invest its surplus cash in short term marketable securities
because it is suitable hedging against cash uncertainties and will also give
some returns (interest income)
Virgin should publish its own annual report which will satisfy information
needs of stakeholders and also increase the credibility of information provided
by Virgin
Page 43 of 46
Virgin should use multi period approach in terms of sale decision because
standard approach which is already exists in Virgin has some inherent
problems
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
It should stop using traditional approach from now It should use NPV
method in credit granting to marginal accounts
In monitoring accounts receivable Virgin should use sales-weighted DSO
method because it has least limitation compared to the others
It should be more flexible in granting credit which will ultimately increase its
sales
To get the appropriate number of quantity to be ordered per order it should
use DSO model
It should be ABC system for proper monitoring of inventory
10 CONCLUSION
The use of other peoples money in business is usually an expensive resource Before
looking outside for finance a firm should examine its own working capital cycle to
make sure that every rand of its own internal funds is being fully utilized Good
management of working capital is part of good financial management Effective use
of working capital will contribute to the operational efficiency of the whole
organization optimum use will help to generate maximum returns Furthermore
working capital management is not an end in itself It is an integral part of the firms
overall management The needs of efficient working capital management must be
considered in relation to other aspects of the Virgins financial and non-financial
performance Thats why when planning the development of a business it is critical
that the impact of working capital be fully assessed
Page 44 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
BIBLIOGRAPHY
Scherr FC (1989) International Edition Prentice-Hall International Inc Modern
Working Capital Management Text and Cases
Hussain Riaz (2002) Working Capital Management
Robertson Lonnie (July 1998) Inventory Management
httpwwwasashoporg visited on March 13 2006
The Art of Cash Management
httpwwwinccom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management
httpwwwstudyfinancecom visited on March 13 2006
White Paper ndash Managing Working Capital
httpwwwplanwareorg visited on March 13 2006
Management of Working Capital
httpwwwbusinesscentralcoza visited on March 13 2006
Cash Management
httpwwwsbagov visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management Objectives
httpwpsprenhallcom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management
Page 45 of 46
httpwwwadvancemecom visited on March 13 2006
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Business Receivables Financing
httpwwwbbtcom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Finance
http wwwfnbcoza visited on March 13 2006
Tips to manage your working capital
httpsmallbusinessninemsncomau visited on March 13 2006
Inventory Financing
httpwwwfranklincapitalnetworkcom visited on March 13 2006
Accounts Receivable Management
httpwwwfranklincapitalnetworkcom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management
httpwwwtreasurygovtnz visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management
httpwwwtreasurystrategiescom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Works
httpwwwinvestopediacom visited on March 13 2006
Treasury Services
httpwwwjpmorganchasecom visited on March 13 2006
what were about
Page 46 of 46
httpwwwvirgincom visited on March 13 2006
Annexure
Annexure
Interview with YASEER RIZVI
Mr Yaseer Rizvi the DMD of Global Beverage Co Ltd obtained his MBA degree
from a reputed university He had been the Director of Ocean Container Ltd before
joining in Global Beverage Co Ltd He possesses a nice personality
I interviewed Yaseer Rizvi Excerpts from his interview are as follows ndash
Shah Kamal Sir would you please tell me do you invest in short term marketable securities
Yaseer Rizvi Basically we do not invest our surplus cash in short term marketable
securities like T-Bill commercial paper certificate of deposit etc But we keep our
surplus cash in Bank
Shah Kamal Would you tell me something about transit time for a typical check
Yaseer Rizvi Well in Virgin the transit time for a typical check is ndash
For mail float 2 to 3 days
At firm float 6 hours
Clearing float 1 to 3 days
Shah Kamal Do you maintain any cash concentration mechanism like depository transfer check automated clearing house and wire transfer
i
Annexure
Yaseer Rizvi Our position in this case is very strong as we use all the mechanisms
you mentioned As Virgin is a firm with small deposits spread over a substantial
number of banks so we tend to use depository transfer checks extensively It is less
costly We also use automated clearing house and wire transfer but later is used in a
less extent
Shah Kamal Sir what techniques of disbursement management is used by your firm
Yaseer Rizvi Like other firms Virgin tries to retain the cash for as long as possible
But we always perform it in an ethical manner We do not use management of
disbursement float as it seems unethical We follow Zero-Balance Accounts method
for managing disbursement We do not prefer Controlled Disbursing method since
Zero-Balance system is already practiced in Virgin
Shah Kamal How do you hedge cash balance uncertainties
Yaseer Rizvi Well you may say that we do not invest in short term securities but for
facing cash difficulties we keep our surplus cash in bank
Shah Kamal Sir would you please tell me the general terms of sale of Virgin
Yaseer Rizvi Though it is difficult to maintain a fixed terms of sale our general terms
of sale is 210 n30 But for prime customers we offer special terms of sale
Shah Kamal What are the sources of credit information in case of your firm
Yaseer Rizvi We grant credit on the basis of prior experience with the customers In
case of a new customer personal contact is weighted
Shah Kamal Does your firm consider 5 Cs in granting credit
ii
Annexure
Yaseer Rizvi In case of Virgin Capital and Character get more importance than the
others Mind one thing personal relationship is the main measure in granting credit
Shah Kamal Do you use NPV method in credit granting decisions
Yaseer Rizvi We do not use NPV method But we think that NPV is a suitable
method and we have to use it from the next period
Shah Kamal Sir how do you handle the problem of bad debt
Yaseer Rizvi Well in this case our position is very strong Yet we do not face any
problem because of bad debt Just note that we make more than 80 of sales in cash
and we monitor accounts receivable very carefully
Shah Kamal What level of inventory is maintained by Virgin
Yaseer Rizvi We maintain a minimum level of inventory but do not have to face
stock out problems because inventory is managed efficiently
Shah Kamal What is the normal lead time
Yaseer Rizvi In case of imported goods normal lead time is about 1 month and when
we purchase raw materials from inside the country lead time is 1 to 3 days
Shah Kamal What method do you use for managing inventory
Yaseer Rizvi We do not use any method particularly rather inventory decision
depends on business cycle and market situation Long before the Eid festival we
bought large amount of sugar because price of sugar was increased on the occasion
of Eid
iii
Annexure
Shah Kamal What are the main items of inventory of your firm
Yaseer Rizvi Well these are ndash aluminum can pet chip sugar label chemical and
artificial sweet
Shah Kamal What are the uncertainties in maintaining appropriate level of stock
Yaseer Rizvi These are ndash
bull Increase in price of raw materials
bull Sales uncertainty
bull Market trends etc
Shah Kamal Thank you for your kind cooperation
Yaseer Rizvi Most Welcome
iv
Global Beverage Company Limited
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Sources of Uncertainty in Cash Forecasting and Hedging Uncertainties
Virgin faces uncertainty in cash forecasting mainly from two sources These are ndash
sales and production cost In peak season (hot season like autumn summer) sales
increases but in dull season (eg in winter) sales decreases drastically Production
cost may be increased because of increase of price of sugar chemicals aluminum
can Virgin follows two methods for hedging cash balance uncertainties These are ndash
i) Holding a stock of extra cash and
ii) Extra borrowing capacity
815 Modes for the Management of Cash and Temporary Investments
Virgin does not follow any of these methods wholly Virgin receives cash
continuously and pays salary at steady rate and pays continuously for other
expenses So it neither follows Baumol model nor Beranek model It has no upper
control limit lower control limit return point in case cash management So it neither
follows Miller-Orr model nor Stone model
In Summary
Page 36 of 46
Standard Compliance by Virgin Soft Drinks
Generally all firms hold cash and
marketable securities
Virgin holds only cash
Firms hold cash and marketable
securities for some reasons like
bull Cash for transactions
bull Cash and near-cash assets as
hedges
bull Temporary investments
bull Compensating balances
Virgin holds cash only for
two reasons ndash
bull Cash for transactions
bull Cash as hedges
Available money market instruments Virgin does not invest in any such
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
(short term securities) are ndash
Treasury Bills
Commercial Paper
Certificates of Deposit
Bankerrsquos Acceptance
Repurch menase Agree ts
instruments They only keep cash in
Bank Account
Mail Float
(1 to 5 days)
At Firm
Float
(025 to 1
day)
Clearing
Float
(0 to
2 days)
Mail Float
(2 to 3 days)
At firm
Float
(025
day)
Clearing
Float
(1 to 3
days)
Figure Transit time for a typical check Figure Transit time for a check for
Virgin
Strategies that firms can use to reduce
the delay in receiving funds are ndash
Selecting of Banks with
accelerated clearing capabilities
of check processing Acceleration
at the firm
ectronic collection Use of el
procedures
Use of lockboxes
Virgin follows the first three strategies
but does not use lockboxes
Available cash concentration
mechanisms are ndash
Depository transfer check
ouse Automated Clearing H
(ACH) electronic transfer)
Wire transfer
Virgin uses all these mechanisms of
cash concentration
Available sets of techniques for cash
disbursement management are ndash
ement of disbursement
Page 37 of 46
Manag
float
Virgin uses zero-balance accounts
technique
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Zero-Balance Accounts
Controlled disbursing
Firms may make cash flow forecasts
over periods of various lengths yearly
flows quarterly flows monthly flows
weekly flows or even daily flows
Virgin forecasts cash on yearly basis and
monthly basis
Cash forecasting system may involve ndash
Distribution
Scheduling
Virginrsquos cash forecasting system
involves a combination of distribution
and scheduling
Two common approaches to cash flow
in generating the cash forecast
and disbursement Receipts
approach
Adjusted net income approach
Virgin uses the receipts and
disbursement approach
There are many items to forecast Virgin forecasts only major items like
AR payroll etc
Four common approach to forecasting
fina i ndash nc al variables are
Spot method
Proportion to another account
Compounded growth
Multiple dependencies
Virgin uses spot method for forecasting
cash It uses proportion to another
account method for other variables and
remaining two methods are frequently
used
Sources of uncertainty in cash
forecasting are ndash
Sales uncertainty
Collection rate uncertainty
Production cost uncertainty
Capital outflow uncertainty
Virgin faces uncertainty mainly from
sales and production cost
Methods for hedging cash balance
unc a
Page 38 of 46
ert inties are ndash
i) Holding a stock of extra cash
Virgin two available methods for
hedging cash balance uncertainties
Th ese are ndash
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
ii) stock of near-cash Holding a
assets
iii) Extra borrowing capacity
iv) ary surpluses in Investing tempor
near-cash assets
i) Holding a stock of extra cash
ii) Extra borrowing capacity
(advance receipt from
customers)
Models for the management of cash and
temporary investments are ndash Baumol
model Beranek model Miller-Orr
model and Stone model
Virgin does not follow any method
wholly but a combination of Baumol
model and Beranek model is occurred
82 INVENTORY MANAGEMENT
21 Certainty Approach
isnt used in
irgin because it thinks it is not possible to implement in Bangladesh
d time is one to three days It
oes not use ABC system of inventory management
8
Main item of inventory of Virgin is Can pet chip sugar label chemical artificial
sweet etc Virgin maintains a minimum level of inventory but it does not have to face
problems because inventory is managed efficiently just-in-time (JIT)
V
Virgin maintains buffer stock because of the shortage of work-in-process (WIP)
inventory Its production process may also be hampered Thats why it maintains
safety stock to avoid stock out cost In case of imported goods normal lead time is
about one month and within the country normal lea
d
Page 39 of 46
Inventory Model
In reality Virgin does not use any of models of EOQ ordering and holding strategy
and safety stock strategy They maintain inventory based on their prior experience
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
822 Uncertainty Approach
Virgin does not use any model for handling inventory uncertainty It says that such
decision depends on business cycle and market situation Long before Eid festival
they bought large amount of sugar because of price increase on the occasion of Eid
In summary
Standard Compliance by Virgin Soft Drinks
Firms maintain inventory to guard
against several problems
Virgin maintains a minimum level of
inventory which is managed efficiently
Some firms use JIT to avoid inventory
cost
JIT is not used by Virgin as it thinks it is
impossible to implement in Bangladesh
Firms maintain buffer stock Virgin maintains buffer stock too
Firms maintain safety stock to avoid
shortage cost
Virgin also maintains safety stock
Firms use ABC system to monitor
inventory
Virgin doesnt use ABC system
EOQ model is an appropriate method
for measuring quantity that has to be
ordered per order
Virgin does not use EOQ model rather
makes order based on experience and
market demand
83 MANAGING ACCOUNTS RECEIVABLE (DEBTORS)
831 Terms of Sale Decision
Page 40 of 46
Virgin offers the term 210 net 30 enables the customers to deduct 2 percent from the
face value of the bill when paying within the first 10 days but if the discount is not
taken the customer must remit the full amount within 30 days But Virgin does not
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
offer the same terms of sale to all customers For prime customers it offers special
terms of sale In setting an appropriate term of sale it costs and benefits regarding
this are compared It uses the standard approach of terms of sale decision as it is
simple to use
832 Credit Granting Decisions
In case of Virgin the Capital and Character of Five Cs get more importance
Although there are many problems with the traditional approach Virgin uses it
because of its simplicity Virgin does not use Net Present Value (NPV) method in
credit granting decision It thinks that NPV is an appropriate method and should be
used next time It does not face any severe problem because of bad debts The reason
is that notes receivable is used when credit is granted
833 Monitoring Accounts Receivable
Virgin monitors its accounts receivable Virgin believes that in any case both positive
and negative durations in accounts signal differences from the results that
management believe to be the most advantageous for the firm
Tools for Monitoring Accounts Receivable
Page 41 of 46
For monitoring accounts receivable there are several tools such as aging schedule
the ratios of receivable outstanding to original sales customers payment proportion
and sales weighted DSO (Days Sales Outstanding) For monitoring accounts
receivable Virgin uses aging schedule fractions and traditional DSO statistics
because of their simplicity in use Although payment proportions ratios of
receivables outstanding and sales weighted DSO methods are free from inherent bias
None of these is used because all these are complex to maintain
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
In summary
Page 42 of 46
Standard Compliance by Virgin Soft Drinks
Generals terms of sale is 210 net 30 Normally Virgin also use general terms
of sale ie 210 net 30
Firms do not offer the same terms of
sale to all customers
Yes For prime customers Virgin offers
special terms of sale
Approaches of terms of sale decisions
are ndash
bull Standard approach
bull Multi period approach
Virgin uses standard approach of terms
of sale decision as it is simple to use and
understand
Source of credit information are ndash
Sellers prior experience with the
customer
Credit agency ratings and
reports
Personal contact with the
applicants bank and other
creditors
Analysis of applicants financial
statements
Customer visit
Main source of credit information to
Virgin is its prior experience with the
customer All other sources are not cost-
effective for Virgin
Approaches of credit granting to
marginal accounts are ndash
Traditional approach
Net Present Value (NPV)
approach
It uses traditional approach still now but
thinks that NPV should be used for the
next periods
Firms monitor accounts receivable
because deviations from the expected
levels of turnover and of bad debt can
Virgin also monitors its accounts
receivable
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
signal several different problems
Different tools for monitoring accounts
receivable are ndash
Aging schedule
Ratios of receivables
outstanding to original sales
Customers payment
proportions
Sales-weighted DSO
For monitoring accounts receivable
Virgin uses aging schedule and
traditional sales outstanding statistics
84 MANAGING ACCOUNTS PAYABLE (CREDITORS)
Virgin has almost accounts payable of Tk 8000000 But most of its liabilities are to
the banks rather than suppliers But we dont have any clear information about
Virgins accounts payable
9 RECOMMENDATION
Virgin should invest its surplus cash in short term marketable securities
because it is suitable hedging against cash uncertainties and will also give
some returns (interest income)
Virgin should publish its own annual report which will satisfy information
needs of stakeholders and also increase the credibility of information provided
by Virgin
Page 43 of 46
Virgin should use multi period approach in terms of sale decision because
standard approach which is already exists in Virgin has some inherent
problems
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
It should stop using traditional approach from now It should use NPV
method in credit granting to marginal accounts
In monitoring accounts receivable Virgin should use sales-weighted DSO
method because it has least limitation compared to the others
It should be more flexible in granting credit which will ultimately increase its
sales
To get the appropriate number of quantity to be ordered per order it should
use DSO model
It should be ABC system for proper monitoring of inventory
10 CONCLUSION
The use of other peoples money in business is usually an expensive resource Before
looking outside for finance a firm should examine its own working capital cycle to
make sure that every rand of its own internal funds is being fully utilized Good
management of working capital is part of good financial management Effective use
of working capital will contribute to the operational efficiency of the whole
organization optimum use will help to generate maximum returns Furthermore
working capital management is not an end in itself It is an integral part of the firms
overall management The needs of efficient working capital management must be
considered in relation to other aspects of the Virgins financial and non-financial
performance Thats why when planning the development of a business it is critical
that the impact of working capital be fully assessed
Page 44 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
BIBLIOGRAPHY
Scherr FC (1989) International Edition Prentice-Hall International Inc Modern
Working Capital Management Text and Cases
Hussain Riaz (2002) Working Capital Management
Robertson Lonnie (July 1998) Inventory Management
httpwwwasashoporg visited on March 13 2006
The Art of Cash Management
httpwwwinccom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management
httpwwwstudyfinancecom visited on March 13 2006
White Paper ndash Managing Working Capital
httpwwwplanwareorg visited on March 13 2006
Management of Working Capital
httpwwwbusinesscentralcoza visited on March 13 2006
Cash Management
httpwwwsbagov visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management Objectives
httpwpsprenhallcom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management
Page 45 of 46
httpwwwadvancemecom visited on March 13 2006
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Business Receivables Financing
httpwwwbbtcom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Finance
http wwwfnbcoza visited on March 13 2006
Tips to manage your working capital
httpsmallbusinessninemsncomau visited on March 13 2006
Inventory Financing
httpwwwfranklincapitalnetworkcom visited on March 13 2006
Accounts Receivable Management
httpwwwfranklincapitalnetworkcom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management
httpwwwtreasurygovtnz visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management
httpwwwtreasurystrategiescom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Works
httpwwwinvestopediacom visited on March 13 2006
Treasury Services
httpwwwjpmorganchasecom visited on March 13 2006
what were about
Page 46 of 46
httpwwwvirgincom visited on March 13 2006
Annexure
Annexure
Interview with YASEER RIZVI
Mr Yaseer Rizvi the DMD of Global Beverage Co Ltd obtained his MBA degree
from a reputed university He had been the Director of Ocean Container Ltd before
joining in Global Beverage Co Ltd He possesses a nice personality
I interviewed Yaseer Rizvi Excerpts from his interview are as follows ndash
Shah Kamal Sir would you please tell me do you invest in short term marketable securities
Yaseer Rizvi Basically we do not invest our surplus cash in short term marketable
securities like T-Bill commercial paper certificate of deposit etc But we keep our
surplus cash in Bank
Shah Kamal Would you tell me something about transit time for a typical check
Yaseer Rizvi Well in Virgin the transit time for a typical check is ndash
For mail float 2 to 3 days
At firm float 6 hours
Clearing float 1 to 3 days
Shah Kamal Do you maintain any cash concentration mechanism like depository transfer check automated clearing house and wire transfer
i
Annexure
Yaseer Rizvi Our position in this case is very strong as we use all the mechanisms
you mentioned As Virgin is a firm with small deposits spread over a substantial
number of banks so we tend to use depository transfer checks extensively It is less
costly We also use automated clearing house and wire transfer but later is used in a
less extent
Shah Kamal Sir what techniques of disbursement management is used by your firm
Yaseer Rizvi Like other firms Virgin tries to retain the cash for as long as possible
But we always perform it in an ethical manner We do not use management of
disbursement float as it seems unethical We follow Zero-Balance Accounts method
for managing disbursement We do not prefer Controlled Disbursing method since
Zero-Balance system is already practiced in Virgin
Shah Kamal How do you hedge cash balance uncertainties
Yaseer Rizvi Well you may say that we do not invest in short term securities but for
facing cash difficulties we keep our surplus cash in bank
Shah Kamal Sir would you please tell me the general terms of sale of Virgin
Yaseer Rizvi Though it is difficult to maintain a fixed terms of sale our general terms
of sale is 210 n30 But for prime customers we offer special terms of sale
Shah Kamal What are the sources of credit information in case of your firm
Yaseer Rizvi We grant credit on the basis of prior experience with the customers In
case of a new customer personal contact is weighted
Shah Kamal Does your firm consider 5 Cs in granting credit
ii
Annexure
Yaseer Rizvi In case of Virgin Capital and Character get more importance than the
others Mind one thing personal relationship is the main measure in granting credit
Shah Kamal Do you use NPV method in credit granting decisions
Yaseer Rizvi We do not use NPV method But we think that NPV is a suitable
method and we have to use it from the next period
Shah Kamal Sir how do you handle the problem of bad debt
Yaseer Rizvi Well in this case our position is very strong Yet we do not face any
problem because of bad debt Just note that we make more than 80 of sales in cash
and we monitor accounts receivable very carefully
Shah Kamal What level of inventory is maintained by Virgin
Yaseer Rizvi We maintain a minimum level of inventory but do not have to face
stock out problems because inventory is managed efficiently
Shah Kamal What is the normal lead time
Yaseer Rizvi In case of imported goods normal lead time is about 1 month and when
we purchase raw materials from inside the country lead time is 1 to 3 days
Shah Kamal What method do you use for managing inventory
Yaseer Rizvi We do not use any method particularly rather inventory decision
depends on business cycle and market situation Long before the Eid festival we
bought large amount of sugar because price of sugar was increased on the occasion
of Eid
iii
Annexure
Shah Kamal What are the main items of inventory of your firm
Yaseer Rizvi Well these are ndash aluminum can pet chip sugar label chemical and
artificial sweet
Shah Kamal What are the uncertainties in maintaining appropriate level of stock
Yaseer Rizvi These are ndash
bull Increase in price of raw materials
bull Sales uncertainty
bull Market trends etc
Shah Kamal Thank you for your kind cooperation
Yaseer Rizvi Most Welcome
iv
Global Beverage Company Limited
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
(short term securities) are ndash
Treasury Bills
Commercial Paper
Certificates of Deposit
Bankerrsquos Acceptance
Repurch menase Agree ts
instruments They only keep cash in
Bank Account
Mail Float
(1 to 5 days)
At Firm
Float
(025 to 1
day)
Clearing
Float
(0 to
2 days)
Mail Float
(2 to 3 days)
At firm
Float
(025
day)
Clearing
Float
(1 to 3
days)
Figure Transit time for a typical check Figure Transit time for a check for
Virgin
Strategies that firms can use to reduce
the delay in receiving funds are ndash
Selecting of Banks with
accelerated clearing capabilities
of check processing Acceleration
at the firm
ectronic collection Use of el
procedures
Use of lockboxes
Virgin follows the first three strategies
but does not use lockboxes
Available cash concentration
mechanisms are ndash
Depository transfer check
ouse Automated Clearing H
(ACH) electronic transfer)
Wire transfer
Virgin uses all these mechanisms of
cash concentration
Available sets of techniques for cash
disbursement management are ndash
ement of disbursement
Page 37 of 46
Manag
float
Virgin uses zero-balance accounts
technique
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Zero-Balance Accounts
Controlled disbursing
Firms may make cash flow forecasts
over periods of various lengths yearly
flows quarterly flows monthly flows
weekly flows or even daily flows
Virgin forecasts cash on yearly basis and
monthly basis
Cash forecasting system may involve ndash
Distribution
Scheduling
Virginrsquos cash forecasting system
involves a combination of distribution
and scheduling
Two common approaches to cash flow
in generating the cash forecast
and disbursement Receipts
approach
Adjusted net income approach
Virgin uses the receipts and
disbursement approach
There are many items to forecast Virgin forecasts only major items like
AR payroll etc
Four common approach to forecasting
fina i ndash nc al variables are
Spot method
Proportion to another account
Compounded growth
Multiple dependencies
Virgin uses spot method for forecasting
cash It uses proportion to another
account method for other variables and
remaining two methods are frequently
used
Sources of uncertainty in cash
forecasting are ndash
Sales uncertainty
Collection rate uncertainty
Production cost uncertainty
Capital outflow uncertainty
Virgin faces uncertainty mainly from
sales and production cost
Methods for hedging cash balance
unc a
Page 38 of 46
ert inties are ndash
i) Holding a stock of extra cash
Virgin two available methods for
hedging cash balance uncertainties
Th ese are ndash
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
ii) stock of near-cash Holding a
assets
iii) Extra borrowing capacity
iv) ary surpluses in Investing tempor
near-cash assets
i) Holding a stock of extra cash
ii) Extra borrowing capacity
(advance receipt from
customers)
Models for the management of cash and
temporary investments are ndash Baumol
model Beranek model Miller-Orr
model and Stone model
Virgin does not follow any method
wholly but a combination of Baumol
model and Beranek model is occurred
82 INVENTORY MANAGEMENT
21 Certainty Approach
isnt used in
irgin because it thinks it is not possible to implement in Bangladesh
d time is one to three days It
oes not use ABC system of inventory management
8
Main item of inventory of Virgin is Can pet chip sugar label chemical artificial
sweet etc Virgin maintains a minimum level of inventory but it does not have to face
problems because inventory is managed efficiently just-in-time (JIT)
V
Virgin maintains buffer stock because of the shortage of work-in-process (WIP)
inventory Its production process may also be hampered Thats why it maintains
safety stock to avoid stock out cost In case of imported goods normal lead time is
about one month and within the country normal lea
d
Page 39 of 46
Inventory Model
In reality Virgin does not use any of models of EOQ ordering and holding strategy
and safety stock strategy They maintain inventory based on their prior experience
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
822 Uncertainty Approach
Virgin does not use any model for handling inventory uncertainty It says that such
decision depends on business cycle and market situation Long before Eid festival
they bought large amount of sugar because of price increase on the occasion of Eid
In summary
Standard Compliance by Virgin Soft Drinks
Firms maintain inventory to guard
against several problems
Virgin maintains a minimum level of
inventory which is managed efficiently
Some firms use JIT to avoid inventory
cost
JIT is not used by Virgin as it thinks it is
impossible to implement in Bangladesh
Firms maintain buffer stock Virgin maintains buffer stock too
Firms maintain safety stock to avoid
shortage cost
Virgin also maintains safety stock
Firms use ABC system to monitor
inventory
Virgin doesnt use ABC system
EOQ model is an appropriate method
for measuring quantity that has to be
ordered per order
Virgin does not use EOQ model rather
makes order based on experience and
market demand
83 MANAGING ACCOUNTS RECEIVABLE (DEBTORS)
831 Terms of Sale Decision
Page 40 of 46
Virgin offers the term 210 net 30 enables the customers to deduct 2 percent from the
face value of the bill when paying within the first 10 days but if the discount is not
taken the customer must remit the full amount within 30 days But Virgin does not
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
offer the same terms of sale to all customers For prime customers it offers special
terms of sale In setting an appropriate term of sale it costs and benefits regarding
this are compared It uses the standard approach of terms of sale decision as it is
simple to use
832 Credit Granting Decisions
In case of Virgin the Capital and Character of Five Cs get more importance
Although there are many problems with the traditional approach Virgin uses it
because of its simplicity Virgin does not use Net Present Value (NPV) method in
credit granting decision It thinks that NPV is an appropriate method and should be
used next time It does not face any severe problem because of bad debts The reason
is that notes receivable is used when credit is granted
833 Monitoring Accounts Receivable
Virgin monitors its accounts receivable Virgin believes that in any case both positive
and negative durations in accounts signal differences from the results that
management believe to be the most advantageous for the firm
Tools for Monitoring Accounts Receivable
Page 41 of 46
For monitoring accounts receivable there are several tools such as aging schedule
the ratios of receivable outstanding to original sales customers payment proportion
and sales weighted DSO (Days Sales Outstanding) For monitoring accounts
receivable Virgin uses aging schedule fractions and traditional DSO statistics
because of their simplicity in use Although payment proportions ratios of
receivables outstanding and sales weighted DSO methods are free from inherent bias
None of these is used because all these are complex to maintain
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
In summary
Page 42 of 46
Standard Compliance by Virgin Soft Drinks
Generals terms of sale is 210 net 30 Normally Virgin also use general terms
of sale ie 210 net 30
Firms do not offer the same terms of
sale to all customers
Yes For prime customers Virgin offers
special terms of sale
Approaches of terms of sale decisions
are ndash
bull Standard approach
bull Multi period approach
Virgin uses standard approach of terms
of sale decision as it is simple to use and
understand
Source of credit information are ndash
Sellers prior experience with the
customer
Credit agency ratings and
reports
Personal contact with the
applicants bank and other
creditors
Analysis of applicants financial
statements
Customer visit
Main source of credit information to
Virgin is its prior experience with the
customer All other sources are not cost-
effective for Virgin
Approaches of credit granting to
marginal accounts are ndash
Traditional approach
Net Present Value (NPV)
approach
It uses traditional approach still now but
thinks that NPV should be used for the
next periods
Firms monitor accounts receivable
because deviations from the expected
levels of turnover and of bad debt can
Virgin also monitors its accounts
receivable
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
signal several different problems
Different tools for monitoring accounts
receivable are ndash
Aging schedule
Ratios of receivables
outstanding to original sales
Customers payment
proportions
Sales-weighted DSO
For monitoring accounts receivable
Virgin uses aging schedule and
traditional sales outstanding statistics
84 MANAGING ACCOUNTS PAYABLE (CREDITORS)
Virgin has almost accounts payable of Tk 8000000 But most of its liabilities are to
the banks rather than suppliers But we dont have any clear information about
Virgins accounts payable
9 RECOMMENDATION
Virgin should invest its surplus cash in short term marketable securities
because it is suitable hedging against cash uncertainties and will also give
some returns (interest income)
Virgin should publish its own annual report which will satisfy information
needs of stakeholders and also increase the credibility of information provided
by Virgin
Page 43 of 46
Virgin should use multi period approach in terms of sale decision because
standard approach which is already exists in Virgin has some inherent
problems
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
It should stop using traditional approach from now It should use NPV
method in credit granting to marginal accounts
In monitoring accounts receivable Virgin should use sales-weighted DSO
method because it has least limitation compared to the others
It should be more flexible in granting credit which will ultimately increase its
sales
To get the appropriate number of quantity to be ordered per order it should
use DSO model
It should be ABC system for proper monitoring of inventory
10 CONCLUSION
The use of other peoples money in business is usually an expensive resource Before
looking outside for finance a firm should examine its own working capital cycle to
make sure that every rand of its own internal funds is being fully utilized Good
management of working capital is part of good financial management Effective use
of working capital will contribute to the operational efficiency of the whole
organization optimum use will help to generate maximum returns Furthermore
working capital management is not an end in itself It is an integral part of the firms
overall management The needs of efficient working capital management must be
considered in relation to other aspects of the Virgins financial and non-financial
performance Thats why when planning the development of a business it is critical
that the impact of working capital be fully assessed
Page 44 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
BIBLIOGRAPHY
Scherr FC (1989) International Edition Prentice-Hall International Inc Modern
Working Capital Management Text and Cases
Hussain Riaz (2002) Working Capital Management
Robertson Lonnie (July 1998) Inventory Management
httpwwwasashoporg visited on March 13 2006
The Art of Cash Management
httpwwwinccom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management
httpwwwstudyfinancecom visited on March 13 2006
White Paper ndash Managing Working Capital
httpwwwplanwareorg visited on March 13 2006
Management of Working Capital
httpwwwbusinesscentralcoza visited on March 13 2006
Cash Management
httpwwwsbagov visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management Objectives
httpwpsprenhallcom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management
Page 45 of 46
httpwwwadvancemecom visited on March 13 2006
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Business Receivables Financing
httpwwwbbtcom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Finance
http wwwfnbcoza visited on March 13 2006
Tips to manage your working capital
httpsmallbusinessninemsncomau visited on March 13 2006
Inventory Financing
httpwwwfranklincapitalnetworkcom visited on March 13 2006
Accounts Receivable Management
httpwwwfranklincapitalnetworkcom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management
httpwwwtreasurygovtnz visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management
httpwwwtreasurystrategiescom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Works
httpwwwinvestopediacom visited on March 13 2006
Treasury Services
httpwwwjpmorganchasecom visited on March 13 2006
what were about
Page 46 of 46
httpwwwvirgincom visited on March 13 2006
Annexure
Annexure
Interview with YASEER RIZVI
Mr Yaseer Rizvi the DMD of Global Beverage Co Ltd obtained his MBA degree
from a reputed university He had been the Director of Ocean Container Ltd before
joining in Global Beverage Co Ltd He possesses a nice personality
I interviewed Yaseer Rizvi Excerpts from his interview are as follows ndash
Shah Kamal Sir would you please tell me do you invest in short term marketable securities
Yaseer Rizvi Basically we do not invest our surplus cash in short term marketable
securities like T-Bill commercial paper certificate of deposit etc But we keep our
surplus cash in Bank
Shah Kamal Would you tell me something about transit time for a typical check
Yaseer Rizvi Well in Virgin the transit time for a typical check is ndash
For mail float 2 to 3 days
At firm float 6 hours
Clearing float 1 to 3 days
Shah Kamal Do you maintain any cash concentration mechanism like depository transfer check automated clearing house and wire transfer
i
Annexure
Yaseer Rizvi Our position in this case is very strong as we use all the mechanisms
you mentioned As Virgin is a firm with small deposits spread over a substantial
number of banks so we tend to use depository transfer checks extensively It is less
costly We also use automated clearing house and wire transfer but later is used in a
less extent
Shah Kamal Sir what techniques of disbursement management is used by your firm
Yaseer Rizvi Like other firms Virgin tries to retain the cash for as long as possible
But we always perform it in an ethical manner We do not use management of
disbursement float as it seems unethical We follow Zero-Balance Accounts method
for managing disbursement We do not prefer Controlled Disbursing method since
Zero-Balance system is already practiced in Virgin
Shah Kamal How do you hedge cash balance uncertainties
Yaseer Rizvi Well you may say that we do not invest in short term securities but for
facing cash difficulties we keep our surplus cash in bank
Shah Kamal Sir would you please tell me the general terms of sale of Virgin
Yaseer Rizvi Though it is difficult to maintain a fixed terms of sale our general terms
of sale is 210 n30 But for prime customers we offer special terms of sale
Shah Kamal What are the sources of credit information in case of your firm
Yaseer Rizvi We grant credit on the basis of prior experience with the customers In
case of a new customer personal contact is weighted
Shah Kamal Does your firm consider 5 Cs in granting credit
ii
Annexure
Yaseer Rizvi In case of Virgin Capital and Character get more importance than the
others Mind one thing personal relationship is the main measure in granting credit
Shah Kamal Do you use NPV method in credit granting decisions
Yaseer Rizvi We do not use NPV method But we think that NPV is a suitable
method and we have to use it from the next period
Shah Kamal Sir how do you handle the problem of bad debt
Yaseer Rizvi Well in this case our position is very strong Yet we do not face any
problem because of bad debt Just note that we make more than 80 of sales in cash
and we monitor accounts receivable very carefully
Shah Kamal What level of inventory is maintained by Virgin
Yaseer Rizvi We maintain a minimum level of inventory but do not have to face
stock out problems because inventory is managed efficiently
Shah Kamal What is the normal lead time
Yaseer Rizvi In case of imported goods normal lead time is about 1 month and when
we purchase raw materials from inside the country lead time is 1 to 3 days
Shah Kamal What method do you use for managing inventory
Yaseer Rizvi We do not use any method particularly rather inventory decision
depends on business cycle and market situation Long before the Eid festival we
bought large amount of sugar because price of sugar was increased on the occasion
of Eid
iii
Annexure
Shah Kamal What are the main items of inventory of your firm
Yaseer Rizvi Well these are ndash aluminum can pet chip sugar label chemical and
artificial sweet
Shah Kamal What are the uncertainties in maintaining appropriate level of stock
Yaseer Rizvi These are ndash
bull Increase in price of raw materials
bull Sales uncertainty
bull Market trends etc
Shah Kamal Thank you for your kind cooperation
Yaseer Rizvi Most Welcome
iv
Global Beverage Company Limited
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Zero-Balance Accounts
Controlled disbursing
Firms may make cash flow forecasts
over periods of various lengths yearly
flows quarterly flows monthly flows
weekly flows or even daily flows
Virgin forecasts cash on yearly basis and
monthly basis
Cash forecasting system may involve ndash
Distribution
Scheduling
Virginrsquos cash forecasting system
involves a combination of distribution
and scheduling
Two common approaches to cash flow
in generating the cash forecast
and disbursement Receipts
approach
Adjusted net income approach
Virgin uses the receipts and
disbursement approach
There are many items to forecast Virgin forecasts only major items like
AR payroll etc
Four common approach to forecasting
fina i ndash nc al variables are
Spot method
Proportion to another account
Compounded growth
Multiple dependencies
Virgin uses spot method for forecasting
cash It uses proportion to another
account method for other variables and
remaining two methods are frequently
used
Sources of uncertainty in cash
forecasting are ndash
Sales uncertainty
Collection rate uncertainty
Production cost uncertainty
Capital outflow uncertainty
Virgin faces uncertainty mainly from
sales and production cost
Methods for hedging cash balance
unc a
Page 38 of 46
ert inties are ndash
i) Holding a stock of extra cash
Virgin two available methods for
hedging cash balance uncertainties
Th ese are ndash
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
ii) stock of near-cash Holding a
assets
iii) Extra borrowing capacity
iv) ary surpluses in Investing tempor
near-cash assets
i) Holding a stock of extra cash
ii) Extra borrowing capacity
(advance receipt from
customers)
Models for the management of cash and
temporary investments are ndash Baumol
model Beranek model Miller-Orr
model and Stone model
Virgin does not follow any method
wholly but a combination of Baumol
model and Beranek model is occurred
82 INVENTORY MANAGEMENT
21 Certainty Approach
isnt used in
irgin because it thinks it is not possible to implement in Bangladesh
d time is one to three days It
oes not use ABC system of inventory management
8
Main item of inventory of Virgin is Can pet chip sugar label chemical artificial
sweet etc Virgin maintains a minimum level of inventory but it does not have to face
problems because inventory is managed efficiently just-in-time (JIT)
V
Virgin maintains buffer stock because of the shortage of work-in-process (WIP)
inventory Its production process may also be hampered Thats why it maintains
safety stock to avoid stock out cost In case of imported goods normal lead time is
about one month and within the country normal lea
d
Page 39 of 46
Inventory Model
In reality Virgin does not use any of models of EOQ ordering and holding strategy
and safety stock strategy They maintain inventory based on their prior experience
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
822 Uncertainty Approach
Virgin does not use any model for handling inventory uncertainty It says that such
decision depends on business cycle and market situation Long before Eid festival
they bought large amount of sugar because of price increase on the occasion of Eid
In summary
Standard Compliance by Virgin Soft Drinks
Firms maintain inventory to guard
against several problems
Virgin maintains a minimum level of
inventory which is managed efficiently
Some firms use JIT to avoid inventory
cost
JIT is not used by Virgin as it thinks it is
impossible to implement in Bangladesh
Firms maintain buffer stock Virgin maintains buffer stock too
Firms maintain safety stock to avoid
shortage cost
Virgin also maintains safety stock
Firms use ABC system to monitor
inventory
Virgin doesnt use ABC system
EOQ model is an appropriate method
for measuring quantity that has to be
ordered per order
Virgin does not use EOQ model rather
makes order based on experience and
market demand
83 MANAGING ACCOUNTS RECEIVABLE (DEBTORS)
831 Terms of Sale Decision
Page 40 of 46
Virgin offers the term 210 net 30 enables the customers to deduct 2 percent from the
face value of the bill when paying within the first 10 days but if the discount is not
taken the customer must remit the full amount within 30 days But Virgin does not
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
offer the same terms of sale to all customers For prime customers it offers special
terms of sale In setting an appropriate term of sale it costs and benefits regarding
this are compared It uses the standard approach of terms of sale decision as it is
simple to use
832 Credit Granting Decisions
In case of Virgin the Capital and Character of Five Cs get more importance
Although there are many problems with the traditional approach Virgin uses it
because of its simplicity Virgin does not use Net Present Value (NPV) method in
credit granting decision It thinks that NPV is an appropriate method and should be
used next time It does not face any severe problem because of bad debts The reason
is that notes receivable is used when credit is granted
833 Monitoring Accounts Receivable
Virgin monitors its accounts receivable Virgin believes that in any case both positive
and negative durations in accounts signal differences from the results that
management believe to be the most advantageous for the firm
Tools for Monitoring Accounts Receivable
Page 41 of 46
For monitoring accounts receivable there are several tools such as aging schedule
the ratios of receivable outstanding to original sales customers payment proportion
and sales weighted DSO (Days Sales Outstanding) For monitoring accounts
receivable Virgin uses aging schedule fractions and traditional DSO statistics
because of their simplicity in use Although payment proportions ratios of
receivables outstanding and sales weighted DSO methods are free from inherent bias
None of these is used because all these are complex to maintain
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
In summary
Page 42 of 46
Standard Compliance by Virgin Soft Drinks
Generals terms of sale is 210 net 30 Normally Virgin also use general terms
of sale ie 210 net 30
Firms do not offer the same terms of
sale to all customers
Yes For prime customers Virgin offers
special terms of sale
Approaches of terms of sale decisions
are ndash
bull Standard approach
bull Multi period approach
Virgin uses standard approach of terms
of sale decision as it is simple to use and
understand
Source of credit information are ndash
Sellers prior experience with the
customer
Credit agency ratings and
reports
Personal contact with the
applicants bank and other
creditors
Analysis of applicants financial
statements
Customer visit
Main source of credit information to
Virgin is its prior experience with the
customer All other sources are not cost-
effective for Virgin
Approaches of credit granting to
marginal accounts are ndash
Traditional approach
Net Present Value (NPV)
approach
It uses traditional approach still now but
thinks that NPV should be used for the
next periods
Firms monitor accounts receivable
because deviations from the expected
levels of turnover and of bad debt can
Virgin also monitors its accounts
receivable
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
signal several different problems
Different tools for monitoring accounts
receivable are ndash
Aging schedule
Ratios of receivables
outstanding to original sales
Customers payment
proportions
Sales-weighted DSO
For monitoring accounts receivable
Virgin uses aging schedule and
traditional sales outstanding statistics
84 MANAGING ACCOUNTS PAYABLE (CREDITORS)
Virgin has almost accounts payable of Tk 8000000 But most of its liabilities are to
the banks rather than suppliers But we dont have any clear information about
Virgins accounts payable
9 RECOMMENDATION
Virgin should invest its surplus cash in short term marketable securities
because it is suitable hedging against cash uncertainties and will also give
some returns (interest income)
Virgin should publish its own annual report which will satisfy information
needs of stakeholders and also increase the credibility of information provided
by Virgin
Page 43 of 46
Virgin should use multi period approach in terms of sale decision because
standard approach which is already exists in Virgin has some inherent
problems
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
It should stop using traditional approach from now It should use NPV
method in credit granting to marginal accounts
In monitoring accounts receivable Virgin should use sales-weighted DSO
method because it has least limitation compared to the others
It should be more flexible in granting credit which will ultimately increase its
sales
To get the appropriate number of quantity to be ordered per order it should
use DSO model
It should be ABC system for proper monitoring of inventory
10 CONCLUSION
The use of other peoples money in business is usually an expensive resource Before
looking outside for finance a firm should examine its own working capital cycle to
make sure that every rand of its own internal funds is being fully utilized Good
management of working capital is part of good financial management Effective use
of working capital will contribute to the operational efficiency of the whole
organization optimum use will help to generate maximum returns Furthermore
working capital management is not an end in itself It is an integral part of the firms
overall management The needs of efficient working capital management must be
considered in relation to other aspects of the Virgins financial and non-financial
performance Thats why when planning the development of a business it is critical
that the impact of working capital be fully assessed
Page 44 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
BIBLIOGRAPHY
Scherr FC (1989) International Edition Prentice-Hall International Inc Modern
Working Capital Management Text and Cases
Hussain Riaz (2002) Working Capital Management
Robertson Lonnie (July 1998) Inventory Management
httpwwwasashoporg visited on March 13 2006
The Art of Cash Management
httpwwwinccom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management
httpwwwstudyfinancecom visited on March 13 2006
White Paper ndash Managing Working Capital
httpwwwplanwareorg visited on March 13 2006
Management of Working Capital
httpwwwbusinesscentralcoza visited on March 13 2006
Cash Management
httpwwwsbagov visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management Objectives
httpwpsprenhallcom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management
Page 45 of 46
httpwwwadvancemecom visited on March 13 2006
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Business Receivables Financing
httpwwwbbtcom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Finance
http wwwfnbcoza visited on March 13 2006
Tips to manage your working capital
httpsmallbusinessninemsncomau visited on March 13 2006
Inventory Financing
httpwwwfranklincapitalnetworkcom visited on March 13 2006
Accounts Receivable Management
httpwwwfranklincapitalnetworkcom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management
httpwwwtreasurygovtnz visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management
httpwwwtreasurystrategiescom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Works
httpwwwinvestopediacom visited on March 13 2006
Treasury Services
httpwwwjpmorganchasecom visited on March 13 2006
what were about
Page 46 of 46
httpwwwvirgincom visited on March 13 2006
Annexure
Annexure
Interview with YASEER RIZVI
Mr Yaseer Rizvi the DMD of Global Beverage Co Ltd obtained his MBA degree
from a reputed university He had been the Director of Ocean Container Ltd before
joining in Global Beverage Co Ltd He possesses a nice personality
I interviewed Yaseer Rizvi Excerpts from his interview are as follows ndash
Shah Kamal Sir would you please tell me do you invest in short term marketable securities
Yaseer Rizvi Basically we do not invest our surplus cash in short term marketable
securities like T-Bill commercial paper certificate of deposit etc But we keep our
surplus cash in Bank
Shah Kamal Would you tell me something about transit time for a typical check
Yaseer Rizvi Well in Virgin the transit time for a typical check is ndash
For mail float 2 to 3 days
At firm float 6 hours
Clearing float 1 to 3 days
Shah Kamal Do you maintain any cash concentration mechanism like depository transfer check automated clearing house and wire transfer
i
Annexure
Yaseer Rizvi Our position in this case is very strong as we use all the mechanisms
you mentioned As Virgin is a firm with small deposits spread over a substantial
number of banks so we tend to use depository transfer checks extensively It is less
costly We also use automated clearing house and wire transfer but later is used in a
less extent
Shah Kamal Sir what techniques of disbursement management is used by your firm
Yaseer Rizvi Like other firms Virgin tries to retain the cash for as long as possible
But we always perform it in an ethical manner We do not use management of
disbursement float as it seems unethical We follow Zero-Balance Accounts method
for managing disbursement We do not prefer Controlled Disbursing method since
Zero-Balance system is already practiced in Virgin
Shah Kamal How do you hedge cash balance uncertainties
Yaseer Rizvi Well you may say that we do not invest in short term securities but for
facing cash difficulties we keep our surplus cash in bank
Shah Kamal Sir would you please tell me the general terms of sale of Virgin
Yaseer Rizvi Though it is difficult to maintain a fixed terms of sale our general terms
of sale is 210 n30 But for prime customers we offer special terms of sale
Shah Kamal What are the sources of credit information in case of your firm
Yaseer Rizvi We grant credit on the basis of prior experience with the customers In
case of a new customer personal contact is weighted
Shah Kamal Does your firm consider 5 Cs in granting credit
ii
Annexure
Yaseer Rizvi In case of Virgin Capital and Character get more importance than the
others Mind one thing personal relationship is the main measure in granting credit
Shah Kamal Do you use NPV method in credit granting decisions
Yaseer Rizvi We do not use NPV method But we think that NPV is a suitable
method and we have to use it from the next period
Shah Kamal Sir how do you handle the problem of bad debt
Yaseer Rizvi Well in this case our position is very strong Yet we do not face any
problem because of bad debt Just note that we make more than 80 of sales in cash
and we monitor accounts receivable very carefully
Shah Kamal What level of inventory is maintained by Virgin
Yaseer Rizvi We maintain a minimum level of inventory but do not have to face
stock out problems because inventory is managed efficiently
Shah Kamal What is the normal lead time
Yaseer Rizvi In case of imported goods normal lead time is about 1 month and when
we purchase raw materials from inside the country lead time is 1 to 3 days
Shah Kamal What method do you use for managing inventory
Yaseer Rizvi We do not use any method particularly rather inventory decision
depends on business cycle and market situation Long before the Eid festival we
bought large amount of sugar because price of sugar was increased on the occasion
of Eid
iii
Annexure
Shah Kamal What are the main items of inventory of your firm
Yaseer Rizvi Well these are ndash aluminum can pet chip sugar label chemical and
artificial sweet
Shah Kamal What are the uncertainties in maintaining appropriate level of stock
Yaseer Rizvi These are ndash
bull Increase in price of raw materials
bull Sales uncertainty
bull Market trends etc
Shah Kamal Thank you for your kind cooperation
Yaseer Rizvi Most Welcome
iv
Global Beverage Company Limited
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
ii) stock of near-cash Holding a
assets
iii) Extra borrowing capacity
iv) ary surpluses in Investing tempor
near-cash assets
i) Holding a stock of extra cash
ii) Extra borrowing capacity
(advance receipt from
customers)
Models for the management of cash and
temporary investments are ndash Baumol
model Beranek model Miller-Orr
model and Stone model
Virgin does not follow any method
wholly but a combination of Baumol
model and Beranek model is occurred
82 INVENTORY MANAGEMENT
21 Certainty Approach
isnt used in
irgin because it thinks it is not possible to implement in Bangladesh
d time is one to three days It
oes not use ABC system of inventory management
8
Main item of inventory of Virgin is Can pet chip sugar label chemical artificial
sweet etc Virgin maintains a minimum level of inventory but it does not have to face
problems because inventory is managed efficiently just-in-time (JIT)
V
Virgin maintains buffer stock because of the shortage of work-in-process (WIP)
inventory Its production process may also be hampered Thats why it maintains
safety stock to avoid stock out cost In case of imported goods normal lead time is
about one month and within the country normal lea
d
Page 39 of 46
Inventory Model
In reality Virgin does not use any of models of EOQ ordering and holding strategy
and safety stock strategy They maintain inventory based on their prior experience
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
822 Uncertainty Approach
Virgin does not use any model for handling inventory uncertainty It says that such
decision depends on business cycle and market situation Long before Eid festival
they bought large amount of sugar because of price increase on the occasion of Eid
In summary
Standard Compliance by Virgin Soft Drinks
Firms maintain inventory to guard
against several problems
Virgin maintains a minimum level of
inventory which is managed efficiently
Some firms use JIT to avoid inventory
cost
JIT is not used by Virgin as it thinks it is
impossible to implement in Bangladesh
Firms maintain buffer stock Virgin maintains buffer stock too
Firms maintain safety stock to avoid
shortage cost
Virgin also maintains safety stock
Firms use ABC system to monitor
inventory
Virgin doesnt use ABC system
EOQ model is an appropriate method
for measuring quantity that has to be
ordered per order
Virgin does not use EOQ model rather
makes order based on experience and
market demand
83 MANAGING ACCOUNTS RECEIVABLE (DEBTORS)
831 Terms of Sale Decision
Page 40 of 46
Virgin offers the term 210 net 30 enables the customers to deduct 2 percent from the
face value of the bill when paying within the first 10 days but if the discount is not
taken the customer must remit the full amount within 30 days But Virgin does not
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
offer the same terms of sale to all customers For prime customers it offers special
terms of sale In setting an appropriate term of sale it costs and benefits regarding
this are compared It uses the standard approach of terms of sale decision as it is
simple to use
832 Credit Granting Decisions
In case of Virgin the Capital and Character of Five Cs get more importance
Although there are many problems with the traditional approach Virgin uses it
because of its simplicity Virgin does not use Net Present Value (NPV) method in
credit granting decision It thinks that NPV is an appropriate method and should be
used next time It does not face any severe problem because of bad debts The reason
is that notes receivable is used when credit is granted
833 Monitoring Accounts Receivable
Virgin monitors its accounts receivable Virgin believes that in any case both positive
and negative durations in accounts signal differences from the results that
management believe to be the most advantageous for the firm
Tools for Monitoring Accounts Receivable
Page 41 of 46
For monitoring accounts receivable there are several tools such as aging schedule
the ratios of receivable outstanding to original sales customers payment proportion
and sales weighted DSO (Days Sales Outstanding) For monitoring accounts
receivable Virgin uses aging schedule fractions and traditional DSO statistics
because of their simplicity in use Although payment proportions ratios of
receivables outstanding and sales weighted DSO methods are free from inherent bias
None of these is used because all these are complex to maintain
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
In summary
Page 42 of 46
Standard Compliance by Virgin Soft Drinks
Generals terms of sale is 210 net 30 Normally Virgin also use general terms
of sale ie 210 net 30
Firms do not offer the same terms of
sale to all customers
Yes For prime customers Virgin offers
special terms of sale
Approaches of terms of sale decisions
are ndash
bull Standard approach
bull Multi period approach
Virgin uses standard approach of terms
of sale decision as it is simple to use and
understand
Source of credit information are ndash
Sellers prior experience with the
customer
Credit agency ratings and
reports
Personal contact with the
applicants bank and other
creditors
Analysis of applicants financial
statements
Customer visit
Main source of credit information to
Virgin is its prior experience with the
customer All other sources are not cost-
effective for Virgin
Approaches of credit granting to
marginal accounts are ndash
Traditional approach
Net Present Value (NPV)
approach
It uses traditional approach still now but
thinks that NPV should be used for the
next periods
Firms monitor accounts receivable
because deviations from the expected
levels of turnover and of bad debt can
Virgin also monitors its accounts
receivable
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
signal several different problems
Different tools for monitoring accounts
receivable are ndash
Aging schedule
Ratios of receivables
outstanding to original sales
Customers payment
proportions
Sales-weighted DSO
For monitoring accounts receivable
Virgin uses aging schedule and
traditional sales outstanding statistics
84 MANAGING ACCOUNTS PAYABLE (CREDITORS)
Virgin has almost accounts payable of Tk 8000000 But most of its liabilities are to
the banks rather than suppliers But we dont have any clear information about
Virgins accounts payable
9 RECOMMENDATION
Virgin should invest its surplus cash in short term marketable securities
because it is suitable hedging against cash uncertainties and will also give
some returns (interest income)
Virgin should publish its own annual report which will satisfy information
needs of stakeholders and also increase the credibility of information provided
by Virgin
Page 43 of 46
Virgin should use multi period approach in terms of sale decision because
standard approach which is already exists in Virgin has some inherent
problems
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
It should stop using traditional approach from now It should use NPV
method in credit granting to marginal accounts
In monitoring accounts receivable Virgin should use sales-weighted DSO
method because it has least limitation compared to the others
It should be more flexible in granting credit which will ultimately increase its
sales
To get the appropriate number of quantity to be ordered per order it should
use DSO model
It should be ABC system for proper monitoring of inventory
10 CONCLUSION
The use of other peoples money in business is usually an expensive resource Before
looking outside for finance a firm should examine its own working capital cycle to
make sure that every rand of its own internal funds is being fully utilized Good
management of working capital is part of good financial management Effective use
of working capital will contribute to the operational efficiency of the whole
organization optimum use will help to generate maximum returns Furthermore
working capital management is not an end in itself It is an integral part of the firms
overall management The needs of efficient working capital management must be
considered in relation to other aspects of the Virgins financial and non-financial
performance Thats why when planning the development of a business it is critical
that the impact of working capital be fully assessed
Page 44 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
BIBLIOGRAPHY
Scherr FC (1989) International Edition Prentice-Hall International Inc Modern
Working Capital Management Text and Cases
Hussain Riaz (2002) Working Capital Management
Robertson Lonnie (July 1998) Inventory Management
httpwwwasashoporg visited on March 13 2006
The Art of Cash Management
httpwwwinccom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management
httpwwwstudyfinancecom visited on March 13 2006
White Paper ndash Managing Working Capital
httpwwwplanwareorg visited on March 13 2006
Management of Working Capital
httpwwwbusinesscentralcoza visited on March 13 2006
Cash Management
httpwwwsbagov visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management Objectives
httpwpsprenhallcom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management
Page 45 of 46
httpwwwadvancemecom visited on March 13 2006
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Business Receivables Financing
httpwwwbbtcom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Finance
http wwwfnbcoza visited on March 13 2006
Tips to manage your working capital
httpsmallbusinessninemsncomau visited on March 13 2006
Inventory Financing
httpwwwfranklincapitalnetworkcom visited on March 13 2006
Accounts Receivable Management
httpwwwfranklincapitalnetworkcom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management
httpwwwtreasurygovtnz visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management
httpwwwtreasurystrategiescom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Works
httpwwwinvestopediacom visited on March 13 2006
Treasury Services
httpwwwjpmorganchasecom visited on March 13 2006
what were about
Page 46 of 46
httpwwwvirgincom visited on March 13 2006
Annexure
Annexure
Interview with YASEER RIZVI
Mr Yaseer Rizvi the DMD of Global Beverage Co Ltd obtained his MBA degree
from a reputed university He had been the Director of Ocean Container Ltd before
joining in Global Beverage Co Ltd He possesses a nice personality
I interviewed Yaseer Rizvi Excerpts from his interview are as follows ndash
Shah Kamal Sir would you please tell me do you invest in short term marketable securities
Yaseer Rizvi Basically we do not invest our surplus cash in short term marketable
securities like T-Bill commercial paper certificate of deposit etc But we keep our
surplus cash in Bank
Shah Kamal Would you tell me something about transit time for a typical check
Yaseer Rizvi Well in Virgin the transit time for a typical check is ndash
For mail float 2 to 3 days
At firm float 6 hours
Clearing float 1 to 3 days
Shah Kamal Do you maintain any cash concentration mechanism like depository transfer check automated clearing house and wire transfer
i
Annexure
Yaseer Rizvi Our position in this case is very strong as we use all the mechanisms
you mentioned As Virgin is a firm with small deposits spread over a substantial
number of banks so we tend to use depository transfer checks extensively It is less
costly We also use automated clearing house and wire transfer but later is used in a
less extent
Shah Kamal Sir what techniques of disbursement management is used by your firm
Yaseer Rizvi Like other firms Virgin tries to retain the cash for as long as possible
But we always perform it in an ethical manner We do not use management of
disbursement float as it seems unethical We follow Zero-Balance Accounts method
for managing disbursement We do not prefer Controlled Disbursing method since
Zero-Balance system is already practiced in Virgin
Shah Kamal How do you hedge cash balance uncertainties
Yaseer Rizvi Well you may say that we do not invest in short term securities but for
facing cash difficulties we keep our surplus cash in bank
Shah Kamal Sir would you please tell me the general terms of sale of Virgin
Yaseer Rizvi Though it is difficult to maintain a fixed terms of sale our general terms
of sale is 210 n30 But for prime customers we offer special terms of sale
Shah Kamal What are the sources of credit information in case of your firm
Yaseer Rizvi We grant credit on the basis of prior experience with the customers In
case of a new customer personal contact is weighted
Shah Kamal Does your firm consider 5 Cs in granting credit
ii
Annexure
Yaseer Rizvi In case of Virgin Capital and Character get more importance than the
others Mind one thing personal relationship is the main measure in granting credit
Shah Kamal Do you use NPV method in credit granting decisions
Yaseer Rizvi We do not use NPV method But we think that NPV is a suitable
method and we have to use it from the next period
Shah Kamal Sir how do you handle the problem of bad debt
Yaseer Rizvi Well in this case our position is very strong Yet we do not face any
problem because of bad debt Just note that we make more than 80 of sales in cash
and we monitor accounts receivable very carefully
Shah Kamal What level of inventory is maintained by Virgin
Yaseer Rizvi We maintain a minimum level of inventory but do not have to face
stock out problems because inventory is managed efficiently
Shah Kamal What is the normal lead time
Yaseer Rizvi In case of imported goods normal lead time is about 1 month and when
we purchase raw materials from inside the country lead time is 1 to 3 days
Shah Kamal What method do you use for managing inventory
Yaseer Rizvi We do not use any method particularly rather inventory decision
depends on business cycle and market situation Long before the Eid festival we
bought large amount of sugar because price of sugar was increased on the occasion
of Eid
iii
Annexure
Shah Kamal What are the main items of inventory of your firm
Yaseer Rizvi Well these are ndash aluminum can pet chip sugar label chemical and
artificial sweet
Shah Kamal What are the uncertainties in maintaining appropriate level of stock
Yaseer Rizvi These are ndash
bull Increase in price of raw materials
bull Sales uncertainty
bull Market trends etc
Shah Kamal Thank you for your kind cooperation
Yaseer Rizvi Most Welcome
iv
Global Beverage Company Limited
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
822 Uncertainty Approach
Virgin does not use any model for handling inventory uncertainty It says that such
decision depends on business cycle and market situation Long before Eid festival
they bought large amount of sugar because of price increase on the occasion of Eid
In summary
Standard Compliance by Virgin Soft Drinks
Firms maintain inventory to guard
against several problems
Virgin maintains a minimum level of
inventory which is managed efficiently
Some firms use JIT to avoid inventory
cost
JIT is not used by Virgin as it thinks it is
impossible to implement in Bangladesh
Firms maintain buffer stock Virgin maintains buffer stock too
Firms maintain safety stock to avoid
shortage cost
Virgin also maintains safety stock
Firms use ABC system to monitor
inventory
Virgin doesnt use ABC system
EOQ model is an appropriate method
for measuring quantity that has to be
ordered per order
Virgin does not use EOQ model rather
makes order based on experience and
market demand
83 MANAGING ACCOUNTS RECEIVABLE (DEBTORS)
831 Terms of Sale Decision
Page 40 of 46
Virgin offers the term 210 net 30 enables the customers to deduct 2 percent from the
face value of the bill when paying within the first 10 days but if the discount is not
taken the customer must remit the full amount within 30 days But Virgin does not
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
offer the same terms of sale to all customers For prime customers it offers special
terms of sale In setting an appropriate term of sale it costs and benefits regarding
this are compared It uses the standard approach of terms of sale decision as it is
simple to use
832 Credit Granting Decisions
In case of Virgin the Capital and Character of Five Cs get more importance
Although there are many problems with the traditional approach Virgin uses it
because of its simplicity Virgin does not use Net Present Value (NPV) method in
credit granting decision It thinks that NPV is an appropriate method and should be
used next time It does not face any severe problem because of bad debts The reason
is that notes receivable is used when credit is granted
833 Monitoring Accounts Receivable
Virgin monitors its accounts receivable Virgin believes that in any case both positive
and negative durations in accounts signal differences from the results that
management believe to be the most advantageous for the firm
Tools for Monitoring Accounts Receivable
Page 41 of 46
For monitoring accounts receivable there are several tools such as aging schedule
the ratios of receivable outstanding to original sales customers payment proportion
and sales weighted DSO (Days Sales Outstanding) For monitoring accounts
receivable Virgin uses aging schedule fractions and traditional DSO statistics
because of their simplicity in use Although payment proportions ratios of
receivables outstanding and sales weighted DSO methods are free from inherent bias
None of these is used because all these are complex to maintain
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
In summary
Page 42 of 46
Standard Compliance by Virgin Soft Drinks
Generals terms of sale is 210 net 30 Normally Virgin also use general terms
of sale ie 210 net 30
Firms do not offer the same terms of
sale to all customers
Yes For prime customers Virgin offers
special terms of sale
Approaches of terms of sale decisions
are ndash
bull Standard approach
bull Multi period approach
Virgin uses standard approach of terms
of sale decision as it is simple to use and
understand
Source of credit information are ndash
Sellers prior experience with the
customer
Credit agency ratings and
reports
Personal contact with the
applicants bank and other
creditors
Analysis of applicants financial
statements
Customer visit
Main source of credit information to
Virgin is its prior experience with the
customer All other sources are not cost-
effective for Virgin
Approaches of credit granting to
marginal accounts are ndash
Traditional approach
Net Present Value (NPV)
approach
It uses traditional approach still now but
thinks that NPV should be used for the
next periods
Firms monitor accounts receivable
because deviations from the expected
levels of turnover and of bad debt can
Virgin also monitors its accounts
receivable
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
signal several different problems
Different tools for monitoring accounts
receivable are ndash
Aging schedule
Ratios of receivables
outstanding to original sales
Customers payment
proportions
Sales-weighted DSO
For monitoring accounts receivable
Virgin uses aging schedule and
traditional sales outstanding statistics
84 MANAGING ACCOUNTS PAYABLE (CREDITORS)
Virgin has almost accounts payable of Tk 8000000 But most of its liabilities are to
the banks rather than suppliers But we dont have any clear information about
Virgins accounts payable
9 RECOMMENDATION
Virgin should invest its surplus cash in short term marketable securities
because it is suitable hedging against cash uncertainties and will also give
some returns (interest income)
Virgin should publish its own annual report which will satisfy information
needs of stakeholders and also increase the credibility of information provided
by Virgin
Page 43 of 46
Virgin should use multi period approach in terms of sale decision because
standard approach which is already exists in Virgin has some inherent
problems
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
It should stop using traditional approach from now It should use NPV
method in credit granting to marginal accounts
In monitoring accounts receivable Virgin should use sales-weighted DSO
method because it has least limitation compared to the others
It should be more flexible in granting credit which will ultimately increase its
sales
To get the appropriate number of quantity to be ordered per order it should
use DSO model
It should be ABC system for proper monitoring of inventory
10 CONCLUSION
The use of other peoples money in business is usually an expensive resource Before
looking outside for finance a firm should examine its own working capital cycle to
make sure that every rand of its own internal funds is being fully utilized Good
management of working capital is part of good financial management Effective use
of working capital will contribute to the operational efficiency of the whole
organization optimum use will help to generate maximum returns Furthermore
working capital management is not an end in itself It is an integral part of the firms
overall management The needs of efficient working capital management must be
considered in relation to other aspects of the Virgins financial and non-financial
performance Thats why when planning the development of a business it is critical
that the impact of working capital be fully assessed
Page 44 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
BIBLIOGRAPHY
Scherr FC (1989) International Edition Prentice-Hall International Inc Modern
Working Capital Management Text and Cases
Hussain Riaz (2002) Working Capital Management
Robertson Lonnie (July 1998) Inventory Management
httpwwwasashoporg visited on March 13 2006
The Art of Cash Management
httpwwwinccom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management
httpwwwstudyfinancecom visited on March 13 2006
White Paper ndash Managing Working Capital
httpwwwplanwareorg visited on March 13 2006
Management of Working Capital
httpwwwbusinesscentralcoza visited on March 13 2006
Cash Management
httpwwwsbagov visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management Objectives
httpwpsprenhallcom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management
Page 45 of 46
httpwwwadvancemecom visited on March 13 2006
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Business Receivables Financing
httpwwwbbtcom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Finance
http wwwfnbcoza visited on March 13 2006
Tips to manage your working capital
httpsmallbusinessninemsncomau visited on March 13 2006
Inventory Financing
httpwwwfranklincapitalnetworkcom visited on March 13 2006
Accounts Receivable Management
httpwwwfranklincapitalnetworkcom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management
httpwwwtreasurygovtnz visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management
httpwwwtreasurystrategiescom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Works
httpwwwinvestopediacom visited on March 13 2006
Treasury Services
httpwwwjpmorganchasecom visited on March 13 2006
what were about
Page 46 of 46
httpwwwvirgincom visited on March 13 2006
Annexure
Annexure
Interview with YASEER RIZVI
Mr Yaseer Rizvi the DMD of Global Beverage Co Ltd obtained his MBA degree
from a reputed university He had been the Director of Ocean Container Ltd before
joining in Global Beverage Co Ltd He possesses a nice personality
I interviewed Yaseer Rizvi Excerpts from his interview are as follows ndash
Shah Kamal Sir would you please tell me do you invest in short term marketable securities
Yaseer Rizvi Basically we do not invest our surplus cash in short term marketable
securities like T-Bill commercial paper certificate of deposit etc But we keep our
surplus cash in Bank
Shah Kamal Would you tell me something about transit time for a typical check
Yaseer Rizvi Well in Virgin the transit time for a typical check is ndash
For mail float 2 to 3 days
At firm float 6 hours
Clearing float 1 to 3 days
Shah Kamal Do you maintain any cash concentration mechanism like depository transfer check automated clearing house and wire transfer
i
Annexure
Yaseer Rizvi Our position in this case is very strong as we use all the mechanisms
you mentioned As Virgin is a firm with small deposits spread over a substantial
number of banks so we tend to use depository transfer checks extensively It is less
costly We also use automated clearing house and wire transfer but later is used in a
less extent
Shah Kamal Sir what techniques of disbursement management is used by your firm
Yaseer Rizvi Like other firms Virgin tries to retain the cash for as long as possible
But we always perform it in an ethical manner We do not use management of
disbursement float as it seems unethical We follow Zero-Balance Accounts method
for managing disbursement We do not prefer Controlled Disbursing method since
Zero-Balance system is already practiced in Virgin
Shah Kamal How do you hedge cash balance uncertainties
Yaseer Rizvi Well you may say that we do not invest in short term securities but for
facing cash difficulties we keep our surplus cash in bank
Shah Kamal Sir would you please tell me the general terms of sale of Virgin
Yaseer Rizvi Though it is difficult to maintain a fixed terms of sale our general terms
of sale is 210 n30 But for prime customers we offer special terms of sale
Shah Kamal What are the sources of credit information in case of your firm
Yaseer Rizvi We grant credit on the basis of prior experience with the customers In
case of a new customer personal contact is weighted
Shah Kamal Does your firm consider 5 Cs in granting credit
ii
Annexure
Yaseer Rizvi In case of Virgin Capital and Character get more importance than the
others Mind one thing personal relationship is the main measure in granting credit
Shah Kamal Do you use NPV method in credit granting decisions
Yaseer Rizvi We do not use NPV method But we think that NPV is a suitable
method and we have to use it from the next period
Shah Kamal Sir how do you handle the problem of bad debt
Yaseer Rizvi Well in this case our position is very strong Yet we do not face any
problem because of bad debt Just note that we make more than 80 of sales in cash
and we monitor accounts receivable very carefully
Shah Kamal What level of inventory is maintained by Virgin
Yaseer Rizvi We maintain a minimum level of inventory but do not have to face
stock out problems because inventory is managed efficiently
Shah Kamal What is the normal lead time
Yaseer Rizvi In case of imported goods normal lead time is about 1 month and when
we purchase raw materials from inside the country lead time is 1 to 3 days
Shah Kamal What method do you use for managing inventory
Yaseer Rizvi We do not use any method particularly rather inventory decision
depends on business cycle and market situation Long before the Eid festival we
bought large amount of sugar because price of sugar was increased on the occasion
of Eid
iii
Annexure
Shah Kamal What are the main items of inventory of your firm
Yaseer Rizvi Well these are ndash aluminum can pet chip sugar label chemical and
artificial sweet
Shah Kamal What are the uncertainties in maintaining appropriate level of stock
Yaseer Rizvi These are ndash
bull Increase in price of raw materials
bull Sales uncertainty
bull Market trends etc
Shah Kamal Thank you for your kind cooperation
Yaseer Rizvi Most Welcome
iv
Global Beverage Company Limited
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
offer the same terms of sale to all customers For prime customers it offers special
terms of sale In setting an appropriate term of sale it costs and benefits regarding
this are compared It uses the standard approach of terms of sale decision as it is
simple to use
832 Credit Granting Decisions
In case of Virgin the Capital and Character of Five Cs get more importance
Although there are many problems with the traditional approach Virgin uses it
because of its simplicity Virgin does not use Net Present Value (NPV) method in
credit granting decision It thinks that NPV is an appropriate method and should be
used next time It does not face any severe problem because of bad debts The reason
is that notes receivable is used when credit is granted
833 Monitoring Accounts Receivable
Virgin monitors its accounts receivable Virgin believes that in any case both positive
and negative durations in accounts signal differences from the results that
management believe to be the most advantageous for the firm
Tools for Monitoring Accounts Receivable
Page 41 of 46
For monitoring accounts receivable there are several tools such as aging schedule
the ratios of receivable outstanding to original sales customers payment proportion
and sales weighted DSO (Days Sales Outstanding) For monitoring accounts
receivable Virgin uses aging schedule fractions and traditional DSO statistics
because of their simplicity in use Although payment proportions ratios of
receivables outstanding and sales weighted DSO methods are free from inherent bias
None of these is used because all these are complex to maintain
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
In summary
Page 42 of 46
Standard Compliance by Virgin Soft Drinks
Generals terms of sale is 210 net 30 Normally Virgin also use general terms
of sale ie 210 net 30
Firms do not offer the same terms of
sale to all customers
Yes For prime customers Virgin offers
special terms of sale
Approaches of terms of sale decisions
are ndash
bull Standard approach
bull Multi period approach
Virgin uses standard approach of terms
of sale decision as it is simple to use and
understand
Source of credit information are ndash
Sellers prior experience with the
customer
Credit agency ratings and
reports
Personal contact with the
applicants bank and other
creditors
Analysis of applicants financial
statements
Customer visit
Main source of credit information to
Virgin is its prior experience with the
customer All other sources are not cost-
effective for Virgin
Approaches of credit granting to
marginal accounts are ndash
Traditional approach
Net Present Value (NPV)
approach
It uses traditional approach still now but
thinks that NPV should be used for the
next periods
Firms monitor accounts receivable
because deviations from the expected
levels of turnover and of bad debt can
Virgin also monitors its accounts
receivable
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
signal several different problems
Different tools for monitoring accounts
receivable are ndash
Aging schedule
Ratios of receivables
outstanding to original sales
Customers payment
proportions
Sales-weighted DSO
For monitoring accounts receivable
Virgin uses aging schedule and
traditional sales outstanding statistics
84 MANAGING ACCOUNTS PAYABLE (CREDITORS)
Virgin has almost accounts payable of Tk 8000000 But most of its liabilities are to
the banks rather than suppliers But we dont have any clear information about
Virgins accounts payable
9 RECOMMENDATION
Virgin should invest its surplus cash in short term marketable securities
because it is suitable hedging against cash uncertainties and will also give
some returns (interest income)
Virgin should publish its own annual report which will satisfy information
needs of stakeholders and also increase the credibility of information provided
by Virgin
Page 43 of 46
Virgin should use multi period approach in terms of sale decision because
standard approach which is already exists in Virgin has some inherent
problems
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
It should stop using traditional approach from now It should use NPV
method in credit granting to marginal accounts
In monitoring accounts receivable Virgin should use sales-weighted DSO
method because it has least limitation compared to the others
It should be more flexible in granting credit which will ultimately increase its
sales
To get the appropriate number of quantity to be ordered per order it should
use DSO model
It should be ABC system for proper monitoring of inventory
10 CONCLUSION
The use of other peoples money in business is usually an expensive resource Before
looking outside for finance a firm should examine its own working capital cycle to
make sure that every rand of its own internal funds is being fully utilized Good
management of working capital is part of good financial management Effective use
of working capital will contribute to the operational efficiency of the whole
organization optimum use will help to generate maximum returns Furthermore
working capital management is not an end in itself It is an integral part of the firms
overall management The needs of efficient working capital management must be
considered in relation to other aspects of the Virgins financial and non-financial
performance Thats why when planning the development of a business it is critical
that the impact of working capital be fully assessed
Page 44 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
BIBLIOGRAPHY
Scherr FC (1989) International Edition Prentice-Hall International Inc Modern
Working Capital Management Text and Cases
Hussain Riaz (2002) Working Capital Management
Robertson Lonnie (July 1998) Inventory Management
httpwwwasashoporg visited on March 13 2006
The Art of Cash Management
httpwwwinccom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management
httpwwwstudyfinancecom visited on March 13 2006
White Paper ndash Managing Working Capital
httpwwwplanwareorg visited on March 13 2006
Management of Working Capital
httpwwwbusinesscentralcoza visited on March 13 2006
Cash Management
httpwwwsbagov visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management Objectives
httpwpsprenhallcom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management
Page 45 of 46
httpwwwadvancemecom visited on March 13 2006
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Business Receivables Financing
httpwwwbbtcom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Finance
http wwwfnbcoza visited on March 13 2006
Tips to manage your working capital
httpsmallbusinessninemsncomau visited on March 13 2006
Inventory Financing
httpwwwfranklincapitalnetworkcom visited on March 13 2006
Accounts Receivable Management
httpwwwfranklincapitalnetworkcom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management
httpwwwtreasurygovtnz visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management
httpwwwtreasurystrategiescom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Works
httpwwwinvestopediacom visited on March 13 2006
Treasury Services
httpwwwjpmorganchasecom visited on March 13 2006
what were about
Page 46 of 46
httpwwwvirgincom visited on March 13 2006
Annexure
Annexure
Interview with YASEER RIZVI
Mr Yaseer Rizvi the DMD of Global Beverage Co Ltd obtained his MBA degree
from a reputed university He had been the Director of Ocean Container Ltd before
joining in Global Beverage Co Ltd He possesses a nice personality
I interviewed Yaseer Rizvi Excerpts from his interview are as follows ndash
Shah Kamal Sir would you please tell me do you invest in short term marketable securities
Yaseer Rizvi Basically we do not invest our surplus cash in short term marketable
securities like T-Bill commercial paper certificate of deposit etc But we keep our
surplus cash in Bank
Shah Kamal Would you tell me something about transit time for a typical check
Yaseer Rizvi Well in Virgin the transit time for a typical check is ndash
For mail float 2 to 3 days
At firm float 6 hours
Clearing float 1 to 3 days
Shah Kamal Do you maintain any cash concentration mechanism like depository transfer check automated clearing house and wire transfer
i
Annexure
Yaseer Rizvi Our position in this case is very strong as we use all the mechanisms
you mentioned As Virgin is a firm with small deposits spread over a substantial
number of banks so we tend to use depository transfer checks extensively It is less
costly We also use automated clearing house and wire transfer but later is used in a
less extent
Shah Kamal Sir what techniques of disbursement management is used by your firm
Yaseer Rizvi Like other firms Virgin tries to retain the cash for as long as possible
But we always perform it in an ethical manner We do not use management of
disbursement float as it seems unethical We follow Zero-Balance Accounts method
for managing disbursement We do not prefer Controlled Disbursing method since
Zero-Balance system is already practiced in Virgin
Shah Kamal How do you hedge cash balance uncertainties
Yaseer Rizvi Well you may say that we do not invest in short term securities but for
facing cash difficulties we keep our surplus cash in bank
Shah Kamal Sir would you please tell me the general terms of sale of Virgin
Yaseer Rizvi Though it is difficult to maintain a fixed terms of sale our general terms
of sale is 210 n30 But for prime customers we offer special terms of sale
Shah Kamal What are the sources of credit information in case of your firm
Yaseer Rizvi We grant credit on the basis of prior experience with the customers In
case of a new customer personal contact is weighted
Shah Kamal Does your firm consider 5 Cs in granting credit
ii
Annexure
Yaseer Rizvi In case of Virgin Capital and Character get more importance than the
others Mind one thing personal relationship is the main measure in granting credit
Shah Kamal Do you use NPV method in credit granting decisions
Yaseer Rizvi We do not use NPV method But we think that NPV is a suitable
method and we have to use it from the next period
Shah Kamal Sir how do you handle the problem of bad debt
Yaseer Rizvi Well in this case our position is very strong Yet we do not face any
problem because of bad debt Just note that we make more than 80 of sales in cash
and we monitor accounts receivable very carefully
Shah Kamal What level of inventory is maintained by Virgin
Yaseer Rizvi We maintain a minimum level of inventory but do not have to face
stock out problems because inventory is managed efficiently
Shah Kamal What is the normal lead time
Yaseer Rizvi In case of imported goods normal lead time is about 1 month and when
we purchase raw materials from inside the country lead time is 1 to 3 days
Shah Kamal What method do you use for managing inventory
Yaseer Rizvi We do not use any method particularly rather inventory decision
depends on business cycle and market situation Long before the Eid festival we
bought large amount of sugar because price of sugar was increased on the occasion
of Eid
iii
Annexure
Shah Kamal What are the main items of inventory of your firm
Yaseer Rizvi Well these are ndash aluminum can pet chip sugar label chemical and
artificial sweet
Shah Kamal What are the uncertainties in maintaining appropriate level of stock
Yaseer Rizvi These are ndash
bull Increase in price of raw materials
bull Sales uncertainty
bull Market trends etc
Shah Kamal Thank you for your kind cooperation
Yaseer Rizvi Most Welcome
iv
Global Beverage Company Limited
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
In summary
Page 42 of 46
Standard Compliance by Virgin Soft Drinks
Generals terms of sale is 210 net 30 Normally Virgin also use general terms
of sale ie 210 net 30
Firms do not offer the same terms of
sale to all customers
Yes For prime customers Virgin offers
special terms of sale
Approaches of terms of sale decisions
are ndash
bull Standard approach
bull Multi period approach
Virgin uses standard approach of terms
of sale decision as it is simple to use and
understand
Source of credit information are ndash
Sellers prior experience with the
customer
Credit agency ratings and
reports
Personal contact with the
applicants bank and other
creditors
Analysis of applicants financial
statements
Customer visit
Main source of credit information to
Virgin is its prior experience with the
customer All other sources are not cost-
effective for Virgin
Approaches of credit granting to
marginal accounts are ndash
Traditional approach
Net Present Value (NPV)
approach
It uses traditional approach still now but
thinks that NPV should be used for the
next periods
Firms monitor accounts receivable
because deviations from the expected
levels of turnover and of bad debt can
Virgin also monitors its accounts
receivable
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
signal several different problems
Different tools for monitoring accounts
receivable are ndash
Aging schedule
Ratios of receivables
outstanding to original sales
Customers payment
proportions
Sales-weighted DSO
For monitoring accounts receivable
Virgin uses aging schedule and
traditional sales outstanding statistics
84 MANAGING ACCOUNTS PAYABLE (CREDITORS)
Virgin has almost accounts payable of Tk 8000000 But most of its liabilities are to
the banks rather than suppliers But we dont have any clear information about
Virgins accounts payable
9 RECOMMENDATION
Virgin should invest its surplus cash in short term marketable securities
because it is suitable hedging against cash uncertainties and will also give
some returns (interest income)
Virgin should publish its own annual report which will satisfy information
needs of stakeholders and also increase the credibility of information provided
by Virgin
Page 43 of 46
Virgin should use multi period approach in terms of sale decision because
standard approach which is already exists in Virgin has some inherent
problems
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
It should stop using traditional approach from now It should use NPV
method in credit granting to marginal accounts
In monitoring accounts receivable Virgin should use sales-weighted DSO
method because it has least limitation compared to the others
It should be more flexible in granting credit which will ultimately increase its
sales
To get the appropriate number of quantity to be ordered per order it should
use DSO model
It should be ABC system for proper monitoring of inventory
10 CONCLUSION
The use of other peoples money in business is usually an expensive resource Before
looking outside for finance a firm should examine its own working capital cycle to
make sure that every rand of its own internal funds is being fully utilized Good
management of working capital is part of good financial management Effective use
of working capital will contribute to the operational efficiency of the whole
organization optimum use will help to generate maximum returns Furthermore
working capital management is not an end in itself It is an integral part of the firms
overall management The needs of efficient working capital management must be
considered in relation to other aspects of the Virgins financial and non-financial
performance Thats why when planning the development of a business it is critical
that the impact of working capital be fully assessed
Page 44 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
BIBLIOGRAPHY
Scherr FC (1989) International Edition Prentice-Hall International Inc Modern
Working Capital Management Text and Cases
Hussain Riaz (2002) Working Capital Management
Robertson Lonnie (July 1998) Inventory Management
httpwwwasashoporg visited on March 13 2006
The Art of Cash Management
httpwwwinccom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management
httpwwwstudyfinancecom visited on March 13 2006
White Paper ndash Managing Working Capital
httpwwwplanwareorg visited on March 13 2006
Management of Working Capital
httpwwwbusinesscentralcoza visited on March 13 2006
Cash Management
httpwwwsbagov visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management Objectives
httpwpsprenhallcom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management
Page 45 of 46
httpwwwadvancemecom visited on March 13 2006
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Business Receivables Financing
httpwwwbbtcom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Finance
http wwwfnbcoza visited on March 13 2006
Tips to manage your working capital
httpsmallbusinessninemsncomau visited on March 13 2006
Inventory Financing
httpwwwfranklincapitalnetworkcom visited on March 13 2006
Accounts Receivable Management
httpwwwfranklincapitalnetworkcom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management
httpwwwtreasurygovtnz visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management
httpwwwtreasurystrategiescom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Works
httpwwwinvestopediacom visited on March 13 2006
Treasury Services
httpwwwjpmorganchasecom visited on March 13 2006
what were about
Page 46 of 46
httpwwwvirgincom visited on March 13 2006
Annexure
Annexure
Interview with YASEER RIZVI
Mr Yaseer Rizvi the DMD of Global Beverage Co Ltd obtained his MBA degree
from a reputed university He had been the Director of Ocean Container Ltd before
joining in Global Beverage Co Ltd He possesses a nice personality
I interviewed Yaseer Rizvi Excerpts from his interview are as follows ndash
Shah Kamal Sir would you please tell me do you invest in short term marketable securities
Yaseer Rizvi Basically we do not invest our surplus cash in short term marketable
securities like T-Bill commercial paper certificate of deposit etc But we keep our
surplus cash in Bank
Shah Kamal Would you tell me something about transit time for a typical check
Yaseer Rizvi Well in Virgin the transit time for a typical check is ndash
For mail float 2 to 3 days
At firm float 6 hours
Clearing float 1 to 3 days
Shah Kamal Do you maintain any cash concentration mechanism like depository transfer check automated clearing house and wire transfer
i
Annexure
Yaseer Rizvi Our position in this case is very strong as we use all the mechanisms
you mentioned As Virgin is a firm with small deposits spread over a substantial
number of banks so we tend to use depository transfer checks extensively It is less
costly We also use automated clearing house and wire transfer but later is used in a
less extent
Shah Kamal Sir what techniques of disbursement management is used by your firm
Yaseer Rizvi Like other firms Virgin tries to retain the cash for as long as possible
But we always perform it in an ethical manner We do not use management of
disbursement float as it seems unethical We follow Zero-Balance Accounts method
for managing disbursement We do not prefer Controlled Disbursing method since
Zero-Balance system is already practiced in Virgin
Shah Kamal How do you hedge cash balance uncertainties
Yaseer Rizvi Well you may say that we do not invest in short term securities but for
facing cash difficulties we keep our surplus cash in bank
Shah Kamal Sir would you please tell me the general terms of sale of Virgin
Yaseer Rizvi Though it is difficult to maintain a fixed terms of sale our general terms
of sale is 210 n30 But for prime customers we offer special terms of sale
Shah Kamal What are the sources of credit information in case of your firm
Yaseer Rizvi We grant credit on the basis of prior experience with the customers In
case of a new customer personal contact is weighted
Shah Kamal Does your firm consider 5 Cs in granting credit
ii
Annexure
Yaseer Rizvi In case of Virgin Capital and Character get more importance than the
others Mind one thing personal relationship is the main measure in granting credit
Shah Kamal Do you use NPV method in credit granting decisions
Yaseer Rizvi We do not use NPV method But we think that NPV is a suitable
method and we have to use it from the next period
Shah Kamal Sir how do you handle the problem of bad debt
Yaseer Rizvi Well in this case our position is very strong Yet we do not face any
problem because of bad debt Just note that we make more than 80 of sales in cash
and we monitor accounts receivable very carefully
Shah Kamal What level of inventory is maintained by Virgin
Yaseer Rizvi We maintain a minimum level of inventory but do not have to face
stock out problems because inventory is managed efficiently
Shah Kamal What is the normal lead time
Yaseer Rizvi In case of imported goods normal lead time is about 1 month and when
we purchase raw materials from inside the country lead time is 1 to 3 days
Shah Kamal What method do you use for managing inventory
Yaseer Rizvi We do not use any method particularly rather inventory decision
depends on business cycle and market situation Long before the Eid festival we
bought large amount of sugar because price of sugar was increased on the occasion
of Eid
iii
Annexure
Shah Kamal What are the main items of inventory of your firm
Yaseer Rizvi Well these are ndash aluminum can pet chip sugar label chemical and
artificial sweet
Shah Kamal What are the uncertainties in maintaining appropriate level of stock
Yaseer Rizvi These are ndash
bull Increase in price of raw materials
bull Sales uncertainty
bull Market trends etc
Shah Kamal Thank you for your kind cooperation
Yaseer Rizvi Most Welcome
iv
Global Beverage Company Limited
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
signal several different problems
Different tools for monitoring accounts
receivable are ndash
Aging schedule
Ratios of receivables
outstanding to original sales
Customers payment
proportions
Sales-weighted DSO
For monitoring accounts receivable
Virgin uses aging schedule and
traditional sales outstanding statistics
84 MANAGING ACCOUNTS PAYABLE (CREDITORS)
Virgin has almost accounts payable of Tk 8000000 But most of its liabilities are to
the banks rather than suppliers But we dont have any clear information about
Virgins accounts payable
9 RECOMMENDATION
Virgin should invest its surplus cash in short term marketable securities
because it is suitable hedging against cash uncertainties and will also give
some returns (interest income)
Virgin should publish its own annual report which will satisfy information
needs of stakeholders and also increase the credibility of information provided
by Virgin
Page 43 of 46
Virgin should use multi period approach in terms of sale decision because
standard approach which is already exists in Virgin has some inherent
problems
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
It should stop using traditional approach from now It should use NPV
method in credit granting to marginal accounts
In monitoring accounts receivable Virgin should use sales-weighted DSO
method because it has least limitation compared to the others
It should be more flexible in granting credit which will ultimately increase its
sales
To get the appropriate number of quantity to be ordered per order it should
use DSO model
It should be ABC system for proper monitoring of inventory
10 CONCLUSION
The use of other peoples money in business is usually an expensive resource Before
looking outside for finance a firm should examine its own working capital cycle to
make sure that every rand of its own internal funds is being fully utilized Good
management of working capital is part of good financial management Effective use
of working capital will contribute to the operational efficiency of the whole
organization optimum use will help to generate maximum returns Furthermore
working capital management is not an end in itself It is an integral part of the firms
overall management The needs of efficient working capital management must be
considered in relation to other aspects of the Virgins financial and non-financial
performance Thats why when planning the development of a business it is critical
that the impact of working capital be fully assessed
Page 44 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
BIBLIOGRAPHY
Scherr FC (1989) International Edition Prentice-Hall International Inc Modern
Working Capital Management Text and Cases
Hussain Riaz (2002) Working Capital Management
Robertson Lonnie (July 1998) Inventory Management
httpwwwasashoporg visited on March 13 2006
The Art of Cash Management
httpwwwinccom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management
httpwwwstudyfinancecom visited on March 13 2006
White Paper ndash Managing Working Capital
httpwwwplanwareorg visited on March 13 2006
Management of Working Capital
httpwwwbusinesscentralcoza visited on March 13 2006
Cash Management
httpwwwsbagov visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management Objectives
httpwpsprenhallcom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management
Page 45 of 46
httpwwwadvancemecom visited on March 13 2006
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Business Receivables Financing
httpwwwbbtcom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Finance
http wwwfnbcoza visited on March 13 2006
Tips to manage your working capital
httpsmallbusinessninemsncomau visited on March 13 2006
Inventory Financing
httpwwwfranklincapitalnetworkcom visited on March 13 2006
Accounts Receivable Management
httpwwwfranklincapitalnetworkcom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management
httpwwwtreasurygovtnz visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management
httpwwwtreasurystrategiescom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Works
httpwwwinvestopediacom visited on March 13 2006
Treasury Services
httpwwwjpmorganchasecom visited on March 13 2006
what were about
Page 46 of 46
httpwwwvirgincom visited on March 13 2006
Annexure
Annexure
Interview with YASEER RIZVI
Mr Yaseer Rizvi the DMD of Global Beverage Co Ltd obtained his MBA degree
from a reputed university He had been the Director of Ocean Container Ltd before
joining in Global Beverage Co Ltd He possesses a nice personality
I interviewed Yaseer Rizvi Excerpts from his interview are as follows ndash
Shah Kamal Sir would you please tell me do you invest in short term marketable securities
Yaseer Rizvi Basically we do not invest our surplus cash in short term marketable
securities like T-Bill commercial paper certificate of deposit etc But we keep our
surplus cash in Bank
Shah Kamal Would you tell me something about transit time for a typical check
Yaseer Rizvi Well in Virgin the transit time for a typical check is ndash
For mail float 2 to 3 days
At firm float 6 hours
Clearing float 1 to 3 days
Shah Kamal Do you maintain any cash concentration mechanism like depository transfer check automated clearing house and wire transfer
i
Annexure
Yaseer Rizvi Our position in this case is very strong as we use all the mechanisms
you mentioned As Virgin is a firm with small deposits spread over a substantial
number of banks so we tend to use depository transfer checks extensively It is less
costly We also use automated clearing house and wire transfer but later is used in a
less extent
Shah Kamal Sir what techniques of disbursement management is used by your firm
Yaseer Rizvi Like other firms Virgin tries to retain the cash for as long as possible
But we always perform it in an ethical manner We do not use management of
disbursement float as it seems unethical We follow Zero-Balance Accounts method
for managing disbursement We do not prefer Controlled Disbursing method since
Zero-Balance system is already practiced in Virgin
Shah Kamal How do you hedge cash balance uncertainties
Yaseer Rizvi Well you may say that we do not invest in short term securities but for
facing cash difficulties we keep our surplus cash in bank
Shah Kamal Sir would you please tell me the general terms of sale of Virgin
Yaseer Rizvi Though it is difficult to maintain a fixed terms of sale our general terms
of sale is 210 n30 But for prime customers we offer special terms of sale
Shah Kamal What are the sources of credit information in case of your firm
Yaseer Rizvi We grant credit on the basis of prior experience with the customers In
case of a new customer personal contact is weighted
Shah Kamal Does your firm consider 5 Cs in granting credit
ii
Annexure
Yaseer Rizvi In case of Virgin Capital and Character get more importance than the
others Mind one thing personal relationship is the main measure in granting credit
Shah Kamal Do you use NPV method in credit granting decisions
Yaseer Rizvi We do not use NPV method But we think that NPV is a suitable
method and we have to use it from the next period
Shah Kamal Sir how do you handle the problem of bad debt
Yaseer Rizvi Well in this case our position is very strong Yet we do not face any
problem because of bad debt Just note that we make more than 80 of sales in cash
and we monitor accounts receivable very carefully
Shah Kamal What level of inventory is maintained by Virgin
Yaseer Rizvi We maintain a minimum level of inventory but do not have to face
stock out problems because inventory is managed efficiently
Shah Kamal What is the normal lead time
Yaseer Rizvi In case of imported goods normal lead time is about 1 month and when
we purchase raw materials from inside the country lead time is 1 to 3 days
Shah Kamal What method do you use for managing inventory
Yaseer Rizvi We do not use any method particularly rather inventory decision
depends on business cycle and market situation Long before the Eid festival we
bought large amount of sugar because price of sugar was increased on the occasion
of Eid
iii
Annexure
Shah Kamal What are the main items of inventory of your firm
Yaseer Rizvi Well these are ndash aluminum can pet chip sugar label chemical and
artificial sweet
Shah Kamal What are the uncertainties in maintaining appropriate level of stock
Yaseer Rizvi These are ndash
bull Increase in price of raw materials
bull Sales uncertainty
bull Market trends etc
Shah Kamal Thank you for your kind cooperation
Yaseer Rizvi Most Welcome
iv
Global Beverage Company Limited
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
It should stop using traditional approach from now It should use NPV
method in credit granting to marginal accounts
In monitoring accounts receivable Virgin should use sales-weighted DSO
method because it has least limitation compared to the others
It should be more flexible in granting credit which will ultimately increase its
sales
To get the appropriate number of quantity to be ordered per order it should
use DSO model
It should be ABC system for proper monitoring of inventory
10 CONCLUSION
The use of other peoples money in business is usually an expensive resource Before
looking outside for finance a firm should examine its own working capital cycle to
make sure that every rand of its own internal funds is being fully utilized Good
management of working capital is part of good financial management Effective use
of working capital will contribute to the operational efficiency of the whole
organization optimum use will help to generate maximum returns Furthermore
working capital management is not an end in itself It is an integral part of the firms
overall management The needs of efficient working capital management must be
considered in relation to other aspects of the Virgins financial and non-financial
performance Thats why when planning the development of a business it is critical
that the impact of working capital be fully assessed
Page 44 of 46
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
BIBLIOGRAPHY
Scherr FC (1989) International Edition Prentice-Hall International Inc Modern
Working Capital Management Text and Cases
Hussain Riaz (2002) Working Capital Management
Robertson Lonnie (July 1998) Inventory Management
httpwwwasashoporg visited on March 13 2006
The Art of Cash Management
httpwwwinccom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management
httpwwwstudyfinancecom visited on March 13 2006
White Paper ndash Managing Working Capital
httpwwwplanwareorg visited on March 13 2006
Management of Working Capital
httpwwwbusinesscentralcoza visited on March 13 2006
Cash Management
httpwwwsbagov visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management Objectives
httpwpsprenhallcom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management
Page 45 of 46
httpwwwadvancemecom visited on March 13 2006
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Business Receivables Financing
httpwwwbbtcom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Finance
http wwwfnbcoza visited on March 13 2006
Tips to manage your working capital
httpsmallbusinessninemsncomau visited on March 13 2006
Inventory Financing
httpwwwfranklincapitalnetworkcom visited on March 13 2006
Accounts Receivable Management
httpwwwfranklincapitalnetworkcom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management
httpwwwtreasurygovtnz visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management
httpwwwtreasurystrategiescom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Works
httpwwwinvestopediacom visited on March 13 2006
Treasury Services
httpwwwjpmorganchasecom visited on March 13 2006
what were about
Page 46 of 46
httpwwwvirgincom visited on March 13 2006
Annexure
Annexure
Interview with YASEER RIZVI
Mr Yaseer Rizvi the DMD of Global Beverage Co Ltd obtained his MBA degree
from a reputed university He had been the Director of Ocean Container Ltd before
joining in Global Beverage Co Ltd He possesses a nice personality
I interviewed Yaseer Rizvi Excerpts from his interview are as follows ndash
Shah Kamal Sir would you please tell me do you invest in short term marketable securities
Yaseer Rizvi Basically we do not invest our surplus cash in short term marketable
securities like T-Bill commercial paper certificate of deposit etc But we keep our
surplus cash in Bank
Shah Kamal Would you tell me something about transit time for a typical check
Yaseer Rizvi Well in Virgin the transit time for a typical check is ndash
For mail float 2 to 3 days
At firm float 6 hours
Clearing float 1 to 3 days
Shah Kamal Do you maintain any cash concentration mechanism like depository transfer check automated clearing house and wire transfer
i
Annexure
Yaseer Rizvi Our position in this case is very strong as we use all the mechanisms
you mentioned As Virgin is a firm with small deposits spread over a substantial
number of banks so we tend to use depository transfer checks extensively It is less
costly We also use automated clearing house and wire transfer but later is used in a
less extent
Shah Kamal Sir what techniques of disbursement management is used by your firm
Yaseer Rizvi Like other firms Virgin tries to retain the cash for as long as possible
But we always perform it in an ethical manner We do not use management of
disbursement float as it seems unethical We follow Zero-Balance Accounts method
for managing disbursement We do not prefer Controlled Disbursing method since
Zero-Balance system is already practiced in Virgin
Shah Kamal How do you hedge cash balance uncertainties
Yaseer Rizvi Well you may say that we do not invest in short term securities but for
facing cash difficulties we keep our surplus cash in bank
Shah Kamal Sir would you please tell me the general terms of sale of Virgin
Yaseer Rizvi Though it is difficult to maintain a fixed terms of sale our general terms
of sale is 210 n30 But for prime customers we offer special terms of sale
Shah Kamal What are the sources of credit information in case of your firm
Yaseer Rizvi We grant credit on the basis of prior experience with the customers In
case of a new customer personal contact is weighted
Shah Kamal Does your firm consider 5 Cs in granting credit
ii
Annexure
Yaseer Rizvi In case of Virgin Capital and Character get more importance than the
others Mind one thing personal relationship is the main measure in granting credit
Shah Kamal Do you use NPV method in credit granting decisions
Yaseer Rizvi We do not use NPV method But we think that NPV is a suitable
method and we have to use it from the next period
Shah Kamal Sir how do you handle the problem of bad debt
Yaseer Rizvi Well in this case our position is very strong Yet we do not face any
problem because of bad debt Just note that we make more than 80 of sales in cash
and we monitor accounts receivable very carefully
Shah Kamal What level of inventory is maintained by Virgin
Yaseer Rizvi We maintain a minimum level of inventory but do not have to face
stock out problems because inventory is managed efficiently
Shah Kamal What is the normal lead time
Yaseer Rizvi In case of imported goods normal lead time is about 1 month and when
we purchase raw materials from inside the country lead time is 1 to 3 days
Shah Kamal What method do you use for managing inventory
Yaseer Rizvi We do not use any method particularly rather inventory decision
depends on business cycle and market situation Long before the Eid festival we
bought large amount of sugar because price of sugar was increased on the occasion
of Eid
iii
Annexure
Shah Kamal What are the main items of inventory of your firm
Yaseer Rizvi Well these are ndash aluminum can pet chip sugar label chemical and
artificial sweet
Shah Kamal What are the uncertainties in maintaining appropriate level of stock
Yaseer Rizvi These are ndash
bull Increase in price of raw materials
bull Sales uncertainty
bull Market trends etc
Shah Kamal Thank you for your kind cooperation
Yaseer Rizvi Most Welcome
iv
Global Beverage Company Limited
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
BIBLIOGRAPHY
Scherr FC (1989) International Edition Prentice-Hall International Inc Modern
Working Capital Management Text and Cases
Hussain Riaz (2002) Working Capital Management
Robertson Lonnie (July 1998) Inventory Management
httpwwwasashoporg visited on March 13 2006
The Art of Cash Management
httpwwwinccom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management
httpwwwstudyfinancecom visited on March 13 2006
White Paper ndash Managing Working Capital
httpwwwplanwareorg visited on March 13 2006
Management of Working Capital
httpwwwbusinesscentralcoza visited on March 13 2006
Cash Management
httpwwwsbagov visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management Objectives
httpwpsprenhallcom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management
Page 45 of 46
httpwwwadvancemecom visited on March 13 2006
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Business Receivables Financing
httpwwwbbtcom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Finance
http wwwfnbcoza visited on March 13 2006
Tips to manage your working capital
httpsmallbusinessninemsncomau visited on March 13 2006
Inventory Financing
httpwwwfranklincapitalnetworkcom visited on March 13 2006
Accounts Receivable Management
httpwwwfranklincapitalnetworkcom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management
httpwwwtreasurygovtnz visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management
httpwwwtreasurystrategiescom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Works
httpwwwinvestopediacom visited on March 13 2006
Treasury Services
httpwwwjpmorganchasecom visited on March 13 2006
what were about
Page 46 of 46
httpwwwvirgincom visited on March 13 2006
Annexure
Annexure
Interview with YASEER RIZVI
Mr Yaseer Rizvi the DMD of Global Beverage Co Ltd obtained his MBA degree
from a reputed university He had been the Director of Ocean Container Ltd before
joining in Global Beverage Co Ltd He possesses a nice personality
I interviewed Yaseer Rizvi Excerpts from his interview are as follows ndash
Shah Kamal Sir would you please tell me do you invest in short term marketable securities
Yaseer Rizvi Basically we do not invest our surplus cash in short term marketable
securities like T-Bill commercial paper certificate of deposit etc But we keep our
surplus cash in Bank
Shah Kamal Would you tell me something about transit time for a typical check
Yaseer Rizvi Well in Virgin the transit time for a typical check is ndash
For mail float 2 to 3 days
At firm float 6 hours
Clearing float 1 to 3 days
Shah Kamal Do you maintain any cash concentration mechanism like depository transfer check automated clearing house and wire transfer
i
Annexure
Yaseer Rizvi Our position in this case is very strong as we use all the mechanisms
you mentioned As Virgin is a firm with small deposits spread over a substantial
number of banks so we tend to use depository transfer checks extensively It is less
costly We also use automated clearing house and wire transfer but later is used in a
less extent
Shah Kamal Sir what techniques of disbursement management is used by your firm
Yaseer Rizvi Like other firms Virgin tries to retain the cash for as long as possible
But we always perform it in an ethical manner We do not use management of
disbursement float as it seems unethical We follow Zero-Balance Accounts method
for managing disbursement We do not prefer Controlled Disbursing method since
Zero-Balance system is already practiced in Virgin
Shah Kamal How do you hedge cash balance uncertainties
Yaseer Rizvi Well you may say that we do not invest in short term securities but for
facing cash difficulties we keep our surplus cash in bank
Shah Kamal Sir would you please tell me the general terms of sale of Virgin
Yaseer Rizvi Though it is difficult to maintain a fixed terms of sale our general terms
of sale is 210 n30 But for prime customers we offer special terms of sale
Shah Kamal What are the sources of credit information in case of your firm
Yaseer Rizvi We grant credit on the basis of prior experience with the customers In
case of a new customer personal contact is weighted
Shah Kamal Does your firm consider 5 Cs in granting credit
ii
Annexure
Yaseer Rizvi In case of Virgin Capital and Character get more importance than the
others Mind one thing personal relationship is the main measure in granting credit
Shah Kamal Do you use NPV method in credit granting decisions
Yaseer Rizvi We do not use NPV method But we think that NPV is a suitable
method and we have to use it from the next period
Shah Kamal Sir how do you handle the problem of bad debt
Yaseer Rizvi Well in this case our position is very strong Yet we do not face any
problem because of bad debt Just note that we make more than 80 of sales in cash
and we monitor accounts receivable very carefully
Shah Kamal What level of inventory is maintained by Virgin
Yaseer Rizvi We maintain a minimum level of inventory but do not have to face
stock out problems because inventory is managed efficiently
Shah Kamal What is the normal lead time
Yaseer Rizvi In case of imported goods normal lead time is about 1 month and when
we purchase raw materials from inside the country lead time is 1 to 3 days
Shah Kamal What method do you use for managing inventory
Yaseer Rizvi We do not use any method particularly rather inventory decision
depends on business cycle and market situation Long before the Eid festival we
bought large amount of sugar because price of sugar was increased on the occasion
of Eid
iii
Annexure
Shah Kamal What are the main items of inventory of your firm
Yaseer Rizvi Well these are ndash aluminum can pet chip sugar label chemical and
artificial sweet
Shah Kamal What are the uncertainties in maintaining appropriate level of stock
Yaseer Rizvi These are ndash
bull Increase in price of raw materials
bull Sales uncertainty
bull Market trends etc
Shah Kamal Thank you for your kind cooperation
Yaseer Rizvi Most Welcome
iv
Global Beverage Company Limited
Virgin Soft Drinks Working Capital Management
Business Receivables Financing
httpwwwbbtcom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Finance
http wwwfnbcoza visited on March 13 2006
Tips to manage your working capital
httpsmallbusinessninemsncomau visited on March 13 2006
Inventory Financing
httpwwwfranklincapitalnetworkcom visited on March 13 2006
Accounts Receivable Management
httpwwwfranklincapitalnetworkcom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management
httpwwwtreasurygovtnz visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Management
httpwwwtreasurystrategiescom visited on March 13 2006
Working Capital Works
httpwwwinvestopediacom visited on March 13 2006
Treasury Services
httpwwwjpmorganchasecom visited on March 13 2006
what were about
Page 46 of 46
httpwwwvirgincom visited on March 13 2006
Annexure
Annexure
Interview with YASEER RIZVI
Mr Yaseer Rizvi the DMD of Global Beverage Co Ltd obtained his MBA degree
from a reputed university He had been the Director of Ocean Container Ltd before
joining in Global Beverage Co Ltd He possesses a nice personality
I interviewed Yaseer Rizvi Excerpts from his interview are as follows ndash
Shah Kamal Sir would you please tell me do you invest in short term marketable securities
Yaseer Rizvi Basically we do not invest our surplus cash in short term marketable
securities like T-Bill commercial paper certificate of deposit etc But we keep our
surplus cash in Bank
Shah Kamal Would you tell me something about transit time for a typical check
Yaseer Rizvi Well in Virgin the transit time for a typical check is ndash
For mail float 2 to 3 days
At firm float 6 hours
Clearing float 1 to 3 days
Shah Kamal Do you maintain any cash concentration mechanism like depository transfer check automated clearing house and wire transfer
i
Annexure
Yaseer Rizvi Our position in this case is very strong as we use all the mechanisms
you mentioned As Virgin is a firm with small deposits spread over a substantial
number of banks so we tend to use depository transfer checks extensively It is less
costly We also use automated clearing house and wire transfer but later is used in a
less extent
Shah Kamal Sir what techniques of disbursement management is used by your firm
Yaseer Rizvi Like other firms Virgin tries to retain the cash for as long as possible
But we always perform it in an ethical manner We do not use management of
disbursement float as it seems unethical We follow Zero-Balance Accounts method
for managing disbursement We do not prefer Controlled Disbursing method since
Zero-Balance system is already practiced in Virgin
Shah Kamal How do you hedge cash balance uncertainties
Yaseer Rizvi Well you may say that we do not invest in short term securities but for
facing cash difficulties we keep our surplus cash in bank
Shah Kamal Sir would you please tell me the general terms of sale of Virgin
Yaseer Rizvi Though it is difficult to maintain a fixed terms of sale our general terms
of sale is 210 n30 But for prime customers we offer special terms of sale
Shah Kamal What are the sources of credit information in case of your firm
Yaseer Rizvi We grant credit on the basis of prior experience with the customers In
case of a new customer personal contact is weighted
Shah Kamal Does your firm consider 5 Cs in granting credit
ii
Annexure
Yaseer Rizvi In case of Virgin Capital and Character get more importance than the
others Mind one thing personal relationship is the main measure in granting credit
Shah Kamal Do you use NPV method in credit granting decisions
Yaseer Rizvi We do not use NPV method But we think that NPV is a suitable
method and we have to use it from the next period
Shah Kamal Sir how do you handle the problem of bad debt
Yaseer Rizvi Well in this case our position is very strong Yet we do not face any
problem because of bad debt Just note that we make more than 80 of sales in cash
and we monitor accounts receivable very carefully
Shah Kamal What level of inventory is maintained by Virgin
Yaseer Rizvi We maintain a minimum level of inventory but do not have to face
stock out problems because inventory is managed efficiently
Shah Kamal What is the normal lead time
Yaseer Rizvi In case of imported goods normal lead time is about 1 month and when
we purchase raw materials from inside the country lead time is 1 to 3 days
Shah Kamal What method do you use for managing inventory
Yaseer Rizvi We do not use any method particularly rather inventory decision
depends on business cycle and market situation Long before the Eid festival we
bought large amount of sugar because price of sugar was increased on the occasion
of Eid
iii
Annexure
Shah Kamal What are the main items of inventory of your firm
Yaseer Rizvi Well these are ndash aluminum can pet chip sugar label chemical and
artificial sweet
Shah Kamal What are the uncertainties in maintaining appropriate level of stock
Yaseer Rizvi These are ndash
bull Increase in price of raw materials
bull Sales uncertainty
bull Market trends etc
Shah Kamal Thank you for your kind cooperation
Yaseer Rizvi Most Welcome
iv
Global Beverage Company Limited
Annexure
Annexure
Interview with YASEER RIZVI
Mr Yaseer Rizvi the DMD of Global Beverage Co Ltd obtained his MBA degree
from a reputed university He had been the Director of Ocean Container Ltd before
joining in Global Beverage Co Ltd He possesses a nice personality
I interviewed Yaseer Rizvi Excerpts from his interview are as follows ndash
Shah Kamal Sir would you please tell me do you invest in short term marketable securities
Yaseer Rizvi Basically we do not invest our surplus cash in short term marketable
securities like T-Bill commercial paper certificate of deposit etc But we keep our
surplus cash in Bank
Shah Kamal Would you tell me something about transit time for a typical check
Yaseer Rizvi Well in Virgin the transit time for a typical check is ndash
For mail float 2 to 3 days
At firm float 6 hours
Clearing float 1 to 3 days
Shah Kamal Do you maintain any cash concentration mechanism like depository transfer check automated clearing house and wire transfer
i
Annexure
Yaseer Rizvi Our position in this case is very strong as we use all the mechanisms
you mentioned As Virgin is a firm with small deposits spread over a substantial
number of banks so we tend to use depository transfer checks extensively It is less
costly We also use automated clearing house and wire transfer but later is used in a
less extent
Shah Kamal Sir what techniques of disbursement management is used by your firm
Yaseer Rizvi Like other firms Virgin tries to retain the cash for as long as possible
But we always perform it in an ethical manner We do not use management of
disbursement float as it seems unethical We follow Zero-Balance Accounts method
for managing disbursement We do not prefer Controlled Disbursing method since
Zero-Balance system is already practiced in Virgin
Shah Kamal How do you hedge cash balance uncertainties
Yaseer Rizvi Well you may say that we do not invest in short term securities but for
facing cash difficulties we keep our surplus cash in bank
Shah Kamal Sir would you please tell me the general terms of sale of Virgin
Yaseer Rizvi Though it is difficult to maintain a fixed terms of sale our general terms
of sale is 210 n30 But for prime customers we offer special terms of sale
Shah Kamal What are the sources of credit information in case of your firm
Yaseer Rizvi We grant credit on the basis of prior experience with the customers In
case of a new customer personal contact is weighted
Shah Kamal Does your firm consider 5 Cs in granting credit
ii
Annexure
Yaseer Rizvi In case of Virgin Capital and Character get more importance than the
others Mind one thing personal relationship is the main measure in granting credit
Shah Kamal Do you use NPV method in credit granting decisions
Yaseer Rizvi We do not use NPV method But we think that NPV is a suitable
method and we have to use it from the next period
Shah Kamal Sir how do you handle the problem of bad debt
Yaseer Rizvi Well in this case our position is very strong Yet we do not face any
problem because of bad debt Just note that we make more than 80 of sales in cash
and we monitor accounts receivable very carefully
Shah Kamal What level of inventory is maintained by Virgin
Yaseer Rizvi We maintain a minimum level of inventory but do not have to face
stock out problems because inventory is managed efficiently
Shah Kamal What is the normal lead time
Yaseer Rizvi In case of imported goods normal lead time is about 1 month and when
we purchase raw materials from inside the country lead time is 1 to 3 days
Shah Kamal What method do you use for managing inventory
Yaseer Rizvi We do not use any method particularly rather inventory decision
depends on business cycle and market situation Long before the Eid festival we
bought large amount of sugar because price of sugar was increased on the occasion
of Eid
iii
Annexure
Shah Kamal What are the main items of inventory of your firm
Yaseer Rizvi Well these are ndash aluminum can pet chip sugar label chemical and
artificial sweet
Shah Kamal What are the uncertainties in maintaining appropriate level of stock
Yaseer Rizvi These are ndash
bull Increase in price of raw materials
bull Sales uncertainty
bull Market trends etc
Shah Kamal Thank you for your kind cooperation
Yaseer Rizvi Most Welcome
iv
Global Beverage Company Limited
Annexure
Yaseer Rizvi Our position in this case is very strong as we use all the mechanisms
you mentioned As Virgin is a firm with small deposits spread over a substantial
number of banks so we tend to use depository transfer checks extensively It is less
costly We also use automated clearing house and wire transfer but later is used in a
less extent
Shah Kamal Sir what techniques of disbursement management is used by your firm
Yaseer Rizvi Like other firms Virgin tries to retain the cash for as long as possible
But we always perform it in an ethical manner We do not use management of
disbursement float as it seems unethical We follow Zero-Balance Accounts method
for managing disbursement We do not prefer Controlled Disbursing method since
Zero-Balance system is already practiced in Virgin
Shah Kamal How do you hedge cash balance uncertainties
Yaseer Rizvi Well you may say that we do not invest in short term securities but for
facing cash difficulties we keep our surplus cash in bank
Shah Kamal Sir would you please tell me the general terms of sale of Virgin
Yaseer Rizvi Though it is difficult to maintain a fixed terms of sale our general terms
of sale is 210 n30 But for prime customers we offer special terms of sale
Shah Kamal What are the sources of credit information in case of your firm
Yaseer Rizvi We grant credit on the basis of prior experience with the customers In
case of a new customer personal contact is weighted
Shah Kamal Does your firm consider 5 Cs in granting credit
ii
Annexure
Yaseer Rizvi In case of Virgin Capital and Character get more importance than the
others Mind one thing personal relationship is the main measure in granting credit
Shah Kamal Do you use NPV method in credit granting decisions
Yaseer Rizvi We do not use NPV method But we think that NPV is a suitable
method and we have to use it from the next period
Shah Kamal Sir how do you handle the problem of bad debt
Yaseer Rizvi Well in this case our position is very strong Yet we do not face any
problem because of bad debt Just note that we make more than 80 of sales in cash
and we monitor accounts receivable very carefully
Shah Kamal What level of inventory is maintained by Virgin
Yaseer Rizvi We maintain a minimum level of inventory but do not have to face
stock out problems because inventory is managed efficiently
Shah Kamal What is the normal lead time
Yaseer Rizvi In case of imported goods normal lead time is about 1 month and when
we purchase raw materials from inside the country lead time is 1 to 3 days
Shah Kamal What method do you use for managing inventory
Yaseer Rizvi We do not use any method particularly rather inventory decision
depends on business cycle and market situation Long before the Eid festival we
bought large amount of sugar because price of sugar was increased on the occasion
of Eid
iii
Annexure
Shah Kamal What are the main items of inventory of your firm
Yaseer Rizvi Well these are ndash aluminum can pet chip sugar label chemical and
artificial sweet
Shah Kamal What are the uncertainties in maintaining appropriate level of stock
Yaseer Rizvi These are ndash
bull Increase in price of raw materials
bull Sales uncertainty
bull Market trends etc
Shah Kamal Thank you for your kind cooperation
Yaseer Rizvi Most Welcome
iv
Global Beverage Company Limited
Annexure
Yaseer Rizvi In case of Virgin Capital and Character get more importance than the
others Mind one thing personal relationship is the main measure in granting credit
Shah Kamal Do you use NPV method in credit granting decisions
Yaseer Rizvi We do not use NPV method But we think that NPV is a suitable
method and we have to use it from the next period
Shah Kamal Sir how do you handle the problem of bad debt
Yaseer Rizvi Well in this case our position is very strong Yet we do not face any
problem because of bad debt Just note that we make more than 80 of sales in cash
and we monitor accounts receivable very carefully
Shah Kamal What level of inventory is maintained by Virgin
Yaseer Rizvi We maintain a minimum level of inventory but do not have to face
stock out problems because inventory is managed efficiently
Shah Kamal What is the normal lead time
Yaseer Rizvi In case of imported goods normal lead time is about 1 month and when
we purchase raw materials from inside the country lead time is 1 to 3 days
Shah Kamal What method do you use for managing inventory
Yaseer Rizvi We do not use any method particularly rather inventory decision
depends on business cycle and market situation Long before the Eid festival we
bought large amount of sugar because price of sugar was increased on the occasion
of Eid
iii
Annexure
Shah Kamal What are the main items of inventory of your firm
Yaseer Rizvi Well these are ndash aluminum can pet chip sugar label chemical and
artificial sweet
Shah Kamal What are the uncertainties in maintaining appropriate level of stock
Yaseer Rizvi These are ndash
bull Increase in price of raw materials
bull Sales uncertainty
bull Market trends etc
Shah Kamal Thank you for your kind cooperation
Yaseer Rizvi Most Welcome
iv
Global Beverage Company Limited
Annexure
Shah Kamal What are the main items of inventory of your firm
Yaseer Rizvi Well these are ndash aluminum can pet chip sugar label chemical and
artificial sweet
Shah Kamal What are the uncertainties in maintaining appropriate level of stock
Yaseer Rizvi These are ndash
bull Increase in price of raw materials
bull Sales uncertainty
bull Market trends etc
Shah Kamal Thank you for your kind cooperation
Yaseer Rizvi Most Welcome
iv
Global Beverage Company Limited
Global Beverage Company Limited