24 28 april 2017, vienna, austria - media. · pdf file24–28 april 2017, vienna, austria...

41
24–28 April 2017, Vienna, Austria A New Approach to Teach How to Analyze Tracing Results by a Rapid Visual Method Olivier POTIER

Upload: dangnhan

Post on 21-Mar-2018

215 views

Category:

Documents


2 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: 24 28 April 2017, Vienna, Austria - media. · PDF file24–28 April 2017, Vienna, Austria A New Approach to Teach How to Analyze Tracing Results by a Rapid Visual Method Olivier POTIER

24–28 April 2017, Vienna, Austria

A New Approach to Teach How to Analyze Tracing Results by a Rapid Visual Method

Olivier POTIER

Page 2: 24 28 April 2017, Vienna, Austria - media. · PDF file24–28 April 2017, Vienna, Austria A New Approach to Teach How to Analyze Tracing Results by a Rapid Visual Method Olivier POTIER

Olivier Potier, ICARST 2017, 24–28 April 2017, Vienna, Austria2

Personal interests

2

Page 3: 24 28 April 2017, Vienna, Austria - media. · PDF file24–28 April 2017, Vienna, Austria A New Approach to Teach How to Analyze Tracing Results by a Rapid Visual Method Olivier POTIER

Olivier Potier, ICARST 2017, 24–28 April 2017, Vienna, Austria3

Chemicaland processengineering

Watertreatment

Internationalrelationship

Innovativedesign

Innovation

Personal interests

2

Page 4: 24 28 April 2017, Vienna, Austria - media. · PDF file24–28 April 2017, Vienna, Austria A New Approach to Teach How to Analyze Tracing Results by a Rapid Visual Method Olivier POTIER

Olivier Potier, ICARST 2017, 24–28 April 2017, Vienna, Austria4

HydrodynamicsmodelingTracing

Reactormodeling

Compartmentalmodeling

River

Micropollutants

Personal interests

Chemicaland processengineering

Watertreatment

Internationalrelationship

Innovativedesign

Innovation

2

Page 5: 24 28 April 2017, Vienna, Austria - media. · PDF file24–28 April 2017, Vienna, Austria A New Approach to Teach How to Analyze Tracing Results by a Rapid Visual Method Olivier POTIER

Olivier Potier, ICARST 2017, 24–28 April 2017, Vienna, Austria5

HydrodynamicsmodelingTracing

Reactormodeling

Compartmentalmodeling

River

Micropollutants

this talk

Personal interests

Chemicaland processengineering

Watertreatment

Internationalrelationship

Innovativedesign

Innovation

2

Page 6: 24 28 April 2017, Vienna, Austria - media. · PDF file24–28 April 2017, Vienna, Austria A New Approach to Teach How to Analyze Tracing Results by a Rapid Visual Method Olivier POTIER

Olivier Potier, ICARST 2017, 24–28 April 2017, Vienna, Austria6

Residence Time Distribution

3

Inlet

signalOutlet

signal

Page 7: 24 28 April 2017, Vienna, Austria - media. · PDF file24–28 April 2017, Vienna, Austria A New Approach to Teach How to Analyze Tracing Results by a Rapid Visual Method Olivier POTIER

Olivier Potier, ICARST 2017, 24–28 April 2017, Vienna, Austria7

Residence Time Distribution

3

t

E(t)C(t)

t

00

1

N

)t(C.Q

dt

dN.

N)t(E

1

3

3

.. molm

mol

s

m1s

0

).(

)()(

dttC

tCtE

dttCQdN ).(.

sm

mol

s

m..

3

3

mol

00

0 ).().(. dttCQdttCQN

Inlet

sign

al

Outlet

signalPulse injection

Page 8: 24 28 April 2017, Vienna, Austria - media. · PDF file24–28 April 2017, Vienna, Austria A New Approach to Teach How to Analyze Tracing Results by a Rapid Visual Method Olivier POTIER

Olivier Potier, ICARST 2017, 24–28 April 2017, Vienna, Austria8

Simple reactor models

4

CSTR(Continuous Stirred (Flow) Tank Reactor, Backmix Reactor,Mixed (Flow) Reactor,Gradientless Reactor)

Plug flow reactor

0 = ¶ uC( )¶z

æ

ææ

æ

ææ+

¶C

¶t

æ

ææ

æ

ææ

Page 9: 24 28 April 2017, Vienna, Austria - media. · PDF file24–28 April 2017, Vienna, Austria A New Approach to Teach How to Analyze Tracing Results by a Rapid Visual Method Olivier POTIER

Olivier Potier, ICARST 2017, 24–28 April 2017, Vienna, Austria9

5

reactor in series

recycling

parallel

exchange

short-circuit

Systems are often more complex

How to represent them?

Use of virtual reactors to mimic the global hydrodynamics.

Page 10: 24 28 April 2017, Vienna, Austria - media. · PDF file24–28 April 2017, Vienna, Austria A New Approach to Teach How to Analyze Tracing Results by a Rapid Visual Method Olivier POTIER

Olivier Potier, ICARST 2017, 24–28 April 2017, Vienna, Austria10

Systems are often more complex

6

CSTR(Continuous Stirred (Flow) Tank Reactor,

Backmix Reactor,Mixed (Flow) Reactor,Gradientless Reactor)

Plug flow reactor

Plug flow reactor with axial dispersion0 =

¶ uC( )¶z

æ

ææ

æ

ææ - D

¶2C

¶z2 +

¶C

¶t

æ

ææ

æ

ææ

Cascade of CSTRs

0 = ¶ uC( )¶z

æ

ææ

æ

ææ+

¶C

¶t

æ

ææ

æ

ææ

Q Q

J CSTRs

Pe= uL

DPeclet Number

Page 11: 24 28 April 2017, Vienna, Austria - media. · PDF file24–28 April 2017, Vienna, Austria A New Approach to Teach How to Analyze Tracing Results by a Rapid Visual Method Olivier POTIER

Olivier Potier, ICARST 2017, 24–28 April 2017, Vienna, Austria11

Effect of flowrate change

7

Wastewater

Recycled sludge

REACTOR

settler

Example of the channel reactor:volume 3300 m3, total length 102 m

Page 12: 24 28 April 2017, Vienna, Austria - media. · PDF file24–28 April 2017, Vienna, Austria A New Approach to Teach How to Analyze Tracing Results by a Rapid Visual Method Olivier POTIER

Olivier Potier, ICARST 2017, 24–28 April 2017, Vienna, Austria12

Effect of flowrate change

7

Wastewater

Recycled sludge

REACTOR

settler

Example of the channel reactor:volume 3300 m3, total length 102 m

0

5

10

15

20

25

30

40 90 140 190 240 290 340

J

t (min)

J (full scale plant)

J (pilot plant) 0

5

10

15

20

25

30

35

40

0,00 0,01 0,01 0,02 0,021/ t (min

-1)

Pe

STEP

pilote

t.

. 2

D

L

D

LuP

Water Research, Potier et al., 2005

Page 13: 24 28 April 2017, Vienna, Austria - media. · PDF file24–28 April 2017, Vienna, Austria A New Approach to Teach How to Analyze Tracing Results by a Rapid Visual Method Olivier POTIER

Olivier Potier, ICARST 2017, 24–28 April 2017, Vienna, Austria13

Effect of flowrate, shape and size

7

Wastewater

Recycled sludge

REACTOR

settler

0

5

10

15

20

25

30

40 90 140 190 240 290 340

J

t (min)

J (full scale plant)

J (pilot plant) 0

5

10

15

20

25

30

35

40

0,00 0,01 0,01 0,02 0,021/ t (min

-1)

Pe

STEP

pilote

t.

. 2

D

L

D

LuP

Water Research, Potier et al., 2005

l

wl.w.Q

wh

hD aerationG

23

2

Water Research, Le Moullec et al., 2008

Page 14: 24 28 April 2017, Vienna, Austria - media. · PDF file24–28 April 2017, Vienna, Austria A New Approach to Teach How to Analyze Tracing Results by a Rapid Visual Method Olivier POTIER

Olivier Potier, ICARST 2017, 24–28 April 2017, Vienna, Austria14

How to identify the kind of virtual reactors association?

8

Looking at the RTD graph, people need to be able to rapidly identify the kind of complex virtual reactors association in the system,

and so, need to understand:- the effect of parallel reactors association- the effect of the arrangement of reactors in series- that different associations can lead to similar RTD- the effect of recirculation

Page 15: 24 28 April 2017, Vienna, Austria - media. · PDF file24–28 April 2017, Vienna, Austria A New Approach to Teach How to Analyze Tracing Results by a Rapid Visual Method Olivier POTIER

Olivier Potier, ICARST 2017, 24–28 April 2017, Vienna, Austria15

8

Looking at the RTD graph, people need to be able to rapidly identify the kind of complex virtual reactors association in the system,

and so, need to understand:- the effect of parallel reactors association- the effect of the arrangement of reactors in series- that different associations can lead to similar RTD- the effect of recirculation

TRAINING METHOD: we propose to use the software DTS in an unusual way to perform simulation of different kind of associations.

How to identify the kind of virtual reactors association?

Page 16: 24 28 April 2017, Vienna, Austria - media. · PDF file24–28 April 2017, Vienna, Austria A New Approach to Teach How to Analyze Tracing Results by a Rapid Visual Method Olivier POTIER

Olivier Potier, ICARST 2017, 24–28 April 2017, Vienna, Austria16

TRAINING METHOD: CSTR

9

Page 17: 24 28 April 2017, Vienna, Austria - media. · PDF file24–28 April 2017, Vienna, Austria A New Approach to Teach How to Analyze Tracing Results by a Rapid Visual Method Olivier POTIER

Olivier Potier, ICARST 2017, 24–28 April 2017, Vienna, Austria17

TRAINING METHOD: reactors in series

10

Page 18: 24 28 April 2017, Vienna, Austria - media. · PDF file24–28 April 2017, Vienna, Austria A New Approach to Teach How to Analyze Tracing Results by a Rapid Visual Method Olivier POTIER

Olivier Potier, ICARST 2017, 24–28 April 2017, Vienna, Austria18

TRAINING METHOD: reactors in series

10

Series (CSTR + PFR)

Page 19: 24 28 April 2017, Vienna, Austria - media. · PDF file24–28 April 2017, Vienna, Austria A New Approach to Teach How to Analyze Tracing Results by a Rapid Visual Method Olivier POTIER

Olivier Potier, ICARST 2017, 24–28 April 2017, Vienna, Austria19

TRAINING METHOD: reactors in series

10

Series (CSTR + PFR)

Page 20: 24 28 April 2017, Vienna, Austria - media. · PDF file24–28 April 2017, Vienna, Austria A New Approach to Teach How to Analyze Tracing Results by a Rapid Visual Method Olivier POTIER

Olivier Potier, ICARST 2017, 24–28 April 2017, Vienna, Austria20

TRAINING METHOD: reactors in series

10

Series (CSTR + PFR)

Page 21: 24 28 April 2017, Vienna, Austria - media. · PDF file24–28 April 2017, Vienna, Austria A New Approach to Teach How to Analyze Tracing Results by a Rapid Visual Method Olivier POTIER

Olivier Potier, ICARST 2017, 24–28 April 2017, Vienna, Austria21

TRAINING METHOD: Series or Parallel

11

Page 22: 24 28 April 2017, Vienna, Austria - media. · PDF file24–28 April 2017, Vienna, Austria A New Approach to Teach How to Analyze Tracing Results by a Rapid Visual Method Olivier POTIER

Olivier Potier, ICARST 2017, 24–28 April 2017, Vienna, Austria22

TRAINING METHOD: Series or Parallel

11

Page 23: 24 28 April 2017, Vienna, Austria - media. · PDF file24–28 April 2017, Vienna, Austria A New Approach to Teach How to Analyze Tracing Results by a Rapid Visual Method Olivier POTIER

Olivier Potier, ICARST 2017, 24–28 April 2017, Vienna, Austria23

TRAINING METHOD: Series or Parallel

11

Page 24: 24 28 April 2017, Vienna, Austria - media. · PDF file24–28 April 2017, Vienna, Austria A New Approach to Teach How to Analyze Tracing Results by a Rapid Visual Method Olivier POTIER

Olivier Potier, ICARST 2017, 24–28 April 2017, Vienna, Austria24

TRAINING METHOD: Series or Parallel

11

Page 25: 24 28 April 2017, Vienna, Austria - media. · PDF file24–28 April 2017, Vienna, Austria A New Approach to Teach How to Analyze Tracing Results by a Rapid Visual Method Olivier POTIER

Olivier Potier, ICARST 2017, 24–28 April 2017, Vienna, Austria25

TRAINING METHOD

12

CascadeOf CSTR

Page 26: 24 28 April 2017, Vienna, Austria - media. · PDF file24–28 April 2017, Vienna, Austria A New Approach to Teach How to Analyze Tracing Results by a Rapid Visual Method Olivier POTIER

Olivier Potier, ICARST 2017, 24–28 April 2017, Vienna, Austria26

TRAINING METHOD

12

CascadeOf CSTR

Page 27: 24 28 April 2017, Vienna, Austria - media. · PDF file24–28 April 2017, Vienna, Austria A New Approach to Teach How to Analyze Tracing Results by a Rapid Visual Method Olivier POTIER

Olivier Potier, ICARST 2017, 24–28 April 2017, Vienna, Austria27

TRAINING METHOD

12

CascadeOf CSTR

CascadeOf CSTR

Page 28: 24 28 April 2017, Vienna, Austria - media. · PDF file24–28 April 2017, Vienna, Austria A New Approach to Teach How to Analyze Tracing Results by a Rapid Visual Method Olivier POTIER

Olivier Potier, ICARST 2017, 24–28 April 2017, Vienna, Austria28

TRAINING METHOD

12

CascadeOf CSTR

CascadeOf CSTR

Page 29: 24 28 April 2017, Vienna, Austria - media. · PDF file24–28 April 2017, Vienna, Austria A New Approach to Teach How to Analyze Tracing Results by a Rapid Visual Method Olivier POTIER

Olivier Potier, ICARST 2017, 24–28 April 2017, Vienna, Austria29

TRAINING METHOD

12

CascadeOf CSTR

CascadeOf CSTR

Page 30: 24 28 April 2017, Vienna, Austria - media. · PDF file24–28 April 2017, Vienna, Austria A New Approach to Teach How to Analyze Tracing Results by a Rapid Visual Method Olivier POTIER

Olivier Potier, ICARST 2017, 24–28 April 2017, Vienna, Austria30

TRAINING METHOD: Parallel Cascades

13

MeasureCascade

of 2 CSTRs

Cascadeof 6 CSTRs

Cascadeof 20 CSTRs

Page 31: 24 28 April 2017, Vienna, Austria - media. · PDF file24–28 April 2017, Vienna, Austria A New Approach to Teach How to Analyze Tracing Results by a Rapid Visual Method Olivier POTIER

Olivier Potier, ICARST 2017, 24–28 April 2017, Vienna, Austria31

TRAINING METHOD: Parallel Cascades

13

MeasureCascade

of 2 CSTRs

Cascadeof 6 CSTRs

Cascadeof 20 CSTRs

Page 32: 24 28 April 2017, Vienna, Austria - media. · PDF file24–28 April 2017, Vienna, Austria A New Approach to Teach How to Analyze Tracing Results by a Rapid Visual Method Olivier POTIER

Olivier Potier, ICARST 2017, 24–28 April 2017, Vienna, Austria32

TRAINING METHOD: Parallel Cascades

13

MeasureCascade

of 2 CSTRs

Cascadeof 6 CSTRs

Cascadeof 20 CSTRs

Page 33: 24 28 April 2017, Vienna, Austria - media. · PDF file24–28 April 2017, Vienna, Austria A New Approach to Teach How to Analyze Tracing Results by a Rapid Visual Method Olivier POTIER

Olivier Potier, ICARST 2017, 24–28 April 2017, Vienna, Austria33

TRAINING METHOD: cascades with recirculation

14

Cascade of15 CSTRs

Cascade of15 CSTRs

Page 34: 24 28 April 2017, Vienna, Austria - media. · PDF file24–28 April 2017, Vienna, Austria A New Approach to Teach How to Analyze Tracing Results by a Rapid Visual Method Olivier POTIER

Olivier Potier, ICARST 2017, 24–28 April 2017, Vienna, Austria34

TRAINING METHOD: cascades with recirculation

14

Cascade of15 CSTRs

Cascade of15 CSTRs

Page 35: 24 28 April 2017, Vienna, Austria - media. · PDF file24–28 April 2017, Vienna, Austria A New Approach to Teach How to Analyze Tracing Results by a Rapid Visual Method Olivier POTIER

Olivier Potier, ICARST 2017, 24–28 April 2017, Vienna, Austria35

TRAINING METHOD: Stegosaurus RTD?

15

Page 36: 24 28 April 2017, Vienna, Austria - media. · PDF file24–28 April 2017, Vienna, Austria A New Approach to Teach How to Analyze Tracing Results by a Rapid Visual Method Olivier POTIER

Olivier Potier, ICARST 2017, 24–28 April 2017, Vienna, Austria36

TRAINING METHOD: Stegosaurus RTD?

15

Thank you for your attention.

Page 37: 24 28 April 2017, Vienna, Austria - media. · PDF file24–28 April 2017, Vienna, Austria A New Approach to Teach How to Analyze Tracing Results by a Rapid Visual Method Olivier POTIER
Page 38: 24 28 April 2017, Vienna, Austria - media. · PDF file24–28 April 2017, Vienna, Austria A New Approach to Teach How to Analyze Tracing Results by a Rapid Visual Method Olivier POTIER
Page 39: 24 28 April 2017, Vienna, Austria - media. · PDF file24–28 April 2017, Vienna, Austria A New Approach to Teach How to Analyze Tracing Results by a Rapid Visual Method Olivier POTIER

Olivier Potier, ICARST 2017, 24–28 April 2017, Vienna, Austria39

Chemical Reaction Engineering

4

Plug Flow Reactor: CSTR:

Example with a chemical reaction:

• Q=10 m3/h of a reactant solution

•Conversion Yield : 99 %

• A P

• First order kinetics (k = 4 h-1)

-rA = kCA = rP

Génie de la réaction chimique, Jacques Villermaux, Edition Tec&Doc Lavoisier

Page 40: 24 28 April 2017, Vienna, Austria - media. · PDF file24–28 April 2017, Vienna, Austria A New Approach to Teach How to Analyze Tracing Results by a Rapid Visual Method Olivier POTIER

Olivier Potier, ICARST 2017, 24–28 April 2017, Vienna, Austria40

Chemical Reaction Engineering

4

Volume of the Plug Flow Reactor:VPFR = t Q = 11,5 m3

Plug Flow Reactor:

h 151 990 1

1

4

1

X1

1

k

1 ,

,lnln

t

CSTR:

h 24,75

0,99 1

0,99

4

1

X1

X

k

1

t

Volume of the CSTR:VCSTR = t Q = 248 m3

Example with a chemical reaction:

• Q=10 m3/h of a reactant solution

•Conversion Yield : 99 %

• A P

• First order kinetics (k = 4 h-1)

-rA = kCA = rP

Génie de la réaction chimique, Jacques Villermaux, Edition Tec&Doc Lavoisier

Page 41: 24 28 April 2017, Vienna, Austria - media. · PDF file24–28 April 2017, Vienna, Austria A New Approach to Teach How to Analyze Tracing Results by a Rapid Visual Method Olivier POTIER

Olivier Potier, ICARST 2017, 24–28 April 2017, Vienna, Austria41

Chemical Reaction Engineering

4

CSTR

PFR

Volume of the Plug Flow Reactor:VPFR = t Q = 11,5 m3

Plug Flow Reactor:

h 151 990 1

1

4

1

X1

1

k

1 ,

,lnln

t

CSTR:

h 24,75

0,99 1

0,99

4

1

X1

X

k

1

t

Volume of the CSTR:VCSTR = t Q = 248 m3

22V

V

PFR

CSTR

Example with a chemical reaction:

• Q=10 m3/h of a reactant solution

•Conversion Yield : 99 %

• A P

• First order kinetics (k = 4 h-1)

-rA = kCA = rP

Génie de la réaction chimique, Jacques Villermaux, Edition Tec&Doc Lavoisier