20130901 public meeting_4 (1)
TRANSCRIPT
Upper Malletts Creek
Stormwater Conveyance Study
Project UpdateSeptember 30, 2013
Items to Review and Discuss• Alternatives
▫ Review alternative selection process
▫ Present modeling results and recommendations
• Discussion
• Next step – Final Report and City Council Presentation
Meeting Purpose• Discussion of project recommendations
• Gather public feedback
Project Goals• Reduce probability of flooding by improving
stormwater management
• Identify cost of implementation per level of service
• Do not adversely impact downstream interests
• Maintain and/or enhance water quality
• Long term sustainability
Available Information
• Website
▫ Online at www.uppermallettsstudy.org
• Online Flood Reporting Tool
Original Alternatives
Alternative Development
Alternative Packages
Name Imp
act
Po
ten
tial
Exp
ecte
d C
ost
Alt
ern
ativ
e P
acka
ge 1
Alt
ern
ativ
e P
acka
ge 2
Alt
ern
ativ
e P
acka
ge 3
Alt
ern
ativ
e P
acka
ge 4
Alt
ern
ativ
e P
acka
ge 5
Alt
ern
ativ
e P
acka
ge 6
Alt
ern
ativ
e P
acka
ge 7
Lawton Park High High X X X X X
Eisenhower Park High Medium X X X X X
Lans Basin Medium High X X X X
Pioneer HS (W of 7th) Low Low X
Pioneer HS (E of 7th) Low Low X X X
Cardinal Homes Low Medium X X X
Las Vegas Low Low X X X
Areas Outside of City Boundary 1 2 3 4 5 6 7
Ice Cube Medium Low X
Meadowinds Basin Low Low X
Flooding Map – March 15, 2012
Eisenhower/Churchill Park
Drainage Area
Initial Volume (cu. ft) 425,000Conceptual Volume 390,000Surface Area (acres) 1.9Anticipated Costs $1,250,000
Flooding Map – Post Eisenhower
Pioneer/Scio Church Improvements
Drainage Area Initial Volume (cu. ft) 80,000Conceptual Volume 400,000Surface Area (acres) 2.8Anticipated Costs $1,000,000
Flooding Map – Post Pioneer
Lawton Park
Drainage Area
Initial Volume (cu. ft) 825,000Conceptual Volume 340,000Surface Area (acres) 1.4Anticipated Costs $4,500,000
Flooding Map – Post Lawton
LocationOriginal Est.
VolumeConceptual
Volume
Lawton Park825,000 340,000
Eisenhower Park425,000 390,000
Pioneer (E. of 7th)80,000 400,000
Total 1,330,000 1,130,000
Volume Comparison
Footing drain analysis
Footing Drain Flow as PercentageOf Overall System Flow
94.2%
5.8%
• Measured flow approximately 5 gallons per minute
• Study using conservative flow of 10 gpm
• Total system flow is 483 cubic feet per second
• Total footing drain flow is 28 cfs
Footing drain analysis
Footing Drain Flow as PercentageOf Eisenhower Basin Flow
Footing Drain Flow as PercentageOf Lawton Basin Flow
2.2%
97.8%
5.4%
94.6%
No flow attributed to Pioneer basin due to drainage area specifics
Discussion
Next Steps
• Prepare report
• Presentation to Ann Arbor City Council
Gather Information
Public Engagement
Upper Malletts Creek Stormwater Conveyance Study TimelineP
roje
ct A
wa
rdJ
an
ua
ry 2
013
Ap
ril
20
13
Preliminary Alternatives Analysis &
Memo
Draft Study
Report
Final Study Report
Finalized Alternatives Analysis &
Memo
Ju
ly 2
013
Dec
emb
er 2
013
Ja
nu
ary
20
14
Fe
bru
ary
20
14
Ma
rch
20
13
Data Collection, Monitorin
g, & Modeling
Fe
bru
ary
20
13
Sep
tem
ber
20
13
Upper Malletts Creek
Stormwater Conveyance Study
Project UpdateSeptember 30, 2013