2010 agricultural media summit saint paul, minnesota · 1. st. place: edje technologies....
TRANSCRIPT
2010 Agricultural Media SummitSaint Paul, Minnesota
2nd Place: EDJE Technologies ILoveFarmers.orgCreated by Tiffany Nickelson
Honorable Mention: AgtownTechnologiesClosedHerd.comCreated by Agtown Technologies Staff
1st Place:EDJE Technologies
westernshowcase.comCreated by Sherry Peterson
Great entries in this category. Nice, clean designs throughout. It was
difficult to select the winners. Great use of color, navigation and
organization. The top two sites were unique. The Western Showcase site
has an excellent use of photography separating it from the others. The
images of ILoveFarmers are of equally good quality, but just not as
varied throughout the site as the winning entry. Strong content in the
winning entries.
2nd Place: EDJE Technologiesmorgansmeadows.comCreated by Jimmy Hoover
Honorable Mention: EDJE Technologies shaffergoldrush.comCreated by Amber Martin
1st Place:Agtown Technologies candmherefords.com
Agtown Technologies Staff
All entries provide the visitor thorough and informative content. The top two entries
provided clean design, eye-catching page headers and good use of fonts. All sites are
easy to navigate. The winning entry effectively incorporated social media with Facebook, and the photo gallery is an added attraction to the
home page. The second-place entry may confuse the visitor with the duplication of
page tabs at the top, with those directly beneath. The top two sites clearly and easily
direct the visitor’s attention in a logical manner through the site.
2nd Place: Houston LivestockShow and Rodeowww.rodeohouston.comCreated by Houston Livestock Show and Rodeo Staff
1st Place:Agtown Technologies
nationalwestern.comCreated by Agtown Technologies Staff
The winning entries in this category presented well-designed and well-organized Web sites. They offered
strong design, which also complimented the subject matter and audience. The winning entry also
provided a lot of well-organized supporting news and articles. It will be effective in their search engine
optimization efforts. The top entries handled advertisers’ logos well – in terms of balance of design
and clear exposure for the advertiser. The use of photo slide shows and videos are effective to attract
and keep readers at the site. Overall, good work from all entrants. Two entries just rose above the rest for
overall design, completeness, information and search engine optimization opportunities.
2nd Place: Ohio Cattlemen’s Association “2009 Ohio Cattlemen’s Association THE RING Directory”Created by Jamie King
Honorable Mention: AgTown Technologies“Wow! Burger”Created by AgTown Technologies Staff
1st Place:BEEF Magazine
“2010 BEEF Media Kit”Created by Katie Maas
The BEEF Media Kit package was very well designed. The PDF on the USB seemed more
generic in design.
1st Place:American Angus Association
“2010 American Angus Association Annual Report”Created by Crystal Albers,
Crystal Young and Eric Grant
Well-designed and attractive piece. Nice, efficient use of
space and photos. Easy to read.
2nd Place: EDJE Technologies“Wild, Wild West Simmental Sale”Created by Connie Barbour
1st Place:Agtown Technologies
“Heart of the West Horse Sale”
Created by AgtownTechnologies Staff
The winning entry utilizes attractive design and good use of space. The design is easily readable, except for
areas using gray text.
2nd Place: The Singularis Group“GENETRUST at Chimney Rock Cattle Co. Sale Catalog”Created by Jessica White and Jared Suhn
Honorable Mention: EDJE Technologies “Thomas & Son Farms and Heart Felt Farms Spring Preview Sale”Created by Shari Holloway
1st Place:Hereford Publications Inc.
“Hoffman-W4-Topp Annual Sale Catalog” Created by
Sean Jersett and the HPI Staff
Good copy and image flow. Easy to read and not too
packed with information.
2nd Place: Filament Marketing, LLC“Natures Grown Organics First-To-Know”Created by Filament Marketing and Distillery Design Studio
Honorable Mention: Angus Productions, Inc.“Eby Ranch”Created by Crystal Young
Honorable Mention: The Cattleman“2010 TSCRA Convention Weekend”Created by Linda Lee
1st Place:Angus Productions, Inc.
“Land of Contrasts, Ranching’scommitment to Oregon”
Created by Crystal Young and Eric Grant
The winning entry provides a clean presentation of a clear message.
The design doesn’t get in the way. Overall, in this category, entrants
must remember that special effects and gimmicks are no substitute for
good design and organization of information. Don’t rely on drop
shadows and traditional cut-outs.If you’re doing your own pre-press
work, consult with the printer to determine contrast and saturation
limits and push to those limits. A great design can suffer when
printing renders it flat and dull.Limit the number of typefaces used
in a project! Four is too many.
2nd Place: Agtown Technologies“Premium Natural Beef”Created by Agtown Technologies Staff
Honorable Mention: EDJE Technologies“FarmPro Agribusiness Services, Inc.” Created by Jonina Searl
No first place awarded. Both entries were overcomplicated, and were more graphics than logos. Remember the rules of logo design:Does it easily scale up and down?Does it reproduce well in a single color?Is it concise and memorable?Avoid over-complication. Too many colors and elements are no substitute for good design. Modern is not the same as trendy. Trendy is quickly dated.If you have a stated objective for the logo, try to achieve it with as few elements as possible.
2nd Place: The Singularis Group“Performance Genetics. Trusted Cattlemen”Created by Jessica White and Jared Suhn
No first place awarded. Both submissions were from the same entrant, and both were safe, traditional executions.Special effects and gimmicks are no substitute for good design and organization of information. Don’t rely on drop shadows and traditional cut-outs. If an objective has been clearly identified, make sure the design supports it. For example, if a Web site is being promoted, the URL should be clearly and consistently visible. If promoting an event, don’t bury the notice in a photo.
2nd Place: EDJE Technologies“EDJE Technologies Company Advertising”Created by Jonina Searl and Steve Sellers
Honorable Mention: The Singularis Group“Performance Genetics. Trusted Cattlemen”Created by Jessica White and Jared Suhn
1st Place:Agtown Technologies,
“Premium Natural Beef”Created by Agtown
Technologies Staff
The winning entry offers consistency of
presentation throughout the campaign; a solid
approach to introduce and promote the brand.
1st Place:The Singularis Group
“Performance Genetics, Trusted Cattlemen”
Created by Jessica White and Jared Suhn
A consistent layout with easily identifiable items.
Not cluttered, but a bit busy trying to include a
lot of facts.
Honorable Mention: Filament Marketing, LLC“Organic Means Something”Created by Filament Marketing
1st Place:The Cattle Business Weekly
“Cattle Business, Herd Reference Guide”
Created by Josh Hauk
A very clean, unique approach to the product. Nice color selection and
graphics compliment the logo well. Graphic and
headline pulls you in, encouraging you to read
the rest of the copy.
2nd Place: Ohio Cattlemen’s Association “CLS Show Cattle”Created by Jamie King
1st Place:Ohio Cattlemen’s
Association “Fenton Show Cattle”
Created by Jamie King
Creative approach and a unique concept. Clean
design and to the point. Nice graphic with the
stethoscope.
Honorable Mention: Filament Marketing LLC“Mare’s Match ‘Peace of Mind’ Print Ad”Created by Filament Marketing and Distillery Design Studio
1st Place:EDJE Technologies,
“American Cattle Services”Created by Shari Holloway
The photo says it all. A clean, simple approach. Nice, big headline. The
warm-and-fuzzy approach works.
1st Place:EDJE Technologies
“DeRouchey Cattle Co.” Created by Jonina Searl
Nice use of Photoshop work without being too busy. A
clean layout that emphasizes cattle well. Unique tie in with
cattle being “classy.”
2nd Place:The Singularis Group“Performance Genetics. Trusted Cattlemen.” (Missouri Beef Cattleman) Created by Jessica White and Jared Suhn
1st Place:The Singularis Group
“Performance Genetics. Trusted Cattlemen.” (Florida Cattleman)
Created by Jessica White and Jared Suhn
Consistency and clarity of the items in the ads were good. The designers used creative layout and color choices. Layout was
not too crammed with copy, which gave the ads a clean look. High-quality photos were used.
2nd Place:BEEF“BEEF Daily and Beef Daily Blog”Created by Amanda Nolz
1st Place:High Plains Journal
“Potlucks are key to family status”
Created by Jennifer M. Latzke
Articles in Category 35 are personal and conversational,
providing a lighthearted reprieve from all the facts and
data characteristic of most articles found in livestock
publications. Just as in news stories and commentaries,
however, these articles must be clear, articulate, grammatically
correct and well organized, containing proper sentence
structure and flow of content.
2nd Place:Dairy Today“New Animal Well-Being Program: A Chance to Prove”Created by Catherine Merlo
2nd Place:BEEF“Lion & the Lamb”Created by Joe Roybal
Honorable Mention:Certified Angus Beef“Going Once, Going Twice”Created by Miranda Reiman
1st Place:BEEF
“Tracking Failure”Created by Wes Ishmael
Articles in category 34 provided the author’s viewpoints with detailed descriptions and
much data to support the author’s opinions. Each winning article contained a good introduction and conclusion, sufficient
information and data to support the author’s position, and appropriate use of grammar
and punctuation. Points were made clearly and articles were well organized, flowing
easily to a conclusion, supporting the initial statement. Articles not placing were not organized well and contained too many quotes where paraphrasing would have
been more appropriate.
2nd Place:Dairy Today“Hunker Down 2009”Created by Jim Dickrell and Catherine Merlo
1st Place:Drovers
“Drovers Survival Guide”Created by Drovers Staff
Good depth of reporting. Would like to see more
quotes from sources to help break up the facts and
figures. Good headlines on most stories. Well
organized pieces with great topics.
1st Place:Dairy Today
“The Hurt of Holding On”Created by
Catherine Merlo
Informative story. Good mix of sources and information.
Excellent headline approach. Copy was well-
written and organized.
2nd Place:Beef Today“Out to Pasture”Created by Steve Cornett
Honorable Mention:Ohio Cattleman“Harsh Realities”Created by Elizabeth Harsh
1st Place:High Plains Journal
“Common Ground – Cow dog leadership skills; At my best; Farming with a mouse click”
Created by Jennifer M. Latzke
Ag issues are important to cover, but readers also like to be
entertained. The winner in this category was not afraid to poke fun at herself and leveraged life
experiences to create a series of columns that were very
entertaining to read. Coverage of important ag issues was also
well-done. Weak headlines and spelling errors brought down
scores on some entries.
2nd Place:High Plains Journal“Four-color propaganda”Created by Jennifer M. Latzke
Honorable Mention:High Plains Journal“It’s our job”Created by Jennifer Bremer
1st Place:Drovers
“Food Inc. incites the activists”Created by Greg Henderson
The editors did a great job of using the editorial space to speak on
behalf of farmers and agriculture. We would challenge all editors to
put more energy into their headline writing to draw more readers into
these great stories. The depth of some stories could have been
greater. But, the topics discussed were timely and informative.
2nd Place:High Plains Journal“State funding of livestock market reporting cut”Created by Jennifer M. Latzke
Honorable Mention:BEEF“EPA Throws a Curve”Created by Burt Rutherford
Honorable Mention:High Plains Journal“Bovine tuberculosis not completely eradicated”Created by Jennifer Bremer
1st Place:Dairy Today
“California goes dry”Created by
Catherine Merlo
Articles in Category 29 contain in-depth coverage of various aspects of the livestock industry, including real-life examples of the
challenges faced by those working in this industry. Most submitted articles featured
compelling introductions, good conclusions and a strong writing style, with appropriate
use of grammar and punctuation. Articles not placed contained organizational and
transition problems, run-on sentences, misused semicolons, as well as repeated
use of weak phrases such as “due to,” “there are,” “there is,” and “there has.”
2nd Place:High Plains Journal/Midwest Ag Journal“Hereford Breeders Believe in Family”Created by Jennifer Bremer
Honorable Mention:Drovers“Young Cowboy Goes Far”Created by John Maday
1st Place:BEEF
“The Naturals”Created byJoe Roybal
People want to read about people. Profiles can be the most important part of a
publication. Each entry gave the reader heartfelt, warm, true-to-life characteristics about their sources. It makes me feel good as writers, ourselves, to know that profiles
are being done on people who deserve such a pat on the back. The lead-in of the winning
entry was great, and we were hooked. Written with enough great info and quotes
throughout its long length to keep our interest. Very intriguing, heartfelt profile on a
forward-thinking couple. Glad the writer knew enough to write about the Hatfields,
because they deserved it.
2nd Place:Beef Today“Is your Facility Ready to Receive”Created by Sara Brown
Honorable Mention:BEEF“DNA Dos and Don’ts”Created by Alaina Burt
1st Place:Dairy Today
“Stop the Shrink”Created by
Catherine Merlo
The winning entry provided good information quickly and succinctly. We
loved the “Undercover Agents” sidebar –it’s a good use of humor. The two- to
three-word paragraph starter allowed the reader to scan and get highlights.
Overall, a great way to highlight instruction points, quickly and easily.
2nd Place:High Plains Journal“Keeping the Shelves Stocked”Created by Jennifer M. Latzke
Honorable Mention:American Farriers Journal“Three Ring Farrier”Created by Jeremy McGovern
1st Place:BEEF
“Big Fat Lies?”Created byDiana Barto
Very timely article, and it fits the category of human interest
above all other entries. A great subject, as it is applicable to ag,
beef or the non-ag reader. Great headline.
2nd Place:High Plains Journal“Another genetic defect affects Angus cattle”Created by Jennifer Bremer
Honorable Mention:Dairy Today“Pipeline Dreams”Created by Jim Dickrell
1st Place:BEEF
“Dealing with Deads”Created byAlaina Burt
Technical articles serve as valuable management tools to
producers. New information and research is available every day, but
applying that research to an operation can be a
challenge. Writers in this category did a good job of communicating the main ideas and benefits of technical
information while using producer quotes and lessons learned to give
their stories interest and credibility. The best entries were from writers
who had the skill to weave these two worlds together.
2nd Place:American Farriers Journal“Build Trust and Build Your Shoeing Business”Created by Pat Tearney
Honorable Mention:High Plains Journal“Meat Marketing Tactics Change With Consumers”Created by Jennifer M. Latzke
1st Place:Certified Angus Beef
“Straightforward Success”Created by
Laura Nelson
Thank goodness writers and publications are willing to tackle this
topic. Readers will gain valuable information from each of these entries.
The top entries were outstanding and each deserve a gold star. The winning
entry featured a fantastic lead, the best of the category. It offers detail and puts
a visual spin on a ranching situation. The writer knows how to get great information and great quotes from sources. The article stands out as a marketing profile, offers marketing
points and profiles the source with a sense of humor on an otherwise
traditional topic.
2nd Place:Beef Today“match.cow”Created by Kim Watson Potts
Honorable Mention:Dairy Today“Be the Cow”Created by Jim Dickrell
1st Place:BEEF
“Grazers of the Purple Sage”
Created byBurt Rutherford
With such a large percentage of editorial falling into this category, it’s tough to stand
out from the crowd. Stories with solid leads and opening paragraphs that give the
reader a reason to keep reading rise to the top. Overall, this was a solid category with
lots of good writing and timely subject matter. Would like to see subheads that
communicate more benefits to the reader, as well as more sidebars, info boxes and pull
quotes that give readers additional points of entry into the text.
2nd Place:Hereford World“Inspired”Created by Sara Gugelmeyer
Honorable Mention:High Plains Journal“Equine therapy program heals hearts and minds”Created by Kylene Scott
1st Place:Houston Livestock Show & Rodeo
Bowlegged H Magazine “Myrtis Dightman”
Created byBrad Levy
A great human interest piece inspires the reader by creating a connection
with the story’s subject and their unique role or outlook on life. All
entries in this category do just that. Entries could have been
improved with tighter editing and some with more effective use of
quotes, but overall… good writing.
2nd Place:The American Quarter Horse Journal“Pure Genetics”Created by The American Quarter Horse Journal Staff
1st Place:The Cattleman Magazine
“Mythbusters: BVD”Created by
Katrina Waters
The key to developing an effective technical article is breaking down a complex subject into smaller pieces that can easily be consumed by the
reader. Knowledge and expertise on technical subjects within each
publication’s audience will vary greatly. Technical stories should be
written simply, clearly and concisely, as well as provide illustrations, graphics
and sidebars that increase comprehension. Be careful not to make
technical stories too long—you’ll lose your reader. Consider breaking the
subject up into two or three smaller stories.
1st Place:BEEF
“Sky Bandits”Created by
Dennis Wolf
This illustration is a very light-hearted take on the
bird problem in some feedyards. It is creative
and unique.
1st Place:The Cattleman Magazine
“(Intracoastal)Cattle Crossing”
Created byCarol Hutchison
The photographer did an excellent job of capturing the
adventure of moving cattle across the canal. She captured
both the emotion and excitement of the move while
reflecting the calm and almost routine process. Photographs were well-balanced, followed
the rule of thirds, and had depth. Great artwork.
2nd Place:High Plains Journal“Seed Wheat Issue Cover”Created by Lance Ziesch
Honorable Mention:Tri-State Livestock News“White Ranch”Created by Sharla Hayford
1st Place:High Plains Journal
“2009 Animal Health Issue”
Created byDiana Derstein
We were impressed by the creativity shown in the designs of the publication covers. All
the entries did a good job of communicating the brand of the respective publications. We
would like to have seen more defined objectives versus photo captions and story
cutlines. Placings were chosen by the covers that we felt lead the reader to believe
that he or she would be better off in some way for having the knowledge shared,
combined with eye-appeal and graphic design -- the ones that did the best job of
intriguing us to read more.
2nd Place:BEEF“State of the Industry”Illustration by Greg Hargreaves; modified illustration by Jim Bauer; art direction by Krista Trempe
1st Place:National Hog Farmer
“Teetering on the Financial Brink”Original illustration by Rob Colvin; modified illustration by Jim Bauer;
art direction by Krista Trempe
The winning entry depicts a very good graphic interpretation of the theme, “Teetering on the Financial
Brink.” Bright colors made this entry stand out during the competition,
which will easily translate to the reader moving from cover to
magazine content.
2nd Place:America’s Horse“Tres Seis”Photography by Mikel DonahueDesign by Justin Foster
Honorable Mention:The Cattleman Magazine“Focus on Water”Photography by Mark List Design by Linda Lee
1st Place:The American Quarter Horse Racing
Journal“Seeking Safety”
Photography by Dan Dry
Design by Justin Foster
The challenge for any cover design is to create a focal point that a reader
instantly connects with the stated or implied theme of the issue. The 1st-
place cover accomplishes this task. The jockey’s magenta jacket, the white
taped fingers and eyes pointed upward instantly supports the
stated safety theme.
2nd Place:Houston Livestock Show & RodeoTM/Bowlegged H Magazine “From Show to Shasta”Created by Houston Livestock Show & RodeoTM
1st Place:BEEF
“The Naturals”Layout and design
by Krista TrempePhotos by Joe Roybal
Designing multiple page editorial layouts isn’t always the
easiest of design tasks. Page 1 must be interesting enough to compel the reader to move to
the next page and all the pages that follow. The strategic use of call-outs/life-outs and sidebar
information invites the reader to move through the entire feature. The meatcase photo on the last
page is a perfect visual to conclude the feature article.
2nd Place:Dairy Today“World Dairy Expo”Created by Lisa Behnke and the Dairy Today Special Projects Team
1st Place:Houston Livestock
Show & RodeoTM
“2009 OfficialVisitors Guide”
Created by Houston Livestock Show & RodeoTM
The 1st-place program accomplished a difficult task
by condensing a large volume of information into a very user-friendly program without compromising type
size and readability. Each section was approached with
a regard for intent and function.
2nd Place:Tri-State Livestock News“The Cattle Journal”Created by Sharla Hayford
Honorable Mention:2009 North American Bull Guide/Crow Publication“2009 North American Bull Guide”Design by Sharon Murano
1st Place:The Cattle Business Weekly
“Cattle Business, Herd Reference”Created by Codi
Vallery-Mills, Kindra Gordon, Mary Ravellette, Josh Hauk and
Danielle Stoddard
All entries featured great photography and cover shots. The
content flowed cleanly and readable throughout all issues.
Great use of graphic elements to show the highlighted portions of
the publication’s special issue.
2nd Place:American Farriers Journal“Getting Started in Hoof Care… A Career Guide for the New Farrier”Created by Jeremy McGovern
Honorable Mention:Tri-State Livestock News “Black Hills Stock Show & Rodeo Annual Premier Edition”Created by Sharla Hayford
1st Place:BEEF
“2009 Cow-Calf Issue”Created by BEEF Staff
All pieces featured a clean look and feel throughout, and good use of
photography. The winner really makes the issue a special issue, concentrating on the special issue content and doing
so throughout the piece.Suggestions for all pieces: more
guidance needed directing reader where to go next. Some photography
needed to be color corrected and enhanced more to engage the reader
to continue with the story. Simple is more.
2nd Place:BEEFBeefMagazine.com Created by BEEF Staff
Honorable Mention:Filament Marketing LLCFilamentMarketing.comCreated by Filament Marketing and Distillery Design Studio
1st Place:Houston Livestock Show and
RodeoTM
RodeoHouston.comCreated by Houston Livestock
Show and RodeoTM
The winning entry featured an attractive design with easy
navigation. Good use of sharing buttons and
integration of e-merchandising, signup and
sharing tools (e.g. Facebook and Twitter).
2nd Place:Kansas Stockman“KLA News & Market Report”Editor: Todd Domer
Honorable Mention:Houston Livestock Show & RodeoTM
“Rodeo Roundup E-Newsletter” Created by Houston Livestock Show and RodeoTM
1st Place:Beef Today
“Beef Today’s Cattle Drive”
Created by Beef Today Staff
The winning entry features nice, clean design with quick
access to relevant articles. Not too much information,
which makes for an efficient read.
1st Place:Hereford World
Created by Hereford Publications Inc. Staff
The winning entry features clean use of typography. Initial caps are nice, and
help you find the beginning of the story. Nice use of boldface leads to break up
expanses of text. Nice use of “hero” shots and using larger images for story leads.
Suggestions include using photo captions for ALL images, unless for effect
only. Some nice headlines, but many need more interest to draw reader. Photo
placements in some articles are too randomly placed. Keep it simple. Think
simple, overall shapes. (Flush left, or flush right, or centered. Avoid using all
on same page.)
Honorable Mention:DroversCreated by Drovers Staff
1st Place:Dairy Today
Editorial team led by Jim Dickrell
1st Place:BEEF
Created by BEEF Staff
The top two entries were extremely close, with each having different
strengths. In Dairy Today, its greatest strength was overall design and
striking cow images on covers. It is less intimidating to read, with use of white space and larger type. BEEF’s
greatest strengths are compelling headlines and content, cover blurb
usage, and large use of lead images in several stories.
2nd Place:Houston Livestock Show & RodeoTM/Bowlegged H MagazineCreated by Houston Livestock Show & RodeoTM
Honorable Mention:The American Quarter Horse Racing JournalCreated by The American Quarter Horse Racing Journal Staff
1st Place:America’s Horse
Created by America’s Horse Staff
All entries featured great use of photography and flow of content.
Consistency on the design throughout the pieces assisted the
reader’s flow to the next article. Very clean and simple design concepts.
The winning entry did a great job of not using too much copy and
content. It reads really nicely and has a great use of photography.
Simple is more.