2008-02-07 rotem v samet et al (1233/08) petition in the high court of justice – original petition...
TRANSCRIPT
"1233/08
: ,. .057859373
"""
7546403
' :9545706-09 , :9573974-09
--
:1. ,-
2.-
3.
4.––
5. ,
" ,
'-29 ,
-,
.........................................................................................................................................................3
..................................................................................3...........................................................................4
.....................................................................................................................................................6
..........................................................................................................................................6..............................................................................................................................................8
.........................................................................................................................................9..........................................................................................................................................9
.........................................................................................................................................9
' - ,"..................................................................................................10
..................................12
.................................................................................................................15
,-..........17
–...........................................20
."...........................................................20
...................................................................................21...............................................23
/2-2' '...................25
–....................................................................27
...........................................................................33
"................................................33"–,........36
-2000.......................................................................37 -2004-2005..............................................................40
....................................................................................41
."-2007......................................................................41
.......................................................................................44............................47
"....................................................................................................................53
".......................................................................56
.................................................................57
:-......................................................................................................60
.........................................................................63
..65
.....................................................................................................................................................67
......................................................................................................................................................72
.......................72
............................................................................................................................................73
3
.""
1951:
" -
;
, ,
."
.
, ,
,2002 .
.' .
)"2909/04]" [06.06.2004 (
8)(:
""– ..."
,
... .
,
."
"2909/04'.
.
,
.
.–
–
.
" " . ,
,– ,
, , , .
–.
. ,2004
) :3 :" ,
" .(
.)" (
, ,2 :"
4
, ,
" .
." ,- ,2 :
" ,
, .
.
" ." , :
" , .
.
, .
, ,
" .
" .
.
:
1.-2003
- .
2.2006)"– (
.
3.2004 '" ,
.
. ,
.
.–- .
, ,-
.
.
. , ,
, , ,
,.
5
. ,
,
,
, .
.
" "" ')
18.1.087 ( :" , ,
]–" [ .
"" , ,"
. . ,
65 ," .
. ,
)( ,
,
.
, , , ,
.
.
,
,
. ,
,
,] '16.06.2005 '21 '27-30 ,
'28 '1-2[:
" :
,-
?
:?
:?
: , ,
."
6
. , ,
.
. ,
'
, ,, , ,
.
."
,
.
.
. ,
".
1. ,
,:
1.1. ' '5883/05
'– ?
1.2. '?
1.3. '
,27.03.2005"
?
1.4.
?
1.5.-- '
5883/05 '– ,)–"" (
09.03.2006) ' , :
(
?
1.
7
1.6.
,
?
1.7.1.6 ,
?
1.8.259/06
'–)–"" (
20.09.2006) ' , ' , '
, : (
?
2.
1.9. , ,:
1.9.1.
?
1.9.2.
?
1.9.3.
?
3.
1.9.4.
)
( ,"-1997) :""(?
1.10.:
1.10.1. ,
,
?
1.10.2.502/05 ' ,
-2006)3( ,177)–"" (-
,
93.124) (" ?
8
1.10.3.674/05 ' ,-
2007)1 (783)–"" (–
?
1.11.
?
1.12.38)5 ( ,"-1958]
[)–"" ("
"-
:?
1.13.
,
,
?
2. , '"
/ '" ,"?
3. ," ,
-
-.
4. ,.
5. ,:
5.1.)"
9607/07"1( ;
107.10.2007 .) ( .
"18.10.07 , "– : .
)" (" ." : ,
."" " , , , .
10.
9
5.2.-
,–
)( ,
,"-2 ,
10.07.2006" .
5.3."27.03.2005
;
5.4."
200327.03.2005-
" ,
.
6. , ,
) (2003
.
7. ,
, .
8."
.
9.
"" ,.
'"
.
2 '" ,04.08.200586-872005)" (
"-)".(
10
'-
,"
10. '–
- , ,
77)1 (][ ,"-1984 , '
,
,/ , '
.
11.
.
12.2005"
,] '15.05.2005 , '17 '25-30 , '18 '1-10[:
" , ,
]–"[ , ...
,
, .
, , , ,
, ,
, ....
, ,
. .
... . ."
13. ,
,8.10.2003 ,
," . '
, .
'
.
"8.10.2003'.
14.- , ,
,"' ,
" ' ,
' ,",
11
,'" "
") " ( ,
," , ,"–
" , , ."
" ' ,3.
15.2006-2007
""' ,:
.THE MARKER ONLINE28.8.2006" :
" :""
140 ''" ," :" ,
' ."
.16/4/2006" : :
36" ," :
, , '
, ,' ."
.24.5.2007G" :
" '
.
.16/7/2007" :
:45 ''"
'.
16. , ':
.14.5.2007.
14.5.07'.
.8.6.2007" .
8.6.0721.6.07'.
3 ," . , .-/19–01.03.04
. ' , ,
)" '19 '16-17 .(–1984 . .
, ,) ,
," , .(
12
17. ,-
23.2.2006
,
.
23.2.06'.
18. ,"
, , ,"
" , ,
, ,
DUE PROCESS .
19. . ,"
' ,
'.
20. ,
.
21.27.8.2003 ,-
)16( ,
,45) (
,:" ,
, ,
".
22. ,
, , .
.
, . ,
,- .
,05.08.2004 ,
23.11.2004
13
4 ,14.12.2004
, : ..."
" ,
,... ." ,
,-16
,
." :" ,
" . ,"
14.12.2004 ,
" ,2005 ,
.
23.-16
,
–16- ,
, , .
24. , ,
38)5 ( ,"
" .
25. , -16 ,
,
,
38)5 ( .
"4.
26. :38)5 (" ,
, , :
, ." .
27.30.01.2007
) (
4 , , .
,.
14
2003 ." '
14.05.2007 , :
"
.
–
.
,
."
30.01.07 ,5.
"14.05.076.
28." '12.6.07 ,
)(:
"2002 .
.– .
, .
,
. ,
. -
,."
"12.06.077.
29.38)5 (
,
: .
30."" ,
""" , ,
38)5 ( ,) (
2003.
"" " ," "8.
31. , ,
, ,
.
, , ,
,38)5 (
: .
15
32.:
. ,2006
," ,
.
. ,
"" ,30.01.2007 , :
""]–" [ .
.
," .
. ,
,
.
. , '11.06.07 ,"
"" ' ,
-" ,
"" , :"
" .
. , ,
,
.–
".
33..
20012005"2001.
1.09.2002" ,") () (.
01.01.2003 '270/02 , ,).(
16
10.02.2003" , ,).(
16.02.2003" ,") () ().(
2003 , ," ,)
(– .
16.03.2003 , , , ,5.
04.03.2003 , , , ,.
17.03.2003 , , ,.
27.07.2003.
27.07.2003" ,".
27.08.2003.
17.09.2003 , , , ,6.
24.09.2003.
5) '1727 ( ."
) .( , ,"" .
3309/032003 , . , , ," " ,
2003."2003 ,
" , ,2003. ," ,
"3309/032003 , ,12.12.02 . ," ,27":
"12.12.02 "... . :24.02.03) (
. , ,2002 .–12.12.02
. ,.
. .73190/04 ' ,"2.1.083309/03 .
24.02.03 , :" , ,
,".
3309/03 '"24.02.2003" . ,
"") (.
" , .
6'.
17
2004 ," .
,- .
," .
22.01.2004.
29.02.2004"."
16.05.2004" , , ,".
06.06.2004 , , ,) .
.(
05.08.2004.
23.11.2004 ..
22.12.2004 ,).(
05.01.2005".
2005" , , ,".
,
-
34. ,
/ ," . ,
, ,""
. ,93.124) (":
")(
. ,
, .
,
."
35.
,"
, ,
, .12
18
" "– ,
"" , ,
.
, ,
, , , ,
.
36.- ,
, .
37.2002-2003- ,
/ ,
, , ,
,
. , ,7 ,
.
38.1.9.2002" ,
" ."
-3.
39.16.2.2003" , ,
" , .
40. ,
, ,- ,
.
"-80-90 , ,
, . ,1984
2004 ,
."
)142( ,
.
7 , , :)"4 (
-.6.6.04'
.
19
41.
– ,
..
42."
2003-2004-2005 , ,
.
"" ." ,
.
43.
, .
44. ,-2" ,
,
. ,
, . ,
" ,
.
45. , ,
,
."
,"" .
,
.
46. ,-
, ,
, ,
"
,
."
, , ,
- ,- ,
, ,
, ,
." ,
20
, ,
,
, ,
, .
47.
, , ,
"
.
.
–
48. , ,
, ,
, ,
,
"
."
."
49.:
.
.
..
.
;
.
, ,
;
21
./ ,8?
50. , , ,
, ,
,
,
"
, ,
,
,
.
,
,
.
.
51. , ,
, .
,
– .
.
52."
, .
,
" ,
, .
53. ,
.
8"-- ,""
30.06.2005 , '59 '12-15" : ....
" , ."....") , '18" :( ,."
22
54. , ,
.
55. , ,
."886/79" '
,'")2 (693 ,697"
, '
:"" .
, ,
,
.
56.
: : .
57.
,
-10.10.2006 ,:
"
, ,
.
45 ."
58." "
,9 .
" ,
.
, ,"10.10.2006
" , '"
"
" ."
. , , '" :
9- , ' ,3 ,"
" :" , ' :"
" .
23
. ," .
, , :"
,
" . .
59.- , ,
,
, , : ,
: .
.
60. ,
-.
.
61.
,-
-– .
62.
.
" ,
" ,.
63. '"
,
.
64."–
–
,
, ,
."
. ?" ,
24
,
– . ,
,
,
, .
,.
65."
,
.
66.
" ,
,
, , ,
.
67. ,
, ,
, , ,
.
68. ," , ,
,"
,"
.
25
/2-2' '
69."7 ,
:
) () (
12.04.2005
15.05.2005
16.06.2005
30.06.2005
07.07.2005
04.08.2005
09.08.2005
70. , '/
" ,
" .
71." ,
, , :
.7 ;
. ;
. .
72.
.
"-
, , ,
, .
,
,
.
73.8
,
26
. ,
)16"(
,)25"(" ,
, "- .
,
–
"– .
74./2-2'" ' ,"560)–"'" (
–-
" , ,
, , .
75.
,
, , ,
,
.
) (
,
).(
76.'" ,
. ,
, ,
, ,
,
.
77.
,)
( ,
27
,–
,
, ,
.
78."
. ,"
,
.
79.
.
" '
".
–
80. , ,
24.03.2005 , ' , ,
:"?" . '
" : ."
' ," :
, ,
." '
,
,"28 .
'28 ,
"" :
".
81." , , , :"
"" .
82. ,
'
" , '
" ,3 :
28
"3 ."
')27.3.05 (" ,
"."
83. ' ,:
"1 .."
84.–""" , , ,
, ,
.
85. ."
,
.
86." ,
) : .(
87. ,
,–– . , ,
, ,
,"
" ,
,
: ,
: .
88. ,""
/ , ,
, ,
.
89." ' ,
, .
. ,
,
.
29
-
, '
,
, . '
" ,
" . ,"
"" ,
.
90. ,"-–
,
.– ,
,
" , :
."
, , ,
. ,
,
" . ,
, ,
. ,
"
. , , ,
,10 .
91. , , ,
,
" ,
– ,
" ,
.
," ,
, .
10" , ' , ,
.""" '–.
" ," ," : ,."
30
92. , ' ,
" ,"
,
" .79][ ,"-
1984 , ,
"
. ,"
,
,
. ,– ,
, ,
".
93.
,".
94. '
,
, , , ,"
. '
, ' .
, ' ,
'
,
'
. ,"
' , ,
'.
95." ,
/–
" ,
, ,
.
31
96. ,"
"–"/
, ,
".
97. ,"
" ,
) ( , , ,
,""
, , ,
." ,
)
( , ,
"
,.
98. , ,
,"
,
- ,
.
99. , '"" ,"
)11 (
,"
.
100.
,
," " ,
) :"/3–43 '
" ,)1 (85 ;" /3–3" '
,"233 ,237 .(
,
.
11"" ,.
32
101."
.
102. ,
,"
,
"–,
, ,
,"
, .
103. , ,
,"
, .
104."
,
. ,
, ,
" ,
' ,
. ," ,
, .
105. , '"
, , ,
, '"
"" " .
106. , '
"" " ,/
'.
107.
– ,–.
33
"
108. , ,
, . ?
" ,
" .
" "2005 ,
.
" ,
" . ,1996 ,
,-" "
2003 , ,
./)
07.07.2005 '77-78(" '12 .
26.03.03'.
109. : ,"
) '07.07.2005 , '64 '11-17( '
) '07.07.2005 , '68 '12(]–"
":[
" -- ,
," ,
."
12 '7":" , ,"
26/12/96 , . ,
) '."("––
)109 .() '07.07.2005 '78 '12-13 (1996.
, '2003" "1996 , ,
'""- , ' ,
," " , . -04.09.200734 , :"
–" .– ' .
34
110. ,13 . ,"
, ,
.
, , .
, ' ,
"
,
, ,
, ,".
111. :-" ,
) '3-410.07.06(:
"]-"[84 ,
,90? ....
]
"–"[ ,
.' , '
, .63"– .
."
112. :" ,
" , .
2003 , ,
.2003)
– '7" ( ,
. ,
1989
, ' , ,
2005-6 ,
,"-14 .
1310 '13" ' ," ,
, ' , . , ,
.14/ , '
,07.07.2005 '77 '22 '. , ' ' .
35
,"
1996 .
113."
," ,
.
114." " ,
,1997 .
"
1997 .
, ,
2005 , . :
" " , , ,
. , .
" ,
,
, , .
.
115. ,3 ,
,)" (
"
,)" ( .
,]
)07.07.2005 '79 '13-15( ,"15[ , , ,
, , .3
" ," , ,
.
116."
) :
( , ,
" ,
."
15) '79 '13-15 ( ," : .."
36
. ," " .
,
.
,02.10.2007
" :".
02.10.2007'.
117." , '
" .
, ,".
"–
,
118. '
. ,
.")"–" () '
12.4.2005 , '9 '13-29 , '10 '1-14()(:
""-...
" , .
" ."2003
," , ,
,
, , , ,
, ,
, , , .
" ." ,
, , ,
, , . ,
,...
- , ,
,...
. ,
.
...]–"[
."
37
119." ,
,"
.
, '
.
120. , '"
,
,.
-2000.
121."2"- "2000 ,
"" , .
122.-2" "2000--
".""-"
:" , ,
.") '10.07.2006 '3
(.
123.2" , :
2000 ;2000– :11 .
124.2- , ,
,11
, , :
. ,)
(" "26.11.00" "
" "11 ,7.12.00;
. ,
" "26.11.00" "" "11 ,
7.12.00 .
,;
.-2""
" , ,
38
2000" ,
;
. ,2"
;
. ,
,11 , ,
, . ,"
" " .
125. .
"16 ."
" " , ,
,
.–"
"2005 , ,
" ,
/) '04.08.2005 '91 '5-8(" : ,
, , ,
, .... ,
."
126.14.10.1999"
, , , , ,
.–"
.
"
.
.
")27(
," ,
"
, ,
, ,
2004.
16.
39
127. ,
2000 , ,
.
2000)" ,
15.05.2005 '9 '19-24 .(
128."2000
,2")
, .(
129. ,2001
. .
""2000.
130."2001
] :
,– .[ '
"2001]/26[ ,
" .
131.")28" (" ,
2000––
,
"– ,
–
? ! ,
.
132.:
.
2002-2003 ;
."" ,
,
, '".
40
-2005-2004
133.2" . .
" ,
,"
.
2" ,
2004 ,2004 .
, , ,
.
134." ,
,) '09.08.2005 '23 '16-28(:
:"16.5.2004– '–
–
: ." . .
:2?
:.
:3 '–
: .
.
. .
:"2005–/20–1
?
: ."2 ,3.
:?
:.
135. ,
, ,
.
41
136.
,
- .
137. ,
, .
138.
, , ,
. ,
,,
,
,
, ,
" .
139.
" , .
,
.
."-2007
140."18.10.2007 ,
" ,
,
, ,
" ,
.
. .63188/05]-" [18.10.07'.
141." ,.63188/05]-" [
' . ,"
1990 , ,
) '53 '6-2( :""
42
- . .
... ." , .
" .
142."18.10.2007-
.63188/05" ,-
, ,
– , ,
,
- .
, ,"
, ,
.-") '54 '12-8 , '56 '
32-20 , '57 '4-1 , '57 '28-21 , '58 '5-3( :
: ,
, ?
... : , .
: ? ?
: , .
...
:" , ?
? ?
: .
: , . -
?
:. ....
: -–
1990 ,-1990" .1990
?
: .
:-2003
?
:.
:5]"6–" [ .
?
: .
.
43
: - . ?
: ,- .
:)'/4' .(
- ?
: - , - ,
.-
."
143."
. , ,
–
,
.
144. ,"
:"" , .
.""
" " :"" .
– . .
.
145." ,
–18.10.2007,
,
," , .
,
" , ,2005
,.
146." , , ,
, .27
– .
3"
"– ,-2
,"
44
."
,.
147."
"
" , , .
148.
- , , ,
"
-
, .
.
149. , ,
,)
12.4.05 , '19 '16 '20 '16 , '21 '16-21()(:
"":
68 '7 .9365/01 '
'.
3.4.200511:00
,12:45 ,
-10
,
, :"
".
,
.
, ,
,
.
–4.4 .
, ,–4.4 .19:10
.–6.4 .17:05
45
" :
".
. .
.
.
,
.
....
,
, ,
.
...
" :
,
,
.
."
150.15.05.2005) ' '1 '6-16 , '4 '13-16 , '8 '20-21 , '
9 '19-23 , '13 '1-6) ((:
":
..
9389 ,".
.
.
, .
..
.
-
.
...
..
.
–?
. ..
46
....
:..
,
. ,
. ,
. .
..
.
."
:
..
89 ,'16 ,.
.
,
.
."
151. ,
," ,
,""17.
– .
,
.
152." , ,
,
" ,
17 ," , . ?" '
" , ,- . ' .
' , .
47
, ,
)/13 ,/16.(
153."
, , .
– , , ,
, , .
, ," ,"
–
– .
.
154.
.
)
(–-
, ,
.
,
.
,-10 !!!
'"9:
'1 - ')" , ,1989(
") '
12.04.2005 , '3 '14( ,
) , '4 '10-11( ,
") , '5 '12(.
)" , ,
1988(:
"-15 .
) '15.05.2005 '3 '4-6( , ,
,
48
) , '3 '15-16( ,
. ,
?
. .) , '4 '28-29(,.
. , , ,
?
.) , '5 '
22-24.(
.?
. . ,' .) ,
'7 '28-29..(
) ,1980(:
" .
, .
) '9 '16-17.(
.?
. ..
.
?
. ,.
. ,?
.) , '12 '11-18(.
) ,1989(:
"– .
, ,
, . , .
. ,
.
.
]2003–"[
.
]–" [ .
-360]"180–"[
, .
. ,
, ') '15.05.2005 '14 '1-20.[
49
.
,
?
.?
.?
. ,
,) '16.06.2005 , '21 '
27 '22 '2( .
)" , ,
1988(:
"90
, ,
) ,
'24 '23-25(, ,
" ") , '24 '29-
30( ,) , '25 '4.(
)" , ,
1989(:
" ,
, ,
.
.
") , '27 , '29 '28 '2.(
) ,
1990:(
" ,
) '30.06.2005 '56 '12-14(,
) , '57 '1-2( ,
"
.
.]"
–" .[
) '57 '6-10( ,
50
.
.
. .
.) , '57 '20-25( ,
) , '58 '5-6(.
) ,
1990(:
. ?
..
.?
..
.?
. , .
, .
) , '63 '1-8(.
,) ,1977 ,2006 (:
" . .
, .
.
) '07.07.2005
'72 '20-25( , . , , ,
,
. . .
-2003 ,
) ,'74 '4-8( ,
.
) ,'75 '22-23( .
) , -80 ,0062(:
") '04.08.05
'86 '27( ,) , '87 '12(.
155."
:
51
.–
;
.– ;
.– ,
,
.
156. ,18 , .
,-
–
–
01.09.2002. : ,
,"01.09.2008 ,
.
157." ,
.".
1830.06.2005 '58 '63–– , , ,)
18.09.2003 .(") '60 '22 :("" .")
18.09.2003 ( , ,-/18"" : , ,
, ." '/7-/11"" ,
-9 , , , , , .
.) '09.08.2005 '17 '11-17 ,21-23:(
" .. .... . . ." : ,
,.
..... .? . , .
! ,"
, .
, , , ,– ," " ,
, ,-- ,.
, ' , , ,/1 ,/7 ,/11 ,
18.09.2003" " , ,-3
. .
52
"
,)16"(
.
158.")( ,
" " ,"
01.09.2002- , ,9
,
,
.
159. ,
-)30" ("
.
"- .
20032003 ,
.
"-90 ,
," ,
2000 ,2001
)/26.(
160. , , ,
.-2"
,-19 .
,"
,
.–-10 ,
,2
" .
, ' ,
,-2 ,
19 ," ,.
53
. ,2"
,.
161. ,
,
. ,
,.
162. ,
,
,
93.124) (" .
, ,
, .
163. ,
" , ,
.
"
164. ,
, ,
)25"(" ,
,
"- .
165./)( ,
. ,-
,
" " , , , ,
,
.
166. ,"
,"]/24 []/23 [
]/25 [) :/4 ,
/2 .(
54
167.
,
.
168." ,
, ,"
,– , .
,
, ,
, ,-22 ,
,.
169." ,
)30"("
, . "–
.34""
."
" ,.
170."1989 ,
,] '15.05.2005 '13 '1-28[:
"]2004–" .... [
, .
. ,
, ,
" , ." ,
,
, ,
, ,]–" [
, ,
, ... ,
, ....
, ,
. .
2002 .-2004 .
...
,."
55
171. ,".
172.] '16.06.2005 , '21 '21-26 , '22 '18-21[:
"]–" [
... . ,
25%]–" []–" [ ,
-17 ,18 ,]–" [
7-8 ,-1-3)/8 ... .(]
–" [ ."
173. ,
.
174. ,
.
,
.
175. :
.
, ,
.
,
.
.
."
,"
2003 ,
,
. ,
" ,
.
.-90 ,
,
.
56
"
176.- ,":
"
, ,
.
45 ."
177. ,
, ,
, ,
,
, ,
.
178. ,
, ,
.
179. ,
, ,
, ,
, ,
, .
57
180."2003 ,
. ,
2007 ,
' , ,
/ .
.2006-2007 ,
10.10.2005 ,
"" , ,"
,20 .–
, . ,
, , . . ,
, ,- ,- ,
,
, ,
. , ,.
"'.
181. , ,
, ,
, .
.
182. ,
, ,.
183. , ,
,
.
184. ,
,
,
.
20 ,"- , ,.
," , .
58
185. ,
, ,
,"
,"
.
186.– , , .
, ,
" ,,
, . ,- ,
, ,
, ,
,
, , ,
, . ,
,"
."
,- , , ,
,
- , ,
,-
.
187.- ,
,
, .
.
.
188."" ,
,,)( :
"5 . , ,
"-
".
59
6 ." ,
,
.
9 . , ,/
,
"
,/
21.
10 .
, ,
, , ,
, ;
;
;
.
11 . ,
,
.
,
.
14 .
,
21")"–"( ,12.04.2005 '10 '6-14 :" ....
. ...."....
') '16 '5 :("" ."" ,12.04.2005 '9 '27 '10 '4 :
"- , ,)–" ( , , ,
, , , ,
". : , '
. , , ," -) (" ,
"") ( ,- ," . , , ,
, , .
60
".
15 . ,
"– ,
,
."
189. ," .
. ' .
- ,
.–.
:
-
190. , , ,
, , ,
,.
191.
, ,
.
192./
. ," , ,
, ,
,
,
,
,
.
193.:
"13 ... . ,
,-
,
... .
61
14 ... . -" "
,... .
15 ... . ,
.
,
- ,
,- ... .
, ,
... .
27 . ,
, .
.... .
... . ,
. ,
. ,... .
93.124" ,
,... .
""
.... :
,
.
, , ,
" ,
."
194. ," ,
,"
)2005"( ,
"–
195.)1( :"
" . , ,
:
"20 ... .–
– , ,
62
. . ,
,. ,
, . ,
.
) ,
– ; , , '209 '
219 .( ,
, ,
)39) .( ,
, , ,
.
21 . .
, .
, ,
. , ,
.
.
,.
22 .
'- ,
, .
, ,".
196. ,
.
,
"
."
, ,
,
, , .
197.
, , ,
63
, , ,
.
198." ,
. ," , ,
, .
.
199. , ,
,
.
200."
,.
201.")" ("
." ,
.
,
," ,
,
.
202. ," ,
,
.
203. ,:
27.7.07""
:"
"
,
– ... .
. ,
64
,
?."
21.1.08 ,"
:"
"– .
:") (–
."
21.1.08 ,"
X:"
") ( ,
. , ,
."
22.1.08"
:"
" : ,
–
. ..
: .
,
. .
."
22.1.08:
""" :"
."
22.1.08""
:"
"" ,
" "––
."
24.1.08:
""
) ( .
,
65
" . .
, ,
."
11.
204. ,
,
, ,
.
205." ,
" , ,
.
206.22.01.2008" "
."
, .
""
.
207." ," ,
,28.1.08 :
" ... .
, ,
, ,
, , ,
, ,
."
208. ,
, ,"
.
209. ,
" ,
66
, , ,
, .
210. ,
.
, ,
, ,
,
.
211.
, . ,
, .
, ,
.
212.
, , ,
.
213. , ,
, , , .
214. ,
,18
,"-1984 ,
,.
215.""
525/84 ' ' ,")1 (673 ,693-695 ,
:
" , ,
."
216. ,
" : ;
–
.
67
217. ,"
, ,
.
218. ,
" , ,
, ,
,
,
, .
,
/
/–"
–– .
" ,
: , ,
, , ,
.
219."
,"
,
,"
.
220. ,2000
--90 ,
2003 :" . .
.
, , , ," .
221. ," ./14"06.08.2003
/ :
68
"5.8.0318:30"
.
10."
222./)16.06.2005 '25 '27( .
223./ ,)
2003 ("" ,
")30.06.2005 '58 '5-7( :"
."
" . :
.
224.
. ,:
.30.08.2004"
.
, , , ,
" ,
")(22 , .
. ,
19.01.200522:00
." ,
, , ,
.
.
.19.12.2007 ,
.
" , ,
. , , .
.
22 , ," , , , , . ,
,-12 , . ," ," ,
– , , , , .
69
.02.01.2008 ,. .73190/04
]–" [ ' . ,
" , ,"
.) '90-91(:
":
,
, , ,
,– , , ,
,
. ,
.
, ,-
. , ,
.
. ,
, .-22
04' . .
, .
) ( , ,
. .
:
) (–– . .
, , .
. . .
. . ,
. .– ,
. , .
, .) (
,–.
. - .
–
. ,.
. ,
,, ."– .
–,," , .
. .
. , .,,
70
?? ." .
, ,
. . .
, .– . ,
, ,
, . , .
, : , , ,
, , .
, ,
.
, ,– .
, . ,
, ,
: , ,
. ,– ,.
. .
? . ,
) ( .-
. . ,."
. .73190/04] -" [02.01.08'.
.06.01.2008. .73190/04]
–" [ ' . '
,"
""
." ,"" :
" ."
- .
.03.02.2008 , '
'2007 ,
.
-
.- '
. ''
, ,
.
225. : .
71
, ,2003 ,
:
,
,
)( ,
- ,
- ,
" "- ,
,
,
" ,
,
)( ,
.
226. , ,
, .
" . ,23 ," ,
. , ," .
" ,"
,"
–"
."
, ,
,
. ,
, ,
23" :" ."
9.
72
."
."
, ,
,–
– , , ,
.
227. , , ,
-5 ,–
– .
.
228. ,
.
, ,
,
, ,
, , ,
.
229. : ,
.
230. , , ,
,
, ,
,
,- ,
/ ,
, , . ,
, ,
,.
73
231. , ,
, ,
,
- .
)
,2002-2003( ,
.
232. ,
. ,
,
," :
" " ." ,
")" (
,
,-01.09.2002
,
, ,
,
.
233. ,) , (–
,– .
,
,.
.
234."4191/97 ' ,")5 (330 ,381
':
" - - .
. ,
") " ,)( ( , ,
--- .
- .."
74
235. ' ,
.
236.:
.
5.2 ,
- ,
.
.
,
.
237. '""
.
____________
,"
"
1.
2.
3.
4.
530.01.07
.
6" '14.05.07.
7" '12.06.07.
8"" "16.08.2007
29.08.2007 ." "14.08.2007.
9" :
."
10.
11.
,. .057859373"
.
__________________________________
" ,",04.02.2008 ,
/" '057859373
,
.
___________________________