2-11-2009

7/29/2019 2-11-2009

1/56

L. S. GOGIA, Advocate,

2/20, Nidhi Apartments,

Shastrinagar, Ahmedabad.

Before the Honble Motor Accident Claims Tribunal at City Civil Court,

Ahmedabad.

M.A.C.P. No. 1054/2005, 1051/05 and 1053/05

Applicant : Kirti Shivprasad Koshti, and othersdaughter of deceased father Shivprasad Koshti.

V/s

Opponent : Iffico Tokio General Insurance Co. Ltd.

Sub: Permission to file the Certified Copies of the Documents in respect

of M.A.C.P. NOs. 1054/05, 1051/05 and 1053/05

In addition to the list of documents already submitted on

records, I have to submit the following Certified Copies of the Documents

for the purpose of authentification, which may please be permitted, in the

interest of justice.

Ahmedabad. ( L. S. GOGIA )

Date 23-7-2012. Advocate.

7/29/2019 2-11-2009

2/56




Before the Honble Motor Accident Claims Tribunal at City Civil Court,Ahmedabad.

M.A.C.P. No. 1054/2005, 1051/05

and 1053/05

Applicant : Kirti Shivprasad Koshti,

daughter of deceased father Shivprasad Koshti.

V/s

Opponent : Iffco Tokio General Insurance Co. Ltd.

LIST OF Certified Copies of DOCUMENTS.

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Sl. No. Subject Remarks.

------------------------------------------------------------------------Page No.---------

M.A.CP. NO. 1054/05

1.. F.I.R. 1-2

2.. M.L.C. 3-4

7/29/2019 2-11-2009

3/56

3.. Death Intimation 5-8

4.. Panchayatnama Avedan Patra 9-10

5. Map Panchayatnama 11-12

6. Handing over Dead Body 13

7. Apex Hospital Certificate. 14

8. Short Report of Death. 15

9. P.M. Report 16- 21

10. M. L. C Report 22-23

11. Final Report 24-26

M.A.C.P. No. 1051/05 ( Ramaben Shivprasad Koshti)

1. Map Panchnama 1-2

2. P.M. Report 3-8

M.A.C.P. No./ 1053/05 ( Hiraben Subashbhai Koshti )

1. Map Panchnama 1-2

2. Handing over Dead Body 3

3. Panchnama of Identification of Dead Body 4

4. Crime Details form 5-6

5. Short report of death 7

7/29/2019 2-11-2009

4/56

6. P.M. Report 8-13

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Ahmedabad ( L. S. Gogia ).

Date : 23-7-2012 Advocate.





Ahmedabad.

M.A.C.P. No. 1054/2005



V/s


7/29/2019 2-11-2009

5/56

7/29/2019 2-11-2009

6/56

There is another alternative method : Take the average of the original

income added with its doubled amount viz. 12,422/ + 24,844/- =

37,266/- divided by two which would come to Rs. 18,633/-

B) There is another Judgment of Sushma Thomas in Para -23 of

the above cited Judgment in which the contention had been raised by the

Applicants that the income should be considered by taking the average of

Pay drawn on the date of death occurred in 1988 and that of the Revised

Pay raised by Revision of Pay Commission in the year 2005, while the case

was lying in Appeal in High Court against the Award was passed by the

Tribunal in 1993 which had been rejected on the basis that revised pay

which has occurred after the period of 2 decades, can not be considered.

(C) In our present case, I have to submit that the claimant had

died in the year 2004 in which he was drawing salary of Rs. 12,422/-

and then his pay had been revised by 6th Pay Commission from the

year 2006, immediately after two years from the death of the claimant,

therefore, it would be just and proper if we take the average of theOriginal salary of Rs. 12,422/- + Revised Salary of Rs. 36,714/- which

would work out to Rs. 49,146/- divided by 2 = 24,573/-.

(d) For considering the prospective income, the age has been fixed

upto 60 years only.

In summing of all the circumstances, I have to submit that

there are clear views of the Judgments that the income should be

considered with regards to the prospective income which means that

prospective income should be based on the notional income but that means,

if there is guaranteed income in near future could also be considered as real

income, and accordingly, the whole income of the revised pay could be

7/29/2019 2-11-2009

7/56

taken as income, but however, as we have to follow the principles as

Rule of Thumb, the income should be taken by taking the average of

salary drawn added wity salary revised by 6 th Pay Commission would

be most appropriate method and that way, it would work out to

Rs. 24,573/- in the interest of justice.

3. DEDUCTIONS TOWARDS PERSONAL AND LIVING

EXPENSES:-

There are guide lines to maintain Uniformity as explained in

HIGH COURT OF DELHI IN 2009 ACJ 1298 P 1300-

PARA -14, under Quantum : -

Where the deceased was married, the deduction towards personal and

living expenses should be

One third (1/3rd), where the number of family members is 2 to 3.

One-fourth (1/4th), where the number of family members is 4 to 6.

One Fifth (1/5th), where the number of family members exceeds Six.

In the present case, therefore, the dedufction is to be taken as

1/3rd only.

4. MULTIPLIER:- The age of the Deceased was just 45 years and

odd, as such, the relevant multiplier would be 13.

5. QUANTUM:-

Future Loss of Income:

24,573/- deduct 1/3 = 16,382/ X 12 x 13= 25,55,592-

7/29/2019 2-11-2009

8/56

7/29/2019 2-11-2009

9/56





Ahmedabad.

M.A.C.P. No. 1051/2005



V/s


7/29/2019 2-11-2009

10/56

7/29/2019 2-11-2009

11/56

(B) For considering the prospective income, the age has been fixed

upto 60 years only.

(C). DEDUCTIONS TOWARDS PERSONAL AND LIVING

EXPENSES:-




Where the deceased was married, generally, the deduction towards

personal and living expenses should be based on :

One third (1/3rd), where the number of f amily members is 2 to 3.



(D) With regards to Deductions towards Personal and Living

Expenses the above case, there is one Judgment viz.

2011 A CJ 998, envisaging therein the Judgment 2001 ACJ 1735 (S.C)

which explains that for prospective income, instead of adding and then

deducting, no deduction be made for the House Wife on account of

personal expenses but to take the Original Income and hence, the originalincome of Rs.5000/- p.m. may be taken as per the above cited Judgment..

3. But, In the present case, no deduction may be taken as this pertains

to the House Wife.

7/29/2019 2-11-2009

12/56

4. MULTIPLIER:- The age of the Deceased was 38 years,

according to which the relevant multiplier would be 16.

5. QUANTUM:-


Rs. 4500/ X 12 x 16= 8,64,000-

Loss of Estate / Loss of consortium 50,000-

Loss of Education/ 50,000-

Transportation 5,000-

Funeral expenses 5,000-

----------------------------

Total 9,74,000-

--------------------------------

6. It is prayed that the compensation of Rs. 9,74,000/- with the

interest @ 15% may please be awarded in the interest of justice.

7. Zerox Copy of the Judgment Judgment viz. -


is attached herewith for kind perusal.


7/29/2019 2-11-2009

13/56

7/29/2019 2-11-2009

14/56

The above named Applicant, has to humbly submit his written

submissions as under:

1. This matter pertains to the deceased, Hiraben Subashbhai

Koshti, who died in the vehicular accident due to negligence of the driver

of the vehicle, the necessary documents of which have been produced

and exhibited on the records of this Honble Tribunal, as such, the

involvement of the vehicle has unequivocally been proved. Therefore,

there remain the issues like - i) Income and the deductions to be made

therefrom, ii) Age and iii) Multiplier, which are narrated as hereunder.

2. INCOME : Deceased Hiraben Subashbhai was a House wife,

whose husband was a Businessman and as she wanted to educate her

children and maintain the standard of her family, she was helping her

husband by doing the Accounting and Financing Work by which she

was earning Rs.5000/- p.m.

A) Unique Method : Increase the Original Income by adding 50%,

by which the deceased would get Rs. 5000 + 50% of 5000/- i.e. 2500/

which would come to Rs. 7500/-.

OR:

There is another alternative method : Take the average of the original

income added with its doubled amount viz. 5000/ + 10,000/- = 15000/-

divided by two which would come to Rs. 7500/-

(B) For considering the prospective income, the age has been fixed

upto 60 years only.

7/29/2019 2-11-2009

15/56

(C). DEDUCTIONS TOWARDS PERSONAL AND LIVING

EXPENSES:-




Where the deceased was married, generally, the deduction towards

personal and living expenses should be based on :

One third (1/3rd), where the number of f amily members is 2 to 3.



(D) With regards to Deductions towards Personal and Living

Expenses the above case, there is one Judgment viz.


which explains that for prospective income, instead of adding and then

deducting, no deduction be made for the House Wife on account of

personal expenses but to take the Original Income and hence, the original

income of Rs.5000/- p.m. may be taken as per the above cited Judgment..

3. But, In the present case, no deduction may be taken as this pertainsto the House Wife.

4. MULTIPLIER:- The age of the Deceased was 34 years,

according to which the relevent multiplier would be 17.

7/29/2019 2-11-2009

16/56

5. QUANTUM:-


Rs. 5000/ X 12 x 17= 10,20,000-

Loss of Estate / Loss of consortium 50,000-

Loss of Guardian /Shelter 50,000-

Transportation 5,000-

Funeral expenses 5,000-

----------------------------

Total 11,30,000-

-------------------------------

6. It is prayed that the compensation of Rs.11,30,000/- with the

interest @ 15% may please be awarded in the interest of justice.

7. Zerox Copy of the Judgment Judgment viz. -


is attached herewith for kind perusal.


Date: 9 7 2012. Advocate of Applicants

7/29/2019 2-11-2009

17/56

7/29/2019 2-11-2009

18/56

7/29/2019 2-11-2009

19/56

7/29/2019 2-11-2009

20/56

Jagdish L. Gogia

M/5/32/255, Shastinagar,

Naranpura,

Ahmedabad. 380 063.

MOBILE NO. 98250 56292.

To

The Manager

The New India Assurance Co. Ltd.,

Legal Cell,

Ahmedabad.

Subject : Details of the Driving License. Of Bhopalsing G. God.

File No. ARO/ MTD/INV/ .

Sir,In the above matter I have received D.L. for the verification.

Regarding this I have visited to the R.T.O. office Ahmedabad and collected

the certificate and the same details of the D.L. are as under :

1. Name of License Holder : Bhopalsing G. God..

2. License Number of Holder : GJ 01 058149/2008

3. D.O.I : 19/4/2008.

4. Issuing R.T.O. : Ahmedabad

5. Valid for : MCE5G, LMV, HGV, P.BUS.

6. Validity : 11/4/2008 TO 18/4/2011.

For the above details we are submitting herewith Certificate for the record.

Yours faithfully,

( Jagdish L. Gogia)

Investigator

7/29/2019 2-11-2009

21/56

Jagdish L. Gogia

Investigator,

M/5/32/255, Shastrinagar,

Ahmedabad.

Mobile No. 98250 56292.

To,

The Manager,

United India Insurance Co. Ltd.,

Regional Office.

Ahmedabad.

Reference No. 3692. FILE NO : 500800/48/12/07/00000026

Subject : Bill for Translation From Gujarati to English.

Sir,

1. Per page 50 * 8 400/-

-----------

Total 400/-

-------------

Yours faithfully,

( Jagdish L. Gogia ) Dated : 4/12/2012.

Investigator.

7/29/2019 2-11-2009

22/56

Jagdish L. Gogia


Naranpura,

Ahmedabad. 380 063.

MOBILE NO. 98250 56292.

To

The Manager


T. P. CLIMS HUB,

Ahmedabad.

Subject : Details of the Driving License. Of Ramsinh Bhurasinh.

File No. 210100/31/97/01/98000749. MACP 725/1996

Sir,

In the above matter I have received D.L. for the verification.



1. Name of License Holder : Ramsinh Bhurasinh.

2. License Number of Holder : 433027/AR.

3. D.O.I : 17/12/1982.


5. Valid for : MMV, HGV AND HPV ONLY

6. Validity : 1. 17/12/1982 TO 16/12/19852. 18/3/1986 TO 17/3/1998

3. 6/11/1992 TO 5/11/1995

4. 4/11/1995 TO 5/11/1998

5. 23/11/1998 TO 5/11/2001


7/29/2019 2-11-2009

23/56

Yours faithfully,

( Jagdish L. Gogia)

Investigator

Jagdish L. Gogia

Investigator,


Ahmedabad.

Mobile No. 98250 56292.

To,

The Manager,

The New India Assurance Co. Ltd.,T. P. Claims Hub.

Ahmedabad.

Subject : Investigation bill for the D. L. of Meghval Talsaji Dharmaji

File No. 210100/31/97/01/98000749. MACP NO. 725/1996.

Sir,

1. D. L. Verification Fees 350/-

-----------

Total 350/-

-------------

Yours faithfully,


Investigator.

7/29/2019 2-11-2009

24/56

Jagdish L. Gogia

Investigator,


Ahmedabad.

Mobile No. 98250 56292.

To,

The Manager,


Claims Hub,

Ahmedabad

Subject : Investigation bill for Theft Claim of Vehicle No. GJ 1 FB 1273

File No. 1591/2009

Sir,

With regards to the above cited investigation case, I have to submit my billfor the said investigation, showing the relevant expenditure incurred for the

purpose as shown below :

1. Investigation Fees 2,000/-

2. Traveling Expenses 550/-

Local Travelling Expenses

3. NCRB Report 150/-

-----------Total 1,700/-

-------------

Yours faithfully,

7/29/2019 2-11-2009

25/56


Investigator.

Jagdish L. GogiaM/5/32/255, Shastinagar,

Naranpura,

Ahmedabad. 380 063.

MOBILE NO. 98250 56292.

To

The Manager


T.P. Claims Hub,

Ahmedabad.

Subject : Details of the Permit and Fitness of Vehicle No. GJ 1 AU 4015.

File No. 321/2064

Sir,

In the above matter I have received PERMIT AND FITNESS

for the verification. Regarding this I have visited to the R.T.O. office

Ahmedabad and collected the certificate and the same details of the Permit

only because the details of the Fitness was not available in the R.TO. So I

AM submitting only permit details which is as under :

1. PERMIT NUMBER : 2005/NP/312.

2. VEHILCE NUMBER : GJ 01 AU 4015.

3. VALIDIDY OF PERMIT : 21/5/2010 TO 20/5/2015


5. Valid for : National Permit

6. Validity : 21/5/2009 TO 20/05/2010.


7/29/2019 2-11-2009

26/56

Yours faithfully,

( Jagdish L. Gogia)

Investigator

Jagdish L. Gogia

Investigator,


Ahmedabad.

Mobile No. 98250 56292.

To,

The Manager,


T. P. Claims Hub.Ahmedabad.

Reference No. 3093. Date of Allo : 29/03/2011 By T.P HUB

File No. 32/2064.

Subject : Investigation bill for the Permit of Vehicle No. GJ 1 AU 4015.

Sir,

1. Permit Verification Fees 750/-

-----------

Total 750/-

-------------

Yours faithfully,


Investigator.

7/29/2019 2-11-2009

27/56

Jagdish L. Gogia


Naranpura,

Ahmedabad. 380 063.

MOBILE NO. 98250 56292.

To

The Manager


Legal Cell,Ahmedabad.

Subject : Details of the Permit and R.C Book of Vehicle No.GJ 1 UU 6139.

File No. ARO/NIAC/PERMIT/FITNESS/08

Sir,

In the above matter I have received PERMIT AND FITNESS

and R.C. BOOK For the verification. Regarding this I have visited to the

R.T.O. office Ahmedabad and collected the certificate and the same details

of the Permit AND R. C. Only Where as we have not get the certificate of

Fitness because the details of the Fitness was not available in the R.TO. So

I AM submitting only permit and R. C. Book and the details of which is are

under :

1. PERMIT NUMBER : 1/AD/1998/GCP/2790.

2. VEHILCE NUMBER : GJ 01 UU 6139.


7/29/2019 2-11-2009

28/56


5. Valid for : Goods Carriage for Gujarat

6. Validity : 06/8/2003 TO 07/08/2008.

7. Owner : Agrawal Radheshyam.

8. Date of Reg. : 31/7/2008, Model 1998.

9. Seating capacity : 2 Persons.


Yours faithfully,

( Jagdish L. Gogia)

Investigator

7/29/2019 2-11-2009

29/56

Jagdish L. Gogia

Investigator,


Ahmedabad.

Mobile No. 98250 56292.

To,

The Manager,


T. P. Claims Hub.Ahmedabad.


File No. 32/2064.

Subject : Investigation bill for the Permit of Vehicle No. GJ 1 AU 4015.

Sir,


-----------

Total 750/-

-------------

Yours faithfully,


Investigator.

7/29/2019 2-11-2009

30/56

Jagdish L. Gogia


Naranpura,

Ahmedabad. 380 063.

MOBILE NO. 98250 56292.

To

The Manager


Legal Cell,

Ahmedabad.

Subject : Details of the R. C. Book . Of Vehicle No. GJ 1 UU 6139

File No. ARO/LC/NIAC/PERMIT/FITNESS/08

Sir,

In the above matter I have received R.C. for the verification.


the certificate and the same details of the R.C. are as under :

1. Name of Holder : Radheshyam H. Agrawal

2. R.C BOOF OF : GJ 1 UU 6139

3. D.O.I : 1998.


5. Valid for : 1998 TO 22/9/2009 and Then

Transferred to Mehsana R.T.O.

22/9/2008

6. ENGINE NUMBER : 282475 AND CHASSIS : 200819


7/29/2019 2-11-2009

31/56

Yours faithfully,

( Jagdish L. Gogia)

Investigator

Jagdish L. Gogia

Investigator,


Ahmedabad.

Mobile No. 98250 56292.

To,

The Manager,United India Insurance Co. Ltd.,

Regional office.

Ahmedabad.

Reference No. 3095. Date of Allo : 04/07/2011 By R.O.

File No.

Subject : Investigation bill for Translation from Gujarat to English.

Sir,

1. Translation Pages 8 * 40 320/-

-----------

Total 320/-

-------------

Yours faithfully,

7/29/2019 2-11-2009

32/56

( Jagdish L. Gogia)

Investigator

From : JAGDISH L GOGIA

M/5/32/255, SHASTRINAGAR,

NARANPURA,

AHMEDABAD - 380 063.

( M ) 98250 56292

TO,THE MANAGER,

UNITED INDIA INSURANCE CO. LTD.

O. D. CLAIMS DEPARTMENT,

ASHRAM ROAD,

AHMEDABAD.

SUBJECT : APPLICATION FOR THE POST OF

INVESTIGATOR.

SIR,

With reference to the subject mentioned above, I have to

apply for the post of Investigator in your Own Damage Claims

Department since I am having sufficient knowledge in the line

based on my qualifications and experience of last 11 years in this

line. My Bio data for the purpose is enclosed here-under for

your kind perusal and consideration.

Thanking You,

Yours faithfully,

7/29/2019 2-11-2009

33/56

( JAGDISH L. GOGIA )

INVESTIGATOR

BIO - DATA

NAME : JAGDISH L. GOGIA

DATE OF BIRTH : 16TH JUNE 1968.

EDUCATIONAL &

QUALIFICATION : B.COM AND LLB.

EXPERIENCE : WORKING WITH NEW INDIA

ASSURANCE COMPANY SINCE

LAST 11 YEARS AS A

INVESTIGATOR

LANGUGES KNOWN: ENGLISH, GUJARAT, SINDHI AND

HINDI.

PLACE : AHMEDABAD.

DATE : 8/7/2011

7/29/2019 2-11-2009

34/56

Jagdish L. Gogia


Naranpura,

Ahmedabad. 380 063.

MOBILE NO. 98250 56292.

To

The Manager

The New India Assurance Co. Ltd.,T. P. Claims Hub,

Ahmedabad.


Subject : Details of the Fitness and R.C Book of Vehicle

No.GJ 1 HD 7333. File No. 210100/31/10/01/9800040.

Sir,

In the above matter I have received FITNESS and R.C. BOOK

For the verification. Regarding this I have visited to the R.T.O. office

Ahmedabad and collected the certificate and the same details of the

FITNESS AND R. C. Only Where as we have not get the certificate of

Fitness because the details of the Fitness was not available in the R.TO. So

I AM submitting only permit and R. C. Book and the details of which is are

under :

1. VEHILCE NUMBER : GJ 01 HD 7333.


7/29/2019 2-11-2009

35/56

3. Owner : Devjibhai J. Patel

8. Date of Reg. : 2003.

9. Engine Number : 34719.


Yours faithfully,

( Jagdish L. Gogia)

Investigator

7/29/2019 2-11-2009

36/56

Jagdish L. Gogia

Investigator,


Ahmedabad.

Mobile No. 98250 56292.

To,

The Manager,The New India Assurance Co. Ltd.,

T. P. Claims Hub.

Ahmedabad.


File No. 210100/31/10/01/9800040.

Subject : Investigation bill for the R. C. Book of Vehicle.

No. GJ 1 HD 7333

Sir,

1. R. C. Verification Fees 500/-

-----------

Total 500/-

-------------

Yours faithfully,


7/29/2019 2-11-2009

37/56

Investigator.

Jagdish L. Gogia


Naranpura,

Ahmedabad. 380 063.

MOBILE NO. 98250 56292.

To

The Manager


Legal Cell,

Ahmedabad.

Subject : Details of the Driving License. Of Bhagvandatt k. yadav.

File No. ARO/ MTD/INV/30.

Sir,




1. Name of License Holder : Bhagvandatt k. yadav.

2. License Number of Holder : GJ 01 2005/0110146

3. D.O.I : 26/8/2011.


5. Valid for : MCE5G, LMVCAB,TRAN S,

P.BUS AND 3W-NT.

6. Validity : 26/8/2011 TO 25/8/2014.

7. Not Valid : 30/6/11 to 24/8/2011

7/29/2019 2-11-2009

38/56


Yours faithfully,

( Jagdish L. Gogia)

Investigator

Jagdish L. Gogia

Investigator,


Ahmedabad.

Mobile No. 98250 56292.

To,

The Manager,

The New India Assurance Co. Ltd.,Legal Cell.

Ahmedabad.

Reference No. 3132. Date of Allo : 24/12/2011 By Legal Cell.

FILE NO : ARO/MTD/INV/30.

Subject : Investigation bill for the D. L. of Bhagvandatt k. yadav.

Sir,

1. D. L. Verification Fees 350/-

-----------

Total 350/-

-------------

Yours faithfully,


Investigator.

7/29/2019 2-11-2009

39/56

Jagdish L. Gogia


Naranpura,

Ahmedabad. 380 063.

MOBILE NO. 98250 56292.

To

The Manager

The New India Assurance Co. Ltd.,Legal Cell,

Ahmedabad.

Subject : Details of the R.C Book of Vehicle No .GJ 18 T 9356

File No. TPHUB CDU 210200 2006 800017/526

Sir,

In the above matter I have received R.C. BOOK For the

verification. Regarding this I have visited to the R.T.O. office Ahmedabad

and collected the certificate of R. C. Book and the details of which is are

under :

1. Name of Owner : Chartred Carries Ltd.

2. VEHILCE NUMBER : GJ 18 T 9356.

3. VALIDIDY From : 2003


7/29/2019 2-11-2009

40/56

5. Date of Reg. : 2003.


7. Engine Number : 62256954


Yours faithfully,

( Jagdish L. Gogia)

Investigator

7/29/2019 2-11-2009

41/56

Jagdish L. Gogia

Investigator,


Ahmedabad.

Mobile No. 98250 56292.

To,

The Manager,The New India Assurance Co. Ltd.,

T. P. Claims Hub.

Ahmedabad.

Reference No. 3263. Date of Allo. : 28/11/2011 By T.P HUB

File No. 800017/526

Subject : Investigation bill for the Permit of Vehicle No. GJ 18 T 9356.

Sir,


-----------

Total 500/-

-------------

Yours faithfully,


Investigator.

7/29/2019 2-11-2009

42/56

Jagdish L. Gogia

Investigator,


Ahmedabad.

Mobile No. 98250 56292.

To,

The Manager,


T. P. Claims Hub.

Ahmedabad.


File No. 210200/2006/800017/526.

Subject : Verification of R. C. Book and Bill of GJ 18 T 9356.

Sir,


-----------

Total 750/-

-------------

Yours faithfully,


Investigator.

7/29/2019 2-11-2009

43/56

Jagdish L. Gogia


Naranpura,

Ahmedabad. 380 063.

MOBILE NO. 98250 56292.

To

The Manager

The New India Assurance Co. Ltd.,Legal Cell,

Ahmedabad.

Subject : R.C Book of Vehicle No.GJ 18 T 9356.

File No. 210200/2006/800017/526

Sir,

In the above matter I have received R.C. BOOK For the

verification. Regarding this I have visited to the R.T.O. office Ahmedabad

and collected the certificate and the same details of the R. C. Book and the

details of which is are under :

1. Vehicle Owner : Shah Dipesh S.

2. VEHILCE NUMBER : GJ 01 UU 6139.



7/29/2019 2-11-2009

44/56

5. Valid for : Goods Carriage for Gujarat

6. Validity : 06/8/2003 TO 07/08/2008.

7. Owner : Agrawal Radheshyam.

8. Date of Reg. : 31/7/2008, Model 1998.



Yours faithfully,

( Jagdish L. Gogia)

Investigator

7/29/2019 2-11-2009

45/56

Jagdish L. Gogia


Naranpura,

Ahmedabad. 380 063.

MOBILE NO. 98250 56292.

To

The Manager


Legal Cell,Ahmedabad.

Subject : Details of the R. C. Book . Of Vehicle No. GJ 1 CD 5250

File No. TPH/

Sir,

In the above matter I have received R.C. for the verification.


the certificate and the same details of the R.C. are as under :

1. Name of Holder : Kantibhai Ukabhai Vala

2. R.C BOOF OF : GJ 1 CD 5350

3. D.O.I : 2000.


5. Valid for : 8/9/2000 TO 14/9/2003 and Then

Transferred

6. ENGINE NUMBER : 06757 AND CHASSIS : 91757


7/29/2019 2-11-2009

46/56

Yours faithfully,

( Jagdish L. Gogia)

Investigator

Jagdish L. Gogia

Investigator,


Ahmedabad.

Mobile No. 98250 56292.

To,

The Manager,

The New India Assurance Co. Ltd.,T. P. Claims Hub.

Ahmedabad.

Reference No. 3383. By T.P HUB

File No.

Subject : Verification of R. C. Book and Bill of GJ 1 CD 5250.

Sir,


2. Driving License Verification 350/-

-----------

Total 850/-

-------------

Yours faithfully,


7/29/2019 2-11-2009

47/56

Investigator.

Jagdish L. Gogia


Naranpura,

Ahmedabad. 380 063.

MOBILE NO. 98250 56292.

To

The ManagerThe New India Assurance Co. Ltd.,

T. P. Claims Hub,

Ahmedabad.

Subject : Details of the Driving License. Of Kantibhai Vala.

File No. 210400/01/98000027.

Sir,


Regarding this I have visited to the R.T.O. office Ahmedabad and collectedthe certificate and the same details of the D.L. are as under :

1. Name of License Holder : Kantibhai Vala.

2. License Number of Holder : GJ 01/011317/2000

3. D.O.I : 19/8/2000.


5. Valid for : MCEX. 50CC

6. Validity : 19/8/2000 TO 31/5/2016.


7/29/2019 2-11-2009

48/56

Yours faithfully,

( Jagdish L. Gogia)

Investigator

Jagdish L. Gogia


Naranpura,

Ahmedabad. 380 063.

MOBILE NO. 98250 56292.

To

The Manager


T. P. Claims hub,Ahmedabad.

Subject : Details of the Driving License. Of Viral A. Jhaveri.

File No. ARO/ TPH/INV/210100/31/04/01/98000177 .

Sir,




1. Name of License Holder : Viral Ananatbhai Jhaveri.

2. License Number of Holder : 99/M/10102.

3. D.O.I : 29/01/1999.


5. Valid for : M/Cycle Only.

6. Validity : 29/1/1999 TO 28/1/2019.


7/29/2019 2-11-2009

49/56

Yours faithfully,

( Jagdish L. Gogia)

Investigator

7/29/2019 2-11-2009

50/56

Jagdish L. Gogia

Investigator,


Ahmedabad.

Mobile No. 98250 56292.

To,

The Manager,


Claims Hub.

Ahmedabad.

Reference No. 4002. Date : 25/02/2013

File No. 210001Claims Hub File Vehicle No. GJ 1 BY 5624.

Subject : Bill for Translation from Gujarat to English.

Sir,

1. Translation Bill ( Pages 20 * 45 ) 900/-

-----------

Total 900/-

-------------

Yours faithfully,


Investigator.

7/29/2019 2-11-2009

51/56

FROM : L. S. Gogia Date : 21/6/2012


Shatrinagar,

Naranpura,

Ahmedabad.

To

The Medical Officer, Date: 5- 7 -2012.

C.G.H.S. Hospital,Pragatinagar,

Ahmedabad.

Subject : Issue of Letter to Shalbi Hospital.

Sir,

I have to request you to issue a letter to Shalbi Hospital for

the Treatment as advised in the case paper attached herewith. Two copies

of the C. G. H. S card and case papers are enclosed.

Yours faithfully,

( L. S. Gogia )

7/29/2019 2-11-2009

52/56

7/29/2019 2-11-2009

53/56

4. TPH/DHK/175 REPORT TO BE PREPARED

5. TPH/210200/2012/98000010 REPORT TO BE PREPARED

6. TPH/210100/31/04/01/98000264 DUE TO NON RECIEPT

OF CRIMINAL

7. TPH/210601/31/96/01/98000391 DUE TO VERY OLD CASE

PAPERS ARE NOT AVAILABLE IN THE CRIMNAL COURT.

8. TPH/ORPHAN/11-12/701 DUE TO OUT STATION

ACCIDENT PAPERS ARE PEDNING.

9. TPH/210100/31/05/01/98000018 DUE TO SUMMARY

FILED CASE PAPERS ARE NOT IN ORDER.

10. 107160/LC/CCC DUE TO SUMMARY CASE PAPERS

ARE NOT IN ORDER IN THE COURT

11.TPH/2012/210600/31/09/02/98000046 ONLY

CHARGESHEET IS PENDING DUE TO WRONG CHARGE

SHEET IN THE CRIMINAL PAPERS.

1. Eight cases are very old and very less chanses to be received

criminal papers from the criminal court.

2. Three case papers are ready only report prepared within couple of

days.

( Jagdish L. Gogia)

7/29/2019 2-11-2009

54/56

Investigator

Jagdish L. Gogia


7/29/2019 2-11-2009

55/56

Naranpura,

Ahmedabad. 380 063.

MOBILE NO. 98250 56292.

To

The Manager


Regional Office.

Ahmedabad.

Subject : Reply of your email.

Sir,

Regarding e. mail dated 5/2/2013, I have to state as under :

1. I have to state that I have translated all the documents from Gujarati to

English myself for which I am giving herewith in affirmation and

confirmation that the translation is done by me, Which may please be

taken as singed y me by this message.

2. Regarding your matter of nomination I have to state that all the parties

of the case are residing out side the Gujarat state as such there being

no scope of getting the names of the nominees of the claimants I have

not been able to comply with your requirements.

Thanking You,

Yours faithfully,

( Jagdish L. Gogia )

7/29/2019 2-11-2009

56/56

AFFFIDAVIT

I, the undersigned, Abdulhak A. Shaikh aged 38 years, Muslim

by caste, doing thee Job of Business, residing at 570, Noornagar, B/H, Port

Office, Rakhail, Ahmedabad, do affirm and state on oath as under :

1 Regarding the quirry as to how the distance between Vapi and

Ahmedabad has been shown as per meter reading, whereas it is actually 470

kms, I have to clarify that first I had gone to Jealpur after returning from

Vapi of repairs where I found no repairers were available there for my

vehicle and in that trip from Ahmedabad to Jetalpur and back, about 117

kms were travelled. The Jetalpur repairers told me to go to Sarkhej-Sanand

Road where the concerned repairers are available. So, thereafter, I had

gone to Sarkhej-Sanand road for the repairs and in that trip I have travelled

about 40 Kilometers from Rakhail to Sarkhej as such, return from accident

place VVapi to Ahmedabad and later on Rakhail to Jetlpur and back Rakhail

and again from Rakhail to Sarkhej-Sanand Road, the meter has shown the

reading of 587 Kilo Meters in all.

2.. The above statement is true as per my personal knowledge and I

believe the same to be true and correct.

Solemnly affirmed at Ahmedabad, on 13/3/2013,

Identified by me, Deponent