Final Report

Volume One - Executive Summary

Basewide Energy Study

Fort Indfantown Gap

19971016 254

O,

Dre4Rl % tVT Or Till kR%fl

47 Sop 194

S f 4 .1Wn Ow f.tfcnlcd' £tudlrs Are Lc~uteilhiCit iLhtluttol% A. Atw-vced ire public re'eAie..

MbArta e&.'akefvetd

Final Report

Volume One - Executive Summary

BASEWIDE ENERGY STUDY

FORT INDIANTOWN GAP

0

Prepared for

DEPARTMENT OF THE ARMYFort !ndlantown Gap

Annvllle, Pennsylvanla

Prepared by

XENERGY INC.S0 Mill Road

Bu rlington, Mausachuaetta

Juno, 1988

TABLE Of CONTENTS

section Pogo

VOLlU~M I

I INWODUCI1ON 1.1Il Purpow 1-1

2 scopf *(Work WWI 1-1III. Iamnci mnA 1.112.2. jIrofloi t 8 122LI.) IriatmewtF 1.21.24 Inaermnt C 1-31.2. Pvojcd Dmw~tahmo 1.3

2 mm WCS~CEERGY coImsummoNC 2.1

2.2 14iatoilf amwr Use 2.12.3 1mv Inud UN FY 1945 2.30 2.4 t.'iq Fue Us. Imiadown - FYI! *imvgh FM8 2.32.8 To.ut M u tvkA 2.32A WbvL~w' I luildly Envoy Us 2-s

3 EWRCY 0ONSERVAM40PMMOrTYNI ISCOSUMMARY S.1

3.2 QRV aWdflCW $4!

34 Rwss MemiSewnift Cenwro Symorw~. lvhsftn 34

34.1 Cotnc!an 310013.2 racnmttedamqi & imp~ 1enpT~i Men

SECTION I

0 EXECUTIVE SUMMARY

1.1 Pwrpos.

The pwrpoo of t~s Executive Swwnay is to eurrnw~ae &h imodis of tIM NP.

TMe Amsy EMIwy Plan,.3w , jsblhhe inealy I In, ami both uhotoi and long teNm * m gy as Wo fthArmy conuJimm with the Pretldmntial Exmecutive Order 123 Issued in auid.1977. It tellwathe AjeAmiy onAwrads to wdeeeop detailed Im tenaume plans and fundil gdwommntas. The NationalFrneqy Casm~atow PolicyAct CNIO'A) of 19M2 direts that ai fll Wids owtod anid" op tcd byakdeftl Almny must havs an aneurv conservation etrofits pebwwne by i Jastuary 1950.

mh Daartmenl of heAmny. toWmgh the Corps of Engliwews ahimmc. has contracted with XV;l\U Y

kic. to ptovWd the Ineqy Inglne"wn Aralysis Propsm (SEAP) at Fat ladiantown Gap under contract

number DACA31 .8"117. The rm.Tsof *stuegidy one indchtes indetult in ith wain meport Dackupchlcuations have been prwledd under sepirtle vcAiwwto the C"r of Engaer.

10 1. U p 5@ot'Work (SOW)

Them0.mremnwofwok t b powdd , taedIn th.maract am. o folowS.

1.2.1 Increnwnt A

housing, to aiaht the bildislnproe, earwt efficient. hm oblndseldd ihlcue n

speckwledya onable was anted Wodng the 120 buiIdAsS to bmt Wkaded La the field sunvy abnS withthe Enerop Conservation Opporturst'es (ICO)ID be trAMhW. Net allbU~dlrgasthe Post Wereawninad I* ebib SOW, but instead,.a oew mmw &h ones. Abertispcled hintheSCO eAavk not ervery ICC %wexaavdned (or each Wulding alm emany wett not applcble orappioprisma. Despitt this, testy satiabl energycrinsl propeb were formed at Whs Post.

Cornputer nteling was uWsd o incorporate Wil surisy dais, wcather dau, oupanq cluhuules,

0riyitiuivs m n soquipmnnt data Minsa model efthetyicab~ileep svn and hovalclate poal boss ens i~ conerede ompuw ostunidtee. heop-dmpu Mdl was

capale f asi~g *s eagyra tsofbsmadicngpel n iati fhetl. Mcorlng, arnodavnlwat

kq euvpnnt rripwgyd lstriution ayaaemaW aoemil conersiontequtpml. Ne,4Conputer rmoawas eacifled aganst historical enet use. Mwe wnpuito pragam asalyd the Installation of on hour.by-hiour baei" The com~puter rode vied was DOIE*2 which ha sbevomete Ownduusty suilandd. lItIscomparable to the BLAST perr'i used by Nw Aimy,

Increvnent 11profrcts tawohe utiltics snd enetgy dietbudo syslems, EMCS for bttMzld l d

5?4CS for buildinig lecca. mechanicalr and utthly distributioun systrens The lavaitof thisstady is todetermin the baic cacatvasi arclsatecire of the EMCS to the esterat thet 7elrmary econornic csaculatitmsallbe made odewermine feasiblity per CW oter. The do eintlee shellbe of ufftdenlacuacyqlo bier. Othat uture pm Ject ilesit caiculatlont that %411 be done efte W"mle *A d this study voIl notO devate wroe thatn 20 percent frMM the reautie af "u usdy.

The* results of this Mincrrent Windste ftot a cenntretsed IMCS i A nt rcammnesd at FMe IndieniwlinCepat this atrwaince the Sltcritetn iskas. thin )A Szn'e.a of the 120buildinp did qualify antily tobeVM gupdinto a systM of auomated contrIs, bitt tAkOc A*$ Whtole, wbtien the WINs Of centraliztng MWdnofreaegyttelAted costs waert considened, faWed to meet Ite SIR ciliertl. As iechnolop and femgypnic

dranpe in the future. acent4ails 1W In(Shn t be 1os(t'eletve.

eam wtdaa the Onector of Esiet lg a&M Housag funding suthSmity and managcineti %rombvie. Thesep"JM1 we stio Warred toeas low coet/noceeo Ptclacw In ti~s cOPe dofWsh. IMe Itenti of thisbincrelle Is to peovWIe eergy "Osav fecomsnaCndatres In the lm of rpefic, pr&(Actl 001'sicitons (fo

of eo sersavilalefo )o~s ac~o b th polThese Irdude reduce lighitm Moutm. dowiaalenozzles. .eot Vents. donmestic iOt water rio Cosollo, cost, rmcnfipur DHW tank.

0.

2.4 Increment 0

0 G "Oft a thosSe k savi pr" dovdOopecd in A Ia 0 wch do

The t)o e ftwdy were Nta few o E !COdid not law ft ECI c?,MA, namhy reduce

wfndow stm. drop c I•swuation•cl vrt b coa l. llmps andballast and O&M.

1.= PIoaectDocurentatloan

FwAly, t& SOW deines ad that prot domami-, sdon Ol*u Ybe ad bec the followi fundial

types: ECTP, ICsWad QRW. After review wt all e cmcd, five e" patetprotdocunt•.

Wocn vbeenecreafed. In tadtiff , ote ICN vert grouped frlocal acton oly. intaly. •COs w

11sad wooft c ci*dkveat1prnojcts were develope for fitrm ICO& Mea. grcnrb&naraemme~lud tn rrble 1-..

0ItCPJl3P. I,$

Table 1-1ECO Orounp~n Summery

Pw~ectType COS

QRIP In RelwrV'bfli Ughv"

Fee-psi1 Howlng SYSIenls Conrwols

PECP 2 Oultrgalcaion Fard

PECIP #3 PF" and Dod fstiNon

Root InsulationFlowe InjautfionC&a.k W4d WeatherStropkigStorm windows

Stor DoorsDo(* StaffCOllids Air RoutI CoreolS

Loca Action Only fiMncwtinl F) ROOM~C LMAlRIQ NWSr

Romove V~ftDHW No COS!U~w Coslfleconflgue 0"4 Tank

NoI CodES awsiv ("Mortwr 0) III&CO wrh*w OmgD'OP C.Mg and imlownICorw to 1 CootCIAM

I.fi Sn"ASaSI

01

SICTION 2EXISTING ENERGY CONSUMPTION

V. Inroductlon aWdSumnwry

FIG uses four (4) diffeaM tutla to mauiafy the ewp gyinput uuquirrments c(1Ow facility. Auels Utilized are

thaldly,1 Aid (Nlo. 2 and No, 6), propane iad cal. Dwlng FMSS I. M IWcom eslur"ilf was 118,061MMsI..A ecuo 5s lIgI toyf.2?i se le.Ie all owiWn

ltae for FY83 was 39,703 ITUI/CSF/YFK Mal~n rwm~iah for healing dJgr" days recorded for die site

In FY83% Owconsmptioraftte"I t~o8.77 IM~/GS?/HDD. A breasbowneftirdiotfudgussdat

PIC wchldaonpele l Ita) W comumptiost for Il dvmhicgt M Is shown inT*12-I. Ac~illusn~itlot

of th permet odOwtota~l mwuntptln each ftsd type rupf~t%.s lor FY33 orly, Is sbownit n Flgur 2.1

An analysls o1 (FICaeom *nc haws been candcted and is prownlad and msvsludm in Af aurs 2-1

alirugl 2.31. A brief dhacesslon ofeach kmsi to provided on page 2.3.

rip"rc 2.1 through Figur 2.3 hove boon pl*ottd ham ls dwcaw shsowsin Table 2.1. Use enargy anid

0builcldiaig nventory arm data shwon in Tabl 2-1 Is t*At wNch was provided Wy te Anny for FIG.

Inery ensunsption daza (or FIC for the yesrs FY 1#71 throuh FY I OW was unavaigable.

2.2 NstoricaI iwrgy Use

Table 2.1 ummida 13sefallalrywlde ewlergy data (afote healynt 1961 dtougll IOU3 MAlokbwd a

hettedr4deeedays basetWIF and *41 oliding Inwnt" syaea data fot dthe yvartacdmatsed.

0111019w-ey .

Table 2-1

0 Poclilty.WW. Ensrgy Oalo for FY61 -FY65IM66 FY 111112 FY1163 " 1114 M M36

Ewftasy Wac* (MBeno n740 3A.305 29.467 :11721 216,412

FW OffUsap(MOTU) 111.120 '1131011 112,59 00.818 *6.31

Popane Usage IMISTU) 6.041 4,62t 6.715 7.244 7.109

Cosl UW* (MSTUI) 17,101 36.944 38,201 46.302 K12M

T0OTAL USE (MOTU] 164.309 MICA6~ 167.34 161,091 i1118.0

IWCWIfq Degee Ollyl 0.7110 4,610 4.921 5.12 4.525

ScluatS roCaoll(KSIJ 4,7'$ 7 4.7367 4,7367 4,7367 4,736V

'TOTAL USE CMOTUfl(Sl) 3481 42.112 3055 3623 1"970

'TOTAL USE (K87Uf'BIHOD 000600 000129 000002 0 0=93 0.00177

. Convotuiomr:

hE~lsnity 3413 MBlUfmWIIOwi 25 4 MSTljrlnPrplne 0.026 UBT~lrgallonFuel O01021 41138.700 SIUI/aoflltrus 01, #6 149.700 SILu/gaIn

e36.* a e2 3.2

2.3 Energy End Use - Y 108

I'Ipme2. ilhwstre th pewer of dv bohal ~Onw~rmp oeach fuel yem repriesen Ik1fdby is used for

btt*g fma pump,, mIWcellanews eqTdpmm1 ard son*w coolin. huIelf I, isued (or huatirt andd cwieti ostertlet'g, with moat used for lteadrig. Coal Is usedsutrctly for ?taiming. Popant is used for

dosnestic wattr MeINN and COW14n Space heat~n VAn dorriestc wowe holri gcosr KX% of the

M. Energy fuel Use Breakdown - FY61 throu;h FY86

T.mgrsph in Figure 24 shows ereWg Kill me trendsi over hayeanstuhdied. lrcipaiwarid emcy~lviyuehave mulaied feirlycoamsant. Fuel oil constmption Indicates a slow wend &wnwayd. as coalcuswrsp tlozas. Nsth ilothe ogIN crii conversion of (uel oil-fired equipmerietso coul~lsed"eqatip~n whdic appesnoly has bee occurring over the (lye ear, period studied. Nonihsesth fuel usedid increate bm.oknre Y IMa and FV 1003.

2.8 Total Ineirgy Use Trends

The graph signe 2.pmZrssncie btw " inle'gy ue Gt AC Fos 1961 through 1955 in MI7Us (eft scalt-).

0for Ow Art year period studied, tIe data Indicates Oithedenrgy 6w shows boeth incimresin arid decrweasug

tendAsyear soyear. Even whe~ffat uomisd by heatingdegree s~as shwtby the 131U/I/HDO(right omat) the energy Itertnim; does rot show a Meet Increavaii or decresing trend.

0 rtII -

Figure 2.1energy End-Use Breakdown (FY logs)

0 ~Fort Indlentown (lop, WOWrn, PA

4.21% I C"o mUp MITU)

Figure 2-2Energy Fuel Use Breakdown

Fort Indlaritown Cop, Annville, PA

"14000

NEWw ~~ Ucalue

*00flG.A~d 8

Fgure 2.3

Total Energy UseFort Indlentown Gap, Arninville, PA

Total EurW Us*Fac Manbtown Gap, Amvl~e, PA

250,000.!010

2000.000 0.0000

100,000 0.00600

100,000 l0.004000,O000 '0.00200

0' -160.00000FY( IN1 F'Y ImSJ t 11183 fy 111114 Fy tells

Tow S TU) Tonta us pKtairmmi)

2.M Individual Building Energy Use

Table 2-• p•ents htiddual building pa(oerunce data for lfl 32Dbuildlng plus the uea €omimdoqs

sudbid for tie study. The towal lCRrl, shown Isroach yeat (breach bultkiln kdo t•dudeelemktotityconsumed as astmawd by the D0 .2 c.rmulatmoa. 7he KUU/af rg llsation shmo for each Wutli;: for

FM Indudes who tails are used In the uIldin fot spec heating avid domwslt water heating andslocetity. Data for the table %as pmvldd by agalt .al bells (or esh buidir and the esti•m-do lcilr uae derivd kom the 00D-2 simulations.

The totalFYIfS W ekil•fucl was 87215 MM (%551 of the postr MIol) Od the Mal ekctddtywe was

*,N4,920 kWh (46% of the poltl Wo4*). Almo sikwn in TWl 2-2 atiete peak heating and coolig loads foreach ,bun0 n&r as well as kne emrgy utilizatlon Index (KIbTU/s.t TUe ewny vtliza cm Inden Includesjthe ItsitO fuel and elactlcati use shown.

flGO4-42 2.5

Toble 2-2S1J:,i,-ysd luldIng Ust friled by D1sllding

)4i242.s fl1.406197 PWINS 814.ali Cidblag BMWqWdnS W A; Am U: pool full LAd LAW UU146110"

20004 no 7214 4406 73 245 34241 2no920010 *Ab Will4 01."7 12 42982 27oo 329901:42 Cimpo! 3.1411 1&.123 2,20 12912 2214 3839IT32.104 hAN ilq. 2.39 11241 No 09194 It00 12144We@0 Offics 6,717 17.466 6m 3111Z 3OL14 1075

0.114 0swm 2.u AM47 421 9104 22111) 1 230104.12? Cy"i :1, 20Z572 1,72 1,1410 74032 IC4?9"1922 11 so.0g "21 112114 Wi.t1 1.123 43141 29440 224*?"I426 IT? W 21,64 244 $*As 21140 20490Wm3 Ofce Zia Is14 2392 l1) 74s 410 319991s"5.053 h61rck 4.11 UP3 W4 24.2 101.14 21.3002.04 Ofi~ce 2.00o 12.4 M 4320 24.2 A494

"7 mst n LO U90 2V 4a3 4011 15.67

Ull?~.212 2.2SI*S40 4.18 t 4m 17121

07.23! offic. 1.100 11.190 331 ")m a"9 1204)07.23 too ?ASS0 $4,001 1ti1t 2IV1 3 45 l90itWild3 Offic. 1.01 4.404 070 34,34 31116 261141F.1135 COffce I=22 2144 290 7049 4237 19463

01-1101 Offic. 'A1 4*44 1.1 3am2 3249 111.01W-421 Now Rp. 2.1106 112341 5m 10200 No* 21120W,44 0ffi.. 2.270 Um9 W9 nu. 4&9. 1IMOWd=3) W90 rim) 20127 451 US2 221705 1Will0240004 too 5m 35.332 192 3?3L 2)143 an301,011 glfe. 31.1111 1442 191 11921 to"9 low401.012 0ffic. 3.20? 20.13 243 an* 77.20 IV1320.1) ('fice 1."? 12.221 300 PA.9 46 02 233000160111 Office t,647 25.01 242 "76 $161 247740.320 LanA*Y L.10 lint3 2NS 1239 70u5 10944mot0 0ffice R32 UN2 296 254 MAI8 24.2)0.02 80"mcb 4.m0 WIN4 471 2491? 1312) 2760.06%1 llread. 4,1111 24.33 3Ho a343 2129 litIS 140.10M2 ffc I9. P.4 U4.4 1in M." 329 Sit4*0.0113 herada 4.333 lk.9 Sit 2493 2)433 149420.04M moo. Ma.2 .163 220) 9 740 2392 25.2P942 Isaradi 4.3 23.10191 0 24971, 138.21 221901044 satscam 4,300 Will4 623 249? 2143421 115)740.%23 Offic. LIPS 4O4N it3 31.1 2.46 33702

046A6 Si.7ay 3.41 4,01141 0t5 90 ALM4 2201@11-W km.). 4.20 2K.2M 424 07" 12131 25112

: m"ka 4,1011) sill" 119 son sun Mi454.30c " 11.214 449 24971 229.2 .11.

301,71 llmas 4.30 35.118 4 249717 fun3 f?,23094 Office 3132 24S2 977 U29.2 IRA" 2*3362044M Lob 4I124 211,114 I'm9 22926 231.13 372089499 04aeu N. 3.94 11.747 024 10N 2990 116,)099oo4 S.'Iftiltod 2.1m 1111106 20 ni23 "do9 WI2N2306) out 111.940 11,7129 3.372 4540 540MS46 1173423067 1100 U140 04.02 144 2304? 32840 90102300 Librety, 4.311 21199 064 III3P2 32)26 72422604)40 ... 04.$ mail ;.W .376 220 8022 11641 2349720o2 I..w*. 4.720 M.21 43 2749 a)226 U2442210,011 sam), 41.720 91732 , I"? 274 31026 22627

1GP.r02 6324

0 Tsbbs 2-2 (Conltinued)

110,211111, 11n0 7450 520 2714 1273 10*212423 Iumng L.PG 2W,93 11 18112 2"456 SO."

21416 63297.we 1.11, U.r70 3Us MIS 311* 104 112404

=12 0222. 50,02 32406 WS 1604.0 242.70 2201111420 Semmes .144t 245.m U 3 752439 S43M 4113it1ais stesge 2UN pot70 ft6 W06 U19 99.611

*11841 3,41. 31220 3 2) i li2 t $1 22L.2*12-006 S.1e72 1 019 413.911 2*48 111"6 8314 I0*9

12-03 01112.w 2019 43.1* 1 341.1 312249 131319

if-.06 a"*d a"e~g 45.2 n9o8 U3 .9012 14.1127 am1113.09 Swap4r LM* 406.72 ice4 4.092 M911 61.13114"9 Liesm m 102 0O ?A 2041 f33.9

22031 H.4t 42 2." 9 AM 52 42J 0040 wo 01214 1177I* 2.10M Catelie 1W 48.8111 U56 30s9 111 1470

24293 0432. 4D.= 0,3 A70 4.1.04327 7 02 21117142021 300lw 1192111 26.962 419 22116 2511.26 am3*114105 Office 1.0 4 1a 26.14 316t 2412324103 60m 4.24 57 7I 1 is 6642 2204 2101013.204 as Hi00 U.93 3A.94 731 12.97 1111 31117023.176 300oo 2,174 26.4 7111 223 0414 2691430* 30fic 0.79 21*2 9 219108 324 29

14116 alik 2.391 a"77 M1 14" 2244 1369241O 3no I.M9 33*5 *29 2113.6 224441 20696

142S GO 420 ZW2' M* 171 3 4614 23042 211464342226 000 2.79 2X.0 429 22216 2042 306*23.223 g~loo 4NS 32.09 in 3.71 3304 2A6139242246 8..2 02.2 . 122201 47 1711311, 2040 W964

33.226 No.2 w22 2.4 2316" O 92003 210 '696423.220 34.2 Ca ." 2.4 3210 to4 3209 1064 25.0WHO alike. 4UN IV?16 741 3244 13431 19181*1110 W4eQ 3,111 2woo 362 122* 22224 296.2324202 0111" SAO9 21.13 M6 22709 12328 lout*1616 )%& 4.1*Cin ?I 34.20 61, 112,91 20.1 251%4242116 W 0422. IM42 111.116 44 M1)9 N0.10 $091W3.20 ii 043, 5.137 340 1114 2329 329.0 2962

*2101 Office 4.441 5640 .to 111,06 2991 111164114062N Office am il M43 11306 2131 47 396034NN OWrNqi &W2 21&717 7111 2492 213949 224W1101 0a2ike &4AV W"9 444 lit"4 200 20434

23.II 02321 1.421 111.1"S 90 130 IS 2V474 29I"

0" 2 O12 fine 1449 2441 L176 24174 I)SO" 296441

W2X2. C-- 4.1 3 .7 O 1 14 21

TWbO VA2 (CocnCludsd)

1441? 4g"e LW 14.20 40 Wnn IWAS me16419 Illoop &MI 14A) 04M W34 19.1 MIS4*MCI 5.w Plust 2A2 21474 IN4 )13617 IN" WA)WcoR A14w24C,4d. 12.04 2043 4413 MCI44 3641 WAM

M-219 CItac. 2.M If.27 bl ISM 74.0 10"*

two*4 ak MW O1=i W0 MY1 7144? M204

31-M Orlsen 141 MMS 0 Who, 2114 2119

Isas.1. IlleWay up% e NPom aMA Woove164~d IPu uhie we dav" fd 9M 001. DM.2I bwAV

Nmt lomod 1) W~di.. hod a aetded rF"laftala had on. bboaledm.AMv hem 0014 WWNNO. I %dW 1442 bk 104044 V800. AeIM dh d WOl attu Ul a d MeJR hil .Wmpq.He..4 bav .1 1,46 *Mc t4~W oa efdy *Wet. ON Well voso

New A~ 2h~adup4.01 ol eepeudsdh~40i ousein "S25% mneD plam Aebleda

SECTION 3

ENERGY CONSERVATION OPPORTUJNITY (ECO)BUMMARY

Asa isult *fX84FRC~fswo,A*.eIteewatta and asusbaeqntsalytya, 0" iylitiCarervamtionOppecualiaa (IM)s have ban s~sltod. ThwetInclude tocomianndadess which addreeassaqyefficlucya(#* oflif ambe tesweoproof, winaows), vandbilatl syston* HVAC q'stm Comrols,amom qfMenw doviustic INNa wsr DW#) "Ma. a~mn h100i;yaWSW=

Table 31isdo 1400 WC ater WM~ix Sumnary. 7ma table show the satatsootrch cif theucoreedaVoM et ech o thebatflaSonwitolh rods litt this able stay requtjfe some

02l~whih is Soeater than I a e ndsic tated as RIC. IteS thhe thaslos;On). Indicatting that thenoomeassi riot nouotanded, we wWe SX 1. Finally, If the porltcular remanitendatioa (snotapokab ose* ubildin&we haveInicated ths by N/A.

Aliof the vaintrenetdationu wte fvtthucomeprised as 1P, ORW? or ('10? ICC.. Table 3-2 presentsaiatotabelCO, and iow which cataepy theymperounwt. Local iiaeta tenere o be

Aesleaeedb f~iitymc?.A br~io escription ofthe categoresfollows,

3.1 ECIP

duafoe idwev maiotniable for fssdndlqby QRW rP9MCW. lstuly he waebalig~tp

wincdowsand dares eptacernet doom d*6 IS edar Mft, offrent, Doal WAe to MV so"~eg 9fOwe EO reconamulaneiion Is tIIIA1 Maim todading syitergliai CWefLet

3.2 GRIPsMWdPECIP

QRW reawevm.-rda yous have jaybocka which ean less W n 2 ywars, Irdied in thit stco" inrelaylg tti a lndrto%" of wuWidecant and flvaucn naiISa" soAwm. veall enary asvnp intie OlD Cwomm awe 12.374tu.

I ! I IiHill 1 9liigilt l

fil

Jill

II1 loniigNii ii i

Ii llllllllllllt !ll°tlll,,,,,,,,

J j;I t~i•tll~il |iljjljj~jjjlil llljttij||lt||

|l~l iiititiiiiijV l~iiitVuiliiijiKlit

0 .• ill llllll llil!l!illi!

* jii iittltli~ tilltitllit

'Ii ~ ttilllllttl"Ii

o

I a IV tIII gý gliig o;I IIamkItog itl I UIn Iniam num 141 muna

ill U

311 i44i4iqtiliE4.4itqit.t4it4llii44~4ii443.0__ill lllE"I tlll tlllllllt flllllltl,,ia,

fi* 0" " " ° '" °' '" ' " 'Ii i 444 t 444tti idttqi4i4tt 4t4it 444d|

I53~l g """' 3" " '""" '

{IIJ I ll uitlzJ Elli '4v44444dll44444

[,•1 ti~i~llitl3lUI?3lil~iti~l~|t

IS 44444444q44u q444 t 44444q444

I~ll k ttil•{{ttikkkltlt•lllI ]1 tiil~tilii tllil•lii|i

illl llifil |t~ttl~tli|li|t

0 ll ii l~lllll..,I .=l, .,

Ii4

PII

, k i n ii l Hillkkauakmal laiim oil

J t !' 9 t t ittt ~ its i sit tli t i tltt ii

i III '4

*4

*4 4 4

*44.14444444444444444u4.14.lI N=]I• tiltttttttttlttttllltUlatktkt k

J I t l ! t II

0

0

~!

M all

SI At

A~ pi 1

nPt mcceowdrmdflonm Wthm w(ib poybeds under 4 years Thee an further reduced kdo PEOPO 1 *. POP A and PlC? #. nCP 41~ indudbe hhasfi systie orm o tW lofmefiweisnd lotalaZedoe

ohwwrwZaw Thewwip weU1,96jl.$tu. RO #cp2ladudoodtutffaiioi aw. san

oWrommbanto~olfkJM502u PlC? 03 Mdudes Mbtaftadonolpips aed ducn InsuteadwWM rerft In ow meiy savlop 1362 MOMa

U. othet Maswnl

Ciatebw ok-mmu anc temted 0e loas l IndicngWaf ft adIhy tsuf vii Mode tloe-p4.erdatim The"Wisowe ssdadcNew~ as lcal kwdude tocdwwU# howursddwet~la"girs ofU itures

Doleted IFCO ame ftor rvt.cm o".- 1.117 (SIR1 t 1) for any buikintp. Conversion tov@el andseduced *dow aeakm (on We 06CObMM.

3A Energ ManOWMt CtOMM GYtMM EVIlutIVOn

An lwmy 1ommegm Caore Ikytni MMMI was emotvwod ae t hnIr aeow" Cap and aewcepbud drobp de.ovped.

crio ommrmon aouim asowo &a MM, AX offth parlene dots wae. obbebed fromm (bal

Inv padoortlao enwdc meitdn

rotwe .e~pw"r awulyu for# nookaeenaatete lood sh~ddkgHVACIwmpQettmnbW .adeco*3 o(lI0*4 ghow ~S cooew¶.bb mtoevie oak sm OrAm As per thulOW allbe'nell

.weptaetdeeved wvdlaeddspinst owlMCI54/A"0A mbt44@/AiuS ad

Cow wmote~esod vi oSu MAeIrm w WMW "O4.tTMM incrased by ?A porceet Is

Sevfrp end KM(M IWO costs were coqmpted for each buildng As per Owe Army documented analysisO metod altbuldtzp wfith eatSIRtoes thnrcitme wr Igiuedfrm Sw inalMCSpecknge. T@ theEMCO building field cowt were added the central equipment. MMh and pminat cool.

he reultant RMCS cnsidlered provided monitoring an/r datrlfnctions In 34 bui'dIitp A taof V4p"is would be mqAtm Fot Inplemeretaon. AccordIig o NAWFACO9-449AFhIU36avda., DACS would not IseAppeopeaaetne sine ore than 12S points san reqluired. Sic fth coaldifteoweebetween a wmall sytern CA0 -GM palatal and! a redium syseOn (0- 2.500 Is *bout 12% anidyet peouide for setp~ikan OTuWW.. the medium "fite was aNalyz. ilray. One SOW required ontJI'MCSyrtene having Owe copeday 10 providne expanded coniettrol ughout the Ieee toe he future.

Tate 3-S presents a summerwy ofcost for shelarge, awdiun and email DMCS systems In addition totOw enos and cost auinp lecause die WaIWtls wmere S afelyquite small and head such a omannoinber oipoltnt por butldh'ng bhe savlep were not ST ereugh iotaesilt the mesof an mmCS 7hSilt (f** the nudm Eh4S Syseem Was V7. IT"r whaen ev~atueirt a WnaW hlCS the Six still was In$,owen Ie of A

$A1 Conctustomw Riecmmendations & fEnengy Savins Plan

TM 5. Wowi cocuin eerkh a tule of the irorganllnecirth Ajtalysa Program

MIAPt bmeevdd Energ Study at FIG-

L Curretly, there is edgolfcsantee"wrgwaslot tOe poet inbothbl best fuels Antd cIartlty.7MI6w Ia tM e ag nd contrinob~en of the build kipge

I2N ma jor enarw, consaeavns propoc or efforts hei' been Knsttuted! at the post. In fac Otion of~ ythie UAPI Iwo lWen comp~teed.

I Of~cbuildimpseurayed, Olwee Is o AeI~fcnteomerg npo~eite I~hwlmajorand.a cs*ensltaend Aztawli -1 EICOo are inpteffewnived It I sefratinetd thtS4% of

4. Thes SCOs hae bast groupad Itreo five major psojoct plus local action ktslpemetalt by

MAM A s.

Tobb 343

Final Cost SUMNuuy

Enorgy MIMtigewrit aV4 COMMtr$o m ylfHNNW 63449-EOM APRIL 1I"7

IoInti: 276 -

GanurU aoa $72.017 672.017 671,6411sysiom gq~prwew $1411.2115 $101.902 650.117so~w"r $66,319 860,533 14i,156FPil UrI~ommnI $350.541 $360.581 $630.681Dot Tama M~ds 114,0.33 $411.223 1189.11M

Malrdoinaft(6O%) 645.305 661,662 637,109

?v~s and Irwiiufco $51.413 847,670 842,261orefwwe $102K? 1911.140 $64,522prffit 665644 863.427 $686,3ANow $6,684 S111443 $65.35

TOTCCOI 811611.7011 4186.605 $879,431

SAM-Obmwmbus

Ifslwciay 19,331 56 sOod 43 Ins 1,095sON 47,0646410H 46,1211of ,7.2S ca!M p.126

M OAL 10,259 $51,271

sot 0.70 0.76 0.66

0 Mcarol 3-111

'035.2 FIhCOmm~natlons & Inargy SaVIng8 Plan

ft b momenviwded that anf the ICOswch ic me the tooswiedvm ciuuia (ICIP ,telwwabefundedad Implemmetod. Twenlyon. dliffctwrn IcC. s hown~ o be cotWocr~ive and oem smfftr~ad InTable3.2 below. The lbl ss fo edi CO ftspelflc W savinpeu& vh InM~IN, mvimp aspe1Cwfd olthe bWa OMIV um *(the buildinj SrMyod, mvnp In commetnt dollars, toimrated

0wtco oLSIOKI siplpsybacla. and the savinpo-inevtmenttile CSit). Alsollsihed theroomunld~ gop~n30l fth IC~s

It is orn enced that Sw prcoiae (plus local actin) be Implemented s os

QRIJI #t kfixture Incranduent W/ FluorecentAuteampFluaeteiet I .11tir-

?ECIVII (~AsiINewturnrCunslapeove c*Srq Systcm Conitrols

rncip 02 instal Neitroattiaon Fans

PECIP 3 1hW.11 pipe II Dwoul'ti.s~a

fo JII * Caulk &W~hmrn

hweafl Doorsrnato

Inot"~ Am(l Insulation

L-01l Action Deluy SletedLthISAIFlohaiDvwran fue 5w Noaufr,lwrinve Veft,Aoduca UgJt!"I NountOHWN*CouoLowCuthcwMAVIV WIN Tank

Alat fsetee ecoteddtatteIn pieo aCab kn tond durtlr 1 Y199K'i 'je-oweneutdd

hoosute @ the site of*O that 'fecwc . It Is ommmdneedt that tneplteeetma~cntolle Funded during rYIWE

FIGS W523-12